• Aucun résultat trouvé

Probabilistic Cluster Unfoldings for Petri Nets

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "Probabilistic Cluster Unfoldings for Petri Nets"

Copied!
33
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00072162

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00072162

Submitted on 23 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Probabilistic Cluster Unfoldings for Petri Nets

Stefan Haar

To cite this version:

Stefan Haar. Probabilistic Cluster Unfoldings for Petri Nets. [Research Report] RR-4426, INRIA.

2002. �inria-00072162�

(2)

ISRN INRIA/RR--4426--FR+ENG

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Probabilistic Cluster Unfoldings for Petri Nets

Stefan Haar

N˚4426

Avril 2002

THÈME 4

(3)
(4)

,'-/.10325476"28259;:

<=?>A@CBEDCFHGJIK@#LNMKOQPRIKS1TBPUS1V?PRIK@CIXWYOPRIKS1T

Z BWR[\W]PY>^@_BAW`Sa@_V?MbB^c\BAW

dfeYSQg]B^PYWUGJh3iEjlknm

oUOQVNVpSae3P Z BeYBA`q=?BAeY`q=NBrT#sQDaDtmQuvFwk'xJeYIbM'm1y1yamFzm1{#VNO1|1B;W

}~€A^‚ƒ?„11… <=?IKWOQeRPRIX`MKB†IKTaPYeRS Z Lp`BAW"O‡V?eYS1ˆNO1ˆ?IKMbIXW]PYIK`‰L?T\Š‹S1MZ IKT?|ŒWRB^@OQTtPYIK`AWŠ‹S1eL?TtPRIK@CB Z d(BPYeRIŽT?BPqW^‘’S

W3PReYLN`“PYL?eqOQM”S1eWYOŠ‹B^P][lO1WYWRL?@_V\PRIKS1TNWO1eRB_@O Z B1_•–B—WR=?S˜PR=NOQP"™šœ›J“ž Ÿ¡C^Ÿ^¢_£Q¤Nž¦¥§™“ŽIKWO1T¨O Z BA©tLNOQPRBCŠ‹eqOQ@_B^˜&S1eYª

Š‹Sae«PY=?B`SaTNW]PYeRLp`“PRIKS1TSQŠ'V?eYS1ˆpOQˆ?IKMbIbP][_@_BAO1WRL?eYBAW¬Š‹S1e­`SaTN`LNeReYB^TtP«eYL?TNWA”<=?BŽL?T\Š‹S1MZ IKT?|_W3BA@_O1TtPRIX`^W&IKW`^S1TNW3PReYLN`“PYB Z

ˆJ[_MbS\`AOQMN`q=?SaIK`^BAW¬S1TBAOa`q=—`MKLNW3PRB^e;®aO1T Z O Z IKW3PReYIbˆNL\PRB Z WR`q=NB Z L?MKIKT?|@_BA`q=NO1T?IKWR@°¯R™^šœ›J“ž±Ÿ^¡’¤8Ÿž³²”OQL?PR=?SaeRIK´^IKT?|`MKLNW3PRBAe

Oa`“PRIKS1TpW^<=?BŽV?eRSaˆNOQˆNIbMKIµP][@_B;O1WRL?eRB;WfŠ‹Sae&PR=?B`q=?SaIK`^B’SQŠ(W]PYB^VIbTO_`MKLNW]PYB^e­OQeYB’Saˆ\PYO1IbTNB Z ˆJ[`^S1TNW3PReYLN`PRIKT?|¶j‰O1eRªaSx

·IKB^MZ W¬SaT_PR=?Bn`S1T?¸NIK`P¬|1eqOQVN=CS1Š8PReqOQTNWRIµPYIbSaTNWA®QŠ‹eYS1@¹W3L?IbPYO1ˆ?MKBniŽIbˆNˆNW¬V5SQPYB^TtPRIXOQMXWA•¨B’IKTtPReYS Z LN`BUO1T Z `q=NOQeqO1`PRBAeRIK´^B

W3PRSaV?V?IKT?|CPRIK@CB;WЋS1ePY=?BAWRB@_S

Z

B^MXW^®?O1T

Z

O_W]PYeRSaT?|CjlOQeYª1SxV?eYS1V5B^eRP][1

º†»t¼8½R¾¶¿ ‚À€1… d¬eRSaˆNOQˆ?IKMKIKW3PRIX`E@_BPR=NS Z W^®5Á«SaTN`LNeReYB^TN`^[1®\d(BPYeRI'T?BP’LNT\Š‹S1MZ IKT?|aWA®N`MKLNW3PRBAeUW3BA@_O1TtPRIX`^WA® Z IXW]PYeRIKˆ?L\PYB Z

WR[\W]PYB^@W^

ÂXÃÄ3űÆ;Ç&Ä­ÈÉXűÊÌËÍ

ΫϋÐ'ϧÑAÒ(ÓYϋÔÐϳҫÕ1Ö×qØ­Ù/Ú;Û'Ü;ÝfÞ8ÝR×qÚ;ßáàáÝ3ÚaÕQâ“ã“äqåæ­Ð'Ý]ç/ç;Ý3Û'è]Ý]Ü/Ý éaÕQêëÌ×qç/è]ݓìÑAÚ/Ù;Ù1í“ë‹îÌÝ3ÜïðñNò8ñaó_îÌô/ë§í“Ú/õ“ôEîÌô/Ý­ö«÷Nø8ù\÷—Ù/ë§íqú§Ý3è î

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes

(5)

€ … Á«BP­OQeRPRIX`MKB’IKTtPReYS Z L?IbP&L?TNBEW^@O1TaPYIK©tL?BnV?eYS1ˆNO1ˆ?IbMKIXW]PYB’V5S1L?e&MbB;WoAWRBAO1L\c Z Bnd^PReYI5TNS1T—PYB^@_V5S1eYIKWAWA

k’LN`LNT?Bn=J[JV5SQPR=N>AWRB’TBAW3P&B^c\Ib|^Bn`^S1TN`^B^eYTNOQTtP&MKO¶W]PYeRLN`PRL?eYB’SaLMXO#W?eYBPa”US1LpW Z ^@_S1TtPReYS1TpW¬©tL?BŽMKO—^¢£¤Nž¦¥ ^›NŸ

!

Ÿ“™^šœ›J“ž±Ÿ^¡q

Z

SaT?T?B_L?T‡`^O

Z

eYB_O

Z

OQV?P#"MKO†`^S1TNW3PReYLN`“PYIbSaT

Z

B@_B;W3L?eYBAW

Z

BV?eRSaˆNOQˆNIbMKIµP$_VpSaL?eMbB;WEBc%A`^L\PRIKS1TpWEB^T

VpOQeqOQMKMb>AMbBa'&B

Z

^V?MKIKO1|1BB;W]PE`SaTNW]PYeRLNIµP("VNOQeRPRIKe

Z

BAWŽ`q=?S1IbcMKS\`^O1L\cWRL?eE`q=NO1©tL?B¶`MKLNW]PYB^e;®5O1IbTpW3I(©tLLNT‰@)A`^O1T?IXW3@_B

Z

IKW3PReYIbˆNL*l¯R™^šœ›J“ž Ÿ¡—¤8Ÿž³²©tL?I

Z

SaT?T?B—M+O1L\PRSaeRIXWYOPRIKS1T

Z O1`PRIKS1T*O1L\cv`^MbLpW]PYB^eqW^,&'BAW#@CB;W3LNeRB;W

Z

B"V?eRSaˆNOQˆNIbMKIµP$|1SaL%-

xaB^eYTNOQTtPUMKB#`q=?SaIµc Z O1`“PYIbSaT Z OQTpWUL?Tl`^MbLpW]PYB^e’WRS1TtP’Saˆ\PRBATtLNBAWUBATl`SaTNW3PReYL?IKWYOQTtP;®."VNO1e3PYIbe Z BV5SQPRBATtPRIKB^MXW Z BCiŽIbˆ?ˆpW

O Z OQV?PAWA® Z B;WŽ`q=pOQ@_VNW Z Bj‰OQeYª1SxWRL?eMbBC|1eqOQVN=?B Z B_`^S1T\¸pIµP Z BAWŽPYeYO1TNWRIµPYIbSaTNW^#dSaL?e`B;WE@CS Z >AMbB;W^®TNS1LNWŽIKTaPYeRS/-

Z L?IKWRS1TpW Z B;WUPYB^@_VNW Z OQeYe0^P’BP Z S1T?TNS1TNWnL?T?BC`^OQeqO1`PAeRIXWROQPRIKS1TV5S1L?eŽ`B^L?c1-±M2"?®5BP Z ^@_S1TtPYeRSaTNWUL?TNB#V?eYS1V?eYIKBP Z B

jlOQeYª1SxCŠ‹S1eRPRBa

3¿

;€

½

„/4

…

d¬eRSaˆNOQˆ?IKMKIµP$1®\d”OQeqOQMKMb>AMbIXWR@CBa®*56AV?MKIKO1|1BAWA®\W7A@OQTtPRIX©tL?B

Z

B`MKLNW3PRB^eqWA®?W3[\W3PR>^@_B;WeRBAVNOQeRPRIXW^

(6)

&¡q£^¥³šœ¥X“žÌ¥§™¤ Qš ¥³¤

¶­¶

A‚ ¿ À „Q¿

» A‚ » ;€

m?OaW3IX` 5nB pT?IµPYIbSaTNW EEEŽEEEEŽEEEEŽEEEE u

m?m Ž`A`L?eYeYB^TN`^BnT?B^PYWA®\dfeYB ?c\BAWA®5Á«SaT!N|1LNeYOQPRIKS1TNWA®tO1T

Z

o­L?TNW EEEEŽEEEE "

m? #’T\Š‹S1M

Z

IKT?|aWEEEEEŽEEEEŽEEEEŽEEEE $

m? &eqOQTN`q=NIbT?|CdfeYS\`BAWYWRBAW ŽEEEEŽEEEEŽEEEE $

m?m Á«=pOQT?|aIbT?|CPY=?B&%’IKB^˜&'«Á«MKLNW3PRB^e’G\B^@OQTtPRIX`^W#EŽEEEEŽEEEE(Ay

m?D <IKMKBAW EŽEEEEŽEEEEŽEEEEŽEEEE(;m

)*

¿ 4+§„ ¼-, §‚ » „1 » À/.

10

¿ 4§À2

23

€

k’@#ˆ?IK|1LNIµP][—IKT†<IbMKBAW­O1T Z USaT%-5nBPYB^eY@_IbT?IXWR@4&BP]˜&B^B^T‰Á«MKLNW]PYB^eqWrEEŽEEEE(^D

m  5'-±L?T\Š‹SaMZ IbT?| EEEEŽEEEEŽEEEEŽEEEE(5

5nBAWRIK|1TNW ŽEEEEŽEEEEŽEEEEŽEEEE(Au

D Á«MKLNW3PRBAeUUBP' 5’IXW3PReYIbˆ?L?PRB Z Á«SaTtPReYS1M5Š‹S1ePY=?B6#UT\Š‹SaMZ IbT?|—k’Mb|aS1eYIµPY=?@ EEŽEEEE(7"

(869 » ‚ ¿

~ƒ\~: 4+§€AÌ„

3‘¿

À » 4

!;

Dp <=NBŽd¬eRSaˆNOQˆ?IKMKIµP]["G\VNO1`^B EŽEEEEŽEEEEŽEEEE($

Dpm Á«MKLNW3PRBAe­@CB;O1WRL?eYBAWrEEEŽEEEEŽEEEEŽEEEE(A{

Dpm? <S1ªaB^To­S1L?PRIKT?| EŽEEEEŽEEEEŽEEEE m!

Dpm?m <eqOQTNWRIµPYIbSaT†Á«SaIbT<SaWYWŽEEEEŽEEEEŽEEEE m1m

Dpm? KKfOQT Z @_S1eYB6<EEŽEEEEŽEEEEŽEEEE m1m

=(>

 ¿@?1?

23A8

» €Cƒ

À 3 ƒ\‚7B ¿C

‚ ¿D?«» ‚/ ¼

@)

5? 5nB pT?IµPYIbSaT†OQT Z dfeYS1V5B^eRPRIKBAWSQŠfGtPYS1V?V?IKT?|<IK@CB;WEEŽEEEEŽEEEE mE

5?m jlOQeYª1Sx_dfeYS1V5B^eRP][ EEEŽEEEEŽEEEEŽEEEE mD

5? Á&O1LNWYOQM8h T Z BAVpBAT Z B^Tp`B‡EEŽEEEEŽEEEEŽEEEE mQu

F ¿

„4 €¿ €

(7)

c

a b

b a

A

C D B C D

A B

·IK|1LNeRB '¬Á&O1LNWRO1MOQT Z W3PRS\`q=NO1W3PRIX`ŽIbT Z B^V5B^T Z B^TN`^B

¶'( "¬

<=?B«O1Ib@7SQŠ\PY=?IXW'˜&S1eYª’IXWPYSU@OQªaB”PR=?B NeqW]P(W]PYB^VNW'PRS˜OQe Z WOU|aB^T?BAeYO1MPR=NB^S1eY[ŽSQŠN`SaTN`LNeReYB^TtP'j‰O1eRªaSx’dfeYS\`BAWYWRBAW

IKT?£Q¡“žÌ¥§£Qš³š ¡ ! Ÿ¡YŸ ! šQ¥§™q£šžÌ¥³¢Ÿ^(<=NBŽSaeRIK|1IKTNO1Mp@_SQPYIbxOQPRIKS1T—Š‹Sae&PR=?IXW­OQV?VNeRStO1`q=—IXW«PR=?B Z IXOQ|aT?SaWRIKW«SQŠ Z IXW]PYeRIKˆ?L\PYB Z

WR[\W]PYB^@W¯§WRB^B $?®Q{‹²J'h TCWRLN`q=_W3[\W3PRBA@_WA®QO1WPY=?B^[¶OQeYB¬Š‹SaL?T Z IbT¶PRBAMbB;`S1@_@¶L?T?IX`^OPYIbSaTNWT?BP]˜&S1eYª\W^®/ЧO1L?MbPYW(˜­IKMbMJPYeRIK|1|aB^e

O1MKO1eR@W(O1Wf˜«BAMbM?OaW”SQPY=?B^e(ЧO1L?MµPqW”B^MXWRB^˜­=?BAeRBIKT_PR=?BUWR[\W]PYB^@<=NBUW3L?V5B^eYxJIKWRS1eqW˜­IbMKM?PY=?B^T_SaˆNW3BAeRxaB­W]PYeRB;OQ@WSQŠOQMXOQeY@

BAx1BATaPqWU`Sa@_IbT?|IKTŠ‹eYS1@ Z I8B^eYB^TtP’MKS\`^OPYIbSaTNWA®?˜­IµPY=†T?S|1MKS1ˆpOQMPYB^@_VpSaeYO1MS1e Z BAeRIKT?|D'”SaT?MK["OQMXOQeY@WŠ‹eYS1@ PY=?B#WYOQ@_B

WRB^TpW3Sae­˜­IbMKM'ˆ5BPYSQPYO1MbMK[SaeZ B^eYB Z ˜­IµPY=†eRB;W3V5BA`PUPRS_PY=?B#MKS\`^O1M]MKS1|aIK`AOQM`^MbS\`qªES1Š(PR=NOQPnW3BATNWRS1e;fxaB^TtPYW’IbT Z I8B^eYB^TtP

MKS\`^OQPRIKS1TNW¶OQeYBS1e

Z

BAeRB

Z

S1T?MK[vIµŠUPY=?B^eYBB^c\IKW3PYWCO‰ªJT?S˜­TŒ`AOQLNWYOQM&`q=NOQIKT*ˆ5BP]˜&B^BAT*PR=NB^@*GJIbTp`BSaT?MK[–PY=?B‡£šb£Q¡“¢#

O1eRBŽS1ˆpW3BAeRxOQˆNMbBa®1PY=?BAWRB`^OQLpWRO1MbIbPRIKBAWOQeYBŽT?SQP

Z

IKeRB;`“PRMK[—SaˆNW3BAeRxO1ˆ?MbBnˆ?L\P’O1eRBŽVNOQeRPSQŠ'PY=?BE@_S

Z

B^MLNWRB

Z

ЋS1e

Z

IXOQ|aT?SaWRIKWA

<=NB Z IXOQ|1TNSaWRIKWPqO1WRª"IXW’PRS Z B Z LN`^BPR=NB#MKIbªaB^MK[`AOQLNWRBAW­S1Š”PR=?BCOQMXOQeY@W^®\PY=NOPŽIKWA®pPR=?B £›\šœžÌJ'&|aIbxaB^T‰OVpOQeRPRIXOQM'SaeZ B^e

VpOP3PYB^eYT#S1ŠpOQMXOQeY@W^®Q`^S1TNW3PReYLN`“PPR=NBD/q“¥^šbŸ­^™qŸ^¤5£¡“¥“®1I¦Ba'PY=?BVNOQeRPRIXOQMJS1e Z BAeVNOQP3PYB^eYTNWSQŠ?ЧO1L?MµPqW]£fPY=NOP”eYBAWRVpB;`“P

PY=?BªJT?S˜­T†`^O1LNWRO1MbIbPRIKBAWIKTPR=NBW3[\W3PRB^@®5OQT Z nPR=NOQP’Bc\V?MXOQIKTPR=?BSaˆNWRB^eYx/OQPRIKS1TNWA®\I¦Ba¬˜­=?StW3BOa`“PRLpOQMS\`^`^L?eYeRBATN`B

˜&S1LNMZ =NO/x1B’PReYIb|a|1B^eYB Z PY=?BEVNOPRPRBAeRT"SQŠO1MKO1eR@W«eRB;`B^IKx1B Z PR=?BAT®NT Z PR=NB¶¢ /“ž¬šµ¥1Ÿ^šEOQ@_S1T?|#PR=?B;W3BŽVNO1e3PYIKO1M5Sae Z B^e

WY`BATNOQeYIKSaWfS1ŠŠ§OQL?MbPYWAf<=?BŽ@_BAO1WRL?eYBUŠ‹Sae¬PY=?IKW&MKIbªaB^MKIb=NStS Z =pO1W«PRS¶ˆpBE|1IKx1BAT—ˆJ[OQT"O#V?eYIbSaeRI5V?eYS1ˆNO1ˆ?IbMKIbP][C@_B;O1WRL?eRBnS1T

PY=?B Z I5BAeRBATtPV5SaWYWRIbˆ?MKB?£Q¡“žÌ¥§£Qš³š ! Ÿ^¡RŸ ! ¡“›\¤?“

<=?B_`eYLN`IXOQMVpSaIbTtPIXW’PY=NOPET?BAIµPY=?B^eŽPR=NB Y£Qš”žÌ¥³¢ŸnT?S1eŽPY=?B Y£Qš”“ž±£Qž±ŸnS1ŠfPR=?B_WR[JW3PRBA@OQeYB¶O/xOQIKMXOQˆ?MKB PY=?B

PYB^@_V5S1eqOQM”W]PYS\`q=NO1W3PRIX`#VNeRS\`B;WRWRBAWnPYeRB;OPRB Z IKTlPY=?BMKIµPYB^eqOPRLNeRBC|1BAT?B^eqOQMKMb[eYBA©tL?IKeRBCˆ5SQPR='_<=NIKWEIXWnPR=?B—`AO1WRBCO1MKWRSŠ‹Sae

@_S Z BAMKW Z BAWRIb|aT?B Z PYSeRB^¸NBA`P«`SaTN`LNeReYB^TN`^[#OQT Z T?S1T%- Z B^PRB^eY@_IbTNIKWR@®aWRLN`q=—O1WUŸ^¤5Ÿ^¡R£šœ¥ ;Ÿ ! !pžA™"?£“žÌ¥§™ ­Ÿ^ž¦¡“¥$##Ÿ^žÌ

¯§B1|N %‹²“®&pž A™"?£qž¦¥§™('\¡Y£¤?“¥³ž¦¥¤)/“ž Ÿ¢¶¯Z B#k’MµŠ§O1eRS 5\®pu*‹²­O1T Z q£^¥³šœ¥X“žÌ¥§™"£›\ž¢£ž £¯§oUO1ˆ?IKT+ * GJBA|aO1MKO

5\® 1u?® ",³²®aB^PY`1.-l£Q¡/10 ! Ÿq™^¥Xq¥Q¤25¡ ;™qŸ“q^Ÿq®\WRB^B3 *¦®JOQeYIKWRBŠ‹eYS1@ PR=?B’OaW3[JTN`q=NeRSaT?S1LNW(VpOQeqOQMKMbBAMN`Sa@CV5SaWRIbPRIKS1T_SQŠ

¯Z IXWR`^eRB^PRBEPRIK@_B;²­jlOQeYª1Sx—`q=NO1IbTNWA®?[JIKB^MZ IbTN|—OQ|aO1IbT†O_V?eYS\`B;WRW˜­IbPR=†|aMbSaˆNOQMW3PYOQPRBOQT Z PRIK@CBa&<=NBMbS\`^O1MPReqOQTpW3IbPRIKS1T

VNeRSaˆNOQˆ?IKMKIµPYIbB;WOQeYB_`q=NSaWRB^TlTNS1T%-Z BPYB^eY@_IbT?IXW3PRIX`^OQMKMK[1®Oa`^`^S1e Z IbTN|PYS‰W3Sa@CB!Dšœ¥§™4_PR=pOP@O/[‰ˆ5BeYO1T Z S1@_IK´^B Z IKTvIµPqW

PYL?eYTU<=?B#@_S Z BAM'˜&B Z BAx1B^MKS1V=?BAeRBa®pIXW’O ! ¥X“žÌ¡“¥^›\ž Ÿ ! Q¤5Ÿ%5'=?S˜&B^x1BAeA®NS1T?BBATN`SaL?TtPRBAeYWPY=?B¶O1ˆpSxaBW]PYeYOQPRIp`^OQPRIKS1T

OaW”˜&B^MKM+'IbT_ЧOa`“PA®1PR=?BAeRB’IKWfO1T_L?V?V5B^e¬MXO/[1BAe&6#PR=?BU`^MbLpW]PYB^efT?B^P76¶`SaTtPReYS1MXWPR=?BULNT\Š‹S1MZ IKT?|#OQMK|1SaeRIbPR=N@‘S1TCPR=NBUS1eYIb|aIbTpOQM

TNBP98 ˆJ[lWRB^MKBA`PRIKT?|"PR=?BVNO1e3PYIKO1M(S1e Z B^eESQŠ&V?eYS1ˆNO1ˆ?IbMKIXW]PYIK`C`q=?S1IX`B;W^®O1T Z O"MKS˜&B^eŽMKO/[aB^e;®8PR=NOQPES1Š:8 IµPqW3BAMµŠ]®˜­=?B^eYB

PY=?BAWRB`q=?S1IX`B;W­OQeYBn@O Z B1®NOa`^`^S1e Z IbTN|PRS Z IKW3PReYIbˆNL\PRIKS1TNW|aIbxaB^TˆJ[PR=?B`^L?eYeRBATaP­MKS\`^OQMW3PYOQPRB;W^

·Ib|aL?eRB W3=?S˜UWCO¨`S1@_@_S1T d(BPReYIT?BP—WRIµPYLNOPYIbSaT®f˜­=?StW3BV?eYS1ˆNO1ˆ?IKMbIXW]PYIK`PReYBAOQPR@_B^TtP`^O1LNW3B;W#VNeRSaˆ?MbBA@W;; k

TpOPRLNeYO1MNeqW3P(O1V?V?eYSaO1`q=PRSŽeYO1T Z S1@_IK´^IKT?|UPY=?BVpStWRWRIKˆ?MbB&ˆ5B^=NO/xJIKS1eqWS1T#PR=?BMKBгP”=NO1T Z WRIZ B&IXWPRSEO1WYW3IK|1T#V?eRSaˆNOQˆNIbMKIµPYIbB;W

<:=>?<A@>?<7B>?<AC

PYS‡BAO1`q= PYeYO1TNW3IbPRIKS1T

<ED

Z B^T?S1PRBAWPR=?B‰VNeRSaˆNOQˆ?IKMKIµP][‡PY=NOPFC˜­IKMbMnˆpB‰PR=?B†T?B^cJP—PReqOQTNWRIbPRIKS1T PRS‡ˆ5B

peRB Z ¨<=NB^TŒ˜&B=pO/x1BPYS–eYBA©tL?IKeRB—PR=NOQP

<:=GH<A@IGJ<7B!GJ<ACLKNM

O1WYW3L?@_B"˜­IµPY=?S1L\P_MKSaWYW#S1ŠU|1B^TNB^eqOQMKIµP][–PR=NOQP

<:=!GO<A@3GO<PBGO<ACRQSM

®OQT Z PY=NOPOQMKM

<:T

WEOQeYBVpStW3IbPRIKx1BaŽ<=NIKWŽOQV?VNeRStO1`q=†[JIbBAMZ WnOV?eRSaˆNOQˆNIbMKIµP]["Š‹S1e¶^Ÿ ›NŸ^¤5™qŸ

eqOPY=?B^efPR=NO1TŠ‹S1eE™Q¤5™^›\¡“¡RŸ^¤Nž¡“›\¤aW'`^S1TNWRIZ B^e”PY=?B’eYL?T˜­IbPR=VU*O1T ZW ®JI¦Ba'PY=?B’B;©tL?IbxO1MbBATN`B’`^MKOaWRW¬S1eUž¦¡R£a™YŸfŠ‹S1eY@_B Z

ˆJ["PR=?BP]˜«S—IKTtPRBAeRMKBAO/xJIKT?|aWXU W O1T ZYW U­nGJIKTN`Bˆ5SQPY=l`q=?SaIK`^BAWUO1eRB@O Z B#IKT Z B^V5B^T Z B^TtPRMK[SQŠfS1TNB#OQT?S1PR=?BAe#¯‹IKT†PY=?B

PYB^eY@_IbT?SaMbSa|1[†ˆ5B^MKS˜®PR=NB_P]˜«S‡™šµ›Jqž Ÿ^¡qnOQeYB_IbT Z B^V5B^T Z BATtPq²“®S1T?B_˜&S1L?MZ =?S1V5BCPR=NOQPPR=?BSae Z BAeESQŠ.UOQT ZZW Z StB;W

TNSQP­@OP3PYB^e'”=?S˜&B^x1BAeA®aPR=NBV?eRSaˆNOQˆNIbMKIµP][—PR=NOQP.[U OQT Z PY=?B^T W ŽIXW

< =I\ < B

< B G]< C >

^

îÌô/ݔݠé/×qØ­Ù;ßáݔàáÛ×qßáÛ¦íÜ/àáÛÌè]Ú/Û¦ÛÌÝ3Ünàáç`_åa³ì

(8)

&¡q£^¥³šœ¥X“žÌ¥§™¤ Qš ¥³¤ 5

b c

d b

b

d b c

d

A B

d a

b

B A

B A

B A C

C a

d

b

d b

B

C A

d c

A C B

B B A

A b d

b a

c b a

·IK|1LNeRBm!'”<=?BMKIK@CIbPYOQPRIKS1TNWS1ŠPY=?Bˆ?eqOQTN`q=NIbT?|CV?eYS\`BAWYWW3BA@OQTtPRIX`^W­O1T

Z

PY=?BLNWRBSQŠV?eRB -±WRB^MKBA`PRIKS1T¨¯§WRB^B $³²

˜­=?BAeRB;O1WA OQT Z PR=NB^TXE|1IKx1BAW

<&= \ <7B

< = G+< @

<=?B©tL?S1PRIKB^TtPSQЬPY=?BAWRBCP]˜«SV?eYS1ˆNO1ˆ?IKMbIbPRIKBAWŽIXWEL?TJˆpSaL?T Z B Z O1T Z `AOQT–PYOQªaB£Q¤ ¶VpStW3IbPRIKx1B_xOQMKL?B PR=?IXWE@_S Z B^M(PY=tLpW

T?BAIµPY=?B^eneRB;W3V5BA`PYWA®NT?SaeU@OQªaBAW­LNWRBS1Š]®?PR=NBIbT Z B^V5B^T Z B^TN`^B#SQŠ(PY=?BP]˜&S—`S1@_V5S1T?BATtPYWA«• =?BAT‰MKStSaªJIbT?|_Š‹Sae’O`]PReYL?MK[

MKS\`^OQM@_S Z BAM“®\˜«BŽ=NO/xaB’PYSCˆ5B^˜OQeYB1®J=?S˜&B^xaB^e;®aS1ŠT?SaT%-±MbS\`^O1M8B%8BA`“PqWIbTNB^xJIµPqOQˆ?MKBEIbTd(BPYeRIT?B^PYW'”S1T"PR=?BEeYIb|a=tP&=NO1T Z

WRIZ BSQŠ·IK|1L?eYB 1®?OCV?MXO1`^BŽIXW­O ZNZ B Z ®Qg]S1IKT?IbTN|¶PY=?BEP]˜&S¶VNO1e3PqW^”’S˜®JPR=?B Z BAVpBAT Z BATN`B /IKT Z B^V5B^T Z B^TN`^BSQŠ O1T Z

Z BAVpBAT Z W­SaTPY=?B@OQeYªJIbT?|_S1Š'”IµŠŽIXW­B^@_V\P][a®\PR=?B Z IKWY`LNWYWRIbSaTO1ˆpSxaBneYB^@OQIKTNWxOQMKIZ SQPY=?B^eY˜­IKWRB1®JPY=?B^eYBIXW­OQT

IKT\¸NL?BATN`BnSQŠ SaT_PR=?BnVpStWRWRIKˆ?IbMKIbPRIKBAW’¯ÌOQT Z =?B^TN`^BUV?eYS1ˆNO1ˆ?IKMbIbPRIKBAWq²Š‹S1e ®\OQT Z xJIX`BUxaB^eqWROD''|aIbxaB^TCPR=?BnS\`^`LNeReYB^TN`^B­SQŠ

®aPY=?B’VNeRSaˆNOQˆ?IKMKIµP][CSQŠ IKTN`^eRB;O1WRBAW”Š‹eYS1@

<<2GR<

PYS

<

(h TPR=?BŽSQPY=?B^e Z IKeRB;`“PRIKS1T'®a|aIbxaB^T_PR=NB’S\`^`^L?eReYB^Tp`B

S1Š ®5PR=?BCV?eYS1ˆNO1ˆ?IbMKIbP][SQŠrIKWnB^xaB^T

M

¯§’SQPRB 'U<=?IXW’IXWnO—V?eRSaˆNOQˆNIbMKIKW3PRIX`xJIKB^˜rS1T†˜­=pOPnIXWŽ`^OQMKMKB Z ™ ¤q›Jq¥Q¤"IKT

$±

·?Sae’@_S Z B^MKIbTN|"`SaTN`LNeReYB^TtPUˆ5B^=NO/xJIKS1e;®5OTpOPRLNeYO1M'Š‹eqOQ@_B^˜&S1eYªIXWn|1IKx1B^T†ˆJ[¨›\¤ Qš! ¥³¤_W3BA@_O1TtPRIX`^WULpW3IKT?|;™q™›\¡

¡RŸ^¤5™qŸ ­Ÿ^žÌ¡“¥f¤8Ÿž¦¬h TPY=?BMKIµPYB^eqOPRLNeRBa®JPR=?B;W3BO1eRBLNWRLNO1MbMK[`SaTNW3PReYLN`“PYB Z LNWRIbT?| ^¡R£Q¤5™"J¥³¤ 38¡A™qŸqŸ&Š‹S1MKMbS˜­IKT?| tm[

WRB^BOQMXWRS 7"t®Nm1y\®Nm1m\® 1y±7”c?OQ@_V?MKBAW«Š‹S1e­ˆNeYO1TN`q=?IKT?|#V?eYS\`B;WRWOQeYBEW3=?S˜­T"IbT"PR=NBnP]˜&SCVNOQeRPYW&SQŠ(·Ib|aL?eRBm!'(IKTˆpS1PR=

VNO1e3PqW^®aPR=NBnˆ5B^=NO/xJIKS1e«SQŠPR=NBnd(BPYeRI5T?B^P&SaTPR=?BnMbB^гP&=pOQT Z WRIZ B’IXW&eRBAV?eRB;W3BATtPRB Z ˆJ[_OQTOa`[\`MKIX`UT?B^P&SaT_PR=?BŽeRIK|1=tP ˜&B

˜­IKMbM`S1@_@_B^TtPUSaTPY=?B@_BA`q=NO1T?IKWR@ S1Š'PR=NIKWU`^S1TNW3PReYLN`PRIKS1TˆpBAMbS˜

h TZ $1¦®NOaW­˜&B^MKM'O1W Day±®NVNeRSaˆNOQˆ?IKMKIKW3PRIX`ŽL?T\Š‹S1M

Z

IKT?|aW­Š‹S1e6 -±WYOŠ‹BŽL?TtPRIK@_B

Z

d(BPYeRITNBPYW’˜«BAeRBEIKTtPReYS

Z

LN`B

Z

ˆpO1WRB

Z

S1T

¡ Q›\žÌ¥³¤¢Ÿq£/“›\¡RŸ“<=?IXW”˜&S1eYª\W(˜­IµPY=CTNS

Z

I—`^L?MµP][¶IbTCPY=?BU`SaTaPYBcJPfSQŠ·?eYB^B’Á«=?SaIK`^BUUB^PYWA®1˜­=?BAeRB­OQMKMN`q=?SaIK`^BAW(MKBAO Z -

IKT?|_PRS_ˆ?eqOQTp`q=?IbTN|¶ˆ5B^=NO/xJIKS1e­OQeYBEMbS\`AOQM8PRSCPY=?BV?MXO1`B;W^”·NS1e­|1BAT?B^eqOQM8T?B^PYWA®?=?S˜&B^xaB^e;®1PY=?BT?B^B Z Š‹Sae­eRB -¦TNS1eY@_O1MbIK´^IKT?|

PY=?B¶eYS1L?PRIKT?|V?eYS1ˆpOQˆ?IKMbIbPRIKBAWUŠ‹S1eEOQeYˆ?IbPReqOQeY[T?B^PEW3PReYLN`“PYL?eYBAWUeYBAWRL?MbPnIKTlIK@_VpSae3PqOQTtPneYBAW3PReYIK`PRIKS1TNWUPRSPR=?B_OQV?VNeRStO1`q=SQŠ

$*±<S‰W3BAB_WRS1@_B_SQŠ&PR=NB Z I`^L?MbPRIKBAWA®`SaTNWRIZ BAeEPR=?BMbB^гP=NOQT Z WRIZ BSQŠ­·IK|1LNeRB—m\h±P#W3=?S˜UWOWR@OQMKMfd(BPReYIfT?B^P

8 OQT Z OV?eYB Nc‰SQЬIbPYWŽˆ?eqOQTN`q=NIbT?|"V?eYSJ`^BAWYW^oUS1L?|a=?Mb[†WRVpB;OQªJIKT?|N®BAx1B^eY[†`L?eYeYB^TtPnSae’Š‹L\PYL?eYB¶PYS1ªaB^T‰IKTlPY=?B_T?BPEIXW

eYB^V?eYBAWRB^TtPYB Z ˆJ[‰O`IKeY`^MbB¶IbT–PR=?BCˆ?eqOQTN`q=NIbT?|"V?eYSJ`^BAWYW’TNBPA®O1T ZlZ I8B^eYB^TtPES1L\PY|1S1IKT?|OQeq`^WneRBAV?eRB;W3BATtP’PR=NB Z I8B^eYB^TtP

V5SaWYW3IKˆ?IKMbIbPRIKBAWnPYS`^S1TNWRL?@_B#PY=NOPŽPRSaª1BATUS˜®ˆ?eqOQTp`q=?IbTN|SQŠ&OQeq`^WnIbTlPR=?B_L?T\Š‹SaMZ IbT?|@O/[†`S1eYeYBAWRVpSaT Z PRSO1`PRLNO1M

`q=?SaIK`^BAW PY=?IKW’IKW­PR=?B#`AO1WRBEŠ‹S1e­PY=?B#O1eY`AW­MbB;O/xJIbT?|! J®NSae­Š‹S1e­PY=?B#`q=?SaIK`^BˆpB^P]˜«BAB^T(U OQT Z(W W3BAB^TŠ‹eYS1@#"J$’S˜«BAx1B^e;®

PY=?B^eYB#IXWŽT?S2R`q=?S1IX`B%ES1Š"ˆ5BP]˜&B^B^T‰PR=?B Z I5BAeRBATaP UWA®W3IKTN`^B¶OQMKMSQŠ”PR=NSaWRB#eYB^V?eYBAWRB^TtPUPY=?BC`^S1TNWRL?@_@OPYIbSaT†SQŠfPY=?B

WYOQ@_BPYS1ª1BAT‡SQŠ"JlGJSp®”O1WYW3IK|1T?IKT?|†V?eYS1ˆpOQˆ?IKMbIbPRIKBAWPRS†PY=?B Z I8B^eYB^TtP#ˆ?eqOQTp`q=?BAWS1Š"`eYBAOPYBAWPRBA`q=NT?IK`AOQM&O1W˜&B^MKM&OaW

`^S1TN`^B^V\PYLNOQM Z I—`LNMµPYIbB;W^­¯‹h TCЧOa`“PA®aPR=NB­eRIK|1=tPf=NO1T Z W3IZ B­SQŠ·Ib|aL?eYB­mEWR=?S˜UW”O1T_OQP3PYB^@_V\PfPYSW3SaMbxaB«PY=?BAWRB­V?eYS1ˆ?MKB^@WA®

WRB^BnˆpBAMbS˜’²vknW«O¶`SaTNW3B;©tL?B^TN`^B1®1PR=?BEOQV?VNeRStO1`q=_eRBA@OQIKTNWfMKIb@_IbPRB Z PRSCW3LNˆ5`^MKOaWRWRBAW¬SQŠd(BPYeRI5T?BPqW^®tS1L?PYWRIZ BnSQŠ˜­=?IX`q=

IbPUIKWUT?SQPUOQVNV?MbIX`^O1ˆ?MKB1

<=?BV?eYBAWRB^TtPnO1e3PYIK`^MbB¶W3=?S˜UW­PR=NOQP’PR=NB Z I—`L?MbPRIKBAWŽOQT Z eYBAW3PReYIX`“PRIKS1TpW’`^O1T†ˆpB¶Sx1BAeY`^S1@_BEIµŠ”PY=?B#ˆ?eqOQTp`q=?IbTN|V?eRS/-

`^BAWYW¶WRB^@OQTtPYIK`AW˜­IbPR=ŒIbPYW#PRSaª1BAT%-¦SaeRIKB^TtPYB Z xJIbBA˜ IKW¶eRBAV?MXO1`B Z ˆJ[vO ™šœ›J“ž Ÿ¡ 0A¥§Ÿ&%”*Á«MbLNW3PRBAe¶VNeRS\`B;WRWRBAW˜«BAeRB peYW3P

(9)

VNeRSaVpStW3B Z IKTO ám ",±<=?B_L?T\Š‹SaMZ IKT?|†WRB^@OQTtPRIX`^WESaˆ\PYO1IbTNB Z Š‹eRSa@ IµP˜­IKMbM”=NB^eYBCˆ5BLNWRB Z IbTv`SaTNW3PReYLN`“PYIbT?|ˆ5SQPR=¨PY=?B

TNBP«LNT\Š‹S1MZ IKT?|¶O1T Z PR=?BnV?eYS1ˆNO1ˆ?IbMKIbP][¶@_BAOaW3LNeRB;W^(<=?B^eYBUIXWfT?SCW]PYeRLp`“PRLNeYO1MNeYBAW3PReYIK`PRIKS1T_S1TPY=?BUŠ‹SaeR@ SQŠPY=?B’TNBPA®JT?Sae

O1TJ[ˆpSaL?T Z B Z T?BAWYWUOaWRWRL?@_V\PRIKS1T PR=?BO1V?V?eYSaO1`q="OQV?V?MKIKBAWPYS†£Q¤ Žd(BPReYI'’BPA

h TCW3PRL Z [JIbT?|ŽPY=?BU`MKLNW3PRB^e”WRB^@OQTtPYIK`AW(=?B^eYB1®˜&B˜­IbMKMNWRB^B&ˆpBAMbS˜ŒPR=NOQP¬`MKLNW]PYB^e(L?T\Š‹SaMZ IbT?|tW(T?B^B Z PYSEˆpBU`^S1TNW3PReYLN`“PYB Z

LNT Z B^eWRS1@_B_`S1TtPYeRSaMbMKIbTN|V5S1MKIK`^[1®˜­=?IX`q=l˜­IKMKM”ˆpB_|1IKx1BATlˆJ[PR=NB†™^šœ›J“ž Ÿ¡C¤5Ÿ^ž”IbTtPYeRS Z LN`^B Z ˆpBAMbS˜#<=NB_WRB^@O1TaPYIK`AW

PY=?B^T–MbB;O Z WŽIKT–O"TNOPYL?eqOQM˜&O/[PRSO"V?eRSaˆNOQˆNIbMKIKW3PRIX`@_S Z BAM”S1T†PY=?BW3VNOa`B¶SQŠ«`^S1TN`^L?eReYB^TtPŽeRL?TpW^®˜­IbPR=¨OxOQeYIKBP][SQŠ

V5SaWYWRIbˆ?IKMKIµPYIbB;WŠ‹SaeeqOQT Z S1@_IK´^IKT?|UMKSJ`AOQMKMb[IKTNWRIZ B¬PY=?B&`^MbLpW]PYB^eqW Š‹Sae'PY=?IXW^®Q˜&B¬˜­IKMKM\V?eRB;W3BATtP'P]˜&S’Bc?O1@CVNMbB;W'S1Š¥«Ÿ^š!

`^S1TNW3PReYLN`PRIKS1TNWPY=NOPŽ[JIbBAMZ V?eYS1ˆpOQˆ?IKMbIbPRIKBAW’eRB^¸NBA`PRIKT?|d(BPYeRIT?BP Z [JTNOQ@_IX`^WUO1T Z MKS\`^OQMKIbP][1­<=?B6pTNOQM`S1TtPYeRIKˆ?L\PYIbSaTNW

=NB^eYBU˜­IbMKMpPR=?BAT—ˆpBnPR=NB’IKTaPYeRS Z Lp`“PRIKS1T—O1T Z W3PReYLN`“PYL?eqOQMp`q=pOQeqO1`“PYB^eYIb´;OPYIbSaT¶S1Šfš1¥§™q£š5“ž 8¥³¤ ž¦¥³¢Ÿ““®JOQT Z PY=?B’VNeRSJSQŠ

S1ŠO_W3PReYS1T?|j‰O1eRªaSxCd¬eRSaVpBAe3P][a

<=?BVNO1VpBAeUIXW­S1eY|aO1T?Ib´AB Z O1WŠ‹SaMbMKS˜UWA«GJBA`PRIKS1TlmCeYB^xJIKB^˜UW­ˆNOaW3IX`ET?S1PYOPYIbSaTNW­OQT Z†Z B NTNIµPYIbSaTNW IbTlG\BA`“PYIbSaT ?®N˜&B

Z IKWY`LNWYWfO1T Z_Z B^xaB^MKS1VCdB^PReYINT?B^PfL?T\Š‹SaMZ IKT?|tW”L?T Z BAe«`^MbLNW3PRBAe¬WRB^@OQTtPRIX`^WA<=NB Z IXW]PYeRIKˆ?L\PYB Z TNOPYL?eYB­SQŠ8PR=?B­LNT\Š‹S1MZ IKT?|

O1Mb|aS1eYIµPY=?@$MKBAO Z WULpW­PRSIbTtPReYS Z LN`^B#OQT‰O1L\c\IbMKIKO1eR[`SaTNW]PYeRLp`“PRIKS1T'®?PR=NB"™šµ›Jqž Ÿ^¡¤5Ÿ^ž IbPn˜­IKMbMWR`q=?B Z L?MKB1®pŠ‹eRSa@$PY=?BPYS1V

MXO/[1BAeA®?PR=?B¶S1e Z B^eUS1Š”IbTNWRV5BA`“PYIbSaTŒ¯Dšµ¥§™%^²’SQŠ”PY=?B#`MKLNW3PRBAeYW’IbT†PY=?B#MKS˜&B^e­MXO/[1B^e’T?BP;®5O1T Z PR=JLNWUPR=?B¶S1e Z B^e’IbT†˜­=?IX`q=

PY=?SaWRB­@OQªaB«PY=?B^IKefMKS\`^OQMp`q=?S1IX`B;W^kUMKMNV5S1MKIK`^IbB;W(Š‹S1e Z IbeYBA`PRIKT?|ŽPR=?BULNT\Š‹S1MZ IKT?|V?eYSJ`^BAWYW”`^O1TCˆ5BUSaˆ\PYO1IbT?B Z O1WfO peRIKT?|

WRBA©tL?BATN`B%_S1ŠPR=NOQP¶xJIbeRPRLpOQM¬TNBP @CSaeRBASx1BAeA®IµP_OQMKMbS˜UWEPYSlW3PReYLN`“PYL?eRB—PR=?BWRVNOa`B—S1ŠV5S1MKIX`IKBAW¶˜­IµPY=*O†V?eYS1ˆNO1ˆ?IbMKIbP][

@_B;O1WRL?eRBn`S1TpW3IXW]PYB^TtP˜­IµPY=—PR=NSaWRBnLNWRB Z Š‹S1e&PR=?BŽMKSJ`AOQM8`q=?S1IX`B;W^(<=?BŽV?eYS1ˆNO1ˆ?IbMKIXW]PYIK`’@CS Z BAM8IKW Z BAx1B^MKS1V5B Z IbTGJBA`PRIKS1T

D GJBA`PRIKS1TA5—IKTtPReYS Z LN`B;WnW3PRSaV?V?IKT?|—PYIb@_BAWO1T Z VNeRSxaBAW­PY=?B_W]PYeRSaT?|"j‰O1eRªaSxdfeYS1V5B^eRP][1®O1T Z GJB;`“PYIbSaT–u"B^T Z WnPY=?B

VpOQV5B^e­˜­IbPR=†W3Sa@_BE`^S1@_@_B^TtPYW­O1T Z S1L\PYMbSJS1ª\WA

%&'( *) &

•¨Bˆ5B^|1IKT¨˜­IµPY=vPR=?BˆNOaW3IX` Z B pT?IµPYIbSaTNWŽPR=pOP˜­IKMbMfˆ5BLNWRB Z PR=NeRSaL?|1=?SaL\PA! "$# Z B^T?S1PRB;WŽPR=?B—WRBPS1Šn¤  ¤8Ÿt£ž¦¥

IKTtPRBA|1B^eqWA®pOQT Z " PR=NOQPnS1Š”PR=?B` “¥³žÌ¥0ŸŽIbTtPYB^|1BAeYW &%% IXW’PR=?B_W3B^PnS1Š’¯§OQMKM³²­IKTaPYB^|aB^eqW^Ž·?S1eŽOWRBP('® Z B^TNSQPRB#PR=?BCW3B^P

S1Š”@#L?MbPRI-±WRBPqW*),+-'/.0 "!##Sx1BAe1'OaW32546'87 &B^P39;:<'n·NS1e=)>:?2@4A'87“®˜­eYIµPYB(9;:B) I)C4D9E71FHG PY=?B

“›[ Q¡“žSQŠ)¹IKWPY=?BWRBP3IKJ

<:<

4L)=7NMLOQP

Q,R

9TSK9*:<);Ua

h±Š=VXW/'ZY[' IXWO–ˆNIbTNO1eR[‡eYB^MXOPYIbSaTŒSxaB^e'®«MKBP\V]^CMLOQP

Q_R 4Q`

>La 7\S

a

Vb`cU†OQT Z V a MLOQP

QdR

`eS

a

Vb`cU ˆJ[

B^cJPRB^TpW3IKS1T®”IbŠ1f@W,'®«˜­eRIbPRBV

f MLOQP

Qhg*i=j=k V a

·NS1eO‰ˆ?IKTNO1eR[‡eYB^MXOPYIbSaTHVlW,'mY&'® Z B^T?S1PRBO1WCVon—PY=?B

eYB¸pBc\IbxaBEPReqOQTNWRIbPRIKx1B`MKSaWRL?eYBSQŠV OQT Z OaWpVNqŒPY=?B#IKeYeRB^¸NBc\IKx1BVNO1e3P*VNqM OrP

Q

Vonts

R

4D9

>

9E71Su9;:?'!U#SQŠVnUk ­Ÿ^žÌ¡“¥

¤8Ÿž&¯‹˜­IbPR= £Q¡R™ %¬Ÿ^¥["\ž§3²’IKWnO_PRL?VNMbB¶SQŠ”PR=NBŠ‹S1eY@S8

Q

4wv

>yx >Lz >

)=7$UBAeRBa®v

Q

v;48{7­IXWnOW3B^P’SQŠfV?MXO1`^BAWUO1T Z

x QHx

48{7&O¶W3B^P«SQŠ'PReqOQTNWRIµPYIbSaTNW&W3LN`q=—PR=NOQP|v{}

x Q~

®\OQT Z v[

x

IXWHpT?IµPYBK€a”k’W&LNWRLNOQM¦®tPR=?B N|1LNeRB;Wf=?BAeRBŽW3=?S˜

VNMKOa`BAWOaW&`^Ibeq`MKBAWO1T Z PYeYO1TNWRIµPYIbSaTNWO1W&eRB;`“PqOQT?|aMbB;W^(·?L?eRPR=NB^e;®

z

+-4L4wvlY

x

7?4

x

Y8v*7 7‚.ƒ " # IKW«PY=?B£¡R™ %¬Ÿ¥"Jž

Š‹LNTN`“PYIbSaT—<=?BW3B^P8„†SQŠ£¡R™nS1Š:8 IKW|aIbxaB^T–ˆt[[„CMLOQP

Qmz

]^ 4… "$7 Š‹S1eOT?S Z B*9†:H4wv‡

x

7®WRBP=ˆ‰9;M OrP

Q „ ]^

9 ®

9 ˆ*M OrP

Q „ 9

®(OQT

Z ˆ 9 ˆTM OQP

Q ˆ 9

R

9U3!9 ˆ "k¹TNBP 8 Q 4Qv

>Lx >yz > ) # 7EW3Lp`q=–PY=NOP

z

PYO1ª1BAW(G†O1T Z M

O1WIbPYWSaT?MK[

xO1MbL?B;W^®pIKWn`^O1MbMKB

Z

!

¥³¤8£¡

˜«B#˜­IbMKMTNSQPRB#S1e

Z

IbTpOQeY[—T?BPqW’OaW8

Q

4Qv

>Lx > „ > ) # 7­•–B¶˜­eRIbPRBTŠ|‹CO1T

Z

‹uŠŒŠ‹SaeUPY=?B

@¶L?MbPRI-±WRBPqWŠ|‹

>

‹EŠH:?254

x

7US1ЬIbTNV?L\PS1L\PYV?L\PE˜«BAIb|a=tPYW’Š‹S1e*‹t®8I¦BaŽ|aIbxaB^T®5Š‹Sae F:

x

®8ˆt[†Š|‹Œ4FL7 M OQP

Qz 4F >

‹u7UO1T Z

‹ Š 4FL7ŽM OQP

Qz 4F >

‹u7“k ¢_£Q¡/¥³¤#S1Š1 IKWEO@#L?MbPRI-±WRBPT)$S1ЬV?MXO1`^BAW

IbŠ1)C4‹u7

Q’‘

®˜&B¶WYO/["PR=?BAeRBCOQeYB

‘ ž,aŸ¤NUS1T

VNMKOa`B=‹ PYS1ªaB^TNW­O1eRBWR=?S˜­T"OaWˆ?MKOa`qª Z S1PYWIKT"PY=?B N|aL?eRB;W^)*#(:“254wv*7&IXWPR=NB¥³¤N¥³ž¦¥§£š'¢£¡/Q¥³¤ SQŠ8

<'eqOQTpW3IbPRIKS1TNW«@O/[”f¡RŸ«SaT?BnˆJ[—SaT?B1®JSae&IKT@¶L?MbPRI-±WRBPqW O1Tt[_PYeYO1TNWRIµPYIbSaT@#LNMµPYI- W3B^P–•*+

x

.— "8#EIXW­`^O1MbMKB Z O—“ž Ÿ

5nB^TNSQPRB¶O1W1˜†PR=?BŸ¢ “ž Ÿ 8®pI¦Ba˜™4FL7

Q

G_Š‹S1eŽOQMKM F3:

x

<=NB¶WRBP’S1Š”W3PRBAVNWUS1Š 8zIKW Z B^T?S1PRB Z†š 48{7“’kW]PYB^V

•¶IXW¶Ÿ^¤5£^šbŸ ! IKT‰O_@OQeYªtIKT?|\)"® Z BAT?SQPYB Z ) ›

œ

.%®NIB)$=NO1W­BAT?S1LN|1="PRS1ªaB^TNWUS1T†OQMKM‹T:!v PYSWROQPRIXW]Š‹[PR=?B¶W3L?@ SQŠ

Z B^@OQT Z W&Š‹eRSa@X•J®?eYB^|aO1e Z B Z OaW­OCx1BA`PRSae&IKT %%T ®p`S1Tp`B^eYT?IKT?|“‹ '

)“4…‹ž7 Ÿ ¡‹ Š >

•u¢

> ¯

˜­=NB^eYB¡

\> \

¢+% |£ Y % |£ . %% IKW”PR=?B­IKT?T?BAefV?eYS Z LN`“PfS1Š % |£5nB^TNSQPRBPY=?B’WRBPfS1Š8W3PRBAVNW”B^TpOQˆ?MKB Z IKT—OE@_O1eRªJIKT?|)

OaW¤¦¥ " ¨§©tª-4L)=7NMLOQP

Q,R

•*SŒ) ›

œ

.«U

’Š'`^S1L?eqW3Ba®¬˜\:$¤¦¥ " ¨§©tª-4L)=7”Š‹S1e£¤ ­@O1eRªJIKT?|;)"(GtPYB^VC•_žÌ¡R£Q¤? ¡“¢¶”@OQeYªtIKT?|

­

ÆK®L¯…°²±³²´µ®K¶Åc·í“ëç/Ý îÌÛè3×qçEïQݔàáçt¸ç;àî¦Ý”ç/Ý îr¹³ßá໺“Ý”ÛÌîÌë§Ú/è î¦Ú/ë§Ý]ÛRÕ1Û¦Ý]ݔïQÝ]ßáíL¼fì

(10)

&¡q£^¥³šœ¥X“žÌ¥§™¤ Qš ¥³¤ "

) IKTtPRS_@OQeYªJIbT?|!)

T ® Z BAT?SQPYB Z ) ›

œ

.ƒ)

T

®\IL±¥T) ›

œ . ®pOQT Z ±¥³¥nŠ‹SaeUOQMKMo‹p:;v '

) T 4…‹ž7

Q

)C4‹u7

œ

¡…‹

Š >

•u¢

G ¡Š ‹ >

•u¢

¯Ìma²

k’|aOQIKT®«˜«B"PReYIbxJIXOQMKMb[‡=pO/x1B?)

œ . )+Š‹S1e‰£¤@OQeYªJIbT?|«)"Œk@_O1eRªJIKT?| ) IXW¡RŸq£1™"?£ šbŸ_Š‹eRSa@h) # ® Z BAT?SQPYB Z

)*#

n

œ

.ƒ)"®?I2'U¯§IX²)

Q

)*#Q®?S1e¯§IbI³²«PR=NB^eYBBc\IKW3PYW­O¬¡“¥³¤ —Ÿ ^›NŸ¤8™qŸ)p# ›

œ

.h)

^

›

œ . &

›

œ

.ƒ)

qb^

Q

)"

Œƒ\‚7B

z 4 a&>

`7¥³¤ ! ¥§™q£ž Ÿ#ž"NŸC¤N›\¢ qŸ¡ ž,aŸ¤NEž"?£Qž&?£Y¶ž"\¡›"†ž"?Ÿ_£Q¡R™T4

a&>

`7¶£QžUŸ%0Ÿ¡ NeYIbT?| 5¬¥3`

¥X£ž¦¡R£¤N“¥³žÌ¥

z 4 a&>

`7 0Ÿ“ž"?Ÿ¤p›\¢ qŸ^¡ [1Ÿ^¤?_ž"?£žn¤5ŸqŸ ! ž 8¡RŸ“^Ÿ^¤Nž ¤

a ž‰£Qš³š % £pf¡“¥³¤ `

£Q¤ ! ž"?£Qž%”¥³š³š:YŸ¡RŸ^¢ 10/Ÿ ! q¡¢

a

%ž"?£Qžc¬¡“¥³¤ 9™ ¤pžÌ¡R£“ž”¥X–`–¥X#£8šb£1™qŸ_£¤ ! ž"\›J

a

£_ž¦¡R£¤Nq¥³ž¦¥¤fž"NŸ¡YŸ

¥X#¤ —¡YŸ$^›\¥³¡RŸ^¢_Ÿ^¤Nž ¤C` ¡C£1¬¡“¥³¤ a 5&¥ a

f¡RŸ«¥³ž ¤pš ! ŸNŸ¤ !  Q¤–¥³žÌUIbTNV?L\P 5šb£a™qŸ“±¥C£¤ ! ¥³¤

 #£Q¤ ! 5›\žÌž"NŸ¥³¤ ! ¥§™q£Qž±Ÿ ! ¤N›\¢ qŸ¡ —¤8Ÿ %‘ž ,aŸ^¤? ¤pž;` %&"\¥§™ " ™q£Q¤N¤ QžE¡RŸq›J^Ÿ"ž"?Ÿ^¢ ' "J¥X£ ¢¶¢Ÿž¦¡

¡RŸ­Ÿq™ž¦¥³¤ "NŸ ! ¥³¡RŸq™ž¦¥¤ žÌ¥³¢Ÿ¥³¤¨ž"?Ÿ ­Ÿž¦¡“¥”¤5Ÿ^ž ! ¤5£Q¢¶¥§™«šbŸq£ ! ›JEž"™Q¤?“¥! Ÿ^¡¶£Q¡R™“¥³¤

x

Y;v+£­VNO1WYW3IKx1Ba®

£& D/^Ÿ ! ž"?Ÿ­Oa`“PRIKx1B Q¤5ŸŽ¥³¤8v Y x

5”¥ F(„ ‹ ^›\ž–4‹C„ FL7%¬Ÿ^£*_ž"N£ž‹"¥XVNO1WYW3IKx1B %K¡KžnžÌ¡R£Q¤?“¥³ž¦¥¤ F

' "J¥X ! ¥X“žÌ¥³¤8™ž¦¥¤ %”¥³š³š 8šb£*"£Q¤l¥³¢ Q¡“ž±£Q¤Nž«¡ šbŸ¶¥³¤–ž"NŸ›\¤ Qš! ¥³¤Ÿ^¢£¤Nž¦¥§™6qŸ^š %

–A ["!$##™1e%'&(#-$)™%*?3,+!$#NŒ %$-/.0!1

GJSa@_BŠ‹L?eRPR=?BAeUV?eYB^VNO1eYOQPRIKS1TNWˆ5BŠ‹SaeRB Z B NT?IKT?|;™q™›\¡“¡RŸ^¤5™qŸ#¤5Ÿ^ž§“®\PY=?B#WRB^@OQTtPYIK` Z Sa@OQIKTŠ‹S1eUL?T?Š‹S1MZ IbTN|aWA&k7PYL?V?MKB

S1ŠUPR=?eYB^BWRBPYW  Q 421

> ¤ >

„¬7#IKW_`AOQMKMbB Z OŒ¤8Ÿž&I31 }B¤

Q~

®¬O1T Z „W

421Y«¤7‚B4 ¤$Y41™7

‡h TŒVpOQeRPRIX`L?MXOQe;®

Š‹SaeR|aBP3PYIbTN|vO1eY`˜&B^IK|1=tPYWO1T Z @OQeYªtIKT?|¨SQŠOvd(BPReYI­T?B^P[JIbBAMZ WOvTNBP ˆ?L\PT?B^PYW—O1eRB@_S1eYB|1B^TNB^eqOQMPR=pOQT PR=NOQP

WRIbTp`B NT?IbPRBAT?BAWYWIXWT?S1PeRB;©tL?IbeYB Z   T Q 41

T> ¤ T> „ T7ŽIKW¶OW3L?ˆNT?BP#S1Š  I65 7 1 T

W81”®95 +:7 ¤ T

W,¤8®OQT Z 5 +:7

„ T Q „ }

421

T

Y&¤

T

7b4L¤

T

Y;1

T7 Š‹S1e,<>W@41;¤7“®5PR=NB¶WRL?ˆ?T?B^PnSQŠ  WRVNOQT?TNB Z ˆJ[=< IKW Z BAT?SQPYB Z  <

n•–eYIµPYB

>²91MLOQP

Q „ ]^

9

OQT Z 9?>–MLOQP

Q „ 9 W3B^PA@M OQP Q „ q

OQT Z

KQ

„ n

f<=?B—™Q¤&¥§™^žeRBAMKOQPRIKS1TNW9BCO1T ZED OQeYBn|aIbxaB^TˆJ[ '

1­·?Sae©

^ >

©F:<¤8®\MKBP3©

^ BC ©GFEI†©

^IH

Q

©GFOQT Z > © ^ }=> FF

H

QH~



m\­·?Sae

aE>

`“:$418?¤7®?MKBP

a D

`I‰PY=?B^eYBBc\IXW]P©

^ >

©GF:<¤@'±¥F

^ BC FFa®7±¥³¥F

^

KBa

®pOQT

Z

±¥³¥³¥FF

K

`8

·NS1eKJ W@41“¤7“®8˜­eYIµPYBILNMPOQ|4RJ(7’O1T Z LSUTVQ|4UJ(7UŠ‹S1enPR=?BCW3B^PnS1Šf@_OQc\Ib@OQM/@_IKT?IK@_O1M'BAMbBA@CBATtPYWnSQŠJ ˜eAPA@®

eYBAWRVpB;`“PYIbxaB^MK[1”US˜®\˜&BOQeYBneYBAO Z [PYS Z B NT?B '

,»W

‹

¿ YX ¤5Ÿ^ž  Q

41

> ¤ >

„7¥X#™q£š³šbŸ

!

£V?eYB-±S\`^`^L?eReYB^Tp`BŽT?BPC¥Zr¥³ž¬^£QžÌ¥XQ«Ÿ[

\

’T?S_ˆNO1`qªJ˜OQe Z ˆ?eqOQTp`q=?IbTN|-+S> S

K M

¡¶£Qš³š p:]175

^ nk­`[\`MKIX`IbP]["[`_¥³ž";a@Nb ^ž £¥³¤5Ÿ ! ¢ „¨£#£ *0Ÿcd–4

a @ a 7 ¡¶£Qš³š

a

:<4218$¤75

e nkUˆNWRB^Tp`BSQŠ(OQL\PYS - `SaT\¸NIX`“P[f–4

a D a 7 ¡¶£Qš³š

a

:<4218?¤75

g  ¥X’`^S1T Z IµPYIbSaT%-¦IKT?IbPRIXOQMKIb´AB Z ”¥³ŸGh #3MLOQP

Q

LSRT Q 41;†¤7ŽWi1

' "?ŸvŸ^šbŸ^¢_Ÿ^¤NžÌ %£¡RŸv™q£š³šKŸ ! `SaT Z IbPRIKS1TNW¶ž" ^Ÿ ©Œž"?ŸB^xaB^TtPYW K

X

¤*S\`A`L?eYeRBATN`BT?B^P Q¡kjml¥X–£

8¡RŸ ;™q™›\¡“¡YŸ¤8™YŸ#¤5Ÿ^ž¬ž"?£Qžf¥³¤v£ !! ¥³ž¦¥¤&¥X

\ ’˜«BAMbM-¦Š‹S1L?T Z B Z f¥³ŸGnž"NŸ¡RŸCŸon1¥X“žÌŽ¤ ¥³¤tf¤N¥³ž Ÿ^šN@ ! Ÿq™^¡RŸq£/“¥³¤ —^Ÿ$^›NŸ^¤5™qŸc

^ n`SaT

Z

IbPRIKS1T%-±ˆpSae

Z

B^eYB

Z

[pLMqOQŽ4218$¤7ŽWr1

X

`^OQLpWRO1M5TNBP Q¡,spl7¥X#£ 8¡RŸ& A™q™^›\¡“¡RŸ¤8™qŸ¤5Ÿ^ž«q›N™"ž"?£Qž–S q>¨S

K M

¡C£š³š p:;1

<=?BV?MXO1`^B-±ˆpSae Z BAeRB Z eYBA©tL?IKeRBA@_B^TtP­IKW­TNS1T%- W]PqOQT Z OQe Z ˆ?L\Pn@CB;OQTNWUT?SMbStWRWS1Š|aB^T?BAeYO1MbIbP][ OQTJ[—T?B^PU@_B^BPYIbTN|—OQMKM

S1PR=?BAe­eRB;©aLNIbeYB^@_B^TtPqW­`^OQTˆ5BBcJPRBAT Z B Z

IKTtPRSOCV?MKOa`B -¦ˆ5S1e

Z

B^eYB

Z

S1T?Ba®\˜­IµPY=?S1L?P’`q=NOQT?|aIbTN|¶IbPYW­S1PR=?BAe­V?eYS1V5B^eRPRIKBAWA

<=?B—Š‹SaMbMKS˜­IKT?|leYB^MXOPYIbSaTNW¶O1eRBLNW3B^Š‹L?MIbT OQTNO1Mb[J´AIbT?|–S\`^`LNeReYB^TN`^B—T?B^PYWA*<=?B`AOQLNWYOQM

Z

B^V5B^T

Z

B^TN`^B"eYB^MXOPYIbSaT*IXW

§B M OrP

Q

@«t@]^ ˜­IµPY=‡PR=?BIZ BATtPRIbP][¨eYB^MXOPYIbSaTtBª MLOQP

Q R 4 a&> a

78+

a

:61\[¤¦Ut® Z B NTNB—B^MKB^@_B^TtPqOQeY[¨`^S1TN`^L?eReYB^Tp`[–OaW

Cu M OQP

Q

421;?¤7 F œ

BK D =Bª¨7^ nT?B_Saˆ\PYO1IbTNWBAO1WRIKMb[†PY=NOPk5:7 @ IKWOVpOQeRPRIXOQM”S1e Z BAe 57 §Bb®Cvup®dBCO1T ZwD OQeYB

WR[J@C@_B^PReYIK`O1T Z IbeYeRB^¸NBc\IKx1B 5 +:7 OCV?eRB -¦S\`A`L?eYeRBATN`BŽT?B^P *IXWUOxsplŒI D

Q~

·?S1eUOCˆ?IKTNO1eR["eRBAMKOQPRIKS1T?V«® Z BAT?SQPYB

Références

Documents relatifs

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST