• Aucun résultat trouvé

The Steam Boiler Controller Problem in Signal-Coq

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "The Steam Boiler Controller Problem in Signal-Coq"

Copied!
63
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00072888

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00072888

Submitted on 24 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub-

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,

The Steam Boiler Controller Problem in Signal-Coq

Mickaël Kerboeuf, David Nowak, Jean-Pierre Talpin

To cite this version:

Mickaël Kerboeuf, David Nowak, Jean-Pierre Talpin. The Steam Boiler Controller Problem in Signal- Coq. [Research Report] RR-3773, INRIA. 1999. �inria-00072888�

(2)

ISRN INRIA/RR--3773--FR+ENG

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

The Steam Boiler Controller Problem in Signal-Coq

Mickaël Kerbœuf, David Nowak, Jean-Pierre Talpin

N˚3773

Octobre 1999

THÈME 1

(3)
(4)

.0/21436587:9$;=<:>@?BADC!EFHG#5JI/2K0LNMJO&583HFBP8<Q5SR TUV/W<X>Y>@<[Z\5892]/WR

^_6`(a&b&cedgfh@ijb@kmlJnNbopijqJiro*`(a&b@i

sHtjumvrbowHsyx{zy^f

f$km|}|8umtjo~}bVtjbY€_}b(t€€_}b‚Xƒ:„m„…ƒ†dˆ‡e‰o*umŠ}t*bc@‹m‹X‹VdŒm‹|6k…ŽXb@i

N!‘@’(“4”}•m’m– zpa&um}Žoj_6bV—˜kmtj™šumlSiœ›uXtja-kmžŸ™ i¡a-iB›umt¢o*_}b~Jb@ij™šŽm#u…› t*b@kX‰o*™Ÿ—XbeijqJiro*b(a-i(£:o*_}b&¤8¥¦ §+¨©mª

«e¬!­ ›umt*a-k…žkm|}|}t*uXkX€_®£Q™2¯bm¯o*_}buXaŠ}™š}bY~Nl6ijbVu…›!oj_6bi¡qQ6€_}t*um6uml6i~}k…o*k4°Su4±²žškm}ŽmlSk…Žmb¤8¥¦ §+¨©

km6~Noj_}bV|}t*uQu…›kmi*i¡™ iro€k…:o «e¬ ­ £Si¡b@b(a-i¢oju&Š8bVb@ij|SbY™ k…žšžŸqNijl}™ŸojbY~#km6~|}t*kX‰o*™š@k…žW¯

³{6~}b(b@~®£Joj_}b~}bojb@tja&™š}™ iro*™šV(um6(l}tjt*b(Sq&™Ÿa&|}žš™šb@~´ŠQq-oj_6bi¡qQ6€_}t*um6uml6iBa&uQ~}b(ž®uX±_}™ €_†¤8¥¦+ª

§®¨©µ™ši›uXl}6~JbY~¶iro*tjuX}Žmžšq·i¡™ša&|}žš™¹¸6bYi&oj_6bDi¡|8b@(™¹¸S@k4o*™ŸuXºkm6~·o*_}b=—mb@tj™Ÿ¸S@k4oj™šum»u…›¼i¡l6€_¶ijqQi¡ojb@a-i(¯

½Dumt*b(u4—mb@t@£

«e¬!­

™šiB}u…oBžŸ™ša&™¹o*b@~-o*uijuma&b$¾Q™š6~-u…›+|}t*um|8b(tjoj™šb@iBk…6~Ni¡uS£X™Ÿo*iœl6i¡b\b(6kmŠ}žšb@iyo*u~J™ ijtjb@ŽXk…t€~

±_Sk4o$(kmŠ8b€_}b@€¾Xb@~#~Jl}t*™Ÿ6Žo*_}bij|SbY™Ÿ¸S(k…oj™šum´iro€k…ŽmbX¯

³{µoj_6™šikmt¡o*™š(žŸbX£±¢b&l}6~Jb@tjžš™Ÿ6b&oj_}b-—4k…t*™šuml6ie›bYk4ojl6tjbYi¼u…›œo*_}™ i-¤8¥¦ §+¨©mª

«e¬!­

›umt*a&kmžHk…|}|6tju:km€_

±™Ÿoj_=kž k…t*Žmb¼ij@k…žšb¼@kmijbViro*l6~Jqm£JSk…a&b(žšq¿o*_}bÀ:ojbYk…aÂÁ¢uX™Ÿžšb(t|}t*umŠ6žŸb@a#¯

Ã=Ä:ÅÇÆ*ÈÉ “4Ê!‘m– tjbYkm‰o*™Ÿ—Xb#ijqJiro*b(a-i@£ijqQ6€_}t*um}uXl6ia&uQ~}b(žW£¢—Xb(t*™¹¸8(k4o*™ŸuX®£œa&uJ~Jb@žp€_}b@€¾Q™š}Ž6£¢|}t*uQu…›

kXijij™ iro€k…:o@£JumxW™š6~JlS‰oj™šum

Ë Ì+ÍjÎÐÏ@ÑÍÒ!ӚÎÐÔWÕÖ

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes

(5)

‘ – sykmtja&™Jžšb@iH~J™Çh(t*b(:o*i!›uXtja-k…žš™ i¡a&b@i!|8b(t*a&bo¡o€k…:oHž ke(um6(b(|Jo*™ŸuX~}b@iyijqQi¡oj`@a&b@it*h@kmoj™Ÿ›i(£

žk…|}|}t*uJ€_}b\›umt*ab@žŸžšb¤8¥¦§®¨©…ª «e¬ ­ £HžlJoj™šžŸ™ i*k4oj™šum´uXaŠ}™š}h@b¼~}lž k…}Ž:k…ŽXb\~Jb¼|}t*umŽXt*kmaa-k…oj™šum

ijqQ6€_}t*um}b°6u…o~}b¿~Jum}6h(b@i¤Ç¥¦§+¨ ©#bo~Jb-žkXijij™ iro€k…:o~Jb&|}tjb@l}—mb «e¬!­ £ ijb(aŠ}žšb(ojt*b-|6k…tjoj™ ‰x

l6žŸ™š`(t*b(a&b(:o$km~6k…|Jo*h(bm¯

wH#bÇboY£JžškuX6l6tjt*b(6(b\~Jh(ojb@tja&™š}™ši¡ojbe™š6~Jl}™Ÿojb¼|6kmtBžšb¼auJ~J`@žŸb¼ijq:S€_}tjuX}b\ijl}t¢žŸb:l}b(ž!¤8¥¦ §+¨©

bYiroV›uX6~Jh¿ij™Ÿa&|}žš™Ÿ¸6b&›umtjojb@ab@:ožšk´ij|ShY™Ÿ¸S(k…oj™šum bož k´—mh@tj™Ÿ¸S(k…oj™šumµ~Jb&ojb@žšiijqJiro*`(a&b@i@¯¿wH uXlJojt*bm£

«e¬!­  bYiro|6kXiœžš™Ÿa&™Ÿojh!l}#b@t¡o€k…™š&orq:|8b¼~Jb\|6tjuX|}tj™šho*h@iœbok…™š6i¡™W£Qi¡uX¿lJoj™šžš™ši*k4o*™ŸuX¿|Sb@tja&b(o~Jb\›k…™št*b

kmŠ6i¡ojt€km‰o*™ŸuX~Jb(b"Xl6™®|Sb@lJo#o*tjb¼—Xh(t*™¹¸6h¼|8b(6~6k…:o$žšk|}_Skmijb¼~}bi¡|8h@(™¹¸S@k4o*™ŸuX®¯

$ek…6i#bµ~JuJl}a&b@XoY£p}uXl6iNijuml6žŸ™šŽm}uX6i¿žšb@i#~J™8h@tjb@:o*iNkXi¡|8b@o*i#~Jb†(bojojb k…|}|}t*uJ€_}b´›umt*a&b(žšžŸb

¤Ç¥¦§+¨ ©…ª «e¬!­ ž%k…™ ~JbV~l}}bVh(ojl6~Jb~}b(kmi¢™ ijijl}b~Jb¼ž™š6~JlSiro*tj™šbm£&&i*k˜—muX™Ÿt¢žŸbV|6tjuXŠ}žŸ`@a&be~Jl=i¡ojbYk…a

Š8um™šžšb(tY¯

’Y‘ Æ •)( – ijqJiro*`(a&b@iBt*h@kmoj™Ÿ› i(£:a&uJ~J`(žšb\ijqQ6€_}t*um}bX£m—mh@tj™Ÿ¸S@k4oj™šum£Xa&uJ~Jb(žŸx{€_}b@€¾Q™š}Ž6£:kmi*i¡™ iro€k…:oB~Jb

|6tjb@l}—mbX£}u…xЙš6~Jl6oj™šum

(6)

* +

-,œ

³{oj_6™šikmt¡o*™š(žŸbX£:±¢be™ŸQ—mbYiro*™ŸŽ:k4o*b$oj_6b¼(umaŠ}™Ÿ6b@~l6i¡beu…› oj_}bVijqQ6€_}t*um}uXl6iHž k…}ŽXl6k…ŽXb¤8¥¦ §+¨©&km6~¿um›

o*_}b|}tjuQum›œkmi*i¡™ iro€k…:o «e¬!­ ›umt¼i¡|8b@(™¹›qQ™š}Ž#km6~=—Xb(t*™¹›qQ™š}ŽN|}t*um|8b(tjoj™šb@i\u…›œkž k…t*Žmbi*(kmžŸb(kmijbi¡ojlS~Jqm£

Sk…a&b(žšqm£Qo*_}biro*b@kma ŠSuX™Ÿžšb(t|6tjuXŠ}žŸb@a´¯

^_6™ši¼~JuJl6ab@:o¼™ i¼~J™š—:™ ~JbY~[™š:ojuor±Bu#a-k…™š[|6kmt¡o€i(¯/.!™št*i¡ojžšqm£ k4›ojb@tVkij_}umtjo¼tjbY(k…žšž!u…›Ho*_}b-um:o*bnQo@£

±¢b|}t*b@ijb(:o$o*_}b¿¤Ç¥¦§+¨ ©…ª «e¬!­ ›uXtja-kmžk…|}|6tju:km€_#›umtpoj_}b~Jb@ij™ŸŽX=u…›yt*b@kmoj™š—mbijqJiro*b(a-i(¯$^_6b(®£8±Bb

t*b(|8umtjoVoj_6b¿tjbYi¡l6ž¹o€iu…›$ij|SbY™Ÿ›qQ™Ÿ}Ž†k…6~ —Xb(t*™¹›qQ™š}Ž´oj_}biro*b@k…axЊSuX™Ÿžšb(t|}tjuXŠ}žšb(a ±™¹o*_ oj_}™ ia&bo*_}uJ~+¯

0pu…o€k…Š}žšqm£J±¢bV~Jb@i*t*™ŸŠ8b¼uml}t¼¤Ç¥¦§+¨ ©™Ÿa&|}žšb(a&b(:o€k4oj™šum´™š=~Jbo€k…™šžši@¯

1231 46587:9;=<?>@5BA@CED;F5HGID

f$b@kmoj™š—mbVijqQi¡ojb@a-ik…t*beum›ojb@´i*k4›b(orqNt*™Ÿoj™ (k…ž®km|}|}žš™š@k4o*™ŸuX6i±_}™ €_´kmtjb¼™š=€_6k…t*Žmbeu…›_6k…S~JžŸ™š}Ž&al6ž¹x

o*™Ÿ|6žŸb¿™š:ojb@t*kX‰oj™šumSi¼±™¹o*_ oj_}b-b@:—Q™štjuX}a&b(:o@¯^_}b(q k…t*b-k…ž i¡u´u…›o*b(·(uma&|Su:i¡bY~[um›$i¡b@—mb(t€k…ž|6kmt*kmžŸžšb(ž

(uma&|8um}b@Xo€ioj_Sk4oe(uQum|8b(t€k4ojb¼o*uNkm€_6™Ÿb@—mb¼oj_6bbnJ|8b@‰o*b@~=Š8b(_Sk˜—:™šuml6t@¯^_}uXijb(uma&|SuX}b(:o€itjuXl}Žm_6žŸq

Š8b(žšum6Ž&oju-or±¢u-a-k…™š#|6tjuJbYijipž kmi*i¡bYi(¯¢^_}b(q´k…t*b¼b(™Ÿoj_}b@tp|6kmt¡o$um›!o*_}b™š:ojb(tj›km(bV±™¹o*_´oj_}bb(Q—Q™Ÿt*um}x

a&b@Xo¼±_}™ €_†b@6ijl}tjbYi$o*_}b&bn}€_6km}Žmbu…›Ho*_}b-~}k4o€k}£Çumteoj_6b(qD(kmtjt*q´umlJo¼|}t*uJb@i*ij™Ÿ}Žum[oj_}bYi¡b&~}k4o€k}¯

^_6b(t*b›umt*bm£!uX6l}t*t*b(6(qD™šiu…›o*b(·k… ™ša&|SuXt¡o€k…:oV›b@k…ojl}t*b-o*_6k4oij|8b@™Ÿ¸S@k4oj™šum km6~ |}t*umŽmt€k…a&a&™š}Ž

›uXtja-kmžŸ™ i¡a-i¢_6k˜—Xb\o*uo*k…¾Xb¼™Ÿ:oju-kX(uXl}:o@¯

zp}u…o*_}b(t¢b@i*ijb(:oj™ k…žÇkmij|SbY‰oY£Xa-k˜qQŠSb\oj_6bpa&uXi¡o¢™ša&|SuXt¡o€k…:o@£:™ iBt*b(žš™ k…Š}™šžŸ™Ÿorqm¯!³{6~Jb@b@~+£Qt*b@kX‰oj™š—mb\i¡qJi¡ojb(a-i

kmtjbpu…›ojb@-™Ÿ€_6k…t*Žmbum›t*™¹o*™š@k…ž6_Ql}a-km¿umtBb@uX}uma&™ tjbYi¡uXl}t€b@i@¯ ^_Ql6i@£Xoj_}b@qum›ojb@¿tjb:l}™Ÿt*b›uXtja-k…ž

—Xb(t*™¹¸8(k4o*™ŸuX¿o*u:uXžši±_6b(´ŠSb@™Ÿ6Ž&~}b@ij™ŸŽX}b@~+¯

J8K

Ä

•$LNM!•X”J’)L

ÉO z\i¡qQ6€_6tjuX:q ™ ioj_6b=au:iro-6k…ojl}t€k…ža&uJ~Jb@ž›umt¿uX6l6tjt*b(:o&|}tjuXŽmt€k…a&a&™Ÿ6Ž†k…S~

ijb(b@a-iNo*_Ql6ioju¶ŠSbµ±¢b(žšžkm~}km|JojbY~ ›umt#o*_}bµij|8b@™Ÿ¸S@k4oj™šum0u…›tjbYkm‰o*™Ÿ—Xb†ijqJiro*b(a-i(¯ zpijq:S€_}tjuX}umlSi

ž k…6Žml6kmŽmb@ižŸ™š¾mbEPÀQsRQŸc)ST}umt:UWVǨ!QST6k…t*bœŠ6kXi¡bY~uXoj_6™šia&uJ~Jb(žW¯yÀQ™ŸSb¢oj_}b¢|}t*umŽXt*kmaa&™š}Ž$a&uJ~Jb(žJum›

o*_}b@ijb¼žškm}ŽmlSk…ŽmbYiœ™ i¢›uml66~Jb@~#uX¿oj_6bV™Ÿ:ojb@tjžšb@k˜—Q™š}Žum›!b(nQojb(t*6kmž8b@—mb@Xo€i(£Q—Xb(t*™¹¸S@k4o*™ŸuXiju:uXNŠ8b@(uma&b@i

k&€_6kmžŸžšb(6Žm™š}Ž™ i*i¡l}bX¯

^_6b\ijq:S€_}tjuX}umlSiyk…|}|}t*uXkX€_oju(um6(l}t*tjb@6qYX±_}™ €_Ni¡o*k…tjojbY~&ojuŠSbe™ŸQ—Xb@i¡oj™šŽXk4o*b@~™š!QŸc[Z\T^]Hb@6k…Š}žšb@i

o*uVk˜—mum™ ~¼o*_}™šiy~}™#_¿l6ž¹orqX£X~J™ i¡t*b(Ž:k…t€~J™š}Ž$bnJbYlJo*™ŸuXkm6~(uma&al}6™š@k4oj™šum~Jl}t€k4o*™ŸuX6i(¯ ³Ðoyoj_Ql6ib@6k…Š}žšb@i

o*uij|8b@™Ÿ›qm£6—mb(t*™Ÿ›q¿k…6~#i¡™šal6žšk…ojb¼kt*b@kX‰oj™š—mb¼ijqQi¡ojb@a k4o$k›l}6‰o*™ŸuX6k…ž+žšb(—Xb(žW¯y^_}b`&%? B›bYk4o*l}tjb

um›+oj_}bei¡qJi¡ojb@a ±™šžšž8uX}žšqŠ8be€_6b@€¾mbY~-k4oBoj_}b\™Ÿa&|}žšb(a&b(:o€k4oj™šum#iro€k…ŽXb$umNk|6k…tjoj™ l}ž k…t¢k…t€€_}™Ÿojb@ojl}t*bm¯

½[k…Qq=|}t*umŽmt€k…a&a&™š}ŽNž k…}ŽXl6k…ŽXb@i\žŸ™š¾mbbadcfe gihijkQŸc\l[TУfmegij=hij}©nQ„:£‹\THuXt¤gm¨ogijqpr+¨Hhgie-Qšc@ƒTœk…t*b

ŠSkmijb@~#um´o*_}™šieijq:S€_}tjuX}umlSik…|}|}t*uXkX€_®¯@0\k…a&b(žšqm£ ¤8¥¦ §+¨©!QZJ£!cYŒ\T ™ ipk¿~}k…o*k…°6u4±0ž k…6Žml6kmŽmb¼±_}™ €_

_Sk…6~Jžšb@i™šJ¸66™¹o*bi¡bXl6b(6(b@iu…›y~}k…o*k=s!o*_}b`t #"ut‰¯

vVÄ “L^M•m”J’[LÉO ^_}b†au:iro´uXaa&uX²±¢k˜qºo*u —mb@tj™Ÿ›q ijk…›borqº|}t*um|8b(tjoj™šb@iu…›t*b@kmoj™š—mb[ijqJiro*b(a-i™ši

a&uJ~Jb@ž¹x{€_}b@€¾Q™š}Ž6£Y±_}™ €_t*b(žš™ŸbYi®umi¡bYk…t€€_}™Ÿ6Ž$bnJ|8b@‰o*b@~V|6tjuX|Sb@t¡o*™ŸbYi®™šk¸66™¹o*bBa&uJ~Jb(ž:u…›6oj_}b¢i¡qJi¡ojb(a´¯

^_6™šiNab(oj_}uJ~¶_6kXi¿ijb(—mb@t*kmž$km~J—4kmXo€k…ŽXb@i@¯w.}uXt¿™š6iro€k…6(bm£™Ÿo™ i¿uXa|6žŸb(ojžšqºkmlJojuXa&k…oj™ =k…6~ :l}™Ÿojb

›kXiroY¯H½=umt*b(u4—Xb(tY£m™Ÿo$|}t*uQ~}l6bYiuml6Xo*b(t*bn}k…a&|}žšb@i¢±_}b@No*_}bV—mb@tj™Ÿ¸S@k4oj™šum_6k…|6|Sb@6ioju›km™ŸžW¯HÁ¢lJooj_}b

a-km™Ÿ ~Jt€k˜±Š6km€¾Ji¼um›a&uJ~Jb@žB€_}bY€¾:™š}Ž=k…t*b&oj_6bNiro€k4o*b¿bnJ|}žšuXij™ŸuX†|6tjuXŠ}žŸb@a km6~†oj_}bNtjbYiro*tj™ ‰o*™ŸuXµum›

b(nJ|}tjbYijij™šŠ}žŸbœ|}tjuX|Sb@t¡o*™ŸbYi+o*uekpŽm™š—mb(£˜~}b@™ ~}kmŠ}žŸbX£˜žŸuXŽm™ …¯³{S~Jb(bY~+£4|}t*um|8b(tjoj™šb@i+o*_6k4o™š:—Xumžš—mbH|Sk…t€k…a&bo*b(t€i

(7)

uXt}um´žš™Ÿ}bYk…tQl}a&b(t*™ (k…žÇ—4k…žšl}bYi(k…6}u…o$Š8b¼|}tju4—Xb@~~J™Ÿt*b@ojžšqN±™Ÿoj_=ka&uQ~}b(žŸxЀ_}bY€¾mb@t@¯

^_6b(umt*b(a |}tju4—Q™š}Ž ™ši¿}u…o¿žš™Ÿa&™ŸojbY~¶Š:q·oj_}u:i¡b=t*b@i¡ojt*™šoj™šum6i@¯0‡\ºoj_}b[u…oj_6b(t-_6km6~+£¢oj_}™ i-a&bo*_}uJ~+£

±_6™š€_´™ iŠ6kmijb@~#um´k&a-k4o*_}b(a-k4o*™š@k…ž+žšumŽX™šeŽm™š—mb@ŠQq#k›uXtja-kmž®i¡qJi¡ojb(a´£}t*b:l}™št*b@i™šXo*b(t€kmoj™šumN±™Ÿoj_

k¿l6i¡b@t@¯e^_}bo*_}b(uXtjb@a |6tju4—Q™š}Ž-|}t*uQ(b@i*i$™ i$o*_}b(t*b›uXtjbi¡žšu4±Bb@toj_Sk…=o*_}ba&uJ~Jb(ž€_}bY€¾:™š}Ž¿uX}bm£Çk…S~

™Ÿo$(kmijuma&bo*™Ÿa&b@i¢Š8beojb@~}™ŸuXl6i(¯H^_6b(umt*b(a |}t*u4—mb@t*i¢(kmNŠ8bVž kmi*i¡™Ÿ¸6b@~km@umt€~J™š}ŽVo*uo*_}b(™št~Jb(ŽXtjb@b\um›

kmlJojuXa-k4oj™šum¯!^ uQumž iHžš™Ÿ¾Xb «e¬ ­ QŒ\TÇumta@j6¦ ¬ t*b:l}™štjb\kV_}™šŽm_}b@tœ™šXo*b(t€kmoj™šum-±™Ÿoj_¿o*_}bplSi¡b@tBk…S~&oj_Ql6i

o*_}b(q#k…t*be@k…žšžŸbY~[/t t t'?qt‰¯

«e¬!­ ™šie±¢b(žšžHi¡l6™¹o*b@~=o*u´tjbYi¡uXžŸ—XbuXa|6žŸb(nD|}tjuXŠ}žšb(a-i(¯³Ðo¼b@6k…Š6žŸbYi$o*u#a-km}™Ÿ|6l}žšk…ojb›umt*al}ž kmi\u…›Boj_}b

@k…ž l}žšl6ium›!™š6~JlS‰oj™š—mb(um6i¡ojt*l6oj™šum6i Qšc@‹\TУ6b(nQojb(S~Jb@~´±™Ÿoj_=umxW™š6~JlS‰oj™šum Qšcmc'TУSk&žšumŽX™š@k…ž+ž k…}ŽXl6k…ŽXb

(uma&™š}Ž›t*uma orqQ|8b\o*_}b(uXtjqX¯y^_:lSi(£Jij™Ÿ6(b «e¬!­ (kmN_6km6~Jžšb\™šJ¸6}™Ÿojb¼uXŠJvrb@o*i@£:™Ÿo™ši¢±¢b(žšž+km~}km|JojbY~-oju

t*b(|6tjbYi¡b@Xoij™ŸŽX6k…ž i(¯

12 "!E5 A;o5H7 G$#%'&d<)(35+*-,.&0/@;1*2&0(435*6&879(35HG

C maximum gradient of increase maximum gradient of decrease maximal outcome of steam

:;:

:;:<

<

pump controllers provided data: flow

pumps capacity:

provided data: status P

M2

N2

N1

M1 M1

M2 N1

N2 steam boiler maximal capacity:

minimal limit:

maximal limit:

minimal normal:

maximal normal:

C U2 U1 : : : W

=;=

>;>

steam measurement device provided data: outcome of steam

water level measurement device provided data: quantity of water

.!™ŸŽXl}tjb&csysH_QqQij™ (k…ž+b@Q—:™št*um}a&b(:o

ÀQb@—mb@t*kmž$›umt*a-k…žea&boj_6uQ~6ib@6k…Š6žŸb[oju»ij|8b@™Ÿ›q²k…S~ —mb@tj™Ÿ›q k·t*b@kmoj™š—mb[ijqJiro*b(a´¯ ³{ umt€~Jb@t¿oju

(uma&|6kmtjbo*_}b(™štiro*tjb@}Ž…o*_6iBkm6~-±¢b@km¾:6b@i*i¡bYi(£:kuXaa&uXN(kXi¡beiro*l6~Jqm£Q™W¯bX¯!oj_}b¼iro*b@kmaŠ8um™šžŸb@t¢(um:ojt*umž

(8)

ij|8b@™Ÿ¸S@k4oj™šum´|}t*umŠ6žŸb@a#£6_6kmiŠ8b(b@´|}tjuX|Su:i¡bY~#Š:q6¯x{fV¯6z$Š6tj™ k…žW£}w$¯8ÁXtjŽXb(tk…S~¯ k…}ŽXa&kXkm€¾ Qƒ}£

cm£ l\TЯ´^_}b¿umt*™šŽm™š6k…žHij|SbY™Ÿ¸S(k…oj™šum ™ iV™Ÿ}›umt*a&kmž2£!Š}™ kmijb@~†oju†k´|6k…tjoj™ l}ž k…tV™ša&|}žšb(a&b(:o*k…oj™šum·km6~ ™¹o

(um:o*km™ŸSiVi¡uXab-kmaŠ}™šŽml}™Ÿoj™šb@i@¯N^_}b@®£ ijuma&b-|}t*b@(™šij™šum6i¼k…S~µijuma&b¿~JbY™ i¡™šumSiVk…Š8umlJoVo*_}b-|}t*umŽmt€k…a

km6~Noj_}bV|}_QqJij™š@k…ž+b(Q—Q™štjuX}a&b(:o¢al6i¡o$ŠSbVa-km~}b¼k…o¸6t€iroY¯

ÇÅ ‘[L•X” ( Ä O L“ ÉO ÄoO ’ ^_}b\|6_:qJij™š@k…žÇb(Q—Q™štjuX}a&b(:o¢™ iuXa|8uXijb@~Nu…› ijb(—Xb(t€k…ž8l}}™Ÿo*iX¢¥¦]‰¯

wBkm€_#um}b¼™ i$€_6k…t€kmojb@tj™(bY~-ŠQq¿|}_QqJi¡™ (kmž®umSiro€k…:o*ikm6~ijuma&b¼u…› oj_}b@a |6tju4—Q™ ~Jbe~6k4o*k6¯

“ É (Ä ‘@’@”}’ Ä ÄoO ’ ^_}b¿|}t*umŽXt*kma _6kXiVojuµuXXo*tjuXžyoj_6bNžšb(—mb@žœum›$±¢k…ojb(t™Ÿ·oj_}b#iro*b@k…a Š8um™šž¹x

b@t@¯·^_6™ši:l6k…:o*™¹orq _6kXio*u†Š8b#}b(™Ÿoj_}b@tojuQu†žšu4± }uXto*uQu[_}™šŽm_®¯»‡po*_}b(t*±™ i¡bX£yoj_}b´ijqQi¡ojb@a a&™ŸŽX_Xo

Š8bk 8bY‰o*b@~+¯¼^_}b|6tjuXŽmt€k…a kmžšiju¿_6kXi$o*uNa-k…Sk…Žmb|}_QqQij™ (k…ž l}}™Ÿo*ip›k…™šžŸl6tjbYi(¯.}umt\oj_Sk4o\|6l}tj|8uXijbm£Çk4o

b@—mb@tjqauXa&b(:o@£S™¹o€i$o€k…¾mbYi™šXo*uNkm@uXl}:ooj_}bŽmžšumŠ6kmžiro€k4o*bu…›oj_6b|}_QqJi¡™ (kmž®b(Q—Q™štjuX}a&b(:o$±_}™ €_=™ši

~}b(}umojb@~¿Š:q-km & N b ¯Hz@umt€~J™š}ŽVo*uoj_6™šii¡o*k4o*bm£Xoj_}be|}t*umŽXt*kma~JbY™ ~Jb@i¢k4o¢b@km€_qJžšb$™Ÿ›

o*_}bijqJiro*b(a al6i¡opiro*um|=uXt$}u…oY£Skm6~´™¹›y}umo@£S™¹o¼km‰o*™Ÿ—4k…ojb@i$umtp~JbYkmoj™š—˜k…ojbYi|}l}a&|6ip™Ÿ=uXt*~Jb@toju-¾Xb(b@|

o*_}bVžšb(—mb@ž®kmial6€_#kXi|Su:ijij™šŠ}žŸb¼™š#oj_}bVa&™ ~}~JžšbVu…›o*_}bi¡ojb@kmaŠ8um™šžŸb@t@¯

^_6beij|SbY™Ÿ¸S(k…oj™šumNkmžšijuŽX™Ÿ—Xb@i¢km~}~J™Ÿoj™šumSk…ž8™ŸJ›uXtja-k…oj™šumN(um6(b(t*}™Ÿ6Žoj_6b\|}_QqJij™š@k…ž6Š8b(_Sk˜—:™šuml6tBum›®oj_}b

i¡ojbYk…aŠ8um™šžŸb@t@¯ 0pkmab@žŸqX£4}b(± —˜kmžŸl6b@i@£m(kmžŸžšb@~kX~˜vrl6i¡ojbY~km6~@k…ž l}ž k4o*b@~V—4k…žšl}bYi(£…kmtjb¢|}t*um|8uXijb@~+¯^_6b(q

b@6k…Š6žŸboju=¾Xb(b@|[o*_}b¿uXXo*tjuXžyu…›¢oj_}b¿ijqJiro*b(a´£a-km6k…ŽX™Ÿ}Ž´k#—Q™šij™ŸuX u…›B™Ÿo*i~JqQ6k…a&™ …£±_6b( k´a&b@k4x

ijl}t*b(a&b(:o$~Jb@—:™ b¼™ i$~Jb(›b@‰o*™Ÿ—Xbm¯

µb€_}uXijb\oj_}™ i$(kXi¡b¼i¡ojl6~JqŠSbY(kml6i¡b¼™Ÿo$™ši±¢b(žšž®km~6k…|Jo*b@~Noju&uml}t$km™Ÿa´£J™W¯bX¯oju-ij_}u4±²o*_}b¼™Ÿ:ojb@tjbYiro

um›œo*_}b´¤8¥¦ §+¨©mª «e¬ ­ ›uXtja-kmžkm|}|}t*uXkX€_®¯³{6~}b(b@~®£®oj_6b|6tjuXŽmt€k…a_6kmieo*u´_6k…6~}žŸb-ijb(—mb@t*kmž|}_QqQij™ (k…ž

|Sk…t€k…a&bo*b(t€i$k…6~D™¹oea&k˜q´l6ijb6umDžš™Ÿ6b@k…t\Ql}a&b(t*™š@k…ž—4kmžŸl}bYi(¯e^_Ql6i(£Çi*k4›borq´|}t*um|8b(tjoj™šb@i\(km}}u…oeŠSb

|6tju4—Xb@~N~}™Ÿt*b@ojžšq¿±™¹o*_=k(žškXijij™ (k…žÇa&uJ~Jb(ž €_}b@€¾Xb(tY¯

# !"$#&%('N *) ,

µbµ|}tjbYi¡b@:o#™š²o*_}™ši´ijb@oj™šum²o*_}b»¤8¥¦§®¨©…ª «e¬ ­ ›umt*a-k…ž¼k…|}|6tju:km€_¶›umtoj_6b ~}b@ij™ŸŽX²u…›t*b@kX‰o*™Ÿ—Xb

ijqJiro*b(a-i¼±_}™ €_†_Skmi¼Š8b(b( |}t*um|8uXijb@~[™Ÿ6Qšc˜„)TЯ-z›o*b(tkm†™šJ›umt*a-k…žyt*b@@k…žšž!um›Bo*_}b&|}t*™Ÿ6(™Ÿ|6žŸbYi¼u…›u…x

™š6~JlS‰oj™šum£y±BbŠ}tj™šb°Sq ~}b@i*t*™ŸŠ8b¿o*_}b «e¬!­ u…xЙš6~Jl6oj™š—mbk…nJ™ŸuXa&k…oj™@k…oj™šum u…›N¤8¥¦§®¨©·£œ±_}™š€_ ™ši

kmžšiju|}tjbYi¡b@:ojb@~™š´~}bo*km™Ÿž i™šnQšc˜„[TW¯

231 ,"& #\< /,+,-9;=<&0/

^_6b¼(uma&a&um|}tj™š6(™Ÿ|}žšb¼u…›™š6~JlS‰oj™šum#b(Sk…Š}žšb@i¢o*ul}S~Jb(t*žŸ™š}beoj_6b¼€_Sk…t€km‰o*b(t*™ši¡oj™ (iBu…›umxW™š6~Jl6oj™šum®¯

µbV™šJ›umt*a-k…žšq-™Ÿ:ojt*uJ~Jl6(b¼oj_}u:i¡b¼™ ~Jb@kXi™Ÿ=ijuma&b¼bn}k…a&|}žšb@i@¯

.O Ê •m’)L ” O ʕ É6Æ LO Ê!•…’)L ‘ Ä ’Y‘ z žŸ™ i¡o@£™2¯bm¯´k0/d& Vi¡b:l}b(6(b-u…›—4k…žšl}b@i@£!™ši~Jb¸66b@~ ™š

«e¬!­ ±™Ÿoj_#oj_}b13254768:9;:<5=(uma&a-k…6~®¯ .6umtb(nJkma&|}žŸbX£

132>4768?9;3<5=@2BA79DCE;GF?9IHKJD=79LHNM

O

;QPRHS25A79>CE;GF:9

(9)

2F HS2BA79?2BA79>CE;7F?9 2>A79DC;7F?9

~}b¸6}bYik¸6}™Ÿojbžš™ši¡ou…›6k4o*l}t€k…ž+Ql}aŠ8b(t€i@¯

³{}›umt*a&kmžŸžšqm£®oj_}™ i~Jb(¸6}™Ÿoj™šum ijk˜qJi\oj_Sk4ok#žŸ™ i¡o™ši¼b@™¹o*_}b(tVo*_}b-b(a&|Jorq†žŸ™ i¡o

O

;QP6£®umt

2Fp™2¯bm¯¿k

—4kmžŸl}b´›uXžŸžšu4±BbY~NŠQqNkžš™ši¡or¯

½Dumt*bV›umt*a-k…žšžŸqX£52BA79DCE;GF?9N~Jb(¸6}b@i¼£Soj_}bi¡b(o\um›!o*_}bžŸ™ iro€i$um›H6k4o*l}t*kmžQl}aŠSb@t*i@¯³Ðoe~Jb@}u…o*b@ipoj_}b

ija-k…žšžŸbYiro¸}nJ|8um™š:o$u…›!k a&um6u…ojuX}umlSiBuX|Sb@t*k…ojuXt¢uXžš™ iro€iu…›!6k4o*l}t*kmž+Ql}aŠ8b(t€is

!

O

;QP#"$% 2F&'()+*,.-0/ km6~01-23"

µb-}u4±(um6ij™ ~Jb(tkmµb(n}k…a&|}žšbum›¢k=(u…xЙŸ6~}l6‰o*™Ÿ—Xb&~}b¸6}™Ÿoj™šum¯†b¿~Jb(¸6}b¿k=i¡ojt*b@kma#£™2¯bm¯¿km

3/ \i¡b:l}b(6(bum›œ—4k…žšl}b@i@¯ †bl6ijb›uXtpo*_6k4oV|}l6tj|8uXijbo*_}b 13254Q68?9;:<>=&(uma&a-k…6~[™Ÿ «e¬ ­ ¯

.6umtb(nJkma&|}žŸbX£

13254768:9;:<5=*2BA795J79#45=DA,5 HKJD=79LHNM

8 2F HS2BA79?2BA795J79#45=DA,5'6 25AQ9>J7974D=DA85+

~}b¸6}bYik…´™šJ¸6}™Ÿojbi¡ojt*b@kma u…›!6k4o*l}t*kmž+Ql}aŠ8b(t€i(¯

³{}›umt*a&kmžŸžšqm£Qo*_}™ ip~Jb(¸6}™Ÿoj™šum=ijk˜qJi¢o*_6k4o\k&i¡ojt*b@kma™ i$k…žš±¢k˜qJi¢Š}l}™šžŸop±™¹o*_´oj_}b 8 2FuX6i¡ojt*l6‰o*umtY£J™2¯bm¯

™Ÿo$™ ik…žš±¢k˜qJik—˜kmžŸl6b\›uXžŸžšu4±¢b@~Š:qki¡ojt*b@kma´¯

½Dumt*b›umt*a&kmžŸžšqm£Q2BAQ95J79745=GA,5&~Jb(¸6}bYi9 £mo*_}bpijboœum›Çoj_}beiro*tjbYk…a-iyu…›+6k…ojl}t€k…žSQl}aŠ8b(t€i(¯!³ÐoB~Jb@}u…o*b@i

o*_}bVž k…t*Žmb@i¡o¢¸}nJ|SuX™Ÿ:o$u…›k;: a&um}umojuX}uml6i¢uX|Sb@t*k…ojumtuX#i¡ojt*b@kma&ium› 6k…ojl}t€k…ž+Ql}aŠSb@t*i)s

:2<= 78 2F#>?@+*,.-0/ km6~2?A-0B"

0pu…o*bBo*_6k4oyo*_}b$ija&kmžŸžšb@i¡oy¸}nJ|8um™šXoyum›So*_}™šiHum|8b(t€k4ojuXt™ši!o*_}bb(a&|Jorqi¡b(o@¯!³ÐoH™šio*_}b(t*b›uXtjbl}6™Ÿ:ojb@tjbYiro*™Ÿ6Ž

™š#oj_}™ i(kXi¡bX¯

Ä •) “˜‘[L ” O Ê[• É}Æ “ Ä • “4‘[L8ÄDC O •m’)LÉO ‘ «e¬ ­ b(Sk…Š}žšb@i®oju¼~Jb¸66bœt*b@l6t*ij™Ÿ—Xbœk…S~umxWt*b@(l}t*ij™š—mb

›l66‰o*™ŸuX6i±™Ÿoj_#oj_}bFE;,G#H ;32>9um|8b(t€k4ojuXtk…6~Noj_}b E;,G&H ;32>9um|8b(t€k4o*umtY¯ .6umtb(nJkma&|}žŸbX£

E;8G#H ;32D9 P5F:65JI P H2BA79>C;GF?9K HS2BAQ9 HNM

ABFQ=5F P #L

O ; P MNM

PO7

2F3G PRQ M

O

HBP 6F3G

O

P5F:65 PRQ#Q

=Q254

~}b¸6}bYik›l}6‰o*™ŸuX=±_}™ €_#@k…ž l}ž k4o*b@i¢oj_6bi¡l}aÂu…›!oj_}bV—4k…žšl}bYiu…›!k&žš™ iroY¯

½Dumt*b-›umt*a-k…žšžŸqX£ o*_}™ i›lS‰oj™šum ™šioj_}b´ija&kmžŸžšb@i¡o¸6nQ|8um™š:oum›oj_}b2?

P5F:65

a&um6u…ojuX}umlSi¼›l}6oj™šum um›

›l6Xo*™ŸuX6i)s

?

P5F365TS

VUXWY/Z[U\W >NU\WJ/Z

] ^U\W _ O

;QP ^UXW `

2EF7'( ^UXW ba ] >

«e¬!­ k…ž i¡u»b(6kmŠ}žŸbYi¿o*uº~}b¸6}b t*b@(l}t*ij™š—mb=›l}S‰oj™šumSiuX0(u…xЙŸ6~}l6‰o*™Ÿ—Xb†ijbo*i@¯ÂÀQl6€_ ›l}6oj™šum6i

™ša&|}žšb(a&b(:o*i\o*_}b&žškQ(q=b(—4kmžŸl6k…oj™šumD|6tj™š6™š|}žšbm¯^_Ql6i@£Çoj_6bt*b@ijl}žŸoeum›Bijl6€_†kN›l}6oj™šum k…|}|}žš™šb@~=o*u#k

(u…xЙŸS~Jl6‰o*™Ÿ—Xb¼umŠJvrbY‰o™ši(uma&|}lJo*b@~#um6žŸqN~}l}tj™š}Ž-k…´b(nQ|6žŸ™ ™Ÿo$(k…žšž+u…›!oj_6™ši›l66‰o*™ŸuX®¯.}uXt™Ÿ6i¡o*km6bs

(10)

E;,G#H

;32>935A H H O

2BAQ9 2BAQ9Q7 25A795JQ9#4>=DA,5 ?25A79>J79&45=GA85IH M

I H25A79 25A79KIEH 2BAQ9>JQ9745=7A,5XK

A5FQ=BF E

&L

O 8

2F3G\Q M

O 8

2F O

GQ

O

5AH

\Q7Q

=Q254

km|}|}žš™ŸbYio*_}b

›l}6oj™šum=o*uNb@kX€_=b(žšb(a&b(:opum›œk¿i¡ojt*b@k…a´¯$z(k…žšž oju-o*_}™šip›l}6oj™šumDuXDkNi¡ojt*b@kma ·£

™šJ¸66™¹o*bŠQq#~Jb(¸6}™Ÿoj™šum®£8(km}}u…op@k…l6ijbV™Ÿo*i$b@—4k…žšl6k4o*™ŸuX›uXt$b(—Xb(t*q¿b(žšb(a&b@Xo€i$um›1·¯¢³{=t*bojl6tj®£(km

Š8bVk…|}|6žŸ™šb@~¿ojuoj_}be¸6t€iro—4k…žšl}b@i¢um›' ™Ÿ›o*_}b@ijb¼—˜kmžŸl6b@ik…t*bpb(nQ|6žŸ™ ™Ÿo@¯H^_}b@®£Jt*b@l6t*ij™Ÿ—Xbp(kmžŸž i¢al6i¡oŠSb

"q) 4£Q™W¯bX¯ o*_}b

«e¬!­

™š:ojb@tj|}t*bo*b(tHal6i¡oœŠSbek…Š}žšbo*uV¸66~&o*_}b$¸St*i¡oœ—4k…žšl}b$um›+oj_}beiro*tjbYk…a´£…o*u±_}™ €_

™Ÿo$±™šžŸžkm|}|}žšq-oj_6b¼›l}6‰o*™ŸuX®£}™š=k¸S}™¹o*b¼oj™ša&bm¯

^_6bD5A H†›l}6oj™šum·~Jb(¸6}b@~·™Ÿ o*_}™šibn}k…a&|}žšb¿™ iVo*_}b¿ž k…t*Žmb@i¡oV¸}nJ|8um™šXou…›oj_}bZ?

5AH

a&um}umojuX}uml6i

›l66‰o*™ŸuX#um››l}:o*™ŸuX6is

?

5A H S >/ ^UWJ/Z29+ ^U\WJ9+ [U\W / ^U\WY/Z29+ ^UXWJ9+

] ^U\W

8

2F#>()

^UW8

2F7 \ ]

\ (

.O Ê •m’)L ” O Ê • É6Æ LO Ê •m’)L K “ Ä ÊfL2•m”J’ Ä ‘ †bD@k…ºbnJ|}t*b@i*i&™Ÿ «e¬!­ oj_6bDi¡a-k…žšžšb@i¡o-ijbo¿um›

b@žŸb@a&b(:o*iN—mb(t*™Ÿ›q:™š}Ž·k t*b(ž k4o*™ŸuX ~Jb¸66b@~ ŠQq¶k·i¡b(oNu…›k…nQ™šuma-i@¯B.}umt¿oj_6k…o|}l}t*|8uXijbm£±¢b=l6i¡b[oj_}b

13254768:9;:<5=um|8b(t€k4o*umtY¯E.}umtebn}kma|6žŸbX£6o*_}b›uXžŸžšu4±™Ÿ6Ž#|}t*b@~J™ (k…ojb~Jb(}umojbYioj_6bija&kmžŸžšb@i¡oeijbo

um› žš™ši¡o*i$u…› Sk4ojl6t*kmž+:l6aŠ8b(t€i¢oj_6k…opum:o€k…™š6ik&Žm™š—mb(:s

cX¯ 1-Z 7 2F# ()

l}¯ -Z/%1-2

>)

2F7(

^_6b «e¬!­ ij|SbY™Ÿ¸S(k…oj™šum#u…› oj_}™ i|}t*b@~J™ (k…ojb¼™ ioj_}b¼›uXžŸžšu4±™š}Žqs

132>4768?9;3<5=5=,5YI2H 2BA79KRH 2BA79DCE;GF?9 ! 74 H HNM

5=,5#"%$B=DAG4H O P H2BAQ9>CE;GF?9\Q O 5=,5 2 O 2F*2 PRQ7Q

5=,5#" 95A;QP H O5,H2BAQ9Q O P H2BA79>CE;7F:9Q O 5=85 2 PRQ7 O5=,5$2 O 2EF5 PRQ7Q'

‡\´o*_}bumoj_}b@t\ij™š~JbX£6o*_}b 132>4768?9;3<5=uXa&a&km6~´b(Sk…Š}žšb@i$oju¿b(nQ|6tjbYijio*_}bž k…t*ŽmbYiropijbo\u…›yb(žšbx

a&b@Xo€i+—mb@tj™Ÿ›qQ™Ÿ6Žkt*b(ž k4o*™ŸuXV~Jb¸66b@~eŠQq\kijboum›Qk…nQ™šuma-i@¯H.}uXt+bn}k…a&|}žšbm£@oj_6by›umžšžŸu4±™š}Ž'&)(+*'-,/.102.3%4,/

|6tjbY~J™š@k4o*b~Jb(}umojbYioj_6bž k…t*Žmb@i¡opijbopum›H6k4o*l}t*kmži¡ojt*b@k…a-io*_6k4oe_6k˜—mb¼o*_}bi*k…a&bV—4k…žšl}bYi$™š=oj_}bijkma&b

uXt*~}b(t[s

cX¯%-2/ 65 - 9++879&)(+*'-,/.102.3%4,/<> 95D

&)(+*'-,/.102.3%,/ 2F# ( 2F7 95D

^_6b

«e¬!­

ij|SbY™Ÿ¸S(k…oj™šum#u…› oj_}™ i|}t*b@~J™ (k…ojb¼™ ioj_}b¼›uXžŸžšu4±™š}Žqs

13254768:9;:<5=;:=<" 2BAQ95J79745=GA,5 H 2BA795JQ9745=DA,5 2BA79>J79#45=7A,5 ! #4 H HNM

=/<Q2BA79EF?9#45=DA,5,H O2 H25A79Q O9>?1@ H2BAQ9>J7974D=DA85Q

O :+<" 2BA79>J79745=DA85 >A@ Q7 O :=<" 25A795J7974>=GA,5 O 8 2F 2 > Q O 8 2F*2 @ Q7Q1

½=uXtjb&ŽXb(}b@t*kmžŸžšqm£(u…xЙŸS~Jl6‰o*™Ÿ—Xb&|}tjbY~J™ (k4o*b@i¼b@6k…Š}žšboju=b(nQ|6tjbYiji¼|}t*um|8b(tjoj™šb@i¼um› \ Nu4—mb@t

i¡ojt*b@kma-i(£Q±_}b@tjbYkmi™š6~Jl6oj™š—mb¼|}t*b@~J™ (k…ojb@ib@6k…Š6žŸbeoju-b(nJ|}tjbYiji¢|}t*um|8b(tjoj™šb@i¢um›C t t‰¯

(11)

2 ,"& #\< /,+,-9;=<?>d5w7E<)&dG 7f;=<i7f;=<)&0/ & w<)/

sœtjuQu…›iBu…› |}tjuXŽmt€k…a|}tjuX|Sb@t¡o*™ŸbYiœ™š «e¬!­ k…t*bpŠ}l}™šžŸouXNkijbou…›!k4nJ™ŸuXa-iyoj_Sk4o~Jb(}umojbYiHo*_}bVi¡b@a&km:oj™ 

um›oj_}bž k…6Žml6kmŽmb¼±™¹o*_D±_}™ €_#oj_}b|}tjuXŽmt€k…a ™ i±t*™¹ojojb@®¯^_:lSi(£S™ŸDuXt*~}b(tojuN_6k˜—mbVb_-(™Ÿb@:op|}t*u:um›i(£

o*_}™ i\ijb(a-k…:o*™šV_Skmipoju¿Š8b±¢b(žšž ijl}™ŸojbY~=oju «e¬ ­ ¯,µbl6ijb›uXt¤Ç¥¦§+¨ ©¿k¿—4kmtj™ k…:o$u…›yo*_}b&i¡b@a&km:oj™ 

um›o*t*kXb@i Qšc TW£6(uma&|}žšbo*b(žšqN~Jb@i*t*™šŠSbY~N™š QŸc4„)TW£6™Ÿ´±_}™ €_#k&ij™ŸŽX6k…ž+™ ik-umxW™š6~JlS‰oj™š—mbeumŠ}vrb@‰oY¯

³{}›umt*a&kmžŸžšqm£œ™Ÿ»oj_}b=ijb(a-k…:o*™šu…›$o*t*kXbYi(£œij™šŽm6kmžšik…t*bt*b(|6tjbYi¡b@Xo*b@~ ŠQq·k†Ql}a&b(t*™š@k…ži¡b:l}b(6(bum›

—4kmžŸl}bYi$k…S~ijq:aŠSuXžšip~Jb(}umoj™š}Ž&oj_6bk…Š6ijb(SbVu…›—4k…žšl}bm¯^_}b@®£Sk#¤8¥¦ §+¨©-|}tjuJ(b@i*i™ši\~Jb¸66b@~=kmi

k´ijboum›ijl6€_ i¡bXl6b(6(b@i¼™šµt*b@ij|8b@‰oVum›ijuma&b-uX6iro*t*km™Ÿ:o€i(¯&³{µoj_}b¿(u…xЙŸS~Jl6‰o*™Ÿ—Xb&—˜kmtj™ k…:oVu…›¢oj_6™ši

ijb(a-kmXo*™šm£Sk-ij™ŸŽX6k…ž ™ši\k-umxW™š6~Jl6oj™š—mbijbo\u…›y—4k…žšl}b@i$km6~´u…›ijq:aŠSuXžšip~Jb(}umoj™š}Ž-o*_}bkmŠ6i¡b@6bVum›

—4kmžŸl}bX¯y^_}b

«e¬ ­

i¡|8b@(™¹¸S@k4o*™ŸuXum›!ijl6€_uXŠJvrb@o*i™ ioj_6b¼›umžšžŸu4±™š}Žqs

132>4768?9;3<5= J5ADP 6B= I HNJD=79KRHKJD=79LHNM

A! FQ= 2>9 H O

J5A>P?6B=" Q

H45=BF =Q2>9IH#

O

J!5A>P 6B=$ Q1

% = L ;32 ;:9E; 2$J;

2BA>P HNM I H JD=79K O J79745=GA,5 O J5A>P 65=" Q7Q1

^_6b A! FQ= 2>9umSiro*tjl6ojuXt¢~Jb@}u…o*b@iœoj_}bVkmŠ6i¡b@6b\u…›—4kmžŸl}b&¯^_}b\|Sk…t€k…a&bo*b(t'~Jb@}u…o*b@iœoj_}b`)(

um›oj_}bij™šŽm6kmž2¯ _}b@=oj_}™ ipij™šŽm6kmž®_6kmi\k-—4k…žšl}b&*#k4opuX}ba&uma&b(:oY£6™Ÿo\™ ip~Jb@}u…o*b@~´ŠQq2H745=BFQ=Q2D9 +*7¯

^_6b(u…xЙŸS~Jl6‰o*™Ÿ—XbHorqQ|8b O J79745=GA,5,Q$~Jb@}u…o*b@ik¼iro*tjbYk…au…›.- —4kmžŸl}bYik…6~™¹oy™ iy~Jb¸S}b@~™Ÿ&i¡o*k…S~}k…t€~

«e¬!­ žš™ŸŠ}t€k…t*™šb@i@¯

^_}™ ie—4k…t*™škmXoe™šiebXl6™Ÿ—4k…žšb(:oeojuoj_}bumt*™šŽm™š6k…ži¡b@a-k…:oj™ km6~D_6kXi¼k…[™ša&|SuXt¡o€k…:oekX~J—4k…:o*kmŽmbs$™¹o

b@6k…Š6žŸbYi¢oju-~J™ i¡t*b(Ž:k…t€~-ojb@a&|SuXt*kmž+™Ÿ6~}bnN±_}™ €_´™šib(nJ|}žŸ™ ™Ÿo$™š#Ql}a&b@tj™ (kmž®i¡bXl6b(6(b@i@¯

µb@k…´}u4± Žm™š—mbeoj_}bi¡b(o$u…›Hk4nJ™šuma-i¢oj_6k…o\umxW™š6~JlS‰oj™š—mb@žŸqNauJ~Jb@žšip™Ÿ «e¬!­ o*_}bum|8b(t€k4o*umt€i¢u…›oj_}b

¤Ç¥¦§+¨ ©¾mb(t*}b@ž+žškm}Žml6kmŽmbs

/

³{6i¡o*k…:o€k…}b@uml6it*b(ž k4o*™ŸuX6is

13254Q68?9;:<>="05=>P7A79; 221 I ? ?43 H JD=Q95 H ! 3 ! #4 HK H

O

JB;

2BA>P6 Q7

O

JB;

2BA>P$Q7

O

J;

25A>P

3

Q#! 74

HIHNM

45=DPGA79;

271="GA H O9>

H O J;

2BADP8 Q7Q O9@

H O JB;

2BA>P8Q7Q O:9

H O JB;

2BA>P

3

Q7Q

O

05=>P7A79;

221

>A@,9

Q7

O 05=>P7A79; 221 O( 2F O A; FQ=Q2>9< Q > Q

O( 2F O A; FQ=Q2>9=\Q @ Q

O( 2F O A; FQ=Q2>9 3 Q 9 Q#Q

45=DPGA79; 271=" H H O9> H O J;

2BADP8 Q7Q O9@ H O JB;

2BA>P8Q7Q O:9 H O JB;

2BA>P 3 Q7Q

O6 H) Q O <H\Q O> H 3 Q

O 6 < > Q7 O 05=>PGAQ9; 271 >@,9 Q7

O 05=>P7A79; 221 O( 2F O H745=BFQ=Q2D9 6 Q > Q

O( 2F O H745=BFQ=Q2D9 <Q @ Q

O( 2F O H745=BFQ=Q2D9 > Q 9 Q7Q1

/

$pb(ojb@tja&™š}™ši¡oj™ ¼a&b(t*Žmb 4>= L AQ6PQ9 s

(12)

E;,G&H

;32>9 4>=

L A 6PQ9IH O ?

HNJD=79Q

O

J;

2BADP Q7

O

JB;

2BA>P$Q7

O

J;

25A>P8

Q HNM

I

?

HJD=Q9KI

> H O

J;

2BADP Q6KI

@ H O

J;

2BA>P8Q6K

ABF =BF

> @ #L

O

2EF

O

H45=BFQ= 2>9 6 Q

>

Q

O

2F "

@

Q@M

O( 2F OH4>=BFQ=Q2>9 O ;32P 6 Q#Q O 4D= L AQ6P 9 >@ Q7Q

O 2EF A; FQ=Q2>9 > Q O 2F O H745=BFQ=Q2D9 <Q @ Q M

O( 2F OH4>=BFQ=Q2>9 O ;324 <Q#Q O 4D= L AQ6P 9 >@ Q7Q

O 2EF A; FQ=Q2>9 > Q O 2F A! EFQ=Q2>9 @ Q M

O( 2F O A! FQ=Q2D9<

Q O 4>= L AQ6PQ9 > @ Q7Q

=Q2>4

/

$pu4±}xÐi*k…a&|}žš™Ÿ6Ž > $B=Q2!s

E;,G&H ;32>9 > $B=Q2 H O H JG=79Q O JB;

2BA>P Q7 O J;

2BA>P$ 7 PRQ7 O J;

2BA>P Q HNM

I H JD=79KI> H O JB;

2BAGP Q6KI@ H O J;

25A>P$ # PRQ6K A5FQ=BF >A@=#L

O 2EF G > Q O7 2F O H45=5FQ=Q2>9 9#4G6B=XQ @ Q M O7 2F G O4> $B=Q2 > @ Q#Q

O

2EF "

>

Q

O7

2F "

@

Q@M O(

2F

O

A; FQ=Q2>9< Q O>

$B=Q2

> @

Q7Q

=Q2>4

/

$pb@žšk˜qNum|8b(t€k4ojuXt s

E;,G&H ;32>9 H45=IH O H JD=79\Q O J;

2>A>P Q7 O J;

2BADP8 Q HNM

I H JD=79KI6 H)RKI> H O J;

25ADP Q6K ABFQ=5F >=#L

O 2EF A; FQ=Q2>9 > Q@M O( 2F O A; FQ=Q2>9< Q O H745= 6 > Q7Q

O 2EF O H45=BFQ= 2>9 <Q > Q@M O 2EF O H45=BF =Q2>9 6 Q O H4>= < > Q#Q

=Q2>4

¤8¥¦ §+¨©¿b:l6k…oj™šum6i$kmtjb6k4o*l}t*kmžŸžšq¿o*t*km6i*t*™Ÿ|Jo*b@~#™š «e¬ ­ ±™¹o*_´oj_}™ ip›umt*a&kmžŸ™@k…oj™šum´u…›o*_}bž k…Jx

ŽXl6k…ŽXbm¯

"†( 0 !E" # %

Á¢bY(k…lSi¡b-um›¢o*_}b¿°SbnJ™ŸŠ6™Ÿžš™¹orqµ±™Ÿoj_·±_}™ €_ oj_6bNumt*™šŽm™š6k…žœij|8b@™Ÿ¸S@k4oj™šum um›oj_}b#iro*b@k…a Š8um™šžŸb@t(km ŠSb

™š:ojb@tj|}t*bo*b@~ QƒTУ+±¢b¸6t€i¡oe}b@b@~Doju#a&km¾mbi¡uXab~Jbo€k…™šžšiea&umt*b|}tjbY™ i¡bum[oj_}b|}_QqJi¡™ (kmž Š8b(_6k˜—Q™šuml}t

um›œo*_}b¿iro*b@kma ŠSuX™Ÿžšb(tk…6~[oj_}b-žšumŽX™š@k…žŠ8b(_6k˜—Q™šuml}t¼u…›™Ÿo™Ÿa&|}žšb(a&b(:o€k4oj™šumµ™š»¤Ç¥¦§+¨ ©µ¯¿^_}b(®£ ±Bb

|6tjbYi¡b@XouXl}t|}tjuX|Su:ijkmžÇ™Ÿ=~Jb(o*k…™šž i$k…6~Noj_6bV|}tjuX|Sb@t¡o*™ŸbYi¢oj_6k…o$(k…´Š8bV€_}b@€¾Xb@~±™¹o*_

«e¬!­

¯

231 3.*=5H9i<D <)&0/ D'&/ ;2! 5 &8*<d< /E7 ( D5H9i<97 ;=<&0/

^_6uXijbN|}t*b@(™šij™ŸuX6iumSb(t* o*_}bŠ8b(_Sk˜—:™šuml6tum›$oj_}b´|}_QqJij™š@k…ž¢l}}™Ÿo*i@£yoj_}b=(um6i¡oj™ŸojlJo*™ŸuX um›$oj_}b#bnQx

€_Sk…}ŽXb@~´a&b@i*ijkmŽmbYi$k…6~=oj_}btjbYkm‰o*™ŸuX´oj_}b@q=™Ÿa&|}žšqm£8o*_}b›km™Ÿžšl}t*b~Jb(ojb@oj™šum®£+km6~´oj_6ba-k…6kmŽmb@ab@:o

um›o*_}bV—Q™šij™ŸuXum› o*_}b~JqQ6kma™ eu…›!oj_}bVijqJiro*b(a X¸6Ž6¯+cX£}|YS ]‰¯

(13)

L2‘(’[L

O

•…’)L

ÉO

 Ä ’

ÈÄQÄoO

K

C

”=L%( “

Ä

‘&”

O

Ê6K K •

ÉO

’@“

É

((

Ä

“˜‘

C

”=L%( “

Ä ‘

z |6l}a&|´(um:ojt*umžšžšb(t¢ojb@žŸž ioj_6bV|}tjuXŽmt€k…a ™Ÿ›!™Ÿo*i$kXijijuJ™ k4o*b@~|}l}a&|´™ši|8uml}t*™š}Ž&±¢k…ojb(t™š:ojuoj_6bVŠSuX™Ÿžšb(t

uXty}u…oY¯!^_6b(®£X™¹oœa-k˜qb@6k…Š6žŸbo*u€_}b@€¾Vo*_}bt*b@k…ž}i¡o*k…ojbum›Çk¼|}l6a|¯ .6umtyb(nJkma&|}žŸbX£m±_}b@oj_}b$i¡o*k…ojl6i

um›k#|}l6a| ™ i ¬ §»km6~†±_}b(µoj_6™ši|}l}a&|µojb(žšž iV™¹oY£o*_}b¿uX:ojt*umžšžŸb@te_SkmieojuD(umJ¸Stja ™Ÿo@£ ojb@žŸžš™š}Ž´oj_}b

|6tjuXŽmt€k…a ™Ÿ›!o*_}™ i$|}l}a&|=t*b@kmžŸžšqN|}t*u4—Q™š~}b@i±k4ojb@t$k4o$o*_}™ i$a&uma&b(:oY¯BÁ¢lJo$o*_}buX:ojt*umžšžŸb@t$(k…=kmžšiju-ŠSb

~}b›b@oj™š—mbX¯!^_Ql6i@£X™Ÿoœ™ iy™ša|8uXi*ij™ŸŠ}žšbo*u~J™ši¡oj™š}ŽXl}™šij_®£:um}žšq±™Ÿoj_&o*_}uXijbp~}k…o*k6£…oj_6bor±Bu¼›uXžŸžšu4±™š}ŽV(kmijb@i

›uXt™ŸSiro€k…6(b$s

|}l}a&| (um:ojt*umžšžŸb@t i¡o*k…ojl6i iro€k4o*be|6tju4—Q™ ~Jb@~ iro€k4ojb¼|}t*u4—Q™š~}b@~ t*b@k…ž

›k…™šžŸl}t*b ›k…™šžŸl6tjb ŠQq¿oj_6be|6l}a&| ŠQq¿o*_}buXXo*tjuXžŸžšb(t iro€k4o*b

@kmijbc qXb@i }u ¬ ¬ ¬ § ¬ §

@kmijbl }u qXb@i ¬ ¬ ¬ § ¬

½=uXtjb@u4—mb@t@£Xoj_}bij|8b@™Ÿ¸S@k4oj™šumnQƒT~JuQb@i$}u…o$i¡o*k4o*b¼|}tjbY™ i¡b@žŸqN±_6k4o9 ¼um››k…™šžšl}tjbVk&|}l6a|´uXtk

(um:ojt*umžšžšb(tpa-k˜q´_6k˜—Xbm¯V³{Do*_}b&i¡|8b@(™¹¸S@k4o*™ŸuX®£®kN|6l}a&|[umt¼k#um:o*tjuXžŸžšb(t\™ši¼~Jb(›b@‰o*™Ÿ—Xb™Ÿ›B™Ÿo*i¼i¡o*k…ojb™ši

™š6(um6ij™ši¡ojb@:oœ±™¹o*_N™Ÿo*i¢iro€k4o*l6i(£Qk…S~¿k|}l6a|N™ši¢k…ž i¡u~Jb›bY‰oj™š—mb\™¹›®™Ÿo|}tju4—Q™ ~Jb@iœkV›k…ž ijbpiro€k4o*bm¯y^_Ql6i(£:™Ÿ›

o*_}b|6l}a&|†k…S~´™¹o€ie(um:ojt*umžšžšb(t$|}t*u4—Q™š~}bk-›k…ž ijbiro€k4o*bŠ}lJoVuX6ij™ši¡ojb@Xo\±™¹o*_=oj_}b|}l}a&|[i¡o*k…ojl6i@£8oj_}b

|6tjuXŽmt€k…a@k…}6u…o¢~}bojbY‰oBoj_}b\›k…™šžŸl6tjbX¯ .6umt¢bn}k…a&|}žšbm£Xoj_}b\›umžšžšu4±™Ÿ}Ž(kmijb@iBk…t*b$}umo¢~J™ iro*™Ÿ6Žml}™ i¡_Sk…Š}žšb$s

|}l}a&| (um:ojt*umžšžŸb@t i¡o*k…ojl6i iro€k4o*be|6tju4—Q™ ~Jb@~ iro€k4ojb¼|}t*u4—Q™š~}b@~ t*b@k…ž

›k…™šžŸl}t*b ›k…™šžŸl6tjb ŠQq¿oj_6be|6l}a&| ŠQq¿o*_}buXXo*tjuXžŸžšb(t iro€k4o*b

@kmijbc qXb@i qXb@i

¬ ¬ ¬ ¬ §

@kmijbl qXb@i }u ¬ ¬ ¬ ¬

Á¢b@@k…l6ijbeu…›o*_}b@ijb¼k…aŠ6™ŸŽXl}™¹o*™ŸbYi(£:o*_}bVi¡|8b@(™¹¸S@k4o*™ŸuX#i¡o*k…ojb@i¢a&umt*be|}tjbY™ i¡b@žŸqo*_6k4o™šuXt*~Jb@t¢oju&~Jbx

o*b@o\k¿uX:ojt*umžšžŸb@t›k…™šžŸl}t*bm£6oj_}b|}t*umŽmt€k…aÂ_6kmio*u¿¾Q}u4±- ut f& o*_6k4op™Ÿo*iekmi*ijuQ(™šk…ojbY~N|}l6a|

±¢umt*¾Jip(umt*tjbY‰ojžšqm¯e³{ i¡l6€_†umS~J™¹o*™ŸuX6i@£8™Ÿ›œo*_}b&um:o*tjuXžŸžšb(t\|}tju4—Q™ ~Jb@iekNi¡o*k…ojb±_}™ €_[™ ip™š6uX6ij™ši¡ojb@Xo

±™Ÿoj_#o*_}biro€k4o*be|6tju4—Q™ ~Jb@~ŠQq-oj_}bV|6l}a&|®£Joj_6bum:o*tjuXžŸžšb(t™ iumŠQ—Q™ŸuXl6i¡žšq¿~Jb(›b@‰o*™Ÿ—Xbm¯

Á¢lJo$_}u4± uXl}žš~±¢beŠ8bijl}tjbeo*_6k4o$k|}l}a&|´±BuXtj¾JiuXtjt*b@ojžšqm£Q™W¯bX¯y_}u4±0(uml}ž ~N±¢b¼¾Q}u4± b(nJkX‰o*žŸq

o*_}bn i¡o*k…ojbu…›pk†|}l}a&|Rµb#@k…}}umoijl}|}|8uXijb¿o*_6k4o-uXXo*tjuXžŸžšb(t€ikmtjb™ŸJ›kmžŸžš™šŠ}žŸb#Š8b@(kml6ijb¿oj_6™ši

_QqQ|8u…oj_6b@ij™šiB™šiœojuQutjbYiro*tj™ ™š—mb$±™Ÿoj_tjb@ŽXkmt*~ojuoj_6bpumt*™šŽm™š6k…ž8i¡|8b@(™¹¸S@k4o*™ŸuX®¯y^_}b(®£Q™š¿umt€~Jb@tœo*u¾Q}u4±

o*_}bt*b@k…žSiro€k4ojbum›Çk¼|6l}a&|±™Ÿoj_6umlJoB(um:ojt*umžšžšb(t€i ™šJ›uXtja-k4o*™ŸuX®£m±¢bal6i¡oœŠ8b$k…Š}žšboju~}bojbY‰oœ|6tjbY™ i¡b@žŸq

±_6™š€_#|}l}a&|6i|6tju4—Q™ ~Jb@~±¢k…ojb@tk…o$b@kX€_qJ(žŸbkX(uXt*~}™Ÿ}Žoju&o*_}bVžŸb@—mb@ž®€_6k…}ŽXb@i@¯

µb=¸6t€iro#umSi¡™ ~Jb(t¿k·auXtjb=ij™Ÿa&|}žšb[ijqJiro*b(a ™š ±_}™ €_ um}žšq uX}b=|}l}a&|²™ i-™šQ—mumžš—mbY~+¯0^_6b(®£

ijl}|}|8uXijbeoj_6k…ooj_}b¼›uXžŸžšu4±™š}Ž(um6~}™¹o*™ŸuX6i_}umž ~´k4o™š6iro€k…:o .'s

/

oj_}bi¡ojbYk…a abYkmijl}t*b(a&b(:o~Jb(—Q™ b¼±BuXtj¾JiuXtjt*b@ojžšq¿k…6~#|}t*u4—Q™š~}b@i *˜¯

/

oj_}bV±k4o*b(tžšb(—Xb(ž+a&b@kXi¡l}t*b(a&b@Xo~Jb@—:™ bV±¢umt*¾Jiumt*t*b@‰o*žŸq¿km6~|}tju4—Q™ ~Jb@i(˜¯

/

oj_}bV|6l}a&| Xu…›y(km|6km(™¹orq ]œo*b(žšžšio*_6k4o$™Ÿo*ipiro€k4ojb¼™ i ¬ §¯

/

oj_}bi¡o*k…ojl6i$u…›o*_}bV|}l}a&|´™ i ¬ §

(14)

µbV}u4± ~Jb¸66b\o*_}b¼›umžšžšu4±™Ÿ}Ž&—4k…t*™ k…Š}žšb@i)s

/

a&™Ÿ}™ša-k…žkX((b@i*i¡™šŠ}žšbežšb(—Xb(žÇ›uXtoj_}bV}b(nQo™š6i¡o*kmXo . ae™Ÿ›!oj_}bV|}l6a|=™ ii¡ojum|6|SbY~is(

7

/

a-k4nJ™Ÿa-kmž®km((b@i*i¡™šŠ}žšb¼žŸb@—mb(žÇ›uXtoj_}bV6bnQo™Ÿ6i¡o*km:o . aV™¹›!oj_6bV|}l}a&|´™šii¡ojuX|}|SbY~is(

7

/

a&™Ÿ}™ša-k…žkX((b@i*i¡™šŠ}žšbežšb(—Xb(žÇ›uXtoj_}bV}b(nQo™š6i¡o*kmXo . ae™Ÿ›!oj_}bV|}l6a|=|6tju4—Q™ ~Jb@i¢±k4ojb@t)s2(

7

/

a-k4nJ™Ÿa-kmž®km((b@i*i¡™šŠ}žšb¼žŸb@—mb(žÇ›uXtoj_}bV6bnQo™Ÿ6i¡o*km:o . aV™¹›!oj_6bV|}l}a&|´|}tju4—Q™ ~Jb@i¢±k4o*b(t[s2(

7

µbV_6k˜—Xbpo*_}b¼›umžšžŸu4±™š}Žtjb@žšk…oj™šum6i)s

(

7

( U * : .1U

' : . 7

(

7

( U * : . a ' 7 : . 7

(

7

( 7

a @: .

(

7

( 7 a @: .

³{»umt€~Jb(tVo*u[Š8bijl}t*b¿oj_Sk4oo*_}bNŠ8um™šžšb(t_6kmikmojl6kmžŸžšq†Š8b(b@ ijl}|}|}žš™ŸbY~·™š·±k4ojb@t@£!o*_}b¿›uXžŸžšu4±™Ÿ6Ž

(um6~}™¹o*™ŸuXal6iro$Š8bV—mb@tj™Ÿ¸6bY~is

( 7

6(

7 (

7 9(

7

Xrc[]

³{6~}b(b@~®£—4k…žšl}b@ieum›œoj_6™ši¼™š:ojb(t€ijb@‰o*™ŸuX[t*b(|}t*b@ijb(:o¼žŸb@—mb@žši¼km@bYijij™ŸŠ6žŸb±™¹o*_ umt¼±™¹o*_}uml}oVijl}|}|6žŸqDum›

±k4o*b(tY¯B^_Ql6i@£}o*_}™šieuX6i¡ojt€k…™šXo€ib(6kmŠ}žšbVoju-Š8bijl}t*b¼oj_6k…o$oj_}bi¡qJi¡ojb(a _6kXiŠSb@b(Dijl}|}|}žš™šb@~DkX‰ojlSk…žšžŸq

™š´±¢k…ojb@t¢™Ÿ›yk…6~#um6žŸq¿™Ÿ› s

( 7

(

7

@: . (

7 U (

7

Xl$]

@: . : .7 ' a<'

7 Xƒ]

7 : . )' a ' 7 X^S ]

µb6u4± ŽXb(}b@t*kmžŸ™(boj_}™ ipt*b(ž k4o*™ŸuX®£ÇumSi¡™ ~Jb(t*™š}ŽNkNijqJiro*b(a±™Ÿoj_ |}l6a|Si\±™Ÿoj_µ(km|6km(™¹o*™ŸbYi

o*u ¯

µb~Jb(¸6}b¼oj_6b\›uXžŸžšu4±™š}Ž›l}6‰o*™ŸuX6i)s

! "!#$

&%('('('(%*)+

S ,,,,,, - W /

. ^W _

™¹› .

` ™¹›}umo

Références

Documents relatifs

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST