Computational and Inferential Difficulties with Mixture Posterior Distributions

HAL Id: inria-00073049

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00073049

Submitted on 24 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents

Computational and Inferential Difficulties with Mixture Posterior Distributions

Gilles Celeux, Merrilee Hurn, Christian Robert

To cite this version:

Gilles Celeux, Merrilee Hurn, Christian Robert. Computational and Inferential Difficulties with Mix- ture Posterior Distributions. [Research Report] RR-3627, INRIA. 1999. �inria-00073049�

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Computational and inferential difficulties with mixture posterior distributions

Gilles Celeux, Merrilee Hurn, Christian Robert

No 3627

TH `EME 4

3)4 56)7 $82 )

9;:=<><=?A@B1?C<>?ADFE'GIHJ?AKLKM:><=?A?;NDKLOGIB1PKM:>@QR:TSUOWVXZYI?AKQ

[\^]_a`b1cedgfh_i^jlkmnfpoCq`m osrtmnfp_afluvkwmvfhosq

x `uvyguzmv]M_a`Mu {oC_ar^jp`|t`Mu

}~vos€`m flun‚

ƒ„kwr…rUoC~zm x `5~n`M{(\^`M~n{(\…`†q‡sˆC‰C‚CŠ;c ceˆwbar…ks‹s`Mu

Œ2ŽM‘^’ss“ [\^flu„rUkwr”`~ x `Mkwjlu„• fpmv\—–Uosmv\;`|gr…jpoC~nkwmvfhosq˜kwq x fpqAmv`M~vr…~v`mnkmnfpoCqr^~voC–^jh`_™u„~n`jlkmn` x mvo

r”oCuzmv`M~vfhos~ x fhuzmv~nfp–…itmvfhosq…u„š›os~„_afp|gmvi^~n`5_ao x `jluœ [\^`uvrU`L{fpU{kwmvfhosq˜osš_afp|Amni^~n`rUoAumn`~nfpoC~ x flumn~vfh–^itž

mnfpoCq…uŸ_1`Lkwq…uŸmn\…km mv\^`1r^~n`Muv`q…{`osš'¡Z¢Z_ao x `MuŸfhu £gq^o• q;fh_a_1` x flkmv`MjpyCœdAmnksq x ks~x;¤ kw~n£so¥{(\Ukwfhq

¤ osqAmv`¦'ks~vjhomv`L{(\^q^fl§Ci…`MuiUuzi…ksjpjhy—\UkR¥s` x fp¨{i^jpmvfh`Mu• f©mn\ª•«`Mjpjpž¬uz`Mr…kw~(kmn` x _1o x `Luuvi…{(\ksuog{M{i^~

\…`~n`s­Amv\^` ¤ ks~v£Co¥™{(\…kwfhq ¤ oCqAmv`¦'kw~njpo1uvks_1r…jp`M~uzmnkRytu«• f©mn\^fhqk1q^`Mfp‹C\A–”osi…~v\^ogo x osšk!jpot{ksjZ_1o x `

ksq x š®kwfhjhumno™¥gfhuvf©m„osmv\^`M~ `M§Ai…ksjpjhyfh_1r”os~vmnksqAm„_1o x `Luœ°¯±`uv\^o•²mn\…km„`|gr…jpoC~nkwmvfhosq2osšmn\^`Muv`5_ao x `Mu

{Mkwqa–”` fp_ar”oCuv` x osq!mv\…` ¤ kw~n£so¥{(\Ukwfhq ¤ osqAmv`Ÿ¦'ks~vjho5uvks_1r…jp`M~°i…uzfhq^‹mn`_arU`M~v` x mv~(kwq…uvf©mnfpoCq…u°–…kCuz` x

oCq³Fkwq…‹s`¥gfhqkwjh‹sos~nfpmv\^_™uMœ´„o•'`¥C`~LµkCumv\^`2r^~vfhos~ x fhuzmv~nfh–^itmvfhosq x oA`Lu5q^osm x flumnfpq^‹Ci^fluz\–”`m•'``Mq

mn\^` x f©¶Z`~n`qAma{os_ar”osq^`MqAmnuMµmv\^`rUoAumn`~nfpoC~_afp|Amni^~n` x flumn~vfh–^itmnfpoCqªflu1uvyg_a_1`mv~nfh{kwq x mv\gi…uaum(kwqtž

x kw~ x `Lumnfp_™kwmvos~(u5uvi…{(\ªksu5r”oCuzmv`M~vfhos~5_a`Lkwq…u{Mkwq^q…owm–”`i…uv` x œ˜dgfhq…{`mv\^flufluksjhuvomv~ni^`™š›os~_1oAum

q…osqtž¬uzyg_a_a`mn~vfl{™r^~nfpoC~nuMµ°•'`2r^~nosr”oCuv`2kwjpmv`M~vqUkmvfh¥s`Lu5š›oC~a·kRyC`Muvfhksq±fhqtš›`M~v`Mq…{`š›os~1rU`M~v_!itmnkwmvfhosqªfhqtž

¥ks~vflkwqAmŸr”oCuzmv`M~vfhos~(uMµUfhq…{jhi x fhq^‹˜k{jhi…umn`~nfpq…‹ x `M¥Afl{`akwq x mv\…`a{Mkwjhjmvokwr^r^~nosr…~vflkmn`jpoAuvuŸš›i^qU{$mvfhosqUuœ

¸

q—fh_arUoC~zm(kwqAm uvfx `žTfhunuzi…`owš°mn\^flu uzmvi x y˜fhu¹mv\…`!\^fh‹s\…jpfh‹s\Amvfhq^‹owšmn\^`ºU`|tfp–…fpjhf©my˜ksq x k x kwrtm(kw–^fhjhf©my

osšF³Fksq^‹s`M¥Afhq ¤ `mv~nosr”osjhfhuzžT´Ÿksuzmvfhq^‹CuIkwjh‹sos~nfpmv\^_™ukCu«§Ai…kCuzfpžTksitmvoC_™kmv` xa¤ kw~n£so¥1{(\…kwfhq ¤ oCqCmn` ¦'kw~njho

ksjp‹Cos~nf©mn\^_™u'• \^`qmv\…`5rUoAumn`~nfpoC~ x fhuzmv~nfp–…itmvfhosqfhu„£Aq…o• q2i^rmvoka{osq…uzmnksqCmLœ

»˜¼A½Z¾n¿À ÁŽs“ ¦«jhkCuvuvf©”{kmnfpoCq4µ4jlkw–”`j'uz• fpmn{(\^fhq^‹Uµ³Fksq^‹s`M¥gfpq x fp¶”iUuzfhosq…uMµFjhoCunuš›i^qU{$mvfhosqUuµ ¤ kw~n£so¥

{(\Ukwfhq ¤ oCqAmv`¦'kw~njpoUµtuzfh_i^jlkmn` x mv`M_arU`M~vfhq^‹…œ

ÂlÃ7ÄvÅTÆMÇÄ ÈÉhÅTÊ>ËÌ

Í4ÎRÏÑÐ4Ò7Ó$Ԯ՟Ò4Ö(ÐF×Ö(ԛØ>ÏÙÖ(ÚÑÚ۟Ð>ÜL×R×wÓ$Ô®Ø=݁ÞßÛ¹Ø>ÎRÝÍFà5á˜âRݬØãÒ7Ó$Ô®ÕsäCåÓ$âØ=Ô>Ö(å¬ØIæçè4çsæZÍ;é$êvëMì$ì$é$íLçÍ4ÎRÝIÖ(ÜLØ=ÎRÓ$ԮаÖ(Ô®Ý

î

Ô>ÖnØ=ݬïhÜRÚgØ=Ó'Ø=ÎRÝ×Ö(ԛØ>ÏÑåÏÑ×Ö(âØ>ÐØ>Ó'Ø=ÎRÝ°Ò7Ó$Ô®ÕMÐ=ÎRÓ$×RÐZð>àåvæ7ÜLßsÝTñ°Ö(âRބð>àæ7àæòóÔ®Ûñ¬ç…ô«çwæ7݁ÚÑ݁ÜLõŸÏÑÐ7ÒÏØ=ΠöãâLÔ=ÏÙÖá4ÎR÷$âRݬø

ù

ÚÑ×w݁Ðvätà1çAúÜLÔ=â!ÏÑÐÒÏØ=Î1æ7Ԯ݁Ð=Ø®øãöãâRÐ=ÝzݹÖ(âRÞ!ûâLÏüÝzÔ®Ð>ÏØãÛÓ(ï4ý7ÖnØ=ÎAäUæZÎAç„á4Ó$ßw݁ԮØIÏÑаÒFÏØ>Î1æZÔ=݁Ð=Ø®øãöãâRÐ=݄݁Ö(âRÞaûF×RÔ=݁Юø

ù

æ4þáÿ„ê$ì$íLäÜRâLÏüÝzÔ®Ð>ÏØÞRÝá4Ó$ÜR݁âAç

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rhˆone-Alpes

±)7 ª

Ž “ kwqUui^q{osqAmv`|Amn`„–…kRyMuvfp`Mq4µsq^oCi…uq…osi…uIfpqAmM~v`LuvuvosqUu°kwit|ar^~nos–^jh]_a`Mu x`|tr^jhosfpmnkmnfpoCq

`m xfpqAmn`~nr^~mnkwmvfhosq x `jlk™jhosfk™rUoAumn`~nfpoC~vf xi…q;_ao x ]jh` x `_Mjhksq^‹s`Cœ¬qAmn~vfhq…uv]M§Ai^`_a`MqCmLµ…jlk™jhosfk

r”oCuzmv`M~vfhos~nf xi…q—_ao x ]jh` x `1_Mjhksq^‹s`!r^~Luz`MqAmv`™¡Z¢Z_1o x `Luœ³F`Mu _mn\^o x `Mu{jlksunuvfh§Ai^`Lu x ` ¤ oCqAmv`ž

¦'ks~vjhoar…kw~„{(\Ukãq^`Mu x ` ¤ kw~n£so¥™osqAm„`Mq‹q M~nksj x `5‹s~(kwq x `Mu x fp¨{i^jpmLu r”osi^~„~n`Muzmvfpmvi…`~„{`Lu _ao x `Mu

mn~v]LuurUkw~!Mu#"FjL{(\…kwqAmvfhjhjpoCq^q^`i…~ x ` ¤ oCqCmn`žz¦'kw~njpo¹~v`Lumn` x ksq…ujp`'¥soCfhuvfpqUkw‹s` xi…q!_ao x `uvksq…ur…kw~n¥s`ž

q…fp~%$!¥Afluvf©mn`~jp`Lu kwitmn~v`Lu'_1o x `Lu xM‹Cksjp`Lu«fh_arUoC~zm(kwq…{`MuMœ&¹osi…u_aoCqCmn~voCq…u'§Ci…`Ÿj `|tr^jpoC~nkwmvfhosq x ` {`Mu

_ao x `Lu rU`Mitm('mv~n`fp_ar”oCu`)$ajL{(\…kwqAmnfpjhjpoCq^q^`Mi^~ x ` ¤ oCqAmv`žz¦'kw~njho!`Mq˜itmvfhjpflunkwqAm x `Mu mv~(kwq…uvf©mnfpoCq…u x `

~n`š›~nosfx fluvuv`_a`MqCmš›oCq x `Luuvi^~°jp`Lukwjh‹soC~vfpmv\…_1`Lu x `„³Fksq^‹s`M¥gfpq4œ ¤ ksfhu x ksq…u°i^q{Mk x ~n`q^osqafhqtš›os~n_™kmnf©šµ

{os_a_a`™jhkjhosf«kr^~vfhos~nfmv~(kwfpmv`™jh`Mu{os_ar”oCunkwqAmnu x i_*Mjhksq^‹s` x `2_aksq^fh]~n`1fhq x fp¶+~n`q…{f,M`sµjhkjhosfIk

r”oCuzmv`M~vfhos~nf…`Lumuzyg_mn~vfl§Ai^`¹`m«jh`Mu«`Muzmvfh_™kmv`Mi^~(u«{jhkCuvuvfh§Ai^`LuI{os_a_a`¹jh`Mu«_1oyC`q^q…`MuIkrUoAumn`~nfpoC~vf”uzoCqAm

fhqgitmvfhjhfhunkw–^jh`MuMœ-¬jlu5jp`™~n`Muzmv`MqAm x.ksfpjhjp`Mi^~(ukR¥s`L{ x `Lu5jhosflu5kr^~vfhos~nf°fhqtš›os~n_™kmvfh¥s`Lu§Ci…f x flumnfpq^‹Ci^`qAmjh`Mu

{os_ar”oCunkwqAmnuŸ`qAmv~n`a`it|7œ*&„osiUur^~voCrUoAuzoCq…u

x

f©¶+~n`qAmn`MuuzoCjpi^mvfhosq…u r”osi^~5_a`q…`~/$–^fp`Mq3j

fpqtš0M~v`Mq…{`

–UkRyMuvfh`q^q^`1$—rUkw~vmvfh~

x

`jhosflu1k3r”oCuzmv`~nfhos~nf«fhqg¥Rks~vflkwqAmn`Mu!r…kw~1rU`M~v_!itmnkwmvfhosq

x

`Mu1fhq

x

fl{`Mu

x

`Lu™{oC_!ž

r”oCunkwqAm(u

x

i"_*Mjhksq^‹s`Cœ3³

i^q…`itmnfpjhfluz`i^q^`mv`M{(\…q^fh§Ai^`

x

`{jhkCuvuvfpU{kwmvfhosq4µj

ksitmv~n`uv`š›oCq

x

`uzi^~!jhk

_afhq^fh_1flunkmvfhosq x `š›oCq…{$mnfpoCq…u x `r”`~vmv`!ksr^r^~nosr^~nf2`MuMœ43„q5$ž¬{6smfh_arUoC~zm(kwqAm x `1{`mvmv`*mni x ``Lum jhk

_afluz`I`q7¥gfx `q…{` x `jlk uvosi^r^jh`Munuv` x `Mukwjh‹sos~nfpmv\^_a`Mu x `I³Fksq^‹s`M¥Afhqtž¤ `mn~voCrUoCjpfluzžT´Ÿksuzmvfhq^‹«§Ai^fCrU`Mi^¥s`MqCm

'mv~n`¹¥gi…u'{oC_1_a` x `Mu'kwjh‹soC~vfpmv\^_a`Lu x ` ¤ osqAmv`ž¦'ks~vjho5r…kw~{(\…klq^`Lu x ` ¤ ks~v£Co¥§Ai…ksuvf”ksitmvoC_™kmvfl§Ai^`Mu

jhos~(un§Ci…`Ÿjlk1jpoCfFk1rUoAumn`~nfpoC~vfZq kwfpm¹{oCq^qgi§Ai $1i^q^`{oCq…uzmnkwqAmn`Ÿr^~n]MuMœ

8À

LŽ

¾

’9

“

{jhkCuvuvfpU{kwmvfhosq4µ^~n`qg¥C`~(uz`M_1`MqAm x

mnfh§Ai^`mnks‹s`sµ

x

fp¶”i…uvfhosq…u

x

`³Fksq^‹s`M¥Afhq4µtš›oCq…{$mnfpoCq…u x `

r”`~vmv`Cµ^{(\…kãq^`Lu x ` ¤

kw~n£so¥

x ` ¤

osqAmv`ž¦'ks~vjho…µA~v`š›~voCf

x

fhunuz`M_a`qAmuvfh_i^j2sœ

! F™%I

¦«oCq…uvfx `M~'mv\^`5_afp|Amni^~n` x fhuzmv~nfh–^itmvfhosq

• \…`~n`"! #$

&%'%&%()

'%&%'%&

µUmv\^`!•«`Mfp‹C\Amnu„unkmnfhuzš›ygfpq^‹

+*-,

• fpmv\

.

%&%&%

.

#/ µUkwq x

mn\^` 102 u–”`fhq^‹!š›~voC_ uzoC_1` r…ks~nks_1`mv~nfh{ š®kw_afpjhysµgš›oC~«`|^kw_ar^jh`Ÿ`|gr”osq…`qAmvflkwj>œ ¸ q2fx `MqCmnf©”kw–^fhjpfpmy

r…~voC–^jp`M_ umn`_™u š›~voC_ mv\^`1fhqA¥ks~vflkwq…{`osš 3 i…q x `~r”`~n_itm(kmnfpoCq—owšImv\^`1fpq x fh{`MuMœ[\^flur^~nos–^jh`_

flu™•'`jhj©žT~n`M{oC‹sq^fluv` x fhq mv\^`˜jhfpmv`~(kmni^~n` š›os~`|^kw_ar^jh`sµ[f©mvmv`~nfhq^‹wmnosq4µ„dg_afpmv\²kwq x ¤ kw£so¥Zµ '465876 µ

ksq x fhu„i…uziUkwjhjpyuzoCjp¥C` x –Ayfp_ar”oCuvfpq…‹aksqfx `MqAmvfpš›yAfhq^‹2{osq…uzmv~(kwfhqAm osqmv\^`rUkw~(kw_a`mn`~(uµgš›oC~ fpq…uzmnksq…{`

9*

%&%'%

* ¤ `q…‹s`~(uv`q ksq x ƒ oC–U`M~zmLµ '4:4 ‰^µ°ƒ fl{(\…ks~ x uvosq"kwq x<; ~n``Mq4µ 464 Štµos~™dAmv`Mr^\^`qUuµ

464 Š œ[\…`1fx `MqCmnf©”kw–^fhjpfpmy;{oCq…uzmv~(kwfhqCm_™kRy˜`¥C`q—–”`1mv\^`™uzmnks~zmnfpq^‹rUoCfpqAmš›os~5kq^oCqtž>fhqtš›oC~v_™kmnfp¥C`

_ao x `Mjpjhfpq…‹…µ„ksu2fpq ¤ `q^‹C`~(uz`Mq kwq x ƒ„os–”`~vm 464 ‰ os~ƒ og` x `M~kwq x ¯±kCuvuv`~n_™kwq 464 Š œ [\^`

{os_ar^itm(kmnfpoCq…kwj x fp¨{i^jpmvfh`Mu ~n`Muvi^jpmvfhq^‹1š›~voC_,•'os~n£Afhq^‹!• f©mn\k1r”oCuzmv`M~vfhos~ x flumn~vfh–^itmnfpoCq–Uksuv` x osq

ks~v`kwjluvo1•'`jhjpžT{(\…ks~zmn` x kwq x ¥kw~nfpoCi…u ¤ kw~n£so¥™{(\…ksfpq ¤ oCqAmv`¦'kw~njpoauzmv~(kmv`M‹sfh`Mu'\…kR¥C` –”``Mqr^~voCrUoAuz` x

fhq3mv\^`1jpfpmv`M~nkwmvi^~n`

fp`M–UoCj©mksq x ƒ oC–U`M~zmLµ '4:4

b…µZoC~ ³Ffpi4µ³4flkwq^‹kwq x ¯3oCq^‹…µ 464:5:

œ/¬q^š›`~n`q…{`!oCq

mn\^`™r…ks~nks_1`mv`M~nuŸfhu mn\^`q

x

`M~vfh¥s`

x

š›~nos_ mv\^`

¤

ks~v£Co¥{(\Ukwfhq

¤

oCqAmv`2¦'kw~njpounkw_ar^jh`sµ7mn\^`·kRys`Muvflkwq

`Lumnfp_™kwmv`Mu –”`fhq^‹˜{oCq…umn~viU{$mv`

x

kCuŸ`M~v‹Co

x

fh{1kR¥s`M~nks‹s`Lu i…uvfpq^‹

x

flkw‹Cq^oCuzmvfl{uŸowš{oCqA¥C`~n‹s`Mq…{`ksq…kwjhytuz`

x

fhq ; i^fh\^`q^q…`i…{>=&?A@BDC '4:4648 œ

3¹qtš›os~vmvi^qUkmv`Mjpymn\^`~n`!ks~v` x f©¨{i…j©mnfp`Lu¹• fpmv\—mv\^`!_1o x `Mj~n`r…~v`Luz`MqCm(kmnfpoCq4µ…–”owmn\—kmŸmv\^`E=GF(HIBKJLG@M

?$NJO kwq x km!mv\^`PN2OQ?R=&L$HILG=&?S@?$NJO um(kw‹s`CœUTfh~(umnjpyCµmv\^`fhqtº…i^`Mq…{`owš„mn\^`r…kw~(kw_a`mn`~!os~ x `~nfpq…‹˜š›os~

fx `MqCmnf©”kw–^fhjpfpmysµtfpšiUuz` x µtfhu\Ukw~ x mvo™kCuvuv`Munukwq x fhu {`~vmnkwfhq^jhy™jp`Luvu–”`q…fp‹Cq2mn\…kwqr^~n`¥gfpoCi…uvjpy1mv\…osi^‹C\Cm

uvfhq…{`„fpmI\…kCuIk5–”`Mks~vfhq^‹5–”owmn\™osqamv\…` x `Luzfh‹sq™kwq x rU`M~zš›oC~v_™kwqU{` owš7mn\^` ¤ ks~v£Co¥{(\…ksfpq ¤ oCqAmv`Ÿ¦'kw~njho

unkw_ar^jh`~5ksq x oCq—mn\^`a~v`Luzi^jpmvfhq^‹fpq^š›`~n`q…{`sµ4ksu •'`a• fpjhj x `_aoCq…umn~nkwmv`Cœ!dg`M{osq x jpyCµZmv\^`™`|gr…jpoC~nkwmvfhosq

osš mv\^`r”oCuzmv`~nfhos~!uvi^r^r”os~vm!–gyuzmnkwq x kw~ xª¤ ks~v£Co¥3{(\…ksfpq ¤ osqAmv`˜¦'kw~njpo—unkw_ar^jh`~(u!_akRy±`fpmv\…`~a–U`

mnogoVBDJ W)@BÙµ'fhq mn\^`˜uz`Mq…uz`mv\Ukm1mv\^` ¤ ks~v£Co¥±{(\…ksfpq ¤ osqAmn`;¦'ks~vjho3unkw_ar^jh`fhu1i^q…ks–^jh`mno3¥gfluzfpmamv\^`

• \…osjh`~(kwq…‹s`owšŸmv\^`˜r”oCuzmv`M~vfhos~™_ao x `MuMµ'i…uziUkwjhjpy uzmnkRygfhq^‹ fpq mn\^`˜q^`fh‹s\g–”osi^~n\^ogo x osšŸoCq^`˜owš mv\^`

_™kw€os~_ao x `Mu• fpmv\~nks~v`«€i^_ar…u –”`m•'``Mq_ao x `MuMµtos~ oCq2mn\^`5{oCqCmn~nks~vy1mnoAoEXYO[Z)?S@6\&BD=µtfpqmn\^`5uz`Mq…uz`

mn\…km¹mv\^`5oC–…uz`M~v¥kwmvfhosq…u ks~v`ksjpjhot{kmn` x mvo2ksjpj4mv\^`{os_ar”osq^`MqCm(uowšmv\…`_ao x `j4fhqmv\^`!{osi…~nuv`owšmv\^`

uvfh_i^jlkmnfpoCq4µ^~n`Muvi^j©mnfpq…‹1fhq;uvfp_afhjhks~ `Muzmvfh_akwmv`Luš›os~ mn\^`

uœdgi…{(\

x

fp¨™{i^jpmvfh`Mu¹ks~v`r…ks~zmnfh{i^jlkw~njpy

oC–g¥AfhosiUu • \^`q3uzyg_a_a`mv~nfl{r^~nfpoC~nu¹kw~n`i…uv`

x

oCq˜mv\^`!r…kw~(kw_a`mv`~Ÿr…kwfh~(u

µ7ksu„fhq

fp`M–UoCj©m5kwq

x

ƒ„os–”`~vm 1'4:4

b µ…¦«\^fp–

1'464876

kwq

x

ƒ fl{(\…kw~

x

uvosq2ksq x];

~v`M`q 464

Š

µtuvfpq…{` mv\^`r”oCuzmv`~nfhos~

x

flumn~vfh–^itž

mnfpoCqflu'mv\…`q˜kwjluzo1fhqA¥ks~vflkwqAm'mvoarU`M~v_!itmnkwmvfhosqowšmv\^`fhq x fl{`MuMœ[\^flu~v`Luzi…j©m(u«fhqfx `qAmvfl{ksj7_aks~v‹CfpqUkwjlu

š›oC~Imn\^`¹rUkw~(kw_a`mn`~IrUkwfh~nuMµsmn\…km'fhu«_™kw~n‹sfhq…kwjlu• \…fh{(\2ks~v`¹fpq x `r”`q x `MqAmosšQ^Uœ[\…`+N2O[?S=&L$HILG=&?R@?NJO!osš

mn\^`1rUoAumn`~nfpoC~ x flumn~vfh–^itmnfpoCq;flu„mn\AiUu x `jhfh{Mkmv`1uzfhq…{`1ksqAyfhqtš›`~n`q…{`mn\^~nosi^‹C\˜rUoAumn`~nfpoC~¹_a`Mksq…u š›os~

`|^kw_ar^jh`sµF`M~v‹Co x fh{™kR¥C`~(kw‹C`Mu flu5fhq…kwr^r…~voCr^~vflkmn`™uzfhq…{`mv\^`Luz`™_a`Mksq…uks~vfluz`amn\^~nosi^‹C\—mn\^`_™kw~n‹sfhq…kwj

x fhuzmv~nfp–…itmvfhosq…uMœ ¤ osq^fpmvoC~vfhq^‹owš'mv\^` ¤ kw~n£so¥;{(\…ksfpq ¤ oCqCmn`¦'kw~njpo˜unkw_ar^jh`™i…uvi…kwjhjpy±uz\…o•„u mv\…kwmf©m

x oA`LuIq…owm`|tr^jhos~n`„mv\…`¡Z¢g`L§Ci…fp¥kwjh`qAm_ao x `Mu«owš4mn\^`Ÿr”oCuzmv`M~vfhos~ x flumn~vfh–^itmnfpoCquvfpqU{`„mn\^` `Muzmvfh_akwmv`Lu«osš

mn\^`_™ks~v‹Cfpq…ksj4r”oCuzmv`~nfhos~ x fhuzmv~nfp–…itmvfhosq…uŸkw~n`uzmv~nosq^‹CjpyksuvyA_a_a`mn~vfl{5fhq;_aoCuzm {Mksuv`MuMœ¹[\^flu„flu x `M`r^jhy

i…q…uvkwmvfluš®kC{$mnos~ny;š›~nos_ kwq ¤ kw~n£so¥3{(\Ukwfhq ¤ osqAmv`˜¦'kw~njpo—rUoCfpqAm!osš„¥gfp`M•5µuzfhq…{`f©mar^~n`Muv`qAmnu!k˜~(kw~n`

uv`mvmvfhq^‹2• \…`~n`•'`£gq^o• mv\…kwmuvos_a`!~v`M‹sfhosq…u osšmv\…`r…ks~nks_1`mv`M~Ÿuvr…ks{`\…kR¥C`q^owm –U`M`q3¥Afluvf©mn` x –gy

mn\^`

¤

ks~v£Co¥ {(\Ukwfhq4œ

¸ q `L§Ci…fp¥kwjh`qAm™r”`~(uzr”`M{mvfh¥s`fhu™mvoª{oCq…uvf

x

`M~1mv\…kwm™mv\^`Luz`˜~n`¥C`Mkwjh`

x

uzyg_a_a`ž

mn~vfh`Mu«fhq

x

i…{`Ÿ–…kCuzfl{¹{osqAmv~nosj”¥kw~nfhkwmv`Lu• \^fl{(\ks~v` uzi…{(\mv\…kwm«mn\^`ŸiUuzi…ksj7uvks_1r…jp`M~nu«kw~n`¹q^`M¥s`~uzmvosr…rU`

x

ks‹Cksfpq…uzmImn\^`Muv` ¥Rks~vflkmn`Mu«fpq2mv\^`• f

x

` _akw€os~nf©myaosš{kCuz`Luœ

¸

jpmv\…osi^‹C\uvos_a`• \…kwm«r^~n`Muvi^_artmni^osi…uMµg•«`

{osq…uvfx `~ mv\Ukmkwjh_aoCuzmŸmn\^`™`qAmvfh~n`my˜owš ¤ kw~n£so¥˜{(\…ksfpq ¤ osqAmn`¦'ks~vjhounkw_ar^jh`~(u fp_ar^jh`_a`MqCmn` x š›os~

_afp|gmvi^~n`™_ao x `jlu5\…ksu š®ksfpjh` x mno;{oCqA¥C`~n‹s` ¤ os~n`o¥s`M~Mµ7•'`a• fhuv\±mvo;uzmv~n`Munumv\Ukm\…ks~v_ {kwq±~n`Muvi^j©m

š›~nos_ mn\^`'uzmnkwmvflumnfh{MkwjAfpqAmn`~nr^~v`mnkwmvfhosq5owš ¤ kw~n£so¥{(\…kwfhq ¤ osqAmn` ¦'ks~vjho¹unkw_ar^jh`Mu4r…~vo x i…{` x –gy5r^jlks{fpq…‹

{osq…uzmv~(kwfhqAmnu¹osq;mn\^`ar…kw~(kw_a`mv`~(uMœ ¸ j©mn\^osi…‹s\4µZš›~nos_ kum(kmnfhuzmvfl{ksjr”osfhqAmosšI¥gfp`M•5µZmv\^`a`|gr…jpoC~nkwmvfhosq

osšFmn\^`¡Z¢t_ao x kwj7~n`‹sfhosqUuIosšFmv\…` r”oCuzmv`M~vfhos~ x fluzmv~nfp–^i^mvfhosqfhu~n` x i…q x kwqAm uvfpqU{` mv\^`5fhq x fl{`Lu ^aowšmv\^`

{os_ar”osq^`MqCm(uks~v`]OJ?Ifx `MqCmnf©”kw–^jh` µmn\^`2r…fh{mvi^~n`r^~no¥gfx ` x –gy—mn\^` ¤ ks~v£Co¥3{(\…ksfpq ¤ oCqCmn`¦'kw~njho

unkw_ar^jh`1_akRy˜–”`sµkwq x fpq _™kwqgy;{Mksuv`MuŸfhuMµ4fhq…{oC_1r…jp`mv`a–U`L{ksi…uz`1mn\^` ¤ kw~n£so¥{(\…kwfhq kwjh_1oAumq^`M¥s`~

jh`MkR¥C`Mumn\^`1¥Afl{fhq^fpmyowšosq…`r…kw~vmvfl{i…jhks~¹jhog{Mkwj_1o x `1kwq x mv\gi…uŸosq^jhy˜{o¥s`M~nu¹kaš›~nkC{$mnfpoCq;owš°mn\^`!uvi^rtž

r”os~vm¹osšmn\^`5mn~vi^`rUoAumn`~nfpoC~MµU`¥s`Mqi^q x `M~„mv\…`fx `qAmvfpUks–^fpjhfpmy{osq…uzmv~(kwfhqAmMœ T^os~¹mv\^flu„~n`MkCuzoCq•«`5š›`M`j

mn\…km1mv~ni^q…{MkmnfpoCq…uosš„mv\^`r…ks~nks_1`mv`M~!uvr…ks{`_™kRy€`Mosr…ks~ x fM`mv\…`~n`Muvi^jpmvfhq^‹;fhqtš›`~n`q…{` {oCqCmn~nks~vy

mno—r^~n`¥gfhosi…urU`M~nuvrU`L{$mnfp¥C`Muk x osr^mv` x fpq ; ~ni^`mE=&?"@BDChµ 46464

µoC~!ƒ oC–U`M~zm1kwq xª¤ `q^‹C`~(uz`Mq4µ '464:5:

œ

I¥s`q˜• \…`qmv\…`5mv~ni^q…{Mkmvfhosq x og`Lu„q^osm¹_ao x f©š›ymv\^`r^~vfhos~ x fhuzmv~nfh–^itmvfhosq

• \^fl{(\˜fhu¹q^owm„`|tkC{$mnjpymv\^`

{Mksuv`¹fhq ¤ `q^‹C`~(uz`Mqkwq x ƒ oC–U`M~zmLµ '464

‰^µCos~ ƒ og` x `M~ kwq x ¯±kCuvuv`~n_™kwq4µ '4:4

Š

µCmv\^`5{(\^oCfh{`ŸosšF• \^fl{(\

osšImn\^`ar…kw~(kw_a`mn`~(u¹flui…uv` x š›os~5oC~ x `M~vfhq^‹ mv\Ukm5fhuMµFfhq3mv\^` ; kwiUuvuvfhksq3{Mksuv`sµ7•'`fh‹s\Am&Z&Ca_a`Mksq'Z&C

¥ks~vflkwq…{` jh`Mk x u mvo˜kr…kw~vmvfl{i…jhks~ rUkw~vmvfpmvfhosq±owš'mv\^`{os_ar^jh`mv`™r”oCuzmv`M~vfhos~ x fluzmv~nfp–^i^mvfhosq • \^fl{(\±_™kRy

_ao x fpš›y mv\^`˜{os~n~v`Luzr”osq x fpq^‹—fpqtš›`M~v`Mq…{`Cœ [\^`r”osfhqCm™kmafluvuvi^`\^`~n`flu!mv\…kwmamv\^`mv~ni^q…{MkmnfpoCq x og`Mu

q…owmq^`L{`Mununkw~nfpjhy;~n`MuvrU`L{$m5mv\…`‹s`Mos_a`mn~vy—ksq x uz\Ukwr”`owš'mv\^`2i^q^~n`Muzmv~nfh{mv` x r”oCuzmv`M~vfhos~ x fluzmv~nfp–^i^mvfhosq4­

• \…fpjh` uvos_a`Ÿos~ x `~nfpq…‹Cu_™kRy™q^fl{`Mjpy™fluvosjlkmv` kuvfpq…‹sjh`Ÿ_ao x ` owš4mn\^fhu x fluzmv~nfp–^i^mvfhosq4µt_aoCuzm«• fhjhj7fpqg¥soCjp¥C`

rUkw~vmnu5osš¹uz`M¥s`~(kwj°_ao x ksjI~n`‹sfhosqUuœ ¸ {osq…uv`M§Ai^`Mq…{`™osš mv\^fluflumv\…kwmf©š¹k;rUoAumn`~nfpoC~_a`Mkwqflu5mn\^`q

{Mkwjl{i^jlkmn` x µmn\^`2`Lumnfp_™kmn`2• fhjpj x •'`jhj«fhq k—¥Rksjpjh`y±–”`m•'``qªmv\^`¡Z¢_ao x `Lu~(kmn\^`~mv\…ksq {jhoCuv`™mvo

oCq^`aowš'mv\^`M_œ-¬q k x^x fpmvfhosq4µ~v`M_ao¥Afhq^‹mv\^`™oC~ x `~nfpq^‹{oCq…uzmv~(kwfhqCmš›~nos_ mn\^`™r^~nfpoC~umnfpjhjjh`MkR¥C`MuŸmv\^`

`|tr^jpoC~nkwmvfhosq™r^~nos–…jp`M_ oCrU`Mq4­gosq^`Ÿ_i…uzm x `M{fx ` • \^`mv\^`M~Imn\^`Ÿr”oCuzmv`M~vfhos~ x flumn~vfh–^itmnfpoCq2flu«uvit¨{fh`qAmvjhy

•'`jhj x `Luv{~vfh–”` x –gy—mn\^` ¤ ks~v£Co¥;{(\…kwfhq ¤ oCqCmn`¦'kw~njpo;unkw_ar^jh`sµmv\Ukmflu• \^`mv\^`M~mn\^`i^q^`|tr^jpoC~v` x

rUkw~vmosšFmn\^`uzi…r^rUoC~zm¹{Mkwq–U`5~n`M{o¥s`M~v` x –gyrU`M~v_!itmnkwmvfhosq…uMœ

³Fos‹sfl{ksjpjhy f©mš›osjhjpo•„u4mv\…kwmk„q…o¥s`jCrU`M~nuvr”`M{$mnfp¥C`osqmv\^`uzfh_i…jhkwmvfhosq5owštmn\^`Ir”oCuzmv`M~vfhos~ x flumn~vfh–^itmnfpoCq

ksq x mv\^`—~v`Mjhkw|gfhq^‹ owš mv\…`;fx `qAmvfpUkw–…fpjhf©my {oCq…uzmv~(kwfhqCm(ua_i…uzm2kwjluvojp`Lk x mvoªk q^o¥C`j¹ksr^r^~noCkC{(\"km

mn\^`2fhqAmv`M~vr^~n`m(kmnfpoCqªum(kw‹s`Cµmv\…kwm!fluš›oC~1·kRys`Luzflkwq fhqtš›`~n`qU{`2fhqmn\^fhu1uv`mvi…r4œ Tfh‹si^~n` fpjhjpiUumn~nkwmv`Mu

mn\^`fh~v~n`jh`¥ksq…{`5osšiUuzfhq^‹r”oCuzmv`M~vfhos~„_a`Lkwq…u¹• \^`qmn\^`fx `qAmnf©Uks–^fhjpfpmy{osq…uzmv~(kwfhqAm„fhu¹q^owm `qtš›oC~n{` x µ

–gyr^~n`Muv`qAmnfpq^‹3mv\…`{Mksuv`osšŸk—mv\^~n``˜{oC_arUoCq^`qAma`|trUoCq^`qAmnfhksj'_afp|gmvi^~n`• \^`~n`{os_ar”osq^`MqCm(uakw~n`

uvit¨{fh`qAmnjpy˜{jhoCuv`5mnokwjhjho• kum(kwq x kw~ x ; fp–^–UuŸunkw_ar^jh`~¹mvo2_ao¥C`5š›~v`M`jhy–U`m•«`M`q˜mn\^`_ao x `MuMœ ¬q

mn\^flu¹{kCuz`Cµ^mn\^`5mv\…~v`M`_™kw~n‹sfhq…kwj7r”oCuzmv`M~vfhos~ x fhuzmv~nfp–…itmvfhosq…u x fluzr^jlkRyka\…fp‹C\ x `‹C~v`M`5owšuzfh_afpjlkw~nfpmykwq x

mn\^flu™jp`Lk x u1mnoq^`Mks~vjhyªfx `qAmnfh{Mkwj„r”oCuzmv`M~vfhos~™_a`Mksq…uMµ«fhq owmv\…`~™•'os~ x u1mvoªk±~n`r^~n`Muv`qAmnkwmvfhosq owš mv\^`

_ao x `MjF–gy2`Luvuv`qAmvflkwjhjhy2kuvfpq^‹Cjp`5`|trUoCq^`qAmvflkwj x fhuzmv~nfh–^itmvfhosqFœdgfh_afpjlkw~¹r^\^`q…os_a`q…k™{Mkwq˜–”`os–Uuz`M~v¥C` x

fhq ; ~vi^`m"=&?A@BDC '4:4648 š›os~'mn\^`5{osqUumn~nksfpq^` x {Mksuv`Ÿjh`Mk x fpq…‹mvo™ksq2`Muzmvfh_™kmn` • \…`~n`ŸoCq^` {os_ar”osq^`MqCm

o¥C`~n• \^`jh_™umn\^`5owmn\^`~(u• \^fl{(\–U`L{os_a`q^`M‹sjhfp‹Cfp–^jh`sœ

[\^`Ÿkw~n‹si^_a`qAmr^~nosr”oCuv` x –gy!mv\^flur…ksrU`M~Iflu°mn\…km k mn\^`„i^qU{osqUumn~nksfpq^` x rUoAumn`~nfpoC~fhumv\^`¹_1oAum

qUkmvi…~nksj r”oCuzmv`M~vfhos~ x fhuzmv~nfp–…itmvfhosq™mno!{osq…uvfx `~LµC`Luzr”`M{fhksjpjhy!fhq2q…osqtžTfpq^š›os~n_akwmvfh¥s`¹uv`mvmvfhq^‹CuMµ – mv\^`M~v`

`|tfhuzmIks{M{`jh`~(kmnfpq…‹uzmv~(kmn`‹Cfp`Lu• \^fh{(\a…mIq…kmni^~(kwjhjpy!fpqamn\^`„_af©|gmni^~v`„uv`mvmvfhq^‹…µAq^osm~v`L§Ci…fp~nfpq…‹k x^x fpmvfhowž

qUkwj…fh_ar^jh`_a`qAmnkwmvfhosq™`¶”oC~zm(uµ { mv\…`~n`„`|tflum«ksj©mn`~nq…kmnfp¥C`Mumno5mv\…`¹r”oCuzmv`~nfhos~_a`Mksq…u• \…fh{(\™r^~no¥gfx `

Tfh‹si^~n` " ¤ kw~n‹sfhq…ksj„rUoAumn`~nfpoC~™\^flumnos‹s~(kw_™u1š›oC~mv\…`;r…kw~(kw_a`mv`~(u

^ /:Y8 osš5k

{os_ar”osq^`MqCm `|tr”osq^`MqCmnfhksj_afp|gmvi^~n`š›oC~¹mn\^`auvks_1r…jp`!r^~vo x iU{` x –Ay˜kum(kwq x ks~ x ; fp–^–Uu unkw_ar^jh`~¹š›os~

ksq˜i^q…{osq…uzmv~(kwfhq^` x uvyg_1_a`mv~nfh{5r…~vfhos~

i^q^fpš›os~n_ fh~vfl{(\^jh`m¹oCqmv\^`!¥s`L{$mvoC~„owš

uŸkwq x `|trUoCq^`qAmvflkwj

G/3

osq˜mn\^`

u µ”–…kCuz`

x

osq;kuvfh_i^jlkmn`

x

unkw_ar^jh`owšIuvf`

/

,6, kwq

x / ,

,6,:,

f©mn`~(kmvfhosqUuœ LG=

BK= =(BZ Z&W)@BD= ? = =&NY?AJ ? =YNZ)?SJLG@ ? =YN[=(L"? = @BX[=+J ?[=6LcN`?[=6@L 6=&L ?[= X[= C!

p

lambda

0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8

02468

Component 1

p

lambda

0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0

0123456

Component 2

p

lambda

0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0

0246

Component 3

uv`qUuzfh–^jh`„·'kRyC`Muvfhksq1ksq…uv•«`M~numno5mv\^`¹`Muzmvfh_akwmvfhosq™osšUmn\^`¹r…ks~nks_a`mv`M~nuosš

1

œTm«fhuI•«oC~zmn\1q…owmvfhq^‹5mn\…km

• \…fpjh`!fhqtš›oC~v_™kmnfp¥C`r^~nfhos~(u¹{ksq;_™kw£C`f

x

`qAmvfpš›ygfpq…‹{osq…uzmv~(kwfhqAmnu„~n`

x

i^q

x

ksqCm–gyr^~vo

x

iU{fhq^‹

x

fluzmvfhq…{$m

x

fhuzmv~nfp–…itmvfhosq…uŸosq—mv\^`a{oC_arUoCq^`qAmŸrUkw~(kw_a`mn`~(u

µ”mn\^`Muv`!r…~vfhos~(u„_aoCuzmowšãmv`Mq3uzmvfhjpj°ksjpjho• š›os~5uzoC_a`

ks_aosi^qAmowš”uv• fpmn{(\^fhq^‹–U`m•«`M`qmv\^`„{os_arUoCq^`qAm(u• \…fh{(\1fhuq…owm°os–…uv`~n¥s`

x

š›os~°uzmnksq

x

kw~

x

ksjp‹Cos~nf©mn\^_™uœ

[\^`r…ksrU`M~fluos~n‹Cksq^fhuv` x ksuFš›osjhjpo•„u"4•'` x `Luv{~vfh–”`Ifhqadg`L{$mnfpoCq1‚„mv\^`um(kwq x kw~ x kR¥kwfhjhks–^jp` ¤ kw~n£so¥

{(\Ukwfhq ¤ osqAmv`'¦'ks~vjho„uvosjhitmvfhosq…uFkwq x uv\^o•3mv\^~nosi^‹C\`|^kw_ar^jh`MuZmn\…kmmv\^`My¹š®ksfpjsmvo¹kC{(\^fh`¥s`mn\^`~n`M§Ai^fh~v` x

uvyg_a_1`mv~nysœ¯3`mn\^`q™fhqAmv~no x i…{` fhqdg`M{mvfhosqˆ5kŸmv`M_arU`M~vfhq^‹uzmv~(kmn`‹sy5• \…fh{(\™fluuv\^o• qmno5o¥s`M~n{os_a`

mn\^`˜r^~n`¥gfhosi…u x fp¨{i^jpmysœ ¬q²dg`M{mvfhosq…uabªksq x 7 µ'•«` x `M¥s`MjpoCr"¥kw~nfhosi…u™ksr^r^~noCks{(\…`Muš›os~ x `M~vfh¥gfpq…‹

·kRyC`Mu'`Muzmvfh_™kmv`Lu'š›~voC_+ka{oC_1r”osq…`qAmzžT• fhuv`5uzyg_a_a`mn~vfl{ ¤ kw~n£so¥™{(\…ksfpq ¤ oCqCmn`¦'kw~njpoauvks_ar^jp`Cœ°¯3`

{osq…{`qAmv~(kmn`¹mn\^~nosi^‹C\^ositm oCqq^oC~v_™ksjZksq x `|tr”osq^`MqCmnfhksj7_af©|gmvi…~v`Luµgmn\…km„flu

#"

$

%#&

kwq x

'

)%

´¹o•«`M¥s`M~«mn\^`ksr^r^~noCks{(\uzi…‹s‹s`Lumn` x \^`~n`5`|gmn`q x u x fp~n`M{mvjhymnoowmn\^`~mygr”`Mu osš_afp|gmvi^~n`Mu

}osfluvuvosq4µ

}°ks~v`mvo…µ`mn{wœ

µ„ksq x kwjluvo mvoªosmv\^`M~2{kwmv`‹Cos~nfp`Luaowš5jlkmv`MqAm2¥kw~nfhks–^jp`˜_ao x `Mjhu

ƒ oC–U`M~zmLµ '464:5:

kwq x

q…osqtžTfx `qAmvfpUkw–…jp`r^~nos–^jh`_™uMœ dtfp_afhjhks~vjhysµ'•«`oCq^jpy"{osqUuzfx `~1mn\^`;{kCuz`owš5uzyg_a_a`mn~vfl{r^~vfhos~(uMµ–^itm

oC–g¥AfhosiUuzjhysµ_ao x `Muzm x `Mr…kw~vmvi^~n`Mu™š›~voC_uvyg_1_a`mv~ny •'osi^jx jp`Lk x mno uzfh_afpjlkw~2–U`M\…kR¥gfpoCi^~• \^`Mq mv\^`

r…~vfhos~

x

og`Muq^owm{osi^qAmv`M~mv\^`™jlks{(£—owšf

x

`MqAmvfpUkw–^fhjhf©my±uzit¨{fp`MqCmnjpy3umn~voCq^‹sjhysµFkCu5_a`qAmvfhosq…`

x

kw–”o¥s`sœ

i…~{(\^oCfh{`IosšUuzyg_a_a`mn~vfl{Ir…~voCrU`M~r^~nfhos~(u4flu…€iUumnf©…`

x

kCuFfhq!ƒ„fh{(\…ks~

x

uzoCqkwq x ;

~v`M`q 1'4:4

Š

µRq…kw_a`jhy

–gy™kwq`_ar^fh~vfl{ksj

x

`mv`M~v_afhq…kmnfpoCqowšjpot{kwmvfhosqtž¬un{kwjh`„r…ks~nks_a`mv`M~nuI–…ksuv`

x

osq™mn\^`

x

km(kž¬uzr^~n`Mk x œ ¤

os~n`

r…~v`L{fluz`MjpyCµ«•'`˜i…uv`;{osqw€i^‹Ckwmv`r^~nfpoC~nuafhq –Uosmv\ {kCuz`Luµ«mv\Ukm2flu G/6&%'%&%'&/3 x fhuzmv~nfp–…itmvfhosq…uosq mv\^`

•'`fh‹s\Am(uµ

1/ x fhuzmv~nfh–^itmvfhosqUuoCq5mv\…`un{ksjp`«r…kw~(kw_a`mv`~(u

ksq x % &

ksq x " ,

&/

, % &

x fluzmv~nfp–^i^mvfhosq…u

oCq2mn\^`5_a`Mksq…u $ œ

(01 5±F ),Ÿ5) 3))

¯±`«{osq…uvfx `~Fmv\^`'um(kwq x ks~x5¤ kw~n£so¥Ÿ{(\Ukwfhq ¤ osqAmv` ¦'kw~njpo„unkw_ar^jh`~(u4fhq5mni^~vq!uz\^o• fhq^‹ mn\…km`MkC{(\š®kwfhjhu

mnoks{(\…fp`M¥s`mv\…`ŸuvyA_a_a`mn~vy1fhq^\^`~n`qAm«mvo5mn\^`¹• \^oCjp`„mv~ni^`Ÿuzmnkwmvfhosq…ks~vy x fhuzmv~nfh–^itmvfhosqFœ¯±`Ÿ{osq…{`qAmv~(kmn`

fhq$‚tœˆ;oCqmv\^` ¤ `mv~nosr”osjhfhuzžT´Ÿksuzmvfhq^‹Cu!kwjh‹soC~vfpmv\^_ –…kCuz` x osqªmv\^`³Fksq^‹s`M¥Afhq x fp¶Zi…uzfhosq"• \^fl{(\ • fhjpj

jlkmn`~'–U` i…uv` x fpqkmn`_arU`M~vfhq^‹aumn~nkwmv`M‹sysµguvfpq…{`sµAmvo!osi^~£gq^o• jh` x ‹C`sµAf©m\…kCuIq^osm'–”``Mq2yC`mr^~voCrUoAuz` x

fhqmv\^`5jhf©mn`~(kmni^~v` fhquvi…{(\uz`mzmvfhq^‹Auœ ¸ mmv\…fhu„uzmnks‹s` •«`q^osmv` mv\Ukm f©m„flu kwjh•kRygu«r”oCunuzfh–^jh`Ÿmno™ks{(\^fh`¥C`

jlkw–”`j^uv• fpmn{(\^fhq^‹ –U`m•«`M`q!mv\^`¹¡Z¢_ao x `Lu–Aymn\^`„uvfp_ar^jh` k x^x fpmvfhosq1owšZkŸuzmv`Mrafpq!mv\^` ksjp‹Cos~nf©mn\^_†• \^fl{(\

r…~voCrUoAuz`Lu¹k~(kwq x os_ r”`~n_itm(kmvfhosq—owšmn\^`!jlkw–”`jlu k ¤ `mv~nosr”osjhfluž¬´¹kCumnfpq^‹Au¹uzmv`Mr—• fpmv\3kC{{`rtm(kwq…{`

r…~voC–…kw–^fhjhf©myaosq…` œ i^~'fhq…uzfluzmv`qU{` osquv`Mks~n{(\…fpq^‹š›os~kwqkwjh‹sos~nfpmv\^_ • \^fl{(\{MkwqkC{(\^fh`¥s`Ÿuzyg_a_a`mv~ny

• fpmv\…ositmuvi…{(\±k_ao¥s`1mygr”`1flu mv\Ukmkwqgy;{osq…{`~nq…u o¥s`~5{osqg¥s`M~v‹C`q…{`!kw~n`1q^owm5q^`L{`Mununkw~nfpjhy x `Mksj©m

• fpmv\–gy2uvi…{(\k1uzmv~(kmn`‹Cy• \^fl{(\uvfp_ar^jhyksjpjh`¥gflkmn`Mu«mv\^`5_aoAum os–g¥gfhosi…u uvyg_1r^mvos_œ

!#"

[\…` ; fp–^–Uuunkw_ar^jh`~flu5mn\^`_aoCuzm{oC_1_aoCq^jpy3i…uv` x kwr…r^~voAks{(\3fpq_afp|Amni^~n``Muzmvfh_™kmvfhosq±š›oCjpjho• fpq…‹

fh`–”osjpmkwq x ƒ oC–U`M~zm 1'4:4%$ µ'4:4 b µIksq x •«`˜• fhjpj¹q^owm x •'`jhj„oCq fpm2jhosq^‹C`~amn\…kwq q^`L{`Mununkw~ny”­„uv``

¦«\…fp– 1'4:4:76 oC~!ƒ fl{(\…ks~ x uvosqksq x<; ~n``q 1'4:4 Š š›oC~1k x^x fpmvfhosq…ksj x `mnksfpjluœ3[\^`2–…kCuzfl{aš›`Lkmvi…~v`osš

mn\^` ; fh–^–…u5unkw_ar^jh`~5fhq—mn\^fhuuz`mvi^r flu mv\^`ksi^‹s_a`qAm(kmvfhosq3owš«mv\^`™r…ks~nks_a`mv`M~nu osš 3 –gy—kw~vmvfpU{flkwj

ksjpjhot{kwmvfhosq¥kw~nflkw–^jh`Mu'&)(vµ`MkC{(\osq…`«–”`fhq^‹ksunuzot{flkmn` x • fpmv\1osq^`'owš…mv\^` ( ufhqoC~ x `M~Fmno+*x `ž>_afp|-,°mv\^`

oC–…uv`~n¥s` x unkw_ar^jh`sœ°[\^flu«ksjpjho•„uIuvfh_i^jlkmnfpoCq™owš7mv\…`¹r…ks~nks_1`mv`M~nuIowš4`MkC{(\{oC_1r”osq…`qAm'{osq x fpmvfhosqUkwjhjpy

oCqmv\^`akwjhjhog{MkmnfpoCq…uµ…mnks£Afhq^‹fhqAmvoks{{osi^qAm¹oCq^jhy2mn\^`!oC–…uv`~n¥Rkwmvfhosq…u„• \^fh{(\—\…kR¥s`–”``Mq—kwjhjhog{Mkmn` x mvo

mn\^flu1{os_ar”osq^`MqCmLœ &„osmv`mv\…kwmaoCq^`2osš„mv\…`_™ksfpq

x

`š›`L{$mnu1osš„mv\^`

;

fh–^–…uaunkw_ar^jh`~1fpq"mv\^fluauz`mzmnfpq^‹

flumv\^`i^j©mnfp_™kwmv`kmzmn~nkC{$mnfpoCqowš mv\…`jhot{kwj«_ao

x

`MuMµmv\…kwm1flumn\^`ksjp_aoAum1fp_ar”oCunuzfh–^jh`uvfp_!i^j©m(kwq^`Mosi…u

~n`ž¬kwjhjhog{MkmnfpoCq osškª‹C~voCi^r²owšoC–…uv`~n¥Rkwmvfhosq…u™mvo k x

fp¶”`M~v`MqAm{oC_arUoCq^`qAmMœ ¬qJ`|trU`M~vfh_a`qAmnuMµ mv\…fhu

–”`\UkR¥Afhosi…~1•ksu1oC–…uz`M~v¥C` x fpq –”owmv\ mn\^`i^q…{oCq…uzmv~(kwfhq^` x kwq x mv\…`;{osqUumn~nksfpq^` x {Mksuv`MuM­«mn\^`˜~n`Muvi^j©m

fhqªmn\^`{osqUumn~nksfpq^` x {kCuz`–U`Mfpq^‹3mv\Ukmmn\^`{osqUumn~nksfpq^` x r…ks~nks_1`mv`M~flu!–…fhkCuz` x fpq mv\^``¥C`qAmmn\…km

uvit¨{fh`qAmos–…uv`~n¥kmvfhosqUu2kw~n`;• ~nosq^‹Cjpy kwjhjhog{Mkmn` x œ T^oC~fhq…uzmnkwqU{`sµ¹fpq kªq^oC~v_™kwjŸi^q^fx fh_1`Mq…uvfpoCq…kwj

_afp|gmvi^~n`sµUf©š°mn\^`{oCq…uzmv~(kwfhqCm %

/.

% &

–U`Lkw~(u osqmn\^`¥kw~nfhksq…{`Lu„kwq x fpš

&%'%&%(G

0

ks~v`ksjpjhot{kmn` x mvo

{os_ar”osq^`MqCm1* ,wµ^kwq x

G

&%'%&%(G

&32

kw~n`kwjhjpot{Mkmv` x mno{oC_1r”osq…`qAm1*v‚4,µt• \^fhjh`5mv\^`5oCr^r”oCuvf©mn`uz\^oCi^jx

\…osjx mn\…kmafhuMµ°mn\^`{os_a_aosqª¥ks~vflkwq…{`owš

&%&%'%(1

0

flujlkw~n‹s`M~mn\…kwq mv\^`{oC_1_aoCqª¥kw~nfhksq…{`osš

G

&%'%&%(G

&32

µAmv\^` {osqUumn~nksfpqAm• fhjpj”jp`Lk x mno`fpmv\…`~kwqi^rg•kw~ x –^fhkCu°š›oC~ % &

os~'k x o• qg•'ks~ x –^flksuš›os~

%

–U`L{kwiUuz`5kwqkwjhjhog{MkmnfpoCquv• f©m({(\• fhjhj OI= 3=&L'og{M{i^~Lœ

Tfh‹si^~n`Mu„‚aksq x ˆafhjhjpi…uzmv~(kmn` mv\^`5jlks{(£osš5*z_af©|tfhq^‹6,Ÿosšmn\^`{(\…kwfhq…u'š›oC~mv\^``|trUoCq^`qAmvflkwj4ksq x mv\^`

q…os~n_aksj«{Mksuv`MuMµ~n`Muvr”`M{$mnfp¥C`jhysœ;¯ \…fpjh`mn\^`o¥C`~(kwjhj ¤ ks~v£Co¥—{(\…kwfhq ¤ oCqAmv`¦'ks~vjho;unkw_ar^jh`2`|t\^fh–^fpmnu

Tfh‹si^~n`!‚ "ƒ„`r^~n`Muv`qAmnkwmvfhosqfhq;mv\…`

r^jlkwq…`owš°mn\^` ; fh–^–…u unkw_ar^jh`ksunuzot{fhkwmv` x • fpmv\3kuvks_ar^jp`

osš

/:

,:,6,

uzfh_i…jhkwmv` x r”osfhqAmnu š›~nos_ k

{oC_1r”osq…`qAm¹`|tr”osq^`MqAmvflkwj4_afp|Amni^~n`sœ N2LGW&BD=(ZW)JLcLG=(Z$H JO ?RJ

W)J H[JO=(OQ?

/ ?$LcN@O BK=cZ>?SJPWJ H[JO=(OQ?

@O PW(LGJZ)Z(=(Z ?SJ W)J H[JO=(OQ?

C! [\^`2\^fhuzmvoC‹s~(kw_™u5oCq

mnosr;ksq

x

~nfp‹C\CmŸowš°mv\…`r^jhowmkw~n`mv\^`!`Muzmvfh_akwmv`Lu¹osšmn\^`1_aks~v‹CfpqUkwj

x

fluzmv~nfp–^i^mvfhosq…u¹owš

( R?RJ)H !kwq

x (

RLcN ?!œ

• •

p

lambda

0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0

02468

0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0

01234 02468

0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5

Gibbs sampling

(10000 iterations)

mn\^~n`` Mosq^`LuIosšFfh_1r”os~vmnksq…{`CµAmv\^`{oC_1r”osq…`qAm'{(\…ksfpqUu

)

q^`M¥s`~uv• f©m({(\2fhqmv\…`Ÿq^oC~v_™ksj”{Mksuv`

ksq x `|t\^fh–^f©moCq^jhy!k _ao x `~(kmv` x `M‹s~n``owšZuz• fpmn{(\…fpq^‹5–”`m•'``Mqm•'o5{oC_1r”osq…`qAmnufhq1mv\^`„`|trUoCq^`qAmvflkwj

{Mksuv`sœ Tfh‹si^~n` r^~no¥gfx `Mu„ksq˜osr^r”oCuvf©mn`fhjpjhi…uzmv~(kmvfhosq˜fhq˜`|tr”osq^`MqAmvflkwjuv`mvmvfhq^‹CuMµ…qUkw_a`jhy2mn\…km{oC_!ž

r…jp`mv`„uv• f©m({(\^fpq…‹ _™kRyot{M{i^~Lœ

¬q1_™ksqAy!{ksuv`MuMµmn\^` ; fp–…–…uunkw_ar^jh`~fhui^q…kw–…jp`'mvo5_ao¥C`Imn\^` ¤ kw~n£so¥

{(\Ukwfhq—mnoksq^owmn\^`~5_ao x `aowš`M§Ai…ksj°fp_ar”os~vmnksq…{`a–”`M{ksi…uv`1osš«fpmnu5fhq…ks–^fpjhfpmy˜mvo;uzmv`Mr3o¥C`~¥kwjhjp`Myguosš

jho•†r^~nos–…ks–^fhjpfpmysœ ¬q3k x^x fpmvfhosq4µ”mv\…`~n`fluŸq…o2•kRyoCq^`!{Mkwq™€i x ‹s`1• \^`mn\^`~Ÿmv\…`!q^`Mfp‹C\g–UoCi^~v\…oAo x osš

Tfh‹si^~n`ˆ "aƒ `Mr^~v`Luz`MqAmnkmnfpoCq3osš mv\^` ; fp–^–Uuunkw_ar^jh`2ksunuzot{fhkwmv` x • fpmv\ªk;unkw_ar^jh`osš

,6,

uvfp_!i^jhkwmv` x

r”osfhqAmnu'š›~nos_+k

{os_arUoCq^`qAm q^oC~v_™kwj7_afp|gmvi^~n`sœ @ = Z \)JBZ @Z"N2ONXYL= C!

Weight Variance

Mean

kuvrU`L{fpU{1_ao x `™\…ksu–”``Mq uvit¨{fh`qAmnjpy;`|tr^jpoC~v` x µ4`M¥s`q3mv\…osi^‹C\—mn\^`™r…kmn\ owšImn\^` ¤ ks~v£Co¥{(\Ukwfhq

{Mkwq –”``|tr^jhosfpmv` x mno;r^~no¥gfx `™k~nosi^‹C\kwr^r^~noR|tfp_™kwmvfhosq—osšmv\^`_™ks~v‹Cfpq…ksj°rUoAumn`~nfpoC~ x flumn~vfh–^itmnfpoCq

osšmv\^`{os_ar”osq^`MqAmr…kw~(kw_a`mv`~(u ( ) ( /6'%&%&%& ¡ œ—[\^flukwr…r^~voR|tfh_™kmvfhosq±•ksuoC–tmnksfpq…` x fhq

mn\^`5`|tr”osq^`MqAmvflkwj4{kCuz`Cµ Tfp‹Ci^~v`5bUµt–gy{oC_ar^itmvfhq^‹amn\^`5rUoAumn`~nfpoC~ x fhuzmv~nfh–^itmvfhosq˜kwm„`Mks{(\fpmv`~(kmnfpoCqosš

mn\^` ; fh–^–…u¹{(\Ukwfhqksq x –AykR¥s`M~nks‹sfhq^‹…µCš›os~ `Lks{(\˜uv§Ai…ks~v` owš°k

, ,

‹C~vfx fpqmv\…`

I

uzr…kC{`Cµtmv\^`

¥ksjpi^`Luowšmv\^`5r”oCuzmv`M~vfhos~ x flumn~vfh–^itmnfpoCq…u• f©mn\^fhqmn\^`un§CiUkw~n`sœI¦«os_ar…ks~vfhq^‹mn\^flu…‹si…~v` • f©mn\mv\^`5r^jhowm

osšmv\…`

;

fp–^–Uu5uvks_1r…jp`1fpqPTfp‹Ci^~n`a‚^µ7• \^fpjh`1mv\^`™unkw_ar^jh`ar^jposm{o¥s`M~nuŸ_aoCuzm osšImv\…`1\…fp‹C\3~n`‹CfpoCq…u¹osš

mn\^`„`Lumnfp_™kmn`

x

_™kw~n‹sfhq…ksj=µsmv\^`„~nf

x

‹s`Lu°–U`m•«`M`qamn\^`¹_ao

x

kwjU~v`M‹sfhosq…u°ks~v`¹_1flunuzfhq^‹…œ

&¹owmn` mv\…kwm«• \^fpmv`

~n`‹CfpoCq…u„fhq9Tfh‹si^~n`bkw~n`fpq

x

fh{Mkmnfp¥C``fpmv\…`~ owšIkjho•†r”oCuzmv`~nfhos~¹r…~voC–…kw–^fhjhf©myos~ owšq^o¥gfhuvf©mŸmvomv\^`

{os~n~v`Luzr”osq

x

fpq…‹!un§CiUkw~n` –gy™mn\^`

¤

ks~v£Co¥a{(\Ukwfhq4œ

Tfh‹si^~n`™b " ¸

r…r^~voR|tfh_™kmvfhosq±owšmn\^`

_™ks~v‹Cfpq…ksj°rUoAumn`~nfpoC~ x flumn~vfh–^itmnfpoCq š›os~5mn\^`2`|trUoCq^`qAmvflkwj

_afp|gmvi^~n`1unkw_ar^jh`1owšTfh‹si^~n`1‚^µ7os–tm(kwfhq^` x –Ay;kR¥C`~(kw‹Cfpq^‹amn\^`1¥Rksjpi…`Mu owšmn\^` €osfhqAm r”oCuzmv`M~vfhos~km mv\^`

r”osfhqAmnuosšk ; fh–^–…u„unkw_ar^jh`og{M{i^~n~nfpq^‹1fhq`Lks{(\uv§Ai…ks~v` owšk1‹s~nfx œ

0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8

02468

!

¸

uzmnksq x ks~ x kwjpmv`M~vq…kwmvfh¥s`'mvomn\^` ; fh–^–…uunkw_ar^jh`~I• \^`q1mv\…` x flumn~vfh–^itmnfpoCq1osš”fhqAmv`M~v`LumflukR¥kwfhjhks–^jh`'i…r

mno1k!{oCq…um(kwqAmfhu«mv\…`Ÿ~(kwq x os_ •'ksjp£ ¤ `mv~nosr”osjhfhu g´Ÿksuzmvfhq^‹Cu«kwjh‹soC~vfpmv\^_œ³4`m !

x `q…owmv`Ÿmv\…`Ÿ• \^oCjp`

rUkw~(kw_a`mn`~¥s`L{$mvoC~ km f©mn`~(kmnfpoCq$µtmn\^`qmn\^`5q^`|gm„¥kwjhi^`flu r^~nosr”oCuv` x kCu

! !

.

‚

• \…`~n`

flu°i…uvi…ksjpjhy1{(\…oCuv`q™ksuk_i^jpmvfh¥kw~nfhkwmv` q^oC~v_™kwj…os~'¦'ksi…{(\gy

x

`Mq…uzfpmysµgkwq x

fluI{Mkwjhfp–^~(kmn`

x

mvo

kC{(\^fh`¥s`Ÿk‹sfh¥s`Mq2ks{M{`Mrtmnksq…{`Ÿ~nkwmv`¹fhqmn\^`ks{{`rtm(kwq…{`¹r^~nos–Ukw–^fhjpfpmysœ T^oCjpjho• fhq^‹ ; `jh_™kwq4µ ; fhjh£gu'kwq x

ƒ„os–”`~vmnu 1'464 ‰ µUk™‹CoAo x ~(kwq^‹C`š›os~ mn\^`!kC{{`Mrtmnksq…{`5~(kmn`owš°~(kwq x os_+•kwjh£ ¤ `mv~nosr”osjhflu t´¹ksuzmvfhq^‹Au

ksjp‹Cos~nf©mn\^_™u'fhu

,

%D/

, % œ

Tfh‹si^~n` 7 r^jhowm(umv\^`uvks_1r…jp`™oC–tmnksfpq^` x i…uvfpq^‹mn\^`2unkw_a`uvfp_!i^jhkwmv` x±x kmnk—uvks_1r…jp`kCu5i…uv` x š›os~

Tfh‹si^~n`¹‚tœ°[\^`Ÿuzfh_afpjlkw~nf©my!–U`m•«`M`q™mn\^` …‹Ci^~n`MuIuv\^o•„umn\…kmImv\^`My1–”owmn\™~v`L{o¥C`~mv\…`Ÿunkw_a` š›`Mkwmvi^~n`Mu

osš«mn\^`r”oCuzmv`M~vfhos~ x fluzmv~nfp–^i^mvfhosq –^itmš®ksfpjImvo;kC{(\^fp`M¥s`™uvyA_a_a`mn~vy3owš'mv\^`2_aks~v‹CfpqUkwjluœ ¸ j©mn\^osi…‹s\ •«`

x `jhfp–”`~(kmn`jhy {(\^oAuz`˜jho• ks{M{`r^mnkwqU{`˜~(kmv`Lu™š›oC~mv\…` ¤ `mv~nosr”osjhfhu g´Ÿksuzmvfhq^‹Cu™ksjp‹Cos~nf©mn\^_µ«mn\^`;Uq…kwj

kC{{`rtm(kwq…{`~nkwmv`–”`fhq^‹jpo•'`~ mn\…kwq

,

%K/ µ”fpq;oC~ x `~„mnokwmzmv`M_artm¹mno2_ao¥s`5š›i…~zmn\^`~ŸfpqAmvo2mv\^`mnksfpjlu¹osš

mn\^`um(kmvfhosqUkw~ny x fluzmv~nfp–^i^mvfhosq4µgmn\^`Ÿosmv\^`M~«_ao x `Lu'ks~v` umnfpjhj”mvogo!š®kw~kR•'kRy!š›os~'mv\…`Ÿr^~nosr”oCunkwj…mvo1~v`Lks{(\4œ

Tfh‹si^~n` 7 "5ƒ `r…~v`Luz`MqCm(kmnfpoCq—fhq3mn\^`

r^jhksq^`aowš«mv\^` ¤ ks~v£Co¥˜{(\…kwfhq ¤ oCqAmv`2¦'kw~njpounkw_ar^jh`akCuž

uvot{flkmn` x • f©mn\;k™uvks_ar^jp`5osš

/:

,:,6,

uzfh_i…jhkwmv` x r”osfhqAmnu š›~nos_ k

{oC_1r”osq…`qAm„`|tr”osq^`MqCmnfhksj4_af©|gmni^~v`

ksq x k!~(kwq x os_,•kwjh£ ¤ `mv~nosr”osjhfhu g´Ÿksuzmvfhq^‹Cu'kwjh‹soC~vfpmv\…_œ

• •

p

lambda

0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0

02468

0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0

01234 02468

0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5

Random walk sampling

(10000 iterations)

¸

~n`rUkw~(kw_a`mn`~nfhunkmnfpoCqowšmv\^`5`|gr”osq…`qAmvflkwj7r…ks~nks_a`mv`M~nukCu I

( /

( )I'

(

1

•ksui…uv` x uvo

mn\…kmŸmv\^`1~(kwq x oC_6•kwjh£

‚

•'osi^jx q^owm–”`\^fhq x `M~v` x –gy{osq…uzmv~(kwfhqAmnu¹osq˜mn\^`!uvi^r^r”os~vmMœ´„o•'`¥C`~Lµ

mn\^`'‹s`oC_a`mv~nyowš^mn\^`rUoAumn`~nfpoC~ x fhuzmv~nfp–…itmvfhosq!~v`M_aksfpqUu4mnoAo x fp¶”`M~v`MqAmš›~nos_ kŸi^q^fh_ao x kwj x flumn~vfh–^itmnfpoCq

mno!ksjpjho• uzit¨{fp`MqCmks{M{`r^mnkwqU{`¹osš4• fx `¹_ao¥s`Luœ¬q2osmv\^`M~I•'os~ x uµgkwq2fhuvowmnosq^fl{ ~(kwq x oC_ •'ksjp£Zµs`M¥s`Mq

• fpmv\k5jhks~v‹C`„¥kwjhi^`„osš

µC\…kCumnogouz_™ksjpjZk{(\…ksq…{`„osš4`q…{osi^qAmn`~nfpq^‹5oCq^`¹osšZmv\^` ~v`M_™kwfhq^fpq…‹ ¡Z¢ /3

_ao x `Luœ[\^`'unkw_a`{oC_1_a`MqCm°kwr…r^jpfh`Mufhqmn\^`«q…os~n_aksjA{Mksuv`sµwkCuuv\^o• qfhq Tfh‹si^~n`«‰Ÿ• \^`M~v`«q^oŸ_afp|tfpq^‹

ot{M{i^~(u'–U`m•«`M`qmv\^`mn\^~n``5{oC_1r”osq…`qAmnuMœ

Tfh‹si^~n`„‰ "ƒ `r…~v`Luz`MqCm(kmnfpoCq!osš”mn\^` ¤ ks~v£Co¥{(\…kwfhq ¤ osqAmn`Ÿ¦'kw~njpo5unkw_ar^jh`„ksunuzot{flkmn` x • f©mn\k5uvks_ar^jp`

osš

,6,

uzfh_i^jlkmn` x rUoCfpqAm(uš›~voC_ k

{os_arUoCq^`qAm°q^oC~v_™kwjg_afp|Amni^~n`ksq x kŸ~(kwq x os_†•kwjh£ ¤ `mn~voCrUoCjpflu

´Ÿksuzmvfhq^‹Cu ksjp‹Cos~nf©mn\^_œ

Weight Variance

Mean

q…` x f©¨{i^j©my• fpmv\mv\…`~nksq x oC_+•kwjh£r^~nosr”oCunkwjlufhu„mv\…kwm„mv\^`Myks~v`*mvogo™~(kwq x oC_ ,„mno–”`kw–^jh`mvo

\…f©m5mn\^`™owmn\^`~5_ao

x

`Mu• f©mn\ uvit¨{fh`qAm~n`‹Ci^jhks~vfpmysœ

¸

_aos~n`™k

x

ksrtmvfh¥s`™kwjpmv`M~vqUkmvfh¥s`1flumv\^`{jhkCuvuosš

³kwq^‹C`¥gfhq

x

fp¶”i…uvfhosq

¤

`mv~nosr”osjhflu t´¹ksuzmvfhq^‹AuFkwjh‹soC~vfpmv\…_auFr^~nosr”oCuv`

x

–gyƒ oC–U`M~zm(uksq

x

[•'``

x

fp`

'4:4:7:

• \…fh{(\kw~n`–…ksuv`

x

osqk1~nksq

x

os_+•'ksjp£

x

~vfpšãm„r^~nosr”oCunkwj

.

&

`

.

ˆ