Stack Algorithms in Implicit Framing, Free Access and Blocked Access for CATV Networks

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00072499

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00072499

Submitted on 24 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Stack Algorithms in Implicit Framing, Free Access and Blocked Access for CATV Networks

Cédric Adjih, Philippe Jacquet, Paul Mühlethaler

To cite this version:

Cédric Adjih, Philippe Jacquet, Paul Mühlethaler. Stack Algorithms in Implicit Framing, Free Access and Blocked Access for CATV Networks. [Research Report] RR-4129, INRIA. 2001. �inria-00072499�

(2)

ISRN INRIA/RR--4129--FR+ENG

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

Stack Algorithms in Implicit Framing, Free Access and Blocked Access for CATV Networks

C´edric Adjih , Philippe Jacquet , Paul M¨uhlethaler

No 4129

Mars 2001

TH `EME 1

(3)

(4)

>@?BA!CEDGFIH AKJLDGMONQPRM!DGSTDGU!UWVYX[ZF]\_^Va`bNQPcZ=^!SedgfM!ShVa`iMZ=SGVBC

j'kmlLnpoqRr s(tLuvoEwyxBz{o|}uv~Buv|lLnpoLu

W1vo|e}Qs.'

s}wymv|(ovoLkmokmo"mqir %wyvucyqer qKwyyoLu

!¡¢E£1¤m¥y¢a¦ §b|¨km©ªucmwy[oc«¬omvoLuoa|2©®I|kmo"¯hwynpo«¬°y¯wyLouu±mvy|¨BL²ªu'¯h

w{uv©®m²ªo©®a|¨o²®oLwEÃoLÁmBLouu"©®Äw{¯hvoLop2³m²®B°yoÅwyLoLuvu@npÆoy¿ ÀÁopukm«|¨kmw|

ukm«-|kKw|w#~BKwynp©®|xmm©®{¯|¨ko wLLouu[ouv©®uv|oLmo mwy¨wynpo|oL2Ç0©®npmÃou

|¨kmo2oLv¯hyn wymLo±³y|k{©ª#|¨oLvn u'¯|kmxkmmx|cwyImo²ÈwE~BuL¿

ÉIÊaËÍÌvÎÏ £1Ð¡y¦ .wy³m²®o2j.´Ñmo|§«¬v°½µT·Wj.´5o|§«¬°Æ¸Ò[xmmuÂ|¨oLwynkKwymoL²TÒ¯hwynÓ

©®mmÒuÂ|wy°Rwy²®y©ª|kmn{ÒL¯hooQwyLoLuuÒy³m²ªÆ°oL"wyLoLuvuLÒyoLÂ¯hn wymoWoÃwy²ªxKw|¨©ªÔÒwLLouu

moL²®w~y¿

Õ×ÖØ§Ù§ÚÛ'ØQÜÝ¾Ù§ÞGßà

(5)

()&( 3( +#& 6' )"

¡ ! ¦ obKwm©®o mvuobmwymu ²ªoILwymo%mob²ÈwÄLLoLÆ|¨©®y mobmvy|¨²®ou

#"wLLluexm}tuoEwxÆzb%$y³m²ªtLu}mo"|tL²®tÃB©®u©ª{moLuc©®npm²®tn o]|¨w|¨©ªmu'uv©®npm²®ou}o|eoLÓ

¯hn wya|¨ou'#"xbwy²ª©¾|¨kmnpoeo%m©ª²®o±wEÃyoL@x'& ¯h¨wynp©®m)(e©ªn ²®©®©ª|oy¿+*}xmu}x|¨©ª²®©ªumu

xm{wy²®y©ª|kmnpoco{©®²®o-,]xm©_n t²Èwyoe²ªoLu'tu²ªx|¨©ªmu.o±L²ª²®©®uv©® oLxmuoxm²®o.&§uoLuÓ

u©®y/(Ò}Lo|%w²®v©ª|kmn oI[ox|0|o21 wyv©ªÃytLoY³m²®3,]xmtLoyx41 wyv©ªÃytLoY²®©ª³mo¿5*}xmu

n a|mu6,]xmo"²7"wyLlLu}³m²®3,]xmt"oLxÆ|RwEÃy©®(xm%np[Â|ön o]|}mt|önp©®m©ªuv|ö¿*}xmu

n a|mutLwy²®on o]|,]xmoR²8"wivxuv|¨on oa|.~BKwynp©9,]xmocmx Kw¨wynpl|o}moRoLuv©®uÂ|¨oLLo

#"wLLluÇ[ox|wynptL²ª©®voL2²®ou[ov¯hvn¹wmLou:1b²Èw¯h©®u"oLÅ|oLnpo mo¹mtL³m©¾|o|mo

mtL²®wy©®u¿

;7Ï

¢i¡

Ì

¥=<

¦

s}tuoLwyxº $y³²®t{mo%|¨t²®tÃÆ©ªu©ª9µT·Wj.´;mo|§«v°Æ¸Ò}EwyKw²cnpa|wya|LÒ

&§¯h¨wn ©ªm>(Ò[wy²ª©¾|¨kmnpooLÄm©®²ªoyÒÔwLLlu"²ª©®³mvoyÒ_wLLlu2³m²®3,]xmtyÒ_tÃyw²®xKw|©®%mo[ov¯hÓ

n¹wyLoyÒmtL²®wy©®u'#"wyLlLu¿

(6)

Coax Amp

End user Cable TV

headend

E©®xmvoqGFIH±oLmo¨wy²_wkm©¾|¨oL|¨xmvo¯hy}·Wj.´¿

J

_p+{)"

·5·Wj.´Ñmo|§«v°#mka~Bu©®Lwy²®²¾~#²®B°]u'²®©ª°yo2w|¨voLo2n¹wmo2y¯!aw1zÆ©Èw²ÔEwy³²®oLu}wy%xmuvxÆÓ

wy²®²¾~LÃou'w#wyoLw"y¯ÔuoÃyoLwy²Í³m²ªÆ°]u¬y¯_kmxuoLu¿Qj'kmoeomÆÓ§xuoLvu'wyvoeLymmoL|¨o |¨

«v°]ukKwEÃocxmuxmwy²®²¾~|§«|§~B[ouy¯ÍkKwymmo²®uLFxmmuÂ|¨oLwyn kKwymoL²®uwympm«(muv|oLwyn

wyboLbxmuoL¿Rj'kom©®uÂ|¨v©®³mx|©®{uv~BuÂ|¨oLn o²®©®oucy%|¨kmo"kmoEwÆÓ§omb«(km©®k%©®ue²ªÆLw|¨o

w|'|¨kmo2vÆy|(¯|kmo±|¨ooy¿OÆooQPmxmoq¿

j'koexmmuÂ|¨voEwyn kKwymoL²[©®u³aÃÆ©ªxmuv²ª~pw2ukKwyvoL kmwymmo²Íu©ªmLoewy²®²m|kmo}oLmÆÓxmuou

xmuo"|¨wymuvn ©¾|¨uw||¨kmopu¨wynpo|¨©®npoIµh|km©®u.&§|©®npo(@|wy°oLu@©ªa|¨bwLLyxma|mvKwyaw1|¨©®y

moL²®w~¸Ôy|kmoLÂ«(©®uoQ©¾|©ªu)w}²®²ª©®uv©®Ô¿Íj'kmoLvo¯hvowyoLRp©®oLa|!wyLoLuvu!mvy|¨BL²a©ªu_moLomoL

|¨¹uvkKwyvo"|¨k©®u}³Kwym«(©ª|¨kÍ¿cj'kmo@moLuv©®Iy¯QwyLoLuvu±kKwymoL²!uvkmoLnpo"¯hyR·Wj.´xÆÓ

uv|¨voEwyn0kKwymoL²Ô©ªum©ªuxmuuvoL{©®TS×qVUÍwym ¯hxmÂ|¨kmo.³Kwy°]vxmm#¯h.·Wj.´7mo|§«¬°]u

(7)

©®u(©ªÃyoLÔ¿§%KwyÂ|¨©ªLxm²®wy'¨wy©®m wymIuv~Bmkmvm©Ew|©®{ukmon ou±wyvo"m©ªuxmuuvoLÔ¿'§

S¾qVU«oxmuvoIw%|oo{yuv|w° wy²®y©¾|¨kmn;|¨vxm²®o |kmo#Ly]|oLa|¨©ª wyLoLuuy¯R·Wj.´

xmmuv|oLwyn kKwymoL²¶¿¼§ SU'¯hxv|¨koL«v° ©®npm²®on oa|w|©® wm oLÂ¯hn wymo

wyKwy²¾~Æuv©®u¯c|oLo{wy²ªv©ª|¨kn;©® |¨kmo ¯hwynpo«¬°Áy¯±·Wj.´mo|§«y° ©®uoLuvoLa|¨oÔ¿

OÆkKwyv©®mwY·Wj.´ xmuv|oEwn kKwymoL²'vo%,]xm©®voLu©ª wymm©¾|¨©ªÁ|Ywb¨wymn wLLouu

ukmon o2wouovÃw|¨©ª#ukoLnpoy¿Qj'kmo2ukKw©®³[o|§«ooL{|¨kmo±wymmn*wyLoLuvucuvkmoLnpo

Lxmuvuem©ÍooLa|}¯h¨wynp©®py|Æ²®u¿.!zÆLoLÆ|e¯h}ozÆoLv|ue©ªIwymmn wLLouuRuvkmoLnpo

o¯hoomLou=S×qÒmÆÒ D U[«(©®²ª²[³o±moLoLuvu¨wyÂ~ |¨¯hxm²ª²ª~pxmmoLuÂ|wy|kmoR«¬° mouoLa|oL%©ª

|¨km©ªu}mwy[oL¿¬§I|¨k©®u(KwyoL'«¬o@xmuvo|kmo"uv©®my²®o±©®a|oL²ªoEwEÃo%uÂ|wy°{wy²ª©¾|¨kmn0©®#¯hvoLo

wymY³m²®B°yo½wLLouu2«(km©®kÄ©®u±oLu©ª³[oÁ©ª SUWwymY«o«(©®²ª²!mu©ªmoLwyY©ªn m²ª©®©ª|

¯h¨wynp©®m SD UT¿ À½ouki«|¨kKw||kmo{³m²®B°yo»wyLouu¹Lwy¼³[o©®npm²ªoLnpoLa|¨oÅ|¨ÄkKwEÃo

wyLoLuuKwywynpo|¨oÇ ©®npmviÃyoLuW|¨ko}oLÂ¯hn wymo(³[y|k©®|¨oLvn-y¯[|¨kmvxmkmx|¬wym

moL²®w~Bu¿±j'km©®ucKwyoLR©ªuevawym©LoLbwyue©¾|e¯h²ª²®«(uL¿6OÆoL|¨©®yY ©¾ÃoLuRw¹ukmyv|±voLn wy©®ÆÓ

moL±¯hRuÂ|wy°b¯hvoLopwymY³m²ªÆ°oLÁwyLoLuvuwy²ª©¾|¨kmnpucwymÄmÃB©®mou±|§«{©®np[yv|w]|

moLÂ|¨©ªoLu±y¯|¨kmouo wy²®y©¾|¨kmnpuL¿ OÆoL|¨©®y

D

voLv|uuv©®nx²Èw|©®bvoLuvxm²ª|u2¯hy±uv|w°

wy²®y©ª|kmnpue³y|¨kY¯h±¯hoo¹wyLouu@y³²®B°yoL½wyLoLuvuL¿#§Á|kmouoLm½Kwyv|y¯uoÓ

|¨©®y D «o#uÂ|¨xmÆ~Åkm«0|¨kmo Æ~Æmwyn ©ª¹|¨xm©®m%y¯}[ou©ªuv|oLmowyLoLuuKw¨wynpo|oLÇ

©®npmÃou.|¨kmo2oLÂ¯hn wymo±©®#|¨onpu}¯|kmxkmmx|}wmIoL²ÈwE~BuL¿

j'k©®uemwy[oekKwue³oLoL%muvoLwyuew¹Ly]|©ª³mx|¨©ª|¨ |kmoQQaÆ¿¾qE¹nÓ

n ©¾|¨oLo¿

2{

À½o2¯hÆxmu}%uv©®m²ªo2©®a|¨o²®oLwEÃouv|w°%wy²ªv©ª|¨kn uÒÆ«(©ª|kI|kmo¯hy²®²®«(©ªmoLoL¨w²moÓ

uLv©®|©®$F

ÃB©®v|xKwy²Æuv|w°@y¯uxLLouuÂ¯hxm²[vo%,]xmouv|¨u¿QQwykxpa|wy©ªmuomÆÓ§xuoLvuW«(km©®k

kKwEÃoL²ª²®©ªmoL¹|o|¨kmo}©ª#|¨kmo©®'²Èwuv|.|¨wymuvn ©ªuuv©®w|v|¨on |L¿

"!$#&%(')'+*,%-".0/1.

X

!32)/145%

X76 498:4";

X

4 872=<>!$?:4

X

.@8:4A %CB34AD*

X

E?&B$.

X

2)F48HG

\I

(8)

¸e|kmopwy²®y©ª|kmn oLoL©¾Ãou"¯hoLom³Kwy°FL²ª²®©ªu©®ymuLÒ_wmÁuvxmLoLuvuxm²¬o%,]xmouv|uL¿

|WmxmuvkmoLuLyoumm©ªm±Ly]|oLa|¨©ªyxmmuQwymuvxmLoLuuÂ¯hxm²=o ,BxoLuv|u¬uÂ|¨voL

©® |kmo2uv|w°Bu¿

¸R|¨ko¹wy²ªv©ª|¨kn wy²ª²®BEw|oLuR|¨ko¹uo|@¯'u²ªy|¨uÒxmuv©®m{|¨kmopo ,]xmoLuÂ|¨uLyÆÓ

|¨o]|©®u'xmu'¯hn0|¨kmo2uv|¨wy°]uVF

0 ¸©¾¯©¾|(©®u'vo%,]xmoLuÂ|EÒK|¨koL{Kw|wnp©®m©ªu²®|¨u¬wyowy²ª²®BEw|oL

0

¸_©ª¯K©¾|!©ªu!wcLa|¨oa|¨©®yyxmÔÒ|kmoL@La|¨oa|¨©®yn ©ªm©®uv²®y|u)wyo¨w]|oL

«(©ª|k{wyI©ªmoLa|©PKo'y¯|kmo2mo%,]xmoxmoL%xÔ¿

0 ¸¼unpoÆEwyuv©®upa|¨o]|©® n ©ªm©®uv²®y|uwyvo{y¨wya|¨o ¯ho«.Ó

Lyn ouLÒ«(©¾|¨k wImo¯Gwyx²ª|µLLo]¸"yxm½©®mo]|©PKoL¿ OÆxk wbmo«0vxm

«(©®²ª²Í³o2Ewy²ª²®oL{w

,3 &,&3

¿

Iwya~m©[oLvoLa|([y²®©®©®ou.Ewy{³o©ªn ²®oLnpoLa|oL «(©ª|km©® |km©®u.¯hwynpo«¬°F

O]|wy° n wyKwoLnpoLa| _ E E! E

ew|wÃouvxmuea|¨oLa|©®{u²ªy|¨u m©ª©¾|§~ | mw|w uv|w°Bu}npoLyoL

*}o«¬LnpoL}wyLouu ¯hoo"wLLouu ³m²®B°yo%wyLouu

*}o«¬LnpoLvucoLvu©ªuv|¨omLo qÓ§oLvu©ªuv|¨omLo xmu©ªm[ou©ªuv|oLmo@s

ÀÁo2kKwEÃo©®npm²®on oa|¨oL |§«¬|§~ÆoLu}y¯uv|¨wy°#n¹wKwyon o]|VF

uv|¨wy°=Ò_ EOmw|wuv|¨wy°=Ò=m©ª©¾|§~ |pmw|w¿

uv|¨wy°=¿

·Onpo±mo|wy©ª²®oImou©®Æ|¨©®yIy¯|¨kmo©®npm²ªoLnpoLa|w|©®¹y¯!|kmoE EÑwy²®y©ª|kmn

«(©ª|¨k¯hoowyLouueÃyoLuvxmuR³m²ªÆ°oLwLLouuÒÔwymI[ouv©®uv|oLmo@ÃouvxmuRmBÓ§oLuv©®uÂ|¨oLLo

µÂqÓ [ou©ªuv|oLmo¸¿

wym{w¯|¨o'|¨kmouoyÒ=voLux²ª|¨u'¯!|¨kouv©®nx²Èw|©®mu¿

(9)

!#"$%!&(')!* (+,-

KwynpoL²ª~%w#³[yxmmÄ|¨kmo]xmn³oL2y¯¬Kwywy²®²ªoL²!²®²ª©®uv©®IoLuv²®xÆ|¨©®yb|¨ooLuÒ!wyY|kmo

./102/10 3 Ï 54Ð Ï 4»¢76 Ê 4# ! Ê £ Ï98;: ¤m£i¤ << Ê <¬¥ Ï < <1<T¡=<Ï 4 £ Ê ¡ Ï <)¢>< Ï 4¼¢E£ Ê]Ê ¡

²®oEwEÃyo}uÂ|wy°@[²ª©®~Òy«(kKw1|¨oÃyoL¬©ª|W©ªu¯hoLo}wyLouuW³m²®B°yo¹wLLouu¿j'k©®uWmv[ov|§~©ªu

©®a|¨ooLuÂ|¨©ªm³[oEwyxuo©ª|'uvkm«(u}|kKw|'uv©®m²ªoR©®a|oL²ªoEwEÃo2uÂ|wy°#w²®v©ª|kmn u©®©ªn m²ª©®©ª|

uoÃyoLwy²)©®a|¨o²®oLwEÃoLu'«(km©ªkIÃB©®mowy{|©®n wy²[xÆ|¨©®²ª©Lw|¨©ª¹y¯|¨ko³mwym«(©ª|¨kÔ¿

? Ï < <@<G¡=<Ï 4 Ê ¡ Ï < )¢><Ï 4A£ Ê]Ê ¡CBD? AFE

/

!zÆLo|@¯hy±By|2yxmmuLÒoEwk½vxm

Ewy²ª²®oLI³a~I|kmoc(Ò 1G +HG ,]xmoLxmoY©®%|kmo"ÃB©®Â|¨xKw²a|¨oLa|©®buÂ|wy°{Lyn oue¯hn |kmo

|¨oLvKwyÂ~Åu²®©ª|@y¯}wy ²ªmoL"xÅ«(km©®k kKwEÃo©¾Ão ©®uvo¹|¨Ywb²®²ª©®uv©®Ô¿%j'km©®u©ªu

|¨xo%oÃyoLg©®¼¯hoowyLoLuvu u©ªmLo%|kmo%yxmu#wyxmnpoLa|oL y¯2o«¬LnpoLvu#wyoIuv|©®²®²

©ª©®Kw1|¨oL¯hvn|¨kmo}|¨oLvKwyÂ~ uvm²®©¾|y¯)wy y²®moyxmÍ¿Wj'kmoLvo¯hvoc«¬oREwy ¯hn wy²®²¾~

³Kwy°a«.w²®©ªm°±|¨kmo.yxmu³[o|§«ooL|¨kmonÑ©ªvmoL!|±³|¨wy©®

C,++

y¯=vxmmuÒaoEwyk

|¨oo |¨onp©®Kw|©®m%¼wYuv©®my²®o vÆy|yxmÍ¿½À½o#Lwy²®²uxmk uv|¨vxm|xmo{wÄ²ª²®©®uv©®

s}ou²ªx|¨©ª%jooµ¶.s!j}¸¿[·Ñmo«-.s!j ©ªueoLboLwykb|¨©ªn o"w¹vÆy|cvxmb©ªueEw²®²®o

³]~p|¨koRe'¿B· .s!jg©ªu¬²®uvoL¹«(kmo#©ª|u²Èwuv|¬x kKwyu¬³[ooL#Ew²®²®o¹wm kKwyu©ªÃyoL

& *c²®²ª©®uv©®/(¬¯hoLom³Kwy°=¿Q· .sjg«(k©®k kKwumy|¬~o|.³oLoL#²®uvoL ©ªu¬uwy©®p|¨³oe©ª

mBLouu©ªmm¿

Àg©¾|¨k{|¨kmou©ªm²®o2©ª]|oLv²®oEwEÃyo@uv|¨wy°Iwy²®y©ª|kmn{ÒÆ|¨ko.s!juem²®wE~#|¨kmo²ªo"¯ &©ªnÓ

m²®©ªL©ª| (R©ªa|¨oLv²®oLwÃyoLu}u©ªmLouoÃoLwy²W.sj9EwyIu©ªnxm²ª|¨wymoxmu²¾~ ³o"©ªmBLouu©ªmm¿ÀÁo

I £ Ï9:WÊ £i¢ Ë 0KJ

+MLON+ )+ =PG /+RQSN+ B.++'&%&)-&/78++5/%N 78 '2T

22 ($ )+: !47%&'=)++&,+?&- 3UL &%&2+ 9 2!WV1+3C!

<#,++ &$+&4XQ A,3+

Y Z[,]\ &'^O!&_&UU`a^_2-b%&K-cd#-b !e(

À½o"wyuuvxmnpo@kmoo"|kKw|ew ³m²ªÆ°oLwLLouuRuÂ|wy°{wy²ªv©ª|¨kn©®u}xmuvoLÔÒ«(©ª|¨k%wya~|§~Æo

y¯!a|¨o]|©®2fKw|¨wuÂ|wy°]u@µ _ EÒE! EÒn ooÔÒ + HG

¸¿

(10)

§@³m²®B°yowyLoLuvuLÒmo« LnpoLvu!moÃo!©®a|oLv¯hoo«(©ª|¨k"Lxmvo]|²ª~,]xmoLxoLvxmmu¿

|¨©®npoe©ªwBy|'vxmÔ¿W§#|¨ko±u©®n@xm²Èw|©®u¬«(©ª|km©® «owyuvuxmnpo±|¨kKw|.uxmk{oLm{xmuvoL

OB©®mo{oLwyk»yxm¼Ly]|¨wy©®u omÆÓ§xuoL«(km©ªk»kKwEÃo{Ly²®²®©ªmoLÅ|o|¨kmop¯h|kmo

u¨wynpoBxn³[o"¯¬|©®npoLuLÒ)©¾|"©ªu±[yuu©ª³m²®o|I©ªn m²ªoLnpoLa|2w /+ +')2! ÃyoLvu©®y½y¯

³m²®B°yo wyLoLuvuL¿ E=y2|km©®uuoL©Èwy²QLwyuop«o¹wyuuvxmn op|¨kKw1|"|kmoLvo¹wyvo LmoL|¨oL

y¯|kmo |¨kmo"xmuvoLvuL¿{²®oLwy²¾~

¿¹Àg©¾|¨kY|¨km©ªu2k]~By|¨koLu©ªu"©¾|©®u2©®np[yuu©ª³m²®o

|¨kKwEÃyoR|§«¬n yo}oLmÆÓ xmuo'kKwEÃB©®muvxmLoLuvu©ªÃyoL²¾~#L²ª²®©ªmoLpn yoc|kKwy |©®npoLuL¿

E=xv|¨koLnpvo |¨kmo{]xmn³oLpy¯eyxmubµhn ©ªm©®uv²®y|u¸oLoLoL»|Áuv²ªÃyoIw»©®©ª|¨©®wy²

L²ª²®©®uv©®ÍÒ 1G +HG |¨kmo]xmn@³[o±y¯mÆoLu±©®I|¨kmovoLum©®m{.s!j±Ò[Ewymy|2ozÆoLoL

¿

Ê !½¤m£¦ {©®m©ªu²®|¨u'Ew%³o"©ª]|oLv²®oEwEÃyoL%«(©¾|¨k{Kw|wpu²ªy|¨uÒ[wm{«¬o@kmwÃyo@|¨pLyÆÓ

.s!juWuv©®mo(wy²®²]|¨ko'oLn wy©ªm©®mcyxmmuWn w~"³o«.w©ª|¨©ªme¯h|¨¨wmunp©®uvu©®y@¯hoLom³Kwy°=¿

Lnpm²®o|¨o²ª~ oLuv²ªÃyoLÔ¿

ÀÁoRuvkm« ³oL²ªi« wÃoLÂ~ ©ª]|oLvoLuv|©®moLÂ|§~ «(km©ªk#uv|¨w|¨ou|¨kKw1|'mo|oLvn ©ªm©®uÂ|¨©®

u©®²®o©®a|¨o²®oLwEÃoQ³m²®B°yowyLoLuu)uÂ|wy°±w²®v©ª|kmn umviÃB©ªmoW³[yxmmmo@wyLouu)moL²®wE~Æu¿

I £ Ï9:WÊ £i¢ Ë .$J

+ N+. )+ =PG /4&!2+& ,+3+! &+5/.)+I&2+.+ )+#"2T

#/& $5& +&C! &/ 3RQ N4+5/ + PG + ! $N&/L N+ )+Q 34&!

/+RQ ( NT+ PL,+3+5/AT')229 )YG <*)+ =PG +/+RQABKN/+ +DT

')2C! &2+Q) +2+5% &+ NV234+5/ + &YT !7%&' 2

L& ('*)+-, &

/.0

'12, + ')22 HG

7KB.+.( + & 43657

08

(*)+')+ =PG /+RQdN+ +:95L& 57

;8

'

)+-,

&=<

>'1 +

I £ ÏÔÏ98 ¦ ÀÁo PKvuv|2|¨{mviÃyo |kKw| L , &/?%@

.0BA

)C'D +2©ªu±|¨kmopn¹wiz©ªnxmn moL²®w~

³[o|§«ooL|§«2LymuoLx|©ªÃo(BLxmvoLmo}¯|kmo'oÃyoLa|+&uÂ|wy°"oLnp|§~=(¿!j±|¨km©ªuoL«¬o

o¯ho|Rmy[ov|§~ q«(km©®kuÂ|w|oLu!|kKw||¨kmoo'wyvo.w|!n yuv| L .s!ju©®uv©®nx²ª|wmoLxu

mBLouu©ªm w| wya~ |¨©®npoy¿ OÆ©ªmLoIoEwykºy¯R©ª|¨u .s!jEwmmy|#a|wy©ªmu¹npvo{|kKwy

(11)

? @

.0 A

«(©®²®²[moLoLuvu¨wyÂ~I³o2ozÆkKwyxuv|¨o%³o¯hvo L , &/?@

.0 A ) ' +'np©®©®u²ªy||©®npoRxmm©¾|¨u¿

j'k©®uR³xmm©ªuPKvuv|R|kmon w1zÆ©®nxmn|©®npo¯hew ¨wymnoLmÆÓ xmuoR«(©ª|kw mo«

o%,]xmouv|'| PKm#|¨kmoemozB|(By|x |¨|¨wymuvn ©¾|EÒ 1G+ «(koL#|¨kmoeuv|w°¹«(©®²ª²vo|xm

|¨{oLnp|§~Yuv|¨w|¨o¿ OÆoLmÔÒ«(kmoLÅwymmo½y¯ L np©®m©ªu²ªy|¨uR©¾|©®uwy²®uv#|¨kmopn¹wiz©ªnxmn

OB©®mo¹|¨kmoo#wo wIn¹w1zÆ©ªnxmn;y¯C vo|¨wymuvn ©ªuu©ªmuÒWwymm©ªmI|km©®u"n¹wiz©ªnxmn

moL²®w~yÒ«¬o"³Æ|wy©ª |¨kmo2ozÆmvoLuvu©®y%y¯|¨kmo2n w1zÆ©®nxnwyLouueoL²ÈwE~y¿

p #2)"{&( #

-!e ; (! -b ('

j'kmo2u©®n@xm²Èw|©®uxmuvo|kmo2Kwy¨wn o|¨oLvu'y¯|wy³m²ªoq¿

OÆ©®nx²Èw|©®muKwywynpo|¨o ´wy²®xmou

*cxmn³oL'¯wy|¨©¾Ão2uv|¨w|¨©ªmu y

e©®uÂ|wymo±¯hn*uv|w1|¨©®ymu.|¨kmoLwymoL y°]n4µGwym©ªm]¸

McmuÂ|¨oLwyn Kw1|w|¨wymunp©®uvu©ª#¨w|oLu

D

{³m©ª|u fu

QvKwyw|¨©ª#moL²®wE~ u f°]n

)omy|k{¯u©ªnxm²®w|¨©ª D uoLmmu

H2xKwm³Kwm{wym{moÓwyn³²®o mxm¨w1|¨©®y#y¯ ³a~]|¨oLu

I©®m©ªu²ªy|.uv©Lo q ³]~]|oLu

coEwmoLm{mvÆoLuuv©®mpmo²ÈwE~ npu

coEwmoLm{mvÆoLuuv©®mpukoLnpo ¯hoLoL³Kwy°wymIwy²ª²®BEw|©®¹w|(oEwyk{np©®m©ªu²®|

j!wy³²®oqGF *}o|§«¬° OÆ©ªnxm²®w|¨©ª Pmxm¨w1|¨©®y!wywyn o|¨ou

Æ¿#QwykÅmBmop©®u2npÆmo²®oÄÃB©Èw{wNE E ,BxoLxmo¹«(koLo ²®BEwy²ª²ª~IoLoL¨w1|¨oL½Kwy°yo|¨u

wyo±uÂ|¨voLÔ¿Qj'kmou©Lo2y¯|¨kmo2mBmo±³mx>[oL(©ªu'uo|}|¨ yKw°yo|uL¿

(12)

Kwy°yo|e²ªoLm|¨k ³Kw³m©®²ª©ª|§~

qi ¿

qa ¿

yy ¿y

a ¿a

qa ¿

qiÆqE ¿ D

jwy³m²®o" FQwy°yo|e²ªoLm|¨km©®uÂ|¨v©®³mx|©®

·'m©ª|©®Kw²ª~Kwy°o|uewyvoRuom©®#·Wj} Lo²®²ªu±µGnp©®©®u²ªy|¨uQ¯hw ³a~B|oLu(KwE~aÓ

²®awyK¸ÒmwmIoL©ª|kmoL'©®y~aÓ ³Kwy°]©®mmy'Kw|wmEw1|¨oLmw|¨©ª{wyo2xmuvoLÔ¿

Y ]!*;^ \ &('^O!&_&U

j'kmoRouxm²¾|¨u.ÃB©®m©ªm¹|¨koenpoEwy#wLLouu(mo²ÈwE~ÃoLvuxmu'|kmoekKwmmoL²Í²®awy¹wyoe©ªÃyoL

©® PKxmvopwm D ¿

j'ko¹ouxm²¾|¨u"ukm« |¨kKw1|"|kmo oLÂ¯hn wymo ¯'m©[oLvoLa|©ªn ²®©®©ª|c¯h¨wynp©®m#«(©¾|¨k

mopwy²®y©¾|¨kmn{Ò¯hvoLooLa|v~ E! E0uÂ|wy°=Ò)|¨kKw1|2[ov¯hvn u±uv²®©®yk]|²ª~I³[o||oL±|¨kKwY|kmo

y|¨kmou¿¹j)«IoEwumuozÆm²®wy©®Y|¨k©®u2³[o||oL2[ov¯hvn¹wmLo]FPKvuv||¨kmo¯Gwy|2|¨kKw|2¯hvoLo

oLa|¨Â~bwy²ªv©ª|¨kn u'uvkmxm²ª%²®«¬oLcL²ª²®©®uv©®nx²ª|¨©ªm²®©ªL©¾|¨©®ou¬|kKwyb³m²ªÆ°oLYwy²ªv©ª|¨kn u

µh«(©ª|km2[ouv©®uv|oLmo¸ÒBuvoLm|¨kmo.¯Gwy||¨kmw|W|¨kmo'uv©®nx²Èw|oL _ E wy²ªv©ª|¨kn u©ªÃyo

m©ª©¾|§~ |pmw|wÒÆ«(km©®k{n¹wE~#oL²ÈwE~Bu(L²ª²®©ªu©®y¹ou²ªx|¨©ªÔ¿

;&_[ , %&U (!^ \d &('^

!&_&_

§Ix'©®npm²®on o]|¨w|¨©ªÔÒa«¬o"xmuvoL%wuv©®npm²®oeukmon o2¯h(sQF

s ©®u'©ªm©ª|©Èwy²ª©oL | LoLv

LvoEwyuvoLÔ¿

(13)

0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05

0 200000 400000 600000 800000 1e+06 1.2e+06 1.4e+06 1.6e+06 1.8e+06 2e+06

Delay (seconds)

Bandwidth (bit/second) - Emission

blocked, no R free entry, no R FIFO, blocked, no R FIFO, free entry, no R

E!©®xo2 FQ·)Ão¨wyo2mo²ÈwE~ ÃyoLuvxmue©ªmmx|(²ªawyÔ¿

j'ko ¨w|©®mwy²®o©ªu"|¨kmw|"¯hy@oEwkÅuxmLouuv¯hx²'o%,]xmouv||kmoLvo ukxm²®Áxkm²ª~Ä³o

moa|¨o]|©®@n ©ªm©®uv²®y|L¿;E!©®xoQR©¾ÃoLu!wy©ªmoEw}y¯Kkm« s oÃy²ªÃouW©®|¨kmo¬n ©ªm©®uv²®y|

uv|¨voEwyn{¿

*}y|¨©ªLo|¨kKw1| «(©¾|¨km©ª |¨k©®upukmon oÒ(wyu¹uvkm«(º |kmobwy³ÃoIozwynpm²®oÒ.©ª¯±ymo

Ç 3 )b|¨¼Ç 3 Ô¸Ò(|¨kmo ©¾| «(©®²ª²cn wy°oYwÅo%,]xmouv|{gmo¯|kmo9¯h²ª²®«(©®m

µG©®npm²ª©®L©¾|¯h¨wn ©ªm]¸Ò©®u |km©®u¹Lmuv©®uÂ|¨oLa| «(©¾|¨kºw²®²®BEw1|¨©®Áa|¨oLa|©® np©®©®u²ªy|p³a~

³m²®B°]u@µhkmoLvo_¸Òm«(©¾|¨k{wu©ªn m²ªoeÃwy²®xoy¿

|¨oLLo)|¨kop©[oLomLo©ªuRm«5|kKw|±|¨kop³²®B°yoLÃyoLuv©®u"won yooR ©®o]|2|kKwy

¯hoLocÃoLvu©ªmuL¿IEKw@m©®voL|'LnpKwyv©®uv y¯_|kmoRLymuo ,BxoLmoLu}y¯©®npm²®on o]|¨w|¨©ªmu

(14)

0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05

0 200000 400000 600000 800000 1e+06 1.2e+06 1.4e+06 1.6e+06 1.8e+06 2e+06

Std. Dev Delay (seconds)

blocked, no R free entry, no R FIFO, blocked, no R FIFO, free entry, no R

E!©®yxmo D FIO]|wymmwy{moÃB©®w|¨©ª#y¯|¨kmo2mo²ÈwE~ Ãouvxmuc©ªmmx|(²ªawyÔ¿

: contention minislots for colliders or data minislots

R=1 R=1 R=1

Contention Data

R=2

R=1 RQ!=0 R=2 Data ...

...

R=1 R=1

Data R=n

R=n R=n-1 R=n-2 R=n-3 ... R=2 R=1 R=1 ...

Minislots

: contention minislots for root group

Minislots (continued below)

(15)

0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05

0 200000 400000 600000 800000 1e+06 1.2e+06 1.4e+06 1.6e+06 1.8e+06 2e+06

Delay (seconds)

blocked, with R free entry, with R FIFO, blocked, with R FIFO, free entry, with R

PKxmvoyÒKuoo PKxmvoLu wm Æ¿

(16)

0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05

0 200000 400000 600000 800000 1e+06 1.2e+06 1.4e+06 1.6e+06 1.8e+06 2e+06

Std. Dev Delay (seconds)

blocked, with R free entry, with R FIFO, blocked, with R FIFO, free entry, with R

3O@ _"

(17)

0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05

0 200000 400000 600000 800000 1e+06 1.2e+06 1.4e+06 1.6e+06 1.8e+06 2e+06

Delay (seconds)

FIFO, blocked, no R FIFO, blocked, with R

(18)

0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05

0 200000 400000 600000 800000 1e+06 1.2e+06 1.4e+06 1.6e+06 1.8e+06 2e+06

Delay (seconds)

FIFO, free entry, no R FIFO, free entry, with R

(19)

0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05

0 200000 400000 600000 800000 1e+06 1.2e+06 1.4e+06 1.6e+06 1.8e+06 2e+06

Delay (seconds)

blocked, no R blocked, with R

(20)

0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05

0 200000 400000 600000 800000 1e+06 1.2e+06 1.4e+06 1.6e+06 1.8e+06 2e+06

Delay (seconds)

free entry, no R free entry, with R

(21)

&'/&.&(&(

uoLwyk%s}o[yv|(mq ÒÍq Ô¿¾Òwy]xKwyÂ~{yÆq¿

*es(§·Os}ouoLwyk%s}o[Â|(mq ÒD

Í¿ªÒEKoL³xKwyÂ~{yÆq¿

s(oLv|cÔ¿¾ÒEKoL³mvxKwyÂ~{yqR|pwymoEwy¿

Ô¿¾Ò%wyvkbyyq±|¨pwymoEwy¿

(22)

wym

uvxmmu©ªm

¿@ÀÁomoLm|¨ouv|¨wy° & +

j'kmoLvo¯hvouÂ|wy°

&

+B3guv|w°

& + '

A

'

A

p¿

Ò.|kmoL «¬obkKwEÃyobuv|¨wy° & + 3

A

D'

A

& + R¯hwy²®²!#"$

¿

)

*

Ò|¨kmop«¬o(kKwEÃo

uv|w°

&

+#3+%(' '

A

'$

A

p¿

ÀgkoLÅw#vxm|¨kmw|"wyxmYkKwu³oLo½Lwy²®²ªoL³a~b|¨ko c9wymY|¨ko¯hooLm³mwy°

%(-#/D

A

p¿

&

+B3%(' ' A

'0

A

Ò1%('

A

(23)

Unité de recherche INRIA Lorraine, Technop ôle de Nancy-Brabois, Campus scientifique, 615 rue du Jardin Botanique, BP 101, 54600 VILLERS L ÈS NANCY

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rh ône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST MARTIN Unité de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis, 2004 route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 SOPHIA-ANTIPOLIS Cedex

Editeur´

INRIA, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex (France)

ISSN 0249-6399