HAL Id: inria-00072270
https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00072270
Submitted on 23 May 2006
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub-
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
Optimal Risk Control under Excess of Loss Reinsurance
Mohamed Mnif, Agnès Sulem
To cite this version:
Mohamed Mnif, Agnès Sulem. Optimal Risk Control under Excess of Loss Reinsurance. [Research Report] RR-4317, INRIA. 2001. �inria-00072270�
ISRN INRIA/RR--4317--FR+ENG
a p p o r t
d e r e c h e r c h e
THÈME 4
INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE
Optimal risk control under excess of loss reinsurance
Mohamed Mnif and Agnès Sulem
N° 4317
November, 14 2001
+',.-0/2143657+98:<;>=?/285'@AB8$C6DEFGH361I
J)KMLNPOQSR TVUWNYXMZ\[^]_UW`baPO]c`bde]_UWNfUWg_[^]hUi`ba
j Oglk6gl]_LNfOgcm`bNfdMZWOonVOg
prq_`tslOu]wv*xrJ#y{z|
}c[~dMd`bq] j Oq_OmKeOq_mKeOa2Q eR `bONSOqQP~~eR ~d[~bOg
?u~ Ogl]hX j k]hKeO?`bde]_UWNP[~Z"qlOUiaMg_XMq_[~aMmOd.`bZiUWmuk `^¡{[^a¢UWaMglXMqh[~aemOm`~NPd[^a£k¥¤#KMUimK~UibOg
d[~q]#`~¡$Ui]hg)deq_ONfUWXeN(g]hq_O[~N¦]_`P[^aM`~]hKeOq)m`~NPd[^ba k?UWaOonVmK[~aMbO&`~¡[~a`bMZiUW [t]hUW`~aP]h`glXMdMd`bql])]_KMO
j Ui§.OqlOaMmOO]¨¤"OOa]hKeO[^NP`bXea£]#`^¡]hKeO&mZ\[~UiN¦[^a j gl`bNfO&qlO]_Oa ]hUi`ba©ZiO~OZ«ª¬J)KMUig#m`ba ]hq_[~m]UWg)£aM`¤#a
[~gSOonemOglgf`^¡#ZW`bglgSq_OUWaMglXMqh[~aemO~ª®J)KMO¯`b6slOmu]hU°bO`~¡)]_KMO?UWaeg_XMq_[~aMmO¯m`bNfd[~ba k UWg&]h`±NP[tnVUWNfUW²O]_KMO
OunVdOm]_O
j
Xe]_UWZWU°]¨k`~¡U°]hgqlOglOql~O[^]gl`bNfO{dMZW[~aMaMUiaMYKM`~q_UW²`ba?[^a
j
XMa
j
Oq)[YaM`~aMaMOb[^]hU°VU°]¨kfm`baMg]hq_[~UWa ]ª
O¬glXMdMd`bg_O¬]hK[t]q_OUiaMg_Xeqh[~aMmO"UiaMmXeq_g[#m`bg]deq_`bd`bql]_UW`baM[~Z^]_`#]_KMO¬g_Ui²O¬`~¡Vq_UWgl{qlXMa k>]_KMO¬q_OUiaMg_Xeqh[~aMmO
m`bNfd[~~a£k~ª OS³qlgl]>deq_`bOOunVUigl]hOaMmO[^a j XMaMUi´6XeOaMOg_gq_Og_XMZ°]hgw¡<`bqc]hKMUigw`bde]_UWNfUW²[t]hUW`~a©dMql`bMZiONµ£k
XMg_UiaMgl]_`VmKM[~gl]_UWmwm`ba ]hq_`~Z¶NPOu]hKM` j gªr|¨a[Sg_Om`ba j d[~q]e¤"O>g_`~ZibO]hKMO[~glg_`6mUW[^]hO j· OZiZWNP[~a¯O´6XM[^]hUi`ba
a£XMNPOq_Uim[~ZiZikP£k?XMg_UiaMf[~a[^ZWb`bqlUi]_KMN[~g_O j `~a©d`bZWUimkPUi]_Oqh[t]hUW`~aMgª
¸©¹ ºB»l¼S½ t¾^ T6]h`6mK[~g]hUWm&m`~a£]_q_`bZ¿2gl][t]hOYm`baMg]hqh[^UWa ] j k6a[~NfUWm&dMql`bbqh[^NPNfUWaMdeq_UWaemUWdeZWO~M6Uig_m`~g_Ui]¨k
g_`bZiXe]hUi`ba¶ey`¤[^q j [~ZWb`~q_Ui]_KMN*VUiaMg_XMq_[~aMmO~q_OUWaMglXMqh[^aMmO^q_UWgl?m`~a£]_q_`bZ¿ª
ÀÁ<Â$ÃÁ<ÄÅ\ÃÆÇlÈÉtÊËtÇÆuÉ̿ͱÊÎÍ®Ï6ÐuÑ^ÆÌ«ÐoÍ¿ÆuÒÓÌ«Ê ÔÊ¢Õ2Ì«ÆuÑ^ÐoÑÒÓÖ×Ò×Í¿Ø_ÙÊÎÍ¥Ú>ÆÔÛlÖ×Ê_Ù±ÄÖÓØlÐÍ«ÆuÒÓÌ¿Ê_ÙÜÝBÂ$Ã$Þ Ü&ß$ÚÃáàoâuãuãtÜ
ßäeà Ú&ÐÍ¿åtØæ)ÐÍ«ÒÓÈÉÊ_ÙÜÝBÐuÙ¿Ê®àoçèhéÜ&ß$ËÒ×êÊÌëÙHÒ×ͿرÕÐuÌ¿ÒìÙ*àÜSéíÕ2ÖÓÐÇÎÊ®îÉtÙ«ÙHÒÓÊÉ9àoâéuâèÕÐoÌ«ÒÓÙÝ.ÊlÔÊïðçâÜ&ÊÎÅ\æ)ÐoÒÓÖiñ
æËÒ×òWóôÐuÉtÙ¿ÙlõæÐoÍ¿å£õö<ÉtÙ«ÙHÒÓÊÉ6õò÷Ì
ø
Á<Â$ÃÁ<ÄÅ\ÃÆÇlÈÉtÊËtÇÆuÉÌ¿ÍlÜÊlæÐuÒ×ÖWñ2ÐoôËÊlÙlõÙHÉÖÓÊæcóÒÓËÌ«ÒÓÐtõò÷Ì
a]_X j UiOZ\[?d`bZWU°]hUW´£XMO&`bde]_UWNP[~ZWO j Oq[~g_glXMqh[^aMmO jXMaMOm`~NPd[^baMUWO j[^g_g_Xeqh[~aMmOP´£XMU
q_O~Oqlg_O XMaeO d[~q]hUWO j Og¯dMqlUWNfOgf´6X OZWZWO*q_O`bU°]¥XMaMO±[^Xe]hqlO©m`bNPdM[~baMUiO©OamK[^aMbO jXMa OaM [
bONfOa ]
j
OmOZiZWO ëmU! d[kbOqfZW[
j
U°§"q_OaemO?Oa£]_q_OZ\[*][~UiZWZWO
j
OmKM[~´£XMOg_UWaeUWgl]_q_OP´6XeUg_XMq6UWOa ]Ou]XMa
mOq][~Uia?aMU°bO[^X j Owqu]hOa£]_UW`ba j `baMa#^ª%$O>m`ba ]hq_[^])Og])m`~aMa£X*gl`bXMgZiO{aM`~N j O{q[^g_g_Xeqh[~aMmO jOunVmLg j O
d.Oql]hOgª'& `b6slOm]hU°¡ j O>Z\[&m`bNfd[~~aMUWO j[^g_g_Xeqh[~aMmO>Og] j OwNP[tnVUWNfUWg_Oq"Z Og_d(q_[~aMmO j O>Z Xe]hUiZWU°]) j O>gl`ba
m[~dMU°][~Z]hOq_NfUWa[^Zg_`~XMg>XMaMOm`ba ]hqh[^UWa ]hO j Od`bglUi]hU°6Ui]) j X®m[^dMUi]h[~Z*¯]_`bXe]>UiaMgl]h[~a ]ª a±g_XedMd.`~g_O´£XMO
Z\[¯q+[~glg_XMq_[~aMmOOaMbOa j q_OXMa®m`-,e]>dMql`bd.`~ql]hUi`baMOZ*?Z\[f][~UiZWZWO j X®q_Uig_´£XMOOaMm`bXeq_X®d[~qwZW[?m`bNfd[~~aMUWO
j
O{q+[~glg_XMq_[~aMmO^ª
a¯deq_`bXe~OwZ
OunVUigl]hOaMmOO]"Z
XMaMUimUi]
j
O{ZW[&gl`bZWXe]_UW`ba
j
OmO{deq_`bMZiLNfO j
`~de]hUiNPUigh[^]_UW`ba
Oa?Xe]_UWZiUWgh[^a£]
j
OgN.]_KM`
j
Og
j
O{m`ba ]hq/~ZWOcgl]h`6mK[~g]hUi´6XeO~ª10w[~aMg"XMaMO{glOm`ba
j
OwdM[~ql]_UWO~£`baPqg_`bX
j
a6XeN23
q_UW´£XMONPOa ]Z ´£X[^]_UW`ba j O · OZWZiN¯[~a®[^g_g_`6mU4O5mOdMql`bMZiLNfOOa¥Xe]hUiZWUWg_[~a ]wXMa [~Zib`bq_U°]hKMNfOYM[~gg_Xeq
Z [~ZWb`~q_Ui]_KMNfO jy`¤[~q j ª
6 ½ » 87 ð $`ba ]hq/~ZWOgl]_`VmK[^gl]hUi´£XMO~!$`ba ]hq_[~UWa ]_O j"u][^] deq_UWaemUWdO j OdMql`bbqh[^NPNP[^]hUi`ba j k6a[9
NPUi´6XeO~~gl`bZWXV]hUW`~a j O6UWglm`bglUi])^ [~Zib`bq_U°]hKMNfO j O#y`¤[~q j b[~g_glXMqh[~aemO~£q+[~glg_XMq_[~aMmO^ m`ba ]_q/bZiO j O#q_Uig_´£XMO~ª
. /
f"
J)KMUWgd[~dOq$m`baemOqlaMg0]hKeO"]hKeO`bqlO]hUim[~Z6[~a j a£XMNfOq_Uim[~Z6gl]_X j k&`~¡`~de]hUiN¯[~Z qlUWgl&m`ba ]hql`bZ£`~¡[~aYUiaMg_Xeqh[~aMmO
m`bNfd[~a k~ª0J)KMO{qlOglOql~O>dMq_`6mOg_g"`~¡¶]hKeOUiaMg_XMq_[~aMmO{m`~NPd[^ba km`baMglUWg]hg `~¡[deq_ONfUWXeN gl]_q_O[^N¤#KeUWmK
m`bNfNfUi]hg"]hKMOm`~NPd[^ba k¯]h`d[k]_KMO&[~NP`~XMa ])`~¡]_KMOmZW[~UWNfg[^])]_KMOUiq#[~q_qlUi^[~Z¿ª
J` q_O
j
XMmO©]hKMO*q_Uig_2]hKeOUWaeg_XMq_[~aMmO©m`bNfd[~~a£k4~UibOgPdM[~ql]P`~¡w]_KMO©deq_ONfUWXeN gl]hqlO[~N ]_`í[~ae`~]hKMOq
m`bNfd[~~a£k~eUia?OunVmK[~aebO>`~¡[~a?`beZWUWb[^]hUi`baf]_`Sg_XedMd.`~ql]]_KMO
j
U°§BOq_OaemOwO]¨¤"OOa*]_KMO>[~Nf`bXMa ]`^¡O[~mK
mZW[~UWN [~a j g_`bNfO³enVO j ZiO~OZ#m[~ZiZWO j qlO]_Oa ]hUi`baðZiO~OZ«ª4J)KMUigPm`ba ]hq_[~m]fUWg£aM`¤#a [^gPOonemOglg¯`~¡{ZW`bglg
q_OUWaMglXMqh[~aemO~ª OPg_XMded.`bglO?]hK[t]YqlOUWaeg_XMq_[~aMmO¯UWaMmXMq_gY[m`bg]SdMql`bd`bql]_UW`ba[^Z0]h`©]_KMO?glUW²OP`~¡]_KMO?q_Uig_
][~^Oa©£k¯]hKMOq_OUWaMglXMqh[^aMmOm`~NPd[^ba kbª
J)KMOY`~6slOmu]hUi~OY`~¡]hKMOUWaMglXMqh[~aemO&m`bNfd[~ba kUigc]_`¯NP[tnVUWNfUW²Ow]_KMO&OunVd.Om]_O j Xe]_UWZWU°]¨k`~¡]hKMO&]hOqlNPUia[~Z
¤O[~Zi]_K `bOq>[~ZWZ$[ j NPUig_g_UiMZWOg]hqh[t]hO~UWOgc¤#KMUWmK±g_[^]hUigl³Og>[¯aM`~aMaMOb[^]hU°bO¤"O[^Zi]hKm`baMg]hq_[~UWa ]w`~Oq{]_KMO
¤#KM`bZiOUWa ]hOql^[~Z102,3465¿[~a
j
]_`
j
O]hOq_NfUWaMO]hKMO`bdV]hUWNP[~Z$d.`~ZWUWmuk`^¡"qlOUiaMg_XMq_[~aMmO~ªSJ)KMUig>dMq_`~MZWON ¤[~g
¡<`bq_NYXMZ\[^]_O j £kYx{glNSXMg_glOa¶6y17tsl [b[~q j [~a j J[~£g_[~q18«~~b:9¶¤#KM`>m`baeg_Uj Oq_O j ]hKMOUig_glXMO`~¡2`bdV]hUWNP[~Z£q_Uig_
m`ba ]_q_`bZ [~a jíj Ui6Uj Oa j¥j UWg]hqlUWMXe]_UW`ba®d`bZWUimUiOgªPJ)KMOk Nf` j OZWZiO j ]hKMO¤"O[~Z°]hKídeq_`6mOglg[~g[ j U°§BXeg_UW`~a
dMq_`6mOg_g>[^a j qlOd[~q_[~NfO]hqlUW²O j ]_KMOYdeq_`bMZiON k*m`baeg_Uj Oq_UiaMP]_KMO j q_Ui¡ ]#]_Oq_N `~¡]hKMO j Ui§.XMg_Ui`ba©[~g]_KMO
[~glUWm>m`~a£]_q_`bZdM[~qh[~NfO]_Oqe¤#KMUWmK*ZWO[ j g)]h`f[gl]h[~a j [^q j gl]h`6mK[~g]hUim&m`ba ]hql`bZdMq_`~MZWON©ª
|¨a¢]hKMUigSd[~dOq ¤"ONP`
j
OZ"]hKeO*qlUWgl dMql`VmOglgf`^¡c]_KMOUWaMglXMqh[^aMmOm`bNPdM[~ba kí k¢Xeg_UWae [ m`bNfd.`bXea
j
p`bUig_gl`badMql`VmOglgª#|¨a±v©aeUi¡¬[~a
j
prK[~N;8¿~be<9o2gl]h`6mK[~g]hUim`bdV]hUWNfUW²[^]hUi`ba?dMql`bMZiON UWg#g]hX
j
UiO
j
¤#KMOa
]hKMO>g][^]_O>dMq_`6mOg_g#OZW`~aMbg]h`[m`ba bOun¡H[^NPUiZik`~¡$g_ONPUiN¯[^ql]hUiaM [~ZiOgª$=nVUWg]hOaemO&[~a j XMaMUi´£XMOaMOg_gc`~¡
]hKMOgl`bZWXe]_UW`ba¯`~¡]_KMO>`bde]_UWNfUW²[^]hUi`baPdeq_`bMZiON(UWg)dMql`~O j km`ba ~Oql]_UWaM]hKeO j k6a[~NfUWm>dMql`bMZWON(Uia ]h`f[
gl]h[^]hUim&deq_`bMZiON*ªJ)KMO&mK[~q_[~m]_OqlUW²[t]hUW`~a©`~¡]hKMO&g_`~ZWXe]_UW`baUWg#`bV][~UiaMO j k©Xeg_UWae¯[ j X[~Z¶¡<`bqlNSXMZW[^]hUi`ba¶ª
|¨a©]_KMOdeq_OglOa ]wdM[~d.Oq]hKeOm`ba bOunVU°]¨k©deq_`bdOq]¨k`~¡]_KMOqlUWgldMq_`6mOg_g j `VOgae`~]{Ke`bZj Om[^XMg_O`~¡]_KMO
OunVmOg_gw`^¡Zi`bg_g#m`~a£]_qh[~mu]2UWa*m`~a£]_qh[~g]¤#U°]hK]hKeOdMql`bd`bql]_UW`ba[^ZBq_OUWaMglXMqh[^aMmO&m[~glO>8<g_OOYJ$`bXM²U?8¿~bb:9-9uª
0{XMO&]h`]hKMOYv[~ql~`6U\[~a©m`ba ]hOon6]2]hKMOq_OUiaMg_Xeqh[~aMmOdeq_`bMZiON NP[k.O&gl]_X j UiO j k*[ j UWqlOm] j k6a[^NPUim
dMq_`~bqh[~NfNfUWaMYy{[~NfUWZ°]h`baA@b[^m`bMU · OZWZiN¯[^a?O´£X[^]_UW`baB8Hy)@ · UWag_KM`~ql]C9oª
z`bq¯m`ba ]hq_`~Z{dMql`bMZWONPg¯[~a j [~glg_`6mUW[^]hO j y)@ · O´6XM[^]hUi`baMg)]_KMO±aM`~]_UW`bað`~¡>6UWg_m`bg_U°]¨k gl`bZWXV]hUW`~a¶³q_g]
UWa ]hql` j XMmO j k $q_[~a j [^ZWZ [~a j &Ui`baMg&UWa EDbbe$UWg&£aM`¤#a]h`O?[*d.`¤"Oq¡<XMZ"]_`V`bZ¿ªyOq_O~`¤#UiaM©]_`
]hKMOg][^]_Om`baMgl]_qh[~Uia ]M¤"O&aeOO j ]h`fm`baeg_Uj Oq#m`ba ]_qh[~UiaMO j 6UWg_m`bg_U°]¨kg_`~ZWXe]_UW`baMgªrJ)KMUWg#aM`^]hUW`~a¤[~g#³q_g]
UWa ]hql` j XMmO j k*TV`~aMOqF8EDbHGb[:9oª
J)KMOdeXMq_d`bg_O*`~¡]hKMUigfdM[~d.OqPUig]h`ídeq_`bO[~aðOonVUWgl]_OaMmO [~a
j
XMaMUi´£XMOaMOg_g?qlOglXMZi]¡<`bq]hKeO
j
k6a[^NPUim
dMq_`~bqh[~NfNfUWaMO´6XM[^]hUi`ba[~glg_`6mUW[^]hO j ]h`*]hKMUigdeq_`bMZiON [~a j ]hKMOa ]_`g_`~ZibOPUi]& kíXeg_UWae [~a OJIfmUiOa ]
a£XMNPOq_Uim[~Z¶NfO]_KM` j e]hKeO&m`ba bOq_bOaMmO`~¡¤#KeUWmK*UWg)Oaeg_XMqlO j k]_KMOXMaMUW´£XMOaMOglgqlOglXMZi]ª
J)KMOSd[^d.OqwUWg`bq_ [^aMUWglO j [^g{¡<`bZWZi`¤#gªcJ)KMOdMq_`~MZWONµUig¡<`bqlNSXMZW[^]hO j Uia®TVOmu]hUi`ba®Vªw|¨a±TVOmu]hUW`~a®e¤"O
gl]_X j k]_KMOdMql`bd.Oql]_UWOg{`~¡¬]hKMOY^[~ZiXMOY¡<XMaem]hUi`ba¶ª>|¨a TVOm]hUi`ba±QMB¤"OdMql`~OS]hK[t]w]hKMOS^[~ZiXMO¡<XeaMm]_UW`ba±Uig
[©m`baMgl]_qh[~UiaMO j VUig_m`bg_U°]¨k gl`bZWXV]hUW`~a `~¡]hKMO¯[~g_gl`VmU\[^]_O j yK@ · O´£X[^]_UW`baBª*|¨a¢TVOmu]hUW`~aML*¤"O¯dMql`bO¯]_KMO
XMaMUi´6XeOaMOg_g{`^¡]hKeO&gl`bZWXV]hUW`~a*`^¡]hKeOyK@ · ª.TVOmu]hUi`baNGUWg j Ob`^]hO j ]h`fa6XeNPOq_UWm[~Z[~a[^Zik6g_Uig)`~¡]_KMO&y)@ ·
O´£X[^]_UW`baOSJ)KMO?yK@ · O´6XM[^]hUi`baíUig j Uig_mq_O]_UW²O j k¥XMg_UiaM©³MaMUi]_O j U°§BOq_OaMmOfg_mKMONPOg[~a j g_`bZ°bO j £k
Q
XMg_UiaM[~a±[^ZWb`bqlUi]_N [~glO
j
`ba]_KMOÎy`¤[^q
j
[~Zib`bqlUi]hKeNC8d.`bZiUWmukUi]hOqh[^]_UW`ba9uªcXMNfOqlUWm[~ZqlOglXMZi]_gw[~qlO
dMq_Og_Oa ]_O j ª J)KMOkdeq_`6Uj O>]hKeO&`~de]hUiN¯[~Z.d.`~ZWUWmuk¯`^¡qlOUWaeg_XMq_[~aMmO^ª
u % *u#
&Ou])3 3$O#[>m`bNfdMZWOu]hOdeq_`b[^MUWZiUi]¨k&g_d[^mO~ª O)m`~aMg_Uj Oq¬[~aUia£]_ObOq0^[~ZWXMO j qh[~a j `bN NfO[^g_XMqlO
! #"C3 %$#o j O³MaMO j `ba&)3 3uB[~g_gl`VmU\[^]_O j ]h`?]_KMON¯[^q_~O j d.`bUia ]>dMq_`6mOg_g'( 3*),+'!-.C3-0/21(435uª
yOqlO~6),(78"93";: 2<3Uig[cm`bXMa ]hUiaM#dMq_`6mOg_gm`~q_q_Og_d`ba j UiaM#]h`)]hKMO¬q_[~a j `bN ]hUiNPOrd`bUWa ]_g=)<4?>%3-@/A1(43
`~¡[~q_qlUi^[~Z£`~¡2]hKeOmZW[~UWNfg[^a
j
),+BC-.3-@/A1(D3Uig0[wglO´£XMOaemO#`~¡qh[~a
j
`bN ^[~q_UW[~MZWOg¤#U°]hKY^[~ZiXMOg0UiaY]hKeO
N¯[~ql?g_dM[~mOFEHGI1JLK ª O&][~^OMEON 0P<3RQ0)¤#U°]hKAPS 2eª#x{gcXMg_XM[~Z«
[~a j ( 3*),+TC-.C3-7/41(D35
[~q_O>Uj Oa ]hU°³O j k?]hKeO¡<`~q_NSXMZW[
C02,3" 5VUAWXYN[Z
>5\^]_a`!bRcd6egf*_ih
!+j>kC3
¡<`bq#[~ZWZ?"l/ 02,3465[^a
j
Wm/AnM¤#KMOqlOn Uig)]hKMO
·
`~q_OZ.o(ë³OZ
j
`bapE¯ª
O[^g_g_XeNPO¯]_K[^]
UWgSqlUWbK ]+ëm`ba ]_UWa£XM`bXMgY[~a j
2,3WqMN 2¡<`~qS[~ZiZWr/sn{ª O j OaM`^]hO k71tuN
)A8"932Mvw";v 4X3w]_KMOq ¨m`bNfdMZWOu]hO j ³Z°]hqh[t]hUW`~aPbOaMOq_[^]hO j kf]_KMOwq_[~a j `bNNfO[~glXMq_O
! #"C3 %$#oª O
[~g_glXMNPO]hKM[^]xLycUWg)]hqlUi6U\[^Z[~a j b
Nsª"J)KMOq_[~a j `~N NPO[~g_XMqlO
! #"C3 %$#UWgc[~glg_XMNfO j ]h`fK[bO[~a
UWa ]hOaMg_U°]¨k NfO[~glXMq_OFz<! #"C3 %$#N|{Y! %$#} 6"#¤#U°]hK~X{YC <$|Q ¤#KMUWmK¥NfO[~aMg]hK[^]>]_KMOqlOUWg>[?³aeUi]hO
a6XeNS.Oq{`~¡BslXeNPdMg
j
XMq_UiaM?[^a£k*³aMU°]hO&]hUWNfO&UWa ]hOql^[~Z«ª
· k j
O³aeUi]hUi`ba`^¡r]hKMOUWa ]hOaMg_U°]¨kz<! #"C3 %$#o.]hKeO
m`bNfd.OaMgh[t]hO j slXMNfddMq_`6mOg_g j O³MaMO j £kO
! #"C3 %$#YN
C #"C3 %$# {YC <$ #"C3
UWg{glXMmK±]hK[t])
02,39" 5UDWXC32v"Xv 4X3UWg{[@63C"9)NP[~ql]_UWaM [^ZWO>¡<`bqw[^ZWZ."q/ 02,3465[~a j W/n{ª
Og_KM[~ZWZ[^g_g_XeNPO>]hKM[^])]hKMO>¡<`bZiZW`¤#UWaeSaM`ba j O~OaMOqh[~mukm`ba j Ui]hUi`baKM`bZj g O
{ vI
{YC %$#;sQ 3 8«6ªi<9
¡<`bq)g_`bNfOq{ S 2e2[~a j
$k{Y! %$#lsQ 8«6ªìH9
L '77 ¹AVC
<:** ,
{
) ; (
E
,
{YC %$#YNI?!$# %$
=
+k # C ,!' N : K* ¢¡V 8 + $,£¤
#,¤ F ) 8 #
x qlO]_Oa ]hUi`ba ZiO~OZrdMql`VmOg_g&UWg&[~a¥C
e Î[ j [^de]hO j dMql`VmOglg¦§N¨¦
e
32Av©"v 4£>Uia ]hOqldMq_Ou]hO j [~g>]hKeO
q_UWgl¯ZiObOZ¶¤#KMUWmK*UWg)glXMdMd`bql]_O j £k¯]hKMOUWaeg_XMq_[~aMmOm`bNPdM[~ba kbª
L
U°bOa[©qlO]_Oa ]hUi`baZWOubOZ;¦ ¤"O
j
OaM`~]hOP k.¦
e
>]_KMO
j
U°§BOq_OaMmOP.Ou]¨¤OOa¢]hKMOfdMqlONfUWXMNáq_[^]hOfd.Oq
XMaMU°]Y`~¡)]_UWNfOq_OmOU°bO j k¥]hKMOPm`bNfd[~~a£k [~a j ]hKMOPdMq_ONPUiXMNáqh[t]hO¯dOqXMaMU°]Y`~¡)]_UWNfOd[~Uj k ]_KMO
m`bNfd[~~a£k¯]h`]hKMOqlOUWaeg_XMqlOqª
J)KMO{qlUWgldMq_`6mOg_g`~¡.]hKMOUWaMglXMqh[^aMmOm`bNfd[~a kXMa j Oq"]_KMUWg OunVmOg_g`~¡ZW`~g_g m`ba ]hq_[~m]UWgr]hKeOa?bU°bOa¯ k O
e N e
!¦5} ' e
$s¦
! 3 %$#C3 "vv 463
¡<`bq#[~aUWaeUi]hUW[~Zq_OglOqbO [^])]hUiNPO£"oª
Mg_OqlbO]hKM[^]#]hKMOgl]h[^]hOdMql`VmOglgcm[~a©[~ZWgl`fOOunVdMqlOg_glO j [^g O
e N e
¦5 '
Z
]
s¦ 3
¤#KMOqlOF( Uig{[Pp`bUig_g_`~a dMq_`6mOg_gc¤#Ui]hK©UWa ]hOaMg_U°]¨kN ~ {YC <$u.[~a
j
[~q_O&UǻUǻ
j
q_[~a
j
`~N ^[~qlU\[~eZWOg
UWa j OdOa j [^a£]c`~¡( K[6UWaM³aeUi]hOw³Mq_gl]cNf`bNfOa ]! .ª
"
z2ql`bN¦ae`¤7`ba¶M¤"Om`baMglUj Oq[dMqlONfUWXMN(qh[^]_O>`~¡]_KMO&gh[~NfOw¡<`bq_N [~g#UWax{glNSXMg_glOa¶y17tsl [b[~q j [~a j
J[^6g_[~qF8«~~b:9O
¦ N#$ M _
&% ¦=9' ( M *)0+
p¦ 5C3 8¿VªÓH9
¤#KMOqlO,% ¦=Uig#[dMq_`bd`bq]hUW`~a[~Z.¡H[^m]h`~q)gh[^]_UWgl¡k6UiaM-% 2# N 2f[^a j %¦ N#% S 2U°¡¦2S 2eª
J)KMOP³Mq_gl]&]hOq_N `^¡]hKMOqª×K¶ªgY`^¡6=r´£X[^]hUi`ba 8«Vª×:9wUWg>]hKeOPOonedOmu][^]_UW`ba `~¡]_KMOP[~NP`~XMa ]`~¡]hKeOPmZ\[~UiNPg
j XMqlUWaM[XMaeUi]"`~¡¶]hUiNPO^ªJ)KMOg_Om`ba j ]hOqlN`~¡B]_KMO{qª×K¶ªg`^¡ =r´£X[^]hUi`ba 8¿Vª×:9¬Uig ]_KMOcdMq_ONPUiXMN©b¤#KeUWmK?Uig
bUi~Oa]h`f[~aM`^]hKMOqcm`bNfd[~ba k?`^¡0UWaeg_XMq_[~aMmO>]_`fglXMdMd`bql]#]_KMO
j
Ui§.OqlOaMmO&O]¨¤"OOa]hKeO[^NP`bXea£]#`^¡]_KMO
mZW[~UWNfg)[~a j ]_KMOq_O]_Oa ]hUi`ba*ZWO~OZ¦ j Xeq_UWaeP[XMaeUi]#`~¡$]hUiNPO^ª
OUiNPd`bg_O]hKMO>¡<`bZiZW`¤#UWaMYm`baMg]hq_[~UWa ]#`ba]hKMO>¡H[~NfUWZ°kf`~¡g][^]_OdMq_`6mOg_g.MO
e : 2,3 ¡<`bq#[~ZWZ "lv/v 4 8¿Vª×Q:9
U°bOa10 S 2ee¤"O&UWNfd.`bglO
¦ v20 ¡<`bq#[~ZWZ "lv/v 4 8¿VªL9
x{a[ j NfUWglg_UiMZWOPd.`bZiUWmuk¦ Uig[~a[ j [~dV]hO j g]h`6mK[~gl]_UWmdMql`VmOg_gp!¦ ed d6b
q_UibK ]m`~a£]_UWa£XM`bXeg g_XMmK
]hK[t] $`ba j U°]hUW`~aMg8«VªQ 9w[~a j 8¿VªL9w[~q_Og_[^]hUigl³O j ª O j OaM`~]hOf k43 C"C35 w]_KMOg_Ou]`^¡[~ZiZr[ j NfUWglg_UiMZWO
d.`~ZWUWmUWOgª
?¹ íM76 V! ¡V K* 3 8"C38 6 KCa 2F/93 8"C38 'EF ";/ 02,3465 @/A1JqK
&O]: j OaM`~]hO&[Xe]_UWZWU°]¨kP¡<XeaMm]_UW`bag_XemK©]hKM[^]
Uig)XMaMUi¡<`~q_NfZikfm`ba ]_UWa£XM`bXMgaM`ba j Omq_O[~g_UiaM¯[^a j m`baMm[~O¢ 8¿VªGH9
G
J)KMO`~6slOmu]hUi~OY`~¡]hKMO&UWaeg_XMq_[~aMmO&m[^NPd[^ba kUWg)]h`PN¯[neUiNPUi²O{]_KMO&OunVd.Om]h[^]hUi`ba©`^¡]hKeOXe]_UWZiUi]¨k?`^¡]hKeO
]hOqlNPUia[~Z~[^ZWXMO>`~¡$]hKeO&qlUWgl¯dMql`VmOg_g j Ou³aMO j k
8"C38 3¦=N)¢
e
b
3
`~Oqc[~ZiZ¶d.`~ZWUWmUWOgl¦/93 C"C35 uª O j O³aMO]hKeO^[~ZiXMOw¡<XMaMmu]hUi`ba?[~g
?C"C38 YN
e
=C"C38 3¦=R 8«6ªìH9
J)KMO>]hOqlNPUia[~Z.m`ba
j
Ui]hUi`baUWg)~UibOa© k
?4635 N M R 8«6ªÓ:9
?¹ íM76 .g ( * , 8 * K * ('68 C%K>( C
) , & : C ) N R¤ ¦4N 2 2# N 2 q, k¤
8"C32# N 2 'EF "l/ 02,3465
±$# &% w & %^*
|¨a®]_KMUWg>glOmu]hUW`~a¶¤O¡<`6mXMg`ba®dMql`6UiaM]hK[^]>]_KMOS^[~ZWXeOS¡<XMaMm]_UW`ba©.OZW`baM~gw]h`
C02,3465U 1JqK.u
]hKMOg_Ou]c`~¡m`ba ]hUia6Xe`bXMg)¡<XMaMmu]hUW`~aMg#UWa 02,3465UA1JLK¥[^a
j
XeaMUi¡<`bqlNPZ°kfm`ba ]hUia£XM`bXMg#UWa ª
· k?]hKeO j kVaM[~NPUim>dMq_`~bqh[~NfNfUWaMdMq_UiaMmUidMZWO^V¤"OK[~OO
?C"C38 N
e
)T ?8"¥ "!,38
e
e
K #$&%
93 8¿Vªi<9
¡<`bqY[^a£k¥g]h`bdMdeUWaM*]hUWNfO'!w/)(
eb 24v "v 4[~a j 2 H0 4s w"o$¤#KMOqlO*(
eb
UWg]hKeO¯g_Ou]S`~¡)[~ZWZ
gl]h`~dMdMUWae]_UWNfOgO]¨¤"OOa")[^a j 4&ª
&Ou]#XMgcOgl]h[~MZiUWg_Kgl`bNPO>deq_OZiUWNfUWa[^qlkfOg]hUWNP[^]_Og)`ba]hKeO&Nf`bNfOa ]hg)`^¡]hKeO>gl][t]hOdMq_`6mOg_gª
+ ¹ í-, C/.
^
%/ 02,310<5
-#H
32N4328 % 34£S 2 , 'E
"/ 02,3465
A/A1JqK 2F§ 40 "5
)76
e
e
K #
8695v)
2
;:<# 8¿VªìH9
= ½¶½?>"x)mm`~q j UiaM]h`Y]_KMOyA@
B Zj OqUWaeO´£X[~ZiUi]¨kb6Ui]g_X,IfmOg)]h`dMql`bO8¿VªìH9¬¡<`bq %'NC0Vª¬z`bq"aM`~][t]hUW`~a[~Z
g_UWNfdMZiUWmU°]¨kb£KMOq_O[t¡ ]hOqD j OaM`~]_Og#[SbOaMOqlUWm>m`baMgl]h[~a ]ª¬x{dedMZik6UWaeS|ë])/ g)ZWONPNP[&]_`
e
e
K #
V¤"O
`be][^UWa
)76
e
e
K #
-6 v) 2E
)GF e K #
e
.¦ H )IF e
K #
e
$p¦ KJ ! %$#} HDL
TVUWaemO ¦ UWg)`bXMa j O j
[^a
j
$ ¦ v$¡<`bq#[^ZWZ/ 0"C3 4 5[~a
j
¡<`bq#[~ZWZ$¢/@EP£k 8«VªÓH9"¤"OK[~OO
)76
e
e
K #
86*v) 23
¤#KMUWmK*UWNfdMZWUiOg)8¿eªÓH9uª
|¨a ]_KMO¡<`bZWZi`¤#UiaMZWONPNP[eB¤"OfdMq_`bOf]hK[t]&¤#KeOa ]_KMOfq_OglOqbO¯deq_`6mOglgYqlO[~mKMOgY[ZW`¤ ZWO~OZ [^]]hUiNPO
/ 0"C3465«V]hKMO`bde]_UWNP[~ZBm`ba ]hql`bZUWgx¦XN 2¡<`~q#[~ZWZ / 0:3 4 5¿ª
+ ¹ 8, g ¡V N -#H /[1JqK M, 'EA "T/ 02,3 4 5 [/1JqK F8 K'E, %
C'
5 '+ -#H
M/ 0"C3465 ¦2/DWM8"C38
N,
e
¦N 2
'EF
/ 0H3465
=
½¶½?>
"
zql`bN(]_KMOdMq_ONPUiXMN¦q_[^]hO>Oonedeq_Oglg_Ui`baM8¿VªÓH9ue¤"OKM[~O
!¦= N % $
_
&% 5 )A0
p¦ 5U°¡¦S 2
2 Ui¡¦DN 2
&O]. N 9
]!K
9
ª¬|¨a]hKeUWg#m[~glO O
U°¡ 2F ¦ ]hKeOa¦; 2 8HeªÓH9
0{O³MaMOV]N )7 :g_XMmK*]hK[t]¦: 3£ª T6UWaMmO]_KMOm`ba ]_q_`bZ.¦¢Uig)q_UW~K£]_m`ba ]_UWa£XM`bXMg
¦ : 8Heª×Q:9
glUWaM]hKeO&K k6d`~]hKMOg_Uig
e
& M]_KMO j O³MaMUi]_UW`ba`~¡$V])[^a j 0<#uV¤O&`be]h[~UWa
2 v
e
N
e
!¦
e
} #"
$:s¦
e
! #"C3 %$#
$:I¦
e
! #"C3 %$#C3
¤#KMUWmK*UWNfdMZiUWOg ]hK[t]
$s¦
e
C 6"C3 <$;& 3
[~a
j
m`baeg_O´£XMOa ]hZik
$:s¦x ¡<`bq#[~ZiZV$'/@ET
z`bq$*ZW[~q_~OOaM`bXebK¶¤OfK[bO O¦ ¤#KMUimK m`ba ]hq_[ j UWmu]hg|¨aMO´6XM[~ZWU°]¨k 8¿eªQ 9oª.$`baMg_O´£XMOa ]hZ°k [~ZWZ
[ j NfUWglg_UWeZWOm`~a£]_q_`bZigYNSXegl]gh[^]_UWgl¡ kOY¡<`~qY[~ZiZ : b¦D ªglUWaM 8«Vª×:9[~a j glUWaMmO!¦=N 2eU°¡
¦DN 2ee]_KMO`bde]hUiN¯[^ZBm`~a£]_q_`bZBUWgx¦N 2S¡<`bq#[~ZiZ A/ 0H3465¿ª
0{O³aeOW
C"C38 )[~gJO
W
8"C38 N ),¦/AWM8"C38 g_XMmK*]hK[^] O¬Ui¡]hKMOq_OOunVUigl]hg9/ 0"C3465g_XemK©]hKM[^]
e v 3
]hKeOa¡<`bq#[~ZWZ A/ 0H3465 3¦N 2%36
+ ¹ í-, , 3 "A, 2 T T& ¢¡V
W
8"C38 lG WMC"C3 ;G WC"C38
= ½¶½?>J)KMOglOm`ba j UWaMmZWXMglUW`ba Uigw`b 6UW`bXegwg_UiaMmO,Sª|ë]>q_ON¯[^UWaMg{]_`dMq_`~OS]hKMOS³qlgl]UiaMmZiXMg_Ui`ba¶ª
&Ou]¦/AW
8"C38 uª 0{Ou³aMO
!BN ) :w"g_XMmK*]hK[t]
e
& 3 4
|ë¡ ¢/!BB]hKMOa9
e : ¤#KMUWmK±UiNPdMZiUWOg.
e : 2eªw|ë¡ ¢:C!BB]hKeOa9 e
# [~a
j
g_`¦ N 2e
¤#KMUWmK*dMq_`~Og#]hK[^]¦/AWC"C3 uª
&Ou]#XMg[~dMdMql`nVUiN¯[^]_O{]hKeO¡<XeaMm]_UW`ba9 k*[g_O´6XeOaMmOY`~¡&UWdMglmKMUi]_²¡<XeaMm]_UW`baMgª
+ ¹ í-, =)K ,% 8 1 -#H6 K* (' *'C% , >
3-4:
2#
N^¤ "%'EC (
=
½¶½?>#T6UWaMmO UWg)XMaMU°¡<`bq_NfZikfm`ba ]hUWa£XM`~XMg#UWa M¤O&m[^a
j
Ou³aMO>]hKeO&Nf`
j
XMZWXeg)`~¡m`ba ]hUia6XeUi]¨k
%k N .) = & )glXMmK©]_K[^] 6 B 6v[~a
j 3B/1JqK36
zU°nT-D/A1(¥ª!0O³aMO >
[~g)¡<`bZWZi`¤#g O
> N
M 3 Ui¡ N -
¤#KeOq_O p/@1( 3
-=
_
-
&
-
9 B
-
- Ui¡
-
&v ,
_
-
z2`~qY[~ZiZ §/s1JqK]_KMOqlO?OunVUigl]hg /1( glXMmK]hKM[^]
> v v
K ]
> ª glUWaM©]hKMOPm`baMm[VU°]¨k[^a j ]hKeO
NP`bae`~]h`baeUWmU°]¨kf`~¡ ¤"O&KM[~O
2v = &
> lv ,
_
-
&
-
3
[~a j ]hK£XMg
"!#%$
6 = &
> 6%v
%
_
-
R
J)KMUWgUiNPdeZWUWOg"]_KMO>XMaMU°¡<`bq_Nm`~a£~OqlbOaMmO`^¡ >
]_` YV¤#KMOap-±b`6Og]h`TQ ªr|ë]q_ONP[~UiaMg]h`deq_`bO>]hKeO
&UidMg_mKeUi]h²&dMql`bd.Oql]¨k©`~¡0]_KMO¡<XMaem]hUi`ba > ª &O]! 3/ 1JqKª OYglXMdMd`bg_OY]_K[^]!7S&.ªcJ)KMOq_OYOonVUWgl]_g
% 3'/@1( g_XMmK*]hK[t] / 0 9
> 3 9 K ]
>
[~a j B/ 0(
>
3)(
K ]
>
uª
D
TVXMded.`bglO>]hK[^] %M
_ : ' _
ªrJ)KMOa¶
> = >
N > &
> %
-
9
]
Z
(K ] > _
- >
-
> ' _
-
>
N -= B
%-
%
_
-
&
%
-
9 9
]
Z
(K ]
_
-
&
-
-=M
' _
-
' _
-
&
'
-
9
v -
%
_
-
RB
9
]
Z
(K ]
_
-
&M
-
v 05-
%
_
-
RT
TVXMded.`bglO>]hK[^] %M
_ N '¨e]hKeOa
> = >
N > &
> %
-
> ' _
-
>
v -
%
_
-
RT
TVXMded.`bglO>]hK[^] %'N '¨M]hKeOa
> = >
v -
6
_
-
R ¢ C3
¤#KMUWmK*dMql`~Og#]hKMO &UWdeg_mKMU°]h²dMq_`~d.Oql]¨k`~¡ >eª
$`baMglUj Oqcae`¤ ]hKMO&[~X6neUiZWUW[~q"^[~ZiXMOw¡<XMaMmu]hUW`~a
>
8"C38 N
h e
>
8"C38 3¦=C3
¤#KMOqlO
>
C"C38 3¦= N )A0 >
e
b
(5¿ª |¨a]hKeOP¡<`bZiZW`¤#UWaM*ZWONPNP[e¤O¯gl]hX j k ]_KMO?dMql`bdOql]_UWOgY`~¡)]_KMO
¡<XMaMmu]hUW`~a > ª
+ ¹ 8,
"l/ 02,3465 A/A1JqK
8 8 $'C%
>
) % *
8
>
8"C38 YN
h e
>
C"C35 3¦= 8HeªL9
=
½¶½?>"J)KMO>NP`~aM`~]h`~aMUWmUi]¨k`~¡]hKeO{¡<XMaMmu]hUW`~a"
>
UWa-Uig"]hqlUi6U\[^Z«ª =r´£X[~ZiUi]¨kN8¿VªLH9 UWg[Sm`baMglO´£XMOaemO&`~¡
&ONPNP[+8¿eªÓH90ªJ$`{deq_`bO ]hKMO!&UWdMglmKMUi]_² deq_`bdOq]¨kPt¤O¬³en 3B/1JqKg_XMmKS]_K[^]AS .ª$J)KMOqlO"OonVUWgl]_g
[cglXM j Ui6UWglUW`ba FNI$iy $5];g^0$¥N/t¤#KeOq_O J /A1( glXMmKY]_K[^]$2w$
$
]lv / 0_ 3 J 5ǻ
>
C"C38 >
C"C3 N Z
] >
8"C3$
>
C"C3$
]
N Z
]
h e
)A0 >
e
b
(5^
h e
)A0 >
e
b
(5
N Z
]
h e
)A0 >
e
b
(5
h e
)A0 >
e
b 5
v Z
]
h e
)A0 >
e
b
(5
h e
)A0 >
e
b 5
v Z
] 0 >
65$
2$
]6
N 0 > 6 B 63
¤#KMOqlO¯]hKMOP³q_g]UWaMO´£X[~ZWU°]¨k®UWg j O j XemO j ¡<ql`bN &ONPNP[ 8Heª×:9u]hKMO¯Z\[~g]YUiaMO´£X[~ZiUi]¨k®Uig j O j XMmO j ¡<ql`bN
&ONPNP[ 8Heª×Q:9[~a j 0 >
UWg]_KMOm`~aMgl]h[~a ]`~¡!&UidMg_mKeUi]h²Y`~¡ >
ª&J)KMUWgwdeq_`bOg]_KMO5&UWdMglmKMUi]_²SdMql`bd.Oql]¨k
UWa `^¡]hKeO¡<XeaMm]_UW`ba
> ª
J)KMOq_O~XMZ\[~qlUi]¨k¯`~¡]_KMO>^[~ZWXMOw¡<XeaMm]_UW`ba"?m[~a*.O>g][^]_O j [~g)¡<`bZWZi`¤#gJO
¹6½ ¹ , C )K , % 8 'C T/
02,3 4 5VUA1JqKV
= ½¶½?>&Ou]";/ 02,3465« A/A1JqKª TVUiaMmO,
> ;v ¡<`~q#[~ZWZV-@/@1( e¤"O&K[bO
2v ?C"C38 >
C"C38 lv
h e
)M
e
b
= >
e
b
=
g_UiaMP]_KMOYXeaMUi¡<`bqlN m`ba bOq_bOaMmO`^¡ >
]h`¤[~q
j
g UWa1JqK¤O`be][^UWa©]_K[^]
>
C"C35 cm`~a£~OqlbOgw]_`
8"C38 &¤#KMOa¥-m Q ¡<`~q[~ZWZ /1JqKr¤#KMUimKdeq_`bOg]_KMOXMaMU°¡<`bq_N m`~a£~OqlbOaMmO©`^¡ >
C"C3*]_`
8"C3i#UiaA1JqK$ªwzq_`~N &ONPNP[N8HeªLH9u2¤O j O j XemOS]hKeOYXMaMU°¡<`bq_N m`ba ]hUia6XeUi]¨k*`~¡ UWaªw|ë]wqlONP[~UWaegc]_`
dMq_`bO]hKeO&m`ba ]hUia6XeUi]¨k`~¡ ¯Uia 02,3 4 5.UA1JqK$ª!&Ou] 3 ;/@1J
K
2'v "l v 4ª cg_UiaM]hKMO j k6a[~NfUWm
dMq_`b~qh[~NfNPUiaMYdeq_UWaemUWdeZWO 8Heªi*9"¤#Ui]hK BN 7"{ &ONPNP[A8¿VªLH9[^a j &ONPNP[ 8¿eª°<9 ¤"O&`be][^UWa
6 >
(H3 >
C"C38 6 v 6 > H3 >
8"C3 6 6 >
C"C3 >
C"C35 6
N 6 > H3
h e ) >
(H38
e
'6 6 >
C"C3 >
C"C38 6
v 0 >
h eK )76
e
6 :0
> 6 B 6
v 0 >
2
6 x 7"6 0 > 6 B 66
TVUWaMmO3
>
m`ba bOq_bOgXeaMUi¡<`bqlNPZ°kP]_` V¤O&m`baemZWX j O>]hK[^] PUWg)m`ba ]hUWa£XM`~XMg#UWa 02%3465U1JLKª