HAL Id: inria-00070210
https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00070210
Submitted on 19 May 2006
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Distributed Architecture for Resource Management in Large Scale Grids
Emmanuel Jeanvoine, Louis Rilling, Christine Morin, Daniel Leprince
To cite this version:
Emmanuel Jeanvoine, Louis Rilling, Christine Morin, Daniel Leprince. Distributed Architecture for Resource Management in Large Scale Grids. [Research Report] RR-5814, INRIA. 2006, pp.13. �inria- 00070210�
ISSN 0249-6399 ISRN INRIA/RR--5814--FR+ENG
a p p o r t
d e r e c h e r c h e
INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE
Distributed Architecture for Resource Management in Large Scale Grids
Emmanuel Jeanvoine and Louis Rilling and Christine Morin and Daniel Leprince
N˚5814
Janvier 2006
Systèmes numériques
34)!-$657&)$8:9
;,<=<?>A@CB DFE/GADF>A@HJIJKL@ D
∗ >M@ NPOIJBKRQSKRERELKR@ T
† >A@NPUWVXYKRQ[Z\KL@ D^]_IJX`KR@
‡ >A@NPa>M@ KRDbE ODFcXYKR@dFD
§
egfihkjml`nWoYhqpgrsnut[vxwzyFrsoYh
{ vx|~}o[j { vmwh
/~ |bvkj/iovxo`so`vxsop$bs[7 pFgwzo[v/~b,` o`h
%`[ s ¡£¢
vmw¤[|n
rijxw¥p
vx| FwioYh/o[p |r
^|bn
rij
jmwz|p
| ¦&o`v/jx|
o[vm§¨|vxnpgrsnuo`vmw
©
hmwǻ
n1r
©
jmwz|pMhq¬srij/w¥j/wzh[|n
s©
ojx|WrMhkob®s¯°w
psowh
hkfihkjmo`n±jm
j/o
hko²jmso!rMhko|~§
W©z
v o³hx
©
o vmw
[|n
|bhmo`¦w¥jm$ ojmo`vm|
o`pso[|br h
pM!rspsvxo
©w ¬ ©
ovxo`hm|rsvoYh[®´µp,jmswh
~
o[vY¶[¦·o&ioYhm[vmwz¬Ao¸jm o
o`pso[v
~©
vx w«jxo`jxrsvxo°|~§¯°w
pso
p %¦&o
vxo`hmo[pFj&nu|bvmo
vmjmwr
©
v © f1jxso
~s © w
jmwz|pn
p
~
o`nuo[pFj·hmo[vxgwz[o
p jm o,vmoYhk|brsvo ~©z©|g jxw¥|bphmo[vxgwz[o®s¹ºo vmoYhko`pbj/vxo`hmr ©jxh`¶ |b¬ij w¥psoY¦w«jx ¦·|vx»Fwzp 7 vx|~jx|~jf o
|§A¯²w psoirsvxw¥p o o`vmwznuo[pFj jmwz|p hvxo ©wz¼[oY$|bp1jxso ¢ vxwz½¾~b°jmoYhjx¬MoY¶ jm jhms| ¦¿jxsooÀwzo[pMf
|§jxso!vmoYhk|brsvo ~©z©|i jmwz|phko`vmgwo®
ÁÃÂFÄJÅxÆ$Ç È¡É¢
vmw|bn
rijmwzp
¶Aiwhjxvmwz¬srijxo`hkfihkjmo`n¶
o`o[vmªLjx|~ª
o`o[v| bo[v
©z
fupso[j¦&|bvm»ih`¶ivmoYhk|brsvx[o
©¥©
|i
jmwz|pC¶ihmo
©
§ÊªRso
~©
w¥p
ËÌCÍkÎÐÏYÑ·ÍÒ ÓzÎÐÔRÕÖ
∗×MØØ/ÙÚ[Û\ÜÝÞßÜkÙÚàáâ¾Ú\Ümãâ¾äLâ¾åRÙYÞæzä
†ç áÛ\â¾åmÞèCâ¾Ý¾Ý¾â¾Ú\é[ãâ¾äêâ¾åÐÙYÞæ¥ä
‡ëì äLâ¾åêíRâ¾Ú\ÜÞîáäêâ¾Ú~ãâ¾äêâ¾åÐÙYÞæ¥ä
§ï ÙÚ\â¾ÜÝÞç Üð\äêâ¾Ú\ñÜxãÜòYæ¥éòYæêÞæzä
Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes
IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex (France) Téléphone : 02 99 84 71 00 - International : +33 2 99 84 71 00
Télécopie : 02 99 84 71 71 - International : +33 2 99 84 71 71
),+29 88 9 ),+ 88
¡ o`h vmw©z©oYh7ioà ~©r ©/ o`vmnuo[jkjmo`pFj%io§¨|rsvxpswzv ©zº r wzhxh p oÃio¤ ~©r © pst`[o`hxh w¥vxo
ri hkwzn$r © jxw¥|bp hpgrsnut`vmwyFrso`h%n wzhio[nuo`rsvmo`pFj|bn s©o[io`h¿rijmw©whmo[vY®&¯²w pso¤o`hkjr p hkfihkjml`nWo
yFrsw o[vxnuoj,io7hkwzn s©w o`v ©½rijmw©wzh jxw¥|bpº½rspso vxw©¥©oWso v p io1t`so ©¥©oW[|n |bhmt[ouio1vxo`hxhm|rsvoYh
tjmt`vm| l`pso`h&oj/ps|bp ¬ ©o`h`® p ho[j vkjxwz ©ob¶gps|r hst`vxwz|pMh ©½ vsw«jxo`jmrsvxo t[pst`v ©oio¯°w pso
o[j·p |r h vxt`hmo[pFjm|bp h s©r h vkjxwz[r ©wzl[vxo[nuo`pbj ©oYh·hmo[vxgwz[o`h&io o`hkjmwz|p%½~ s©w jmwz|po[jqC½©¥©|i jxw¥|bp
so&vxo`hxhk|brsvo`h`®°|r h vxt`hmo[pFjx|p hio`hvxt`hmr ©j jh[¶Y|¬sjmo[pgr h bo`¸r p vx|~jx|~jf o&§¨|pMjmwz|p pso © io·¯°w pso
©|vh½o t`vmwznuo[pFj jmwz|p hvxt ©whmt[o`hhmrsv © ©z jmoªR§¨|vxnuo ¢ vxw½bs¶yFrsw¸nu|pFjmvxo[pFj ©½oÀ w¥jmtsr
hmo[vxgwz[o³C½©¥©|i jxw¥|bpso³vxo`hxhm|rsvoYh[®
Ç Y Å ¡P¢ vxw©¥©oWsoW ~©r ©¶Ahmfihjxl[nuo1swzhkjmvxw¥¬ rst¶Jvxt`hmo rs ©| wzyFrsoYh w¥vmª~ªM wzv`¶ ©¥©|i jmwz|p^io
vxo`hxhm|rsvoYh[¶ rijx|~ªÐvmt v jxw¥|bp
+1 7,+
hmw¥n1r ©z jmwz|p¤pgrsnut`vmwyFrso$|i[[r o$rspso s© o vxt |p it`v pFjmo$ p h³io$ps|bn$¬svxo[rsÃs|n wzpso`h
hxwzo[pFjxwMyFrsoYh%| ©½o[ t`vmwznuo[pFj jmwz|p vxt[o ©¥©o^oYhjÃ|ijmo`r hmo¶q|bw¥vxo^wzn |Fhmhmw¥¬ ©ob® { |r vvxt ©whmo[v[o`h
hmwzn$r © jxw¥|bp h[¶CC½wzn |bvkj pFjxhnu| fo`p hio ©[r © i|bw¥bo[pFjjmvxo7o[n s©| ftYh[®! p io7vmt |bp ivxo [o`h
¬Ao`hm|wzp h`¶ ©o`h/o`pFjmvxo vxwzhmo`hqo[j²wzp hkjmw¥jmrijxw¥|bp h°hmojm|brsvmp o[pFj°o`vxh ©o,vxo vm|br o[nuo[pFj/io ©o[rsvhnu| fo`p h/io
~©r © |r vq§¨|vxnWo`v/io`h vmw©z©oYhio! ~©r ©®
" pso vxw©z©ousou ~©r © o`rij$|bpbjxo[pswzv!rspºps|n1¬svxoWwzn |bvkj pFj,io7vxo`hxhk|brsvx[o`h`¶ v s o`hio ©ª
[r © jmo`rsvh$|br=hj jxw¥|bp h1so%jxv w©¶yFrswhm|pFj1st[jmt`vm| l[p o`h`¶iwh o[vhmt[o`h t`| v swybr o[nuo[pFj$o[jWpso
|r pFjWi|bpspso[v rMrspso b v pFjmwzoio ¬sw©w¥jmtb®$#&o`hW|pFjxv w¥pFjmoYh,wzn s©wyFrso[pFjyFrC½rspso vmw©z©oioª
nuo`rsvmo![|n
s©
oio 1rsjmw
©
whko`v`¶sj
pFj
v ©
oYh
inuwzpswzhkjmv
jxo[rsvhqyFrso
v ©
o`hqrsjmw
©
wh
jmo`rsvxh`®
p hoj
vmjmw
©
o¶ ps|br h
vxt`hmo[pFjm|bp h
©½
vxsw¥jmoYjxrsvmoio¯²w
pso¶rsphkfihkjml`nWo/C½o[
©
|bw«j
jmwz|p
|rsv
vmw
©z©
o°yFrswhmw¥n
s©
w o
©½rsjmw
©
wh
jmwz|pio`h&vmoYhmhm|r vx[o`h¸½rspso
vxw
©z©
o® /|~jxvmo
vxw¥p [w
M~©
|¬i}oYjmw¥§Co`hkj
©½rijmw
©
wǻ
h jxw¥|bpjxv
p h
M
vxo[pFjmo³io
©½o[pMhko`n$¬
©
o!io`h·vxo`hxhk|brsvx[o`h·io
©zW
vmw
©¥©
oh
p hyFrso
©
oYhqrijmw
©
wh
jmo`rsvh&p½
w¥o`pbj
uhmo!hk|br wzo[v/io
©W©
|i
©
wh
jmwz|p¶sio
©z
iwh
|bpsw¥¬ w
©
w«jxt!|rio`hst§
w
©z©z
p oYhio`hvxo`hxhm|rsvoYh[®
p hur p vxo[nuwzo[vWjmo`n h[¶ps|br h vmtYhko`pFjm|pMh$¯²w pso¶ps|jmvxohmfihjxl[nuo½o[ s©|bw«j jxw¥|bp |brsv ©z
o`hkjmwz|pio`h/vmoYhmhm|rsvoYhq½r pso vxw©z©o® °|r hqt`ps|p&%[|p hqp |bh|b¬i}o`jmw¥§êh[¶sp |bh/s|bw«io,|bp o jmwz|poj
vmtYhko`pbjx|p h ©½ vxsw¥jmoYjxrsvmoio¯°w p o® /|br h vxt`hmo[pFjm|bp ho`p hmrsw«jxoo[pitj w©©oYhhko`vmgwo`h·io oYhjxw¥|bp
C½ss©wz jmwz|pMh$o[ju½~©z©|g jxw¥|bp=iovmoYhmhm|rsvoYh[®/|br h vmtYhko`pFjm|pMh ©o`h1vmtYhkr ©j jxhuioYh$o[ t`vmwznuo[piª
j jxw¥|bp h!yFrsoups|r h b|p h²vxt ~©whkt`o`h oY$ps|jmvxo vm|jm|jf oW¯°w psouoj © vxw©z©ouC½o[ t[vxwznWo`pFj jxw¥|bp
¢ vxw½b('¥*)R®! pFjiou|bp ©rsvxo¶Aps|rMh vxt`hmo[pFjx|p h³io`h²jxv rs s vxo[pFjxt`h ¯°w p o |rsvo
yFrswC[|p [o[vxpso ©zW o`hkjmwz|pio`hqvxo`hxhk|brsvo`h·½rspso vmw©¥©o®
+ ,
- +
),8[
,
[-,+
-/.10 2436587:9<;>=@?BA
°|r h
vxt`hmo[pFjm|bp h³
p h[ojkjxo
vmjmwzo
©
o`h³|¬s}o`jxw«§êhyFrsoups|br h
b|p h³hm|rs
w«jxt
jkjmo`w¥pMivmo
|rsv
©
|bp o
jmwz|pirÃhkfihkjml`nWo¯²w
pso®
½|b¬i}o`jmw¥§
vmwzp w
©
o`hkj
©z
hmwzn
©
ww¥jmt%C½rijxw
©
wh
jmwz|p io
©
vxw
©z©
o
|r v
©
oYh,rijxw
©
wh
jmo[r vxh`®C p
C½|i[[r
©
jmo[v
©
[|n
s©
oiw¥jmtw¥pMirsw¥jmo
v ©o v
p p |n$¬ vmo³iovmoYhmhm|rsvoYh[¶bps|rMh·hm|r
w¥jm|bp h·|DJvmwzv
©½rijmw
©
wh
jmo`rsv!rspsougwhkwz|p4ioWjf
oFEBGHE
IJKMLFJKN8OPRQ*&
®C /wzp hmwL¶rsp rsjmw
©
wh
jmo`rsv,i|w¥j
|brs|bw¥v
hm|r nWo[jkjxvmo rspsoºjSbso hmrsv ©z? vxw©¥©o io rswhpC½wzn |bvkjxo ybr o ©z©oºvmoYhmhm|r vx[o¶&h pMhhmoºhm|rMwzo[vio`h
vxo`hxhm|rsvoYh&yFrswhmo[vx|pFjqrijmw©wzhmt[oYh |brsv ©½o[gtYrijxw¥|bpso,hk|bp ss©wz jmwz|p®
o`hWrijmw©wzh jxo[rsvh$vxt ©wh pFj1ioYh1hmw¥n1r © jmwz|pMh$pgrsnut[vxwybr o`h1tj pFjuhm|rsbo[pFj$ ¬sw¥jmrstYh ^rijmw©wzhmo[v
so`h v ~ oYh t[vxt[oYh M v!rsp oYhjxw¥|bpsp w¥vxoWso1jxv ri¶ ©ounu|iioio7hk|brsnuwzhxhmw¥|bpºioYh³jSbso`h!i|bw«j
hmo!v ~s vx|iso[virnu|iio,io$hm|r nWwhxhkwz|prijmw©wzhmt,hkr v/rsp oYhjxw¥|bpsp wzvxosojmv ri® p h/[o!nW|iio
souhm|r nWwhxhkwz|pC¶ ©½rijmw©wh jmo`rsv§¨|r vmpsw¥j r hmfghkjml`nuoWr pso7io`hxvxw jmwz|p4|pFjxo[p pbj,ioYhw¥ps§¨|vxn jmwz|p h
|r v&yFrso © jSso rswhmhmoT[jmvxo/oit`[rijmt`o®>#&o`hw¥pi§¨|bvmn jmwz|p h o`rso`pbjq|bp o`vmpso`v voio`n ©o³io`h
vmt[ªRvxo`yFrswh·n jmt`vmwzo ©h&jmo ©h/yFrC½rspsoj w©¥©o!½oYh M o!iwhxybr o!|rrspps|n1¬svmoio vx|ioYhmhmo[rsvh`®
p h&rspso vxw©¥©o ©o`h&vmoYhmhm|rsvoYhhk|bpFj&o s©|w¥jmt`o`h&io²n psw¥l`vmoYh¸st[jmt`vm| l[p o`h`®U¸p%oDAo[j`¶gw©M o[rijqf
b|wzvio`hvxo`hxhm|rsvoYh&o[ s©|bw«jxt[oYho[pÃnu|iio!wzpbjxo[v jmw¥§jxo ©z©oYh°yFrso,ioYh/hj jxw¥|bp h/io!jxv w© rijxw©wh pbj
èèÚWVYXBZ\[@]
©½|vi|psp
p [o[rsv wzpgri|brÃio`h
v
s
o`h&§¨|p jmwz|psp
pFj
oY²r phmfihjxl[nuo uwzn
orspswyFrso,|bnunWo
o`vmvxw
soY 'H)
v1o[io[n
s©
o® °oYhWvmoYhmhm|rsvoYh
o[rsbo[pFj
r hxhkw jxvmoo
s©
|w¥jmt[oYh$o`p=nu|iio%p |p=wzpiª
jxo[v
jmw¥§·|bnunWo7ioYh
v
~s
o`h²§¨|bp jxw¥|bpsp
pFj
oY$r p
o`hkjmwz|psp
w¥vxouioWjmv
ri®J¯°w
pso7i|bw«jjxvmo
~ ¬ ©o%½o s©|w¥jmo[vuoYh$iwDJt[vxo[pFj1jf o`hWio%vxo`hxhm|rsvoYh |brsvWo[p¿v jxw¥|bp ~©wzhmo[v ©½ `l`h`® ²o s©rMh[¶
p |r h!hm|rs w¥jm|pMh!|pMhko`vmbo[v ©oYh,hmfghkjml`nuo`hoiwhj pFjxh!hmrsv ©o`h v s o`h|r ©o`h,hkj jmwz|p h!soujmv w©
pybr o ©o`rsvo s©|w¥j jmwz|ph p h·rijmw©whmo[v/¯²w psovmoYhjxo |bhxhmw¥¬ ©o®
U¸p¿jmo[vxnuo%½t`so ©¥©o¶¯°w pso%s|w¥j |brs|bw¥v[jmvxorijxw©wzhmt bo`Wrspso vxw©z©oso v p so1j w©¥©o%yFrsw
[|n |vmjmo s©rMhkwzo[rsvhWnuw©z©wzo[vh7iovxo`hxhk|brsvx[o`hWiwh o[vhkt`o`huhmrsv s©rMhkwzo[rsvhuhkw¥jmoYh t`| v ~ swzyFrso`nuo[pFj
t ©|bw pst`h`®²o s©r h`¶bp |r hpso²hm|rs w¥jm|pMh h|bp hmwzit`vmo`v ©o`h¸vxo`hxhm|rsvoYhrijmw©wzhmt[oYh|bnunWo ¬ ©oYh¸oj
jx|r }|brsvh vmtYhko`pbjxo`h· pMh ©W vxw©z©o® { |brsvio`hqv whm|p h·½ inuwzpswzhkjmv jxw¥|bpC¶grspso³vmoYhmhm|r vx[o o[rij/jxvmo
vxojxw¥vxt[ouio © vmw©z©ob® p h!o7 h ©o7it vmj o`rij jxvmo pbjxwz[w t® pMh ©o7 h| ºrspsouvxo`hxhk|brsvx[o
oYhj&Fwjxw¥nuo³½r pso²it[§ w©¥© pMo¶ ©o²it vkj&pso o[rij h$jxvmo pFjmww tb®´© § rij wzp hkwAyFrso ©o°hkfihkjml`nWo
|r v vxw©¥©o^|bpFjmwzpFr o 4§¨|pMjmwz|p pso[vn ~©z vxt ©z swzh vxw¥jmwz|p io ©z vxo`hxhm|rsvob® { |rsvnWwzpswznuwzhmo[v
©
o`h[|p hmt`yFrso`p oYhio4oYhit§
w
©z©z
p oYh[¶qps|jmvxoºhmfihjxl[nuo4i|w¥j
|bhxhmt`io`vioYh
vx|
vxw¥t[jmtYh½
rsjm|~ª
vxt
M
v
jmwz|p® °|r hqjxv
w«jx|p hqioYh
vx|
vxwztjmtYhq½
rijm|ªRvxt
M
v
jmwz|pio!¯°w
pso!
p h ' )Ю
²r
|wzpFjqio²grso³so
©½
inuw¥pswhkjmv
jmo`rsvY¶bps|br h·hk|brs
w¥jm|bp hyFrC½rspso²vmoYhmhm|r vx[o
rswhmhmoT[jmvxo¸}|bw¥pFjmo
|br%vxojxw¥vxt[oio ©z1 vxw©¥©o°jxvmlYhhkwzn s©o[nuo[pFj`¶syFrso ©ohmfihjxl[nuo |brsv vxw©z©o²pso!hm|w¥j M h·jmvx| w¥pFjxvmr hmw¥§oj
yFrC½w© psovmoYyFrsw¥o`vkj hqrspso!wzp hkj ~©z© jmwz|p|bn s©wyFrst[ob®
-/.- $= 7 997! ;>="
p$iojxv w«jxo[v © vx|¬ ©t`n jmwyFrso¸io © v pMiot`so ©¥©o¶`ps|rMh |bp h| jmt |rsvrspso&[|p [o jxw¥|bp
[|n
s©
ljxo[nuo[pFj²iwhkjmvxw¥¬sr t[o®< /wzp hmwL¶
©z
st§
w
©z©z
p o$C½rsp o$vxo`hxhk|brsvx[o!ybr o
©
|pMybr o!pC½o`pFjmv
$#
pso
h
©z
st§
w
©z©z
p o!|bn
s©
l[jmo!irÃhmfghkjml`nuo®
°|r h7it[j
w
©z©
|bp hW
p hF'H)
©½rsjmw
©
wh
jmwz|p iovmtYhko
ri
©| wyFrso`h
w¥vmª~ª
M
wzv1|bnunWo§¨|pM
jxw¥|bp
|r v
©
o`hhmo[vxFwoYh°ioW
rij³p w¥bo
r p h²¯°w
p o®
%
vmwzp [w
©
o1v
wzhm|p¤C½rijxw
©
wh
jmwz|p so`h²vmtYhko
ri
©|
wzyFrsoYhqvmtYhkwio,
p h
©
o[r vxh
vm|
vmwztjxt`h½
rsjm|~ªÐ|v
b
pswh
jmwz|pC¶i½
rijx|~ªÐvmt
v
jxw¥|bp%o[j²io
hmh
~
o
©½t`so ©¥©o®
jmrso ©¥©o[nuo[pFjY¶ ps|br hqpso vx| |bhm|p h hio,hm| ©rijmwz|poÀ o |rsv ©o`h vm|b¬ ©l[nuo`hio!hmt`[rsvmw¥jmt
o[j |r v ©o`h·|bnWn1rspsw jmwz|p h·io[ pbjqh[½tj ¬ ©wzv ,jmv o[vh¸ioYhqhko`vmbo[rsvhn p j w¥vxo`h|rio`h vxoª
§¨o`ri®
-/.&% ')(P9T=@;7:9<;+*(>7,T7.- =/T7
rsvxo/hm t[n
jxwzhmo
©½o[p hmo[n1¬
©
o/io`hhmo[vxgwz[o`hir7hmfghkjml`nuo¯°w
pso/iwhxrijxt`h¸
p ho[j
vmjmw
©
o®
1½
rijxvmoYhhko`vmgwo`hhm|pFj
vxt`hmo[pFjxt`h
p h'0H)R®#&o`h/hmo[vxgwz[o`h
o[rsbo[pFj°hko,
©z
hmhmo[vo`pjmvx|wh
jxt
|vxw¥oYh
yFrswhm|pFj
©
oYh³hmo[vxgwz[o`h³iou¬
h³pswzo
rC¶
©
o`hhmo[vxFwoYh²so1
rij!pswzo
r^o[j
©
o`hhmo[vxFwoYh²C½wzpFjmo[vm§
[o
©½rijmw
©
wh
jmo`rsvY®
1!2435276 8 Â $9!:ê Â 7È Â s<;=:>9 Â
p h&¯°w p o¶Fps|r h |bp h¸[|p&%[rrspo`p hko`n$¬ ©o²so²hmo[vxFwoYh[¶Fiw¥jxh·io²¬ h¸p w¥bo r®#&|bnWnuo° p h
r p$hkfihkjml`nWo·½o
s©
|w¥j
jxw¥|bp,
©
hxhkwyFrso¶
©½wzpbjxt[vj io&[o`hhko`vmgwo`hio¬
hp w¥bo
r!p½oYhj
hio¸§¨|brsvxpsw¥v
?>@
è
?A
Interface de soumission des tâches
Informations d’exécution
Équilibrage de charge
Transfert de fichiers
Gestionnaire d’applications
Allocation de ressources
Réservation de ressources
Réseau P2P structuré
Réseau P2P non structuré Interface
avec le gestionnaire
local
M /vsw¥jmo`jmrsvxo!irÃhkfihkjml`nWo¯²w pso
sw¥vxo`jmo[nuo`pbjWio`h,hmo[vxgwz[o`h ©½rijmw©wh jmo`rsv$n wzh s©rsj ~jWio7§¨|r vmpswzv$ioYh!§¨|bp jxw¥|bpsp ~©w¥jmt`h |brsv ©o`h
hmo[vxgwz[o`hqio! rijpswzo rC®
p^½ hxhkr vmo`v ©oYh/|bnWn1rspsw jmwz|p ho`pFjmvxo ©oYh°iwDAt`vmo`pFjxhp!rMsh°io ©zu vmw©¥©o!oj²o[p¤it w«j³io`h
st§ w©z©z p oYh |r pFjwzpFjmo`vmbo[pswzv`¶Aps|br h |bp h²[|p&%[r io`ri hmo[vxgwz[o`hyFrsw|DJvmo`pFjioYh!|br so`hio
[|nun$r pswz jxw¥|bpWjmv o`vxh·ioYhqvmtYhko ri ©| wzyFrsoYh wzvkª ª w¥vY®
" p vxo[nuw¥o`v%hmo[vxFwo o[vxnuojC½t[j ¬ ©wzvioYh%[|nun$rsp wz jmwz|pMhºjmv o`vxhursp vxt`hmo r ©| wybr o
hkjmvxr jmrsvxt®
oYhvxt`hmo
ri
©|
wyFrso`hhjxvmrMjmr vmtYh%| DAvxo[pFjÃio`h§¨|pMjmwz|p p
~©
w«jxt`hioºps|nun
~
o^oj¤io
©
|i
©
wh
jmwz|p oÀ
oYh[® pMh7¯°w
psob¶ps|br h
b|p hunuwho[p!r Fvxorsp vxt`hmo
r ©|
wzyFrso¤hkjmvxr jxrsvxt
§¨|bp ituhkr v { hjxvmf 'z`H)Ю! /wzp hkwR¶w© oYhj b v pFjmwyFrsou ybr o1p!rM^io ©z vxw©¥©o o[rij[jmvxo1wio[pFjxw t
so²n p w¥l`vmo²rspswybr o²o[j·pC½wzn |vmjmoyFrso © p!rM o[rij/|bpFj jmo`v v&vx|rij ~ o°pC½w¥n |vmjmoyFrso © rsjmvxo
p!r ,o`p$rsp1ps|n1¬svmo ©wznuw«jxt·so·h rijh[®H o` { hkjmvxf¶ o&ps|n1¬svmo·ioqh rijxho`hkjo`p$nu| fo`pspso
log16(n)
|
no`hkj ©o!p |n$¬ vmoio!p!r h p h ©o!vxt`hmo r®
" phmo`[|p hmo[vxFwo o[vxnuoj°½tj ¬ ©w¥v/so`h/[|nun$rsp wz jmwz|pMh Wjxv bo[vhr pvxt`hmo r ©| wzyFrsops|bp
hkjmvxr jmrsvxt® #&ohko`vmgwo o[vxnuoj io ©|i ~©whko`vio`hp!r sh p h ©ohmfghkjml`nuo vkjxw¥v½rspso&so`hxvxw jxw¥|bp
§¨|bp it`o²hmrsvrsp%o[p hmo[n1¬ ©o³½ jkjxvmwz¬srijh[®>#&|pFjxv w¥vxo[nuo[pFj r%hko`vmgwo/io²vmtYhko rhkjmvxr jxrsvxt¶b[o²hmo[vxgwz[o
p½| DAvxo h ©b v pFjxw¥ouioujmvx|r o[vrsp4p!rM [|vxvmoYh |p pFj rsp oio`hxvxw jmwz|pC® vxo` o[vso
p h$rsp¿vxt`hmo r p |p¿hkjmvxr jxrsvmth[½o*DJo`jmrso v1w¥p |p jmwz|p |br vWio`h1 vxw pbjxo`h,C½wzps|pM jxw¥|bp
C½rsp o!vmoYybr&jmo! p h ©o!vmtYhko rC® p hq¯²w pso¶ [o!hko`vmgwoo`hkjq§¨|p it,hmrsv ©o vx|~jm|i[| ©oei n ' )R®
" p jxvm|bwzhmwzl[nuo7hko`vmgwoWo`hkj! v tuioW§ wzvmo ©½wzpFjmo[vm§ [o o` ©o o`hkjmwz|psp wzvmo ©|i ~© io ybr o
vxo`hxhm|rsvob® /|br h
|bp h¸t`|iyFrst
p h
©W
vmjmwzos®¥yFrso
©
oYhqvmoYhmhm|rsvoYh
|rs
w¥o`pbj6jxvmoo[
©
|bw«jxt[o`h
bo`!iwDJt[vxo[pFj
oYhjxw¥|bpsp
w¥vxo`h/so,vmoYhmhm|r vx[o`h
©
|g
ri®
o$hmo[vxgwz[o,½wzpFjmo`vk§
o
bo`
©o oYhjxw¥|bpsp
w¥vxo
©
|i
©
§¨|brsvxpsw«jqrspsowzpFjmo[vm§
[o
t[pst`vmwyFrso²yFrswoYhjh
tYw
~©
wzhmt[o
|brsv
yFrso²jf
oio
oYhjxw¥|bpsp
w¥vxo²io
vxo`hxhm|rsvoYh[®
U¸p pC¶ps|br h |pMh°|bp&%r^rspºhmo[vxgwz[o1ioWvxt`hmo[vx jmwz|p¤ioWvxo`hxhk|brsvx[o`h`®<#&ouhko`vmgwo |rsv³¬srij
so t[vxo[v © [|p [rsvxvmo`p o³½ [[l`h ,rspso³vxo`hxhk|brsvx[o°yFrswhko`v w«j·v vmob® °|r h·pC½ |bp h ho`p |bvmo²nuwzh
o`p!r Fvxo!o!hmo[vxFwo! p hq¯°w p o®
1!243521 8 Â $9!:ê Â 7È Â ;=:>9 Â
°|r h
|bp h/[|p&%[r^yFr
jxvmoWhko`vmgwo`h²ioW
rij³pswzo
rC¶M§¨|p itYh³o[p
vkjxw¥oWhkr v
©
o`hhmo[vxFwoYh
vxtª
hmo[pFjxt`h
p h
©zW
vkjxw¥o,s® ®¥b®
èèÚWVYXBZ\[@]
" p
vmo`nWwzo[v/hmo[vxgwz[o
s
o ©t o`hkjmwz|psp
wzvmo½
~ss©
w
jxw¥|bp h·o`hkj°
v
t³io§¨|r vmpswzv
ri
~ss©
w
ª
jxw¥|bp h
©
o³nu| fbo[psoh`½oit`[rijmo`v ¬ ©
o[nuo`pbjY®/|br hqvmo`o`ps|p h
s©
r hqo[pÃit[j
w©
hmrsvo,hmo[vxgwz[o³
p h
©z
M
vmjmwzo ®
" p hmo`|bp ^hmo[vxgwz[o¶ ~s o ©t ©¥©|i jmo[r v²ioWvmoYhmhm|r vx[o`h`¶so`hkj v t$iouitY|r Fvxwzv°oj!½~©z©|brso[v
so`hqvxo`hxhk|brsvx[o`h ©wz¬svxo`hio ©W vxw©z©o ri ss©wz jmwz|pMh[®P#&o!hmo[vxFwooYhj/it[j w©z©t, p h ©1M vmjmwzo³
¯²w pso |Fhmhml`io r hmhmwgrsp7hko`vmgwoqio·jmv p hk§¨o[vmjio Mswzo[vh o[pFjmvxo&p!r shyFrsw o[vxnWo[jio·jmv p hk§¨tª
vxo[v&jm|br h ©o`h·t ©t[nuo[pFjhqpst`[o`hxh w¥vxo`h ©½oit`[rijmwz|piwzhkj pFjmo!½rspso ~s ©w jmwz|pC®&#&ohko`vmgwo o`vmnuoj
©½rijxw©wzh jxo[rsvqio³pso M h·hkohk|br wzo[v·irst s©|wzo[nuo[pFjqio Asw¥o`vxh¬swzp wzvmoYh&so ©½ss©wz jmwz|p%ojio`h
Asw¥o`vxhq½o[pFjxvmt`o!|rio!hk|bvkjxw¥ob®
°|r h b|p h r hxhmwq[|p&%[r?r p hmo[vxgwz[o½t`yFrsw©w¥¬sv ~ oioà v o® #&oÃhko`vmgwoo`hkj ©o o`p pbj
sfFp nuwzyFrso4io ©½~©z©|g jxo[rsvioºvmoYhmhm|rsvoYh[® U¸pPo*DJoj`¶ ©oºjmo[n h½oitYrijxw¥|bp_½rspso jSbso oYhj
hm|r o[pFjwzn vmt`Fwhmw¥¬ ©o®\ /wzp hmwrspsovmoYhmhm|rsvops|bp,s|whkwzo v ©½~©z©|i jmo`rsviovmoYhmhm|rsvoYh rswhmyFrC½o ©z©o
t[j w«j$|i`r t[o o[rsjWhmovmo[jmvx|rsbo[v ©w¥¬ vmo vxl`h!rsp¿[|rsvmj$wzp hkj pFjY® ½|¬s}o`jxw«§oYhj1so|bvmvxw o[v ©o`h
st`hmt`yFrsw
©
wz¬svxo`hio
v o·ybr w
o[r o[pFj¸hmo
vx|iirswzvmoq
p h o`h
hkª
©
s® /|jmvxo
s
vx|g o&½t`yFrsw
©
wz¬sv
~
o
so1
v
o,o`hkj°§¨|bp it[oWhkr v
©
nuw
v jmwz|p¤so
|wzpbjh²so1vxo
vxwhko$C½
ss©
wz
jmwz|pMh[®j
pbj!i|bpspst1yFrso
p |r hp o²hm|rs
w«jx|p h
M
h¸nu|iiw o[v
©
oYh
~ s©
w
jmwz|p hio`hrijmw
©
wh
jmo`rsvh[¶Fojmjmo§¨|bp jxw¥|bpsp
©
w¥jmt/wzn
|Fhko
©ohmr s |vmjir$hmfihjxl[nuohm|r hkªz} o`pFj|nunuo o`vmvxw so` ' ) M vo[io[n s©o®°|r hpC½ |pMh ho[p [|vxo
nuwhqo[p !rsgvxo[ojmjmo§¨|pMjmwz|p p ~©w«jxt! p hq¯²w pso®
1!2435243 8 Â $9!:ê Â Ç :&:êYi Â
°|r h vxt`hmo[pFjm|bp hn w¥pFjmo`p pFjÃio[rs hko`vmgwo`hyFrsw!hk|bpbj v tYh%io § wzvxo ©½wzpFjmo[vm§ [o^o`pbjxvmo
©½rijmw©wh jmo`rsvoj ©o,hmfghkjml`nuo®
o/hko`vmgwoqio/hk|brsnuwzhxhmw¥|bpWio·jSsoYh
o`vmnuoj ©½rijmw
©
wh
jmo`rsv¸io/hm|rsnuo[jkjmvxohkoYh
~s © w
jmwz|p h o`p
§¨|brsvxpswzhxh
pFj°rspsouioYhm[vmw
jmwz|p |n
|vmj
pbj°jmvx|wh
vkjxw¥oYh[®
%
vmo`nuw¥l`vmo
vmjmwzo1[|n
|bvkjxo
©
o`hsoª
nuwzp h&o[vh
©
o`h¬sw¥p
wzvmoYh¸oj
©
oYh Asw¥o`vxh½o`pFjmvxt[o~hk|bvkjxw¥o/so
©½
ss©
wz
jmwz|p®
hkoY|pMio
vkjxw¥o°s|pspso
r psoWso`hxvxw
jxw¥|bp ioYht
©
t[nuo[pFjh²n
jmt[vxwzo
©
h²o[j
©| wz[w¥o
©
h³vxo`yFrswh
|brsv
©½oit`[rijmwz|pºio
©½
~ s©
w
jmwz|pC®
jxvm|bwzhmw¥l`nuo
vkjxw¥oW|bn
|vmjmoWio`h³t
©
t`nWo`pFjxh³|
jxw¥|bpspso
©
hyFrsw
nut
©
wz|vxo[pFj
©
o$§¨|bp jxw¥|bpspso`nWo`pFjio
©½~ss©w jxw¥|bpn wzh²yFrswpsoWhk|bpFj h²vxw«jxwzyFrsoYh[® |vh½rspsoWhk|brsnuwzhxhkwz|p¶sw© § rij²§¨|rsvxpswzv ©o Mswzo[v
so²ioYhm[vmw jmwz|pio © jSso²oj ©½ ivxo`hxhmo°½rspso°n sw¥p o êyFrso ©[|p yFrso¸io ©, vxw©¥©o°yFrswJoit`[rijmo ©o
hmfihjxl[nuo¯°w psob®
ohmo[vxFwo½wzpi§¨|bvmn jxw¥|bp¿½oit`[rijmwz|p o[rijuvxo[p hmo[w pso`v ©½rijxw©wh jmo[r v1hmrsv ©½tj jWiohk|bp ~ ª
©w jmwz|pC®C´© pC½o`hkj h |Fhmhmw¥¬ ©o%so|p p $#jmvxo ©½tj j1C½ pMo[nuo`pbj$C½rsp o ~s ©w jmwz|p h p h!o`p
b|wzvw¥pMhjxvmrsnuo`pbjxt ©o1[|gso®#&o o`p pbj ©oWhko`vmgwo,oYhj³ ~M ¬ ©o$½w¥pMiwzyFrso`v³hmwr pso ss©wz jmwz|p
t[jmt7o[gtYrijxt[o7hmrsv,rspso7vxo`hxhm|rsvob¶Jhmw¸rsp o ~ss©w jxw¥|bp jxo[vxnWwzpsthm|p4oitYrijxw¥|bp |brºo`p |bvmo7hmw ©z
vxo`hxhm|rsvo²st[¬Ao[v o pFj ©½~s ©w jmwz|p hmrs¬swr pso,it§ w©z© p [o®
9 C,++), k) 8·)[,+
oWhmo[vxgwz[o$io o`hkjmwz|p^C½ss©wz jmwz|p rsp¤v ©o vmwznu|viw© p h²¯°w psob®!#&oWhko`vmgwo$oYhj³vmoYhª
|pMh ¬ ©oir7[fg ©oiogwzo/|bn ©o[jC½rsp o ~ss©w jxw¥|bpC® |bvxhxyFrC½rspso ~s ©w jmwz|pWo`hkjhm|r nWwhmoq p h
¯²w pso¶Jrsp oYhjxw¥|bpsp wzvxo$½~ss©w jxw¥|bp |bhxhktY pFj³rsp^wio[pFjxw pFj³rsp wzyFrsoWo`hkj rijx|n jxwzyFrso`nWo`pFj
?>@
è
?A