Stack Algorithms at High Loads : Analysis of Unfairness or Singular Behaviours

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00072498

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00072498

Submitted on 24 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Stack Algorithms at High Loads : Analysis of Unfairness or Singular Behaviours

Cédric Adjih, Philippe Jacquet, Paul Mühlethaler

To cite this version:

Cédric Adjih, Philippe Jacquet, Paul Mühlethaler. Stack Algorithms at High Loads : Analysis of Unfairness or Singular Behaviours. [Research Report] RR-4130, INRIA. 2001. �inria-00072498�

(2)

ISSN 0249-6399 ISRN INRIA/RR--4130--FR+ENG

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Stack Algorithms at High Loads: Analysis of Unfairness or Singular Behaviours

C´edric Adjih , Philippe Jacquet , Paul M¨uhlethaler

No 4130

Mars 2001

TH `EME 1

(3)

(4)

+ $,*- &$,./01)$,2,)435./7612'8

9:<;8=?>A@CB1;EDF>AGIHKJLG8>AMN>AO8OQPSRUTV@XW(YP[Z\HKJ]T^Y8M`_baG8McP[ZdGT^MAP<=

egfihFjlkmLn o/pFqrk?sut<vwk)x7qry<qrxzhFjlkFq

{Q|z}~rkx`7{Kog

o7suiV}|rx/k |rkFfik)|zfikimun su|rq]um`n mdEsuukFq

'8)? i¡u[¢ £xzfi¤¥qQisuUk)|F¦§¨kg¤¥[©k)qrxz¤¥[s-xzkxªfik«As-¤¥|zkFqzq8}u«Vqrxs-¬suF)kFqrq"su®¯}|r¤¯xªfj1q

¤¥°}d©ukF|r®¥}[su±F}i¤¯xz¤¥}iq)²´³µkwqzf}d§¶xzfEs-x1F}[©k)[xª¤¥}uEsu®]·s-qrx1£¹¸8¤¥|rqrxºLtxl«c|zkFk&»

suF)kFqzq]qrxªsu¬wsu®¥}u|z¤¯xzfijlqi|z}©<¤¥kti¼«Asu¤¥|/fEsuikF®suF)kFqrqs-x7fi¤¥ufC®¯}[suiq)²"½Iqzti¾iqrk)x

}u«QkF¼»£tiqrkF|rqjºs?yqrxªsu|r©ukiti|r¤¥iºik)x£§¨}|z¬w}©k)|z®¥}suiqLs-q]xªfk}uxªfkF|`}¼ik)q`Fsuxªt|zk

xªfik§/fi}u®¥kfEsuikF®K?s-EsuF¤¿x£y²³Àkqzfi}§ÁxªfEs-xxzfik¸8¤¯|zqrxL£µ¸8¤¯|zqÂx Ltx«c|zk)k»s-FFk)qzq

qrxs-¬i|r}uxª}<F}u®¼FsuF}Vk¨§/¤¿xªfxzfi¤¥qti«Asu¤¯|zik)qzq|z}¾i®¯kFjw²0egfikg¾i®¥}<¬uk)suF)kFqrqQqrxs-¬

su®¥}u|z¤¯xzfijlqsu|rki}ux/qzf}d§/¤¯ilti«Asu¤¯|zik)qzq/i|z}u¾i®¥k)j1q)²

ÃCÄ[ÅÇÆrÈÉ

Êu¢ÌË

xªsu¬ºs-®¥}|r¤¯xzfij1q)¦«c|zk)ksuF)kFqrqF¦E¾i®¯}¼¬-kFsu)FkFqrqF¦«As-¤¥|zkFqzq)¦¼«c|zsuj1¤¯ii¦

su¾i®¥keÍIikx£§"}u|z¬ÎÏ"½QeÍÁikx£§"}|r¬¼Ð¦^tiiqÂxª|zkFsujfEs-iikF®

ÑÓÒÔ£Õ£Ö×gÔKØÙ¿Õ£ÚAÛ)Ü

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt

Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex (France) T´el´ephone : 01 39 63 55 11 - International : +33 1 39 63 55 11

T´el´ecopie : (33) 01 39 63 53 30 - International : +33 1 39 63 53 30

(5)

,. l2& .I 0./ ./$1)$,2,).8

¢ "k1Esui¤¯kF|i}tqp)xztii¤¯}iq ®pXti¤¯xzpikFqi|z}uxz}¼)}®¥k)qsu)Fh)qkF su|z¾i|rk

EsuiqLkFqF}uii¤¯xz¤¥}q`ikqrti|zfEs-|zk-²7}tiqjl}[xª|z}uiqXtik®¤¥jli®¯pFjlkF[xs-xz¤¥})®suq»

qz¤Xtik,ÎAik)|zi¤¯kF|Ls-|z|z¤¿©p|zkFjl¤¥k)|]qrkF|Â©¼¤Ð]ik® s-®¥}|r¤¯xzfij1ksu)Fh)qkFSsu|r¾i|zk!,su|z|r¤¯©p)k

®¥¤¥¾|zki|r}¼)ti|zkti\su)Fh)qL¤¥ip"Xti¤¯xªsu¾i®¥k-²·#suF)hFqLVkFtx%$)xz|zkF}jli®¥hxªk)j1k)Xx7¤¯XxzkF|ri¤¯x%!

ikFqKtxz¤¥®¥¤¯qªs-xzkFti|rqsutl¾VpFip'&EFk/(tilqz}tiq»£k)iqzk)j¾i®¥k/ik/)kFt¼vX»£)¤EUk)iEsu[x®¥k)qQUp)|z¤¯}¼ik)q

ikqrti|zfisu|zkit|rpFqrk?sut ²)7}tiq7j1}uXxz|z}q%Xtik®¤¥jli®¥p)j1k)Xxªs-xª¤¯}ºk®su®¯}|z¤¿xªfijlk

kFsu|r¾i|zk*!Lsu|z|r¤¯©upFk®¯¤¥¾i|rkk"x£y<Uk|zkFjl¤¥k)|su|r|z¤¿©p"|zkFjl¤¥k)|qrkF|Â©¼¤Uk)|zjlk)xk|zp)qz}ti|zk

Fki|r}¾i®¥h)j1k`(p"Xti¤¯xzpu²·(kFq/i|z}-xª}<F}®¯kFqk)Cs-|z¾i|rk+!s-FFh)q/¾i®¥},Xtipikjl}[xª|zk)[x/Esuq

iki|z}¾®¥hFjlkL(pXti¤¿xªp-²

- É

d

Æ

¡.

¢

{Q|z}-xª}<F}®¯kFq(su)FhFqk) su|r¾i|zk-¦suF)hFq®¥¤¯¾i|zk-¦KsuF)hFq¾i®¥},Xtipu¦Kp"<t¤¯xªp-¦

/ «c|ªs-j1¤¯i10¦X|rpFqzkFsut2u¾i®¯pikxªpF®¯p)©<¤¥qr¤¥}ÎN"½QeÍ k)x£§¨}|z¬¼Ð¦^FsuEsu®(jl}[xsu[xF²

(6)

? @

$(l2w0)$

½ jti®¿xª¤¯i®¥k7su)FkFqrqgik)x£§¨}|r¬º®¥¤¯¬uk`"½QeÍ#§/¤¯xzf,s®s-|zk7U}-xªkF[xz¤su®^}u«0qr¤¥jti®¿xsukF}tiqr®¯y

su)xz¤¯©k/k)i¼»£tqzkF|rq¨fisuqQxªfik/V}uxªk)Xxz¤su®¯¤¯x£y xª}kx¨¤¯[xª}Lxªk)j1V}|zsu|ry}d©ukF|r®¥}[sulF}uii¤¯xz¤¥}q

§/¤¯xªf ¤¥iqÂxsu[xs-ikF}tq,ikFj1sui¹qrk)©k)|ªsu®Lxz¤¥jlkFq1®su|rkF|lxªfEsu´xzfik\fEs-iikF®FsuEsu)¤¯x£yu²

³bfikF\xzfikxª}-xsu®}AUkF|zk)®¥}[s-¤¥q]¾Uk)®¥}§#xªfkfEsuikF®FsuEsu)¤¯x£y¦U¤¯x]¤¥q]k?suqÂyxª}ºtEsu|»

su[xªkFks1«Asu¤¯|]s-FFk)qzqLxz}ºk)©ukF|Ây\kF¼»£tiqrkF|L¾VkFFsutiqrkxªfik)|zk¤¥q7i}º§"sywxª} &Eislqzti¾iqrk)x

}u«kFi¼» tiqzk)|zq§/¤¯xzfkFi}utif|zkFqrqz}t|zFkik)jºs-i\xª}tiqrkxªfik§/fi}®¯k¾Esu§/¤¥xzfsui

ikF[y<¤¥ixªfXtiq7su[y}uxzfikF|/s-FFk)qzq/xª}l}uxªfkF|gi}<ikFq)²

£}d©ukF|r®¥}[suqz¤¿xªtEs-xz¤¥} ¤¯x¤¯q)|zti)¤su®[xª}]fikF¬ xªfEsx8k©kF|Âys-)xª¤¿©k¨kFi¼» tiqzk)|8}¾¼xsu¤¯iq

«Asu¤¥|8suF)kFqzqQxz}xzfik/s?©-su¤¥®¥su¾i®¥k¾Esu§/¤¥xzf ¦[}uxzfikF|Â§/¤¥qzkgqr}jlkkFi<»£tiqrkF|zqK§/¤¥®¯®¼®¯}[suxzfikF¤¯|

Es-xsjtfC«AsuqÂxªkF|gxzfEsuw}uxªfik)|F¦E}|g¤¯,§"}|rqrx]?suqrkqr}jlk}uxªfik)|/kFi¼» tiqzk)|zq7§/¤¥®¥®Uik)©ukF|

k)xCsu[ybsu)Fk)qzqF² ¸E}|,kvsujli®¥k\§/fkF xzfikxª}uxªsu®Lik)jºs-i ¤¯q'x£§/¤¥)kSxzfikSfEsuikF®

?suEs-F¤¯x£yu¦s-Xy1fEsu®¿« }u«(xzfik`k)i¼» tiqzk)|zqFsu'qrxzk?su®Çsui'}<F)ti[y1xzfik]§/f}®¥k]¾Esui§/¤¯xªfÇ¦

suixªfikQ}-xªfik)|(fEsu®¯«X)}ti®¯¾UkQqÂxs?y¤¥qÂxsu|Â©-s-xª¤¯} ²0egfi¤¥qÇ¤¥q0sqz¤¿xªtEsxª¤¥}usu suii|r}i|r¤s-xzk

C½7 qrfi}ti®¯s?©}¤¯ ²8½]®¯xªf}tifxzfi¤¥q8su|rxz¤¥F®¯k")}iFk)|ziqKjl}|zk¨i|ªsxª¤¥)ti® s-|z¤¥®¿yLxªfkgqrxs-¬

su®¥}u|z¤¯xzfij ¤¯ºxªfk`F}uXxzkv<xg}u«"½QeÍÎÏsu¾®¥k`eÍÐikx£§"}u|z¬1xzfik`|rkFqrti®¯xzqgsu|zk7k)ikF|zsu®

«c}|gqrxªsu¬wsu®¥}u|z¤¯xzfijlqF²Q7}d§¨k)©ukF|7«c}|/slu}¼}<F}jli|zk)fikFqz¤¥}uC}u«xªfik|rkFqzt®¯xªq7}u«xªfi¤¯q

EsuVkF|xªfk«c}u®¥®¥}§/¤¯i|zk«ckF|rkFi)kFq`Fsu¾Ukfik)®¥«ct®7B¼¦'C¼¦DFE

egf¤¥q`isuUk)|`fEs-q`¾VkFkFi|z}V}qrkFsuq`sºF}uXxz|z¤¯¾itxª¤¯}xª}1xzfikKKHG[¼²¿m?º)}j»

j1¤¿xªkFk-²

I $w ./ ./$

egfikµqÂxsu¬ su®¥u}|z¤¿xªfij F}iqr¤¥qÂxªq¤¯[xª} j1suEs-¤¥i°s ©¼¤¯|rxztEsu®qrxªsu¬ }-«xª|zsuiqzjl¤¯xrxªk)|

|z}tiqF² egfkFqzk|r}tiiqlsu|rkXtikFtkF ¤¯ xªfik,©<¤¥|ÂxªtEs-®"qrxªsu¬^¦"|zsui¬uk)°«c|r}j ¾U}uxrxª}j

xª}xª}u ²³bfikFws«ck)kFi¾Es-¬,}u«F}®¯®¥¤¥qr¤¥}l}<FFt|zqF¦¼xªfik|r}ti'§/fi¤¯f?sutiqrkFxªfik)}®¥®¯¤¿»

qz¤¥}u1¤¯q¨qri®¥¤¿x¨¤¯[xª}xzfi|zk)k]qrti¾i|r}tiiq¨§/fi¤¥fºsu|zk]qrxª}u|zkFºsu[su¤¯1¤¯1xzfik%Xtik)tiku²Q³bfik),s

j1¤¯i¤¥qr®¥}ux¤¥q8|ªsu[xzkF ¦[sLu|z}ti¤¯q?s-®¥®¥k)«c}|8xz|ªsuqzjl¤¥qzqr¤¥}sui¤¥q©<¤¥|rxztEsu®¯®¯y ikXtik)tikF

«c|z}j xªfikqrxªsu¬^²

egfkF|zk]su|rk]qrk)©k)|ªsu®E§"s?y¼qxª} ¤¥jli®¥k)j1k)[xxªfik7qrxªsu¬su®¯}|z¤¿xªfij §/fi¤¯fºik)Uk)iº}5J

m²g«c|zk)k }u|g¾i®¥}<¬uk)su)Fk)qzq!K

¼²/qrxªsu¬'j1suEsuk)j1k)[x?²

LMLONQPRFSUT3V

(7)

³Àkfis©uksu®¥|rk?su¼ywsuEsu®¿y¼qrkFxzfikqÂxsu¬Csu®¥u}|z¤¿xªfijlqg¤¥w«c|zkFksuF)kFqzqLsui\¾i®¯}¼¬-kF

suF)kFqzq1B EN²Q£,xªfi¤¯qEsuVkF|"§¨k¤¥[©ukFqrxz¤¥[sxªk`xzfikLqrxªsu¬'j1suEsuukFjlkF[x?²½]®¯xzfi}tif1xªfiky

su|zkKi®¯kF[x£y}xz¤¥}q(¤¥ qrxs-¬jºsuisukFjlkF[x(§¨k¨|rkFqÂxª|z¤¯)x0}t|zqzk)®¯©ukFq8}uxzfik¨su®¯xzkF|zis-xª¤¿©kJ

xªfik ·0suqÂx/£¸8¤¯|zqÂx]t¼xÎN·(¸ Ð"j1suEs-kFjlkF[x2K

xªfik ¸8¤¯|zqÂxg£¸¤¥|zqÂx]LtxÎN¸8¸Ð"j1suEsuk)j1k)[x?²

egfik·(¸j1suEs-kFjlkF[x]¤¥q/xªfikjl}qÂx`)}[©kF[xz¤¥}Es-®8j1suEsuk)j1k)[x]«c}|]qrxªsu¬s-®¥}-»

|z¤¯xzfij ¤¯°xzfikC®¯¤¯xzkF|ªsxªti|rku¦ B¿m¦¨X¦¨¼¦G<¦FEÏ² xº)}iqz¤¯qrxzq1¤¯Xxz}Àu|ªsu[xª¤¯ij1¤¯i¤¥qr®¥}uxxª}

|z}tiq«c|z}j ¾U}-xzxª}ujC¦sui xz} Xtik)tikF¤¯iqzi®¯¤¯xzxzkF |r}tiiqqÂxsu|Âxª¤¥\«c|z}j ¾U}uxrxª}j

xª}<}i²\£ Esu|Âxª¤¯Fti®¥su|·(¸¶su®¥®¯}d§/q i¤¯qrxª|r¤¥¾it¼xªkF j1suEs-kFjlkF[x §/¤¯xªf}txVkF|rjºsukF[x

j1}¤¯xª}u|z¤¥i¦Kqz¤¥Fkw}ikwi}¼k)q1}uxºkFkF±xª}µ¬Xi}§ '= xzfikqr¤Fkw}u«]xªfikCqrxs-¬

s-x/«ckFkF¾Esu¬,xª¤¯j1k¤¥}|rikF|/xª}l|zk)qzfik)iti®¯kxªfik |zkxª|zsuiqzjl¤¥qrqz¤¯}iqÎA}k }ui®¯yik)kFwxª}

j1}¤¯xª}u|Kxzfik`qrkXtik)iFk}u«(k©k)Xxzq / F}u®¥®¥¤¯qz¤¯} 0sui / i}¼» F}®¯®¥¤¥qr¤¥},0¾Vk)x£§¨kFk)w|rk)xz|ªsuiq»

j1¤¯qzqz¤¯}iqªÐ²°·(k?suqÂxº¾it¼xºi}-x1®¥suqrxF¦¨§/fik) i|r}Esus-xª¤¯} ikF®¥sy ¤¥qFk)|z}i¦g·(¸4k&vis-)x

ikF®¥sy'suEsu®¿y<qz¤¥qg¤¯qxª|zsu)xªsu¾i®¥k-²

egfkg¸8¸´jºsuisukFjlkF[x¤¥q®¥kFqrq8)}[©kF[xz¤¥}Es-®Ï²8 x8F}qz¤¥qÂxªq¤¯[xª}`u|ªsu[xª¤¯i`jl¤¥¤¥qÂ»

®¥}uxzq8xª} |z}utiiqQqrxªsu|rxz¤¥i«c|r}jÁxz} ¦Xsuixª} Xtik)tikF¤¯iqri®¥¤¿xzxzkF|r}tiiqQ«c|z}uj ¾V}uxzxz}jC²

¸8¸ i}<kFqKi}ux¨su®¯®¥}§°®¥¤¯j1¤¿xªkFqzk)iqz¤¯i¤¥qrxz|z¤¯¾itxªk)1j1suEs-kFjlkF[xQqr¤¥i)k7}uik/jtiqrx

'+= ¬Xi}§ xªfk7qr¤)k7}-«Uxzfikgqrxªsu¬¤¥}|rikF|xz} )}|z|rkFxª®¯yqzfik)iti®¥k/|rk)xª|zsuiqrj1¤¯qzqz¤¯}iq)²

£,}uti|¤¥jli®¯kFjlkF[xs-xz¤¥}Ç¦xªfik)}[xªkF[xz¤¥},|r}ti¸8¸ qrxªsu¬º§"suqjlkF|rkF'§/¤¿xªf

xªfikEsxs,|zk"<tkFqrxqrxªsu¬ ²egfk«c}u®¥®¥}§/¤¯i'kvsujli®¯kqzfi}§/q fi}§Áxzfikqrxªsu¬\k)©u}®¯©ukFq

§/¤¯xªf,xz¤¥jlkJ

m minislots contention minislots

FIFO Stack

Collision Request Data Collision

...

Request for m minislots Collision

Request for n minislots

Feedback

minislot allocation

"!ML# "$

(8)

Ë ¤¥i)k"xªfik)|zkg¤¯qs`}k» xz}-»£}uik"j1suii¤¯iL¾Vk)x£§¨kFk)xzfik/¸8¸´qrxªsu¬suxªfikjl¤¥¤¥qÂ»

®¥}uxsu®¥®¯}¼Fs-xª¤¯} ¦xªfkF|zkk&v¤¯qrxzq/sqrxª|zsu¤¥ufXxr«c}|r§"su|r,¤¥jli®¥k)j1k)Xxªs-xª¤¯}º}-«xzfi¤¥qsu®¥}u|z¤¯xzfij

¤¥qz¤¯i®¥k`¤¥[xªk)|z®¥kFs?©kJ

ÐUegfikKsu®¯}|r¤¯xªfj ¬-kFk)iq8sV}¤¯XxzkF|KÎcF}tXxzkF|ªÐ xz}xªfikQkv<x&E|zqÂx0i}¼»£su®¥®¯}¼Fs-xªk)

j1¤¯i¤¥qr®¥}ux!K

Ð/½]®¥®0|zk)Fk)¤¯©k)|zk"<tkFqrxzqsui\)}®¥®¯¤¥qr¤¥}iq/s-|zku|ªsu[xªk) ÎA)}[xª¤¯ti}tiqªÐ/jl¤¥¤¥qÂ»

®¥}uxzqgs-x7}i)ku¦E¾VkF¤¯ii¤¯is-xgxªfk / F}tXxzkF|/}u«xªfik &E|rqrx7i}<»su®¯®¥}<?s-xzkF'qr®¥}ux 0K

dÐ «ExzfikF|rk/su|zk¨tiEsu®¯®¥}<?s-xzkFjl¤¥¤¥qz®¯}uxªq(xzfEs-x§¨}ti®¯¾Uk¨§suqÂxªk)xzfikfikFsu¼» kFi

su®¥®¯}¼Fs-xªk)q¨xzfikFj¶suqg|r}¼}-x/|z}tw)}[xªk)Xxz¤¥}wjl¤¥i¤¯qz®¥}-xªqÎ [Ð&²

.8* $".

egfikqz¤¥jti®s-xz¤¥}q"tiqrk xzfikEsu|ªs-j1kxªkF|rqg}u«xsu¾i®¯km²

Ë ¤¥jt®s-xz¤¥}iqEsu|zsujlk)xªk)|zq Ísu®¥tik)q

]tij¾VkF|g}-«suxª¤¿©kqrxªs-xª¤¯}iq u

`¤¥qÂxsui)k«c|z}j qrxsxª¤¥}uiqxª}fikFsuikF u¬Xj ÎA|zsui¤¯iXÐ

`}§/iqrxz|zk?s-jEs-xsxz|ªsuiqrj1¤¯qzqr¤¥},|zs-xªk ¤¥ &E¤¯xªk

]iqÂxª|zkFsujEsxsxª|zsuiqzjl¤¥qrqz¤¯},|ªs-xzkFq 1w¾i¤¯xzq-q

{K|r}Esus-xª¤¯},ikF®¥s?y CÇq-¬Xj

·0k)iuxzfw}-«qz¤¯jti®¥s-xª¤¯} qzkF)}iiq

tEs-|zi¾Es-iwsuiwi|zk&»suj¾®¥k iti|ªsxª¤¥}u,}u« C¾[yXxªkFq

C¤¥i¤¯qz®¯}uxqr¤Fk m*D¾XyXxzkFq

]k?s-ikFiwi|r}¼)kFqzqr¤¥ilik)® s?y jlq

]k?s-ikFiwi|r}¼)kFqzqr¤¥ilqzfkFjlk «ckFkF¾Esu¬suiCsu®¯®¥}<?s-xz¤¥}ºs-x/k?sufwjl¤¥i¤¯qz®¥}-x

e8su¾®¥km J 7k)x£§¨}|z¬ Ë ¤¯jti®¥s-xª¤¯}"} &iti|ªsxª¤¥}u{8su|zsuj1kxªk)|zq

³Àk7su®¥qr}tiqzk/xªfikg«c}®¯®¥}§/¤¥suqzqrtij1¼xª¤¥}uiq!J¤¥jli®¥¤¯F¤¿x«c|zsuj1¤¯ii¦}i¤¯uy[»£¾isu¬X¤¥ii¦

5F}jlitxªs-xª¤¯} ¦V{}¤¯qzqr}\xª|zs1&Eu²`egfikqz¤Fk}-«xªfikEsu¬ukxªqL«c}®¯®¥}§/q]sº|ªsui}ji¤¥q»

xª|z¤¯¾itxz¤¥}'§/fi¤¯fC¤¯qg¤¯©ukF¤¥,xªsu¾i®¥k <²

LMLONQPRFSUT3V

(9)

Esu¬ukx`®¯kFi-xªf |z}¾Es-¾i¤¥®¯¤¯x£y

¤¥,¾i¤¿xªq

C¼md ²D

m[- ² D

uu#G ²u

[ D ²[

Gm [ ² C

md¼m? ²

esu¾i®¥k JK{su¬ukx`®¯kFi-xªfi¤¥qÂxª|r¤¥¾itxz¤¥}

egfk|rkFqzt®¯xªqg}-«8xªfk qr¤¥jt®s-xz¤¥}iq¨fikF|rktiqzkxªfk qzsujlk«c|zsujlk)§¨}|z¬ºsuiwqªsujlk

x/¤¯qi}uxk?suqÂy'xª}ikxªk))x/ti«As-¤¥|zkFqzqgti®¥k)qzq/¾[yºxª|zsuF¤¯ixªfkfEsuiik)® txz¤¥®¥¤?s-xz¤¥}

}u« k)©k)|ry¹k)i¼» tiqzk)| KxzfXtiq'xªfik\xz}uxs-®`Xtij¾VkF|'}-«¾[yXxªk)q,xª|ªs-iqzjl¤¯xrxªkF¹¾[y k?sufb}u«

xªfik-ºqrxªs-xª¤¯}iq`§"suq®¯}k)\sui¤¯qL|zk)U}u|rxªk)¤¥xzfik«c}®¯®¥}§/¤¥il|zsuifi¤¯FqF²£\xzfik

|ªsufi¤¥)qF¦ xªfklu'©-su®¥tik)qF¦0su|rk|zk)i|zk)qzkF[xzkF ¦qz}|ÂxªkF¾[y¤¥F|zkFsuqz¤¯i'©-su®¥tkFqF²³bfikF

xªfiki|r}uxª}<F}u®8¤¥q]«Asu¤¥|)¦U«ck)§Ái¤AÇk)|zkFFkFqFsuS¾UkqrU}uxrxªk)¾Vk)x£§¨kFk)xzfikqrxªs-xª¤¯}iq)¦0sui

xªfikg)ti|r©uk]¤¯q8©k)|ry)®¥}qrkxª} sufi}|r¤F}uXxªsu®®¯¤¥ik-²³bfkFlti«Asu¤¯|zik)qzqQ}<FFt|zqF¦[xzfikgFti|Â©k

¤¥qgqrxzkFiVkF|)²Q³bfikFxªfikti¼«Asu¤¥|rikFqrqg®¥k?s-iqgxª}qz}uj1kkF¼»£tiqrkF|rq7qÂxsu|Â©-s-xª¤¯} ¦xzfikFti|Â©k

|zkFj1su¤¯iqQ}Fk)|z}xªfi|r}tifitx¨suqK®¥}ixzfikF|rk]s-|zk/qrxªsu|r©<¤¥ tqzkF|rqsulqrfi}§/qsqzfisu|z

qrxªk)w§/fkFCxzfik &E|zqÂx7i}¼» qrxs-|r©<¤¥ii}<ik¤¯qgkFi)}ti[xªk)|zkFÇ²

egfk|ªsufi¤¥)qLsu|rk|zk)U}|Âxªk)S«c}u|]xªfk«c}®¥®¯}§/¤¥i1sujl}ti[xªqL}-«Qxª|ªs1kFik)|ªs-xz¤¥}5J

m²#CC¾ -q Îcfi¤¥uf'¾itxg},}©kF|r®¥}[s-ikF,)}ii¤¿xª¤¥}uiqÐ&¦i¼²XC¾ -qÎA}©ukF|z®¯}[suik)^Ð¦isui

i²G-C¾ -qgÎA}©k)|z®¥}suikFEÐ¦[su«c}|xzfik"«c}®¯®¥}§/¤¥i]su®¯}|z¤¿xªfijlq!J ¸8¸¹¾®¥}<¬ukFs-FFk)qzq

§/¤¯xªfk)Xxz|rywVkF|zqr¤¥qÂxªkFFk ¦^¸8¸I«c|zk)ks-FFk)qzq7§/¤¯xªfCo¦^·0¸Á¾®¥}<¬ukFCsu)FkFqrq]§/¤¿xªf

¦E·(¸ «c|zkFk su)Fk)qzq/§/¤¯xªfwo¦^suiw·(¸I«c|zk)ks-FFk)qzq/§/¤¯xzfi}tx ²

"!#$%$$'&()

£wf¤¥f,xª|zs*l¾itx/i}uC}©k)|z®¯}[suik)w)}ii¤¿xª¤¯}iqÎm²#Clw¾ -qF¦Ejlk?s-,ikF®¥syº|z}tfi®¯y

kXtEsu®`xz} [ jlqÐ¦7su®¯®7xzfikSsu®¯}|z¤¿xªfijlqlUk)|r«c}|rj )}j1isu|ªs-xz¤¯©ukF®¯y §/¤¿xªf¹|zk)qzVkFx,xª}

«Asu¤¥|rikFqrqF²

egfk¨i¤AÇk)|zk)iFk)q}u«<xªf|z}tiufiitx¾Ukx£§"k)kF xªfEs-xqÂxs-xz¤¥}iq0}¾qzkF|Â©k)su|rk¤¯isu|rxsu&»

F}ti[xªsu¾i®¥k]xª}Esxªti|zsu®Çi¤AÇk)|zk)iFk)qg}u«0Xtij¾VkF|}u«k)ikF|zs-xªk),Esu¬-k)xªq)¦Vsuq¤¥®¯®¥tiqÂxª|zs-xªk)

¤¥,xªfik«c}®¯®¥}§/¤¥+&Et|zk

"!ML# "$

(10)

0 5000 10000 15000 20000 25000 30000 35000 40000 45000

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Number of bytes transmitted to head-end (load: 1.45Mbps)

Stations (sorted)

LIFO blocked w/ R LIFO free LIFO free w/ R FIFO blocked w/ R FIFO free w/ R

¸8¤¥t|zkm J#7tij¾VkF|K}u«Uxª|ªs-iqzjl¤¯xrxªkFl¾[yXxªkFq¨Uk)|¨qÂxs-xz¤¥}ÎAqÂxs-xz¤¥}q¨s-|zk/qz}|Âxªk)^Ð¦<¤¥itx

®¥}[sumu²1C¾iqF²

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Number of packets

Stations (sorted)

packets emitted (experiment)

¸¤¥ti|rk J ]tj¾Uk)|g}u«ukFik)|ªs-xzkFwEsu¬ukxªq7Uk)|/qrxsxª¤¥}u ²

LMLONQPRFSUT3V

(11)

0 10000 20000 30000 40000 50000 60000

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Stations (sorted)

¸8¤¥t|zkL J ]tij¾VkF|"}u«0xª|ªs-iqzjl¤¯xrxªkFº¾XyXxzkFq/Uk)|qrxªs-xª¤¯}SÎcqrxsxª¤¥}uiqgsu|rkqz}|ÂxªkFEÐ¨¤¥itx

®¥}[suw<²1C¾iqF²

x¤¯ii¤¥Fs-xªk)qxªfik/Xtij¾VkF|K}u«UEsu¬-k)xzq 4+&54+U 4 " ¾[y1uV}¤¥qrqz}qr}ti|z)kFq`ÎAk"<t¤¯©[»

su®¥k)Xxgxz}1uqz}t|zFk)q7x£y<VkmdÐ¦i«c}|/uqrkF)}iiq)¦V¤¯wsqr¤¥jli®¥k`kv¼Uk)|z¤¯j1k)XxF²

"!#$%$ $'& ) %) )

%

£w}©ukF|z®¯}[suik)F}i¤¯xª¤¯}iq)¦¼xªfk¸8¸Ásu®¯}|z¤¿xªfijlq¨sui'xªfk·(¸ su®¥}u|z¤¯xzfijlq§/¤¿xªf

¾i®¥}<¬uk)su)Fk)qzq7Uk)|r«c}|rjqrxz¤¥®¥®UF®¯}qzk)®¯y¦isuii}lqz¤¥ui¤ &EFsu[x/ti«Asu¤¯|zik)qzq/¤¥qg}u¾iqzk)|r©k) ²

¨tx¤¿xsuUkFsu|zqxªfEs-x"¤¥lxªfik·(¸ ?suqrk`§/¤¯xzf1«c|rkFkLs-FFk)qzq Î §/¤¯xªfº}|§/¤¿xªfi}utx Ð&¦

ti«Asu¤¯|zik)qzq/}¼)Fti|rqF¦i«c}|/s®¥}su,}u«8su¾U}utx]¼²ºw¾iiq!Jqz}uj1kqrxªs-xª¤¯}iq ÎAsu¾U}utx/ CÐsu|rk

tiEsu¾i®¯kLxª}xª|zsuiqrj1¤¿x?²

«/xzfik'®¥}su ¤¥qi}ti¾i®¯kFbÎcqzk)F}i |zsuif ¦Q²GSC¾iqÐ&¦Kxzfik,Xtij¾VkF|}-«/qrxsxª¤¥}uiq

tiEsu¾i®¯kLxª}xª|zsuiqrj1¤¿xg¤¥q/su®¯qz}i|zsujºsxª¤¥Fsu®¥®¿y¤¥i)|zkFsuqzk) ÎAsu¾U}utxmm[Ð&²

£°xªfik«c}®¯®¥}§/¤¥iCx£§"}ÀqzkFxª¤¯}iqF¦¨§"ks-xzxzkFjlxxª}¤¯©uks Xti¤¥¬ ¤¯iqz¤¯f[x}u«`xzfik

¾Uk)fEs?©¼¤¯}|g}u«xªfiki¤AÇk)|zk)Xx/«c|rkFk suF)kFqrq`su®¯}|r¤¯xªfj1q)²

"!ML# "$

(12)

0 10000 20000 30000 40000 50000 60000 70000 80000 90000

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Stations (sorted)

¸8¤¥t|zk`;J ]tij¾VkF|"}u«0xª|ªs-iqzjl¤¯xrxªkFº¾XyXxzkFq/Uk)|qrxªs-xª¤¯}SÎcqrxsxª¤¥}uiqgsu|rkqz}|ÂxªkFEÐ¨¤¥itx

®¥}[su,²GlC¾iqF²

ÄXÄ E¡[¡ Ä ? Ä É

£À¤¯ &Ei¤¿xªkV}¤¥qrqz}SV}iti®¥s-xª¤¯} ¦Ç«c}u|Lxªfikx£§¨}}©k)|z®¥}suSF}i¤¯xª¤¯}iq}t¼xª®¥¤¯ikFfkF|zk-¦

xªfikQ«c|zk)k"s-FFk)qzq|zk)qz}®¯txª¤¯}§"}t®¥ ¾UkK¤¥qrxs-¾i®¥k-¦-s-i xzfikqrxs-¬<q§"}uti®¥ |z}§µ¤¥ &E¤¯xª®¿y²

³b¤¯xªf &E¤¯xªkKV}iti®¥s-xª¤¯} ¦¤¯Xxzti¤¯xz¤¯©ukF®¯yu¦xªfikKqrxªsu¬?su |r}d§µkFi}utifxzfXtiqf}®¥kF}tif

F}®¯®¥¤¥kF|zq)¦(qz}xªfEsx}®¯ys®¥¤¯j1¤¿xªk)<tj¾Uk)|}u«qÂxs-xz¤¥}iq su|rk®¥k)« x }t¼x?¦sui|zk?s-f s

qrxsxªk}u«kXti¤¥®¯¤¥¾i|r¤¥tijw²

³b¤¿xªf1s «c|rkFk`k)[xª|ry1·(¸ qrxªsu¬^¦qrxªs-xª¤¯}iqs-xxªfik/xª}uº}u« xzfik7qrxs-¬1s-|zk7¤¥ &E¤¯xªk)®¯y

ikF®¥syukF ¦Vsus®¥¤¯j1¤¿xªk)'Xtij¾VkF|/}u«qrxsxª¤¥}uiq/j1}}U}u®¥¤)kFqxªfik tiiqÂxª|zkFsujfEs-iikF® J

qzfi|r¤¥i¬^²Kegfi¤¥qgfikFi}uj1k)i}w®¥k?s-iqxª}xªfikqrfi}§/Cti¼«Asu¤¥|rikFqrqF²

³b¤¿xªfw«c|zkFk kF[xz|ryC¸8¸ qrxªsu¬^¦ s1¬X¤¯i}u«|z}ti¼»£|r}¾i¤¥µÎAe LC½Ð/kFjlkF|zukFqF²]L

s|zsuii}uj Xtij¾VkF|}u«¨F}®¯®¥¤¥qr¤¥}q]§/¤¥®¯®8j1suikls,qzti)Fk)qzqr«ct®¨|rkXtikFqÂx?²1egfikF|rk)«c}|rkxzfik

LMLONQPRFSUT3V

(13)

L qzj1su®¥®¯kF|lxª¤¥jlk\qr?su®¯ku¦`§/fik) xzfikSqrxªsu¬¹¤¥qsu|r}tii ¤¯xzq,qrxzk?suy[» qrxsxªkSj1kFsu

i}À}uxº)}®¥®¯¤¥ik-¦Qxªfiky §"}t®¥ ¾Vkwsu¾i®¯kxz}Àj1su¬-kCqrtiF)kFqzqÂ«cti®`|rkXtik)qrxªq)² t|1¸¸

egfk|ªs?§/¾Esu¬¹}u«¸8¸ ¤¯j1®¥kFjlkF[xªs-xª¤¯}iqº¤¯q'xªfikSXtij¾VkF|,}-«i¤AÇk)|zk)XxCo

qrxs-¬V²legfiklXtij¾VkF|«c}|¾[yXxªkFq«c}|o Esu|ªs-j1kxªkF|qrfi}ti®¯À¾Vk®su|rkk)i}tif5Jxzfik

xªfik)}|zkxª¤¥Fsu® ¾V}tii«c}|/o ¤¥qgi|r}V}|rxz¤¥}Es-®Uxª}xzfik<tj¾Uk)|/}u«8qÂxs-xz¤¥}qF²

³ÀkLi¤¯ºi}-x¤¥jli®¯kFjlkF[xEsu¬ukx/F}?s-xzkFEs-xz¤¥}º¤¥º}uti|"qr¤¥jti®¥s-xª¤¯} ¦[¾it¼x"§¨kLqrxz¤¥®¥®

¤¥i)|zk?s-qzkºt«Asu¤¥|rikFqrqF²³b¤¯xzfµ¾V}tiiik) F}ui?s-xzkFEsxª¤¥}uÀxªfkºi|r}uxª}<F}®¤¥q qrxz¤¥®¯®Qti«Asu¤¯|

qz¤¥Fk`is-xssu®¥®¯}¼Fs-xª¤¯}¤¥q &Ei¤¿xªk`VkF|¨tiqzk)|F²³b¤¿xªfºt<¾V}tiikF,)}i?sxªkFis-xª¤¯}ºti¼«Asu¤¥|»

ikFqrq`§"}uti®¥\}<F)ti|`¾tx`«c}|7}uxzfikF|]|zk?s-qz}xzfEsu\)}®¥®¯¤¥qr¤¥}|zk)qz}®¯txª¤¯}wqz¤¥Fkslqzti¾iqrk)x

}u«8tqzkF|rq])}ti®¯wqÂxªkFsu® xªfik§/fi}u®¥k¾Esu§/¤¥xzfw§/¤¿xªf,«ck)§ |zk"<tkFqrxF²

. É ¡ Ä Ê i¡[¡ Ä F Ä É

¾Xywsqrti¾iqzkxL}u«tiqrkF|zq]tii®¯kFqzq/tiX¾V}tiikF\)}i?sxªkFis-xª¤¯}¤¥q7su®¥®¯}§"k) ²¸^t|rxªfkF|zjl}|rk

su[y'qrxªs-xª¤¯},¤¥s-Xy'F}®¯®¥¤¥qr¤¥}1|z}uti'§/¤¥®¯®Çti®¿xª¤¥j1s-xzkF®¯y¾Vksu¾i®¯k`xª}j1su¬uksqrtiF)kFqrqr«cti®

|zkXtik)qrx¨tii®¯kFqzqK¤¿xQkF[xªk)|zq¤¥¤¯iik"&ii¤¯xzkF®¯y|zk)UkFs-xªk)1)}®¥®¯¤¥qr¤¥} §/¤¯xªf¤¥¤¯xzq|z}uti§/fi¤¥f

fEsuiVkFiq§/¤¯xzf'i|z}u¾Esu¾i¤¯®¥¤¯x£y Fk)|z}i²Q£ºxzfik`k&vsuj1®¥kFq¨}u« xzfik`qr¤¥jti®¥s-xª¤¯}iqxzfik`¾i®¯}¼¬-kF

su®¥}u|z¤¯xzfij suiVk?su|rqg«cti|rxzfikF|gxª}¾Vk suq«Asu¤¥|suqg«c|zkFk su)Fk)qzq]¸8¸ su®¥u}|z¤¿xªfijlqF²

I$")2()$

xªkF[xz¤¥}|zk)qz}®¯txª¤¯}wsu®¥u}|z¤¿xªfijlqF² Ë ¤¥jt®s-xz¤¥}1|zkFqrti®¯xzq/qzfi}§ xzfEs-x?¦EtiikF|/fi¤¯f¤¥itx

®¥}[suqF¦ ti¼«Asu¤¥|rikFqrq}¼)Fti|rq§/¤¿xªfxªfk·0¸ qrxs-¬«c|zk)ksuF)kFqzqsu®¯}|z¤¿xªfijlq7¾itxxªfis-x

xªfi¤¯qti«Asu¤¯|zik)qzqQ¤¯qi}uxKi|rkFqrkF[xK§/¤¯xªfxzfik/¸8¸¹qrxs-¬«c|zk)k/suF)kFqzqsu®¯}|r¤¯xªfjC²0egfik)|zk

¤¥qqz¤¯i¤&E?su[xti¼«Asu¤¥|rikFqrq§/¤¿xªfSxªfikqÂxsu¬¾i®¯}¼¬-kFÀsuF)kFqrqsu®¯}|z¤¿xªfijlq`¤¯·0¸ }|

"!ML# "$

(14)

¸8¸±j1}<ik-² Ë ¤¯jti®¥s-xª¤¯}|zk)qzti®¿xªqsu®¥qr}`qzf}d§ xzfEs-x0xªfk"tiqrk"}u«is]y<Esujl¤¥VkF|zqr¤¥qÂxªkFFk

Esu|ªs-j1kxªkF|g}¼k)q7}ux/¤¥itikFi)kxªfik«Asu¤¯|zik)qzqF²

.g*-../$"./

B¿m!E²U·Q²Usuqzqrk)yu¦ / "}®¯®¥¤¯qz¤¥}uo7k)qz}®¯txª¤¯}½`®¥u}|z¤¿xªfijlq/suio7sui}j» ½gF)kFqzqL"}j»

jti¤¥?sxª¤¥}uiq 0ª¦¤¥ !"#%$&'!)(+*,-./F¦

²·(}i} Qi¤¯xz}|F¦

102("345.1$6!87:91,#;<%.!84=

?>?>

¦ Ë i|z¤¯ikF| ÍKk)|z®¥sui¦³b¤¥k)¼» 7k)§A@}|z¬^¦<m Gm¦

u»ªm¼²

"|r}[suiFsuqrx "fisuiik)®8§/¤¯xzfS¸^k)kFi¾isu¬ 0¦BCEDF =?0G!"HI<J=LK.$F!"</M5<;!

+N

¦8m ¦

C d»ÂG¼²

BFE {²s-xªf[y<qF¦8{²0¸8®¥sd~r}®¯k)x?¦

/

L»s-|ry\)}®¥®¯¤¥qr¤¥}\|rkFqr}®¥txz¤¥}su®¯}|r¤¯xªfj1q]¤¥S|ªsui}j»

su)FkFqrqqÂy¼qÂxªk)j1q§/¤¿xªf}| ¾i®¥}<¬uk)µfEsuikF®"suF)kFqzq)¦0'¤¥PO.QLQLQ3R U&;,S & O &2.2%T

BE {²Usu"<tk)x?¦{²LJVifi®¯k)xªfisu®¥k)|F¦{²Lo/}¾VkF|Âx?¦

/

"½QeÍ qr®¥}uxrxªkF#jti®¯xz¤¥i®¯kÀs-FFk)qzq

C½7`¦0 `o/£½Io7k)qzkFsu|zfo7k)U}|Âx/im D¼¦ m ²¿¦WsuXtEsu|ryum²

BCE {²EsuXtikx?¦¼{²¼JVifi®¯k)xzfEsu®¥k)|F¦<{²Xo/}¾VkF|Âx?¦ / {kF|r«c}u|zj1su[x¨¤¯j1®¥kFjlkF[xªs-xª¤¯}}u«Vxª|rkFk

F}u®¥®¥¤¯qz¤¯}|zk)qz}®¯txª¤¯}},"½QeÍ ik)x£§¨}|z¬^¦0 ]o7£½ o7k)qzkFsu|zf,o/kFV}|Âx"im?¼¦<uÇ¦

¸EkF¾i|rtEsu|Âywumu²

BDFE {²Xs-Xtik)xF¦g{²¨JVfi®¥kxªfEsu®¯kF|)¦{²o/}¾VkF|rxF¦ / ¸E|zsuj1¤¯i\i|r}uxª}<F}u®¥q} tiqrxz|zk?s-j

fEsuikF®g¤¯°"½QeÍ4k)x£§¨}|z¬Xq!JwsuqÂy<j1xz}uxª¤¯'ik)®s?y suisu®¯y<qz¤¯qF¦0 `o/£½¶o/kFqzkFsu|zf

o/kFV}|rx] ²¿¦ixª}lsuUkFsu|7umu²

BE`²U½g~r¤¥fÇ¦U{²Ys-Xtik)xF¦({²UJVfi®¥kxªfEsu®¯kF|)¦ /ÂË xsu¬½]®¥}|r¤¯xzfij1qg¤¯¤¯j1i®¯¤¥)¤¯x«c|zsuj»

¤¥i¦<«c|rkFks-FFk)qzq)¦Esui,¾i®¯}¼¬-kFsu)Fk)qzq 0ª¦i `o/£½#o/kFqrk?su|rfCo/kFV}|ÂxLm Ç²¯¦ium7xª}

suiVk?s-|F²

LMLONQPRFSUT3V

(15)

BGFE ²¸^syu}®¥®¯ku¦{²-¸8®¥sd~r}®¥kx?¦À²-]}-«c|z¤Ï¦{² su"Xtik)xF¦ / ½]Esu®¿y¼qr¤¥q}u«Es Ë xs-¬ ½]®¥}u|z¤¯xzfij

«c}|7|ªsui}jjti®¯xz¤¥i®¯k»£suF)kFqzq7F}uj1jti¤¥Fs-xª¤¯} ¦0O.QLQLQ R &;,S O &2.2+/S R 4( ¦

BFE ·Q²<Ck)|ªsu¬-}qF¦i`² "¤¥qri¤¥¬X¤¥su ¦ / `kF®¥sysuEsu®¿y¼qr¤¥qQ}u«Vxªfk

»su|Âyqrxªsu¬|ªsui}j»su)FkFqrq

m GG²

B¿mE {²suXtikx?¦X{²uJVif®¥k)xzfEsu®¯kF|F¦ / C¤¯i¤¥j1su Js`fi¤¯fqrUk)kFsu)FkFqrqQi|z}-xª}<F}®X¾EsuqrkF

}ws«c|zk)ks-FFk)qzq7xª|zk)k su®¥}u|z¤¯xzfijw¦07 ]o7£½Io7og»£ Gu¦ ²¿¦(m G G¼²

"!ML# "$

(16)

Unité de recherche INRIA Lorraine, Technop ôle de Nancy-Brabois, Campus scientifique, 615 rue du Jardin Botanique, BP 101, 54600 VILLERS L ÈS NANCY

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rh ône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST MARTIN Unité de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis, 2004 route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 SOPHIA-ANTIPOLIS Cedex

Editeur´

INRIA, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex (France)

ISSN 0249-6399