Optimal Control of Discrete Event Systems under Partial Observation

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00072592

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00072592

Submitted on 24 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de

Optimal Control of Discrete Event Systems under Partial Observation

Hervé Marchand, Olivier Boivineau, Stéphane Lafortune

To cite this version:

Hervé Marchand, Olivier Boivineau, Stéphane Lafortune. Optimal Control of Discrete Event Systems under Partial Observation. [Research Report] RR-4046, INRIA. 2000. �inria-00072592�

(2)

ISRN INRIA/RR--4046--FR+ENG

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Optimal Control of Discrete Event Systems under Partial Observation

Hervé Marchand, Olivier Boivineau, Stéphane Lafortune

N˚4046

Novembre 2000

THÈME 1

(3)

(4)

7682$9 :8;

<=?>A@CBEDGFH>AIKJLFHM N!OQPSRUTU@TV=?>+W*XCTY@TVM =ZFH[L\]OQ^_]BZ` J FHM =ba-FdceXC>A_][ M =Zf

g2hjikml+n9oqp&rAstlAuwvyxzl{|s~}ys~{tikml]s

el{-QLLg&p

p-uwjHwt{&jl:tl]hjlhjlw?Zo-K?lk'jtl:?wo*uwwlAs

zA ¡K¢j£w w¤ ¥ lmul¦§Z{tlAtl]se{lAS¦§uzjl¨©§u?sts|ªQ?y{t¦§k+u© ??{t?©t?j©«lAk+s&ª¬w®9¦§sl{l'?lZ{¯°}yse{lk+s

±

|!¯j²´³ ¥ l'uwy?y{-{thl:ª¬wk+u©§¦§stkµwªLstvjHl°¦§stw}z?Z{tw©C{thlw}b¶§n]¸·ud8k*yylA©,{hjlst}°s~{tlAk4u?s2{thjl'k+u¹wlA

©ºuwvuwwl»wlluK{tl]¼°}u'½¦¾{lse{uK{tl:k+u?hj¦«l

±U¿

¯yÀb²´³ÂÁ9vj-?Z{tw©Cjwj©§lkª¬?©«©§K¨-s!{thl®{thjlAw}¼¦«Ã¶§nK·u

¦ºs»huuw{tl¦§ÄlA°}0{thjl'jtl]s~lAlªvjwZ{tw©§©ºuj©§ll?lZ{sAÅj{hjl*j{¦«?SªyvjtldludÆ??{t?©?s~{s&ª¬?

lAwlA?{s'uwu¨!wse{tAuwstl¼wyel]´{¦«?lzª¬vjd´{t¦§w³Ç-K¨!l?l]Åwkmuwtl]Ã{t{thl0¨!w¹E¦«G¶«nAK·ÅQ¨!l¨&¦ºs~h{t{uw¹wl

¦§Z{tÃuwAwv?{*ut{t¦ºu©2?s~lAtKuwj¦«©§¦«{e}w³ÈÁ9vj+stw©§vy{t¦§wuwjj?u?h?s~¦ºs~{s'ª|{e¨!s~{tlAsA³Èg2hjl½se{+se{l¦§s'{hjl

jl¦«KuK{¦«?Éª|uwÊwstlwlA:ª¬w'{thlzuw~{¦§uw©«©§}vjwstlKuj©§l

¿

¯yÀÉÅLAu©§©«l]ÊuËQwstlwlAAÅ¨&hj¦ºhu©§©«K¨-svs'{t

k+u?s~¹+{hjlvjdyl©«}°¦§j+j?yl{lkm¦«j¦ºstk4udz{¼?se{tvd´{|uSuwjj¸x°¦§k+uK{¦«?zª{thlvjj?s~lAtKuwj©«l»{uelA´{w}

?s~{sA³ ¥ l:{hjlÆyl½jl:{hjlHltª¬wk+ul:k*l]uwstvjl:w0{thj¦ºs-?stlwl&uK{hjl-{thuwSw0{thjlw¦«?¦«uw©

¿

¯yÀ#¦«{stl©«ªe³

ÌÍ{thl¼s~l]wdbs~{tlÅ¨!l*vds~l*{thlmuw©«?w¦¾{hjkÎjlAstlZ{tl]b¦§¶«nAK·{tSst}°?{hjlAst¦§ÄlmuEwy{¦«k+u©stvjjk+u?hj¦«l*wªQ{hjl

ËQwds~lAt?l]³g2hj¦ºs-stvjjk+uwhj¦§jl®©§lAuws!{t*{thjljlAst¦«lA0s~vdlAt°¦ºs~?ª¬?2{thjlst}yse{lk8³

ÏSÐZÑCÒÓÔ ¡KÕw¤ 9¦ºsttl{tl:?lZ{|¯°}yse{lk+sÅCÁ9y{t¦§k+u©ËwZ{t?©UÅ°Lut{t¦ºu©Á9stlKuK{¦«?

Öº×,Ø~ÙÚ]Û!Ø&ÜÝºÙÞUßà

-©ºs~¼uwjdl]us&uws-p-lAstlAuh8p&lHwt{|-Ë2á®p-?KnAÅdËw©§©«lAwl®ª j?¦«jlAl¦«â+ËwZ{tw©á»wvjSp&lAd?~{s9â

ã|j¦§wlst¦¾{e}+wª ÀS¦ºhj¦§?uw,Åj-jS|tHw|¯°lAy{tlAkHl|www³

ä2å,æ¸çéèLêYë~èUë~ìêUíæçéè èUî¸ï¸ïð´êYñUëeò*çéóïKìê¬ñôõ®ö¬÷ø,öúùÊìó¸òôõ®ñUæ¸ë!ûëeïKìêYñUü&ëeóñQðýCûëÍý§ëeó¸èUë2ø,ë~èUë~ìêUíæ'þÿdó´çéó¸ëeëeêYçéó§û û øþLÿ

îñVçéò]çéèVíeçéïéçéóKìê¬õ ó¸çëeêUèUçñúõSø,ëeèVë~ìêUíVæböúó]çñVçìñUçë ø,ö|ð´óZðGÿdó¸ëeêõSÿéëeíÍñUêUð´ó¸çéíeèûëeèUç´ó8ý§ð´ê ð´ô¸çéëìñYý§ð´êYü&è®ìó]ò

ü-ìóKì´ëeò»ôõ|ñUæ¸ëLùêUüQõ|øëeèVë~ìêYíæ&íeë«ù øCî¸ó¸ò]ë~ê´êUìóñ ûùù! "#%$'&(#*)+#, '-/.'.10

2

ÿ3éëeíeñUêYçéí~çñ54ò¸ë76KêVìó]í~ë'8?ûçAçéèVçéð´ó9øëeíæ]ë~êYíæ¸ëQëÍñ û49ë9éð´ï¸ïëeü&ëeóñ:0)'8ì9ëeóAî¸ëQò¸î<;!4~ó=4~êUìûë>; ìîéë7$'?=)9")A@ìü-ìêYñ!@Cëeò¸ë+BC#

6KêVìó¸íeë

D

ûëeï]ñ:0ðýÂÿéëeí'0!ÿó0þE@Âð´ü&ï]î]ñVëeê>FAíeçéëeó¸íeë'8Gó¸çH0Qðý

çéíæ¸çìóI8):-' =)KJCë~ìHì9ëeóAî¸ë'8Zùó¸óùêYôð´ê:8

çéíæ¸çìó"/L=): '$(#,?=):?'?=0

èUñUë~ï]æKìó¸ëMëeë~íeè:0î¸ü&çéíæI0ëeò¸î

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes

(5)

:682$9 ® 8 :&

¤ -?vs-j?vs&¦§Z{trlAsstws2¦º¦mvjjlj?vjwlA©«©§l©ºuwsstl®jljwj©§ikmlAs|yl?k*k+uwyl:wj{t¦§kmuw©«l?³ ?vj

l©ºujÅyj?vs&uwjwy{ws2©§l»ª¬wkmuw©«¦ºstk*l®¦ºststv8yl:©§u'{hjr?t¦§l:yl:©§umst}°?{hjiAstl:yl:??{?©«lAvj&yl+¶§n]]·l{&k*yyrA©«¦ºstws2©§l

st}yse{ikml:?Z{tw©§lL?k*kml&r{uZ{Q©§l&©ºujZuwl2k+uZvjr2wrAjrr2uvjl&k+uwhj¦§jl®r{uK{sL½j¦ºsA³l&jt?j©§ikml-yv

wZ{tw©§l2wds~¦ºyrr!lAs~{Lst¦§k*¦§©ºu¦§tl»l©§vj¦jl»¶§n·l{stl2Auuw{tr¦ºs~l!u ©ºu»jtr]s~lAl&r?rjlAkmlZ{s¦§??{t?©§uwj©§lAs

l{:©§u0jw{t¦§wÃyl*ª¬w{t¦§wÃyl+j{s:stvj:©«l]s»rwrAjlkmlA?{s³mgwvy{lª¬w¦ºsAÅ,u:ud?~{:uvyxS{u¸Kuwvyxbyl8¶«nAK·Åj?vs

wvs:©§uwds:jus©«lzAuwyl+vjjl¼?s~lAtKu{t¦§wEut{t¦§l©§©«l¼jvÊs~}ys~{tikml?³-w{tl¼s~?©«vj{t¦§wÉs~lmªYuw¦¾{'lÊ8r{uHlAs

wsL©ºu:jlkm¦«iAtl?Åwj?vsyrAt¦§w?syvs~}ys~{tikml-dut{t¦§l©§©«lAk*lAZ{wstlwr&vj+?stl¸u{tlAvjAÅZujHl©§r! #"$#%'&'(#)*&'(´Å+?v¦

,kmrkmw¦ºs~l.-!vjjl-uwjj¸xy¦«k+uK{¦«?*jv¼j{QylAs {uelA{tw¦§lAs j?yV?stl¸uwj©§lAsA³ã-jl|j{¦«?mjl|y{sL?stl¸uwj©§lAs

stvj+©§lAs*{uelA´{w¦§tl]sl]se{zjr½j¦§l/Eut{t¦§¼ylSl{~{tlS?stl¸u{tlAvjA³|vuw?{+©ºuÃs~l]wdyl8r{uwdl?Åwvsmvy{¦«©§¦ºs~?s

©0u©§ww¦«{thjkmlQtr]s~lA?{rjuws!¶«nAK·jHwvjLst}ZZ{hjr{¦§stlvjjl&stwvsk+uwhj¦§jl!wy{¦«k+u©§l2yv+ËQ~Á9stlwlAAÅ¸?tlAstd?juw?{

uwv0wkmHwt{tlkmlA?{&?y{t¦§k+u©,yvSst}°s~{tiAkml»¦§j¦«{t¦ºu©

1Ô ] Ò £2 ¤ ¯y}°s~{tiAkmlAs*r?rjlAk*lAZ{s&y¦ºsttl{sAÅj?k*k+uwyl®wy{¦«k+uw©«l?ÅjwstlKuK{¦«?zuw~{¦«lA©«©§l

(6)

' +10.Q 01 ®´$9 ®

ÌÍbwllu©VÅj{thljvjH?stlª?y{t¦§k+u©wZ{tw©¦§s|{t0se{vy}0{thjl'dlAhu¸°¦«?uw©,jwHlt{t¦§lAs&wªQu¼st}°s~{tlAk

±

u©ºstzuw©«©§lA

©§uw?{´²´ÅLkmyyl©§lAuwsub|¦ºsttl{tlwlA?{+¯°}yse{lk+s

±

|!¯j²´Å {Æ{uw¹wlzu?yKuZ{uwwl+wª|uSut{t¦ºv©§uwse{tvd´{tvtl?Åu

{?ljlAu{tl0ustvjHlZ¦ºstw*¨&hj¦§h?s~{tu¦§s{hjlSs~}ys~{tlAk#{tÃuyl]s~¦§lAÊHlhdu¸Z¦§wmuwA?y¦§jb{t ?vduZ{t¦«{u{t¦§wl

uw Zvuw©«¦«{u{t¦§wltl ?v¦«lkmlZ{s³ÉÌÍ{thjl0½lA©§ª9wZ{tw©!ª99¯CÅ{thjl8s~vdlAt°¦ºs~?t}É?Z{tw©{thjlAw}E¦§j¦«{t¦ºuK{lA

°}Ep-uk+uwjwl¼ud ¥ ?jhuk ¶«n¸]·tK°¦ºylAsuwÉujjwt¦ºuK{l'{hjl?tl{t¦ºuw©l°°¦«wk*lAZ{:ª¬ws~{uw~{¦«j8{ÆlAuwstw

uwd?vy{|?y{t¦§k+u©wZ{tw©V³&ÌÍ8{th¦§s|ª¬uwkml¨!w¹HÅj{thjl'dlAhu¸°¦«?s&wªs~}ys~{tlk+s9ul:k*yylA©«l]S°}0stlZvjlAl]s-wª lAwlA?{s

K?l*uÆ½¦¾{l0uw©«jhduHl{A³Êg2hlj©ºuZ{m¦§s*ljlAstlZ{lAÉ°}Êstwkmlz¹°¦§Êwª9uvy{wk+uK{w,Åu

¿

¦«¦¾{lS¯°{uK{l0Àbuwhj¦§jl

±U¿

¯yÀb²´ÅC{huK{:?ljlAu{tlAs»stlZvjldlAs9ª!l?lZ{s

±

?®u?´{¦«?s²-{tht?vjwhÆ¦«{s®lxylAvj{t¦§w,³g2hl*wZ{tw©ª{thjlmj©ºuZ{

¦ºs+{hjl dlA~ª¬?tkmlA°}¦§jhj¦§j¦¾{¦«ÈstwkmlÆl?lZ{sz¦«"!$#AÅ&{hjlstl{0ª?Z{tw©§©§uwj©«lSlAwlA?{szu?s¼wdZs~l]{tÉ{hjl

stl{%!'&#

±)(*

s~{udjsSª¬?bvjwZ{tw©§©ºuj©§l]²0wªmlAwlA?{s8{thduK{EAuj{ÆHlÈy¦§tl]´{©«}GjlwlAZ{tlA ª¬wkyvt¦«³

Ç|K¨lAwlAAÅ¦§È{thjlSu?s~¦º8s~l{tvjwª»stvjdlAt°¦ºs~?t}ÉwZ{tw©2{hjl?t}?ÅQwj{t¦§kmuw©«¦«{e}Ê¦ºsm¨&¦¾{htl]s~HlA{*{És~l{¼¦«©«vds~¦§w

uwb{th°vs:u©§© ©«lA?uw©LdlAhu¸°¦«?s»ul'l Zvu©§©«}S?°°

±

ÄAl0?s~{²»udb¦§©«©§lZu© Hlhu¸°¦§ws9uwtl*lZvuw©«©§}Æu?

±

¦§y½¦¾{l

?s~{²³Gg2hjlb¨?t¹Ê¦§¶§nK·»lj¦§hlAs*{th¦§ss~l{tvj%°}È{thjlbu?jy¦«{t¦§wªZvuw?{¦¾{uK{¦«?lSk*l]uwstvjlAsm¦§{thjlSª¬?tk ª

yAvjtlAluwZ{tw©ZZse{ª¬vj´{¦«?sAÅK{t»uj{tvjl{hjlQªYu?´{{thu{ stwkmlQ©§lZu©?dlAhu¸°¦«?sulQHl{~{l{thduw{thjlAsA³

ÌÍ {hj¦§suwdlAAÅ:¨!lulÉ¦§?{llAs~{tl] ¦§ u%jlA¨ ©ºuwssSª+wj{t¦§kmuw©'wZ{tw©:jw©«lAkmsSª¬w9¦ºsttl{tlÉ?lZ{

¯y}°s~{tlAk+s

±

|!¯j²´³ ¥ l+uwjwy{»{thjlmª¬?tk+uw©«¦ºs~k wª!stvjdlAt°¦ºs~?t}SwZ{tw©{thlw}É¶§n]]·QuwÆkmyyl© {hjl+s~}ys~{tlAk uws®u

½dj¦¾{l+se{uK{tl*k+uwhj¦§jl

±Y¿

¯yÀb²³Á9vj:?Z{tw©jt?j©§lk ª¬w©§©§K¨-s-{hjl*{thjlAw}S¦«¶«nAK·QudÆ¦ºs»hduuw´{l¦«ÄAlAS°}8{hjl

tl]s~lAl»ª vjwZ{tw©§©§uwj©§l9lAwlZ{sÅ°{hjl:j{¦«?wªyAvjtlAl®udwZ{tw©,?s~{sª¬w-lAwlA?{s2u8u*¨?s~{~Íu?s~l

?yelA{t¦§wl+ª¬v´{¦«?,³ÊÇ-K¨!l?l]ÅwkmulAÉ{tÆ{hjl0¨?t¹E¦« ¶«nAK·&uÈwkmuwtl]E{tb{thjl0{hjl*¨?t¹ys'ylAuw©«¦§j

¨&¦«{thÃ?y{t¦§k+u©QwZ{tw© ª&9¯¶Å,+jÅQnA¸·Å¨!l+¨&¦§sthE{t0{uw¹wl+¦§Z{tSuwAwv?{:uw~{¦§uw©LwstlKuj¦§©§¦¾{e}-¦«É?Z{tuws~{AÅ

{hjlSjl°¦§wvs'{thlw¦§lAsmw©«}jlAu©&¨&¦«{th{{u©§©«}Ê?stl¸uwj©§l0st}yse{lk ljlAstlZ{uK{t¦§wds³%¯°l?lu©&?lAy{szu

t?dlA~{¦«l]swª{hjlÊs~vdlAt°¦ºs~?t}%?Z{tw©®jwj©§lk vylSdut{t¦ºu©®wstlKuK{¦«? ¨!llEs~{tvj¦«l] ¦§ ¶jÅ&Å.ZÅ/¸·

uwkmwj»{hjls³ Ç-K¨!l?l]Å¸{thjlA}?j©«}jt?dZs~l2u Zvu©§¦«{uK{¦«?l!{thjlAw}:ª¬w {hjl-??{t?©°ªÂ|¦ºsttl{tl&?lZ{¯°}ys~{tlk+sA³

Á9vj8stw©§vy{t¦§w uwjj?u?hwst¦ºse{szwª:{e¨se{lsA³ g2hls~{ut{t¦§jÊHw¦§Z{0¦ºs0u

¿

¯yÀ ¨&h¦§h5ltl]s~lA?{s+{hjl

?©«?u©2Hlhu¸°¦§wmª:uEw¦§wlAst}yse{lk8Å¦§©«vj¦«jÉ¦«{s¼vjjwds~lAtKu©«l8y}°ukm¦ºsA³ ¿ wk {hj¦ºs ¿ ¯yÀÉÅ?vj¼u¦§k ¦ºs

{?ljlAu{tlbuÈs~vjHl°¦§stwz{thu{0?l¦¾½dlAszuw°}t?dlA~{e}È{thu{0¨!lb¨!wv©§%¨&¦ºsth%{tuwss~y¦ºuK{lS{t¦«{AÅ-ª¬wk {hjl

stl{¼wª»u?lAy{uwj©§l8wZ{tw©§©§ls*u?wy¦«b{Ãstwkml8km¦«¦«km¦§ÄAuK{¦«?%¦¾{l¦«?,³%g2hj¦§s¼¦§s+¨&hduK{+huws¼dlAl%uw©«©§lA

{hjlb9L~Á9y{t¦§k+u©§¦¾{e}Èjt?dlA~{e}0wª®u

¿

¯yÀ ¶§nK·³GÌÍÈ{hjlSª¬ukml¨!w¹Êwª»uw~{¦§uw©-wds~lAtKuK{¦«?,Å{hjlS½s~{zse{l

¦ºs:{hjljl¦«KuK{¦«?Éª-uÉ?stlwl®ª¬?{hjlzuw~{¦§uw©«©§}bvjwstlKuj©§l

¿

¯yÀÉÅ uw©«©§lAÉuEËQV?s~lAt?l]³0g2h¦§s'se{lÊ¦ºs

lAl]stsu}st¦«l-vjj?stl¸uwj©§l!lAwlA?{su©§wl2Auj{L{t¦§wwlAu:s~HlA¦¾½H2dlAhu¸°¦«?ªÂu:??{t?©«©§l]³ ¥ l-yl½jl&{hjl

Hltª¬wk+ulkmlAu?s~vjl?8{thjl¼ËQV?stlwl&uK{hjl|{thuwÆwÆ{thjl'w¦«?¦«uw©

¿

¯yÀ ¦«{stl©«ªe³®Ç-K¨!lwlAAÅ¨l'¨&¦«©§©k+uw¹wl

{hjlzlAl]stsu}El21Cwt{s{tb¹?llAÉ{tuw¹Eª&{hjl¦§yª¬?tk+uK{¦«?Ã{thu{*hduws*y¦§sudl]ulAÃ¨&¦«{thÊ{hjlz¦§j¦«{t¦ºu©&s~{tv´{vjtl?³

s~HlA¦§uw©«©§}wÅ{thj¦ºs-?s~lAt?l&u©§©§K¨-s2vs&{¼tlAkmlkHl-uwÆujt¸xy¦§kmu{t¦§wª {thjl'?s~{s-ª {thjlvjjwds~lAtKu©«l:Zse{s

Hl{e¨!llAS{e¨!¼wstlKuj©§l:l?lZ{sA³|g2hj¦ºs»ujj¸xy¦«k+u{t¦§w8uwst¦ºu©§©§}?tlAstHw{tz{thjl'¨?s~{AÅH¦V³l?³«Åd{thjl*hj¦§whjl]se{]Å

?s~{ª&{hjlj¦31CllZ{'vjwstlKuj©§l+{uelA´{w¦«l]s®{thduAuÉyvj'Hl{e¨!llAÉ{e¨!ÆwstlKuj©§l+l?lZ{sA³ÆÌÍjllA,Å

st¦§lz{thjl]s~l+{uelA{tw¦§lAsuwtl+{'?stl¸uwj©§l¼¦¾{*¦§s'jw{'H?ss~¦§j©§l¼{tbtl]KwlA:{thl¦§*?s~{sA³ ¥ lz{thjlAtlª¬wl¼jlAlA

{u?ststvjkml+{thduK{{hjl0¨?s~{u?s~l°AvjsA³bÀSwlK?lu?s¨!lz¨2uZ{{tEylAuw©¨&¦«{thwy{¦«k+u©2?Z{tw©Q¨!l¼jlAlAÊ{t

s~{t?tl®{hjlAstl?s~{s-¦§8{thlwds~lAt?l]³ÌÍ8{hjl'stlAwSs~{tlA,Åd¨!lvstl:{hjl:{thlw}0¦«É¶§nK·{ts~}°Z{thjl]s~¦§Äl'uSwj{t¦§kmuw©

wZ{tw©§©§l9wtl]s~Hwdy¦«+{t0{thl'?y{t¦§k+u© tl]se{t¦º´{lAbdlAhu¸°¦«?AÅC¦§s~wªYu®uws»¦«{»¦ºs:uwhj¦§lKuwj©«l'°}Æuu?ykm¦§sst¦«j©§l

±

¦U³lw³§ÅQhZ}yst¦§Au©§©«}Éws~{tv´{¦«©«l¸²stvjHlZ¦ºstw]³

¥

l8vstlu?¹ZVjwdu?u{t¦§wEª¬wk#{thl

±

wj©§}j²??uw©!s~{u{tl0ª-{hjl

?stlwl»{SwlluK{tl*{hjl¼s~vdlAt°¦ºs~?AÅ,duwstlAEwÃl?lZ{Zse{:ª¬v´{¦«?s³0g2hjl¼stvjdlAt°¦ºs~?:¦§ss~}°Z{thjl]s~¦§Äl]b¦§Êu

k+uwjjl{thduK{2w¦§wlAsQ{thlk/?y{t¦§k+u©Cs~vjjs~{tv´{vjlwÅy?s~¦ºs~{tlZ{!¨&¦¾{hz{hjl9{t¦§wª9L~Á9y{t¦§k+u©§¦¾{e}+wªQ¶§nK·³Lg2hjl

?yelA{t¦§wl®ª¬vjd´{t¦§wShduws|um¨!ws~{~Íuwstl9ª¬wk0³&g2hjl{t{u©,¨!ws~{~Íuwstl:?k*vy{u{t¦§wuw©?k*©«lx°¦«{e}zwª {thj¦ºs|stlAw

4

û #ï]ñUçéü-ìéçñúõ&èUñVìó¸ò¸è,ý«ð´êûõ]óKìü&çéídêYð'´êVìü&ü&çéóï]ñUçéü-ìéçñúõ 0

(7)

s~{tlA¦ºs-vjj¦º®¦«{thjl:°vjk'dlA-ª se{uK{lAs2¦§{hjl:wds~lAt?l]³

g2hj¦ºs&uwdlA&¦§s-w?u¦«ÄAlAzu?s!ª¬w©§©«K¨-sA³LÌÍÆ¯°lA{t¦§wÆyÅ°{hjl:jl]lAssu}+j{uK{t¦§wds&ul»¦§Z{tyyvl]Â³Q¯°l]´{t¦§wSm¦ºs

jlww{tl]+{t'{thl»tl]s~lA?{uK{¦«?zªu{e}°Hl»wª?s~lAt?lQª¬w&udut{t¦ºu©§©«}+?s~lAt?lA

¿

¯yÀÊÅju©§©§lAzu+ËQwstlwlAA³g2hjl

ËQwds~lAt?l-¦ºs|¦«{stl©«ªuw

¿

¯yÀ ¨&h?stl's~{uK{lAs»??{u¦§Æ¦§yª¬wk+uK{t¦§wÆ{thu{®uw©«©§K¨-s-vs9{z¹wlAlS{u?¹

±

¦§uzlt{uw¦«

¨2u¸}j²Âwª{thl2?s~{wª{hjl2vjjwds~lAtKu©«l{tuKel]´{t?t¦§lAsªd{thjl2¦§j¦¾{¦§uw©js~}ys~{tlAkm³

¿

¦§u©§©§}wÅ¦§{hj¦§sLstlA{t¦§w,Åw¨l!lx°{tlA

{hjljw{t¦§wSwªQwZ{t?©«©ºuj¦§©§¦¾{e}?³2¯°l]´{¦«?S¼¦§s9yl?{lA0{tu+jl¨{t¦§w8wªwy{¦«k+u©??{t?©U³ ¥ l¦§?{tyyvdl:{hjl

{t¦§wSwªQZse{»ªQum{u?l©§lAu?y¦«+{tz{thjlmyl½dj¦¾{¦«?ÆªQuwSwy{¦«k+uw©

±

uws9¨lA©«©uws|9L~Á9y{t¦§k+u©ú²|stvjjk+u?hj¦«lª

{hjlËQV?s~lAt?l]³

¿

¦«du©§©«}?ÅZ¨!l9sthjK¨%hjK¨%¨!l9Auzstw©§wl|{thjlÁ9y{¦«k+u©Â¯°vjHl°¦§stw}¼ËwZ{tw©Hwj©§lk7¨&¦«{thj¦§z?vj

l¨5ª¬ukmlA¨?t¹+vst¦§j*{thjl®{hjl?t}¼tl]s~lA?{lA¦«Ã¶§nK·³

3 &0 :&

ÌÍ{thj¦ºsstlA{t¦§w,Å]{hjlQk+u¦§wly{suw®j{uK{¦«?suwtlQjl½jl]Â³ ÀSwlQyl½j¦«{t¦§ws¨&¦«©§©Zdlw¦§wl:¨&hljl]l]stsu}

¦§0{thjl®ª¬?©«©§K¨&¦§j*stlA{t¦§wsA³Lg2hjl:lAuwjl2¦§s2lª¬lAtlAz{t8¶K·Âª¬?-u°}¼vjjl½jl]8wdlj{sA³

Ð 1 Ô Õ Ð 2 g2hlÆs~}ys~{tlk {tÉHlÆwZ{t?©«©§lAÈ¦§s+uE½dj¦¾{lÆse{uK{l0k+u?hj¦«l

±Y¿

¯yÀb²0¶K·9jl½jl]Z}Èu /¸V{tvjj©§l

!"!$#%!&(')!&+*!$,.-´Å°¨&hjll !¦ºsQ{thjl|½j¦«{tl®s~l{ª,lAwlA?{sÅ/# ¦ºs{hjl9½j¦«{tl9stl{2ªs~{u{tl]sÅ&('»¦§sQ{thl|¦§j¦¾{¦§uw©Âse{uK{tl?Å

&+*G¦§s{thl»vj¦Zvjl»k+u¹wl]¼se{uK{l

±

¦«wllu©VÅZuw

¿

¯yÀ kmu¸}mhu¸?l9stl?lu©k+uwt¹?lA¼s~{u{tlAs²´Åjuw0,¦§s{thl9uw~{¦§uw©

{uwst¦¾{¦«?8ª¬vj´{¦«?yl½jl]SKwlA !123#54768#m³»g2hjl*j{uK{t¦§w9,/:<;!&.=(>Âk*l]us-{thu{?,/:<;!&.=|¦§s»yl½jlA,ÅH¦V³lw³§Å

{hjll¦ºs»u+{tuds~¦«{t¦§wS©ºuHl©§lAS°}8l?lZ{@;Êwvy{»ªQs~{uK{l&m¦§bk+uwh¦«jlm³ ¦«¹?l¨&¦ºs~l?ÅA,/:CBD!$&.=|jljw{tlAs|{thl*s~{u{tl

lAu?hjlAb°}S{uw¹Z¦§j{thjl¼stlZvjlAl*ª!l?lZ{s:yl½jl]b°}S{u?l%B*ª¬t?k s~{uK{l%&z¦§k+u?hj¦«lEm³

¥

l+u{th¦«j¹

wª" u?s'uwvjdwZ{t?©«©§lAÉ©§uw?{*{thduK{¼se{ut{s*uK{%& ' udÊlxyl]vy{lAsGF¸wlAjluK{lAs'ustlZvjlAlª|lAwlZ{s{huK{+ul

u?ly{lAE°}H,°³8Ì{¦ºsu?ststvjkmlA{thduK{{e¨!Sl?lZ{sAuÃjw{dl¼{t¦«?wllAÃst¦«k'vj©«{ulwvds~©§}-km?tlAKwl»{hjl+{t¦§kml

Hl{e¨!llAz{e¨!+?s~l]vy{¦«?l®lwlAZ{s!lxylAvy{tl]0Z}I¦ºs&jw{&jl{tlAtkm¦§jlA0jvj{-¦§s!½¦¾{lw³

¥ ¦«{th8ust©«¦§whZ{!jvy{&wkmkmwujvstl|wª,j{uK{¦«?,Å°¨l»yljw{tl9Z}J,®H{h¼{hjl9dut{t¦ºu©d{tust¦¾{¦«?+ª¬vj{t¦§w0u

{hjl+uw{t¦§wllAwlA?{:stl{®ª¬vj{t¦§w,³K,¼¦ºs»jl½jl]bK?l ! 1 2L#M4A6N#/¨&hjlE¦«{®ltl]s~lA?{s-{hjlmut{t¦ºu©{tuds~¦«{t¦§w

ª¬v´{¦«?,ÅywKwl# 476 !¨&hjlAz¦«{!ltl]s~lA?{s{hjl®uw´{¦«?l|lAwlZ{2s~l{ª¬vjd´{t¦§w

±

¦V³l?³L¨&hjl¦¾{2l{tvtsQ{thl®stl{!ª

lAwlA?{s!{thu{9uw8dllxylAvj{tlA0¦§Æumw¦§wlA8s~{u{tl¸²´³ ¥ lylAj{l:°}I, 1 Åyl½jlA8K?lO#P476 ! 1 Å{thjl'uw´{¦«?l ()&

stl{2ª¬vjd´{t¦§w

±

uws&?jdZs~l]¼{*{thjlu?´{t¦§wl&')*& ,stl{&ª¬v´{¦«?d²´³

g2hjl'dlAhu¸°¦«?|wªL{thjlms~}ys~{tlAk ¦ºs»ylAs¦«HlAÆZ}8u¼du¦§9wª©§uwjwvuwwl]sQ":<R=|uw3QS*K:TR=³:g2hjljl½xZÍ©§?stlA

©ºuwvuwwlRQ@:TR=*¶§n]]·L¦ºs|{hjlm©§uwjwvduwlwlluK{tl]S°}9m³Ì{:¦§s®u0s~vs~l{»wª$! 1 ÅÂ¨&hjll ! 1 jljw{tlAs|{thlEU®©§llAjl

©«Zs~vtl®ª{thls~l{ !¶¸·³&¯°¦«km¦§©§uwt©§}wÅj{thjl©ºuwvuwwl?Q * :TR=&wtl]s~Hwdjs!{tm{hjlk+u¹wl]zHlhu¸°¦§w&wª{hjl

¿

¯yÀ

mÅZ¦V³l?³«Å?{thjl9s~l{QªC{tuKel]´{w¦«l]s ªC{thjl9s~}ys~{tlk ldy¦«¦«J& * ³¯Z{uK{lO& * u+Hl&{hjwvj?hZ{ª,uws{thjl|s~{u{tl-lAu?hjlA

¨&hl8umw¦§wlz{u?s~¹¼¦ºs-wkmj©§l{tl]Â³

V 2Ô £+WX<YZ -

¿

¯yÀ ¦§s&su¦º¼{mdl$ +[]\:¦«ª^Q":TR=?_ Q * :<R=2ujwjVj©§y¹°¦«j*¦«ª`Q@:TR=a Q * :TR=Åy¨&hjll

b ylAj{lAs*{hjlSjl½jxÈ©«Zs~vtl0ª»{thjlS©ºuwvuwwlcbÊ³%g2hjlAstlS?lAy{s¼jlAstlwlª¬vj~{hjl¼wkmkmlZ{sA³%Ìªd ¦ºs

©«y¹°¦«Å¦«{:uSlAu?hÆu¼s~{uK{l&°ÅH¨&hjll,/:<&.=e+jvj{@&3_& * ³|g2hj¦ºs|¦ºs»u©§©§lASu & f['dl]uvds~lzl?lZ{

AuSHl{t¦§w?llAÂ³-&Awy¦§j+{zwv|¦§?{ljl{u{t¦§w8ªk+uwt¹°¦§jÅd¨l*se{uK{tl{thu{|{hjlj©ºuZ{»j©«y¹ys-HlAAuvstl¦«{

lAZ{tlsujlAuwj©«y¹'s~{u{tl&¨&¦«{thj?vy{hdu¸Z¦§j®{lk*¦§u{tlA*{hjl&{uwst¹HÅ?¦U³lw³§ÅZtl]uwhjl]K& * ³L|j{hjl¦§ss~vl&¦§sQ¨&hjl+{hjll

¦ºsu:stl{wªCvjk+u¹wlA*s~{uK{lAsL¦§J {thu{ª¬wk+su:se{t?jw©§}wjjl]´{lAm?k*HwlZ{AÅ?jvy{Q¨&¦«{th 0( %K\ ]\

' g & %'& U³LÌª{thjl:©§uw?{&lA?{ls!{thj¦ºs-stl{-wªs~{uK{lAsAÅ°{thjlA8¨l:?l{&¨&huK{&¦ºs-uw©«©§lA0u ) &2f[K³

h!}®yl½¦¾{¦«?»wª/Q":TR=u@Qi*:<R=´ÅK¨!luwss~vjkml {huK{j¦ºs0(Ê¨&¦¾{h:tl]s~HlA{,{tk&l'Qud@&+**³g2hj¦ºsuwsstvjkmy{t¦§w

kml]us{thu{u©§©j{hjl9s~{u{tlAsªj ul-uwAlAsst¦«j©§l&ª¬wk{thjl9¦«j¦«{t¦ºu©Cs~{uK{lO&('9u+?uwAl]stst¦«©«l2{:{thjl9k+u¹wlAms~{u{tl

(8)

&

*

³SÌÍÉ{hjl'¨?jsAÅ¦«ª&{thlzs~}ys~{tlAk hu?slx°l]vy{lAÉstwkmlIB Q":TR=4 Q *

:<R=´Å{thjlAÊ¦§É½j¦«{tl+{¦«kml?ÅL¦¾{¨&¦§©§©

lxylAvj{tl9s~vhÆ{thu{dB Q *

:<R=|st¦§l*u©§©Hlhdu¸Z¦§ws-hdu¸wl:{hjl'?jHwt{tvjj¦«{e}0{tz{tlkm¦«duK{tl*jwHl©«}?³|©ºuZ{s

hdu¸Z¦§j*dlAhu¸°¦«?s!¨&hj¦ºh0{tlAtkm¦§uK{l®u{&vjjk+u¹wl]s~{u{tlAs&uwtl®¦§©«©§lZu©Âudlxj©§vylAzª¬wkµ?vj&s~?©«vj{t¦§w8s~u?l?³

Ê¢£ XTY Ð D g2hjlÆstl{zwª»Hlhdu¸Z¦§wsmª»{thlb??{t?©«©§lAst}°s~{tlAk ¨&¦§©«©|dlbuÉstvjstl{¼wªdQ":TR=³ ¥ ¦«{th{hj¦ºs

¦§Êkm¦§ÂÅ¨!lzs~{uK{l¼{hjl¼ª¬?©«©§K¨&¦«byl½dj¦¾{¦«?wª|uÆs~vjk+uwhj¦§jlzwª|u

¿

¯yÀ

±

{thduK{+uÉH?sst¦«j©§}Ãdlut{t¦ºu©§©§}

?stl¸uwj©§l]²|¶·V³

0Ð Y`X¬ fX

Ô

Y

A !"!$#i!&l'i!$, - % % $2 D & %K & & $ K ! !O

# #%! ;! !i!&"c# ,i:<;!&.=(>$#8:<, :T;!$&.=a ,/:T;!&.==&% â

Ì{9¦§s-©«l]u2{huK{ , -®¦§s9umut{t¦ºu©Â?jl&w0{hjlstl{|wª

¿

¯yÀÆsA³ ¥ luw©§st¼stu¸}¼{thu{ ¦§s9u+s~vjk+uwhj¦§jl:ª 7uK{O&

¨&hljlAwl& ' &"9#uw'( m³QÀS?tlAKwlAAÅ?¨l:¨&¦§©«©Âvds~l

) :<E!&.= +*, .- ¦ºs2{t¦«kµ¨&¦¾{h0lAstHlA´{&{%& * uwI& '0/ &1 ± n¸²

{mtlAjtl]s~lAZ{!{hjl:s~l{-ª{t¦«k4s~vjkmu?hj¦§jlAs2wª^ uK{k&'¨&¦¾{h0lAstHlA´{2{E& * ³

¿

w2{tl]hjj¦ºuw©Âtl]uwstwsAÅ°¨l®jlAlA{t+yl½jlu8u©§wlAju¦º|?dlAu{t¦§w8u©§©§lA &'(<\ &!{thu{-wk'j¦§jlAs

¿

¯yÀÆsA³

0Ð Y`X¬ fXÔ Y2 & 3 54 $&6 % & j& '07 3# 98 #:@<; & & &'(<\&=?>@4 4 % $23

%2BA!%DC

>E4 F !G!$#G !& '&7 !$# * G !,G-G!HA &'(&

!G ! JI !:

# G # I # :

#d*

G #R* I #R*

:

, G

:T;!$&.= K LM

, :T;!&.= &ON %%

, : :<;!&.= &N % %

&QP & &'(&A6%.&f

±

?²

â

g2hl|kmlwl-wªR uwS4jtyyvdlAs!u:k+uwh¦«jl5F ¨&hjZs~l&{uwst¦¾{¦«?sQuwtl&{hjl»vjj¦§w¼wªÂ{thjl9{tust¦«{t¦§wsQªRGu

4z³g2hjl:kmlwl»ª{e¨*{t¦§k

¿

¯yÀÆs&¦ºs&jw{&jlAlAsstuwt¦§©«}¼u'{t¦§k

¿

¯yÀÉ³dÀSwlK?l]Åw{hjl®{tust¦«{t¦§wª¬vj´{¦«?8¦§s2jw{

lAl]stsu¦§©«}+¨!l©§©,yl½djlAÂ³Ç|K¨lAwlAAÅ°¨!l®Au8se{uK{l9{hjl®ª¬w©§©§K¨&¦«jm©§lkmk+uj³LÌ{s2jt°wª¦ºs-se{uw¦«?hZ{~ª¬w¨2u8¶«nAK·V³

TÐ

Ê¢?

& UR!4V J!; & $g & ( %% 7 %2 (FPWX>E4 !Y &ZP ?[ %A &2&ZP & D

(& ) &.( @&('0\ # : ] ]4 (& 0( $ & !F ! G !$# G !$&(' : !#d* G !, G - % 0( % $ D &

J ^

g2hl+tl ?v¦«lkmlZ{s»{thu{/u_4ÎHl¼s~vjk+uwhj¦§jlAs®wªkµlAs~vtl]s»{thu{¦¾ªk, :<;!&.=uwH,:O:<;!&.=dw{thÃlxy¦ºse{]Å

{hjlc, :<;!&.=a ,:":T;!&.=³Q-K¨:ÅZª¬?2uw©«©3!`4a ) :<E!&.=Q{thj¦ºs2©§lkmk+u'¦§kmj©§¦«l]s!{thu{b>?4c ) :TE!$&.=´Åy¨&hj¦ºh

¦§kmj©§¦«l]s»{thu{ ) :<E!&.=9hu?s»uk+uKxy¦§kmuw© l©§lkmlZ{

±

¦§b{hjl+s~lAstl{huK{u©§©L{hjls»ul*stvjjk+uwh¦«jl]s»ª¦«{²³Ì{¦ºs

jljw{tlA°}Jd :<E!&.=´³

efdÐ YC ÆA A¢y ) Á9vju¦§k ¦§{thjlmª¬?©«©§K¨&¦«8stlA{t¦§ws»¦ºs®{tSst}°?{hjlAst¦§Äl+u8s~vjHl°¦§stw»ª¬?Rµ¨:³A³{A³+u8stdl]¦«½d

wZ{tw©Qwyel]´{t¦§wl?³8Ì{¦§s{thjlAÊ¦§k*Hwt{uwZ{{tS{u¹?l¼¦«Z{buwAwv?{:{hjlzH?sst¦«j¦§©§¦¾{e}b{thu{*lA~{u¦§ÃlwlAZ{sAuj{

Hl'j¦§suj©§lA8°}{thjl*s~vdlAt°¦ºs~?-w&{huK{®lA~{u¦§SlwlAZ{s-k+u¸}dl'j{»wstlwl]°}{thjl*s~vdlAt°¦ºs~?A³&g2hjlAtlª¬wlwÅ

stwkml+wª!{hjl¼lAwlZ{s:¦« !uwtl¼su¦º{tÆHl¼vjdwZ{t?©«©ºuj©§lwÅ¦U³lw³§Å{thjlA¦«'yvtll+uj{Hl¼jl?lZ{tl]EZ}Ãu

wZ{tw©§©§l]Å?¨&hj¦§©§l®{thjl®{hjls&ul®wZ{t?©«©ºuj©§lw³ -8vjdwZ{t?©«©ºuj©§l»lwlAZ{2Auª¬w&lxjuwk*©«l®kmyyl©,umhuwjwl»ª

stlds~?-tl]uwy¦§jZsÅ{thjl{t¦º¹wªQu¼©§y¹HÅHl{

±

s~lAl¼¶·ª¬?|kmwlyl{uw¦«©ºs²³ ,¦§¹wlA¨&¦§stlwÅH??{t?©¨&¦§©«©Hl'uj©«¦§lA8?bu

©§uw?{9{thu{»¦ºs»ut{t¦ºu©§©§}0?stl¸uwj©§lwÅH¦U³lw³»{thl*stvjHlZ¦ºstw»¨&¦«©§© wstlwl?j©§}8us~vs~l{»wª{thl'lAwlZ{s|?ljlAu{tlA

g

6Kð´ê,ë+B]ï=éçéí~çñü-ìñUæ¸ëeü-ìñVçéí~ì?ò¸ëihKó¸çñUçéð´ó¸è8¸ñUæ¸ëLêYë~ìò¸ëeêü-ì~õ-êYëÍý§ëeê,ñVðj)')ik%0

(9)

dut{t¦«{t¦§wjl]u?s

! "! #RI ! &# ¨&¦«{th ! #R8 ! &# e*u0uws ! "! I ! & »¨&¦«{th ! 8 ! & k e/!

±

Z²

±

¿

H?sst¦«j©§l*{tÆyl{tlAtkm¦§jl+¦¾{s:lxy¦ºse{llwÅ,¦«{¨!wvj©ºdl+¦§kmdZstst¦«©«lm{8uw©«©§l°¦ºuK{l'{hjlmªYuw{:{thu{¦¾{*wv©§k+u¹wl*{hjl

st}yse{lk tvjm¦§yl½j¦«{tl©§}*¦«m{huK{Q}°©«l?Åw¨&¦«{thj?vy{{hjl|stvjdlAt°¦ºs~?Lj{¦§¦«³ Ç-ldl-|sstvjkmy{t¦§wSn?Åw¨&hj¦ºhmlZ{uw¦«©ºs

Qt?dlA~{e}Æn?³

A fXÔ Y ; & 5 % $.%.&'(#)$ &EDD &.%( â

¡ Ô Ð ¡¸ Ñ &'( %% &9#E!* B ! ! 1&

,/:CB)!&.=G>1%*%UP & ( 3QD ^

Ô YC ¡ Ô 2 Ô A `Y£w +XÔ YD#¥ l»K¨%¦«©«vdyl»{thjl»©§u?se{2¦§jwlAy¦§lZ{{t*dl®uj©§l9{tmy¦§svdsts!wj{t¦§kmuw©«¦«{e}wÅ°uwkml©§}

u?s~{

±

âuÃyvjtldl+Zse{®ª¬vj{t¦§w

*

¦«dvjtl]z¦§8lxylAvy{t¦§j+u0l?lZ{

±

*

:T;

=³

*

#9- !P6

I

± ; :T;_ !'&#=#" :*

#f:T;=a =~²´³

stll®¦§Æ¯°lA{t¦§w0³

$ %'&

)(Â682$2+*/

&

&,&Q-,

(/.

¿

¯yÀÆsA³Sg2hjlzstvy

±

u¸¨2u¸}¼{hjlmvjj?s~lAtKuwj©«llwlAZ{s9ª{hjl'©§uw?{dmÅC¨l*©§?stl{thl*?s~{9ªQ{thjl*vjj?s~lAtKuwj©«l{tuKel]´{t?t¦§lAs-dl{e¨lAl

¿

±

uws'{thj¦ºs'{tuKel]´{t?t}Ã¦ºs

(10)

¿

¦§wvjlmn Lut{2wª^

e ¢ !2Ð ; 3+% 0(& % T & +%J %&'( &@2 A6\ &N &f & ! *f; 1 !'&

*;& !; & !$;& 1

J & %% & 0 0(\f\&'( &.) & A;b (g &.( ^ *%'& &.)) && &2 &'( $ (\f\&'(]\

&%'&2 & 7&;& ;& ( g & %'& &2&;& ; & &'(& % A B & &.( &'A T ( '&2 (& g &

%&*%&2 &'))*&.% 0(D\f ;7 &.(&T2 (&G ]( , ) &A^ 3A & ) &$ %% &' &'0('& (&6A6

&@ \ &.% % f$ (#(& T&f R*

*

:<; & =

*

:T; & =G!

*

:T; & =

*

:<; & =01%`;% % & (N

A6!$&% (& g & $#%'&'(#)*&'(l

±

Á9stlwlA¼¨&¦«{th

lAwlA?{?s~{s»ª!{tuKel]´{t?t¦§lAs9Hl{e¨!ll{e¨!8s~{u{tl]s³+g2hjlm¨2u¸}8{thjl]s~l+Zse{s:ul*wkmjvy{lAÃudu{~{u?hjlAb{t0{hjl

¿

,/:%!i!& * =S & * ³2g2hjl&!Èl?lZ{-¦ºs evs~{9u

±

(*),+ -/.'02143576890;:=<>0 :@?A0CBEDFGHFJIKD

! ¦ºs|{hjlms~l{»wªQwstlKuj©§llAwlA?{sÅNL ¦§s9{thl*stl{®ªQk+u?Íse{uK{tl]sÅO 'm¦ºs9{thjl*¦«¦¾{¦§uw©k+u?Íse{uK{tl?ÅP7*7¦§s9{hjl

¯Z{ut{t¦§j9ª¬t?k {thjl2¦§j¦¾{¦§uw©°j©§uwZ{^!"!$#E!$&(')!&l*!,.-ÅK{thl2stl{SLµwªk+uwtws~{u{tlAsªA #L¨&¦«©§©°dl&?s~{t¦«{tvy{lA

Ð Ê¢y¡WUT l\ & E ( ) \ ?\) &2 % && V0% &XWkmK°¦«jYD; & ()*&'( $'(+[&.%& &.) &2 ZWjuw¹wl[Y.

; & ( % %\ % &]W%s~{t?jdl]^YD<; &&ju¹?l &') &2 \ )*& $&& R2BA & $ &-Oh&¯ZÍuw´{¦«?l&.) &2 T $

A *% '$#%'&'(#)$2& $D & () &.(l