""""""""" ..."""""""""""""""""","""""""",,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,h',,,,,,,,,,,""""'" "",;'"", "''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""'"""""", """"""""""""",'h"'""""""""""" """""""""""""""""""""""""""''''"""" """"""""""""""""""""""'"""",,,"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""", """"""""""""""""'""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""", """"""""""""""""""""""""""""","""""""""""""""''''''''''''''''''''''''""","''''''" """"""'''''''''''"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""'",,"""""''''''''''''''''',,""'"""" "","""""'''''''''''''''''''''''""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""",""""'""""""'"""" """'''''''''''''''''''''''',''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''""",","""""""""'''''''''''''''''''""'''''''''''''''''",,,""""", """"''''''''''''''''''''''""""",,.,,,,,,.,,,,,,,,.,,,.,"~"~JI"~"~"~"~"~"~"~"~'"""""""""""""""""""",.,,.,,,, ,,."',,,, """" ""'", """ ""'" """ ""'" """ ""'" "'''', ""'" "'''', ""'" ""'"
mm
2. QUELQUES TENDANCES DES PROCESSUS ~m~~",,.,, """'" ~~~~~~ DE LA PENSEE
mm
""" "'''',,, """ "",,, ""'" "'",,, """ "",,, "",,, "",,, ,."", "",,, ""',,, "",,, ",,.,, ",."" ,.""" """ ,.,.",." "",,, ,.,.",,, ""',,, ,,.,,.,., """ "",,, """ "",,, """ "",,, ""',,, "",,, ""',,,~~~~~~ Quelques tendances internes favorisant l'inventivité ~~~~~~
""" "'''',,, ""'" "",,, ""'" ""',,, ""'" ""',,, ""',., "",,, ""'" "",,, """ "",,, """ "",,, """ "",,, ~~~~~~ tendance ludique ; ~~~~~~ "",,, """',, "",,, ""'" "",,, ""',,,
~~~~~~ - tendance vers plus de compréhension,àl'intelligibilité ; ~~~~~~
""" ""',,,
""" ""',,,
~~~g~
-
tendanceàla transgression, au dépassement,àla curiosité ; ~~~~~~""'" ""',,,
""'" ""',,,
""" ""',,,
""'" "",,,
~~~~~~ - tendanceàplus de cohérence interne ;tendanceàl'hannonie des ~~~~~~
"",,, "",,, ~~~~~~ fonnes (esthétique). ~~~~~~ ""'" ""',,, """ "",,, ~~~~~~ ~~~~~~ ~~~~~~ ~~~~~~ ""'" ""',,, """ ""',,,
~~~~~~ Quelques tendances gênant la compréhension ~~~~~~
""'"""" """"""',,, ""'"""" "",,,""" """ """ """ """ """ """ """ ""'" "",,, "",,,
~~~~~~ - égocentrisme (subjectivité accentuée) ; ~~~~~~
""" """
"""
"""~~~~~~ ~~~~~~
~~~~~~ - incompétence logique usage des inférences contextuelles, ~~~~~~
:~:~:: ~~~~~~ n n n fallacieuses, circulaires " n n " ~~~~~~ ~~~~~: "",,, "",,, "",,, ""'" "",,, ""'"
mm
perte de contrôle sur les variations de (nombreux) paramètresmm
~~~~~~
(>à3) ;~~~~~~
""'" ""'"
~~~~~~
. .dié t é ' p r é '~~~~~~
~~~~~~ ngl t sys IDlque; tenaces re sentaUons propres ; ~~~~~~
""'", ''''''',
~~~~~~
- instabilité cognitive et intentionnelles: conflits internes ;~~~~~~
:~~~~~ ~~~~~:
"'''''' ",'"''
~~~~~~ ~~~:~~
~~~m récalcitrance à la rigueur analytique: (préférenceàla simulation ~~~~~~
~~~~~~ ~~~~~~
~~~~~~ des descriptions des récits, exemples, films) ; ~~:~~~
~:~~~~ ~~~~~~
mm
processus (transferts)à coût cognitif minimal. :~~:~~:~~:~~ ~~~:~~ :~~:~~ ~~~~~~ ~~~:~~ ~~~:~: ~~~~~~ ~~::~~ ''''"" """, """"""'""""""""""""""""""""""""""""''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''""""'", """"""""""""""""""""""""""'"","""""""""""""""""""""""""''''",'''''''''''''' ~~~~~~~:~~:~:~:~:~~:~:~~~~~:~~~~~:~~:~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~:~:~~~~:~::~~~::~~:~::~:~:::~~~~::~~~~:~~::~:~~~~:~~~~~~~~:~~~ """"""""""""'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''""""'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''"""""""""",,""'"'''' """""""''''''''''''""""""""""""""","""""""'""""""""''''''''''''''''''''''''"",,"'"''''''''''''''''''''''''''''"'''''''""""""""""""""",,"""""""""''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''""""""''''",
~,,,,,,,,,;,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,"""""""""""""""""""""''''"""",,,""""" """""""""""""""""""",'h"'","'" """"""""""''''""""""",,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,',,'b""'" """""""""""'h'",,,""""""""''''''''''"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""", """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""''''""""""""""""""""""""""""", """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""''''""",,,,,,,,,,",,,,,"''''', """"""""''''"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""''''''''''''''''''''''""""''''""" """""""""""""""""""""""""","""""""""""'"""""""""""""""","""''''", """, ""'", """ """ """ """ ""'" """ ""'" """ """ """ """ ''''", """ """ """ """ ""'" '''''''' """ ''''", ""'"""'" ''''",""'" """ ''''", """ '''''''' """ '''',,,, "",,, """, ""'" """ """, ""'" :::::: 3. FACTEURS CREATIFS :::~:: """ ,,,,,,, """ """ """ """ """ """, """ ''''", "'''', ""'" """ ''''", """ """ """ """ """ """ """', """ "'''', '''''''' """ ""'" """ ,,,,,,,, """ ''''", """ """ "'''', ''''",
~~~~~~ Combinaisons, inter, intra des suites d'objets, réarrangements ~~~~~~
""" ''''", ~~~~~~ pennutations, ~~~~~~ """ ""'" """ ,,,,,,, "'''', """ "'''', """ """ """ ~~~~~~ Inductions ; ~~~~~~ "'''', ,,,,,,, ",,,,, """" ",,,,, ''''",
:~:~:~ Généralisations de divers types ; :~~~~~
"'''', """
""" ""'"
""" """"
~~~~~~ Méthode diagonale (Cantor) ; ~~~~~~
""" "",,,
""" """
~~~~g Résolution d'un problème concret issue surprenante d 'un ~~~~~~
""", ""'" """ ""'" """ ""',,, ~~~~~~ processus ; ~~~~~~ """ ""'"'' """ """ """ "",,,
~:~~:~ Morphismes, analogies, transferts, correspondances entre ~~~~~~
"'''', """ """ ""',,, ",,,,, """" ~~~~~~ phénomènes; ~~~~~§ ",,,,, ""',,, """ """,
~~~~~~ Symbolisation adéquate commutation par symboles ~~~~~~
""" "",,, """ "'",,,
~~~~§~
formalisations;~~~~~~
""" ",,,,,, """ """, """ "''''"mm
Extension des modèles et des théories (asynchronisation des ~m~~""'" """
""'" """
~~~~~~ extensions), tendances vers une meilleure fenne ; ~~§~~§
""" """, ""'" """
~~~~~~
Réflexivité ;~~~~~~
""" """ ""'" """ """ """ """ """§§g§~ Exploration erratique, ludique, au hasard, extension, découverte des §~~§~§
""'" """
~~~~~~ possibles ; ~~~~:~
""'" """
""" """
""" """
~~~~§~ Dialogues, écoute, expérience. §~~~~~
""" """ """ """ "",,' """ """ """ ''''", """ """ """ ""'" """ """ "'"" "",,' """ """""" """""" ""'" """ """ """ """ """ """ """ """,""" .""",""" """" """" """"""""""""""""""""""""""",""""""""""""""""""""""""""""",""""", """""""""''''"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""', """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""'"""""""""""""""''''"" """""""""""""""""""""""",,,,,,,"""""""'""",""""""'"""""""""",""""",""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""", """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""", """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""''''""""""""""",""""", """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""",""""", """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""'"""""""""",,,"""""" "'""""",,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,"""""""""""""""",,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,""""""
,,,,,.,,,,,,,.,.,,,;,,,.,,,,....,,,.,,,,,,,,,,,,,,l't,,,,.,,,,,,,,,,,,,,..,," ..""h''''"""",,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,/,;,,/,,,,",.""',,.,, ,.""""""""""""""".1",,.,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,"""""""""""""""""""""""",,,,,.1,'l"~"~"~"~"~ ""'h"''''''''I'"",..".I""",.I''''''''''''''''''h''''''"""""""""""''''1'''/''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''';'ho " " " , """""""""'""",,."""''''',,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,..""""""""""",,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,..,,,h" ,.""",,.,, """""""'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''1'11',""""",1'1"""""''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''',..""..",..""..'''''''"''''''"..",,,,..,,..,''''''.., ,, ,..,,..,,,..,,,..'''..,
..
",..
",..
,,,..
,,..
,'''..
,, ,,..
''',,..
,'''..
,,'''..
,,,..
'''..
,,,..
'''''',...''''''''', ' "'....1...."''''1'..'''''..''..'''1....1....''....'''..1''1..''..'' ..'''..'' ..1'..'''..1"'1"1'"1'''..
''',..
,,''''''' " "..
"""""'''''''''..
''''''..
,....
'''''''''"..
''''''..
''''''..
,....
"..
''',..
''',..
,,,..
''''''..
,,'''..
,,'''..
"..
",..
"''''..
"..
"" ..,''''''..'1..''..''''../1'·'1 ' ..''..'' ..1'..'''''''' ,.." .."''',,"1""'"''''''''''''1'''1''''''''''''''''''1''''''1''''1'''''1'''''''''1''''''''''1'''"1"'1"1'"'''' ",'''''''1..1'''11''1'''1..'''''''..1'..11''''''''1' ' ..''''.."""1 "''''1....' ..1'..'''''''..''....1..'''''1..'' ..1..''''..'' ..",..'' '''..1'.."..,,,..,,,..,,..::~:::::',.."".."' .."' ..,..,,,....,.."".."' ..,,.."""'..' ..I'.."''''" ,.."',.."",,,..,'''''',..'''''''..''1..''''''''''''''''''''''', ,..,,,,''l''''~:~:~~:~ :::~~:I ::~::: :::~~: ~:~~:~ :::~~: ~:~~:: ,,,,,,..
, ",..
",..
~:~~~~ ~:~:~~ ~~~~~~ ~~~~~~ "",l,,,,, """'l'" ~::::: ~:~::: ~:~~:~::::::
:::~~~ ::~~:: , .." .." ""'1'" ~:~:~: 4 QUELQUES CONDUITES NS L ~::;:::~~~~~~.
D A A~~~~~~
@~~ RESOLUTION DES PROBLEMES· g~~
:::::: :~:::: """" ""''''' """" 1'''1'''' ,,,,,,,..,, ""'1'" """''' ""1" ""'''''' 1''''1'' ,,,,,,,,,, "'''l'' ,..,,'"'' ""1" ,..", " "'''l'' ,
..
"," ",,,,,..
::~::~ ~:::~: ,..,,,,,, ,l''',.... :::~:~ :::~~: :::::: :::::::::::~ Conduites par essais; ::::::
::::::
::::::,,,,,,,,,,,, ,l''''''''
"''''''1 "'1'"
''''l'",::~:~~ Rester "accroché"àun schéma rigide (confiance en la maintenance de ""1"'''~~~~:~
,,,,,,,,, ,l,..,.."
@~ ~~~~s); ~ili~
,,,,,,, 1"''''
, .." .., 1"1"
''''',l" 1'''1''''
~~~~~~ Procéderàdes corrélations provisoires, secondaires ; ~~~~~~
,l"'", 1"1"
..",.., ,l,..,..,
""1"''''' """
"''''...''' 1'"''''''
"",,,,,, "'""
..
"~:~::~ Généralisations empiriques menant à des réussites sans ~::~:~
,
..
,,,,,,,, ,..
"", ~~~~~~ compréhension ; ~~~~~~ "'''''''' 1'''''''' ,,,,,,,,..., """1"'''' """", '''''''1'' "",,,,,, ,l"""~~~~~~ - Etre déconcerté par les résultats (inattendus), par la déconvenue ~~~g~
",,,,,,,,,,, ,l''''''
~~~~~~ d'une régularité (loi) supposée etquine seconfmne pas ; ~~~~~~
",,,,, ,l,,,,,,,,
""""" ,
..
,,,,,"",.., ,l,,,,,,
",,,,,,,,,, ,l"'"''
~~~~~~ Chercherà deviner un "truc", une clefrésolvante plutôt qu'une ~g~~~
"""'''1 """'" g~~~~ méiliode ; ~~~~~~ "'''''1 ''',l,.., ",l,..., '"'''''' ,,,,,,,,, ,
..
",,,, '''',..
, ,..
"",~~~~~~ Chercheràse convaincre par vérifications, par raisonnement, par ~~~~~~
,.."", ,l"'"
~~~~~~ dialogues ; ~~~~~~
""'''' ,,,,l'"''
"
..
,..
", ,..
"",,,,,,,,,,, ,,,,l',,,
~~~~~~ Déduire d'une théorie apprise, induire de nombreux exemples. ~~~~~~
"'",..., ,,,,,,, "",,,, ,,,,,,,, , ,
..
"..
, ,,,,,,,, ,,,,,,,,, ,...",..
, ,..,,,,,, ,l,,,,,,,,,,, "",,,,,, ,..
"..
" ",l", ",l'" ",l,.., ,..",.., """ """ ..,,l,,,, ,,,,l,,, """ '''''''''' ..,,l,,,, "...,,,,, ",..
" ,..
"", """ """,..
" ""',,,, ,..."..., ,..
"..
, ,,,,,,,,, """" ,..."...,~~~~~~ * D'après P. Greco, in "Etudes d'epistémologie génétique. vol XVII. .~~~~~~
"",
..
", ,,,,,,,,~~~~~~ Paris. P.U.F. (avec quelques modifications mineures). ~~~~~~
""''''' ,