Dynamic Resource Management in a Cluster for Scalability and High-Availability

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00072241

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00072241

Submitted on 23 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Dynamic Resource Management in a Cluster for Scalability and High-Availability

Pascal Gallard, Christine Morin, Renaud Lottiaux

To cite this version:

Pascal Gallard, Christine Morin, Renaud Lottiaux. Dynamic Resource Management in a Cluster for Scalability and High-Availability. [Research Report] RR-4347, INRIA. 2002. �inria-00072241�

(2)

ISRN INRIA/RR--4347--FR+ENG

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Dynamic Resource Management in a Cluster for Scalability and High-Availability

Pascal Gallard, Christine Morin, Renaud Lottiaux

N˚4347

Janvier 2002

THÈME 1

(3)

(4)

. /&"-0 "& 1234#56 798;:=<> "&-0? & 1@

ACB@DFEGB@H>IJB@HKHKB@LNMOQPSRQLFTKD"UVTKWXZY\[]LNT^W*O`_aXbW`B2cQMed[@UFUVTKB@c)fg

h*i;j"klmCnpoqFrslFtvuxwylz{rs|xr}z~j"klFr

~}l"z*`tvsr

ot;2zxl-~lF1ilF~1i;lbGJntvbGl"n3mV;tvvlFr

yF", ¡vv¢ £

¤v1xlF>z~?lwxlF"uxzsl9ivi¥@l"s¦§v~ktv;lt;¨©"tzsv;r¥t?"¨©u;rzslFFª)«zrivi¨|

lFrs©1t¬¨l*zss,Gxlxr}z~s¬uxz~lFarsl"~G"lFrQz~i;t,zv¨v¬;tv¨©¨|k9tv;tliG|Grs"t¨;slNru~"lFrrzs~©¬;uxzslN

,l")zsil"¨©u2r}z~l"`xxlNr"Q®,¯l"l"NªVtr`txrzs~¬uxzslN rsl"~G"l/k9tV|u2rl*~lFrsvu1lNr¨x"t,z~lF vx©°@lF±

lFbz/xxlNr"ªb«z¬2lNkSlNr/rsl"2r©zsvlz~ 1i;tvvlNr`9zsil¨u;rzslF/x²;u~tzsv9xul{zs xxl>tx©zsv³ª

~l"¬@Gz{¦´t¨usl £ ?zsir>;t@l"Nª;¯l~v@rslt9vlFl"~-rlFsGl-@l"s¦§v~kSy|b2tkslNru~"l

k9tv;tl"kl"bz©µt9¨u;r}z~l"¶v1xlFzsa;s,Gxl-xrzs~¬uxzslN¶rlFsGlNr¯«z~i¶iviJtV,t¨tv¬¨©©z}|yt2

r~"tv¨tv¬¨©©z}|vh*i;r-rsl"~G"li;tr¬2lFl"¥©k¨l"kl"bz~lFµ©¸·Cv¬@l"¨©2r-¨u;r}z~l"v@l"1t,z~©;rs|xr}z~l"k? h*il

|b2tkslNru1lk9t2tvlFkl"bzCrsl"~G"l¯l ~v@rslk9t¹lFr>xxltvx©zsv¥t;ZslF¬2Gvz>lNt~¨©|

z~~tv;rs;t~l"bzzst¨¨)xr}z~s¬uxz~lFJrsl"~G"lFrv¦º·Cv¬@l"¨©;r>t;³ª@tr{ta"v;rslF»bulF;lª¦§u¨¨©|z~~tv;r2t~l"bz

z~tv¨Ft,zsv2r" £ Jz~il lFvlFzC¦ºtyxxl¦´tv©¨u~lvª(t;¨©"tzsv;r>u;rs©;y~lFrsvu1lNr¨©xFt,zslN¶vZzsil

¦´tv©¨lFJxxllFlFJzsy¬@lSslNr}z1tszslF¦§~vk¼t9;slFbvu2r¨|r~tVvlN¶1ilF1¹G@vbz>¬uxz>zsiltV,t¨tv¬¨©©z}|v¦

z~il>"¨©u2r}z~l"º2lF~tzsrs|xr}z~l"k½rºvu;tv~tvbzsl"lN(ªv;s,GxlFSz~i;t,z«z1r/xrzs~©¬uzslFyrlFsGlFr©k¨l"kl"bz

~lF"vx²2vu1t,z~©9¦§lFtzsu~lFrF

¾¶¿bÀ]Á~ÂÃ ,Äv¢ Å ¨©u;rzslFFª@xr}z~s¬uxz~lFJrs|xr}z~l"k?ª2~lFrsvu;~"l-ktv;tl"kl"bzNª;ivix±ÆtV,t¨tv¬¨©©z}|vª;¦´tu¨©z±

z~v¨l"1t;"lv

ÇÈ(ÉsÊÌËFÍ*ÉÎÏÊÌÐKÑÒ

ÓÔsÕVÖØ×Ù1ÖØÖÚÙ1ÛÜÝ}ÞßàÛ´áØâbÜÛ´ÖØß1ã^ã^áÚÙ1ävå1æáØÛ´áØçÌÙNèé©Û

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes

(5)

?)& Q7&& & 7y) 4 µ à0? & 1

¢ tv;r¨l{¬;uxz*l"wGqNuxz~l"*xlFr/t;¨©"tzsv;ri;tvuxzslNrº@l"s¦§v~k9t;"lFrrsuul{~tv@l

la"t¨u;¨tzsl"u;~rFª³¨lFrz-¦§vszslFkSlFbzrui;t©zsq9xlars2brlFu¸l";rsl"k ¬¨laxlarlFsGlNrCrzs~©¬;uqFr

Ft;tv¬¨lxl?q"~l"S¨©lNrslNrsrsvu1lNr;ib|xrs»bulNrxrzs~¬uq"lNrJz~~tVl"1r¨lFr9«°]q"~l"bz~rS-u2r9xl?¨t

~tv@lv Å l"@l";tvbzFªxurlFsGl>rzs~©¬;uq>@l"uz*l"wx¨©«z~l"*xlFr~lFr~ru1lFrºiG|xr»bul"kl"bz*r©zsuqFlFr

rsuxlNrQ-u;rºxrzs;z~rF Å lrsl"~G"l/lNr}zºx;*xq"@l"2tbzºxlNr`1i;tl"kl"bz1rlv²;vu1t,z~© xl

¨t>v1t@l/xlFt¨u¨t,z~l"u1r)rsu©zsl>uSt}vuxzNª,sl"zs1t©zu xq"¦´t¨©¨t2l*u; -u2( t2r"lztszs¨lvª

;vu;rS~v@rsv;r u rlFsGlvq";q"~»bul°]~tvbz ul?lFrzsv |b2tk»bul?xlNr ~lFr~rsvu1lNr ul

~tv@lCtv;r¨l¬uxz{°]sxlNrrlFsGlNr/~q"2tszsr/i2tuxz~l"kl"bz{xr@v;©¬¨l-lz2tvr~rstvz¦´tv"©¨l"klFz

y¨qF1i;l"¨¨©l Å lSrlFsGl lFrzC~qFtv¨©rq t;r>¨lSrs|xr}z~j"kl lwx¨v©z~tzsvJ@vu;C~tv@l ·Cv¬@l"¨©2r"t

lFrzsv x|G;tvk»bulxlFr slNrsrsvu;~"lFr»bulvu;r ~v@rsv;rslF;¸¨ t}vuxzSvu ¨ly~lz~~tv«zxly-u2

;~tzs»u;l"kl"bz9zs1t2r;tvslFbz¥z~vu;ra¨©lNrarlFsGlNr9xrzs~¬uqFryxlµ·Cv¬@l"¨;r9lz;ty"v;rsqF»bulFbz

z~vuxz~lFr¨lFrtv¨Ft,z~©;r"

t2r¨©lFtvrxl-¨t9xq"¦´t¨©¨t;"l-u;¶-u;(ª¨lFr{t¨"t,z~©;r*lwx¨v©z~tvbz

lFra~lFr~rsvu1lNrsqNrlFbzslFrru;a¨©lµ-u; xq"¦´t¨©¨tbz?xvvlFz"!"zs~lJ~lFxqFktvs~l"al"uru @vz

l~l";srl~qF"qFxlFkSklFz9l"°@lNàzsu;qvªktvr¨tµi;tuxz~l±Æxr@v¬¨©©zsqJu=rs|xr}z~j"kl?lFrzbt1tbzsKªlF

rsu@r~tbz»bul¨©lNrrlFsGlNrxrzs~¬uqFr¦§u~r~rsl"bz¨©lNr*vuxz~©¨rxl-~lFx²;u~tzsva;lFlNrsr~t~lFrF

#'Ã N Á ¡$ ¢ ·C~tv@l xl Ft¨u¨t,z~l"u1r"ªrs|xr}z~j"kl xrzs~©¬u;qvªlFrzsvxl slNrsrsvu1lªi;tuxz~l±

rs2¬©¨©zsqvªzsv¨q"1t2ltuxwa¦´tvuxzslNr

(6)

D E

Q94º)

h)¶lFa"©lFz~¨©|µlwxlF"uxzsl9i;©i¥@l"s¦§v~k9t;"l9t¨"t,z~©;rFª¨u;rzsl"v@l"1t,zs¶rs|GrzslFk9rku;rz°]l"

rsvklJ¨©¬;t¨{slNru~"l¶k9t;tvvl"klFzyrsl"~G"lFratr9¦§ylwtvkS;¨©lZt slFkSvzslJ2tv rs|xr}z~l"kHGIJKªt

rs|xr}z~l"k!v¦G2lF~tzsvl>²;¨©l-Ftv1ilNrGmvm2J*t v¨v¬2t¨(rs1i;lFxu¨l"=GmJK.K>rtvzsilFl"wtk¨lvªtS¨u;r}z~l"

L0M ktV|v°@lFt rzs~©¬uzslF M i;tvslN:N¶l"ks|OGÚªPJrlFsGl`z~Crsu@vsztv¨Ft,zsv2r¬;trlN-vzsil

rsi;tvslNkSlFkv~|S2t1tvxvk?(K\"¨©u;rzslF L0M "ty¬2lxl²2lFtvrtrslz/v¦)xr}z~s¬uxz~lFrlFsGlFrF ul

z~©z~rºrzs~©¬;uxzslN;t,z~uslªz~ilivix±ÆtV,t¨tv¬¨©©z}|v¦]rsu;1iat92lF~tzs-r|xrzslFk rvzºvu2t1tbzslFlF

¯i;l"yt-;Gl¦´t¨rFQN¶v~l",l"Nªvt-xxl>tvx©zsvyv/rsiGuxz~,¯ariu¨¬2lCxvl{¯«z~ivuxz*r}z~v;©

z~il¨u;rzslFt;«z1r~u9t;¨©"tzsv;rF

£ 9z~irº;tv2lFFªb¯l{~v@rsltx|G;tvk{slNru~"l*ktv;tl"kl"bz/rsl"~G"l¯ibrlk9tv©atv¨rºzs

i;xltG|?¹G©2J¦º1i2tlSR§;GlStx©zsv³ª(lFbàz~©Jv>¦´t¨uslCTJz~il¨u;r}z~l"x²;vu;~tzsv?zs

z~il L0M

xrzs~¬uxzslN?rlFsGlFr*tv;zsSzsiltv¨Ft,z~©;r"

h*ir¯v~¹?z~t¹lFrC¨tv"lS¥zsilS¦§1tkl"¯v~¹?¦/zsilaxlNrv¤t2Zk¨©lFkl"bz~tzsv¥¦*·C¬2lF¨©;r

"¨©u2r}z~l"

L0M

Q·Cv¬@l"¨©2rrt¶rs©¨©lr|xrzsl"kktvvl L0M

¯i1i tk9rt,z °]l"~©?z~ilaGrv¤¦tv

M N¶k9tv1il9z~J~vv1tkkl"1rF·Cv¬@l"¨©2rkS;¨©lFkSlFbz~rtZrl"z¦xr}z~s¬uxz~lF rsl"~G"lFrC¦§vzsil

¨©¬;t¨2k9t;tvvl"klFz/¦³kl"kv~|vªb~xlFr~rsvºtv;axr¹~lFrsvu1lNr" L u/l"lFsx|G;tvk{slNru~"l

k9tv;tl"kl"bzºrsl"~bli2tvr¬@l"lFalwx@l"~©klFz~lF¯©zsiz~il{¨©¬;t¨klFkSs|Sk9t;tvvlFkSlFbzºrlFsGl:R´t

r}z~s¬uxz~lF M i;tvslNSN¶lFkv~|TG©mN=J¦`·Cv¬@l"¨©2r*¦§vxxltx©zsv?t;l"Gàz~©³

h*ilyslFktv©2xl"-v¦/z~ir;t@l"r-sbtVU"lNZtr¦§v¨¨©,¯rF £¥zsi;lalwGz rslFzsv¥¯/l9bzs~xxu;l

z~ilkGl"¨(¦zsil-xr}z~s¬uxz~lFrlFsGlNr"v;rsxl"~lF9zsir*;t@l"tv;y;slNrlFz*vu;*trsrsukxz~©;r"

£ M lFzsvy ¯l>xlNrs"s¬2l>zsi;l>~v@rslF9|b2tk>~lFrsvu1lk9tv;tl"kl"bz/rsl"~G"l>t2yrsi,¯ i,¯

©z-²z1r¸·C¬2lF¨©;r L0M tv~1i;«z~lFàz~u~lv M lNàzsv¤¶~,GlFr-rsvklaxlz1t¨rslF¨tzslFZzs?z~ilyrsl"~G"l

k¨l"kl"bz~tzsvt;~lFrsl"bz~r/lwx@l"~©kl"bz1t¨]slNru;¨«z1r"

M

lNàzsvWPslNrlFbz~r/slF¨tzslFy¯/s¹xrt;y¯/l

"v;"¨©u2xl©

M

lNàzsvHX

Y 94&¤+

.

9() 4 : ) )

Z¥l{"v;rsl"`zsir;tv2lF/t-"¨©u;rzslF L0M tvrºt-rl"zº¦(xr}z~s¬uxz~lF9rsl"~blNr"\[ºtv1iarsl"~G"l*s,GxlFr

¨©¬;t¨ktv;tl"kl"bz¦§{v;l¹G©;J¦`iG|xr"tv¨³slNru1lv^];vl"wxtvk¨©lª@ty¨u;r}z~l" L0M ktV|°]l"

t M

N6rlFsGlªv~,Gxt-¦§v~k v¦(v¨v¬;tv¨;kl"kv~|Sktv;tl"kl"bz=G_CJ]vt-`t1t¨¨©lF¨`]¨©l

M

|xr}z~l"k

GJ¯i;1i?~,GxlNrv¨v¬;tv¨]rs¹ak9t;tvvlFkSlFbzF

a^bdc egfihjlkmf.nporqtsduvw"sdxBy^vjlh{z#j|w~}^sOj

£ z~ir)rslFzsv³ªV¯l~v@rsltvlFl"1t¨kxxlF¨v¦trzs~©¬;uxzslNrlFsGlªF;tvz)¦t¨u;rzslFv@l"1t,z~©;

rs|xr}z~l"k?·Cv¬@l"¨©2r L0M rzs~©¬;uxzslNrsl"~G"lFr*x¦§v~k!z~ z~irkGl"¨KQZµlCz~tv¹vlCzsi;l-lwtk¨l¦t

rzs~©¬;uxzslNrsi;tvslNakl"kv~|9z~S¨¨©u;rzs1t,z~lzsir*kxxl"¨K

h*il"¨©u2r}z~l"rk2brlNv¦]t-rslzv¦OxxlNr`Guk¬@l"~lF ¦§~vkCz~:7lzu;rºv2rxl"t

rsl"~G"l*ªva1i;t~vl*v¦2z~ilk9t;tvvlFkSlFbzQv¦³t-rl"z¦(iG|xr"tv¨xslNru~"lFrQv¦2z}|G@l z~-©k¨l"kl"bz

tv 2lF~tzsZrs|GrzslFk t¬;rzs1tvzsv]Sl"wtk¨lvªºt M N%rs|GrzslFk k9t;tvvlFr tµrslz¦>;tl

¦§1tklNr*©iG|xr"tv¨(kSlFkv~|9zskS;¨©lFkSlFbzzsil-Gz~u;t¨(;tvvl-t¬2r}z~~tàzsv

(7)

[ºt1i9xxl¦]zsi;l{¨u;rzsl"/k9tV|i;tVl¨©x"tv¨;r}z1t;"lFrº¦@zsil>iG|Grs"t¨;slNru~"lv

£

;r}z1t;"lFr`v¦

~lFrsvu;~"lB vxxlt~lCktv;tlFy¬b|at ¨GFt¨³rsl"~vlF)¯i;1irtv¨rs ?1i;t~vl>¦);sxlNrsrs

~lF»bulNr}z1r>rsl"bz-¬G|¶slFkzslSxxlNrCtv;µslF¨tzslFJzszsil¨x"t¨Q~lFrsvu1lNr"

£

µzsi;l

M N lwtk¨lvª³t

2tvlrsl"~vl"*rtS¨©xFt¨³rsl"~vl"N £ zslNr@v;;rºz~9;tl>G,t¨tzsvv;tvvl~lF»bulFrz~rF

£ tZxrzs~¬uxzslN¸r|xrzslFkªQ¨©¬;t¨x¦§sk9t,z~©¸r tvr~rx"tzslF¥¯©zsi lNtv1i¤;r}z1t;"la¦{tv t¬x±

rzs1tvzsv³¶h*irx¦§sk9t,z~©¸k9tV|¥"vbz~tv©¥zsi;lyxl"bzs©z}|¤¦xxlNr-zsi2t,zStvsla"v;"l"~lF¥¬G|¥zsil

k¨l"kl"bz~tzsv ¦z~ilZt¬2r}z~~tàzsv z~v v¦>z~ilZiG|xrsFt¨~lFrsvu1lNr" ·C¨©¬;t¨x¦§sk9t,z~©

r ¹vl"zS tµx©~lFzss|¥©2xlwxlF ¯«z~i z~iltv¬;rzs1tvàz~©¸©2r}z1t;"lyGuk¬@l"N slNàz~v~|¥x¦§sk9t,±

z~©¶1i;tlFr,vlFzskSl tvr*~lFrs2;r¬¨©©z}|av¦xxlNr*slFtv~x zsil-k9tv;tl"kl"bz¦`tS;tszsu¨t

tv¬;rzs1tvàz~©1i;tvvlNr"Qh*ilFsl-t~l-rlFvlF~tv¨@¯*tV|xr/zsk9t;tvvl>zsilx~lFàz~v~|a¦QtSvvl"?rsl"~bl

mv £ Jt9lFz~~tv¨©VU"lNtv~t1i³ªtxxlºrJ1i;t~vlC¦`k9tbz~tv©Szsi;l¯iv¨lxslNàz~v~|t

x1tV¯¬;tv1¹¦QzsirCt~t1irz~i;t,zCxxl*k9tV|y¬@lF"vkl t9¬@zszs¨l"lN1¹tr©z{r>"vbz~tàzslN

lFt1iyz~©kltSxxl-lFlFrz~atv""lFr~rv¨v¬;tv¨@x¦§sk9t,z~©³

x

£ t t~t1iµ¬2tvrslF¸¸slNxu;tv;|ªzsilx©~lFzss|µr slF¨Ft,zslN¤v tv¨©¨xxlFrFZh*il

x1tV¯¬;tv1¹S¦(z~ir*tv~tv1i9rºzsi;tzu]tzs ¨©¬;t¨@x¦§v~k9t,zsv9rvlFs|Slwx@l";rs©l>tr/tv¨©¨

©lNr*¦zsil©~lFzsv~|9lFlFzs¬@l-¹vl"z"v;rsr}z~l"bzF

£ tSxr}z~s¬uxz~lFytv~t1i³ªvlNtv1iaxxlCr/1i2t~vlv¦k9tz1t tSru;¬;rl"zv¦(zsil-x~lFà±

zss|

h*i;lZxxlµ© 1i2t~vl¶¦t ;tszsu;¨tvxslNàz~v~| l"bz~s| ryl"lF~tv¨©¨| rz~tzs"t¨¨|=xl"²;lN( h*i;r

tv~t1iblNrº;zrsux°]l"/¦§sk zsilx1tV¯¬;tv1¹xr`v¦(zsil>z}¯/slFG©u;rºtv~tv1i;lFrF £ au/kxxlF¨^ª

¯l;rsxlFt-xr}z~s¬uxz~lF9t;sbtv1i³\[ºtv1ixxl{irz~rtk9tv;tl"`¯i1ir/tsx"lFr~rQ©a1i;tvsl

v¦)k9t2tvxslNàzss|y©x¦§sk9tzsv³

];v9lwtvkS;¨©lªº t M Nr|xrzslFkªºzsil¶,¯;l"¦-t¥;tlrSzsil¶;Glz~i;t,zai2tvr9t¤b|¸v¦

z~ila;tvvl t?¨©x"tv¨;tvvlS¦§~tvklat;¥rzsily¨tr}zlzsJi2tVvl¯s©zz~l"¥zsi;la;tlv7K!x©~lFzss|

k9tv©bz~tv©2r¦§vlNtv1iSbszsu;tv¨;tlzsilxl"bz~«z}|S¦]«z1ru;s~l"bz`,¯l"trzsil{,¯l"`v¦]t©l"S;tl

k9tV|J1i;tvvlS,vlF{z~©kl NJt;tvvlF>v¦/G©szsu2t¨`;tvvl¶"tvµ¬@l9xl²;;lF¤r}z1t,z~Ft¨¨©|Jtr¬2lF©?xxl

1

2 3

Pages Manager

Client Pages Server

Pages Manager

Pages Server

Pages Manager

Pages Server

Request Node 1

Node 2

Node 3

])vu;slm * O'3 -:p8 +!@+ 4!,8 +A=

(8)

£

¸t?¨u;rzsl"¦§sklNZ¬G|¶z~islFlxxlFr R^rlFl ]vu~l?m=Tª¨lz-u;r-tvr~rsukl z~i;t,zt?"¨©l"bz-~G"lFr~r"ª

~u;©?{GlWvªk9tv¹vlFrt%58"+!>¥tkrsrs©;2tvl)

£

¥~l"Czs?v¬z~t¸t?vG|

v¦ª{xxl k u;r}z>¨©x"tzslz~ilk9t;tvvlF¦Jt2¶rlF;?«z>zsilp58p"+!^xxlSS¯i1i¶r

k9tv;tl"¦§s¯*t1rºzsilC~lF»bulFrzzsxxl-z~i;t,zrzsv~lFrºzsi;lC~lF»bulNr}z~lFy;tlvQh*il¨©x"tv¨(rlFsl"ºv¦

{xxl-9vk¨lz~lFrz~il-slN»bulFrzt;rlF;rz~il-;tlCzsxxl9m

a^b@a u*u*yvsdfu

Z¥l"tv¨©¨"vx²2vu1t,z~©zsi;l{rl"z`¦(tvàz~©l*xxlFr`Szsil"¨©u2r}z~l"N K xxlr`;rsxlFslNz~-¬2ltàz~©l

©¦Q«z{i2tvr*vz¬2lFl"¶xlz~lFzslF¦´tv©¨lF¬G|yvzsilFtvàz~©lxxlFrtv;rz{"us~l"bz~¨©|9¬@l"atv;xlFzs

l"Gàz~lF¦§~vk zsilS¨u;r}z~l"Nh*ilrs|GrzslFk r{r~tzsy¬2l +!54'3! ! ¯il"J;yx²;vu;~tzsv

1i2tlCr¬@l"9~xlFr~rslF(.];vz~ilrstv¹vl¦`¨t~©z}|vª¯ltvr~ru;kSlCz~i;t,z¨©|vl-kxx©²2"tzsv?

z~il¨u;rzsl"`"vx²;u1t,zsvSR´tCxxltv«z~©³ªl"Gàz~©v¦´tv©¨u~l=T)k9tV|-GFu`tzQtvb|z~©kl £ zsi;r

"vbzsl"wGzFª@¯/ltrsrsukl-z~i;t,ztax²;vu;~tzsv¶1i;t;vl-v;¨©|i;t;2lF;r{¯i;l"¶z~il rs|xr}z~l"kr{© +!54'3

+! !Qh*iGu;rt-xxl¦´tv©¨u~l{"tvvzºi;t;2lFa¯il"z~il>"¨©u2r}z~l" L0M rºsx"lFr~rt;Gl{tv«z~©

*l"Gzsv³(Z¥l-tvr~rukl>zsi;tz*zsill"z}¯/s¹r*l"l";tszs©zsvlN(ªtvr*t lz}¯v~¹;tszs©zsv¯/u¨

¨lFtaz~Szsil¦´tv©¨u~l-¦rsl"l"1t¨]xxlNrt,zzsi;lrstvkSlCz~©klv

Z¥l trsrsuklzsi;tz{z~ilkku"tzsvJrs|xr}z~l"kvu;tv~tvz~l"lNrzsi;tzzsilFslr{aklFr~rstvvl-¨rz{v

u¨Ft,zslN?klFr~rstvvlFrtv;zsi2t,z{klFr~r~tvlNrt~lxl"¨vl"~lF?zsilv1xl"*z~il"|?t~lrlFbzF^N¶v~l",l"Nª

¯l-tvr~ru;kSlCz~i;t,zklFr~r~tvlNr/tvslvz{t¨©zslFslNyxu~zs1t;rskr~rs©³

a^b oQv f.n o kdyuvj|w f yw~o vsdfo .j f o qtsuv*w`s xByvjlh

zij|w}sdOj

lzu;r,¯ xlFr~~¬2l/¯i;t,z)zsil©k;tàzQ¦;t>xxl/tx©zsv³ª,lFGzsv¦´tv©¨u~lºrt>rzs~©¬;uxzslN

rsl"~G"lv

!#"%$&"(' ) Ã Ä ¿ ;Ä)Ä+*§,*Ã.-

K{¨©¨/zsi;l"¨©u;rzslFxxlNrk u;rz ¬@lx¦§v~klF¥z~i;t,z9t¶lF¯!xxlyr txlN¸© v1xl"zsZ¬@ltv¬¨lazs

"vkku;Ft,z~l{¯©zsiy©zF

L

azsilCz~il"*rxlªz~ill"¯ ;Gl>k u;r}z*¨lFt~9z~ilC"u~slFz*x²;vu;~tzsv

v¦"¨©u;rzslFFmK l"¯ xxls,GxlFrtx©zsv;tv¨;ib|xrsFt¨Q~lFrsvu1lNr{Zz~il9¨u;rzsl"Nh*il"~l¦§slª]t

;l"¯!¨GFt¨rlFsl"k u;r}zS¬2l~lFtzslF v¤zsi;ltv;xlF¸;Glvµh*i;r xxlyk9tV|¤t¨rZ;tszs;t,z~l9zs

z~ilv¨v¬;tv¨k9tv;tl"kl"bz v¦zsi;l?rsl"~G"lv £ zsir9"trltZlF¯ k9t;tvvlF lFlFr z~µ¬@l¶~lFt,z~lF(

NZt;tvvl"1rQlwxlNuxz~©-9z~il";GlFrk u;rz¬2l>©x¦§sklN v¦]zsil{tx©zsv9v¦(t;l"¯ xxl9v1xl"

z~9rlF;y©z;tsz¦)zsilx~lFàz~v~|v Z il"z~ilxxl-tvx©zsv~xlFr~rs©Srvk¨lz~lF(ªtv¨©¨³tàz~©l

;GlFr*¦zsi;l¨u;r}z~l"k u;r}zi;tVlCzsilr~tklG©lF¯ ¦zsi;l"¨©u2r}z~l"{"vx²;u1t,zsv

!#"%$&"/! ) Ã Ä ¿¶¿0 *^¡1*Ã-

Z i;l"atxxlrºrsiGuxz/x,¯ªzsi;l"~lrº¨©lNrsr`;ib|xrsFt¨~lFrsvu;~"lFrQzsil{"¨©u2r}z~l"Nh*il>v~~lFrs2;x

¨x"tv¨Grsl"~vlFQr`rzs2lN(

£

z~irºvbz~lwGzFª,z~il¨u;rzsl"

L0M

ku2r}zrzsv zsi;lu;rstvvl¦2zsilNrl*~lFrsvu1lNr

tv;¥xxlFrku;rz rzs¤zsJrsl";¤klFr~r~tvlNrCzs¶z~ilylFGzslF¥¨x"t¨rlFsl"NSN¶slF,vlFFª(;tvz ¦*zsil

(9)

©~lFzsv~|¸k9tV|¸¬2lJrzsslN zsil¶xxl¶rsiGuxzz~© ,¯³

M

µz~ilFrslJxslNàz~v~|¸l"bzs~©lNrSku;rza¬2l

kv1t,z~lFbzsCvlv`rsl"vlF~tv¨vzsilFQxxlFrF

£

Sv1xlFz~C¬2t¨t;"lºz~il*¨©btvv¦2k9t2tvCx©~lFzss|

lFbzs~©lNr*v?t¨¨(ktv;tl"1r"ªG©zk9tV|a¬2l-u2rl"¦§u¨(zs9"vkuxz~lt ;l"¯ x©~lFzss|axrzs~©¬uzsv¦§u;àz~©³

h*i;lS"¨©l"bz~r>~lF»bulFrz~r>lFlF¶z~¬@l zs1t;rsk«zszslFJzszsilS~©izCk9t;tvvl"CxlFrs©zsl zsilSk©~tzsvJv¦

rsvklx~lFàz~v~|l"bz~slFrF\K>r`zsi;l{rl"z¦(iG|xr"tv¨xslNru1lFrQk¨l"kl"bzstGz~u;t¨~lFrsvu;~"lk9tV|

1i2tl9¯il" tJxxlylFbàz~©¸i;t;2lF;r"ª`rsvklyx~lFàz~v~|ZlFz~slFrku;rz ¬@lyu;@tzslN¤zsJ~l2lFàz

z~il9lF¯'¯*tV|Ztbszsu;tv¨`slNru~"l rkS;¨©lFkSlFbzslF³p]©;tv¨©¨|vª«¦*~G"lFr~rlNrt~lSl"wxlFuzs?v¥zsil

rzsxxlvªGz~il"|yku;rz¬2l-kv1t,z~lFabzsSzsi;l"tvzsvlxxlNr"QK{r¦§tSxxl-tvx©zsvªxzsil

;Gl ¨lFtVGaz~ilS"¨©u2r}z~l"ku;rz©x¦§sk¼vzsilFxxlFrCZv1xlF{z~i;t,zt¨¨QslFk9t©;tvzsvl xxlFr

i2tVvl>zsilr~tklG©lF¯ ¦zsi;l-l"¯ ¨u;rzsl""vx²2vu1t,z~©³

!#"%$&"%$ ) Ã Ä ¿ *$ ¿

K k9t¤x«°]l"~l"2l¬2l"z}¯/lFl"¥t;Gl ¦´tv©¨u~lStv;ZzsilSz}¯;slFbvu2r>rs«z~u;t,z~©;rrCzsi;tz-ty¦´t¨©

;GlFt;z*z~«¦§|avzsilF*xxlFr¦«z1r¦´t¨©u;sl M S©zrlNlNrsr~t~|Szsi;tztv¨©¨³tàz~©lC"¨©u;rzslF*xxlFr

lzslNàzt?xxlS¦´tv©ü~l9¬2l"¦§v~ltvG|JslN,l"~|Jtvàz~©³ Z ilF¤t?;Gl ¦´tv©ü~l9x"u;~rFª(zsi;laü;r}z~l"

¨rslFrazsilµ¨©xFt¨{~lFrsvu;~"lFr9v¦-zsilZ¦´t¨©lN xxlvª>t k9t;tvvlFyt; zsil¥x©~lFzss| l"bzs~©lNry©z¯*tvr

k9tv;t©2h*i;lCx~lFàz~v~|©x¦§sk9tzsvarsvkl>;GlFrk9tV|S;z¬2lC,t¨tG|Gkv~lvªbt;yi;tvr/zs

¬@l~lF;rzs~u;àz~lFSxu~©-~lF",vlFs|(sx"lFr~rlNrQlwxlF"uxzs-vSz~il*¦´t¨©lNSxxl{t~l*¨©br}ztv;riu¨

¬@l~lFrz~tvz~lF¦§~vk ty1ilN1¹G2©bz>t¦zsl"C~lF,l"~|vª©¦ºtG|lwxr}z1r"N¶v~l",l"Nª;rklklFr~rstvvlFr{rlFz

z~Szsil¦´tv©¨lFxxl-"tvvz*~lFt1iyz~il"xlNr}z~©;tzsv³

¼9 Q/

£ zsir?rlNàz~©³ª{¯lZ~lFrsl"bz?t l"lFsZx|G;tvkZslNru~"lJk9t;tvvlFkSlFbzrsl"~blZzsi;tzk9tv¹vlFr

1i2tlFr©z~il¨u;rzsl""vx²2vu1t,z~©ylNt~¨©|z~~tv;r2t~l"bz/z~zsil L0M xr}z~s¬uxz~lF?rsl"~blNr"

{Gltv;x«z~© t;¤rsiGuxz~x,¯ tvsl9k9txlyk¨©l"zslF¨©|µzs1t;rs;tvslFzz~¶zsilt;¨©"tzsv;rtr}±

rsukSzsi;tz>tSsx"lFr~r*kSv1t,z~©klN1i;trsk rs,GxlF³(K xxl¦´t¨©u;slrt¨rSz~~tv;r2t~l"bz

¦§1ilF1¹G@vbzslFt;¨©"tzsv;rF

^bdc qtjlu*s f.nSoqo sd j\uf yw"Oje o o .j&rj& v z#j|w}sOj

L u;-vtv¨Qrz~JxlFrsv¤t¨tV|vlF©¥zsi;la¨u;r}z~l" L0M ª]zsi;tz¯/laFt¨¨tvtvxz~tzsv¥¨tV|l"Nª(¯i1i¤r-

1i2t~vl9¦k9t2tvZ"vx²2vu1t,z~©¤1i2tlFr-¸zsi;l¨u;rzslF t2¤zsZzs~©vl"slNv²;vu1t,z~©µv¦

rzs~©¬;uxzslN rlFsGlNr¯ilF lFlFxlNtR¦§ l"wxtvk¨©lªt,¦z~l"xlz~lFàz~© v¦{tJxxly¦´t¨©u~l=T £ zsil

;s2brlN tv~1i©zslNàz~uslªz~il L0M xrzs~¬uxzslN rlFsGlFrS~l"¨| v=z~ilJtvtvxz~tzsv=¨tV|l"¯i1i r

¬2tvrslF9azsi;l"¨©u2r}z~l"*vkk u"t,z~©rs|xr}z~l"k R]vu~lCTàh*iltv;txz1t,zsvy¨tV|l"ºr*xlFrsvlN9zs

k9tv¹vlCslNv²;vu1t,z~©1i;tvvlNr/zs1t;rs;t~l"bzzs9tG|a¹G;¦Qxrzs~¬uxzslN?rlFsGlv

h*il¯*tV|xr}z~s¬uxz~lFSrlFsGlNrtvsl~v~tvkSklN-rQu;;1i;t;vlF³ K=vlFl"~ºbzsl"s¦´tv"l*i;tvrQ¬@l"lF

l²;lNy¬@lz}¯l"lFrzs~©¬;uxzslNrsl"~G"lFrt;yzsi;ltvtvxz~tzsvy¨tV|vlFF £?tvx©zsv¯lC¯*tbzzsi;tVl

tSl"lFs{;svzsx¨]zsi;t2x¨©l-tvb|y¹b;¦Qx²;vu;~tzsv1i2tlC?t9¨u;r}z~l"N(Zµlxvz¯tvbz

z~9xlFrs©tr*k9tG|yx©°@lFslFbzkSlN1i;t;rsk9rtvr;tszsu;¨tv1i;tlFrz~il¨u;rzslFv²;vu1t,z~©³

(10)

h*ilttz~t,z~©¨tV|vlF/r¶1i;t~vl>¦zsil¦§¨©¨,¯©;z1tvrs¹Gr

mv*©k¨l"klFz~©;¥tµ~zsx"v¨/¦§vtJxxlzs¥©¦§v~k zsi;l"SxxlFr zsi2t,z«zrtxlF vriGuxz

x,¯³ª

xxlz~lFzs9xxl¦´t¨uslNr"ª

*~,bxt9v2rr}z~l"bzG©lF¯ ¦)zsil"¨©u2r}z~l"{"vx²;u1t,zsvª

;Gv1x;t,z~©;z~il-~zsx"v¨]zs9xlNt¨(¯©zsi¶t9¨u;rzslFv²;vu1t,z~©1i;tvvlª

PxkS;uxzsJt¶xr}z~s¬uxz~©¥¦§u;àz~©¥zsi;tz¹vl"lF;rz~ilaxslNàzss|¶lFbzs~©lNr-k9t;tvvl"klFz-¬;tv¨«±

t;"lF¬@lz}¯l"l"k9t;tvvlF~rFª

X*¨©xFt,zsSzsi;l-ktv;tl"*¦`tS;tszsu;¨tvlFbzs~|a¦)zsilx~lFàz~v~| R§¯©zsi¶t7'3=!Tàª

GxlFtv¨©¯©zsi?k©~tzsv¦©~lFzsv~|9l"bz~slFr*¯ilF¶tS"vx²2vu1t,z~©1i;tvvlCi;t;2lF;r"

Communication Communication

Superviseur Superviseur

Distributed Service 2 Distributed

Service 1 Distributed

Services Network of

Nodes Adaptation

Physical Network

Node 0 Node 1

]©uslQ 2< $!,!@2 8'

h*iltvtvxz~tzsv¨tV|vl"ku;rz)¬@lºtvr©2xl"@l";l"bztr³@r~r¬¨l`¦§sket{r@lF"«²2/rlFsGl®,¯l"l"Nª

©~lFzsv~|Sl"bzs~©lNrk9t2tvlFkl"bzºrº¬bGvu;rs¨| @l"s¦§v~klF9¬G|Szsil>slF¨tzslNaxr}z~s¬uxz~lFyrsl"~G"lv Zµl

;l"lF z~i;tVvlrsvklvlFl"~/2lF~tzsv;rQ¨¹vl{t1¹b;,¯¨©lNxvlFkSlFbzFªt2Srs@lF©²22lF~tzsv;r¦§lFt1i

rsl"~G"lv:N¶slF,vlFFª2¯il"¤t1i2tlx""u~r>Zz~ilS"vx²2vu1t,z~©Zt¨¨`rlFsGlFr>lFlF¶z~?2lF¦§sk

rsvkl~lFx²;u~tzsv³

£

zsir¯*tV|vªb¦§vlNtv1irsl"~G"l-rk©¨t*v@l"1t,z~©;rrl"lNxlFt,zz~ilrstvkl

z~©kl

K xrzs~¬uxzslNJrsl"~blFt¶u;rsl-z~il ttxz1t,z~©¨tV|vlF{t,¦z~l"Ct9slFvr}z~l"~©;rzslF³h*ilSr@lF"«²2

¦§u;;àz~©;rt~lxlF"¨tvslNxu;sSzsir~l"rzslFs;

h*irr/z~il>k9tv©slNtvrsv9¯iG|¯/lr;¨©©z/z~iltvtvxz~tzsva¨tV|vlFºz~z}¯;tvz1r"Q]~rzFªxt¨©¬;t¨

klN1i;trsk l²;lNr)rsvkl/vl";l"~ºv@l"1t,zsv2r³;rxlºzsil*tvtvxz~tzsv¨tV|vlFF M 2lN©²2/rsl"~G"lz1tvrs¹Gr

r*~,GxlNy¬G|ytS¨uv±K;rrs|GrzslFk?

L l>©k@vsz~tvzºz~tvrs¹ zs¬@l{@l"s¦§v~klF¯ilFytx²;u~tzsv91i;tvvlxFu~slNSrzsil>kSv1t,±

z~© v¦@x~lFàz~v~|l"bzs~©lNr" £Szsiltv;txz1t,zsv ¨tV|l")zsilx~lFàz~v~|-l"bzs~lFrk©~tzsvrQ@l"s¦§v~kSlN

¶¦§u>2tsz~rmR]©u~l T{xu~©;t 585 !!6 "+ 8[ºtv1iZrzslFJk9tV|¶"t¨¨Qtyrs2lN©²2rsl"~G"l

¦§u;;àz~© R´~,bxlNy¬G|9z~il-¨u±Ì©2rr|xrzsl"k T

(11)

Before Adaptation

In Adaptation

Tx

In Adaptation

Rx

After Adaptation Migration

Ack

]vu~l- ?B85 !!6 =85'

$&"('."('

¿ÌÃ ¿ *2V 1*Ã.-

h*i;l tv;txz1t,zsv¶¨tV|vlF~l";tvslNrz~ilkv1t,zsv¶v¦ºxslNàzss|©¦§v~ktzsv³Ch*ir>rz~tvvli;tv@l";r

¬@l¦§slu]tzszsil-¨x"tzsvN

$&"('."/! ¿ - Ä *- Ã

h*i;l¨©xFt,zsr{tvr~rsuklF?u]t,z~lF(B]v>lFt1i?rsl"~G"lFrFªz~ilxslNàz~v~|yl"bz~slFrzsi;tz>ku2r}z>1i2tl

k9tv;tl"{tvsl kSv1t,z~lFz~yz~il "v~slNr@v;©yxxlFrFK vlFl"1t¨tv1¹G,¯¨lFxl"kl"bz{rsl"bz{z~tv¨©¨

$&"('."%$ y¿ ¡ ¿ *0@¿

$&"('."

¿ *2V 1*Ã.-

^b@a v*jlw~no(Oj v j^o Bkdj f.ntv j kdf.xoQk e j&rf.w ego o .j&rj& v

z u5vj&

Nrsl"~G"lv

£ µzsil9"v;rsl"~lFZrsl"~G"lvª³txslNàzss|?lFz~s|J"v~slNr@v2rz~tGz~u;t¨Q;tvvlv ³lz-u;rCz1t¹l

Ft¨¨r !"$#&%'"("()+*-,.0/G £ ZzsirCvbz~lwGzFª2zsil¨l"bz>k9t¹lFr>ta~lF»bulFrz{

(12)

L

^b ho vo v~sfo j|w

KztvG|Jzskl R85 !!6 ~+ =8¥v +!54'3 +! !CT-rlFvlF~tv¨2tsz~r-v¦/z~ilytv;txz1t,zsv¥¨tV|vl"z1t¹l

$&"%$&"(' ¿ 0 *´ Ã

;Gltv;z~"lFrz~il¨u;rzsl"N

h*ilrslzv¦rsu2lFsGr~r/z~il-¨u;rzsl""Gv@l"1t,zslC~xlFzsk9tz1ttS;rsrzslFzGl"¯ v¦

v¦z~ilrs"v@l¦zsir;tv2lFFªxr*lwxlF"uxzslN(

¬@lz}¯l"lFyz~il-xxltv;az~il-v¨v¬2t¨³rz~t,z~l¦z~il¨u;rzslFFª;l²;lNy¬G|yzsil"v;rsl";rsu;r~z~G"v¨K

1 2 3

6 4

5

Tx Heho Rx Heho

Abs Heho

Consensus (Abs) Failure

No Failure Logical Add No response

Add/Del Rx Hello Tx Welcome Tx Hello

Tx Welcome Physical Add

]vu~l #/` "+A :!!

rs|xr}z~l"k?h*ilSlwGzrzsl" R´rz~tzslT{r>zsi;lS¨vFt¨)u@;t,zslª³¯ilFslzsil9rsu2lFsGr{z~svl"1r{x~lFà±

~lz~sl"lFr*tS+!,4'3:+!,!,"

(13)

1 2 3

Physical setting Logical setting (migration)

Consensus

]vu~l:P 0&(')*+!,0+!,!,

$&"%$&"/! Ã ¡ x Ã

az~il¨u;r}z~l"t2yxslNàz~v~| lFz~slFr/k9tV|9¬2lClw1i;tvvlN9¬@lz}¯l"l"az}¯/SxxlFrºzsi2t,z¯/lFsl>t¨slNtvx|

£

zsi;r¯*tV|vª

B C D

16 E

4 4 4 4

A

16 16 16

8 8 6 5 5 6 5 5

4*16 entries

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15

9"l"¨¨rFh*il"~l-t~lC*S;GlFrt°@lNàzslNaz~9lFt1iv¦zsi;lFrsll"¨¨r"

(14)

"v;rz~tvbz*zskSl

h*il>krz/z~l"~lFrzs-¦§lNt,zsu;sl>rzsi;tz¯ilFyt"vx²;u1t,zsv91i;tvvl{i;t@l"2rº9zsi;l>¨u;rzslFFª

$&"%$&"%$ # - ¿

rsu¬;rslz¦(z~il{~lFrsvu1lNr"\Z il"t-~lFrsvu1l;rz~tv;l{1i2tlFrºrºkv1t,z~lF(ªzsilCtvr~rx"tzslF9«±

rsl"~G"lv

E ?& ) # " -0µ&" 4 <>&-)

bdc Bk j j vo v~s f

£

lFrFª;tkl"¨|Z;Glytv«z~©¸vlFbàz~©³ªQt;¤xxla¦´t¨©u~lFrFsvzsx¨r©k¨l"kl"bz~lF¤¸zsil

ttz~t,z~© ¨tV|vlFt~lxlFr~~¬2lN¦§~vk z}¯C@vbz~rº¦]bl"¯)zsi2t,zºv¦@z~ilxxltxlNSzs-vºl"GzslN

¦§~vkzsila"¨©u;rzslFFª¯i1i¥¯lFt¨¨`slN»bulFrzs?xxlvª)t;Zzsi;tz¦*tG|Jz~il"tàz~©l xxl9¥zsil

"¨©u2r}z~l"Nªx¯i1i¯l"t¨¨³tv¬2rlFsG ;Glv

"('."('

Ã ¿ ¿G¿ $¿¶¿ 0@¿ - F

£ ?z~illFvlFzv¦t9xxltx©zsv¶v>l"Gàzsvª2xslNàz~v~|yl"bz~slFr;l"lF¶zsa¬@lk©~tzslN(ª;¶v1xl"

z~?¬;t¨t;"lSzsil9Guk ¬2lF-¦x©~lFzss|¶lFz~slFrk9tv;tlFJ¬G|µlFtv1iµxxlv Z i;l"¸t¶x²;vu;~tzsv

1i2tl{rtvu;lNayz~il¨u;r}z~l"NªxrlFvl"1t¨]kku"tzsv;r/k9tV|9x"u;/¬@lz}¯l"lFxxlNr"`h*il

lFrzs;t,z~©;r¦`rsvkl¦QzsilNrl"vkku;Ft,z~©;r*k9tV|yi;tVl1i2tlFxul-z~zsil-lFbàz~©?¦Qzsil

lFrzs;t,z~©¶xxlzsi;llF¯ ©~lFzsv~|l"bzs~©lNr{xrzs~©¬uzsv³{h*i;lFrslvvakku"tzsv;r

tvslxlF¨tV|lFytv;a;zt¬@vszslN( £yz~ir¯tV|ªb~u;©t;¨©"tzsv;r*xvzz~"l>z~il-x²;vu;~t±

z~©1i2tlv