• Aucun résultat trouvé

Graph Rewrite Systems for Program Optimization

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "Graph Rewrite Systems for Program Optimization"

Copied!
43
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00073743

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00073743

Submitted on 24 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access

archive for the deposit and dissemination of

sci-entific research documents, whether they are

pub-lished or not. The documents may come from

teaching and research institutions in France or

abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est

destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents

scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,

émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de

recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires

publics ou privés.

Graph Rewrite Systems for Program Optimization

Uwe Aßmann

To cite this version:

Uwe Aßmann. Graph Rewrite Systems for Program Optimization. [Research Report] RR-2955,

IN-RIA. 1996. �inria-00073743�

(2)

ISSN 0249-6399

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Graph Rewrite Systems For Program Optimization

Uwe Aßmann

N˚ 2955

August 1996

(3)
(4)

/0"132547698;::< =>? @BA3@C5DFEHG@BIJK@'LKMONPJRQSJK@BL @STUQSVOLRQSWLYXZ7A'[MPLRJR\;W]@ ^_ Ma`[email protected]degf.h hUVaiiM _ Tj]@ _ @BQ > @ _ Q > @kIMlCOmOnOnoDFf"WNPWXTpBmOmOq5DFrOm!isVaNO@BX tvuYwSxzyz{|OxP} => JRX~isVai@ _ j]@BA3MPIX,T _ VaT@BX > M€N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@.XZ7XT@BA‚X~QSVOIƒ[@.WsX@Bj„TM!Xi@BQSJK…†Z„VOIj‚NO@BI]@ _ VaT@ i _ MON _ VOAMOiT,JRA„JK‡BVaT,JKMPIXBˆŠ‰M _ T@ _ A„JRIVaT,JKMPI‹MO…T > @ŒXZ7XT@BA„X‚+@j]@SŽO@BLKMOiX,MPA3@I@S _ WsLK@’‘“[sVOX@Bj‹Q _ JKT@ _ JRV7” j]@’•IJRI]N—–,˜O™;šO›œŸž¡ †¢£–Œ¤P¥¦šŸ§s™¨¥–S©¥Ÿ †žª–«œŸ¬zœŸžª–B­œŸˆ¯®°@±VOLRXM²j]@’•³I@´œŸž¡¥bšOž¡ µ+¶*šOž¡ ¸·O¹MO…5N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@«XZ7XT@BA„X  > JRQ > VOW]TMPA‚VaT,JRQSVOLRLKZºX@BLK@BQ’T,X3X,JRI]NPLK@HIM _ A„VOL~…»M _ A„X5…»M _ A‚VOIlZ±I]MPI7‘ªj]@ST@ _ A„JRIJRXT,JRQvXZ7XT@BA‚XSˆ = M¼JRLRLRWXT _ VaT@ T > @½T@BQ > I]MPLKMONOZv~@¾Xi@BQSJK…†Z3isV _ T,X+MO…YT > @¾LRVa‡SZ‚Q’M7j]@¾A3MOT,JKMPIƒMOiT,JRA„JK‡BVaT,JKMPI¿ˆ‰]M _ T > @ _ @BX,WsLKT,JRI]N!N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@ XZ7XT@BAÀQSLRVOX,X@BX!VWIJK…†M _ A@SŽaVOLRWVaT,JKMPIÁVOLKNOM _ JKT > AÂJRX5NPJKŽO@BIˆ¼c½I«T > @‚[³VOX,JRXMO…ÃT > JRX5A„@ST > M7j¼T > @‚MOiT,JRA„JK‡S@ _ NO@BI]@ _ VaTM _ c ^ =ÃĦŐĦƯ> VOX![@S@BIÁj]@SŽO@BLKMOi@Bjˆ Ä TJRXMPI]@vMO…UT > @v• _ XT5TMMPLRX3 > JRQ > QSVOIº[@vWX@Bj±TM¼Xi@BQSJK…†Z VOIVOLKZ7X,JRX+VOIj3T _ VOIX…†M _ A„VaT,JKMPI‚WIJK…†M _ A„LKZ5VOIj3+@Ui _ @BX@BIlT+Q’MPA3isJRLRVaT,JKMPI‚T,JRA3@ _ @BX,WLKT,XMO…NO@BI]@ _ VaT@Bj‚MOiT,JRA„JK‡S@ _ Q’MPA„iMPI@BIlT,XSˆ Ç9ÈlÉÊ,Ë!̳yzÍYwP} egMPA3isJRLK@ _ NO@BI]@ _ VaTM _ ”si _ MON _ VOAMOiT,JRA‚JK‡BVaT,JKMPI”Xi@BQSJΕ³QSVaT,JKMPI”XT _ VaT,JΕ³QSVaT,JKMPI”ŽO@ _ Z > JKN > ‘ªLK@SŽO@BL LRVOI]NPWsVaNO@BXS”sŽ7JRX,WVOLi _ MON _ VOA„A‚JRI]N ÏÑÐ!Ò ÓÕÔªÖB× Ò ÓgØ¿ÙRԓڡÛSÜ ÝÞß(àzáãâáåäçæ’èé“ßUé“ê£ë(ì£æ½í¾ë(î¸é¡äçìï(ß(à£î“âzë(ì!ë*ìaâ¾ð~ñ½ß(é“ê£è¦îò¦ß(áåáçèë*óŸà£èbôõÎî¡ßŸð‹é“êzè+ó(î¡ßŸà£ö5÷ø£ùúüû¼ë*éÝ»ýþûüݸúŒûüßBòbÿSà£èbì£ò¦ßŸàzî¸é  à£î¸äçìzó~ðñÃöOߒô†é»âzßBò¿ñSèë*îé“ê£è¦ñgö£î¡ßSäÎâ€èâUë(ìUèzò¦è¦áåáçèbìSéèbì Säãî¡ß(ì£ðÃèbìSé³é“ßÞ¿î¸äåé“èþé“ê€äÎô³öaë(öOè¦î èbî¸é“ê£ß*áãâ þßPðë(ìzìþìzä’è¦î“ô†äçé»ñÃß(õ î¡èbðÃèbì³ö£î¡ßSß*õî¡èëŸâ.é“êzè öaë*öOèbî£ë(ìaâUö£î¡ß(öOߒô¸èâ"é“êzèþé“èbî¡ð Ó*րԓÙKÚ(Ó "!ÕÛ#!“Ó%$ !&KÙ»ÓÔ('(ԓٻÓÕ×~Ô é“ßgî¡èbö€áãëŸò¦è ë*ì½èë(î¸áåäçèbî£ðÃߟî¡è àzó(áåñ ìaë*ðÃè)³ùë(î¡ß*áÝ»ìaë+*î¡àaâzèÕáêzè¦áçöOèâðÃèYé“ß~äçðÃözî¡ßŸèþð~ñ-,³ìzó(áåäãô¸ê.³úYìUö£î¡èSäçߟà£ô€ð+àaò“êî¡èô†é“î¸äãòÕé“èâ/’èbî“ô†äçߟì"ß(õ;é“ê€äãôöaë(öOè¦î¿ë(ö£öOèbë(î¡èâ äçì10ú3254"6"789*êzäãôÞßŸî¡æUêaë(ôöaë(î¸é¡áåñ/:Oèbèbì½ô¸à£ö£öOß(î¸é“èâ:Sñ/,³ô¸ö£î¸äåéüö£î¡ß;†èòÕéüýYß=<">"4)4ù÷ í#?lúYû@,@ A

YÞè"úYô¡ô¸ðë(ìzìBYäçì£î¸äãëCõÎî3D£î¡ßŸð²ýþß@4)6ÃߟìFEGþì€äHŸèbî“ô†äåé†ñ½ß*õJI ë(î¸áãô¸î¡à£êzè)O݆ì£ô†é¡äåé“àzéüõ&Kàzî ?sî¡ßŸóŸî“ë*ðÃð-àzìaâLë,é“èbìaô†é“î¡àzæSé“à£î¡èbìF

MYäçìaòÕèbìONP?sî¸äçèô¡ô¸ìzäåé(N†øBé“î9> Q6CRSTUI ë(î¸áãô¸î¡à£êzè)Vþè¦î¡ðë(ìSñW€ëŸô¡ô¸ðë*ì£ìBYäçì€õKߟî¡ðë,é¡äçæXàzìzäYæŸë*î¸áÎô¸î¡àzê£è)â€è

Unité de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt

Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex (France)

Téléphone : (33 1) 39 63 55 11 – Télécopie : (33 1) 39 63 53 30

(5)

 U%"   ȝwȁ} e+@ST5V _ T,JRQSLK@„@7isLRJR\;W]@„Q’MPA‚A3@BITLK@BX'XZ7XT ? @BA3@BX'j]@ _ G @G@BQ _ JKT,W _ @ƒj]@„N _ Vai > @3i@BW]ŽO@BIT@ST _ @ƒW]T,JRLRJRXG@BX iMPW _ XigG@BQSJΕ³@ _ @STNþG@BI+G@ _ @ _ j]@BX¾MOisT,JRA„JRX,VaT,JKMPIXj]@3i _ MON _ VOA„A3@BXBˆ ^ MPW _ LRVHT@ _ A„JRIVOJRX,MPI¼j]@BXXZ7XT ? @BA3@BXB”YI]MPWX

V€ŽOMPIXj+G@SŽO@BLKMOisi+G@±j]@¼IMPW]ŽO@BVOW¨Q

_ JKT ? @ _ @BXX*W _ LK@BX _ ? @SNPLK@BXS”@BIj~G@’•³IJRX,X*VOIlT9j@BXŒœŸ¬zœŸž–B­3–Ÿœl–«¥ –! –B¶B¥Ÿ †ž¡›;¥–"l–

¤P¥¦šŸ§s™7–„–*˜a™;šO›œ’ž¡ #(œ(ˆ%$"MPWX"V€ŽOMPIXoG@SNPVOLK@BA„@BIlT½j+G@’•³IJYLRVoœ’ž¡¥¦šOž¡ µ~¶(šOž¡ †·P¹oj]@BXUXZ7XT

? @BA3@BX"j]@ _ G @G@BQ _ JKT,W _ @!j@N _ Vai > @O” \;WJYi@ _ A3@STUj]@5Q > MPJRX*J _ VOW]TMPA„VaT,JR\;W]@BA3@BIT"WsI]@'WIsJR\W]@'…»M _ A3@'IM _ A„VOLK@'iMPW _ j]@5I]MPA5[ _ @BWHXZ7XT ? @BA3@BX½I]MPI7‘ j+G@ST@ _ A‚JRIJRXT@BXSˆ ^ MPW _ JRLRLRWXT _ @ _ Q’@STT@«T@BQ >

IJR\;W]@O”I]MPWsXoXi+G@BQSJΕsMPIXH\;W]@BLR\;W]@BX‹G@ST,Vai@BX9jWi

_ MO[sL ? @BA3@°j &MOiT,JRA‚JRX,VaT,JKMPIjW j+G@SisLRVOQ’@BA„@BIlTj]@ƒQ’M;j@„isV _ @BX*X@BWˆ'$UMPWX5j]MPIIMPIXiMPW _ LK@BX5QSLRVOX,X@BX _ G @BX,WsLKT,VOIlT@BXWI VOLKNOM _ JKT > A„@ƒWIsJK…»M _ A„@

j &¦G@SŽaVOLRWVaT,JKMPIˆ)(¿@3NþG@BI+G@

_ VaT@BW _ j*&MOiT,JRA„JRX@BW _ Xc ^ =ĦŐÄÕÆ V‹G@STG@ƒj+G@SŽO@BLKMOisi+G@ƒX,W _ LRVo[sVOX@3j@„Q’@STT@‚A´G@ST > M;j]@Oˆ e+&@BX,TYL,&åWIj@BX¿i _ @BA‚JK@ _ XMPW]T,JRLRXþ\WsJaT _ VOJKT@+WsIJK…»M _ A±G@BA3@BITj]@BXüVOIVOLKZ7X@BXY@ST¿T _ VOIX,…»M _ A‚VaT,JKMPIXSˆ-$UMPWXüi _ G @BX@BITMPIX \;W]@BLR\;W]@BX _ G @BX,WsLKT,VaT,XUj]@T@BA„isXÃj]@Q’MPA„isJRLRVaT,JKMPI9j]@BXUQ’MPA3iMPX,VOIT,Xj &MOiT,JRA‚JRX@BW _ XÃVOJRIX*JNYG@BI~G@ _ G @BXSˆ .Ìxzw’Ê*|0/1È$} E9G@BI+G@ _ VaT@BW _ j]@3Q’MPA„isJRLRVaT@BW _ XB”MOiT,JRA„JRX,VaT,JKMPI«j]@!i _ MON _ VOA‚A3@BXS”XigG@BQSJΕ³QSVaT,JKMPI¿”þXT _ VaT,JΕ³QSVaT,JKMPI” LRVOI][email protected]]@ > VOW]TIJKŽO@BVOW”i _ MON _ VOA„A‚VaT,JKMPIvŽ;JRX*W]@BLRLK@

(6)

-.  þ, .-® _ JKT,JRIN«VOI´MOiT,JRA„JK‡S@ _ …†M _ VŒi _ MON _ VOA„A„JRINLRVOI]NPWVaNO@HJRXVOIº@ _,_ M _ ‘“i _ MPI]@ƒVOIsj´T@BjJKMPWX!T,VOXˆ Ä I´M _ j]@ _ TM X > M _ T@BI²j]@SŽO@BLKMOi³A3@BIT„T,JRA3@O”+TM«…¸VOQSJRLRJKT,VaT@ŒŽ£VOLRJRjsVaT,JKMPI”VOIjºTM±JRA3i _ M€ŽO@9A‚VOJRIlT,VOJRIVa[³JRLRJKTªZO”UV¼A„@ST > M7j]MPLKMONOZ …†M _ Xi@BQSJΕ³QSVaT,JKMPI²VOIsj NO@BI@ _ VaT,JKMPIºMO….MOiT,JRA„JK‡S@ _ XJRX > JKN > LKZ j@BX,J _ Va[sLK@OˆUMz~@SŽO@ _ ”gWsIlT,JRLÃI]Mz Xi@BQSJΕ³QSVaT,JKMPI A„@ST > M;jsX > VOIjLK@BjMPIsLKZ!X*W][T,VOX7XMO…i _ MON _ VOA MOiT,JRA„JK‡BVaT,JKMPI¿”M _ T > @SZ!LK@Bj„TMMOiT,JRA‚JK‡S@ _ X > JRQ > @7@BQSW]T@Bj„TMM X,LKMzULKZO”lM _ T > @SZ+@ _ @ÃQSLKMPX@Bj3XZ7XT@BA„XY > JRQ > ~@ _ @+T,JK@Bj!TMV½Xi@BQSJΕ³Q+@BIŽ;J _ MPIA3@BITYM _ JRIT@ _ A„@BjJRVaT@ÃLRVOI]NPWVaNO@Oˆ =U> JRXƒisVai@ _ j]@BA„MPIXT _ VaT@BX > Mz N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT,JRIN±QSVOI[@ŒWX@Bj$…»M _ Xi@BQSJΕ³QSVaT,JKMPI¨VOIj‹NO@BI]@ _ VaT,JKMPI¨MO… i _ MON _ VOAMOiT,JRA‚JK‡BVaT,JKMPIˆ => @„Q’@BIT _ VOL+JRj]@BVoMO…ÃMPW _ A3@ST > M7j°JRXTM _ @SNPV _ j±VOLRLJRI]…†M _ A‚VaT,JKMPI¼JRI«VOI«MOiT,JRA„JK‡S@ _ VOX½VƒX@ST½MO… N _ Vai > XBˆ ^ _ MON _ VOA MO[]`¦@BQ’T,XB”JRIT@ _ A„@BjJRVaT@5Q’M7j]@!JRIXT _ WsQ’T,JKMPIXS”VOIji _ @BjJRQSVaT@BX.M€ŽO@ _ T > @'@BIT,JKT,JK@BX MO…ÃT > @ƒi _ MON _ VOAV _ @vVOLRL _ @Si _ @BX@BIT@Bj«@BJKT > @ _ VOX5I]M7j]@BXM _ @Bj]NO@BX!JRI«T > @BX@„N _ Vai > XSˆ ^ _ MON _ VOA VOIsVOLKZ;X,JRX!VOIj T _ VOIsX…»M _ A„VaT,JKMPI²V _ @Hi@ _ …»M _ A3@Bj´[;Z±N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT,JRI]N]ˆ = Z;isJRQSVOLRLKZO”UVOIVOLKZ;‡BJRI]N i _ MON _ VOA‚X3A3@BVOIX3@BILRV _ NPJRI]N N _ Vai > X½UJKT > I]@S @BjNO@BX > JRQ > _ @Si _ @BX,@BIlT¾T > @3JRI…»M _ A‚VaT,JKMPI” > JRLK@3Q’M7j]@T _ VOIsX…»M _ A„VaT,JKMPI°A3@BVOIsX _ @S _ JKT,JRI]N N _ Vai > X[;Z3j]@BLK@ST,JRI]N!VOIj‚VaTT,VOQ > JRI]NX,W[N _ Vai > XBˆ => WXT > @UMOiT,JRA‚JK‡BVaT,JKMPIƒi _ M7Q’@BX,X~JRX+jJKŽ7JRj]@Bj„JRITM!V'X@B\;W]@BIQ’@ MO…N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@UX,Z;XT@BA VaiisLRJRQSVaT,JKMPIXS”7XT,V _ T,JRIN… _ MPA T > @JRIT@ _ A3@BjsJRVaT@ _ @Si _ @BX,@BIlT,VaT,JKMPI‚NPJKŽO@BI„[;Z5T > @… _ MPIlTb‘ @BIj¿”;VOIj _ @BX,WLKT,JRIN'JRI„VOIƒJRIT@ _ A3@BjJRVaT@.N _ Vai >  > JRQ > JRX > VOIj]@Bj3M€ŽO@ _ TMT > @U[sVOQl‘“@BIjƒ…†M _ Q’M7j]@UNO@BI@ _ VaT,JKMPIˆ "M€+@SŽO@ _ ”³ > @BIƒT _ Z7JRI]N!TM!X,i@BQSJK…†Z„i _ MON _ VOA MOiT,JRA‚JK‡BVaT,JKMPIoUJKT > N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@XZ;X,T@BA„XS”;~@¾A‚VBZ„@BVOX*JRLKZ Xi@BQSJK…†Z9XZ7XT@BA„X"T > VaT¾I]@BJKT > @ _ T@ _ A‚JRIVaT@!I]M _ Z7JK@BLRj°WIJR\;W]@5I]M _ A„VOLü…»M _ A„XSˆ => WsXUMPW _ isVai@ _ j]@’•³I]@BX½XMPA„@ I]@S _ WsLK@’‘“[sVOX@Bj$T@ _ A„JRIVaT,JKMPIQ _ JKT@ _ JRV7”'žª–S¥Ÿ­! »¹³šOž¡ †·P¹S¬Á– z¤l–°š1O »ž¡ ¸·O¹ºVOIsj—žª–B¥(­! †¹sšOž¡ ¸·O¹B¬¼œ’›Bž¡¥¦šl¶Bž¡ ¸·O¹]ˆ => @SZ _ @BX,WLKTÃJRIƒT > @½QSLRVOX,XÃMO…+–*˜a™;šP›lœ’ž¡ »¢a–½¤O¥bšŸ§™o¥b–B©¥( †žª–œŸ¬zœŸžª–B­œŸˆ‰W _ T > @ _ A3M _ @O”+@¾j]@SŽO@BLKMOiŒœŸž¡¥bšOž¡ µ~¶*šOž¡ ¸·O¹‚MO… N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@gXZ;X,T@BA„XS”£ > JRQ > VOWTMPA„VaT,JRQSVOLRLKZ'X,@BLK@BQ’T,X Vœ’ž¡¥¦šPž¡ µ+– 5¹s·O¥Ÿ­!š#’·O¥Ÿ­$…»M _ A„VOIZ¾I]MPI7‘ªj]@ST@ _ A„JRIJRXT,JRQ XZ7XT@BA‚XSˆ => JRX"T@BQ > IJR\;W]@3JRX½@BXi@BQSJRVOLRLKZ°JRA3iM _ T,VOIT"…†M _ T > @3Xi@BQSJΕ³QSVaT,JKMPI¼MO…i _ MON _ VOA MOiT,JRA„JK‡BVaT,JKMPI° > JRQ > _ @B\;WJ _ @BX I]@SNPVaT,JKMPI¿”lj]@BLK@ST,JKMPIVOIj!VOjjJKT,JKMPI5MO…sV _ [sJKT _ V _ ZX*W][N _ Vai > XSˆ => JRXüMO…†T@BI _ @BX,WLKT,X JRI5I]MPI7‘ªj]@ST@ _ A„JRIJRXT,JRQ XZ7XT@BA‚XUj]@BLRJKŽO@ _ JRINƒI]MPI]‘“@;i@BQ’T@Bj _ @BX,WLKT,XSˆUd;T _ VaT,JΕ³QSVaT,JKMPIŒX@BLK@BQ’T,X½I]M _ A„VOL¿…»M _ A‚Xà > JRQ > V _ @ _ VaT > @ _ IVaT,W _ VOL [@BQSVOWX@T > @X@BLK@BQ’T@Bjj]@ _ JKŽaVaT,JKMPIX _ @ST,VOJRIX,W][N _ Vai > X+ > JRQ > V _ @¾MOT > @ _ UJRX@j]@BLK@ST@Bj¿ˆ f i _ VOQ’T,JRQSVOL~A„@ST > M7j°…»M _ NO@BI]@ _ VaT,JRIN9MOiT,JRA‚JK‡S@ _ Q’MPA„iMPI@BIlT,XUJRLRL[@¾`Wj]NO@Bj¼MPI«T > _ @S@ƒQ _ JKT@ _ JRV7ˆ9‰ J _ XT JKToA!WXT‚[@ŒVa[sLK@TM´@;i _ @BX,XvV«[ _ MPVOj _ VOI]NO@ŒMO…i _ MON _ VOA VOIVOLKZ7X,JRXvVOIj‹T _ VOIX,…»M _ A‚VaT,JKMPI²i _ MO[sLK@BA„XBˆ—®°@ j]@BA„MPIXT _ VaT@ŒT > JRXv[;ZXi@BQSJK…»Z7JRI]NÁX@SŽO@ _ VOL½isV _ T,XvMO…'T > @KšS¬$¶*· l–«­·Ož¡ ¸·O¹²VOIVOLKZ7X,JRXHVOIsjT _ VOIX…†M _ A„VaT,JKMPI  h½d]m“ˆ5d7@BQ’MPIjŒT > @!NO@BI]@ _ VaT@Bj¼VOLKNOM _ JKT > A„X¾A!WXT _ WI@! ‚QSJK@BIT,LKZ°XMvT > VaT½T > @Q’MPA3iMPI]@BIT,X.QSVOI¼[@!WX@Bj JRIvi _ VOQ’T,JRQSVOLMOiT,JRA„JK‡S@ _ XSˆ => WX+~@ > V€ŽO@j]@SŽO@BLKMOi@BjoVWIJK…†M _ A@SŽaVOLRWVaT,JKMPI9VOLKNOM _ JKT > A …»M _ T > @¾NPJKŽO@BI _ @S _ JKT@ XZ7XT@BA‚XS” > JRQ > +M _ 7X@! ‚QSJK@BIT,LKZÁMPI²jJ _ @BQ’T@Bj²XisV _ X@oN _ Vai > X3VOIj´MO…†T@BI _ @BX,WLKT,X3JRIºLRJRI@BV _ M _ \;WVOj _ VaT,JRQ VOLKNOM _ JKT > A„XSˆ => J _ j!T > @UXi@BQSJΕ³QSVaT,JKMPI‚A3@ST > M7jA!WXT [@#"s@7JK[³LK@VOIji _ MzŽ;JRj@VOI3MOi@BIXZ7XT@BAHˆ c½W _ A„@ST > M7j QSVOI > VOIsjLK@5V _ [sJKT _ V _ Z9X,MPW _ Q’@!VOIjŒJRIlT@ _ A„@BjJRVaT@LRVOI]NPWVaNO@BX¾[@BQSVOWX,@'T > @!X > Vai@5MO… T > @!N _ Vai > X"JRX¾Xi@BQSJΕs@Bj JRI¼VojsVaT,VHA3M7j]@BL¸ˆ => @MOiT,JRA‚JK‡S@ _ Q’MPA3iMPI]@BIT,XQSVOI°[@!NO@BI]@ _ VaT@Bj«JRI«XT,VOIjV _ jŒi _ MON _ VOA„A‚JRI]N‚LRVOINPWVaNO@BXS” VOIj9A„VBZƒ@BVOX,JRLKZo[@¾JRIlT@SN _ VaT@Bj9UJKT > @7JRXT,JRIN„… _ MPIlTb‘“@BIsjXÃM _ [sVOQl‘“@BIsjXSˆ =U> @3XT _ WQ’T,W _ @!MO…~T > @i³Vai@ _ JRXVOX…»MPLRLKMzUXSˆ3‰ J _ XT¾+@3j]@BA3MPIsXT _ VaT@T > @3WX,@5MO…+N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@3XZ7XT@BA„X [;Z²V±X > M _ Tƒ@7VOA„isLK@O”T > @ŒQ’MPLRLK@BQ’T,JKMPIMO…'JRIlT@ _ A„@BjJRVaT@ŒQ’M;j]@@7i _ @BX,X,JKMPIsXSˆ =U> JRXvQSVOI$[@j]@BX,Q _ JK[@Bj$[Z²V ŽO@ _ Z±X,JRA3i³LK@‚N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@oXZ;X,T@BAH” VOIj±+@ƒNPJKŽO@HVOI´JRj]@BVMO…" > JRQ > Q’M7j]@vQSVOI´[@ƒNO@BI]@ _ VaT@Bj´TM°@7@BQSW]T@ JKTSˆÁd;@BQ’T,JKMPIºCj]@’•³I]@BX5MPW _ I]MOT,JKMPIÁMO…UN _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT,JRI]NVOIsj @ > VOWX,T,JKŽO@oN _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@oXZ7XT@BA‚XSˆ d;@BQ’T,JKMPI rj]@’•³I@BX'T > @ƒXT _ VaT,JΕ³QSVaT,JKMPIÁMO…UN _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@vXZ7XT@BA„XSˆ => @BI +@vi _ @BX@BIT!JRA3iM _ T,VOIT'isV _ T,X'MO…UT > @oLRVa‡SZ Q’M7j]@‚A„MOT,JKMPI¼MOiT,JRA‚JK‡BVaT,JKMPI” JRIQSLRWjsJRI]N9XZ7IlT,VOQ’T,JRQ‚@B\;WJKŽ£VOLK@BIsQ’@‚MO…JRIT@ _ A3@BjsJRVaT@„@7i _ @BX,X,JKMPIsX%$¸X@BQ’T,JKMPI&]ˆçC(',” NPLKMO[sVOLgjVaT,V)"sMzVOIVOLKZ7X,JRX*$¸X@BQ’T,JKMPI&]ˆçr(',”VOIj«T > @ƒT _ VOIX…†M _ A„VaT,JKMPI«i > VOX@+$¸X@BQ’T,JKMPI]ˆ,-',ˆŒd7@BQ’T,JKMPI´nj]@BVOLRX UJKT > T > @‚WsIJK…»M _ A @SŽ£VOLRWsVaT,JKMPI±VOLKNOM _ JKT > AH” XT,VaT@BX5JKT,X'Q’MPXT'…»M _ MPW _ @]VOA3i³LK@BXS”YVOIj«NPJKŽO@BX!VHX > M _ TM€ŽO@ _ Ž7JK@S MO… MOT > @ _ @SŽaVOLRWVaT,JKMPI°A3@ST > M;jXBˆd7@BQ’T,JKMPIŒq‚j]@BX,Q _ JK[@BXUi _ VOQ’T,JRQSVOLþ@7i@ _ JK@BIQ’@BXU"JKT > MPW _ A3@ST > M;jˆ Ä I9M _ j]@ _ TM j]@BA„MPIXT _ VaT@!JKT,X½ŽaVOLRJRjJKTªZT > @!MOiT,JRA„JK‡S@ _ NO@BI]@ _ VaTM _ c.0/21435146 > VOX.[@S@BIŒj]@SŽO@BLKMOi@Bjˆ Ä T¾JRX½MPI]@5MO…T > @5• _ X,T TM;MPLRXg > JRQ > QSVOIƒ[@"WsX@Bj„TMXi@BQSJK…†Z3i _ MON _ VOAkVOIVOLKZ7X,JRXšO¹ .T _ VOIX…†M _ A„VaT,JKMPI¿ˆ Ä T > VOX+[@S@BIƒWX@Bj‚TM5NO@BI]@ _ VaT@ X@SŽO@ _ VOLUi _ MOTMOTªZ;isJRQSVOL.MOiT,JRA„JK‡S@ _ isV _ T,XƒJRIºT > @Q’MPA3isJRLK@ _ … _ VOA„@S~M _ Áe+Md7Z7$98~Xi _ JKT‚i _ Ma`b@BQ’Tvec Å ^ f.h:8;'  f.fUŽd]m“”gVOIj´+@Hi _ @BX,@BIlT3XMPA„@ƒ•sNPW _ @BXQ’MPIQ’@ _ IJRI]N°T > @BJ _ @! ƒQSJK@BIQ’ZOˆº®°@9Q’MPIQSLRWsj]@oT > @oisVai@ _ UJKT > V X@BQ’T,JKMPIVa[MPW]T _ @BLRVaT@Bj9~M _ oVOIjoVOI9MPW]T,LKM;MƒMPIH…†W]T,W _ @¾~M _ ³ˆ

(7)

Block

Stmt

Expr

::=

Collect-Expressions-1

Block

Stmt

Expr

Proc

Proc

Proc

Block

Expr

Stmt

Collect-Expressions-1

Stmts

Exprs

Stmts

Exprs

Blocks

Blocks

AllExprs

Blocks

AllExprs

Stmts

Exprs

‰þJKNPW _ @„p  "!# $%egMPLRLK@BQ’T,JKMPI9MO… @7i _ @BX,X,JKMPIsXÅ _ MPA T > @XT,VaT@BA„@BIlT.LRJRXT,X

&(')+*-,/. 01/2435241768:9<;4=?>@/AB/CED3GFH8JIK9<17;4=L/M7AB(NPO/Q RJS(TPSUO/Q"VWJX/@UO

Y *-,J)+*-,. 03[Z]\K3GFH8JI^9<17;`_/M7MaVWJX/@UO b <dcegf:hji#k[lUmnilJo<o%pPq(r[iGsJmutpJv >@/AB7wgL/M7AB(NPwRJS(TPSUwxVWJX/@ < b y{zg|J}g~~+€‚„ƒ \^1/…5†zˆ‡^‰JŠ y{zg|J}g~u~ ‹„Œ€-C?F<1/…#Ž/=†z‡Š y{zg|J}g~~+=‘Œ‹-C’/IK6 IK=†zˆ‡{“/Š

y{z |a}g~~ 3”„=aC•+–P€4\K=†zˆ‡n—UŠ

b <d˜iG™4i^šjvnpPf:e"™ ›B< b €-CœF<FH• –U€4\^=žŸ37  ‰ JKNPW _ @'CE~f"IHVOLKNOM _ JKT > A X,MPLKŽ;JRI]N¡   /gx!^ $ ¢5£(¢ ¤¦¥§+¨[©«ª§+¨(¥¬ => JRX X@BQ’T,JKMPI3i _ @BX@BIT,XV¾X > M _ T@7VOA„isLK@Oˆ ®°@UXi@BQSJK…»Z!V¾N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@X,Z;XT@BA T > VaTVaTT,VOQ > @BX~VOLRL@;i _ @BX,X,JKMPIX JRI´T > @HX,T,VaT@BA3@BIT3LRJRXTMO….VŒi _ M;Q’@BjsW _ @ƒTM°T > @oi _ M7Q’@BjW _ @ƒMO[]`b@BQ’TSˆ => @oX,JRA3i³LK@‚N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@HXZ7XT@BA JRI ‰ JKNPW _ @°pvQ’MPIX,JRX,T,X!MPILKZ«MO…"MPI]@ _ WLK@%¡  "!# $"x­;ˆ => @„•sNPW _ @ƒQ’MPIT,VOJRIXT > @ _ WsLK@ƒJRI´TÕ~M …†M _ A„XBˆ = MT > @vLK@S…†T5T > @vM _ JKNPJRIVOL _ @S _ JKT@ _ WLK@vJRX!j _ V€UIˆ Ä …UV _ WLK@ƒMPILKZ±VOjjX'@Bj]NO@BXS” +@ƒQSVOIÁVOLRX,MŒWsX@ƒV X > M _ T > VOIj‚…»M _ AH”l > JRQ > j _ V€UX~T > @ _ Wmail protected]ŽaV _ JRVOIlTgisV _ T~MPILKZ„MPIQ’@O”]VOIjƒT > @.VOjsj]@Bj„@BjNO@BX+V _ @½jsVOX > @Bjˆ => JRX X,JRA„isLRJΕs@BXgT > @'Xi@BQSJΕ³QSVaT,JKMPIXSˆ ®°@¾VOX,X*WA3@T > VaT~T > @½JRIT@ _ A3@BjJRVaT@ _ @Si _ @BX@BIlT,VaT,JKMPIƒi _ M€Ž7JRj]@BX+T > @UMO[]`b@BQ’T+TªZ;i@BX¯®E°?±²;” ³´+±² µ”?¶+· ¸?·”VOIj ¹º » °³”VOX+~@BLRLVOX~T > @½jJ _ @BQ’T@Bj _ @BLRVaT,JKMPIX¼³´+±² µ½;”?¶+·+¸¾·½;”lVOIj ¹º » °½;ˆ¼ / gx!^ $4x­½VaTT,VOQ > @BX VOLRLY@;i _ @BX,X,JKMPIX"MO…VOLRLþXT,VaT@BA3@BIT,X.JRIV‚i _ M7Q’@BjW _ @'JRIlTMvV‚jsJ _ @BQ’T@Bj _ @BLRVaT,JKMPIÀ¿´E´ ¹º» °½+JK… VOI9@BjNO@Á³´+±²-µ½ @]JRXT,X[@STª+@S@BIºVŒi _ M;Q’@BjW _ @®E°¾±¾²VOIj´VŒ[sLKM;Qó´ ±¾²-µ³”~VOIj±T > @ _ @HJRXVOIÁ@Bj]NO@Ķ+· ¸?·½H… _ MPAų´ ±² µ¼TM¼V XT,VaT@BA„@BIlT]¶%· ¸¾·³”þVOIj°T > @ _ @‚JRXVOI¼@BjNO@ ¹ º» °9… _ MPAƶ+· ¸?·TMVOI¼@7i _ @BX*X,JKMPI ¹º » °s”YT > @BI°T > @ _ @„UJRLRL[@3VOI @Bj]NO@Ç¿´´ ¹º » °½!… _ MPAÈ®°¾±²TM ¹º» °³ˆ =U> WX"T > @5MPILKZVOQ’T,JKMPIŒ > JRQ >  / "!^ $¾i@ _ …»M _ A‚XUJRX TM„VOjsjo@Bj]NO@BXMO…LRVa[@BL«¿´´ ¹ º» °½TM‚T > @ > MPXTUN _ Vai > ˆ c¾W _ VOJRAÂJRXTMNO@BI]@ _ VaT@ƒMOiT,JRA„JK‡S@ _ XVOIj«MOiT,JRA„JK‡S@ _ isV _ T,X'VOW]TMPA„VaT,JRQSVOLRLKZ … _ MPA Xi@BQSJΕ³QSVaT,JKMPIXSˆ =U> WXB” NPJKŽO@BIoT > JRXgN _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@¾XZ7XT@BA9”;V5i _ VOQ’T,JRQSVOL¿MOiT,JRA„JK‡S@ _ NO@BI]@ _ VaTM _ X > MPWLRjƒNO@BI]@ _ VaT@VOIv@7@BQSW]T,Va[sLK@¾i _ M;Q’@’‘ jW _ @TM[@@BA5[@Bjj]@BjJRITM'V'Q’MPA3isJRLK@ _ ˆc. /2143 146´JRXX,WQ > V¾TM;MPL¸”]VOIj3‰ JKNPW _ @½CQ’MPIT,VOJRIX~T > @ULRVBZOMPWT~MO…T > @ Q’M7j]@‚JKT'NO@BI]@ _ VaT@BX5…†M _  / "!^ $Oˆ„‰]M _ MPW _ @]VOA3isLK@‚~@ƒVOX,X,WA„@T > VaTT > @3NPJKŽO@BI _ @BLRVaT,JKMPIX V _ @ _ @Si _ @BX@BIT@BjvVOXÃX@ST,XÃMO…YI@BJKN > [M _ X@ST,XÃJRIvMO[]`b@BQ’T,X $¸jJ _ @BQ’T@BjvN _ Vai > X+UJKT > @BA5[@Bjj]@BjƒI]@BJKN > [M _ X@ST,X!',ˆ~f"X VOLRLsMO[]`¦@BQ’T,XB” > JRQ > A‚VBZ![@A„VaT,Q > @Bj3[;Z   /gx!^ $4x­;”PA!WXT[@ _ @BVOQ > Va[sLK@"… _ MPAkV¾i _ M7Q’@BjW _ @ Ž7JRVHT > @ƒj]@SisJRQ’T@Bj _ @BLRVaT,JKMPIXS” +@‚X,JRA„isLKZNO@BI@ _ VaT@ƒX,@SŽO@ _ VOLLKM;MOisX'M€ŽO@ _ T > @ _ @BLK@SŽaVOIT'I]@BJKN > [M _ X@ST,XSˆ Ä I¼MPW _ QSVOX@T > @ _ WLK@!T@BXT¾Q’MPIjJKT,JKMPI¼JRX½ŽO@ _ ZX,JRA3i³LK@% > @BI]@SŽO@ _ +@ > VBŽO@@BI;WA„@ _ VaT@BjŒVoX,WJKT,Va[sLK@!i@ _ A!W]T,VaT,JKMPIMO… I]M7j]@BX $¸V¼¥– –,˜ ',”Y~@‚j _ VB VOI¼@Bj]NO@[@STª+@S@BI¼T > @QSW _,_ @BIlTˆ®E°?±²z‘ªI]M;j@5VOIjŒT > @3QSW _,_ @BIT ¹ º» °P‘ªI]M7j]@Oˆ Ä …+~@ LKM;M°VaTT > @ _ @BX,WsLKT,JRI]NHVOLKNOM _ JKT > A X,W]i@ _ •³QSJRVOLRLKZO”üJKT > VOXQ’MPXTÊÉ5$Ë®°¾±¾²Ë{˳´+±² µ½Ë{Ë<¶%· ¸?·5Ë{Ë ¹º » °«Ë',ˆUMz~@SŽO@ _ ”þJRI A„MPXTÃJRIlT@ _ A„@BjJRVaT@ _ @Si _ @BX@BIT,VaT,JKMPIXÃT > @A„@BIlT,JKMPI]@Bj _ @BLRVaT,JKMPIXņM _ A V!T _ @S@’‘ªLRJ O@5XT _ WQ’T,W _ @½ > JRQ > i³V _ T,JKT,JKMPIX T > @MO[]`¦@BQ’T,XBˆ => WXÃ+@NO@STUV3LRJRI]@BV _ VOLKNOM _ JKT > A JRIoT > @I;WA5[@ _ MO…þ@7i _ @BX,X,JKMPIsXSˆ

(8)

Intermediate code

Transformation

Frontend

Backend

....

Analysis 1

Analysis n

IC+information

Intermediate code’

Specification

Specification

Specification

generates

generates

generates

‰ JKNPW _ @9rEo®°@ _ @SNPV _ j´T > @oMOiT,JRA‚JK‡BVaT,JKMPIÁi _ M7Q’@BX,X3VOXV°X,@B\W]@BIsQ’@oMO…"N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@HXZ7XT@BA VaisisLRJRQSVaT,JKMPIXSˆ => JRQ v[M 7@BXV _ @i > VOX@BXà > JRQ > V _ @NO@BI@ _ VaT@BjH… _ MPA Xi@BQSJΕ³QSVaT,JKMPIsXSˆ ¢5£  ©%©¨  ¥ ˆ§ ¾§ ¥ ® > @BIƒ~@½Xi@BQSJK…†Zi _ MON _ VOAVOIVOLKZ7X,JRXÃVOIj‚T _ VOIX…†M _ A„VaT,JKMPI„UJKT > N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT,JRIN+@½VaTT,VOJRIvV5WIJK…†M _ AkŽ;JK@S MO…T > @ÃJRIlT@ _ A3@BjJRVaT@LRVOI]NPWsVaNO@UVOIj!T > @VOIVOLKZ7X,JRX JRI…»M _ A‚VaT,JKMPIü@SŽO@ _ ZT > JRINJRX _ @Si _ @BX@BIT@Bj3VOX N _ Vai > XS”PVOIjVOLRL VOQ’T,JKMPIX¾V _ @'j]MPI]@'[ZoN _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT,JRI]N]ˆ Å M _ @SMzŽO@ _ ”~@5QSVOIŒXisLRJKT"VOIsj9Q’MPVOLK@BX,Q’@3Xi@BQSJΕ³QSVaT,JKMPIsX"@BVOX*JRLKZO” > JRQ > @BIVa[³LK@BX'A„M;jWsLRV _ Q’MPA3iMPX,JKT,JKMPI MO…gi _ MON _

VOA MOiT,JRA„JK‡BVaT,JKMPIsXSˆ UMz~@SŽO@

_ ”  > @BI«~@ƒJRIQ _ @BVOX@ƒT > @„I;WA5[@ _ MO… _ WsLK@BXS” ~@vA„V€Z°@BVOX,JRLKZ«Xi@BQSJK…†Z¼I]MPI7‘“T@ _ A‚JRIVaT,JRI]NHM _ I]MPI7‘ªj@ST@ _ A„JRIJRX,T,JRQ3XZ7XT@BA„XSˆ => WsXJKT!JRX[@STT@ _ TMjJΑ Ž7JRj]@.T > @"MOisT,JRA„JK‡BVaT,JKMPIvi _ M7Q’@BX,X+JRIlTMV5X@B\;W]@BIQ’@.MO…¿N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@½XZ7XT@BA VaiisLRJRQSVaT,JKMPIXg > JRQ > V _ @½X@SisV _ VaT@ VOIj«T > WsXX,A„VOLRLK@ _ $¸‰þJKNPW _ @ƒr(',ˆ8VOQ > MO…gT > @BX@„N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@„XZ7XT@BA„XNO@BI]@ _ VaT@BX5Voi _ M7Q’@BjW _ @3JRI«T > @„JRA3‘ isLK@BA„@BIlT,VaT,JKMPI«LRVOI]NPWVaNO@3MO…+T > @3Q’MPA3i³JRLK@ _ ”¿VOIjŒT > JRX½i _ M;Q’@BjW _ @JRX¾QSVOLRLK@Bj¼… _ MPA T > @3A„VOJRIŒQ’MPA„isJRLK@ _¾_ MPW]T,JRI]@ Vaii _ MOi _ JRVaT@BLKZOˆ =U> @½MOiT,JRA„JK‡BVaT,JKMPI9i _ M7Q’@BX,XÃXT,V _ T,XgUJKT > V!N _ Vai > NPJKŽO@BIo[;Z‚T > @½… _ MPITb‘“@BIj”] > JRQ > JRXgT > @Va[sXb‘ T _ VOQ’T¾XZ7IT,VT _ @S@5M _ T > @5JRIT@ _ A„@BjJRVaT@Q’M;j]@!X@B\;W]@BIQ’@Oˆ½‰ J _ XT.i _ MON _ VOA VOIVOLKZ7X,JRX½JRX.i@ _ …»M _ A„@Bjˆ = Zi³JRQSVOLRLKZ T > JRXUJRXÃjJKŽ;JRj@BjoJRIlTM3X@SŽO@ _ VOLN _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@XZ;X,T@BA„XS”]VOA3MPIN' > JRQ > V _ @¾MPI]@¾M _ X,@SŽO@ _ VOL¿jVaT,V£‘4"sMz VOIVOLKZ7X@BXSˆ => @BIT > @T _ VOIX…†M _ A„JRIN„N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@3XZ7XT@BA„X½QSVOIŒ[@5VaisisLRJK@Bjˆ'f"…†T@ _ XMPA3@!JKT@ _ VaT,JKMPIXMO…~VOIVOLKZ7X@BXVOIj T _ VOIsX…»M _ A„VaT,JKMPIXÃT > @A3M7jJΕs@BjoQ’M7j]@JRX > VOIsj]@BjvM€ŽO@ _ TM3T > @¾[sVOQl‘“@BIsjˆ =U> @VOj]ŽaVOIlT,VaNO@BX"MO… T > JRXX,Q > @BA3@'V _ @T > @…†MPLRLKM€"JRI]N]ˆ+‰ J _ X,TS”sV3X,WJKT,Va[³LK@XisLRJKTUJRITM‚X*A„VOLRLK@ _ N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@ XZ7XT@BA‚X"JRXMPLRVaT@BXI]MPI7‘ªQ’MPI-"³W@BIQ’@@@BQ’T,X¾VOIjzM _½_ @BXMPLKŽO@BX¾IMPI7‘“T@ _ A„JRIsVaT,JKMPIˆ½d;@BQ’MPIsj”³…†M _ X,A„VOLRLK@ _ XZ7XT@BA„X +@HQSVOI´MO…»T@BI´NO@BI@ _ VaT@9LRJRI]@BV _ M _ \;WVOj _ VaT,JRQvVOLKNOM _ JKT > A„X![@BQSVOWX@oX,A‚VOLRLK@ _5_ @S _ JKT@oXZ7XT@BA„X5MO…†T@BI > VBŽO@HV LKMz~@ _ ·O¥ l–S¥gT > VOIH[sJKNONO@ _ MPI]@BX $¸X@BQ’T,JKMPI°n(',ˆ => J _ j¿”]T > JRXUjJKŽ7JRX,JKMPIo[ _ @BV ;XUT > @MOiT,JRA‚JK‡BVaT,JKMPI9T,VOX Hj]M€UI9JRIlTM Q’MPA„iMPI@BIlT+i _ MO[sLK@BA‚X > JRQ > QSVOIv[@½XMPLKŽO@BjoJRIj]@Si@BIj]@BIT,LKZOˆ Ä …¿~@¾j]MI]MOT+•³Isj‚V5N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@¾XZ;X,T@BA …»M _ VvQ’@ _ T,VOJRIŒT,VOX”M _ XMPA3@!j]@SŽO@BLKMOi@BjŒXZ7XT@BA T,W _ IX"MPW]T.TMv[@5TM;MvX*LKM€”+@5QSVOI°VOLKgVBZ7XX,WXT,JKT,W]T@!JKT½[Z9V > VOIsj7‘“ _ JKTT@BI¼VOLKNOM _ JKT > AHˆ Ä I°VOIZ@SŽO@BITS” T > JRXJRX¾T > @„QSVOX@3…†M _ T > @3… _ MPITb‘“@BIj¼VOIj¼T > @[sVOQ ‘“@BIj T > @SZ°V _ @ JRA„isLK@BA3@BIT@BjoVOXUWX*WVOL¸ˆ Ä I°M _ j@ _ TM9A‚V O@3T > JRXX,Q > @BA3@+M _ ”þVOLRLXi@BQSJΕs@Bj¼VOIj > VOIj7‘“ _ JKTT@BI«VOLKNOM _ JKT > A„X > VBŽO@‚TM _ @S…†@ _ TMV WIsJK…»M _ A jVaT,VA3M7j]@BL;MO…T > @UJRIT@ _ A3@BjsJRVaT@ _ @Si _ @BX,@BIlT,VaT,JKMPIˆ =U> @ _ @S…†M _ @ÃT > @Õ _ XT XT@Si3MO…T > @UA„@ST > M7jQ’MPIX,JRXT,X

(9)

MO…þj]@SŽO@BLKMOisJRI]NV PšOž“š‚­· l– üM _ ¤O¥bšŸ§™vœ’¶S™7–S­š…†M _ T > @½JRIlT@ _ A„@BjJRVaT@ _ @Si _ @BX,@BIlT,VaT,JKMPI  d]Q > m7p!  d;®mOn“ˆ®°@ > V€ŽO@TM„A„M;j@BL³T > @…»MPLRLKMzUJRI]N¾ paˆ"T > @TÕZi@BX"MO…N _ Vai > IM;j]@BXBˆgf.A3MPIN3T > @BX@5V _ @'JRIT@ _ A3@BjsJRVaT@'Q’M7j]@'JRIX,T _ WQ’T,JKMPIX.X,WQ > VOX"@;i _ @BX,X,JKMPIXS” XT,VaT@BA3@BIT,XS”LKM;MOisXS”ÃVOIj²i _ M7Q’@BjW _ @BXSˆ‹f"LRX,M«i _ @SŽ7JKMPWX,LKZÁVOIVOLKZ;‡S@Bj‹JRI]…»M _ A„VaT,JKMPI²QSVOI$[@o@BIQ’M7j]@Bj²JRI I]M7j]@BXgMO… N _ Vai > XS”]@OˆN]ˆsŽ£V _ JRVa[³LK@j]@’•³IJKT,JKMPIsXS”M _ @7i _ @BX,X*JKMPIo@B\WsJKŽ£VOLK@BIQ’@5QSLRVOX,X@BXSˆ C;ˆ"T > @„TÕZi@BXMO…ÃN _ Vai > @Bj]NO@BX $ _ @BLRVaT,JKMPIX!',ˆ9®°@ > V€ŽO@‚TMA3M7j]@BL VOLRL~i _ @BjJRQSVaT@BX'~@‚UJRX > TMJRI]…†@ _ Va[MPW]T T > @vi _ MON _ VOA9” J¸ˆ@OˆT > @ _ @BLRVaT,JKMPIX[@STÕ~@S@BI´T > @vMO[]`b@BQ’T,XMO…"T > @oJRIlT@ _ A„@BjJRVaT@ _ @Si _ @BX@BIlT,VaT,JKMPI¿ˆ´d;MPA„@ @7VOA„isLK@BXþV _ @ _ @BLRVaT,JKMPIXX,WQ >

VOX QSLRVOX,X,JRQSVOL "³M€Áj]@Si@BIj]@BIQSJK@BXB”£@B\;WJKŽaVOLK@BIQ’@

_ @BLRVaT,JKMPIXS”PQSVOLRLRJRIN _ @BLRVaT,JKMPIXS” M _ Q’MPIT _ MPL "sMz _ @BLRVaT,JKMPIXSˆ f"LRXMÁT > @¼JRI]…»M _ A„VaT,JKMPI¨T > @°… _ MPITb‘“@BIj¨i _ M;jWsQ’@BXS”U@OˆN]ˆ"@;i _ @BX,X,JKMPIT _ @S@ iMPJRIlT@ _ JRINM _ XT,VaT@BA„@BIlTULRJRX,T,XS”sA!WXTg[@A3M7j]@BLK@Bjˆ  @S…†M _ @Ã+@gj@BA3MPIXT _ VaT@+T > @+iMz~@ _ MO…MPW _ Xi@BQSJΕ³QSVaT,JKMPIA3@ST > M7j'UJKT > X@SŽO@ _ VOL7@]VOA3isLK@BXþ+@j]@’•³I]@gXMPA„@ T > @SM _ Zƒ > JRQ > @BIsX,W _ @BXgT > VaTUT > @NPJKŽO@BIHN _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@XZ7XT@BA„Xg[@ > V€ŽO@i _ MOi@ _ LKZOˆ    *-!+, "- "  (-!%UB "kk  => JRX+X,@BQ’T,JKMPIoj]@’•³I]@BX~MPW _ I]MOT,JKMPIƒMO…¿N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@.X,Z;XT@BA9”;X,MPA3@½I]@S$T@ _ A„JRIVaT,JKMPIƒM _ j]@ _ JRI]NPXS”7VOIjœŸž¡¥bšOž¡ µ ¶(šOž¡ †·P¹MO…N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT,JRI]N]ˆ =U> @ _ @BX,WLKT,JRI]N¾N _ Vai > _ @S _

JKT@ÃXZ7XT@BA QSLRVOX*X@BXQSVOI![@ÃWX@BjI]MOT MPILKZ5…†M

_ i _ MON _ VOA VOIVOLKZ7X,JRX[sW]T¾VOLRXMH…†M _ T _ VOIX,…»M _ A‚VaT,JKMPIˆ‰ J _ XT¾+@3j]@’•³I]@3XMPA„@I]@S QSLRVOX,X@BXMO…+T@ _ A„JRIVaT,JRI]NvN _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@

XZ7XT@BA‚XS”üQSVOLRLK@Bj‹– €¤l– ¦š1O †ž¡ »¢a–’”g– €¤l– “œ’› Sž¡¥bšP¶Bž¡ †¢£–S”üVOIj´œ’›Bž¡¥¦šl¶Bž¡ †¢£–½N

_ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@‚XZ;X,T@BA„XSˆ!fkX*W][QSLRVOX,X½MO… @Bj]NO@’‘ªVOjsjJKT,JKŽ[email protected],Z;XT@BA‚X V _ @5– €¤l–š11O †ž¡ †·P¹H¥b–B©¥( †žª–"œ’¬€œ’žª–S­'œ  f lmOn£[ “ˆ => @BI+@i _ @BX@BIlT~V!œŸž¡¥bšOž¡ µ~¶*šOž¡ ¸·O¹ > @BW7‘ _ JRX,T,JRQ¾…»M _ N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@XZ7XT@BA„XB”] > JRQ > NPJKŽO@BXUV3WIsJR\W]@X,@BA„VOIT,JRQSXÃTM„A„VOIZvI]MPI7‘ªj]@ST@ _ A‚JRIJRXT,JRQ¾XZ7XT@BA‚XSˆ £(¢ +ª     ¨G§%¨a¬   y€{üw => _ MPW]N > MPW]TÃT > JRXÃisVai@ _ ~@'Q’MPIX,JRj]@ __ @S _

JKT,JRI]NPXUMO… O †¥–,¶Bžª– +¥– KšOž¡ ¸·O¹sšã”VOIj Kš *– K– N

_

Vai

>

XSˆ

vÈ! #"%$»x$†Ì" '&

–Sž)( *– šoµ¹s »žª–°œS–Bž„· #¼¶*·O¹]œŸž“šO¹ž†œ*Hž†™7–LRVa[@BLRX,+-(À Ñœ°ž†™7– O œ/.’›;¹³¶Bž3›7¹ ¸·O¹Š· #°ž¡© ·ÁœB–Sž†œ

(102(43657(489Už†™7–'I]M;j@šO¹ ‚@Bj]NO@3LRVa[@BLRX:+<;ü™7–S¹´š $

_

@BLRVaT,JKMPIVOL'=(+‘?>!@BA CEDGFH0 $IKJMLNJMOQPASR '¶(·O¹7œ’ Ñœ’ž†œ‚· #

ž†™7– #S·ηP© »¹¤T+

U

+VI  Ñœ'š"µ¹s »žª–œS–Bž+·#UI]M7j]@BX:+

W

+YX·l–ŸœšO¥– Kš (– R– ƒ© »ž†™*Kš *– åœ!#’¥¦·O­2(43 B¬3š%#’›7¹s¶Bž¡ ¸·O¹ZOQPASRTI\[](43^+`_9–'¶*š ¿š3¹³· l–'© »ž†™*Kš *– aP

PbÕ¹s·l– +c;ü™7–œB–Sž%I)dE0e OgfhIŒËOQPASR$O '%0iPkj^l6I · #5š Pk¦¹s· –Ÿœ #S·O¥Ÿ­œ'š5I]M7j]@j]MPA‚VOJRIm+

n

+o;ü™7–U@Bj]NO@BXVLpl $Irq`Isqh( '%0e Ltdml6IuqoIvj d

Bwax

 œš #SšO­! ά„· # S †¹sšO¥Ÿ¬

_

@BLRVaT,JKMPIX·O¢a–S¥4Isq`Iy

©þ™7–S¥––,šl¶’™– z¤l–YzYfKL  Ñœ Kš *– K– )S¬„š{P%f|( 8 +o_9–5¶(šYšO¹¼– €¤–5© »ž†™)Kš *– P9Pb– €¤– +

Ä A3i³LRJRQSJKT,LKZVOX,X,M;QSJRVaT@Bj UJKT > F V _ @3X@SŽO@ _ VOL…†WIsQ’T,JKMPIXSˆ}z PASRÇL~[(48$i _ Ma`b@BQ’T,XVOI¼@Bj]NO@3TM9JKT,XLRVa[@BL¸ˆ => @ņWIsQ’T,JKMPIX€,‚ƒ@B„…z†Jˆ‡ˆAT@,>Sz…‡`TL1[‰I i _ MzŽ;JRj]@"XMPW _ Q’@UVOIsj!T,V _ NO@ST+IM;j]@BX …†M _ @BjNO@BXSˆ ®°@"X,V€Z5T > VaTŠzYfKL—JRX  †¹s¶B ,l–B¹ž7TM^€:‚ƒ@B„…z$‹z 'üVOIj{‡ˆAT@,>Sz…‡!$‹z '¿ > JRLK@ €:‚ƒ@†„…z $‹z'üVOIjŒ‡ˆAT@,>Sz…‡!$‹z 'YV _ @š1.SšP¶(–B¹ž¸ˆ f.LRL]VOja`bVOQ’@BIT I]M7j]@BXþMO…V I]M7j]@¾V _ @QSVOLRLK@BjHJKT,X¹³–S R¤£™-*·O¥½œB–Sž¸ˆ =>

@½…¸WIQ’T,JKMPI° †¹a l–ª¤P¥b–(–4TIŽ[IMO…þVIM;j]@½JRXÃT

>

@¾I;WA5[@

_

MO…þJRIQ’MPA„JRI]N

JRIQSJRj@BIlT@Bj]NO@BXo †¹a l–ª¤P¥b–(–$O ')0 ˑe,zyfiL¡ˆAT@,>Sz…‡!$‹z '{0’OjË㈱d7JRA‚JRLRV

_ LKZ«j]@’•I]@‚T > @ƒ…¸WIQ’T,JKMPI¨·O›7ž? l–ª¤P¥b–(–!TM [@vT > @oIWsA'[@ _

MO…UMPW]TNOMPJRIN¼JRIQSJRj]@BIT@Bj]NO@BXH·O›7ž?–ª¤O¥–*– $O 'Œ0 ˑe,z“fLÂ˔€,‚ƒ@B„…z$‹z'•0’OjË㈠f¯IM;j]@ƒUJKT

>

 †¹a l–ª¤P¥b–(–$O '=0H–JRX5QSVOLRLK@Bj¥¦·€·Ož¸ˆ

Ä …ÃI]@BQ’@BX,X,V _ ZO”~@ƒJRIj]@¼T > @ƒQ’MPA3iMPI]@BIT,XMO…Vg(~‘“N _ Vai > F~0 $IŒ—JMLt—J OQPASR — ',”@;T@BIj‚T > @…¸WIQ’T,JKMPIsXOQPA˜R+VOIjZz PA˜RgTM'X@ST,XMO…JKT@BA‚XS”VOIsj3WX@ †¹a l–ª¤P¥b–(–~VOIj9·O›7ž? l–ª¤P¥b–(– _ @BXT _ JRQ’T@Bj TM„X,i@BQSJΕQ¾@Bj]NO@LRVa[@BLRXSˆ

(10)

egMPIlT _ V _ ZTM¾MOT > @ _ Vaii _ MPVOQ > @BXJRI!T > @gLRJKT@ _ VaT,W _ @Ã+@gjM½IMOT j@BVOL"JKT > V _ [sJKT _ V _ Z5A5WsLKT,JΑ“N _ Vai > XSˆ  @BQSVOWX@ L2l $Iq I qV(48 ',”O[@STÕ~@S@BI5Tª+M¾I]M7j]@BXYX,@SŽO@ _ VOL;@Bj]NO@BX V _ @+VOLRLKMz~@Bj¿” > M€+@SŽO@ _ ”PT > @BJ _ LRVa[@BLRX A!WXT¿[@+jJRXT,JRIQ’TSˆ ‰]M _ T > @'isW _ iMPX@BXgMO…MOisT,JRA„JK‡BVaT,JKMPIŒJKT"JRX.I]MOT"I@BQ’@BX,X,V _ ZoTMƒVOLRLKM€ X@SŽO@ _ VOLY@Bj][email protected]… T > @'X,VOA„@LRVa[@BL¿[@STª+@S@BI TÕ~M„IM;j]@BXx@Bj]NO@BX _ @Si _ @BX@BIlTÃi _ @BjJRQSVaT@BXÃMPIoT > @BJ _ XMPW _ Q’@VOIsjvT,V _ NO@STUI]M7j]@½MO[]`b@BQ’T,XS”sVOIjoV!i _ @BjJRQSVaT@@BJKT > @ _ > MPLRjsXUM _ j]M;@BX"I]MOT > MPLRjˆ UMz~@SŽO@ _ ”¿JKT½JRX"ŽO@ _ Z9JRA3iM _ T,VOITTM > VBŽO@jJ@ _ @BIT _ @BLRVaT,JKMPIX.[@BQSVOWsX@+@'gVOIT"TM _ @Si _ @BX@BIT5jJ@ _ @BIT 7JRIjXMO…UJRI]…†M _ A„VaT,JKMPIˆc¾I¼T > @ƒMOT > @ _ > VOIj” VOLKT > MPW]N > VaTT _ JK[sWT@BX'…†M _ I]M;j@BXA„V€Z°[@ JRIT _ M7jWQ’@Bj”¿T > JRX¾JRXLK@S…»T¾MPWT¾…»M _ T > @3X*V O@MO…+X,JRA„isLRJRQSJKTªZOˆ Ä …~j]@BX*JKNPI]@Bj¼QSV _ @S…¸WLRLKZ$†MPILKZJRIT@SNO@ _ ŽaVOLRW]@BXS”üMPILKZ A‚VaT,Q > JRI]N5JRI _ WLK@BX!',”7I]M;j@UVaTT _ JK[sW]T@BX+j]M5I]MOT~Q > VOI][email protected] > @ _ @BX,WLKT,X MO[sT,VOJRI]@BjvJRI3T > JRX~isVai@ _ ”l[@BQSVOWX,@UT > @SZ3QSVOI [@X@S@BIVOXÃ@;T@BIsX,JKMPIHMO… T > @I]M7j]@LRVa[@BL¿X@ST (43½ˆ d7@SŽO@ _ VOLMOi@ _ VaT,JKMPIX+MPIh(~‘“N _ Vai > XgV _ @¾XT,VOIsjV _ j‚@;T@BIX*JKMPIXgMO…üX@STgMOi@ _ VaT,JKMPIXgMzŽO@ _ I]M;j@BX+VOIsj„@Bj]NO@BXBˆf (~‘“N _ Vai > F0F ‰ 5oF  JRXUQSVOLRLK@Bj«›7¹ ¸·O¹MO…F ‰ VOIj|F 

”JK…#F 0 $I{— 5ZI{—:JMLt—5}Lt—,JMOQPA˜R —%5NOQPASR — ',ˆ

d7JRA‚JRLRV _ LKZ3j]@’•³I@T > @=(~‘“N _ Vai > ‘ªJRIT@ _ X@BQ’T,JKMPI«VOIj3T > @Y(~‘“N _ Vai > ‘ªJRIQSLRWX*JKMPI¾ˆ => @ O  .–S¥–S¹³¶(–ŠF 0F ‰ F  MO…F ‰ VOIj F  JRX F10 $Ir0 I —  I — ,JMLÂË3^JOQPASR —  Ë3 ',ˆ => @X,@STUMO… VOLRL#(~‘“N _ Vai > XUM€ŽO@ _ (¨JRX.QSVOLRLK@Bj w ˆ => @X@STMO…VOLRL (~‘“N _ Vai > XÃM€ŽO@ _ V!• 7@BjHX@STMO… I]M7j]@BX I ” w 3 ‘0 $ w Ë3=J*5ŠJ ',”…†M _ A„XÃV5•³IsJKT@LRVaTT,JRQ’@Oˆ f-(~‘“N _ Vai > ‘ªA3M _ i >

JRX,A’> mF-[ Q’MPIX*JRXT,XMO…gTÕ~M…†WIsQ’T,JKMPIX > 3 QI — [IkVOIj7> 8 QL — [ L

 > JRQ > …¸WLΕ³LTÕ~MƒQ’MPIjJKT,JKMPIX" /†{su È/YyzÈ;wBÈ;y]{]x$†Ì"

O7fhI —  OQPA˜R $/>B3$O ''0'OQPASR — $O ',”

 z=fhL — !z:PA˜R$/>B8;$‹z ''#0z:PASR — $‹z' $?"ü|!$†ÍþÈS"ü|PÈ|þyzȝwBÈ7y7{x$†ÌE" z\f Lt— y€:‚ƒ@†„…z 8 $/> 8 $‹z''0 > 3 $‹€,‚ƒ@B„…z 8 $‹z'',”h‡ˆAT@,>Sz…‡ 8 $/> 8 $‹z''0 >B3 $‡A!@,>Sz ‡ˆ8  $‹z'' Ä …[MOT > > 3 VOIjy> 8 V _ @vJRIa`b@BQ’T,JKŽO@O”#>«JRX'QSVOLRLK@Bj¨ †¹….B–,¶€ž¡ »¢a–’ˆ Ä …Ã[MOT > > 3 VOIjy> 8 V _ @vX,W _ `¦@BQ’T,JKŽO@O”#>¼JRX!QSVOLRLK@Bj œ’›;¥/.B–,¶Bž¡ †¢£–Sˆ Ä …#>JRX¾JRIa`b@BQ’T,JKŽO@„VOIjŒX,W _ `¦@BQ’T,JKŽO@3JKTJRX¾VOI´ œ’·O­·O¥ª§™ œŸ­5ˆ{> 3! :> 8‹V _ @!MO…»T@BI¼@;T@BIj@BjŒTMvX,@ST,X¾MO… I]M7j]@BX½VOIj@Bj]NO@BXSˆ Ä …QSLK@BV _ … _ MPA Q’MPIlT@7TS”> 3! :> 8‹V _ @VOLRXMoQSVOLRLK@Bj >sˆ®°@!MO…†T@BIŒ _ JKT@Œ>SFJRIXT@BVOjŒMO…> $‹F' TM„X*VBŽO@[ _ VOQ O@ST,XSˆ   y€{$y€ÈË‚y†$»x€È9y /†È;w Ä IvM _ j]@ _ TMj]@’•³I@.N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@ _ WsLK@BXÃVOIjƒTM3VOLRLKM€—X,MPA3@¾A3M _ @.@7i _ @BX,X,JKŽO@BI@BX,XņM _ T > @BJ _ LK@S…»Tb‘ > VOIjoX,JRj]@BXS” +@¾• _ X,T > VBŽO@TM‚@;T@BIsjoT > @j]@’•IJKT,JKMPIoMO… V}(~‘?>!@BA:CEDˆ vÈ! #"%$»x$†Ì"   (#";‘“N _ Vai >%$

0 $IKJMLNJaOQPA˜R:JMOmz >SA ‡Mz&('5 œ½š^(Y¸¤P¥¦šŸ§s™ šO›P¤O­3–S¹žª– 5S¬š #’›7¹s¶Bž¡ ¸·O¹H¹³–Õ¤PšOžª– ˆ

LŽ[) ©þ™ ¸¶’™«žª– 眂©þ™7–Sž†™]–S¥‚šP¹²– €¤–•z°· #„ž†™7–„¤O¥bšŸ§™  œ„¹³–ª¤lšOžª– +*¦¹³–Õ¤PšOžª–  $‹z'=0 ž¡¥Ÿ›]–,'+

$ ™;š£œvšŒ¥b– ΚOžª–  ( ¡¤O¥bšŸ§™ $-.,/ © †ž†™ŒšY¹–ª¤PšPžª– – €¤l–’œ'œ’ž¡¥( ç§P§7– 0* $-.,/ 0 $I|JML

e,zNfgLÂËOmz >SA ‡Mz& $‹z'401‡b@†ƒEzBjBJMOQPA˜R1'+ ;ü™7–

œB–Sžg· #'š(#"¡¤O¥bšŸ§™lœ' Ñœ'¶(šK– 32 w4

+

f ¤O¥bšŸ§™º¥–S©¥Ÿ »žª–9¥(›-R–{@g0 $57698 l9:'Q’MPIX,JRXT,X!MO….VK– #Ÿž?ª™;šO¹ °œŸ ,l–;5-f<2 w 4 ”V´¥(›-R–H †¹¢zšP¥( ¸šO¹ž 8f= w *b »¹sžª–S¥ #’šP¶Ÿ–¾¤O¥bšŸ§™'5”VOIjoVo¥Ÿ K¤a™ž?ª™;šO¹ „œŸ ,l–: f= w $¸‰ JKNPW _ @ -',ˆ $U@SNPVaT@Bj9@Bj]NO@BXV _ @¾MPILKZƒVOLRLKM€+@Bj JRI‚LK@S…»Tb‘ > VOIsj‚X,JRj@BX T > @SZ!V _ @"WX@Bj3TMT@BXT+T > @UVa[sX,@BIQ’@UMO…¿X,W[N _ Vai > XBˆ Ä I3T > @NPJKŽO@BI‚•sNPW _ @BXMO…N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@ _ WsLK@BX +@UVOII]MOT,VaT@.VI]M7j]@Ã[Z!JKT,XLRVa[@BL¸”;VOIj3JK…I]@BQ’@BX,X,V _ Z5[;Z!VOI„JRj]@BIT,JΕ³QSVaT,JKMPIƒIWA5[@ _ ”PJRIM _ j]@ _ TM'JRj@BIlT,JK…†Z T > @¾X,VOA„@.IM;j]@BX~MPIoLK@S…†Tb‘VOIsj _ JKN > Tb‘ > VOIsjƒX*JRj]@BXSˆ 8VOQ > _ WLK@¾VOLRXM > VOXgV!IVOA3@ $ > @ _ @?>ÊŸ‘*p',ˆ ®°@¾VOLRXM3WX,@"T > @ …†MPLRLKM€UJRIN„T@ _ A‚X"

(11)

A

B

C

A

B

D

A

B

C

D

::=

RS-1

a

b

a

c

a

b

c

‰ JKNPW _ @ ¾f"[M€ŽO@% (¿@S…†Tb‘5VOIj _ JKN > Tb‘ > VOIj²X*JRj]@Oˆ.MzUI$LK@S…†T" _ WLK@9j]@BLK@ST,JKMPI‹JKT@BA„XBˆ.M€"I²A„JRjsjLK@% _ WLK@ JRIŽ£V _ JRVOIlT  ˆ.M€UI _ JKN > T" _ WLK@VOjjJKT,JKMPIJKT@BA„X

rule invariant K

left hand side L

right hand side R

redex invariant gK

redex gL

transformed redex gR

g

g

g

‰ JKNPW _ @'nEh@BLRVaT,JRIN„MO… V _ WLK@VOIj9V _ @Bj]@vUJKT > T > @¾M7QSQSW _,_ @BIQ’@Y> I /  $@('j‘0'I  $ _ WLK@T@BXT"I]M;j@BX!' L  /  $@ '`‘0'L $ _ WLK@T@BXTU@Bj]NO@BX!' (  /  3 $@('‘0'OQPASR  $I  ' $ _ WLK@T@BXT"I]M;j@LRVa[@BLRX ' (  /  8 $@('‘0z:PA˜R  $L ' $ _ WLK@T@BXTU@Bj]NO@LRVa[@BLRX!' (  /  $@('‘0(  /  3 5h(  /  8 $ _ WLK@T@BXT"LRVa[@BLRX ' I  $@('j‘0'I  $ _ WLK@JRIŽ£V _ JRVOIlTUIM;j]@BX ' L  $@('‘0'L $ _ WLK@JRIŽ£V _ JRVOIlT@BjNO@BX!' (  3 $@('j‘0'OQPA˜R $I ' $ _ WLK@JRIŽ£V _ JRVOIlTUIM;j]@LRVa[@BLRX!' (  8 $@('j‘0z PASR  $L  ' $ _ WLK@JRIŽ£V _ JRVOIlT@BjNO@'LRVa[@BLRX!' (  $@('j‘0(  3 5h(  8 $ _ WLK@JRIŽ£V _ JRVOIlTULRVa[@BLRX!' I($@ '‘0I I  $ _ WLK@VOjjsJKT,JKMPI9I]M7j]@BX!' L  $@('j‘0iL L $ _ WLK@VOjjsJKT,JKMPIH@Bj]NO@BX!' (  3 $@('‘0'OQPASR  $I  I  ' $ _ WLK@VOjjsJKT,JKMPI9I]M7j]@¾LRVa[@BLRX!' ( 8 $@('‘0z:PASR  $L L ' $ _ WLK@VOjjsJKT,JKMPIH@Bj]NO@LRVa[@BLRX!' (  $@('‘0(  3 $@('5o(  8 $@(' $ _ WLK@VOjjsJKT,JKMPI9LRVa[@BLRX!' I  d $@('‘0'I I  $ _ WLK@j]@BLK@ST,JKMPII]M7j]@BX!' L  d $@ '`‘0'L  L  $ _ WLK@j]@BLK@ST,JKMPI9@Bj]NO@BX!' ( d 3 $@('j‘0'OQPASR  $I  I  ' $ _ WLK@j]@BLK@ST,JKMPII]M7j]@LRVa[@BLRX!' (  d 8 $@('j‘0z:PA˜R  $L L ' $ _ WLK@j]@BLK@ST,JKMPI9@Bj]NO@LRVa[@BLRX!' ( d $@('j‘0( d 3 $@ 'E5K( d 8 $@(' $ _ WLK@j]@BLK@ST,JKMPILRVa[@BLRX!'  )/†È{%-/?$†|P{x$†ÌE" f _ WsLK@t@=0 $5 6 8 l :'þJRX+VaiisLRJRQSVa[[email protected]M5V{(~‘“N _ Vai > F!”T > @™7·£œŸžY¤P¥¦š’§™l”JK…T > @"…»MPLRLKMzUJRI]NQ’MPIjJKT,JKMPIX > MPLRj ! x " °{x€|†%$?"$# ! w Yu%#³yz{%ºx€È;wSx " ‰ JRIj°VOI«JRIa`¦@BQ’T,JKŽO@o(~‘“N _ Vai > ‘ªA3M _ i > JRX,A~>À5 -.,/ [F”üQSVOLRLK@Bj‹·€¶*¶B›7¥  ¥b–B¹s¶(–Sˆ#> $5 -.,/

'JRXQSVOLRLK@Bj ¥b– l–,˜P”sJKT,XI]M7j]@BX¾¥– l–*˜o¹s· l–’œ(”sJKT,X@Bj]NO@BX¥– l–*˜9– €¤–ŸœŸˆ

 @BQSVOWX@ 5 -.,/ JRXWX@Bj¿” I]@SNPVaT@Bjƒ@Bj]NO@BX+… _ MPA 5´V _ @½I]@SNPLK@BQ’T@Bj”VOIj‚[email protected]M!Va[[ _

(12)

::=

A

B

A

B

::=

A:1

A:2

A:1

A:2

A

B

C

::=

A

B

D

GRS-1

GRS-2

GRS-3

a

a

b

NOT c

d

NOT c

d

e

a

f

a

g

‰ JKNPW _ @'qEÇ5%VX,JRA„isLK@¾N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@XZ7XT@BA œŸ› ª¤P¥¦š’§™'MO…F!”]J¸ˆ@OˆsJK…m>B3$I 'JRXÃT > @X@STÃMO… _ @Bj]@oI]M7j]@BX+… _

MPA > 5”I]MOTVOLRLLRJRI ;JRI]N@BjNO@BXÃMO…þIM;j]@BXgJRI

>B3 $I 'ÃI]@S@BjTM‚[@!JRIh> 5Uˆ => @N _ Vai > F > 5¨JRX½QSVOLRLK@BjÁ¥b–’œŸž~¤P¥¦š’§™lˆ 8jNO@BX"… _ MPAŽF > 5JRITMZ> 5 A„V€Z‚@]JRXT $ՙ ,1l–B¹«– €¤–Ÿœ* PšO¹¤㠆¹¤o– €¤l–’œ',ˆ ! x  " "üÈ #³{]x€È;Í$È;Í%#³È9xzȝwSx $‹z}0 $O ‰ JMO  J P ')f L  JB¹³–Õ¤PšOžª– ($‹z ' 0 ž¡¥Ÿ›– ' 0 $/> 3 $O ‰ 'MJ> 3 $O  'MJ P 'Œf6LV—” J¸ˆ@oJK…UVOI6P‘“@Bj]NO@oJRI<LÁJRX!I]@SNPVaT@Bj”~[@STÕ~@S@BI´T > @vQ’M _*_

@BXiMPIjJRI]NI]M7j]@BX!JRIy> 3 $I  '¾IM7P‘“@Bj]NO@oA„V€Z

@7JRX,TSˆ ! x " yzÈ/†{]x†$†ÌE"´|PÌ “ /†ÈlxzÈS"üȝw€wx€È;wSx az}0 $O ‰ JMO  J P'Œf6L ($@('ˆ $/> 3 $O ‰ 'MJ> 3 $O  'MJ P ' f L — J¸ˆ@OˆþI]MOT'VOLRL @Bj]NO@BX > JRQ > T > @VaiisLRJRQSVaT,JKMPIMO…%@5+MPWLRjHVOjjHV _ @VOL _ @BVOj]ZoJRI|Fˆ Ä …@.JRXVaiisLRJRQSVa[³LK@O”!@Uj@ _ JKŽO@BX… _ MPA F‹T > @ (~‘“N _ Vai > ¯[Z'i@ _ …»M _ A„JRI]N"T > @g…»MPLRLKMzUJRI]NXT@Si³XJRI!M _ j]@ _ $ O †¥b–*¶Bž l–B¥( †¢zšPž¡ †·O¹oF [  ' !

{ " yzȝÍþÈ ºÈÍ #sȍÍYÈ /†Èx$†ÌE" f.LRL _ @Bj]@3@Bj]NO@BXÃA‚VaT,Q > @Bjƒ[;Z _ WLK@½j]@BLK@ST,JKMPIv@Bj]NO@BXÃV _ @½j]@BLK@ST@BjL — ‘0'L — >B8;$L  d $@('' ! {  " %$†ÍYÍþÈ "ÁÈ;Í%#³ÈÍþÈ/†Èx$†Ì" f"LRL _ @Bj]@'@BjNO@BX V _ @j]@BLK@ST@Bj„ > JRQ > V _ @UJRIQSJRj]@BITTMI]M7j]@BXA„VaT,Q > @Bj[;Z _ WLK@ j]@BLK@ST,JKMPI9IM;j]@BXxL — ‘0iL — e $O ‰ JMO  J P'fKL — ËO ‰ O  f`> 3 $I d $@(''Mj ! { " "üÌÍYȍÍþÈ/†Èx$†ÌE" f"LRL _ @Bj@‹I]M7j]@BXoA„VaT,Q > @Bj[;Z _ WLK@°j]@BLK@ST,JKMPI I]M;j@BXoV _ @°j]@BLK@ST@Bj6I{— ‘0 I{— >B3 $I d $@ '' ! { " "üÌÍYȍ{ÍþÍ$»x†$†ÌE" fºX,@STþMO…³I]@SÁI]M;j@BXYQ’M _,_

@BXiMPIjJRI]N"TM I  $@('JRX VOjj@BjTM^FÇ I — ‘0'I — 5 e OjË\f

I $@('MJMOQPA˜R — $O '0'OQPASR  $ 'Mj

! { " È;Í%#³È{sÍYÍ#$»x$†ÌE" f X,@ST„MO…I]@S @BjNO@BX‚Q’M _,_ @BXiMPIjJRI]N°TM<L  $@(''JRXƒVOjj]@BjÁTM F!”ÃJK…½T > @SZÁV _ @I]MOT VOL _

@BVOj]Z9JRI“F]  ‘0 $I — JML — 5ge $/>B3 $O

‰ 'MJ> 3$O  'MJ P 'PË $O ‰ JMO  J P ' fgL  jBJOQPA˜R — '+ > @ _ @{OQPASR — > VOX [@S@BIHVaii _ MOi _ JRVaT@BLKZo@;T@BIsj]@Bjˆ4L — VOIsjhLV _ @5X@ST,XS”³J¸ˆ@OˆVa…†T@ _ T > @'VaiisLRJRQSVaT,JKMPIMO…@!T > @ _ @"JRLRLüXT,JRLRL

[@.MPIsLKZƒMPI@)P‘“@Bj]NO@[@STª+@S@BIo> 3 $O

‰ 'VOIjo> 3 $O  ',”sXM3T > VaT JRXV3~@BLRLΑ“…†M _ A3@Bj (~‘“N _ Vai > ˆ   y€{$y€ÈË‚y†$»x€ÈHwSÉ¿wSxzȼw

f *b¥b– ΚOž¡ ¸·O¹sš'¤O¥bšŸ§™ƒ¥b–B©¥( †žª–.œ’¬€œ’žª–S­“0 $%J 'þQ’MPIX,JRX,T,XMO…VX,@STMO…N

_ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@ _ WLK@BX¼VOIj„V{(~‘“N _ Vai >  $†T > @‚š€˜P ¸·O­ ',ˆ => @X,@STMO…VOLRLN _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@XZ7XT@BA„XUJRXQSVOLRLK@Bj! ˆ ‰ JKNPW _ @!q‚Q’MPIlT,VOJRIsX.VOI@]VOA3isLK@'MO… V3N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@'XZ7XT@BAHˆ"hUWLK@"Ç5Ÿ‘*p'VOjjX.V$#;‘“@Bj]NO@5[@STÕ~@S@BITÕ~M I]M7j]@BX+UJKT > LRVa[@BLRX¯¿‚VOIsj ³„ > JRQ > V _ @½LRJRI O@Bjo[Z‚VOI&%a‘“@Bj]NO@5$¸VPn(',ˆ'Ç5Ÿ‘*p¾JRXÃIMOTgVaisisLRJK@BjoJK…¿T > @ _ @¾JRXÃVOL _ @BVOjZ

(13)

A:R1

A:R2

A:1

A:2

A:3

A:4

NOT c

d

occurrence g

occurrence g

i

d

d

i

d

d

‰ JKNPW _ @  Å VaT,Q > JRI]NMO… ]5Ÿ‘ÕC'TMVOIv@7VOA„isLK@ > MPXTgN _ Vai > ˆf"[MzŽO@¾T > @ _ WLK@O”]j]MzUIƒT > @½N _ Vai > ˆhUWsLK@½IM;j]@BX V _ @'A„V _ O@Bjo[;Zvhp £h"C;ˆ $U@SNPVaT@Bj _ WLK@¾@BjNO@BXT@BXTT > @Va[sX@BIQ’@¾MO… @Bj]NO@BX"JRIoT > @ > MPXTÃN _ Vai >

VOI #;‘“@Bj]NO@ $†T*r(',ˆ Ç5Ÿ‘ÕCƒVOjjsX"VOI  ‘“@Bj]NO@![@STÕ~@S@BITÕ~M ¿‘ªI]M7j]@BX$¸VPn('

> JRQ > V _ @I]MOT½VOL _ @BVOj]ZLRJRI O@Bj[;Z9VOI ²z‘“@Bj]NO@)$†T*r(',ˆ  @BQSVOWX,@~@WX@!VOI°JRIa`b@BQ’T,JKŽO@M;QSQSW _,_ @BIQ’@Œ>9JRI _ WLK@!VaiisLRJRQSVaT,JKMPI«Q’MPIjJKT,JKMPI $†TBp',”Q> $^¿ 'VOIj > $^¿-'"A!WX,T.[@3jJ@ _ @BITSˆ Ç5’‘Õr _ @BA„M€ŽO@BXV O‘ªI]M7j]@)$¸VPr('UTMONO@ST > @ _ UJKT > VOI«JRIQ’MPA‚JRI]N P‘“@BjNO@ $¸V]p'.VOIj VOLRLKM7QSVaT@BXVvI]@S l‘ªI]M7j]@$¸V -'g"JKT > JRIsQ’MPA„JRI]NP‘“@Bj]NO@ $¸VPn(',ˆ¾‰ JKNPW _ @;„X > M€"X"VOIM7QSQSW _,_ @BIQ’@5MO…]5Ÿ‘ÕC‚JRIV iMPX,X,JK[³LK@ > MPXT½N _ Vai > ˆ =U> @ _ WLK@!A„VaT,Q > @BX¾VoI]MPI7‘ªJRIjWsQ’@BjX,W[N _ Vai > Q’MPIT,VOJRIJRI]NoT > @ _ @Bj@I]M7j]@BX¿!VOIj ¿ˆ Ä I°T > JRXisVai@ _ ~@‚WX@3VoXi@BQSJΕ³QN _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@‚Vaii _ MPVOQ > ˆ $"MPI]@3MO…gT > @3Vaii _ MPVOQ > @BX _ @SiM _ T@Bj¼JRI°T > @ LRJKT@ _ VaT,W _ @¾X@S@BA„XTM5A„@S@STT > @.@;@BQSWT,JKMPI‚@! ƒQSJK@BIQ’Z„Q _ JKT@ _ JRV5 > JRQ > V _ @ _ @B\;WJ _ @Bj‚…†M _ i _ MON _ VOA MOisT,JRA„JK‡BVaT,JKMPIˆ => JRXYQ’MPIQ’@ _ IXþ@BA'[@BjjsJRI]NÃMO… _ WLK@BXB”£NPLRWsJRI]N.Q’MPIsjJKT,JKMPIXS”OVOIj > JRjj]@BI@Bj]NO@BXSˆ ®°@ _ @BXT _ JRQ’TþT > @ _ WLK@+VaiisLRJRQSVaT,JKMPI Q’MPIjsJKT,JKMPIXgTM'T > MPX@"T > VaTgQSVOIƒ[@UT@BX,T@BjoJRI‚Q’MPIX,T,VOIlTgT,JRA3@. > @BI‚V!X@ST~MO…YI]M;j@BXMO…¿T > @ > MPX,T~N _ Vai > JRXgWIj@ _ JRIŽO@BXT,JKNPVaT,JKMPIˆ => WX [email protected]@' †¹¢zšP¥( ¸šO¹ž _ WLK@"@BA5[@BjsjJRI]N   ‰YE¾mOn“”]J¸ˆ@Oˆ[email protected]M'I]MOTgVOLRLKM€ > JRjsj]@BI3@Bj]NO@BX+TM5[@ _ @BjsJ _ @BQ’T@Bj”7XisLRJKTM _ Q’MPVOLK@BX*Q’@Bjˆh@Bj@;@BX~VOLK+V€Z;X _ @S…†@ _ TMV½• ;@Bj3I;WA5[@ _ MO…IM;j]@BXVOIj@Bj]NO@BXSˆ Å M _ @"LRJK[@ _ VOL @BA5[@BjjJRI]NoA„@BQ > VOIJRX*A„X½+MPWLRj¼…†M _ AVOjjsJKT,JKMPIVOL _ WsLK@3VaiisLRJRQSVaT,JKMPI±Q’MPIjJKT,JKMPIXSˆvf.LKT > MPW]N > T > JRX _ @BX@BA5[sLK@BX T > @'VOLKNO@S[ _ VOJRQ5Vaii _ MPVOQ >  8 

(Ym†– “”+@j]M‚I]MOTUWX@'JKT,X.¤Λ7 »¹;¤‚¶(·O¹ O †ž¡ ¸·O¹ƒ[@BQSVOWsX@JKTi

_ M > JK[sJKT,X > JRjsj]@BIv@Bj]NO@BX TMI]M7j]@BX~ > JRQ > V _ @½j]@BLK@ST@Bjˆ = M5T@BXTg > @ST > @ _ > JRjj]@BI‚@Bj]NO@BX+@]JRXT+JRX _ VaT > @ _ @7i@BIX,JKŽ[email protected]J _ @BQ’T@BjƒN _ Vai > X [@BQSVOWX@++@ > V€ŽO@gTM.LKM;MW]i!XMPW _ Q’@BXþMO…JRIQ’MPA‚JRI]NU@BjNO@BXVaTY@SŽO@ _ Z _ WLK@gVaiisLRJRQSVaT,JKMPIˆ "@BIQ’@ _ WLK@~VaisisLRJRQSVaT,JKMPIX I]@S@BjoIMOTÃ[@½isWsX > MPW]T,X+JRIvT > @QSVaT@SNOM _ ZvMO…þN _ Vai > XgVOIjoV _ WLK@¾j]M;@BXÃI]MOTVOLKgVBZ7X > V€ŽO@VOIoJRIlŽO@ _ X@Oˆ "M€+@SŽO@ _ ” T > JRX"JRXI]MOTUJRA„iM _ T,VOIlTg[@BQSVOWX@~@V _ @MPILKZoJRIlT@ _ @BX,T@Bj9JRI _ @S _ JKT,JRI]N„VOIjoIMOTUJRIoisV _ X*JRI]N]ˆ d7MPA3@MO…+T > @3Vaii _ MPVOQ > @BX _ @SiM _ T@Bj°JRI°T > @3LRJKT@ _ VaT,W _ @„V _ @„I]MOTVaisi _ MOi _ JRVaT@[@BQSVOWX,@T > @SZWsX@3JRIjWQ’@Bj X,W[N _ Vai > T@BXT,XJRIsXT@BVOjvMO…þA‚VaT,Q > JRIN]ˆ Ä …¿D …»M _ T > @VaisisLRJRQSVaT,JKMPIoMO… V _ WLK@"D VOLRL¿LRJRI7JRI]N _ @BLRVaT,JKMPIXÃ[@STª+@S@BI I]M7j]@BX!+@ _ @oTM¼[@ƒ@BIWA„@ _ VaT@Bj”+Xi@BQSJΕ³QSVaT,JKMPIX+MPWLRjÁ[@ _ VaT > @ _ jJ ƒQSWLKTTM _ @BVOjÁVOIj´ _ JKT@Oˆ´hU@BVOLRJRXT,JRQ MOiT,JRA‚JK‡S@ _ X,i@BQSJΕQSVaT,JKMPIX5UJRLRL +M _ ¼MPI±VOI«@BIM _ A3MPWXVOA3MPWITMO… _ @BLRVaT,JKMPIsX'MzŽO@ _ T > @‚MO[`¦@BQ’T5TªZ;i@BXMO…ÃT > @ JRIT@ _ A3@BjsJRVaT@ _ @Si _ @BX@BIlT,VaT,JKMPI¿ˆ+®°@'@BXT,JRA„VaT@'T > VaT"V3…†WLRLΑ4"³@Bj]NO@BjHMOiT,JRA‚JK‡S@ _ UJRLRLüWX@Va[MPW]T"r†–3‘"p…–B–3MO[`¦@BQ’T TÕZi@BX½VOIj9V _ MPWIj±p…–B–3‘n†–B– _ @BLRVaT,JKMPIXSˆ½f"LRXMvJRIjWsQ’@Bj9X,W][sN _ Vai > T@BX,T,X"i _ @SŽO@BIlT½Xi@BQSJΕ³QSVaT,JKMPIX.… _ MPA [@BJRI]N @7T@BIj]@Bjƒ@BVOX,JRLKZ JK…üI]@S _ @BLRVaT,JKMPIXÃV _ @½VOjj]@BjƒTM > MPXT+N _ Vai > XB”…†M _ A3@ _ LKZ3A„VaT,Q > JRI]N _ WLK@BX~X*Wjj]@BILKZI]@S@BjvI]MOT A‚VaT,Q > VOIlZ7A3M _ @   ‰YE¾mOn“ˆU®JKT > A‚VaT,Q > JRIN]”³+@5QSVOIŒVa[sX,T _ VOQ’T"… _ MPA VOLRLYIMPI7‘ _ @BLK@SŽaVOIlT _ @BLRVaT,JKMPIXBˆ"M€+@SŽO@ _ ” JK…IM;j]@BX.V _ @j]@BLK@ST@Bj”VOLRL JRIQSJRj]@BIT½@Bj][email protected]…T > @!I]M7j]@'A!WX,T"VOLRXMv[@'j]@BLK@ST@Bj¿ˆd7@BQ’T,JKMPI¼n„QSLRV _ JΕ³@BX > M€ŠT > JRX QSVOI9[@jMPI]@¾UJKT > LRJRI]@BV _ @;@BQSWT,JKMPI9Q’MPXTSˆ   vÈ7y$]{]x†$†ÌE"üw (ü@ST¾[@$60 $J 'Vf   ˆf l–S¥Ÿ »¢£šOž¡ ¸·O¹9JRI $JRX¾VƒX,@B\W]@BIsQ’@5MO…4(~‘“N _ Vai > XYF^[ YF ‰ [ [`F  ” LRJRIO@Bj±[;Z¼jJ _ @BQ’T!j]@ _ JKŽaVaT,JKMPIX!WIj]@ _'_ WLK@BXŒ@ f gˆ9®°@vX,VBZ¼T > VaT•F  JRX)l–B¥( †¢zš  K–'… _ MPA‰F  $‹F  < [ F  ',ˆ Ä …gT > @ _ @‚JRX'I]MK@7f  > JRQ > QSVOI¼[@„Vaii³LRJK@Bj¼TM7F  ”F 

JRXQSVOLRLK@Bj´V¼¹s·O¥Ÿ­š #’·O¥Ÿ­ MO… ~ˆof j]@

_

(14)

žª–B¥(­! †¹sšOž¡ †¹¤'JK…O°JRXÕ³IJKT@O”³MOT > @ _ UJRX,@„¹s·O¹a¦žª–S¥Ÿ­! »¹³šOž¡ »¹;¤aˆ Ä …VOLRLYj]@ _ JKŽaVaT,JKMPIXUJRI ÁV _ @T@ _ A‚JRIVaT,JRI]N]” ºJRXUVOLRXM QSVOLRLK@Bj±žª–S¥Ÿ­! »¹sšPž¡ »¹¤Oˆ = ~MVOLKT@ _ IVaT,JKŽO@jsJ _ @BQ’TÃj]@ _ JKŽaVaT,JKMPIX+MO… _ WLK@BX@ ‰ 0 $5 ‰ 6 8 ‰ l : ‰ ' VOIjZ@  0 $5  6 8  l :  ' … _ MPA  V _ @5QSVOLRLK@Bj  †¹ l–b§7–S¹ l–S¹ž¸”JK… T > @SZoQSVOIH[@JRIlT@ _ Q > VOI]NO@Bj54F   4F ‰ [4F “ 0   ƘF  [     4F “ ˆ c.T > @ _ UJRX@3T > @SZŒV _ @‚QSVOLRLK@Bj±VOI$·O¢a–S¥ ʟ§³ˆ =U> @…»MPLRLKMzUJRI]NŒj]@’•³IJKT,JKMPIsX > MPLRj¼…†M _ VOIsj«JKT,XjsJ _ @BQ’Tj]@ _ JKŽaVaT,JKMPI _

@BLRVaT,JKMPIy[ˆ ºJRX½QSVOLRLK@Bj œŸž¡¥b·O¹¤¶*·O¹+›–S¹sžYJK…

 F ‰ J*F  J*F “ f“(~‘?>!@BA CD F  F ‰ [ F “ 0    F  [  =F “  > @ _ @3JRX T > @ _ @!"s@]JKŽO@QSLKMPX,W _ @UMO…[‹ˆ => JRXJRXVaTLK@BVOXT T > @QSVOX,@JK…VOLRL]i³VOJ _ X MO…jsJ _ @BQ’Tj]@ _ JKŽaVaT,JKMPIX V _ @"JRIj]@Si@BIj]@BITSˆ ¼JRX QSVOLRLK@Bj¶(·O¹ g›–S¹ž¸”7JK…  F ‰ J*F  J*F “ f w !F  < F ‰ < [ F “ 0   !F  < [  < F “ ˆ ±JRXÃQSVOLRLK@Bj«¶(·O¹¢£–B¥¸¤–S¹žJK…þJKTÃJRXgT@ _ A„JRIVaT,JRIN!VOIsjƒQ’MPI"³W]@BIT   m†– “ˆ+d7WQ > XZ;X,T@BA„Xgj]@BLRJKŽO@ _ V!WIJR\;W]@½I]M _ A‚VOL …†M _ A  $"@S lC “ˆgE _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@XZ7XT@BA„Xg"JKT > X@SŽO@ _ VOLYI]M _ A„VOL…†M _ A„XÃV _ @QSVOLRLK@Bj«¹s·P¹a–Sžª–S¥Ÿ­! »¹s Ñœ’ž¡ †¶Bˆ £    ¨a¬ª§+¨G¥¬   ª j¨[§+¨(¥¬ f X@ST‚MO….N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@ _ WLK@BX ŠT@ _ A‚JRIVaT@BXMPI²V°•³IJKT@9V]JKMPA  JK…½@SŽO@ _ Zºj]@ _ JKŽ£VaT,JKMPI‹XT@Si²VOjjsX„XMPA„@ @Bj]NO@BXTM!V!i³V _ T,JRQSWLRV _Ã_ @BLRVaT,JKMPIˆ~fgTLRVOXTà > @BIƒT > JRX _ @BLRVaT,JKMPI9JRXÃQ’MPA3isLK@ST@½T > @¾j]@ _ JKŽaVaT,JKMPIoi _ M;Q’@BX,XgA!WXTgXTMOi [@BQSVOWX@~@MPIsLKZƒVOLRLKMz—MPI]@@Bj]NO@UJKT > VQ’@ _ T,VOJRILRVa[@BL[@STª+@S@BIHTÕ~MƒI]M;j@BXSˆ vÈ! #"%$»x$†Ì" ! Í #sÈlÊ*{ÍþÍ$»x†$³ÈHy /†È " & –Bž *– “0 $%J 'f   Q+!–¡µ¹³–#’·O¥4@=0 $5 6 8l :'9f  ž†™7– œB–Sžg· #@Bj]NO@’‘ªVOjjsJKT,JKMPI7‘“T@ _ A„JRIsVaT,JKMPILRVa[@BLRX   8 $@ '‘0 e:P%f|(  8 $@('PË  zt0 $O ‰ JMO  J P 'fhL  $@('TOQPA˜R  $O ‰ 'MJMOQPASR $O  ' f|(  3 $@('Mj ž†™7–œB–Sžg· #T@ _ A‚JRIVaT,JKMPI7‘ªX,W[N _ Vai > I]M7j]@LRVa[@BLRX  3 $@('j‘0e:P%f|( 3 Ë  zV0 $O ‰ JMO  J  'fhL  $@('MJ Žf   8 $@('j OQPASR  $O ‰ '0iP OQPASR  $O  '%0iPkj ž†™7–"T@ _ A„JRIVaT,JKMPI7‘ _ @BLRVaT,JKMPIX »¹  L $@('j‘0e,z^fhL`˔z PASR $‹z'f   8 $@('Mj ž†™7–œB–Sžg· #T@ _ A‚JRIVaT,JKMPI7‘ªX,W[N _ Vai > I]M7j]@BX5 »¹ 

I  $@('j‘0e OgfhI  ËOQPASR  $O 'f

 3 $@ 'Mj  #   8

$@(' 0!+ +†–:+ž†™7–B¥b–„šO¥b–3¥(›-R–š11P »ž¡ ¸·O¹ – €¤l–’œ'©þ™ ¸¶’™šO¥–3·P¹ 㬃 †¹s¶B ,l–S¹sž+ž“·H¥(›-R–5 »¹¢£šO¥Ÿ †šO¹sžÃ¹s· l–’œ @

 œ'¶*šR– 5@Bj]NO@’‘ªVOjjsJKT,JKŽO@T+ ¾¹°– €¤l– ¦š1O †ž¡ »¢a–!¥(›-R–V@9© †ž†™NI($@('0I d $@('0iL  d $@ '0 Ñœ!¶*šK– 5@Bj]NO@'VOjsjJKT,JKMPI _ WsLK@*(–,¶*šP›lœB–  †ž+·P¹ 㬃š11£œ3– €¤–Ÿœ…+ f.IÁ@Bj]NO@’‘ªVOjsjJKT,JKŽO@ _ WsLK@HVOjjX3VaT3LK@BVOXT‚MPI]@ _ WLK@HVOjsjJKT,JKMPIÁ@Bj]NO@H > JRQ > JRX3MPILKZ±JRIsQSJRj]@BIlT„TM _ WLK@HJRIŽ£V£‘ _ JRVOIT!I]M;j@BXSˆ =U> @„LRVa[@BL MO…ÃT > JRX'@Bj]NO@+$†T > @BX@ƒ@Bj]NO@BX!'.j@BI]MOT@‚V&$¸X@ST'MO…!' _ @BLRVaT,JKMPIX5MO…ÃT > @ > MPXTN _ Vai > $†T > @ T@ _ A‚JRIVaT,JKMPI7‘ _ @BLRVaT,JKMPIsX!'" > JRQ > V _ @[@BJRI]NoQ’MPA3i³LK@ST@Bj¼jW _ JRIN‚T > @3VaisisLRJRQSVaT,JKMPIXMO…+T > @ _ WsLK@Oˆ => JRX½i _ M€Ž7JRj]@BX T > @[sVOX,JRXņM _ – z¤l–…bš11P »ž¡ †¢£–N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@XZ7XT@BA‚X" vÈ! #"%$»x$†Ì"  ! Í #sÈlÊ*{ÍþÍ$»x†$³È #³yz{²yzȝ˂y$»xzÈHwSÉ¿wSx€È °w " 60 $%J 'tf   ´ Ñœ¶*šK– 3@BjNO@’‘ªVOjjJKT,JKŽO@  #  @ ‰ 0 $5 ‰ 6 8 ‰ l : ‰ 'MJM@  0 $5  6 8  l :  '9f    $O ‰ JMO  J P 'fKL  $@ ‰ 'MJ Pf   8 $@ ‰ '` OQPASR   $O ‰ 'MJMOQPA˜R   $O  ' f|(  3 $@  '

 +¸– +¿š¥Ÿ›-K–’œ"šO¥b–– €¤–…bš11O †ž¡ »¢a–¾šO¹ !¹³·'¥Ÿ›-K–½š1£œ.¹³· l–Ÿœ.ž“·'ž†™]–½žª–S¥Ÿ­! »¹sšPž¡ †·O¹“œ’›Õ¤O¥bšŸ§™v¹s· l–’œ.·#"šO¹³·Ož†™7–S¥

¥Ÿ›-K–:+c;ü™7–S¹ l–¡µ¹³–5ž†™7–œB–Sžg·#@Bj]NO@’‘ªVOjjsJKT,JKMPI7‘“T@ _ A„JRIsVaT,JKMPI9LRVa[@BLRX· #    8 $  '¼‘0   "!   8 $@('

(15)

šP¹ vž†™7–"T@ _ A‚JRIVaT,JKMPI7‘ªX,W][sN _ Vai > · # ž“·**–5ž†™]–œŸ› ª¤P¥¦šŸ§s™· #  ‘0 $I  ‘0   "! I  $@('MJML  ‘0   "! L  $@('MJMOQPASR  Ë3 ' ;ü™]–œS–Sžg· #'š Y– €¤l– ¦š1O †ž¡ »¢a–¾¤O¥bšŸ§™¥–S©¥Ÿ »žª–œ’¬zœŸžª–S­'œ' œ'¶*šR–   Q+

 ¤O¥bšŸ§™Á¥–S©¥Ÿ »žª–oœŸ¬zœŸžª–B­ © »ž†™Á– €¤–9š1O »ž¡ ¸·O¹‹¥(›-R–Ÿœv Ñœo¶*š K– o@Bj]NO@oVOjjsJKT,JKMPI

_ @S _ JKT@vXZ7XT@BA $G5 '*+ ;ü™7–œB–Sžg· #'šY– €¤l–!š1O »ž¡ ¸·O¹°¥–S©¥Ÿ »žª–5œŸ¬zœŸžª–B­œ œ'¶*šR–  ' Q+ Ä Iv@Bj]NO@’‘ªVOjjsJKT,JKŽO@N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@XZ7XT@BA„Xg+@QSVOIHJRj]@BIT,JK…†ZƒVX,W[N _ Vai > MO…üT > @V7JKMPA9”]T > @3žª–S¥Ÿ­! »¹sšPž¡ †·O¹ œ’›Õ¤O¥bšŸ§™lˆ Ä T,XƒI]M7j]@BX3QSV _,_ ZºLRVa[@BLRX„… _ MPA  "!  3 $@ '(”gJKT,X‚@Bj]NO@BX‚… _ MPA   8 $  ',ˆhUWLK@BXƒA„V€ZÁA„VOIJKisWsLRVaT@ V _ [³JKT _ V _ Z«I]M7j]@BX5VOIj±@Bj]NO@BXS” @]Q’@SiT!T > VaT!@BVOQ > MO…UT > @BAÂMPILKZ$š11aœ9– €¤l–’œTMŒT > @‚T@ _ A„JRIVaT,JKMPI7‘ªX*W][N _ Vai > ˆ => WXT > @"T@ _ A„JRIVaT,JKMPI7‘ªX*W][N _ Vai > JRX[@BJRI]N'Q’MPA3isLK@ST@BjvVOIj„T > @.X,Z;XT@BAkT@ _ A‚JRIVaT@BXSˆj5"V _ @.ŽO@ _ Z3Xi@BQSJΕ³Q N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@XZ7XT@BA‚X [@BQSVOWsX@gT > @SZ'MPIsLKZ'VOjj!@Bj]NO@BXTM¾N _ Vai > X  ftlmOn£[ “ˆ ®°@UQSLK@BV _ LKZ > V€ŽO@  '   ! ˆ  ¿È;̳yzÈ   !

 È7y y$?"ü{]x$†ÌE"ÁÌ"t   "“&

–Sž;*– “0 $J 'f  Q+ žª–B¥(­! †¹sšOžª–Ÿœ!·O¹5µ¹ †žª– Œ+



# 0 $I  JML  JMOQPA˜R  '  — œ+ž†™7–Užª–S¥Ÿ­! »¹sšPž¡ †·O¹“œ’›Õ¤O¥bšŸ§™„· # ´šO¹ 





8

$ '~ Ñœgž†™7–ÜS–Sž¿· #– €¤l– ¦š1O †ž¡ †·O¹

žª–B¥(­! †¹sšOž¡ ¸·O¹ Kš *– åœ*+š)l–S¥Ÿ »¢£šOž¡ ¸·O¹° »¹ ¨™;š£œ'šOž+­·£œŸžË

  8 $  'PËEËI  Ë  œ’žª–¦§œ…+ y€ÌÌ,} $bp' Gf ' ˆd;T,V _ T,JRI]N'… _ MPA ”;V'j]@ _ JKŽaVaT,JKMPI &{0F < [  MO… Œ…»M _ A„X VOIƒVOX,Q’@BIjJRIN'Q > VOJRI‚JRI $ w 3 J*5J 'g[@BQSVOWX@T > @ _ WLK@BX"MO…´MPILKZVOjjH@Bj]NO@BXBˆ ½W]@'TM _ WLK@'VOjjJKT,JKMPIŒVOQ’T,JKMPI$¸VPn('g@BjNO@BX"V _ @!VOjj]@Bj MPILKZ·O¹s¶(–Sˆ => WX @SŽO@ _ Z‚jJ _ @BQ’T~j@ _ JKŽ£VaT,JKMPIvLK@BVOjX+TM!VOI]MOT > @ _ (~‘“N _ Vai > JRI $ w 3  J*5J ',ˆ  @BQSVOWX,@ $ w 3  J*5J ' JRX•³IJKT@O”]T > @Q > VOJRIHMO…þT > @j@ _ JKŽ£VaT,JKMPIJRXI]M;@ST > @ _ JRVOIˆ => WsX'±T@ _ A„JRIVaT@BXMPI ˆ $¡C('  f   ' ˆ 

@BQSVOWX@  VOjjX5VOIj j@BLK@ST@BXJKT@BA„XS” T

> @vJRI]isW]T,XMO…UjJ _ @BQ’T!j]@ _ JKŽaVaT,JKMPIX!I]@S@Bj I]MOTƒ[@9X,W][sN _ Vai > X„MO…¾T > @ _ @BX*WLKT,XS”UVOIj²T > @Œj]@ _ JKŽaVa[sLK@9N _ Vai > X„j]M´I]MOT‚…»M _ AV«LRVaTT,JRQ’@Oˆ "M€+@SŽO@ _ ”U@SŽO@ _ Z N _ Vai > j]@ _ JKŽ£Va[sLK@ƒ… _ MPA  Q’MPIlT,VOJRIX!VX,W][N _ Vai >  > JRQ > JRX _ @BX,T _ JRQ’T@Bj±TMT > @ƒT@ _ A‚JRIVaT,JKMPI7‘ªX,W][sN _ Vai > IM;j]@BX I  1I  ˆ„e+MPIX,JRj@ _ T > JRX¾X@STMO…gX,W][sN _ Vai > X $ w 3 J*5ŠJ ',”YVOIj°VOI«V _ [sJKT _ V _ ZjJ _ @BQ’Tj@ _ JKŽ£VaT,JKMPI<F2[  «ˆ F > VOXVoX,W][sN _ Vai > F  f w 3 ˆ  @BQSVOWX@Z@‚A!WXT¾VOjj«VOI°@Bj]NO@3TMHVoT@ _ A„JRIVaT,JKMPI7‘ _ @BLRVaT,JKMPI¼MO… F!”  > VOXV X,W[N _ Vai >   f w 3    > JRQ > JRX½T > @ _ @BX,WsLKT"MO…+VaiisLKZ7JRI]No@3TM|F ˆŒF  <  > MPLRjX½JRI0 w 3 ˆ => @ _ @S…»M _ @ @BVOQ > j]@ _ JKŽ£VaT,JKMPI+&K0 F  [ F ‰ [ %[ F  JRI  >

VOX'VOX,XM7QSJRVaT@Bj VOI VOX,Q’@BIjJRIN9Q

> VOJRI«MO…ÃX,W][N _ Vai > X½MO… T > @oF JRI w 3 J*F  pF  ‰    F   ˆ => JRXX,@B\W]@BIsQ’@‚JRXVOLKgVBZ7X'•³IJKT@3[@BQSVOWX,@; w 3 JRX•³IJKT@Oˆ => WX & T@ _ A‚JRIVaT@BXS”sVOIsjHVOLRXM ~ˆ Ä IŒ[MOT > QSVOX@BX¾T > @3I;WA5[@ _ MO…~@Bj]NO@BXJRI°VoQ’MPA„isLK@ST@N _ Vai > MzŽO@ _ I   I  UJKT > Ë   8 $ 'PË _ @BLRVaT,JKMPIXJRX LRJRA‚JKT@Bj°[ZŒË   8 $ 'P˾ËI  Ë  ˆ  @BQSVOWsX@3@SŽO@ _ ZŒjJ _ @BQ’Tj]@ _ JKŽ£VaT,JKMPI¼VOjsjX¾VOI°@Bj]NO@O”üJKT,XLK@BI]NOT > QSVOI°[@VaTA3MPX,T Ë   8 $ 'PËËI  Ë  ˆ f.XUVOI9@7VOA„isLK@Q’MPIX,JRj@ _ T > @N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@XZ7XT@BA¯JRIH‰ JKNPW _ @‚paˆ  @BQSVOWX,@+@ > VBŽO@ŒI $a Ց  "!^ $""­('20  0 I  d $a  "!# $’‘*p'0 L  d $a / "!^ $’‘*p',”   "!# $ÁJRX VOI 5Oˆ ®°@ > VBŽO@   8

$a / "!^ $""­ 'i0 e"¿´E´ ¹ º» °½˜jO”  3 $a / gx!^ $4x­ 'Y0uex®E°?±²TJ ¹º » °jOˆ  / "!^ $T@ _ A„JRIVaT@BX'MPI´VH•IJKT@‚JRI7‘ T@ _ A„@BjJRVaT@ _ @Si _ @BX@BIT,VaT,JKMPIˆ ‰ JKNPW _ @ Q’MPIT,VOJRIX"Tª+M„MOT > @ _ @7VOA„isLK@BXSˆ~f.LKT > MPW]N >  5VOjjsXI]M7j]@BXS”sV3j@ _ JKŽ£VaT,JKMPI9T@ _ A„JRIsVaT@BX > @BI T > @ _ @BLRVaT,JKMPI ·  °+¸ "!%%·± °oJRXQ’MPA3isLK@ST@Oˆ„®°@ > VBŽO@   8 $   54x­ ' 0-e"·  °%¸ "!%+·¾± ° jO”  3 $   54x­ ' 0 e"¿jOˆ ‰ JKNPW _ @´mºj]@Si³JRQ’T,X > MzÂV$j]@ _ JKŽaVaT,JKMPI—JRI   5¼[@ > V€ŽO@BX"@BVOQ > _ WLK@ VaiisLRJRQSVaT,JKMPIŠVOjjXVOI@Bj]NO@ TM$T > @ T@ _ A‚JRIVaT,JKMPI7‘ªX,W[N _ Vai > ”  > JRLK@vJKT,X!I]M7j]@BX!V _ @vLK@S…»TWITMPWQ > @Bjˆ Ä I Q’MPIT _ VOjJRXT,JRIsQ’T,JKMPI#Ê  5ƒVOjjJKT,JKMPIsVOLRLKZ Q _ @BVaT@BX ¿‘ªI]M;j@BXSˆ => WXgT > @ _ @JRXUI]M3T@ _ A‚JRIVaT,JKMPI7‘ _ @BLRVaT,JKMPIVOIjHV3j]@ _ JKŽ£VaT,JKMPIA„VBZƒ[@I]MPI7‘“T@ _ A‚JRIVaT,JRI]N]ˆ  @BQSVOWX,@5T > @NPJKŽO@BIT@ _ A„JRIVaT,JKMPIQ _ JKT@ _ JKMPI _ @[email protected] > @…†@BVaT,W _ @BX"MO…T > @ _ WsLK@BXUVOLKMPI]@!JKT"QSVOI[@j]@BQSJRj]@Bj JRIºVOIºMOiT,JRA„JK‡S@ _ NO@BI]@ _ VaTM _ ˆ $5v > JRQ > jM¼I]MOT3WX@HI]@SNPVaT,JKMPI‹JRIÁT > @BJ _ LK@S…»Tb‘ > VOIsjºX,JRj]@BXS”gV _ @HI]MOT„MPILKZ T@ _ A‚JRIVaT,JRI]N]” [³W]T5VOLRX,MŒX,T _ MPI]N°Q’MPI-"³W]@BITS”VOIj T > WXQ’MPIlŽO@ _ NO@BIlT  ftlmOn£[ “ˆ =U> @SZ«QSVOI´[@‚WX,@Bj TM°Xi@BQSJK…†Z JRIT _ Vai _ M7Q’@BjW _ VOLYjJRX,T _ JK[sW]T,JKŽO@jVaT,V£‘4"sMz VOIVOLKZ7X,JRX  f lmOn£[ “ˆ  @BQSVOWsX@ 5'MPILKZVOjj@Bj]NO@BXS”T > @SZHMOi@ _ VaT@ MPI T > @vQ’MPA3isLK@ST@ƒLRVaTT,JRQ’@oMO… _ @BLRVaT,JKMPIX5M€ŽO@ _ T > @ƒI]M;j@BXMO…ÃT > @ƒV7JKMPA9ˆ)8VOQ > jsJ _ @BQ’T5j@ _ JKŽ£VaT,JKMPI±@BILRV _ NO@BX5V

(16)

A:1

::=

A:1

A:2

B

A:1

A:1

::=

A:1

A:2

A:3

A:2

TGRS-1

NTGRS-1

terminator

any

non-terminator

any

‰ JKNPW _ @  f.Iƒ@Bj]NO@’‘ªVOjjJKT,JKŽO@¾N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@¾XZ;X,T@BAk"JKT > T > @"@Bj]NO@’‘ªVOjsjJKT,JKMPI7‘“T@ _ A‚JRIVaT,JKMPIHLRVa[@BLYžª–B¥(­! †¹sšOž“·O¥ VOIj9V3I]MPI7‘“T@ _ A‚JRIVaT,JRI]NN _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@X,Z;XT@BA

A

A

A

B

B

termination-subgraph

A

A

A

B

B

termination-subgraph

B

B

A

A

A

B

B

termination-subgraph

B

A

A

A

B

B

termination-subgraph

B

B

B

B

B

B

‰ JKNPW _ @5mEfŠj]@ _ JKŽaVaT,JKMPI9JRIoT > @¾@BjNO@’‘ªVOjjJKT,JKŽO@5N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@XZ7XT@BA   5

(17)

_ @BLRVaT,JKMPI´VOIj«V9j]@ _ JKŽaVaT,JKMPI …»M _ A‚XVOI«VOX*Q’@BIjJRI]N9Q > VOJRI±JRI¼T > @„LRVaTT,JRQ’@Oˆ  @BQSVOWsX@ _ WLK@„VaiisLRJRQSVaT,JKMPIsX'QSVOI [@ JRIT@ _ Q > VOI]NO@BjoV _ [sJKT _ V _ JRLKZO”]@BVOQ > _ WLK@½A3M7j]@BLRX~V'jJRX,T _ JK[sW]T,JKŽO@½…¸WIQ’T,JKMPI”7VOIj‚T > @$5.A3M7j]@BLRX~V5jsJRXT _ JK[sW]T,JKŽO@ jVaT,V£‘4"³M€… _ VOA„@S~M _   ftlmOn£[ “ˆ => WXS”¿•IjJRI]NoV9IM _ A„VOLþ…†M _ AMO…ÃVOI $5!MzŽO@ _ VOI V7JKMPAÂJRXX*JRA„JRLRV _ TM •³IsjJRI]N‚V„• 7iMPJRIlT.JRIVƒjJRXT _ JK[sW]T,JKŽO@!jVaT,V£‘4"sM€ … _ VOA„@S~M _ g~@Vaii³LKZHVOLRL _ WLK@BXUTMƒT > @ > MPXT.N _ Vai > WIT,JRLYV • 7iMPJRIlTS”]T > @I]M _ A‚VOL³…†M _ A9”7JRX _ @BVOQ > @Bjˆ £    ¨a¬ª§+¨G¥¬  § +ªE§+¨G¥ ¬ ®°@5VOLRXM„QSVOI9WsX@¾@Bj]NO@M _ IM;j]@j@BLK@ST,JKMPI9TM„VOQ > JK@SŽO@T@ _ A„JRIVaT,JKMPIˆ vÈ! #"%$»x$†Ì"  !

*Yu¿x£y€{|Px$³È9y -/†È " &

–Sž(–  0 $%J 'Vf   Q+ 5–¡µ¹³–%#’·O¥Y@N0 $56 8 l :'tf  ž†™7– œB–Sžg· #@Bj]NO@’‘ªX,W[T _ VOQ’T,JKMPI7‘“T@ _ A‚JRIVaT,JKMPILRVa[@BLRX   8 $@('‘01e:P%f|(  d 8 Ë $O ‰ JMO  J P 'fhL  d $@('MJ OQPA˜R  $O ‰ 'MJMOQPASR  $O  ' f|(  3 $@('MJ P f|(  8 $@('Mj ž†™7–œB–Sžg· #T@ _ A‚JRIVaT,JKMPI7‘ªX,W[N _ Vai > I]M7j]@LRVa[@BLRX  3 $@('‘0e:Pf|(43ÊË  z 0 $O ‰ JMO  J  'fhL  d $@('MJ uf  8 $@(' OQPASR  $O ‰ '0iP OQPASR  $O  '0iPkj ž†™7–œB–Sžg· #UI]M7j]@’‘ªX,W[T _ VOQ’T,JKMPI7‘“T@ _ A‚JRIVaT,JKMPIHLRVa[@BLRX   3 $@ '‘0 (  d 3 $@(' (  3 $@(' ž†™7–"T@ _ A„JRIVaT,JKMPI7‘ _ @BLRVaT,JKMPIX »¹  L  $@('j‘0e,z^fhL  ˔z PASR  $‹z'f   8 $@('Mj ž†™7–œB–Sžg· #T@ _ A‚JRIVaT,JKMPI7‘ªX,W[N _ Vai > I]M7j]@BX5 »¹ 

I  $@ '‘01e O“foI  ËOQPA˜R  $O '9f

 3 $@('E5   3 $@('Mj  #   8 $@ ' 0 ! @H œ¶*šK– 5@Bj]NO@’‘ªX,W][sT _ VOQ’T,JKŽO@T+  #   3 $@(' 0 ! @H œ¶*šR– !I]M7j]@’‘ªX,W][sT _ VOQ’T,JKŽO@T+ d]JRA„JRLRV _ TMŠ@Bj]NO@’‘ªVOjjJKT,JKŽO@¨N _ Vai > _ @S _ JKT@XZ;X,T@BA„X±MPW _

VOJRA JRX´TMŠj@’•³I]@$V žª–B¥(­! †¹sšOž¡ ¸·O¹aªœŸ› ª¤P¥¦šŸ§s™

… _ MPA  > JRQ > JKT@BA„X9V _ @«X,W][T _ VOQ’T@Bj WIT,JRLT > @ XZ;X,T@BA XTMOi³XSˆ Ä T,X9IM;j]@BXVOIj¨@Bj]NO@BXQSV _,_ Z¨LRVa[@BLRXH… _ MPA  "! $  3 $@('E5   8 $@('' $†@Bj]NO@’‘ªX*W][T _ VOQ’T,JKŽO@°XZ7XT@BA„X 'M _ … _ MPA  "! $   3 $@('E5  3 $@('E5   8 $@ ''$¸X,W][T _ VOQŸ‘ T,JKŽO@5XZ;X,T@BA„X!' vÈ! #"%$»x$†Ì" ! Í #sÈlÊ{"üÍ$w Yuüxzy€{s|Ox$³È#³yz{²yzÈl˃y$»x€È9wSÉ¿wSx€È °w " !–¸µ¹³– #’·O¥ “0 $J 'f   vž†™7– œB–Sžg· #@Bj]NO@’‘ªX,W[T _ VOQ’T,JKMPI7‘“T@ _ A‚JRIVaT,JKMPILRVa[@BLRX· #   8 $  '¼‘0   "!  8 $@(' šP¹ vž†™7–œS–Bž+· #UX,W][T _ VOQ’T,JKMPI7‘“T@ _ A„JRIsVaT,JKMPIHLRVa[@BLRX!· #    $ 'j‘0    !   8 $@('5   3 $@ ' “0 $%J 'f ! « Ñœ@BjNO@’‘ªX,W][T _ VOQ’T,JKŽO@†à#  @ ‰ 0 $5 ‰ 6 8 ‰ l : ‰ 'MJM@  0 $5  6 8  l :  'f&Œ  $O ‰ JMO  J P'fKL  d $@ ‰ 'MJMOQPASR  $O ‰ 'MJMOQPA˜R   $O  ' fK(  3 $@  'MJ P f|(  8 $@  'Mj

Références

Documents relatifs

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST