HAL Id: inria-00071644
https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00071644
Submitted on 23 May 2006
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Modeling and Validation of Globally Asynchronous Design in Synchronous Frameworks
Mohammad Reza Mousavi, Paul Le Guernic, Jean-Pierre Talpin, Sandeep Kumar Shukla, Twan Basten
To cite this version:
Mohammad Reza Mousavi, Paul Le Guernic, Jean-Pierre Talpin, Sandeep Kumar Shukla, Twan Bas- ten. Modeling and Validation of Globally Asynchronous Design in Synchronous Frameworks. [Re- search Report] RR-4935, INRIA. 2003. �inria-00071644�
ISRN INRIA/RR--4936--FR+ENG
a p p o r t
d e r e c h e r c h e
ε
INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE
Modeling and Validation of Globally Asynchronous Design in Synchronous
Frameworks
Mohammad Reza Mousavi1, Paul Le Guernic2, Jean-Pierre Talpin2, Sandeep Kumar Shukla3, Twan Basten1
1 Eindhoven University of Technology
2INRIA/IRISA-Rennes
3 Virginia Tech
N˚4935
Septembre 2003
THÈME 1
ε
! #"%$& ')(+*),$
-.$/ 0 213 ')(*4,$65+*487:9;*4<3$
=>@?BADCECEAGFIHKJMLNAO=>GP)QRANS/T
1UWV
AGP)XZYJ\[]P)J_^a`)Tcb
2UBd JNAG`e
V
TfJM^g^aJ]hiAGXfj)Tc`
2U
k
AG`)F4JMJMjlmP)CnAD^
k
?&P)o&XpA
3U
hZqrAG`srAGQgtaJM`
1
1 u
Tf`)F)?4>vSGJM`w`)TxS@JM^gQaTxt!yz>G{ihiJ_b|?)`)>@Xc>@}Gy
2 ~
H
~!D~
H ~ k
eHKJM`4`)JMQ
3
Tf^g}@Tf`)TfA\hJMb|?
: 33gg+3g
W i¡i¢g£v¤¦¥¢a¢g§
Z¨v¨G©vaª« v«ª« v¬®¯_°±M²³µ´Ng¨g¶v· ¸¸_±a¹r¨ º_g
»+¼4½g¾¿|ÀvÁ¾Â à ÄÅRƳÇȬ©v|ÉÊ_¬ËÇÈ33©ÄÌÉ̬vºÍ¬©ÏÎ|ÄÊÉÅ©v|ÉÊ_¬Ï ÇM¬Dª« v_¬vD©aÐÉ̺¬
É̬E\ÄÑÉÑÒÓªÄ̪«ÔÆN¬ª« v¬v_¨_º« 33Éʬvº³r©gÄcÕÏ: ÉÌ3 ÄÌÄÌ|ÖZ8ÍЩv˨v_¨DgÐÉÊaÇ
º_ÄÊ_¶ ÄÌÄ̳N¬ª« v¬v_iÉ̬vºmÐN¬ª« v¬ÉÊ8vÄÌ ÉÌ¬Ë ¬D©\3©gÄÑÒÓª« vgª«ÔNÉ̬vºNÄÌÔNÉÑ«Õ
× K ¨v¨v__ª« Eªg ¬n¶D³v3 ÉÊØgg©n_3 ÉŪ« ¬ÐÇÈ|É̬E ÇË©gÉ̺¬Ùª¬DÐÉÅÉʬºÍÇ
ÖÚN¬ª« v¬v_ÐÄ̪_3¨DMÐa©rN¬ª« v¬v_)ª_r¨G¬¬MBÉ̬MÇÈvÄÌÄÌ8M¬Dª« v_¬vD)vÄÊÉÊÒpªÄʪ«Ô
3©gÄ/¨vgÎNÉʬvºr vÛ|ÖgÜMvÉÌÎ| Ä̬ªÕ´NÉʬDªv8M¬Dª« v_¬NÉ̬v rg¬ ¶ÄÊK3N©vÄÌÉʬvº
É̬KM¬Dª« v_¬vD4©vgÉʺ_¬8ÇÈ« 3gÖÝ_ÔgÞ ÖÝZgÔ |É̪g ÄÌÄÊÉʬߩaÐN¬ª« v¬ÉÊØgÉʬvº¨v ªÄ
Eà|«ª« &à/ vM¬Dª« v_¬vD3©ÄfÕO´Nª« E¨vª_ÄßÉ̬É̬϶vÉ̬vº_r ¶Gr ¨G_ÐÉ̶vÉÌÄÊÉÊ
Ç/ÇÈ_ ÄÌÄÌKÉʬNÎ_gÐÉ̺_|Éʬº v¶Dg RÎNÉÊ_: Ǻ_ÄÊ_¶ ÄÌÄÌKM¬Dª« v_¬vDݪ3¨D_¬v¬M«:ÉʬmM¬Dª« v_¬vD
g¬NÎMÉ̬v3¬M«B ¬©r vg¬ªÄÌÎ_« ºÉ̬vº vNÄÅW ¬©8gª« v¬vÉÅÜMvgB©vÎgÄÊ_¨Da©r|ÎB©aª_©g)ÇÈ_WÐDª«
g¬NÎMÉ̬v3¬M«ÕW: vÄÑÉÊ|ºM Ä@ Ç4 ÉÌaÐa «ª« +ÉÅ:¨v|ÎNÉÌ©vi v¨G_ÐÉ̶vÉÌÄÊÉÊKr©gÄ/ ¬D©
¶vÉÊÄÅ©záâã4´EÉ̬z\Ö:RÆ˨aÐgÎ_3¨v|άE¨v¨GÉÌg3Ö vg¬Ù©v¨vÄÌ|a©O_¬n¬
_ÐN¬ª« _¬vݬvÖÝ_Ô@Õ
ämåMæ@çèé ¿|ê4½Â ë 3Äß3 v©vgÞ4g¶Gg©v©vg©Ï©aÐÉ̺¬&Þ)º_ÄÊ_¶ ÄÌÄÊÍN¬ª« v¬v_Äʪg ÄÌÄÊ
N¬ª« v¬v_Ú «ª« vÉÑgªvg
ìÅí¦îïpðgñ:îò4óÌïpôfõö
Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes
*)'4( \ 3')(*4
½  _Ú¨v_¨DMÐ_¬Úv¬v ÉÌi¨GvÄÅ8r©gÄÊÉÅ|É̬ZÄÅÎ|ÄÊÉÅ©v|ÉÊ_¬©v3g
_ÐN¬ª« _¬vg: m3|_¬m©¦àv¬m3N©vÄÌ©¨vº_33 É̬ÐN¬ª« _¬vvÄÊÉÊÒf ÄÊ_ºÕ _ZÒ
©vÉÊ_¬3ÄÊa3¨v¨vÉÊar©v]ÐÐ3a8º_ÄÊ_¶ ÄÌÄÌ3¬MKN¬ª« v¬vag¬EÉÊÄÌÉŬ_+©vgraª« v¬vÉÅÜMvg©
ÉÌvÄÅ|ÉÊ_¬K©r©gÄÑÒÓª« vaª«ÔMÉ̬vºDÕ
¨¨vª« v¨GKgv33¬nÄÅ]¬ÇÈ_ É̬
_|ÉÅÜMvi©&àv¬ÐÐgrª_¬ÉÑv©iª3¨DM¬MÚª¬¬vgªgÚ©i3¬vÉÌiN¬ª« v¬v¬+¬
38N¬ª« v¬v8vÄÊÉÊÒf v_Ä̺_gÜMvÉÌÎ| Ä̬Mx¬mÛ i m¨v3ÉÌaÕÝ_r38ÄcàN¬ª« v¬v¬v
¨Gv¨¬Æºg¬v« Är©gÄÊÉÅK©v ¬v¬ÆÉÊÄÚ©Kª_¬ªg¨É̬ËM¬Dª« v_¬vÞ/¬vª« v«ª« v¬D
©v¬ªrÉʬDÐggZ©3¬vÉÌ_|ÉÅÜMvv¬¨v ªÄÌ©©vgM¬Dª« v_¬vÉÅ É̬ªg ¨¶vÄÌ©3©NÒ
gÄÊÉÅ3ÄÊmª3¨D_Ð3¬MN¬ª« v¬v©Äcà ¨v¨ÄÊÉŪ É̬Eª¬ÉÅ©ÈÄÌ«ÜMvªgÄÌ\gШDMÉ̶vÄÊ!Õ
ÝÐÉ̬ÐgÐÉÊ_¬³©8¨vª_ÄÊ@ÄÅK¨G_ÉʶvÉÌÄÌÉÑ8©¦à©ÉÌiÇÈrgÄÊÄÌ3g¬_ÄÊrª_r¨Gg3¬M©
3gM¬Dª« v_¬vg© ¬v¬mÉÊÄ)©ª¬ª¨ÉÊ_¬]ÐN¬ª« _¬v©v¬ª©&àÉÊÄÌÉÅÐgÄÌgZ_ÉÌÄÅZ
ÄÌg4gª« v¬ÉÌÜMva xª_3¨vÉÊÄÅ|ÉÊ_¬&Þ|¬ÇÈ_ É̬&ÞRÎgÉ"!Dªg|É̬#/©gÎgÄÊ_¨v¨DggBRÎ_gªßªg)_ÉÌÄÌgÕ)ã&:¶v
©v¬v r«RÎ| ÉÌÄBgЩ¨GrÐÄÅ3N©vÄÌÉÌ|ÉÊ_¬\ÄÌmª¬Ðª!ÉÊ_¬Í©&ફ vÉÊaª!vaáâã´
xºÄ̶ÄÊÄÌ3g¬_:N¬ª« v¬vaWÄÌNªg ÄÌÄÊg3¬M:N¬ª« v¬va$W©¦à¬v3¬vĘ́vgÎ| ¬MÚ©aÚ¨v_¨vÉÊg
ÇÈ_3gÄÊÄÌ3¬M« ¶vÄÌÉÌgRÎ| ¬MZ©ÄÌg©g¨vÄÊ|_vv¬aÐa M¬Dª« v_¬vÕ
%;é ¾a½ ç Á'& Â)( N©vg)ÇÈ_3ÄÌÄÌggÞª_¬ªg¨É̬©Z3gBg¬ÇÈÉÌgÞ_ª« vÉÊaª!va4ºÄ̶ÄÊgrg¬M
_ÐN¬ª« _¬vgÝÄʪg ÄÌÄÊgrg¬MN¬ª« v¬va
; < 8/*),'ß
´M¬Dª« v_¬vDÝÄÅ ¬ººgÚ RÎ_i¶Gg¬Ng¬ÐÉÌÎgÄÊ+Ða©Éʬ xªÒ ЩgÉ̺¬ Ç4 ÇÖ: ¬© ©NÒ
Ö: WNÐg>=¯?pÕâZ¨¨vÄÊNÉ̬vºiN¬ª« v¬v_¦ÄÅ ¬vº_ º_g@Zg ÄÊÒpÖÝ_ÄÅ©i©vgÉʺ_¬&Î_g ÄÌg© vÉÌЬº
¬©KÖÚgÔ¨D_ÉʬM«Ý|Î_ÝÉÌ3ÕWâZ¶D_ª! ¬©+g3rÄÌg ¬¬©ÐM¬M«|¦ÞMÇÈ3Ħ ¬©ÐªgªÉ̬ª!
¬_É̪g ÈÖ É̪« ƨRÎ_g©\ v+ÖÚRmÇÈ_A@KªÉÊg¬_rÐÉÌvÄÅ|ÉÊ_¬Ë ¬©ÍÎgÉ"!Dªg|É̬\N_ÄÌ 3¬º
vЬvº3¨GÉ̬_«: ÇBÐDª« ÄÅ ¬ººggÕCBZ|ÖÚÎ_aÞ_ vM¬Dª« v_¬vDÚ_v3¨ÉÊ_¬+v¬D¶D
KÄÊÉÌ3ÉÑÉʬvº+ÇxªaÕ × ¬m_¬v8ÉÌ©v ÇB v8¨Daª!vÞ@É̬³©ÉÅÉ̶vg©mgÄÑÒfÉÌ3ÐÐg3gÞ¨|ÎNÉÅ©Éʬº
É̬vºÄÌÞÇÈvÄÊÄÌÐN¬ª« v¬ÉÊØgg©ªÄÌNª«Ô|ÎgZ©ÉÌÐÉ̶va©¬v©gR+¶GÎg¨Dg¬ÉÊÎ__ª!D ÄÌÄÊ
É̬ÇÈaÉʶvÄÌÕ × ¬ v vgZÐÉÅ© Ç v¨Ggª!ÞÉʬ¬ ¬ ÒÓªg ÄÌ6©aÐÉ̺¬/Þ_ v¨v¨º_ É̬
©vÄÅR8Ǧ vªÄÌNª«Ôr|ÎgB iª« vĘ́+ÉÊØgZ¶Daª_raÝ3 ݶÐ_ªÄÌZÉʬ+¨v|ÎNÉÅ©É̬vºÉʬºÄÌÐN¬ª« Ò
¬ÉÊØgg©+ªÄʪ«Ô@ÕB: NÞÄÊÄG g©_ É̬ݪg ÄÌÄGÇÈ:3ÉÊK ÇN¬ª« v¬v_߬©+_ÐN¬ª« v¬W©vgÉʺ_¬
¨D|ЬgÕ
!"#D%'"(*),+!.,%*E0FG(!"H4I"(*),+!.,%J*9#0FK4LK©gÉʺ_¬ DRÎKgrgº_g©ËÉÌ¬Ë vÒ
ª¬MÝ_gBÉ̬+g¨G¬ v ¶G|ÎZ3g¬_ÉÊ_¬vg©+ª« ÄÌÄÊg¬vºaW ¬D© RÎaªÉÌÎa©3|Ú|¬MÉÊ_¬
ÇÈ 8NÐg ÄÌÎ_Ä4©gÉʺ_¬]ª_r8v¬vÉÊÕNMÓ¬\áâiã´m©vgÉʺ_¬&Þ v8 ÉÌiª_r¨G_g©ÇßÐN¬Ò
ª« _¬vª3¨G¬vg¬M i RÎ_ ÉÌiÄ̪ Ä4ÐN¬ª« _¬viªÄ̪«ÔЪ!vg ¬©]ª3¬vÉ̪g|
DÐÉ̬vº_ÐN¬ª« _¬vª« vg3ggÕ: vg8 RζDg¬\Î_« Ä4|Ð3¨«KÇÈ_ ÄÌÉÌØ8áâiã´]©vgÉʺ_¬
cÐgÇÈvr¨ÄÊ_ÞO=Êa±Þ±?!Õ
P ¿ é
¼&
å
RQ&¾gÀ¾
å åS
¾
MÓ¬E Ę́D ¨GaÞÝÖÚm©v©gr m¨v_¶vÄÌ Ç3©ÄÌÉ̬vºË ¬©EÎ| ÄÌÉÌ©v ÐÒ
É̬vººÄ̶ÄÊÄÌmN¬ª« v¬v_ª3¨DMÐÉÊÉ̬\ ÇÝN¬ª« v¬v_ª3¨G¬vg¬_«Éʬ\ v38vÄÑÉÑÒÓªÄ̪«Ô]ÐN¬Ò
ª« _¬v¨vº_r3É̬vºÇÈ« 3ÖÚÔ1TUWVGXOY[Z|Õ4: v: É̬ºM ÄM Ç@Ъ« r ¬3 ¨v¨Mª« ÉÅ4ÄÊgΫ º_
v+ÉÊ8vÄÅ|É̬ˬ©Ír©gÄߪ« vaª«ÔMÉ̬vºM_ÄÊÔNÉÊÉÅÉʬvºÇÈ_ª« ÍÇÈrgÖÝ_Ô1=ÌA?pÕ × v8Ð_ÄÊÉÊ_¬
ªg ¬m¶G8g¬]ÇÈ3Ä/3 v©Ä̺_KÇÈ_iª_3¨DMÐÉ̬vºKNÉÅÐÉ̬vº\MÓI¶vÄ̪«ÔÞG©gÉʺ_¬vg©ÖÉÊ ÍÐN¬Ò
ª« _¬vrv3¨É̬gÞWÉ̬z ¬E_ÐN¬ª« _¬vÇx vÉ̬OË ÉÅÇÈÏ vm©g3¬©v3ÇZ_r_|Öà
áâiã´©aÐÉ̺¬gÕ
× v ¨¨vMª« zª¬I¶G\v33ÉÌØa©IK« ¬ÐÇÈ3ÉʬºË vÍ©gÉ̺¬ ª¬ÉÌÐÉ̬vºÏÇÖÝnÐN¬Ò
ª« _¬vÄÌOª_r¨G_g©Ùª3¨D_¬v¬M«3OË©vgÉʺ_¬E |ÉÌ]!^._)ON¬ª« v¬v_ÄÊϪ3¨DMÐa©
ª3¨G¬vg¬_«Õ´NÉ̬ªKM¬Dª« v_¬N]©Ng¬vÉÅÉ̬ÏM¬Dª« v_¬vD©vgÉʺ_¬ÆÇÈrgÖÝ_ÔgÞ¦ÖÝ
gÔnÇÈE©gN¬ª« v¬vÉÌØÉ̬vºÏ¨ª_ÄZE|ª« I vÆN¬ª« v¬v_3©ÄfÕ ë É̬©É̬vºEª«
¨ª_Ä/¶vÉʬº_¶D_ v¨G_ÉʶvÉÌÄÌÉÑ ÇBÇÈ_ÄÊÄÌÉ̬NÎaÉʺM|É̬vº3 v¶G RÎNÉÌi ÇßM¬Dª« v_¬vD
ª3¨G¬vg¬_«:Éʬm_ÐN¬ª« v¬Ý¬NÎNÉʬrg¬MgÕ
MӬϴNaª!É̬˷ÖÚr¨aÐg¬_33gÄÌ g©\ÖÚÔGÕ´Naª!É̬˱Þ/ª_¬_« É̬© !¬vÉÊÉ̬ÇÝ v`TUWVOa
X6Y[Z3ÄÅ ¬vº_ º_ÕÝ´N¶ÐaÜMv¬MÄÌÞÖÝ©v !¬v¬ÉÌ©a Ä4©gN¬ª« v¬vÉÌØÉ̬vºr¨vª_Ä&Éʬºv¬N¶D_v¬©a©
!ÇÈƪ« D ¬v¬vgÄÌ3¬©O¨|Î_+Éʪaª!3Éʬz´Naª!É̬n¯ÕÙ´NÉ̬ªm ¬nv¬N¶Gv¬©vg© !vÇÈ˪« ¬v¬Äª¬v¬v
¶G+ÉÌ3¨vÄÌ3¬Ma©ËÉ̬bTUWVGXOY[Z4Þ4 vÉÅ8¨vª_ÄWÉÅ_¬vÄÊÆ ¬OÉÊ º_ÉʬD ³3©Äݶv3ÉÑ3ª ¬Ë¶G+DÐa©
_ÇÈgg¬ªr3©Ä)ÇÈ_ ¬v¬vÒf¨GÇÈgª©vgM¬Dª« v_¬vÉÌØg|ÉÊ_¬]¨v NªÄÅÕr: v¬/Þ&ÖÝ3¨v|ÎNÉÌ©v
vª¬©vÉÑÉÊ_¬v¬D©8Ö vÉ̪« Æ vÉÅ8©aÐÉ̺¬Ïªg ¬Ë¶G+ !¬g©Æ³m¬vÖÝ_Ô\ ÇZ¶Gv¬©vg©Ï¬©Í N
ÉÌ3¨vÄÌ3¬M¶vÄÌ !vÇÈ]ª« ¬¬vÄÅÕMӬϴNaª!ÉÊ_¬Ë²vÞ&ÖÚ¨v_¨DMЬ\ÉÌ3¨vÄÊg3¬M É̬ƶN\© !¬vÉ̬vº v
!ÇȪ« D ¬v¬vgÄÌB¬©8 vÖ« ¨¨vÉʬºÈ vZ¨ª_Ä v¬D©8ª3¨D_¬v¬M«4¨vÎ_¬M4|Î_ÖÉÊÉ̬vºi v
¶ Gg©v vÕ ë v r__ÞvÖÚ¨vaÐg¬M©vgÉʺ_¬gÐÉÌ| v¨v¨v¨vÉÌ !vÇÈKª« ¬v¬vgÄ/ÐÉÌØ
É̬¨v_ª!ÉÌªÕ ë ÉʬÄÊÄÌÞG´NgªÉ̬rv3 ÉÊØggÝ aÐvÄʬ©¨vaÐg¬MÝ vª¬ªÄÊD©ÉʬºrÔgÕ
*<
MÓ¬ =· ?pÞÚ©ÉÅÐÉʶvvÉ̬vº TUWVGXOY[Zͨvº_38ÉÅ©ÉÌg©nv¬©gKÐN¬ª« _¬v3ª¬©ÉÊÉ̬DÕI´NÉ̬ªmÄÊÄ
ª3¨G¬vg¬_« Kv3g©\mÖÚÔ³ÖÉÊ ÏmÉʬºÄÌKÐ8ªÄÌNª«Ô@Þ/ vg_Þ/ vÉÊØg Ç: K¶v @
ÉŬ v« ÄÌÄÊmgÐÉŪ!a©m_¬vÕ1MÓ¬ =Êg¯?fÞ& v¨v¶ÄÊg ÇÚ©vgª_3¨DMÐÉ̬vºHTUWV[X6Y[Z¨vº« ÉʬM
ª3¨G¬vg¬_«+ÉÅ©ÉÌg© ¬© O ¬D©vÐ D ÔNÉʬºÏ3gª« ¬vÉÌĘ́v¨G_g©nÇÈ_ vÆN¬ª« v¬v_
ª3¬vÉ̪g|ÉÊ_¬O Ǫ_r¨G¬¬MgÕ × v3ÖÚÔËNg¬©vr vaÐvÄÊrÇ =·Þ¯?ËN¬ª« v¬v_
É̬vº_:ÖÚ ¬D©vÐ D ÔNÉʬº8ÉÅ:g3|Îg©+g©Dªg©+K3N¬MgÕ
MÓ¬ =Êa± ?pÞB vÉÅv Çiª3v¬É̪g|É̬vÒf¶_Ða©Ë©gÉ̺¬OÉÅ3©v©vag©¦Õ Mp3ÉʬM©ªg8 ÉÅ©g
Ç !)_ +`# A+*%É̬O_©vrÍÉʬMÇxªÖÚ È¨G_ÉʶvÄÌÏ3ÉÅÐ|«ª« vÉ̬vº Éʬ¨vK ¬©O¨v
É̺¬ÄÌgÕ ë ÉÊÇÈÜMvgvgi vg¬]¨v¨G_g©m_¨vÉÊ3ÉÊÉÌÎ8ª3¬vÉ̪g|ÉÊ_¬ª« D ¬v¬vgÄÌgÕNMpiÉŪÄÌÉÊ3a©
v |v¬N¶D_v¬©a© !vÇȪ« ¬v¬ÄÅ ÉÅ©gĪ3v¬É̪g|É̬m3aª« ¬vÉÅ3ZÇÈN¬ª« v¬v_
©vgÉʺ_¬ ÈN¨ag©Ùâ¶Ð«ª!ÝÒ"!igÉ̺¬ ë ÉʬvÉÊÍ´M ( _ª« vÉʬg_Kâ ë ´ ( ÇÈ_KÐ v_Ð !Õ
: ¬mâ ë ´ ( Z !¬va©+É̬M$# ë ´ ( ZÖ vÉŪ« ª¬MÉʬmr¬vÖÝ_ÔKǶGv¬D©g©!vÇÈKª« D ¬v¬vgÄÌ
¬©8¶Äʪ«ÔNÉʬºr3aª« ¬vÉÅ ZrÄÌ_ÐKª« ¬v¬vgÄ@|Îgª3Z v«|3ÉÅÐ|«ª« ¨_¶vÄÊgÕ
× vBª¬MÉʶÉ̬ vÚÖÝ_Ô Ç[=Ìg±?ª ¬¶D:ÐrÉÌØa©É̬ ßÇÈ_ÄÊÄÌ|ÖÉʬºZÖÚÉÅvg&% ë ÉÌÐgÞ
ÖÚÇÈ ÄÌÉÊØg vª_¬ªg¨:Ç)_ÐN¬ª« v¬Ý©gÉʺ_¬É̬ v$T UWV[XOYGZrr©gÄcÕW: ÉÌÚÇÈ_ ÄÌÉÌØg|ÉÊ_¬
¨|ÎNÉÅ©gD +¨G_ÐÉ̶vÉÌÄÊÉʳ³¨v|Îr vªÄÌÉÊ ÇZÉÅ©gÄÝ_ÐN¬ª« v¬N]ÖÉÊ Ov¬N¶D_v¬©a©Ë¶v @
¬©Æ vª¬©vÉÑÉÊ_¬ÇÈ_8 !D¬vÉʬº³ÉÊ8\¶Gv¬D©g©O¶v @aÕ ( |ÎggÞ4ÉÊr¨v|ÎNÉÌ©vg vÇȬª
v_ÉÅªÄ 3N©vÄ ÇÈ_&ÉÌr¨ÄÊgrg¬M|ÉÊ_¬&ÇvM¬Dª« v_¬NÕ&´Ngª¬©vÄÊ_ÞaÖÚB¨v¨G_W¨v«ªÉŪ Ä ©vgÉʺ_¬
gÐÉÌ3 r 3ÉÌØ3 Ç:¶v @É̬³ v !¬va©\©vgÉʺ_¬\ |ÖÚª ¬Æ©aªg8 v 3_v¬MÇ
¶Äʪ«ÔNÉʬºÇÈ_Z¬v ĦNÐg ¶G RÎNÉÌaÕ
: vÖÚÔÆ Ç'ÚgË ¬©Ù´N¬M|ÎMÉŪ« ÏÉ̬ =² ?ZЩvÉÊar vÉÅv Ç_ÐN¬ª« _¬vÉʬM«ª!ÉÊ_¬
¶GÖÚg¬ÐN¬ª« v¬(#ßÐggĨvº_Õ/: Þ v v_BÄÌÎ: vZ¨v¶ÄÊg; Ç@|ÎgÖÉÊÉ̬vº
3a º_g:©vKM¬Dª« v_¬N¶M¨v¨G_Éʬvºr¨v NªÄ@ |Z¶vÄ̪«Ô: v¬D©Z¨ªa:v¬MÉÊÄ
vgªgÉÊÎ_Ú¨vNªg:ª¬DÐv3aÚ v©v rÎ| ÄÌvÉʬ v¶v @aÕWâZÄÊ v_vº É̬+ vÉÌZÖÚR3 v¶v @
ÉÌØÉÌ:gÐÉŪ!a©K
1ÞN v¨ « ÄÌÄÌÄÌÉÌ ¬©¨vĘ́GÄÌÉʬvÉ̬vºÉÅ©gªag©¦Õ
MÓ¬ =*) ?fÞÚ©ÉÅÉ̶vÉÊ_¬EÇiÐN¬ª« _¬vrgÜMv¬MÉÌÄÚ¨_º« xÉʬÙNÄÌ Ç+#ßÐggĨvº«
ÉÅ©ÉŪÐa©¦ÕbMÓ¬n vÉÅK ¨¨vMª« &ÞW v]_ÐN¬ª« v¬rÉ̬_«ªÉ̬O¶GÖÚg¬n v]ª3¨D_¬v¬M«3ÉÌ
g¬ª¨vÄÌ a©8É̬
send ¬© recieveª_33¬©vW¬©8 v3Éʬ G_ÐWÉÅBÉ̬NÎgÐa©rÉʬN¨ÄÊ_É̬vº
¨v¨v¨vÉÅ|¨vÄÌ_ªaWÇÈ_Ú¬©+ ¬©+aªÉÌÎaWÉ̬+_©gW83É̬vÉÊ3ÉÌت_r8v¬vÉŪ É̬+¬©|ÉÌrÉÌØ
¨D « ÄÌÄÊgÄÊÉÅÐÕ BZ|ÖÚÎ_aÞ ÉÅÐv Ƕv @ÐÉÌØÉÅÝÄÌÇÉÌ3¨vÄÊÉŪÉÊZ ¬©+g É̬W8¶G©v©gg©¶N
É̬NÎaÉʺM|É̬vº vi ¬MÉ̪gW Ç cN¬ª« v¬v_$)¬D©K ¬©3gªÉÌΪ3 ¬©WÖ vÉŪ« KÉ̬K¬vÖÚR
_Ú v vgÉʬNÎ_ÄÊÎ_gÝ ÉÌÉÅÐv_Õ
MÓ3¨vÄÌ3¬MÉʬvºN¬ª« v¬v_ÐÐg3ÉʬvºÐN¬ª« v¬ÄÅ ¬ººg:ÉÅ ÄÅÐKЩvÉÊa©mÉʬ =¹?fÕ
âZÇg3©v !¬vÉ̬vºÆ]º_¬vgÉŪ+ ¬MÉ̪+r©gÄÚÇÈÐN¬ª« _¬v ¬©EM¬Dª« v_¬vDª_r¨ É̬&Þ
v+ Ðg¬MÉ̬ÏÉÅÇȪDÐa©Æ¬ËÉÌr¨ÄÊgrg¬MÉ̬vº\ª3v¬É̪g|É̬Æ3gª« D ¬vÉÅÐ8Ъ« Ï_vÄßNÒ
ªÄÊDÐÉ̬Eraª« ¬ÉÌr¬©Ï¬D©ØÒfÎ_gÕÏâZÄÊ v_vº E g3gª« D ¬vÉÅÐ3ª¬O¶GÎÆ ¬D©ÏÉ̬
_ÐN¬ª« _¬v3 ©vgÉʺ_¬&Þ: v³¨ ¨G+©vMa¬vкºa+¬NO¨vªgÐ É̬vºÆÇÈÐN¬Ò
ª« _¬v©aÐÉ̺¬D ¬©Æ ÉÊÎNÉ̬vºÉ̬Ϫ_3¨D_¬v¬MÉ̬Ðv3¬Ma©ÍÖÉÑ Æ vaÐKЪ!vggÕK: vÉÌÉÌ
_¬v Ç vº__ ÄÅÚ Ç4 v¨aÐg¬_¨¨Dg ÈÖÉÊ g¨Daª!: !vÇÈKª« D ¬v¬vgÄÌ!Õ
: v³ÖÝ_ÔÏÇ1=°?3N©vÄÅKN¬ª« v¬N ÈÉ̬MÄÌgRÎNÉʬºÆ¬_É̪g$rÉ̬bM × âZv Æ3©Ä
DÐÉ̬vºN¬ª« v¬v_ª38v¬vÉŪ|ÉÊ_¬³3gª« D ¬vÉÅÐÕ$BZ|ÖÚÎ_aÞ&©vrm©É"Ggg¬ªa¶DÖÝg¬\ v
3©gÄÌ Ç:ª_r¨ É̬ xª« \_iÉ̬v¨vv¬¶vÄÊÉ̬vºÐr¨vÉ̬³É̬]M × â_3 !Þ¦ v3¬v ÉÊ_¬
Ƕv GgZÉÌ:É̬Mg¬ÄÊÉÌØa©+É̬ÉÌ©v v ¬MÉ̪g: Ç =°?/¬©ÉÌ:¬ ©©ag©+¨vÄÌÉ̪ÉÑÄÊ_Õ
1r $&Z7 - $/ #
: i ¶D_ª!ßM¬M«|3 Ç/ª_Ò-T UWV[XOYGZ ÉÌݺÉÌÎg¬Éʬ ë É̺_Õ MÓ¬ vÉÅÚÐN¬M @ÞMTUWVGXOY[Z¨vº«
ÉÅ©aª3¨G_g©ÍÉ̬_mÐgΫ ÄBª3¨D_¬v¬M«ÕÝ_r¨G¬¬Mv3g©³mÖÚÔ]ÐN¬ª« v¬ÄÊ
¬©Éʬm¨D « ÄÌÄÊgÄcÕ !igª3¨DMÐÉÊÉ̬ÇB`T UWV[XOYGZr¨v_º« 6ªg ¬¶GZ3gvÄÊZ Ç)Òf3¬Nv¶G
Ç × Z´ Ý_3rgªÉÌÄ × m: v´ vÄÊÇ$Úª_r¨G¬¬MßßDÐÉ̬vº8©vgª_3¨DMÐÉÊÉ̬gª« v¬ÉÌÜMva߶_Ða©
_¬mº« ¨v m¨D ÉÊÉ̬vÉ̬vº cÐgÇÈiv 3¨vÄÌ =Ìa·Þg¯?Õiâ ÐÉ̬vºÄ̪3¨D_¬v¬Mª¬DÐÉÅ«ZÇ߬Nv¶G
ÇiÉʺ_¬ Ä:© !D¬vÉÑÉÊ_¬gÕÏ: v3 Ç ÄÌÄ:É̺¬Äݬ3g8ÉÌ3©g¬v g©Ï¶N
X ÖÉÊ EN¨vÉŪ ÄÚ38¶Dg
x, y, z, . . .Õ: vgKKÇÈgÖ ¨ÉÌ3ÉÑÉÊÎ_K¨G«|«iÉ̬ TUWVGXOY[ZmÄÊÄÌ|ÖÉ̬vºÇÈ©v !¬vÉÊÉ̬ËǶÉ̪
¨ªaggÕ): vi¨vaÉ̬
x=preval y © !D¬vgÝ D|: vÉʺ_¬ Ä@¬ra©
x v_ÄÌ©vß ¨gÎMÉÌD
Î|ÄÊvi Ç/Éʺ_¬ Ä
yÞM¬©ÉÊÚÉÅÝÉʬvÉÊÉÅ ÄÌÄÌKÐß
val NgÞ x¬© y N¬ª« v¬v_!Õ: iaÜ_D|É̬
x = y when z © !¬vg x m RÎ_ vKÎ| ÄÌvÇ
y Ö ¬ z Ę́vaÐg¬M ¬©
trueÕ+: v+gÜM|ÉÊ_¬
x=y defaultz © !D¬vg x ¶N y Ö v¬ÉÊZÉÌ:¨vg¬MZ ¬D© vgÖÉÅi¶N
zÕ Program ::= PName= Component |
Component||sProgram Component ::= CName=Expressions
Expressions ::= Expression |Expression,Expressions Expression ::= x=preval y|
x=ywhenz | x=ydefaultz | x=f(y, z, . . .)
ë Éʺ_v3 %WâZ¶Ð«ªZ´M¬M«|+Ç9TUWVGXOY[Z
⨠)ÇÈ_ ¨vÉÊ3ÉÊÉÌÎÚ¨G«|_gÞ|ÖÚÚ_v3ÝÉÌÐg¬ª: Ç@¬M¶G) Ç@ ÉÑ v3ÉŪڨG«|«
c ¬© Éʬ¨ ÉŪÄÌgÞZaÜM ÄÌÉÑ_Þi©g¬v g© ¶M
==K Ô_\ª3¨v«|É̬¬ N¬ª« v¬v_ÄÊ
RÎ|ÉÊÄÅ ¶vÄÌ3 ºv3¬M«Õ$MÓ¬Ævv 3¨vÄÌg Ç TUWVGXOY[Z¨vº_Þ@ÖÚÐ
∧x m v_Ð ¬©]ÇÈ
true when(x==x)Ö vÉŪ« ÉʬMvÉÑÉÊÎ_ÄÌK3g¬« vªÄ̪«ÔK Ç
x|Õ
À &å\Så_ç*P &xÀvÁ å å ¿ /ШGgªÉÑÇÈÉʬvº_ÄÊݨvÄŪݶv @aÞ !«4ÖÝÚºÉÌÎÝШGgªÉ!Dªg|ÉÊ_¬
Ç43Éʬvº_ÄʪÄÌÄ&33Þv_ÚÇÈÄÌÄÊ|ÖZ&%
data = msgIndefault(pre0data) msgOut = datawhen∧msgOut
: v]¶D|Î_¨_º« ÄÌÄÌ|ÖZrÇÈÉ̬©¨G¬D©¬M+g_©E¬©nÖÉÊ]_ªªag c©¬ a©n¶M
msgIn
©
msgOut ¬© v3gr_ªgÄÊÄÔg¨: vÄÅÐÖÉѬmÎ|ÄÊv8 ¬©ÉÅZÉ̬vÉÊÉÅ ÄÌÉÊØgg©
0Õ: v
[[x=pre val y]] = {b|{x,y}|tags(b(x)) =tags(b(y)), b(x)(t(b(y)1)) =val,
∀i∈ , b(x)(t(b(y)i+1)) =b(y)(t(b(y)i))}
[[x=ywhenz]] = {b|{x,y,z}|tags(b(x)) =tags(b(y))∩ {t|t∈tags(b(z))∧b(z)(t) =true},
∀t∈tags(b(x)), b(x)(t) =b(y)(t)}
[[x=ydefaultz]] = {b|{x,y,z}|tags(b(x)) =tags(b(y))∪tags(b(z)),
∀t∈tags(b(x)),(b(x)(t) = (b(y)(t) ∧ t∈tags(b)(y)))∨
(b(x)(t) =b(z)(t) ∧ t /∈tags(b(y)) ∧ t∈tags(b)(z)))}
4 ¶vÄÌ3 %W´N¬_É̪g: Ç)ÄÌ3¬M« TUWV[X6Y[Z aÜM|ÉÊ_¬
É̬©g¨Dg¬©g¬ª¶DÖÝg¬+ v«|i Ç/É̬v¨vv:¬©K_¨vvÉ̺¬ÄÌÝÐ v|ÖZß a¬DªÇ/¨GÄÌNª« _¬M
É̬ TUWVGXOY[ZË©aÐÉ̺¬/Õ: vÉŨv|ÎNÉÌ©a33 v]¨G_ÐÉ̶vÉÌÄÊÉÊÏÇÈ_+©gN¬ª« v¬vÉÌØÉ̬vº\ v\©gÉʺ_¬gÕ /
ª« D ¬vº_ vÉÌÉʬvÉÊÉÅ ÄÝШGgªÉ!Dªg|ÉÊ_¬\mÉ̬vºĄ̈vÄŪ3¶v GgÖ vr vKªg ÄÌÉÊm¶DÖÝg¬Æa©v
¬©\ÖÉÊa 8ÇÈ_ªg©Í ¬©³ !ÐÉ̬ !DШvÉʬDªĘ́vÄÊÉŶDÐgÎ_g©¦Þ&ÖÚ3 RÎ8mÔr v
ÇÈ_ÄÊÄÌ|ÖÉ̬vºrª« D ¬vº_gÝ3 v¨vº« %
data = (msgIn when(notfull))default (pre0data)
full = (falsewhen∧msgOut)default ((true when∧msgIn)default (prefalsef ull))
msgOut=datawhen(∧msgIndefaultf ull)
∧data = (∧msgIndefault∧msgOut)default∧f ull
: vÉŨ_º« _¬vÄÊ\ÖÉÊa vKÎ| ÄÌvKÇ:É̬v¨vv8É̬_m K¶v @aÞ)ÉÑÇ vK¶v @8É̬v ÇÈvÄÊÄ: ¬D©
_¬vÄÌÄÊÄÌ|ÖZ:+Ô v8©v 3ÇÈ v¨vaÞ@ÉÑÇB v¶v Ggª¬MÉʬÐ_rr©v|«vÕZ: v8¶v @
ÉÅÝÉʬvÉÊÉÅ ÄÌÄÌKÐݶGg3¨ ¬©+¶Daª3aWÇÈvÄÌÄ@Ö v¬8©|ÉÑ ÉÅÚÖÉÊЬ8ÉÊÚ¨|ÎNÉÅ©g©3 |
ÉÊZÉÅ:¬v « Ôg¬_Z| v33_rg¬MgÕ
1Fifo msgIn
full msgOut
msgIn 1 2 3
full false true true true false
data 0 1 1 1 1 3
msgOut 1 3
ë
É̺v·%ß´r¨ÄʶG RÎNÉÌ: ÇB
1Òp¨vÄÌ_ª¶v @
MÓ¬ vÉÅ/¨D ¨GaÞaÖÚßDÐß vß º_ºa©r©gÄI=ÌA?MÇOTUWV[X6Y[ZZÄÅ ¬ººW© !¬vg©Éʬ =Êa¸ ?fÕ4ºº_g©3©Ä
Ç9=Ìg¸ ?&© !¬vgÚ¶G RÎNÉÌÚ Ç TUWVGXOY[Z¨vNªg x¨vº« WÉʬ+Ú Ç/É̬©g¨Dg¬©¬MZÉʺ_¬ ÄÅW |
R\ RΩÉ"Ggg¬MÉÌ3ª ÄÌggÕ: NgÞ4ÉÊ¬Æ vÉÌ "(*),+-.,%3©ÄfÞ4ÉÌ3KÉ̬v 8¬vgªgÉÌÄÊ
ÄÌÉ̬vggÕ!i¬v|ÉÊ_¬Ç) TUWVGXOY[Zr¨ªaÚÉÅZ© !¬vg©_ÚÇÈÄÌÄÊ|ÖZgÕ
åKS¾ xéS å,S4é ¾aÀ¾ céISÙé À P ¿ é Á å ½a½ :ÉÌ3ÉÌÚ« Ôg¬KÇÈ63©g¬
T xªÄÊÄÌg© % ÖÉÊ m3¨ÐÉÌÄ&«©g
ÕÚ: vÉŬv ÉÊ_¬ Ç4ÉÌr8 ÄÌÄÊ|ÖZÝÇÈiШGgªÉ!Dªg|É̬Ç)©ÉÅÐÉʶvvg©¨ªag
ÖÉÊ ÄʪÄiªÄʪ«Ô ȨG_ÉʶvÄÌnÖÉÑ ©É"Ggg¬_ a$¬©zM¬Dª« v_¬vÉÌØg|ÉÊ_¬E¨GÉ̬MgÕ #WÎ_¬M
Î|ÄÊva ÇÝÉʺ_¬ Ä)|¨GÉ̬M ÇWÉÊ3_Õ8: v3ÐÇÝgάM«
ε=T ×V ÉÅ+ÄÅ|ÉÊ_¬³¶GÖÚ¬³º_
¬©ÎRÄÊg
V!Õ Ã ©g¬v vÉÊ3Ç4gÎg¬_
e ¶M t(e)ÕßâÉʺ_¬ Ä
s∈S :T →V ÉÌ3¨ÐÉÌÄ ÇȬª!ÉÊ_¬©v !¬vÉ̬vº3 vÎ| ÄÌv ÇBÐÉ̺¬D Ħ|Îg©É̪ª« É̬ǫ ºM NgÞgÎg¬_«:ÉʬmÉʺ_¬ Ä
rÉ̬_¬ ÄÌÄÌ]«©g©\ ¬©\ vÉ̺_ Ðra©mm¶DÖÚÄÌÄÑÒfÇȬ©g©!Õ ë _ÐÉ̺¬Ä
sÞÖÝ
©v¬v+ÉÊ
ià OgÎg¬_
i ∈ ¶N si
¬©Æ vÐv¶vÒpª« ÉʬO ÇÄ̬vº
n+ 1 ÐÐÉʬvº³ÇÈ_
ià
gÎg¬_i¶M
si...i+n
Õ: vrÐiÇWÎg¬Mi ÇßÉʺ_¬ Ä
s v¨m+ vr¨GÉ̬_
t ÉÌ©g¬v g©m¶N
[s]t
¬D© v
Ä̬º Ǧ vª« D É̬+ Ç/É̺¬Ä
sÉÅÝ©v¬vg©+¶N
|s| ∈ ∪ {∞}ÕGMÓ¬+ vÉÅÚ¨ ¨GaÞNÖÝ iª¬ª¬vg©
ÖÉÊ O¨vªgÐaª_¬_« É̬vÉ̬vºmÉʬ !¬vÉÊÈgªÉÌζDg RÎNÉÊ_gÕ B|ÖÝgÎaÞ4vgvÄÊrª¬Ë¶DgÉÌÄÊ
º_¬vgÄÊÉÌØa©3ª|Îg !D¬vÉѶDg RÎNÉÊ_gÞ_:ÖÝgÄÊÄfÕ
â¶G RÎNÉÌ
b∈B:X →S ÉÅ:¨D ÉÅ ÄGÇÈv¬ªÉ̬© !¬Éʬvº3Éʺ_¬ Ä@Î| ÄÌvgÝÇÈ_:©vÉ@¬MZÐÉ̺¬D Ä
¬D 3g:ÇÈ6 v
XÕ!i É̬ ÇWr¶Dg RÎNÉÊ_
b ÉÅ©v¬vg©¶N
vars(b) ¬D©¨vg¬M«ÐÉ̺¬Ä
¬D 3gZ ÔNÉ̬vº¨ÐÉ̬m vÉ̶Dg RÎNÉÊ_gÕâ;¨vªg
P ⊆B ÉÅKi ÇB¶Dg RÎNÉÊ_Z|ÎiKª_r3_¬
i ÇßÉʺ_¬ Ä&¬D 3gi© !¬Éʬvº©É"Ggg¬_¨DMÉ̶vÄʶDg RÎNÉÊ_ÇW¨vº« xKª3¨G¬vg¬_ !ÕÖÚ
¨ªag
P ¬© QgÜMÄ
P =QÚÉÊÇ vª¬M« É̬+ v3Ç4¶G RÎNÉÌ«Õ4W aª!É̬
Ç:¶G DRÎMÉÌ
b ¬ËmÇÚÎ| ÉÅ ¶vÄÌg
var ⊆X x©g¬v g©Æ¶N
b|var
ÉÌ©v !¬va©Í¶M\aÉŪ!Éʬº
v8©v É̬m ÇB v¶G RÎNÉÌ
varÕßgª!ÉÊ_¬m Çߨªa
P ¬ var x©v¬vg©]¶M©g¬v g©
¶N P|var
ÉÌ©v !¬va©Í¶M³¨vgªÉ̬³Ç:ÄÊÄBÉÊrg¶G¶G RÎNÉÌ«Õ$Mp«© ÄfÞ©v¬vg©Í¶N
b\var
cÐÉÌ3ÉÊÄÅ ÄÌÞ
P\var
!ÞÉÌZ3 vÐÒp ¬©ÇÈ_
b|vars(b)\var
Õ
´ ¬MÉŪZ Ç)¶É̪aÜ_D|É̬DÉʬ]TUWVGXOY[ZÉÌZ©v !¬va©Éʬm4 ¶vÄÌÞÉʬ3Z ÇB©¬v É̬ Ç) v
¶DÉ̪¨vªgggÕ
åKS¾ xéS Q¦¾g¿ å ¾aÁ S À S ê Q¦¾g¿ å ¾aÁ ç À &å,S Á å â¶Dg RÎNÉÊ_
b ÉÅKËЫª« vÉʬºÍÇ
¶G DRÎMÉÌ
c ©¬va©Æ¶M
b ≤c ÉÊÇZ ¬©Æ_¬vÄÌ\ÉÊÇ
vars(b) = vars(c) ¬©Í vKÉÅ«m¶Éaª!É̬
f :T →T ª«
∀t, u∈T, tu⇔f(t)f(u)
∀t∈T, tf(t)
∀x∈vars(b)dom(c(x)) =f(dom(b(x)))
∀x∈vars(b)∀t∈T, b(x)(t) =c(x)(f(t))
MÓ¬MÉÑÉÊÎ_ÄÌÞßЫª« vÉʬº\ª« ¬vºa +ÉÊ3mªg ÄÌK Çi¶Dg RÎNÉÊ_Ö vÉÊĄ̈vaÐgÎNÉ̬vºm vªg Ä
_©vÉʬvºMÕÖݶG RÎNÉÌ«
b ¬© c Ыª« ÍaÜMvÉÊÎ|ÄÊg¬_aÞ©g¬v g©Í¶N
b ≶cÞ/ÉÊÇZ ¬©Í_¬vÄʳÉÑÇ
vZNÉÅÐÚ¶G RÎNÉÌ
dÐDª«
d≤b ¬© d≤cÕB: v© !¬ÉÑÉÊ_¬+ Ç/Ыª« vÉ̬vº ¬D©ª«
aÜMvÉÊÎ|ÄÊg¬ª3ÉÅNg¬©g©\¨ªagÉ̬vºÄÌ3¬MÐÒpÖÉÅЪ_3¨ É̬\ ÇÚrg¶G¶G DRÎMÉÌ«gÕ
´Nª« 3ªÄÌ_vÝÇ@¨vªa4ÉÌß©¬va©¶N
P∗¬©8ÉÌB© !¬va©r_
{b|∃c∈P, b≶c}Õ4âÙ¨vNªg
P É̪« ÒÓªÄÌ_g©+ÉÑÇB ¬©¬ÄÊKÉÊÇ
P∗=PÕ
åKS¾ xéS Q æ6S Á/¿ éSé 4½ P Àv¿RÀ &&å & é é ½ ¾ xéS ´Ng ¬MÉŪÇWÐN¬ª« v¬:¨ÄÊÄÌÄ
ª3¨G_ÉÑÉÊ_¬ c©¬va©¶N
||s!ÞvÉÅZ© !¬vg©_ÚÇÈÄÌÄÊ|ÖZ&%
P ||sQ={d|X∪Y|∃(b, c)∈P×Q, d|X =b|X∧d|Y =c|Y}
Ö v
X =vars(P) ¬D© Y =vars(Q)Õ
Ýå ÏÀ zâZÄÌÄ>TUWVGXOY[Zr¨_º« ÝЪ« vÒpªÄÊMÐa©¦Õ
+- MÓ¬¨Ggª!Éʬº ÈÉ̬O4 ¶vÄÌm ÞÖÚ+3 D|¶_ÐÉŪKÐ 3g¬_«¨vgÎЪ« vÒpªÄÊMÐa©¬vggÕ
´M¬Dª« v_¬vD¨ « ÄÌÄÌĪ3¨G_ÉÑÉÊ_¬I ÄÅÐO¨vaÐgÎ_gª« ÒÓªÄÌ_g©¬g xÍã&3ϯEÉʬ v
â¨v¨G¬©ÉÊ !ÕÙ: NÞß vÄÌ3]ÇÈ_ÄÊÄÌ|ÖZr¶NÏ ¬Ùªv« ÄÚÉ̬©ªÉ̬n¬E vmЪ!v Çi v
¨_º« Õ
åKS
¾
xéS +å
&xÀ
À¾
céIS À S
ê &
éNè À &
å,S Á å
'Úg RÎNÉÊ_
b ÉÅKgÄÌ É̬mÇ
cÞ@©vÒ
¬ a©Ù¶N
c v b ÉÑǬ©Ù¬vÄÌÙÉÑÇ
vars(b) = vars(c) ¬©nÇÈ ÄÌÄ
x ∈ vars(b), b|{x} ≤ c|{x}
Õ
MÓ¬MvÉÑÉÊÎ_ÄÌÞNÄÅ|v|ÉÊ_¬Kª« vaÝ©É"@¬M:É̺¬ÄDÖÉÊ ¨DMÉʶÄÊ©É"Ggg¬MÚ«|g ÈÖ vÉŪ« +R3¬v
¨aÐgÎ_ªÄ/_©gÉ̬vº !Õ/ÖÚ+¶G RÎNÉÌ«
b ¬© c Û|ÖaÜ_ÉÊÎ| Ä̬MaÞ@©v¬vg©³¶N
b≈cÞ@ÉÑÇ
¬©3¬ÄÊ3ÉÊÇ
∃d, bvd∧cvdÕWZÄÅ|v|ÉÊ_¬rÇ&¨vNªgÐaBÉÅÝ© !¬va©KÐÉÌ3ÉÊÄÅ ÄÌ8¶N ¬KgÄÊg3¬MÐÒpÖÉÌ
ª3¨ÉÅÐ_¬+ǶG RÎNÉÌ«Õ
åKS¾ xéS +å,S À S Q S À &x½ 'Ú RÎNÉÌ
b[y/x]xÉÊ3ÉÌÄÌÄÌÞa¨vNªg
P[y/x]@ÉÌ& vßaÐvÄÊ
Ç߬rÉ̬vºÐÉ̺¬Ä)¬ 3
x ¶N 8ÇÈg \É̺¬Ä¬3
y y /∈vars(P)É̬ b xÉÊ3ÉÌÄÌÄÌÞ¦É̬\ÄÊÄ
¶G DRÎMÉÌ«ÚÉʬ
PÕ
- $& ')(+*) Ý
: ÍÉÊ Ç ÉÌgª!ÉÊ_¬ ÉÅÙºÉÌÎÍ ¬ ÉÌ3¨vÄÌ3¬M É̬ xÙª_¬ª³Ö:RnÇ83©ÄÌÄÌÉʬvº KÇ
_ÐN¬ª« _¬v¨D « ÄÌÄÊgÄݪ_3¨DMÐÉÊÉ̬ËÉ̬ TUWVGXOY[Z]Ä̬vºD º+ÐÉ̬vº³N¬ª« v¬v_ x¨D_Äʪ« v¬v_
ª¬ÐªgÕ
Ã
]Ð ÖÉÑ z© !¬ÉʬvºÆ vm¬vÉ̬n ÇM¬Dª« v_¬vD¨ÄÊÄÌĪ3¨DMÐÉÊÉ̬٠¬D©
gÐÉŪ!iÉʪg ÄÌÄÊ_©ga©m©ÉÅÉ̶vg©ÍÐÐÉ̬vºDÕ: v¬&Þ¦ÖÚ3Ð v|Ö |¨vÄŪÉʬvº¨vÄÌÉ̪ÉÑ
©|©¨G¬D©¬ªÉÊaÇWÖÚ+ª_r¨G¬¬MiÖÉÑ \¬]v¬N¶D_v¬©a© !vÇȶv @ x©v !¬va©³ ¬MÉ̪g ÄÌÄÊ
É̬ vg3ÉʬD© ÚÉ̪gª!ÉÌ3¨vÄÊg3¬M É̬ ÇBN¬ª« v¬v_:ª DĦ¨ « ÄÌÄÊgÄ/ª_3¨DMÐÉÊÉ̬&Õ
: ¬&ÞvÖÚÐZg¨vÄŪ vv¬N¶D_v¬©a©!vÇÈÖÉÑ !vÇÈKª« ¬v¬vÄÅ: ÇBr¶D_v¬©a©ÐÉÌØ_Õß/©
vÉÅÞNÖÚZÉʬNÎ_gÐÉ̺_| ª¬©ÉÊÉ̬DWv¬©vÚÖ vÉ̪« K vÉÅßÄÌg_©vß8ªgª!ÝÉÊ3¨vÄÌ3¬M«|É̬/Õ): ÉÌ
gªÉ̬K«W vZ v_ÉŪ ÄDºv¬D©3¬K©aÐN¬ª« v_¬vÉÌØg|ÉÊ_¬3ÇÈÝ3¨vÉÌÉŪÄD©aÐÉ̺¬KÉ̬ vZÇÈ_ÄÊÄÌ|ÖÉʬº
gªÉ̬&Õ
!"#$"%'&("*)+-,/.0!12342657"*89
: 3ÉʬÆÉÅ©g¶G Éʬ©Ë©vgM¬Dª« v_¬vÉÌØÉ̬vºÉÅÉÌ3¨vÄÊg3¬MÉ̬vºm vKN¬ª« v¬v_¨ « ÄÌÄÊgÄWª_r¨G Ò
ÉÊÉ̬ÆÉʬ TUWVGXOY[Z]©gÉʺ_¬Éʬº !vÇÈ]ª« ¬¬vÄÅÕ
ë
É̺±m©g¨vÉ̪mª« vg3 ÉŪ3ÎNÉÊgÖ; ÇZ©aÐN¬Ò
ª« _¬vÉÊØa|ÉÊ_¬&Õ MÓ¬Ë ÉÌ8¨vNªgÞ)¶NÍÉʬM©ªÉʬvº\ !vÇÈͪ« ¬v¬ÄWÇÈ_8aª« Ï©v ]©v¨G¬©g¬ªÆ_¬
