HAL Id: inria-00071454
https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00071454
Submitted on 23 May 2006
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Comparison between Aloha and CSMA in multiple hop ad hoc networks
Paul Mühlethaler, Mikael Salaun, Amir Qayyum, Yasser Toor
To cite this version:
Paul Mühlethaler, Mikael Salaun, Amir Qayyum, Yasser Toor. Comparison between Aloha and CSMA in multiple hop ad hoc networks. [Research Report] RR-5129, INRIA. 2004. �inria-00071454�
ISRN INRIA/RR--5129--FR+ENG
a p p o r t
d e r e c h e r c h e
INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE
Comparison between Aloha and CSMA in multiple hop ad hoc networks
Paul M¨uhlethaler , Mikael Salaun , Amir Qayyum and Yasser Toor
No 5129
Mars 2004
TH `EME 1
$!%324%5 6*
798:<;>=@?<A<;CBEDFAG85;HBEIKJMLN=@OCP8BM;RQ8;S85:<TVUWLGX%YZOCIK[\8^]_]:<Y`8T<acbd8eFeFBEI%f>gghIKi
jlknmo*p*q9rtsuwvxpwy{z^|}p ~>vx^v~mo*pwv
p ~>>NsR9
sRy{ E~R^ppwknpkpEqF{ryvErqw ny¡Epwv
¢}£¤w¥¦¨§©{¥{ª3« ~xz^ ¬\ {n®°¯±p²k ^³Rp~´µ Ex¶^v®·v>y*¸Ep}z¹C~ ¹y¨~pº~x {n®±{»l²¼¯° {~> ¬Gpwvxpwyk
v~xz^®°pFvGknyW¸Epµ5ppwKy®°pF {z~´®½~k*yvx5pw ®·y¯^pwo*kny{vx®·v< {*x Ez^~x®±¡º ~ ¾ {¯·v»0 ~xkpo*pwy{M~x®±o p
yEpwvv ~x ^ {¯·v^pwvx®±¡{pF¿¬À {odz¯½~®°kn {ÁyEÂk ^3p ~´ {¶^vpw pw®°¸Ep3¯°pFvxvd Env®·^pwy~x®± {_»"ÃÄk®±¯°p
®±´®°pw"p~´µ Ex¶K~xkp5pnp Å~> {¬<wyx®±pvxpnvx®±¡*kny{v5ppwvkn ¨´}~ 3p¸Ep}vx®°¡E®½Å5yM~Ʊq/ÇSÈn®±
odz¯°~x®±k { y{k ^µp ~´ {¶^vh~xkn®±v5ppÅ~yplÉMzpwv~x®± {y¯±pµvx®° pNkn®±p* {¯±¯±®±vx®° Envy{xpµ¶¾ ¨´
~ v®±¡{n®½ÅwyM~x¯±^pw¡{y{^pl5px¬À {o*y{n pl {¬_ « ʲËHy®°pw « pnvxpR\z¯°~x®±¯±pR² pFvxvÌ ~ ¾ {¯·vƨÇH»
ÍÎv®±¡"y}vx®°o*¯±pz~9pwy{¯°®·v~®±o* ¾p¯HÈ5´pd {o*ny{xp~kp ¡{¯± {ny{¯_~xknx Ez¡{knz^~Î {¬l « ²x {~x ^ E¯±v
y{n²>¯° EknyR®±odz¯°®±k Ey{k ^p~´µ Ex¶^vw»j Îo3y®±E~y®±~xkn®±v< Eo*ny®±vx {Èw´pµyEvxvxzo*pµy{®±vx ~x E®·
nx E¡Ey¨~®° E´®°~xk Ez^~ {nv~yE ¯±pwvºynp~´µ Ex¶ ^^pFvº¯° ^y~x®± {nvάÀ E¯°¯± ¨´®°n¡"y"< {®·vxvx { ¾pwvv»dÃp
{o*ny{xp"xpFvzn¯½~v* ¬>~k®·v3o* ¾p¯R´®°~xkÄvx®°odz¯±y~x®± {nvw»ÏÃpvxk ¨´Ð~kny¨~FÈyE/~zny¯±¯°Eȵwyx®±p3vxpnvx®°n¡
®±o* ¨¸{pwvN~xknp9¡E¯° Eny¯~xknx Ez¡{knz^~w»Gjlk®·vlxpFvzn¯½~ Ez¯±}p9~k {z¡EkM~~ d5pº®° EM~xy{^®·/~®° EK´®½~k"y
nxpw¸M®± {zvv~xz^ÊÆÑWÇS»jlkpxpFy{vx {% ¬~xk®·vyypM~R {M~yE^®± ~x®± {%®±vlp|¾n¯±y{®°pFÒ»
Ó\ÔMÕhÖ×Ø
¦¨Ù¤{ª
²Kkn ¾9³Rp~´µ Ex¶hÈEpw¬À Exo3y p>pw¸¨y¯±zny¨~®° E_È^
«
²Vnx {~x ^ E¯CÈMx Ez^~x®±¡dx {~x ^ E¯CÈ
®±M~xpw¬Àpwxpwn pEÈ^cÚ{M^»±q{qEÈEk®·^pw ^^pwvwÈvy¨~x®·y¯ÒpzvpE»
Û·ÜÒÝxÞSßwàlÝáâ±ÞSãHä å
æNç0èêé5ëì_í_î<ï@ðWñóòôóõö÷ø¨ùÀúì_ùüû
ý<þnÿ
ì
íÒõ ÷Hõñ ±ò/ñÒûWöõì_õHõñóöºèÎë/èWõõñóèÒéèC÷
Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt
-, " $!"32.('3)+ .-"0-}
¤ ª p% EopzvpFvu~xzn^pFv {M~du~xu"o pwupFv*vz ¯±pwv ~x ^ {¯±pwvp% {z^~y¡Ep}yv¯±pwv
uwvxpwy{z^| y{Ák ^%p~Kv5uw®±y{¯°pwo pwM~¿¯Njynv*¯±p"¡{ {z5p"p%~yW¸¨y{®°¯²Î³RNjº»µµpFv*u ~xz^pwv
{nppM~®±n ®±ny¯±po*pwE~¯±y { p~x®± {K^pÎx {~x ^ E¯°pFv^pR {z~y¡Ep Ezl^pwvNxuFvpFyz^| o E®±¯°pFv»
yvµ¯±p9owo*p>~po*nvwÈM¯·y { p~x®± {}^p9 ~ ¾ {¯±pwvy{mwvµ Ez¯°pFvµuwvxpwy{z^|3y{Kkn ¾Îozn¯½~®±vyz^~
y*p zpFyzn {z\o* {®±nvRy~~xpwM~x®± {_»²R¯± {vRÉMzpy{nv¯±pwv>xuFvpFyz^|Ků±y{®°pwv¯±p5uuÅ pd^p¯·y3^u ¹
~pw ~x®± { xuFy¯·y¯±pl^pl E~pznvxplpwv~<®±o* E~yM~Æ°q ÇHÈMynv<¯±pwv<uwvxpwy{z^|y{dk ^oz¯°~x®·vxy{z^~N pl5uuÅ p
5pz~~xp*xpwo ®·v9pÂy{znvp*y{º¯°pFvº ¾pznvwy{kuFv>5pzn¸{pM~^uw¡{y{^pw>~xmFv9vx®±¡{®°Åy~x®±¸{pwo pwM~9¯±pwv
5px¬À {o3ynpwvº^zÁ « ² ËSyx®±p « pwnvxpK\z¯°~x®±¯°pK²w pFvxvÌdƨÇH»3 z~x®±¯°®·vxy{M~ºzn o ^^mw¯°p3vx®°o ¹
n¯°po3y{®±vuwy{¯°®·v~xp{Èn {znvÎ Eo y {nvl¯±p^un®½~9¡{¯± {ny{¯_^z¿ « ²¼p ~βR¯± {ky3ynv>¯°pd {M~p |¾~xp^p
uwvxpwy{z^|dyEdkn ¾Roz¯°~x®·vxy{z^~w»< {zNxuFy¯±®±vxpp ~~p> Eo*nyy®·v E_Ȩ EznvNvxz5 Evx {nv<znpR {ny{¡Ey~x®± {
®·vx ~x {5p}vynvd {v~y{ ¯±p}p~ znp%^®·v~x®°z~x®± {Zp%< {®·vv E vny~x®·y¯±p}5 {z ¯±pwv ¾pznnvd^zZxuFvpFyz_»
³> {znv> {o*ny{x Env¯°pFvuwvxz¯½~y¨~v^p po* ^^mw¯°pyW¸Epwº^pwv>v®±oz¯·y¨~®° Envw»N³R Eznvlo* {M~x {nvÉMzp¬óy{®½~
¯·y ^u ~pw/~®° E"p95 {x~xpwznvxp9y{o uw¯°®± {p>¯±p^un®½~¡{¯± {y¯H»Gµpºuwvxz¯½~y¨~lpwz^~>vxpon¯°pwpw% {M~xy{^®·/~®° E
yW¸EpwÎzpu~xzn^pnxuF uwpM~xp*ÆÑWÇH»0y y{®±vx {"^p p~~xpy{ny{xpwE~p9 {M~xy{®± ~x®± {}pFv~Rp|^¯°®·ÉMzupE»
Ø ¥F¤ Ö © ª suwvxpwy{z¿yEkn ¾{Èuw¸Wy{¯°zy¨~x®± {Â^p35px¬À {o3ynp{È_ ~ ^ {¯±pK « ²Èx {~x ^ E¯°p3^p
{z~y¡Ep{Ⱦ®±E~px¬Àupnp{Èv~y{nyKNcÚ{M^»±q{q{Ⱦ ¾pwznvyEkuwvwȾxuwz^~x®±¯±®±vy¨~®° E"vxny¨~®±y{¯°pE»
: ;
d <3$"-%2N0
jlknpKo3y¨ {d {¡{pwvvº®± ´®°p¯±pwvvo* ^^po knyEv Epwpw y\np´ ~xpFk®·y{¯µypwy\y{x EznÂÃÄ®±xpw¯°pFvxv
0²>³pE»¡»l@ÚEE»°qEq ƨÇSÈ5>®°NNs ²Î³ ÆWÇSÈ=<µ¯±zp~x ¾ ~k_»\ {®±¯±py{k ^np ~´ {¶M®±¡*®·v>y3pw´
pwvxpwy{kdypwyR´kn®±k kny{v<5pnp Å~pwd¬Àx Eo ~xk®·vGpwo pwx¡E®°n¡>´®±xpw¯°pFvxv0~xpFk E¯° E¡{{»Gµ {M~xy9~x ²Î³>v
´knpp~xkpx Eny¡My¨~®° E" {nv~xy®±M~vR^ } ~9znvzy¯±¯°%®°o*5 Evxpdv~x®°¡EpM~Rpwv~x®± ~x®± {nvwÈn®±\à ²Î³>v
~kp ~xynvxo*®±vvx®° Ey{¡{pd®±v9¸Ep"¯±®±o ®°~xpFÒ»djlknp np ~´ {¶ {npw/~®°¸¾®°~\kny{vÎ~ %p¯±\ {¿y} {z^~®°n¡
y{¯°¡E {®½~koдk®·ky¯±¯° ¨´RvlnyE¶{p~lp|kny¡Epºp~´µpwp ^^pwvln ~>^®±xpF/~¯°%´®½~k®°\y{®° xpFy{k_Èvxpp
Å¡{zp3q{»ljlk¾znvÈ®°y{¾¹Sk ^ºp ~´ {¶^vȾ~kp {z~x®±¡3®±vvxzp®±vÎy3¶{pw}®·vxvxzpE»jlk®·v>y{xpFy*kny{vRxpF p®±¸{pF
y*v~x {¡ ®±E~ppwv~l¬Àx EoÐ~xknpy{yE^po*®·>´ {¯·Ò»G²~~xkpM~xpwxnp ~¡E®°pwp®°n¡*jy{vx¶ n { p3ËÀNjGÌ
y*np´ ´µ Ex¶¾®±¡*¡{ {z\²Î³RNj(ËC\ {n®°¯±p²k ^³>Nj´ {¶Ìlv~yx~xpF®° qF{?>^»µjlk®·vR¡Ex Ezkny{v
nx ^^znpw ¾zo*p {znvx Ez^~x®±¡ {5 Evy¯·vlÆÈ@>¾ÈEÚÈM¨ÇS»Êy¾dnz¯±®±wy¨~x®± {vknyW¸Epl {o*ny{xpFd¸¨y{x®± {znv
{z~x®±¡3y¯±¡{ {®°~xko3vµ¬À {RyE¾¹Hkn ¾Îp~´µ Ex¶^vw»
0®±¡{znxp*qBAG²>yE}kn ¾ºnp ~´ {¶3´k®±k"pwpwv {z~x®±¡~ 3pnvxzpydnx EpwR {npw ~x®±¸M®°~
²> ~kp¶{pwd®·vxvxzpδk®±k}kny{vNxpF p®±¸{pF*oznk3¯±pwvvy¨~~pM~x®± {}®±v~xkpº^pwvx®±¡{3 ¬yEpwvvNvkpo*pwv
~ 3pznvpF®°yE"k ^p ~´ {¶^v» zp~x *~kp¡{pw¾z®°npoz¯°~x®±k {\nx Epw~% ¬Gy{k ^ºp~´µ Ex¶}y
y{¶{p~kny{vl~ 3pp ~y{nvxo ®°~~pw%~x 3pwyEk%®°~vRÅnny{¯^pwv~x®±ny~x®± {_»Njlkn®±v¯±pwyEvl~ 3 {~xpM~®±y{¯v®±ozn¯½¹
~ypw {znv~xynvxo*®±vv®± {vl®°"~xknpp ~´ {¶K´®°~xk\~kp®±vx¶K {¬G {¯±¯°®·vx®° E"´®°~xk®±v~y{E~~y{nvxo ®°~~pv {
®±nzxpwº¾9~xknpzoz¯·y¨~®°¸EpNpC5pF/~< ¬nvx®°odz¯½~ypw {znv_~xynvxo*®±vvx®° Env»znvxzny¯Mv®±¡E¯°pµk {np ~´ {¶5È
®°~knyEvºpwp vxk ¨´Ê~kny¨~y"®± {y{x®±pºvpwnvp3 {¬N~kp}kny{p¯RËS « ²9Ìy{ ~xzny{¯°¯±Êvx®°¡E®½Å5yM~¯°
®±o* ¨¸{pwvN~xknp95px¬À {o3ynp> {¬0zpº²R¯± {kny~xpFk®·ÉEznpwvºÆ±q/ÇH»Gydoz¯°~x®±k {"p¾¸¾®±x Eo*pM~ {M~xp|M~
y p¸¾®± {znv´ {¶Ëóy{n%~x ~xkpy{z^~xkn {v ^5pwv~R¶¾ ¨´¯°pF^¡{pÎ~xknpºÅnv~Rv~zn^}~x *knyW¸{p9®±M¸Epwv~x®±¡Ey~xpw%®±
~kpºypwy {¬0y{w pwvvNvkpwo pFvN®±}odz¯±®°k E}p~´µ Ex¶^vÌ<knyEvµvxk ¨´3~kny¨~ EE~y{xd~x d~xknp>Ån¡Ezpwv®±%y
vx®±¡{¯±plk {*p~´µ Ex¶d « ʲcyn*²>¯° Ekny9knyW¸{pl®±*y9odz¯½~®°kn {K EM~xp |¾~vx®°o*®±¯±y{Gpw¬À Exo3y pwvw»0jlkn®±v
®·vpw ®·vxp¯±~kpy®±o {¬_~xkn®±vlyx~x®· ¯±pR~ {o*ny{xp9²R¯± {kny´®½~k\ « ʲV ~ ^ {¯·v®±K~kp EE~p |¾~µ {¬
yE}kn ¾ºnp ~´ {¶¾vw»
jlk®·vRy5pR®·v {¡Ey{®EDpw"y{v¬À E¯°¯± ¨´Rv AG~xkpp |¾~>vxpw/~®° E®°M~x ^^znpwvp¯·y¨~pw"´µ Ex¶^vy{n"®°M~x ¹
zn pFvÎ Ezv~zn^E»yx~x®· z¯·y9®°~xkn®±vvxpw ~x®± {Ê´p ´®°¯±¯Gynvx´µpw>~kp ¬À {¯±¯° ¨´®±¡"ÉEznpwv~x®± {nv A>´k¾
®·v®°~®°M~ppwv~x®±¡"~x Envx®±^pwd « ²(nx {~x ^ E¯±vºy{v~xkpwyp*znvxzny¯±¯°~xk Ez¡{kM~ {~~x \5pKznvxp ¬Àz¯
¬À Eµ´®±p¯±pwvvNp~´µ Ex¶ 5pwy{znvxpÎzy¯±pR~ {5pδ®°~xk%k®±n^p" {¯±¯±®±vx®° E_»<Ãp9´®±¯°¯Òy¯·vx p |^¯·y®±K´k¾
²>¯° Eknyy{*p>~xk Ez¡{kM~G~x {z^~pw¬À Exo(
«
²Ä®±Kyozn¯½~®°k E3p ~´ {¶h»Kvxpw ~x®± {3ÑÈE´µp>p¸{pw¯° E
y vx®±o n¯°pv~y~x®·o ^^pw¯R~ {o*ny{xp\²>¯° Ekny ync
«
ʲ oz¯°~x®±k EÏnp ~´ {¶ÁynÏ´p Eo yp
«
²yn"²R¯± {kyd E"~xkpnyEv®·vl ¬0~xk®·vo* ^^p¯H»
«
pF/~x®± {*®·vR^p¸E ~pw}~x 3y*^¾nyo*®·v®±oz¯·y¨~®° E
{¬²>¯° Ekny*yn « ² ´kn®±k E^Åno*v~kppwvxz¯½~vl ¬0~xkpv~y~x®·ºo ^^pw¯C»
'dº0 Á0!% 0 "$ < º0$ 63
jlknpp y{xp~´µ "v~y~xp¡E®°pFvR~ "vxkny{xp*y}o*pF^®°zno"»Ê~kp Ånv~º {pEÈ_y¯±¯±pw {M~x {¯±¯°pFÊyE pFvxvwÈ5~xkp
vxkny{x®±¡®±v {¡Ey{®Dwpw { ypwp ~xpwxo*®±pwÂy{vx®±v~xk®·v®·v~kp}v~xy¨~xpw¡{znvpF¿®°Áj ²(nx {~x ¹
{¯·v»jlkp}y{¯½~pny¨~pKv~y~xpw¡{Ê®·v~kpKyn {o4yEpwvvº~xpFk®·ÉEznp{ÈG²R¯± {kny\y{nÁ « ²Ðx {~x ^ E¯±v
y{xp}®°Á~xkp^®±xpF/~*¯°®±p" ¬~xkn®±v*ynx My{k_»Â²RZp | pw¯°¯±pM~*vzo*o3y ¬Îy{ EyEkpwvº~ Êodz¯½~®°n¯°p
yEpwvv9wy¿p*¬À Ezn¿®±ÏƱq/ÇS» znp*~x ~xknp3¡{p¾z®±p*o* {®±¯±p*y{n¿ {5pÂknyy{ ~xpwx®·v~®±wv> {¬lyEÊkn ¾
np ~´ {¶¾vwÈ®°~d®·v¡Eppwy{¯°¯±yE^o*®½~x~xpFÂ~xkny~dy\yn {o y{pwvvº~xpFk®·ÉMzpKozv~ pKzvpFÒ» « ²
ËSyx®±p « pnvxpÎz¯½~®°n¯°p²pwvvÌGx {~x ^ E¯±vNknyW¸{p>pwp}´®·^pw¯°3v~xzn^®±pw}®°}´®°p¯±pwvv 0²>³>v9Ʊq ÇS»<
´®±p¯±pwvvÎnp ~´ {¶¾v9´kpwxp3y{¯°¯G~kp3 ^^pFvyp ´®°~xkn®° y{x®±pvpwnvxp pwyEkÊ®°~y{¿5pKvxk ¨´Ê~kny¨~
~k®·vN~pwkn®±ÉMzp9 Chpvµydv®±¡{n®½ÅwyM~µ®±o* ¨¸{po*pwE~µ ¨¸{pN~xkpvx®°o*¯±pβ>¯° Ekny vxkpwo*p>´kpwxpÎny{¶Ep ~v
y{xp9vpwM~l´®°~xkn {z^~Ry¾*®° Ey®°pwµvxpnvx®°n¡n»GR ¨´p¸Epµy ´®±xpw¯°pFvxvµp~´µ Ex¶*´kpwxp9 ^^pwvly{xp9 ~
odz^~xzy¯±¯° ´®°~xk®± y®°pw vxpnvxp"xpFy{k ´®±¯°¯Rvxz.Chp ¬À {o ~xknp"kn®±pÏ ^^pwv* E¯°¯±®·v®± {nvd {¯±po»
jlknp%k®·^pwZn ¾p" {¯±¯°®·v®± {Á®±v*y¿v®°~xzny~x®± {Z®°Z´k®±kÏyZ {Á¡E {®±¡\~y{nvo*®·vxvx®± { ®·v*v5 {®±¯°pF ¾
yÊv®±oz¯°~y{p Eznvpo* ~p3~xyvo*®·vxvx®° E {¾~xkp" zodz¯·y¨~x®±¸{p}pChpw/~ ¬>vxznk ^®·v~yM~~y{nvo*®·v¹
vx®± {nvw»3jlk®±v¸{p~xyvo*®·vxvx®° Ey{¯½~k {z¡Ek5p®±¡\z¯±pwM « ²(wy¿ ~^p~xpF/~~xknp3 {¡E {®±¡
~y{nvxo ®·vv®± {_»²R¬ü~xpwº~xkp*®±®½~®±y{¯Gny5p9¬À {o j0 {y¡E®µÆWǾzo*p {zv>ny{pwv9o* Ev~x¯±\®±Ê~kp3{{v
nx E MvpF¿pw^®·y~xpwÂnx {~x ^ E¯±v9~ Ê EpK´®°~xkÂ~k®·v {¯±poƱqw^ȵq{qȵqF¾ÈµqwÑ^ȵq¨ÇS»\jlkpK¡{pwpy¯
®·^pFy ¬~xkpFvp9 ~x ^ {¯·v®·vN~ d®±o*¯±po*pM~yo*pwky®·vo ®±K~kpÎpwp®±¸{pw~x ~pw/~l®°~vxpF pw^~x®± {_»
jlknp pwp®±¸{pwδlynv9®½~vpw®°¡EkM5 {º ^^pFvº ¬®½~vº {¿¡{ {®±¡"xpF pw^~x®± {_»*jlk¾znv9~xknp*wyx®±pºvxpnvxp*®±v
p|¾~xp^pw y{x Ezn¿~kp}pwp®±¸{pd pwy¨~®°n¡ÊyÁyE^®°~x®± {ny{¯Np|^¯°zv®± { y{xpFy\®°Á´k®±kZv~y¨~x®± {v´®±¯°¯
n ~R5py¯±¯° ¨´pw}~x Kv~y{~>y ~y{nvxo ®·vv®± {_»NÅn¡{zp ´µpkyW¸{pppwvxpM~xpF%y{p |yo*¯±p ¬Gvzk
y\~xpwkn®±ÉMzp3A*~xkps<j « j « o pFknyn®±vxo4´kn®±k ®·v y E^~x®± { ®± ~kp%NÚEE^»±q{qKv~y{ny{Ò»
ÃÄknpy*p~´µ Ex¶Kn ¾p®°M~pnv~x }vxpny*5 {®±M~R~x K5 {®±M~Rny{¶Ep ~FÈ^~xkpdv Ezpº ^^pvxpnvRx®± {
~ K~kp ny¨~y}ny{¶Ep ~ºy}vxo*y{¯°¯nyE¶{p ~ºy{¯°¯±pws<j « ny{¶Ep ~wÈhs<j « v~y{nv>¬À {spwÉMzpFv~ºj « pÒ»S¬
~k®·vl¸{p*ny{¶Ep ~®±v {xpF/~x¯± xpF p®±¸{pFK¾*~xknp9pwp®±¸{pwµy}®°¬~kpÎpwp®±¸{pwµ®·vxpFy{^*~ dpwp®±¸{pÎy
np´Áy{¶{p~wȨ~k®·vG ^^pRyv´pv_~ º~xkpRvx {znpµ ^^p¾yvxo3y¯±¯^ny{¶Ep ~Gy{¯°¯±pwKj « Ëü¬À {lµ¯°pFyGj
« pnnÌ »ÎS¬N~xkp3j « ny{¶Ep ~>®·v9y¯·v }vxznw pwvv¬Àz¯°¯±xpF pw®°¸Epw¾"~xkp v Ezp ^^pEÈ~k®·vÎn ¾pdv~yx~v
~y{nvxo ®°~~®°n¡d®°~vy~ydny{¶Ep ~l®°o*o*pw®±y~xp¯±}y¬ü~xp~kpºxpF p~x®± {} {¬~kpj « »²^®°~x®± {ny{¯°¯±K5 ~k
~kpds<j « y{¶{p~Îy~xkp3j « nyE¶{p~>y}~kp~ ~y{¯zy~x®± {\ {¬G~xkp¬À {pwvxpp~y{nvxo ®·vv®± {_È
~k®·vG®°¬À {o*y~x®± { ®±v¡{®±¸{p ®±d~kpR³>²ËC³Rp ~´ {¶²R¯±¯± ¾wy¨~®° EGpF/~ {/Ì/È{vxppEƨÇS»Gjlk¾znvGy¯±¯^~xknp ^^pwv
´®°~xkn®°Ê~xynvxo*®±vv®± {y¡Ep¬À {o ~xkp~xynvxo*®½~x~xpw9y{n~xknpdpwp®±¸{pÎypyW´y{xp {¬G~xkp*^zy¨~®° E
{¬Ò~xkp>¬À {pwvxppwd~y{nvxo ®·vv®± {Ky{n3y{ ~lv~yx~µyº~y{nvo*®·vxvx®± {3®±3~xk®·vN~x®±o pδ®°^ ¨´»G>¬ {zvxp
~k®·v>o*pwky®·vo {o*¯±po*pM~v>~xknpznvxzny¯<y{x®±p>vxpnvxp{»9jlk¾znvÎp5pn^®±¡" {\~kpdwyx®±pÎvpwnvp
~kpwvxk {¯· yn { ~kp%yE/~xzy¯µ~xynvxo*®±vv®± {Ây¡Ep{È~xknp}p |¯°znvx®± { ypwy®°nzxpFÂM¿~kp%³Î²
wyp*®±n ¯±zn^pFÊ®±~kp3v~yny{y{x®°pwÎvxpnvxp p | ¯±znvx®° Eypwy} {ºy{ Eo*¯°pwo*pM~º~xk®·vºypwy»
®±¡{zp*ppwvxpM~vRvzky3v®°~xzny~x®± {_»Î>¬ {zvpº~k®·vÅn¡Ezxpdy{vvzo*pFvl~xkny~>~kp {ny{¡Ey~x®± {"®±v
®·vx ~x {n®±Î´®½~k * {nv~yE ¯±pwvl´k®·k%®·vpw®±vxp¯±Ky\yEvxvxzo*^~x®± {%~xky¨~´µp´®±¯±¯Òznvp®±"~xk®·vRv~xzn{»
S S DD
Carrier sense area
CTS range RTS range
0®±¡{znxp.Aµy{x®±plvpwnvpºy¡Ep{Ès<j « yn\j « y{¡{p
ÃÄ®°~xk3vxznk y{ yEvxvxzo*^~®° E~xknpRy®°pwvxpnvxpl¯°pw¸{pw¯¾wy*y¯±´yW^v0pl~zpF~ 9 BC5pwy p | ¯±znvx®° E
y{xpFy\®±n ¯±zn^®±¡¿~xkp"p |¾~yÊp | ¯±znvx®° EZypwyÊ pwy¨~pw ¾Â~kp\³>² vkpo*pE» jlkny¨~*®±vd~kpxpFy{vx {
´k¾%´µp´®±¯±¯0 Envx®±^pw®°~kpnxpFvpwE~R´ {¶K E¯°"yKvx®°o*¯±p « ²¼x {~x ^ E¯Ò´®½~k {z~9y{n^®½~®° Eny¯
¬ÀpFy¨~zxpE»3R ¨´p¸{pwή°~ozv~5p3´µpw¯°¯Gznn^pv~x ¾ ^~kny¨~º~xknp3pkny{n pFyEpwvvvxkpwo*pwvº^pwv ®±pF
®±VƱqwÈqEqÈqF^ÈqFÑ^Èlq¨ÇRwyÁ5p"¸{pÂznvxp ¬Àz¯®± ~kp" {M~xp|¾~ {¬> {Z®±vx ~x E®·K {ny{¡Ey~x®± {¿¬À {
®±nv~y{n pή°"yp~´µ Ex¶*vxk ¨´®°n¡ {v~y{ ¯±pwv~x d¬ÀxpwpÎy{®° nx Eny¡My¨~x®± {ËCv~ppw¯CÈ {nxp~xp{»±»±»Ì »jlkpFvp
nx E Mvxy{¯±v´®±¯°¯Ò5py¯·v *znvxp ¬Àzn¯Ò¬À {¯± {¡*nyE¶{p~vlv®±npÎ~kp%xpF^znpÎ~kp Mv~ {¬<y* E¯°¯±®·v®± {_»
ÏyÊpwpM~dny{pwÆ°qWFÇ9z^~y¿yºzo3y*vxk ¨´ ~xkny~d~kpy{/~zny¯~kx Ez¡{knz^~d®± yozn¯½¹
~®°kn {´®°p¯±pwvvºp~´µ Ex¶´®°~xkÏy{n^ Eo ¯±¯± ^y¨~pw¿ ^^pFv®±vy{/~zny¯±¯± º´knpp
^pn ~xpFvº~xknp3nyn´®±¾~k®°¿®°~ vw»K²~~x "~kpKyz^~k {vº5pwv~¶Mn ¨´¯°pF^¡{pd~xk®·vny{pw´yEv9~xkp
Åv~Ry¨~~po*^~R~ 3p¸¨y¯±zny~xp9~xkpº~ ~y¯Ò~kx Ez¡{knz^~ ¬Gy\y{%k ^ºp~´µ Ex¶h»jlk®·vl®°n®½~®±y{¯v~zn^"kny{v
o* {~x®±¸Wy~xpF¬Àzx~xkpw9 {M~x®°nz^~x®± {nvR~x %p¸¨y¯±zny¨~p~kp¡E¯° Eny¯~xk {z¡Ek\ ¬NyE\p ~´ {¶^v»> Æ°qFWÇ<~xkp
¡E¯° Eny¯n~xk {zn¡{kz~µ®·vNpw¸Wy{¯°zy¨~xpF*¬À {p¡{zn¯±y{Ny{3kn ¾Îp~´µ Ex¶^vw»0jlkpδµ Ex¶*y{x®°pF*®°ÊÆ°q>FÇhxpw¯±y~xpwv
~ Kvxknpw^z¯±®±¡3 {5px~x®±pwvl ¬<@Ú{E»°qEqή±\y{"k ^p~´µ Ex¶^vly"vxk ¨´@~xkny~>y{"k ^ºp~´µ Ex¶
wy\vy¯±p®°¬~kp~yKºxpwo*y{®°v¯° ^wy¯H»²>\®°o*5 {x~yM~> {n¯°znvx®± {\y{\pyW´%¬Àx Eo4ƱqFWÇ~xkp
o*pF^®°zno vxkny®±¡º®±v~xkpR¯±®±o ®°~x®±¡¬óyE/~ {®±Ky{ k ^p~´µ Ex¶^vw»²Ä¶EpÅ¡{zp®°Ky{Ky{ k ^lp~´µ Ex¶
®·vl~kp~kpy{kn®°pw¸Wy{¯±p9¾zodpwR ¬vx®°odz¯°~ynp {zvvznw pFvxv¬Àz¯Ò~y{nvo*®·vxvx®± {nvw»\y} « ²nx {~x ¹
{¯HÈ_~kpKy{x®°pwvpwnvp ~kxpFvkn {¯·Ê´®±¯°¯Np3~kp3¶{pwny{y{o p~xpwÎ~ \xzn¯°p ~xknpK¾zo5p {¬5 ~pM~x®·y¯
vx®±oz¯°~y{p Eznv~y{nvo*®·vxvx®± {nvw»¿>¬> Ezvp3~ {o*z^~pK~xknp"yE/~xzy¯¡{¯± {ny{¯Np~´µ Ex¶Ê~xk {z¡Ekz^~
´p*knyW¸{pd~x pw¸Wy{¯°zy¨~xp ¬À Eºy"¡E®°¸EpÂy®°pwÎy¡Ep~kp3 {ny{®±¯°®°~~xkny~º~xk®·vº~xyvo*®·vxvx®° EÊ®·vº ~
vx5 {®±¯°pF*Md~xknp>®±E~px¬Àppnp>y{znvxpw*¾~kp> {~xkpwNvx®°odz¯½~ypw {znv~xynvxo*®±vvx®° Env»0}vxznkKyyEvpRy
¯±p¡E®½~®°o3y~xpÉMzpFv~®° Ewy\5p~xknp¬À {¯±¯± ¨´®°¡(AN^ ¾pwvR~xkpdy®°pwRvpwnvp~xpwkn®±ÉMzpdvk ¨´ 5p ~~pÎpw¹
¬À Exo3y{n pl~kny*~kp> Eo*¯°p~xpw¯°*v~y¨~®±v~x®·y{¯vxp¯±pw/~®° E ~xkny~µ®·v {5py¨~pw ®±Kyzp>²R¯± {kyºx {~x ^ E¯C»
jlky¨~®±vlnxpF ®·vpw¯°3~kpÉMzpwv~x®± {"zn^pwRp |y{o ®±ny~x®± {}®±"~xkpºpwvxpM~R EM~x®°z~x®± {_»Nξ¸¾®° Eznv¯±*~x
wyx3 Ez^~Ryd¬óy®±R {o*ny{x®·vx {}5 ~kÊ « ²y"²>¯° Ekny oznv~p E^~x®±o*®DwpwÒ»
-%0 "Ð"$ 3$" ¨ ('3)+ %$ !"
jlkn®±v"vpF/~®° EÄ®±v"^®±¸M®·^pFÄ®°V¬À {z%o3y®±cnyx~vw»jlkpÊÅnv~"nyx~%®·v}^pw¸{ {~xpwÄ~x ÁnxpFvpwE~®°n¡ ~xkp
¡Eppwy{¯Ny{vvxzo*^~x®± {nv { p®±¡\y{^®± \ {ny{¡Ey¨~®° E_È_nyE¶{p~dy{^~xzpKy¿~xkp%p ~´ {¶h»"jlkp
vxpw {n*vxpw ~x®± {3pwvxpM~v~xkpº « ²co* ^^pw¯C»Gjlkp>~xk®±3vxpw ~x®± {3pwvxpM~v<~xkp9²R¯± {knyo ^^pw¯C»Gjlkp
¯·y{v~RvpF/~®° E%p5 {x~vlpwvxz¯°~v¬À {o(~kpo* ¾p¯·vl {~xk"¬À {Î « ʲyn²R¯± {ky»
p ~znvyEvxvxzo*p~kny¨~y{¯°¯<~kp*p ~´ {¶\ ^^pwv9´®±¯°¯<~y{nvxo ®°~´®½~k¿~xkp3vyo*pd5 ¨´pE»dÿp3´®±¯°¯
zvpÎ~xkp9¬À E¯°¯± ¨´®°n¡¬Àz/~x®± {
!#"
~ * {o*z^~p9~xkpº5 ¨´µpw$ % ly~R^®±v~y{n p& ('®·vµzvzny{¯°¯±
wy¯±¯°pFK~kp^pFyW*¬óy{ ~x Ew»
jlkpwxp>®±vµy {~xkpwN¸{pwx ¯·y{vv®·y{¯y{vvzno ~x®± {K En pwxn®°¡ {xpF/~pwp^~®° E3 ¬_ynyE¶{p ~F»S~®±v
zvzny{¯°¯±yEvxvxzo*pwd~xky¨~µyº Expw ~<~xynvxo*®±vv®± { ®±o n¯°®±pwv~´µ En^®°~x®± {nvw»<jlkplÅnv~ Ep®±vG~xkny~~xkp
vx®±¡{ny{¯v~xp¡{~xk {¬~xknpdpwp®±¸{pw\~xynvxo*®±vv®± {\®·vºy5 ¨¸{py%¡{®±¸{pw\~xknxpFvk E¯±)*%+
!#,.-
»jlkp*vpF En
Ep ®±v9~kny¨~º~xknp y¨~®° " ¬µ~xkp3vx®°¡Eny¯Gv~xp¡{~xk¿¾~xkp*®±E~px¬Àppnp*®±v9¡{pwy~xpw>~kny~xkpKwy^~zp
¯±p¸Ep¯H»jlk®±vÎ En^®°~x®± {\®·vR¶¾ ¨´"~x K5p~kp « s(Ë« ®±¡{ny{¯ ¨¸EpM~xpw¬Àpwxpwn ps>y¨~x®± MÌlx®°~xpwx®·y»jlkp
®±M~xpw¬Àpwxpwn p0/p |^5p®°pwn pFʾ\~kp*~xynvxo*®±vvx®° E®±v9~kpKvxzo ¬µ~xkp*~kpo3y¯G E®±vxp*yn ¬~xkp
{nzxpwE~~y{nvxo ®·vv®± {nvw»~xkp¬À {¯±¯° ¨´®±¡nÈn´µp´®±¯±¯^pw ~p¾21 ~kpdwy^~zp¯°pw¸{p¯H»Ã¿py{
vxzo*o3y®Dwp>~kpº~´ * {n®½~®° Envlxzn¯°®±¡ ~xkpwy^~zp9 {¬<y nyE¶{p~
435
*%+
!#,.- yn
%
/
361)7
j0´µ 3^®ChppM~R®°M~px¬Àppnp9o* ^^pw¯±vy{xpº´®·^p¯±KznvxpwÒ»
¿~xknpdÅv~yn¿v®±o*¯±pwv~ {pEÈ_´µp {n¯°Ê {nvx®·^p9~xknpKv~x E¡{pFv~º®°M~px¬Àpp9~x \^pF ®·^p*®½¬~xkp
pwp^~®° E ®±vd Expw ~ {n ~w»Ê ~xk®·vdo ^^pw¯N´p%yEvxvxzo*p*~xkny~~kp%wy^~zxp% {^®½~®° E ®·v~x p
¸Ep®½Åpw}¬À {l~xknp®°M~xpw¬Àpwxpw´®½~k"~xkpo3y|¾®±oznoÐ ¨´pRv~xpn¡~xk»jlk®±v> {^®½~®° E%®·v´®·^p¯±}zvpF
®±Ávx®°odz¯·y¨~x®± { ´ {¶^v» n {d®°nv~y{n p}®½~ ®±v~xkp% {p}~xkny~d®·v®±o*¯°pwo*pM~xpF ¬À {~xkp% Ú{E»°qEq
nx {~x ^ E¯Mo* ^^pw¯®° ~kplnvvx®°odz¯±y~x EƱqwÚ¨ÇHÈ{~xk¾znvy{¯°¯¾~kpRv®±ozn¯±y~x®± { ´µ Ex¶^v0znv®±¡º~k®±v~ ¾ {¯nyE/~xzy¯±¯°
y{xp9znp~k®±v>v®±o*¯°pºo* ^^p¯98
jlkp%vpF {o* ^^pw¯N®·vº~xkpK~x ~y¯µ®°M~xpw¬Àpwxpwn p3o* ^^pw¯C»"Â~xkpK~x ~y¯®±M~xpw¬Àpwxpwn p3o* ^^p¯N~xkp
{M~x®±z^~x®± {" ¬Gy¯±¯Ò~kp®°M~px¬Àppvy{xp9~y¶{pw®°M~x 3yE EzM~w»jlkp {n®½~®° E%~ 3xpF pw®°¸Ep9y*nyE¶{p~
®·v~xk¾znv
;:
<>=
= 351?7
´knppA@^pn ~xpFvR~kp ®°M~xpw¬ÀpwxpwÎy{nB
=
^pw ~pwv>~xkp*^®·v~ynp5p ~´ppw~xknppw pw®°¸¾®±¡}n ¾pdy
~kp®±M~xpx¬Àp@»jlkp®±M~xpx¬Àpp p A
<>=
%
=
l®±v> ¬ü~p\y{¯°¯±pw\vxk ~Rn {®·vpE»µÍRn¯°pFvxvÎv~y¨~xpFÒÈn´p´®±¯°¯
zvpº®±%~k®·v´µ Ex¶*~kpvxpw En%o ^^pw¯Ò¬À {l~kp®±E~px¬Àppnp{»
n {l~xknpp ~´ {¶hÈM´pznvxp9~xkpº¬À E¯°¯± ¨´®°n¡ yEvxvxzo*^~x®± {vA
C
~xkp\yE¾¹Hkn ¾}p ~´ {¶¿®±v*^pw¯° ¨Epw EZy{Zypwy ¬&DvxÉMzny{xp%o p~xpwv"Ëü~ Âvx®±o n¯°®°¬À ´µp"´®±¯°¯
y{vvzno p9~kny¨~EDÁ®±vR®°^Å®½~p {Ry~l¯±pwyEv~¯·y¡{pWÌ
C
~xkp¯± ^y~x®± {" ¬~xkpp~´µ Ex¶3n ¾pwv¬À {¯±¯± ¨´Rvyd< E®±vv E}5 {®±M~Rx ^pwvvµ {¬®±M~xpwnv®°~È
C
¬À {ly¡E®°¸Ep3 ^^pή½~vNpw®°¡Ek¾ EN ^^pFvN´®±¯°¯55p>®±%yyd^®±vR {¬_yE^®±znvG~kp>~y{nvxo ®·vv®± {*y¡Ep
: {¯±Kpw®°¡Ek¾ En ¾pwvRwy%¬À {´y{}ny{¶Ep ~vµ¬À ERydn ¾p{È
C
~xkpyn^´®·¾~kÂËCy®±y~xpWÌN {¬0~kpvxknypw}yE^®° *o*pw®°zo ®±v ®±"n®½~ vwÈ
C
y¯±¯Ò~xknpny{¶Ep ~vknyW¸Ep>~kpvyo*pv®EDpEÈ
C
~xkpnp ~´ {¶3 ^^pÉMzpzpFvypy¯±´yW^vN¬Àz¯°¯HÈ
²n^®½~®° Eny¯±¯±{ÈM´µpR´®±¯±¯5yEvxvxzo*pR~kny¨~µ~xkp>~xy K®·vµvx¾o o*p~x®±{È{¬À Eµy¡E®°¸EpKvx {z p~kpÎpwv~x®±ny¨~®° E
®·vlyn^ Eo*¯°}vxp¯±pw ~xpFÒ»
#
S~µ®±vG´p¯±¯n¶¾ ¨´d~xky¨~N®±% « ²Änx {~x ^ E¯±v<®°~N®·v®±o 5 Evvx®°¯±pl~x ~xynvxo*®½~Ny{n xpF p®±¸{p®±*~xknp>vxy{o*p
~®°o*pE»jlkMzv>´kpwp¸EpºyK ^^p*²~xynvxo*®½~vÈ5~xkn®±v9 ^^p ´®°¯±¯¯° ^¶~kp~y{nvxo ®·vv®± {yE pFvxvR¬À {
{~xkpw0n ¾pwv0®°~xkp¸¾®±®°®°~ ¬n²»WÃply{¯°¯E~xk®·v<ypwyRy{x Ezn²Á~xknpxy{x®°pwvxpnvxpµy{xpFy/»R ¨´p¸EpFÈ
~kpºy¨~yvx®°¡Eny¯5vpwE~l¾3²@wyK {~vxznpwvv¬Àzn¯°¯±*p9xpF pw®°¸Epw*®±%y¯±¯~xkp9p | ¯±znvx®° E}ypwynÈ{~kpÎny¨~y
´®±¯±¯5p*vznw pFvxv¬Àz¯±¯°pw pw®°¸Epw\®±y%vo3y{¯°¯±pºypwyKwy¯±¯°pF~xknpxpF pw^~x®± {Êy{xpFy/Èn~kp y{¡{p {¬~xkn®±v
y{xpFydwy"pº~zpF%¾3~kpy{x®±pvpwnvxpÎ~kpwvxk {¯·}´kn®±k^p ~po*®°pFv~xkp¯±p¸Ep¯Ò {¬<vx®°¡Eny¯Òy{ ¨¸Ep
´kn®±ky*~y{nvxo ®·vv®± {knyEv~x %p ^®C5pwxpFÒ»RÃÄ®°~xk\~kp®·v {~x {®·ºy{^®± 3o* ¾p¯´µpkyW¸{pyEvxvxzo*pwÒÈ
~kpdwyx®±pRvxpvp ypwy3y"~xkpdxpF p~x®± {ypwyK´®°¯±¯5p ®±vx¶^vR ¬Gy{^®±znv>xpFv5pw ~x®±¸{p¯±" ~pw?:
-
y{n2:dÈvpwpÎÅ¡{zpÑ»
®±¡{zpÑ1ANy®°pwlvxpvpypwy y}pwp^~®° E"y{xpFy
S~®±vy¯·v ´µpw¯°¯¶Mn ¨´*~xkny~
«
²V ~x ^ {¯·vGoznv~µ®±n { Ey~xpRyn ~xknpµvkpwo pR~x vkpwz¯°p
~y{nvxo ®·vv®± {_»jlk®±v vkpw^zn¯°p%®±vdznvxzny¯±¯°ÂyÊvx®±o n¯°p%ny{¶E CÏvkpwo pEÈ<~xk®·vdo pFknyn®±vxo ®±vdznvxp ¬Àz¯
~ Ê^pFv®±¡{ny~xp}y\~xynvxo*®½~x~xpd´kpÁo*y{¾ ^^pFvdy{xp3´ly®°~x®±¡\¬À Edy¬Àpp"knynp¯N~x Êvxpn ~xkpw®°
y{¶{p~w»<\ Ev~µ {¬ü~xpw" « ²@´kp}znvpF3 {%yy{^®± kny{p¯5y¯·v znvpFvµy{}y{n^®½~®° Eny¯5o*pwkny{®·vo
~ y{¶¾ ¨´¯±pw^¡Ep E®°M~G~ 95 {®±M~Gny{¶Ep ~v<y~0~kpR²>¯±p¸Ep¯H»ÃÄkpw3yÎy{¶{p~®·vG Expw ~x¯±ºxpF p®±¸{pF
¾}~xkppwv~x®±ny¨~®° E_È~k®±v>¯±y~~p>vxpnnvRyyE¶Mn ¨´¯°pF^¡{pwo pwM~nyE¶{p~~x 3®±^¬À {o ~kpvx {z pº ^^p
~kny¨~9~xknp y{¶{p~9ky{v9pwp¿ {pw/~¯°pwp®±¸{pw_»² ²> y{¶¾ ¨´¯±pw¡{po*pwE~>~xpwkn®±ÉMzp*®·v9xpFy¯±¯°
®±o* E~yM~ EÂyyE^®° \o*pF^®°zno 5pwwyznvxp} {¯±¯°®·v®± {vy{¿n ~d5p}^p~xpF/~xpF ¾Ê~kp3~y{nvo*®°~~®°¡
n ¾pwv"y{v"^ {p¿ {VG~xkpwxnp ~w» Î y y{^®± Áo*pF^®°zno"ÈÎ~xknp5 ¨´µpw%^pFyW ®·v"vx Zv~x {n¡ ~xkny~y
~y{nvxo ®°~~®°n¡ ^^p®·v%nyDDw¯°pF ¾Z®°~v} ¨´ ~xynvxo*®±vv®± {Äy{nÄy{ ~"^p ~pw/~y vx®°odz¯½~ypw {znv
~y{nvxo ®·vv®± {_»0 ~xk®·v<´µ Ex¶dyndpwvxpF ®·y¯±¯°®° ~xknpRv®±oz¯·y¨~®° E*nyx~G´µpl´®±¯°¯zvpRy
«
² ´®°~xk3y{
yE^®°~x®± {y¯Ò²>ÄyE¶¾ ¨´¯°pF^¡{pwo*pM~w»0Ãp´®±¯°¯Òzvpºy*v®±o*¯°pºnyE¶{ BC"o*pwky®·vo»G²/~zny¯±¯±3~xkp
nx {~x ^ E¯¾~xkny~N´µp´®±¯±¯nznvxpl¬À {G~kp>vx®°odz¯·y¨~x®± {*´®±¯°¯pR~xkpNÁÚ{M^»±q{q²>Áy{pwvvGo*pwkny{®·vo
´®°~xkn {z^~~kps<j « j « {^~®° E_»
²>¯½~k {z¡Ek « ʲР~ ¾ {¯µ®±v ®±kppM~¯°¿ ~3yÊvx¯± ~~pw nx {~x ^ E¯N´p}´®±¯°¯ly{^ E^~ yv¯± ~x~xpF
o* ^^pw¯C»jlk®±vo* ^^p¯¾®·vznv~®½Åpw®±~kpµ¬Ày{o pw´µ Ex¶9 ¬ {z<y{vvzno ~x®± {nv0¾Î~kpµ¬À {¯±¯° ¨´®±¡>po3y{x¶^vw»
{zºy{k ^p~´µ Ex¶"nyE¶{p ~vÎy{xp~xynvxo*®½~x~xpw¬À {¯±¯° ¨´®±¡}~xkpK « ²xzn¯°pE»ºjlk¾znv9p|^p^~άÀ {
xvx®°odz¯½~ypw {znv ~xyvo*®·vxvx®° EÁËóv~y{~®°n¡%´®°~xk®± y%vxo3y¯±¯ E¯°¯±®±vx®± {Ê´®±n^ ¨´>ÌÎy¯±¯<~xknp {~xkpwº ^^pwv
vx®±oz¯°~y{p Eznv0~xynvxo*®½~x~x®±¡yply~G¯°pFy{v~ : -
yny{~F»0jlk¾znv~xknpp ~´ {¶y{ ~x®±¸M®°~wy pvxpp3yEvy
vxznw pwvvx®° E ¬5~xyvo*®·vxvx®° Env ¬h ^^pwvG®±v~y{E~G¬À {oy¨~¯±pwy{v~ : -
ydpFy{kd~xynvxo*®±vvx®° E®·vG ¬5~xkp
vyo*p^zny~x®± {\y{w {^®±¡ ~x K Ez>yEvxvxzo*^~x®± { {¬G {nv~y{M~Rny{¶Ep ~>vx®Dwp{»ljlkMzvp¸EpE~k®±¡*~y{¶{pwv
n¯±yE pÎyEv®°¬_~xknpÎp~´µ Ex¶*y{ ~x®±¸¾®½~ ´yEvµyvznw pFvxvx®° E3 ¬0vx¯± ~vN®°%´k®·k}v~y¨~®° EnvNn ~µ´®°~xkn®°"y®°pw
vxpvpKpwyEk yp}vxpn^®±¡\~kp®± ny{¶Ep ~wÈGvxpp3Å¡{zp}®± ´k®·k ´p%y{xp}vyo*¯±®±¡Êvx®°odz¯½~ypw {znv
~y{nvxo ®·vv®± {®±ÁyvÉEzypKypwy ¬l~kp}p~´µ Ex¶h»\j0 ~y{¶{p3®±M~x yE {zM~~xknp}nyE¶ BCÏyÂ~xkp
yE¶¾ ¨´¯°pF^¡{pwo*pM~d^zy¨~®° E_ÈG´p%´®±¯°¯yE ~kp%o*pFyZzy~x®± { {¬R~xknp"y{¶Â C ~x ~xknp%nyE¶{p~
zy~x®± {}yEvN´p¯±¯Òy{vµ~xknp9^zny~x®± {K {¬_~xkpyE¶Mn ¨´¯°pF^¡{pwo pwM~µynK~xkpº^zy¨~®° EK ¬~xkpº « ËóE~p
ny{o*p « ny{®°¡¾Ì p~´µpwp nyE¶{p ~v*ynÏ5p ~´ppÏ~kp\ny{¶Ep ~KyZ®°~v}y{¶¾ ¨´¯±pw^¡Epo*pM~w» ²R¯±¯
~kpwvxp^zny~x®± {\´®±¯°¯p y{pw"~x }~xkpdny{¶Ep ~>^zny~x®± {~x }¡{p ~Î~xkpo pFyÊzy~x®± {\ {¬~kp xvx¯° {~
~kny¨~º®·vÎzvpF®± EzÎo* ^^pw¯CÈ_vxppdÅn¡{znxp*^»²/~zny¯±¯±y{vάóyºy{vÎ~xknp~kx Ez¡{knz^~º®±vº En pwxnpwy{¯°¯
~kpwvxp ¨¸EpkpwyEvRy{\pwpÊvxzo*o3y®Dwpw¾y3oz¯°~x®±¯±®±wy¨~®° E\¬óy{ ~x {Îy¯±®±pw~ 3~xkp y®±>y¨~p
vx®±o n¯°\^pwx®±¸{pFMy3z¯±p ¬<~kxpwp{»9R ¨´p¸{pwl~xk®·vÎo ^^pw¯ MpFv>n ~>~y¶Ep®°M~ }y{w {znE~9 {¯±¯±®±vx®° E
{¬p ~´ {¶Ê ^^pFv´®°~xk®±Áwyx®±pvxpvp3y¡Ep{» E®±nv~y pK®°~d®·v5 Evv®±¯±p3~x ¿ Env®·^pw~xkpFvp
{¯±¯°®·vx®° Env¾ zv®±¡ÂyÊo* ^^p¯Rvx®±o ®±¯·y ~x ~xkpÊ « ʲo ^^pw¯^pwv ®°5pwZ®±@Ʊq/ÇS»Ïjlkp^ Eo ®±ny{E~
¬óyE/~ {®±vvkn ¨´3~x pÎ~xknpÎy¨~®° d ¬Ò~xknpÎ {y¡Ey~x®± {K^pw¯±yW*¯±znv^p ~pw ~x®± {K~®°o*pº ¬yny{¶Ep ~lvpwE~
¾*y ^^p>~x EpR ¬_®°~vNp®±¡{k¾5 {®°n¡ ^^pwvµyn* {¬Ò~xkp>~xynvxo*®±vvx®° E*p¯·yW ¬yny{¶Ep ~w»Ã¿p>´®±¯°¯
vxzo*o3y®DwpR~kpºpChpw/~l ¬~xkp ´®½~k®°y{x®±pµvxpvpÎy{¡{p9 {¯±¯±®±vx®° Env Îyn} ¬_~kpº ~xknp ¨¸{pkpFy{
¾ yºoz¯°~x®±¯±®±wy¨~x®± {*¬óyE/~ {
-
~k®±v¬óy{ ~x {µy*5p>vxpp3yEv<~xkp> {o3y¯±®Dwpw~xk {z¡Ekz^~
®°¬>~kp"p ~´ {¶Â´yEv y¿vx®°¡E¯°p"k EÁp~´µ Ex¶hÈ<~xk¾znvd~kpo*y|^®°odzo1y{k®±p¸¨y{¯°p%~xknx Ez¡{knz^~ ®±Zy
vx®±¡{¯±pºk {"p ~´ {¶3´®±¯°¯_5p -
j0 K Eo nz^~xpº~kpp ~´ {¶3~kx Ez¡{knz^~R ¬< {znÎ « ²y{"k ^ºp~´µ Ex¶}´µpºknyW¸EpÎ~ 3pwv~x®±o3y¨~xp
~kp}o3y|¾®±ozno.Mzno5p ¬>vx®°odz¯½~ypw {znv~xynvxo*®±vvx®° Env®±Á EzdyE k ^}np ~´ {¶Ê´®°~xkÁpwvx5pw/~
~ "~xkp3y{x®±pºvpwnvp*y¡Ep : -
»*S~®±vºpFy{vx~x \ Eo nz^~xp ~xkn®±vºÅ¡{zpd®°¬~xkp ~xyvo*®°~~xpwvy{xp ®±
yxpw¡{z¯·ydny¨~x~xp E y¡{®·Â { E pwÉMz®±¯·y¨~xpwy{¯~x®·y¡E¯°pFv» {d~xknp}¡{®·Â´µp}Ånn y{n¿¬À {
~kpK~pwvvpw¯°¯·y¨~®° E ´®½~k pwÉMz®±¯·y¨~xpwy{¯G~x®·y¡E¯°pFv®°~d®·v
»Êjlkp%Êy¨~xpwx ky¾¹S {p*x ^pwvvKƱqwWÇ
y{¯°¯± ¨´Rv Ep~x %z®±¯±Êv~yx~x®±¡3¬À {9y3< {®·vxvx {\nx ^ pFvxvR E®°M~9y}^p®°¸Epw ^ pFvxv´knpp~´µ } ^^pwv
y{xp35 {znnÂ~x Êp2: -
yyx~w»j0 Ê Env~xz/~®°~wÈG {npK¡{®±¸{pFvo3y¶¾v ~x \~kpK®±®½~®±y{¯µ< E®±vv E
nx ^ pFvxvw»<jlkp>o3y¶^v´®±¯°¯h5p9yy{n^ {o ¾zodpwµzn®½¬À Exo*¯±*®±v~x®°nz^~xpFK ¨¸{pw>ËónÈ°qWÌ/»Gjlkp9y¨~p
ky¾¹S {p®±vly~xk®±pFK ^ pFvxv^p®±¸{pwKM3vxp¯±pw ~x®±¡~kp9 ^^pwvµ´®½~k}~kpºvo3y¯±¯±pwv~µo3y¶*´®½~k®°
y^®·v* ¬µy{®°znv:
-
»}jlkp3 E^~y{®°npwx ^pwvvδ®±¯±¯knyW¸{p ~kp3 {5px~~xkny~~´µ 5 {®±E~v ¬~xkn®±v
®°¡Ezp9(A² vxy{o n¯°p {¬~xknpp ~´ {¶*~xynvxo*®±vvx®° Env
®±¡{zp.A
«
¯± ~~®°o*p®±" Ezo* ^^p¯
nx ^ pFvxvÎypdy~ί±pwy{v~&: -
y{nyx~w»º²R®°M~xpwxpFv~®°n¡K¬Àpwy~xzp®·vÎ~xkny~9®°~º®±vÎ Mvxvx®±¯°p~x Eo nz^~xpd~xkp
®±M~xpwnv®°~K {¬0~kpy¨~p%ky¾¹S {p> ^ pFvxvw»Gjlk®±vl®±M~xpwnv®°~
®·v
,
vxpp*ÆWÇS»
Z~xkp"¬À E¯°¯± ¨´®°n¡Ê´p"wyZyEvxvxzo*p%~xkny~ ~kp^p®°¸EpwÁx ^pwvv {¬>~xknpyE/~zny¯±¯°¿~y{nvo*®°~~®°¡
n ¾pwv®°y3 « ² p ~´ {¶3y{%5py W|^®°o3y~xpwKMKydyn^ Eo(®·¶Ky¯±¡{ {®°~xko» E®°M~vl®°%~xkp
®±®°~x®·y¯Ò< {®·vv EK ¾pwvvµy{xpºk Mvpw}y¨~y{^ Eo nz^~l~xkp Env~xy®±E~~xky¨~l * ~xknpvpw¯°pF/~pwK5 {®±M~v
y{xp9´®°~xk®±?: -
¬Gy p´ vpw¯°pF/~pw% E®°M~w»
jlkp"y¨~p kny¾¹ ExpK^ ¾pFv {~dp |yE/~x¯±Â {pwvx En~x Ê Ez*
«
²Ðyn {o n®±¶Âo* ^^p¯
yEvº®½~ {z¯·p*~k {z¡EkM~y¨~º~xkp*Åv~¡{¯·ynp{» _p~znvº®±o*y{¡{®±p3y"y{n^ {o ®±¶Êo ^^pw¯nyEvpFÊ E
~kpÊvxk {x~xpFv~%ny{¶E Cc~®°o*p®±Vy ^®·vx¶Z {¬ºyn¡{p?: -
>~k®±v}o* ¾p¯9®±vK~xkpÊ®°pw ~%¯±®°pÊ ¬y pwy¯
« ²( ~ ¾ {¯H»p ~zvvxz5 Evxp*~xkny~~xkp}o*y{x¶znvxpw®±Â~xkp"y¨~p¿ky¾¹S {p*M¿y\5 {®±E~
ËóxpwpwvxpM~x®±¡y%np ~´ {¶"n ¾pFÌ9®·v9~xkp3®±¾¸{pvxpd {¬N~xknpKvpw¯°pF/~xpFÊy{¶{ BCÂ~x®±o pE»3jlkMzvy"vxp¯±pw ~xpF
n ¾p"®·v ~xknp"n ¾p"´®°~xkÏ~kp\vo3y¯±¯±pwv~*y{¶{ BCZ~®°o*p\´k®·kÏ®±v*p|^yE/~¯°Z « ʲ»N> ¨´µpw¸{p ´kpw
n ¾pwvknyW¸EpKy¯±xpFy{^pwp pw¯°®±o*®°ny~xpFÂMÂy\vxp¯±pw/~pw ^^pK~xkpw¿vxk {zn¯±¿5p}po* ¨¸{pF¬À {o4~xkp
nx ^ pFvxv>~x \wyx {Ê~xkp* ^^p3vxp¯±pw ~x®± {_» jlk®±vv~xpwÊ®·vº ~®±n ¯±zn^pFÊ®±~xkp3y~xpÊky¾¹S {p
nx ^ pFvxv<´kn®±k*p |^¯·y®±nv<´k¾~kpRy~xp*kny¾¹ Expl^ ¾pwv< {~p |y{ ~x¯±d {xpFv5 {n~x Ezµ « ²
y^ {o®·¶\o* ¾p¯H»S~y¿y¯·v "5pd {~x®· pF~kny¨~9~xkp*¾zodpw9 {¬ « ʲpw¯°¯±®°¡E®°n¯°p* ^^pFvή±y
p¡Ez¯·ylp ~´ {¶K E>vpw¯°pF/~pw"¾%y3y~xpkny¾¹ Exp9 ¾pwvv¸¨y®°pFvl´®½~k :
-
»Ãp´®±¯°¯~xk¾znv
yEvxvxzo*pKy¸{p®°¬Àʾ¿vx®±oz¯·y¨~®° E~kny¨~~xkp%Mzno5p {¬ln ¾pwv®± yn^ Eo «
ʲ vxp¯±pw/~®° E®±v
~k¾znv ;:
- : -
È %:
-
l´®±¯±¯5pyK Env~yM~R´kpw?:
-
®·vR {~R~x Kvxo3y¯±¯0y{n %:
- : -
´®±¯°¯
5ppFÉEzn®°¸¨y¯±pM~R~ ¬À {Îvxo3y¯±¯vxo*y{¯°¯ : -
»Ã¿pdwy~kMzv>y{vvxzo*pº~xkny~>~xknpo3y¨|^®°odzo Mzno5p> {¬
5 Evvx®°¯±pvx®°odz¯°~ynp {zvR~y{nvo*®·vxvx®± {®±vΡ{®±¸{pw\¾
j "y~xzp~xknp~x {~y{¯~kx Ez¡{knz^~Î {¬
~kpp~´µ Ex¶K´pknyW¸EpÎ~ ~y¶Ep®°M~ Ky{ {zM~l~xknpvznw pFvxvy¨~pº ¬Gy ~xynvxo*®±vv®± {»_p ~RzvR^pn ~xp
¾
-
~xkpKyW¸Epy¡{pd {¯±¯±®±vx®° EÊy¨~p {¬y%~xyvo*®·vxvx®° E®±¿ Ezy{¾¹Sk ^ p ~´ {¶¡{®±¸{pwÊ~kny¨~y¨~
¯±pwyEv~Î~´µ E¯°¯±®·^®°n¡} ^^pFv9y{xpd ~º´®°~xk®±¿wyx®±pÎxpFy{k_»jlkp*¾zodpwÎ {¬~xynvxo*®±vvx®° E\¬Àxpwpd {¬
kn®±p\ E¯°¯±®±vx®± {nv®·vl~xk¾znv
»j 3 {o*¯±p ~xpº Ezp¸¨y¯±zny~x®± {"´µpºknyW¸EpÎ~ ~y¶Epº®°M~x
yE {zM~Ny¯±¯~kp>np ~´ {¶ ¨¸{pwxknpwy{nv~xkny~NknyW¸{p5ppw}^pFvxx®±pF3y5 ¨¸{pE»0ÿpRknyW¸EpRvk ¨´Kyv®±o*¯°p
z¯±p {¬~xkpp y{p*yn¯°®±pw_»ºjlknp¡{¯± {y¯0~xk {z¡Ekz^~9 ¬~kp p ~´ {¶¿Ëó®° ¯±zn^®±¡}~kp xpw¯±yWEpw
y{¶{p~vÌ®·vl~kMzvA
D -
;:
-
-
: - 7
j0 9 {o*z^~p~xkpy{ ~xzny{¯M~xk {z¡Ekz^~< ¬~xkpp~´µ Ex¶hȨ´pµ´ {z¯·kyW¸{p~ ºo*y{¶{py*y{vvzo*^~®° E
{np®±¡ ~xkpyW¸Epy¡{p9¯±p¡{~xk®°\¾zodpwR ¬<k Env 5p ~´pp\y*¡E®°¸Ep\v Ez pyn%~kpp¯·y¨~xpF
pwv~x®±ny¨~®° E_»GR ¨´p¸{pwl´µpº®±E~pn% {n¯°3~ 3 {o*ny{xpº¡E¯° Eny¯5~xknx Ez¡{knz^~ ¬G « ²yn% ¬<²R¯± {kny
®± odz¯½~®°kn { p~´µ Ex¶^vº~k¾znv~kp%y{ ¨¸Ep*¬À {oz¯·y\´®±¯°¯¡{®±¸{p}znvpw {z¡Ek ®±^¬À {o3y¨~x®± {» {o ~xkp
y{ ¨¸Ep¬À Exodz¯±y}´µp*vxppd~xkny~:
-
wyp*znvxpw~x {^~®°o*®EDpd~xkp*¡E¯° Eny¯0~xk {zn¡{kz~w» ξ¸¾®° Eznvx¯°
´p knyW¸{p~ }Ån~kp*¡{ ¾ ^~xy{p C<»dÎ~kp {p knyÒÈÒ´®½~k¿y%vo3y{¯°¯ :
-
´p´®±¯°¯y{¯°¯± ¨´o* {p
n ¾pwv®±"~xkpnp ~´ {¶3~x *~y{nvo*®°~w»~kp ~kp>knyn"®°¬ : -
®±v>vo3y¯±¯Ò~kp¾zo5p> ¬G {¯±¯±®±vx®° E
¬À {o ^^pFv>n ~δ®°~xkn®°¿y®°pw>vpwnvxppwy{k\´®±¯±¯05pdkn®°¡EkpF»>ÿpÅn|"~kp~y{nvxo ®·vv®± {\y¡EpA:
~ *pnvxzpÎ~kpp~´µ Ex¶K {pF/~®°¸¾®°~Kznvx®°¡ ~kpxpFvzn¯½~v¬Àx Eo Æ^q/ÇS»
S~*oznv~d5p}´p¯±¯ ~pwÂ~kny¨~d~xkp%xpw¸¾®° Eznvo* ^^p¯l^ ¾pwvd {~ Envx®±^pwdy{M E¯°¯±®·v®± { E ~xkp
yE¶¾ ¨´¯°pF^¡{pwo*pM~µnyE¶{p~w»Gjlkp®±o n¯°®· ®°~>y{vvzno ~x®± {"®±vl~kny¨~R´knp%~xkpwxp®·vl K E¯°¯±®·v®± {% {"~xkp
~y{nvxo ®°~~pw%ny{¶Ep ~FȾ~xkpyE¶Mn ¨´¯°pF^¡{pwo pwM~µnyE¶{p ~®·vy¯·v 3 {¯±¯°®·v®± {}¬Àxpwp{»
; # .
ÿpÂyp Envx®±^pwx®±¡ÏyÁvx®°o*¯±p¿²>¯° EknyZx {~x ^ E¯Î´knppÊp~´µ Ex¶ ^^pFv"y{xpznvx®°¡ÏyZ {nv~y{M~
~y{nvxo ®·vv®± {nx Eny®±¯±®½~ ~x 9z¯°p~kplny{¶Ep ~~xynvxo*®±vv®± {v»j0 ºpwvxpM~0~kplpFv~G5px¬À {o3ynp
¬À E²R¯± {knynÈ´p*´®°¯±¯Ny{vvxzo*pd~kny¨~~kp3 ~ ¾ {¯G®·vvx¯° {~~xpFÒ»Kjlk®·vy{vvxzo*^~x®± {Ây¯·v \y{¯°¯± ¨´Rv9znvº~x
yE¶¾ ¨´¯°pF^¡{p~kpÊy{¶{p~%y¨~%~xkp²> ¯±p¸Ep¯H»jlkp¿v¯± ~"´®°¯±¯>~kpp ¬À ExpÊpn {o*ny{vv3~kpny¨~y
y{¶{p~µ®°~vxp¯°¬0y*~xkpyE¶Mn ¨´¯°pF^¡{pwo pwM~ny{¶Ep ~vxpM~l¾d~kpº^pwv~x®±ny¨~®° E} ^^p9®°¬_~xk®·v¯±y~~plkny{v
nx Epwx¯±pwp®±¸{pwd~kp>nyE¶{p~w»0jlknp>¾zo5pN ¬vx®°odz¯½~ypw {znvG~xynvxo*®±vv®± {vG®°*~kp>np ~´ {¶y{
5pKpFy{vx®°¯±Êpw¸Wy{¯°zy¨~xpF A®°~d®·v D yn¿~kpK {~y®±pF¿~xk {z¡Ekz^~d®±vº~kpp ¬À Exp D
"!
+
# /»
²Îvl®°Ê
«
ʲ@´py{%znvxpy xz¯±pº ¬0~xkpp9~x ~y¶{pº®±M~x 3y{w {znE~~xknp ¨¸{pkpFy{*~kMzv~xkpºp~´µ Ex¶
~ ~y¯^~kx Ez¡{knz^~ÎËó®°n¯°z^®°n¡xpw¯±yWEpwdny{¶Ep ~vÌ®·v¡E®°¸Ep*¾ D %$ & '
"!
+
( G´knpp
%$ <p {~xpwv~xkpR¬ÀyE/~x®± { ¬h~kp>vx¯° {~znvpF Md~xknp>y¨~yºny{¶Ep ~F»)3´®±¯°¯pRzvpF ~x {~x®±o ®EDp
~kpº~xknx Ez¡{knz^~Ry{v^ Epº®°ÂÆѨÇS»
