Trellis Processes : a Compact Representation for Runs of Concurrent Systems

HAL Id: inria-00070452

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00070452

Submitted on 19 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Trellis Processes : a Compact Representation for Runs of Concurrent Systems

Eric Fabre

To cite this version:

Eric Fabre. Trellis Processes : a Compact Representation for Runs of Concurrent Systems. [Research Report] RR-5554, INRIA. 2005, pp.34. �inria-00070452�

ISSN 0249-6399 ISRN INRIA/RR--5554--FR+ENG

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Trellis Processes : a Compact Representation for Runs of Concurrent Systems

Eric Fabre

N˚5554

April 2005

Systèmes symboliques

)

*!#+% ,

)

(%+-%&/.101 234

5*687:9<; =?>68@

∗

ACBEDGFHJI<KLD(DBCI-MNPORQTSCU2KLD

V3W NYXZKJFD[\QTDGF W QRM]LNPI

^&_Y`a` N W FbaK W KL]dc2K W ]dc2K/e-fCghghgYikjml `aW QROonhphphg-jrqYi `_Ys KLD

tvuxwLy{zY|a}hyh~



e€FGc2K&F

W

U2K1]LNPe2]JU

WGW

KJe2]JBDKJI

_

eCFGQT]LD{

W

Uae2D'NY‚

_

]LNPe2]JU

WGW

KJeCF(DGBEDGFKJI

_YW K W K

`aW KLDdKJeCFKLb

_ D

`_YW FGQ

_

OƒN

W

baK

W

D'NY‚

KJ„…KJeCFD{†3‡N W K `2W KLDKJeCFDKJFD(NY‚DGU2]dc W Uae2D(QRe _ ]LNPI `_ ]JFI _ eae2K W 2F Wd_ bEQRFGQTNPe _ O _Y`a`aW N _ ]dc2KLD W KJORBNPeˆM Wd_ e]dcaQRe s

`aW NC]LKLDDKLD{†‡'cK‰I _‹Š QRI _ O?M Wd_ e2]dcaQRe s1`aW NC]LKLDDxNY‚ _ DGBEDGFKJIŒ‚ŽN W FGc2K `aW K8 ŠW KJO_ FGQTNPe PQTD‘CeN’*e _ DoFGc2K“UaeE‚”NPOTbEQRe s

NY‚FGc

_

F*DGBEDGFKJIŒ†•eE‚ŽNPOTbEQRe

s

D—–”NY‚

_

2e2Q˜FdK1]LNPI

`

OTKJFK

`aW K8

Š

NY‚FGc2KJI€™

_YW

K\U2DKLb€‚ŽN

W

I<NCbaKJO˜š›]dc2KL]d‘?QRe

s<`

U

WG`

NhDdKLD{

W K _ ]dc _ MaQRORQRFœB _ e _ ORB?DQTD{“DGB?DFKJII<NPeaQRFN W QRe s N W bEQ_Ys e2NhDQTD{“KJF]h†  e `_YW FGQT]JUaO_YW žFGc2KJBKJePXGNBŸeaQT]LK‚ _ ]JFN W QR  _ š

FGQTNPe `aW N ` K W FGQTKLD1FGc _ F _ OROTN’FGc2KbaKJ„¡KJOTN ` I<KJeCFNY‚“bEQTDGF W QRMaUaFKLb¢‹I<NCbEU2O_YW_ Os N W QRFGcaI<D{‚”N W I<N¡b2K8O]dc2KL]d‘?QRe s N W

bEQ

_Ys e2NhDGQTD{†

 evFGc2QRD']LNPI£I-UaeaQT] _ FGQTNhe E’žK `aW N ` NhDK _ e _ O˜FdK W e _ FK _ e2bDdNPI<KJc2N’¤QReCFK W I<KLbEQ_ FK W K `aW KLDKJeCF _ FGQTNPe‚ŽN W“W Uae2D

NY‚ž]LNPe2]JU WGW KJeCFDGB?DFKJI<D{’*c2K W K¥FGQRI<K¥QRD1UaeE‚ŽNPOTbaKLbƒƒMaUaF1e2NPFFGc2K¥]LNPeE¦2QT]JF W KJO_ FGQTNPe †  e§‚ŽK8’¨’žN W baD’žK _ M _ eEš

baNPe©FGc2K

W

KLSCUaQ

W

KJI<KJeCFFGc

_

F—e2Nˆe2NCbaK<NY‚

_ M Wd_

e2]dcaQRe

sk`aW

NC]LKLDdDMK£QReªDKJO˜‚«š›]LNPeE¦2QT]JF{

_

eb

_

OROTN’¬]LNPeE¦2U2KJe2]LKvNY‚

]LNPeE¦2QT]JFGQRe s caQTDGFN W QTKLD†$­ªK1NPMaF _ QReŒQReˆFGc _ F*’ _ B€F W KJORORQTD `aW N¡]LKLDdDKLD{ _ e2bFGc2K1FGQRI<K8š®UaeE‚ŽNPOTbEQRe s NY‚ _ DGBEDGFKJIŒ†‡'c2K

O_ FGFK WW K `aW KLDKJeCFDFGc2KD _ I<K]LNPeE s U Wd_ FGQTNPe¯DKJF _ D-FGc2Kv‚_ I£QRORQ_YW UaeE‚ŽNPOTbEQRe s ’*caQROTK€MKJQRe s I<N W K]LNPI `_ ]JF¥QRe

’*QTbEFGc †§°§N

W

KLN„…K

W

$F

W

K8ORORQTD

`aW NC]LKLDdDKLD

s

KJe2K

Wd_

ORQR {KFN§]LNPe2]JU

WGW

KJeCF£DB?DGFKJI<D-FGc2K€U2DGU

_

Ože2NPFGQTNPeNY‚F

W

KJORORQRD¥NY‚

_ e

_ UaFNPI _ FNPe 2’*caQT]dcŒ‚”N W I<D*FGc2K—DGU `2` N W FNY‚xI<NhDGFNPeEš®ORQRe2K—I<NPeaQRFN W QRe s_ Os N W QRFGcaI<D{†

‡'c W NPU s c _ DGUaQRF _ MaOTKv]LNYš W K8¦KL]JFGQTNPeNY‚*F W KJORORQTDe2KJFDQReªFGc2Kv] _ FK s N W B©NY‚(D _ ‚ŽK£e2KJFD{o’'K¥2e _ ORORB `aW N„¡K<FGc _ F

FGQRI<K8š®UaeE‚”NPOTbEQRe

s

DKJePXZNBFc2KkD

_

I<Kˆ‚

_

]JFN

W

QR 

_

FGQTNPe

`aW N ` K W

FGQTKLD

_

DvDF

_

e2b

_YW

b¯UaeE‚ŽNPOTbEQRe

s

D{'’*caQT]dcI

_

‘¡KLDvFGc2KLDK

I<N W K—]LNPI `_ ]JF&DGFW U2]JFGU W KLD ` NhDDQRMaOTK] _ e2bEQTb _ FKLD(‚ŽN W bEQTDGF W QRMaUaFKLbŒ„¡K W Q˜] _ FGQTNPe¢YbEQ_Ys e2N…DGQTD _ Os N W QRFGcaI<D{†

±ˆ²…³´µ¶ zY·w…~

]LNPe2]JU

WGW

KJeCFžDGB?DFKJIŒ

V

KJF

W

Q2e2KJF{…F

W

U2K(]LNPe2]JU

WGW

KJe2]JB<DKJI

_

eCFGQT]LD{…M

Wd_

e2]dcaQRe

s`aW

NC]LKLDDhUaeE‚ŽNPOTbEQRe

s 

KJ„…KJeCFDGF W U2]JFGU W Kh2F W KJORORQTD{2] _ FK s N W BFGc2KLN W B… `aW NCbEU2]JF{a‚_ ]JFN W QR  _ FGQTNPe

¸˜¹oºœ»®¼{½(ºž¾ ¿R»®À®ÁJÂ

ÃÄYÅÇƃÈÉËÊ®ÌÅÇÆoƎ͋ÎYÎhÉdʎϮÐGÑ&ÒLÓÔoÕxÔ2Ã΋ʮÉ֔ÐZ×ØÏxÙ{ڐÛՉÜ{ݘ͋ÞPыÐZÑ&ÒLÓ(ϮċÐߋʮÐZދכÄà\ÅáދÅÇƔώʎÓ\ÉdÝ2ÔoÐZƎÐGâʮלġã

∗ ä®åhæèçZéCê‹ä®ë…åhæìé

ÜYíLî{ïJð?ñ«òLóô{îLõJö{ïdîïJ÷Ëóañ«øLî

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes

IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex (France) Téléphone : 02 99 84 71 00 - International : +33 2 99 84 71 00

Télécopie : 02 99 84 71 71 - International : +33 2 99 84 71 71

2 G

+-% 20 234 (%x+%\

w ~ K*b ` ORQ_Ys K(bUae£DB?DGFHJI<K']LNPe2]JU WGW KJeCF W K `aW LDKJeCFK*baK“‚_ NPe£]LNPI `_ ]JFK'FNPUaFKLDOTKLDK Š L]JUaFGQTNPe2D3baK

]LK'DGBEDGFHJI<Kh† KLDb

`

ORQ

_Ys

KLD3DdNPeCF$O

_YWGs

KJI<KJeCFUaFQ˜ORQTDLD]LNPI£I<K*NPUaFGQRO2baKž„

W

Q˜]

_

FGQTNPe<baKžI<NCbaHJOTKh¡KJF{

W

L]LKJI£I<KJeCF{

]LNPI£I<K DGU `a` N W F ` NPU W baKLD _Y`a` ORQT] _ FGQTNPe2DŒbaK bEQ_Ys e2NhDGFGQT]h† N W DSCUUae,DGBEDGFHJI<K§]LNPe2]JU WGW KJeCFŒDdK§bL]LNPI ` NhDK

KJe `aW NCbEUaQRFDGB?e2]dc W NPe2K baKk]LNPI ` NhD _ eCFD ` ORU2D ` KJFGQRFD{*DNPe b ` ORQ _Ys K§DKˆ‚_ ]JFN W QTDK baKŒO_ IJI<KkI _ eaQTH W K§KJe

`aW

NCbEUaQRF&baKLDb

`

ORQ

_Ys

KLD&baK—]LKLD]LNPI

`

NhD

_

eCFdD{†žKJFGFK

`aW

N

`aW

QJF KLDF"!¥O

_ M _ DdK—baKLD

_ Os N W

QRFGcaI<KLDI<NCbEUaO

_ QW KLD\NPU

bEQTDGF W QRMaU#LD(baKbEQ_Ys e2NhDFGQT]h†%$\NPU2D*b#J] W QR„¡NPe2D(QT]JQƒUae2K _ UaF W K1‚ _ NPe  ` O˜UD(]JNPI `_ ]8FdKPbaK W K `aW LDKJe?FK W O&KJe2DKJI-MaOTK

baKLD¥K Š L]JUaFGQTNPe2D£bUae DGB?DFHJI<K€]LNPe2]JU WGW KJeCF{!kO&_ QTbaKbUae2KDGF W U2]JFGU W KSCU2K€O&NPe _Y`a` KJOROTKOTK'›F W KJQRORORQTD)(d† [ _ e2D

]LKJFGFK\DGF

W

U2]JFGU

W

Kh?OTK\DGBEDGFHJI<K\KLDGFžb

`

ORQ\OTK&OTNPe

s

baK&O&

_‹Š

K&FKJI

` N W KJO®EI

_

QTD

`_

D'b

_

e2DžO

_

bEQRI<KJe2DGQTNPeˆbaKLD']LNPeE¦2QRFD

–+*-,/.0,‰OTKLD(]dc2NPQŠ baKF Wd_ e2DGQRFGQTNPe2D&b _ e2D*UaekDGBEDGFHJI<K1e2NPekbJFK W I£QReaQTDGFK™8† ^\_Y`a` KJOTNPe2DS¡U2KOTKb ` ORQ_Ys Kb ` ORQTK—]LKLD

baKJU Š bEQRI<KJe2DQTNPe2D{3]LKS¡UaQ'baNPeae2KbaKLD¥DGF W U2]JFGU W KLDM Wd_ e]dc _ eCFKLD£baNPeCF¥O_ F _ QROROTK _ U s I<KJeCFK Wd_Y` QTbaKJI<KJeCF{†21&e

I<NPeCF

W

KSCU2K\OTKLD*F

W

KJQRORORQTD$XGNPUaQTDDKJeCF*baKLD*IJI<KLD

`aW

N

`aW QJF LD

_ Os JM

W

QTSCU2KLD(SCU2K\OTKLD(b

`

ORQ

_Ys

KLD{2KJF*e2NPF

_

I£I<KJeCFbaKLD

IJI<KLD `aW N `aW QJF LD\baK—‚ _ ]JFN W QTD _ FGQTNPe †3žKJO_ KJek‚_ QRF&baKLD\] _ e2bEQTb _ FD&F W HLD&QReCF W KLDD _ eCFD ` NPU W O_ DU ` K W „CQTDGQTNPe§KJe

ORQs e2Kv–”KJFbEQTDGF W QRMaU#LK™*baKDGBEDGFHJI<KLD(]LNPe2]JU WGW KJeCFD&bEQTDGF W QRMaU#LD†

4#¶ y{w ´ }5 ~ DGBEDGFHJI<KŒ]LNPe2]JU WW KJeCF{ W LDK _ U¤baK V KJF W Q®*DJI _ eCFGQTS¡U2K baK ]LNPe2]JU WGW KJe2]LK „ Wd_ QTKh `aW NC]LKLDdDGU2D€baK

M Wd_ e2]dc2KJI<KJeCF{b ` ORQ_Ys KhDGF W U2]JFGU W K—b6J„Je2KJI<KJeCFD{2F W KJQRORORQTD{aFGc#LN W QTKbaKLD(] _ F s N W QTKLD{ `aW NCbEUaQRF{a‚ _ ]JFN W QTD _ FGQTNPe

(%&%&

y{z ¶ · }hy¶

² y{wv|

·

¶ 5:·

w

nE† _

FK

s N W

BˆNY‚xe2KJFD †—†—††—†—††—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—† g

nE†Çn 1\]L]JU WGW KJe2]LK—e2KJFD _ e2bˆUaeE‚”NPOTbEQRe s D/†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—†

nE†Çq ^ KJO_ FGQTNPe2D(MKJFœ’žKLKJekFGc2KFœ’žN<] _ FK s N W QTKLD,†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—†

nE†i °kUaORFGQ˜š›]JOTNC]d‘e2KJFD—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—† {p

! " z ² 55#:w ² y{w

$

qE† [1K82eaQRFGQTNPe †—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—† {n

qE†Çn ‡ W KJORORQTD `aW NC]LKLDDKLD _ e2bˆFGQRI<KUaeE‚”NPOTbEQRe s D †—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—† {g

qE†Çq žNYš W K8¦KL]JFGQTNPe§NY‚

T r ^QReCFN N ets ††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—††—†—†† &%

² 5:|Ey¶ w<u ² y µ-²C² ' ² y{w)($y{z ² 5 5#«w ² w<| · ¶ 5:·* w ,+

i2† žNYš W K8¦KL]JFGQTNPe§NY‚

Occ ^QReCFN T r †—††—†—††—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†† nhp

i2†Çn žNPI ` NhDGQRFGQTNPe NY‚ _ bYXØUae2]JFGQTNPe2D †—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—† nhp

t.-- 5#:}…|Ey¶ y ¶ 5«|au ² 5² · ² y{w

/

gE† _ FK s N W QTKLD&NY‚xO _ MKJOTKLbŒe2KJFD ††—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—† nhn

gE†Çn 0 _ ]JFN

W

QR 

_

FGQTNPekQRekKJOTKJI<KJeCF

_YW BF

W

KJORORQTDKLD†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—† nhq

gE†Çq 1&FGc2K W(`aW N ` K W FGQTKLD&NY‚$F W KJORORQTDKLD †—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—† nhq

1 2

|az3:|Ey

¶ w<|az

¶

·¯y4

² 4 ² 4y

}hy

¶

5 † l#] _ U2D _ O I<NPe2NPFNPeaQT]—‚:Uae2]JFGQTNPe †—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—† nhg

5

†Çn [\Q76K W KJeCF(I<K WGs K W UaOTKLD*QReŒFGc2K—DKLSCU2KJeCFGQ_ Oo]LNPI ` NPe2KJeCFD †—†—††—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—† n 5

8 9¶ }5w¶ ,1

t : ¶ ²<;²…³ - ¶

y{w<|au ¶ oy<|a·=0

}hy¶ w

,>

l† VW NCbEU2]JF ††—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—† n)

l†Çnl*bYXZUae2]JFGQTNPe †—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—† n)

l†Çq žNPe2DGF W U2]JFGQTNPe †—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—† qhp

l†i

VW N ` K W

FGQTKLD†—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—††—†—†—† q$

? @

y4 ² }A4 ¶ «} ²k¶

² y ¶ zB-4*«w ©w

!C

9 D z ¶ · }hy ¶ 5:|au ² 5² ·y{z ² 55#:w ² y{w !C

E 9¶

F-x|az3:w

¶ µ

«y4HG

² z ²

·I-z

¶ } ² ww

²

wJ

!K!

%&

+ d(%

‡'c2KvUaeE‚ŽNPOTbEQRe

s

FKL]dcaeaQTS¡U2K€’

_

D-QReCF

W

NCbEU2]LKLb QReŸFGc2K€K

_YW

ORB %hp D naoi2xg

_ D _

]LNPeC„¡K8e2QRKJe?F’

_ B FN W K

`aW KLDKJeCF

W Uae2D¥NY‚&]JNPe]8U WGW KJeCF£DGBEDGFKJI<D{$QRe FGc2KDNYš›] _ OROTKLb '›F W U2K]LNPe2]JU WGW KJe2]JB DKJI _ eCFGQT]LD†( ‡'c2K€QTbaK _ QTD-FN W K `aW KLDKJeCF

F Wd_ XZKL]JFN W QTKLD3NY‚]LNPe2]JU WGW KJeCF‰DGB?DFKJI<D _ D `_YW FGQ_ O2N W baK W D3NY‚KJ„…KJeCFD Wd_ FGc2K W FGc _ e<DKLSCU2KJe2]LKLD{hQRe£N W baK W FN1] _Y` FGU W K

FGc2K-‚

_

]JF1FGc

_

F—DNPI<K£KJ„…KJeCFdD

_YW K¥e2NPF]

_

U2D

_

ORO˜B

W

KJO

_

FKLb

_

e2b FGcCU2D—]LNPUaOTb NC]L]JU

W

QRe

_

e?B N W baK

W

oN

W

KJ„¡KJe

_

FFGc2K

D _ I<KFGQRI<Kh†‰‡'caQTDDKJI _ eCFGQT]LD(c _ D(FGc2K _ bE„ _ eCF _Ys K—FN W KLbEU2]LK—b Wd_ DFGQT] _ ORORBFGc2KeCUaI-MK W NY‚ W KJOTKJ„ _ eCF W Uae2D{2DGQRe2]LK

U2DKJOTKLDD1QReCFK W OTK _ „?Q˜e s D _YW K¥e2NPFF _ ‘…KJe QReCFN _ ]L]LNPUaeCF{†‡'c2K¥UaeE‚ŽNPOTbEQRe s NY‚ _ DGBEDGFKJI4] _ e FGc2KJe MK¥„CQTKJ’žKLb _ D _

]LNPI

`_

]JFb

_ F _ DGF

W

U2]JFGU

W

KFN<DGFN

W K _

OROƒFGc2KLDdK

`

NhDDQRMaOTK

W

Uae2D†

•&eE‚”NPOTbEQRe s D-’žK W K W KJ„CQTDGQRFKLbªQReªFGc2K hp D _ D _ ]LNPeC„¡KJeaQTKJeCF-FNCNPO‰‚ŽN W „…K W Q˜] _ FGQTNPe ` U WG` NhDKLDQRe `_YW FGQT]JUaO_YW

’*QRFGc¥FGc2K“QTbaK _ NY‚2eaQRFK']LNPI ` OTKJFK `aW K8 Š EA E$)h {na Ji {gE$

5  &%›†x° N W K W KL]LKJeCF$’žN W ‘ ÇnhpEc _ DDGc2N’*e¥FGc _ F

UaeE‚”NPOTbEQRe

s

D']LNPUaOTb

_

OTDN—MK&c2KJO

`

‚:UaOFN-DNPOR„…K&bEQ

_Ys e2NhDGQTD

`aW

NPMaOTKJI<DžQRe]LNPe2]JU

WGW

KJeCF*DGBEDGFKJI<D{ *-,/.0,3FN

W

KL]LN„¡K

W“W Uae2D

K Š?` O_ QReaQRe s NPM2DK W „ _ FGQTNPe2D `aW NCbEU2]LKLbMCB<FGcaQTD'DGBEDGFKJIŒ†$‡'caQTD _Y`a`aW N _ ]dcc _ DžMKLKJe ` U2DGc2KLbv‚ŽN W ’ _YW b€FNDNPOR„¡KFGc2K

bEQ_Ys e2NhDGQTD `aW NPMaOTKJI ‚ŽN W * *. DGBEDGFKJI<D{ *&,.,v]LNPe2]JU WGW KJeCF-DB?DGFKJI<DI _ baKvNY‚*DKJ„…K Wd_ O‰]LNPI ` NPe2KJeCFD-’*QRFGc

OTNC]

_

ORQR {KLbŒQReCFK

Wd_

]JFGQTNPe2D{†‰l"bEQTDGF

W

QRMaUaFKLb

_ Os N W

QRFGcaI ’ _

D*baKJ„¡KJORN

`2`

KJb‚ŽN

W

FGcaQTD

` U WG`

NhDKhEM

_

DdKLbNPe

_ ‚ _ ]JFN

W

QR {KLb

W K `aW KLDKJeCF _ FGQTNPeªNY‚žFGc2K¥UaeE‚”NPOTbEQRe s NY‚“FGc2K s OTNPM _ O3DGBEDGFKJI Çn$h nhnEƒnhq›†-‡'caQTD W K `aW KLDKJeCF _ FGQTNPeªDF _ FKLD1FGc _ FFGc2K

UaeE‚”NPOTbEQRe s NY‚ _ ]LNPI ` NPUae2bkDB?DGFKJI ] _ eŒMK—K ŠE`aW KLDDKLb _ D(FGc2K `aW NCbEU2]JF&NY‚xUaeE‚ŽNPOTbEQRe s DNY‚$QRFD(]LNPI ` NPe2KJeCFdD{a‚ŽN W

_ e _Y`a`aW

N

`aW Q_

FKe2NPFQRNPeNY‚

`aW

NCbEU2]JF{†‡'caQTD‰QTD

_

e2NPFGc2K

W‰`

N’žK

W

‚”UaOQTbaK

_

FN—]LNPI

`aW KLDD3‚”U

W

FGc2K

W

FGc2K(b

_ F _ DGF

W

U2]JFGU

W K

W K `aW KLDKJeCFGQRe sk_ ORO W Uae2D1NY‚‰FGc2K¥DGBEDGFKJIŒ†1‡'caQTD&‚_ ]8FdN W QR  _ FQRNPe W KLDUaORF1] _ e§MK¥baK W QR„…KLb bEQW KL]JFGORB¡ `2W N„CQTbaKLb NPe2KQTD

e2NPF W KJORU2]JF _ eCF‰FN1c2K _ „?B `aW NCNY‚ŽD{†žUaFFGc2K*I<NhDGF3DGQRI ` OTK _ e2b£KJOTK s¡_ eCF“baK W QR„ _ FGQTNPe<QTD `aW NPM _ MaORB£bEU2K'FN i›h’*c2K W K

QRF*QTD(K

ŠE`aW

KLDDKLbˆQReˆFGc2K

Wd_

FGc2K

W&_

MDGF

Wd_

]JF-–:MaUaF

`

N’žK

W

‚”UaO«™“‚

Wd_

I<KJ’žN

W

‘NY‚]

_

FK

s N W BFGc2KLN

W

B¡†

‡'c2KNPMEXGKL]JFGQR„¡KNY‚FGcaQTD `_Y` K W QTD(FN W KJ„CQTDGQRFFGc2K—e2NPFGQTNPe§NY‚UaeE‚ŽNPOTbEQRe s QRe N W baK W FN `aW N„?QRb2K _ e2NPFGc2K W&W K `aW K8š

DKJeCF _ FGQTNPe©‚ŽN W—W Uae2DNY‚(]LNPe2]JU WGW KJeCFDGBEDGFKJI<D{†A ` KL]JQ˜] _ ORORB¡FGc2K<UaeE‚ŽNPOTbEQRe sk` K W ‚”N W I<D _ . . ! * !NY‚

_

DGB?DFKJIΠ 0xQ

W

DGFNY‚

_

ORO®"*$# . QTD1Uae

W

NPOROTKLb&%oFGc2KUaeE‚ŽNPOTbEQRe

s

QTD

_€`_YW FGQ

_

O3N

W

baK

W

NY‚žKJ„¡KJeCFD{†'žUaF

_

OTDN !)( *

_YW K1K ŠE`_ e2baKLb&*3K _ ]dcFGQRI<K\FGc2K W K\QTD _ ]dc2NPQT]LK1MKJFœ’žKLKJe

n ^` NhDDQRMaOTK\KJ„¡KJeCFD{

n^{M Wd_ e2]dc2KLD _YW K1] W K _ FKLbƒEFGc _ F'’*QRORO}

e2KJ„…K W I<KLKJF'K _ ]dcˆNPFGc2K W*_Ys¡_ QRe©–”]LNPeE¦2QT]JFD _YW K&Q˜e2c2K W QRFKLb™8†3‡'caQTDXØUDGFGQ˜KLD“FGc2K&e _ I<K1NY‚+ ! , *-!/.0 & .OO‰FGc _ F

QTD‰]LNPI£I<NPeaORB<U2DKLb<QRevFGc2KORQRFK Wd_ FGU W Kh†l\D _ ]LNPe2DKLSCU2KJe2]LK&NY‚ƒFGcaQTD“baNPUaMaOTK&K ŠE`_ e2DGQTNPe CFGc2K(UaeE‚ŽNPOTbEQRe s-s KJe2K Wd_ ORO˜B

QRe2]

W K _

DKLD1QRe OTKJe

s

FGc

_

e2b§QRe ’*QTbEFGc †-‡'caQTD1QTD1DGF

W

QR‘?QRe

s

QRe FGc2K¥]

_

DK¥NY‚

_ e _ UaFNPI

_

FNPe %*-,/.0,

_

DKLS¡U2KJeCFGQ

_

OI

_ š

]dcaQRe2Kh?‚”N W ’*c2QR]dcˆFGc2K\UaeE‚ŽNPOTbEQRe s QTD*DGQRI ` ORBvFGc2K1 ..NY‚ _ ORO ` NhDdDGQRMaOTK W Uae2D{?„?QTKJ’žKLb _ D'DKLSCU2KJe2]LKLD*NY‚KJ„¡KJeCFD{†  e

]LNPI£I-UaeaQRFGQTKLDže2NPF“]LNPe2]LK W e2KLb€MCB<]LNPe2]JU WGW KJe2]JB _ D ` KL]JFD _ e2NPFGc2K W“W K `aW KLDdKJeCF _ FGQTNPeNY‚ W Uae2D“c _ D `aW KJ„ _ QROTKLb€U ` FN

e2N’—†

V

NhDDQRMaOTK

W

Uae2D

_YW K W K

`aW

KLDKJeCFKLbˆNPe

_

.*8?’*caQT]dc

_

I<NPUaeCFD'FNUaeE‚”NPOTbEQRe

s

FGQRI<K\MaUaF2! !)( * 8 *&,.0,

bEQ76K W KJeCF–”]LNPeE¦2QT]JFGQRe s ™ W Uae2DKJe2bEQRe s QRe©FGcK<D _ I<K<DGF _ FK _ F—FGQRI<K

t ^{_YW K£I<K WGs} KLbƒxDGQRe2]LK£FGc2KJB c _ „¡K£FGc2K<D _ I<K

‚:UaFGU W K3–ŽDKLK& s † ™8†3l&D _ ]LNPe2DKLSCU2KJe2]LKhaFGc2Kb _ F _ DGF W U2]JFGU W K W K `aW KLDKJeCFGQRe s<W Uae2D shW N’(D _ OTNPe s FGc2K1FGQRI<K _‹Š QTD

MaUaF

W

K8I

_

QRe2DMNPUae2baKLbŒQReˆ’*QTbEFGc †

‡'caQTD W KJI _YW ‘ Wd_ QTDKLD$DKJ„¡K Wd_ O?SCU2KLDGFGQTNPe2D{†0xQW DFxNY‚ _ ORO®PQTDQRF ` NhDDGQRMaOTK“FN&K Š FKJe2b-FGcaQTDF W KJORORQTD W K `aW KLDdKJeCF _ FGQTNPe¥FN

W Uae2DNY‚]LNPe2]JU WGW KJeCF‰DGBEDGFKJI<D"4ŒA ` KL]JQ˜] _ ORORB¡…’žKž’'NPUaOTb¥O˜QR‘¡KžFN1] _Y` FGU W K shWd_Y` caQT] _ ORORBFGc2K']LNPe2]JU WGW KJe2]JB _ D ` KL]JFD{

MaUaF

_ M _

e2baNPeªFGc2K<QReE2eaQRFK<QReac2K

W

QRF

_

e2]LK€NY‚*]LNPeE¦2QT]JFD

_

e2b

_

OROTN’ OTNC]

_

O3I<K

WGs

KLD-NY‚*]LNPeE¦2QT]JFGQRe

s

caQTDGFN

W

QTKLD{†€‡'c2K

NPMEXZKL]JFGQR„¡KQTDžNY‚ ]LNPU W DdKFN `aW KJ„…KJeCF _ eK ŠE` OTNhDGQR„…KeCUaI-MK W NY‚ ` NhDDGQRMaOTKcaQTDFN W QTKLD“FN‘…KLK ` F Wd_ ]d‘vNY‚Z¡‚”N W K Ša_ I ` OTK

QRe NPeaORQRe2K€I<NPeaQRFN W QRe s _ Os N W QRFGc2I<D{† A?KL]LNPe2bEORB¡baNCKLD _ ‚_ ]JFN W Q˜  _ FGQTNPe `aW N ` K W FœBŸK Š QTDGF‚”N W DGU2]dc DGF W U2]JFGU W KLD54

‡'caQTD¥QTD

_

e2KL]LKLDD

_YW BŸQRe

shW

KLbEQTKJeCF<QRe„?QTKJ’ NY‚\bEQTDGF

W

QRMaUaFKLb I<NPeaQRFN

W

QRe

s

¢YbEQ

_Ps e2NhDGQTD

`aW NC]LKLbEU

W

KLD{† l&e2bŸ2e

_

ORORB¡

’*c _ F _YW K\FGc2K W KJO_ FGQTNPe2D'MKJFœ’žKLKJeFc2KLDK6 .*7 . . _ e2b€UaeE‚ŽNPOTbEQRe s D84 ACU WG`aW QTDGQRe s ORB¡?Fc2K W K\K Š QTDGF'DGQRI ` OTK

_ e2DG’žK W D'FNFc2KLDK1SCU2KLDGFGQTNPe2D{?FGc _ F*’žKK Š?` OTN W K1QReFGcaQTD*N W baK W †­ªK\QReCFKJe2DGQR„¡KJORB W KJORB€NPe _-W K _ DNPeaQRe s£`aW N ` NhDKLb

QRe9 i›xFGc

_

F-QTD

_

ORI<NhDGF¥]JUaF

_

e2b

`_

DGFKLb

_

FDKJ„¡K

Wd_

O ` O_

]LKLD-QRe FGcaQTD

`_Y`

K W  _ e2bŸFGc

_

F’žK

W

KL]

_

OROžQReŸFGc2K€e2K

Š F

DKL]JFGQTNPe †

$\NPFK:*§l ‚”KJ’ I<NPeCFGc2D _ ‚”FK W FGc2K baKJ„…KJOTN ` I<KJeCFNY‚F W KJORORQTD€e2KJFD{'FGc2K _ UaFGc2N W ] _ I<K _ ’ _YW K NY‚ _ DQRI£QRO_YW

]LNPeCF

W

U2]JFGQTNPe; & ›ƒUae2baK

W

FGc2K¥e

_

I<K£NY‚ 'œ°§K

WGs KLb

V3W

NC]LKJDdDKLD{†(¤[\Q76K

W

KJe2]LKLD

_

e2b DGQRI£QRO

_YW QRFGQTKLD

_YW K _ e _

ORBEDKLb QRe

_Y`a` KJe2bEQŠ [†

<

ÃÄYÅÇÆ1âdÎY΋ʮÉ8âËכČÅÇÆ>=JÐØʎÓÎhÉËÎYÍ?áâÊ\ÅáÞϮċÐ-эÅA@8Åϛâ ?$×ZÉBCB“ÍYދÅÇ×GâdÏ®ÅÇÉËÞYÆ×ZÉ BCBžÍYދÅÏ«ÓLÜݘÉdÊ1ÐED‹â B*Î?ÇÐ8Ü Ï®É£Ê®ÐØ΋ʮÐZƎÐØÞ{Ï&ƔϛâdÏ®ÐZÆ&ÉËݓâ

×ØÉ8Þ)=JÉ ?á͍ϮÅÇÉ8ÞPâF?CÐZދ×ZÉ{ыÐØÊGÜYâËÞPÑ\эÐG=JÐE?áÉËÎ&Ï®ÄYÐIHxÅÏ®ÐØʮҋÅCâ ?A@ËÉËÊ®ÅÏ®ÄB1ÜPâJB(âFDÅABžÍBK?áÅÇÌ8ÐG?ÇÅáċÉLÉ{Ñ1ÐZƔϮÅAB(âdÏ®ÅÇÉ8Þ1â ?A@ËÉËÊ®ÅÏ®ÄB1ã

a

b a

b

c c

c a c

c a a

b a

a b c

a b

a

a b c

a b c

a

a b

a b c

a

b c

. . . . . .

0Q

s U W K :* . . ! *) #5

,

*-! .. *, _

3*$!#** A . *-!

*-!/.

. ! . 6!

*-

.*

*. , ,

x (% +%

)

d%(

‡'caQTD-DKL]JFGQTNPebaK82e2KLDNPU W e2NPF _ FGQTNPe2D‚ŽN W-V KJF W Qže2KJFD– V $1™8NC]L]JU WGW KJe2]LKe2KJFD–&13$™8KJF]h†<0N W I<N W K€baKJF _ QROTD

DKLK1 ÇnhgoN W n 5 ›†‡*c2K]LNPeCF W QRMaUaFGQTNPe NY‚xFGcaQTD `_Y` K W 2DKL]JFGQTNPe2Dq _ e2bi2EQTD'M _ DdKLbˆNPeŒ] _ FK s N W QT] _ O]JNPeDGF W U2]JFGQTNPe2D

_

e2b

W

KLDGUaORFD

`aW

N„¡KLbˆMCB­ QRe2DG‘¡KJOƒQRe i:›EFGc

_

F(’žK

_

OTDN£e2KLKLbˆFN

W

KL]

_

ORO®†

"!$#$%'&(#$)*+,'-

² y . l ! . aQTD _ iPš®FGU ` OTK

N = (P, T,→, M⁰)^{’*c2K W K} P, T <sup>_YW K W KLD `</sup> KL]JFGQR„…KJORB¥FGc2K ` O_ ]LK _ e2b<F Wd_ e2DGQRFGQTNPe€DKJFD/P

_

e2b → ⊆(P×T)∪(T×P)QTDFGc2K3¦N’

W

KJO

_

FGQTNPe

W

KJO

_

FGQRe

s\`

O_ ]LKLD

_

e2b-F

Wd_

e2DGQRFGQTNPe2D10h†

M⁰ :P → {0,1,2, . . .}^QTD

_ I-UaORFGQTDKJFNPe

P <sup>W K `aW</sup> KLDKJeCFGQRe s FGc2K1QReaQRFGQ_ O7#5 12 *$!/.©NY‚$FGc2K1e2KJF{*&,.0,‰FGc2KeCUaI-MK W NY‚$FNP‘…KJe2D(FGc _ F(K _ ]dc ` O_ ]LK QReaQRFGQ_ ORO˜Bc2NPOTbaD{†43\QR„…KJe _ e2NCbaK

x∈P∪TY’žK“baKJe2NPFK“MCB

•x^{_ e2b} x^{•QRFD `aW K8š _ e2b `} NhDGFZš›DdKJFD{ *&,/.0,$QRFDoQRI£I<KLbEQ_ FK

`aW

KLbaKL]LKLDDN

W D _

e2b¥DGU2]L]LKLDDN

W

DxQRe

→^{†xl F Wd_} eDGQRFGQTNPe

t∈T ^{QTD . ! . –”N W *65:. ™ QRe _ I _YW ‘?QRe s} MhbaKJe2NPFKLb MCB

M[ti^aQ76 ∀p∈^•t, M(p)>0^{† 0xQW QRe s} t ^{‚W NPI} M B?QTKJOTbaD(FGc2KeK8’"I _YW ‘?QRe s

M⁰=M−^•t+t^•2’*caQT]dck’žK

baKJe2NPFK‰MCB

M[tiM^0† M ^{QTD _*W K _ ]dc _ MaOTKžI _YW ‘CQRe s Q76£FGc2K W KžK Š QTDGFD _} DKLSCU2KJe2]LK

s= (t₁, t₂, . . . , t_n)^{NY‚2F Wd_} e2DGQRFGQTNPe2D

–”N W_ /!?™ _ e2b QReCFK W I<KLbEQ_ FKvI _YW ‘CQRe s D-DGU2]dc FGc _ F

M⁰[t1iM1[t2iM2. . .[tNiMN = M^{ _ MaM W KJ„?Q_} FKLb©QReCFN

M⁰[siM^†

 eFGcaQTD `_Y` K W a’žK—]LNPe2DGQTbaK W NPeaORB 70.e2KJFD{ *&,/.0,‰e2KJFD'‚ŽN W ’*caQT]dc ` O_ ]LKLD(c2NPOTb _ F*I<NhDGFNPe2K1FNP‘¡KJeˆQRe _ eCB

W K _ ]dc

_

MaOTKI

_YW

‘CQRe

s 8

†§­ªK€FGcCU2DQTbaKJeCFGQ˜‚”BªI

_YW

‘CQRe

s

D¥FN DGUaM2DKJFD¥NY‚

P^{† 0N W} FKL]dcaeaQT]

_ O W K _ DNPe2DD

`

KL]JQ˜]

_

ORO˜B

FGc2KU2DKNY‚

W

KL]JU

W

DGQR„…K

`aW NC]LKLbEU

W

KLDQReŒFGc2K—DKLSCU2KJO®E’žK

_

OTDN£ORQ˜I£QRF&NPU

W

DKJOR„¡KLD*FN<D

_

‚”K1e2KJFD(’*c2K

W

KFc2K1eCUaI-MK

W

NY‚

I _YW ‘…KLb ` O_ ]LKLD W KJI _ QRe2D(2eaQRFKh _ D*’žKJORO _ D(FGc2K1eCUaI-MK W NY‚KJe _ MaOTKLbˆF Wd_ e2DQRFGQTNPe2D _ FK _ ]dckI _YW ‘CQRe s †

4#¶ zB-4:w9. ‡N*FGU W eFGc2K3]LNPOROTKL]JFGQTNPeNY‚ƒ–ŽD _ ‚”K™e2KJFD QReCFN _ ] _ FK s N W B¡‹’žKe2KLKLbFGc2K3K Š F Wd_ e2NPFGQTNPe-NY‚EI<N WG` caQTDGI

MKJFœ’žKLKJee2KJFD{† KJF

N₁,N₂ MKvFœ’'Nke2KJFD$’*QRFGc

Ni = (Pi, T_i,→i, P_i⁰)^ i = 1,2^{†§‡N baK82e2K _ I<N WG` caQTDI} φ :N1 → N2

 _ e _ FGU WË_ O W KLSCUaQW KJI<KJeCFQTD*FGc _ F W Uae2D(NY‚

N1

_YW KFGU W e2KLbŒQReCFN W Uae2DNY‚

N2

†“A?N _  W DGF _ FGFKJI ` F

]LNPUaOTbˆMK _ D'‚”NPOROTN’(D*

h†

φ <sup>QTD _`_YW FGQ_</sup> O ‚:Uae2]JFGQTNPe 2I _Y`a` QRe s<` O_ ]LKLD(FdN ` O_ ]LKLD _ e2bˆF Wd_ e2DGQRFGQTNPe2DFN¥F Wd_ e2DQRFGQTNPe2D{

nE†

φ ^`aW

KJDdK

W

„…KLD(FGc2K1¦N’

W

KJO

_

FGQTNPe 

qE†*FGc2K

W

KLDGF

W

QT]JFGQTNPe

φ :P₁⁰ →P₂^{0 QTD*MaQ}XGKL]JFGQR„…Kv–”NPeŒQRFD(baNPI

_

QRe NY‚baK82eaQRFGQTNPe™8

:

Ú¥ÐыɞÞYÉdÏ Ê®Ð<;L͋ÅÇÊ®ÐxÏ®ÄPâÏ

P ^âËÞYÑ T ^{ÒhÐ=YÞYÅÏ®Ð8ã}

>

Ú¥Ð3âdƎƎÍB*ÐÐZâËכÄ1Î?áâË×ZÐÅáƃʮÐG?áâdÏ®ÐGÑ&Ï®É'É8ÞYÐ$ώʛâËދƎÅÏ®ÅÇÉ8ޗâÏM?ÇÐGâËƔÏGÜhâdÞPÑ&ÐGâËכÄ\ώʛâËދƎÅÇÏ®ÅÇÉËÞÄPâdÆâÏM?ÇÐGâËƔÏÉ8ދÐÅáދÎY͍ÏoÎ?áâË×ZЉâdÞPÑ&É8ދÐ

ÉËÍ‹Ï®Î‹Í‹Ï Î?áâË×ZÐ8ã

?

ÃÄYÅÇÆo΍ʮÉ8ÎhÐØʎϫÓ×GâËÞ\ÒhÐ @ËÍPâdʛâdÞLÏ®ÐZÐGÑ&Ò{Ó(ÅáÞLώʮÉ{эÍY×ZÅÇÞ@žÆŽÉ@×GâF??ÇÐZÑBAC

½xÁ DFEœ½GEIH‹¿KJLM3Á DNJ

A

Eœ»

ã