• Aucun résultat trouvé

Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information"

Copied!
25
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00070579

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00070579

Submitted on 19 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub-

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,

Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information

Miklos Molnar, János Levendovszky, Patrice Leguesdron, Csaba Végsö

To cite this version:

Miklos Molnar, János Levendovszky, Patrice Leguesdron, Csaba Végsö. Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information. [Research Report] RR-5428, INRIA. 2004, pp.21. �inria- 00070579�

(2)

ISRN INRIA/RR--5428--FR+ENG

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Multicast routing with QoS based on incomplete link state information

Csaba Végsö, Miklós Molnár, János Levendovszky, Patrice Leguesdron

N˚5428

Décembre 2004

Systèmes communicants

(3)
(4)

/0%12345*0

687:9<;59>=?A@B7DC/EAFHGJILKNMLOB7PGJQBMLR5SUTWVWFHXBSURYQB7PZ'[]\U[ARY^Q_\N7D`AK/abAFdce9<fWTWILgA[hZ'[A@BiY[]7W^YTDQBRdj

kmlonqpsrt!uDn'vwxt!ty_z|{}vD~zApsn

€d w‚qup„ƒ†…„‡‰ˆe…

…„~Š_ŠUw  p„‹ou  uDvŒ_u  vŒ_uzŽ]3‘m’“‰”–•†—Dvut˜  u’x™x™‘”–’oš0Š|~x›xuWn

œPžDŸ 3¡_¢xŸx£¥¤ Œ_{¦nHŠ|~xŠ<u



{¦nHvwxz|vu



z_uD‹8§'{¨p©ŒP‹ouDªxuD«¨w]Š_{¨z|›4z_w3ªxuD«<~«}›xw



{¨p©Œ|t!n5¬­w



ty_«¨p©{¦v~xn®p



wxyops{¨z|›

{}z¯Š|~]v°xupn©§'{¨psvŒ_uW‹¯vwxt!ty_z_{¦v~3ps{¨w]z¯z_upq§w  °on0§'Œ_uz±psŒ_u  u{¦nz_w‰~:ª:~x{¨«¦~˜|«¨u²u³o~]v´p{}zo¬­w  t²~3ps{¨w]z

~x˜<w]yop5p©Œ|u'«¨{}z_°n®ps~p©uWnY{¨z8p©Œ|u'z_upq§w  °BµN¶·z8p©Œ_uWn®u„vD~xn©uDnYŠ  wx˜<~˜_{}«¨{¦n®p©{¦v¸t!wo‹ouD«}n5vD~z!˜<u'y<n®uW‹8~xz|‹p©Œ_u

›]w]~x«Awx¬|psŒ_u  w]yop©u'n©u«}uDvp©{}wxz8Š  wovuD‹oy  u{}nYpswe¹|z|‹!~z!~x‹ot!{¦n©n©{}˜_«¨u  wxyopsuº§'{»psŒ8t²~³m{}t²~«oŠ  wx˜<~˜_{}«¨{¨pqlxµ

¤ Œ|u¼ty|«»ps{}vD~xn®pŠ  wx˜<~˜_{}«¨{¦n®p©{¦v w]yop©{}z_›t8wo‹ouD«B§'{»psŒ˜|~z<‹o§'{}‹op©Œ~xz|‹Pvw]n®p  uD½Ay_{ uDt!uzApH{}zp©Œ|uevD~xn©u

wx¬{¨z<vwxt!Š_«}upsu¼{}zo¬­w  t²~3ps{¨w]z{}n  uD‹oy|vuD‹8psw~‹_up©u  t!{}z_{¦nqps{}vekAp©uD{¨z_u  p uu„Š  wx˜|«¨uDtµ ¤ Œ_u†ty_«¨p©{¦v~]nqp

 wxy_p©{}z_›vwxz|vu  z_{}z_›psŒ_u!uz|‹m¾¿p©wx¾¿uDz|‹h‹_u«¦~:l  uW½]y|{ ut!uzAp0v~z‰˜<u8p  ~xz|nq¬­w  t!uW‹À{}zÁn©wxt!u!v~xn©uDn¼p©w

¹<z|‹o{}z_›Ân®Œ_w psuDn®p4Š|~3psŒ|n4˜Uupq§uuz‰p©Œ|u²ty_«¨p©{¦v~]nqp4z_wo‹ouWn4˜|~xn©uD‹‰wxzÁuD½Ay_{}ª3~«}uzAp‹oupsu  t!{¨z_{¦n®p©{¦v!«¨{}z_°

t!uW~xn©y  uWnµ

ÃÂÄAÅBÆsÇÈ  3ɞx£ËÊ upq§w  °BÌoty_«¨p©{¦v~]nqp  wxyops{¨z_›<Ì<͆y|~«}{¨pqlw¬5kmu  ªm{}vuxÌ|kApsu{}z_u  Š  w]˜_«¨uDt

ΦÏ/ЩÑÓÒDÔºÐ'ÕÖ}ÑÓ׿ØÙ

ÚÛ:ÜÞÝmß/à´áãâßäÝoÝLå:æ:æà´áãçLèqéêëYçLÛ:èBÝ¿ìqÜÞèqíç¿Üî3ì<ìqàïðà´æè®áLäsçLÜÞà´íæ:áãàñãè®ì·çòqó/äôõäsçLà´ímòBêè·çðß/èqèqí¸ö­÷öãøDùP÷Nèqí:íWè®Ý®úû3áLäí:ìqè

äí:é†çLÛ:èdüèqæ3äá­ç¿ý'èqíçàþ|ÚoèqôÞèqìqà´ý'ýå:í:ÜÞì®äsçLÜÞà´íAú3óBåWé3äæè®ÝãçYÿNí:ÜèqáLÝLÜçðë¼àþ_Úoè®ì¿Û:í:à´ôÞàë4äíWé<ìqà´í:à´ý'ÜÞìqÝ®úåWíäáãë

óBå:é3äæèqÝLçÿí:ÜèqáãÝ¿Üçðë†àþ_Úoè®ì¿Û:í:à´ôÞàëeäí:é <ìqà´í:à´ý'ÜÞìqÝ®ú5øøÛ:ÜçÛ:Üçê:ý'èÛDå

öYøDùÀïUö­÷öãøDùHú0ÜÞâDôÞà´Ý0à´ôÞí3äáÜÞáLÜÞÝ¿äþ}á

óBå:é3äæèqÝLçÿí:ÜèqáãÝ¿Üçðë†àþ_Úoè®ì¿Û:í:à´ôÞàëeäí:é <ìqà´í:à´ý'ÜÞìqÝ®úWôÞèèqí:é:àÛ:Üçê:ý'èÛå

öYøDùNïðö­÷0ù÷dú _äsç¿áãÜÞìqè!"Aè´åWè®ÝLé:áãà´íÜÞí:ÝÓäsï¦áLèqí:í:èqÝþ}á

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes

(5)

*,+$%'&%' %'

ž £ •†~xz|n4vup4~  ps{}v«¨u]Ì/z_wxy<n4‹o—ª]u«}wxŠ_ŠUwxz|n0‹ou!z_w]y_ªxuW~yo³À~x«¨›]w  {»psŒ_t!uDneŠ<w]y  «}u  wxy_ps~›]u

ty_«¨p©{¦v~xn®p4‹_~z|n0«}uDn  —Dn©uD~xyo³À‹ou²vw]t8ty_z_{¦v~p©{}wxzµ € «¨y<n0Š  —Wv{¦n®uDt!t8uDzApDÌ/z_w]y|n0Š  wxŠUw]n©wxz|ne‹ouDn4~x«»¾

›]w  {»psŒ_t!uDn†Š<w]y  «}uDn4v~]newh«}uDn0{}zo¬­w  t²~3ps{¨w]z|nen®y  «—ps~p‹ouDne«}{¨uDz|n0z_u²n®w]zApeŠ|~]ne¹<~˜|«¨uWnµ € w]y  «¨u

Š w]˜_«¨rDt!u‹oy  w]yops~x›xuty_«»ps{}vD~xn®pe~:ª]uDvvwxzAp ~{}zAp©u‹_u˜|~xz|‹ouŠ|~xnsn©~xzAp©uw]yh‹y_z‰vwop0›x—Dz_—  ~«}{¦n®—]Ì

z|wxy|n0Š  wxŠUw]n©wxz<n¼«¦~p  ~z|n®¬­w  t²~3p©{}wxzÁ‹oyÁŠ  w]˜_«}rt!u!«¨w  ns½Ay_u«{¨zo¬­w  t²~p©{}wxzÁuDn®p0{}z|vwxt!Š_«}rp©u!uDzÁy|z

Š w]˜_«¨rDt!u!‹_uPkAp©uD{¨z_u  ‹o—psu  t!{¨z_{¦n®p©u²—D½Ay_{}ª3~«}uzApDµNw  n©½Ay_u8«¦~h͆wAk‰‹ou²«}~$vwxt!ty_z|{}vD~3p©{}wxzÁty|«»ps{»¾

vD~xn®puWnqp„‹ow]z_z_—Duen©wxy|n«¦~¬­w  t8u0‹y_z_u0«}{¨t!{¨ps~3ps{¨w]z‹_y‹o—D«}~x{‹ou0˜<w]yop'uz˜<w]yopDÌoz|wxy|nºŠ  wxŠUw]n©wxz<n¸‹ou

p  ~xz|n®¬­w  t8u  «}u4Š  wx˜_«}rt!ueuz$y_zŠ  wx˜_«}rt!u4n®{}t!{¨«¦~{ u†yops{¨«}{¦n©~xz]p¼‹_uDnºª3~«}uy  nº‹o—psu  t!{¨z_{¦n®p©uDn'n©y  «}uDn

«}{}uz|nDµ

Ê

w]y|nºuz‹ow]z_z_wxz<n¸y|zA§ n©wx«}yop©{}wxz$~Š_Š



wovŒ_—Du†ŠUwxy



«}u



wxyop~›xu]µ

È ŸWž Æ ¢ £ …„—Dn©uD~y_³BÌ  wxy_ps~›]u†ty_«¨p©{¦v~xn®pDÌ_½Ay|~x«¨{¨p©—‹_u0n©u  ªm{}vuxÌoŠ  wx˜|«¨rDt8u4‹oukApsu{}z_u 

(6)

; <

NY²& H

¶·z  w]yop©{}z_›t!up©Œ|wm‹|nÌ/§'Œ_uDzÁ~vw]z_z_uWv´p©{}wxz‰~«}«¨wov~p©{}wxz  uD½Ay_uWnqp0{¦n†Š  uWn®uDz]psuD‹/Ì~Š|~p©Œ‰n©u«}uDvp©{}wxz‰{}n

u³ouDvy_p©uD‹Pp©w8¹|z<‹~xz~]‹ot!{}nsn®{}˜_«}u>=ãw  psŒ_u0˜<up®p©u ? Š<~3p©Œw  p  uDu¼¬ wxt~xt!wxz_›p©Œ_u4~:ª3~{}«¦~˜_«}u  wxy_p©uDn

psŒ|~3pPns~3ps{}n®¹|uWnpsŒ_u  uD½Ay_uDn®pDµ •†{A@Bu  uzAp  wxyops{¨z|›±n®p  ~3psu›]{¨uWn8vD~z ˜<uÀ~xŠ_Š_«}{¨uW‹>{}z w  ‹ou  psw±ns~3ps{}n®¬­l

psŒ_u  uD½Ay_uDn®p©uW‹ vwxz|‹_{»ps{¨w]z|n8w¬ep©Œ_u‰Í†wmk>~:§º~  uvwxt!ty_z|{}vD~3p©{}wxz<nµ ͆wAk ›xwA~«¦n8vD~z ˜<uÀ~]vŒ_{}uªxuW‹

§'{¨p©Œ p©Œ_uŒ|u«}Š w¬º¹_³ouD‹±w  ‹olmz|~xt!{}v  wxy_p©{}z_›Ànqp  ~p©uD›x{}uDnDµ¶·z¯psŒ_uvD~xn©u²w¬„‹olmz|~xt8{¦v  wxyops{¨z|›Âp©Œ_u

 wxy_p©{}z_›$Š  wovuD‹oy  u=­t²~{}z_«}lÀpsŒ_u  w]yop©{}z_›ps~x˜_«}u ? {¦n  uDªm{}n©uD‹/µ…„wxyops{¨z_›p~˜_«}uDnvD~z±˜Uu~«¨p©u  uD‹Á~3p

~¹_³ouD‹ÂŠUwx{}zAp†{}zÀps{¨t!uw  ~]vvw  ‹o{¨z|›!p©wpsŒ_u!nqp~3p©uw¬5psŒ_uz|upq§w  °Uµ¼¶·zhvu  p~{}zh‹olmz|~t!{¦v  wxyops{¨z|›

n©wx«}yops{¨w]z|nNn©wxt!u5uª]uzApsnN{¨t!Š_«}{¦v~3psudpsŒ_uHt!wo‹o{¨¹<v~p©{}wxz4w¬  wxy_p©{}z_›ºps~x˜_«¨uWnN~xz|‹n©w'p©Œ_u  w]yop©{}z_›'˜UuDvwxt!uDn

uDªxuDz]p4‹ouDŠ<uDz|‹ouzApWµ

¤

Œ_u!y|n®uW‹



wxy_p©{}z_›Pp~˜_«}uDn4vD~zÁ˜<u!Š



u¾ÓŠ_«¦~z_z|uD‹‰§'{»psŒhpsŒ_u²Œ_u«}ŠÁw¬~xz‰wB@<¾Ó«}{¨z_u

vwxt!Š_yop~3ps{¨w]zÁw

 Š  uŠ|~



uW‹‰w]z¯‹out²~z<‹‰§'Œ|uz vŒ|~xz_›xuWn4~



u8z|uuD‹_uD‹/µ

¤

Œ_uvw]t!Š_yops~p©{}wxz¯v~xz¯˜<u

vuzAp



~«}{DCuD‹w



‹o{¦n®p



{¨˜_y_p©uD‹"E}š‘'F¿µ5¶·zÂ~zmlPvD~xn©uep©Œ_u



wxyopsu4vwxt!Š_y_ps~3ps{¨w]z=ðp©Œ|u4Š|~3psŒHGWp



uDu0n©u«}uDvp©{}wxz

?



uD½Ay_{



uDnu7Iv{}uzAp„Š|~p©Œw

 p 

uDu0vwxt!Š_yop~3ps{¨w]z~x«¨›]w



{»psŒ_t²nµ

¤ w¯Š<u



¬­w

 t 

w]yop©{}z_›¯§'Œ_{¦vŒ v~xz



uW~«}«¨l ˜UuhvD~«}«¨uW‹ ͆wmk



w]yop©{}z_›|̸p©Œ|uÀu³_~xvpª3~«}y_uDn²wx¬4«¨{}z_°

‹_uDnsv  {¨Šopsw  nJ=L~:ª3~{}«}~x˜_«¨u˜|~z<‹o§'{}‹op©ŒÌN‹_u«¦~:lxÌA‚q{»p©p©u  Ìupsvxµ? n©Œ_w]y_«}‹h˜<u8°mz_w3§'z‰~p†psŒ_u!Š  wxŠUu  z_wo‹ouDn

§'Œ|u  u5p©Œ_u  wxyopsuHn®uD«¨uWv´ps{¨w]zn®Œ|wxy_«¦‹4˜Uud¬­y_«¨¹|«}«¨uW‹{}zp©Œ|uHz_upq§¸w °e§'Œ_{}«¨uv~«¦vy|«}~p©{}z_›  wxyopsuDnDµLK„z_¬­w  p©yo¾

z<~3p©uD«¨l]ÌxpsŒ_{¦n¸{¦n¸z_wp'~ŠUw]nsn®{}˜_«}u¼§º~:lw  {}›x{}z|~p©uD‹8¬ wxt psŒ_u  uD½Ay_{ uD‹²~t!w]y_zAp¸w¬NvD~Š|~]v{¨pql8n©Œ_w]y_«}‹P˜<u

y<n®uW‹psw!‹_{}n®p {¨˜|yop©uep©Œ|uDn©u4u³_~xvpª3~«}y_uWnº{¨zp©Œ|uez|upq§w  °Uµ ¤ w!~:ª]wx{¦‹y|n©{}z_›8p©Œ_u4n©{¨›]z_{»¹Uv~zApº¬ ~xv´ps{¨w]z

wx¬'z_upq§w  °hv~xŠ|~xv{»pqlh¬­w  p  ~z|n©t!{»p©p©{}z_›À«}{¨z_°±n®ps~3psu{}zo¬­w  t²~3p©{}wxzNÌNpsŒ_uPª3~«}y_uWn4w¬'«}{¨z_°¯‹ouWn©v  {}Šopsw  n

vD~zÀ˜Uu!~x‹oª]u  p©{¦n®uW‹$Š<u  {}wo‹o{}vD~«}«¨l$w  w]z_«¨lÂ~p¼p©Œ|ups{¨t!u8{¨z|n®ps~xzApsn†§'Œ_uz‰Š  uW‹ou¹<z_uD‹$psŒ  uDn©Œ_wx«¦‹_ne~  u

u³_vuuW‹ouD‹µ5¶·zpsŒ_{¦n'§~:l!psŒ_u  wxyops{¨z|›!~x«¨›]w  {»psŒ_t²nºv~z$n©u«}uDv´p  wxy_p©uDnº˜<~xn©uD‹wxzp©Œ_u4«¦~xn®p„~x‹oª]u  p©{¦n®uW‹

ª3~x«¨y_uWnw¬N«}{¨z|°‹ouDnsv  {¨Š_p©w  n~z|‹v~zwx˜op~{}zn©wx«}yop©{}wxz<n¸§'Œ|{}vŒv~z˜<u0½Ay_{¨p©u4‹o{.@Uu uDz]p¬ wxt p©Œ|u0n©w¾

«}yops{¨w]z|n¸vwxy_«¦‹²˜Uu¼¬­w]y_z|‹²°mz_w3§'{}z_›4psŒ_ueu³_~xvpHª3~«}y_uDnDµdkmw|Ì]p©Œ_u



wxyops{¨z_›t8up©Œ_wo‹_nºvD~zw]z_«¨l8§w



°w]z

M{¨z<vwxt!Š_«}upsu'{¨z_¬­w



t!~p©{}wxzNMº~xz|‹!v~xz!¹|z|‹!wxz|«¨l8n®y_˜_¾¿w]Šop©{}t²~«



wxyopsuDnY¬­w

PO w3§„n



uD½Ay_{



{¨z_›Í†wmkBµ

¤

Œ_u

n©{}t8Š|«¨uWnqp0§~:lpswvD~«¦vy_«¦~3psun©y_˜o¾ÓwxŠops{¨t²~«



wxyopsuDn†{}n0n©{¨t!Š_«}lÂu³ouWvyops{¨z_›p



~x‹_{»ps{¨w]z|~«t!up©Œ|wm‹|n>=ãuxµ›|µ

•†{‚q°mn®p



~w

RQ

u«}«}t!~xz_zo¾3S_w



‹~x«¨›]w



{»psŒ_t²n5psw¹|z|‹n®Œ|w



p©uDn®pHŠ|~p©Œ|nDÌT¼w]yw

 ¤ ~x°3~Œ|~]n®Œ_{¨¾·‡À~3pn®y_lA~t²~

~x«¨›]w



{»psŒ_t²n0EސoÌVU'F5p©w¹|z|‹‰Š|~



p©{¦~«5n©Š|~z_z|{¨z_›p



uuWn

?

w]zÀp©Œ|u8«¦~xn®p4~x‹oª]u



p©{¦n®uW‹À«}{¨z_°hª:~x«¨y|uDnDµ ¤ Œ_{¦n0{}n

psŒ_u4t²~z_z|u  Œ_w3§ p©Œ_uvy © uzAps«¨l²y|n©uD‹  wxyops{¨z|›Š  wpswovwx«¦nºv~xz§w  °E: Ì_‘FÓµ

¤ Œ_uu7@BuDvp©{}ªxuz|uDnsn¼v~xz˜<u{¨z|v  uW~xn©uD‹˜ml$y|n®{}z_›²psŒ_u°mz_w3§'«}uD‹o›]u~˜Uwxyop†p©Œ_ut8uWvŒ|~z|{}n©t wx¬5p©Œ_u

~]‹oªxu  ps{}n©ut!uDz]p!w¬0«}{¨z_° ‹ouDnsv  {}Šop©w  nW=­u]µ›<µ §'Œ_{¦vŒ psŒ  uDn©Œ_wx«¦‹_n²~  u$y|n©uD‹ ‹oy  {¨z_›±psŒ_uÂwxŠUu  ~3ps{¨w]z ? µ

Q ~]n®uW‹hw]z‰psŒ_{¦n~z<‹Án©wxt!u~$Š  {}w  {d{¨z_¬­w  t!~p©{}wxz±~˜Uwxyopp©Œ_u²˜UuŒ|~:ªm{}w  wx¬psŒ_uª3~«}y_uWn4w¬p©Œ_uP«¨{}z_°

‹_uDnsv  {¨Šopsw  nÌoŠ w]˜|~˜_{}«}{}n®p©{¦v0t!wm‹_u«¦n„v~xz˜Uun©up„y_Š$pswŠ  w3ªm{}‹ou0t!w  u4~Š_Š  w]Š  {¦~3psu  w]yop©uWnº¬­w  ͆wmk

O w3§„nXE“_ÌZYFÓµ ˆ†˜mªm{¨w]y|n©«¨l]̺p©Œ_uÁwx˜o‚quWv´ps{¨ª]uhw¬4psŒ_u  w]yop©uÁn®uD«¨uWv´p©{}wxz ˜<~xn©uD‹ w]z ‹o{.@Uu  uDz]ppqlmŠ<uWnPwx¬

Š w]˜|~˜_{}«}{}n®p©{¦vPt!up©Œ_wo‹_nvw s uWn®ŠUwxz<‹_np©w¯‹oupsu  t!{¨z_u$psŒ_uÂwxŠ_p©{}t!~x«  w]yop©uWn̸§'Œ_{¦vŒ vD~z ¬­y_«¨¹|«¨«¼p©Œ_u

͆wmk  uD½Ay_{ ut!uzApº§'{»psŒt²~³m{}ty|tŠ  wx˜|~x˜_{}«¨{¨pqlxµ

¤ Œ_u  ue~  u¼wxp©Œ_u H uD~xn©wxz<nd§'Œml8p©Œ_u  w]yop©{}z_›t8up©Œ_wo‹_nv~xzwxz|«¨l!§w  °w]z{¨z<vwxt!Š_«}upsu†{}zo¬­w  t²~3¾

ps{¨w]zµdkmy|vŒ~  uD~xn©wxzvwxt!uDnd¬ w]t p©Œ_uˆ0k € S¯~xz|‹ € Ê†Ê ¶dŠ wxp©wovw]«}nDÌ]§'Œ|{}vŒ§w  °ond{}zPŒ_{}u  ~  vŒ_{¦v~x«

t²~xz_z_u  Ìm§'Œ_u  uep©Œ_u0ª3~«}y_uWnºw¬NpsŒ_u0«¨{}z_°P‹_uDnsv  {¨Šopsw  nwxzPŒ|{¨›]Œ_u  Œ_{}u  ~  vŒ_{¦v~x«|«}uªxuD«}n'~  u0v~x«}vy_«¦~3p©uW‹

~]n¼~:ª]u



~›xu4ª3~x«¨y_uWn¼w3ª]u



psŒ_u8«¨w3§u



w]z_uDnDµ4kmw|Ì



w]yop©{}z_›{¨zÂpsŒ_uDn©u8«¨uDªxu«¦n¼~



u8~«¦n®wP˜|~xn©uD‹$w]zÀ{¨z<vwxt8¾

Š|«¨up©u„«}{¨z|°8ª3~x«¨y_uWn-=ðpsŒ_u¼u³_~xv´p¸ª:~x«¨y|uDn5¬



wxt p©Œ_u†«¨w3§u



«}uª]u«¦nH~



u'z_wxpH°mz_w3§'z

? E“FÓµ5•¼up©u



t!{¨z|{¨z_›p©Œ_u

psŒ



uDn©Œ_wx«¦‹_nDÌ]§'Œ_{¦vŒP~



u„y<n®uW‹!p©w˜<u0~x‹oª]u



p©{¦n®uW‹/Ìx{¦n~z{}zAp©u



uDn®p©{}z_›ps~xn©°8˜<uWv~y<n®u†{»pºt!uD~z<nH‹



~:§'{¨z|›

~˜|~«¦~z<vu„˜Uupq§uuDz²p©Œ_u†z_upq§w



°!v~Š<~xv{¨pql8y|n®uW‹!¬­w



‹o{¦nqp



{}˜_yops{¨z|›p©Œ|u†«}{¨z|°!n®ps~p©u†{¨zo¬­w



t²~p©{}wxz~z<‹

(7)

psŒ_u{}z|vw]t!Š_«¨up©uDz_uDnsn„wx¬psŒ_u{}zo¬­w



t²~3ps{¨w]zÂnqpsw



uD‹{¨zÀp©Œ_u



wxy_p©{}z_›²ps~x˜_«}uDnDµ¶·z<v



uD~xn©{}z_›!p©Œ_u‹o{}n®ps~xz|vu

˜Uupq§uuDzhpsŒ_u!p©Œ



uWn®Œ_w]«}‹|n4‹ouDv



uW~xn©uDn†p©Œ_u²z|uDvuWn©ns~



lÀv~xŠ|~xv{»pql$¬­w



~x‹oª]u



p©{¦n®uDt!uzAp4§'Œ_{¨«}u²{}z|v



uD~]n®uWn

psŒ_ue{¨z|vwxt!Š_«}upsuz_uWn©n¸w¬N{}zo¬­w



t²~3ps{¨w]zP~˜Uwxy_p¸«}{¨z_°²ª3~x«¨y_uWnµHˆ†zPp©Œ_uewpsŒ_u



Œ|~z<‹§'Œ_uDz²p©Œ_u4‹o{¦n®ps~z<vuDn

~  u0‹ouWv  uD~xn©uD‹~x‹_ªxu p©{¦n©ut!uzApºuªxuDzApsnº§'{}«¨«/wovvy  t!w  ue¬ uW½]y|uzAp©«}l(=­ty|vŒ$t!w  ue˜<~z|‹o§'{¦‹mpsŒt²~:l

˜Uuez_uuW‹ouD‹¬­w  «¨{}z_°n®ps~p©uet8uWn©ns~›]uDn ? ÌA˜_yop't!w  u¼Š  uDv{}n©u¼«}{}z_°nqp~3psu†{}zo¬­w  t²~3ps{¨w]zP§'{}«¨«B˜Uuen®p©w uW‹{}z

psŒ_u  w]yop©u  n8=­p©Œ_u²Š  wx˜<~˜_{}«¨{¨pqlÂw¬¸¬­y_«¨¹|«¨«}{}z_›p©Œ_u͆wmk  uD½Ay_{ uDt8uDzAp0~x«¨w]z_›PpsŒ_u²n®uD«¨uWv´psuD‹  w]yop©u!§'{}«¨«

˜Uu4{}z|v  uD~]n®uW‹ ? µ

¤ Œ_ut²~{}z¯¬­wovy|n8wx¬'p©Œ_{¦n8Š|~ŠUu  {}npswh{}z]p wo‹oy<vuPz|u§ty_«»ps{}vD~xn®p  wxyops{¨z|›‰~«}›xw  {¨p©Œ|t!n§'Œ_{¦vŒ

~  u8~˜_«}up©wŠ<u  ¬­w  t  wxyopsu8n©u«}uDvp©{}wxz‰˜|~xn©uD‹hwxzhŠ  w]˜|~˜_{}«}{}n®p©{¦v«}{¨z|°Ât8uW~xn©y  uDn†{¨z‰p©Œ_u²vD~xn©uw¬¸p©Œ_u

t!wAnqppqlmŠ_{¦v~x«HpqlmŠUuDnw¬e͆wAk  uD½Ay_{ ut!uzApsn =­w3ª]u  ~«}«dvw]n®pDÌ5uDz|‹m¾¿p©wx¾¿uDz|‹¯‹ou«¦~:lÁw  ‚q{¨p®psu  Ì5t!{¨z_{}t²~«

˜<~z|‹o§'{¦‹mpsŒ ? ~z|‹$~xz|~«}l2Cuep©Œ_uD{ n'ŠUu  ¬­w  t²~z|vuDnº~›A~{}z|nqpºpsŒ_uvy © uzAp©«}lPn®ps~xz|‹_~  ‹o{DCuW‹P~«}›xw  {¨p©Œ|t!n

=ã§'Œ_{¦vŒ§w  °†w]z M´{}t!Š  uDv{¦n©uM5‹oup©u  t!{}z_{}n®p©{¦v¸«¨{}z_°4t!uD~]n®y  uDn ? µ ¤ Œ_u uWn®y_«¨psn~  udpsuDn®p©uW‹˜ml4u³mp©uDz|n©{¨ª]u

n©{}ty_«¦~3ps{¨w]z|nµ

¤

Œ_uWn®u0pswxŠ_{¦vnº§'{}«}«˜<u0p



uW~3psuD‹{¨zp©Œ|u†¬­w]«¨«}w3§'{}z_›²nqp



y|vp©y



u

{¨z

V#* $

psŒ_u4t!wo‹ou«~xz|‹p©Œ_u4z_wxps~p©{}wxz{}nº{}zAp



wm‹_y|vuW‹Ppsw8ps~xv°m«}uep©Œ_u4Š



wx˜|«¨uDt!

{¨z

V#* $#"

§u$Š



w]Š<wAn®u$n©wx«}yop©{}wxz|n¬­w



p©Œ_uÂty_«»ps{}vD~xn®p



w]yop©{}z_›±Š



wx˜_«}ut {}z p©Œ_uÂvD~xn©uwx¬

{¨z<vwxt!Š_«}upsu0{¨zo¬­w  t²~p©{}wxzy|n®{}z_›p©Œ_uepqlmŠ_{¦v~x«Í†wAk²w]˜o‚quDvp©{}ªxuWn~xz|‹Pp©Œ_u4~Š|Š  w]Š  {}~p©u¼t!up  {}vDn

{¨z V# 7%$ u³mpsuz|n©{¨ª]u4zmy_t!u  {}vD~«~z<~«}lmn©{¦n'w¬p©Œ_ut8up©Œ_wo‹_n†~  u4›x{}ªxuDz˜Uu¬­w  u4psŒ_uvwxz|v«¨yo¾

n®{}wxz<nµ

& '

%U 4.(*²&%'±& %' Y(

Nup*),+.-0/21354˜<up©Œ|uP›  ~Š|Œ  uDŠ  uWn®uDzAp©{}z_›$p©Œ_uz_upq§¸w  °hp©wxŠUwx«}wx›]lÁ~xz|‹¯«}up8y|nn©y_Š_ŠUw]n©upsŒ|~3p

psŒ_u²z_upq§¸w  °Â{¦n4~˜_«}u!p©w$ŠUu  ¬­w  t1͆wAk  wxyops{¨z_›$t!uDvŒ<~z_{¦n®t²nDµ S_w  psŒ_{¦n  uW~xn©wxzhp©Œ_un®ps~p©u!w¬p©Œ_u

z|upq§w  °h{¦nt!wxz_{¨p©w  uW‹¯~z|‹±«}{}z_°±ª:~x«¨y|uDnvw s uWn®ŠUwxz<‹o{¨z|›pswÂp©Œ|un©u«}uDv´psuD‹ ͆wmk‰›xw]~x«}n~  u°mz_w3§'z

§'{¨p©ŒÁ~²›x{}ªxuDzh‹ow]y_˜op®¬­y|«¨z_uWn©nDµ ¤ Œ_u«}{¨z|°ª3~x«¨y_u8t!uD~]n®y  ut!uDz]pe~z|‹$psŒ_u8Š  w]Š|~›A~3ps{¨w]zwx¬5p©Œ_uª3~«}y_uDn

~  ue{}z|n®y  uW‹§'{¨p©ŒpsŒ_u4Œ_u«}Šw¬5~²Í4ˆ0k € «}{¨°]u4t!uDvŒ|~xz_{}n©t E: Ì_‘FÓµ

Nup¸y<nHn©y_Š_ŠUw]n©u„p©Œ<~3p  wxyopsu  nH~]‹oªxu  ps{}n©uºp©Œ_u†ª3~«}y_uDnHw¬Bp©Œ_u†«¨{}z_°²‹ouWn©v  {}Šop©w  ndw3ªxu  psŒ_u¼z|upq§w  °UÌ

{}zp©Œ_u0¬­w]«¨«}w3§'{}z_›¬ã~]n®Œ|{¨w]z6

¤ Œ_ueŠ|~  ~t!upsu  ~3³o{}n =ðpsŒ_u0n®upwx¬Š<wAn©n©{¨˜|«¨ueª3~«}y_uDn¸w¬psŒ_ue«¨{}z_°²‹ouDnsv  {}Šop©w ? {}nºvw3ª]u  uD‹8§'{¨p©Œ~

›  {}‹!78+:9<;>=?1@+:AB1CDCCD1EGFxµ

ƒp¼uD~]vŒPps{¨t!u{}z|n®ps~xz]p'psŒ_uª3~«}y_u;>=5{¦n„~]‹oªxu



ps{}n©uD‹P¬



w]tpsŒ_u«}{¨z_°H-JIK1?L4´Ì<{»¬Yp©Œ|u4ª:~x«¨y|u4w¬Yp©Œ_u

«¨{}z_°‹ouDnsv



{¨Š_p©w



w]z«}{}z_°-JIK1?L4ºn®p©uŠ<n'{¨zApswpsŒ_u4{}z]psu



ª3~«M-J;>=1?;>=DNPO4´µ

¶·z p©Œ_{¦n!§º~:l¯uD~xvŒ «¨{}z_°#-QIP1LR4TS:3 Œ|~]n8~¯Í†wAk>‹ouDnsv  {}Šop©w *UVWBXY[Z §'Œ_{¦vŒ {}n²~]n©n©y_t!uD‹ p©w±˜<u

 ~z<‹owxt ª3~  {¦~˜_«}u4n®y_˜_‚quDv´pºpsw!p©Œ_uvwxz|‹o{¨p©{}wxz<~«/Š  wx˜|~x˜_{}«¨{¨pql‹o{¦nqp  {}˜_yops{¨w]z¬­y|z|v´ps{¨w]z

\ V=Z

]?^`_bac?d

-Qe42+#fg-UVWBXY[Z2h eKi;>= hjUVWBXY[Zh ;>=DNPO4

(8)

¶·z$vu



p~{}zPv~]n®uWndpsŒ_u



~z<‹owxt ª3~



{}~x˜_«}uDnvw

s

uDn©Š<w]z|‹o{}z_›4p©wp©Œ|u0‹_{A@Bu



uzApº«¨{}z_°onºv~zP˜<u4vw]z|n©{}‹m¾

u 

uW‹~]nº{¨z<‹ouŠUuz|‹_uzAp



~xz|‹ow]tª3~



{}~x˜_«¨uWn =ãv´¬qµHkouDv´ps{¨w]z

: ? µ

¤ Œ_un©up'wx¬ty_«»ps{}vD~xn®p'›



wxy_Št!ut˜Uu



nº{¦nº›x{}ªxuz$~z<‹‹_uz_wxp©uD‹˜ml /

/²µ

¤ Œ_ue›xwA~«Uw¬psŒ_u0ty_«¨p©{¦v~]nqp  wxyops{¨z_›{}n¸psw¹|z<‹P~Š|~  p©{¦~«Bn®Š<~z_z_{}z_›p  uu §'Œ_{¦vŒn©Š|~z|n¸¬­w  ~x«¨«

I{}z /

~xz|‹²§'Œ_{¦vŒvw s uWn®ŠUwxz|‹|nYp©wp©Œ_u  uW½Ay_{ uD‹P͆wmk²v  {¨p©u  {}wxz²§'{¨p©ŒpsŒ_u¼t²~³m{}t²~«UŠ  wx˜|~x˜_{¨«}{¨pql

fg-H͆wAk¥v  {¨p©u  {}wxz {¦n p  y_u4 =qš ?

§'Œ|u  u {¦np©Œ_un©up„wx¬Np  uDuDn'n©Š|~z_z|{¨z_› / µ

¤ Œ_u4t!wAnqpº¬ uD½Ay_uzAps«¨ly<n®uW‹Â͆wmkv {¨p©u  {}wxz|n¬­w  ty_«¨p©{¦v~]nqpºp uDu0n©u«}uDvp©{}wxz$~  u4~z|~x«¨lon©uD‹{}zp©Œ_u

z|u³mp¼n®uWv´ps{¨w]zwx¬Np©Œ|{}n'Š<~ŠUu  µ

) ¸*,+%% 23Y*0

¤ Œ|u²Í†wmkÀ~:§º~  u  w]yop©{}z_›Š  w]˜_«}ut²neª:~  l${}zhpsŒ_u!y|n©uD‹Àw]˜o‚quDvp©{}ªxu¬­y_z|v´ps{¨w]zÁ~xz|‹À{}z‰p©Œ_u!y|n©uD‹h«¨{}z_°

t!up  {}vDnµ¼ƒ ¬­u§Š|~xŠ<u  n†~z|~x«¨l2CDu4p©Œ_u²Í†wAk  wxyops{¨z|›Š  wx˜_«}ut §'{»psŒh‹oup©u  t!{¨z|uD‹Â«}{¨z|°t!up {}vDn¼~z<‹

§'{¨p©Œ8~Š_Š  w]Š  {¦~3psuHw]˜o‚quDvp©{}ªxud¬­y|z|v´ps{¨w]z|nµYƒ «}~  ›]uHw3ªxu  ªm{}u§¯~z<‹v«¦~xnsn©{»¹<vD~3ps{¨w]z4w¬  wxy_p©{}z_›¼Š  wx˜|«¨uDt!n

~xz|‹!n®w]«¨y_p©{}wxz|n5vD~z!˜<u„¬­wxy_z|‹!{}zWE’F¿µ ¤ Œ_uWn®u„~xz|~«}l2CuDn5~  uºw]yopHw¬/nsvwxŠUu'w¬Bwxy  Š|~ŠUu  µdˆ†y  ~z|~x«¨l2CDu

~x{¨t²nºpsŒ_u  wxy_p©{}z_›²Š  wx˜_«}ut §'Œ_uzÂpsŒ_u«}{¨z|°ª3~«}y_uWn¼~  u4t!uD~]n®y  uD‹§'{¨p©ŒÂy_z<vu  ps~x{¨zApql]µ¸¶·zÀw]y  vD~xn©u

psŒ_uÍ†wAk



wxyops{¨z_›8t!wo‹ou«¦n'˜|~]n®uW‹Pw]z‹oup©u



t!{}z_uD‹ª3~«}y_uDn'vD~zz_wp„˜Uu~Š|Š_«¨{}uD‹µ

euDz_u



~«}«¨l]ÌUp©Œ_u͆wAkhv



{»psu



{¨w]z$¬­w



ty_«¦~3ps{¨w]zh‹ouŠUuz<‹_newxzÀpsŒ_upqlAŠUu8w¬dpsŒ_uy<n®uW‹À«}{¨z_°Ât!up



{}vDnµ

¶Ó¬ep©Œ|uÀ«¨{}z_° ª:~x«¨y|uDn~



u°mz_w3§'z §'{»psŒ y_z|vu



ps~{}zApqlx̸p©Œ_uhwx˜o‚quWv´p©{}ªxu¬­y_z<v´p©{}wxz<n!¬­w



ty_«¨p©{¦v~xn®p²p



uu

n©u«}uDvp©{}wxz$v~xz˜Uu0¬­w  ty_«¦~3psuDnº~xn¬­w]«¨«}w3§„nDµ

šxµ'ƒ¼nsn®y|t8{}z_› !*'9.#$H# 1>0*, # w¬«}{¨z|°8t!up {}vDn =ãuxµ›|µY˜|~z<‹o§'{}‹op©Œ ? p©Œ_u0v  {¨p©u  {}wxzv~xz˜Uu†§  {»p©p©uDz

~xn

! #"

VDWXY[Z

UVDWXY[Z$&%

§'Œ_u

 u % vw

©

uDn©ŠUwxz|‹_n¸pswpsŒ_u~xn©°xuW‹Pª3~x«¨y_u =ãuxµ›|µYp©Œ|u4z_uuW‹ouD‹˜|~xz|‹o§'{¦‹mp©Œ

?

’oµº¶·zhpsŒ_u!v~xn©uwx¬ %B%#*, # wx¬Hy_z_{¦v~]nqp0«¨{}z_°Àt!up  {}vDn„pq§wPpqlmŠ_{¦v~x«vD~xn©uDn†w¬ty_«¨p©{¦v~]nqp0wx˜o¾

‚quDvp©{}ªxuDn¼n®Œ_w]y_«¦‹P˜Uu‹o{¦nqps{¨z_›]y_{¦n®Œ_uW‹/µ

=ã~ ? S|w  ͆wAk  uD½Ay_{ uDt8uDzApvw]z|vu  z_{}z_› # #7)%'33'#$H%)($ =­u]µ›<µ‹ouD«}~:l]Ì©‚q{¨p®psu  Ì3z_u›A~3ps{¨ª]u

«}wx›A~  {»psŒ_t w¬p©Œ|u4Š|~xv°]upº«¨wAn©n ? p©Œ_uv  {¨p©u  {}wxz$v~xz˜Uu4§  {¨p®psuzÂ~xn

* ^,+>a-/.Qd021 3

VWBXY[Z

* ^,+>a-4.d

UVWBXY[Zh65

7 u  u 5 vw © uDn©ŠUwxz|‹_npsw4p©Œ|u¼ª3~«}y_u'pswx«}u  ~3p©uW‹8˜Alp©Œ|ue͆wAk  uD½Ay_{ uDt8uDzAp =­uxµ›|µpswx«}u  ~3p©uW‹

uDz|‹m¾¿p©wx¾¿uDz|‹ ‹ouD«}~:l ? ~xz|‹&8

‹ouz|wp©uWnpsŒ_u±n®upw¬Š|~3psŒ|nP˜Uupq§uuDz p©Œ|uÁn©uz|‹_u  =49 S

/ ? ~xz|‹p©Œ_u  uWvuD{¨ª]u  =;: = SH/

)<

9=9F 1?@2+ A1<CCDCD1> ? z_wo‹ouWn0=¿km{¨z|›x«}u8kmw]y  vu‡Ây_«¨p©{¦v~]nqp

t!wo‹ouD«? w  psŒ_uHŠ<~3p©Œ<nN˜Uupq§uuDz4uªxu  lez_wo‹ou¸Š|~{ wx¬ /

=ーzAlkmw]y  vuH‡Ây|«»ps{}vD~xn®pNt!wm‹_u«? µ

ˆ  {}›x{}z|~3psuD‹†¬ w]t psŒ_ud¬ uD½Ay_uDzAp©«}l†y|n©uD‹n®w]y  vu5˜|~xn©uD‹4~xŠ_Š_«}{}vD~3ps{¨w]z|n~z<‹ep©Œ_u~«}›xw  {¨p©Œ_t!{¦v

vwxt!Š_«}u³o{¨pql²p©Œ_u4Š<~ŠUu  {¦n'vwxz<vuzAp  ~p©uD‹Pp©w8psŒ_ukm{}z_›x«}ukmwxy  vue‡Ây|«»ps{}vD~xn®p„t8wo‹ouD«Lµ

(9)

=­˜

?

S|w



uD½Ay_{



ut!uzApsnNvwxz<vu



z_{}z_›ºp©Œ|u

#$

wx¬mp©Œ_un®Š|~xz_z_{}z_›ºp



uudp©Œ_u'͆wAkev



{»psu



{¨w]z

vw

s

uWn®ŠUwxz<‹_n¸p©w

3

VWBXY[Z

UVWBXY[Zh

§'Œ|u  u {¦nºpsŒ_uvwAnqpºp©w]«¨u  ~p©uW‹˜mlpsŒ_u‹out²~xz|‹/µ

¤ Œ_u²w]˜o‚quDvp©{}ªxu!w¬p©Œ|u²ty_«¨p©{¦v~]nqp  wxyops{¨z|›{¦n0psw$¹|z|‹±~z±wxŠ_p©{}t!~x«Yp  uu

§'Œ_{¦vŒÁn©Š|~z<n0p©Œ_u

ty_«¨p©{¦v~xn®p'z_wo‹ouDn¼~z|‹t!w]n®pº«}{}°xu«}l²¬­y_«¨¹|«}«}n'p©Œ_uÍ†wmkPv  {¨p©u  {}wxzÌoz<~t!u«}l

šxµ'vw]z|n®{¦‹ou



{}z_›8˜<wxp®p©«}uz|uDv°pqlmŠUu4w¬«¨{}z_°Pt!up



{}vDn

0O

fg- ! #"

VWBXY[Z

UVWBXY[Z$ % 4 =L’

?

’oµ'vw]z|n®{¦‹ou  {}z_›!~x‹_‹o{¨p©{}ªxu0pqlmŠUu0w¬Y«¨{}z_°Pt!up  {}vDn

=ã~

?

{}zp©Œ_uvD~xn©u†wx¬uDz|‹m¾¿p©wx¾¿uDz|‹½Ay|~x«¨{¨pql



uD½Ay_{



uDt!uzAp

fg-

* ^+a-.d0 1 3

VDWXY[Z

* ^,+>a- .d

UVWBXY[Z h 5 4 =: ?

=­˜

?

{}zp©Œ_uvD~xn©u†wx¬Y~xzw3ª]u



~«}«/vw]n®pº¬­y_z|vp©{}wxz

fg-

3

VWBXY[Z

UVWBXY[Z h 4 =­‘ ?

¤

Œ_u0¬­w]«¨«}w3§'{}z_›8‹_{}nsvy|nsn©{¨w]z~xz|~«}l2CuDn¸psŒ_u4wxŠops{¨t!{DCD~p©{}wxzps~xn©°on4=L’

?

¾=­‘

? µ

! "#$&%'(*)#$(+

¤ Œ|uº¬­wx«}«¨w3§'{}z_›0«¨uDt!t!~4n®ps~p©uWnYp©Œ|~p =L’ ? v~xz8uW~xn©{¨«}l˜Uu'p  ~z<nq¬­w t!uD‹p©w~kmp©u{}z_u  p uu'Š  wx˜|«¨uDt ~z<‹

n©w²v~xzw]z_«¨lP˜<u~xŠ_Š  w:³m{}t²~3psuD‹{}z$Š<w]«¨lmz_w]t!{}~x«Bp©{}t8u]µ

,¸Ä ¡-/. +J281 )%B#3, #$H% #7) *# # $A9' 5103284# ($'.#$ 3>$62 ,

+> + Z, 9##0QRW 4*2 ,H*B!$.#7+ #(%B#$3#7+> + #*#A')#%"/ A21

-QIP1LR4 !#72656VWBXY[Z +87:9<; gf>=UVDWXY[Z$&%@?A

Z6 53BC

un©uu°p©Œ_u4ty_«»ps{}vD~xn®pºp



uu

0O !

fg- ! "

VWBXY[Z

UVWBXY[Z$ % 4

§'Œ|{}vŒ{}n„uD½Ay_{}ª:~x«¨uDzAppsw

0O

!

fg-ED

VWBXY[Z

UVWBXY[Z$ % 4

(10)

ƒ†n©n©y_t!{}z_›!{¨z|‹_uŠUuz|‹ouDzAp



~xz|‹owxtª:~



{¦~˜|«¨uWn = A# A

«}{¨z|°P{}z|‹ouŠUuz<‹ouz|vl

?

fg-ED

VWBXY[Z

UVWBXY[Z$ %

4+

VWBXY[Z

fg-

UVWBXY[Z $&%

4

~xz|‹Pp©Œ_u4w]Šop©{}ty_t v~xz˜Uu‹ou¹<z_uD‹˜ml

0O ! #"

3

VDWXY[Z

7:9<; 2fg-UVWBXY[Z $&% 4 =L ?

¤ Œ|u  u¬­w  u0~xnsn®{}›xz_{}z_›8t!uD~xn©y  u 5 VWBXY[Z p©w²«}{¨z_° -JIK1?L4º~xn 56VWBXY[Z + 7:9;2fg-UVWBXY[Z$ % 4´µ¸Íµ„µ•µ

7 uy  {}n®p©{¦v4t!upsŒ_wo‹_n0=9T¼w]yÌ ¤ ~°3~xŒ|~xn©Œ_{¨¾Ó‡À~psn©y_l]~xt²~_Ìmupvµ? vD~zÀ~xŠ_Š  w:³m{}t²~3psu†psŒ_uw]Šop©{}t²~«n©w¾

«}yops{¨w]z E FÓµ

## ! >! #$&%'(*)#(+

ƒ†n¸vD~z˜Uu0n®uDuz²¬ wxt =:? ~xz|‹X=㑠? ÌApsŒ_uen©u«}uDvp©{}wxz²wx¬p©Œ_u†wxŠops{¨t²~x« € k ¤ ˜|~]n®uW‹!wxzP~]‹_‹o{¨p©{}ªxu„pqlmŠUu†wx¬

«}{}z_°t!up  {¦vn„‹_uŠUuz|‹_n„wxzp©Œ_u½Ay|~x«¨{¨pqlPv  {¨p©u  {}wxzµ

- É Æ Ÿ È|ÆsÄ É È   Ä ­  Ä Ä

euDz_u



~«}«}lxÌ<p©Œ_uŠ|~3psŒ|n¼˜Uupq§uuDzÂp©Œ|u8n©uz|‹_u



z|wm‹_u8~xz|‹$p©Œ|u



uDvuD{¨ª]u



wxz_uWn¼vw]zAps~{}zÀvw]t!t8w]zÀ«}{¨z_°on

{}zÂ~!ty_«¨p©{¦v~]nqp¼p



uuxµkmw|Ì|p©Œ_u



~z<‹owxtt!uW~xn©y



uWnºw3ªxu



psŒ_uDn©uŠ|~p©Œ|n¼nqp~3p©{¦n®p©{¦v~«}«}l‹ouDŠ<uDz|‹$wxz$uD~]vŒ

wxp©Œ_u

 µ ¤ ~°m{¨z|›{¨zApsw~xvDvwxy|z]p5psŒ_u¼uDªxuDz]pndwx¬B{}z|v«¨y|‹_{¨z_›p©Œ_u†n©~xt8u¼«¨{}z_°V=ãn

?

{}zP‹o{.@Uu



uDzApHŠ|~3psŒ|n



uWn®y_«¨psn

~xz!wxŠops{¨t!{DCD~3ps{¨w]z8ps~xn©°Œ<~:ªA{}z_›0Œ_{}›xŒvwxt!Š_«}u³o{»pql]Ìxn©{¨z|vu'p©Œ|u5‚qwx{}zApH‹o{}n®p



{}˜_yop©{}wxz²wx¬<psŒ_u„Š|~p©Œ|nHn®Œ_w]y_«¦‹

˜Uu4°mz_w3§'zµ

!

fg- D

* ^,+>a-.d021

9 3

VWBXY[Z

* ^,+>a-4.Qd

UVWBXY[Z h 5 F4 =U ?

ˆ 

{}›x{}z|~3psuD‹4¬



wxt p©Œ_uº¬ã~]v´pdpsŒ|~3p5psŒ_u



u'{¦nYz_w~:ª3~{}«}~x˜_«¨uºt!upsŒ_wo‹p©wn©wx«}ªxu4=U

?

‹o{



uDvp©«}lxÌxp©Œ_uº¬­w]«¨«}w3§'{¨z|›

‹_{}nsvy|nsn©{¨w]z{¦ndvw]z|vuDzAp  ~3p©uW‹w]z²~4n®ŠUuDv{}~x«|v~]n®uº§'Œ_uDz!p©Œ_uY‚qw]{¨zApH‹o{¦nqp  {}˜_yops{¨w]z²w¬Up©Œ_u'Š<~3p©Œ<nd{}z|v«}y|‹ouW‹

{}z‰p©Œ_u € k ¤ nep~°xuWn0~  u«¦~3ps{¨ª]u«}lÀn®{}t!Š_«}l¬­w  tË~z|‹‰{¨p{}n4‹oup©u t!{}z_uD‹‰˜mlÂp©Œ_u8¹  n®pepq§wt8w]t!uzApsn

=ã˜ml²p©Œ_u4u³oŠ<uWv´p©uW‹ª:~x«¨y|u~z|‹Pp©Œ_u4ª3~  {¦~z|vu ? µ

Nup„y|n'{}zAp wo‹oy|vu  ~z|‹_wxt ª3~  {}~x˜_«}uDn=d~]n

<=P+

3

VDWXY[Z

* ^,+>a-/.Qd UVWBXY[Z

~xz|‹  uD§ {¨p©u =U ? ~xn

fg-D

=! PO

9"<= h65 F4

(11)

ƒ¼Š_Š_«}lA{}z_›!psŒ_uvuDz]p



~x«/«¨{}t!{»p'psŒ_uw



uDt v~xz˜Uu0¬­w



ty|«}~p©uD‹~xn

#"

CDCC

e 9 7 O

- e 7

4

O

-e 7

4[F

- 4

;

e 1 =

'?

§'Œ|u  u = + 3*9 =F{¦nºpsŒ_uu³oŠUuDvp©uD‹$ª3~x«¨y_u4wx¬ = Ì = + 3*9 - = 7 =4- 7 4[F]Ì @1 + A1<CCDCD1>

~xz|‹&> vw s uWn®ŠUwxz|‹|npsw±p©Œ_uÀvD~  ‹o{¨z<~«}{»pql¯wx¬†psŒ_uÀn®upw¬eŠ|~3psŒ|nµ ¤ Œ|uÂt!~p  {»³

vD~z uD~]n®{}«}l ˜<u

vD~«¦vy_«¦~3psuD‹‰§'Œ_uz ~]n©n©y_t!{}z_›p©Œ_u«}{}z_°h{}z|‹ouDŠ<uDz|‹ouz<vl =­w¬'vw]y  n®u8p©Œ|uŠ|~3psŒ±{¨z|‹_uŠUuz|‹ouDz|vlÁ{¦n4z_wp

p  y|u ? = + 3

VWBXY[Z

* ^,+>a-4.0d * ^+a-d

VWBXY[Z

C =㓠?

kow|Ì<p©Œ_u8½]y<~«}{»pqlw¬ "! {}n†‹oupsu



t8{}z_uW‹Â˜mlPpsŒ_ut!uW~zª3~«}y_uDn†~z|‹Àª:~



{¦~z<vuDn„w¬d«}{¨z_°Â‹ouWn©v



{}Šopsw

 n

~x«¨w]z_›8p©Œ_u4Š<~3p©Œ<n„~z|‹psŒ_un®y|t wx¬psŒ_u4ª3~  {}~xz|vuWnºw¬p©Œ_uvwxt!t!wxz$«¨{}z_°on'{}z|v«}y|‹ouW‹{¨zp©Œ|u4p  uu]µHƒ¼n

vD~z‰˜<u²n©uuzh¹|z|‹o{}z_›p©Œ_u!w]Šop©{}t²~«5n®w]«¨y_p©{}wxzht!uW~z|n0~vwxt!Š_«}u³h‹_{}nsv  upsuw]Šop©{}t!{.CW~3p©{}wxzhps~]n®°BÌn®p©{}«¨«

§'Œ|uzp©Œ_uº‚qw]{¨zAp¼‹o{¦nqp  {}˜_yops{¨w]zps~°]uDnº~!n®{}t!Š_«}l¬­w  t«}{¨°]u = '? µ

¶·z8p©Œ|uº¬­wx«}«¨w3§'{}z_›|Ì~eŒ_uDy  {}n®p©{¦v›  uuD‹_l~«}›xw  {¨p©Œ_t{¦nYŠ  wxŠUw]n©uD‹p©we¹|z|‹!~xŠ_Š  w:³m{}t²~3psuD‹n©wx«}yops{¨w]z|nµ

•†uz|wp©uT/$#PpsŒ_u$n®up!wx¬„p©Œ|u$‹_uDn®p©{}z|~3ps{¨w]z|n§'Œ|{}vŒ ~  un®p©{}«¨«ºz_wxpvwxz|z_uDvp©uD‹ p©w‰p©Œ_uÂn©Š|~z|z_{¨z|›Àp uu

+ -0/ 1 3 ?4Y˜Uu{}z_›y_z<‹ou  vwxz|n®p  y|vp©{}wxzµ¶·z²w  ‹ou  psw  uD›x{¦nqpsu  psŒ_u„uz<‹m¾Lpsw¾Óuz|‹!‹ouD«}~:l]Ì]~0§u{}›xŒApML&%

{¦n¼~]n©n©wov{¦~3psuD‹Pp©wuW~xvŒÂz_wo‹ou(' S / ´µ ¤ Œ|{}n¼§¸uD{¨›]Œ]p†{}n†v~«¦vy|«}~p©uD‹$~]nºp©Œ_u8n®y|t wx¬psŒ_ut!uW~z$ª3~«}y_uDn

~xz|‹ª:~  {¦~z<vuDnº~x«¨w]z_›8p©Œ_u4Š|~p©Œ$vw]z_z_uDvp©{}z_›8p©Œ_u4z|wm‹_u)'8p©w8p©Œ_un©wxy  vu†z_wo‹ou 9{¨z + -/ [1 3 >4[

L % + 3

VWBXY[Z

*

^,+>a*>d

VDWXY[Z,+

VWBXY[Z

¤ Œ_u~x«¨›]w



{»psŒ_t §w



°mnº~]n¬­wx«}«¨w3§„n<

šxµ.-~«¦vy_«¦~3psuep©Œ_u4«}{¨z|°Pt!uD~]n®y  uDnº~]n 5 VWBXY[Z +

VWBXY[Z + 3*9 UVWBXY[Z FAÌ0/-JIK1?L4ST3g

’oµ„kmup/$#+:9 :<=1?@+ AB1CDCCD1> F4~z|‹T/ + 9=9F]Ìo§'Œ|u  u)94{}nºpsŒ_un©uz|‹ou  z_wo‹ou4~z|‹!L1 +32

: µS{¨z|‹ n©Œ_w  p©uWnqp8Š|~3psŒ|n¬w]t uD~xvŒ>ty_«¨p©{¦v~]nqp!z_wo‹ou :<=*S /4#Pp©wÁuD~]vŒ>z_wo‹ou5 S:/ 4w¬†p©Œ_u

vy s uzAp©«}lPvw]z|n®p  y|v´psuD‹Pp  uu76

V#. X8 Z ! #"

* 3

VWBXY[Z

*

56VWBXY[Z:9 =Y ?

‘|µ„kmu«}uDvp'p©Œ_un©Œ_w  psuDn®pºw]z_u 6 V#

.<;

X8 ; Z ! "4#

.

0= - X8 0=?>

9bL 8 +A@

VWBXY[Z

* ^,- .aB d

56VWBXY[Z FB

oµ'ƒ'‹_‹uD~xvŒz_wo‹ouC'e{}z|v«}y|‹ouW‹{}z 6 V#

.D;

X8 ; Z p©w/ =/ + / FE 9' F ? §'{»psŒpsŒ_uºv~«¦vy|«}~p©uD‹§¸uD{¨›]ŒAp

L&% +:L 8 ;G+H@

VWBXY[Z

* ^*aB ; d - VWBXY[ZI+

VDWXY[Z

4Ì/§'Œ_u  u 6 V#

.D;

X8 ; Z + 6 V#

.<;

X% Z E 6 V% X8 ; Z µeƒ'‹|‹

p©Œ_u4uW‹o›xuWnºw¬p©Œ_u4Š<~3p©Œ

6 V#.; X8 ; Z p©wg3

U_µ„kmup/$#)+ /$#

< 9 :<=; FB

Références

Documents relatifs

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST