HAL Id: inria-00072129
https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00072129
Submitted on 23 May 2006
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub-
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
A vertex centered high order MUSCL scheme applying to linearised Euler acoustics
Ilya Abalakin, Alain Dervieux, T.Atiana Kozubskaya
To cite this version:
Ilya Abalakin, Alain Dervieux, T.Atiana Kozubskaya. A vertex centered high order MUSCL scheme applying to linearised Euler acoustics. [Research Report] RR-4459, INRIA. 2002. �inria-00072129�
ISRN INRIA/RR--4459--FR+ENG
a p p o r t
d e r e c h e r c h e
THÈME 4
INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE
A vertex centered high order MUSCL scheme applying to linearised Euler acoustics
I. Abalakin, A. Dervieux, T. Kozubskaya
N° 4459
April 29, 2002
3-22!*4$576!-2*6!$829$
:<;'=>'?A@B?ACDFE'GIH4=J;LK!MONQP&DFMORSTUH'VW;LX!Y[Z\R4>4]^C_?I`8?Aa
bdcfe2gihkjmlonIpqgrfsut<vwpyx\z.hvxU{|vwpygipu}~tv~pqxUz
h}~I}v~eQgihQ}x\gi{fsyh2|hQ}
'wxhvnIgt\}c
t{_{x\v hwhQcfhQwc_hzAjUjIl{f~pqsUf_\\kloUm{_tUUhQ}
!Q2< f¡UU¢ bdcfpu}£wh2{AxU~v{fwxU{Ax\}~hQ}£t1sqpyz_hQtwpu}h W¤ rfsqh2 pu}~2~h2v~pu}~tv~pqxUz.v~ct<v£¥pqsqs¦Ah§2xUgi{_tv~pq¦fsyh
¥pyv~c!}x\gmhh2|pq}v~pqzf}vwtv~hxU¨t~v©pyzzIrfgihQ~pu2tUs_gihvwcfx }L¨ªx\©x\gi{f~h^}~}~pq¦fsyh«_x<¥}'xUzr_z_}vw~r0v~r_~h
vw~putz_Urfsut<vwpyx\z_}2¬bdcfhmpqgm{AxU~vwtUzOv{fwxU{Ah2~vpq}£v~c_hmr}hmx¨9t}vwt¦_pysqpq}wt<vwpyx\zWv~hQ~g}pqzO®\xUsq®Ipyzf!}pyIv~c|¯
x\
h2
hQ~pq®<t<v~pq®Uh^}2¬bdcfhgtpqzWp
hQtipu}dv~x1whQtUsypq°2hvwcfpq}{fwxUUtgigihk¦I
hQ®Uh2sqxU{_pyzft1}wcfhQgmhkvwc_t<v
hQz<x<|}§}~rf{Ah2x\zO®\h2wUhQz_h\p±¬hU¬²tcfpqUc³x\zO®\h2wUhQz_hx\
hQi¥cfh2z²p´vpu}t{f{fsqpqh
vwxJtJ2tUvwhQ}~pqtUz
vw~putz_Urfsut<vwpyx\z¬µJhi{f~h^}hQzOvt¶v~h^}vQtU}~h§®<tUsyp t<vwpyz_¶vwcfhiv~cfhQxUwhvwpqQts4xU h2x¨dtUQrftU2·tz v~cfh
}~x¯¸2tUsysqh btg¹v~h^}v42t\}h\^tUsysqx<¥pyz_}x\gih©x\gm{twpq}~xUz_}¥p´vwcv¥9xxv~c_h2vI{fpu2tUs\zIrfgihQ~pu2tUs\}wcfh2gihQ}
¨ªx\tU2xUr_}v~pu2}Q¬
ºW»O¼[½w¾¿
<ÀU¢
x\r_}vwpqQ}2\zIrfgih2wpqQts_}wcfh2gih^}2OcIO{Ah2w¦AxUsqpqdgix
h2su}Q\sqpyz_hQtwpu}h
m¤
rfsyhQ9h^ÁOr_t<vwpyx\z_}2
r_z_}vw~r0v~r_~h
gihQ}~cfh^}
©êÄÄmÅ<ÄkÆÈÇÊÉBËÌÍ2Ì9ɱÎÏÈÅÊÐÌ^Å<ÄkÑ0ÉBÒÑ~ÓÕÔÖ0×0ØÐ2ÙQÅUÚÇÊɱÉBÆÛÌ
Ü
êÝÚÃßÞ9ÅÖ0Ø0ØÐÚÑ0Ç^àBáLâÊáÉãIÇ^ÒÆÈÑ0äÈáÉÅ<å8æ|Ïç0è^Å<Ø0é0ç0Ø0ÖêQÑ0ë^ìÊÆÛÌwíßÞîàBÆÈëUÑ0äÈÆÈÉÅÊï<ðBÌîÊÒá
ñ
êÄÄmÅ<ÄkÆÈÇÊÉBËÌÍ2Ì9ɱÎÏÈÅÊÐÌ^Å<ÄkÑ0ÉBÒÑ~ÓÕÔÖ0×0ØÐ2ÙQÅUÚÇÊɱÉBÆÛÌ
6!*k2!$ 576!-2-2Q
*2$
$ ! - *6¶$
6!
¢
xUr_}'{_~x\{xO}x\z_}4rfz}~c2gtkzIrfg2wpqÁOrfhd{AxUrfLsqhQ}QÁOr_t<vwpyx\z_} ¤ rfsqh2©sypqzQtU~pu}2hQ}'ÁOrfp_hQ}v9x\g§¯
{t<v~pq¦fsqhtÊ®UhQk2h2~vwtpqz_}d}wc2gtU}}vwtUz tU h2zv~wpqtUzfUsqhQ}d{AxUr_sqtmgQQtzfpuÁOrfh hQ}d«rfp hQ}x\gi{f~h^}¯
}~pq¦fsyh^}dzIrfg2wpqÁOrfh\¬h{AxUpqzOvpygi{AxU~vwtzOvhQ}vs pqzOv~wx r_0vwpyx\z hkv~h2wgihQ} h}vwtU¦fpqsypu}~tv~pqxUz~hQ{xO}~tUzOv
}~rf hQ} 2wpy®2h^} xU ~h1}~py[¬9hQsqt·hQ}v§Qtsqpu} hQz xUz}vw~rfpu}wtzOvrfz }wc2gt·}~rf{Ah2x\zO®\h2wUhQz\v^
h^}v"! pywh x\ ~h#2sqh2® mÁOr_tz xUzst{f{_sypuÁOrfh$! h^}vw~putz_Urfsut<vwpyx\z_}Qt~vQ}~pqh2zfzfh^}2¬xUr_}{f¯
}~h2zOvwxUz_}syhm2tsur_s rfzQtU}v~hQ}v£®<tUsyp tzOvsxU whkv~cQxUwpqÁOrfh h{fQ2pq}~pqxUz.{frfpu}r_z2t\}vwhQ}v &% t
btg{hQ~gihv~vwtUz\v hQ}x\gi{_ttpu}x\z_}tÊ®UhQ tr|vw~h^}}~c2gtU}vI{fpuÁOrfhQ}dhQzt 2wx\tU2xUr_}v~puÁOrfhU¬
'#¿ ^ ½ ¡ ( ¢ xUr}vwpqÁOrfh\d}wcQgit\}izIrfg2wpqÁOrfh^}2gix e2sqhQ}cII{hQ~¦AxUsqpuÁ\r_hQ}Q ¤ rfsyhQ1sqpyz^twpq}U
gtUpysqsqtUUh^}9z_xUz|¯¸}vw~r0v~r_^}
# $&%('*),+.-
'/$0+.%
bdc_h!zIrfgih2wpu2ts}pqgr_sqtv~pqxUz xU¨v~cfh{fwxU{_tU\tv~pqxUzÕx¨£¥tÊ®\hQ}¥pyv~c21_}v~¯±x\ hQ{_tUvwpqtUs p43[h2wh2zOv~puts
h^ÁOr_t<vwpyx\z_}1xU¨kcII{Ah2w¦x\sypu.vI{hpyzI®\xUsq®UhQ}¶t p452rfsyv.tU{f{fwxÊIpqgt<vwpyx\z²{fwxU¦_syhQg¬ t<vwcfh2}pqgi{fsyh
}~hQ2xUz ¯±x\ hQt\22rfwtv~hgihv~c_x }dc_tÊ®Uh¦hQh2z.grc!r_}~h tUz tU{f{fwhQ2pqtv~h ¨ªxUhQsysqpy{fv~puk{f~x\¦fsqh2g}2¬
6¸z²xUzOvwwt\}v^¨ªx\71w}v¯xU h2§cIO{Ah2w¦AxUsqpqQ}24zfxUvmx\zfsyJvwcfh h2wpy®<t<vwpyx\zÕx¨\h2zIrfpqzfh2sqÕ}h^x\z xU h2
gih2v~cfx }c_tU}§x\}v~h tWsyxUvx¨h3Ax\v}2¦fr|vitsu}xWpyv§}~h2h2g}v~c_tvgix\}vx¨}~hQx\z ¯xU h2gih2v~cfx }
8
tz hQ®UhQzJgixO}vxU¨9vwcfpq ¯ xU hQxUzfh^}9tU~hivwxIx pq}w}~py{_tv~pq®Uhivwx tsqsyx<¥ h51pqh2zOvhQzfxUr_UcÕtUQrft<vwh
2xUgi{fr|vt<vwpyx\z_}dx¨4tUx\r_}v~pu2}¨ªxUwhQtUs[sypy¨ªh{fwxU¦fsqh2g}Q¬
nIhQ®UhQwtUsA\xIx cfpqUcxU h2}wcfh2gihQ}tU~hzfx<¥7tÊ®<tUpysut¦fsqh£¨ªxUwh2Ur_sqtU9gihQ}~cfh^}
8
}~h2hUI¨ªx\dhftgi{fsqhU
:<;=
90¬©bdc_h2¶tU~h h2wpq®Uh ¨ªwxUg}wcfh2gih^}d¥p´vwcsqx<¥ pq}w}pq{_tv~pqxUzftvdsqhQt\}vd¨ªx\rfvwc|¯xU h2tUQrft<vwhUIxU
¥pyv~cWt pu}~}~py{t<v~pqxUzzfxUvdsutwUhQv~c_tUz¶vwcfh pu}~}~py{t<v~pqxUzt{f{_sypqh pqz¶¨ªx\rfvwc|¯ xU h2tUQrft<vwh}wcfhQgmh^}2¬
bdcfhQtU}~hkx¨4~hQUrfsutdgihQ}~cfhQ}pq}tiwh2sut<vwpy®\h2sqhQtU}~pqh2xUz_hU¬'µJh2tUz!rfz
h2}vtz
vwcfpq}p´¨4¥9h2xUz|¯
}~p
h2kvwcfh¶}~pygi{fsqp1h
2t\}hix¨t
®UhQv~pqxUzJ¥p´vwcÕxUz}vtzOv®UhQsyx|pyvU¬>6¸zJvwc_t<vQtU}~hU?1z
pqzf·t.UxIx
t ®Uh^0vwpyx\zJ}wcfh2gihipu}hQ}w}hQzOv~putsqsy@1z pqzf tzJpqz\vwh2w{x\sqtv~pqxUzÕ}wcfh2gihU¬>6¸z vwcfh12t\}hixU¨t 9x\rfwtUzOv
zIrfg§¦hQkhQÁOr_ts4vwxBADCq}x\gmh}wcfh2gih^}Qtzh2®UhQz¦AhihftUvQ¬FEfrf~v~cfhQQ&~hQUrfsutgihQ}~cfhQ}tU~hm{_t~v~pu0¯
r_sqtU~sq¶¨FtÊ®\xUrft¦_syhv~x¶v~cfh h2wpq®Êtv~pqxUzWxU¨Lcfpy\c|¯xU h2t\22rfwtv~h}wcfhQgmh^}vwc_t<vkx\}v£t¶wtv~cfhQ}gtUsys
zIrfg§¦hQx¨4xU{Ah2t<vwpyx\z_}9¨ªxUdv~c_h2pqtU}w}hQg¦fsqU¬
bdcfh2t\}hxU¨dr_z_}vw~r0v~r_~h gmh^}c_hQ}wh2{_~h^}hQz\v}kv~c_h¶gt<|pqgitUs p451rfsyvU¬GEpqw}vQgihQ}~c pq~wh2U¯
r_sqtU~pyv·tgi{fsqp1hQ} pu}{Ah2}pqxUzJ{fcfhQzfxUgihQz_tf¬inIhQ2xUz sqU&gitUzIWr_}h2¨ªrfs'zIrfgih2wpqQts4gihvwcfx } x.zfxv
h2Iv~h2z hQt\}pqsy
8
vwwt pyv~pqxUz_tUsA2xUgi{_tUv9}wcfh2gihQ}Q\¨ªxU©h2ftgi{fsqhH94vwxvwcfhJIrfz_}v~wr_v~rfwh LK QtU}~hU¬4b&x tÊ
h^}~}~h2zOvwpqtUsysqv¥xk¨FtgipqsypqhQ}©x¨}~c_h2gihQ}'hQz<x<mcfpy\c|¯xU h2'xU¨8t\22rfwt\\Ux\z_}hQ~®<tv~pqxUzm{f~x\{hQvwpyh^}Ltz
pq}w}pq{_tv~pqxUzixUzfh^}2Uv~cfh£t tU{|vwtv~pqxUzmx¨ ¤ NM¯±vI{h£}~cfhQgihQ}v~xrfz_}v~wr_0vwrf~h gmh^}c_hQ}
8O:
=
9OtUz v~cfh
P£pu}~2xUzOv~pqzIrfxUr_}¯RQktsqh2SOpqzgihvwcfx 8O:
=
9¬UT9rfvvwcfhQ}~hv¥9x§¨FtgipqsyxU¨}wcfh2gih^}tU~htUQrft<vwh£hQzfxUrf\c
x\zfsq·p´¨v~c_h2tU~hixU¨9¨ªx\rfvwc|¯xU
h2^¬6¸zvwc_t<vsutU}v2t\}h\v~c_h22xUz_}~rfgihtsqtU~\hi2xUgi{fr|vwpyz_h3Ax\v
¨ªx\9h^tUc1r_zVSIzfx<¥z|tz
v~cfhQ1twhh52pyhQzOvx\zfsyi¥cfhQz¶hQzfxUrf\c1zfx
h^}tU~h£r_}~h
tUz
t§®UhQ~i}gtUsys
hQ~wxUpu} h2gtUz h ¬
E_~x\g vwcfhQ}~h wh2gtS|}.¥9h Qtz hQ~pq®Uh vwcfh ¨ªx\sysqx<¥pyz_ ~h^xUgigtz t<vwpyx\z_}¨ªxU·r_z_}vw~r0v~r_~h
gih^}cfh^}W
¯ 8
pX9'¦frfpqs }~hQx\z ¯xU h2'}wcfh2gih^}v~c_tvLpyzI®Ux\sy®\htU}¨ªh2¥ pu}~}~pq{_t<vwpyx\zit\} xcfpqUc|¯xU hQ4}wcfhQgmh^}2
¯ 8
pypY99hQÁOrfpq{¶vwcfh}h^xUz ¯±x\ h2d}~cfhQgih£xU¨}~rf{hQw2xUzI®UhQ~\h2z_2h{fwxU{Ah2~v~pqhQ}9xUz.2tUvwhQ}~pqtUz1gihQ}~cfhQ}
tUz r_}ht\}x¨ßv~hQzWtU}d{Ax\}w}pq¦fsqhkQt~v~h^}putzgihQ}~cfpyz_mxU¨}~rf¦fwh2\pyx\z_}x¨v~cfh2xUgi{fr|vt<v~pqxUzts xUgtUpyz¬
TW}r_{hQw2xUzI®UhQ~\h2z_2h{_~x\{hQvwpyh^}¥9hgmh^tzWvwc_t<v£v~cfhm}~c_h2giht{_{fsypqhQ}v~xtw¦fp´vwwtU~¶rfz_}v~wr_0¯
vwrfwh gihQ}~cfhQ}¶¦fr|v¶pqz ~hQUpqxUz ¥cfh2wh.v~c_h·gihQ}~c pu}¶Qt~v~h^}putz9v~c_hWv~wrfz_Qt<v~pqxUz³hQ~wxUipu}¶}~gitUsysqh2
¦I }~h2®\h2ts4xU hQw}x¨dgt\zfp´vwr h\¬1}k¨FtUtU}
8
pX9pu}x\z_hQ~z_h ¥hih2gi{fc_t\}pq°2hivwc_t<vvwcfhivwt\}OS pq}
2xUgi{fsqh8¬@6¸z hQh pq}w}pq{_tv~pqxUz }~cfxUrfs x3[h2mt·x\gi{hQz_}~tv~pqxUz vwx pu}{Ah2}~pyx\zÕpyzÕvwcfh!}~h2z}hvwc_t<v
h2fhQ}w}~py®\h2sq pu}{Ah2}~h cfpqUc ¨ª~h^ÁOrfh2z_2pyh^}}~cfxUr_s ¦Ah tgi{Ah pqz·x\ hQvwx!tÊ®Ux\p xO}~2pysqsut<v~pqxUz}tz
sutwUhhQ~wxU}Q¬bdcfh¦_tUsqtUz_hpq}Uh2z_h2tsqsyxU¦|vtpqzfh ¦IWcfxIx\}~pqzfcfpqUc|¯ xU h2£tU22rftU\¬[Zx<¥h2®\h2^
pqzvwcfh hQ~pq®<t<vwpyx\zx¨8v~c_h\P }wcfh2gih\Obtg tz xU¯±¥xUSUhQw}{fwh¨ªhQLv~x§xU{|vwpygipq°2hv~cfh}~cfhQgih¨ªxU
sqx<¥7{_c_tU}~hkh2w~x\9¦Ahv~v~h2v~c_tUzS\h2hQ{fpyz_it\22rfwt\
8R:<;=
90¬
6¸zv~c_pq}d¥xUS¥9h{fwxU{Ax\}~hvwxihIv~hQz
t§¨FtUgmpqsq1x¨®Uh2~v~h2I¯ 2h2zOv~hQ~h
rf{I¥pyz
}wcfh2gih^}t{f{fsqIpyz_
vwxmv~wpqtUzfUrfsut<vwpyx\z_}Q¬06v¥pqsys&c_tÊ®Uhv~c_h£¨ªx\sysqx<¥pqzfi{f~x\{hQvwpyh^}W
8
pX9vwcfh}wcfh2gihkpq}2xUz_}~h2w®<t<vwpy®\hU
8
pypY9v~c_h pq}w}~py{_tv~pqxUzpq} h2wpy®\h ¨ª~x\g}pyIv~c|¯ xU hQ h2wpy®<t<vwpy®\hQ}Q
8
pypqpX9dv~cfh}wcfh2gihkpu} 1f¨ßv~c|¯xU hQtU22rft<v~h¥cfhQzpyvpu}t{f{fsqpqh v~xti2tUvwhQ}~pqtUz!gihQ}~c¬
"
+ - $
$ '/$ +.% -
5
'/$0+.%
"! 575 $#
# -
%{I¥pyz }wcfh2gih^}ix¨ Qx rfzfx<® vI{AhWh2z<x<²t syxUv1x¨kpyzOv~hQ~h^}vwpyz_ ÁOr_tUsypyv~pqhQ} rfh.v~x vwcfh·{Ah2~¨ªhQ0v
t hQÁOr_tv~pqxUzx¨4v~c_hrf{I¥pyz pyzf¶gmh^c_tz_pq}~g vwcfh2!pyzI®Ux\sy®\hk¥p´vwcWrfz_}v~hQt ¶¥dtÊ®Uh^}2¬&%z|¨ªx\vwrfz_t<vwh2sqU
vwcfh1tgix\rfzOvx¨ pq}w}~py{_tv~pqxUzv~cfhQ2xUzOvwtUpyz }hQh2g}g§r_c sqtU~\h2v~c_tUz zfhQ2hQ}w}~tU~.¨ªx\tz tUQrft<vwh
z_xUz|¯x\}wpqsysut<vwxUw.zOr_gmhQ~pu2tUsLtz_}~¥h2^¬1}t.x\z_}~hQÁOrfh2zhU&v~cfh xUgipyztzOvv~hQ~g x¨v~cfhzIrfgih2wpu2ts
hQ~wxUpu}2tU~wpyh ¦Ivwcfh pu}~}~py{t<v~pqxUz&¬
µJh!}~rfU\hQ}vv~x ¨ªxUwUh2v§t¦AxUr|vm}vw~pu0vmgmx\zfxvwxUzI tz vwx Uh2vpqz_}{_pywh ¦IBPpqwhQ0vnIpqgrfsut<vwpyx\z
vwhQcfz_pqÁOrfh^}pqzW¥cfpqcWz_xUz|¯ pu}~}~py{t<v~pq®Uhc_py\cWxU h2tU{f{fwxÊ|pygt<vwpyx\z_}twh}vwt¦_pysqpq}~h pqzWUxIx tUQr|¯
tU22xUz p´vwpyx\z_}vwc_tzSI}vwx[1_syv~hQw}¥cfpucwh2sqxUz®\h2w\¯cfpqUchQ®Uh2zxU h2 h2wpy®<tv~pq®UhQ}Q¬&µJhd}c_tUsys1_}v
}~cfx<¥ c_x<¥ v~c_pq}Qtz¦h xUzfh¥pyv~cWtmxUzfh2¯ pygih2z}pqxUz_tUs[cfpy\c|¯xU h2(')%n gihv~c_x gix p41_h pqz
}~r_c.tigtzfzfhQdv~c_tvv~cfh xUgipyztzOv pu}~}~py{t<v~pqxUz!v~hQ~g pq}t}~pyOvwc|¯ xU h2 hQ~pq®<t<v~pq®Uh\¬ 6¸zv~cfhsqpyz_hQt
QtU}~hUIvwcfpq}dpu}h2|t\0vwsyvwcfhx\z_}v~wr_0vwpyx\z¶x¨
:j =
tsu}~xmr}h pqz : =¬
*,+.- /1032547682:9-<;>=@?/3ACBEDFHGJILK39.254M6.FHN
&hvr_}J1w}vxUz}p h2dvwcfhkv~c_hxUzfh2¯ pqgih2z_}~pqxUz_tUs[2xUzI®Uh^0vwpyx\z¶hQÁOr_tv~pqxUz
OPRQTSUOUVCWYX
8R;
9
bdc_h\1zfp´vwh¯ ®Ux\syrfgihgihv~c_x pu}dr_}h ¨ªx\v~cfh}~{_t<vwpqtUs[tU{f{fwxÊ|pygt<vwpyx\z¬5ZM[m A\]^\`_ h2zfxUv~hv~cfh
pq}wwhvwpy°^t<v~pqxUz{AxUpqz\v}x¨v~c_hgihQ}~c¬ E_xUhQt\c pq}wwhvwpy°^t<vwpyx\z!{AxUpqzOvQf¥h}vt<vwh>W
O
[ba
O5c Z7[d©tz
¥h h1zfhkv~cfh2xUzOv~wxUs[®\xUsqrfgihe [ tU}vwcfhpyzOvwh2w®ÊtUsHfZ
[g(h
i7j
Z
[klh
im
¥cfh2whRZ
[kRh
i W ZM[
Q
ZM[kon
p ¬
&hvrq
WtsuO
[vmv~cfhirfzSOz_x<¥z®\hQ0vwxU¥cfx\}~hixUgi{AxUzfhQzOvw}ktwhmtU{f{fwxÊ|pygt<vwpyz_v~cfhm¨ªrfz0v~pqxUz
O5c
Zwdpqz1h^tUczfx h,]§x¨8v~c_hgihQ}~c¬'µJh¦frfpqs v~c_h®Uh^0vwxU1x
c
qrdt\22xU pyz_v~xm}{_tv~putsAt{f{fwxÊ|pygt¯
vwpyx\z!xU¨
czy5c{O d.d
V
f¥cfpuc.2tz¦Ah¥~pyvvwh2zWtU} W
x [ c q|d
W A
} Z c~
[k h
i
~
[g hi d
~
[k hi
W~lc{O [klh
i
j O [klh
iu
d 8D9
¥cfhQ~h
O
[3h
i
h2zfxUv~hkv~c_h®ÊtUsyr_hQ}xU¨
O
tv¦x\rfz tU~pqhQ}dxU¨42xUzOv~wxUs8®\xUsqrfgihe[¥pyv~c
~lc{O
j.
d W
f c A
z
cS d.d
OTQc
A
Cz
cS dd
Hm
¬
QxU
pqzfkv~xv~cfhR')%£n ·gihvwcfx
xUsqxU\
8R:=
90\v~c_hsqh¨ßvtz
wpy\cOv9x\z\vw~x\sf®Ux\syr_gmh¦x\rfz
tU~
}vwtv~h^}
O
[lh
iu
pu}¦fr_pysyvr_}~pyzfisqpyz_hQtpqzOv~hQ~{AxUsut<vwpyx\z¶¨ªx\~g§rfsqt\}NW
nfcfh2gihQ}
ÊÀ »
; ; ;
; ;
¯
;
j
; ;
¯
;
j
j ; ;
¯
; ; ¯
;!;
j
;
¯
; ; ¯
;!;
bt¦fsqh
;
WLQrftU2x¨ p3[h2wh2zOv®UhQw}~pqxUz_}x¨v~cfhz_h2¥ }~cfhQgihpqz
;
PQtU}~h
O [k3h
i
W O [ Q n } O [k3h
i
O [klh
i W O
[kwn
n } O [k3h
i
O [g,h
i
W O
[g n Q n } O [g(h
i
O [g(h
i
W O [ n } O [g(h
i
8
9
¥cfh2wh } O
[h
iu
twhk}~sqxU{AhQ}Q|pB¬hU¬LtU{f{fwxÊIpqgt<vwpyx\z_}©xU¨ hQ~pq®<t<vwpy®\h£vwh2wg
O
Z ¬ } O
[k hi W c A
d
cO [kon
O [ d Q cO [ O
[g<n d 8
jL9
} O
[k3h
i W c A
d
cO [kon
O [d
Q cO
[k
O [kwnd
8
D9
¥c_h2wh pq}©rf{I¥pyz
pyzf{_ttgihvwh2'vwc_t<vdx\z\vw~x\sq}'v~cfh2xUg§¦fpyzt<v~pqxUzxU¨[¨ªrfsysqirf{I¥pyz
tz
2h2zOv~hQ~h
}~sqxU{AhQ}Q¬ E_xU
W
A§vwcfh}~c_h2gihkpq}vwcfh}vtz
t
vwcfpy
xU
h2tUQrft<vwh}~cfhQgihU¬
6¸z v~cfh.{fwhQ}~h2zOvi®UhQvwhI¯2h2zOv~hQ~h x\z\vwhIvQ©cfpy\c x\ hQmt\22rfwt\ pu}§z_xvixU¦|vtpqzfh ¦O tcfpqUcfhQ¯
x\ h2mpyzOv~hQ~{AxUsut<vwpyx\z ¦frfv1¦O²tz pyzOv~hQ~{AxUsut<vwpyx\z vwc_t<v1x\gi{hQz_}~tv~h^}vwcfhWh2wwxUixUgipqzf¨ª~x\gv~cfh
1z_ts2h2zOv~ts p43[h2wh2z_2pyzfipqz 8D9¬Lbdcfpu}d¥~pyv~h^}tU}¨ªxUsqsqx<¥}W
} O [k hi W cA
d
c{O [kwn
O [d
Q c{O
[ O [g nd
Q c O [g<n
Q O [ O
[kwn
Q O [k
d
8{
9
Q c O
[g
Q O
[g n O [ Q O
[kwnod
} O
[k h
i W cA
d
c{O [kwn
O [ d Q c{O [k
O [kon d
Q c O [g<n
Q O [ O
[kwn
Q O [k
d
8
9
Q c O [ Q O
[kwn
O [k
Q O
[k d
¥cfhQ~h tUz
tU~h·r_{O¥pqz pqzf²{_ttgihvwh2}vwc_t<v.xUzOvw~x\sv~c_hx\g¦fpqz_tv~pqxUz x¨¨ªr_sysq
r_{O¥pqz tz 2h2zOv~hQ~h }~syx\{h^}2¬
µJhxU¦_}~h2w®Uh£v~ct<v}wcfh2gihQ} h^}~2~pq¦Ah pyz
8
9dtwhkpyzUhQzfh2ts8}~hQx\z ¯ xU h2dtUQrft<vwhk¦fr|vv~c_h2
¦AhQ2xUgihcfpqUcf¯±x\ hQLtUQrft<vwhd¨ªxU9}~xUgih®<tsqrfh^}Lx¨[vwcfh{_tUwtUgihv~hQw} tz
¬4µJhzfxUv~hvwc_t<v
¨ªx\
W X j W
A!¥9higt<|pqgipq}~hmv~cfh hQUwh2hix¨drf{I¥pqz pqzf_¬1sq}~x_ 1f¨ßv~c xU hQtU22rftU
pu}x\¦|vwtUpyzfh ¥p´vwc tUzÕt h^Á\rt<v~hcfx\pq2hx¨v~cfhivwcfwh2h1xIh52pyhQzOvw}Q¬ Efx\v~cfpu}sutU}v2t\}h\&¦fr|v¥pyv~c
W X
Iv~c_h2z.¥9hk\hvthQz\vwwtUs´¯ p43AhQ~hQz_h }~p´Ivwc|¯±x\ h2dtU22rft<v~h}wcfh2gih\¬
Y FHD
e
V
;
|¬ ;
;
¯
;
f¬È
;
¯
; ; ¬UO
;
¯
; ; ¯
;!;
; ¬
bt¦_syh· W)'WtIpqgts 9xUr_wtUz\vizIrfg¦Ah2}
8
h2|{fsypupyv1
}~c_h2gihH9¨ªxUmvwcfh.¨ªxUrf p43[h2wh2zOv¶}{t<v~puts
}wcfhQgmh^}
8R;
Ptz_tUsy|}~pq}9
*,+* 6.I252:N 6.N4M2l6.964
µJh2tUz2xUg§¦fpyz_h£vwcfht¦Ax<®Uhk}wcfh2gihk¥p´vwcv~cfh}vwtUz t rfzf\h¯ kr|vvtvwpygiht ®<tz_2pyzf¬
nIpqz_2hLv~c_hL{frfw{xO}h©pq}v~x2xUgi{fr|vwhLsypqzfh^tt\x\r_}vwpqQ}2Q¥9h92tz}~pqgm{_sypy¨ªv~cfh©rfzfUh2¯ krfvvwt}wcfhQgmh
vwxmv~cfhsqpyz_hQtwpu}h
tgihQ}~xUz!®<twpqtUz\v 8O: =
9¥cfpuc.¥~pyv~h^}tU}¨ªxUsqsqx<¥}W
q "!
W
q#
q %$&!
W q "!
Q
}('
_
*) Q A
,+zq %$
g<n
!.-
j ) W
AUC CC._
q # kwn
W q 0/1!
89
µJh§whQQtsqs&pqz bt¦fsqhm}~xUgihvI{fpu2tUsgtIpqgts E zIrfg¦Ah2}¨ªx\vwcfh§}~p´I¯¸}vt\h }~c_h2gihU
¥c_pqchQz_}r_~htUsqxU¦_tUstUQrftU2x¨ 1®Uh¨ªx\Lv~c_hv¥x¦h^}v}~cfhQgihQ}LxU¨8v~cfh£{fwxU{Ax\}~h ¨Ftgipqsy\¬4bdc_pq}
vt¦fsqhpqsqsyr_}v~t<vwhQ}v~c_tvv~c_h§t¦Ax<®Uh§}~cfhQgihQ}QtzW¦Ahr_}~h ¥p´vwc E zIrfg§¦hQx¨'vwcfhx\ h2xU¨'v~cfh
r_zfp´v\¬
2 %
'*)
' ) 5 - ' +3- $
5
%
$0+ % " # 5
bdc_h¨FtgipqsyixU¨P¹}~cfhQgihQ}'vwc_t<vpq}x\z_}~p hQ~h pq}9t
"F!14 Y&5 ">4U Y 65O4">H"787 %5
"^
Ut{_{fsyIpqzfxUzvw~putz_Urfsut<vwpyx\z_}2tUz xU¨
95O
vI{h\¬µJhd~h2¨ªh2v~x : =
¨ªxU't hvtpqsyh
hQ}wwpy{|vwpyx\z!xU¨&vwcfpq}¨Ftgipysq¶xU¨}wcfh2gih\¬
~x\rfz hQt\c¶®UhQvwh¶pu}d¦frfpqsyv£tih2sqs[¨ªxUsqsqx<¥pyzfmvwxmgtUpyz.xU{fv~pqxUz_} W
¯LhQp´vwcfh2v~cfhhQsys&pq}dsqpygipyv~h ¦O¶{_t~vx¨v~cfhgih pqtUz_}dx¨4}rfwwxUrfz pyzf§v~wputzf\syh^}2
¯xUv~cfhmh2sqspq}£¦frfpqs´vktUQxU pqzfiv~xtzWp hQt¶x¨UTdt~v~c 8O:
=
9¦Omx\pyzfpqzfvwcfhih2zOvwh2xU¨'h \hQ}¥pyv~c
vwcfhhQzOv~h2xU¨}~gtsqsyh^}vpqsqhk2xUzOvwtUpyz_pyzfmvwcfhx\z_}p hQ~h v~wputzf\syh\¬
bdcfh1«_r||hQ}tU~h1t\}~}~h2g§¦fsqh xUzÕtz h Uh¯ ¦_t\}h {fwx|h^}~}Q&p±¬h\¬¶¨ªx\hQt\ch Uh
]·¦h2v¥9hQh2z v¥x
z_x hQ}
tUz ]_ftUz v~cfhQzW}rfgigih ¨ªx\hQtUczfx h
t\}¨ªxUsqsyx<¥} W
:<;>=?:A@CBD@FEP QHG ~1@
[ W X 8
9
!"
I
J
EpqUrfwh
;
WH'.h putz.h2sqsx\z_}v~wr_0vwpyx\z
I
J
EpqUr_~h W9pqw2rfghQz\vwh2 ITdt~v~c K 2h2sqs&x\z_}v~wr_0vwpyx\z
¥c_h2wh
~1@
[twh£hQsyhQgmhQzOvwtw«_rfIh^}x\gm{_r|v~h
¥pyv~cWpqh2gtUzfzW}x\sy®\h2}2¬
µJh\1_w}v9whQQtsqs_vwcfh£¨ªhQt<vwrfwhQ}LxU¨tz¶hIv~hQz
h
®UhQw}~pyx\z{fwxU{Ax\}~h
pqz :j = : =
¨ªxU
¤
rfsqh2Qtsurfsut<vwpyx\z_}2¬
bdcfh zOr_gmhQ~pu2tUspyzOvwh2Ut<vwpyx\z²¥pyv~c tUz³rf{I¥pyz }wcfh2gihW\h2zfhQwtUsysqÕsyh^t }v~x t{_{f~xÊ|pqgt<v~pqxUz}
¥c_pqctU~hLx\zfsq\1w}v¯xU h2t\22rfwtv~h\¬&bdcfh ' %£n ¶gmh2v~cfx x\syx\Ux¨f®<tz&h2hQ&c_t\}&¦Ah2hQzhIv~hQz h
vwx.®Uh2~v~h2I¯2h2zOv~hQ~h rfz_}v~wr_0vwrf~h ¨ªx\~g§rfsut<v~pqxUz}pqz xU h2£v~x.whQtUc}h^xUz x\ hQt\22rfwt\
8
}~h2h
¨ªx\'hftgi{fsqh : =
9¬bdcfpu}'h2Ovwh2z_}~pqxUzwh2sqpqhQ}4xUz§v~c_hh2®<tsqr_t<vwpyx\z«_rfIh^}4¥p´vwcihIv~t{AxUsut<vwh ®<tUsyrfh^}
BD@
[\
B [ @
tvv~cfhpqzOv~h2~¨FtU2hkx¨&vwcfhhQsysu}
8
EpqUrfwh9W4¥p´vwc?W
B @[ W B @ Q X C
c B d @[ C
]
B [ @ W B [ X C
c B d[ @ C
]
8O;
9
¥c_h2whv~cfhIh2Iv~t{AxUsut<v~pqxUz }~syx\{h^}K
c
B d@[ E[ @
tU~h1x\¦|vwtUpyz_h r_}~pyz_ t·x\g¦fpqz_tv~pqxUzÕx¨2h2zOv~hQ~h
tUz rf{I¥pyz \wt pyhQzOvw}Q¬
6¸zx\ hQ'v~xpqz_2~h^tU}~hdv~cfht\22rfwt\xU¨[v~cfh¦tU}~pq(')%n ·2xUz_}v~wr_0vwpyx\zU¥h{fwxU{Ax\}~hdv~x h1_zfh
vwcfhQ}~h}sqxU{AhQ}t\}¨ªxUsqsyx<¥} W
bdc_hk2h2zOv~hQ~h \wt pqh2zOv
c B d@[
pu} h1_zfh t\}
c
B d@[ C
] W B [ B @ ¬
bdc_hzfx tUs\wt pyhQzOv
c B d@
pu}9Qtsurfsut<vwh x\zv~cfhkhQsys e @
t\}LvwcfhktÊ®Uh2t\hdx¨8v~c_h£\wt pyhQzOvw}'xU¨v~cfh
- +
S S
j i
Wi Wij Wji Wj
Iij
EpqUrfwhVW' x\}~p´vwpyx\z!xU¨
B @
[tUz B [ @ x\z
:
@ [ =
vw~putz_UsqhQ}¥cfpucpqz_2syr h£vwcfhx\z_}~p hQ~h z_x h W
c
B d@ W A
:
;>=c
e @d :
;?=c
d
$
B $
~ $
8O;D;
9
bdc_h1rf{I¥pyz Ut pqh2zOvpq}§x\gm{_r|v~h tU22xU pqzfv~xWvwcfh h1_zfpyv~pqxUz xU¨vwcfh x<¥z}vw~h^tg+tUz rf{|¯
}v~whQtUg vw~putzf\syh^}d¥cfpuc·2tz.¦Ah§t\}~}~x|put<v~h ¥pyv~c·tUzWh \h f @ [ m 8
Epy\rfwhjL90¬bdcfh x<¥z_}vw~h^tg
tUz rf{_}v~whQtg v~wpqtUzfUsqhQ}dtwhk~h^}{AhQv~pq®UhQsy1z_xv~h @
[tUz [ @ ¬ M£zfhkc_t\}}x W
c
B d
@[ W
B
tz
c B
d
@[ W
B
¥cfhQ~h
B
W
$
B $
~ $
tU~hmvwcfh
; ¯
QktUsyhQSIpqz1Ut pyhQz\v}©x\z1vw~putzf\syh
¬4bdcfpq}dx\{|v~pqxUz!tsqsyx<¥}9hIv~hQz_}~pyx\z_}9v~xx|2tUs ¤ Ivw~hQgrfg.P£pygipqz|¯
pu}~cfpyz_ 8 ¤ P 9}wcfh2gih^}tU}}~cfx<¥z¶pqz :=¬
µJhLzfx<¥ }{AhQ2p´¨ª£xUrf&gmh2v~cfx ¨ªx\&x\gm{_r|v~pqzfdv~c_h'hIv~t{AxUsut<vwpyx\z}~syx\{h^}
c B d@
[9tz
c
B
d{[
@ W
c B d@
[C
] W c A
d
c B d@[ C
] Q c
B d
@[ C
]
Q
c
B d
@[ C
] p c B d@[ C
] Q c B d@[ C
]
Q
c
B d
! C
] p c B d@ C
] Q c B d[DC
] j
8O;
D9
bdcfh2xUgi{fr|vt<vwpyx\z!xU¨
B [ @
pu}tz_tUsyx\Ux\r_}W
c B d[ @ C
] W c A
d
c B d[@ C
] Q c
B d
[ @ C
]
Q
c
B d
[@ C
] p c
B d
[
@ C
] Q c B d[ @ C
]
Q
c B
d
C
] p c
B d[DC
] Q c B d @C
]"
j
8O;
9
bdcfh1v~h2wg$#
B&%
'
!
pq}v~cfh1\wt
pqh2zOvt<vvwcfh¶{AxUpqzOv)(+*
@[
¬·bdc_pq}sqt\}v\wt
pqh2zOvpq}§x\gm{_r|v~h
¦I1pqzOv~hQ~{AxUsut<vwpyx\z¶x¨v~cfhz_x ts8Ut pyhQz\v®<tsqrfhQ}tvvwcfhzfx h^}xUzOvtpqzfh pyzv~c_h£¨Ft\hkxU{_{xO}pyv~hv~x
pqz·vwcfhmrf{I¥pyz v~wputzf\syh
@[ ¬bdcfhixIh512pyhQz\v} tz
twhrf{I¥pqz pqzf{_ttgihvwh2}vwc_t<v
D *ij D *ji S
Tij Tji
S m
i j
n r
s
EpqUr_~hjW&xIQtsqpq}wt<vwpyx\z¶xU¨&v~c_hhIv~tmpyzOv~hQ~{AxUsut<vwpyx\z!{AxUpqzOvw} (+*
@[
tUz ( *
[ @
xU¨z_x ts8Ut pyhQz\v}
M£ h2
¯¸}wcfh2gih
;
;
¯¸}wcfh2gih
;
j
'~h^}hQzOv('Whv~c_x
;
¯
;
U ¯
; ;
'~h^}hQzOv('Whv~c_x
;
¯
;
U ¯
;
bt¦fsqhVW'22rftUxU¨ p3[h2wh2zOv®UhQw}~pyx\z_}x¨v~cfhz_h2¥ }wcfhQgmhkpqz·Pwh2\rfsqtUQtU}~h
2xUzOv~wxUsAvwcfhx\g¦fpqz_t<vwpyx\z!xU¨&¨ªrfsqsq¶rf{I¥pqz tz hQz\vwh2wh }sqxU{AhQ}Q¬
bx}~rfg r_{[v~cfh^}h}wcfh2gih^}c_tÊ®\hx\zfsy·}~pyOvwc|¯xU h2 pu}~}~py{t<v~pqxUztz twh§pqz \h2zfhQwtUs}~hQ2xUz ¯
x\ h2t\2r_wtv~hk¦fr|v£v~cfhQ¦AhQ2xUgihcfpqUc_h2~¯±x\ hQtU22rft<v~hpqzWvwcfhsqpyzfh^t2tU}~hk¨ªxU}x\gih®ÊtUsyr_hQ}xU¨
vwcfh{_tUwtUgmh2v~hQw}
8
}~h2h :<;
=9 tUz
_}~h2h :<;D;=
tz btU¦fsqhk_¬
"
$&%
5 ) $
'/$0+.%
bdc_h1z_t<vwrftsLgix h2s©¨ªxUvwcfh¶{_~x\{_tOt<v~pqxUzJx¨tU2xUr_}v~pu2}pyz t«rfp pq}kvwcfh!2xUgi{fwhQ}w}pq¦fsqh tÊ®IpyhQ¯
nIv~xDS\hQ}'h^ÁOr_t<vwpyx\z_}2¬ Zx<¥h2®\h2v~c_h2pq©r_}~h¨ªxULv~cfpu}©{_rf~{Ax\}~hpu} p451rfsyv9}~gitUsysAtgi{fsqp´vwr hxU¨8®ÊtU~put<vwpyx\z
vwc_t<v2xUw~h^}{AxUz }Lvwx1tU2xUr_}v~pu2}{fcfhQzfxUgihQz_tf¬
6¸zv~c_tv4QtU}~hLv~c_h9sqpyz_hQtwpu}h ¤ rfsqh24gix h2sIpq}UhQzfh2tsqsqkt~h^tU}~xUz_tU¦fsqh'xUzfh\¬bdcfh ¤ rfsqh24hQÁOr_tv~pqxUz_}
tU~h hQzfxvwh ¦I&W
B PwQ cB d
V3Q|c B
d
W X
8O;
jL9
tUz
v~cfhQpysqpqzfhQtU~pu}~tv~pqxUz!zfhQtUdt}v~h^t
1«_x<¥
B
¥~pyv~h^}W
B P Q c
cB
dB dV Q c
cB dB d W X C 8O; D9