HAL Id: inria-00072616
https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00072616
Submitted on 24 May 2006
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub-
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
Blind subspace-based eigenstructure identification under nonstationary excitation using moving sensors
Laurent Mevel, Albert Benveniste, Michèle Basseville, Maurice Goursat
To cite this version:
Laurent Mevel, Albert Benveniste, Michèle Basseville, Maurice Goursat. Blind subspace-based eigen- structure identification under nonstationary excitation using moving sensors. [Research Report] RR- 4024, INRIA. 2000. �inria-00072616�
ISRN INRIA/RR--4024--FR+ENG
a p p o r t
d e r e c h e r c h e
Blind subspace-based eigenstructure identification under nonstationary excitation
using moving sensors
Laurent Mevel, Albert Benveniste, Michèle Basseville, Maurice Goursat
N˚4024
Octobre 2000
THÈME 4
9;:=<">@?BACDE?GFH?BIKJMLION?P>QCSRT?PAF=?BAUOVQC@?XWJYDEU[Z]\"^BI[?_R`:aV@V@?GFU[I[IO?XbcJYDE:=<>@UOZB?edgfH<>@V@:aC]h
i0jkclnm.op qarslStuwvBx&rzyX{|mcx$yX}x&rslgrz~vBx&rzyX{
mS~&=~xkclnm]~]yXlg}uzm@Hm]~
;yB /mcxTqarsl_v
$vB}}yX&x m`m]jmcjm{oBo|pTcxyXmpg}vBm]~
e-]P qat~&}vX]mr mc{ax&rvBx&rzyX{vBusyX&rsx&jln~jv] m$}y mc{¡m@¢_crzmc{x£¤yX;}mc/£¥yX&lgrs{
yXtx&}tx/¦§yX{usr mc{ax&rvBx&rzyX{¨yB£)x&jm7mcrsmc{~&x&&tcx&tmSyB£;vusrs{mvBª©¨«K©¬~&H~&xmcl®~&tH &m]cxxy
t{]yX{ax&yXusuzm M¯ t{lnmvX~&tm M¯ vB{ {yX{~&xvBx&rzyX{vB&°m@crsxvBx&rzyX{Y±¡qatj²v¡}yXuzmcl³vB&rz~m]~Srs{
lnm]jvB{rzvBu-mc{rs{m]mc&rs{ ¯ £¤yXªlny vBuvB{vBusH~&rz~$yB£- =rsvBx&rs{e~&x&&tcx&tm]~TvB{ l_vXjrs{m]~G±´
]yXlglnyX{µ}vXcx&rz]mx&jmcmgrz~`xy¶]yXusuzm]cx vBxv¡£¤yXl· vB&=rs{¸~mc{~yX7uzy=vBx&rzyX{~ ¯ t~&rs{¶yXx&j
m vB{ lny =rs{~mc{~yX~ ¯ rs{eyX mcxy7lgrslgrz$x&jmªv] vBrsuwvBrsusrsx§_yB£ v.uwvB&mc~mcx6yB£Y~mc{~yX~±
i0jm}t&}y~myB£$x&jrz~}vB}mcgrz~xy¹rs{ m]~x&rsvBxm¶jyº»~&t~}vX]m@¦¼vX~m r mc{x&rvBx&rzyX{½vB{
m.v vB}xm xyjvB{ uzm.~tj|v~&rsx&tvBx&rzyX{ ¯ xy}y m7rsx~]yX{~rz~&xmc{ct{ mc'{yX{~&xvBx&rzyX{vB&
m@crsxvBx&rzyX{ ¯ vB{ xynmc}"yX&xyX{|vmvBu-vB}}usrzvBx&rzyX{|m@vBlg}uzm±
¾¸¿ÀÁÂà PÄ- Å usrs{ mcrsmc{~&x&&tcx&tm¡r mc{x&rvBx&rzyX{ ¯ {yX{~&xvBx&rzyX{vB&µm@crsxvBx&rzyX{ ¯ ~&tH¦
~}vX]m.vBusyX&rsx&jln~ ¯ lnyG ars{_~mc{~yX~ ¯ =rsvBx&rzyX{¨vB{vBusH~&rz~±
ÆÇ ÈKɼÊËÈÌ ÍsɼΥÏ]Ð
ÑÒBÓÕÔÖ×ؼÙÒBÚQÔÛÜ/Ü/Ý0Þ/ÚإؼÓÕÜ&ßà×QáPâÖYÓãâ¼ÒBÓÕÝàâ¼ÒBÜäåاÚQæ'ÜçÖ"×QؼÙ6×QäèáPؼÜçÙ@Ú-éGؼ×ê[Ü/ÞçâYëìícî6ïðòñó=ôGõçöaõ|÷sæ'×ßPÜ/ø
ÛXÚQÔ¥Ü/ß¡ùâ¥Ø¼áBÞçâ¼áGاÚQøæ'×QÝBÓãâ¼×QؼÓÕÝBú.áPÔ¥ÓûÝPúüKý$þ¤ÿ)ÜçاÚâ¼ÓÕ×@Ýù`ùâ¼Ü/æ ÓûßPÜ/Ý]â¼ÓXÞ&Úâ¼ÓÕ×@Ý !Þ/×]×اßPÓÕÝXÚâ¼Ü&ßgÛ
aÜ/ácÜ/Ý"ÜçøûúQÓÕáBæ
ðòõ ñ
ð!"$#%'&)()*'+,.-0/*21)*)34657*'+18*'+:98;',8*8<9'(792;2%=-?>8(@
A
ðòõ :Bñ
õC"57%;2;D*217923232*8<9'(98;D%=-?>2(:
E ñ
ðF"/%'&(792GD*=-IH)JK&(7;D%2,8<9K+(79'%=-?>8(:
Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes
!"#"(#§ *7 ;24 &® (ª -,.-/!0!(
(. !'!(ª&"®.! ªª -'!" 24('
m]~TvBusyX&rsx&jlnm]~ r mc{x&rvBx&rzyX{¬}vBT~yXt~/¦§m]~&}vX]m]~TyX{xª£¥vBrsx$uzmct~ª}mct m]~
}yXtSur mc{ax&rvBx&rzyX{ v] mctuzm meuwv ~x&&tcx&tm_}yX}m t{²~&=~xkclnmnusrs{vBrsm~yXtlgrz~
t{mTm@crsxvBx&rzyX{¡{yX{]yX{x&Xu]m ¯ {yX{¡lnm]~&t]m`mcxà{yX{H¦§~&xvBx&rzyX{{vBrsm±àm$x§=}"m mª}yXuzkclnm
rs{axmc& arzmc{ax|mc{ c{rzm¬l]vB{ratm ¯ }yXt¶u vB{vBus=~m¹lny vBuzm m¬~&x&&tcx&tm]~|yXt l_vXjrs{m]~
mc{ arsvBx&rzyX{~G± «§u$m]~&x t~vBm|]yXtvB{x ¯$ vB{~e]m yXl_vBrs{m ¯ m ]yXusuzm]cxmc m]~ yX{{]m]~
mc{²}yG mc{vB{]m m¡vB}xmct~! ]mc&xvBrs{~m]~ ¯vBtx&m]~lnyXrsuzm]~ ¬}uwvX"]~ r$#cmc{x~
mc{
yXrsx~
¯
vP{
rslgrsxmct{m~&rsx&tvBx&rzyX{¡y&%nt{n{yXlSm
mvB}xmct~6"mvBt]yXt}e}ust~;rslg}yX/¦
xvB{ax.~mcvBrsx rz~&}yX{rsuzm±('7vB{~7]mcx7vB&x&rzcuzm ¯ yX{)cx&t rzm]yXlglnmc{axv vB}xmc7ur mc{x&rvBx&rzyX{
}vB~yXt~/¦§m]~&}vX]m]~ t{mgxmcusuzm_~rsx&tvBx&rzyX{ ¯ m clnyX{ax&mc~Qv¶]yX{~&rz~&xvB{]mn~yXt~Sm@crsxvBx&rzyX{
{yX{H¦§~xvBx&rzyX{{vBrsm
¯
mcx
mn}]~mc{xmc
m]~S]~&tusxvBx~m@H}*c&rslnmc{axvBtHEyXxmc{t~~&t
yX{{]m]~
]mcusuzm]~G±
àmx&v XvBrsuv+cx0m,#Mm]cx&t vB{~)uzmàv m t}yB &mcx.-tm0/Xv${y!13254*687:9;=<0>?<A@¤©|y mcu
vX~m
CB
x&&tcx&tvBu6lnyX{rsxyX&rs{ t~&rs{EDGFYÁÃ=H-mcvBx&rzyX{
À
xmcl3r
mc{ax&rvBx&rzyX{I
¯
tr;m]~x.]yB¦
yX yX{{.}vBuwv~y=crcx5JLKM< ¯N mct mc{ ¯!Å mcusrtm±
Oà Á QP « mc{ax&rvBx&rzyX{|v] mctuzm m`~&x&&tcx&tm`}yX}m ¯ m@crsxvBx&rzyX{¶{yX{H¦§~&xvBx&rzyX{{vBrsm ¯
vBusyX&rsx&jlnm]~ m7x§=}m7~yXt~/¦§m]~&}vX]m ¯ vB}xmct~ªlnyXrsuzm]~ ¯ vB{vBusH~m m]~' =rsvBx&rzyX{~±
qat~}vX]m@¦¼vX~m usrs{mvB'~&=~xmclr mc{x&rvBx&rzyX{ lnmcx&jy ~1032 ¯ 1 ¯ 1,-54"jv mT}y mc{¸m@¢_crzmc{x
£¥yX_x&jm|r
mc{x&rvBx&rzyX{ yB£.x&jm|mcrsmc{~&x&&tcx&tm¬yB£vµusrs{mvBlStusx&r¦¼ vB&rwvBuzm¬~&H~&xmcl¸± ´${
rslg}yX&xvB{xrs{~&xvB{]meyB£àx&jrz~}yXuzmcl rz~~&x&&tcx&tvBu6 =rsvBx&rzyX{ vB{vBusH~&rz~ ¯ vX~m yX{µlnmvP¦
~tmclnmc{x~£[yXl+vX]]mcuzmcyXlnmcxmc~gyX~x&vBrs{µvBtm]~ ¯ º'jmcmex&jm/mc¬rz~~tmnrz~xy¸r mc{x&r£¤
=rsvBx&rs{jvBvXcxmc&rz~&x&rz]~ @[lny
m]~àvB{
lny
vBu!~&jvB}m]~ I-yB£Mlnm]jvB{rzvBuM~&x&&tcx&tm]~à~&tH &m]cx
xy.t{]yX{x&yXusuzm M¯ 6(7 5 `vB{ "$68!#"$$90m@HcrsxvBx&rzyX{Y±;i6a}rzvBu"m@vBlg}uzm]~àvBmªy #"¦
~jyXm~x&&tcx&tm]~7~&tH /m]cx`xy~&ºàmcusu ¯ trsu rs{~7~&tH /m]cx`xy¡º'rs{ yX7mvB&x&jtv /m ¯ &r m]~ ¯
vBln~ ¯ º'rs{~~&tH /m]cxSxy:tx&xmcSrs{;:rsjx ¯ vB{ x&t&rs{m]~~&tH /m]cxSxy¸~&xmvBl x&t&tuzmc{]m ¯
£¤&rzcx&rzyX{rs{"mvB&rs{~ ¯ vB{ rslg}mc/£¤m]cx)vBuwvB{crs{±´ mcuzmc vB{x;vB}}yvXjnxy$~x&&tcx&tvBuvB{vBu¦
H~&rz~SjvX~.m]mc{E~&jyGº'{Exy mcus°yX{µx&jmnlny mcusrs{¹yB£lny m]~vB{ lny vBu~&jvB}m]~x&jyXtj
~xvBxm¡~}vX]mmc}m]~mc{xvBx&rzyX{~%01<4¯ vB{ x&jm¡t~myB£"$=?>=@A"$?9¸vB{ "$+5$#$ @A$'+5
mcrsmc{~x&&tcx&tm.r mc{x&rvBx&rzyX{¨lnmcx&jy ~B02 ¯ 14§±
´ ]yXlglnyX{E}vXcx&rz]mnrs{° =rsvBx&rzyX{ vB{vBusH~&rz~7rz~7xy ]yXusuzm]cx vBxv¡£¤yXl3 vB&ars{ ~mc{~yX
uzy=vBx&rzyX{~ ¯ t~rs{TyXx&jm vB{ lnyG ars{~mc{~yX~ ¯ rs{nyX mcxyTlgrslgrz'x&jm'v] vBrsuwvBrsusrsx§nyB£Mv
@[ltjIuwvB&mc$~mcx$yB£~mc{~yX~±'q=mc mcvBu-~&t]]m]~~&rs m vBxvn~mcx~$vBm7m]]yX m M¯ º'rsx&j|~mc{~yX~
vBx r$#mcmc{axeuzy=vBx&rzyX{~¡yX{x&jm ~x&&tcx&tm± q=yXlnm|yB£7x&jm¨~mc{~yX~ ¯ vBusuzm x&jmC 'D, E
~mc{~yX~ ¯ vBm /mc}xgm M¯ º'jrsuzm¶x&jm yXx&jmc~vBm¶lnyG m ±½i0jrz~¡~mcx&t} ¯ t~&tvBusus²m@£¥mc&m
xyvX~>="$95 'D, E .~mcx&t}F0Õ<4;vB{
x§=}rzvBusus vX~m
yX{¹vByXtxTxmc{¨~mc{~yX~
¯
vB{¨lgrslgrzgv
~rsx&tvBx&rzyX{¸rs{¶º'jrzj|jt{ m ~TyB£)~mc{~yX~ªvBm.v] vBrsuwvBuzm±
ya]m]~~&rs{|}yXus=m@£¤mcmc{]m vBxv¸£¤yX~&x&&tcx&tvBuvB{vBus=~rz~Srz~gvXjrzmc m xy v]E°}mc/¦
£¥yX&lgrs{¬mcrsmc{~&x&&tcx&tmr
mc{x&rvBx&rzyX{£¤yXmvXj m]]yX
~mc}vBvBxmcus
¯
vB{
x&jmc{ lnmc&rs{
x&jmem]~&tusx~yXxvBrs{m £¤yXm]]yX ~g]yX&m]~&}yX{ rs{¹xy r$#Mmcmc{xg~mc{~yX}yayXuz~±HGTyºmc mc ¯
}yXuzml_vBxjrs{ l_v]¹"m{yXx.mvX~&¨rs{¬}vXcx&rz]m ¯ vB{ x&jat~7x&jmgm]~&tusx.yB£0mcrsmc{ m]cxyXustH¦
rs{¡l_v]|{yXx`"m]yX{~&rz~&xmc{ax±.i0jmcm@£¤yXmx&jm!atm]~&x&rzyX{°vB&rz~m]~Txy_}mc/£¤yX&l8mcrsmc{~&x&&tcx&tm
r mc{ax&rvBx&rzyX{aµlnmc&rs{°x&jm vBxv¹yB£Tx&jm¶~&t]]m]~~&rs m¡m]]yX ~ ¯ vB{ }ya]m]~~rs{¬x&jmcl
uzyXvBusus ¯ rs{~&xmv yB£)lnmc&rs{_x&jm`r mc{x&rvBx&rzyX{¨m]~&tusx~±
i0jm }t&}y~m¨yB£.x&jrz~e}vB}mc¡rz~_xyErs{ m]~&x&rsvBxm¹jyGº·~t~&}vX]m@¦¼vX~m
r
mc{x&rvBx&rzyX{
lnmcx&jy ~`vB{ mv vB}xm xyejvB{ uzmvn}"yXus=m@£¥mcmc{]m~mcx&t} ¯ rs{|x&jmS}m]~mc{]myB£àvB{|t{H¦
lnmvX~tm vB{ {yX{~&xvBx&rzyX{vB& m@crsxvBx&rzyX{Y±ª«K{|~m]cx&rzyX{¬ ¯ ºm&rzm:¸mc arzmcºyXtx&}tx/¦§yX{us
]yG XvB&rwvB{]m@¦ &rs mc{ ~&t~}vX]mnr mc{x&rvBx&rzyX{²lnmcx&jy ~±¶i0jmnl_vBx&jmcl_vBx&rzvBu0lny mcusrs{|yB£
x&jmS}"yXus=m@£¥mcmc{]mS~mcx&t}¸rz~$~&xvBxm rs{¨~m]cx&rzyX{H-H±0´ ~&xlnmc&myB£x&jm vBxvgrz~ª}yX}"y~m
£¥yXx&jm~&xvBx&rzyX{vB&gm@crsxvBx&rzyX{evX~m ¯ vB{ ~&jyº'{exyT£¥vBrsurs{nx&jm0{yX{~&xvBx&rzyX{vB&nyX{m±«K{n~m]@¦
x&rzyX{o
¯
v$]y vB&rwvB{]m{yX&l_vBusrIGvBx&rzyX{g}&rzyX)xy$lnmc&màrz~ }yX}y~m
£¤yX-x&jm~rslg}usrm
vX~myB£
m]]yX ¦ mc}mc{ mc{x`m@crsxvBx&rzyX{ ¯ vB{ rsx~rslg}uzmclnmc{axvBx&rzyX{|rz~rs mc{Y±;i0jm`£¤tususe{yX{~&xvBx&rzyX{H¦
vB&evX~m ¯ rs{eº'jrzj¶x&jm$m@crsxvBx&rzyX{¶rz~6{yX{~xvBx&rzyX{vB&eº'rsx&jrs{x&jmTm]]yX ~ ¯ rz~'v m]~~m rs{
~m]cx&rzyX{¶
¯
º'jmcm.v]yX{~&rz~&xmc{cem]~&tusx0rz~à}y mc{Y±KJ$tlnmc&rzvBuMm]~&tusx~0yXxvBrs{m
yX{¸vmvBu
vB}}usrzvBx&rzyX{¬m@vBlg}uzmgvBmSmc}yX&xm rs{¨~m]cx&rzyX{ 2H±-rs{vBusus ¯ ~yXlnm]yX{cust~&rzyX{~.vBm v]º'{
rs{¸~m]cx&rzyX{H2=±
.S(*³-(;5à'"-S&5 !S - $!&%'!(
°me]yX{~&r mcSusrs{mvBlStusx&r¦¼ vB&rwvBuzm~&H~&xmcln~ m]~c&rsm aµv rz~cmcxm@¦¼x&rslnm~&xvBxmn~}vX]m
lny mcu !#"$%&
' ()
@ 1 I
º'jmcme~&xvBxm
vB{ yX~mc& m yXtx&}tx*'·jv] m rslnmc{~&rzyX{~*+vB{ -,¯ m]~&}m]cx&rs mcus ¯ vB{
º'jmcmTx&jm`~&xvBxmT{yXrz~m$}ya]m]~~/.
$%102
rz~'vB{ &6(7 $ 437vBt~~&rwvB{¡º'jrsxm`{yXrz~mT~m"atmc{]m
º'rsx&j ImcyglnmvB{|vB{ M¯ rs{¸x&jm.~xvBx&rzyX{vB&vX~m ¯ ]yX{~&xvB{xT]y vB&rwvB{]m.l_vBx&&r6587
9
$%:$<;
=?>@BA
5#CD.BE8FGEDH
0
º'jmcm
9
.2I
0 mc{yXxm]~x&jm0m@H}"m]cxvBx&rzyX{nyX}mcvBxyX±i0jmàº'jrsxmc{m]~~6vX~~tlg}x&rzyX{nyX{gx&jm'~&xvBxm
{yXrz~m$vB{ x&jmTvB~mc{]mTyB£ lnmvX~&tmclnmc{ax0{yXrz~mªrs{ @ 1 I;vBmª£¤t&x&jmc rz~ct~~m rs{¡~m]cx&rzyX{ 2H±
mcxYx&jm;}vBrs~J.LKNMPORQ
0
"m;x&jm;mcrsmc{ vBustm]~-vB{ mcrsmc{ m]cxyX~)yB£x&jm;~&xvBxmx&vB{~rsx&rzyX{Sl_vBx&&r
¯ vB{ m@{m:STQ
>@BA U(
ORQ±°m7vX~~&tlnm$x&jvBx'x&jm`~&=~xmcl jvX~à{ylStusx&rs}uzm7mcrsmc{a XvBustm]~ ¯
vB{ x&jt~ex&jvBx_x&jmVK ~evB{ STQ ~¡vBm¶}vBrs&º'rz~m|]yXlg}uzm@]yX{X çtvBxm±½«§{}vB&x&rzctuwvB ¯XW
rz~ "!vB{mcrsmc{a XvBustm|yB£`~&xvBxm¸x&vB{~&rsx&rzyX{l_vBx&&r ± i0jm ]yXusuzm]cx&rzyX{ yB£`}vBrs~V.LKYMZSQ
0
£¥yX&l·vnvB{yX{rzvBu-}vBvBlnmcxmc&rIGvBx&rzyX{¬yB£;x&jmS}"yXuzmS}vB&x$yB£;~&H~&xmcl @ 1 I ¯ m@£¤mc&m xyevX~ªx&jm
~=~&xmcl»mcrsmc{~x&&tcx&tm±'´ vB{yX{rzvBu-}vBvBlnmcxmc&rIGvBx&rzyX{|rz~Tv}vBvBlnmcxmc&rIGvBx&rzyX{¹º'jrzj|rz~
rs{a XvB&rwvB{axªº.±±x±;jvB{m]~ªrs{¶x&jmS~&xvBxm`vX~&rz~±
ya]m]~~&rs{yXtx&}tx']yG XvB&rwvB{]m`l_vBx&&rz]m]~0rz~0yB£Yrs{xmcm]~x0£¤yX mc&_uwvB&m vBxv~mcx~±)i0jm
r$#Mmcmc{]m"mcxKºm]mc{¬x&jm]y vB&rwvB{]m@¦ &rs mc{¬£¥yX&l8yB£~&t~&}vX]mgvBusyX&rsx&jln~`º'jrzj¬ºàm m@¦
~c&rs"m${yº vB{ x&jmTt~&tvBu vBxvP¦ &rs mc{¸£¤yX&l rz~àlgrs{yX ¯ vBxuzmvX~&xࣥyXàmcrsmc{~x&&tcx&tm`r mc{H¦
x&rvBx&rzyX{ 01 ¯\[ 4§± àyG XvB&rwvB{]m@¦ &rs mc{~&t~&}vX]m¹r mc{x&rvBx&rzyX{yB£x&jm¬mcrsmc{~&x&&tcx&tm
.LKYMZSTQ
0 ~rz~vX~m yX{¸x&jmT£¥yXusuzyº'rs{e~xmc}~± mcx
]_^
>@BA
9 ' ' ;
a`
^
vB{
b*c edf
>@BA ghhhhhhi
]<j ] ±±± ]
fP`N
] ]k
±±± ] f
±±± ±±± ±±± ±±±
] c ] c
±±
±l]
c
mfP`N nZo
ooooo
p
>@BA rqs1tvu
.w] ^0
@¥I
m`x&jm7x&jm]yXmcx&rzvBu-yXtx&}tx/¦§]y vB&rwvB{]mvB{ G`vB{N/mcuYl_vBx&&rz]m]~ ¯ m]~&}m]cx&rs mcus±;«§{ax&y tcrs{
x&jm7cy~~/¦§]y vB&rwvB{]m.mcx§ºàm]mc{ x&jm.~&xvBxmvB{ x&jm.yX~mc& m yXtx&}tx~ 7
>@BA
9
' ;
rsm]cx$]yXlg}txvBx&rzyX{~$yB£)x&jm/]^ ~'£[yXl®x&jm7lny mcuYm"atvBx&rzyX{~uzmv xy
]^
( ^
@#-I
vB{ xyx&jm7ºmcusu:/={yº'{ 01314M£¥vXcxyX&rIGvBx&rzyX{
b c
edf c
.( M *0
f . M 0
@[o I
º'jmcm
c .( M *0
>@BA ghhhhi (
(V
±±±
(V
c
`N nZo
ooo
p
vB{ f . M 0
>@BA
.
fP`N
0
vBm x&jm yX~mc& vBrsusrsx§vB{ ]yX{x&yXusuwvBrsusrsxK l_vBx&&rz]m]~ ¯ m]~}"m]cx&rs mcus± «K{x&jm|~m"tmcu¯ ºàm
yB£¤xmc{ yX}¸x&jm.yX mc~$yB£-x&jm7~=~&xmcl®l_vBx&&rz]m]~G±
i0jm'yX~mc& XvBx&rzyX{gl_vBx&&r
(
rz~;x&jmc{£¤yXt{ rs{gx&jmà~&xuzy=/a¦¼yºyB£"x&jm'yX~mc& vBrsusrsx§
l_vBx&&r
¯ º'jmcmvX~0m@=}uzyXrsx&rs{x&jmª~&jr£¤x6rs{a XvB&rwvB{]m$}yX}"mc&xKnyB£
}y =r m]~àt~;º'rsx&jex&jm
~xvBxm@¦¼x&vB{~&rsx&rzyX{ l_vBx&&r ¯ £¤yXl+º'jrzj²x&jmmcrsmc{~&x&&tcx&tm-.LKNMZSTQ
0
m]~&tusx~G±¨i0jm/mc
£¥mvBx&tmrs{_£¥vXcxyX&rIGvBx&rzyX{ @[o I)º'jrzjeº'rsusu"mmcuwvB"yXvBxm yX{ ¯ rz~;x&jvBx6x&jmªuzm@£[x6£¥vXcxyX yX{us
mc}mc{ ~-yX{x&jm6}vBrsR.
( M *0
¯ vB{ x&jt~-yX{x&jmmcrsmc{~&x&&tcx&tm0yB£~&=~xmcl @ 1 I ¯ º'jmcmvX~-x&jm
m@crsxvBx&rzyX{
$
yX{us¶v#Mm]cx~x&jm`&rsjxª£¥vXcxyX x&jyXtj¸x&jmScy~~/¦§]y vB&rwvB{]m.l_vBx&&r ±
i0jmvXcx&tvBu)rslg}uzmclnmc{xvBx&rzyX{EyB£;x&jrz~T~t~&}vX]mvBusyX&rsx&jl8jvX~$x&jmmclg}rs&rzvBu;]y vB&r¦
vB{]m]~
] ^
' ' ;
a`
^
@¥I
~t~&x&rsx&txm £¤yX<] ^ rs{ b*c
edf ¯ =rzmcu rs{¶x&jmmclg}rs&rzvBuOGTvB{N/mcu)l_vBx&&r
b*c edf
±BG$yGº xy
~mcuzm]cx6x&jm{atlSmc'yB£YuwvB~.
" 0
vB{ x&jt~x&jm$~&rIm$yB£
b c edf
rz~ rz~ct~~m rs{e~m]cx&rzyX{ 2H±
i0jm_q ' yB£
b c edf
vB{ rsx~`x&&t{vBx&rzyX{EvBx7x&jm m]~&rsm lny mcuyX mc.arzmcuM¯ rs{¬x&jm 'D
D 8"! ¯ vB{¶m]~&x&rsl_vBxm
£¥yXx&jmTyX~mc& vBrsusrsx§_l_vBx&&r ¯ £¤yXl º'jrzj . ( M 0
vB{ . KYM STQ
0
vBm`m]]yG mcm
vX~ª~ /mcxjm
vBy m±
(&*`])"-® -#ª"&%-0!( !'!('"*³-,.-ç
!0!(
«K{~&xmv yB£;v~&rs{uzm7m]]yX £¥yX'x&jm.yXtx&}tx*.w' 10
yB£)~=~&xmcl @ 1 I ¯ ºàm7{yº jv] m¬m]]yX ~
' j d
'
ªm]]yX
' j dk
' k
ªm]]yX I&I&I
' j d
'
$m]]yX @2I
]yXusuzm]cxm ~t]]m]~~&rs mcus± -vXj m]]yX ]yX{axvBrs{~ vBxvG' j d
£[yXl vµHm 'D, E
~mc{~yX¶}"y=yXu ¯ vB{ vBxv '
£¤yXl v (*"$+,'&¬~mc{~yX¶}y=yXu¼±®i0jm¬{tl"mc¨yB£~mc{~yX~
l_v m r$#mcmc{ax7rs{¨x&jmm vB{ x&jmlnyG ars{¶}y=yXuz~ ¯ vB{ x&jt~`rs{¬mvXj¬m]]yX ¯ x&jm
lnmvX~tmclnmc{x` m]cxyX~_' j d
vB{ '
l_v¶jv] m r$#Mmcmc{x rslnmc{~&rzyX{~±ªi0jrz~rz~M/a{yGº'{
t{ mcªx&jm7{vBlnm.yB£)}"yXus=m@£¤mcmc{]mS~mcx&t}C0Õ<4§±
i ynmvXj¸m]]yX @
I0]yX&m]~&}yX{ ~ªvg~&xvBxm@¦§~&}vX]m.mvBusrIGvBx&rzyX{ rs{¶x&jm`£¥yX&l
!""
#""$
!
"?$
' j d
( j
.[m@£¥mcmc{]m7}yayXu
0
'
(
.¤~mc{~yX'}"y=yXuM{&% 0
@823I
º'rsx&j v¶~&rs{uzm_~xvBxmgx&vB{~&rsx&rzyX{µl_vBx&&r ¦$~&rs{]mnx&jm_~vBlnmn~&H~&xmcl3rz~7mcrs{|yX~mc& m M¯
vem yX~mc& vBx&rzyX{°l_vBx&&r
(
j£¥yX.x&jmHm ~mc{~yX7}yayXu ¯ vB{ v~&}m]crnyX~mc& vBx&rzyX{
l_vBx&&r
(
]yX&m]~&}"yX{ rs{_xyguzyavBx&rzyX{ yB£)x&jm`lny =rs{e~mc{~yX'}"y=yXu¼±
i0jm$}yXuzmcl®rz~àxy{
jyº xygv
vB}x0x&jmTyXtx&}tx/¦§yX{us]y vB&rwvB{]m@¦
&rs mc{ ~&t~}vX]m
vBusyX&rsx&jl1yB£`~m]cx&rzyX{½¨rs{yX mcexy¬r mc{x&r£¤²x&jm¸mcrsmc{~&x&&tcx&tm¨yB£ rs{ @823I ¯ yX{x&jm
vX~rz~gyB£Tx&jm¶lnmvX~tmclnmc{x~E@ 2Iº'jrzj ºàm¸~&jyXtu lnmc&m¸~yXlnmcjyGº»£¥yXx&jrz~g}t&}"y~m±
´0xSx&jrz~7}"yXrs{ax
¯
xKºy }"yXrs{ax~S~&jyXtu
mg~&x&m]~~m
±-rs~&x
¯
x&jmn]yX&{mc~xyX{mnrs{°~m]cx&rzyX{E¶rz~
£¼vXcxyX&rIGvBx&rzyX{ @#-I)º'jrzj ¯ yB£ ]yXt~m ¯ jyXu ~;£¥yX6mvXjyB£Mx&jm m]]yX ~º'rsx&j¡v7$' uzm@£¤x
£¼vXcxyX
(
vB{ v7$' &rsjax;£¼vXcxyX ±-«K{n}vB&x&rzctuwvB ¯ mc mc{_x&jyXtj_ºàm y7jv mTvX]]m]~~
xy mclg}rs&rzvBuàm]~&x&rsl_vBxm]~yB£'x&jm_]yG XvB&rwvB{]m]~ 9 '
'
a`
^;
yB£'x&jmnlnyG ars{¹~mc{~yXS}"y=yXu ¯
x&jmc°vBmeyB£0}y=yX.jmcus}µm]vBt~mnx&jmcrsS£¥vXcxyX&rIGvBx&rzyX{~ @#-I.~&jyº t}Ev¶m]]yX ¦ mc}mc{ mc{x
~xvBxm@¦§yXtx&}tx]yX&mcuwvBx&rzyX{
~rs{]m_x&jm~mc{~yX~uzy=vBx&rzyX{²jvB{m±Eq=m]]yX{
M¯
ºàmejv m¡{y
vX]]m]~~;xy.cy~~&¦¼m]]yX ]y vB&rwvB{]m]~ 9 ' =
'
` ^;
º'rsx&j )(
H ¯ ~&rs{]m~mc{~yX6}"y=yXuz~ vB{
H
y{yXx7m]]yX
¬
vBxv~rslStusxvB{m]yXt~&us±gi0jat~
¯
ºmgvB{{yXx~&xvX/¹vBusux&jm
vBxv~mcx~`rs{µv
t{ratm7 m]cxyX ¯ yXx&jmc&º'rz~m7ºm7ºàyXtu jv m7xygjvB{ uzm7rs{]yXlg}uzmcxm]y vB&rwvB{]m.l_vBx&&rz]m]~±
´ ]yX{~m"atmc{]m7yB£ x&jy~m$x§ºy£¼vXcx~ ¯ rs{x&jmT}"mc~&}m]cx&rs m`yB£ trsu rs{_v GTvB{N/mcul_vBx&&r
mc{X &y=rs{¡v£¥vXcxyX&rIGvBx&rzyX{|}yX}"mc&xK
¯
rz~ªxyn]yX{]mc{x&vBxmyX{¸x&jm.]yG XvB&rwvB{]m]~Trs{a yXus ars{ex&jm
'D, E 6"$@±!yXl{yGº3yX{ ¯ ºm¨x&jat~¡£¤y=ct~eyX{ x&jm¨x§ºày £¤yXusuzyGº'rs{ £¥vBlgrsusrzm]~¶yB£
]yG XvB&rwvB{]m]~
] j d
^
>@BA
9 ' j d
' j d
` ^ ; M ] ^
>@BA
9 '
' j d
a`
^ ; @[ I
yB£)º'jrzj ºm.vB{ ]yXlg}txmmclg}rs&rzvBum]~&x&rsl_vBxm]~
¯
£¤yXuwvB~
W ±
´ ~&x)lnmc&m'yB£!x&jm vBxvTrz~){yGº }yX}"y~m £¤yX)x&jm'~&xvBx&rzyX{vB&rs{}tx;m@HcrsxvBx&rzyX{evX~m±
«Kx'rz~'~&jyGº'{ xy£¼vBrsuMrs{¶x&jm7{yX{~&xvBx&rzyX{vB&¸vX~m ¯ mc mc{¸t{ mcªx&jm7~&rslg}usr£[=rs{evX~~tlg}x&rzyX{
yB£~&xvBx&rzyX{vB&¶m@crsxvBx&rzyX{¸º'rsx&jrs{¸x&jm7m]]yX ~±
Ã*F F ¿ DH DOÃ*F Ã D F ¿ µH D «K{|x&jm~&xvBx&rzyX{vB&|vX~m ¯ x&jmm@crsxvBx&rzyX{
]yG XvB&rwvB{]mSl_vBx&&r yam]~0{yXx mc}mc{ yX{¸m]]yX 7
9 $
$
= ;
5#CD.BE8FlEDH
0
vB{ x&jm7cy~~/¦§]y vB&rwvB{]m.mcx§ºàm]mc{ x&jm.~xvBxm.vB{ x&jm`m ~mc{~yX~yXtx&}tx
>@BA
9
' j d
;
y=m]~O"! mc}mc{ yX{ mcrsx&jmc±)i0jmcm@£¤yXm ¯ £¥yX-vBusu=x&jmm]]yX ~
M&I&I&IaM ¡vB{ uwvB~ W¯
x&jm7]yG XvB&rwvB{]m]~$rs{ @ [ I6£¼vXcxyX&rIm ¯ º'rsx&j|vg]yX{~xvB{xB &£¼vXcxyX ¯ vX~
] j d
^ ( j ^
>@BA
] j
^
@I
] ^ ( ^
àyX{~m"tmc{ax&us ¯ £¥yXmvXj¸uwvB W¯ ºmSvB{ ~&xvX/x&jm:]
^ ~0rs{xyevuzy=/a¦§]yXustlg{ m]cxyX
]^
>@BA ghhhhi ] j^
]
^
±±±
] ^ n oooo
p @ 1I
º'jrzj¶£¼vXcxyX&rIm]~$vX~
] ^ ( ^ @ 131 I
º'jmcm
(
rz~'x&jm.uzya /¦§]yXustlg{¨yB£)yX~mc& vBx&rzyX{¸l_vBx&&rz]m]~
(
>@BA ghhhhi ( j
(
±±±
( nZo
ooo
p @ 1I
!& +5 6+5 6 # 5 + ' H$E "$!
i0jmcm@£¥yXm ¯ x&jm GTvB{N/mcuªl_vBx&&rEusuzm º'rsx&jx&jy~m¸]yXustlg{H¦§~&xvX /m ]y vB&rwvB{]m]~ ¯ º'jrzj
jvX~*.
" 0
x&rslnm]~ªvX~'l_vB{ayº~$vX~ª]yXustlg{~ ¯ £¼vXcxyX&rIm]~$vX~
b
>@BA
qs1tvu
.w]
^ 0 .( M
*0
. M 0 @ 1,-I
vB{ x&jm¸vBusyX&rsx&jl m]~c&rsm rs{ ~m]cx&rzyX{|£¤yXgx&jm¶~xvB{ vB vX~m¶vB{ m¸vB}}usrzm xy
b
±¡«§{EyXx&jmcSºyX ~ ¯ º'jmc{Ex&jmgrs{}txm@crsxvBx&rzyX{µrz~~&xvBx&rzyX{vB& ¯ ºmevB{°}ya]m]m vX~.r£
ºàmjv x&jm£¤tusu~mcx`yB£~mc{~yX vBxvv] vBrsuwvBuzmgvBusxyXmcx&jmc ¯ rs{~&xmv yB£~mc{~yXT}"y=yXuz~$º'rsx&j
vB&=rs{¡uzy=vBx&rzyX{~±«§{¹x&jrz~.vX~m ¯M rsm]cxSvB}}usrzvBx&rzyX{µyB£x&jmg~&t~}vX]mnvBusyX&rsx&jl3xy¡x&jm
]yXustlg{H¦§~xvX/m ]yG XvB&rwvB{]m]~+@ 1IYrz~;vT~&rslg}uzm0~yXustx&rzyX{gxyTx&jm0}yXusam@£¥mcmc{]m0yXtx&}tx/¦§yX{us
mcrsmc{~x&&tcx&tm.r mc{x&rvBx&rzyX{¨}yXuzmcl¸±
¡¿ à BÄ Á Ä ¿QH;¿ F Ä ¿ F ¿ DH DOÃ*F à D F ¿ µH D «§£ºàm$vX~~tlnm'x&jvBx6x&jmªrs{}tx
m@crsxvBx&rzyX{ ]yG XvB&rwvB{]mSl_vBx&&r
mc}mc{
~yX{¸x&jm.m]]yX
rs{
m@
7
9 $
$
= ; 5
CD.BE FlE
H0
x&jm7cy~~/¦§]y vB&rwvB{]m.l_vBx&&r
>@BA
9
' j d
;
vBuz~y & > $)"$
GTmc{]m ¯ £¤yX
M&I&I&I M vB{ W¯ £¼vXcxyX&rIGvBx&rzyX{~ @I${yºº'&rsxm
º'rsx&j¨vm]]yX ¦ mc}"mc{ mc{ax ] j d
^ ( j ^ @ 1co I
] ^ ( ^ @ 1I
vB{
m]cxyX_]
^
yB£~xvX/m
]yG XvB&rwvB{]m]~
m@{m
rs{ @ 1I0{yguzyX{mcª£¥vXcxyX&rIm]~`vX~rs{ @ 131 I@±
´T~6v`]yX{~m"atmc{]m ¯ &txm0£¤yX]m$vB}}usrzvBx&rzyX{eyB£M~&t~&}vX]mªvBusyX&rsx&jl g~&xvX/=rs{.x&jm\]
^ ~
rz~){yXx;vB{_vB}}yX}&rwvBxm~yXustx&rzyX{gxy$x&jm'mcrsmc{~x&&tcx&tm'r mc{x&rvBx&rzyX{e}yXuzmcl rs{x&jm'vX~m
yB£-m]]yX
¦
mc}"mc{
mc{ax$rs{}tx$m@HcrsxvBx&rzyX{¸{yXrz~m±i yncrsctl mc{xªx&jrz~
r¢_ctusx§
¯
x&jm.r
mvrz~
xy)"$(*$
x&jmT]yG XvB&rwvB{]m`l_vBx&&rz]m]~(@ 1co I§¦ @ 1Ixyl_v /mTx&jmcl#uzyay&/=rs{nvX~àr£ x&jmc_ºàmcm
yXxvBrs{m º'rsx&j¸x&jm.~vBlnm.m@crsxvBx&rzyX{Y±
(ª !0!(ª'"*+-,7-/!'!( 0!8('24ª-0!(
yX{ rs{¡x&jmvB}}yX}&rwvBxm{yX&l_vBusrIGvBx&rzyX{ ¯ ºm}"mc/£¥yX&l r$#Mmcmc{x`]y vB&rwvB{]m~xvX/=rs{
yX}mcvBx&rzyX{~£¤yXx&jm vBxv.£[yXl x&jmªm@£¥mcmc{]m`vB{ lny =rs{~mc{~yX~ ¯ m]~&}m]cx&rs mcus±«§{eº'jvBx
£¥yXusuzyº~
¯
ºm7t~m`x&jm7mc{mc&rz7{yXxvBx&rzyX{~rs{ax&y
t]m
rs{ ~m]cx&rzyX{|H±
¡¿K¿ ¿ F ¿ ¿ F Ã B i0jvB{N/=~¡xy @ 1co I ¯ vBusuTx&jm%G`vB{N/mcu`l_vBx&&rz]m]~¡trsusxyX{½x&jm vBxv
mcusrs mcm anx&jmªm@£¥mcmc{]m`~mc{~yX~àyB£Yx&jm m]]yX ~ࣥvXcxyX&rIm$º'rsx&jx&jm$~QvBlnm 'D£¼vXcxyX
vX~
bj d
> @LA
qs1tvu
.w]
j d
^
0?
. ( j M *0
. M 0 @ 1 2I
°m7vB{ x&jt~}y=]m]m vX~0£¥yXusuzyº~G± mcx
] j^
>@BA
] j d
^ ] j dk
^
I&I&I_]
j d
^
m.x&jmSuzya /¦¼yGº m]cxyXTyB£;x&jmmc{x&rsm~mcx$yB£;m@£¥mcmc{]m vBxv_]yG XvB&rwvB{]m]~±$«§xª£¥vXcxyX&rIm]~
vX~
] j^ ( j ^ M º'jmcm
>@BA
.
klI&I&I
0 @ 1 23I
i0jat~6x&jm GTvB{N/mcu!l_vBx&&rusuzm º'rsx&j_x&jy~myº0¦§~&xvX /m ]yG XvB&rwvB{]m]~ ¯ º'jrzj_jvX~ ¸x&rslnm]~
vX~l_vB{¶]yXustlg{~$vX~'yGº~ ¯ vBuz~y£¼vXcxyX&rIm]~$vX~
b j
> @LA
qs1tvu
.w]
j
^
0?
. ( j M *0
. M 0 @ 1 [ I
JTyXxm¡x&jvBxl_vBx&&rGb jevB{²m¡yXxvBrs{m aErs{axmc&uzmv] =rs{°x&jm¡uzya /¦§]yXustlg{~eyB£ªx&jm
G`vB{N/mcu l_vBx&&rz]m]~_bj d
rs{ @ 1 2I@±'´T~~&tlnm7x&jvBx$}vBrs4.
( j M *0
rz~$yX~mc& XvBuzm±0i0jmc{ ¯ }vB&x&r¦
x&rzyX{rs{¶x&jmn&rsjx`£¼vXcxyX yB£ @ 1 [ ITrs{¹x&jmg~vBlnml_vB{{mcvX~ rs{ @ 1 23I ¯ ºmm]]y mcSx&jm
&rsjax0£¥vXcxyX~
. M 0
yB£@ 1 2I;£¤yXvBusu
M&I&I&I M ;± JTyXxm$x&jvBx'}y=]m]~~&rs{x&jmTm@£¥mcmc{]m
vBxv' j d
$8"E z= ¯ yX{¸x&jm7vX~&rz~yB£)x&jm&! GTvB{N/mcuYl_vBx&&r£¼vXcxyX&rIGvBx&rzyX{C@ 1 [ I ¯ rz~
l_vB{ vBxyX&¡£¥yX'l_v /ars{e~&tm7x&jvBxºàm mvBuMº'rsx&j¸x&jm$(7 0~&xvBxm7vX~m]~rs{ @823I@±
OÃ DGF ¿ F Ã P i0jvB{N/H~xy @ 1I ¯ x&jm7G`vB{N/mcu6l_vBx&&r°trsusxyX{µx&jm_]yG XvB&rwvB{]m]~yB£
x&jm vBxv '
£¤yXl+x&jm¡lny =rs{¹~mc{~yX}y=yXurs{²m]]yX mc{X &yH~v|m]]yX ¦ mc}mc{ mc{x
£¼vXcxyX&rIGvBx&rzyX{
b
>@BA
q_s1t%u
.w]
^
0?
.( M 40
. M 0 @ 1 I
´T~~&tlnm$x&jvBx ¯ £¥yX0vBusu ¯ x&jmT}vBrs . M 0
rz~']yX{ax&yXusuwvBuzm±6i0jrz~0rz~vmvX~yX{vBuzm.vX~~tlg}H¦
x&rzyX{ ¯ rsx; /t~&x$xmcusuz~ªx&jvBx ¯ º'jrsuzmSx&jmm@HcrsxvBx&rzyX{¨l_v]|jvB{m ¯ ºm{m]m rsx$xyem@crsxmvBusux&jm
lny m]~`yB£6x&jm~&H~&xmcl ¯ £¤yX`mvXj vBxv¡~mcx±7´T~~&tlnmvBuz~y¡x&jvBx ¯ t}¹xy¶v_}"mc<xvBx&rzyX{°yX{
x&jm0m]]yX rs{ m@Hm]~ ¯ . M 0
rz~)x&jm'm]~&x;]yX{ rsx&rzyX{m ]yX{x&yXusuwvBrsusrsx§_l_vBx&&rnvBlnyX{Sx&jm
. M 0 ~± yXTvBusu ¯
M&I&I&I M ¯ ºàm m@{m.x&jm`{yX&l_vBusrIm l_vBx&&rz]m]~
b
> @LA
b ; . M 0 . M 0 ; . M 0
`N
. M 0
@¥I