• Aucun résultat trouvé

The Progressive Second Price Mechanism in a Stochastic Environment

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "The Progressive Second Price Mechanism in a Stochastic Environment"

Copied!
39
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00071828

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00071828

Submitted on 23 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub-

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,

The Progressive Second Price Mechanism in a Stochastic Environment

Patrick Maillé, Bruno Tuffin

To cite this version:

Patrick Maillé, Bruno Tuffin. The Progressive Second Price Mechanism in a Stochastic Environment.

[Research Report] RR-4758, INRIA. 2003. �inria-00071828�

(2)

ISRN INRIA/RR--4758--FR+ENG

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

The Progressive Second Price Mechanism in a Stochastic Environment

Patrick Maillé , Bruno Tuffin

N˚4758

Mars 2003

THÈME 1

(3)
(4)

,

-)+ .$/('

021436587:9<;>=?1@7:ABA:CEDGFIH-5KJLMONPJQRLTS

UWV4XZY[\2]_^`Kab[Kcedgfh[ijabkgalimXZY[Ka

npobqerl[itstomYqeo

^tceuvuwqxoyitzg[om[K{|V4[Zo|{|Vv[}.~€g€‚eƒ„]&…†c€o|a‡€ˆxˆe‰]_‰x‚(u4c€Šx[Ka

‹hŒ+KŽZ<v‘eŽe’ “ [t{qx}4ay”•zg[Ko+”–}(ibVv”•aIu4ceuw[Koce}-ced4{im”—qx}g˜š™4ceab[Kz.uvob”•{”–}vŠ›ab{|V4[ZY[Wob[8{[Z}œim—k”–}œibomqGzvd4{[8z

™Gk2žc€Ÿ8c€o ce}4z¡G[ZYom[i imqjc€––qG{Kc<im[+™wc€}4zg¢”•zGimV.c€Yqe}4Šdway[KomaK£UWVv”•a Y[K{|Vwc€}v”•ayYE¤6{Zce—–[Kz›npomqeŠxob[8abab”–¥e[

¡g[K{qx}4zEnpom”–{Z[e¤¦¢Wceajayibdwzg”—[8z§d4ab”—}4Š)ibqGqe•aj¨©obqxYª}vqx}g˜«{qGqeu@[Zo|c<im”—¥x[Šxc€Y[imVv[Zqxobkx¤v¨©qxo2c¬4fG[8z†ab[iPqe¨

u4–c6kx[Zo|a†­©”B£[x£—¤jd4ay[Koma|®£ “ [¯{qeYu4ceob[§V4[Zom[§ibVv[„ob[8ayd4°i|a±qe™vimc€”–}v[8z²”—}>ibV4c€i{Zcxay[³¢”°imV²ibVv[„Yqeom[

om[Kce—”•ayib”•{)ay”—ibd4c€ib”–qe}´¢V4[Z}´uv•c6ke[Koma›o|c€}wzgqeY–k„[K}xim[Zo(qeo.–[Kc6¥x[ibVv[ŠxceY-[x£ “ [ceamayd4Y-[±ibV4c€i.ibV4[Zk

[K}œib[ZoWce{K{qxomzg”–}vŠ›imq-c.n+qx”–amabqe})uvomqg{[KamaK¤œce}4z)–[Kc6¥e[j”°ic<¨µim[ZoWc€}±[ZfGu@qe}4[Z}œib”•c€–—k)zg”•ayibom”—™vdvib[Kzhayqerlqedvom}

im”—Y[x£

“

[.ayV4q<¢¶imV4c<iimVv”–aPalimqg{|V4ceayib”•{›ceamaydvYugim”—qx}§{Zc€}4}vq€it™@[.ab·œ”–uvu@[KzEab”—}4{Z[”°i2{Zc€}E–[Kcxzhimq)¥e[Kobk

zv”°¸¦[Zom[Z}œiob[8ayd4°i|aZ£

¹§ºœ»¦¼m½.¾ <¿+e’ …³c€om·eq<¥±{|V4ce”—}4aK¤gÀtqx}g˜š{ZqGqeu@[Zo|c<ib”–¥e[2ŠxceY[PimVv[Zqxobkx¤gnpom”–{Z”—}vŠw¤vU[K—[8{qxY-Y(dv}v”•{Zc€ib”–qe}4a

Á•Â*ÃbĚÅKÆWÃÇ+ȖĚÉBÊË

ÌpÍ6ÎtÏ|ÐÒÑÒÑÒÓbÔ+Õ:ÓlÖ6Ö6Ól×yØÓyÖ8×:ÙÛÚµÜ6ÕÛÓlÙBÏ|ÝÖ6ÓØޗÕ

ß

Ü8ÙBàKáրÔ+ÐÒÕÛÐÒךÏ8ØޗÕ

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes

(5)

-)+ .t$/(' *' )#*'

 ’ Àtqxd4a2{qe}way”•zg`Zomqe}wajzvce}4a›{[ic€obib”•{–[.d4}v[(Y`ZibVvqgzg[zg[(imc€om”—¬w{Zc€ib”–qe}†™4cxay`K[(abdvo›zg[Ka

[K}4{|VvXKob[8a [ZiWom`K{Z[ZYY[Z}œi”—}œimobqgzgdv”—ib[2u4ceoWžc€Ÿ8c€oW[ij¡G[KY-om[iWu@qedvotce—–qedv[Ko•c-™4c€}wzg[Puwceamabce}xim[j[K}ximob[

dvib”–—”•abc€ib[KdvomaK£[Y`K{Zce}v”•ayY[e¤@c€uvu@[Z–`! #"!$%'&(")$*+,-%.|¤*c`Zib``Zibd4zg”–`(/)10c€”•zg[.z20qedgim”—•a”•ababd4a

zv[)–cimVv`Zqxob”–[±zg[Karl[Zdgf }vqe} {qGqxuw`Komc€ib”—¨ÛaZ¤uwqxdvodv} }vqxY.™vom[-¬vfg`±zg[›rlqed4[Zdvo|a±­©”B£[e£–¤dgim”—–”•abc€ib[Zd4oma|®£

Àjqed4a{ZqeYu4ceobqx}4a2”–{Z”p—[8aom`Kabdv°i|c<i|a›qe™gim[Z}Gd4azvce}4a{[±{Kceac6¥x[K{(–c§ab”°imd4c<im”—qx}¯uv—dwaob`8c€–”–ayib[q,3„–[Ka

rlqxdv[Zd4omaj[Z}œibom[Z}œijqxd†ayqxoyim[Z}œijc€–`Kc€ibqe”–om[ZY[Z}œijzgd)rl[Kd £jÀjqed4aPaydvu4uwqœayqx}4a54œd60”—•at[K}œibom[Z}œiPzvce}4at–[rl[Zd

ab[Z–qe} d4}Ouvomqg{[Kamabd4a.zg[nqe”•ababqe} ¤[Zi([Z}Rayqxoyim[Z}œi-ceuvobX8adv}´ib[ZYu4a-zg[Eay`yrlqedvo([fgu@qe}v[K}xim”—[K—–[ZY[K}xi

zv”–ayibom”—™4dv`e£pÀjqed4aWYqe}œimobqx}4a74xd4[{[ibib[VGkGuwqeibVvX8ay[ce—`8c<ibqx”—om[j}4[uw[Kdgi8imob[qxdv™v–”—`K[e£

9 ¾ Ž8 ¼ ‘;: ’ Vwc=<µ}v[Katzv[(…†ceob·xq<¥@¤vUWV4`Zqeom”–[.zg[Kaprl[ZdgfE}vqx}³{qGqeu@`Zo|c<im”°¨ÛaK¤4U+c€om”°¬@{Zc<im”—qx} ¤wUW`K—`8{qxY(˜

Y(dv}v”•{Zc€ib”–qe}4a

(6)

(' ) '

P[Kabuv”—ib[-ibV4[([ZfGu@qe}4[Z}œib”•c€Šeomq<¢WibV³q€¨ imVv[c6¥6ce”—•c€™4—[(ob[8ayqxdvom{Z[KaP”—} {qxY-Y(dv}v”•{Zc€ib”–qe}³}4[il¢qeom·GaK¤@ibVv[

”–}4{Zob[8ceab[jq€¨ibVv[›}GdvY(™w[Koq€¨d4ab[Zo|aK¤Gce}4zhibVv[›}v[K¢Tab[Zom¥œ”•{[8apimV4c<i}v[K[KzYqeom[2ce}4zhYqxob[P™4c€}4zv¢”–zGimV ¤

qe¨µib[K}–[Kcxz±imq){qe}4Še[Kayib”–qe}uvomqe™v–[ZY)aK£

ši-ibVGd4a-™@[K{qxY[Ka(qe™G¥G”—qxd4aimV4c<i-ibVv[uvom”–{Z”—}4Š„am{|Vv[ZY[Ka(™4cxay[8z qe}@c<iy˜šo|c<ib[8ah­Û”—}4zv[Zu@[Z}4zg[K}œiqe¨

dway[Koma0 {qx}4ayd4Y-uvib”–qe}w®›ceob[}vqei.aydv”—imce™v–[±c€}GkGY-qxob[x¤*™w[8{Zced4ay[imVv[Zk zgq§}vqeiimc€·x[”—}œibq†cx{Z{Zqedv}œi›ibVv[

}4[ZŠxc€ib”–¥e[2[fGib[Kob}wc€–”°ilkh{Kc€d4ab[Kz™Gkhc-u4c€obib”•{d4–ceodway[Koqe}ibVv[qeibVv[KomaK£

…†ce}Gk-om[K{Z[Z}œi u4ceuw[KomaV4c6¥x[jayd4ŠeŠe[8alim[Kz)ce}4z±ayibd4zg”–[Kzh}v[Z¢>ce—–qg{Zc€ib”–qe}±c€}wz)uvom”–{Z”—}vŠ(Y[K{|V4ce}v”–abY)aZ¤

¨©qxo±¢”–ob[K—[8aba)}4[il¢qeom·Ga-¢Vv[Kob[†ibVv[†[ZfGib[Zom}4ce—”—ilk´”•a)ibV4[†”—}œim[Zob¨©[Zom[Z}4{Z[—\€¤P\8‚G¤P\Kƒ! š¤tc€}wzO¨©qxo±¢”–ob[8z

}4[il¢qeom·Gaj¢Vv[Zom[(ibVv[[fGim[Zom}4c€–”°ilkE”•a2[fguvom[Kamay[8z†”–}†ib[KobY)a2q€¨—qœabab[Ka›c€}wz"6qxoPzg[K–c6k‰g¤*v¤œ¤ ƒv¤I\e\€¤

\6‡G¤p\Kv¤‡g\# B£$«} ™wqeibV {Zcxay[8aZ¤ibVv[)om[Kabqedvo|{[8a­©™4ce}4zg¢”•zGibV ¤I{ZqeYuvdgim”—}vŠ§u@q<¢[Zo®jVwc6¥e[-ibq§™@[)¨Ûc€”–om—k

zv”–ayibom”—™4dgib[8z c€Yqe}vŠEd4ab[Zo|aK£st– qe¨imVvqxab[)¢qeom·Ga{Zqe}4ab”•zg[Zoce} [8{qx}vqeY”•{)c€uvuvomqxcx{|V³imq†alimd4zgk„ibVv[

zv”°¸¦[Zom[Z}œi›uvobqxuwqœay[8z§Y[K{|V4ce}v”•ayY)aK¤¦ce}4z†Y)ce}œk†cedgibV4qeo|ajd4ab[.”–} u4c€obib”•{dv•c€oPibV4[.¨©qxobY)c€–”•ayY q€¨ ! %

" -$&1%=7+'& () $*ibqzg[Kam{om”–™w[ibVv[™@[ZVwc6¥œ”–qeoqe¨wd4ab[Zo|ac€}4z(ob[8ayqxdvo|{[Way[K—–[Zo|aZ£+«}4zg[K[Kz*¤ecxa+ibVv[

u@q€im[Z}œib”•c€Idway[Koma2q€¨c}4[il¢qeom·E{ZqeYu@[ib[-¨©qxo›ibVv[om[Kabqedvo|{[x¤¦ce}4z {Zc€}„™w[±{Zqe}4ab”•zg[Zom[Kz„cea2™w[KV4c6¥G”—}4Š

ab[Z—¬wabVv–ke¤<imVv[¨©o|c€Y[Z¢qeom·›q€¨¦}vqe}g˜«{qGqxuw[Komc€ib”–¥e[Šxc€Y[ibV4[Zqeomk”•aIu4ceoyim”–{Zdv–ceob–k¢[Z–°˜«ayd4”°im[Kz.ibquvom[Kzg”•{i

imVv[›qedgi|{qxY-[8aq€¨imVv[c€–—qg{Kc<ib”–qe}c€}4zuvom”–{Z”—}4Š(Yqgzg[ZB£pUWVGd4aK¤ximVv[{qx}4{[Kugimaqe¨+ayibo|c<ib[KŠek±ce}4zhÀPceabV

[ 4œdv”—–”–™vob”–dvY ceob[{Z[Z}œibo|c€*}vqeib”–qe}4aWqe¨imVv[u4c€u@[Zo8£

«}EimVv”–atu4c€u@[Zo8¤v¢[P¨©qg{Zd4aqe}imVv[ob[8{[K}xitom[Kabdv—imaWuvom[Kab[Z}œim[Kz™Gk¡G[ZYom[ijce}4zEžc€Ÿ8c€o”–},—\8ˆ! c€}wz

–\.-& B¤ {Zqe}4{Z[Zom}v”—}4Šhc€} c€d4{ib”–qe}†Y[K{|Vwc€}v”•ayYE¤*{Zce—–[Kz³npomqeŠeom[Kamab”—¥x[.¡G[K{Zqe}4z³npob”•{[­©n¡gn®¤*imV4c<i{qxdv•z

™@[-d4ay[8z§imqce—–qg{Zc<im[(™wc€}4zg¢”•zGimV„c€Yqx}vŠhd4ab[Zo|a­Ûce–abq{Kc€–—[8z†uv•c6ke[Komat¨©obqxY }vq<¢j®£/«}³ibVv[K”—o›¢qeom·@¤

imVv[›c€dgimVvqeo|a u4ob[8ay[K}xiibV4[Pn¡gn+¤wc€}4z±abVvq<¢¶abqeY[Puvobqxuw[Koyim”—[8a dway”–}vŠ(ibqGqe•ap¨©omqeY Šœc€Y[timVv[Zqxobk0+ibV4[Zk

[ZfgVv”—™4”°ice} %!1%= &5"&1%21#3d4ab[Zo ™w[KV4c6¥G”—qxoK¤xuvobq<¥x[ibV4c€ic54 6798 %3%21$%8:T”•apom[Kcx{|Vv[Kzc<¨µim[Zo

cj¬4}v”—ib[Wim”—Y[x¤xc€}wzibVwc<iIibV4[W{Zqeomob[8ayu@qe}wzg”—}4ŠPc€––qG{Kc<im”—qx}.”•a2; -%+”–}.imVv[ay[K}4ay[imV4c<iI”—ipYc€fg”—Y”–ŸZ[Ka

imVv[abqG{Z”–ce¦¢[K°¨Ûceob[x£

<jq<¢[K¥e[Zo8¤œqe}v[2”—Yu@qeobimce}xiceamabdvYugib”–qe}Ycxzg[2™œk±žc€Ÿ8c€oWc€}4z¡G[ZYom[i”–aimV4c<iWibV4[P}GdvY(™w[Ko>=qe¨

u4–c6kx[Zo|a”–a{qx}4ali|c€}œi zgdvom”–}vŠ.c€–wibVv[tŠœc€Y[e¤œ¢Vv”•{|V±zgqG[Ka }vq€iWay[K[ZY ¥e[Zomk.om[Kce—”•ayib”•{¢Vv[Z}±{Zqe}4ab”•zg[Zom”—}4Š

«}œim[Zom}v[i {Zqe}v}v[8{im”—qx}4a+¨©qeop[Zfvc€Yuv–[e£?«}4zg[Z[8z*¤e”–}ibV4[@om[Kc€g¢qeom•zA@<¤€{Zqe}v}v[8{im”—qx}4aI[Z}œim[ZoIqeo —[8c6¥e[ibVv[

}4[il¢qeom·ho|c€}4zgqxY—kx¤gibVv[K”—o2zgdvo|c<im”—qx}†zg[Zu@[Z}4zv”—}vŠqe}EimVv[ilkGuw[(q€¨pc€u4uv—”•{Zc€ib”–qe} £UWVv”•atu4Vv[Z}vqxY[Z}vqx}

”•a±–”–·e[Z–kRibqRzv[ib[Kob”–qeo|c<im[EibVv[„qeugim”—Y)ce—”—ilkRqe¨ibVv[ c€d4{ib”–qe} ¤tce}4z²om[4œdv”–ob[8a¨©dvobibVv[Ko”–}G¥e[8alim”—Šœc<ib”–qe}£

UWV4[Zom[ce—om[Kcxzgk§[fg”•ali|ac¨©[Z¢ om[K{Z[Z}œiu4c€u@[Zo|a›¢Vv[Kob[-ibV4[)}œd4Y.™@[Zoq€¨uv•c6ke[Zo|a2¥<c€omk§q<¥e[Zo2im”—Y[B–\K‰g¤

\DC! š£E«}†u4ceoyim”–{Zdv•c€o8¤@¡œi|c€VvayV4q<¢ta”—}F—\DC! +ibV4c€i2abqeY[.c€dw{ib”–qe}§Y[8{|V4c€}v”•abYaP{Zce}†™w[([#G±{”–[Z}œiP¨©qeoPc

{Zqe}4ayimce}œi}GdvY(™w[Koq€¨u4–c6kx[Zo|aZ¤G™vdgiimV4c<iWimVv[[#G±{”–[Z}w{kh{Kc€}™w[›–qxayiW”–}§calimqG{|Vwceayib”•{j[K}œ¥G”–obqx}vY[Z}œiK£

Àj[Z¥x[ZobibVv[K—[8abaK¤¦”—}F—\8‰g¤\.C! ibV4[-ced4{im”—qx}4a›c€om[(ayimc<im”–{e¤¦Y-[8c€}v”–}vŠibV4c€i2u4–c6kx[Zo|aj{Zce}v}vqei2Yqgzg”—¨©kEibVv[K”—o

™4”–zvaK¤v¢Vv[Kob[8cea”–}imVv[n¡Gn imVv[c€d4{ib”–qe}”–ajzgkG}4c€Y”•{€£

«} ibV4”–a)uwc€u@[Zo8¤¢[Euv–ce}Oimq —qGqx·Oc<i)¢V4c€i±[fGib[K}xi)imVv[§uvomqeu@[Zobib”–[Ka-q€¨2ibV4[§n¡Gn Y[K{|V4ce}v”•ayY

V4”—ŠxVv—”–ŠeVœim[Kz™Gk)žc€Ÿ8c€o ce}4z±¡G[KY-om[iWalim”—–@Vvqe•z)¢Vv[K}±uv•c6ke[Zo|aI[K}xim[Zoc€}4z–[Kc6¥x[ibVv[PŠxceY-[Pce{Z{Zqeo|zg”–}vŠ

imqnqe”•ababqe}uvomqg{[8abab[KaK£+«})qxomzv[ZoIimq(zgqimV4c<i8¤x¢[t¢”–—@”–}ximobqgzgdw{[jc{Zqe}œib”–}Gdvqedwal˜Bib”–Y[t…†c€om·eq<¥.{|Vwc€”–}

imV4c<i¢”–—*™@[d4ab[Kz±ibq)zg[Kam{om”–™w[2ibV4[›ced4{im”—qx}™@[ZVwc6¥œ”–qeo8¤gc€}4zh¢[›¢”–—*”–}G¥e[8alim”—Šœc<ib[PibV4[2u4obqxuw[Koyim”—[8aqe¨

imVv[n¡Gn ”–}§ayd4{|V§cayibqg{|V4ceayib”•{2{qe}œim[fGiK£

UWVv[ u4c€u@[Zo ”•a qxobŠœc€}v”–ŸZ[8zPcxa¦¨©qe––q<¢taZ£H«}.¡g[K{im”—qx}.‡g¤8¢[pzv[Kam{om”—™@[ibVv[n¡Gn§Y[K{|Vwc€}v”•ayY?uvom[Kab[Z}œib[8z

™Gk†žc€ŸKceoPce}4z„¡G[KYob[Zi2”–}I–\Kˆ! š¤ce}4z 4œdvqeib[imVv[Z”–o›Y)c€”–}³om[Kabdv°i|aZ£ “ [”—}œimobqgzgd4{Z[.”–}¯¡g[K{im”—qx}„‰hibVv[

(7)

 $% %33$8 !8#;

…³c€om·eq<¥{|V4c€”–}-Y-qgzg[Kvd4ab[Kz.ibqayibd4zvkibVv[Šœc€Y[W¢”°imVomce}4zgqeY c€omob”–¥<c€•a+ce}4z-zg[Zu4ceoyimdvom[Ka+q€¨¦uv•c6ke[Zo|aK¤

ce}4zEuvom[Kab[Z}œiil¢q±zg”°¸¦[Zom[Z}œiju@qxamab”—™v”––”°im”—[8atq€¨I”–}v”—ib”•c€™4”–z*¤@zg[Zu@[Z}wzg”—}4Šhqe}imVv[.uv•c6ke[Ko0aW”–Še}vqxomce}4{[›qeo

·G}vq<¢–[KzvŠe[qe¨IibVv[-™v”•z†uvomq€¬4–[(c€i2V4”–a2c€omob”–¥<c€B£2¡G[8{im”—qx}³h”•a›zg[Kzv”–{Kc<ib[8zEibqEc)imVv[Zqxob[Zib”•{Zceayibd4zgk§qe¨

imV4c<ij…³c€om·eq<¥±{|V4ce”—} ¤v¨©qG{Zd4ab”—}vŠ)qx}ibVv[[Zfg”–ayib[K}4{[qe¨c)ayimc€ib”–qe}4ceobkhzv”–ayibom”—™4dgib”–qe} £ “ [ibVv[K}§uvob[8ay[K}œi

ce}4z-{qeYY[Z}œiI”–}¡G[8{im”—qx})‚2abqeY[}œd4Y-[Kob”•{Zcegob[8ayd4°i|aqx™gimce”—}4[Kz.¨©obqxY ay”–Y.d4–c€ib”–qe}4aK¤eab”—}4{Z[Wqe™gi|c€”–}v”—}4Š

ce}4c€–kœib”•{tom[Kabdv—ima”–azg”G){Zdv—iK¤vc€}wz)¢[j¬4}4ce—–k±{qx}4{–d4zg[2c€}4z)Šx”—¥x[PabqeY[Pzv”—om[K{ib”–qe}4ap¨©qeo¨©dgibdvom[2¢qxob·

”–}†¡G[K{ib”–qe} -v£

$/+#$

“ [uvom[Kab[Z}œiWVv[Zom[2ibVv[n¡gn²Y-[8{|V4c€}4”–abYE¤GibV4c€iW¢Wcea¬womayitzg[Kam{om”—™@[Kz™GkhžceŸKceoWce}4z§¡G[ZYom[i”–} –\Kˆ& B¤

¨©qxoWibVv[ce—–qg{Zc€ib”–qe}q€¨¥6ceob”•c€™4—[Z˜šab”—ŸK[2abV4ceob[8aqe¨com[Kabqed4om{Z[2ceY-qx}vŠay[K¥e[Zo|c€¦d4ab[Zo|aK£pst}§[fGim[Z}4ab”—qx}qe¨

imVv[ab{|V4[ZY[jimq)c(}4[il¢qeom·{Zqe}œib[ZfGiW¢WceaWayibd4zv”—[8zh•c<im[ZoW™Gk¡G[ZYom[i(9 &3 —\<. š¤g™vdgit¢[2{Zqe}4{Z[Z}œibo|c<im[

V4[Zom[±qe} imVv[E{Zceab[±qe¨jc³ab”—}vŠx—[ob[8ayqxdvo|{[e¤+™4cxay”•{Zce—–k³imVv[™4c€}4zv¢”–zGimV´q€¨jc„ay”–}vŠx—[{qeYY(dv}v”•{Zc<im”—qx}

–”–}v·¦£

P[Z}vqeib[†™Gk =EibV4[³ay[Zihq€¨›uv•c6ke[KomaK¤ce}4z ™Gk ibVv[†ibq€i|c€jceYqedv}œi±q€¨c6¥<c€”––ce™v–[

om[Kabqed4om{Z[e£ np•c6ke[Komaayd4™vY”°i™v”•zvaZ¤xc€}4zibVv[K}ibV4[ced4{im”—qx}v[Z[Ko­Û”:£[e£–¤<ibV4[}v[Zil¢qxob·v®ayV4ceob[8a imVv[ob[8ayqxdvom{Z[

ce}4z{qeYuvdvib[KaibVv[›uvom”–{Z[›ibq™@[{|V4c€omŠe[8z)ibq[8ce{|Vuv–c6kx[ZoW™4cxay[8zhqx}himVv[ob[8{[K”—¥x[Kzob[ 4xd4[KayimaK£

”•zvaceob[P{|Vvqxab[Z})imq.™@[2‡<˜šzg”–Y[Z}4ab”–qe}4ce0+[Kcx{|V)uv–c6kx[Zo ´ayd4™vY”°i|ac™v”–z! #"$&%('")+*,".-/102"$

34

576$8 34

:9<;=-¤w¢Vv[Kob[' " ”•aimVv[(zv[Kab”—om[Kz 4œd4ce}xim”°ilkq€¨pom[Kabqed4om{Z[›ce}4z* " ibV4[ 8 %Wuvom”•{[uv•c6ke[Ko>

”•a2¢”—––”—}vŠibqu4c6kE¨©qxoPimV4c<i›om[Kabqedvo|{[x£UWVvobqxdvŠeV†ibVv[u4ceuw[KoK¤2 ?@%( BACD5 #E#-P¢”–—pzg[K}vq€im[.imVv[™v”•z

u4obqe¬4—[x¤vc€}4zF G " H%( BACDI "GJAB5 "K ABI #EC-¢”—– ™@[›ibVv[™4”–zuvomq€¬4–[2ibV4c€ituv–c6kx[ZoLI¨Ûcx{[KaK¤vabq(imV4c<i

MN%O "QP RG "-£jUWVv[npomqeŠxob[8abab”–¥e[¡G[K{Zqe}4zEn ob”•{[h­Ûn¡Gn®Pc€––qG{Kc<im”—qx}Ece}4zEuvom”–{Z”—}4Š±obd4—[”•ajzv[¬4}v[8z†cea

¨©qx—–q<¢ta.0uv•c6ke[KoSW”•ajc€––qG{Kc<im[KzEimVv[ 4œd4ce}xim”°ilkUT " %O C-¤*c€}4z†”–a2{|V4c€omŠe[8zibVv[-uvom”–{Z[WV " %( C-¤¦¢Vv[Kob[­©”—¨/X

zv[Kab”—Šx}4aibVv[Y”–}v”–Y.dvY±®

TY")%O #-Z '",X

[\

^] _

`Da#b`c.degf

h " ' eDij

K

­l\8®

V " %O #-Z _k

fh

" * k 3T k

%O RG "-l]T

k

%( ")P G "-.6 ­:‡e®

UWV4[Yq€ib”–¥<c<im”—qx}¨©qxotimV4c<iP{|V4qe”•{[›¨©qeotibVv[(uvob”•{”–}vŠ)omdv–[”–atibV4c€imVn" {Zq<¥e[KomaimVv[mobayqg{”•c€*qxuvu@qeobibdv}v”—ilk

{ZqxayiqpPqe¨+u4–c6kx[ZoL0aWuvom[Kab[Z}w{[e¤g”B£[e£ibV4[zg[K{Z–ceob[8zh¢”–—–”–}vŠe}v[8abaimqu4c6k±q€¨+uv•c6ke[Zo|a¢Vvq)c€om[›[fv{–d4zg[8z

™Gkuv•c6ke[Zom0aj™v”–zO­Ûab[Z[r+”–Šedvom[±\6®¤¦¢Vv”•{|V†”–ajq€¨µim[Z}„{Kc€–—[8zibVv[-ay[8{qx}4z§uvom”–{Z[e£jsj–abq4¤w¨©omqeY!­l\6®¤@ibVv[

u4–c6kx[Zo|a.c€om[abqeobib[8z ™Gk¯ibVv[K”—odv}4”°i)uvom”–{Z[e¤IimVvqxab[™v”–z4zg”—}4Š³imVv[EVv”—ŠxVv[KayiŠe[i-ibV4[™4ce}4zg¢”•zGibVRibV4[Zk

om[4œdv[8ali8¤vc€}4zabq-qx}d4}xim”—}vq)Yqeom[Pom[Kabqedvo|{[2”•ac6¥6ce”—•c€™4—[x£

šiP{Kc€}™w[om[ZY)ceob·x[Kz)imV4c<iimVv[.ce—–qg{Zc<im”—qx}homdv–[Še”–¥e[Z}™Gkts 4œd4c€ib”–qe}¯­l\6®uvdv}v”•ayV4[Kauv•c6ke[Koma¢Vvq

™4”–z¯c<iimVv[±amc€Y[uvob”•{[±ce}4z¯ceab·†Yqeom[-ibV4ce}„imVv[±c6¥<c€”––ce™v–[4œd4ce}œib”—ilk³c<iimV4c<iuvom”•{[e¤¢Vv”•{|V Y)c6k

om[Kabdv—i”–}.ct}4qe}g˜šqeugim”—Y)ceœce—–qg{Zc<im”—qx}ay”–}4{Z[pibV4[™4ce}4zg¢”•zGibV(”–a}vqei¨©dv–—kce—–qg{Zc€ib[Kz £UWVv”•a¢Wceac€omŠedv[8z

™Gk³Ud:G)}¯”—} ҇€ˆ! š¤+¢Vv[Zom[)cab–”—ŠxVxim—k³Y-qgzg”—¬4[8z ce—–qg{Zc€ib”–qe} obdv–[”–auvob[8ay[K}œib[Kz £ “ [±zg[8ab{Zob”–™w[Vv[Kob[

(8)

.

Q q6

q2 q1

qi q3

q5

p6

p5

p3

p2

p1

q ai Q q6 q5

ci p

0 pi

.

r+”—Šxdvom[-\ 0pst–—qg{Kc<ib”–qe}Ec€}wzhuvom”•{[2ibq)u4c6k±¨©qeouv•c6ke[Ko/

imVv”•aob[K¥G”–ab”°im[Kzab{|V4[ZY[e¤g¢Vv”•{|V¢”—– ™@[d4ay[8zh”–}ibVv[om[Kayiq€¨+ibVv[uwc€u@[Zo8£ P[¬w}v[

<"Q% 5 G ".-

[\

^] _

efh

"

`Da

'

e#ij

K

­Û‰x®

cxaibVv[om[ZY)ce”—}v”–}vŠ-™4c€}wzg¢”–zgibV§c<ijc-Še”–¥e[K}d4}v”°itu4ob”•{[x£UWV4[c€–—qg{Zc€ib”–qe}

T " %( C- ' " X ' "

e ` a h `c

' e " %* " 5 RG "- ­©œ®

ce—–q<¢ta+uv•c6ke[Zo|a¢Vvq›™v”–zc€i+imVv[tamc€Y[Wuvob”•{[ * "@ibq2ibqeimc€––k.ayVwc€om[ imVv[tc6¥<c€”––ce™v—[74œd4c€}œim”°ilk.c€iIuvob”•{[ * "y£

UWV4[ uvom”–{Z[{|V4ceobŠx[Kz2imqj[Kcx{|Vuv•c6ke[Zo”–aibV4[Z}(ayib”––G{ZqeYuvdgim[Kzdway”–}vŠSs 4xdwc<ib”–qe}­:‡e®£+ši+”–aabVvq<¢}”–} ҇€ˆ!

imV4c<i2ibV4[(om[Kabdv—imajibV4c€i›žc€ŸKceoPce}4z³¡G[KY-om[i›qe™vimc€”–}v[8z†c€om[(ayib”–—[Zfgcx{iP¨©qeoPibVv[-YqGzv”°¬4[8z³ce—–qg{Zc<im”—qx}

omdv–[e£

«}qxomzg[Ko¦ibqYqgzg[ZeibVv[Iu4–c6kx[Zo|a0™@[ZV4c6¥G”–qeo8¤Z¢[pc€•ayqW}v[K[KzPibqom[Zu4ob[8ay[K}xi*imVv[Z”–o u@[Zo|{[Kugib”–qe}"<¥<c€–d4c<im”—qx}

qe¨*ibVv[2ay[Kob¥G”•{[imVv[Zk){Kc€}±Šx[iK£np•c6ke[Ko0auvom[¨©[Kob[K}4{[8a c€om[tYqgzg[Z–[Kz±™œk)c#4œd4cxay”—˜š—”–}v[Kceopdgim”—–”°ilk¨©d4}4{˜

im”—qx}qe¨imVv[›¨©qeomY

" %( C- " %+T " %( C-Q-l]V " %( C-n ­:‚e®

¢V4[Zom[B"”•ahuv•c6ke[Ko 0a ! 38&1% .8 )#1% w¤t¢Vv”•{|V¶zg[Zu@[Z}wzvahqx} ibVv[ 4œd4c€}œib”—ilk q€¨om[Kabqedvo|{[§Vv[

om[K{Z[Z”–¥e[8aZ£

¡G”–}4{Z[u4–c6kx[Zo|a.c€om[cxababdvY[Kz ibq¯ce{i)ab[Z—¬wayV4—kx¤ ayq„ibVwc<i-ibVv[Kk ¢”—–t{|VvqGqxab[)ibV4[Z”–o-™4”–zR”—}Rqeo|zg[Zo

imq±Y)c<fg”–Y-”–ŸZ[.ibVv[K”—o2”–}4zg”–¥œ”•zgd4cedgim”—–”—ilkE¨©dv}4{im”—qx} £¯UWVv[(ce—–qg{Zc€ib”–qe}EŠxceY-[.¢qxob·gatcxat¨©qx—–q<¢ta90[Kcx{|V

u

Ö<ÏÜ6à6ÝÓ«Ù Ö6×ÛÙBÕ:Ï|ÐÒÖZÙÞ!Õ ÓyÏ"$#›Í8ÑÏ%ÓlÕ&yÏ|ÖPÜeÓÙBÏ"'Ól֛ÐÒÖÙ(Ï" à6ÖÙbØ*)&,+¦Ó -ÓlÕ <Þ!Õ ×:ÐÒÎÍ6ÑÒÐlÐÙ%ךÏ"'Ó./+*Ó

Ö8×BÐ6ÓlÕÐÒÖjÙ0#6ÐÒ× Í<Ï|̀ÓlÕÙ0#6Ó1yÏ|×BÓ2+ÐÙ(#à8Ù+Ü8à/6ÝÓ«Ù Ö6×ÛÙBÕ:Ï|ÐÒÖÙbØ

(9)

- $% %33$8 !8#;

u4–c6kx[Zoj{Kc€}§Y)c€·x[c)™v”•z§[Kcx{|Vd4}v”°i|ajqe¨ib”–Y-[x¤w·G}vq<¢”–}vŠ±u@[Zob¨©[K{ib–khimVv[.™4”–zvaPY)cezg[.™œkibV4[.q€imVv[Zo

u4–c6kx[Zo|am G "£…§qeom[Zq<¥x[Zo8¤4”—i›”•a›ceamayd4Y-[8zEibVwc<i2il¢quv–c6kx[Zo|at}v[K¥e[KoP™v”•z c<iP[Zfvce{im—kEimVv[abceY-[.ib”–Y[e£

sPapcuv•c6ke[Ko0a+™v”•z”–ac›ob[Kuv—k.ibqW G " ¤xžc€Ÿ8c€opc€}wz±¡G[ZYom[i zg[Z¬4}v[imVv[jab[i qe¨@uv•c6ke[Kol0ab˜š™w[8aliob[Kuv—”–[Ka

­©¨©qeotce}

4

®cxa

0" %( G "O-&# #"l102" l"I%( #"P G ".- "Q%O " P G "(- ]# " !02"q

Y[8c€}v”–}vŠimV4c<i0

"

”•apimVv[Pab[iq€¨ ™v”•zva ibV4c€iuv•c6ke[Ko+{Kc€})Y)c€·x[e¤œ[Z}4abdvom”—}4ŠVv”–Y cdgib”–—”—ilk){–qxab[ibq.ibVv[

Y)c€fG”–Y.d4Y ob[8ce{|V4ce™v–[j¨©omqeY –[KamaibVwc€}8£

sj}b˜šÀPceabV§[4œdv”–—”–™vom”—d4Yª”•atimVv[Z} zg[¬w}v[Kz†cxajc±¬vfg[KzEu@qe”–}xi2q€¨l0

"

0 " %O G ".-¤¦¢Vv[Zom[}vq

u4–c6kx[Zo{Zce}”–}4{om[Kcxay[2Vv”•adgim”—–”°ilk™Gk±Yqeom[PimV4c€}t™Gk±d4}v”—•c<im[Zo|c€–—k{|V4c€}vŠx”—}4Š(Vv”•aW™v”•z*£

Uqzg[Zom”–¥e[ibVv[Kqeom[im”–{Kc€vom[Kabdv—imaK¤eayqxY[tceamaydvYugim”—qx}4aIc€om[WY)cezg[qx}(imVv[t¥<c€–d4c€ib”–qe}(¨©dv}4{im”—qx}4a(–\Kˆ& 0

‹K Ž¾! #" $ *< ? L

$ " %4 -

4

$

B"5%( %% -$*1%2 193n

$ " 4 ! %%!$*=% + ) %8 &8

$'&)(

" 4 +*, 4 ,

"

%*Y- 4.- 0/213* ,

"

%*Y-4

"

%5/-l]

(

")%*<]6/-87

UWV4[Z} ¤+zg[¬4}4”—}vŠ†cimobdvibVg¨©dv™v”•z cxacE™v”•z #"S%('")+* "O-›abd4{|V ibV4c€i>*,"> " %+'D"O-­©ibV4c€i.”–aK¤™4”–zvzv”—}vŠ

cOuvom”–{Z[„[ 4xdwc€2ibqOibVv[¯Y)c€omŠe”–}4c€P¥<c€–d4c<im”—qx}w®¤›žceŸKc€oc€}4z?¡G[ZYom[iEuvomq<¥e[†”–} –\Kˆ& 2imVv[ ”—}4{Z[Z}œib”–¥e[

{ZqeYu4c€ib”–™v”—–”—ilk±uvomqeu@[Zobilke¤g¢Vv”•{|Vzv[Kam{om”—™@[KaWVvq<¢Tuv•c6ke[Zo|aW{qxdv–z{|VvqGqxab[PibVv[K”—ot™4”–zva.0

9  ¾ ¾ ÛŽ ¾: !; 9

< " %( G "-!=?>A@ *B)*B4 " %C

"

%*Y-:I G "-5 ­2-x®

D! ,-$E 8:5"1% 6FB0 ? G G " !0 G "8 B&l<"Q%

4

I G "(-

4

00H 4

"2H%5IR")KJ "O-.L %NM IR"

3< ")%O G "O-l]6PO/

"

%4 -6K

J "$

"

%5IR".-

­B€®

% $8:).8:3AD% 1 $*"3*.- $ "3 *;-$> W G " 7

UqR[K}4abdvob[†ibV4c€iimVv[„™wc€}4zg¢”•zGimV¶”•a}4q€iabqe•z¶c€ic´ibqGqO–q<¢ —[K¥e[K:¤2c´™v”•z^ Q %O?+*RQ#-h”–a

”–}œibomqgzgd4{[8z*£UWV4”–aY[8c€}4aWimV4c<iimVv[q<¢}v[Koq€¨ibV4[ob[8ayqxdvom{Z[›¢”—–ab[Z– ”°i2c<ijcY”—}4”—Y(dvYªd4}v”°iPuvob”•{[

*RQe¤p¢V4”–{|VR”–a){Kc€–—[8z¯ibVv[Eom[Kab[Zom¥e[±u4ob”•{[x£OUWVv[Eay[K—–[Zo){Zce} ibVGd4a™@[Eay[K[Z}Rcxac³uv•c6ke[Ko­Û}vq€i)”–} ®

¢”—ibV c±¥<c€–d4c€ib”–qe}†¨©d4}4{im”—qx} B")%('R-S * Q 'G£sPa2c{qx}4ab[4œdv[Z}w{[e¤wibV4[(VGkGuwqeibVv[8ay”•a <")%

4

5 G "(-S

4

qe¨

n obqxuwqœay”—ib”–qe} \›”–aW¥x[Zom”°¬4[8z*£

UWVv[-c€dgimVvqeo|ajabdvŠxŠe[KayitimV4c<i›uv•c6ke[Zo|atabdv™vY”—iP™v”•zva›ce{K{qeo|zg”–}vŠibq1s 4œd4c<im”—qx}O­Be®¤¦¢”—ibV§imVv[-{Zqe}g˜

ayibo|c€”–}œijimV4c<i›ibV4[Zom[-ceob[(}v[Z¥x[Zo›Yqeom[ibVwc€} qe}v[(uv–c6kx[Zo›ay[K}4zg”–}vŠEch™v”•z c<i2ibVv[)amc€Y[im”—Y[e¤S”—¨c€}wz

qx}v–k”°¨@”°ip”–}4{Zob[8ceab[KaibVv[K”—oI”–}4zg”–¥G”–zvd4c€gdgim”—–”—ilk.™Gk.c<iI–[Kcxali 8£+UWVv”•a”•a¦rld4ayib”—¬4[Kz-”–}$–\Kˆ! v™Gk.{Zqe}4ab”•zg[Zom”—}4Š

c oy™v”•z-¨©[Z[:pWq€¨T8£+UWV4[Z}”°i {Kc€}™@[jayV4q<¢}­:ay[K[/—\D-! B¤xnpomqeu@qxab”°im”—qx}(G®ibV4c€i dv}4zg[Ko sjamabdvYugib”–qe}E\e¤eibVv[

ce—–qg{Zc€ib”–qe}hŠœc€Y[{qx}œ¥x[ZomŠe[8ac€¨µib[Zotc(¬4}4”°im[}œd4Y.™@[Zotqe¨™v”•zvaWimqc(imobdgimVg¨©dvVUWb˜šÀPceabVh[ 4xd4”—–”—™4ob”–dvYE£X

Y[Z

#6ÐÒ× Ö/6ÐÙ:Ð֛ÐÒ×*ÎÓ«Ù Þ!Õ*Ó\8Ï|ÎÍ6ÑÒÓ2+ #6ÓlÖ2Í6ÑÏ %ÓyÕÛ×(#/ ×:ÓÙ(Ü8Ð2Ï|×%8Ö/(#6Õ0Öà6×BÑ%2Ó -ÓlÕ%^]Eà6Ö6ÐÙ:×&|ÞvÙ:ÐÒÎÓØ

_ Z

#6Ó2 Ö -ÓlÕ:ÝÓlÖ/lÓ |ÞgÙ0#6ÓIÜ6Ð8×ÐÒ× Í6Õ,-Ó ›ÐÒÖ K` +&#8ÓyÖPÍ6ÑÏ%ÓlÕÛ×+Ï"«Ù+Ï|×*+*Ó26Ól×(lÕÛÐÒÜ€Ó #8ÓyÕÛÓ.€Ï|Ö/jÙ(#6ÓIÓGaZà6ÐÒÑÒÐÒÜ6ÕÛÐÒà6Î

Ù(#<ÏmÙÐÒ× Õ:ÓyÏ"$#8Ó2ÐÒ×Ö8ÓlÓl×B×BÏ|Õ:ÐÒÑ%2Ïbdc:Ú

v

Ï|×(#jÓGaKà8ÐÒÑÒÐÒÜ6Õ:ÐÒà8Î

(10)

«} qeo|zg[ZoPibqEqx™gimce”—}„ob[8aydv—ima›ce™wqxdgi›ibVv[[#G±{Z”—[K}4{k§qe¨ ibV4[-n¡GnTY[8{|V4c€}v”•abY¤ayqxY-[cez4zg”°im”—qx}4c€

{Zqe}4zv”°im”—qx}4ac€om[P”–Yuwqœay[8zqe}ibVv[¥<c€–d4c€ib”–qe}¨©dv}4{im”—qx}4a.0

‹K Ž¾

&

4

G l

$

0*,?*

?*B * 4

" %*- ] "%* -^]

%* ]*

-n

$ " %4 -1 9<;

UWVv[›¨©qx—–q<¢”–}vŠ(om[Kabdv—ij{Zce}himVv[Z}E™@[ayVvq<¢}¯­Ûab[Z[–\.-! ©®0

9  ¾ ¾ ÛŽ ¾ % ;$ D%24 798 %3%21$%8:@ ?0

E! ) $$1" ! % +&33 &1%

T N%OT Q %( D-:)T A %( #-:IT E %( D-Q-7 )ST

" Q

d

c Q T

" ! 8: & E 8:5"%

1% F ) &3 C7. T dO

)

!

#"

$% _

" Q

" %(T "-'&(@] _

" Q " %+T

"

-*)?%,+ - ­Ûƒx®

L+ -$.-H #T 34

I 6E K A " T " 4 7

/ "#10 j $/ )2 < &##p'Z 43 #++2#52&# 7#76

' +

«}imVv”•aab[K{ib”–qe} ¤œ¢[j—qGqe·c<i ibVv[Puvob[K¥G”—qxd4a ced4{im”—qx})Y-[8{|V4c€}4”–abY ™@[ZVwc6¥œ”–qeo ”—}hc.alimqG{|Vwceayib”•{[Z}G¥G”—omqe}v˜

Y[K}xi8£

“

[jibVGd4apY)ce·e[jabqeY[jcxababdvYugib”–qe}wapqe}imVv[j¢Wc6k.u4–c6kx[Zo|aI[Z}œib[KopimVv[jŠœc€Y[e¤œaydv™4Y-”—i™4”–zvac€}wz

–[Kc6¥x[e¤gzgom”—¥G”–}vŠ-ibq)c…†c€om·eq<¥)u4obqg{[8abaK£

89;: <>=@?A=CBDFEHG=@?7IJ?7I

‹K Ž¾LK $* *&,%B % 8: 1$ . %%5$*&&38&1% .8 )#1% P7 :8

"3&*;$W% $;9 $%NM 19*$ %ilkGuw[O $93=QPSR " ggK<g( % + )&E % ! 38&1%

.8 )#1% % " JTVU

cXW

7 4(8L "3 *;-$ $5 +'& ; $ % +$ $ % ")$* -.L % $6

Y ! ) *" . )PL "3 *;-$ % = ; $* % + %-$# "!$* 1 1%3%* %1$%2198:%Z7

#7%#8 ";" = ) "3 *;-$[*" - $*%) ; " ! ,- $6 ) ; !$%2 1935 $& "3&*;$. *"

R5$$%=; $ % +$ % "!$* L %) $6 Y U Y Z%\RQ-87

sce{|V-ilkGuw[t{Kc€}){qxobom[Kabuwqx}4z.ibqczg”—¸@[Kob[K}œi ·G”—}4z-qe¨¦ceuvuv–”–{Kc<ib”–qe}§­©ib[Z–[Zu4Vvqe}Gke¤x¥G”–zg[Kq4¤e¬4—[tibo|c€}4ay¨©[Zo8£—£–£Ò®

¢”—ibV§zg”—¸¦[Zom[Z}œi™4c€}4zv¢”–zGimVEob[ 4xd4”—om[ZY[Z}œi|aZ£

‹K Ž¾^] ,$*" 9%_R "3&*;$5a`&8 $ % % +'& % &-" !1%2&33*&% %1$%2198:

$ ! ,& & $%2 193n.L % " $6 9-$cb U %! ," ! ;#.$&33 &) $ ")$* -55 ! % "$%98:3$

%) ; " ! ,-7 ./) #8: 8:3&1% 1 ) L % &) "3&*;$(%&33& 8 $% + % '` 8 $7

(11)

ƒ $% %33$8 !8#;

P”—¸@[Kob[K}xiY-[8c€}±abq€rlqxdvob}-im”—Y[Kac€om[}v[8{[Kamamc€omk¨©qeozg”°¸¦[Zom[Z}œiceuvuv–”–{Kc<im”—qx}4aZ¤œay”–}4{Z[t¢c€im{|Vv”–}vŠ.c›¥G”•zg[Zq

Šx[Z}v[Komce—–k)}v[K[Kzvac-Y.dw{|V–qe}4Še[Zo{Zqe}v}v[8{im”—qx}him”—Y[›ibVwc€}E—qœcezg”–}vŠc-¢[K™uwc€Še[P¨©qeo”–}4ayimce}4{[x£

‹K Ž¾ , *" #%_R#"3 *;-$ % + $= "," $8 %* 819 % )PL 1-%

# %%5$*/1%-87 --$% 1% % $$*B=8: .- 33 L &" )-%2 37 %$%2198:% L %

" $& # -$

U %) ; " ! ,- .5&33 &) $ $6 ) ; & $%2 1#387

‹K Ž

¾ 9 . " %2193B1% 798 %1%- % %-$# L %F %-$*91%NM. % "

) 1-% ) 1 819 % $( .) .-$N #"$ %+'")+* "O-: L+ $*>'D" 34 576 34 I767

sPababdvYugib”–qe}-P”–a+”–}ximobqgzgdw{[Kz.”—}-qeo|zg[KoimqPqx™gimce”—}-cP…†ceob·xq<¥2{|Vwc€”–}.¢”—ibVcPzg”•am{om[ib[Wayimc<im[abu4cx{[e£

UWV4”–aI”•apzgqx}v[¨©qxoil¢qom[Kcxayqx}4a90 ¬4omayip”—i ”–ap[Kceab”–[Zoibq(c€}4ce—kGŸZ[imV4c€})…†ceob·xq<¥.{|V4c€”–}4a¢”—ibV±{Zqe}œib”–}Gdvqed4a

ayimc€ib[abu4ce{Z[e¤vc€}wzab[K{Zqe}4z”—}Euvo|ce{ib”•{[c{qx}xim”—}Gdvd4Y q€¨uvom”–{Z[KaW”•aWdv}v–”—·x[Z–k±ibqV4ceuvu@[Z} £

[K{Kc€d4ab[-q€¨pimVv”–azv”–am{om[im”—Ÿ8c<ib”–qe}³q€¨ imVv[uwqœabab”–™v—[4œd4c€}œim”°im”—[8ajimV4c<i{Kc€}³™@[)ceab·e[8z†c€}4z³™w[8{Zced4ay[

qe¨imVv[2¬4}v”—ib[}GdvY.™@[Zoqe¨+zg”—¸¦[Zom[Z}œi¥6ce—dwc<ib”–qe}h¨©dv}4{ib”–qe}4aK¤gibV4[›ab”—ibd4c€ib”–qe}¢Vv[Zom[2ab[Z¥x[Zo|c€@uv•c6ke[Zo|a™v”•z

c€iibVv[abceY-[)d4}v”°i(uvob”•{[)”•a–”–·e[Z–k†imq§V4c€u4uw[K} £Uq§Y)c€·x[±aydvom[ibVwc<iibV4[±™4c€}wzg¢”–zgibV ”•aqeuvib”–Yce°˜

–k zg”•alimob”–™vdgim[Kz*¤p¢[ceob[Šeqx”—}vŠ†ibq d4ay[hibVv[Ec€––qG{Kc<im”—qx} obdv–[¯­©œ®¤Iomc€ibVv[Ko.imV4c€}T­l\8®¤I¨©qe––q<¢”—}vŠ³ibVv[

ceobŠxdvY[Z}œimaqe¨ ҇€ˆ& š£

sPatc€}vqeibVv[Kot{qx}4ay[ 4œdv[Z}4{Z[e¤G[Kcx{|Vu4–c6kx[Zo{|VvqGqxab[KaVv”•aW™v”•zcxa¨©qe–—q<¢taK£

‹K Ž¾ 819 %1% + !8LF1-% B &3$, &*5"!$*-- "3 *;-$ &,% %NM

% % %2& 8:%3'%*.8 )#1% 8 % + 1$8:).8:3A1% =87 " $ 33*C> "3 *;-$> L %33 819% ) 1-%

#"Q%O

G

"O-H%

'D"Q

*,"2C" %

'".-Q-:,L %

'"$ !

Q d

l"%)%+'D"Q,C" %+'D"O-)- P G

"O-

# 1 =$% O1- &' "3 " %'+ 8 $* P5& -$$* 3*5L ) % &

' " "!' "

=?>A@$# ' " 34

576 ',4 ^]

k

fh

"

`&%nb(')

cT W ' "+* ! ' " ,!' " 9-7

.j}v—”–·e[(žc€Ÿ8c€otce}4z†¡G[ZYom[i8¤4¢[.zgq)}vqeij”—}œimobqgzgd4{Z[cWoy™v”–z¨©[K[:p.jV4[Zom[e¤wabq)uv•c6ke[Koma{Kc€}§ayd4™vY”°i

™4”–zvacxa-abqGqe}Ocxa-”°i”—Yuvomq<¥e[8aimVv[Z”–odgib”––”°ilkx£Os{imd4c€–—kx¤ ab”—}4{Z[himVv[E™v”•zRab[i”–azg”•am{om[ib”–ŸZ[8z*¤ c„™v”•z

{|Vwc€}vŠx[P¢”–—{qeomom[Kabuwqx}4z)imqc-dgim”—–”—ilkh”–Y-u4obq<¥x[ZY[Z}œiŠeom[Kc€ib[ZoibVwc€}§c{[Zobimce”—}ibV4ob[8ayVvqx–z £

“ [-ibVv[K} zg”•ayib”–}vŠedv”•abV†il¢qzg”—¸¦[Zom[Z}œi›{Kceab[KaK¤¦[Kce{|V„q€¨ ¢V4”–{|V {qeomom[Kabuwqx}4zg”–}vŠ)ibqqe}4[(qe¨ ibV4[.¨©qx°˜

–q<¢”–}vŠ(·G}vq<¢–[KzvŠe[›ceamaydvYugim”—qx}4aW¢Vv[K}[K}œib[Zom”–}vŠ-ibVv[Šœc€Y[e£

‹K Ž¾/0 "3&*;$W -$ +'& n % ! WL $* . -$ 1% =5!

819 %$) ^O% %1%2&3PI1% %('")

"

%('".-Q-:,L+ $*1'" % - $ ! ,& 3*I; $ % +F ,8 %.- $

%$%2198:% ) " %21937#81%%- % $1-% B %! ," -) ; . 33 &) $#$6! ,& !$%2 19387

1 ”–¥e[K}„imV4c<iimVv[)uv•c6ke[KoPimq€i|c€–—k„”—Šx}vqeom[KaPibV4[)™v”–z uvomq€¬w—[x¤Vv[±{|VvqGqœay[8aP”—ima™v”–z o|c€}4zvqeY—kx£±s¨µ˜

im[Zom¢ceomz4aZ¤gVv[.¢”—–™@[”–}g¨©qeomY[KzEq€¨imVv[uvomq€¬4–[c€}wzE¢”—–™@[.c€™4—[imq±{|V4c€}4Še[Vv”•at™v”•z§ce{K{qxomzg”–}vŠ-ibq

sPababdvYugim”—qx}±g£+UWV4”–apab”—ibd4c€ib”–qe}){qxdv–z-V4ceuvu@[Z})zg[Zu@[Z}wzg”—}4Šqe}-ibVv[Pzg[ZŠxob[K[qe¨¦ab”—Šx}4c€–”–}vŠ›uvobqg{Z[Kzgdvom[Ka

imV4c<i ceob[W”–Yuv—[KY[Z}œib[8z”—}-ibV4[}v[il¢qeom·¦£+<tq<¢[Z¥x[Zo8¤<¢[¢”––4c€•ayq{Zqe}4ab”–zv[ZoibV4[t{Zceab[W¢Vv[Zom[tc€omom”—¥G”–}vŠ

u4–c6kx[Zo|aabdv™vY”—itibVv[K”—o™@[Kayit™v”•z 0

(12)

.

¯ qi

ui

¯ qi

α ui

Q q θiq

p

p

.

.

Q q θi

q

ui θi

ai ¯qi αθi

¯qi α ; si

¯qi α

ci ¯qi αθi¯qi α; si

¯qi ui

p

p

.

r+”–Šedvom[-‡0PUWVv[(il¢q{Zce}4zg”•zvc<im[KaP¨©qeoPibV4[-™@[Kayi›™v”–zH0jqe}³ibVv[–[¨µi8¤¦ibVv[dgim”—–”°ilk†cxababqg{”•c<im[Kz§¢”—ibV„ibVv[

™4”–z '"­:c€om[Kc”—}¯Šxob[Kkg®j”•aayY)ce—–[Zo2ibVwc€}! ibV4c€iceamayqg{”•c<im[Kz³¢”°imV„imVv[)™v”•z '"J9! ­©ibVv[±zv”°¸¦[Zom[Z}4{Z[”–a

imVv[§c€om[Kc³”—} ™v•ce{|·v®£ UWVv”–a-”•a-ibVv[§{Kceab[™@[K{Kc€d4ab[

"

%&!'D"9 --”•aalimob”•{im—kOŠeom[Kc<im[Zo(ibV4ce}´imVv[Euvob”•{[

* ! )*

k

B*

k

1

"

%&!'".-5œ£jUWVv[(ob”–ŠeVœiy˜šV4ce}4z¬4Šedvom[”–—–d4ayibo|c<im[KaimVv[({Kceab[¢Vv[Z}

"

% !'D" 9 - *

u4–c6kx[Zo IY(d4ayiimVv[Z}E{qxY-uwc€om[tibV4[Pdgim”—–”—ilk±Vv[2¢qxdv–zhqe™gi|c€”–}±™Gk)™v”•zvzg”–}vŠ '!" ­©”–}Šxob[Kkg®¤gc€}4zimV4c<iVv[

¢qed4–zŠe[ZiW™Gk±™4”–zvzv”—}vŠ!' " 9- ¤@{qe}way”•zg[Zom”–}vŠ.imVv[c€––qG{Kc<im”—qx}homdv—[)­Ûœ®£

‹K Ž¾0 "3 *;-$? -$$ + n %%.-$ .$) B1% ")$*a 3: !

% %2& #3* 81#%E % 1- 1% 3% ;--$%21 %E 8:" %7

q€imV§ay”—ibd4c€ib”–qe}4a­:ceaW[ZfGu4ob[8abab[Kzh™œksjamayd4Y-uvib”–qe}4aƒc€}wz Cœ®¢”—– ™@[{qeYu4ceob[8z±}GdvY[Zom”•{Zc€––ke£

“ [}vq<¢¶}4[Z[Kzimqzv[¬4}v[›imVv[ayimc<im[ayu4cx{[›q€¨+ibV4[omce}4zgqeY u4obqg{[8abaK£

89 4G1G?IJD ?AEG=@? "!$# E&%' =()+*

“ V4[Z}´sjamabdvYugib”–qe}4a(‰Eibq¯Vvqe•z*¤cea.¢[K— cxaqx}v[±c€Yqe}4Š†sjamaydvYugim”—qx}4a.ƒ†qeoC§”•a.{|V4qxab[Z} ¤ibVv[

o|c€}wzgqeYuvomqg{[8aba", zg[Kam{om”—™@[Kzce™wq<¥x[”•aIc›{qe}œim”—}Gdvqxd4al˜Bib”–Y[zg”–am{om[im[˜«ayuwce{[…†c€om·eq<¥{|Vwc€”–}-zg[Z¬4}v[8z

q<¥x[ZoibV4[›ayimc€ib[abu4ce{Z[

- /.

0

21

%qD?< 8 34 576D-

0

¢V4[Zom[›cayimc€ib[43§”–atob[Kuvob[8ay[K}œib[Kz

3!&%I%XR)AB)'#A-:D#%XR " )' "-nD%\R

0

I'

0

-Q- ­2Cx®

”—¨ibVv[Kob[)c€om[65 uv•c6ke[Zo|aP”—} ibV4[)Šxc€Y[x£ «}4zv[Z[Kz ¤cEali|c<im[)q€¨ imVv[)uvomqg{[Kama2”–a2imVv[Z} imVv[±ay[Ziq€¨u4c€”–oma

%\R "I' "-¨©qeojce—uv–c6kx[Zo|a/ ”–}EibVv[Šœc€Y[c<iimV4c<ijYqxY-[K}œiK£ R" ”–au4–c6kx[Zo 0ailkGu@[e¤@{|V4c€o|ce{ib[Zom”–ŸZ”–}vŠ(V4”–a

¥<ce—d4c€ib”–qe}¨©dv}4{ib”–qe}†ce}4zibVGd4aV4”–at¨©dgibdvom[™v”•zvaK¤wce}4zU' " ”•atV4”–aPceab·e[Kz4œd4c€}œim”°ilkx¤4¢Vv”•{|VE”–aPayd:G±{Z”—[K}xi

imq)zg[Kam{om”—™@[2ibVv[{Zdvomob[K}xi™v”•z¯­©·G}vq<¢”–}vŠ-ibVv[›ilkGu@[R"®¤4ay”–}4{Z[2™4”–zvajc€om[›cxababdvY[Kz±ibq)™@[›ibomdgibVv¨©dv:£

(13)

\8ˆ $% %33$8 !8#;

…§qxob[Kq<¥e[KoK¤œ¢[zv[K{”•zg[›imq)·e[Z[KuhimVv[uv•c6ke[Koma”–}imVv[Z”–otqxomzg[Koq€¨+[Z}œibomkh”–}ibVv[Šœc€Y[e¤vabq-ibV4c€itibVv[

ceobom”–¥6ce4qe¨c}v[K¢²ilkGuw[Z˜,R

uv•c6ke[Koabdv™vY”°ibib”–}vŠ™v”•zt'

¢”–—¦”–Y-u4—k±c.ibo|c€}4ab”—ib”–qe})¨©omqeY ayimc<im[ 3ibq

ayimc€ib[43

%)%XR)AB)'#AD-:DD%XR

0

)'

0

-nD%\R

I'

-Q-Z£

898 <6!$* I )aG$)aE * !$ G?7I

P[Z}4q€ib[™Gk 3 3

cibo|c€}way”—ib”–qe}„¨©obqxY ali|c<im[63¯imq§ali|c<ib[ 3

­©¢[Zom[ 32+3

-®£)UWVv[Kob[)ceob[(ibVvom[Z[

u@qxamab”—™v–[2ilkGuw[8aWq€¨+ibo|c€}4ab”°im”—qx}h¨©qxoWibVv[…³c€om·eq<¥){|V4c€”–} , ¢[alimd4zgk0

$

‹±6 : ¾  ºœ½ :ې »wº 

31 %)%XR)AR)'#A-:D#%XR

0

)'

0

-)- 3R %)%XR)AR)'CAn-:DD%XR

0

)'

0

-nD%\R

0 K ABI'

0 K An-)- ­y\Kˆx®

qg{Z{d4obom”—}4Š(¢”—ibVEo|c<ib[

( %3$+3

- A

K A Y Z%\R

0 K A - R0 K A =gg K<¨©qxotibV4[.dv}v”—¨©qeomY ”—}4”°im”–ce™v”•z†{Kceab[

­©¨©qe–—q<¢”–}vŠ)sjamabdvYugib”–qe}Eƒx®¤4c€}4z

( %3$+3

- M Y Z/%XR

0 K A:- ”°¨l'

0 K A ' 0 K A(­Ûab[Z[sPababdvYugim”—qx}†e®c€}4z R0 K Am gg K<

4

q€ibV4[Zom¢”–ab[B

¨©qxoWibVv[”–}v”—ib”•c€ ™@[Kayiy˜šom[Zuv–kh{Zcxay[­ÛsPababdvYugim”—qx} Cœ®£

$

º g6Ž º³¾  :ې »wº 

3 %I%XRA )' A -:D#%XRq"G A )'D"GJA -nD%XRq"))'D"O-nD%\Rq"K A )'D"K A -nD%\R

0

I'

0

-Q-

3

H%Q%\R A I' A -nD%\Rq"GJA I'"G A -:#%XRq"K A I'"K A -:#%XR

0

)'

0

-Q- ­y\e\8®

qg{Z{d4obom”—}4Š(¢”—ibVEo|c<ib[

( %3$+3

- b "£

$

ºœ½ ŒVÛ¿  ¾   :© º v¿ » º  º ŽH :ې »wº  ­©ibVv[™v”•z({Kc€}(™w[dv}4{|V4ce}vŠe[8z”—¨w”—i+”•ac€–ob[8cezgk

qeugim”—Y)ce*¨©qeoWimVv[{qx}4{[Kob}v[8z±uv•c6ke[Ko|®

3 H%Q%\R A I' A -:#%XRq"))'"O-:D#%XR

0

)'

0

-)-

3 %)%\R A )' A -nD%\Rq") '"O-:#%XR

0

)'

0

-)- ­y\8‡e®

¢”°imV '" zg[8ab{Zob”–™@[Kz”—}§sjamabdvYugib”–qe}³G£IUWVv”•aWimomce}4ay”—ib”–qe}qg{Z{d4omaW¢”—ibVEo|c<ib[

( %3$+3

- "£

89 4G1G?IJD ?AE!* )! G$)aE * *#" )+*%$ * )'G?7I )'& )(* ? *.? !$ GE!

“

[E”—}wzg”–{Kc<im[§Vv[Zom[V4q<¢ ibV4[†ali|c<ib[8a{Zc€} ™@[†ayqxoyim[Kz*¤”—} qeo|zg[Zo-imq ¢om”—ib[§zgq<¢}RibVv[§”–}g¬4}v”—ib[8ay”–Y)c€

Šx[Z}v[Komc€ibqxopY)c<ibom”—f-¨©qxo imVv[P…³c€om·eq<¥({|Vwc€”–} £ “ [›zg[K{Z”–zv[tibq(qeomŠxce}v”—ŸK[ibV4[2ayimc€ib[Ka¢”—ibV)imVv[2{Zqe}4zv”°im”—qx}

imV4c<iibV4[Pimq€i|c€¦}GdvY.™@[ZoWq€¨uv–c6kx[Zo|ap”–}4{om[Kcxay[8aZ£ rvqxoW[fvc€Yuv–[e¤G”—¨¢[Pzg[Z¬4}v[,+ .-+,O 0/x¤œibVv[›ayimc<im[Ka

{Kc€}™w[qxomzv[Zom[Kzhcxa¨©qe–—q<¢ta.0

%21-

3547698

Q:;<!=

>

#%q

4

-nD%qg -:D#%5>+ -

3 476 8

A?:;<=

>A@CB TED

K A

WCFHG

<GF D%)%q

4 - P %qg

4

-Q- #%Q%qg

4 - P %Q-)- D%)%5>+ - P %>I+ -Q-

3 476 8

J

:;<!=

>

F

@KBL TED

K A WL

FHG

< G F

Références

Documents relatifs

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST