An introduction to Utility Maximization with Partial Observation

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00072440

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00072440

Submitted on 24 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub-

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,

An introduction to Utility Maximization with Partial Observation

David Lefèvre

To cite this version:

David Lefèvre. An introduction to Utility Maximization with Partial Observation. [Research Report]

RR-4183, INRIA. 2001. �inria-00072440�

(2)

ISRN INRIA/RR--4183--FR+ENG

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

THÈME 4

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

An introduction to utility maximization with partial observation

David LEFÈVRE

N° 4183

Mai 2001

(3)

(4)

$

%&' )(+*,-#.%% /

02143#57698;:)<=?>A@B:

CDFEGIHJLK MONPG/QFRTSVUWNPXZYIHU[XZ\]UWNPGNP^WSVU_N`XZY

a H^cb4^cUWEdGHd^[edXZG\FRPHfOHd^

gihWXkjcHUl+miC;n?op

qrSV\F\sXthcU a HhWHeuDFHdhceuDFHvYxwJFy{zZ|}K l~SVN#tZ]y[K JZJ\StZH^

{kFt HrZN`tH%StYXZHhc4NPHXtU_DFHrU_DFHXZhcbIStY a GHUWDFX a ^N`YtXZR`tH a N`Y\XZhcU

XZRPN`X%XZ\]U_N`GIN`{SVUWNPXZY\FhWXtFRPHGI^i;N`UWDI\FSthcUWNTStRFXtF^WHhcVSVU_N`XZYb/\SVhcU_NPStRFXZ]^WHdhVSVU_N`XZYOu

HGH{SVYIU_DFSVUUWDFH a hcN`¡U\FhWX4edH^W^StY a U_DFH a hWN¢4NPYF/hWX;YFNPStYGXtU_N`XZYBSV\F\sHdSthWN`YF/N`Y

U_DFH)^cUWXOeuDSV^cU_N`e

a

N¢£¤HhWHYUWNTStRH¥QSVU_N`XZY¦Xth[UWDFH/^cHdedQ]hWN`U§b+\FhcNPeHd^rSthWHYFXtU

a

NPhcHdeUWR`b2XtO

^WHdhVStFRPHXth-NPYZH^cUWXZhW^[NPYUWDFH%GBSVhW¨tHU{©CDFHDFN`^cU_XthcbXV&^cHdeQFhWN¢U§b2\FhWN`edH^[N`^St^c^WQFGH

a

U_XAeXZYF^cUWN`UWQ]U_HBUWDFH«ªk¬¯®NPY]XZhcGBSkU_NPXtY«S{VStNPRPStFR`H°UWX}NPYZH^cUWXZhW^°StY a U_DFH2N`YZHd^U_GHdYU

\FhWX4edH^W^WH^;SthWHrU_DFHY2hWHd¥QFN`hWH a U_XLH%S a SV\]U_H a U_XLUWDFH?YSkU_QFhWStRs±R¢U_hWSVU_N`XZYIXVU_DFH\]hWNPeH

\FhWX4edH^W^WH^d²p§Y³U_D]HedXZG\FR`HU_HIGBSVhW¨tHULedSt^WHV ©HXZOUuStN`Y³HfO\FR`NPedN¢UXthWGLQFRPStHXZhUWDFH

XZ\]U_N`GBSVR´H{StR¢U_Dµ\FhcXOeHd^c^N`Y¶S¦-S{bZH^WNPStYOBedXZYU_Hf4U{ ©;DFHdY¶U_DFH a hWN`¡U/ZHdeU_XZh°N`^StY

QFYFXZF^cHdhZH

a

hWStY

a

XZG·VSthcNTSt]RPH%;N`UWD~¨YFX;Y}\FhWN`XZh

a

NPÛ_hcNPFQ]UWNPXZY¤¸HfO\FRPNèdNÙ[hcHd\FhcHd^WHYO

UuSVUWNPXZYF^XZhUWDFHXt\]U_N`GBStRtNPYZH^cU_GHdYU&\FhWX4edH^W^SthWH´XZYFR¢b a HdhcN`tH a ;D]HdY/UWDFH^U_X4eu¨ a hWN¢¡U

NP^/GX a HdR`RPH a St^/S}¹)SVQF^W^cNTStY³\]hWX4edHd^c^d H2StR`^WX¦edXZYF^cNa Hh/U_D]HBe{SV^WH2XtN`YFedXtGI\FR`HUWH

GBSthc¨tHUStY a euDSthWSteUWHdhWN`dH?UWDFH?Xt\]U_N`GBStRN`YZHdÛ_GHdYU\XZRPNèdN`Hdî;DFHdY2\]hWNPeHr\]hWX4edHd^c^-Xt

hWNP^c¨bSt^W^cHUW^[XZR`RPX;^S^cUWXOeuDFSt^cUWNPe%ZXZRPSVU_N`RPN¢U§bIGX a HdR7

º¦»¼¤½c¾L¿ kÀ&t g#XZhcUcXZRPN`XµXZ\]UWNPGNP{SkU_NPXtY -±R`UWHdhcNPYFF [\SthU_NPStRXZF^cHdhtSkU_NPXtY ?Q]UWNPR`N`U§b

GBSkfON`GIN`{SVUWNPXZY a bOYFStGINè%\FhWXtZh_StGGNPYFF ]ÁRTSVhW¨xÂÃ^-XthWGLQFRPS] ]Û_X4euDStÛ_NPe%tXZRTSVUWNPR`NÙ§bZ

(5)

$

XZQF^ a XtYFYFXZYF^QFY'St\HdhQ a H¦RPS}UWDdXthWNPH2HU a Hd^GU_DFX a H^hcHdRPSVU_N¢^

StQOf'\FhWXtFRPEGIH^ a ÂXZ\]UWNPGNP^WSVU_N`XZY a H~\XZhU_HHQFNPR`RPH^HY XZF^cHdhtSkU_NPXtY \SthU_N`HdRPR`Ht g&Sth

XZF^cHdhtSkU_NPXtYA\SthU_NPHRPR`Hu xYFXtQF^%HdYU_HY a XZY]^%¥4Q]HR`H/\FhcXOeHd^c^WQF^ a H a hWN`¡U?HUR`H/GXZQ]ZH

GIHYUhcX ;Y]NPHdY/St\F\SVh_StN`^W^_SVYU a SVYF^&R7Â¥QSVU_N`XZY a N`£dhcHdYU_N`HdRPR`Hi^cUWXOeuDSV^cU_N`¥QFH\XZQFh#RPH^

\FhWNf a Hd^SteU_N`^©hcNP^W¥Q^Y]Hr^cXZYU\SV^ a N`hWHeU_HGIHYUXtF^WHhcVStFR`Hd^´\Sth´RPHd^©N`YtHd^U_NP^c^WHQFhW^

a

StYF^%R`HGBSthceuDtiÂÃDFN`^cUWXZNPhcH

a

Hd^\FhcN¢f

a

Hd^)SteU_N¢^%hWNP^c¥Qd^Hd^U^WQF\]\sXZ^dHedXZY]^cU_N¢U_QFHh

RTSONPY]XthWGISVU_N`XZY a N`^W\XZYFNP]RPH²StQOfN`YZHd^U_N`^W^WHQFhW^¦HU¦XZYHfONPZH a H^¦\FhcXOeHd^c^WQF^

a ÂÃN`YZHd^U_N`^W^WHGIHYUL¥QÂNPRP^^cXZNPHYU/S a SV\]U^ RTS2±R`UWh_SVUWNPXZY}HYFZHY a hHB\SVhR`H\]hWX4edHd^

^WQF^ a Hd^\FhcN¢fs"!StYF^R`He{St^ a H^GISthWeuD#d^edXZG\FR`HU_^ YFXZQF^)XZ]UWHdYFXtYF^ a Hd^XZhWG/QFRPH^

HfO\FRPN`edN¢U_Hd^2\XZQFhR`H \]hWX4edHd^c^WQF^ a H²hWN`euDFHd^c^WH«Xt\]U_N`GBStR`H a SVYF^¦R`H²edXZYU_Hf4U_H a ÂÃQ]Y9NPY4

ZHd^U_N`^W^WHQFhSb$d^cNPHdY¤ RPXZhc^W¥QFH+RPH a hWN¢¡UHd^cUIQFYFHVSthWNPStFR`HStRdSVU_XZN`hWH a H+RPXtN-NPYFN¢U_NPStRPH

edXZYFYQFHV¸

a

H^XZhWGLQ]RPHd^[HfO\FR`NPeN`U_H^r\XZQFhrRPH)\FhWX4edH^W^cQF^

a ÂNPYZH^cU_N`^W^cHdGHdYUXZ\]UWNPGIStRYFH

^WXZYU\Fhd^cHdYUHd^¥4Q]HRPXZhc^W¥QFHR`H

a

hcN`¡U/Hd^cU°GX

a

dR`NP^\SthQFYµ\FhcXOeHd^W^cQF^I¹)SVQF^W^cNPHdY¤

XZQF^edXZY]^WNa dhWXtYF^StQF^c^WNsRPH[e{St^ a Hd^-GISthceuDd^-N`YFedXtGI\FR`HUW^´HUe{SVh_SteUdhcNP^cXZYF^R`Hd^\sXZR`N¢

U_NP¥QFH^ a ÂNPYZH^cU_N`^W^cHdGHdYU´XZ\]U_N`GBSVRPHd^&RPXZhc^W¥QFH-R`H\FhWX4edH^W^cQF^ a H\FhWNf a Hd^´SteUWN`^ hcNP^c¥4Q#d^

^WQFN¢U;QFY¦GX a EdR`H a H%ZXZRPSVU_N`RPN¢U[^cU_X4euDSt^U_N`¥4Q]Ht

% ¿ ½ '& Xt\]U_N`GIN`^_SVUWNPXZY a H²\sXZhU_HHdQFN`RPRPH^d ;±R`UWh_SttHt [XZF^WHhcVSVUWNPXZY \SthU_N`HdRPR`Ht

\FhWXZth_StGGBSkU_NPXtY a b4YStGNP¥QFHV VGISkfONPGNP^WSVU_N`XZY a ÂQ]U_N`RPN¢Ut {XthWGLQFR`H a HÁRTSthc¨ ZXtRTSVUWNPRPN¢U

^cU_X4euDSt^U_N`¥4Q]H

(6)

& '

°& +´

CDFH-\FhcXZFRPHG XtGBSkfON`GIN`dNPY]-U_DFH-HfO\sHeU_H a QOU_NPR`N`U§bhcXZG U_HdhcGIN`YStRH{StR¢U_DLDSV^ sHHdY

RTSthcZHdR¢b°^cU_Q

a

NPH

a

NPYBUWDFHRPN¢U_Hh_SVUWQFhWHV oXZhUWDFHedSt^WH%XteXZG\FRPHU_H?GISthc¨tHUW^d 4H%hcHHdhU_X

()SVh_SVUW{St^StY a StR*)¢yZy,+ ]ÁX{fSVY a nrQFStYF-)|.+XZh*/edXZYFH?StY a ()SVh_SVUW{St^0)V|.+ oxXth©UWDFH

e{St^cHIXtNPY]edXZG\FRPHU_H°StY a21 XZhedXtYF^cUWh_StN`YFH a GBSVhW¨tHU_^ #HIhcHHhUWX(SthWSVU_dSt^)StY a StR

)¢y + #n[HISVY a g#H{Sthc^WXZY3)54.+´StY a Á4N`U_StYFN76°SVY a ()SVh_SVUW{St^)J.+7mv^WStRPN`HdYU%H{SkU_QFhcHN`Y

U_DFHSVsXZH/\St\HdhW^?NP^rUWDFHSt^c^WQFG\]UWNPXZYAXV8 uª%9 °ª#"$% ªk¬#;:rN`YtHd^U_XZhc^%DS{ZH

S)eXZGI\]RPHUWHrŸFX;R`H a ZH[XtSVRPR]UWDFH?\SVh_StGHUWHdhW^ŃPYtXZR`tH a N`YUWDFH[^cU_X4euDStÛ_Nè a N¢£¤HhWHYO

U_NTSVRHd¥QSVUWNPXZYXZh;U_DFHSt^W^cHU?\FhWN`edHd^;nrXHZHhd sNPY+\Fh_SteU_N`e{StR^WN¢U_QSkU_NPXtYF^;XZYFH)e{StYFY]XtU

XZF^WHhctH?U_DFH^WH¥QSVYUWN`UWNPHd^ a N`hWHdeU_R¢b<:U_DFHr¥QS a hWSVU_N`e[VSthcNTSVUWNPXZYStY a DFHdY]edH?UWDFH a N¢£¤Q4

^WNPXtYedX4H,=edN`HdYU;XtUWDFH%^cUWXOeu¨^\FhcNPedH?\FhWX4edH^W^e{SVY+HH^cU_N`GBSkU_H a \FhWHedNP^cHdR¢bBhWXtG UWDFH

^_StG\FRPH\SVU_D¤ 4]Q]U´YFHdN¢U_DFHh U_DFH a hcN`¡UiZHeUWXZh©YFXZhiU_DFH;QFY a HdhcR`b4NPYF)hcX;YFNTStY°GXtU_N`XZY

MONPYFeH/\FhcNPeHd^%SthcHL\FQF]RPNP^cDFH a StY a S{VStNPRPStFRPH%UWXBU_DFH/\FQFFR`NPet sN`Ur^WHHdG^%hWH{SV^WXZYSVFRPH)U_X

edXZYF^cN a HhSGBSVhW¨tHUGX a HRs;DFHhWH%HedXZYFXtGINè%StZHYUWê{StYXZ]^WHdhZH^cUWXOeuÏ\FhWNèdH^/ªk¬¯®

:St^;U_DFHQFY

a

HhWR`b4N`YFB\FhcNPeH\FhcXOeHd^c^HtXZR`tHd^d sNPYZH^cUWXZhW^rXZF^WHhctHLU_DFH)XZQ]UWedXZGHd^?StY

a

U_DQF^;XZ]U_StNPY2N`Y]XZhWGISVUWNPXZYIStXZQ]UU_D]HU_hWQ]HVStR`QFHXt#U_D]H%^cU_X4euDSt^U_N`e%\Sth_SVGIHU_Hdhc^dip§Y

U_DFN`^-h_StGHXZhW¨x FN`YZHd^U_GHdYUr\FhWX4edH^W^WH^?SVhWHhWH¥4Q]NPhWH a UWX°sH)S a SV\]U_H a UWXUWDFH±R¢U_h_S

U_NPXtYLZHdY]Hdh_SkU_H a bU_DFH-^cHdeQFhWN¢U§bL\FhcNPedH^d ^cXU_DSVUNPYZH^cUWXZhdÂ^©\sXZhUWXZR`NPX;euDFXZN`edH^i^WDFXZQ]Ra

sHSV£sHdeUWH a bU_D]H/NPYOXZhWGISVU_N`XZY2edXtYU_StNPY]H a N`Y¦UWDFH/^U_X4eu¨+\]hWNPeHd^[XZYFR¢bZ;CDFNP^[^WN¢U_QS

U_NPXtY2NP^-edStRPR`H a U_D]H%e{St^cH)XV> !"t&ª#"$% ªk¬#ÚWX a NPÛ_NPY]ZQFNP^cD2NÙ-hcXZG U_DFHe{SV^WH%Xt

uª%9 ª#$% ªk¬#9?;D]HdhWHUWDFHVSthWNPStFR`Hd^;D]NPeuDeuDSthWSteUWHdhWN`dHUWDFH%^cU_SVU_HXV#UWDFH

±YStYFeNTStR¤GBSthc¨tHU[SthWH)StR`RSt^c^WQFGH a¦a

NPhcHdeUWR`bIXZF^cHdhcVSt]RPH@

CD]H)\]QFhW\XZ^WHXt#U_D]NP^XZhW¨BNP^-U_X°ZN¢ZHStYXZHhc4NPH XtU_D]H)\FSt\sHhW^;hWHRTSVUWH a ;N¢U_D

U_DFH-^UuStY a Sth a \XZhcUcXZRPN`Xr\]hWXZFR`HdG NPYLUWDFH-edSt^WHXt\SVhcU_NPStRXZF^cHdhcVSVUWNPXZY]^d p§Y^cHdeUWNPXZY4

H a Hd^cedhcNPH´UWDFHGISthc¨tHU#GX a HdRStY a ^WHU&UWDFH´HfO\sHeUWH a Q]UWNPR`N`U§b?hcXZG9UWHdhWGNPYFStRtH{StR¢U_D

GBSkfON`GIN`{SVUWNPXZY \FhWXZ]RPHdG+ MOHeU_N`XZY'|²\]hWHd^cHdYU_^U_DFH+^WXtRPQ]UWNPXZY³;DFHY'UWDFHGBSthc¨tHUIN`^

edXZG\FRPHU_HV#p§Y^WQF]^WHdeU_N`XZY|]¢yZ U_DFH´GIX

a

HRZ;N`U_D)\SthU_NPStRZXZF^cHdhtSkU_NPXtYF^NP^U_hWStYF^cXthWGH

a

NPYU_XXZYFH;;N`UWDIeXZG\FRPHU_H;XZF^cHdhcVSVUWNPXZY]^d ;DFHdhcHStR`RF¥QStYU_N¢U_N`Hd^©NPYZXtR`ZH a SthcH?S a St\]UWH a

U_XUWDFH?YFSVU_QFhWStR±R`UWh_SVUWNPXZY°Xt¤U_DFHr^WHdeQFhWN¢U§bB\]hWNPeHd^ CDFH?HdR`R¢§¨YFX;YIGIHU_DFX a ^N`YUWDFH

edXZG\FRPHU_HiXZ]^WHdhVSVU_N`XZYF^edXZYUWHf4UedStYUWDFHdY)HSV\F\FRPN`H a StY a XZhRTSkU_HdheXZG\SthWN`^WXZY¤ H

hWHdedStRPR#NPY~^WQFF^cHdeU_NPXtY |OUWDFHLZHYFHdhWStRhcHd^cQFR`UW^XtA(Sth_SVUW{St^ HdD]XOed¨b}StY a MODFhWHZH

(7)

)¢yZy+ p§Y9^cQFF^WHeUWNPXZY9|]|O QF^WN`YF¶U_DFH GBSVhcU_N`YFStR`HASt\]\FhWXSVeuD9Xt #SV¨4Y]Hdh )¢yz + H

euDSth_SVeU_HhWN`dHBUWDFHBXZ\OU_NPGIStRiH{StR¢U_D³\FhcXOeHd^c^°StY a UWDFHXZ\]UWNPGIStRiNPYtHd^cUWGIHYU°\sXZR`NPeNPHd^

XtU_DFHI\sXthcUWXtRPNPX+\FhcXZFRPHG¦+CDFN`^LNPYZXtR`ZH^S~\FhcXOeHd^c^~;DFN`euDµNP^)U_DFHIedXZY a N`U_N`XZYStR

HfO\sHeU_SVU_N`XZY¦tN`ZHY¦UWDFH)SVStN`RTSt]RPHN`Y]XZhWGISVUWNPXZYXVU_D]H/q[S

a

XZY4

N`¨tX

a

b4G

a

HhWN¢tSkU_N`tH

Xt&UWDFHGBSVhcU_N`YFStR`HrGH{SV^WQFhcH;N¢U_DhWH^W\HdeUrUWX°UWDFHXZhWN`ZNPYFStR¤\FhcXZSt]NPRPN¢U§bGIHdSt^WQFhcHt

p§Y°^cQFF^WHeUWNPXZYI|]JF tH[^cDFX DFX U_XedXtGI\FQOU_HN`YSr-S{bZH^WNPStYOeXZYU_HfOUd ;DFHdY

U_DFH a hWN¢¡UrtHdeUWXZhN`^StYAQ]YFXZF^cHdhctH a h_SVY a XZGVSthWNPStFR`H;N¢U_DA¨YFX;Y}\FhcNPXZh a N`^cU_hcNPFQ4

U_NPXtY[^WNPY])UWDFHrGHUWDFX a XZRPXttb a HZHRPXZ\H a NPY )¢y{z.+ HrtN`ZH[^WHZHh_StRhWH\FhWH^WHdYU_SVU_N`XZYF^

XtUWDFH\]hWX4edHd^c^StY a~a HhWN`tH)tHdhb¦HfO\FRPNèdNÙXthWGLQFRPStHXZhU_D]HXZ\OU_NPGIStR¤H{SVRÙ_D+\FhcXV

edHd^c^d HU2QF^2GHdYU_N`XZY UWDSVU (SthWSVU_dSt^2StY a

DFStX )y.+%SVRP^WX«^WXZR¢ZH~UWDFH}\sXthcUWXtRPNPX

XZ\]U_N`GIN`{SVUWNPXZY~\FhWXZ]RPHdG Xth/S+-S{bZH^WNTSVY³NPYZH^cUWXZh/FQOU/N`Y³S¦GXZhcH^c\sHedNPStRPN`dH a edXtYO

U_Hf4Ud ;DFHdY³UWDFH a hWN`¡U)ZHeUWXZhLNP^/S aFa N¢U_N`XZYStR¢b}St^c^WQFGH a UWXAHBNPY a Hd\HdY a HdYUXt-UWDFH

hWX;YFNPStY²GIXtUWNPXZY²\FhcXOeHd^c^);DFNèuD a hWN`tHdÛ_DFHISt^c^WHUW^\]hWNPeHdÎCDFH^W\HdeNTStRiedSt^WHXt

RPXZSVhWN`UWDFGNPeQ]UWNPRPN¢U§bQFYFeU_NPXtY2StY a YFXthWGIStRs\]hWNPXth a N`^cU_hcNPFQOU_NPXtYIXZh´U_DFH a hcN`¡U\FhWX4edH^W^

-St^[S a]a hWH^W^WH a bhcX ;Y]H/StY a D]N`UWU )Ã%+7

M4QFF^WHeUWNPXZY²|]IN`^ a HZXtUWH a U_XBUWDFHLedXtGI\FQOUuSVUWNPXZY¦XtiU_DFH/\FhWX4edH^W^BNPY~UWDFHLZHYO

Hdh_SVR-^WHUWU_N`YF²Xt[XZQFh\XZhcUcXZRPN`XAXZ\]UWNPGNPdSVU_N`XZY \]hWXZFR`HdG+«p§Y )y4.+7 St¨YFHhZN`tHd^StY

HfO\FRPN`edN¢UhcHd\FhcHd^cHdYUuSVUWNPXZYXthFQ]UDFNP^´XZhWGLQ]RTSNPYZXZR¢ZH^S\FhcXOeHd^c^;DFNPeuDN`^´UWDFH

edXZY a N`U_N`XZYStR&HfO\HdeU_SVU_N`XZY²Xt´U_DFH a hcN`¡UtHdeUWXZh tN`ZHY}U_DFHS{VStNPRPStFRPHNPY]XthWGISVU_N`XZY

p§Y³^WQF]^WHdeU_N`XZY |]O HB^W\HdedNPStRPN`dH°U_DFH a b4YStGNPed^Xt-;D]NPeuD¶StR`RPX;^Q]^/U_XAeXZG

\FQ]U_H bGH{StY]^[XVU_D]H (StR`GBSVYOQ]ebB±FR`U_Hhdr^cNPYFBÁRTSVhW¨xÂÃ^;XZhcGLQFRTSO OH)UWDFHdY

XZ]UuSVNPYHfO\FR`NPedN¢U;hWH\FhWH^WHdYU_SVU_N`XZYF^;XZhU_DFH)XZ\]UWNPGIStR¤N`YtHd^U_GHdYU?\XZR`NPedN`Hd^N`YUWHdhcGI^;Xt

U_DFH\FhWHON`XZQF^cR`b a H^WedhcNPH a \]hWX4edHd^c^WH^SVY a StY a U_D]H a HU_HdhcGIN`YFNPÛ_Nè%edXZY a NÙ_N`XZYStR

edXVSthWNPStYFedH©QFYFeU_N`XZYLXt!"§ g&SthcUWNPedQ]RTSth a HUuStN`RP^;NPRPRHXZhc¨tH a XZQOU&XZh#U_DFHRPXZZSthWN¢U_DO

GINè°StY a \XHhU§b4\HIQ]UWNPR`NÙ§b~Q]YFeUWNPXZYF^ NÙWD UWDFHBR`XZSthcNÙWDFGINèQOU_NPR`NÙ§b¦QFYFeUWNPXZY¤

U_DFH)XZ\]UWNPGIStR\XZhcUcXZRPN`Xe{StY¦sH)XZhWGIStRPR¢b a HdhWN¢ZH a hWXZG U_DFHedXZG\FRPHU_HXZF^cHdhtSkU_NPXtYF^

e{St^cHIb²hWH\FRTSVedNPY]U_DFHQFYFXZ]^WHdhVStFRPH a hcN`¡U\FhcXOeHd^c^#b²N`U_^%Hd^U/H^cUWNPGISVU_H$ 9:

U_DFN`^\FhWXt\sHhcU§bAeXZhWhcHd^c\sXZY a ^%U_XU_D]H^WXV e{StR`RPH a ^WHd\FSth_SVUWNPXZY}\]hWNPY]edNP\]RPHtp U%N`^%SteU_QStR`R`b

\FhWXZH a NPY(QStYS-)y&%%+U_DFSVUN`YIUWDFH%l¦HhcUWXZYU§b4\sHrXtXZ\]UWNPGIStR 1 edXZYF^cQFG\]U_N`XZY\FhWXtO

RPHdGNPYAS2RTSteu¨ZMOeuDFXZR`Hd^GISthW¨VHU;N¢U_D}QFY]XZF^WHhcVStFR`H a hWN¢¡U?tHdeUWXZhd UWDFHL^cHd\SthWSVU_N`XZY

\FhWN`YFedN`\FRPHD]XZRa ^N¢&StY a XZYFR`bBNÙ_D]H)QOU_NPR`NÙ§bQFYFeU_NPXtYF^;SthWHR`XZSthcNÙ_D]GINèt

(8)

p§Y²^cHdeUWNPXZY}J] ¤HLUWhWHdSVUU_D]HLe{St^cHXt´NPYFeXZG\FRPHU_H/GISthc¨tHUW^d)p§YAU_DFN`^?h_SVGIHXZhc¨x

()SVh_SVUW{St^StY a QFH)y&%+s^cUWQ a bU_DFHr\FhWXZ]RPHdG XtGBSkfON`GIN`dNPY]%HfO\sHeUWH a Q]U_N`RPN¢U§bLhWXZG

edXZYF^cQFG\]U_N`XZY¦]Q]U?;N¢U_DAShWH^cU_hcNPeU_N`tHLSt^c^WQFG\]UWNPXZY+XZY~UWDFH a N`£sQF^WN`XZY~GISVU_hcN¢fB;DFNPeuD

NPG\FRPN`Hd^rUWDSVUU_D]HGHUWDFX

a

XZRPXtZNPH^

a

HZHdR`XZ\H

a

N`Y²^WHdeU_N`XZY«|XZhUWDFH°edXZG\FR`HU_HGISth

¨tHUe{St^cHLSthcHLSt\F\]RPNPedStFR`Ht

H)U_DFHY}edXZY]^WN

a

HdhrUWDFH/\XZhUWXZR`NPX°XZ\]UWNPGNP{SkU_NPXtY2\FhWXZ]RPHdG

S a hWH^W^cH a b¦giDStGStY a Q]HdYFH-)Ã %+;DFHhWHUWDFH/Û_X4eu¨\FhWNèdHd^;XZR`RPX S^cUWXOeuDSV^cU_Nè

ZXZRPSVU_N`RPNÙ§b)GX a HdR #p§YB^cQFF^cHdeUWNPXZYIJF¢yZ H[QF^WH[hWH^WQFR¢U_îhWXtG ^cUWXOeuDSV^cU_Nè±RÙWHdhWN`YF%U_DFH

XZhcb)U_X%hcH a QFeHU_DFHXZ\OU_NPGNPdSVU_N`XZY)\FhWXZ]RPHdG ;N`UWD\SthU_NTSVROXZ]^WHdhVSVU_N`XZYF^iNPYUWXXZYFH-;N¢U_D

edXZG\FRPHU_HXtF^WHhcVSVU_N`XZYF^´CD]HHdR`R¢ a HtHdRPXt\sH a GISthU_NPY]StRPH a QSVRPN`U§bBSt\F\]hWXSteuD+Xt*)J.+

StY

a )y +-StR`RPX;^%QF^)U_X~tHUHfO\FRPN`edN¢U%XZhWGLQ]RTStH\FhcXON

a

NPY]+UWDFHBXZ\OU_NPGIStR N`YZHd^U_GHdYU

\sXZR`NPeNPHd^¸VUWDFNPÛuSt^c¨N`êdSthWhcNPH a XZQ]UNPYL^cQFF^WHeUWNPXZYJF;;D]HdhWHV NPYS aFa NÙWNPXZY¤ UWDFH-^c\sHedNTSVR

e{St^cH)XVR`XZSthcNÙ_D]GINè?StY a \XHh;U§b4\HQOU_NPR`NÙ§b°QFYFeU_N`XZYF^;NP^Û_Q a N`H a

d)d' /,-#*

ÁXZYF^WNa HdhiUWDFHXZRPR`X ;N`YFeXZYU_NPYQFXtQFîU_NPGH-GX a HdR]XZh©S%±YSVYFedNPStRFGISthW¨VHUédXZY]^WNPÛ_N`YF

Xt?XtYFH2hWN`^W¨«hcHdHsXtY a ? XZhSVYF¨µSteedXZQFYU @L;D]XZ^WH+\FhWN`edH2\FhcXOeHd^c^N`^°St^W^cQFGH a XZh

^WNPG\FR`NPedN¢U§bLU_XHH¥4QFStRSVU-H{SteuD2U_N`GIHStY a

hcNP^c¨bB^WHedQFhcN`U_N`Hd^ ?^cUWXOeu¨^ @;N¢U_DBUWDFH

\FhWN`edH%\FhcXOeHd^W^ "!$#% "!&' )(*&+-,/.1020203./ 546&+-,-,-798-;:=<?>@.BACED/ZXtHdhWY]H a b:

F 5GH&+-,I!J 5GH&+-,LK MGN&+-, F O P QR-S

(3T GR

&+-, FVU

R

&+-,HW ?7O¢y @

5G&'>X,Y!JZ1G[:\]_^ ?7O@

n[HdhcH U ! # U `! &U (9&a-,b.1020203. U 46&+-,-, 7dc e:f<g>h.BAC'D NP^BS F a N`GIHYF^WN`XZYStR

hWX;YFNPStY¦GXtUWNPXZY ?;N¢U_D+\sXt^W^WN`FR`b F`ij @XtYAS°\FhWXZFStFNPR`N`U§bB^W\SteH-?Ekl.Bmn.po @ H

a HdYFXVU_Hb#2mHD)U_D]Hqo´StQ]ZGIHYUuSVUWNPXZY2Xt#U_D]H±FR`U_hWSVU_N`XZY2ZHYFHdhWSVU_H a b U

p§YµH¥QSVU_N`XZY ?7O¢y @ UWDFH a hcN`¡U-?tHdeUWXZhLXtUWDFHSV\F\FhWHedNPSVU_N`XZY«hWSVU_H^ @r!f#&!

& (*&a-,b.102020M. M4@&+-,/8Bs:<?>@.BACEDStY a UWDFHItXZRTSkU_NPR`N`U§b}GISVUWhWN¢f

T

!t&

T GR

&+-,B,u(HvwGyx

R

vw4¦SthcH

(9)

H%NPYUWhWX a QFedHm !$#2m

8B;:=<?>@.BACED%U_DFH o©SVQFZGHdYU_H a ±R`UWh_SVUWNPXZYIZHdYFHh_SVUWH a

bUWDFHL\FhcNPedH)\FhcXOeHd^W^ ¸sNPYU_Q]N`U_N¢ZHR`bZ #2m ND°hWHedXZh a ^rUWDFHLDFN`^cUWXZhcbXtU_DFHLGISthc¨tHUrQF\

U_XU_N`GIHI#;DFHdhcH{St^;#2m

D[hWHd\]hWHd^cHdYU_^©U_D]H-NPY]XthWGISVU_N`XZYeXZRPR`HdeU_H a b/XZF^WHhc4NPY]St^W^cHU

\FhWN`edHd^;QF\U_XUWNPGH

ohcXZG YFX XtY ZH[^WDFStRPRSV^W^WQ]GIH;U_DSkU©XZYFR`bqmt&S

a

St\]U_H

a

\]hWX4edHd^c^WH^SthcH;XZF^WHhc

StFRPHV OUWDSVU-N`^d 4H%^cQF\F\XZ^WHUWDSVUN`YtHd^U_XZhc^NPYU_D]NP^±FYStYFeNTStRsGBSthc¨tHUGIX a HRsXZ]^WHdhZH

^cU_X4eu¨ \]hWNPeHd^XtYFR`bt H~e{StR`RrU_D]NP^B^cN`UWQSVU_N`XZY'UWDFHAedSt^WH}Xt\FSthcUWNTStR[XZF^cHdhcVSVUWNPXZY XZh

\SthcUWNTStRN`Y]XZhcGBSVUWNPXZYIU_X a NP^cUWNPYFtQFNP^cD¦N¢U[hcXZG·U_D]HedSt^WHXt&§Q]RPRN`Y]XZhWGISVUWNPXZYOr;DFHhWH

HdedXtYFXZGNPeStZHdYUW^DS{ZH°SBeXZYU_N`Y4Q]XZQF^%SteedH^W^U_XUWDFH/HYU_NPhcHLDFN`^cU_Xthcb+XtiU_D]HLGBSVhW¨tHU

hWHd\]hWHd^cHdYU_H

a

bU_D]H±FR`U_hWSVU_N`XZY#2m ND

p eI@@Mh

HU;QF^[edXZYF^cN

a

Hh;StY+NPYZH^cU_Xth;;D]XIedStY¦N`YZHd^U[NPY2U_DFH & O ,St^cNPe%^cHdedQ]hWN`UWNPH^d

»

¿ "!$#&% J ¡¬' ('t®){ª% *' ¬ ,+©¬ ;

-

¬# ªk¬ t/.

J #d0. m - _ª 21 ! #*1!! &313(9&+-,/.1020203.41L46&+-,/8B :$<?>@.BACED 2

!(5

687

9;:<:

T 7

1!

:=:> F @? O2ABL^ZX^9^ ?7OÃ| @

HhWHSth a 1LG&a-,St^-U_DFH)StGXZQFYUUWDFH)StZHdYU[NPYtHd^cUW^rN`Y2U_DFH2C ED

^cUWXOeu¨2SkU a SVU_H

XtU_HrU_DSVUU_DFH[ SteUU_DSVUNPYZH^cUWXZhW^-DFStH%XZYFR¢bI\FSthcUWNTStRxNPYOXZhWGISVU_N`XZY°NP^GIX

a

HdR`RPH

a

b+hcHd¥QFNPhcNPYFUWDSVUF1³NP^[S

a

St\]U_H

a

UWXIU_D]H)±R¢U_hWSVU_N`XZYZHdYFHh_SVUWH

a

b2UWDFH/^U_X4eu¨2\FhWN`edHd^

p§YXtU_D]Hdh©XZh a ^d ONPYI\FQFhW^cQFNPY]LNPYZH^cUWGIHYU a HdeNP^cNPXZYF^ 4UWDFHSVZHdYU-DFSt^-SVUDFN`^ a N`^W\XZ^_SVR

NPY]XZhcGBSkU_NPXtY}StXZQ]UU_DFHHtXZRPQOU_NPXtY XtU_DFHISt^c^WHU/\FhWN`edH^FQOU/YFXVU/SVsXZQOUUWDFHIHYU_NPhcH

DFNP^U_XZhbXt#U_DFHGISthW¨VHUd

H2^WDFStRPR a HdYFXtUWH2bHGJI xK

UWDFHVStRPQ]H2Xt;U_DFH2\XZhcUcXZRPN`X~eXZhWhcHd^W\XZY a NPYF}U_XAUWDFH

NPYZH^cU_GHdYU[\FhcXOeHd^W^L1«StY

a

U_DFHN`YFN`UWNTStRNPYZH^cUWGIHYULM©pU[NP^ZN¢ZHY¦b:

G I xK

!NM O 6

9 1 7 O O

FP O 6

9 1 7 O T O

FVU

O ^ ?7OJ @

(10)

» ¿ "!$#<! ¬ ¡¬$$ ¬* uª 1 t¡ #d

){ª%- <-

ªk¬ ª)8 J, ¡ ® )"_ª% "¡¬ t t _ª#d ) 5

G I xK

i >h.0BL^Z ^.p> A^

" ¬¤ª% #d® &,M5,; Lª) #d;¡¬$$ ¬ uª

L L @l [

CDFH;StZHYU©DFSt^©SQ]U_N`RPN¢U§b)Q]YFeUWNPXZY

c

<?>@. A , \# AjD[^WQ]euDUWDSVUiN¢UiNP^ ^U_hcNPeUWR`b

NPYFehWH{SV^WNPY]F F^cUWhWN`eU_R¢bBeXZYFedStHt edXZYUWNPYQFXZQF^cR`b

a

N`£sHdhcHdYU_NPStFRPHSVY

a

^_SVUWNP^c±FHd^ :

! #"

K%$

]'&

)(E&,M5,I!j> ?7O@

CD]H\]^WHdQ a XV§N`YZHdhc^WHQFYFeU_N`XZY²Xt©U_DFH a HhWN¢tSkU_N`tHLXt*v;N`RPR#sH a HYFXtUWH a b,+ c

&'>@. A ,- \ StY a N`^ a H±Y]H a SV^;XtRPRPX;^8:

+5&.@,Y! #/10 #*M i >82)(E&,M5,3. D ^ ?7O @

XtU_H+U_DSkUBU_D]H¦QFYFeU_N`XZY4+ SteU_QStR`R`b¶HdeXZGIH^IUWDFH~N`YtHdhc^WH~QFY]eU_N`XZY Xt5 ( N`

# #" K%$

9 (

&3M5, ! A SVY a bSVYStRPXttbB;N¢U_D ? O@ FN`U^WSVU_N`^c±H^

! #"

K%$

&

+5&6.6,Y!r>^ ?7O%@

XtU_H%UWDSVU : &+5&.@,B, i &,M5,[O7.3<8+5&.@,9HMLC[. : M[.;.=< >^ ?7OÃz @

H)S aFa hcHd^c^[UWDFH%XZRPR`X ;N`YFL\FhcXZFR`HdG :

> ¿ &» !$#!? &ª% '$$¬ ¡7®F) O¬ ªk¬@Et¬ - '$$¬¡¬t t

MA< > . ; J, ¡7®F)"uª% "¡¬ t t.

B`<C &,G I xK

7 , C ?7O4 @

xK

(11)

CD]H)VStR`QFHQFYFeU_NPXtY2XtUWDFNP^\FhcXZFR`HdG!N`^;:

&3M5, !

I E

K

B`<C &,GJI xK

7 , CX^ ? 4`y@

» ¿ "!$# ª%"){ªk ª8 _ª 1": E &3M5, ¡¬# ¡¬

t¡ ª t

", -)*,

$

,-, /,-#*

CDFhWXZQ]ZDFXZQ]UIU_DFN`^I^cHdeU_NPXtY -U_DFH¦YQFGLHdhBXV%hWN`^W¨b'St^W^cHU_^BNP^°U_DFH¦^_StGH~SV^IU_D]H a N

GIHYF^WN`XZY~XtU_DFH a hWN¢ON`YFIhWX;YFNPStY~GXtU_N`XZY U xU_DFSVU?N`^d ! F SVY a U_D]HZXtRTSVUWNPRPN¢U§b

edX4H,=edN`HdYU

T

N`^rSeXZYF^cU_StYU[NPYZHhcU_N`FRPH%GISVUWhWN¢f

T

h 5 @ h$I

ÁXZYF^WNa HdhIU_DFHA\XZ^cN`U_N¢ZH¦RPX4e{StR;GISthcUWNPYFSVRPH ! # N8B_: <?>@.BACED a H±FYFH a b'UWDFH

XZRPR`X ;N`YFLH¥4QFSVU_N`XZY : F 3! & T G (

+,

7

FVU . 9 ! ^ ?|]¢y @

HGBSV¨tH%U_DFH%XZR`RPX;NPY]LSt^c^WQFG\]U_N`XZY2U_DFhcXZQFZD]XZQ]U;U_DFN`^^WHeU_N`XZY :

2{ "!# ¿ ?$#&%$# _ª % &'o.9#2m D%, - "¡¬' t

HLU_D]HdY a H±FYFH'&o!St^UWDFHL\FhcXZSt]NPRPN¢U§b+GIHdSt^WQFhcHLHd¥QFN¢VStRPHYU?U_X o XtYm

7

U_DFSVU

S a GN`U_^U_DFH)q[S a XZYO N`¨tX a b4G a HhWN`VSVUWN`tH &+A,9:

F(&o

F o

!) &+A, ^

H)StR`^WXNPYUWhWX a QFedH%UWDFH a NPGHdYF^cNPXZYSVRs\FhcXOeHd^c^

&

U ! # &U !& &U (b&+-,b.9020203. &U 4L&a-,B,b8-;:=<?>@.BACED a H±YFH a b:

&

U

3!

U

@O

6

9 T G ( O F P ^ ?|]@

(12)

´b¹%NPhc^_StYFXÂ^U_DFHXZhWHG¦ U & NP^ S%hWX;YFNTSVYLGIXVU_NPXtYQFY a Hdh UWDFHYFH \]hWXZSVFNPR`N`U§b

GIHdSt^WQFhcH o& ;N`UWD+hcHd^c\sHeU;U_X°U_DFH%±R¢U_hWSVU_N`XZY #2m ND

HiYFX³eXZGHU_X-UWDFH XZRPR`X;NPYF¨tHb \sXZN`YU;DFNPeuD)^cU_SVU_H^U_DSVU StY a &U ZHdY]Hdh_SkU_H

U_DFH^_StGH°±R`UWh_SVUWNPXZY

H a

H±YFHIUWDFH a

N`GIHYF^WN`XZYStRhWHUWQFhWY \FhWX4edH^W^ ! #!

& (*&a-,b.102020.4L&a-,B,/8B : <?>@.BAC'Db

F 5GN&+-,I! 5GH&+-, F GH&+-,;. C! .1020205. ^ ?|]Ã| @

HDS{ZHU_DFH%XZR`RPX;NPY] a HdeXZG\sXZ^cN`UWNPXZYF^XZh-U_DFHhcHU_Q]hWY+\FhWX4edH^W^ :

F 3! F 3O

T

FVU ?|]J @

SVY a F

3!

T F &

U

V^ ?|]@

q;HdRPSVU_N`XZYF^?|]|@SVY a ? |]@NPG\FR`b+U_DFHY UWDSVU !SVY a U & ZHdYFHh_SVUWHUWDFH^_StGH

±R`UWh_SVUWNPXZY^WX/UWDSVU;m NP^edXZYUWNPYQFXZQF^´l¦XZhcHdXZHhd YFXtUWHrUWDSVUH%e{SVYQF^WHUWDFH?hcHUWQFhWY

\FhWX4edH^W^ Xt ?7|O| @-SV^;UWDFHXZF^cHdhcVSVUWNPXZY\FhcXOeHd^c^d

CD]H´H{StR¢U_DHd¥QSkU_NPXtY-?7OÃJ @¤e{StY)sHihcH;hcN`UWUWHdY)NPY%U_HhWG^Xt]UWDFH´hWX;YFNPStYGIXVU_NPXtY

&

U St^

G I xK

! M O 6

9 1 7

O T F &U O ^ ?|] @

gihcXZFRPHG OÃ|NP^-U_DQF^;H¥4Q]N`VStRPHYU[UWX<:

l¦SkfONPGNPdH

B`<C &,GJI xK

7 , C

^cQF4jcHeU[U_X

F GJI xK

! 1 7

O T F &U O . GJI xK

9 ! M .

XtHdhrStRPR m

§S a St\]UWH a \sXtRPNPeNPH^@1! :,FEN&3M5,

CD]NP^;St\F\]hWXSteuD2;N`RPR¤H%edXtYtHdYFN`HdYU ?^cHdH^WHeU_N`XZY+|]Ã| @´XZh-^cXZR`4N`YFXZQFh\SVhcU_NPStRPR¢b

XZF^WHhctH

a

Xt\]U_N`GIN`{SVUWNPXZYI\FhWXZ]RPHdG+

(13)

n[XHZHdh U_DFHhWH%NP^-S/GIXthWH^bO^U_HGBSVUWNPe?S{bU_X/hWH a QFedH%U_D]H%XZ\]U_N`GIN`{SVUWNPXZYgihWXtO

RPHdG 4|;;N`U_D)\SthU_NPStRNPY]XthWGISVU_N`XZY%U_X;U_DFHe{St^cHXtxS[GIX a HR;D]HdhWHStRPReXOH=edNPHYU_^iSthcH

HfO\FRPN`edN¢UrXZhcGLQFRPStH)Xth?U_DFH/XZ\]U_N`GBSVR#N`YZHd^U_GHdYU\FhcXOeHd^W^SVY

a

U_DFH/XZ\]U_N`GBSVRH{SVR`U_D¤

C&X U_DFN`^I\FQ]hW\XZ^WHV edXZYF^cN

a

HhIUWDFH~\FhcXOeHd^c^

U ! #

U ! &

U

(9&+-,/.1020203.

U

46&+-,B,/8Bn:

<g>@.-A CED a H±FYFH a b : U

! &

U 6

9 T G (

B`< O :m O C FP

. ?|]%@

;D]HdhWHU NPÛ_DFHNPY]YFXtSkU_NPXtY \]hWX4edHd^cÎNPY U_DFH±RÙWHdhcNPYFU_DFHXZhcbtm?Y³N`YUWQFNÙWN`tH

NPYU_HhW\FhcHUuSkU_NPXtYµXtrUWDFH2U_HhWGNPYFXZR`XZtbAN`YFYFXVSVU_N`XZYµ\FhcXOeHd^W^NP^LUWDFH2XZRPR`X;NPYF :´b

GIHdStYF^Xt#U_DFHhcHdRTSkU_NPXtY

F U 3! U ] P

2 U 3! U & ] P U & T G ( B`<

:m C F

H¦YFXtU_HU_DFSVU F U N`^UWDFH2§NPYFY]X VSVUWNPXZY4\SVhcUIXtU_D]H¦YFH XZF^cHdhcVSVUWNPXZY XZ]U_StNPY]H a

sHU§HHdY -StY a 5O F OsHe{StQF^cHN`U-N`^U_D]H a N`£sHdhcHdYFeH%sHU§HHdYU_DFH%YFH9XtF^WHhcVSVU_N`XZY

StY a ;DSVU;HHf]\HdeUrUWX°XZF^WHhctHZN¢ZHY+UWDFH\St^cU[XZ]^WHdhVSVU_N`XZYF^d

´b edRTSV^W^WN`e{StRhcHd^WQ]R`U_^+NPY ±R¢U_HdhcNPYFµUWDFHdXZhb ? ^WHH XZhHfFSVGI\FR`H HdYF^cXZQF^c^_StY )y+7

()SVRPRPNPStYF\FQ]h;)¢y{%+#XZh[gSth a XZQOf )ÃVJ+ @ U N`^?S mV FhWX;YFNPStY+GIXtUWNPXZY^cXIU_DFSVUrH/edStY

YFX a H^WehWNPH-U_D]H a b4YStGNPed^XtxU_DFH\SVhcU_NPStRPR¢b%XZF^cHdhZH a GIX a HR4;N¢U_DFN`Y°S?h_StGHXZhW¨

Xt&S°eXZG\FRPHU_H%XZF^cHdhtSkU_NPXtY2GIX a HdR7 O;DFHhWH)StR`R¤¥QStYU_N¢U_N`Hd^NPYtXZR`tH a SthWHS a St\]U_H a U_X

U_DFHXZF^cHdhtSkU_NPXtY+\]hWX4edHd^c^ :

F "3!J "-<B`<

:m CF 3O

T

FU aC[^ ?|]Ãz @

n[XHZHdh 4UWDFH\FhcNPedHH\S{bLXth&U_D]NP^ N`^U_DSkU U_DFHeXZYF^UuStYU2NPY ?7O¢y @&NP^hWHd\]RTSteH a

bBU_DFHGXZhWH%eXZGI\]RPNPedSVU_H a \FhWX4edH^W^ B`<

:m C7

edXZYU_Hf4UXVsQFR`RFNPYOXZhWGISVU_N`XZY ksXVU_DXZhiH{SV^cbhcHHdhcHdYFeH?SVY a RTSVUWHdhiedXtGI\SVhWNP^cXZYNPYLUWDFH

U_hWHdSVU_GHdYU;Xt#U_D]H)\FSthcUWNTStRsNPY]XZhcGBSkU_NPXtYe{St^cHt

(14)

" L 6l [ h h M h

p L

H?UWDQF^[St^W^cQFGIHrU_DSVUU_DFH a hcN`¡U\FhWX4edH^W^ ²StY a UWDFH a hcN`4NPYFLhWX;YFNPStY+l¦XtUWNPXZY U

St\F\H{SthcNPYF¦NPY«UWDFHB^U_X4euDSt^cUWNPe a N`£sHdhWHYU_NTSVRH¥4QFSVU_N`XZY ? 4`y @XZh)U_DFH^cHdeQFhWN¢U§b³\FhcNPedH^

SthWHXZF^WHhcVStFR`HXZh[NPYtHd^cUWXZhW^?NPY~UWDFH/GISthW¨VHUStY a UWDSVU?UWDFHUWh_S a NPYFI^cU_hWSVU_HZNPH^SthcH

S a St\]UWH

a

U_XU_D]H±FR`U_hWSVU_N`XZY #2m ND

HhWHdedStRPR UWDFH°^WXZR`Q]U_N`XZY²XtgihcXZFRPHG OÃ|+N`Y UWDFH°e{St^cHIXVQFR`RiNPY]XZhcGBSkU_NPXtY ? ^cHdH

()SVh_SVUW{St^ HdDFX4ed¨b+SVY a M4DFhWHZH )¢yZy,+@

»4¿ » ?#<! ª ! ){ª% $$®- uªk¬# t¬9.`:=&E>@. A ,0.

B< 7

+5&. 7 , C? A ?|]4 @

# ¬ ª t$$&ª) "¡¬ t t

GI xK

7 ! +5& .

7 , ?7|O`y@

uªk¬# t¬. 4¬ ¯® ¡¬ #d®

B< 7 +5& .

7 , C5! M ^ ?7|O`yZy@

# ª t t _ª G

I xK

t¬ °ª t ¡¬$$ ¬> _ª 1

9 7¯® ¡¬ #d®5

G I xK

!

B`< 7

+5&. 7 , :

mC ! M O 6

9 1 7 O T F &U O

?7|O`y @

;L J q h F 6 h$L eI@

p§Y+^cHdeU_NPXtY¦|O`yZ 4HDS{tHUWh_StY]^cXZhcGIH a XZQFhGISthW¨VHUGX a HdR¤N`YU_XXZYFH;N¢U_DedXtGI\FR`HUWH

XZF^WHhcVSVUWNPXZYF^?CDFN`^?Sb+HLe{StY²SV\F\FR`bUWDFH/GHUWDFX a XZRPXZVb2XZhrUWDFH/edSt^WH/;D]HdY}QFRPR

a

N`Y]XZhWGISk

U_NPXtYHUQF^)YFXtUWNPedH°U_DFSVU)NPY²U_DFHXZhWGLQ]RTStH ? |]`y{ @ ? |]¢y @?\FhcX 4N

a

NPYFU_D]HIXZ\OU_NPGIStR

RPHtHdRrXt%U_HhWGNPYStRH{StR¢U_D StY a U_DFHAXt\]U_N`GBStRN`YZHd^U_GHdYU\FhcXOeHd^W^2N`Y U_D]HAe{St^cHAXt

(15)

QFRPR;NPYOXZhWGISVU_N`XZY ´U_DFH¦\FhWX4edH^W^ HYUWHdhc^2NPY S«\]hWXZGNPYFHYUI St^cDFNPXtY9p§Y UWDFHAe{SV^WH

Xt#hWHd^U_hcNPeUWH a NPY]XthWGISVU_N`XZY N`U^cHdHGI^;YSVUWQFh_SVR¤U_X°\FhcXkjcHdeU[UWDFHs&'o.9#2m D%,§GISthcUWNPYFZStRPH

U_XAU_D]H2S{tSVNPRTSVFRPHNPY]XthWGISVU_N`XZY SVULU_N`GIHsStY a DFHYFedHV ´UWX}edXZYF^cNa Hh/U_D]H2\FhWX4edH^W^

q!$# N8B;:=<?>@.BACED

a

H±YFH

a

b:

L&+-,Y!HB<

:m

C5!HB<B< 7 :m C :m C !HB< 7 :m

C[^ ?7|O`y|@

XtU_H%UWDSVU °NP^;S &Eo.-m , §GISthcUWNPYFSVRPH;;N`U_D B< 7 C5! Z

CD]HrXZR`RPX;NPYF?hWHdRPSVU_N`XZYFîhWXtG ^cUWXOeuDSV^cU_Nè[±FRÙ_HhWN`YF%U_DFHXZhcb;N`RPRFHrQ]^WHQ]RsN`Y°UWDFH

^WHd¥QFHRXt&UWDFNP^\FSt\sHh :

oXZhHtHdhcb m GIHdSt^WQ]h_StFR`H?hWStY a XZGvVSthcNTStFR`H ° hm

O

§GH{St^cQFh_SVFRPH[h_StY a XZG tSVhWN¢

StFRPH StY a m O GIHdSt^WQFhWStFR`H%h_StY a XZG!VSthWNPStFR`H U ;N`UWD > * P A) FHDS{ZH

: &B`< C !HB< CX. ?7|O`y{J @

&

B`<

:m C5!

B< O :m

CX. ?7|O`y&@

SVY a B`<& U :m

C5!

B`< O U :m

C[^ ?7|O`y@

´bUuSt¨NPY] U ! (

(

NP^´S & o& .Bm ,§ GBSthU_N`YFStR`Ht

MONPYFeHlm NP^ZHYFHdhWSVU_H a b U & (

xStY a StR`^WX] FGLQF^UrDFStH/SeXZYU_NPYQFXtQF^ZHdhc^WN`XZY

´»

«

?$#!? &ª%$$® 1 :A

E

&,M5,0.

&

B`<G I xK

7 C "M ^ ?7|O`y&%@

gihcXOXtA:

CD]H^cQFF^cUWN`UWQ]U_N`XZY2XtUWDFHHfO\FhcHd^W^cNPXZY ?7|O@tHdhcN`±H a b U & N`Y ? OJ @RPHdS a ^-UWX :

GJI xK

! M O 6

9 1 7

O T F &U O ^ ?7|O`yz@

(16)

CD]NP^%^WD]X ;^ NPYA\SVhcU_N`edQFRPSthd U_DSkUU_DFH\]hWX4edHd^c^ G I xK

N`^%SYFXZY]YFHdSkU_N`tH & o& .Bmw,

RPX4e{StR4GBSVhcU_N`YFStR`Ht kDFHdY]edHb°oxSVU_XtQÂÃ^ HGIGIS] tS^WQF\HdhcGBSthU_N`YFStR`Ht#p Ui^_SVUWNP^±Hd^ UWDFHdY

: &B`<G I xK

7 C &B`<G I xK

9

C5! M^ ?7|O`y4@

HNPYU_hcX a QFedHUWDFH%QFYFeUWNPXZY c &'>@. A , &'>h. A C a H±YFH a b

&.@, !HB< 7 +5&. 7

,HC5! B`<8+5&.& 7 , CX^ ?7|Ot@

´» « ?$#,)

&.@, ?NA ){ª% $$®5.:=&'>@.0A , ?7|OOy@

¬ J 4¬ uªk¬# t¬(.`:=&E>@. A , 2 <! 5

&.@,I!NM ^ ?7|OZ@

gihcXOXt : [Y a HhUWDFH St^W^cQFG\]U_N`XZY ?7|]Oy @ rUWDFHAQFYFeU_NPXtY NPY]DFHdhcN`U_^hcXZG +

U_DFH%\FhcXZ\HdhcU§bBXtHdNPY]°SLedXZYU_N`YQFXZQF^ F^cUWhWNPeU_R¢b a HedhcH{St^cNPYF°GISt\F\FN`YF/Xt &E>@. A ,N`YUWX

&'>@. A , ÁXZY]^WHd¥QFHYU_R`bt -U_DFHhWH+HfONP^U_^BS QFY]NP¥QFH+edXZYF^UuStYU .j: &'>@. A ,L^cQFeuD U_DFSVU

& .h,Y! M

H a

H±FYFH : K ! +5&. 7

,;^ ?7|Ot|@

´» « ?$# # Jt¬ 4ª% $%" #d K

,+

B< 7 K

C5! B`<& K C ! M . ?7|OVJ @

B`<& & K ,B,

G C ? A . ?7|O @

t¬ L){ª% $$®; ª%"){ªk ª 1e:FE &,M5, . 8!$$ 5

B`<C &3G I xK

7 , C B`<C & K

,HC^ ?7|O @