Comparative Study of Routing Protocols for Mobile Ad-hoc networks

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00071448

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00071448

Submitted on 23 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub-

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,

Comparative Study of Routing Protocols for Mobile Ad-hoc networks

Thomas Clausen

To cite this version:

Thomas Clausen. Comparative Study of Routing Protocols for Mobile Ad-hoc networks. [Research Report] RR-5135, INRIA. 2004. �inria-00071448�

(2)

ISRN INRIA/RR--5135--FR+ENG

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

THÈME 1

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Comparative Study of Routing Protocols for Mobile Ad-hoc NETworks

Thomas Clausen

N° 5135

Mars 2004

(3)

(4)

3 465('8789;:=<> ?(+

@(ABDCFEHGJIKLEHMGONQP

RTS6U"VXWXY[Z]\_^a`bWacedgfJW,hi`bjg`khlU"VXWa`

monlprqkW,hisitumovw\yx_z[{

\ycr|6|}pQn~hygWnlWaSWanlS6WHgYOQZ {crn`yrQrZe|6ceeWa`

Ja".ee tu(hlS`)|6ce|}Wana)WigWa`l,nl}WihbSWz|ghbVX¡ aWaJ¢£¡6¤(¥¦hlc.hlW\_pQdghbmonbpehbpg,pQ§¨©z[¢¥g\iª

«Ya¬.L«e®©rcy|nlpQcQhb¯eW°nlpedhby|nlprhlp¦"pe§e±²pen{³pe§Wµ´_¦¶©Spgw·ivwR£)penl¤g`w¨¸{´i·ivwR`ª¹º=WwWa¯®ce§¡d}c.hbW

¡hl`|HW"nb±²penlV(cr6"WohlSnbpQdeSW,fgS6ced6`khl¡¯QW)`bVd§»c.hl¡pQ6`£d}`~[hbSW_·iW,hk)penl¤¥g¡Vd§crhbpQn°¨²}`lQª

«

Y©ecr}

"peVX|6cenbW_¡hbSpehbSWancQ¦¶LS6p¦|nbpehbpg,pQ§`a}`b|HWa,¡¼}acr§§¡jhbSW´_¦¶©Spgzg¶u½iWaV(cr6³½`~hlce6,W¾°Wahlpen

¨¸´iz[½_¾[ª

«

rynlpedhb¿|nbpehbpg,pQ§ycr6ÀhbS6W½ij¦6ceV»¥¦pQdnl"W³\_pedghl¡6¨¸½[¥\iª

«

®i|nlprhlpg,pe§L¹ºÁW

`~hbd}gjÂhlSW³|nlprhbpg"pe§»`d66gW"nJ¯®cenbj¦Ã,pQ6g¡hbpe6`³¨ÄpggW³VXpe§¡¡hkje)W"hkµpQnb¤ÀW"6`bÅhkjªXce6À_¡hbS

¯.cenbj¦_hbnc.Æ y¨¸Rixµm®Ç½imrg¡ÈDW"nlW"h¦dV}Wanpe±6,pe6Wa,hbpe6`É.`~hbnlWaceVX`ª}hbp|nlp.¯»gWwcÊd6cr§Åhc.hl¡¯QW

cQ`b`bWa`l`bVWah)pe±£hbS6Wcr||§»"cr6¡§ÅhkjJpr±hbSW|nlprhlpg,pe§»`)¡³g¡ÈDW"nlW"hy`b"W"6cenbpQ`a¹

Ë³ÌÍDÎlÏÐ .Ñe ´_gSpgÒW,hk)penl¤g`"µ\_pedghl¡6¿ce§¡QpenlÅhlSV)z[¢¥\°6`®¶u`~Vd§»c.hl¡pQÓo|HW"nb±²penlV(cr6"W

Wa¯.cr§d6c.hl¡pQÓg|nlprhbpg"pe§Ô,pQV|}crnl`bpeÓ¹

(5)

+£_ %2,*,_+ 5('

½[cr6`Ò,WÁ|6cr|6¡Wana_pQd6`J^a,nl¯epe}`(§¡WÁ|nlprhbpg"pe§W=z[¢¥g\

«

Ya¬.L

«

e.©iÊdiWO`khÒd |nlprhlpg,pe§WgW

nlpedhlcrQW|nlpQce,hb¡±o,pe,d³|Hpedn§¡WOìnlâ`bWacedgfVXpe6¡§Wa`[ceSpg¨Ä{´·yvwRyª,¹D·iped6ì^"¯.cr§dpQ6ì`bWaì|}Wan~¶

±²pQnbV(ce6,WO`ene"WgWa``b¡Vd§crhbpe6`W,f¦hbWa6`~¯eWO`6cQ`~^aWa``~dn§¡W`~Vd§»c.hlW"dn6`

«

Y"LW"hpQd6`§Wa`

"peVX|6cenbpQ6`wc®¯QWai"W"§§¡WO`TcedghbnlWa`µ|nlprhlp¦"pe§Wa`)gW[nbpQdghlceeWe¦gpQQhTW"|6crnbhb»,d6§¡W"n_´iz[½_¾

«

rÓW,h_½[¥g\

«

O©¹·ypQd6` ^"hbd6gpe}` §Wa` |6nbpehbpg,pQ§¡WO` `~pQd6`JWa`J"pe6Åhl¡pQ6`(¯.crnl¡^aWa`¨ÄVXpe§¡¡hb^QigWa6`~¡hb^®ª(W"hc®¯eWO

Wa`whbnc.¼}a`µgWgpQ^"WO`)¯®cenb^a`¨ÄRixµmÇi½mgVd§¡hb|§"Åhl^gWa`T,pQWOhbpe}`lªwc.¼6ÒgW|6nbpggdnlWidW

WO`khl¡V(crhbpeÊd6ce§¡¡hlcrhb¯eWTgWa`"pe6g¡hbpe}`°ce||§acr§Åhl^)gWO`|nlprhbpg"pe§Wa``~pQd6`ÅÈD^"nlW"hl`°`l,^a6crnlpQ`a¹

Ð O Î nlUa`bWacedgfceSpgr}cr§epenl¡hbSVXWgWnlpedghcreWQg`~Vd§»c.hl¡pQ}`l^"¯.cr§d6crhbpegW|}Wan~±²pQn~¶

V(ce6,WQ,peVX|6cenlce`bpegW|nlprhbpg"pe§Wa`

(6)

@ A

!£ (Ò'w,!

´VXpe§¡Wce¦¶©SpgW"hkµpQnb¤¿¨Ä{í·yvµRyªi»ìc,pQ§¡§Wa,hbpe³pr±o6p¦WaàH_S6ScenbWcr§WhlpJ,pQWa,hpQ

c_nbWa§¡WO`b`)VXWagdV ±²pQnbVXXcrcenb6Åhlnlcenbj(cr}Jgj¦6ceV»[W,hk)penl¤D¹tuVX|§»,¡hThbS»`_gW,¼}Åhl¡pQpe±

cÒW"hkµpQnb¤³»`hlSWX±Äce,hhbS6crh§¡¤g`"gdWXhlp³pggW(VXpe§¡¡hkjce6=prhbS6W"n±Äce,hbpQnl`aÓV(c®jcr|6|}WOcrncr}

`lcr||HWacen_c.h_cr¦jXhbVXWe¹oRTS»`T¡cX{´i·ivwR ¡VX|§¡WO`)hbS6crhThbSW[hbpQ|}pQ§¡pQej(V(c®j(HWj}crVX¶ocr}

hlS6c.hnlpedghl¡6Jpr±µhbnc.Æ hbSnlpedQScÒVd§¡hb¡¶©Spe|Á|6c.hlS»`Wa"Wa`l`bcenbj¡±)cr§§pggWa`cenbWhbpÒ}W(ce§¡Whbp

"peVXVd6ac.hlWe¹

´ ¤QW"jF`l`~d6W³¡ {´·yvwR` »`(hlSW³WO,Wa`l`bÅhkjÀhbS6crh hbSWnbpQdghb¿|nlprhbpg"pe§»`XVd6`~hJHWcr§Whbp

nlWa`b|Hpe6Xncr|»g§jhlphbpQ|}pQ§¡pQe»"cr§}S6crQWa`°(hlSWyW"hkµpQnb¤D¹´)hwhbS6Wi`bceVXW_hbVXWeggdW_hlphbS6Wi§¡VX¡hbWa

}cr6g_»¦hlSÀc®¯.cr§ce§¡W hbSnlpedQSÂVXpe§WJncegpQhlW"nb±Äce"Wa`a¡hX`¡VX|HW"nc.hl¡¯QW(hbS6crhhlSWceVXpedhpe±

"pehbnlpe§HhlnlcrÆ(egeWaW"nc.hlWa ¦jJhbSWnlpedghl¡6|nlprhlpg,pe§»`)`y¤eW"|h_crhicVVdV¹

¥¦Wa¯eWanlce§|6nbpehbpg,pQ§`W,fg»`khO£cenbWO`b`b¡6JhlSWX|nbpQ§W"V(`[pr±µnlpedhb¿VXpe§¡WXceg¶LSpgW"hkµpQnb¤g`a¹

¥gd6S¿|nbpehbpg,pQ§`cenbWQÓhlnlcQgÅhl¡pQ6cr§§je¡¯¦»gWa¿hbphk)p,§»ce`l`~WO`"gW"|HW"6¡³pQÃ_SW"ÃcpggWce¶

ÊdnlWa`wcnbpQdghbWihbpcgWO`khl¡6crhbpeÓ¹

8B1&,

|nlprhlpg,pe§»`wcenbWS6crnce,hbW"nl "Wa¦jXpggWa`)ceaÊd¡nlcr}

V(ce¡hlce¡6¡JnbpQdghbWO`ipQg¶©W"V(cr6Ó¹ituQW"Wanlce§¸}_SW"=c nlpedghlWhbpÒcrd6¤6p._gWa`~hb6crhbpe»`inlW,¶

ÊdnlWa¦jcpggWQcÊdWanbj`DC}ppggWOXpehbphlSWyW"hkµpQnb¤cr6nlW"|§¡WO`",pQQhcr|}p`b`b§¡W_nlpedhbWa`

hlphbSWgWa`~hb6c.hl¡pQÓcrnlW(nbW"hbdnlWaÓ¹Jv°fcrVX|§Wa`pr±_nbWOce,hb¯eWX|nlprhbpg"pe§»`¡6"§¡d}gW(hbS6WFE~´_ÃsipgJz

½W"V(ce6¿½i»`khcr6"WX¾°Wahlpen\ypedghl¡monlprhlpg,pe§HG¨¸´iz[½_¾[ª

«

YJIOµcr6KEb½ij¦6ceV» ¥¦pQdnl"W(\_pedghl¡6G

¨¸½[¥\iª

«

¬®L¹

"$ BL1&,J |nlprhbpg"pe§»`µcenbWS6crnce,hbWanb "WO(¦jJcr§§ÔpggWa`)V(crhlce¡XnlpedghlWa`µhbp(cr§§ÔgWa`~hb6crhbpe6`

ÒhbSW6W,hk)penl¤ c.hycr§§ÔhbVXWa`a¹oRTS¦d6`Td6`b¡(c|nlpQcQhb¯eW[|nlprhlp¦"pe§LcpggW`TVXVXWag»c.hlW"§jcr6§¡W[hbp

nlpedhbWX¨²penynbpQ|}ª)c|}ce¤eW"ha¹v°fcrVX|§Wa`Tpe±|nlpQcQhb¯eW[|nlprhlp¦"pe§»`)¡6"§¡d}gW[hbSWEbR£pQ|}pQ§¡pQejNM)nbpceace`~h

}ce`bWapQ\_W"¯QW"n`~W"¶Lm°crhbS.OpQnbTcrngG°nlpedghl¡|nlprhbpg"pe§}¨¸RPMT\_m>O°ª

«

Ya.¦ce6hlSWQElz|ghl¡VX "WO¢Ó¤

¥¦hlc.hlW\_pedghl¡6(monbpehbpg,pQ§RGX¨Lz[¢¥\iª

«

YO¬®©¹

tuÃhlS»`|6ce|}WanahlSWz|ghl¡VX "WOÂ¢Ó¤¶u¥¦hlc.hlW\_pQdghbmwnbpehbpg,pQ§w_§¡§)}W|nlWa`bW"hbWOÔ¹º=WJ_§¡§

Wa`l,nl¡HWihlSW|nlprhbpg"pe§L¦cQ`)µWa§¡§ÓcQ`µW"fg|}p`~W`~pQVXW[pe±ÓhbS6W|nbpehbpg,pQ§`µ6ce`b[S6cenlcQhbWanb»`~hb»"`whbSnlpedQS

`bVd§»c.hl¡pQ6`"¹³º=W _§¡§µhbS6W"À"peVX|6crnlWz[¢¥\ _ÅhlSÃhk)p³nbWOcehl¡¯QW |nlprhlp¦"pe§»`"´iz[½_¾ce6Ã½¥g\¹

tuÀ|6crnbhb»,d§»crnl§jeµW_¡§§)±²pg,d6`peÂWO`khcr§»`~ShbSW±Äce,hhbS}c.hJz[¢¥g\-cQ`c|nlpQce,hb¯eW(|nlprhlpg,pe§

"peVX|§W"VXW"h`)hbSWnlWacQhb¯eW[|nlprhlp¦"pe§»`"¹

STS UKVDWYX[Z]\_^P`6abcX

RTS6W_nbWaVXce¡}gW"npr±HhbS6`°|}cr|HW"no_§¡§6}W_pQnbcr "WOce`±²pQ§¡§p.y`Ld£X`bWa,hbpe geµW_gWO`b"nb}WThlSWz[¢¥\

|6nbpehbpg,pQ§cQ`[c|nlpQcQhb¯eWnbpQdghbÒ|nlprhbpg"pe§±²pen{´i·ivwR`"W"VX|S6cQ`~ "hbSWhbS6nbWaW6gWa|}Wa6gW"h

"peVX|HpeWaQh`V(cr¤¦¡6[d6|hlSW_|nlprhlp¦"pe§L¹£º=Wycr§»`~p|nlp.¯¦WT`bpeVXWT6`~eSh`"rcrWahbS6nbpQdeSW,fgS6ced6`k¶

hl¡¯QWW,fg|HW"nl¡VXW"h`ycr6³`bVd§»c.hl¡pQ6`"6peÒhbSWgWa`b¡Qpr±hbSW|6nbpehbpg,pQ§¸¹µtu`~WOhbpe³6µWhbnlpggd6,W

hlSW nlWacQhb¯eWX|nlprhlpg,pe§»`ÃeWaW"ncr§Lce6¿gWa`l,nl¡HWJ´iz[½_¾-ce6Ã½¥g\ Â`~pQVW W,hlce¡§L¹ÒºÁW(hlSW"

|6nbpg,WaWaÔg³`~WOhl¡pQ}¦jJgWa`l,nl¡6pQdny`b¡Vd§crhbpeÒW"¦¯¦¡nlpe6VWahag6,§d6ghbSW`b"W"6cenbpQ`µµW

d}`~WQ¹RTS6nbpQdeS(|nlp.¯¦¡c§cenbQWi`bW,hµpe±£ncr6gpQVX§¡jeWaW"nc.hlWa(`l,W"}crnl¡p`"ece§¡§D,pQg±²penlVX¡6hbpX`~pQVXW

QW"Wanlce§g`b"W"6cenbp[`b|HWa,¡¼}ac.hbpe}`"QµW_crV>crh°|nbp.¯¦»gd¦cQ`~WO`bVd§»c.hl¡pQ6`"¹°¥¦WOhbpe([|nlWa`bW"hl`

ce6Òg`l,d}`b`bWa`_`bW"§Wa,hbWanlWa`bd§Åh`Tpr±pedny`bVd§»c.hl¡pQ6`"gce6hbSW|6ce|}Wan_`_"pe6"§¡d}gWaÒÒ`bWa,hbpefe¹

(7)

: 5Ò "%)_="!J?4Ô "!# $& (')*

RTS6WXz|ghl¡VX "WaÁ¢Ó¤¶u¥¦hlc.hlW\_pQdghbÒmonlprhbpg"pe§µ¨©z[¢¥g\ªy»`c|nlpQcQhb¯eW§¤¶©`~hlcrhbWnlpedhbJ|nlpr¶

hlpg,pe§L¦W"VX|§p.j¦¡|}WanbpggVXWa`l`bceeWyW"fS6crQWyhlpd|Dc.hlW[hbpe|Hpe§peQacr§}¡g±²pQnbV(crhbpe JWOceS pggW

ÃhlSW6W,hk)penl¤H¹Áº S§¡WÒS6c®¯¦¡6`~pQVXW,pQVXVpQ6cr§¡hbWa`_ÅhlSz¥¦m>O

«

Ya®©)z[¢¥g\ »``b|}WO,¡¼}"ce§¡§j

Wa`b¡QWaÂhbp=pe|HW"nc.hbWÒÂhbS6W"pehbW"f¦hpe±[{´·yvwR`"µ¸¹We¹F¡ 6ce6g_»¦hbSg¶u,pQ6`~hbncrWaÔoj}crVX

6W,hk)penl¤¦`a¹

tuhbS»`y`bWa,hbpeÓ¦)W[|6nbWO`~WaQh_gW"hlcr§»`Tpr±ÓhlSW|nlprhbpg"pe§LcQ`TµWa§¡§Ôce`_Wa`l,nl¡HW[`bpeVXW[pr±hbSWpe|HW"nc.¶

hl¡pQ6cr§ÔW"fg|}WanbW"6"Wa`)hlS6c.hyS6c®¯QWC6d6W"6"WahbSWW"¯eWa§¡pQ|VXW"h_pr±hbSW|nlprhlpg,pe§ÔgWO`~e£¹

PTS U Z Q` >a X `VDba

xµpQ6,Wa|ghbd}cr§§¡jQÔz[¢¥g\ ,pQQhcr6`_hlSnlW"WQW"Wanb»W"§W"VXWaQh` d_cJVWOS6cr6`bV ±²pQniWa¡QS¦}pQn`bW"6`b¡66}c

VXWOS6cr»`bV ±²pen£W,Æ ,W"h£g¡ÈHd}`~pepe±g"pehbnlpe§®hlnlcrÆ r®cr6cTVXWaS6ce»`~V;±²pen£`bW"§Wa,hbycr6ÅÈDd6`b¡

`bdgÆ ,W"hyhlpe|Hpe§peQacr§Ôg±²penlV(c.hbpe³hbS6WW,hk)penl¤J³pengWan_hbp |6nbp.¯¦»gWpe|ghl¡V(ce§£nlpedghlWa`a¹)RTSWO`~W

Wa§¡WaVXW"hl`_cenbWgWO`b"nb}WOJ³gW,hcr§`TÒhbSW±²pQ§¡§p._6¹

Ì Ð ! Ì#" "$

MTcQ`~»"ce§¡§jer6W"eS¦}pQno`~Wa6`b¡»`°hlSWy|nlpg,WO`b`hlSnlpedQS_S»S cpggWiW,hbWOh`wS6ceeWO`hbp¡hl`wW"eSg¶

HpenlSp¦pgÔ¹oRTSWWa¡QS¦}pQnbSp¦pgpr±°c6p¦We },pQhlcr6`)hlSW`~W"hypr±pggWa`T_¡hbS³_S6SÒhbS6W"nlW[W"fg`~hl`

cg¡nlWa,h§¡¤¿p.¯QW"n_S»SÀcrhlc³V(c®jHW hlnlce6`bV¡h~hlWa ¨Ä¡ÀW"¡hbSWanpen}pehbSÀgnlWahl¡pQ6`ª¹/Od6n~hlSW"n

crh~hlnbdghlWa`iacrHWce`l`bp¦"crhbWOJ_¡hbS`bd6ScX§¡6¤HDgWa|}Wa6g pehlSW¡nlWa,hbpe£¨¸`lª)_S»S,pQV¶

Vd»"crhbpe`J|}p`b`b§¡WQ¹ t©±hlnlcrÆ(³acr pQ§¡j_C6p.0¡ pQWgnbWOhl¡pQ&¨ÄWe¹6¹ Å±hlSWpggWO`(S6c®¯QW

cQ`~j¦VXVXW,hlnb»hbncr}`~VX¡h~hbWanl`ª}hbS6W§¡6¤Ò»`[`bcehlpJHW *(#N, o& ¹t©±°hlnlcrÆ("cefC6p.&¡}pehbSÁÅ¶

nlWa,hbpe6`aDhbS6W§¤»`[`lcr»hbpÒ}W *oFN o& ¹t©±µhbSWanbWXW"f¦»`~hcÒ`bjVXVXW,hlnb»§¡¤HW,hk)W"WaÁpggW 0

ce6pggW 6p¦W 0 `y`lcr»JhbpX}Wc *o# o&F ,H J560( pr±pggW ¨¸cr6¯¦"W¯eW"n`lcQª¹

tuJz[¢¥\.hbS6Wy,pe},W"|hopr±Ôc

<>45B/ H J560(

»`°¡hlnbpggd6"WaÔ¹´ hk)pr¶©Spe|W"eS¦Hpen°pe±HpggW

»`)`~VX|§¡j(cpggWi_S»S S6cQ`µc`~j¦VXVXW,hbnl»y§¡¤hlpc`bj¦VXVW"hbnliW"eS¦Hpenµpr±ÓpggW

´·i½ _S»S

»`TpehypggW

Åh`~Wa§Å±y¨²L¹We¹°pggW

"ceprh_HWchk)pr¶©SpQ|JWa¡QSHpen_pe±¡hl`bW"§¡±lª¹

´ |nlVW³QpQce§µ±²pQnz[¢¥g\0»`hbpÃHW,pQV|6§¡W"hbW"§jÂ6gWa|}Wa6gW"h pe±hlSW³d6gWanb§j¦¡6=§¤¶L§»c®jeWan

HW"Ád6`~WOÔ¹º S§Wce6gÅhl¡pQ6cr§µ¡±²penlVXcrhbpe¿±²nlpeV hbS6WJ§¡¤¿§»c®jeWana`~d}SÂce`g±²pQnbV(c.hl¡pQÂcrHpedgh

W"fg`~hbWa6,Wpe±°§¡¤g`_hlp W"eS¦Hpeny6p¦Wa`ice6Ò§¡¤³Êd6cr§¡hkje6V(c®j}Wdghb§¡ "WO¦jJhlSW|nlprhlpg,pe§L6acrnlW

»`whlcr¤QW" `bd6S(hlS6c.hµhbSW|nbpehbpg,pQ§}acr(±²d}hbpeJ_ÅhlSpedghO¹oRTSWcQg¯.crhlceeWO`ocrnlWeQhbS6crhwhlSWi|nlprhlpg,pe§

VXVXWag»c.hlW"§j"cr=HWXW"|§p.jeWO³peÁVp`khW"f¦»`~hbÒce6cehb»,|6c.hlWa_nlW"§Wa`l`6W,hk)penl¤ÒhbWan~±ÄcQ,Wa`

ce6pe|HW"nc.hb(`bj¦`~hbWaV(`"¹

RTSWWa¡QSHpen`bW"6`b¡6JVXWaS6ce»`~V Ãz[¢¥g\ »`[Wa`b¡QWahlppQ|}WanlcrhbW¡6W"|HW"6gWahb§j³¡ÁhbSW

±²pQ§¡§p._()c®j dµWaceS³6p¦W|HW"nl¡pgg»"ce§¡§jJWaV¡hl`[c sivw¢£¢zi¶LVXWa`l`lcreWQ6,pQhlcr(hlSWpggW `p._

cQgnlWa`l`wcQ`w)W"§§Ôce`)chbS6W§`~hTpr±£Wa¡QS¦}pQnl`w¤6p._(hbphbSW[pggWQ6"§¡d6¡hbS6W[`~hlcrhbd6`µpr±ÓhlSW[§¡¤

hlpXWaceSÒWa¡QSHpen¨ÄWe¹6¹o`bjVXVXW,hlnb»[penycQ`~j¦VXVXW,hbnl»aª¹

Çi|}pQ nbWO,Wa¡¯¦Àsyvµ¢£¢zi¶©VXWa`l`bceeWO`"_cÃpggW="cehbS¦d6`Qc.hlSW"n¡±²penlVXcrhbpe gWO`b"nbÂ¡hl`

6W"eS¦}pQnbS6ppg³ce6hk)pr¶©Spe|³Wa¡QS¦}pQnbSp¦pgÔHce`µWa§¡§ce`gW,hlWah[hbS6W EbÊd6cr§Åhkj1Gpr±ohlSW§¤g`i¡hl`

(8)

6W"eS¦}pQnbS6ppg d[hlSW(§¡¤±²nbpQV8cÒpggW

hbpc6W"eS¦}pQn

0

``~j¦VXVXW,hbnl»XÅ±)hbSW(6p¦W

`~WaWa`¡hl`

p._³cQgnlWa`l`TÅ±ohbSWsyvw¢¢zi¶©VWO`b`lcrQW[±²nbpQV

0

¨Ä_ÅhlScr¦j§¡¤`khc.hbd}`lª)¶µprhbS6W"nl_`bWhbSW§¡¤Ò`

cQ`~j¦VXVXW,hlnb»r¹

vwcQSpggW)V(crhlcr6`cr¡g±²pQnbV(crhbpe`bW,hOrgWa`l,nl¡6yhbS6W)6W"eS¦}pQnl`cr6hbSW)hk)pr¶©Spe|W"eSg¶

Hpen`a¹¥¦d6S¡g±²pQnbV(crhbpe»`,pe}`~»gW"nlWa¯.ce§¡»±²pQnci§¡VXÅhlWa|}Wanbpgpr±hl¡VXWQecr6Vd6`~hHW)nbW"±²nbWO`~SWO

crh)§WacQ`khT|HW"nl¡pgg»"ce§¡§jXhbpnbWaV(crJ¯.cr§Ó¹vof¦|6¡nlWa¡±²penlVXcrhbpe »`T|dnleWOX±²nlpeV hbS6W[6W"eS¦}pQn~¶°cr}

hk)pr¶©SpQ|JWa¡QSHpen_`bW,h`"¹

Ì"Ì Ì aO HÌ! ÄÐ"

sivw¢£¢zi¶LVXWO`b`lcrQWa`(crnlW³W,fS6ceeWO }W"hkµWaW" Wa¡QSHpen`(pQ§¡jQ¹RTSW"j |nlp.¯¦gW³WOceSpggW_¡hbS

hlpe|Hpe§peQacr§Ôg±²penlV(c.hbpeÒd|hlpXhkµp(SpQ|6`yc®Tc®je¹osip.µWa¯eW"nO`b¡6"W{´i·ivwR`acr}Wpr±°crnlÅhlnlcenbj

`b "WeÔcJVW"hbSpg`nbWOÊd¡nlWa³±²penÅÈDd6`b¡hbpQ|}pQ§¡pQe»"ce§£g±²penlV(c.hbpe¡hbpJhbSWW"hl¡nlWW"hkµpQnb¤D¹tu

z[¢¥g\HhbS6`»`¡hlnbpggd6"Wa¡Á±²penlV pr±)cJQW"Wanb»Tc®j³pr±µW,Æ ,W"hb§jg¡ÈDd6`~³crnl¡hbncrnljÒ"pehbnlpe§

hlnlcrÆ _hbpXcr§§DpggWa`µJhlSW6W,hk)penl¤H¹º S§¡W[HW"¡nlWa,hb§j(d6`~WO z[¢¥g\ ±²pQn)g¡ÈDd6`~peÒpr±Ôhlpe|Hpr¶

§peQacr§¡±²penlVXcrhbpeÓHhlSWXVWOS6cr6`bV `[d6¡§»ÁcQ`cr6gWa|}Wa6gWaQhce6W"Æ ,W"h{mw\T¶C6p¦p¦¡

VXWOS6cr»`bVÒcr6=V(c®jhlS¦d6`HW d6`bWa=hbpacrnlnbjprhbS6W"nhkj¦|}WO`pe±T"pehbnlpe§hlnlcrÆ(³¨ÄWe¹6¹J±²pen`bW"nl¯¦"W

`l,p.¯QW"nlj|nlprhbpg"pe§»`°W,haª¹tu6W"WaÓ crJpe|HW"nc.hbpe}cr§6"pehbW"fhOrhlS`µVXWaS6ce»`~V )cQ`±²ped66Xhbp}W

ce WacQ`~jXTc®j±²pQn)cpggWQ¦"pe6WahlWaXhlpHprhlSc{´i·ivwR;ce6 c_nlWa 6W,hk)penl¤HehbpXcr6ped6"Wi¡hl`

E~pQg¶LV(ceW,hGnbpQdghb("ce|6cr6¡§Åhl¡WO`)hbp({´·yvwR pggWO`"¹

zWpr±°hlSW|nlVWnbWOÊd¡nlW"VXWaQh`"D`~hlc.hlWaÁ`bWa,hbpeÃYTce`ahlS6c.hgdWhbp§¡VXÅhlWa}cr6g_»¦hlS

nlWa`bped6nl"Wa`aahlSW_p.¯eWanbS6Wace±²nbpQV,pQQhlnbpQ§ehlnlcrÆ )`bSpQd§HW_¤eW"|h°crhocVXVdV¹RTS`ar±²pQn°c["pehbnlpe§

VXWO`b`lcrQWgWa`~hbWOhlpÒce§¡§pggWa`[hlSWXW,hk)penl¤D}VX|§¡Wa`[hlS6c.h(¨²ª[cr§§6p¦Wa`[Wacr§§j³nbWO,W"¯eWhbSW

VXWO`b`lcrQWe¦_S§¡W ¨Ä¡ªµhbS6crhyprhThlpp(V(cejgd|§ac.hlW[nlW,hlnlce6`bV»`l`~pe6`)pe±£hbS6WVWO`b`lcrQWpga,dn`"¹

´ `b¡VX|§W|dnlWC}ppgg(`~hbnc.hbWaejQQ_SWanbWce§¡§DpggWO`)±²penl)cenl cC6p¦pggWaVXWa`l`bceeW[Å±hbSWaj S6c®¯QW

6prh|6nbWa¯ped}`~§j ±²penl)cenlgWO hbSW=VXWa`l`bceeWVXWaW,hl`hlSW¼}nl`~h|6cen~hÒpr±hlSW=nbWOÊQd6¡nlW"VXW"h'd¿hbS6crhce§¡§

6p¦Wa`a»gWOcr§§¡jQnlWa"W"¯eWic,pQ|jXpe±ÓhbSW[VXWa`l`bceeWQ¹RTSW`bWa,pQ6(|6cen~h)`)pQ§¡jX|6cen~hlce§¡§jXVXW,h)hbSnlpedQS

Ekhbncr}`~VX»`b`b¡pQ(gd|§ac.hlWiW"§V6crhbpe GQWa§¡VX¡}c.hbhbSW`~¡hbd}c.hbpe(_S6W"nlWyhk)p,pQ|¡WO`ope±ÔhbSW`bceVXW

VXWO`b`lcrQWcrnlWyhlnlce6`bV¡h~hlWaJ±²nbpQV-cQ¡¯QW"pggW.¹osyp.)W"¯eWanace¯eW"JpggWVeShT}WnlWa"W"¯hbSW

`lcrVXWVXWa`l`bceeW±²nbpQV hk)p6W"eS¦}pQnbpggWa`a¹oRTS»`T`y¡§§¡d}`khlnlcrhbWa¼}ednlWYOc¹

RTSW±ÄcQhThbS}c.hicVXWa`l`bceeW[`_§¤eW"§j(hlpHWnlWa,Wa¡¯QWaJjc6p¦WVpQnbWhbS}crpe6"W`_c|nlpe§W"VKd

d}`~Ã|dnlWKC6p¦pgg6T_SWac¿VXWO`b`lcrQWÒ»`(hlnlce6`bV¡h~hlWa p.¯eWanXhbSW³_nlW"§Wa`l`(VXWagdV_cr§§iprhlSW"n

6p¦Wa`T_¡hbSnlcQg¡pXncrQWpe±hlSW[hbncr6`bVXÅhbhb(pggW_§¡§ÓWaÅhlSW"niS6c®¯eWhbpXnlW"V(crÒ`b§¡WaQhOpen_V(c®j

W"fg|}WanbW"6"WVWO`b`lcrQW§pQ`l`_gdW[hlp ,pe§§`b¡pQ6`a¹

RTSW(z[¢¥g\&|6nbpehbpg,pQ§£cr||6§¡Wa`crpQ|ghbVX¡ aWa C6p¦pgg VXWaS6ce»`~VD"cr§§Wa³{³mw\_¶C6p¦pgg6}hbp

VXV "WhbSW|nbpQ§W"V0pr±ogd|§»"c.hlWnlWa,Wa|ghbpepe±oVWO`b`lcrQW_ÅhlS¡Ác(nbWaepeÓ¹TRTSWpQ|ghbVX¡ Oc.hl¡pQ

»`µ|}Wan~±²pQnbVXWaX hlSWy±²pQ§¡§p._Tc®j dcpggW[`~Wa§¡WOh`µc`bd6`bW,h)pr±Ó¡hl`)`~j¦VXVXW,hlnb»yWa¡QS¦}pQnl`aQacr§§¡WO

hlSWpggWO`y{³d§¡hbmpeQh[\_W"§»c®jg`[¨¸{³mw\ `ª¹)vwceSpggWhlSd}`_S6ce`_c³¨Ä|}p`b`b§¡jW"VX|ghkjªT`bW,hypr±°{³mw\

`bW"§Wa,hbpQnl`¨²6W"eS¦}pQnl`a¦_S»SS6c®¯QW[`bW"§Wa,hbWO hlSWpggWce`_{³mw\ª¹6´&pggWQ`~Wa§¡WOhlWaÒce`_{³mw\S6ce`

"!#"%$&

i

i i

#'(!)*+,-.*"/0 "

i

#/213"+4+4$5#"/67"#"8

i

,"9

i

:( ;6!

i

!$(.2=<3#"

i

,%.?>& ="! 7

i

@

i

$5:

i

-$5+ #"BA

(9)

(a) (b)

OednlW[Y d 9 )8h PL' . P *o *o! Y-f)R 8,)2J* 0F; 56* &(

5NNo*(* ! *#56 ' 56 &(,% 9P1&B5_ o < 6! % K ' 8 &(,* 56:

L1K (&(,,*f &(( 56KNo*(* ! ; 5>))( ' ,*K K* )(&,( 0, 56/&( , ' /*

-f)RQ )

hlSWnlWa`b|}pQ6`b¡§Åhkjpr±°nbWa§c®j¦#C6p¦pggWaVXWa`l`lcreWO`)±²nbpQV ¡hl`[{³mw\ `bW"§Wa,hbpen`a¹)´ VXWO`b`lcrQW[WaVXÅhbhbWa

¦j6p¦W »`hlSd}`pe§jnlW,hbncr}`~VX¡h~hbWO¦j6p¦W 0 Å±DpggW `o¡hbSWy{mw\`~Wa§¡WOhbpQn°`~W"hopr±}6p¦W 0 ¹

´`T¡§§d6`khlnlcrhbWOJJ¼}ednlWYaÓE~acrnlW,±²d§HG`~Wa§¡WOhl¡pQpe±{³mw\i`¨hbS6W¼6§¡§WapggWO`lª)V(c®j(enlWacrhb§jXnbWOgd6,W

d|§ac.hbWnlW,hlnlce6`~VX»`b`bpe6`a¹

º S§W`~Wa§¡WOhb({³mw\i`"Hc6p¦W[dhb§¡ "WO`_¡±²penlVXcrhbpegWa`l,nl¡6hlSWhkµpe¶LS6pe|J6W"eS¦}pQnl`ace`

cQ"ÊdnbWO¿±²nlpeV hbSWWa¡QS¦}pQn`bW"6`b|nlpg,WO`b`a¹Ã´y§§)6p¦Wa`X`~Wa§¡WOhhbSWa¡n({³mµ\y`¡6W"|HW"6gWahb§je

|HpQ`l`b¡§jJSp¦p`~ÅÈDW"nlW"hicr§epQnb¡hbS6VX`µpen_S6W"dnl`~hb»"`µ±²pQny`~Wa§¡WOhb(cYEkVXVXce§RG{³mw\&`~W"ha¹oRTSW

¦¯.crnlceQhX±²pQn(hbSWÁcr§epenl¡hbSV(`X»`")hbS}c.hJc¿VXWa`l`bceeWQµWaV¡h~hlWa¦jÂhlSWpggWÁcr6 nlW"§»c®jeWaF¦jÀ¡hl`

{mw\y`a_µpQd§nlWacQS cr§§yhbS6WpggW`(hk)pr¶©SpQ| 6W"eS¦}pQnl`a¹

«

r|nlWa`bW"hl`Jcr cr}cr§j¦`b»`(pr±{³mw\

`bW"§Wa,hbpecr§epQnb¡hbSV(`a¹

´ 6p¦W³`J¡g±²pQnbVXWOFpe±[¡hl`{³mw\ `bW"§Wa,hbpen `bW,hJhbSnlpedQS¡g±²pQnbV(crhbpe |¡Qej¦6ceeeWOÃhlpÃhbSW

sivw¢£¢zi¶LVXWO`b`lcrQWa`a¹

RTS¦d6`_SWaÁd}`~{³mw\T¶C6p¦pgg¡66ÔhlSW±²penl)cenlg nld§W±²penS6cr}g§¡ C6p¦pggWa=,pQQhlnbpQ§VXWO`k¶

`lcrQWa`)ÒWOceSpggW}Wa¡6d

Ye¹)hbSWVXWa`l`bceeWVd6`kh[}WVXWacrhyhlpJHW±²pQnbTcrngWa¿¨Ä¡6ac.hbWO³¦j¡g±²pQnbV(crhbpe³³hbSWSWacQgW"n

pr±hbSWVXWO`b`lcrQWOª

g¹)hbSWVXWO`b`lcrQWVd6`khy6prhyS6c®¯QWHW"WaÒnlWa"W"¯eWO ¦j hlSWpggW}W"±²penlWece6

¹)hbSWpggWVd6`khS6c®¯eWHW"W"Á`~Wa§¡WOhbWOce`i{mw\&¦jJhlSWpggWQ6±²nlpeV_SShlSWVXWO`b`lcrQW[Tce`

nbWO,Wa¡¯QWa

(10)

RTSWz[¢¥g\ |nbpehbpg,pQ§6`b|}WO,¡¼}"crhbpe

«

Ya¬®ÔgW,¼}Wa`)ceWaW"nl»_VXWa`l`bceeWT±²penlV(c.hµce6 ce cr§epenl¡hbSV

±²pQn|nbpg"Wa`l`~J`bd6SVXWO`b`lcrQWa`a¹RTS`[6,§d6gWO`[hbVXW,¶Lhbpr¶©§¡¯QW,pQ6`bgWanlcrhbpe6`aÔ`~WOÊdW"6"W¦dV}Wanl`

&

pQdgh_pr±°`b"pe|HW[±²penThbS6`yWa`l,nl¡|ghl¡pQÓ¹

ÐwÐ Ð6Í " ©Ð Àg ¸Ð"

RTS6W){³mµ\ C6p¦pggiVXWOS6cr»`bV `gnbWOhl§¡jd6`bWa¦jz[¢¥g\¿±²pQn°gÅÈDd6`b¡6ihlpe|Hpe§pee»"ce§Qg±²pQnbV(c.hl¡pQ

hlphbSWW"hkµpQnb¤D¹

tuÒz[¢¥g\¦cr§§}6p¦Wa`µ_ÅhlSJcpQg¶©W"VX|ghkjX{³mw\;`bW"§Wa,hbpQnµ`bW,hµ|HW"nlp¦acr§§¡jeWaW"nc.hlWichbpQ|}pQ§¡pQej

"pehbnlpe§wVWO`b`lcrQW¨ÄRixw¶©VXWa`l`bceeWOª,¹³RTS`Rixw¶©VWO`b`lcrQWX`g¡ÈHd6`bWaÃhbpce§¡§µpggWa`¡¿hlSWJ6W,hk)penl¤H

d}`~{³mw\ C6p¦pgg¡66¹´ Rixw¶©VXWa`l`bceeW"pehlce¡6`hlSW(cegnlWa`l`[pr±ohlSWXpggWXeWaW"nc.hl¡JhbSW(Rixw¶

VXWO`b`lcrQWe£cQ`µWa§¡§µce`[hbS6WJcenbWO`b`bWa`[pr±yce§¡§°hlSW {³mw\ `bW"§Wa,hbpQnl`pe±µhlS6c.h6p¦We¹RTS¦d6`hbSnlpedQS=c

Rixw¶©VXWa`l`bceeWQ£cpggW W"ÈHWOhb¯eWa§¡j=cr6ped6"Wa`nlWacQS6cr6¡§Åhkjhlpcr§§o¡hl`{³mw\ `bW"§Wahlpen`"¹¥¦6,W ce§¡§

6p¦Wa`S6c®¯QW`bW"§Wa,hbWa¿ce={³mµ\ `bW,hO£nlWacQS6cr§Åhkjhlpce§¡§°6p¦Wa`_§¡§oHW cr6ped},WahbS6nbpQdeSÁhbSW

6W,hk)penl¤H¹RTSWnbWO`~d§¡h`ihbS6crhce§¡§pggWO`i_§§nlWa"W"¯eWc |6cen~hlce§£hlpe|Hpe§peejÒencr|6Spr±°hlSW6W,hk)penl¤H

V(cQgWJd|ÀjÃce§¡§)nbWOceS6ce§W pggWa`ÃhbSWÒW"hkµpQnb¤¿cr6ÃhbSWÒ`~W"hpe±y§¡¤g`HW,hk)W"WaÀc6p¦Wcr}

¡hl`J{³mw\ `bW"§Wa,hbpen`a¹;Çi`b¡6¿hbS»` |6cen~hlce§_hbpQ|}pQ§¡pQejÂQnlce|SÓ)Åh`(|HpQ`l`b¡§WhbpFcr||§jFcÃ`bSpQn~hlWa`~h

|}c.hbS¿cr§epQnb¡hbS6V±²pQn,peVX|dhbpe|ghl¡V(cr§nlpedghlWa`±²nlpeV cpggWhbpcr¦j³nlWaceS}cr§WgWO`khl¡}c.hbpe=

hlSWJ6W,hk)penl¤ «Ya¬®©¹´ pehb»,WOcr§W nlWa`bd§Åh`hbS6crhhlSWJ`bSpenbhbWO`kh|}c.hbSÀpeghcrWa=±²nlpeV8hbSW|6crnbhb»cr§

hlpe|Hpe§peQj³jW"§»gWO¦j³hlSW(Rixw¶LVXWa`l`lcreWO`iS}c®¯eWhbSW `lcrVXW§¡WarhlS=cQ`[hbSW(`bSpenbhbWO`kh|6crhbSÁ±²nbpQV hbSW

±²d6§¡§Ôhlpe|Hpe§peQj

«

L¹

RTSWwhbpQ|}pQ§¡pQe»"cr§e¡g±²pQnbV(crhbpeWacQSpggWw»`£¯.ce§¡»±²penc_§¡VX¡hbWa|}Wanbpgpr±ghl¡VXWerce6Vd6`kh}W

nlW,±²nlWa`bSWOc.h§¡WOce`~h|HW"nl¡pgg»"ce§¡§j[hbpinlW"V(ce¡¯.ce§¡»Ô¹R£p¡VX|nlp.¯eWonlWacQhl¡¯QW"WO`b`Óhbpi6W,hk)penl¤[gj¦6ceVXa`"

cQg¡hbpe6ce§gRixw¶LVXWa`l`lcreWO`ÓV(c®jHWµQW"WanlcrhbWaÓ¹£v°fg|nbWOg±²pQnbV(c.hl¡pQ»`|dnleWa±²nbpQV&hbSW)hbpQ|}pQ§¡pQej

Qnlce|SÓ¹

PT \ WYX[ZVh`6b >cVQa WYX=Zb X=c X

z[¢¥g\ S6cQ` HW"W"hlSWÁ`bdgqkWOhJpe±W,fgS6ced6`khl¡¯QW`khld6gWa` hbSnlpedQS cr6ce§¡jg`b`a_`~Vd6§crhbpe6` ce6W,f¦¶

|HW"nlVWahl`aocr6¿hlSWJnlWa`bd§¡hb|nlprhlpg,pe§µ`§»crnleW"§j¿c³|nlp¦d6hpr±ype|HW"nc.hl¡pQ6cr§µW,fg|HW"nl¡Wa6,WO`cr}

nlWaÊdnlW"VXW"hl`a¹tuhlS»`y`~WOhl¡pQÓgµWpQdghb§¡6W`~pQVWpe±hlSWa`bWW,fg|}WanbW"},Wa`a¹

Ì " JÐ £ Ì"aÌ e ÄÐ"

º S6¡§WyhlSWce¡§¡hkjhlpnlpedghlWicrhlc_¡hbSc{´i·ivwR »`"¡}gW"WOÔhbSW|nbpenl¡hkjhce`b¤±²pQnµc{´i·yvµR

nlpedhbX|nbpehbpg,pQ§¸¦)W±²ped}JhlS6c.h_hlSWcr6¡§ÅhkjJhbpX.qkWa,hiW,f¦hbWanb}cr§ÔnlpedghlWa`TQhlphbSWW"hkµpQnb¤J)cQ`)c

|6nlcQhb»"ce§nlWaÊdnlW"VXW"ha¹{´·yvwRnbpQdghbÒ`[6cQ`~WO³pehbSWg±²penlV(c.hbpe=ceaÊQd6¡nlWahlSnlpedQSRix

VXWO`b`lcrQWa`)_S»SÓg¡|nl6,|§Wece¯eW"nbhb»`bWc§`~hypr±SpQ`~h~¶©nlpedghlWa`a¹

v°f¦hlW"nl6cr§nlpedghlWa`µpQd§³hkj|6acr§§¡j³HWWaÅhlSW"n`bWaÊdWa6,WO`ipe±wtum°¶ucegnlWa`l`bWa`ypQnc.hlW"Tc®j¦`yhbphbSW

_S6pe§W[tuhlW"nlW,hOgVXce¤¦¡(Rix VXWa`l`bceeWa`)VX|nlcQhlacr§H±²penyg»`~hbnl¡dhb `~d}Sg±²penlV(c.hl¡pQÓ¹

(11)

; 56NJ* )2 * ,

Çyhb§¡ "hbSW[W,fg»`khl¡eWaW"nlyVWOS6cr6`bV(`o±²pQn)g¡ÈDd6`~,pehlnbpQ§hbnc.Æ eQhlSW[nbWOÊQd6¡nlW"VXW"hwpe±

cTc®j pr±¡rqkWahl¡6(nbpQdghbWO`)hbp ,pQhbd6ped6`T`bWaÊdW"},Wa`Tpe±cQgnlWa`l`~WO`))cQ`_`bcrhb»`k¼6WO`bV|6§¡jJhbSnlpedQS

hbnlpggd6hl¡pQÃpr±ic³6W" hkj¦|}Wpr±yVXWa`l`lcreWQ¹³mprhbWahb»cr§§¡j=W"VX¡h~hbWOÂ§Wa`l`±²nlWaÊdWaQhl§¡jÁhbS}crÃhlSWRixw¶

VXWO`b`lcrQWa`awhlS`W,f¦hlW"6`b¡pQ )cQ`XhbS¦d6`Òcr6§¡W³hlpÃhlce¤eWgnlWahceg¯.ceQhcrQWÒpe±hbSWpe|ghl¡VX ac.hl¡pQ6` pe±

{mw\]C6p¦p¦¡}¹

" Ì

mwnlcQhb»"ce§gW,fg|HW"nl¡VXW"h`o`~S6p.µWOhlS6c.hwWa¯eWacepehbSWanb_»`bWy`khc.hb»TW"hkµpQnb¤ ,pQQhl¡¦dpQd6`pe|HW"nc.hl¡pQ

)ped6§F`~dgÈDW"n±²nlpeV hlnlce6`~W"hX§¡p`b`pr±nbpQdghbWO`hlpÁ|}crnbhl`pr±yhlSWW,hk)penl¤D¹Ãt©h()cQ`pQ6`~Wanb¯QWa¿hlS6c.h

hlSW "ced6`bW±²pQnhbS»`Tce`ÁhlSW±Äce,hhbS6crhhbSW(|HW"nl¡pgg»W"VX»`b`b¡pQÁpe±)"pehbnlpe§°VXWa`l`lcreWO`y±²nlpeV hbSW

6g¯¦d6cr§TpggWO`S}ceÂHWa"peVXW`~j¦6Snlpe6¡ aWa d º S6W"FcÁpggWÒnbWa|}pQn~h`c=S6ceeWJhbp=Åh`({³mw\T¶

`bW,h=¨² cÂsivw¢£¢z VXWO`b`lcrQWOª_WaVX`l`~pe pe±cÀRixw¶©VWO`b`lcrQWVXc®j HWÁ`b¡Vd§ÅhcrWaped6`b§jÀhlnbeQW"nlWa

cÃ`bW,hJpe±[Wa¡QS¦}pQnb¿pggWa`a¹ ¥¦d6S Rix VXWa`l`bceeWa`X)ped6§,pQ§¡§»gWc.h hlSWnlWa"W"¯¿pggWO`"

_S6W"nlW W"¡hbS6W"npr±ThbSWVXWa`l`bceeWa`µpQd§Â}WnbWO,W"¯eWO¨Äcr}Ã|}pehbWaQhlce§¡§j=prh±²penl)cenlgWO=¡hbphbSW

6W,hk)penl¤gª,¹Rixw¶LVXWa`l`lcreWO`icenbWW"VXÅhbhbWO|HW"nl¡pgg»"ce§¡§j¦j³pggWa`[_S»SW"f¦|HW"nlW"6"WpÒS6cr6eWa`ihbp

hlSW"nw{³mµ\ `~Wa§¡WOhbpQnw`bW,ha¹RTS¦d6`aedhb§6WQ¹}¹"§¡pg¤gnb¡±hoXhbSWy6p¦Wa`°d¶©`bj¦6Snlpe "W)hbS6WyW"VX»`b`b¡pQ

pe±µRixw¶©VWO`b`lcrQWa`aÔ,pe§§`b¡pQ¶ycr}§pQ`l`¶Tpe±whlpe|Hpe§peejg±²penlV(c.hl¡pQ)ped§»pg""dnO¹RTS»`"£¡ÁhbdnlÓ

)ped6§³acrd6`bWnbpQdghbWO`_hlp(hbVXWpedhcr6³`lcr||HWaceny±²nlpeV0|6crnbhl`ypr±°hbS6WW,hk)penl¤ ¶TgWa`b|¡hbW|S¦j¦`b»"cr§

"pe6Wahl¡¯¦¡hkje¹

v°fg|HW"nl¡VXWaQh` 6g»"crhbWa hlS6c.hW"g±²pQnl"¡qk¡h~hlW"n=¨ÄcÂ`bV(cr§§gWa§c®jQ)ncr}gpeVX§jÂ|»¤eWaF±²pQnJWacQS

|}ce¤eW"h±²nlpeV8hbSW¡hbWanb¯.ce§ µ`bWae¹ª pQÀ`~Wa6gpe±yWaceSÂ"pehbnlpe§µVXWa`l`bceeWa`nbWO`~d§¡hbWOÃ

±²WaµWani,pQhbnlpe§ÔVXWa`l`bceeW"pe§§¡»`~pe}`)¶)cr}S6W"6"W¡³VXpQnbW`~hlce§¡WnlpedhbWa`a¹ Oed6nbWXce6³`~S6p.y`ThbSW

¦dV}Wanopr±Ô|6cQ¤eW"hl`o`bW"haQnbWO,Wa¡¯QWaXcr6(nbpQ||}WOXgdWyhlpEk6pnbpQdghbWThlpSp`khGTXhbSW`bceVW`b"W"6cenbp

_¡hbS³ce6J_¡hbS6pedgh°qk¡h~hlW"nO¹

_¡hbSJqkÅhbhbWanW"g±²pQnl"WahlS6crÁ_ÅhlSpedghO¹RTSWnbWaV(cr¡6`bW"haÔdh6prhnbWO,W"¯eWOÔÔc.hc |6cQ¤eW"hl`[crnlW

nbpQ||}WO³V(cr§jdWhlp,pQ§¡§»`~pe6`aDgnbpQ|6`¡hbWan~±ÄcQ,WÊdWadWa`W,hr¹[tu|6cen~hl"d§cenbjÒ_SWad6`b¡

qk¡h~hlW"nO°µWJpe6`bW"nl¯eWhbS}c.hc§cenbQW crVXpedhpe±y|6ce¤QW,h`crnlW gnlpe||HWa¿±²pQnpehbSWannbWOce`bpe6`hbS6ce Ek6p

nlpedhbWhbpSpQ`~hG6_S6W"nlWace`y_ÅhlSpedghwqkÅhbhbW"nODcr§Vp`kh[cr§§gnlpe|6`icrnlWgdWhlpFE~p nlpedghlWhbp S6pQ`~hG¹TRTS6`

»`[c(6c.hldncr§,pe},WaÊdWa6,W1dµVXpQnbW|6ce¤QW,hl`y}Wa¡nbpQdghbWOcr§WVX|§¡Wa`[VXpenlW|6cQ¤eW"hl`y6`bW"nbhbWO¡hbp

hbWan~±ÄcQ,WyÊdW"d6Wa`wce6XVXpenlW_|6ce¤QW,h`hbS6crhµ"ce(}Wyhbncr6`bVXÅhbhbWaXpQXhbSWVXWag»c¹RTS»`o6,nlWacQ`~WO`hbSW

§¤eW"§j¦Sp¦pgJpe±,pQeWO`khl¡pQ6`Tcr6gnlpe|}`"¦HprhbS³ÊQd6W"dWO`_cr6ÒhlSWVXWag»c¹

OednlWcr6¼6ed6nbWÒ`bSp.&hlSW`b|}Wanl`bpepe±ohbS6W|6cQ¤eW"h[gnlpe|6`¨ÄdWhbpÒ§cQ¤Òpe±ohbpQ|}pQ§¡pQej

hlSW(g»`~|HW"n`~peÁ_ÅhlSÒqkÅhbhbW"n»``bVXce§¡§W"n[hlS6cr=_ÅhlSpedha¹(RTS»`VWOcr6`hlS6c.hhbS6W(|}Wan~±²pQnbV(cr},W_¡hbS

Wag±²pen,WOqk¡h~hlW"ny»`Tpehype§j HW,h~hlW"nOdghice§`bpXVXpenlW[`~hlce§¡WhlS6crÒ_¡hbSpQdgh°qkÅhbhbWana¹

(12)

0 5000 10000 15000 20000 25000 30000 35000 40000

Number of Packets

Sent Received No route drop

With jitter Without jitter

OednlW d ; 56KJ ! N0(, N : &(?1,* *, (&( J( Y BB ( 0((&( * N % 4

J) 0 )R ; 56 N0B f , L 1,*( o*o.* * <Q5 <Q5N,', &(( o%

6*oF*(*o .&( B) &(? *

_'o, $& ('µ*"+

z[¢¥g\F`°c[|nlpQcQhb¯eWµ|nlprhbpg"pe§L.VXce¡hcr¡6[g±²pQnbV(c.hl¡pQce}pQdgh°nbpQdghbWO`hbpcr§§gWa`~hb6crhbpe6`c.hoce§¡§

hl¡VXWO`"¹°RTSWi"pe6`bWaÊdWa6,W_pe±}hlS»`µce||nlpQceS»`hbS6crhwhlSWicrVXpQdhopr±Ó,pQQhlnbpQ§ghbnc.Æ T»`o6gWa|}Wa6gW"h

pe±hbSWcehld6cr§£hbnc.Æ ce6VXpe§¡¡hkj|6c.hbhbWanb6`i¡hbSW6W,hk)penl¤H¹y´icr§¡hbWanb}c.hb¯eWce||nlpQcQS»`yhlS6c.h

pe±nlWacQhl¡¯QW|nlprhlpg,pe§»`a¹DMTcQ`~»"ce§¡§jegcXnlWace,hb¯eW[|nlprhbpg"pe§ÔnlWace,hl`µhbpXhlSWhbnc.Æ [hbSWW"hkµpQnb¤Dgcr}

"pe6`~hbnld6,hl`)nbpQdghbWO`T_SW"WaWagWO¶wcr6pe§j(hlpXhbSp`~WpggWO`)hbp(_S»SÒcXnlpedhbW[`_6W"WaWaÔ¹

RTSW[,pQVVXpQ(W"§W"VXW"hµ nlWacQhb¯eWi|nbpehbpg,pQ§`o`whbSWVXWaS6ce`bV d6`~WOX±²pen)g»`b"p.¯eW"nlnbpQdghbWO`"¹

RTS6W`~pQdnl"W6p¦WW"VXÅh`ycXnlWaÊdWa`~h_VXWa`l`bceeWegnlWaÊdWO`khl¡6XcnlpedghlW[hbpXhbS6WgWa`~hb6c.hl¡pQpggWe¹wRTS6`

VXWO`b`lcrQWi»`>C}ppggWOÔgL¹WQ¹°nbWa§c®jQWaX¦jJcr§§DpggWa`)JhlSWW,hk)penl¤DQd6Qhl¡§Ô¡h_nbWOceSWO`ohlSWgWa`~hb6crhbpeÓ¹

RTS6W|6crhbS³±²pQ§¡§p.µWO¦jhlSWnlWaÊdWO`kh[VXWa`l`bceeW»`inlWa"pengWa³hbS6WVXWa`l`lcreWQ}ce6³nlW,hbd6nbWOhbpJhbSW

`bW"}gW"n_¦j(hlSWgWa`~hb6crhbpeÓgpQn_jJ¡hbWanbVXWOgcrhbWpggWO`T_ÅhlS³`~dgÆ "¡WaQh_hlpe|Hpe§peQacr§D¡±²penlVXcrhbpeÓ

¿cJnlW"|§j³VXWa`l`bceeWQ¹RTSd}`Vd§¡hb|§¡WXnlW"|§j³VXWa`l`bceeWO`yV(c®j³nbWO`~d6§ÅhOÔjW"§»gÒVd§¡hb|§W|}c.hbS}`[¶Tpe±

_S6ShbSW`bSpQn~hlWa`~hT»`)hbp(HWd6`bWaÔ¹

tuÒhbS6`y`bWa,hbpeÓ6µWhbnlp¦d6,W[hk)pnlWacQhl¡¯QW|nlprhlpg,pe§»`a´iz[½_¾cr6Ò½¥g\6_¡hbSÒhlSW|dnl|HpQ`bW

pe±|nlp.¯¦¡Xc(,pQhbW,f¦h_Ò_S6SÒµWacrÒW"¯.cr§d6c.hlW[hbSWS6cenlcQhlW"nl`~hb»"`)pr±oz[¢¥g\¹

(13)

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16

Number of tests

Number of packets in lost due to route unavailability in thousands

2−4 4−6 6−8 8−10 10−12 12−14 18−20 26−28 28−30 30−32 32−34 34−36 With jitter

Without jitter

OednlW6d

; 56N0(, YY,*(* *( & N0B . &(? * )2J*o Y %. )H4

10,)H ; 56F 0( Y 61&B?1 *F Y*5<>( , o)+*F 5 * J*

PTS \

tuÂhbSW´_Âsypg³zg¶u½iWaVXce6Â½`~hlce6,W¾°Wa,hbpen|nlprhlp¦"pe§[¨Ä´iz[½_¾ª_SW"Fc`bpedn,W nlWaÊdnlWa`c

|}c.hbShlp hlSWgWO`khl¡}c.hbpe£Hc

B B ,*(

VWO`b`lcrQW`C6p¦pggWa³hlSWW"hkµpQnb¤D¹_Çy|HpenbWO,W"¯¦¡6

`bd6SciVXWa`l`lcreWQ.cipggWTW"fgceVX¡WO`Åh`§pg"ce§nlpedhbW,¶u"cQSWohlp[S6Wa¤¡±Hci±²nbWO`~SnbpQdghbWµhbphbSWTnlWaÊdnbWO

g±²pQnbV(c.hl¡pQFce}pQdghhlSWnbpQdghbWQ¹ zihbS6W"nl_`bWe°hlSW K o*o `XnlW,hlnlce6`bV¡h~hlWaÀd6`~¿c|6dnbW

C}ppggVWOS6cr6`bV _ÅhlSÁ§pg"cr§gd|6§¡»"crhbWW"§¡VX6c.hl¡pQÓ¹´i`crÁpe|ghl¡VX ac.hl¡pQÓÔ´iz[½_¾ W"VX|§p.j¦`

B% )R VWO`b`lcrQWX`nbWO,W"¯eWO_¡hbS6¡Âc³"W"nbhlcr=hbVXWehbSWJVWO`b`lcrQWX`»`l`~dWO¿crQce¡¿_¡hbSÂc§»crnleWan

acrÒ}WWO`khcr§»`~SWOÔ¦hbS6W|6ce¤QW,hl`TcenbWgnlpe||HWaÓ¹

º SWa c§¡¤`oW,hbWOhlWahbpHWynlpe¤QW"¨ÄW"¡hbSWanohlSnbpQdeSXcWa¡QSHpeno`l,p.¯QW"nlj[|6nbpehbpg,pQ§¸ecQ`°

z[¢¥g\penwhbSnlpedQSJc§¤¶L§»c®jeWanoprhlÅ¼H"c.hl¡pQ}ªhlSW[W,hbWOhl¡pggW[`l`~d6Wa`wc . o VXWO`b`lcrQW

hlphlSpQ`bW[W"eS¦Hpen`w_SpXS6c®¯QWiHW"Wad6`bcnlpedghlWp.¯QW"nµhbSWp. nlpe¤QW"§¡¤D¹°RTSWa`bW6p¦Wa`T_§¡§

hlSW"S6c®¯QWihlp(`l`bdWW"

. B ,*(*

hbp(nlW"|}crnµhlSWnlpe¤QW"JnlpedhbWa`a¹

(14)

0 2 4 6 8 10 12

Number of tests

Number of received packets in thousands

0−2 2−4 4−6 6−8 8−10 10−12 12−14 14−16 16−18 18−20 With jitter Without jitter

OednlWd

; 56# 0( F %,*o*F*#8( & . 0( F P61&B?1,* (&( J(/; 5#N0B F

&(?1,* .*56<>( % oJ)+*Y56 * *

PT

RTS6WJ½ij¦6ceVXJ¥gpedn,W \_pQdghb|6nbpehbpg,pQ§oW"VX|§p.jg`hbSWÒ`bceVXW(6ce`b VWOS6cr6`bV8pe±_peg¶ugW"V(ce6

C}ppggc

B ,*(

cr6Ãc®Tcr¡hbhlS6c.hhbSWÒgWa`~hb6c.hl¡pQÃpggWepQncrÃhbWanbVXWacrhbW pggW

_¡hbS¯QW"nlÅ¼6WOJ¯.ce§¡»Jg±²pQnbV(c.hl¡pQÓgnlW"|§¡WO`T_ÅhlS³c

BY )R

¹

½¥g\WaVX|§¡p.jg`y`bped6nl"WnbpQdghb}6HprhbSÁce`ic )c®jpr±opehlcr §p¦pe|±²nlW"WapeV cr6cQ`yc Tc®jJpe±

Eb`bS6crnl¡6GcypggWa`£nbpQdghbWoaceSW°_¡hbSpehbSWan£pggWO`ÔhbSWwW,hk)penl¤ dÓ`~6,WwWaceScrhlc_|}ce¤eW"h£,pQQhcr

nlpedhbg±²pQnbV(c.hl¡pQÓ.pggWO`ce§¡pQ[Åh`|6c.hlSÓece`)W"§§gce`pggWa`_S6Sp.¯eWanbSWOcrnÔhlSWThbncr}`~VX»`b`b¡pQ6`a

V(c®jJ"pe§§¡WOhycr}aceSW[hbS6WnbpQdghbWg±²penlV(c.hbpe±²pen_§»c.hlW"n_d6`bWe¹

\_pQdghbW=V(crhbW"}cr6"WÁ»`Ò6ce`bWa pQ;WOceS SpQ|;nlWa"W"¯ cr cQ¤¦p._§¡WOgeVXWaQhJ±²pencÀ|6cQ¤eW"h

hlS¦d6`_gW,hlWa,hl`_cnlpe¤eWa nlpedghlWec o »`µnlW,hldnlWaJhbphbS6W`bped6nl"We¹°Çy|HpeÒnbWO,Wa¡¯¦c %

c®¯.ce¡§»cr§Weg¡hV(c®j}Wd}`~WOJ±²pQnynlW"V(cr c.hchbp(hlSWgWO`khl¡}c.hbpeÒ¶Tcr§¡hbW"nl6crhb¯eW"§je}cXW"&nlpedghlW

`l,p.¯QW"nlj»`_¡hb»c.hbWOÔ¹

¢£¡¤QW´iz[½_¾½¥g\dgÈDW"n`tum>|6ce¤QW,hl`¡ÂhbSW`~pQdn,W pggWÒ_S§¡WnbpQdghbWÒg»`b"p.¯eW"nlj»`|}Wan~¶

±²pQnbVXWOÔ¹

(15)

X')_!Ò "+

º=WX,pe}gd6hped6n`bVd§»c.hl¡pQ6`id}`~hbSWW,hk)penl¤³`~Vd6§crhbpen[6`

«

`bVd§»c.hl¡[hlSWyHW"S6c®¯¦penpr±Dtuvovov

Q¹¡YQY

«

,Hce`°6,§d6gWO_ÅhlS(6`l6d£WOceSpggW_S6ce`wcnce¡pncrQW

pe±TQrVW"hbWana_SW"¿ppe}`khce,§Wa`cenbW|nlWa`bW"hacr6=cÒpeVX6cr§°6ce6g_»¦hbS¿pe±TÒ{³¡hÉr`"¹ RTSW

{´ix `lSW"VXW`icrÒ¡VX|§W"VXW"hc.hbpepe±£hbS}c.hi`b|}WO,¡¼6WaÒ¦j tuvovov

Q¹¡YQYe¹

RTSWi|dnl|}p`~Wype±Ôpednw`bVd§»c.hl¡pQ6`°»`°hbpd66,p.¯QW"no(_S»S `~¡hbd6crhbpe6`°hbSWy6g¯¦d6cr§}|nbpehbpg,pQ§`

S}c®¯eWhlSW"n³`khlnbWarhlS6`cr6;µWOcr¤¦WO`b`bWa`aync.hbS6W"nhbS6ce;hlpF|nlpeVXpehbW=peW=|nlprhbpg"pe§ce`ÒeWaW"ncr§§¡j

E~HW,h~hlW"nGhbS}crÁhbSW(pehbSWanl`a¹RTS¦d6`aÓÁpQnlgWan[hbpc®¯epe»QW,hbhbnlWa`bd§¡hl`_S»SÁ±Äc®¯epen[W"¡hbS6W"npr±µhbSW

|6nbpehbpg,pQ§`a°µWÒcr||6§¡jÂc=`khlnlcrhbWaej=pr±[`b|HWa,¡±²j¦¡6=cÁ`~W"hpe±i|6crncrVXW"hbW"n`Ò¨²¦dVHW"nXpe±ipggWa`aopggW

VXpQ¡§¡hkjeÔhlnlcrÆ(S6cenlcQhbWanb»`~hb»"`W,hlOªÔ±²nlpeV _SS¿c§cenbQW¦dV}Wan[pe±)`l,Wa6crnl¡p`cenbWncr6gpQVX§¡j

QW"WanlcrhbWOÔ¹RTS6Wa`bW`b"W"6cenbpQ`µ_¡§§ÓHWg¡ÈHWanbWaQhOjeW"h_S6c®¯eWhbSW`lcrVXWp.¯eWanlce§¡§ÔS6cenlcQhlW"nl`~hb»"`a¹

º=W6ce`bWcr§§Ôpedny`l,Wa6crnlpQ`)pehbSW±²pQ§¡§p._X6ce`b|6cenlceVW"hbWanl`Ld

rpggWO`

YaQefYaQe[¼6Wa§

ee`bWa"pe6`_`bVd§»c.hl¡pQJhl¡VXW

e(x$MT\&`khlnbWOcrV(`"g6¹¡Y`bWar¹|6cQ¤eW"hThbWanb¯.cr§L6er¦jhbWa`É®|}ce¤eW"haDYaX`bWa`~hbnlWacrVgdnc.hbpe

Çi§¡WO`b`TpehbSWanb_»`bW`~hlc.hlWa_SW"ÒgWa`l,nl¡6hlSW`~Vd§»c.hl¡pQJnlWa`bd§¡hl`aQhlSW`~Vd6§crhbpe6`)crnlW["peg¶

d6hlWaÒ_ÅhlS³`b"W"6cenbpQ`),pQg±²penlVX¡hlphlSWcrHp.¯eW[|6cenlceVW"hbWanl`a¹

vwcQS`bceVX|§¡W|}pQ¡ha}nbWa|nlWa`bW"hbWOhbS6W`b¡Vd§crhbpenlWa`bd§Åh`y`~WOhl¡pQ`yhbSWVWOcrhcr¤eWa

p.¯QW"nyQÅÈDW"nlW"h`l,Wa6crnl¡p`""peg±²pQnbVXhbp(hlSW`lcrVXW|6cenlceVW"hbWany`~W"ha¹wº=WWaV|6S6ce`b¡ aWe6hbS6crhyhbSW

`bW,hype±QX`b"W"6cenbpQ`)|HW"ni`lcrVX|§W|}pQ¡hicenbW[hbS6W`bceVW±²pQnycr§§ÔhbS6WhbSnlW"WhlWa`~hbWaÒ|nlprhlpg,pe§»`a¹°t¹WQ¹°±²pen

cQ¡¯QW"`bceV|6§¡W|HpeQhOghbS6WWaceSpr±hbSW|6nbpehbpg,pQ§`TcrnlWhbWa`~hbWOÒ_ÅhlShlSW`lcrVXWeX`b"W"6cenbpQ`a¹

Xa *",! _+£Ò*+

¥g¡Vd§crhbpe6`ÓS6c®¯eWHW"W""pe6d6hlWa[_ÅhlS¯.crnljTVXpe§Åhkj[cr6¯.crnlj¦¡6)¦dV}WanÓpr±hbnc.Æ °`~hbnlWaceVX`

hlpiW"fgceVX¡WwhbSW)|nlprhlp¦"pe§»`Ôg¡ÈHWanbWah,pQhbW"h`"¹°xµpeVX|6crnl»`~pQ6`ÔS6c®¯QWo}WaW"gpeWµpehlSWµ±²pe§§¡p._d

|}ce¤eW"hXW"§¡¯QW"nlj=nc.hlWe),pehlnbpQ§whlnlcrÆ(p.¯eWanbS6WaceÓ°nbpQdghbWÒ§¡WarhlSÓTcr6À|}Wan~±²pQnbV(cr},WÒd6gWanXRixµm

hlnlcrÆ r¹

PTS UKV >X ` X=ab>X=Z V `X VDc UKV X ` X=aV

RTS6W|nlVW|nlpe|HW"nbhkjÒ±²pencJnlpedhbJ|nlprhlpg,pe§»`[hbpÒ|nbp.¯¦»gWnlpedhbWa`HW,hk)W"W"=`~pQdn,Wa`[cr}gWO`khlÅ¶

}c.hbpe}`"¹_RTS¦d6`_pQWVXWacQ`~dnlWpr±o`bd6""Wa`l`T±²pen[c(nlpedghl¡(|6nbpehbpg,pQ§Ó`yhbSW±²nlcQhbpe³pe±oc.hcX|6ce¤QW,hl`

HW"(`bd6""Wa`l`k±²d§§jJgW"§¯eW"nlWaJhbpXhlSWgWO`khl¡6crhbpe6`a¹