A Hierarchical Checkpointing Protocol for Parallel Applications in Cluster Federations

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00071492

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00071492

Submitted on 23 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub-

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,

Applications in Cluster Federations

Sébastien Monnet, Christine Morin, Ramamurthy Badrinath

To cite this version:

Sébastien Monnet, Christine Morin, Ramamurthy Badrinath. A Hierarchical Checkpointing Protocol for Parallel Applications in Cluster Federations. [Research Report] RR-5091, INRIA. 2004. �inria- 00071492�

(2)

ISRN INRIA/RR--5091--FR+ENG

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

A Hierarchical Checkpointing Protocol for Parallel Applications in Cluster Federations

Sébastien Monnet and Christine Morin and Ramamurthy Badrinath

N˚5091

Janvier 2004

THÈME 1

(3)

(4)

)*+,#*-./0*-1.23 ,#-

4#57698;:=<?>A@7B"CED;B B @7<FG8;B HJILK M?>N:=<?>AB @OCED;M?>ABQPR8;B HQS8UTV8;TXW M=<?KZY\[8;H M=>AB98]<^K_

`a]bcdegf!hi=jkd=lnmpoGdqrjkspjtqubcd=j

vxwkynztdqv1{rh|~}

hl]Uy7w~qpdwud=ad=wua]d7nne*f7lndw7f(]lnnd=j

G=(nn

yppdGynm] Oln=l(qkynUjln'¡Udp ¢pd=£ qkyynccRm¢l(qu ]¤cLyppm] d?j¥qkaUl(qRc$l^sX¡Ud

dopd=mqkd=\y7p ¦;d=wkd=7q*m]jtqudwj$Ql£m]j~qkd=w$§¨d=pd=wulqkynZ©{ªjGl£ m]j~qkd=w«§¨d?pdwl(qu y7\yncwujkd=j

yn§ªllnwk7dGmc¡;dwyn§ryppd=j=¥¬quadwud*jla 7awuyn¡Ul¡ qts®y§,l¯yppd*§°lmwkd7©£±Xdwuyn;y7jkdl

a] d=wulnwua¢ln9ad=²;yn7qu ]wuyquypyn qua]l(qyncR¡ ]d=jl¤jksUawky7³d=ad=²;ynqk*qkd=a]´md

]jkd, mUjtqudwjl]*l$y7cLcRm¢lqkynpµ¶ Upm]d?$qud=a¢´md¡;dqt·dd+m]j~qkd=wuj=©9`aj]wkynqkypy7¹¸quj

quyGquad$a]lwlnqkd=wk¢jtqu=jyn§%l mUjtqudwg§¨d=pd=wulqkynº°lnwk7dmcR¡Ud=wgyn§xyppd?j¥1anaX¢l(qkd=]s¯ln]¯y(·

¡Ul]p·¢quadqt·ynwu² %qkd?ay7 y7nd=j¹¡;dqt·dd mUjtqudwju»©¼{'wud c]lwus;dwk§¨ynwuc$l]d9d(lm]l(qu y7

;dwk§¨ynwucd=\m]jk½l½pjuwudqud¯d7dq*jkcm¢l(quynwGjkay(·j$qua]l(q*qka]dOwuyquyynªj*j~m]¾ql¡d¯§¨y7wyppd

ynm] $l] ¢lqkyn]j=©

¿¤ÀÁ¹ÂuÃÄ

(Ån

m]j~qkd=wRÆd?pdwl(qu y7Z¥

ad=²;yn7qu ]Ol]'hd=y(7dwusn¥Æ]lm]¾qkµNquyndwl]dn¥v lnwuln d

{r=l(qu y7Z¥ yppd ynm]

Ç¢È1ÉkÊ¶Ë=ÌÉÍÎÊ¶ÏAÐÑ

Ò%Ó=ÔtÕ(Ö×NØNÙÚÔtÛÜÝ,ÞßÛ^Û^ÔàØ¶áÙÚâNÙÚ×AÖ?Üãâ

ä¬å1æ

âNÙÚ×°ØAÙÚÛ^ÔßÜÝ,Þßâ°ÙÚÛáÙÚâ°ÙÚ×¶Ö?Üã â

ç

Õ(Öè^â°ÙÚÛ(Öâ¶áÙÚÛ?è^ÙéÖ?Ü æ^ê

ÜëtÞßì

(5)

*- 3* 0*,#0-

d?j,l¢l(qu y7]j,pdRqts;d$y7m¢lndLpd$yppd?jª;dm]ndqquwkdp¢jkid=jgd=cyppmd=j

ynccm]=lqujrUy7m(lqgjdopi=mpqkd=wgjkmwª¾¦¹iwudqkd?jr7wuln;d=jrm]d§¨i?piwl(qu y7Z©rd§¨i?piwl(qu y7

d«nwl;d=jpd=l¢m¢l(qudmwjy7cUy7w~qlqm£7wuln]XyncR¡wkdpd«m]]j¥ ¢l¤wuyn¡]ln¡ qkiGpdpiµ

§°ln ¢l]dRmOm]¯d?jtqgqkwub=jªid7idn©y7m]jgwuyn;y7jkyn]jrmOwuyquypyndpdjulm7d7lnwudpdR;ynquj

dRwudwu¢j~dLaiwlwa´mdR´7m]¬yncR¡dRm]dqud=a]´md$pdjklnmnd=7lnwupdRyynwpyn]idLpdUy7 quj,pd

wud]wk¢j~dlm£jkdmd*nwl;d«dqLmdqkd?a¢´7m]dpd*jklnmnd=7lwpd$pdUy7 qujLpd*wkd=wujkd$ Upm quj

Ulw d?jy7cLcRm¢lqkyn]jdquwkdg d?jnwl;d=j=© dg]wkynqkypy7 d,y7dqlmpo=lwlnqkiwu¢jtqu´md?j%md

§¨i?piwl(qu y7Ldnwl;d=j9pdªl¢m]lqkdm]wujº¨7wuln]RyncR¡wkddm]j=¥n¢l(qud]didni=ddq9§°l¡dpi¡]¾q

dry7cLcRm¢lqkyndqkwudd=jxnwl;d=j»ß© d=jxwudc b=wkd?j9i(ln m]lqkyn]j¬wki?ljkid?j l¢pdrm«jkcmpµ

¢l(qudmw!Li=ni]dcdqujjuwudqjcLy7qkwudq´7m]dgdwuyquyyndªd?jtql7lpquilmpo+l¢l(qu y7]jpd,qtsUd

ynm]lnnd,pdyppd?j©

"Ä ? Â $# §¨i=pi=wulqkynpdnwl;d=j=¥ Uy7 qjRpdwkd=wujkdn¥qky7 i=wuln]dlmpo®§°lmqkd=j=¥¬l] ¢lqkyn]j

Ulwl b= d?j¥py7m¢l7dgpdyppd=j

(6)

% &

R¼ $3*0x#

m]j~qkd=wR§¨d?pdwl(qu y7]j$y7qul½lX¢lwundm]c¡;dw$y§gyppd=j$ln]Vlwudadqkd=wky7nd]dynmUj© ryppd=jVl

mUjtqudw%lnwkdyn§qkd=« ²7d=¡sLlR}p{ ºN}spj~qkdc {rwkd?l dqt·ynwu²» ·a dªm]jtqudwjxlnwkd ]²nd=«¡s {rj

º ypln#{rwkd?l dqt·ynwu²»ynwr±O{ ªjRº°±y7wk¢¯{wud=ldqt·ynwu²»ß©`adLl¢l(qu y7]jwum«y7¯j~mUa

lnwua]¾qud=ßqumwud=jglwudRyn§qkd®ppd?Oqky¤y7ccm¢lqk*cLyppm] d?j©`ad=jkdLcLyppm] d?j,cl^s¤]dd=Oqky

wum¯y7Op ¦;d=wkd=q, m]j~qkd=wujr§¨ynwg(lwu y7m]jwud=l7j~y7]j"'jkd=mwu¾qts7¥Ua]lnwu·lnwkdy7wªjky§qt·lwudy7]j~qkwl7qj¥;ynw

¡;d==lm]jkd¬quadl¢l(qu y7d=d=jlr7dwusª¢lwundxm]c¡;dw y§yppd?j© {Rdolcdxyn§Ujkm]al] ¢lqkyn]j

¢jLynd+y7m ]®jkd7dwlj~cm¢l(qu y7½yd=jRqka]lq«j~y7cLdqkcd=jLdd?£quy'ynccRm¢l(qud· qkaVd=l7a

ynqkad=w=©

`ad% qkd=wulqkmwudxpd?jkwk¡;d=jl ynq#yn§]ad=²;yn7q(^wud=j~qulnw~q1wuyquyyn¢jZjkm¾ql¡d¬§¨y7w# m]j~qkd=wuj#¡mpqnd=wks

§¨d=··ynwu²LaUlnj¡Ud=d*pyndªqkyln]lpqqkad?j~dgwuyquyyn¢j¬quyR¢lwundgjk=ldªlnwua qkd?ßqumwkd?j%jkm]a*lnjm]jtqudw

§¨d?pdwl(qu y7]j9lUquy,quln²nd¡;dd¸qxy§;qka]dry7cLcRm¢lqkynL]l(qkqkdwu]j9yn§¹yppdy7m ln=l(qu y7]j©

±Xd¯wuyn;y7jkd¤la] d=wulnwua¢lnad=²;yn7qu ]X]wkynqkypy7·aa\a]l7j$l® c¾qud=\c]lnq«ynVqkad

;dwk§¨ynwuc$l]d$y§yppdGynm] ¯l] ¢lqkyn]jdopd=mpqkd?® £l¯ mUjtqudw§¨d?pdwl(qu y7Z©*{ªjR}p{ dq~µ

·ynwu²pjm]j~d?$m]j~qkdwj dopa¡ q¬ y(·lqkdUsRln]Ra 7aquawuynm7ampq?¥7l,yynwp]l(qud=Rad=²;yn7qu ]

lnwuy7l7aX=l'¡;d«m]jkd=XqkyOd)«dqks®ad=²;yn7qqkadGj~qulqkd«yn§qkadwkypd=juj~d?j,dopd=mpqk¯]jkpd

l¤ mUjtqudw?©*{ªjdqt·%y7wk²pj,m]jkd=X§¨y7w qudwyn]d=qk¯m]j~qkdwj£l¤m]j~qkdw§¨d=pd=wulqkyn'lwud {rj

y7wR±{ rjL· qkaVl¯cmUaanad=wR¢l(qud]s'l]½l¯y(·%d=w¡]ln]p·¢qka½qka]ln½}p{rj=¥%lOyynwp Ul(qkd?

a]d=²Uy7 qu lnwuy7l7aL=lynq¬¡Udªm]jkd=$l(qxqkad§¨d?pdwl(qu y7 d=ndA©9`adadwlwa¢lnpwkynqkypy7p·%d

]wky7Uyj~dwud d?jynl$ynccRm¢l(qu y7pµ¶ ]m]d?¤ad=²;yn7qu ]«jtquwulqkd7s«quy«¡mOl$nyn¡]ln¼ad?²7µ

;ynqry§¬l«yppdy7m ]Gl] ¢lqkyn+dopd=mpqkd?+yn¯jkd7dwlZm]j~qkd=wujry§¬l«m]j~qkd=w§¨d=dwl(qkyn¼©{

ynccm]=l(qu y7pµA]pmUd=Lad?²;ynqkl]wkylna¢j9wud=l7j~y7]l¡d%§¨ynwxydynm] l] ¢lqkyn]j

l7j qudwkµAcyppmdynccRm¢l(qu y7]jlwud,yqnd=wksG qkd=]jk 7dn©

*

mwwuyquypynA¥9·a¢a£¢jL=l d?,+

.-

|ad?²Uy7 qkwkynqkypy7xquadwud=l§qkd=w=¥¬aUlnjR¡Ud=d½jkcmpµ

¢l(qud=m]j~'lXpjuwudqudd=nd=7q$jk cRmlqky7w=©£vxwkd= c ]lnwks'wud=jkm qujjkay(· qka]lq$¾q$·ynwu²jR·d· qka

ln=l(qu y7]j ²ndyd,ynm] ]©

`adwkd=c$l]pdwGy§,qka¢j]l;dwjGynwu7l] ³=d=\lnj§¨y7 y(·j=©}d=qkynQ®wud=jkdq$quadOwuyquypyn

d=jk 7¯wu ] ] d?j©,}d=qkyn/$pd=juwu ¡;d=jrqka]dadwlwa¢l¼wkynqkypy7#ync¡] *yynwp]l(qud=¤lU

ynccm]=l(qu y7pµA]pmUd=$a]d=²Uy7 qu qkd=a]´md?jxGlRm]jtqudw%§¨d=pd=wulqkynZ©9}d?ßqkynGwud=jkdquj

jkyncdy§%qkad«ln 7ynwu¾quac$j¥}d=qkyn'+j~ay(·j,l+julcd$dopd=mpqkynX·¾quaXqkad+ .- |,ad=²;yn7qu ]

]wkynqkypy7N©}d=qkyn10nnd?jl¡wu d§9d=juwu pqu y7+y§qkadjuwudquddnd=qrj~cm¢l(quynw·dm]jkd=§¨ynwrqkad

d=(lm]l(qu y7Lyn§¹qkad2+ .- | wuyquypynUl]$ln]ls³d=j¬wkd= c Ulwus;dwk§¨ynwucln]dwud=jkm quj=©#|àG}pd=ßqu y743¥

y7mw·ynwu²$jync]lwud=G·¾qua¤wkd=lqkd?«·ynwu²j=©¬}d=qkyn65ynUm]pd=j=©

7 8

-¼ " *%ß+-

9;:=< >@? ACBD=EGFIHJAKFLEEMJNPORQST?UHJE

WVXV #YNnpZYÄ\[ Ä Å À #T] ±XdRyn]jk¢pdw]lnwuln d#l¢l(qu y7]jpd?j~n]d=*m]jk «qkadyppdy7m ]

cyppd=N©v¬wuypd?jkjkd=jyn§ qka¢jr²]+y§xln=l(qu y7]jlwudppd?¤7quy«nwuynm]]jº¨cyppmd=j»ß©vxwkypd?jkjkd=j

]jkdxquadjklncLd%nwuynmLy7cLcRm¢lqkd%lªyq ·a dy7cLcRm¢lqkyn]j#¡Udqt·%d=dRwkypd=juj~d?j¼¡;dyn7 ]

(7)

quyGp ¦;d=wkd=qrnwuynmUjlwud c qkd=Z©|à7qudwkµA7wky7m¤y7cLcRm¢lqkyn]jc$l^s¡UdR ;dd=¯l7jOÆ 7mwud

e,y7wqkad=s«c$l^sGy7]j~¢j~qyn§doa]l7d=j¡;dqt·ddqt·yLcyppmd=j§¨y7wdolcdn©

Simulation Treatment Display

Cluster 1 Cluster 2 Cluster 3

Cluster Federation

Ænmwude ' \ /

Á = À Ä Å À #T] ±Xdlnjuj~mcdªqkadª§¨yny(· jksj~qkd=c cydA© {ªjj~a]y(·« +Æ 7mwud,¥l4\ j

ljkspjtqudcLµAd7d¹cyppmd,qka]lqcdcdqujqkadwuyquypynA©|¶qjln¡dªquy$jkl^7drquadwuyd=juj~d?j%j~qulqkd?j¥

quy=l(quaOdnd=wks+qkdwkµ¶wkypd=juj~d?jcd=jujklnndn¥¹lU¤qky*y7cLcRm¢lqkd· qkaXyquadwgyppd?j§¨y7wªwuyquypyn

]dd=]j©

Process1 Virtual inter−process Process2

communication send deliver

: application level : system level : virtual link between nodes : physical link : system call

Node1 Node2

transmit/receive

Æ 7mwkd'b /

G( Y¨ À # À Ä Å À #9 [ Å [#À ÃÄ V? V"YÄ\[ ] ±dlnjujkmcdglm]j~qkd=w%§¨d?pdwl(qu y7l7jl

jkdqgy§x m]j~qkd=wujª7qudwy7d=qkd?+¡s¤lG±O{ ¥;qkd=w~µàm]j~qkdwª ²pjª¡Ud= d qkad=wgd=p¢lqkd=¯ynwrd=nd=

|àqudwudq?¥7y7wxl { ©p}m]a«lnGlwa qkd?ßqkm]wkd¢jxjkm qul¡] dr§¨ynw¬quadªyppdry7m ]l] ¢lqkyn$cyppd

d=juwu ¡;d=®l¡;y(nd7©xl7aX7wky7m®y§wuyd=juj~d?j,c$l^sOwum® £l¤ m]j~qkd=w·ad=wkd$dqt·%y7wk²O ²pja]l^7d

jkc$llqkdUd=j9lU¢lwund¡]lUp·pqka]jºA}p{ g»ß©±Xdlnjuj~m]cLd%qkaUl(q¬l,j~d=7q9cd=jujulnd%· ¡;dwkd?dnd?

¯l¤lnwk¡ qkwlwus«¡mq¸] qkd¢lUjy§ qkcdn©`a¢jcd=ln]jqkaUl(qquaddqt·%y7wk²«¢jwud¢l¡dn¥ qªpyd?jyq

y7jkdcd=jujulnd?j© `a¢j%l7jkjkmcpqu y7« cd=jxqka]lq%quadr§°lnm q%quyndwl]dcd=a]lnjkc a]lnjxqkyqul²7dª=lwud

yn§#pµAqkwl]jk¾qcd=jujulnd?j¥pjk Ud,qka]dsGlnwkdlnjujkmcd=yqqky$¡;dy7j~q=©

(8)

Y# ¼

À

? V"Y

Ä [ ]

±d*lnjuj~m]cLd«qka]lqLy7 sXyn]d«§°lm]¾qLy=mwjlqLl¯qkcLd7© +ry(·%d=nd=w=¥#qkad

]wkynqkypy7]lnL¡;drdoqkdUpd=Lquyqky7 d=wulqkdrjk cRm qul]dynmUj §°lm quj%lnjxdop¢lL}d?ßqu y75© `ad§°lmwkd

cyppd=U¢j9§°ln µ¶j~qky7Z©± adGlyppd§°ln ¢jx q%·Uynq%jkd]$cd?jkjul7d=j¬lnscynwudn©`adr]wkynqkypy7pquln²nd=j

qky$ln=y7mq]d qkad=wyncjujk y7y7ws³?lqkdª§°lm quj=©

9;:9 RB .O ?S=HQS=HPDTF B E FLDTB F OJOJDS F QST?UHJE S=H D=MJE Q BBARBFXQS=?UHCE

*À V À[ Å À[ YÀ , [ Å£ Ä\[ ZY°= À[ ,?p À ] `adr¡]lnjk]wk]dy§Zl¡]l7²·lnwuRdwuwky7w9wkd?y(7dwus

qud=a]´md?jª¢jgqky*;dwu ypp¢ln s¯jtquynwudLl*y7]jkj~qkd=7qj~qul(qudy§¬quad$l¢l(qu y7Oy7wudwgqky*¡Ud$ln¡ d

quy¯wud=j~qulwkq§¨wuyncqkad=wkd«®qka]dGd7dqy§l+§°ln mwudn©¤{ ]wkypd?jkjjtql(qkdynUj~¢jtqjy§ln xqkad*l(ql¤¾q

]dd=]jqky$¡;dgwud=j~qulnw~qud=Xº¨A©d7© qkadw~qum]l1cd=cLy7wks7¥p ¢j~qyn§y7Ud=d=G¸]d=j=¥]jky²7dqj¥dq©Ú»ß©¬{"]lnwuln d

ln=l(qu y7j~qulqkd¢j¬pd¸]d=$l7j qka]drj~dqxy§1l qujxwkypd=juj~d?j9jtql(qkd?j©2 b! cLd?l]j9qka]lq¬qkad=wkd

¢j]d qkad=wªpµAqkwl]jk¾qªcLd?jkjul7d=jºNj~d=qª¡mpqgyqgwkd?d= 7d=]»y7wr7ay7j~q~µ¶cd=jujklnnd=jº°wkd?d= 7d=+¡mpqgyq

jkdqß»x*qkadjkdqyn§#wuypd?jkjj~qulqkd=jj~qky7wkd?1©

¯d=jujklnnd=j7dd=wulqkdpd=Ud=]pd=]d=j=©Æynwrdolcdn¥;Æ#nm]wkd$$]wkd?j~d=7qjqka]ddopd=mpqkyn¤yn§ qt·%y$wuyµ

d=juj~d?j,·a¢aX¡;yqua£jtquynwudLqkad= wyplnxjtql(qud=j$º£ln] wud=jk;d=ßqu 7ds»ß©G{ cd?jkjul7d jj~d=7q

§¨wuync.wuypd=jujeqkyG]wkypd?jkjªp©|¶§9quadRdopd=mqkyn¤¢jrwud=j~qulnw~qud=§¨wky7c.qkadLj~dqªy§¬j~qulqkd=j n¥;qkad

cd?jkjul7d )· Za]l^7dª¡;dd=¤wkd?dnd?«¡sG]wkypd?jkjR¡mpqªyqjkdq¡s«wuyd=juj,e$º¨na]y7j~q~µ¶cLd?jkjul7d?»©

vxwkypd?jkjge,· Zjkd])ln7ln Gqkywuyd=juj·a]a*j]yqy7]j~¢j~qkdq?© `a]d}qulqkd O=l*pd;d]

y7Gquady7qkdqy§ ·a]a*c$l^sGpd;dUy7Gquadj~qul(qud ©

P1

m S2

Time P2

S1

Æ#nm]wkd $' \! #"U #"U b#

`adcyjtqwud=d=qwud=ynw«yn§ ly7]jkj~qkd=7qj~qulqkd,jrld=Gqkad %$ \©

& À V Ä Y[ "Y[(' À Ä Å# ] à]dgwud=y(nd=wksL d,ln¡;dg§ÿnm]*l(qad?²;ynq%qu cd$ºÄ©dn©9·ad=

quadj~qulqkd=jªlwudjtquynwud=]»©`a¢jcdquayp¤jªln d=+yy7wup]lqkd=¤a]d=²Uy7 qu U©`a]jrcLd?l]jqkad=wkd

¢jLl¯qt·yµ¶a]l7j~d«yncc¾qwuyqkypynpmwu ·a¢al] ¢lqkyn£cd=jujulnd?jlnwkdG§¨wky7³d¼©± qka½qkad

]pd=Ud=]pd=7qad?²Uy7 qkRcLdqkayp1¥pd?lna«]wkypd?jkj%y§ l]lnwuln d¹l] ¢lqkyn*l*jtquynwudr qujypl

j~qulqkd· qkay7mpqªlns*j~s]a]wky7 ³?l(qu y7Z©x`adwud=y(nd=wks djªyncmqkd=+lqrwky7 ¡]l7²$qkcdn©)ªm]lnjk¾µ

jks]awuyny7m]j$cdquaypj+l¢j~ydopj~q=© Æy7wdolcd¯qka]dXln=l(qkyn cd?jkjul7d=jG=l¡;dXm]j~d?\qky

] 7nsµA¡Uln²jkyncdcy7wkdp§¨y7wkc$l(qu y7¤ ynwpdw§¨ynwªqkadRwkd?dnd=wqky²y(·"¾§x qª]dd=]jquyj~qkynwud quj

yplnj~qulqkdn©`a]jg¢lnj~qgcdquaypO¢j,ln d=¯ynccm]=l(qu y7pµA]pmUd=Oad=²;yn7qu ]]©+*Ú-,9wky(¢pd=j

dquln d=p§¨ynwuc$l(qkyn+l¡;ynmqqkad?j~dp ¦;d=wkd=qrad=²;yn7qu ]qud=a¢´md=j=©

(9)

p

'UÀ

=7#

À

V Ä Y[

ZY

[(' `ad9¢lwund9mcR¡Ud=wZy§yppd?j¼lUª]dqt·ynwu²r;dwk§¨ynwucln]d ¡;dqt·dd=

mUjtqudwjpy+yqly(·l*nyn¡]ln¬j~s]awuyn] ³?l(qkyn¼©R{®]pd=Ud=]pdqad?²Uy7 qk+cd=a]ln¢j~c

yd?jLyq¸q«d=¾quadwZ'*qkwln² ]pd=Ud=]pdUd=jLqky'yncmpqudquad¤wud=y(7dwusd¤l(q$wky7 ¡]l7²qu cd

·ynm]+¡;d7dwusGa]lnwu+lU¤yppd=jrc$l^swuyn ¡Uln²$quy«nd=wks*yn¢¤ad=²;ynqujºNpyncy«d¦¹d=q»©|¶§¬·%d

qkd=]®qkyXyn¯qkdwkµàm]jtqudwLynccRm¢l(qu y7]jGº¨qky®l^ny7X7qudwkµ¶ mUjtqudwRd;d]pd=]d=j»ß¥x·%ddd?

quadd=d·¢j~dRpdqudwucL¢jtquGº+«»l7jkjkmcpqkyn¼©`a]d +)l7jkjkmcpqu y7¤cLd?l]jqka]lqr·%dRlwud

ln¡d,qky«wud¢l^slUlwl d=Zdopd=mpqkyn+¯l«m]j~qkd=wqka]lqªwuyppm]d=jdopl7ßqu sGqkadjulcdcd=jujulnd?jlnj

quadR¸]wuj~q,dopd=mpqkynZ©R`aj,l7jkjkmcpqkynOjgnd=wks¤j~qkwuynU©hd]l^sl]lwlddopd=mpqkyn¯cd?l]j

dqkd?ßqu U¥ynn7 ]RlUwud]l^sLln 1]ynpµàpdqudwuc ¢j~qk¢ªd=nd=7qj¥p·a]a*jndwus«p)«m q=©

YÀ ^^ Y°7#1 À V Ä Y[ "Y[ ' |à]j~¢pdlm]j~qkdw#·%dxm]j~dlyy7wup]lqkd=,ad?²Uy7 qkcdquayp1©

|¶qd=]j~m]wkd?jrqua]l(q,quad$jtquynwud=Oj~qulqkd+ºquad«m]j~qkdwad?²Uy7 q»r¢jynUj~¢jtqudq=© yynwp Ul(qkd?¯ad?²7µ

;ynqk¯¢j;y7jujk ¡d«]jkpdlOm]j~qkd=wRlnjyppd=jRlwud«7qudwy7d=qkd?· qka½l¯ana';dwk§¨ynwuc$l]d

]dqt·ynwu²«º¨y(·½¢l(qud]sl]L¢lwund¡]ln]p·¢qkaU»©

yy7wu ]lqkd?Rad?²Uy7 qk,¢j9l,·%d= µAd?jtql¡¢j~ad?

qud=a]´md *5 ,¶¥ *%,¶¥ * e7e,¶¥ *e,·a¢aX¢jwud¢l(qu 7dsOd?lnjks¯qky¤cdcdq=©¯{

m]j~qkd=w dnd=

ad?²7µ

;ynqª¢jr=l d? quadwud=l§qkdw?©r`adLlnjuj~m]cLqkyn+qkaUl(qrquadmcR¡Ud=wryn§¬ qkd=w~µàm]j~qkd=wrcd=jujklnnd?j

¢jy(·Qd=ln]jm]jqky$m]jkdlynccRm¢l(qu y7pµ¶ ]m]d?Gcdquayp*¡Udqt·%d=d+m]jtqudwj©9`a¢jcd=ln]jd=l7a

mUjtqudwql²7d=j; Upd;d]dqksn¥¹¡mpqg §¨ynwuclqkyn¤¢jrl7pd=¤qky«d?lna¤7qudwkµ¶ mUjtqudwrynccm]¾µ

=l(qu y7Z©¬|¶qc$l^sGd=l7Gquadwud=d= 7dwquyqul²7dl ; º°=l d?G§¨y7wud= ª»qky«d=]j~m]wkdgqka]dwkd?y(7dwus

d]wky7nwud=juj© `adwud§¨y7wkdO·%dXwuyn;y7jkdl£a] d=wulnwua¢lnrwuyquypyn,y7c¡½yynwp Ul(qkd?lU

ynccm]=l(qu y7pµA]pmUd=ad=²;ynqk¤º+ .- |~»ß©

8

-¼% ßG &½# &

*LXR#* " ,#$

`a]jjkd=qkyn*wkd?j~d=qujqka]d+ .- |ad?²;ynqkLwkynqkypy7N¥quadlny7wk qka]cj=l*¡Ud,§¨y7m]* *3 ,¶©

;:=< D=MCE Q B DTBUBXD RB .O ?S=HQS=H

|àOd=lna¯ mUjtqudw?¥Ul$quwul7p qkyn]ln1qt·%ynµA]a]lnjkdy7cLc qªwuyquypyn#jrm]jkd=1©r{rO qk¢l(qky7wryppd¡wkylnµ

=lnj~quj$º° ' quj mUjtqudwß»,l ; bºNlny7wk qkac $7»ß©{¬qka]d«m]jtqudw]yd=jl7²]y(· d?pndRqkad

wud=´md?jtq?¥(qka]dLqkadr qk¢l(quynw9yppd¡]wkyln=lnj~quj l A©{r 7ynwu¾quac,wudwud=jkdqj ynmw9c d=cdpµ

ql(qu y7yn§xqka]dqt·%ynµAaUlnjkdRy7ccL qwuyquyynA© dqt·%d=d¯quad$wud=´md=j~ql]qka]dyncc¾qcd?jkjul7d=j=¥

ln=l(qu y7cd=jujklnnd?jLlnwkd+´mdm]d=qky®wudnd=qLqkwl(µàm]jtqudw$pd=Ud=]pdUd=j¤º°ln 7ynwu¾quac n»©\|à

y7wudwªqky*¡Ud$l¡] dLqky*wudqkwudnd l(qlG®lnjkdLy§%lyppdL§°l m]wkd7¥1d=lnayppdwkd?y7wu¤ qujg]lnw~q

yn§qkad ß¥¬l]''quadGcdcy7wksXy§lyqka]dw]ydG'qkad*m]j~qkdw?© d==lm]jkd«yn§qua¢jRj~quln¡ d

j~qky7wulnndg cdcd=7ql(qu y7Z¥yn] s«y7djk cRm¾qld=ynm]j§°lnm q ¤lm]j~qkdwrjquyndwl(qud=1©xl7a ;j

mcR¡Ud=wkd?1© xlna¯]ydl« m]j~qkd=wªc$ln quln Ujªlj~d?´7m]d]dmc¡;dwº¯»ß© ¢jª ]wkd=cdqkd?

d?lnaqu cdlW;¢jyncc¾qkqkd?1©`a]jdUj~mwud=j¼qkaUl(qqkadj~d?´md]d%mcR¡Ud=w#¢j#qkadjulcdxy7Rlqkad

]yd=j9yn§1l mUjtqudwrº°ynmpqj~¢pdqka]dqt·%ynµA]a]lnjkdyncc qxwuyqkypyn»ß©#`a]d jxm]jkd=R§¨ynw¬qkd=w~µàm]j~qkdw

d;d]pd=]s+quwul7² U©ª|àUpdd?1¥1d=l7aOm]j~qkdwgql²nd?jr quj ;dwu ypp¢ln sn¥¹]pd;dUpdqks+§¨wuync

quadyquadwj=©

(10)

;:9 RBARBFXQS=?UH DTBUBXD RB .O ?S=HQS=H

|àOynmw,l] ¢lqkyn¯cyppdA¥1y7cLcRm¢lqkyn]jr¡Udqt·%d=d¤qt·yGwuypd?jkjkd=jr Xp¾¦¹dwudq,m]jtqudwjrc$l^s

ln;d=lw?©x`a¢j7dd=wulqkd?jpd;d]d] d?j¡;dqt·dd ql²nd=+ ¯p ¦¹dwudqrm]j~qkdwj=©ªd;d]pd=pµ

d?jgdd?¤qky*¡;dquwul7²nd=¯ Xynwpdwrqky+l y(·"quad$l] ¢lqkyn¤quy¡;dwkd?jtqlwkqkd=¤§¨wky7c lyn]jkj~qkd=q

j~qulqkd7©½Æy7wu ]Xl ½qka]d*wud=dnd=wj m]j~qkd=w§¨ynwd=l7aqkdwkµàm]jtqudwl] ¢lqkyncd?jkjul7d

·ynm]·ynwu²¡mqxqka]dry(nd=wka]d=lnR·ynm¢¡Udªamndl7j¬ q%·ynm¢L§¨ynwdmUj~d= d?jkj¬a]d=²Uy7 qj©|àGÆ 7mwud

U¥m]j~qkdwxrql²nd?jZqt·yg§¨ynwd? ºquad¸] d=Ryn]d=j»#lq9cLd?jkjul7dxwud=dpqu y7Z¥nlUqka]dl¢l(qu y7

ql²7d=jªcLd?jkjul7d=jª quy*l7y7mqªy7 s¤·a]d¯quadL§¨ynwd? j,yncc¾qkqkd=Z© £¢jªmUj~d§¨m'g

quadd7dqy§9lL§°lmwkd7¥]lwuyn ¡]l7²qky X '· Z¡;dyn]jkj~qkd=qº +¤·ynm¢G¡;djkdqrlU

wud=dnd?¤l7ln ;»ß©

*

¯qkadLyquadwga]lU1¥;§¨ynwG ®¢jªmUj~d= d?jkj"'m]jtqudwLea]l7jr]yqgj~qky7wkd?¯ls

;¡;dqt·ddO¾qjqt·y«cd=jujklnndjkdUp ]]©|àOqkadRdnd=qry§xl«§°l mwud qª·#a]l^7dqkywky7 ¡]l7²«qky

; ¤·aa· ¹§¨ynwdgm]j~qkdwqkywuyn ¡]l7²quy ;n© ¤·ynm]Ga]l^ndª¡Ud=d*m]j~d§¨m¹yns$ §

mUjtqudwe,·%y7m¢Ga]l^7djtquynwud=Gl l§qkd=wj~d=]p Ol]¡Ud§¨ynwudj~d=]p 7©

C1

C2 CLC1

Time

CLC2 CLC3

m1 m2

Ænmwud,' I" ! + # /

`am]j=¥xl ; ¢j§¨y7wud=®£quadwud=dnd=wj m]j~qkd=wRy7sX·a]d½l aUlnjR¡Ud=d½j~qky7wkd?'

quadjkd]pd=wj m]j~qkd=w b\ b; b! ! $

b!ß©,`a¢jª¢j,y77quwky7 d=+mUj~«quad º° qkwuyppm]d=¤X}d?ßqu y7 $©e?»©g`a]dLmwkwudq,m]jtqudw j

jkd=´md=]dmc¡;dw+¢j] 7nsµA¡Uln²nd?\ynEd=lnaQ qkd=w~µàm]j~qkd=w*ln=l(qkynEcd=jujklnndºA}d=qkynJ]©$

d=juwu ¡;d=j%qka]dcLd?jkjul7dªlqulj~qkwum]ßqumwkd^»ß©9`#yL¡;dl¡dgqky$pd?¢pd,¾§ l ;J]dd=]jqky¡Ud, qk¢l(qkd?1¥

ln ¼qkadLwuypd=jujkd=j¯d=l7a¯m]j~qkdwªdd?+qky²nd=d+qka]d¢lnj~qªwud=d= 7d=¤jkd=´md=]dmcR¡Ud=w§¨wuync d=l7a

ynqkad=w mUjtqudw?©#{qka]d=jkdjkd=´md=]d%m]c¡;dwjlnwkd%jtquynwud=Rl Jºrwkd?ßqrd=Ud=]pd=]d=j9d=qky7w=¥

*Ú-,¨»ß©x{r 7ynwu¾quac 0jkay(·jay(·quadwkd?d= 7dwpd=d=j § qdd?jquyL qk¢l(qudl§¨y7wud= ©

¯ynwudr§¨y7wkc$ls\' Rjqkad Ed=qkwus«y§9m]j~qkdwß¥;l] ! jquadjkd=´mdUd,mc¡;dw

yn§ m]j~qkd=w ©

Æ]ynwlm]j~qkd=w'

|¶§ "#ß¥ $"

|¶§ &%

'

ß¥ $"P bU$ )(+* \#\,^©

ryqud,qka]lqqkadRj~³dyn§ qkad ¢jqka]dmc¡;dwªy§9m]jtqudwj+qkad§¨d?pdwl(qu y7Z¥]]yqqka]dmc¡;dw

yn§]yd=j=©$|àXy7wudw,qky+a]l^7dLqkad«julcd ln] yn®d=l7a]ydL]jkd«l¤m]jtqudw?¥¼·dm]j~d

quad$j~s]a]wky7 ³?l(qu y7¤ ]m]d?O¡s¤quad ; qt·yµ¶a]l7j~dLy7cLc qwkynqkypy7¼quy*jks]awuyn³dqkad=c

ºNlnj,pd?jkwk¡Ud?¯¡s¯lny7wk qka]c.»ß© %lnaqkcLdRqka]d+ jgm¹lqkd=Z¥¼l«§¨y7wud= ; ¢j,¾qulqkd?

·a]a¯d=]jkmwkd?jqua]l(ql#qkadLyppd=jª¯qka]dL m]j~qkd=wª·a]aOqul²7dRl,;· ¡;dqu cd?jtqlcUd?¯¡s

quadjulcd lqyncc¾qqu cd7©

(11)

;: ?UEGQ?PFU?S=A M B ?UDDJF ;E

yy7wup]lqkd=*ad?²;ynqk cd=jquy$wky7 ¡]l7²$qkaddqkwkd mUjtqudwyn§ lL§°lnm¾qtsyppdn©±Xd·lnq

quyG c qªquadLm]c¡;dwgy§% m]j~qkd=wujrqkaUl(qªwuyn¡]ln²¹©r|¶§xqkadj~d=]pd=wªyn§xl«cd=jujklnndyd?jr]yq,wky7 ¡]ln²

·a] dquadLwkd?dnd=wªpyd?j¥;qka]dLjkd]dw jgm]j~qkdw,pyd=jgynqªd=d=¯qky*¡UdR§¨ynwd?+qky*wky7 ¡]l7²;©ª± ad

lGcd=jujklnnd¢j,j~d=7q,ynmqujkpdLl mUjtqudw?¥Uquadj~d=]pdwgyn7jª qgy7pqkcj~qk¢ln s+ ¾qjª7yn¢l(qu dcdcy7wks

º° y7n7d=cd=jujklnnd?jxlwudrmUj~d?«yn] s §Zqkad,jkd]pd=wyd?jx]yqwky7 ¡]ln²»©`a¢j%jjkay(·«¡s$lnynwu qkac

©`ad+cd=jujklnnd+j$l7²y(· d?pnd?£· qkaVqka]d¤wkd?dnd=wj ·aa\¢j$ynn7d=½lynX·¾qua\qkad

cd?jkjul7dg qujkd §º°ln 7ynwu¾quac 3n»ß©`addoqgj~d?ßqkyn+do]ln ]j·aa¤cd?jkjul7d=jlwudwud¢l^snd?G+qkad

d=nd=7qyn§lL§°lmwkd7©

;: ?UDDJF

± a]dlryppd§°ln mwud¢j pdqud=qkd=Z¥qka]d mUjtqudw wky7 ¢j¡]ln²,quyª quj ¢lnj~q¬jtquynwud=1;"º¨qkadd=juwu pqu y7

yn§ qkad§°ln mwudpdqkd=qky7wjrynmpqªy§9qka]djkyn;dy§ quajr]l;dwß»ß© * dyppd¤d=lna¤ynqkad=wrm]j~qkd=wr

quadg§¨d=pd=wulqkyn*wkd?d= 7d=jl bA©9|¶qynql]jqkadg§°lnm¾qtsm]jtqudw j qua]l(qrynwuwkd?j~;yn]]j

quyquad ;QquyR·a]a¾qwky7 ¢j%¡]ln²¹© ± ad*l]ydªwud=dnd=j%j~mUal *ldwkqx§¨wuync lnyquadw

mUjtqudw9· qkaL¾qj9d· ¥(¾q¬ad?²j §; qujxm]jtqudw d=d=jquywky7 ¡]ln²,¡sync]lwuª quj \dquwks

ynwuwkd?j~;ynUp ],qkyquad§°lnm qts mUjtqudw¬quyquadrwud=dnd= ©|¶§1qkadr§¨ynwucdwx¢j%nwud=l(qudw9qua]lGynwxd?´m]l

quy*qkad$¢l(qkqkdw qujm]jtqudwd=d=jgquy+wky7 ¡]ln²+quy*qkad¸]wj~q$º¨qkadGyn¢pdwß»4; ·aaXa]l7j,¾qj

d=qkwusRy7wkwud=jk;yn]pgqkyqkad§°lnm qtsL m]j~qkd=w¬nwud=lqkd=w qka]ln$ynw¬d?´7mUlquyqka]dwkd?d= 7d= ©n`adyppd

qua]l(qaUlnjwud=d= 7d=«qkadln d=w~q¾qulqkd?jqkad,wuyn ¡Uln²¹©

|¶§¬l$ m]j~qkd=wd=d=jquy$wky7 ¡]l7²Gpmd,quyGlwkd?d= 7d=*ldwkq=¥ qªjkd]jrl6 6#bynquln $ quj

]d· quy$ldwkqln Zqkadynqkad=wm]jtqudwj©9`a¢j¢jay(·quadwud=y(7dwusRdjryncmqkd=Z©

xnd+ §9¾qjrm]j~qkd=wrpyd=j]yqrd=d=qkyGwky7 ¡]ln²¹¥lyppdwkd?d ]l6 6 b¡wuy7l7l7jtqj¾q

+¾qjr m]j~qkd=w=© yn7nd?Gcd=jujulnd?jj~d=7qrqky$yppd?j *quad§°lm]¾qts*m]jtqudwrl7²y(· d?pnd?«· qka¯l

7wkd?l(qudwqka]lnGquadldwkqynd$º°ynwynqrln²y(·d=p7d=«lqrl¢»%· 1quad+¡;dwkd?j~d=q=©

* m]wLynccm]=l(qkynµA]pm]d=®cd=aUl¢j~c c d=jRqua]l(qm]jtqudwj]dd=£qky²ndd=£cm]¾qu d ;

ln] y7nnd?«cd=jujulnd?j©9`ad=s«d=d=qky¡;d7lwu¡]lnndµày7 d=qkd?1©

;: F CF B ?D=DTB \Q S=?UH

*

m]wxwuyquyyn;dd?jxqkyRj~qky7wkdªcm qkd4; g d=l7a«m]jtqudw ynwpdwxqkyLyncmqkdªqkadgwkd?y(7dwus

dlqwuyn¡]ln²ªqkcdn© `ad%cd=cLy7wksy7j~qc$l^s,¡Ud?y7cLdcL;ynwkqulnq=©¼v d=wkypp=l s7¥^ynw·adLlryppd

cd=cLy7wksjklqkmwl(qud=j=¥llwu¡]l7dªyn d?ßqkyn*¢j ]¾qulqkd=Z© * mw7lnwk¡Ulnd,y7 d=qky7w¢jdqkwl ³=d=1©¬{

]yd¾qulqkd?jªlG7lwu¡]lnndy7 d=qkynZ¥; q,l7j~²pjy7d]yd¯d=l7aOm]j~qkdwªqky*j~d=]¤¡]l7² qujgj~qªyn§

ln #qka]d l7jkjkyp¢l(qkd?*·¾qua¯qka]dRj~qkynwud= ; ß©`ad=¯¾q,j~cm]lqkd=jgl§°ln mwud¯d=l7a¯m]jtqudw

ln]+²nd=d]jqkadLj~c$ln d=j~q quy«·a¢a¤qka]dRm]j~qkd=wujyn§9qkad§¨d=pd=wulqkyn¤cnaqrwuyn ¡]l7²¹©|¶q,j~d=]j

l7d=qkynwªynql ]«lZqka]dj~c$ln d=j~q ,qky«y7dyppd¤d=l7a¯m]j~qkdwr·aa¤¡]wkyln=lnj~quj qª

qujrm]jtqudw?©

%lnayppdwudcy(nd?jqkadW; ·aa$aUl^ndqka]dwxm]j~qkdw dqkwusRjkc$l d=w qka]lnqkadrjkc$l d?jtq

º°wkd?dnd?G*qkad7d=qkynwß»%lnjuj~yp¢l(qud=GqkyLqka]dwrm]j~qkdw?©

`a]dsOlnjkywudcy(7dynn7d=OcLd?jkjul7d=jrqka]lqlwudLl7²]y(· d?pnd?¤·¾qua'l jkcln dwgqua]lqkad$wudµ

(12)

dnd=wj% mUjtqudwj~c$ln d=j~q ©p{ny7wk qkac 5Ll¡;ynmqlwu¡]l7dry7 d=qkynGcd?jkjul7d=j¬¢jl(qqka]dªd=]Gyn§

]doqrj~d?ßqu y7Z©

# -

`a]j9jkd=qkyn]wkd?j~d=7qj#qkadc$lLln 7ynwu¾quac$jy§quadR+

.-

|

ad?²;ynqkgv¬wkynqkypy7N©(¤ynwudpdqlj

=lX¡Ud«§¨ynm]X *0%,ªº¨£Æwud]a;»ß©G`#y¤c$l²nd qRjk cd$·%dqkwuym]dquad$yqu y7®y§ ß©*|à

d?lnaG mUjtqudwyndªwkc$lwus6 ln]$yn]dgjkd=yn]lnwks Rlwudray7jkdº¨*lRjtql(qk¢·l^s$l(qqkad

qk¢l ³?l(qu y7U»ß© `ad=jkdr]yd=jxlnwkdwud=jk;yn]jk ¡] d§¨y7w¬§°ln mwudrpdqud=qkynZ¥wkd?jtqlwkqk,§°lm]¾qtsyppd?jxlU

qkd=w~µàm]j~qkdw9]wkynqkypy7]y7cLcRm¢lqkyn]jº°wky7 ¡]ln²Rldwkqxl]lwu¡]l7dyn d?ßqkyncd=jujulnd?ju»©#`ad

ln 7ynwu¾quac$j%lnwkdªyqpdquln d=1¥§¨y7wdolcdn¥ !" #$ Z. (,,cd?l]jj~qkynwuquad, ypln1jtql(qkd

ypln sGlUGy7*lnyquadwyppd$ºNl]*·l qkL§¨ynw qujl7²]y(· d?pnd=cLd=q»ß©

%lna+m]jtqudwa]l7jlLm¢´7m]d|¥]ln]* +d?lna mUjtqudw?¥pd=lna*yppda]l7jl¢j~ylLm¢´mdwuln²¹©

C:=< FXQ FPE Q M \QMBE

`a]d=jkd,lnwkdjkyncdl(qljtquwkm]qkmwud=jm]jkd=**qkadln 7ynwu¾quac$j©

& Ä\[ == [ =

I b gmcR¡Ud=wy§ m]j~qkdwj=©

I b!$ quad|yn§ m]j~qkd=w ©

qkadmcR¡Ud=wy§ yppd=j¤m]j~qkdw ©

J quad|yn§#yppd $*qkad m]j~qkd=w ©

9j~dqy§ mUjtqudw¬d=l7pdwj=©

+ %j~dqy§¼quad,yquadw m]j~qkd=wujd=l7pdwj%µ¬ +d=l7a m]j~qkd=w=¥quadd=lndwj%aUl^ndªqky¡Ud

l¡d,qky$ynccm]=l(qkd,· qka*qka]dyqka]dwj©

Y À

(

" pd=l^s«¡;dqt·dd=+ad=lnw~qu¡Ud?l(quj%§¨y7wqkadg§°ln mwudpdqud=ßqu y7Z©

J$ " gpd=l^spm]wkr·a]a·dj~ay7m¢a]l^nd%wkd?d= 7dxl(q d?lnj~q#y7dxad?lwkqk¡;d=lq¼§¨wuync

d7dwus«yppd, ¤lm]j~qkd=w=©

! $ #Z." Rc$l(op cRmc qu cd¡;dqt·dd*l1#. b%lUG qujynwuwkd?j~;yn]pµ

]/ A©

"U # J" Oc$locm]c qu cdqkyO·l qLl§qkd=wLl, b§¨y7wwud=d= Oln

ln²y(·d=p7cdquj=©

(13)

" Rqkcd¡Udqt·%d=d+7lnwk¡]lnndgynd=ßqu y7]j=©

Z. " qu cd¡;dqt·dd=qt·yLmp§¨ynwd? ; ©

$ À ^

\ quadjkd=´mdUd,mc¡;dw?©

qkad ¼©

bZ. %l¡;yynd=l,quy²y(·X¾§]l]yd¬j#mwuwudqksr,qkadxqt·%y]a]lnjkdxy7ccL q¼wuyquypyn

º¨A©d7©xad?²;ynqk»©

lLnd?ßquynw·¾qua + ¬dqkwu d?jqkywudcdcR¡Ud=wqkadwud=dnd=Gad=lnw~qu¡Ud?l(qj©

" ly7s«y§ 7©

Z.C jkdqyn§yppd?jqka]lqa]l^nd,ln²y(·d=nd,l6 bN©

J

j~dqyn§]yd=jqkaUl(qa]l^7dgl7²]y(· d?pnd,l # " bA©

! wuln²«y§#qkad¢lnj~q "¾qulqky7w=©

%Ä' xl7aL]ydynj 7yn¢l(qkd%cdcy7wkscd?jkjul7d=jwkd=lqkd?quy qkd=w~µàm]j~qkd=w ynccm]=l(qu y7]j '

quadrcd?jkjul7d¾qj~d=¾§t¥7qkadªwkd?d= 7dw j9|R¥l]Lquadªjkd=´md=]dmcR¡Ud=wxyn§1qkadªwkd?dnd=wº¨²y(·$¡sLqkad

cd?jkjul7dgl7²]y(· d?pnd=cLd=q»ß©

C:9 HCSTQ S=FLD=S F QST?H

{r 7ynwu¾quac ejqkadR qk¢l³=l(qu y7¤j~d?´7m]d]dn¥] qª¢jrynd¡s*d=l7a*]yd +quadR mUjtqudw§¨d?pdwl(qu y7

lqª¢lmUa¤qkcdn©,|¶qgjkdqjrquad #¥]quadLjkd=´md=]dm]c¡;dw?¥¹jkyncdR^lnwk¢l¡] d?jrlU¤ ]¾quln ³dj~y7cd

qu cd=wuj=©

#';Ä Y°U ]¾quln ³=lqkyn

!"$#

%$&'('*),+

"-.0/

%$&2143 /

5627 8

3:9;=<>?

A@CBEDGF2H2/

IJKLEMON2PEQORSTCUVWYXZ0[G\C]_^4V`

!ba/

IJKLEMON2PEQORSTCUcd2e

^4V`

!ba/

fhgjiYkmlon

Op2q!.rs*t0u

IJKL0MON2PQORESTCUvc:w

dX Vx

^4V`

!ba/

(14)

C: >@BEE F BXE E Q M \QM B

¯d=jujklnnd=jdopaUl7d=«¡s«]yd=ja]l^7dªquad,§¨yny(· j~qkwum]ßqumwkd '

qka]dpd=qk qtsGy§#qkadjkdUpdwº°¾qjwuln²Gln] mUjtqudw|gju»

#

b

«ºNj~d=d / #+lny7wk qkac«»©

Gº°jkddW" Llny7wk qkac«»©

b¤qkadjkdUpdw jjkd=´md=]d,mcR¡Ud=w=©

(15)

#';Ä Y°1 ¤d=jujulnd?j r¢j~Ul(qua]

r

%

f ` !#"%$'&("%)!%*,+-"%.%&0/j`21 :"!

[q r:s.t0u

3

"%!%!54#6("27)98

3

+;:<">=%?@!+A"9)

/

BC

f

rD2s

` +FEGH"

#

D B tJIKMLN

M%O5P#Q5R JLSISTCU`

a2/

D B t

gjiYk(k2TVU IVK

TWI2I%XJ2M%O#R JLS2I2STCU`

a/

D B tJYZ

[#SRJLS2IS:TCU`

a/

D B tJ\I

]

M%RJLS2IS:TCU`

a/

D B tJ^_JN

lYg

_

Ujk`UjkmlYg

N

QOL#QST:LJI5a2IST5Q#R JLS2I2STCU`

a/

rs*t

C fB t

b@ !9+c4>$d8)

3

4?`4G0G ?*A=%4+e*f8$

3

"9!!54#6("27)%8

3

+e:<"V!4

3

"g=%?@!+A"9)gh2$'8+e:(*e$6i+A8M&08

/

f q0!

V

j

d2e

/+F)9@d"

rs*t0u

k

QWT Sl S

k5k J ]

SU`

a/

t0m

Bt

S2SI2Q%nSTCU`

a/

t0m

B t 3

"%!%!54#6("27)98

3

4$d8+e:<"%)>=%?@!+-"%) *e$o+;:<"p7"%&("%)%4+F*f8$

/

f q0!

V

j

d2e

/+F)9@d"

r:s.t0u

?F"+q+;:<">=%8#8)%&*e$'4+-"&M=%:<"%=9r9G 8*e$<+<st$H*e!:

/

k

QWT S9lS

k5k%u TWRvK#Q U`

a/

t0m

B t

BC

f

rD2s

`+eE5G "

#

D B t

gji k(k`TwU IK

Ujk(l g N

+;:<"V$'8#&(" *e!G4)5+p87V*,+e!>=9?@ !9+-"%)9!?xy"+

/

TWII%XEJ2M%O#a2I2ST5Q5R JLS2IST U`

a/

D B t U IVK

J2M%O

u

TWRvK#Q

k

Q9S2S9RJLS2IS:TCU`

a/

r:s.t

C fB t

b@!+p4>$'8)

3

4?`4G0G ?*A=%4+F*f8$

3

"%!%!4#6"

/

RS

k5k%u TWRvKQ

k

Q9S2SR JLS2I2STCU`

a/

C: RB .O ?S=HQS=H FLD ? S!QCN E

(16)

#';Ä Y°Z ]¾qulqkd ²v9q

*e$H*,+F*f4?*54+F*f8$ 87!8

3

"&04+f4>!+F)%@'=+F@)9"9!

/

<>? <1?

E/

5627 8

3:9;=<>?

H2/

838?8

? 7

%$&

3 </

+A4r0"g+;:<"V$'8#&("!g8 $o+-"%$d+A4+e*("=%:<"%=9r9G 8*e$<+

/

Q JO SP SLQJ9QQ%nSO5P5Q U a/

4!%rJ+e:<"g8+e:<"%)w$d8&("%!w*e$ +;:<"=%?@!+A"9)+A8M&08J+;:<" !4

3 " /

X2TWJS2J

k

QSO5P5QCU a/

*e$ =%4!#"87`794*e?@)"g&@)9*e$ 6 +e:<"=%:<"9=%r9G 8*e$d+

/

IJKLEMON2PEQORSTCU p V

"!$#:!

X

^4V`

!ha2/

cd?jkjul7d· U¡;d

&%

vx` l]«¾qjxjkm¡pqtsUdª· ;¡Ud ~{

&%

~»·¾qua b«quyquadyppdªwkd=wkd?j~d=qkd=L¡s

©

±Xd$lnXjkddRqka]lqqkad$jks]awuyn³=lqkyn¯]pm]d=X¡s+qkadqt·y*a]lnjkd$y7cLc qwkynqkypy79l¢j~y+j~spµ