Overhead in Mobile Ad-hoc Network Protocols

HAL Id: inria-00072683

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00072683

Submitted on 24 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub-

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,

Overhead in Mobile Ad-hoc Network Protocols

Philippe Jacquet, Laurent Viennot

To cite this version:

Philippe Jacquet, Laurent Viennot. Overhead in Mobile Ad-hoc Network Protocols. [Research Report]

RR-3965, INRIA. 2000. �inria-00072683�

ISRN INRIA/RR--3965--FR+ENG

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Overhead in Mobile Ad-hoc Network Protocols

Philippe Jacquet and Laurent Viennot

No 3965

Juin 2000

TH `EME 1

0'12435246687:9<;%=?>A@7?BDC;%EFHGI;%@JK7LEMBONP247?EEQ%BDR

STUVXWXY[Z]\^K_`WKacbedOWfg_`he_ifjUVXWK_

kmljnpoiWfgqgrskmt8\Iuv[w

\Iapxyx%ncl`fIzeW'ljWK{|TyWKlj{|TyW&}~c€?c‚?ƒ„Z]…?by†‡}ˆc‰c‰c‰'ZŠˆp€‹xacŒcW_

ŽO)K‘’”“y•c‘c– STyW xyl`W_—WK}Lf}ynpfjWOxyljncx%n?_`WK_˜a:_`byl`™?Whšnp›Ixyljnpfjne{ncœ.n”™cWKl`TyWaczy_†}žVXn?Ÿy†œ‡W a?z¡ ¢Tyne{

}Wfi£#nclj¤¡_K¥§¦g} ac}apœ‡he_—†¨_m†¨_8xl`n?x©nL_—WzXf`n˜WK_—f`†‡VXapf`Wªn”™cWljTyWaczzebyWgf`nX{n?}?fjl`n?œxa?{|¤cWfj_K¥§¦I}ap}acœhe_`†‡_

ac}z«_`†V˜byœ¨a”f`†‡nc}©_ acl`W:xl`n?x©nL_—Wz¬f`n¬WK_—f`†‡VXapf`W­n”™cWljTyWacz®zebyW­f`n¯}ync}e ¢ncxyf`†‡VXacœ†fih®np›'fjTyW­ljncbyf`WK_

{nc}_—f`ljb{f`WKz Ÿ¡hO_`ncVXW-xyl`ncf`ne{n?œ‡_K¥

°²±L³<´jµ¶ ’”·)c– £†ljWœ‡WK_j_}yWfi£.n?l`¤<¸eacz¡ ¢Tyne{p¸en”™?WljTyWKa?zM¸?¹n¡n¡zy†}yŒ©¸eTyWœ‡œ‡n

º¨»M¼`½¢¾K¿¼À)Á‡½¢Â4ÃÄ

Å8Æ©ÇIÈ|ÉËʨÌeÍ|ΔÏ`ÐKÏsÑÒÑÓeÔÖÕÒ×Ø`Ù|ÚÓ|Û܍ÏsÝÞDϗ×yÔ¨ßÒÞ

à

Æ©ÇIÈ|ÉËʨÌeá×jÚÞÓjÝÛyԇâ”Ï—ÓjÝÒÝKãjÛ܍ÏsÝÞDϗ×eÔÖßÒÞ

 – k8œb_`†‡Wbyl|_xyljnpf`ne{ncœ‡WK_#zeW'l`n?befjacŒcW_._`nc}Lfxyl`n?x©nL_—^_#x©n?bylœW_l`^_—Wapbed_jap}_œAa?z¡ ¢Tyne{

_`ac}_†‡}e›l|ac_—f`ljb{ÒfjbyljWÒ¥²kn?byl˜œ‡WK_˜{n?V‹x©apljWl¸§}yn?b_xl`n?x©nL_—n?}_'by}yWap}acœhe_`WzeWOœ¨a„_`byl|{|TapljŒcWzeW

fjlja©{Papxyx%ncl`f`^KWPxaplœ‡WK_Xxyljnpfjne{ncœ‡WK_‹WKbed¡ 4VVXW_¥g}yW:_—h¡}Lf`TUK_`WP_`bylœ‡WK_ze†<^ljW}Lfj_xl`ncf`ne{n?œW_

Wde†‡_—fjac}?f|_WK_—fgxyljncx%n?_`^W?¥ap}acœhe_`W-_`Wze^{n?byx©WW}„zeWKbedPxapl`f`†‡WK_! ap}©apœ‡h¡_`WzeWœ¨a_`byl|{|TapljŒcW'zebyW

acbed x©a#"LbyWf|_IzeW{nc}Lf`l%$cœ‡W-Wfªac}apœ‡he_—W'zeWœ¨a_`bylj{|T©apljŒcW-zebyW'&Xœ¨aX}ync}y 4n?xef`†‡Vapœ‡†fj^zeWK_ljncbyf`WK_zap}_

{Wl`fjac†}_#xyljnpfjne{ncœ‡WK_K¥

(&¶

‘

´

•#)

–

l`^_—Wapb_`ac}_œ4¸yn”™cWKl`TyWaczM¸L†‡}ync}za”f`†‡nc} ¸eTyWœ‡œn

1 2

˜" 8"§

STW.n?ŸeoiWK{f`†‡™cW#np›yfjTy†‡_}npf`W#†¨_)f`n-_—bylj™cWKh[f`TyWn”™cWKl`TWKacz_AVXWfŸ¡hVXncŸy†‡œWacze 4Tyne{.}yWfi£#nclj¤[xyl`ncf`ne{n?œ‡_

†‡}Pxapl`f`†¨{bœ‡acl#Ÿ%Wfi£#WWK} ljWKa?{Òfj†™?Wªxyljnpfjne{ncœ¨_ap}©zOxyljnp sac{f`†‡™cWªxyl`ncf`ne{n?œ‡_K¥

S§ncx%ncœ‡ncŒ?h nc›mlja?ze†nO}yWfi£#nclj¤e_†‡_ªb_`bapœ‡œ‡hPzyW}_`W˜ac}z²™”aplj†W_Inc›Öf`W} ¥3šW‹acl`WŒ?nc†‡}yŒfjn _`WWfjTa”f

{nc}Lf`ljncœ¡n”™?WljTyWKa?z'†}Xxyljnpfjne{ncœ¨_§›nclfjTy†‡_)fih¡x%Wnp›%}yWfi£#nclj¤e_)zyWx%W}zy_mVXac†}œhn?}fjTyW£aDh'l`n?bef`W_ apljW

{nc}_—f`ljb{f`WKzA¥w„ap}yWf#xyljnpfjne{ncœ¨_$4Y‚e¸657Axyljncx%n?_`WgVap†‡}yœ‡hXfi£.n‹£aDh¡_m›ncl{ljWKapf`†‡}yŒ‹l`n?bef`W_8†‡}a?z¡ ¢Tyne{

}Wfi£#nclj¤¡_

Yc¥#f`TyW‹{œ¨ac_j_—†¨{acœMnc}yW˜{nc}©_—†¨_if|_†‡}²W™cWKl`h }ynezeWWKV‹†f—fj†}ŒTyWœ‡œ‡n?_I†‡}²ncl|zeWKlf`nœ‡WKacl`}fjTyW'f`n?x©n?œn?Œch

aV‹W{|Tap}†‡_`V †¨_ fjTyW} b_`WKz‹f`n˜Ÿyljn?acz{ac_—f f`T†‡_.†}y›ncljVXapf`†‡nc}Xncl#a_`b68{†‡W}Lf.xacl—f.np›A†f8f`n˜Ÿ©W

apŸyœ‡W-f`n{ncVXxybefjW'l`n?bef`W_%9

ˆe¥nc}XfjTyWInpfjTyWl.Tap}©zM¸La-™?Wljh˜_`†VXxyœ‡WI£aDhnc› ©}ze†‡}yŒa'ljncbefjWI{n?}_—†¨_—fj_ †‡}X¹n¡neze†}Œ¸?f`TyWg_`ncblj{W

¹n¡nezy_Ia‹xac{|¤?Wfap}z fjTyW'xa”fjTO›n?œœ‡n”£#WKz ŸLhf`TyW'xa?{|¤cWf#fjnXl`Wac{|TfjTyWzeW_ifj†}apf`†‡nc}†‡_Ib_—WzM¥

STyW_—Wfi£.n apxyxyljn?a?{|TyWK_acl`W™cWljh zy†<WljW}Lfª£†f`T„l`WKŒ?apl|z f`nO{nc}Lf`ljncœ§n”™cWKl`TyWaczM¥rs}²fjTa”f[_—WK}_—W

fjTyWOac}apœ‡he_—†¨_-VaczeW†‡} f`Ty†¨_'xacx©WKl_`WŒcljWŒLa”fjWK_ªf`TyWOxyl`ncf`ne{n?œ‡_-xl`n?x©nL_—Wz:›n?lacz¡ ¢Tyne{X}yWfi£.n?l`¤e_-†‡}

fi£#nXVap†‡}O¹©aD™?ncl|_ ;:—TyWœ‡œnXxyljnpfjne{ncœ¨_=<ªap}z>:i¹n¡n¡zy†}yŒ‹xyljnpfjn¡{ncœ¨_?<Ò¥

STyW_`WK{nc}zšapxxyl`nLac{|T:†¨_'™?Wljh:a”f—fjlja?{Òfj†™?W˜›n?l-fi£.nljWKac_`nc}©_ [†}y›ncljVXapf`†‡nc}š†‡__ifjncljWKz:n?}yœ‡h²›ncl

a?{Òfj†™?Wl`n?bef`W_

f`TyW l`W_if‹np›f`TyW f`n?x©n?œn?Œch­VXaDhšŸ%WO†‡Œc}yn?l`Wz 'ap}©z †fXapœ‡œn”£I_f`n„{l`Wa”fjW"Lby†‡{|¤¡œ‡hša

ljncbyf`W†‡} ljWKa?{Òf`†‡nc}šfjn„œ¨apljŒcWVXncŸ†œ‡†fih?¥­¦gœVXn?_—f‹acœœ.f`TWOxyljncx%n?_`WKz xyljnpfjne{ncœ¨_apf‹w:ac}yWf‹b_`Wf`T†‡_

VXW{|Tap}y†¨_`V¥[STyWVXnL_if[x©n?xybyœ¨apl[†‡_[¦gvA@CBD4ˈcˆe¸MˆyYE7ŸLh„u.Tacl`œ‡WK_gkWlj¤L†‡}_K¥GFeb{|T„axl`ncf`ne{n?œ £†‡œœ

Ÿ%W{acœœ‡WKzaH:s¹©nLneze†‡}yŒXxyljnpfjn¡{ncœI<|¥

STyW ©lj_—fIapxyxyljn?a?{|TOVaDhXfjac¤cW'aczy™Dac}LfjapŒ?Wªnc› fjTyW'œn?}yŒXl`n?bef`†‡}yŒXWdex%Wlj†WK}{W[†‡}d¡Wz}yWfi£#nclj¤e_

›nclWdeacVXxyœW?¸©vGF¡k)J l`Wac{Òf|_Ÿ©Wf—fjWlfjn‹œ‡†‡}y¤ ac}z}ynezeW[›ap†‡œbyljW[f`Tac}²\rsk Ÿybyfg_—WKWV_#f`nXxyljnezeb{W

VXn?l`Wn”™?WljTyWKa?zM¸ ap}z {ncVX†‡}yŒ:›ljncV ydeWz }yWfi£#nclj¤e_¸n?}yW {ncbyœ¨z f`T†}y¤ fjTa”fX†f‹ljWKa?{Òfj_Ÿaczyœhšf`n

}Wfi£#nclj¤žVXncŸy†‡œ†fihc¥K3­W­apljW²Œcnc†‡}yŒšf`n¯_—WKWPf`TapfO†f †‡_}npfOapœ‡£aDh¡_‹fjTyW„{Kac_`Wc¥ STWljW²†‡_Vac†}yœ‡h

n?}yWOxl`ncf`ne{n?œmnp›IfjTy†¨_¹©aD™?nclxl`n?x©nL_—Wz a”f‹w„ap}yWf v LFy\M4YNL¸YcYE7Ÿ¡hPO[aDhLh¡byVP¸ …Lac{ "LbyWfK¸ ap}©z

w:byTyœ‡Wf`T©apœ‡Wl8†¨_.†}_`xy†‡l`WzX›ljncV f`TyWªl`n?bef`†‡}yŒx©apl`f$4‡Yˆ¡¸%YK€Q7<np›MfjTyWgœ‡†‡}y¤Xœ‡aDh?Wl8xl`ncf`ne{n?œqI†‡x©WKl`œ¨ap}4€74¥

r¢f-†¨_ªaOœ†‡}y¤:_—fja”fjWxyljnpfjne{ncœ)†‡}:f`TW‹_—fih¡œW˜np›#vGF¡k)J¬fjTa”f-Vap¤?WK_[_—x%WK{†©{ncxefj†VX†SRKapf`†‡nc}_g›ncl[lja?ze†‡n

}Wfi£#nclj¤¡_K¥ STy†¨_)xyljncx%n?_`†fj†n?}fjac¤cW_§a?ze™”ap}LfjacŒcW8nc›yf`TW#¤¡}yn”£œ‡WKzyŒcW8nc›fjTyW#f`ncx%ncœ‡ncŒ?h-œne{acœœ‡h[f`n-Vap¤?W

W8{†‡W}LfŸyl`nLaczy{Kac_—f`†‡}yŒ¥TF¡b{|TPxyljnpfjne{ncœ¨_#£†œ‡œAŸ%W{acœœ‡WKzU:iTWœ‡œnXxyljnpfjn¡{ncœ¨_?<Ò¥

J)œn¡neze†‡}yŒXxyljnpf`ne{ncœ¨_ qIWKœœ‡nXxyljnpf`ne{ncœ¨_

J)†deWz n”™?WljTyWKa?z VXWZY\[ ]^Z_$`ba6cde=Y\[

w²n?Ÿy†œ‡†fihOn”™cWKl`TWKacz Vgf,hSij]lkjmno^pe=qrY\[ fUhis]lkjdn^ZetdQcQY[

S)apŸœW˜Y# vu#ac}ze£†¨z¡f`T n”™cWKl`TyWacz‹np›AŸ%npfjTOxyljnpfjne{ncœ¹©aD™cn?lj_K¥§S)apŸœW[€zeWfjap†‡œ¨_mfjTyWgxacljacVXWf`WKlj_8b_`WKzM¥

S)apŸyœ‡WžY:xl`W_—WK}?f|_ncbl l|_if VXac†} ljWK_`byœf {n?}{WKl`}†}yŒž{nc}Lf`ljncœgn”™cWljTyWaczM¥ STyW:npfjTyWl Vap†‡}

ljWK_`byœf[nc›8fjTyWxyljWK_`W}Lf[}npf`W{nc}{Wlj}_ªf`TyWXn”™cWKl`TWKacz„zebyW‹f`nP}yn?}e 4n?xef`†‡Vapœ‡†fih²nc›.ljncbefjWK_[ncŸyfjap†‡}yWz

Ÿ¡h¹©nLneze†‡}yŒ©¥mS§acŸyœWˆ˜Œc†‡™cW_a›n?l`Wfja?_ifjW[nc›§fjTyWap}©apœ‡h¡_`†¨_#ac}z_—†‡Vbyœ¨a”fj†n?}_xyljWK_`W}Lf`WzOœ¨a”fjWl¥

vªxef`†‡Vapœ vªxef`†‡Vapœ vªxyf`†‡VXacœ

ze†¨_if|ap}{W ze†¨_if|ap}{W ze†¨_if|ap}{W

ˆ € 5

A†‡}yW-£†fjT²{nc}Lfj†}¡byn?b_zeW}©_—†fih ˆe¥Ëˆ €y¥5 5¥€

kmœ¨ap}yW'£†f`T²{n?}Lf`†‡}Lbncb_zeWK}_—†fih ˆe¥N 5¥Ëƒ ‚y¥Ëˆ

FLf`lj†‡x£†f`T:ƒc‰}ynezeW_ ˆe¥‡Y €y¥Ëˆ 5¥€

F "LbapljW[£†fjT\Np‹}ynezeWK_ ˆe¥€ €y¥‚ 5¥

l`†¨z £†fjT 5L‹}ynezeWK_ ˆe¥Ëˆ €y¥5 5¥Ëƒ

S)apŸœWXˆ ¦ ™?Wl|apŒ?W'œWK}yŒpfjT„np›mljncbyf`WK_gncŸef|ap†‡}yWKz:ŸLh¹n¡neze†‡}yŒ›n?lª}ynezeW_ªapf[ze†¨_—fjap}©{W‹ˆy¸%€ ap}z\5O†‡}

™”acl`†‡ncb__j{WK}aplj†nL_¥

vgfjTyWl#¹n¡neze†‡}yŒ˜xl`ncf`ne{n?œ‡_#xyljncx%n?_`WKzapfw„ap}yWf†‡}{œbzyW-Sgv[\g¦ 4ˈp‰e¸ƒ7MŸLh w ¥ F<¥©u.ncl|_—n?}Oap}©z

B˜¥k aplj¤<¸Z@GFe\ 4‡Yƒ¡¸§Y57Ÿ¡h …©¥u#ljn¡{|T ¸ @¥…?ncTy}_`nc}²ac}z@¥w:acœfoRc¸AvA@ªw:\Ik 4Ye¸ YQ7§Ÿ¡hF<¥ ¢…©¥ AWKWc¸

wž¥

Wljœ‡a¸Aap}z uª¥ —uª¥§u.Ty†¨ap}yŒ©¸Aap}z­\ @ªw„¦g\y4Y?¸ ˆ"7¢¥UF¡n?VXW˜nc›8f`TWK_`W‹xl`ncf`ne{n?œ‡_[apljW˜_`x©W{†©{acœœ‡h

zyWK_`†Œ?}yWKzP›n?l Oªn F²n?lªV˜byœf`†¨{ac_—f'_—byxx©n?l—f¥%F¡ncVXW˜np›8fjTyWK_`W‹ncxefj†VX†SRW˜f`TyWK†l[¹n¡neze†‡}yŒ{n?_—fK¥STyW_—W

™”acl`†‡ncb_-n?xef`†‡VX†Ra”fj†n?}_'apljW}ynpfac}apœ‡hrRWz„†‡}šf`TyWxl`W_—WK}?f}npf`W?¥IWK™cWKl—fjTyWœ‡WK_j_¸§£.WŸ%Wœ‡†‡W™cWXfjTa”f

fjTyWVap†‡}ž{nL_if'fjWljV_†¨zeW}Lf`†Wz †} fjTy†‡_xapx%Wl˜apljW_ifj†œ‡œ8™”apœ‡†¨zš›nclfjTyWK_`Wxyljnpfjn¡{ncœ¨_'byx fjn„_—n?VXW

V˜byœf`†‡xyœ†¨{apf`†‡nc} ›ac{f`ncl|_#f`nXŸ%W'†‡zyW}Lf`†WKz†‡}PWKac{|TP{a?_—W?¥

¦g}ynpfjTyWl xyl`nc ¢a?{Òfj†™?W xyljnpfjne{ncœxl`n?x©nL_—Wz¬apfOw:ap}WfO†¨_FeS)¦g\ 4N¡¸Q7ªŸ¡h¯…©¥…¥ aclj{†‡ap  by}ap 

¦{W™?WK_ap}©z w ¥-F¡x%ncT}A¥ STyW²b_`W:np›a\:—}yW†‡ŒcT¡Ÿ%nclxyljnpfjn¡{ncœI<Pac}z®œ†‡}y¤®_if|a”fjW²byx%za”f`W„xac{|¤?Wfj_

LF 'VaDh­_`byŒ?ŒcWK_—f-f`Tapf˜†f†¨_aPTyWKœœ‡n:xyljnpfjn¡{ncœ

†} fjTyWO_`W}_`WXf`T©a”f˜}W†‡ŒcT¡Ÿ©n?lj_'acl`Wzy†‡_j{n”™?WljWKz

xl`nc ¢a?{Òf`†‡™cWKœh ¥AqIn”£#W™cWKlK¸f`TyW.apbefjTyncl|_A_`WWV f`nªzeW}¡hªf`TyWmb©_—Wmnc›eTyWœ‡œngxac{|¤?Wfj_K¥ASTyW.£#aDhI}W†‡ŒcT¡Ÿ©n?lj_

acl`Wze†¨_`{n”™cWKl`Wzap}©zljncbefjWK_ acl`W{n?}_ifjl`b©{Òf`Wz†‡}‹f`Ty†¨_xyljnpfjn¡{ncœe†¨_ _ifj†œ‡œyby}©{œ‡WKapl)fjn'b_¥vJ)†}©apœ‡œh?¸”f`TyWKl`W

†¨_ac} TLh¡Ÿylj†¨z­xl`n?x©nL_—†f`†‡nc} <\k 4Q7.Ÿ¡h)¥…¥ qªaca?_ap}z wž¥\'¥§kWKapljœ‡VXac}šf`Tapf˜{byV˜byœ¨a”f`W_Ÿ%npfjT

TWœ‡œnXxa?{|¤cWf|_ap}z ¹n¡neze†‡}yŒ?_K¥

3šW:apljWPŒcnc†‡}yŒšf`n _`WWf`T©a”fŸ%npf`T«acxyxyljn?a?{|TyWK_˜VaDhžn”™cWKl—f|ap¤cWOf`TyW²ncf`TyWKlzeWx%W}©ze†}Œ nc}¬f`TyW

xl`n#œW_Xnp›[f`TyW„}yWfi£#nclj¤žap}z¯fjTyW²f`l|a8{c¥H¦ ŒcWK}yWlj†‡{VXnezeWœª†‡_Œc†‡™cW}¬†‡} FeWK{Òfj†n?}«ˆ­fjap¤¡†‡}yŒ †‡}

a?{{ncby}LfzeW}_`†fih np›gfjTyWP}yWfi£#nclj¤<¸ VXncŸy†‡œ†fihc¸8f`l|a8{{ljWKa”fj†n?}A¸8ac}zžfjlja8{ zeWK}_`†fih?¥ F¡W{Òf`†‡nc}©_‹€

ac}z\5²acl`W‹zeW™?npf`Wz²fjn fjTyWXWK_—f`†‡Va”f`†‡nc}­np›{nc}Lfjl`n?œ§n”™?WljTyWKa?z²Ÿ¡h:ap}acœhrR†‡}yŒ Ÿ©ncf`Tšf`TyWX}¡byV˜Ÿ©WKl[nc›

{nc}Lf`ljncœ.xac{|¤?Wf|_˜ac}z fjTyW†‡lXŸap}zy£†‡z¡fjT¯{n?_—fK¥PF¡W{Òf`†‡nc}®ƒ:zeWapœ¨_‹£†fjTžf`TWn”™?WljTyWKa?z zebyW f`n­f`TyW

}nc}e ¢ncxefj†Vacœ†fih

†‡} }¡byVŸ%WlXnc›gTyncx©_%np›gljncbyf`WK_K¥bF¡WK{f`†‡nc}¬‚­{ncVXxapljWK_Ÿ©ncf`T ¹©aD™cn?lj_›ncl_—n?VXW

_j{WK}aplj†‡n?_K¥

”' ) #"%$&')(X/

3šW[}yWWz_—n?VXWgxacljacV‹Wf`WKlj_mf`nVXnezeWKœfjTyWª}Wfi£#nclj¤˜†‡} a˜_—†‡VXxyœWªVap}y}yWKl8fjTa”fapœ‡œ‡n”£I_ f`n‹{n?V‹x©apljW

Ÿ%npfjTxyljnpf`ne{ncœ¡¹©aD™?ncl|_†}a[fjlja?{ÒfjacŸyœ‡W£#aDh?¥§STyWKh‹acl`W_`byVXVXacl`†SRWz‹ŸLhXS)apŸyœ‡WI€y¥s3­Wª_—byxx©nL_—WfjTa”f

fjTyW._`Tacx©Wmnc›ef`TyW.}yWfi£#nclj¤g†¨_§l`n?byŒcTyœ‡h-_if|apŸyœ‡W

fjTyW8x©apl|apVXWfjWl|_MŸ©WKœœ‡n”£žapljWm_`byxyx%n?_`WKz{nc}_—fjac}?f Map}©z

fjTa”fª†f[†‡_ªapœ‡£#aDhe_{n?}y}yW{Òf`WzM¥rs}²fjTyW_`W"LbyWœ4¸ZY zeW}yncf`W_f`TyW˜}¡byVŸ%Wlªnp› }ynezeWK_g†}:f`TyW}Wfi£#nclj¤%¸

IWfi£.n?l`¤xacljacVXWf`WKlj_

Y }¡byVŸ%Wlnc›)}ynezeW_

}¡byVŸ%Wlnc›)WzeŒcW_

Y aD™cWKljacŒcWªzyWŒcljWW[np› a‹}ynezeW

_ EY œ†‡}y¤zeW}_`†fih

k œ†‡}y¤ Ÿyl`Wap¤”apŒ?Wgl|a”fjW

VXncŸy†‡œ†fih

m aD™cWKljacŒcWgœ‡W}Œpf`Tnp› a‹l`n?bef`W

S§lja8{gxacljacVXWf`WKlj_

W ljncbyf`W'{ljWKapf`†‡nc}Ol|a”fjW

x%Wlg}ynezeW

q }¡byV˜Ÿ©WKlnp› ac{f`†‡™cW[l`n?bef`W_

x%Wlg}ynezeW

ac{f`†‡™¡†fih

kmljnpfjne{ncœMx©apl|apVXWfjWl|_

^ TyWKœœ‡nl|a”f`W

a fjncx%ncœ‡ncŒchOŸyl`nLaczy{Kac_—f.l|a”fjW

d aD™?Wl|apŒcW[_—†SRW-nc›§fjncx%ncœ‡ncŒchŸl`nLaczy{Kac_—f#xa?{|¤cWfj_

aD™?Wl|apŒcWª}¡byVŸ%Wlnc›)ljWfjljac}_—VX†¨_`_`†‡nc}_.x©WKlIŸyljn?a?zy{a?_if

c

EY Ÿyljn?a?zy{a?_ifncxyf`†‡V‹†SRKapf`†‡nc} ›ac{f`ncl

S)apŸyœ‡W€ k apl|apVXWf`Wl|_#b_`WKzOf`nap}©apœ‡h RKWªxl`ncf`ne{n?œ‡_#n”™cWKl`TWKaczA¥

fjTyW}¡byVŸ%Wlªnp› WKzyŒcWK_

£#W{n?}_`†‡zeWKlf`T©a”fIfi£#n}ynezeW_IapljWœ‡†}y¤?WKzPŸ¡hPap}PWKzeŒ?W†› f`TyWKhacl`WacŸyœW

fjn‹{ncVXVb}y†‡{Ka”fjW-zy†ljWK{f`œ‡hc¸¡WKa?{|TOnc}W[†¨_.f`TyWK}P}yW†‡ŒcT¡Ÿ%ncl#np› fjTyW-npfjTyWl Ò¸

fjTyW'aD™cWKljacŒcWgzeWKŒcljWW[np›§a

}n¡zyW

f`TyWzyWŒcljWW[†¨_#f`TyW'}¡byV˜Ÿ©WKl#nc›)}W†‡ŒcT¡Ÿ©n?lj_.np› a˜}ynezeW¥mSTyWzeW}©_—†fihnp›§f`TyW-}yWfi£.n?l`¤£†‡œ‡œAŸ©W

†‡VXx©n?l—f|ap}Lfg†‡}:fjTyW›n?œœ‡n”£†}ŒOap}acœhe_`†‡_K¸£#W£†‡œ‡œ fjTLb©_gb_`W'fjTyW

Ir* /E&

_

Y\[

EY ¥

S§nOVXnezeWKœ§VXncŸ†œ‡†fih?¸<£.W˜†}Lf`ljnezeb{W k ¸<f`TW‹aD™?Wl|apŒcW-}¡byV˜Ÿ©WKlªnc›mœ†‡}y¤²ŸyljWKac¤DacŒcWx%Wl[œ‡†}y¤²zebl`†‡}yŒ a

_`WK{nc}z

aœ‡†}y¤²œ¨ac_—fj_Qk _`WK{nc}z_g†‡}šaD™?Wl|apŒ?WÒ¥H3šWac_j_—bV‹W˜f`T©a”f'†f†¨_-{n?}_if|ap}Lf'ap}z„f`Tapf'œ†‡}y¤

{l`Wa”fj†n?}'Ÿapœ¨ap}{WK_ œ†‡}y¤'ŸyljWKac¤DacŒcW

†‡_)_`byxyx%n?_`WKz{nc}_—fjac}Lf Ò¸

kœ‡†}y¤e_K¸”†}f`ncfjapœ4¸”apljW.{l`Wa”f`Wz

x%Wl#_—W{n?}zM¥ Inpfj†‡{Wf`T©a”f.†f8†¨_mœ‡ncŒ?†‡{Kapœefjn_—bxyx©nL_—WIf`Tapf8f`TWf`ncfjapœ©}¡byVŸ%Wl.np›Mœ†‡}y¤X{ljWKapf`†‡nc}ncl8œ†‡}y¤

Ÿl`Wap¤”apŒ?W†‡_[xyljncx%ncl`f`†‡nc}©apœAfjnOfjTyWX}¡byVŸ%Wl[np›8œ‡†‡}y¤e_¥¦g}ynpfjTyWl[xacljacV‹Wf`WKl[zeWKx©WK}ze†‡}yŒVXac†}œh²n?}

fjTyW_`Tapx%W-np›)f`TyW'}yWfi£.n?l`¤†¨_#f`TWaD™cWl|apŒ?Wgœ‡W}yŒcf`T m }¡byVŸ%Wlgnp›Tyncx_ .np›aXl`n?bef`W?¥

u.n?}{WKl`}y†‡}yŒ{nc}Lf`ljncœyn”™?WljTyWKa?zM¸”£#WIVap†‡}yœh‹}yWKWKz‹f`nV‹nezeWKœyfjlja8{{l`Wa”fj†n?}A¥ Wf-W zeWK}ynpfjWf`TyW

aD™?Wl|apŒ?W}¡byVŸ%Wl-np›#l`n?bef`WX{ljWKapf`†‡nc}­ŸLh:a }ynezeWzebylj†‡}yŒ²a _`WK{nc}zM¥‹¦I}yncf`TyWKl-†}e¹©byW}LfxacljacV‹Wf`WKl

†¨_gf`TyWX}¡byVŸ%Wl[np›#_—†‡Vbyœfjac}yWn?b_ga?{Òfj†™?WljncbefjWK_ªx©WKl[}n¡zyWc¸MzeW}npf`Wz:Ÿ¡h\q%¥'STy†‡_[VXnezeWœ)†¨_ªl|a”fjTyWl

_`†‡V‹xœW-Ÿybefª†fI†¨__—b 8{†WK}Lff`n{n?V‹x©apljWgfjTyW-fi£.nXljncbefj†}ŒXacxyxyljn?a?{|TyWK_K¥

F¡n?VXWxapl|apVXWfjWl|_ªzyWx%W}z n?}„fjTyWxyljnpf`ne{ncœ¨_¥XqIWKœœ‡n²xyljnpf`ne{ncœ¨_ª†‡}{œbzyWl`WKŒcbyœ¨apl-TyWKœœ‡n?_K¸ ap}©z

ljWŒ?byœ¨aplŸl`nLaczy{Kac_—f`†‡}yŒ„nc›If`n?x©n?œn?Œch †}y›ncljVXapf`†‡nc}A¥ AWf ^®ap}©zba Ÿ%Wf`TyWP}¡byV˜Ÿ©WKl‹nc›gTyWKœœ‡n?_Xap}©z

Ÿl`nLaczy{Kac_—f˜†‡}e›ncljVa”f`†‡nc}¯xac{|¤?Wf|_ljWK_`x©W{Òfj†™?Wœ‡h WVX†f`f`Wz Ÿ¡hžaš}ynezeWPzebylj†}yŒ a _—W{n?}zM¥

¦Iœ‡œIxa” 

l|apVXWf`Wl|_gacl`W˜WdexyljWK_j_—Wz²†‡}:f`WKl`V_ªnp›8l|a”fjWK_gf`nŸ©WX{n?}_`†‡_—f`WK}?f¥­¦g_[TyWKœœ‡nOxl`ncf`ne{n?œ‡_[ze†¨_`{n”™cWlgf`TyW

fjncx%ncœ‡ncŒ?hf`Tl`n?byŒcTf`TWTyWœ‡œ‡n?_K¸©aTyWKœœ‡nxa?{|¤cWfIVXac†}œh†}©{œ‡bzeWK_If`TyW˜œ†¨_—fgnp› }yWK†Œ?TLŸ%ncl|_nc› a}ynezeWc¥

r¢f|__`†RKW‹†¨_[f`T¡b_apxyxyljnDde†Vapf`Wœ‡h a?zyzeljWK_j_—W_¥AWf d zyW}yncf`W‹f`TyW aD™cWl|apŒ?W_`†RKWnp›8fjTyWXf`n?x©n?œn?Œch

x©ac{|¤cWfj_Ÿyljn?a?zy{a?_ifjWKz Ÿ¡h aX}ynezeW?¥.qIWKœœ‡nxyljnpfjne{ncœ¨_{ac}Pb_—W-fjTyW†‡lg¤¡}yn”£œ‡WKzyŒcW-np›)f`TyWf`ncx%ncœ‡ncŒ?hf`n

n?xef`†‡VX†RKWªŸl`nLaczy{Kac_—f`†‡}yŒ¥§rizeWKacœœ‡hc¸rY WVX†¨_`_`†‡nc}_#apljWg_`b68{†‡W}Lf.fjn˜Ÿl`nLaczy{Kac_—f.ap}†‡}e›n?l`Va”fj†n?}f`n

WK™cWKl`h }ynezeWc¥gST†‡_gTac_If`nOŸ%W˜{ncVXxacl`WzOfjnY WKV‹†¨_j_—†‡nc}_›nclªa¹n¡neze†}Œ¥ AWf Ÿ©Wf`TyW‹aD™cWKljacŒcW

}¡byV˜Ÿ©WKlnp›-WVX†¨_`_`†n?}_˜f`nža?{|Ty†WK™cWPašŸyl`nLaczy{Kac_—fK¸.£.W²zeWK}ynpfjW²ŸLhPc:f`TW²Ÿyl`nLaczy{Kac_—f‹n?xef`†‡VX†Ra”fj†n?}

›a?{Òfjncl¸

c

EY

_ c Ò¥

J)œ‡nLneze†‡}yŒ[xyljnpf`ne{ncœ¨_ VaDh'†‡}{œ‡bzeWTyWKœœ‡n?_§›ncl zeWf`W{Òf`†‡}yŒ[œ†‡}y¤Ÿl`Wap¤”apŒ?Wc¥L^˜£†‡œœ¡fjTyW}Xapœ¨_—n[zeW}npf`W

fjTyW†‡l8l|a”fjWc¥ vgf`TyWKl`£†¨_—WfjTyWgœ‡†‡}y¤˜œ¨aDhcWKl †‡_8b_`WKz˜f`nzyWf`W{Òf8œ‡†‡}y¤˜Ÿl`Wap¤”apŒ?Wc¥ rs}XfjTa”f#{ac_`Wc¸Lap}†‡}Lf`WljWK_—f— 

†‡}yŒ˜xapl|apVXWfjWlm†¨_8f`TyW[VX†}y†‡Vapœ©f`†‡VXWªŸ%Wfi£#WWK}fi£.n˜{nc}©_—W{befj†™?W¹n¡neze†}Œ?_8›ncl.aydeWKzzyWK_—f`†‡}a”fj†n?}

›ljncV f`TyW_japVXW_—n?bylj{Wc¥§r¢f†¨_Ÿ%ncby}zyWKz‹Ÿ¡h'f`TyW#fj†VXWf`T©a”ff`TyWljWxœh'›ljncV f`TyWzeW_ifj†}apf`†‡nc}‹}yWWzy_)f`n

ljWKa?{|T‹f`TyW[_—n?bylj{Wc¥)S8h¡xy†¨{acœœ‡hc¸?†f#†‡_8†}fjTyWª_japVXWn?ljzeWKlmnp›AVacŒc}y†f`bzyWgac_mf`TyWITWœ‡œnx%Wlj†‡n¡z

apljncb}z

Y'_`WK{nc}z ¥v3­W'£†‡œœAf`T¡b_b_`W ^ ›nclf`T†‡_fj†VXW?¥

3šWapljW-}yn”£ acŸyœW[fjnXac}apœ‡hrRW-xyljnpfjn¡{ncœ<n”™cWKl`TWKacz_8nc›)Ÿ%npfjT ¹%aD™cncl|_K¥

˜" žI #"%$&')(

3šW{nc}_`†‡zyWl†‡}Pf`Ty†¨_g_`WK{f`†‡nc}Pf`TW{n?}?fjl`n?œMn”™cWKl`TyWaczO†}:ad¡Wz}yWfi£#nclj¤<¥.STyWa?zyze†f`†‡nc}acœ {nL_ifInc›

VXn?Ÿy†œ‡†fihO†¨_{nc}©_—†¨zeWljWKz †‡} fjTyW}yWd¡fg_—W{Òf`†‡nc} ¥mSTyW'Vap†‡}P{nc}Lf`ljncœ<n”™?WljTyWKa?znp›)¹n¡neze†‡}yŒXxyl`ncf`ne{n?œ‡_

†¨_[zebyWfjnf`TW¹n¡neze†‡}yŒ?_K¥[vª}yW¹n¡n¡zy†}yŒ {n?_—fj_gf`TWWVX†¨_`_`†‡nc}²np›)Y x©ac{|¤cWfj_gnp›8{n?}_—fjap}Lfª_`†SRWc¥-vª}

fjTyW²npfjTyWlT©ap}zM¸.f`TW²VXac†}®{n?}Lf`ljncœn”™cWKl`TWKaczžnp›-TyWœ‡œn xyljnpfjne{ncœ¨_‹†‡_f`TyW²x%Wlj†neze†¨{WVX†¨_`_`†n?}¯nc›

TWœ‡œnL_8£Ty†¨{|TOT©aD™cWga‹_—†SRWªxyljncx%ncl`f`†‡nc}acœyf`n

¥ AWf ^ Ÿ©Wªf`TWª}¡byV˜Ÿ©WKl#nc› TyWKœœ‡n?_.x©WKl_—W{nc}©zM¥)STWh

{n?_—fC^ZY x©ac{|¤cWfj_.x©WKlI_—W{n?}zM¥STyW'{n?_—f{ap}apœ¨_—n‹Ÿ%WªW_ifj†Va”fjWKz †} f`WKl`V_#np›§Ÿap}zy£†‡z¡fjT ma˜TyWœ‡œn

x©ac{|¤cWf8_—†SRWg†‡_

fj†VXW_mfjTyWgaczzel`W_`_mœWK}yŒpfjTj9¡TyWœ‡œnL_ fjTLb©_mb_`Wga'Ÿac}ze£†¨z¡f`TOnp› ^ Y

^ _ Y\[

f`TyW

†‡VXxyœ‡†‡{†fIby}†fih †‡_#fjTyWaczyzyl`W_`__`†RKW-x©WKlI_—W{nc}©z Ò¥ gn”£'¸eœWfIb_ŒcnX†‡}VXn?l`W-zeWf|ap†‡œ‡_K¥

"!

S§n­{l`Wa”fjW a­l`n?bef`W †} ¹n¡n¡zy†}yŒ­xyljnpf`ne{ncœ¨_¸fjTyW_`ncblj{WOVap¤?WK_a„¹n¡neze†‡}yŒ­ac}z fjTyWzyWK_—f`†‡}a”fj†n?}

_`W}©zy_aljWxyœ‡hXŸ¡hXf`TyW-ljncbefjWI›ncœ‡œ‡n”£.WzŸ¡hXf`TyW l|_ifxa?{|¤cWf#np›§f`TyWª¹n¡neze†}Œ˜†fl`W{W†‡™cW_¥STy†¨_{n?_—fj_

WZY$#b]Y ` m egxac{|¤?Wf|_Inp›8{nc}_—fjac}Lfª_—†SRW˜x©WKl'_—W{nc}©zM¥ª¦&¹n¡neze†}ŒOxa?{|¤cWfªVXac†}œh²{n?}Lfjap†‡}_gf`TyW

a?zyzeljWK_j_—W_np› fjTyWX_—n?bylj{Wap}©z:zeWK_—f`†‡}apf`†‡nc}:nc› f`TyW‹l`n?bef`W?¸%ac}zPfjTyW˜a?zyzeljWK_j_Inp›8f`TyW˜WVX†f`f`WKlªnc›mf`TyW

x©ac{|¤cWfK¥gSTWŸac}ze£†¨z¡f`Tš{n?_—fª†¨_gf`T¡b_[apxyxyljnDde†Vapf`Wœ‡h V W YP]Y ` m-eÒ¥ªqgWœ‡œn xyljnpf`ne{ncœ¨_ITaD™?W'f`TyW

a?ze™”ap}LfjacŒcW.np›©T©aD™L†‡}yŒ-apœ‡œel`n?bef`W_)l`Waczeh-›n?l)b©_—Wap}©z˜zen-}yncf VXac¤cWap}¡h'n”™cWKl`TWKacza”f l`n?bef`W{ljWKapf`†‡nc}A¥

vª} f`TW'npf`TWlTac}zM¸efjTyW†‡l ydeWKzP{n?}Lf`ljncœ<n”™cWKl`TyWacz†‡}{œbzyWK_fjTyW{nL_ifnp›)l`n?bef`W'{l`Wa”f`†‡nc} ¥

&% '(*)!+,-./0 "!

rs} aPTyWKœœ‡nPxyl`ncf`ne{n?œ5¸MWac{|Tš}ynezeWXWVX†fj_'WK™cWljh ^ _—W{n?}z­aTyWKœœ‡n²{n?}?f|ap†‡}y†‡}yŒOfjTyWœ‡†‡_—fnp›#}ynezeWK_

›ljncV £Ty†¨{|Tž†f‹TWKapl|_TWœ‡œnL_ap}©z †f|_‹n”£} aczyzyl`W_`_

` aczyzeljWK_j_`WK_ Ò¥„STy†¨_‹apœ‡œn”£I_f`n„†‡Œc}ncljW

b}y†‡zy†ljWK{f`†‡nc}acœ8œ‡†}y¤e_|98VXncljWn”™?Wl¸§Wac{|T }ynezeWœ‡WKaplj}_f`TyWœne{Kapœmfjncx%ncœ‡ncŒ?h­byx f`n ˆ²Tyn?x_

a:}ynezeW

¤¡}yn”£I_O†f|_}yW†‡ŒcT¡Ÿ%ncl|_Oap}©z f`TW­}yWK†Œ?T¡Ÿ©n?lj_Onp›Wac{|T«n?}yW¥ STy†¨_œne{Kapœ[†}e›n?l`Vapf`†‡nc}«†¨_Ob©_—Wz f`n

n?xef`†‡VX†RKWŸyljn?acz{ac_—f`†‡}yŒ©¥,Jncl'WdyacV‹xœWV˜byœfj† ¢x%nc†‡}?fljWœ¨aDh:_`Wfj_apljWX{ncVXxybefjWKzš†‡}žv sFe\'¥ASTyW_—W

_`Wf|_gacœœ‡n”£«fjnW8{†‡W}LfjœhŸyljn?acz{ac_—f

_`WW4Y‰Q7 ›n?lª_`ncVXWap}acœhe_`†‡_ Ò¥qIWKœœ‡n?_If`T¡b_ª{n?_—fA^ZYxac{|¤?Wfj_

x%WlI_`WK{nc}zap}©za‹Ÿac}ze£†¨z¡f`TPnc›v^L]

` Qe=Y ¥

S§nO{n?VXxybef`W'ljncbyf`WK_K¸©aXVX†‡}y†‡VXacœ§_`byŸ_`Wfgnc›§fjTyW'fjncx%ncœ‡ncŒch Tac_f`nŸ%WŸyljn?a?zy{a?_ifjWKzM¥mrs}­v sFe\'¸

fjTyW'¤¡}yn”£œ‡WKzeŒ?W[nc›acœœAf`TyWV˜byœf`† 4x%nc†‡}LfIl`WKœ‡aDhO_`Wf|_†¨_I_—b 8{†WK}Lff`n{n?VXxybef`W_`Tyn?l—fjWK_—fIxa”fjTljncbyf`WK_

_—WKWU4YNL¸MYˆ¡¸ YK€Q7M›n?lV‹n?l`W-zeWfjap†‡œ¨_%¥mSTy†‡_Ÿl`nLaczy{Kac_—f`†‡}yŒ˜{n?_—fj_cY WKVX†‡_j_—†‡nc}x%WlŸyljn?a?zy{a?_if¸?fjTa”f

†¨_a6cY\['xa?{|¤cWfj_x%WlI_`WK{n?}zM¸yac}z aXŸ©ap}ze£†¨z¡fjTnc›La6cdY\[L¥

3 †f`Tap}XaczapxefjWKzvGF¡k)J#¸pnc}W#£#ncbœ‡zWdex©W{Òf)d

` ?¥Lu#befm†‡}‹a-zeWK}_—W}yWfi£.n?l`¤<¸pa-{acl`W›byœ‡œh

_`Wœ‡WK{f`Wz_—byŸ©_—Wf.np› _`†SRWU]Yemnc›<f`TyWU]Y\[Qefjncx%ncœ‡ncŒchX_`Tyncbyœ¨zXŸ%Wª_`b68{†‡W}LfK¥ ¦I}Oncxefj†VX†SRWKzTyWœ‡œn

xl`ncf`ne{n?œL_`Tyncbœ‡zTaD™cWaª_`Vapœ‡œ6d¡¥ vª}f`TyWnpfjTyWlTac}zM¸”fjTyW¤¡}yn”£œWzeŒcW.np›yfjTyW#›byœ‡œ¡f`ncx%ncœ‡ncŒ?h'œne{Kapœ‡œh

acœœ‡n”£I_f`n aD™cn?†‡z b©_—WKœW_`_‹ljWf`l|ap}©_—VX†¨_`_`†n?}_‹zebylj†}yŒšŸyljn?a?zy{a?_ifj†}yŒ©¥žrizeWapœ‡œh?¸8WKa?{|T ljWfjljac}_—VX†¨_`_`†‡nc}

£#ncbœ‡z‹†‡}e›ncljV }yWK£¬}n¡zyWK_K¥)rs}xlja?{Òf`†¨{W?¸c£†f`Tac}ncxefj†VX†SRWKzXTWœ‡œnxl`ncf`ne{n?œ5¸pn?}yœ‡h‹a-x%Wl|{WK}?f|apŒ?W

nc›<f`TyWKV £†‡œ‡œŸ%Wg}yWK£œh‹†}y›ncljV‹WzM¸LhL†‡Wœ¨ze†‡}yŒHc U]Y eÒ¥

F¡WKW 4‡YQNL¸©YK‰e¸%Yˆe¸YK€7›ncl#zeWf|ap†‡œ‡_.apŸ%ncbef

_`b{|Tncxefj†VX†SRKapf`†‡nc}_K¥,F¡WKW F¡WK{f`†‡nc}²‚˜›nclI_`ncVXW-WK_—f`†‡VXapf`†‡nc}_nc›LcXap}z d¡¥

STyW ydeWKzHn”™cWKl`TyWacz®nc›TyWœ‡œ‡n xyljnpfjn¡{ncœ¨_O†¨_ f`T¡b_ ]^\` a e=Yxac{|¤?Wf|_x%Wl²_—W{n?}zM¸gb©_—†‡}yŒ¯a

Ÿ©ap}ze£†¨z¡fjTnc›-](^ _G` a6cde=Y [ ¥

r¢›.a¹n¡neze†}ŒOxyljnpfjn¡{ncœ§b_—W_gTWœ‡œnL_Ifjn zeWf`WK{f[œ‡†‡}y¤²ŸyljWKap¤”acŒcWc¸©†f|_[TyWœ‡œn n”™cWKl`TyWacz£†‡œœ)Ÿ©W>^ZY

x©ac{|¤cWfj_‹x%WlO_`WK{nc}zM¸.b_`†}yŒžašŸac}ze£†¨z¡f`T®nc›H^ZY ¥ 3šW²£†œ‡œI}yWKŒcœ‡WK{ÒfXfjTy†‡_œ†‡}yWKaclX›ac{f`ncl†‡}¬f`TyW

_`W"LbyWKœ

ap}z¤?WWKxnc}yœ‡h "?b©aczel|a”fj†‡{fjWljV_%¥ u.n?}L™?Wl|_—WKœhf`n˜£Ta”f8n?}yWg£#ncbœ‡z‹fjTy†}¤a”fl|_—f.Œcœ¨ap}©{Wc¸

¹©nLneze†‡}yŒ[xyljnpf`ne{ncœ¨_ zen[†}¡™?ncœ‡™cW.a ydeWKz˜{n?}?fjl`n?œ?n”™?WljTyWKa?z-W™?W}£†f`Tncbef TyWKœœ‡n?_)ap}zl`n?bef`W{ljWKapf`†‡nc}

a?_f`TWljW†‡_ªap}:a?{Òf`†‡™cWl`n?bef`W-fj†VXWn?bef

›nclªV‹n?Ÿy†‡œ†fih Vac}apŒ?WVXW}LfIljWKac_`nc}©_%¸aljncbefjW'VXaDhWdexy†‡ljW

†›I†f˜†¨_}yncfb_`WKz ›ljW"LbyWK}Lf`œ‡h­WK}yncbyŒ?TA¥3šWO†‡}?fjWŒ?ljapf`WfjTy†‡_˜n”™cWKl`TWKacz­†‡} f`TyW xyljW™¡†n?b_-›a?{Òf`n?lŸ¡h

_`byxyx%n?_`†‡}yŒ‹f`Tapf$WP†‡_#fjTyW'l|a”f`W-nc›§ljncbefjW-{l`Wa”fj†n?} n?l#ljW›ljWK_`Ty†‡}yŒa”›ÖfjWlf`†‡VXWn?befK¥

˜" žI !"§ 'PÒ"

rs} Ÿ©ncf`T¯{Kac_`WK_K¸§VXn?Ÿy†œ‡†fihš†¨_˜™L†¨_`†Ÿyœ‡WfjTyljncbyŒ?Tžœ†‡}y¤ ŸyljWKac¤DacŒcWac}zž{ljWKapf`†‡nc}A¥­¦ œ‡†}¤šŸl`Wap¤”apŒ?W†‡_

zyWf`W{ÒfjWKz W†f`TyWKl£TyW}P_—n?VXW[TWœ‡œnL_#acl`W[}ynXVXncljWªljWK{W†‡™cWzncl£TyWK}a˜œ‡†}y¤O›ap†‡œbl`W[†‡_ljWx%ncl`f`WzŸ¡h

fjTyW'œ‡†}y¤Oœ‡aDh?Wl¥

3 TW}:aXœ‡†}y¤ŸyljWKac¤DacŒcW-ne{{bylj_I†}:aljncbyf`Wc¸yf`TyWljncbyf`†‡}yŒ†}y›ncljVXapf`†‡nc}PVb©_ifgŸ%W'"Lby†¨{|¤¡œh byx%za”f`WzM¥

rs}¹n¡neze†‡}yŒxyljnpfjn¡{ncœ¨_¸yaXx©ac{|¤cWf†‡_I_`W}LffjnXf`TyW_`ncblj{Wª£Ty†¨{|T²xyljne{WWzy_#f`nljncbyf`W'{ljWKapf`†‡nc}A¥8ST†‡_

fjT¡b_g{ncljl`W_—x%nc}z_#f`nOa>k #m #qrY ljapf`Wnc›¹n¡n¡zy†}yŒ zebyW'fjnœ†‡}y¤ŸyljWKap¤”acŒcW

aœ‡†‡}y¤PŸyl`Wap¤”apŒ?W-†‡_

T©apljV‹œ‡WK_j_#£TyW}}yn‹l`n?bef`W-b_`WK_.fjTyW'œ†‡}y¤ Ò¥m{nc}_`†¨zeWlj†}Œf`T©a”fœ†‡}y¤ Ÿyl`Wap¤”apŒ?WªzeWf`W{Òf`†‡nc}†¨_Ÿ©n?by}zeWz

Ÿ¡h^:ac}zf`TapfgfjTyWl|a”fjWa”fg£T†‡{|T:a}n¡zyWVap¤?WK_¹n¡neze†‡}yŒ?_I›ncl[aydeWKz²zeW_ifj†}©a”f`†‡nc}²†¨_ªŸ©n?by}zeWz

Ÿ¡h ^ ¸yac_ze†¨_j{b_j_—WzO†‡}\F¡WK{f`†‡nc}²ˆe¸¡fjTy†‡_l|a”fjW-†‡_acœ£aDhe_8Ÿ%ncby}©zeWKzŸ¡h^A¥mSTW[n”™?WljTyWKa?zzebyW-fjnXœ†‡}y¤

Ÿl`Wap¤”apŒ?Wª†¨_#f`T¡b_CfUhSi ]lkjqrmno^ZqretY # ]Y `Pm e#x©ac{|¤cWfj_#np›)f`Tl`WKW-a?zyzeljWK_j_—W_#x©WKlI_—W{nc}©zM¥

STyW-n?}yœh {ac_`W[£TyWljW'ap}OTWœ‡œnXxyljnpfjn¡{ncœ<£†‡œœMVap¤?W[a?zyze†f`†‡nc}acœA{n?}?fjl`n?œ%zybyW-f`nXœ‡†}y¤OŸyl`Wap¤”apŒ?W

†¨_ £TyWK}a-œ†‡}y¤‹np›%f`TyWIŸl`nLaczy{Kac_—f`WKzf`n?x©n?œn?ŒchŸyljWKac¤e_¥)¦I}aczze†fj†n?}apœŸyl`nLaczy{Kac_—f)x©ac{|¤cWfmbyx<zya”fj†}yŒ

fjTy†¨_†‡}e›ncljVa”fj†n?} †‡_f`TyWK}žŸyljn?a?zy{a?_ifjWKzM¥:STyW xyljncŸacŸy†œ‡†fih:f`T©a”f‹a„œ†‡}y¤ ŸyljWKac¤DacŒcWne{{byl|_†‡} f`TyW

Ÿl`nLaczy{Kac_—f`WKz[fjncx%ncœ‡ncŒ?h[†¨_sd ¥)¦¯}ynezeW#£†œ‡œLf`T¡b__`W}z˜ap}˜a?zyze†f`†‡nc}acœ?Ÿl`nLaczy{Kac_—f xac{|¤?Wf)£†fjT˜l|a”fjW

kjd¡¥qIn”£#W™?WlMfjTy†¨_§l|a”fjW.†¨_§Ÿ©n?by}zeWzŸ¡h[f`TyW#œ‡†}y¤'Ÿl`Wap¤”apŒ?W8zeWfjWK{f`†‡nc}l|a”fjW

^ ¥)STyWaczze†fj†n?}apœ

n”™?WljTyWKa?zXzebyWªf`nœ‡†‡}y¤ŸyljWKap¤”acŒcWI†‡}TyWKœœ‡n˜xl`ncf`ne{n?œ‡_8†‡_8f`T¡b_-fUhiL]lkjdn^ZetY+#,cY f,hSi ]kjdno^pe?cY\[

x©ac{|¤cWfj_#x%Wlg_`WK{nc}zO£†fjT:a˜Ÿ©ap}ze£†¨z¡fjTnc›LfUhSiL]lkjdno^pe]dC`"e?cY\[?¥

J§œ‡n¡neze†}Œ‹xl`ncf`ne{n?œ‡_

ka?{|¤cWfj_ u#ac}ze£†¨z¡f`T

J)†deWKzn”™?WljTyWKa?z W Y

[ V W Y

[

w²ncŸ†œ‡†fih n”™cWKl`TyWacz fUhi ]kjm n^Zetq Y[ VTfUhSij]lkjm n^ZetqrY\[

qIWKœœ‡nxyljnpfjn¡{ncœ¨_

ka?{|¤cWfj_ uap}zy£†‡z¡fjT

J)†deWKzn”™cWKl`TyWacz a6cY\[ ]^Z_$` a6cdetY\[

w:ncŸy†‡œ†fihOn”™?WljTyWKa?z fUhSi ]lkjdno^pe?cY\[ fUhSiL]kjdno^pe=dQcY\[

S)apŸœW,5 [w:ap†‡}­{nc}Lf`lj†Ÿbef`†‡nc}„f`WljV_ªf`nP{nc}Lfjl`n?œ§n”™?WljTyWKa?z²†}šacz¡ ¢Tyne{˜}yWfi£#nclj¤Pxyl`ncf`ne{n?œ‡_K¥˜u.n?_—fj_

acl`W[Œc†‡™cWK} †‡}P}¡byVŸ%Wlnc›)xa?{|¤cWfj_#x©WKlI_—W{n?}zO†‡}PŸap}©ze£†‡zef`TA¥

&% *

¦!œ‡†}y¤ {l`Wa”f`†‡nc}H†‡_ }ynpfP}yncf`†¨{WKz«†}H¹n¡n¡zy†}yŒ¯xyljnpf`ne{ncœ¨_by}Lf`†‡œ'a }W£ ljncbefjW„b_`†}Œžf`TW­œ‡†}¤ †‡_

{l`Wa”fjWKzM¥gn„aczze†fj†n?}apœ n”™?WljTyWKa?z:fjT¡b_'ne{{bylj_K¥ ¦ª_apŸ%n”™cW?¸AfjTyWnc}yœ‡h­a?zyze†f`†‡nc}acœmn”™cWKl`TWKacz:›ncl

TWœ‡œn²xyljnpfjne{ncœ¨_'VaDh­{ncVXW›ljncVa²Ÿyljn?acz{ac_—f-f`n?x©n?œn?Œch:byx<zyapf`†‡}yŒ¥\u#bef†‡} f`TWO{a?_—Wnc›a:œ†‡}y¤

{l`Wa”fj†n?}A¸ef`TWljW†‡_g}yn}yWKWKzf`n _—WK}z²ap}:a?zyze†f`†‡nc}acœAbyx<zya”fjWxa?{|¤cWfIŸ%W›n?l`W-fjTyWx%Wlj†‡n¡zy†‡{-n?}yWc¥ In

a?zyze†f`†‡nc}acœMn”™cWKl`TyWaczne{K{byl|_†}PŸ%npfjTxl`ncf`ne{n?œ‡_K¥

S)apŸyœ‡WU5²_—byVXVaplj†SRWK_gf`TWap}acœhe_`†‡_ªnp›#Ÿ©ncf`T xyljnpf`ne{ncœ)¹©aD™cn?lj_ª{n?}?fjl`n?œn”™cWljTyWaczM¥STWh:Ÿ%npfjT

†‡}{œbzyWap} U]Y\["e-n”™cWKl`TWKaczA¥%3šW}yn”£ ›n¡{b_'n?}šac}šncf`TyWKl-fih¡x©Wnc›#n”™?WljTyWKa?z gfjlja8{˜†‡}{l`Wac_`W

Ÿ%WK{Kapb_`W-np›)}ync}e ¢ncxyf`†‡VXacœMl`n?bef`W_¥

!

"§ šO"§/ I

qgWœ‡œn xyljnpf`ne{ncœ¨_ITaD™?Wf`TW‹a?ze™”ap}LfjacŒcWnc›8{ncVXxybyf`†‡}yŒ n?xef`†‡Vapœ)l`n?bef`W_ 4‡YQN"74¥u.nc}©_ifjl`b{f`†‡}yŒOljncbyf`WK_

Ÿ¡hO¹n¡n¡zy†}yŒO†‡_g™cWljh _`†‡V‹xœWŸbefgVaDhOœ‡WKa?zf`n}yn?}e ¢ncxefj†Vapœ l`n?bef`W_ "Lby†fjWnp›ÖfjW}A¥STyW˜ap}acœhe_`†‡_nc›

fjTyW'œ‡W}yŒcf`T²np›)f`TW'l`n?bef`W_ncŸef|ap†‡}yWKz Ÿ¡h¹n¡neze†‡}yŒ†¨_ "Lby†fjW'f`lj†¨{|¤Lh?¥g3šW'£†œ‡œ ljWK_—f`lj†‡{fncbyl|_—WKœ™?WK_.f`na

n?}yWªzy†VXW}©_—†‡nc}acœMap}acœhe_`†‡_.ap}z _—†‡Vbyœ¨a”fj†n?}_.†}Ofi£.n‹ze†VXWK}_—†‡nc}©apœM_—x©ac{W?¥ u.n?}_`†‡zeWKl`†‡}yŒ‹a'¹n¡neze†‡}yŒ¸

£#WO{Kapœ‡œ ¹n¡neze†}Œ„ze†¨_if|ap}{Wnp›Ia²}ynezeWf`TyWœ‡W}Œpf`T nc›f`TyW {nc}©_ifjl`b{f`Wz l`n?bef`WX›ljncV!f`TyW¹n¡n¡zy†}yŒ

_`ncblj{Wmf`n[fjTyW}ynezeWc¥s3­W{Kapœ‡œyze†‡_—fjac}{W#np›<ag}n¡zyW.fjTyWœWK}yŒpfjT˜nc›%ac}ncxyf`†‡VXacœel`n?bef`W.›ljncV,f`TW_`ncblj{W

fjn‹f`TyW'}ynezeW?¥T3­Wacl`W-Œ?nc†‡}yŒfjn‹f`ljhf`nXW_ifj†Va”fjW-f`TyW-l|a”fj†n‹¹n¡neze†‡}yŒze†‡_—fjac}{W-n”™?Wlze†¨_if|ap}{Wc¥

! "/ ""/ -

Febyxyx%n?_`W-f`TyW}n¡zyWK_gacl`W'zeWK}_`Wœ‡hOxyœ¨ac{WKzPnc}²aXœ‡†}Wc¥-3­W{nc}_`†¨zeWlfjTyWxyljncxacŒ?apf`†‡nc}np› a‹¹n¡n¡zy†}yŒ

n?}‹f`TyWx%n?_`†fj†™?WI_—†¨zeWnp›%f`TWga”de†¨_VXa?zeWŸ¡hfjTyWœ†‡}yW?¥STWnclj†Œ?†}‹np›%f`TyWIapde†‡_†¨_f`TW¹n¡neze†}Œ-_`ncblj{W

a?_8n?l`†‡Œc†‡}Oac}z†fj_#by}y†f†‡_8f`TW[l|ap}ŒcWInc›§a}n¡zyW

ap}OWKVX†‡_j_—†‡nc} a”fx©nL_—†f`†‡nc}{n”™cWl|_ nH` Ò¥

¦#fa!d¡Wzfj†VXWªf`TyW[}ynezeWK_.£†‡œœ‡†}ŒfjnljW ¢WVX†f.f`TyW[xa?{|¤cWf.›ncljVazeWK}_—W-_`Wf†}Oac}O†‡}Lf`Wlj™”apœ n4¥

¦g}¡hO}ynezeW†‡}Pf`T©a”fg_`WfgVaDh _`b{K{WWz†}PWVX†f—fj†}yŒ

f`T†‡_g†‡_ªzebyW'fjnljac}zencVX†SRKapf`†‡nc}†}PfjTyW{|Tap}}yWœ

1

1 1 1 1

1

new limit

1 1

2 3

0

x x x x x

1 2 3 n−1 n

nodes reached by the flooding uninformed nodes

y_n

distance flooding distance

limit

xn+1

y yn+1

n+1

(a)

(b)

(c) ^xn+1

J)†‡ŒcbyljWY#

a J)œ‡n¡n¡zy†}yŒzy†‡_—fjac}{W'™?Wl|_—b_zy†‡_—fjac}{Wap›Öf`Wlgf`TyW'WKVX†‡_j_—†‡nc}Pnc›

¥-@ª†¨_`{nc}Lf`†‡}¡by†fj†W_†‡}

fjTy†¨_[›by}{Òfj†n?} apljWX{Kapœ‡œWz„œ‡†‡V‹†fj_K¥¦ œ†‡VX†f†¨_acœ£aDhe_ªapf-x%n?_`†f`†‡nc} ` ‹›ncl_`ncVXW `¥

Ÿ u#ac_`W

£TWljWf`TyWg}yWd¡f.WKVX†‡_j_—†‡nc}Xn?}f`TyWgl`†‡ŒcTLf8nc›

†‡_8nc}XfjTyWgœ‡W›Öf#np›<f`TyWªœ†‡VX†f

`

¥

{.u#a?_—WI£TWljW

fjTyW'}yWdLfWKV‹†¨_j_—†‡nc}nc}f`TW'l`†‡ŒcTLfnp›

†‡_n?}OfjTyW'lj†Œ?T?fnc› f`TW'œ†‡VX†f

`

¥

a?{{WK_j_.xl`ncf`ne{n?œ¥)S§n‹›ncœ‡œn”£«n?}OfjTyW-Wd¡f`WK}_`†n?} nc› f`T†‡_†‡}Lf`Wlj™”apœ4¸e£.W[nc}œh›ne{b_nc}Of`TyW'WKV‹†¨_j_—†‡nc}_

fjTa”f[ne{{blI†}:f`TyW˜†}Lf`WKl`™”acœ n

f`TWnpfjTyWl|_Izen }ynpf[{|Tap}yŒ?Wap}¡hLf`Ty†‡}yŒfjnf`TWxyljncxacŒ?apf`†‡nc}

xl`ne{W_`_[ap}©z²f`TW¹n¡neze†‡}yŒPze†‡_—fjac}{W Ò¥' Wf

¸ Ÿ%W˜fjTyW‹x©nL_—†f`†‡nc}­np›mfjTyW lj_—f-WVX†‡_j_`†n?}„†‡}

n ¢¸¥‡¥‡¥¸

ªŸ%W-f`TyW'x%n?_`†fj†n?} nc›§fjTyW l|_ifWKV‹†¨_j_—†‡nc}†} n

`¢¥

rs} n ` 4¸œ‡Wf

`

Ÿ©WPfjTyW:œ‡†VX†fOŸ©Wfi£.WKW}¬f`TW²}ynezeWK_XfjTa”f TaD™cW²_japVXW¹n¡n¡zy†}yŒ

zy†‡_—fjac}{WIa?_

ac}z‹f`TynL_—WgTaD™¡†}yŒ[¹n¡neze†‡}yŒze†¨_—fjap}©{WIn?}yWVXncljWf`Tac} ¥ STW¹n¡neze†}Œze†‡_—fjac}{W

†¨_{œ‡WKacl`œ‡hap}†‡}{ljWKa?_—†‡}yŒ›by}{Òfj†n?}A¸yap}©zOac_8f`TW[}n¡zyWK_#†}

n

` <TaD™?WgljWK{WK†™?WKzXfjTyW-WVX†¨_`_`†n?}

nc›

¸efjTyW†‡l¹n¡neze†‡}yŒze†¨_if|ap}{W'†‡_}npfIŒcljWKapf`WKl.fjTap}PfjTyW-¹n¡neze†‡}yŒze†¨_if|ap}{W'np›

xyœ‡b_nc}Wc¥ F¡WW

J)†‡ŒcbyljWXY[›nclIap}†‡œœ‡b_—f`l|a”f`†‡nc} ¥

rs}zyWWKz˜£#W{Kap}‹{ncVXxybyf`W#f`TyWxyljncŸ©apŸy†‡œ†fihze†¨_ifjl`†‡Ÿybefj†n?}nc›

¥ AWf

] eizŸ©W#f`TW#xl`n?ŸapŸy†‡œ‡†fih

fjTa”f

<¥Inpfj†‡{WXf`Tapf

zeWKx©WK}zy_'n?}yœ‡h:nc}

¥¦g_†œ‡œb©_ifjljapf`WKz­Ÿ¡hJ)†Œ?byljWY?¸AfjTyWljWapljW

Vac†}yœ‡h˜fi£.n{Kac_`WK_.zeWx%W}zy†}yŒ˜nc}XfjTyWªx%n?_`†f`†‡nc}np›

£†fjTOljWŒ?acljz˜fjn'f`TyWªœ†‡VX†f

`

¥r¢›A†f#†‡_

n?}f`TW[œ‡W›Öf¸enc}yWªŒcWfj_

`

`

¸Lf`TyW[œ†‡VX†f›n?l

n

` M†¨_8fjTyW-_`acV‹W[ac_8›ncl

n ` 4¥§r¢›†f)†¨_)nc}fjTyW#l`†‡ŒcTLfK¸Dn?}yW.Œ?Wf|_

`

` c¸DfjTyW#œ†‡VX†f)›ncl

n

` ¡†‡_

fjTyWglj†‡ŒcTLf8Ÿ%ncby}znp› n ` 4¥s3šWg†‡V‹VXWze†‡apf`WKœhzeWzeb{Wgf`TyWg›ncœ‡œn”£†‡}yŒljWK{byljl`WK}{W

l`WKV‹WKVŸ%Wl

fjTa”f

†¨_by}y†›ncljV †‡}

n

`

] e

]re #Pz `

] e#z

u.œ‡WKacl`œ‡h ]6e c¥v3šWgfjT¡b_zeWKzeb©{W

[ ] e ` ] eÒ¥v3šWgfjTyW}P{n?VXxybef`W

] e -` r[ ` ] e ] et[ ] eÒ¥

†¨_fjT¡b_g_—fjapf`†‡nc}acl`hO›ncl

£†f`T

] e ] e¥

STyW‹VXWKac}„™”apœ‡byW‹np›

†‡_ªfjTLb©_

] eez V V¥-STW˜xyljncŸ©apŸy†‡œ†fihf`Tapf-a

}W£®¹n¡neze†‡}yŒze†¨_if|ap}{Wgœ‡†VX†f#†¨_#{ljWKa”fjWKzX†¨_mfjT¡b_ V¥)STyW[aD™cWKljacŒcWze†¨_if|ap}{WInp›

†‡_#{œ‡WKacl`œ‡h ¥

r¢f|_ª¹n¡n¡zy†}yŒPze†¨_if|ap}{W˜†¨_[f`TW‹}¡byV˜Ÿ©WKl-np›.ze†¨_—f`†‡}{Òf-¹n¡neze†‡}yŒ œ‡†‡V‹†fj_-†‡} n

¢¸ V # ¥STyW

l|a”fj†n¹n¡n¡zy†}yŒ ze†‡_—fjac}{W˜n”™cWKlgze†¨_if|ap}{W†‡}²f`Ty†¨_ªV‹nezeWKœ†‡_If`T¡b_ VapxyxyljnDde†Vapf`Wœ‡hc¥ªSTa”fgVXWap}_

fjTa”f}nc}e ¢ncxefj†VacœIl`n?bef`W_X£†œ‡œg{n?_—fOap}®n”™cWKl`TyWacz Ÿap}zy£†‡z¡fjT np›HVV np›[f`TyW:n?xef`†‡Vapœfjlja8{

Ÿ©ap}ze£†¨z¡fjTA¥

&% /* *

3šW l|_ifmxl`W_—WK}?f8_`†‡Vbyœ¨a”fj†n?}_ {œ‡n?_`Wf`n-fjTyWxyljW™¡†n?b_VXnezeWœ4¥r¢f8†‡_mx©nL_`_`†ŸœWfjn_—†‡Vbyœ¨a”fjWIaª¹n¡n¡zy†}yŒ

£†f`Ta-{n?}Lf`†‡}Lbncb_zeWK}_—†fihnc›©}ynezeW_ f`TyW}Wd¡fmWVX†f—f`WKl †‡_8{|Tyn?_`W}‹a”fml|ap}zen?V †}‹fjTyWIapljWKa[{n”™?WljWKz

Ÿ¡h‹f`TWg¹n¡neze†‡}yŒ¥ ¦I›Öf`Wl-Y‰c‰c‰WVX†‡_j_`†n?}_¸%YK‰?‰c‰-}ynezeW_apljWg{|Tyn?_`W} a”f.l|ap}©zencV †‡}f`TW[acl`Wa{n”™?WljWKz

Ÿ¡h-fjTyW#¹n¡n¡zy†}yŒ'apf)fjTa”ffj†VXWap}zf`TW†‡l§¹©nLneze†‡}yŒ'ze†¨_if|ap}{W#ac}z‹ze†‡_—fjac}{WapljW{ncVXxybyf`WKzA¥sJ)†‡ŒcbyljWˆ

_`Tyn”£I_fjTyWWK™cn?œbefj†n?}Pnp›f`TyW˜ljapf`†‡n¹n¡neze†‡}yŒze†¨_if|ap}{Wn”™cWKlIze†¨_if|ap}{W'›ncl˜Y|@&_`†‡Vbyœ¨a”fj†n?}_gac}z:ˆ@

_`†‡Vbyœ¨a”fj†n?}_¥3­WO{Kap} _`WWfjTa”f'fjTyWO_`†V˜byœ‡apf`†‡nc}_{nc} l`V!ncbylY"@ ac}apœ‡he_—†¨_'ap}z _`Tyn”£ f`Tapff`TyW

l|a”fj†n[¹n¡neze†‡}yŒze†¨_if|ap}{Wn”™cWKlmze†‡_—fjac}{WfjW}z_ f`n”£apl|zy_#Yc¥‚'apxxyl`nDde†‡Va”f`WKœh'†‡}Oˆ@˜¥gnpf`†¨{WIf`Tapfmf`TyW

ˆ@®{bylj™cW#†‡_acŸy}yncljVapœ‡œh'zeW{ljWKa?_—†‡}yŒI›n?lœ‡acl`Œ?W.ze†¨_if|ap}{WK_K¥§STy†¨_†¨_)ac}‹acl—fj†›a?{Òfnp›yfjTyW_—†‡Vbœ‡apf`†‡nc} a

©}y†fjW¹n¡neze†‡}yŒ'†‡_mVXa?zeW

Y‰c‰?‰gWKV‹†¨_j_—†‡nc}_ _`n-f`Tapf8ap}XWKzeŒ?WW <WK{f8†‡_mncŸ_`Wlj™cWz›n?lmœ‡acl`Œ?W#zy†‡_—fjac}{W_¥

ST†‡_xyTW}yn?V‹WK}ync}£†‡œœAŸ%W'W}©{ncb}?fjWljWKz nc}Papœ‡œA_—†‡Vbœ‡apf`†‡nc}_K¥

S§n­T©aD™cWOa„V‹n?l`W l`Wapœ‡†‡_—f`†¨{†¨zeWa:np›fjTyW}ync}e ¢ncxyf`†‡VXacœ†fih np›I¹©nLneze†‡}yŒ­l`n?bef`W_¸ £#WOTaD™?WVaczeW

_`†‡Vbyœ¨a”fj†n?}_-£†fjTža²ze†¨_`{l`Wf`WVXnezeWœ £#W_—bxyx©nL_—WXfjTa”f˜}ynezeWK_acl`Wxœ‡a?{WKzšl|ap}zyncVXœh„†}ža Adeq

ljWK{fjac}yŒcœ‡Wap}zšfjTa”ffjTyWl|ap}yŒ?WXnp›IaP}ynezeW†¨_YK‰?‰PVXWf`WKlj_†}žacœœ8zy†ljWK{f`†‡nc}_

†fX{n”™?Wl|_[a²zy†‡_`¤­nc›

l|aczy†b_.YK‰?‰ ¥LJ)†Œ?byljW#€ª†œ‡œ‡b_ifjljapf`W_AfjTyW_—†‡Vbyœ¨a”fj†n?}nc›nc}yW.¹n¡neze†‡}yŒª†‡}˜f`Ty†¨_VXn¡zyWœ4¥sJ)†‡ŒcbyljWK_L5[ac}z˜ƒ

xl`W_—WK}?f8_`†‡Vbyœ¨a”fj†n?}l`W_—byœfj_

nc›%fjTyncb©_`ac}zy_mnc›<¹n¡n¡zy†}yŒL_% £†fjTOa'_ifjl`†‡x

aYK‰?‰c‰”dƒc‰gljWK{fjap}Œcœ‡Wap}©z

aª_ "Lbacl`W ƒp‰?‰”dƒp‰?‰ %£†f`TXze†%WKl`WK}?fzeW}©_—†f`†‡WK_)np›©}ynezeWK_K¥§STyW#ze†¨_if|ap}{W.nc›ag}ynezeW.†‡_)}yn”£ fjTyW#œWK}yŒpfjT

nc›a_`Tyn?l—fjWK_—fIl`n?bef`W-›ljncV f`TyW_`ncblj{Wc¥ gnpfj†‡{W-f`TapfIf`TyW™DacœbWK_n?Ÿ_—WKl`™?WKzO›nclIœ¨apljŒcW'ze†¨_—fjap}©{WK_gapljW

œ‡WK_j_VXWKac}y†}Œp›byœ%_—†‡}{W#›WK£¬}n¡zyWK_ ljWKa?{|TfjTyWK_`W™”apœ‡byWK_K¥L3šWI{ac}_—WKWf`TapfmTy†Œ?TzeW}_`†fih˜_`†V˜byœ‡apf`†‡nc}_

Œ?Wf{œnL_—WfjnPf`TyW{n?}?fj†}¡byn?b_{Kac_`Wl`W_—byœfj_K¥PqIn”£#W™cWKlK¸ ›ncl™?Wljh­_`xapl|_`WXzy†‡_—f`lj†Ÿbef`†‡nc}_K¸)f`TyWOljapf`†‡n

{Kap}šŒcWfac_'œ‡n”£ a?_XYc¥‰?ƒe¥ST†‡_'†¨__—f`†‡œœ.aP™cWljh:†‡VXx©n?l—f|ap}Lf'›ac{f`ncl'†‡}šf`WKl`V_'nc›#n”™?WljTyWKa?z„_`†}{W†f

ljWxl`W_—WK}?f|_.ƒx©WKlj{W}Lfj_8†}aczyze†f`†‡nc}f`n˜f`TyWgf`l|a8{IŸac}ze£†¨z¡f`T

acl`n?by}zP¥Ëƒw²Ÿ”_.†}a{|Tacl`Œ?WKz

Y?Y[w:Ÿ”_}Wfi£#nclj¤ ¥

1 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14

ratio flooding distance / optimal distance

optimal distance from source

1D 2D

J)†‡ŒcbyljW˜ˆ I\Ia”fj†n¹©nLneze†‡}yŒze†‡_—fjac}{W˜n”™cWKlgze†¨_if|ap}{W™cWKlj_`b_ªze†‡_—fjac}{W›ncl[aO{n?}Lf`†‡}Lbncb_ªzeW}_`†fihnc›

}n¡zyWK_nc}PaXœ‡†}yW

Y|@ #nclnc}PaXxyϬap}yW

ˆ@ Ò¥

s d

a b

c

J)†‡ŒcbyljWO€ ¦¹n¡neze†‡}yŒ:›ljncV?¥šSTyWze†¨_—¤ apljncb}z a:}ynezeW †‡_f`TW apljWKa„{n”™cWKl`WzšŸLhšfjTa”f‹}ynezeWc¥

STWª{ljn?_j_`WK_ Œ?byljWf`TyW[}ynezeW_.ac}z‹f`TyW[œ‡†}yW_._`Tyn”£¬f`TWgljncbefjWK_#{nc}©_ifjl`b{f`WzXŸLh‹fjTyWI¹n¡neze†‡}yŒ¥ STyW

Ÿ©ac{|¤¡Œcljncby}©z²†œ‡œ‡b_ifjljapf`W_gfjTyW_—Tncl`f`WK_—f'ze†‡_—fjac}{W˜›ljncV [}ynezeWK_[†‡}šac}šacl`Wa£†f`T _`acV‹W{ncœ‡ncl-apljW

apfXf`TyW²_japVXWzy†‡_—fjac}{W›ljncV

›byl—fjTyWK_—f}ynezeW_‹acl`WPa”fze†¨_—fjap}©{W²ƒ#Ò¥ Jyn?lXWdyapVXxyœ‡Wc¸.}ynezeW_ †‡_

apf¹n¡neze†‡}yŒ­zy†‡_—fjac}{W‚²›ljncVPap}z a”f‹zy†‡_—fjac}{WP€²›ljncV?¥šST†‡_‹†¨_˜_`†VXxyœ‡h zebyW f`nša "Lby†¨{|¤cWl

xl`n?xapŒLa”f`†‡nc}Onp› fjTyW-¹n¡neze†‡}yŒ›ljncV qap}zf`Tac}Pacl`n?by}zg†‡}f`Ty†¨_#¹n¡neze†}Œ

l`WKVXWVŸ%WlfjTa”fIacœœ

}n¡zyWK_apljW-†}²{ncVXx©Wf`†f`†‡nc} ›nclIa?{{W_`_#fjn‹f`TyW'VXWKzy†‡a Ò¥

1 1.05 1.1 1.15 1.2 1.25 1.3 1.35 1.4

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14

ratio flooding distance / optimal distance

optimal distance from source

density=5 (25 nodes) density=10 (50 nodes) density=15 (75 nodes) density=30 (150 nodes) density=50 (250 nodes) density=100 (500 nodes) density=200 (1000 nodes)

J)†‡ŒcbyljWg5 A\Ia”fj†n¹©nLneze†‡}yŒ[ze†‡_—fjac}{W8n”™cWl§ze†‡_—fjac}{W8™cWl|_`b_Aze†¨_if|ap}{W8†‡}a'Y‰c‰c‰pdƒp‰#_ifjl`†‡x'› ncl)ze†%WKl`WK}?f

zyW}_`†fj†W_¥STyWzeWK}_`†fih:†¨_-Œc†‡™cWK}­†‡}š}LbVŸ%Wl'np›#}ynezeWK_-x%Wlby}y†f'acl`WaO£TWljWXaby}†facl`Wa†¨_-f`TyW

acl`Wa˜{n”™cWKl`WzŸ¡h a‹}ynezeW

ˆ”dMYK‰c‰pdƒp‰ ¥

1 1.05 1.1 1.15 1.2 1.25 1.3 1.35 1.4 1.45 1.5

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18

ratio flooding distance / optimal distance

optimal distance from source

density=5 (39 nodes) density=10 (79 nodes) density=15 (119 nodes) density=30 (238 nodes) density=50 (398 nodes) density=100 (796 nodes) density=200 (1592 nodes)

J)†‡ŒcbyljWƒ 8\ga”f`†‡nX¹n¡neze†‡}yŒze†¨_if|ap}{W'n”™cWlze†¨_—fjap}©{W'™cWKlj_`b_ze†¨_—fjap}©{W'†‡}:aƒp‰c‰pdƒp‰c‰˜_ "Lbacl`W[›n?lf`TyW

_japVXWzeWK}_`†fj†W_gac_$J)†Œ?byl`WH5©¥ISTyWzeWK}_`†fih†‡_gŒc†‡™cWK}†‡}²}¡byVŸ%Wlªnp› }ynezeW_Ix%Wlgb}y†f-apljWKaX£TyWKl`Wa

b}y†fgacl`Wa†¨_fjTyW'apljWKaX{n”™?WljWKzŸ¡hOaX}ynezeW

€y¥‡Y5pdMY‰c‰”dMY‰c‰ ¥

1 1.02 1.04 1.06 1.08 1.1 1.12 1.14 1.16 1.18

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40

ratio flooding distance / optimal distance

optimal distance from source

5x5 grid (25 nodes) 7x7 grid (49 nodes) 10x10 (100 nodes) 15x15 (225 nodes) 20x20 (400 nodes)

J)†‡ŒcbyljWª‚ \Ia”fj†n¹n¡n¡zy†}yŒXze†¨_if|ap}{Wªn”™?Wl#ze†‡_—fjac}{W[™cWKlj_`b_.ze†‡_—fjac}{W[£†f`TPa_%"?b©apljWgŒclj†¨zXf`n?x©n?œn?Œchc¥

rs}˜ncl|zeWl§f`n[Œcl|apŸ'fjTyW#V‹†‡}y†‡VbyV n”™?WljTyWKa?z'{nL_ifnp›}nc}e ¢ncxefj†Vacœ†fih-np›y¹n¡neze†‡}yŒgljncbyf`WK_K¸”£#W8TaD™?W

Va?zeWª_`†V˜byœ¨a”f`†‡nc}©_mnc}f`TyW[_ "Lbacl`WIŒ?l`†¨z )WKa?{|T}ynezeWgT©ac_g5˜}yW†‡ŒcT¡Ÿ%ncl|_

Wdy{WKxef#n?}Xf`TyW[WKzyŒcWK_ Ò¥r¢f#†‡_

{nc}y}WK{ÒfjWKz'WK}yncbŒcTfjngŸ%W#aªljWKac_`nc}©apŸyœ‡Wm}yWfi£.n?l`¤ªf`n?x©n?œn?Œch-ap}z†f†‡_)™?Wljh-_`xaclj_`Wc¥ w:ncljWn”™cWKlK¸K†f †¨_§a

ljWKa?_—n?}apŸœWVXnezeWœ›nclw:ap}Ta”f`fjap} ¥ gnpf`†¨{Wgf`Tapf.†‡}f`TWªap}©apœ‡ncŒcn?b_Y"@HVXnezeWœ

aœ†‡}yWg£TWljWgWKa?{|T

}n¡zyW‹T©ac_[fi£#n }yWK†Œ?T¡Ÿ©n?lj_ Ò¸<fjTyWljWX†‡_'aby}y†"LbyWXl`n?bef`W‹fjnWac{|T­}ynezeWap}z„f`TyWX¹©nLneze†‡}yŒncŸ¡™¡†n?b_`œh

Œ?†™?WK_[ncxyf`†‡VXacœ l`n?bef`W_¥UJ)†Œ?byljWX‚P_`Tyn”£I_ªf`TyWljWK_`byœfj_-n?Ÿefjac†}yWz:›n?l-™Dacl`†‡ncb©_'_—†SRW_ªnc›_%"LbapljW‹Œclj†‡zM¥

3šWn?Ÿ_—WKl`™?W-f`TyW˜£.n?lj_—fIl|a”f`†‡nX›nclgf`TyW˜VX†‡zyzyœWzy†‡_—fjac}{W}n¡zyWK_

›aplª}ynezeWK_ª{WKl—f|ap†‡}yœh Ÿ©WK}yW fg›ljncV

fjTyWWKzyŒcWK_-nc›.fjTyWŒclj†¨z:fjTa”f'›n?lj{W˜fjTyWX¹n¡neze†‡}yŒPf`nPljWKac{|T­f`TWV!_—f`l|ap†‡ŒcTLfjœh Ò¥t8™cW}­›ncl˜a l|a”fjTyWl

_`Vapœ‡œMŒclj†‡zA¸enc}yW'{ac} Œ?WfgaYc¥‡Y[ljapf`†‡n˜›n?lIze†¨_if|ap}{W-€‹}ynezeW_¥

gn”£ f`Tapf'£.W‹TaD™cW‹ap}­†‡zeWaOnc›.}yn?}e ¢ncxefj†Vapœ)ljncbefjWK_[n”™cWKl`TyWaczM¸%£#W‹{nc}_`†‡zyWl-_—n?V‹WX_j{W}©aplj†nL_

›n?lI{n?V‹x©aplj†}yŒX{n?}Lf`ljncœ<n”™cWKl`TyWaczM¥

˜" žI#

')/ /§ !/§.'/

S§nIŒ?†™?Wmax©n?†}Lf§nc›y{ncVXxacl`†¨_`nc}[£†fjT}ync}y 4n?xef`†‡VapœpljncbefjWK_Mn”™?WljTyWKa?zM¸£#WmŒ?†™?Wf`TyW8{nc}Lf`ljncœcn”™cWljTyWacz

nc›8¹n¡neze†‡}yŒPxyljnpf`ne{ncœ¨_g›n?lY

¸ W

y¸ q y¸ k

ap}z m

¥STy†¨_-™”apœ‡byWK_

{ncljl`W_—x%nc}©zfjn'f`Tn?_`WIb_`WKz†‡}Xf`TyW[_—†‡Vbœ‡apf`†‡nc}_8xyl`W_—WK}Lf`WKzX†‡}J)†‡ŒcbyljWAN[nc›v4‚7 s5?‰_`ncbyl|{W_ np›Mfjlja8{

acl`WPb_`WKz®n”™?Wl }ynezeWK_hL†‡Wœ¨ze†‡}yŒbq

¸8{n?}_if|ap}LfŸy†fOl|a”f`W²Œ?†™?W\W

y¸a l|ap}yŒ?Wnc›