HAL Id: inria-00070371
https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00070371
Submitted on 19 May 2006
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
Distributed Multicast Tree Aggregation
Joanna Moulierac, Alexandre Guitton
To cite this version:
Joanna Moulierac, Alexandre Guitton. Distributed Multicast Tree Aggregation. [Research Report]
RR-5636, INRIA. 2005, pp.24. �inria-00070371�
ISRN INRIA/RR--5636--FR+ENG
a p p o r t
d e r e c h e r c h e
INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE
Distributed Multicast Tree Aggregation
Joanna Moulierac and Alexandre Guitton
N˚5636
Juillet 2005
Systèmes communicants
)+*,.- -/,102*43 57698;:<,+=?>,+- @BA578DCE,+- @ :F8HGI3 6KJ<J<*4-ML
NPORQTSVU'WYXFQZ'[DWYW]\_^a`bZFcd^;SVQ
egf [dhTXSjilkjmHnok
kjcdp_p+[ f SjqRX f XFZsr_X f Zsr_Xt^vuxwdyxzDyH{}|x\_`b~~bXSlDD;w%{}dP[D^;SVX'^;SVQVQ X<ZSV`[x^+P$pacDDX<Q
EF'_DD m?\_~S`Z'cxQTS$`Q%^_[dS$QVZ'cd~cda~XWcd`b^_~OIq_\_XS[Sr_X^P\_Wv.X f [Dg[ fV c f qR`^aQ SVcSVXFQ%cd^.q
Z'[D^;S f [D~[DX f r_X<cDq f XF;\_`f X<qS[WYcD`^;Sscd`b^?S f X'X<Q'o f X'XcdD f XFxcdS`b[D^ fX<qR\aZX<QjSVr_X^;\aW]+X f [dgW]\a~
SV`bZFcDQ S[ fV c f qR`^aIQTSscSX<QvcD^aqSraXS f XFX Wcd`b^xSVX'^acD^aZX[DX f r_X<cDqPO¡cD~~b[ `b^_IQ XFDX f cD~gW]\_~S`Z'cxQTS
f [x\_paQjS[Qrac fX$SVr_XYQcDWXqRX'~b`bDX f OS f X'XD%¢£^?SVr_`Qlp.cdp+X f<¤+ X]X'¥Rr_`a`S$Q XFDX f cD~q f c acDZs¦RQ[DgSr_X
X'¥R`bQ S`b^_]p f [DS[RZ[x~bQF§SVr_Xo~bcdSX'^.ZOS[Wcd^acDDX¨ f [x\_p qROP^acDW`Z'Q`Qr_`xr ¤ Sr_XoWcd^acDDX f Qc f XlZ f `S`Z'cd~
p+[D`b^;SVQ/[D.KcD`~b\ f XFQgcD^aqYQ [xWYX f [D\_pR£Qp.X<Z`©.ZX'^;S f `X<Qgc f XQTSV[ f XFq\_^_^aXFZX<QQVc f `b~Oxªr_XF^ ¤D Xp f [Dp+[xQX
c«^aX qR`QTS f `b_\RSVXFq¡p f [dSV[PZ'[D~/SVracSQ `bD^_`©.ZFcd^;S~bO f XFqR\.ZXFQ$Sr_X ^P\_Wv.X f [DZ'[D^;S f [D~/WYX<QQVcdxXFQ$cd^.q
~b`bW`SVQvSVr_X«^;\aW]+X f [djS f XFXFQ `SVr_`b^¬cqR[DWcD`^®O®Q`Wv\_~cS`b[D^.Q ¤/ XQr_[ SVracS[D\ f p f [dSV[RZ[D~
cxZsr_`bX'DX<QD[P[Rqp+X f [ f Wcd^aZ'XocD^aq[x\RSp+X f [ f WQSr_X$p f XF;`b[D\.Q¦P^_[ ^«qR`QTS f `b_\RSVXFq«cd~bD[ f `SraW
¯?°;±4²V³]´ µED S f XFXcdx f X'xcdS`b[D^ ¤ cdx f X'xcdSX<qW]\_~S`Z'cxQTS ¤ ^_X'S [ f ¦RQ
¶·¸¹»ºF¼ª¸½E¾b¹»¿9ÀÁ
ÂÃ7ÄÅsÆÇÆÇÅ<ÈÉÄÊÇËÌÍTÎ9ÅsÏÐEÌÎKÌÑ»Å<ÈÒÎ
Ó
ÅsËÍTÔ<ÅsÆÇÕÇÎKÍÈÖÊÇÌ×K×9ÄÆdÐEÌÎKÌÑ»Å<ÈÒÎ
Xm?\_~S`Z'cxQTS]^X<QTSpacDQ]X'^aZ'[ f X_`XF^®q'pa~[Oq_cd^.Q$¢£^;SX f ^_X'SF X<Q]qRXF\R¥ f cD`bQ[D^.Q
p f`b^aZ`bpacD~X<Qj;\_`f X'`b^_X'^;S%Q [x^«q'p_~b[D`bX'WYX'^;SlQ[D^;S]§~bX]^_[xW] f XqSVcdSVQlqRX f [D\RSscdDX$`bWYp.[ f Sscd^;Sl;\_`
q'p+X'^aqqR\«^_[DWv f XoqRX% f [x\_p.X<QXS~X%^_[xW] f X%qRX%WX<QQVcdxXFQqRX$Z[x^xS f ~Xo^<ZXFQVQVcd`f X<Q p+[D\ f Wcd`b^R
SVX'^_`f ~bXFQlc f f XFQªW]\a~SV`bZFcDQ Slq_cd^.Qj\_^ q_[DWcd`b^_XqRX f [x\RSVcDDXD cd f FxcdS`b[D^qc f f XFQjW]\_~S`Z'cxQTS¨X<QTS
\a^p f [dSV[RZ[D~bXl;\_`p+X f WYXSjqRX f FQ[D\aq f XlZ'XFQªqRXF\R¥p f [D_~bU'WYX<QXF^p+X f WYXSSVcd^;Svp_~\.Q `bX'\ f Q f [D\_p+XFQ
Wv\_~S`Z'cDQ S q\RS`b~`QX f ~X«W'WYXIc f f Xq_X f [D\_SVcdxXDlcD^aQYZX«pacdpa`X fF¤ ^_[D\aQYq'SVcD`~b~[x^aQYp_~b\aQ`XF\ f Q
`b^aZ'[D^PF^_`XF^;SVQZ'[D^aZ'X f ^acd^;S~bXFQp f [DS[RZ[x~X<Q f <cd~b`bQVcd^;S$~cD f 'xcdS`b[D^¡qc f f X<Q' g^ X"!4XS ¤ q_cD^aQ]Z'XFQ
p f[DS[RZ[x~X<Q ¤ ~bc~cSXF^aZX?p+[D\ f f X f ~c qROP^acDW`Z`S?qRX<Q f [D\ap.X<QYXFQ S f cd^aqRX ¤ ~bXFQxXFQ S`b[D^_^.cd`f X<Q
qcD f 'xcdS`b[D^IQ[D^;S$qRXFQop+[D`b^xSsQ$Z f `SV`b;\_X<Qlqacd^aQ%~bXZFcDQ%qRXpacd^a^_XFQoXSqRX<Q%X'^;Sf 'X<QlQp#FZ`©.;\_X<QocD\R¥
f [x\_p+XFQ Q[D^;SQ S[R;\FXFQ `b^P\RS`b~bX'WYX'^;SF%$j[x\aQ p f [xp.[;Q [x^aQ\_^2^_[D\_xXFcD\¬p f [DS[RZ[x~X q_`bQ S f `a\H;\_`
f
Fq_\_`S ~bX?^_[xW]
f
X?qRX?WYXFQVQcDDXFQYqRXIZ'[D^;S
f&
~bXX'^PD[OFQXS;\_`j~b`bW`SX?~bX?^_[xW]
f
X?qc f f X<Qqacd^aQ
\a^qR[xWcd`b^_XD
e c f
q_XFQ%Q `bW]\a~bcdS`b[D^aQ
¤
^_[D\.Qlp
f
[x\_D[x^aQ¨;\_XY^_[DS
f
Xvp
f
[dSV[RZ[D~bXvcqRXY_`bX'^HWXF`~b~bX'\
f
XFQ
p+X f [ f Wcd^aZ'XFQª;\_X%~X%SV[D\RS¨q_X f ^_`X f p f [dS[RZ'[D~bXoqR`Q S f `_\'%Z'[D^_^P\
( ´ < ² ) i¨ f ';cS`b[D^qc f f X<Q ¤ Wv\_~SV`bZFcDQ S ¤Rf FQXFcD\R¥
(v & &(
`Sr1SraX«q_X'DXF~[xp_WYX'^;SY[d¨¢£^;SX f ^aXS ¤ Q XFDX f cD~Wv\_~SV`WYX<qR`bccdpap_~`Z'cdS`b[D^aQ`b^aZ~b\aqR`b^_ f [D\_p¬Z[xWv
Wv\_^_`Z'cdS`b[D^aQr.cÇDX$+X'X'^Iq_X'p_~b[ODX<qmI\_~SV`bZFcDQ Slcd~b~b[ QªS[Y[ f c f qSr_Xp.cDZs¦DX'SVQª[ f f [D\apaQ[D^?cD^
X Z`bX'^;S cÇOIZ'[D^aZ'X f ^_`b^_«acd^aq `bqPSVr ¢£^aq_X'XFq ¤ `b^aQTSVXFcxqH[DªQX'^.qR`^a«QX'xX f cd~ \_^_`Z'cxQTSp.cDZs¦DX'SVQlS[
SVr_XWYX'Wv.X f Qj[d Sr_X] f [D\_paQ ¤ W]\a~SV`bZFcDQ SlZ[x^aQ `Q SVQ`b^IQ XF^aqR`b^_[D^a~O[D^_X$pacxZs¦DX'SS[SVr_X]cDqaq f X<QQª[D
SVr_XW]\_~S`Z'cxQTSo f [D\_p%ªr_XpacDZs¦xXSo`bQoqR\_p_~b`Z'cSVXFqHcS¨SVr_XY f cd^aZsr_`b^_ ^a[Pq_XFQl[dgSVr_X]Sf XFXvZ'[DX f `b^_
SVr_Xo f [D\_pj^_[ f S\_^acdSXF~O ¤ Wv\_~SV`bZFcDQ S`Q^_[dS XF~~4qRXFp_~[OxXFqY[xX f SVr_Xo¢£^xSVX f ^_XS< nl^_X¨[DSr_XoWcd`b^
~b`bW`SVQ%[D SVr_X qRX'pa~[OPWYX'^;S%[dWv\_~S`Z'cDQ S$`bQoSVr_XQZFcd~bXv[D SVr_XY[ fV c f q_`^_QTSscSVXFQ%cd^aq SraXYZ'[D^;S f [D~
[xX f r_XFcxq f XF;\_`f X<q SV[WcD`^;SVcD`^SraX%S f X'XFQF ¢£^«\_^_`Z'cDQ S ¤ SVr_X%[ fV c f qR`^aQ SVcdSXFQZFcd^.XcDD fXFxcS
X<q
¤
cD^aq`b^«Sra`bQ
cÇOYSraXQ `'X$[DSVr_X%[
fV
c f
q_`^_vSVcD_~bXo`Q
f
XFqR\.ZXFqj[
X'DX
fF¤
SVr_XQcDWYXQ [x~\RSV`[x^
ZFcd^_^a[dSl+XvcDp_p_~b`X<q?SV[¢
e
Wv\_~S`Z'cDQ SocxQjSVr_XW]\_~S`Z'cxQTS%cDq_q
f
XFQVQXFQ¨q_[^_[DS
f
X! aX<ZSoSr_Xv~[RZ'cdS`b[D^I[D
SVr_X WYX'Wv.X f Q]cd^aq+XFZ'cD\aQX[dªSr_X f [D\_p¡qROP^acdWY`Z'QFmI[ f X'[DX fF¤ Z'[D^aZ'X f ^_`b^_Sr_XS f XFXWcd`b^xSVX
^.cd^aZ'X[ f W]\_~S`Z'cxQTS ¤ Z'[D^;S f [D~aWX<QQVcdxXFQgS f cÇDX f QXSVr_X¨^aXS [ f ¦cD^aqY\RS`b~b`"FXoc$~c f DXjcDWY[D\_^;S[DSr_X
^aXS [ f ¦ f X<Q [x\ f Z'XFQF
f XFXjcdx f X'xcdS`b[D^`Qgc f XFZ'X'^;S/p f [xp.[;Q `S`b[D^vSr.cS f XFqR\aZ'XFQ SVr_X^P\_W]+X f [d4W]\_~S`Z'cxQTS/[ f c f qR`b^_
Q SVcdSX<Q/S[xDX'Sr_X f `SrSVr_X¨S f XFXjWcd`b^;SX'^.cd^aZ'Xj[DX fr_X<cDqEªr_X¨WcD`^ `qRX<c$[dS f XFXlcdx f X';cS`b[D^v`bQ S[
[ f Z'X]Wv\_~SV`pa~XYW]\a~SV`bZFcDQ S% f [x\_paQ¨S[«Q r.c f X]SVr_XQVcdWYXYqRX'~b`bDX f O«S f X'X `Sr_`b^cqR[xWYcD`^]i ~bcD.XF~¤
ra`bZsr Z'[ fVf X<Q p+[D^.q_QoS[ Sr_XqRX'~b`xX f O S f XFXcd^.q `bQQ`x^_`©+Z'cd^;S][x^_~bOH`b^ SraXqR[xWYcD`^ ¤ `bQvcDq_qRX<q¡S[
XFDX f OIWv\_~S`Z'cDQ SpacxZs¦DXScdS]`^a f XFQVQ f[x\RSX f Q$cD^aq f XFW[xXFqcSXF f XFQVQ f[x\RSX f QF ¢£^Sr_`Q cÇO ¤ Sr_X
^P\_Wv.X f [dE[ fV c f qR`^aYQ SVcdSX<Q`^SVr_X]qR[xWYcD`^?qRXFp.XF^aq_Q¨[D^_~bO[x^SVr_X^P\_Wv.X f [d S f X'X<Q`b^aQTSVXFcxq[D
[x^«Sr_Xv^P\_W]+X f [dg f [D\apaQ'iq_q_`SV`[x^acd~b~O ¤ SVr_XvZ'[D^;S f [D~[DX f r_X<cDq`bQ f X<qR\aZ'XFq?Q`^aZ'X$X S f XFXFQlc f X
a\_`~SF
egf
[dSV[RZ[D~Q%cDZsr_`bX'P`b^_ S
f
XFXcDD
f
XFxcSV`[x^?racÇDX]S[WcSVZsr
f
[D\apaQjSV[S
f
XFXFQoX! Z'`XF^xSV~OIcD^aqQ XFx
X f
cD~gQ [x~\_S`b[D^aQ%racÇxXv+X'XF^ p f
[Dp+[xQXFqI`b^Sr_X~`SX
f
cdS\
f
XD#j[
X'xX
f<¤
cd~b~ SraX Z\
fVf XF^;S%p
f
[xp.[;Q `S`b[D^aQ
Q\!4X
f f
[xWQX'xX
f
cd~q
f c
acxZs¦PQFª¢£^ cd~b~SVr_XFQXp
f
[dSV[RZ[D~Q
¤
c Z'X'^;S
f
cd~b`"FXFq«Wcd^.cdDX
f
`Qj`b^ Zsrac
f
DX$[D
p+X f [ f WY`^acdx f X'xcdS`b[D^aQFªraX f [D\RSVX f Qj[d SVr_XvqR[xWcd`b^ fX<x\aXFQ S¨Sra`bQ¨WYcD^acdxX fj raX'^?SVr_X'O«racÇxX
SV[Y[ fV c f qpacDZs¦xXSsQ[ f f [x\_paQªcd^aq`b^«Sr_`Q cÇOSraXWcd^acDDX f `QjcZ f `S`Z'cd~p+[D`b^;S¨[dEKcd`b~b\ f Xxg¢£^R
q_X'XFq ¤x r_XF^YSr_X¨WYcD^acdxX f KcD`~Q ¤ ^_[$WY[ f Xjcdx f X';cS`b[D^.QEZFcd^Y+XlcDZsra`XFDXFqm?[ f XF[DX f<¤ \_p+[D^ f[x\_p
Zsr.cd^_xXFQ ¤ Sr_XY+[ f qRX f%f [D\RSVX f SracdS]qRXSVXFZSVQoSraXYZsr.cd^_xXFQ%Q ORQ SXFWYcdS`Z'cD~~bO f X<;\_XFQ SVQlSra`bQ$WcD^acdxX f<¤
ra`bZsr`^.qR\aZX<Q~cSXF^aZO [ f SraX$ f [D\_paQF
¢£^SVr_`Q pacDp.X fF¤; X¨p f [Dp+[xQXjc^_X qR`bQ S f `b_\RSX<qp f [dSV[PZ'[D~a[ f S f XFXlcDD f X';cSV`[x^¢£^ cDqaqR`SV`[x^S[
f XFq_\aZ`b^_%SraXj^P\_W]+X f [d4[ fV c f q_`^_%XF^xS f `bXFQ cd^aqvSraXjS f X'XWcD`^;SXF^acd^.ZXj[xX f r_XFcxq ¤ [D\ f p f [DS[RZ[x~7§
$
`&% `bQW]\aZsr ~bXFQVQQ\_RhTX<ZS SV[ Kcd`b~b\ f X<QSVracd^ SVr_X X'¥P`Q S`b^_®p f [dSV[PZ'[D~QcDQ`S`bQ \_~~bO qR`QTS f `b_\RSVXFq ¤
$
``%v`^.qR\aZX<Qc WY`b^_`bWYcD~~bcdSXF^aZO¡SV[qRX<cd~ `Sr¬ f [D\_p¬qROP^acdWY`Z'QYcd^aq
$
`b``%qR[PXFQY^_[DSYQ S[ f X«cd^PO
f [x\_pR£Q p+XFZ'`©+Z¨XF^xS f `bXFQF
ªr_X
f
XFQ S[d¨SVr_X?pacDp.X
f
`QY[
f
xcD^_`'XFq1cDQv[D~b~b[
Q' NPXFZS`b[D^ Hp
f
X<Q XF^;SVQvSr_X«Wcd`b^¬p
f
[DS[RZ[x~bQ
cxZsr_`bX'P`^a?S
f
X'XcdD
f
XFxcdS`b[D^ cd^aq qRXFQVZ
f
`+XFQ]SraXq
f c
acDZs¦RQ][dSra`bQv
f
cdWYX
[ f
¦4I¢£^¬NPX<ZSV`[x^ z ¤
[x\
f p f
[dSV[PZ'[D~ omIEi `Q$p
f
XFQX'^;SX<q¢£^ NPX<ZSV`[x^
¤
X qR`QZ'\aQVQcd+[D\RS$SVr_XcxqRcd^;SVcDDXFQ%cD^aqSr_X
q f c
acxZs¦RQª[d omIi]ªr_X
f
XFQ\_~SVQl[d/SraXvQ`Wv\_~bcdS`b[D^aQlc
f
X]qRX'SVcd`b~bXFq?`b^HNPX<ZS`b[D^wR'E`b^acd~b~bO
¤
Sr_X
p+X
f
Qp.X<ZS`bDX<Qª[dE[D\
f
[ f
¦ c
f
X%D`bDX'^`^INPX<ZSV`[x^«y_
'% &
f X'X cdx f X';cS`b[D^ cxQ%© f QTSvp f [xp.[;Q X<q`^Fcd^.q Q `b^aZX ¤ QX'xX f cd~gp f[DS[RZ[x~bQ%acxQ X<q¡[D^S f X'Xcdd
f X<cdDS`b[D^¡racÇDX.XFX'^1p f [xp.[;Q X<q '_[ f f X'P`STO ¤/ X `b~~qRX<QZ f`b+Xr_X f X[D^_~bO i¨m ¤ r_`Zsr `QvSr_X
© f Q S¨ZXF^xSf cD~`'X<qp f [DS[RZ[x~¤ cD^aq« i¨m ¤. r_`Zsr?`bQjq_XFZXF^;S f cd~b`"FXFqn¨Sr_X f p f [dS[RZ'[D~QSracdS¨cDZsr_`bX'xX
S f XFXjcdx f X'xcdS`b[D^c f XªilmIªjN_Sr.cS p+X f [ f WQgQ \aR7S f XFXjcdx f X'xcdS`b[D^ ¤ NREi.SracdS p+X f [ f Wv
Q$KcDQ Svcdx f X'xcdS`b[D^aQ ¤ ilNaNRm SVracS]`Q]q_XFQ`x^_XFqH[ f Q [x\ f Z'X£Q p+XFZ'`©+ZY f [D\_paQ ¤ i l[PNRm!wcd^.q
¨TNREi"FzSracdSoqRX<cd~ `Sr?.cd^aq `qPSVr Z[x^aQTS f cD`^;SsQ ¤ cD^aq?¨nomIi"<SVracSlq_XFcd~Q `Sr [DX f ~cÇO
Wv\_~S`Z'cDQ SF/ªr_X<Q X$p f [DS[RZ[x~bQªc f Xo^_[dS¨qRX<QZ f `b+XFq`^Sra`bQp.cdp+X f
#%$'& (*),+.-0/213-4)657-98:/2/<;>=6=68:/2=,;-:?'),+
f X'Xgcdx f X';cS`b[D^ f X<qR\aZ'XFQSVr_Xg^P\_Wv.X f [dRWv\_~SV`bZFcDQ S[ fV c f qR`^aªQ SVcdSX<Qcd^.q¨SVr_XgS f XFXgWcd`b^;SX'^.cd^aZ'X
[xX f r_XFcxq¨[cxZsr_`XFDX$SVr_`Q f XFq_\aZSV`[x^ ¤ QX'xX f cd~W]\_~S`Z'cxQTSo f [D\_paQlQ r.c f X$Sr_XYQVcdWYXvqRXF~`bDX f OS f X'X
`Sra`^ c¡qR[DWcd`b^ [D^aQXF;\_XF^xSV~O ¤ ~bXFQVQ]S f XFXFQc f X_\_`b~SSVracd^ `SVr S f cxqR`S`b[D^acD~Wv\_~S`Z'cDQ SF¬[
cDD f XFxcSVXQ XFDX f cD~ f [D\apaQjSV[ SVr_XQcDWX]S f X'X ¤ c~cd+X'~/Z[ ff XFQp.[x^aqR`b^_SV[SVr_X]Sf XFXv`QocDQVQ `bD^_X<q«S[
cD~~SraXvWv\_~SV`bZFcDQ Sop.cDZs¦DX'SVQlcSoSr_X`^a f XFQVQ f [D\RSVX f Qj[DgSr_XYqR[xWYcD`^o¢£^ Sr_XYqR[xWYcD`^ ¤ SVr_XpacDZs¦xXSVQ
c f Xj[ fV c f qRX<qYcDZ'Z'[ f qR`b^_%S[]Sr_`Q~bcD.XF~7/ªr_Xl~bcD.XF~.`Q f X'WY[xXFqYcSSr_XoX' f X<QQ f [D\_SX f Q Q[$SVracSSr_X
p.cDZs¦DX'SVQªZ'cD^+X%[
fV
c f
qRXFq[D\RSsQ `qRXoSr_Xq_[DWcd`b^
¢£^?cDqaqR`SV`[x^S[Sr_X$Wv\_~S`Z'cDQ S[
fV
c f
qR`^avQ SVcSVXFQSVracS¨cD~~b[
SV[WcdSVZsr?cd^`^.Z[DWY`b^_Y~bcD.XF~S[
c?QXSv[dª[D\RSVD[D`b^_«`b^xSVX
f
KcDZ'XFQ
¤
SVr_X +[
f
qRX
f$f [D\RSVX
f
Q%[dªSraXqR[DWcD`^¡racÇxX
f
[D\_pR£Qp.X<Z`©.ZX'^;S
f
`X<Q'
ªraXFQX%Q SVcdSX<QªWYcdSVZsr
f
[D\_p«cDqaq
f
X<QQXFQSV[~cd+X'~Qcd^.qSVr_X'Oc
f
XoQ S[
f
X<q`b^?c
f
[D\_pR»~cd+X'~+SVcD_~Xx
#%$@# ACBEDF;HGI/J+.-08K;>L?NMO/JPRQ 8K)S-9)TGI).L
i¨D fXFxcSVXFqm?\_~S`Z'cDQ S
$
ilm % cDQªp f [Dp+[xQXFq`^UF ¤ y»g¢£^?i¨m ¤ cZ'X'^;S f cd~b`'XFqX'^;SV`STOZ'cd~b~bXFqSr_X
S f XFX$Wcd^acDDX f `Q`b^«Zsr.c f DX%[d WcSVZsra`^_Y f[x\_paQS[~cd+X'~QjcD^aq`^R[ f WY`b^_YSraX$.[ f qRX ff[x\RSX f Qª[D
SVr_`QWcSVZsra`^_. ªr_`QªS f X'X$WcD^acdxX f ¦P^_[ QSr_XvQ X'Sj[d/cd~b~4Sr_XWv\_~S`Z'cDQ SS f X'X<QZ[x^R©aD\ f X<q`b^«Sr_X
q_[DWcd`b^
XSj\aQjZ'[D^aQ`qRX
f
SVr_X]qR[xWYcD`^«qRXFp_`bZSX<q«[D^ 'E`x\
f
X x
r_X'^SVr_X+[
f
qRX
ff [D\RSVX
f VW%f
XFZ'X'`bDX<Qc
X0Y[Z]\
WYXFQVQVcdDXg[
f
Sr_X
f
[D\_p_^ $WYXFQVQVcdDX % ¤
`SEQX'^.q_Qc
f
X<;\_XFQ SS[¨Sr_XS
f
X'XWcd^acDDX
f $WYXFQVQcDDX%
ªraX S
f
X'XWcd^acDDX
f
¦P^_[
Q$SVracS
Va`
cD^aq
Vcb
racÇDXcd~
f
X<cDqROhT[D`b^_XFq Sr_X
f
[D\_pd^4Hªra`bQWcd^acDDX
f
QXFc
f
ZsraXFQo[
f
cS
f
X'Xfel[
f
Sr_XcDD
f
XFxcSV`[x^I[dT^ $cd~bD[
f
`Sr_W zDc %ǻr_XS
f
X'X7e%racxQ%S[HZ[DX
f
Sr_X
f
[D\_SX
f Q Vg`<¤2VW
cD^aq
Vcb
cd^aq?r.cDQ¨S[QVcSV`bQ O«acd^.q
`bqRSr Z'[D^aQ S
f
cd`b^;SVQFj¢»c ZFcd^aqR`q_cdSXS
f
XFX[
f
^«`bQ
[x\_^aq ¤ ^`bQ]WYcdSVZsr_X<qS[?SVr_X ~cd+X'~[dªSraXS f X'Xx?¢»SVr_X f X `Q^_[HZ'cd^.qR`bqacSX S f X'X[ f ^ ¤ SVr_XS f X'X
WcD^acdxX f Z'[D^R©.D\ f XFQcI^_X S f X'X`b^ SVr_Xq_[DWcd`b^1cD^aq cxq_q_Qv`S`b^®SraXWv\_~S`Z'cDQ S]S f XFXQXScSVX f
r.cÇ;`b^_YcDQVQ `bD^aXFqcv~cd+X'~2hSV[YSr_`Q^_X Sf X'Xx
nl^aZ'Xcl~cd+X'~P`bQ WcdSVZsr_X<q$S[%cl f [D\_p ¤ SVr_XSf X'XWYcD^acdxX f `^_[ f WYQSVr_X+[ f qRX fEf [D\_SX f QEcS SscDZsr_X<q
SV[$WYX'W]+X f Q [d+SraX f [D\_p[d+Sr_XWcdSVZsr_`b^_$[di^$S[jh
$
WYXFQVQcDDX %/ªr_XFO]cd~b~acxq_qYcl f[x\_pR£Q p+XFZ'`©+Z
XF^;S f Od^lkmh¨`b^®SVr_X'`f f [D\apR9~cd+X'~ SVcD_~Xx1ªr_Xp f [RZXFQVQv`bQQ`WY`b~bc fv raX'^ cdnpo0qr9o WYXFQVQcDDX`bQ
f XFZ'X'`bDX<q
^
Va`cVWcVcb Vg`
V
V W
Vcb
x§! #"%$'&() '&$'*,+.-
_§/&0*,2131$)145(1&67!89' ':&
zxc_§;' !& <1=>$8?$'"@-1$AB1&
.§;*,+DC,<1#$'"E14,# !&$*,+GFH+IJ=LK9J681&M7"N$!&O-
'E`bD\
f
X D§g
f
XFX%cDD
f
XFxcSV`[x^
`SVr?i¨m
#%$QP RTS ACB D ; P /JGI/J+.-98:;SL'?NMO/P QF8:)S-9)%GI),L
`qR`f X<ZS`b[D^.cd~.i¨D f XFxcSVXFqm?\a~SV`bZFcDQ S
$ ilm % cxQgp f [Dp+[xQXFq `^ >U]»/[]Sr_Xo+XFQ S[D[D\ f ¦P^_[ ~
X<qRDX ¤ i¨m `bQoSVr_Xv[x^_~bOIqRXFZ'X'^;S f cd~b`"FXFq?p f [DS[RZ[x~SVracScDZsra`XFDXFQjS f X'XYcdx f X'xcdS`b[D^o¢£^H ilm ¤
SVr_X$SscDQ¦[DESVr_X$S fXFXWcd^acDDX f `Q¨q_`bQ Sf `a\RSX<q?cdWY[D^_ QX'xX f cd~ f [D\RSVX f Q ¤ Z'cD~~bXFq«Z[ f X f [D\_SX f QFªr_X
QXS[dWv\_~SV`bZFcDQ S S f XFXFQ`bQcd~Q []acd~cd^aZ'XFq cDWY[D^_$SVr_XFQXlZ'[ f X f [D\RSVX f Q' X'S\aQªZ[x^aQ`bqRX f SVr_XlqR[xWcd`b^
q_X'p_`ZSVXFq [x^ 'E`x\
f
XP
r_XF^ SraX+[
f
qRX
fvf [x\RSX
f V W f
X<ZX'`bDX<Qc
X0Y[Z]\
WYXFQVQcDDX[
f
SVr_X
f
[x\_p
^ $WYXFQVQcDDX % ¤
`S]QX'^.q_Q$c
f
X<x\aXFQ SoSV[Sr_X qRX<qR`Z'cSVXFqZ[
f X f [D\RSVX
f
`^ Zsrac
f
xX][D.^ $WX<QQVcdxXY%
ªra`bQoqRXFq_`bZFcSX<qIZ[
f X f [x\RSX
f $[xRSVcD`^aXFq?\aQ`b^_cracDQr«\_^aZS`b[D^ %lQ X<c
f
Zsr_XFQj[
f
cS
f
X'X][
f
^`b^ `SVQ
[ ^ W]\_~S`Z'cxQTSoSf X'XYQ X'S $cd~bD[ f `Sr_W zxc%$¢»Sr_`Qo`^a`SV`bcD~ Z'[ f X f [D\RSVX f qR[PXFQo^_[DSl©a^.qHcZ'cd^.qR`bqacSX
S f XFX ¤ `S f XF;\_X<QTSsQcD~~+SVr_Xl[DSr_X f Z[ f X f [D\_SX f Q $WYXFQVQcDDXlzD %gªraX'O QXFc f Zsr`b^SVr_X'`f [ ^ W]\_~S`Z'cxQTS
S f XFXQ X'S $cd~bD[ f `Sr_WzxZ-%ocd^.q f X'p_~bO?SV[SVr_X`b^_`SV`bcD~gZ[ f X f [D\RSVX f `Sr_XFO racÇxX][x\_^aq¡cZ'cd^.qR`bqacSX
S f XFX
$
WYXFQVQcDDX$zDq % ªr_XF^ ¤ SVr_XqRXFq_`bZFcSX<q«Z[ f X f [x\RSX f Zsr_[P[xQXFQªcdWY[x^_cd~b~Sr_XcD^aQ X f QSraX.X<QTS
ZFcd^aq_`bq_cdSXS f X'XY[ f ^ $
cD~x[ f `SVr_W zDX %l[ f _\_`b~bq_Q]c«^_X S f X'Xx 'E`^acD~~bO ¤ Sr_XZ[ f X f [x\RSX f `^R[ f WQ
cD~~ SVr_XY.[ f q_X f%f [x\RSX f Q%cdS SVcxZsr_XFqIS[«WYX'Wv.X f Q%[D,^I[dSr_XYWcSsZsr_`b^_^ k h $
WYXFQVQcDDX %ªr_X
+[ f qRX ff [D\_SX f QcDqaq SVr_X$ f [D\_p_»Qp.X<Z`©.ZlX'^;S f O7^ k hE`b^Sr_XF`f f [x\_pR»~bcD.XF~.Sscd_~bXD
ªr_XWYX<Zsracd^_`QW \aQ X<q PO ilm `bQ$Q`WY`b~bc f S[SraXWYX<Zsracd^_`QW\aQXFqH;OHi¨m ¤ X'¥_ZX'p_SoSVracS
SVr_XW]\_~S`Z'cxQTSoS f X'XQ X'So`Qoacd~cd^aZ'XFqIcDWY[D^_cd~b~SVr_XYZ[ f X f [D\_SX f QFl¢»SZ'cD^I+X^a[dS`ZX<q«Sr.cScd~bD[D
f `Sr_W#zDZcD^aq«cd~bD[ f `Sr_WzdX`b^I i¨m c f X%KcDQ SX f SracD^Icd~bD[ f `Sr_WzDZ$`b^Ii¨m ¤ Q `b^aZ'X$X X f Sf X'XFQ
c f XoX'cD~\acdSX<q
^
Va`cVWcVcb Vg`
V
V W
Vcb
zd§/&0*521O1$A 14,#J:$'&6&$*G1:&
zxZd§ ! !& <1=$'8 $'"@-1$A 1& '6!'
zDq§/&:+LM.1$ 14,6=>8,=L1= J$!& &$'*51:&
zDXD§;:J:1=>$8?$'" BJ'8,C5=C,<1
'E`x\
f
X$R§g
f
X'X$cdx
f
X'xcdS`b[D^
`Sr? i¨m®
#%$ 8:;F;>G )65 - / /21%?-9?+ = Q 8:)S-9)%GI),L
ªraXop f [DS[RZ[x~bQSr.cS¨cDZsra`XFDXlS f X'Xcdx f X';cS`b[D^ Q\!4X f f [DW Sr f X'X%Wcd`b^?q f c .cDZs¦RQ'
'E`f Q S ¤ Sr_X«S fXFXWcd^.cdDX f cD^aq Sr_X?Z[ f X f [D\RSVX f Qvc f X«Z f `SV`bZFcd~ªp+[D`b^xS[D¨Kcd`b~b\ f X<Q'1¢£^¬ilm ¤ `
SVr_XvZ'X'^;S f cd~b`'XFqS fXFXWcd^acDDX f Kcd`b~bQ ¤ pacxZs¦DX'SVQ¨ZFcd^IQ S`b~~.X][ fV c f q_XFq_\RSo^_[ ^_X f [x\_pIZ'cD^?.X
cxZ'Z'X'pRSVXFqI`b^HSr_XqR[xWYcD`^cd^aqISr_XY f[x\_p WYX'Wv.X f Qr_`bpaQ%c f X]\_^.cd_~bXS[«Zsracd^_xX
$
WX<QQVcdxXFQ
X0Y[Zg\
cD^aq npo0qr9o
[x\_~q$^_[dS +Xp
f
[RZX<QQXFq %¢£^v ilm
¤
`+c¨Z[
f X f [x\RSX
f
KcD`~Q
¤
cD~~;SraX f
[D\apaQcxQQ[RZ`cSX<q
SV[Sr_`QjZ[
f X f [D\RSVX
f c f
X%_`b^aqRXFqSV[vSVr_X'`
f
Z'\
ff X'^;SS
f
X'X<Q'
NPX<Z[x^aq
¤
SraXIWcd^acDDX'WYXF^xS [D%Sr_XI
f
[x\_paQ`b^aqR\.ZXFQQ `bD^a`©.ZFcd^;SZ[x^;S
f
[D~j[xX
f
r_XFcxqM¢£^Bilm
$f X<Q p+XFZS`bDXF~OY i¨m % ¤ cd^POvWYXFW]+X f Q r_`bpZsracD^_DX¨`^aq_\aZX f X<x\aXFQ SVQ/SV[SVr_X¨Sf XFXjWcd^acDDX f $f XFQp+XFZ
SV`xX'~bOS[ SVr_XYZ[ f X f [D\_SX f Q % $WYXFQVQVcdDXY % ¤ SVr_XYQ X<c f Zsr«[ f cZ'cD^aqR`q_cSVXS f XFX $cd~bD[ f `Sr_W#zDc %jcd^.q
SVr_X f X'p_~bO?S[?cD~~g+[ f qRX f$f[x\RSX f Q $WYX<QQVcdxXv % ij~b~/SVr_XFQX cDZS`b[D^aQ%`b^aZ f XFcxQ XvSraX~bcdSX'^.ZO?[ f Sr_X
f [x\_paQF¢£^ ilm ¤ Sr_X f Xl`bQcDqaqR`SV`[x^acd~+Z[x^xS f [x~ `Sr SVr_X f XF;\_X<QTSsQ/SV[vcd~b~_SVr_X%Z[ f X f [D\RSVX f Q $ WYX<QT
QVcdxXzd % ¤ SraXQXFc f Zsr¡[ f c ZFcd^aqR`q_cdSX`b^ SVr_X'`f [ ^ W]\_~S`Z'cxQTSvS f X'XQXS
$
cD~x[ f `SVr_W zxZ-% ¤ Sr_XF`f
f X'pa~`bXFQ
$
WX<QQVcdxXozxq %ªcd^.q SVr_XZ'cD^aqR`q_cSVX%QX'~bXFZS`b[D^
$
cD~x[ f `SVr_W zdX %
ªr_`f q ¤ SVr_XX¥R`bQ S`b^_ p f [DS[RZ[x~bQa\_`~q? f [x\_pR£Q p+XFZ'`©.Z%XF^;S f `X<Qj`b^I.[ f q_X f¨f [D\_SX f QF¢£^aqRX'X<q ¤ Sr_X
WcdSVZsr_`b^_[D c f [x\_p ^SV[c~bcD.XF~>h `bQoQ S[ f XFq«`b^HcD~~SraXv+[ f qRX flf [x\RSX f QlcSSVcDZsraXFq«SV[WYX'Wv.X f Q
[D,^4¢£^Sr_X Z'[D^;SX'¥;S[D SVr_X f X<qR\aZS`b[D^¡[d[ fV c f qR`b^_«QTSscSVXFQ ¤ Q\aZsrHXF^;S f `X<Q$Q r_[x\_~q +X cÇD[x`bqRX<q
+XFZFcd\aQXªSraX'`f ^P\_W]+X f QZFcd~bX `SVrYSr_Xj^P\_Wv.X f [D4 f [x\_paQF¢£^aq_X'XFq ¤ S f X'XlcdD f XFxcdS`b[D^ f XFq_\aZX<Q Sr_X
^P\_Wv.X f [D+[ f c f qR`b^_$QTSscSVXFQg`b^Z'[ f X f [x\RSX f Q ¤ _\RS[D^_X¨ f [D\_pR£Qp.X<Z`©.ZªX'^;Sf Op.X f f [D\ap`Q cxq_qRX<q
`b^Sr_X$+[
f
qRX
ff [D\_SX
f
QF
¢£^SraX$^_X¥PS¨QXFZSV`[x^
¤R
Xop
f
X<Q XF^xS[x\
f
^_X
p f
[dS[RZ'[D~4Sr.cS¨Q[D~bDXFQSVr_XFQX$q
f c
.cDZs¦RQ'
¡ E sE] "]"$E"]%&( &
&&
mI[xQ S][dSVr_Xq f c acxZs¦PQ%[DSr_Xcdx f X'xcdSX<q Wv\_~SV`bZFcDQ S]f cdWYX [ f ¦ Z'[DWYX f [DW Sr_XZXF^xS f cD~`'X<q
XF^;S`STO r_`Zsrv`b^aqR\aZ'XFQ/Z'[D^;S f [D~P[DX f raXFcDq$cD^aqv`bQ `b^_r_X f XF^xSV~OvcoZ f `S`Z'cD~Pp.[x`^;S/[d.Kcd`b~\ f XD ªr_`Q X'^;S`STO
`Q f XF;\_`f X<qQ`^aZ'X$QTSV[ f `^_vSraX$W]\_~S`Z'cxQTSªS f X'X$QXS`b^«cD~~4SVr_X%.[ f q_X ff [D\RSVX f Q `Q`bWp+[xQVQ`_~bX$qR\_XoS[
WYXFW[ f O f X<;\_`f X'WYXF^xSsQ'Inl\ f p f[xp.[;Q `S`b[D^ omIi
$
l`bQ S f `b_\RSX<q®m?\_~S`Z'cxQTS f X'X i¨D f X';cSV`[x^ %
q_[;X<Qª^_[dS f XF;\_`f XocD^;OZX'^;S f cD~`'X<q X'^;SV`STOcDQ omIi `Qª\_~b~bOqR`QTS f `b_\RSVXFq
ªr_XWcd`b^$`bqRX<c[dR[x\ f p f [dSV[PZ'[D~d`QSV[jX'^.cd_~bX/SraX +[ f qRX ff [D\_SX f Q4SV[jWcSVZsr$ f [x\_paQ4SV[j~cd+X'~Q'¢£^
SVr_`Q
cÇO
¤
Sr_XFOZFcd^Y[
fV
c f
q]SVr_X¨Wv\_~S`Z'cDQ S pacxZs¦DX'SVQ
`Sra[D\RScD^PO
f
XF;\_X<QTSgSV[]ZXF^;S
f
cd~b`"FXFqYX'^;SV`SV`X<Q'
ªraX'^
¤
SraXZ[x^;S
f
[D~ [xX
f
r_XFcxq `Q
f
X<qR\aZX<q?¢£^ omIEi
¤
~bcD.XF~bQvc
f
XQ`x^_`©+Z'cd^;S
¤
SVr;\.QSVr_X+[
f
qRX
f
f
[D\_SX
f
Q¦P^_[
B
r_`Zsr
f
[x\RSX
f
Qªc
f
X$Z[xX
f
XFqPOc~cd+X'~Z'[
fVf
X<Q p+[D^aq_`^_vS[cvS
f
X'Xx/¢£^SVr_`Q
cÇO
¤
Sr_X
+[ f qRX ff [x\RSX f Qªc f X$cd_~bXoS[ QXFc f Zsr[ f cY~cd+X'~4[ f cv f[x\_p`^SraX$~`QTSj[DE~cd+X'~QcÇcd`b~bcD_~bXo`b^Sr_X
q_[DWcd`b^
[x^aQ X<;\_X'^;S~bO ¤ `^ omIEi ¤ Sr_X f X`Q/^_XFXFqY[d4^_XF`SVr_X f S f XFXWcd^acDDX f ^a[ f Z'[ f X f [D\_SX f Q/cDQg`^ ilm
[ f ilm _ªr_`QQXFZS`b[D^qRXFQVZ f `+XFQ © f QTSV~OYSVr_X%cd~bD[ f `Sr_W omIi cD^aq QXFZ[x^aqR~bOSr_X cÇO]SVr_X%~`QTS
[D~cd+X'~QjcÇcd`b~bcD_~bXl`b^Sr_XqR[xWcd`b^`QQ X'Sj\_p«POcvS[Dp+[D~b[DxOWcd^acDDX f
P%$'& ? -98K?%-9/JP B L -:?GI; - 8:/2/ A =6=68K/2=6; -:?N),+ ;SLN=6),8K?-
ªraXj.[
f
q_X
fgf [D\RSVX
f
Q ¦DXFX'p c%~b`bQ S [d4SVr_Xj~cd+X'~Q cÇcd`b~bcD_~bX`b^SVr_X¨qR[xWYcD`^Y`b^[
f
qRX
f
S[WcSsZsrY
f
[D\_paQ
SV[]~cd+X'~Q'/ªr_`Q~`Q S[D~bcD.XF~bQ`Qa\_`~Sª;Oc]S[xp.[x~[xDOWYcD^acdxX
f
cd^aq Sr_`QªZ[D^.QTS
f
\aZS`b[D^`QªqRXSscd`b~X<q
~cSVX
f
`b^?Q X<ZS`b[D^«z_P/¢£^Sr_`QjQXFZS`b[D^
¤
omIEi cd~bD[
f
`Sr_W `QjqRX<QZ
f
`b+XFq[
f
WYcD~~bOD
° <dE´ ´ ° ) ´
omIEi `Qc¡^_X qR`Q S f `_\_SXFq¬S f XFXIcdx f X'xcdS`b[D^1p f [DS[RZ[x~7B¢£^ Sr_`Q p f [dSV[RZ[D~ ¤ r_X'^Mc¡+[ f qRX f
f [D\_SX f V¨f X<ZXF`xXFQcvp.cDZs¦DX'S[ f c f [D\_p ^ ¤KV ©a^aq_Qc~cd+X'~2h[ f ^\aQ`b^_ij~bD[ f `Sr_W x/cxQ `Z'cD~~bO ¤
V QXFc f Zsr_X<Q¨[ f cd^¡cDqRX<;\acSVX~cd+X'~.h [ f ^ `b^H`SVQ$~cd+X'~Q X'S! 6V< $j[DSXYSVracS[x^_~OHcQ\_aQXS[D
" 6
V!
`QªX'cd~b\acdSXFq`SraX$~bcD.XF~bQªc
f
X%Q [
f
SVXFqcxZ'Z'[
f
qR`^aS[SVr_X$^P\_W]+X
f
[d Q p.cd^_^_X<q^a[Pq_XFQcd^.q `
[x^_~bOvSVr_X%~bcD.XF~bQ
r_`ZsrZ'[DX
f
cSª~X<cDQ S$#^%#d^_[RqRX<Qªc
f
X¨X'cD~\acdSX<q
/ªr_XF^
V
[
f
c f
q_QgSr_XoW]\_~S`Z'cxQTS
p.cDZs¦DX'SjPOX'^.Z'cdp.Q \_~cSV`^a`S
`SVr«Sr_Xv~bcD.XF~hT¢£^ omIEi
¤
Sr_X+[
f
qRX
fjf [x\RSX
f
Q¨qR[^_[dSlWYcD`^;Sscd`b^
cD^PO f [D\_p_»Qp.X<Z`©.ZlX'^;S f `X<Qªcd^aq«c~bcD.XF~`QQ X<c f Zsr_XFq [ f XFcxZsr`b^aZ'[DWY`^aWv\_~S`Z'cDQ SpacDZs¦xXS<
$¨[dSXgSracdSSr_X .[ f qRX ff [x\RSX f Q4r.cÇDX SraXg¦P^_[ ~X<qRDX [DxSVr_Xg f [D\apoWYXFW]+X f Q r_`bpaQ`b^oSr_XqR[DWcd`b^
ªra`bQl`^_[ f WYcdS`b[D^ ZFcd^H.X f X'S f `XFDX<q«;O?QX'xX f cd~WYX<cd^aQl\aQ\acd~b~O `SrmHn%N e ' ' 9%¢»mHn%N e '
`Qª^_[DS¨qRX'p_~b[ODX<q ¤ cDqaqR`SV`[x^acd~Z'[D^;S f [D~4WYXFQVQVcdDX<Qªc f Xo^aX'XFq_XFq raX'^?c.[ f qRX ff [x\RSX f Vjf XFZ'X'`bDX<Qc
X0Y[Z]\
$f XFQp/c7npo0qr:o %/[ f cv f [D\_p ^ ¤KV ^_[dSV`©aX<Qcd~b~+Sr_X%+[ f qRX fªf[D\RSVX f Q[DSraX%q_[DWcd`b^SVracS`S`bQ
cdS SscDZsr_X<qS[ WYX'Wv.X f Q¨[d>^
$f X<Q pSracdSlcd~b~SVr_X]WYXFW]+X f Qj[dS^«cSSVcDZsraXFqS[ V racÇDX$~bXS %lªraX'^ ¤
cD~~Sr_X+[ f qRX ff [x\RSX f Qª\_p4q_cdSX$SVr_X f [D\apWYX'Wv.X f Qr_`bp?[d ^+ j[ X'xX f<¤ Sr_X]QVcdWYX$¦P^_[ ~bXFqRxX%`bQ
f XF;\_`f XFqY`b^cd^POS f X'XocdD f XFxcdS`b[D^p f [DS[RZ[x~7 i¨m cd^aq ilm¦xX'X'pcd~Q [$SVr_`Q`b^R[ f WcSV`[x^`^Sr_X
S f XFX%WYcD^acdxX f cd^.q`b^Sr_XZ'[ f X f [D\RSVX f Q'
&v
ÕÇÕÇÌ×7ÌÄÆÅsËPÌÆFÒbÄÎKÉjÅV×9ÌÄƨÉjÅ('*)dÍ ÒÄÊÇÆÇÕlÌÆ+-,.,0/È