Cell-based Multicast Grouping in Large-Scale Virtual Environments

HAL Id: inria-00077113

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00077113

Submitted on 29 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub-

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,

Cell-based Multicast Grouping in Large-Scale Virtual Environments

Emmanuel Léty, Thierry Turletti, François Baccelli

To cite this version:

Emmanuel Léty, Thierry Turletti, François Baccelli. Cell-based Multicast Grouping in Large-Scale Virtual Environments. [Research Report] RR-3729, INRIA. 1999, pp.25. �inria-00077113�

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

THÈME 1

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Cell-based Multicast Grouping in Large-Scale Virtual Environments

Emmanuel Léty — Thierry Turletti — François Baccelli

N° 3729

Juillet 1999

3

&"4.!"&5(&/

68797;:=<2>[email protected]?APQPQGRJS>NPT@O?UEQEVM8HXWKPV:Y<ZA[\MO]_^`:YaUaA?A@O@OM

bdcfeg`h`ikjmlnQophQqFrts$huSopvtowuxeg`hQo

yKzx{}|whuxol{t~thQ{`huSX€k

lqF‚ ‚Y{Fzpu~ h8zphTƒc hzƒc hI„Y…N†ˆ‡}‰FŠ‹jŒ}r ŽŽhuiQŠFŠUŠ‘j’‰U“"‚fq}”UhQo

•–—Q˜™›š œF˜F bdc žo‚fq}‚YhzŸ~thTopƒzp YhQo$upc h+g`{}ux¡›q›ux{U„foq}„f~Rupc h+~thQop”F„¢{F£"q¤ƒ{Fg`g"r „ žƒq›ux{U„

qFzxƒcf¥uxhQƒuxr zxh,£¦{UzX§2qFzp”Uh¨wtƒqFŽh©Szªuxrfq}Ž=K„ˆ¡Azx{F„ g`h„AuoN{F„«upc hS¬­„Uuxhzx„ huT®¯°h‚ zx{F‚Y{Uophq}„.q}‚ ‚fzp{AqFƒc

q}uupcfhupzq}„=oª‚Y{Fzpuª¨±ŽqVvUhzT²ˆrfoª„ ”_g"r Žup‚ Žh"g/r ŽupžƒqUowuC”Fzx{Fr ‚foSq}„f~%g"r Ž¥ux‚fŽh«q}”FhQ„AuxoQ®³Cr zkq}‚ ‚fzp{AqFƒc

„ˆ¡F{UŽ¡UhQo`uxc h°~ vA„=q}g`ƒ‹‚fq}zpupup{F„ „ ”;{}£8upcfh´¡ˆzpupr=q}Žkh„ˆ¡ˆzx{F„ g`hQ„Uu„Aup{¤oª‚=q›upžq}Žkq}zxhQqUo$q}„=~µupc h

qUopop{tƒžq›ux{U„{F£uxc hQoph/q}zxhQqUod¶¥uxcŸg/r ŽupžƒqUowu”Uzp{Ur ‚foQ®·¬­„Ÿ{Ur z¶,{Uzp¸\² ¶h~thTopƒzp =hq`g`hupc {t~Ÿ fqUoªhT~

{U„°upc h.uxc h{Uzpv´{}£d‚ ŽqF„fq}z/‚={U„Au‚ zx{tƒhQoxophQoQ²up{´~ huphQzpg`„ h_q}„¹qF‚ ‚ zx{F‚ zxq}uph.ƒhQŽŽ¨­oªºh.op{%upcfq}uupc h

„fƒ{Fg`„f”‘upzq›»_ƒq›uXuxc hzxhQƒh¡FhzXopž~thzphQg.q}„foK¶upc_q‘”F¡FhQ„`‚ zp{U fq} fŽ¥uwv" =hQŽ{›¶µq8oprt»_ƒh„AupŽv"Ž{›¶

uxc zxhQopc {FŽž~®

¼Ÿ½A¾\¿xÀ/Á ™›Â—F à hQŽŽ¨± fqFophQ~¹Äkzx{Fr ‚ „ ”=²§2qFzp”Uh¨wtƒqFŽh«©SzpuprfqFŽ·K„ˆ¡ˆzx{F„ g`hQ„Uuo.ÅO§ˆ©C·Æ²Nǟr Ž¥ux‚fŽh

ǟr Ž¥uxƒQqFoªuSÄkzp{Ur ‚foQ² à {Fg`g/r „fƒQq›up{F„%Èzƒc uphTƒuprfzphU®

#,!"$#' & Q

# !/$ 3 &"4_!/&&5(&/ 012 "&$ 3 $Q

—  à hŸzxqF‚ ‚Y{Fzpu`‚fzpnToªhQ„Uuxh%r „ hŸ„ {Ur ¡FhQŽŽhŸq}zƒc ¥uxhQƒupr zxh~ h‹ƒ{Fg`g"r „ žƒq›ux{U„;‚Y{Frfz_~thQo

qF‚ ‚ ŽƒQq›ux{U„fo,~ hkzxnQqFŽupnk¡ˆzpuprfhŽŽh8qVvUqF„Au,r „”Fzq}„f~_„ {Fg"  zph‘~thk‚fq}zpupžƒ‚fqF„Uuo®KÈf„~ hkzxnQop{Fr=~tzphCŽh

‚fzp{U  ŽeQg`hd~ hdoxƒqFŽqF  Župndzxh„fƒ{F„Aupzxn,‚=q}zXƒhuwvˆ‚Yh~qF‚ ‚ ŽƒQq›ux{U„ ²}„ {UrfoN‚ zx{F‚Y{Uop{F„for „ hqF‚ ‚ zx{ˆƒcfhqFr

„f¡UhQq}r~th8Žžq"ƒ{Frfƒc hkuxzxqF„foª‚Y{FzpuUrfrtupŽžoph~thQoqF”Fh„Auo,hur „%h„fophg"  Žh‘~th8”Uzp{Ur ‚=hTog/r Žup‚={U„Auo®

€S{}uxzph$qFzxƒcf¥uxhQƒuxr zxh_rtupŽoph$r „;~tnQƒ{Fr ‚fqF”Fh_~tvˆ„fqFg`Ar hh„ ƒhŽŽr ŽhQo"~th$Žh„ˆ¡ˆzx{F„ „fhg`h„Au/¡ˆzªuxr hŽ

qF„=oªAr h"ŽqFoxoª{tƒžq›ux{U„‹~th"ƒhQo‘ƒhQŽŽr ŽhQokqV¡FhTƒ~thQok”Uzp{Ur ‚=hTog"r Ž¥ux‚Y{F„AuxoQ®CqF„fokƒh«zxqF‚ ‚={UzªuT²=„f{Frfo

~ nQƒzx¡F{F„=o_r „ h°g`nuxc {t~th  =qFopnh opr zŽq9upc nQ{Fzxh°~thQo‚ zx{tƒhTopoprfo$~ h ‚Y{F„Auxo~ q}„foŽh´‚ Žžq}„2²S‚Y{Fr z

~ nuphQzpg`„ hzkr „ h«uq}ŽŽh«~ h«ƒhŽŽr Žh`q}‚ ‚ zx{F‚fzpnhU® à huªuxh/uq}ŽŽh«~ h«ƒhŽŽr Žh`hQoªu‘ƒcf{Fžoªh"~th«g.q}„ ezxh

Žg«uphQzSŽhuxzxq=ƒ‘zphrŸ‚fqFzS‚fqFzªuxƒ‚=q}„AuSq}„fopAr hŽh/„ {Ug/  zxh~th8£¦zq}„=ƒc oxophg`h„AuxoS~th"ƒhŽŽr ŽhQoS‚fq}z

rf„ ¥uxn~th‘uphQg`‚fo®

Á ˜T— ¿ œ"! —9 ÈSzxƒc uphTƒuxr zph~th à {Ug«g"r „ žƒq}up{F„ ®#SnTƒ{Frf‚fq}”Uh_h„ à hQŽŽr ŽhQoQ²XK„ˆ¡ˆzx{F„ „fhg`h„Auxo

©CzpuprfhŽžo²fÄkzx{Fr ‚YhQoǟr Ž¥ux‚Y{F„AuxoQ²=tƒQq}Žžq}  ŽupnU®

$ %

&/!.%$·!"&

bdcfo/‚fq}‚Yhz/~ hQoxƒzx YhQoupc h_g`{Fup¡Vq}up{F„fo"q}„f~°uxc h$~thToª”F„¹{F£qŸƒ{Fg`g"r „ žƒq›ux{U„9q}zƒc uphQƒupr zxh«£¦{Fz

§q}zx”Fh¨­tƒQq}Žh,©Czpupr=q}ŽfK„ˆ¡ˆzp{U„ g`h„Auxoŧˆ©k·ÆK{U„«upc h¬­„Auxhzx„ huT®Ktrfƒc`¡AzpuprfqFŽ h„ˆ¡ˆzx{F„fg«hQ„AuxoÅO©C·Æ

„fƒŽrf~ hŸg`qUopop¡FhŽv9g"r Ž¥ux¥¨±‚ ŽžqVvFhQz«”Aq}g`hQoQ² Sžowuxzp  rtuxhQ~¤¬­„AuphQzxqUƒup¡Fh‹ˆg/rfŽq}up{F„fo‹ÅS¬ªfÆ'&i)(²q}„=~

opcfqFzphT~"¡ˆzªuxrfq}ŽY¶{FzxŽ~ oQ®b{t~ qVvF²Ag.q}„ˆv«{}£\upc hToªhkq}‚ ‚fŽžƒq}up{F„fo·cfqV¡Fhdux{/cfqF„f~tŽhCq}„.„fƒzphTqFop„ ”8„ˆr g«¨

 Yhz·{}£\‚fq}zpupžƒ‚fq}„AuoKq}„f~`~thTq}Žt¶upc`upcfh~t¥»_ƒr Ž¥u,‚ zp{U  Žhg{F£\oxƒqFŽqF  ŽuwvF®NÇ%{Fzxh{›¡UhzT²Quxc hzxhQqFŽ¥¨ upg`h

zxh Ar zxhg`h„Auxod{F£uxc hQoph/qF‚ ‚ ŽƒQq›up{F„=odg`qF¸FhToupc h/oxƒqFŽqF  Žuwv_‚ zx{F  Žhg g`{Fzxh‘~ ¥»_ƒrfŽ¥uCup{_op{FŽ¡FhF®·¬­„

uxc žo.‚fq}‚YhzT²¶,hŸƒ{U„fop~thQz.{F„ Žv9g.q}„ˆvA¨up{}¨±g.q}„ˆv9q}‚f‚ Žžƒq}up{F„foQ²¶c hzxh%hQqFƒc¤‚fqFzªuxƒ‚fqF„Au`žo. Y{}uxc

op{Frfzxƒhq}„f~zxhQƒhQ¡UhzT®,¯°h/qFŽop{.g.q}¸Fh‘uxc h"qUopopr g`‚tux{U„uxcfq›ukq_oª„ ”UŽh~ q}uxq+*={›¶ žo”Uh„ hQzxq}uphQ~‚Yhz

‚=q}zpupžƒ‚fq}„AuQ®-,{›¶h¡UhzT²U¶hk =hQŽh¡UhSuxcfq›ug`{Uoªu{F£ upcfhkzxhQopr Žuxodq}„=~_g`hQƒcfqF„ žoªg.o,‚ zphToªhQ„AuphQ~$„upcfo

‚=q}‚YhzCƒQq}„‹ Yh/hTqFopŽv%qF~ qF‚tuphT~up{$g`{Uzph/ƒ{Fg`‚ Žhs‹q}‚f‚ Žžƒq}up{F„foupcfq}ukrfoph/oph¡Uhzq}Ž g`hQ~ q_uwvA‚YhQoC{Fz

ŽžqVvFhQzphT~_hQ„fƒ{t~t„ ”Uo&‰(±®

.Coª„ ”Ÿ¬wy g"r Ž¥uxƒQqFoªu"op{FŽ¡FhQo‘‚=q}zpu{}£upc h$oxƒqFŽqF  Žuwv‹‚ zx{F  Žhg  ˆv°qFŽŽ{›¶„f”hTqFƒc+oª{Ur zƒh`up{‹oph„=~

~fq›uxqk{U„ Žv8{U„fƒhux{‘qFŽŽ upc hd‚fqFzªuxƒ‚fqF„Auxo¶¥uxc {Fr uXcfqV¡ˆ„ ”Cup{~ hQq}Žt¶upc`qFoNg.qF„Av"oªhUrfh„Aupžq}Žˆ{FzXƒ{F„t¨

ƒr zxzphQ„UuKr „fƒQqFoªu·oªhTopop{U„foQ®/,{›¶h¡UhzT²}¶upc.q‘ŽqFzp”Uhd„Arfg/ YhzX{F£\cfhuphQzp{U”FhQ„ h{UrforfoªhQzxoQ²›uxzxqF„foªg`uªux„ ”

uxc h$oxq}g`h$~ q}uxqux{´q}ŽŽXuxc h$‚fqFzªuxƒ‚=q}„Auxo~ zxqFg`q}upžƒqFŽŽv‹„fƒzxhQqUoªhTo‘upc h$‚ zp{U fq} fŽ¥uwv {}£ƒ{U„ ”FhTowux{U„

¶upcf„$upc h‘„ huw¶,{Uzp¸`q}„f~$‚fq}zpupžƒrfŽqFzpŽv«q}u,uxc hkzphTƒh¡FhQz,op~ hF®N¬­„f~thQhQ~²t‚ zx{tƒhTopop„f”/q}„f~ fŽuphzx„ ”"qFŽŽ

uxc h8‚fqUƒ¸FhuozphTƒh¡FhT~$q}uuxc hq}‚f‚ Žžƒq}up{F„ŽhQ¡FhQŽ ƒ{FrfŽ~{›¡FhQzpŽ{UqU~.Ž{tƒQq}Ž\zphToª{Ur zƒhQoQ²ˆhQop‚=hTƒžq}ŽŽv$¥£upc h

zxh„=~thzx„f”Sg`{t~tr ŽhžoKq}ŽzxhQqF~ vk‚fzp{tƒhTopop{Fz„Auxh„fop¡Uh0&†(±®&12(foªc {›¶o2upc=q›uK„`qC”Fzx{Fr ‚«ƒ{Fg`g"r „ žƒq›ux{U„

ophupup„ ”f²=qFoupcfh„ˆr g/ Yhz{F£/*={›¶od{}£K~ q›uq«qF„f~upc h/„Arfg/ Yhz{F£rfophzod„fƒzxhQqUoªhU²ˆupc h8‚YhzƒhQ„Uuq}”Uhk{F£

ƒ{F„AuphQ„AuzphTƒh¡FhT~ AvhQqUƒc%‚fq}zpupžƒ‚fq}„Auuxcfq›ukoS„AuphQzphTowux„f”_~thQƒzphTqFophQoQ®,bdc žorfophŽhQoxo„t£¦{Uzpg.q›ux{U„

zxh‚fzphToªhQ„Uuoq‹ƒ{Uoªu/„9uphzxg.o{F£„ huw¶{Fzx¸´ fqF„f~t¶ž~ˆupc2²Kzp{UrtuphQzxo8 fr3YhQz"{tƒQƒr ‚fq}up{F„9qF„f~+h„f~t¨c {Aowu

zxhQop{FrfzxƒhQoq}„f~žodg`qF„fŽv_zxhQop‚Y{F„fop fŽhk£¦{Fzduxc h~thQ”FzqF~ q}up{F„${F£‚Yhzp£¦{Fzxg.q}„fƒhk„Ÿ§ˆ©k®

¯°hqFzp”Ur h`upc=q›u"zxhQƒh¡FhT~°upzq›»_ƒ}²j q}„f~²N„9‚fqFzªuxƒr ŽqFzQ²upcfhopr ‚Yhz4*fr {Fr=o8upzq›»_ƒ«j cfqUo8up{  =h

=Ž¥uxhzxhQ~‹{Urtu‘ =h£¦{Fzxh"ukzxhQqUƒc hQoSupcfh"hQ„f~ˆ¨±c {UoªuQ®bdc h`g.q}„ ~ ¥»_ƒrfŽ¥uwvŸ„‹uxc o =Ž¥uxhzx„ ”g`hQƒcfqF„ žoªg

ƒ{Fg`hQo£¦zx{FgIuxc hdc huxhzx{F”Uh„ hQ¥uwvqF„f~8uxc h~tvˆ„fq}g`žƒuwv8{}£=upc hzxhQƒh¡FhzoQ²T„f{}uK{F„ Žv8„"uxhzxg.o{F£= fqF„f~ˆ¨

¶ž~ˆuxc«qF„f~/‚fzp{tƒhTopop„ ”C‚Y{›¶hz  rtu·q}Žžop{C„/uxhzxg.oN{}£Y~fq›uxqC„UuxhzxhQoªuQ²}¡ˆzªuxrfq}ŽtqF„f~/‚fcAvtopƒQq}ŽˆŽ{ˆƒQq›ux{U„fo®

¬­„.ÈS¬ªÇ5&“(²Aq‘„ huw¶{Fzx¸A¨ŽžqVvFhQzqF‚ ‚ zx{UqFƒc«žoK‚ zx{F‚Y{UophQ~/upcfq}uXh„fqF  ŽhToXop{Fr zƒhTo2ux{8zphTowuxzpžƒuKuxc h~thQŽ¡FhQzpv

{F£X‚fqFƒ¸Uhuodup{q_oªrf foªhuC{F£Kupc h"g/r ŽupžƒqUowuk”Fzx{Fr ‚Ÿg`hg" =hQzxoQ®6,S{›¶,hQ¡FhzT²tuxc ok‚ zx{F‚Y{Uopup{F„%zphAr zxhQo

g`{t~t=ƒq}up{F„fod„upc h8zx{Fr uphzodq}„f~žor „t£¦{Uzªuxr „fq›uxhŽv_„ {FudvUhuS~thQ‚ Ž{›vFhQ~$„uxc h8¬­„Auphzx„ huQ®

¬­„uxc o‚fq}‚YhzT²t¶,h‘‚ zx{F‚Y{Uoph8qfŽ¥uxhzx„f”«g`hTƒcfq}„ žopg ~t{F„fhq›udupc hupzq}„fop‚={Uzªup¨ŽžqVvFhQzQ²Urfop„ ”`g"r Ž¥ux‚fŽh

g"r ŽupžƒqFoªuC”Uzp{Ur ‚fokq}„f~´q}”FhQ„AuxoQ®8³Cr z‘q}‚f‚ zp{AqFƒcŸ„ˆ¡F{FŽ¡FhTo~tvˆ„fqFg«žƒ"©CR‚=q}zpupup{F„ „ ”$„Aup{%oª‚=q›upžq}Ž

qFzphTqFo8ƒQq}ŽŽhT~7 89:q}„=~°upc hqFoxoª{tƒžq›ux{U„ {F£dupc hToªhƒhŽŽžo¶upc¹g/rfŽ¥uxƒQqFoªu"”Fzx{Frf‚fo®¯°h~thTopƒzp =h_q

g`hupc {t~²A fqFophQ~"{F„`uxc hdupcfh{Fzxv/{F£‚ ŽqF„fq}zK‚Y{F„Au·‚ zx{tƒhQoxophQoQ²Vup{/~thuphQzpg`„ hq}„.q}‚f‚ zp{U‚ zxq}uph; 8)<=?>@8

op{upcfq}uupcfh_„=ƒ{Fg`„ ”upzq›»_ƒ.q›u8uxc h_zxhQƒh¡Fhzopž~th.zphQg.q}„fo‘¶¥uxc9q%”F¡FhQ„ ‚ zx{F =q}  Žuwv‹ YhŽ{›¶ q

oprt»_ƒh„AuxŽv Ž{›¶upc zxhQopc {FŽž~®.¯°h.upcfh„+‚ zx{F‚Y{Uoph«g`hTƒcfq}„ žopg`okux{‹~tvˆ„fq}g`žƒqFŽŽv‹‚fqFzªux¥ux{U„ uxc h.©C

„Aup{‹ƒhŽŽo/{}£~t?3YhQzphQ„Uu«oªºhTo²N~th‚Yh„=~t„f”‹{F„+uxc h$~thQ„foªuwv°{}£‚fq}zpupžƒ‚fqF„Uuo8‚Yhz/ƒhŽŽ²upcfh_„ˆr g/ Yhz

{F£dqV¡›qFŽžq}  Žh`g/r ŽupžƒqUowu"”Fzx{Fr ‚foQ²2qF„f~ upc h_Ž„ ¸  =q}„f~t¶ž~ˆuxc9q}„f~°‚ zx{tƒhQoxop„ ”%‚Y{›¶,hQzqV¡›q}ŽqF  Žh`‚Yhz

‚=q}zpupžƒ‚fq}„AuQ®

bdcfh,zxhQoªuK{}£ uxc hd‚fq}‚YhzNžoN{Fzx”Uq}„fºQhQ~qUo2£¦{UŽŽ{›¶oQ®ˆhTƒup{F„"¬ª¬zphQ¡Ah¶ouxc hdŽg`¥uq›up{F„=o{F£fuxc hƒr zxzphQ„Au

¬wy¤g"r Ž¥uxƒQqFoªug«{t~thQŽ²t‚fzphToªhQ„Uuo,upc hƒhŽŽ¥¨± fqFophQ~$”Fzx{Fr ‚f„ ”`oªupzq›uphQ”FvU²ˆqF„f~hs q}g`„ hQouxc hkupzqF~thQ{ 3‹„

ophŽhQƒup„ ”Ÿuxc hƒhŽŽ¥¨­opºQh_‚fq}zq}g`huphzT® ˆhTƒux{U„9¬ª¬p¬/~thQoxƒzx =hTo"qŸg`{t~thQŽ,ux{´hQ¡VqFŽr=q›uph$¡VqFzp{Fr=og`hQqF„

¡›qFŽr hTo8{}£„AuphQzphTowuT®bdc hoªhTƒux{U„ uxc h„;q}„fqFŽvˆºhTo‘upcfh_g`‚fqUƒu/{F£dupc hƒhŽŽ¨±opºQh.{F„+uxc h.upzq›»_ƒ.zxh¨

ƒh¡FhT~9q›u«upc h%zxhQƒh¡Fhzo/qF„f~²=„fq}ŽŽvU²Xh¡›qFŽrfq}uphTouxc h%cfq}„f~ {›¡Fhz"g`hQƒcfqF„ opg q}„f~9upc h%zxhQop~ h„fƒh

uxg`hU®,ˆhQƒup{F„%¬­© ~thTopƒzp =hToq`ƒ{Fg`g"r „ žƒq›ux{U„qFzxƒcf¥uxhQƒuxr zxhC£¦zq}g`hQ¶,{Uzp¸«upc=q›uSq}ŽŽ{›¶oq«~ vA„=q}g`ƒ

ƒhŽŽ¥¨± fqUoªhT~+”Fzx{Fr ‚ „ ”´oªupzq›uxh”Uv´¶upc;q´Žg`¥uxhQ~ „Arfg/ Yhz«{}£g/rfŽ¥uxƒQqFoªu"”Fzx{Frf‚fo®„fqFŽŽvF²·ˆhTƒux{U„

© ~tžoxƒrfoxoªhToSzxhŽžq›uxhQ~´¶,{Uzp¸toQ²YqF„f~°thQƒux{U„´©C¬Cƒ{U„fƒŽrf~thTouxc h`‚fq}‚Yhz8qF„f~‹‚ zxhQoph„Auok~ zxhQƒup{F„foS£¦{Fz

£¦r upr zxh8¶,{Uzp¸\®

!‘4C‘!/&

h£¦{Fzxh/¶h/„Uuxzp{t~tr=ƒh/{Ur zkg«{t~thQŽoCux{ƒqFŽƒr Žžq›uph/upc h.ƒhŽŽ¥¨­oªºhU²=Žhu‘rfo fzowu‘hs qFg«„ h/upc h`~t?3YhQzphQ„Uu

Žg«uxq}up{F„fo`„µrfop„ ”¹g"r Žup‚ ŽhŸg"r ŽupžƒqFoªu_”Fzx{Frf‚fo²·upc h‹ƒhŽŽ¥¨± fqUoªhT~ ”Uzp{Ur ‚ „ ”°oªupzq›uxh”UvF²,qF„f~;upc h

žoxoªr hTod„ˆ¡U{FŽ¡FhQ~$„ŸophŽhQƒup„ ”«upc h8 YhQoªuSoªºh‘{F£ƒhQŽŽ®

"!# $&%('*)+-,/.10234)5&!6$'7$028)

bdcfhzxhSq}zxhSoph¡FhQzxqFŽ Žg`uxq›ux{U„fo,{F„.uxc hSrfophS{F£ g/r Žup‚ ŽhCg"r ŽupžƒqFoªu·”Uzp{Ur ‚foQ®7zxoªuQ²A¶,hCcfqV¡Fhup{"ƒ{F„t¨

opž~thzuxcfq›uSup{t~ qVvF²fg/r ŽupžƒqUowuS”Uzp{Ur ‚foqFzph8„ {FuS„ hstcfqFrfowux fŽh8zxhQop{Fr zƒhTo:9Nuxc h„ˆr g" =hQzS{}£KqV¡›q}ŽqF  Žh

g"r ŽupžƒqFoªuS”Uzp{Ur ‚fod„‹¬wyK¡1.oSŽg`¥uxhQ~%ux{‰<;>=`g`ŽŽ{F„ à ŽžqFoxo qF~ ~ zphTopophQo@?Q®bdc hzxhžoSq}„%„fƒzxhQqUow¨

„ ”.„ˆr g" =hQzS{}£XqF‚ ‚ ŽƒQq›up{F„=odupcfq}uSzxh Ar zphoph¡Uhzq}Žg/rfŽ¥uxƒQqFoªuCqF~ ~ zphTopophQoQ² oªr=ƒc‹qFoŽžqVvFhQzphT~ƒ{ˆ~ „ ”

 =qFophQ~"¡Až~thQ{ˆƒ{F„t£¦hQzphQ„fƒ„ ”=²}{Fz C¬ª«q}‚ ‚fŽžƒq}up{F„foQ®bdcfh¶~thToª‚fzphTqF~"rfoªhS{}£\g/r ŽupžƒqUowuX„fƒzxhQqUoªhToupc h

‚fzp{U fq}  Ž¥uwvŸ{F£qF~f~tzphTopo8ƒ{FŽŽžop{U„fo®`È £¦h¶ oª{UŽr up{F„fo‘cfqV¡Uh«qFŽzxhQqU~tvŸ Yhh„+‚ zx{F‚Y{UophQ~´„°uxc h`ŽuphQzª¨

q}upr zxh8ux{op{FŽ¡Fh8uxc h"g"r ŽupžƒqFoªukqU~ ~tzxhQoxoSqFŽŽ{tƒq›ux{U„Ÿ‚ zx{F  Žhg%®f{Fzkhs q}g`‚ ŽhF²\q$oxƒqFŽqF  Žhg/r ŽupžƒqUowu

qU~ ~tzxhQoxoCqUopop”F„ g`h„Auk fqFophQ~´{F„ k€C cfqUok =hQh„°‚ zp{U‚={AoªhT~Ÿ„ &;(±®"Ȅf{}upcfhz‘{F‚tux{U„ ƒ{Fr Žž~´ Yh«upc h

r=oªh.{F£,uxc h$Ç%r ŽupžƒqUowu/È~ ~ zphTopo/thu à Žžq}g ÅNjÈC à Ƒ‚fzp{Fup{tƒ{UŽK¶c ƒc¹~thTopƒzp YhQo8q}„+c hzq}zƒc žƒqFŽ

 fŽ{tƒ¸‹q}ŽŽ{ˆƒQq›ux{U„‹{}£ à ŽqUopo qF~f~tzphTopophQoCopƒcfhg`h/£¦{Uz‘upc h«¬­„AuphQzp„ hu &‡@(±®«ˆ{Ug`h«qFŽ¥uxhzx„fq›ux¡UhQoSup{upc h

ƒr zxzphQ„Uu,¬wy¹g/r ŽupžƒqUowu,g«{t~thQŽ=c=qV¡FhSqFŽop{8 =hQh„‚ zp{U‚={AoªhT~A9 &=(~thQoxƒzx =hTo·qg"r ŽupžƒqFoªu,qU~ ~tzxhQoxo·op‚fqFƒh

‚=q}zpupup{F„ „ ”+opƒc hQg`h =qFophQ~;{F„;upc hŸ‚Y{Fzpu.„Arfg/ Yhz_q}„=~9uxc hŸr „ žƒqUowu.c {Aowu_qF~f~tzphTopoQ®¤¬­„ CB6 ?8

² q_g/rfŽ¥uxƒQqFoªuk”Uzp{Ur ‚‹žoCž~thQ„Uux=hQ~‹ ˆv%uxc h`‚fq}z«ÅqF~ ~ zphTopoC{}£Xuxc h«”Fzx{Fr ‚ ²qU~ ~tzxhQoxoS{F£Xupc h

ƒ{Fzxh8{}£Nupcfhg/r ŽupžƒqUowuSupzxhhTƲf¶c žƒcŸ”F¡FhTodup{$hQqFƒcŸƒ{Fzxh‘upc h8£¦rfŽŽNoªhuS{}£ à ŽžqFoxoqU~ ~tzxhQoxoªhToop‚fqFƒh

&Š(±®K¬­„"/DE*F6"F=²tq"g/r ŽupžƒqUowu HG F 89Aodž~th„AuxfhT~$ ˆv. Y{}uxc$uxc h8oªhQ„f~thzoop{FrfzxƒhCqF~f~tzphTopoq}„=~

uxc h‘g/r ŽupžƒqUowu”Uzp{Ur ‚ &iJI(±®/„=q}ŽŽvU² ¶¥uxc¬wyX¡K;f²ˆupc h8g"r ŽupžƒqFoªuqF~ ~ zphTopodop‚fqFƒhC¶ŽŽ2 =h8qFodŽžq}zx”Fh‘qFo

rf„ ƒQqFoªuXqF~ ~tzxhQoxoNoª‚=qFƒhU²Fop{Suxc oX¶ŽŽ oª{UŽ¡Uh·uxc hg/rfŽ¥uxƒQqFoªuKqU~ ~tzxhQoxoNqFoxoª”F„ g`hQ„UuN‚ zx{F  Žhg%®-,{›¶h¡UhzT²

qFŽŽuxc hQoph`‚ zp{U‚={Aoªup{F„=okqFzph`oªupŽŽXqUƒup¡Fh«zxhQophQq}zƒc´qFzphTqFokq}„f~°q}zxh"„f{}uƒr zxzxh„AupŽvŸqV¡VqFŽžq} fŽh«{F„ upc h

¬­„Auxhzx„ huT®

ˆhTƒ{U„f~²tg/rfŽ¥uxƒQqFoªuSqF~ ~tzxhQoxophQoq}zxhkhst‚=hQ„foª¡FhkzxhQop{Fr zƒhTo®Nbdc h‘zp{Urtup„ ”.q}„=~_£¦{Uzp¶dq}z~t„ ”uq}  ŽhQo

¶upcf„.uxc hk„ huw¶{Fzx¸"qFzphŽg«uphT~_zxhQop{Fr zƒhToK¶upc$Žg«uphT~_opºQhF®* {Uz·hQqUƒc_g/rfŽ¥uxƒQqFoªu·”Fzx{Fr ‚2²AqFŽŽ=upc h

zx{Fr uphzo{F£tupc hdqFoxoª{tƒq}uphQ~kg"r Ž¥uxƒQqFoªu2uxzphQh·cfqV¡UhKup{C¸FhhQ‚owuq›uxh,q} Y{Fr u¶c žƒc‚Y{Fzpuxo2qFzph·„/upc h,”Fzx{Fr ‚ ®

L7MON1PJQRASUTWVVYXTWZ[Z]\^ V_V^ V7`[V^

H@acbCd[ef

VTWZ]Z[\^ VV7V_g[TWh^@i

,S{Uoªuxodq}„=~_zx{FrtuxhzoqFŽop{/„fhhQ~$up{«zxh‚Y{Fzpu‚Yhzx{t~tžƒqFŽŽv`upcfhz¬wy g"r Ž¥uxƒQqFoªu”Uzp{Ur ‚$g`hQg/ Yhzoªc ‚fo,up{

uxc hzN„ h”Fcˆ Y{Fzx„f”Sg/rfŽ¥uxƒQqFoªuzx{Frtuxhzo rfop„ ”C¬ªÄ8Njy &iUi)(±®Nǟ{Fzxh{›¡FhQzQ²Toª{Ug`h,zx{Frtux„f”S‚ zx{}ux{ˆƒ{FŽžo,Åoªr=ƒc

qUo©ClCǟy &iT‰(¦ÆzxhŽv.{F„upc h‘‚Yhzx{t~tžƒ*f{ˆ{t~t„ ”`{}£g`hTopoxq}”UhQo,upc zx{Frf”Fc {Urtudupc h‘„ huw¶,{Uzp¸\®KȎŽupcfo

uxzxq}»_ƒdcfqFo,qƒ{AowuT²F„ {Fu,{F„fŽv"„.uxhzxg.oX{}£ fqF„f~t¶ž~ˆupc$  rtu,qFŽop{8„_uphzxg.oX{F£A|w{U„_qF„f~`ŽhQqV¡FhŽžq›uxh„fƒvF²

¶cfƒcµoªcf{Fr Žž~9 Yhuxq}¸Uh„¤„Aux{°ƒ{F„fop~ hzq›up{F„ £¦{Fz`„UuxhzqFƒup¡Fh%q}‚ ‚ Žžƒq›ux{U„fo &iT†( ®¤¬­„f~thQhQ~²¶c hQ„

q´‚fq}zpupžƒ‚fqF„Uu«oªhQ„f~ o«q.|w{F„9zxh Ar hTowuT²K¥u.ƒqF„¹uxqF¸Fh$oph¡Uhzq}Ž·cˆr „=~tzphT~¹{}£g`ŽŽžoªhTƒ{F„=~ o/ Yh£¦{Uzph$upc h

=zxoªu_g/r ŽupžƒqUowu‚fqFƒ¸Uhu_q}zxzp¡FhTo® ˆrfƒcRƒ{Aowuo_opc {Fr Žž~µ Yh‹{F ˆ¡ˆ{UrfopŽv ƒ{F„fopž~thzxhQ~¤„µ§q}zx”Fh¨­tƒQq}Žh

ǟr Ž¥uxƒQqFoªuCȂf‚ Žžƒq}up{F„fo"ÅO§ ǟÈCÆSq}„f~ŸqFzp”Ur h8„%£OqV¡F{Fz{F£Xq.  ”F”FhQzSƒhQŽŽ¨­oªºhU²=q}„=~upc hQzph£¦{FzxhF² {F£Kq

Žg«uphT~„Arfg/ Yhz{}£Ng/rfŽ¥uxƒQqFoªud”Uzp{Ur ‚foQ®

3 %(Y&'*) ,/.028, )>$.'7$ ,

h£¦{FzxhS‚fqFzªux¥ux{U„ „f”upcfhkhQ„Aupzph‘oªhu{F£2‚fqFzªuxƒ‚fqF„Auxo,„Aup{«g/rfŽ¥ux‚ Žh‘g/r ŽupžƒqUowud”Fzx{Frf‚fo²Uupcfh‘~fq›uxq"„

¶cfƒc rfoªhQzxokq}zxh«„AuphQzphTowuxhQ~´cfqV¡Fh/up{ =h`ž~th„AupfhT~®¬­„ upc žo‘‚fq}‚YhzT²\¶,h`~th f„ h«upc h'989 =8948)

qUo,upc h8ophu{}£2¡ˆzªuxrfq}Ž\hQ„Uux¥uxhToupcfq}uq/rfophzƒQq}„„AuphQzxqUƒud¶¥uxc ®X€{FuphCupcfq}uh„AupuphQodŽ{tƒq›uxhQ~$¶¥uxc „

uxc hC~ {Fg.q}„`¡Ažop{U„.{}£2q‘‚fqFzªuxƒ‚fqF„Au,oªcf{Fr Žž~`{F„ Žv« =hkƒ{F„=oªž~thzxhQ~`qUo·q8‚fqFzªu,{}£¥uo 48+ =8948)®

,S{›¶,hQ¡FhQzQ² r=oªhQzxo„AuphQzphTowuoSƒqF„‹ƒcfq}„f”Fh~tr zx„ ”.upcfh"ophQoxoª{F„ ²f„‹‚=q}zpupžƒr Žžq}zT²f„ hQ¶ ‚fq}zpupžƒ‚fq}„AuoƒqF„

|w{U„¤{Fz`ŽhQqV¡Uhq°oªhTopop{U„ ®¤t{f²·u.o«g`‚={Uzªuq}„Au`up{°cfq}„f~ Žhupcfh%~ vA„=q}g`ƒ¥uwv {}£uxc hQophŸƒh„Auxhzo"{F£

„AuphQzphTowu‘~tr zx„ ”$upc h`ophQoxoª{F„ ®8³C„fƒh/upc žok~ h„Aup=ƒq}up{F„‹žok~t{F„ hU²q_”Fzx{Frf‚ „f”$owuxzxq}uphQ”FvcfqFoSup{ =h

~ h f„ hT~²fqUƒƒ{Uzx~ „ ”"up{.oph¡Uhzq}Ž\‚fq}zq}g`huphzoQ²ˆoprfƒc%qFouxc h8„ˆr g/ Yhz{F£qV¡›q}Žžq}  Žh‘g/r ŽupžƒqUowu”Fzx{Frf‚fo²

Ž„ ¸9ƒqF‚fqFƒ¥uxhTo«q}u"uxc h%zphTƒhQ¡UhzT²huxƒF® C3\hzxh„Au.”Fzx{Fr ‚f„ ” owuxzxq}uph”UhTo/c=qV¡Fh$ YhhQ„;‚fzp{U‚={AoªhT~+£¦{Fz

§ˆ©C &i91 ²KiV“@(±®"¬­„ upc žo‘‚fqF‚=hQzQ² ¶h"£¦{ˆƒrfo‘{F„ upcfh 89<98 24 4 =8=+¶c žƒc  =qFopƒQq}ŽŽv

ƒ{F„fopžowuo2„/‚fqFzªux¥ux{U„ „ ”uxc h,©k´„Aup{‘ƒhQŽŽžoqF„f~/qUopop”F„ „ ”ux{ShTqFƒc/ƒhŽŽˆqCg/rfŽ¥uxƒQqFoªu”Uzp{Ur ‚ ® Cr zx„ ”

uxc hdoªhTopop{U„ ²VhQqUƒc‚fq}zpupžƒ‚fqF„Uu~ h„AupfhQouxc hƒhŽŽA¥uKžoƒr zpzxh„AuxŽv¡ˆzªuxrfq}ŽŽvKŽ{tƒq}uphT~„ ²Fq}„=~oªhQ„f~ o

uxoC~ q›uq«up{`uxc h"qUopop{tƒžq›uphT~$g"r ŽupžƒqFoªu”Fzx{Frf‚ ®,b{_zxhQƒhQ¡Uhkupc h/~fq›uxq.£¦zp{Ug upcfh{}uxc hz‚=q}zpupžƒ‚fq}„Auxo

„fƒŽrf~ hQ~„uxoqFzphTq/{F£„AuphzxhQoªuQ²thTqFƒc‚fq}zpupžƒ‚fq}„AucfqUoup{k|w{F„upc h8g"r Ž¥uxƒQqFoªu”Fzx{Fr ‚fodqUopop{tƒžq›uphT~

¶upc"upcfhƒhŽŽžoupcfq}uX„AuphQzxophQƒuuxo·q}zxhQq{F£=„AuphzxhQoªuQ®Kˆg`Žžq}zxŽvU²}¶c hQ„«qk‚fqFzªuxƒ‚fqF„AuNg`{›¡UhQoQ²TuX„ hQhQ~ o

ux{ŽhQqV¡Uh/uxc h`g/r ŽupžƒqUowu8”Uzp{Ur ‚fokqFoxoª{tƒžq›uxhQ~Ÿ¶upc°uxc h.ƒhŽŽžoC¶cfƒc+~t{%„ {}u‘„UuxhzoªhTƒuq}„ˆvˆg`{Fzxh/uxo

qFzphTq/{F£„AuphzxhQoªuQ®

bdc h8ƒhŽŽ¥¨± fqFophQ~_”Fzx{Fr ‚ „ ”«owuxzxq}uph”Uv`o‚fqFzªuxƒr ŽqFzpŽv.oªrf¥uq}  ŽhC{U„©k9uxcfq›uƒqF„$hTqFopŽv. =h‘‚fqFzªux¥¨

ux{U„ hQ~"„Uux{‘¡AzpuprfqFŽ q}zxhQqFoŦhU®”=®²U¡ˆzpuprfqFŽtKrfƒŽž~thQqF„`op‚fqUƒhQoÆ® ,{›¶h¡UhzT²Vupc hdg.q}„.~t¥»_ƒr Ž¥uwv/„«upcfo

‚=q}zpupup{F„ „ ”o‘ux{ f„f~ upc h.qF‚ ‚ zx{F‚ zxq}uphT~´ƒhQŽŽ¨­oªºhU®«¬­„=~thhT~²2~thTƒzxhQqFop„ ”$uxc h_ƒhQŽŽ¨­oªºh`„fƒzxhQqUoªhTo

uxc h{›¡FhQzpcfhQqF~"qFoxoª{tƒq}uphQ~/¶¥uxc_~tvˆ„fq}g`žƒ”Fzx{Fr ‚«g`hg/ Yhzopc ‚`¶c hQzphTqFo„fƒzxhQqUoª„ ”kupc hƒhŽŽ¥¨­opºQh„t¨

ƒzphTqFophQoXupc h‘r „ˆ¶dq}„AuphT~.„ £¦{Fzxg`q}up{F„zphTƒh¡FhT~.‚Yhzd‚fq}zpupžƒ‚fqF„Uu0&iJ;(±®N¬­„$uxc hS£¦{UŽŽ{›¶„ ”"opr  fophQƒup{F„ ²

¶h‘hs q}g`„ hkupc h8žoxoªr hTod„ˆ¡U{FŽ¡FhQ~$„ŸophŽhQƒup„ ”«upc h8 YhQoªuSoªºh‘{F£NƒhŽŽ®

3 %(Y& ) A $.'3 0

b¶{ q}‚f‚ zp{AqFƒc hToq}zxh_‚Y{Uoxoª  Žh$ux{´hTowuxg.q›uxh_uxc h YhQoªu.ƒhŽŽ¨±opºQh$„;q §ˆ©k9Nupc hfzowu`q}‚ ‚fzp{AqFƒc

zxh Ar zxhQouxc h`‚ zxh¨­ƒq}ŽžƒrfŽq}up{F„Ÿ{}£q$oªuxq›uxƒ«ƒhQŽŽ¨­oªºh"‚fq}zq}g`huxhzT²=¶cfƒc zphQg`qF„=ouxc h«oxq}g`h«~tr zx„ ”

uxc h/¶cf{FŽh"ophQoxoª{F„ ®kbdc h`oªhTƒ{F„=~Ÿq}‚ ‚ zx{UqUƒc‹ƒ{U„foªžoªuxo„ ~ vA„=q}g`ƒQq}ŽŽvzxh¨±hQoªupg`q}up„ ”.uxc h«ƒhŽŽ¥¨­opºQh

~ r zp„ ”Supc hdoªhTopop{F„ ²TuxqF¸ˆ„ ”C„Aux{CqFƒQƒ{Ur „Au~tvˆ„fqFg«žƒX‚=q}zq}g`huxhzo®2b{Sg`{Fup¡Vq}uph,upc hdƒc {UƒhX{}£f{U„ h·{F£

uxc hQophuw¶{q}‚ ‚fzp{AqFƒc hTo²›Žhu·r=ofzowu,~thQ„Aup£¦v/uxc hS‚fqFzxqFg`huphQzxoN„ˆ¡F{UŽ¡UhQ~"„`uxc hCƒhŽŽ¥¨­oªºhƒQq}Žžƒr Žžq›ux{U„

qF„f~+uxc h„ ²·hs q}g`„ h_uxc hg`‚fqFƒu«{F£upc h%~tvˆ„fqFg«žƒuwv+{}£uxc hQoph‚=q}zq}g`huxhzo{F„9upc h%q}‚ ‚fzp{U‚ zpžq›uxh

ƒhŽŽ¥¨­opºQhF®

½ ´– ½ ™ Á š š!¦šf–!½ !˜¦œFš —Q˜f™ Á — o«q}„;g`‚Y{Fzpuxq}„Au«‚fq}zq}g`huxhz8ux{´uq}¸Uh

„Aux{"qFƒQƒ{Ur „AuK£¦{FzXuxc hCƒhŽŽ¥¨­opºQhSƒqFŽƒr Žq}up{F„` YhQƒqFrfoph¥u”F¡FhToXqŽ{›¶,hQzK ={Ur „f~.{F£upc hkƒhQŽŽ¨±opºhF®

ÈSoNuxc h„ˆr g" =hQzX{}£\g/r ŽupžƒqUowuK”Uzp{Ur ‚foNrfophQ~«žoK„ˆ¡UhzoªhQŽv8‚ zx{F‚Y{Fzpup{F„=q}ŽAup{‘uxc hSopºQh{}£Yupc hƒhŽŽ²

q`oªg.q}ŽŽ2ophu{}£KqV¡›q}ŽqF  ŽhCg"r Ž¥uxƒQqFoªu”Fzx{Fr ‚fod¶ŽŽŽhTqF~up{.q«  ”F”FhQzƒhŽŽ¨±opºQhF®

½ ™ ½ œ ½ ½ ™›—µœFšš –!¦˜½ — ~ h„Aup£¦v9uxc h‹Ž„ ¸¤ƒqF‚fqFƒ¥uxhTo.q}„f~;upcfh‹‚ zx{ˆƒhQoxoª„ ”°‚={›¶hz

qV¡›q}ŽqF  ŽhŸ‚Yhz$zphTƒh¡FhQzQ® ÈSoxoªrfg«„ ”¹hTqFƒcµrfophz_zx{Fr ”Uc Žv ”FhQ„ hzq›uxhQo«uxc h´oxq}g`h‹q}g`{Frf„Uu_{F£

upzq›»_ƒ}²}upc h„fƒ{Ug`„ ”Cupzq›»_ƒ‚YhzKzxhQƒhQ¡Uhz”Fzx{›¶o2Ž„ hQqFzpŽv¶upc"upc hdux{}uxqFŽt„ˆr g/ YhzN{}£\oª{Ur zƒhQo

ƒ{U„Uuq}„ hQ~ „´uxc h.g/r ŽupžƒqUowu8”Uzp{Ur ‚foSup{Ÿ¶c žƒc u8cfqFo8opr  foxƒzx =hT~®«€Sh¡Uhzpupc hQŽhTopoQ² oª{Ug`h«{F£

upc hToªh$‚fq}zpupžƒ‚fq}„Auo8g.qVv´ Yh_Ž{tƒQq›uphT~+{Frtuoªž~th`uxc hqFzphTq{F£„AuphQzphTowu frtu"„fop~th_q´ƒhŽŽXuxcfq›u

„=ƒŽrf~thQo upc žoq}zxhQq{}£t„UuxhzxhQoªuQ®bdc hXzq›up{ Yhuw¶hh„‘uxc h·ƒ{FzxzphToª‚Y{F„f~ „ ”d„ˆr g" =hQz2{}£tr „ˆ¶dq}„AuphT~

‚fq}zpupžƒ‚fqF„Uuo_q}„=~ uxc hŸux{}uxqFŽ„ˆr g/ Yhz${}£8oª{Ur zxƒhQo`zxhQƒh¡FhQ~;zxh‚ zxhQoph„Auxo«uxc h‹‚YhzƒhQ„Uuq}”Uh{F£

89Fdupzq›»_ƒzxhQƒh¡FhT~®kˆ{=²Yupc h`ƒhQŽŽ¨±opºh/qF„f~Ÿg`{Fzxh/‚fqFzªuxƒr Žžq}zxŽvupc h«zq›up{_ Yhuw¶hhQ„

upc h`ƒhQŽŽ¨­oªºh«q}„f~‹upc h`oªºh«{}£Kuxc h`q}zxhQq_{F£X„AuxhzxhQoªuQ²cfqV¡Uh/q$~tzxhQƒu‘g«‚=qFƒu‘{F„‹upc h`q}g`{Frf„Uu

{}£Nr „ˆ¶qF„AuphQ~$upzq›»_ƒF®

½  ½ —˜ ¾ŸÁ š ™T˜¦œš ˜T— zxh‚ zxhQoph„Auxo upc h,zxq}up{S Yhuw¶hhQ„8upc h„ˆr g/ Yhz{}£ ‚=q}zpupžƒ‚fq}„Auxo

q}„f~;uxc hŸoªºhŸ{F£SupcfhŸ©C®X¬­„¤uxc h‹ƒhQŽŽ¨ =qFophQ~9”Uzp{Ur ‚ „ ”+owuxzxq}uph”UvF²·upc h‹qFzphTq´{F£C„UuxhzxhQoªu.o

q}‚ ‚fzp{Vstg`q}uphT~¹ ˆv+upc h%oªg.qFŽŽhQoªu`ophu`{}£kƒhŽŽžo«ƒ{›¡FhQzp„ ”Ÿuxc hŸq}zxhQqŸ{F£S„AuxhzxhQoªuQ®9¬­„ upc hzphTowu

{}£Cupc h‚fq}‚YhzT²X¶hzxh£¦hQz«up{ upc hŸ~t?3YhQzphQ„fƒh Yhuw¶hh„ upc hToªhuw¶{°qFzphTqFo/qUo"upc h 89F

48}²XoªhQh ”Ur zph; ®´ˆ{=²2uxc h~thQ„fop¥uwv°{}£‚fqFzªuxƒ‚=q}„Auxo8„ q%©k „ {Fu/{F„ Žv°cfqFo"q}„¹g«‚=qFƒu

{F„%uxc hqV¡FhQzxqF”Fhk„Arfg/ Yhz{F£N‚=q}zpupžƒ‚fq}„AuxodŽ{tƒq}uphQ~„%upc h"q}zxhQq«{}£N„AuxhzxhQoªuQ²f frtuCq}Žžop{«{U„%upc h

oªrf‚=hQz *frf{Frfodq}zxhQqf®È opg`qFŽŽhzƒhQŽŽ¨±opºh‘ƒ{FrfŽ~_qFŽŽ{›¶Rq YhupuphQzq}‚ ‚ zx{Vstg.q}up{F„.{}£uxc h8q}zxhQq8{F£

„AuxhzxhQoªuqF„f~%q`oª”F„ =ƒQq}„AuzphT~trfƒux{U„{F£opr ‚Yhz4*fr {Fr=oq}zxhQq«q}„f~uxoƒ{UzpzxhQop‚Y{F„f~t„ ”"upzq›»_ƒ}®

½ š ™T˜¦œš ˜ ½ !Á œ˜ ¾9ƒqF„ Yh8rfophQ~„Ÿq`ƒhQŽŽ¨± fqFophQ~”Fzx{Fr ‚f„ ”«©C² up{`hTowuxg.q›uxh‘upc h

 fq}„=~t¶~tupc«{›¡Fhzxc hTqF~‘”FhQ„ hzq›uxhQ~8¶cfh„/‚=q}zpupžƒ‚fq}„Auxoƒzx{UoxoƒhŽŽžo²}qF„f~8uxc hqV¡Fhzq}”UhNupg`h,uxcfq›u

upc h8‚=q}zpupžƒ‚fq}„AuowuqVvto,‚YhzCƒhŽŽ®

!. /&$ Q5 ‘!/&

'*3'7 08! )>K'7% ' .$%A'*8 %(' )

bdcfo`ophQƒux{U„9„Uuxzp{t~tr=ƒhQo«q g«{t~thQŽd{}£CqFzphTqŸ{}£S„AuphQzphTowu.q}„f~9{}£S‚fqFzªuxƒ‚=q}„Auxo" fqFophQ~9{F„ zq}„=~t{Fg

‚Y{F„Au·‚ zx{tƒhQoxophQoN¶c žƒc.o·„=oª‚ zxhQ~«{}£\upcfhSowux{tƒcfqFoªupžƒd”FhQ{Fg`huxzpv/qF‚ ‚ zx{UqUƒc"‚ zx{F‚Y{UophQ~«„&i›‡ (±®Nbdcfo

g`{t~thQŽXq}ŽŽ{›¶oCrfokup{h¡›qFŽrfq}uph«¡›q}zx{Urfokg«hTq}„ ¡VqFŽrfhQo‘{}£,„AuphQzphTowuqF„f~‹Žžq›uxhz‘{F„ up{%qF~ ~ zphTopokžopopr hQo

‚YhzpuxqF„f„ ”«ux{«g`{U  ŽuwvF®Xbdc hqUopopr g`‚tup{F„=oqFzphkuxc h‘£¦{FŽŽ{›¶„ ” 9

bdc h,ƒhŽŽo2£¦{FzxgIq}„„ f„f¥uxh,zxh”Ur ŽqFz2oUr=q}zxhX”Fzx~‘{U„8upcfh,‚ Žžq}„fh"›¶h·¶ŽŽˆ~th„f{}uph$#·upc hdƒhQŽŽ¨±opºhF²

®hF®²tuxc h~tžowuq}„fƒhk Yhuw¶hhQ„uw¶,{.qF~›|ªqFƒhQ„Audcf{FzxºQ{F„AuxqFŽ={Uz¡FhzpupžƒqFŽƒhŽŽ  Y{Fr „=~ q}zxhTo%"

bdc h/‚=q}zpupžƒ‚fq}„AuxoSq}zxhowuq›upžƒqF„f~%Ž{tƒQq›uphT~%{F„%uxc h/‚ Žžq}„fh/qFƒQƒ{Fz~t„ ”«up{$q_zxqF„f~t{Fg c {Ug«{U”Fh¨

„ h{Urfoy{Fžopop{F„‚Y{F„Uu‚fzp{tƒhTopo{F£„Uuxh„fopuwv5&iJ=( "

bdc hq}zxhQq"{}£„AuxhzxhQoªuoq`o Ur=q}zxhC{F£NqFzphTqƒh„AuphQzphT~${U„q"uwvˆ‚ žƒq}Ž‚=q}zpupžƒ‚fq}„AuQ®

)>$.14 028 0 8 ! Y. 0 38$ .1) Y% &83, %(Y&) ' 8 ' .$%A '*82)

&8 Y) %()

¯°hk£¦{tƒrfocfhzxhC{U„$uxc h~tžowuxzp  rtux{U„{F£uxc h‘„Arfg/ Yhz{F£ƒhŽŽod„AuphzophQƒux„f”"uxc h8q}zxhQq"{}£„AuphQzphTowu

qF„f~{F„upcfq}u{}£¹²ˆupc h8„ˆr g" =hQz{}£‚fq}zpupžƒ‚fqF„UuodŽ{tƒQq›uphT~$„upc hToªh8ƒhŽŽoQ®

§2hu8~ h„ {Fuphkupc h‘„Auph”Uhzd‚fqFzªud{}£upc h‘zxhQq}Ž\„ˆr g" =hQz²t„fq}g`hQŽv.uxc h‘ŽqFzp”UhQoªu,„Auph”Uhzopg`qFŽŽhz

uxcfq}„{FzhArfq}Ž\ux{2®X§ hu

# # ÅwiTÆ

#

# #

! ʼnFÆ

€S{}uxhCuxcfq›u"$#

&%('

®N¯ h8‚ zx{›¡Fhk YhŽ{›¶Rupc=q›u

iF®bdc hSŽžqV¶¤{}£)moq8‚Y{F„Uu,g`qUopo,~tžowuxzp  rtux{U„.{F„`upcfhupcfzphQh„Auxh”FhQzxo *,+

' ² *,+

' *,+.-

q}„f~ /0+1- /}² ¶upc%‚fqFzxqFg`huphQzxo

23 4*5+1-

76

ÅO†UÆ

23 4*5+

' /8+9- 6 - '

: Å1AÆ

23 4*5+

' 76

' œFÆ

‰t®bdc h8”FhQ„ hzq›ux„f”/£¦r „=ƒup{F„%{F£;¹²tžod”F¡FhQ„ ˆv.uxc h‘£¦{FŽŽ{›¶„ ”«£¦{Uzpg"r Žq19

<3=!> 6

@?BADCFEHGJIKMLNPOQGJIQR7ASJO Å;UÆ

+0-

'

?BADCFEHGPIKML)R:OTIKMLNPOTITRJADSPO

+U

'

F?BADCFEHG:IQKML)R:OQGPITRJADSPO

fzp{UgI¶,hQŽŽt¸ˆ„ {›¶„«‚ zx{F‚YhzpuphQo{}£Yc {Fg`{U”Fh„fh{Fr=oy{Fžoxoª{U„/‚ zx{tƒhQoxophQo &i]=9(±²}uxc hƒ{U„ f”Frfzxq}up{F„/ophhQ„" ˆv

q"uwvˆ‚ žƒqFŽY‚=q}zpupžƒ‚fq}„AuŦ¶c žƒc¶,h‘Ž{ˆƒQq›uxh‘q}u‚={U„Au WV

V

X¶¥uxc {Fr udŽ{Uoxod{}£”FhQ„ hzq}Ž¥uwvU²toª{"upcfq}uupc h

qFzphTq‘{}£ „AuphzxhQoªuX«oXupc h‘o Ur=q}zxh3"Y 6Z

3"Y

6

ÆXoXupcfq}u,¶c hQzphSupc hC”Fzx~`c=qFoX{U„ h{F£ ¥uo·„AuphzophQƒux{U„

‚Y{F„Auxo‘q›u \[ :]$x² ¶c hQzph [ qF„f~^] q}zxh«„f~ h‚Yh„f~thQ„Au‘zq}„=~t{Fg ¡›q}zxžq}  ŽhQoQ²\hQqFƒc ¶¥uxc°qr „ £¦{Fzxg

~ oªupzx frtup{F„`{F„`uxc h„Uuxhzx¡›q}Ž_3"` # 6 ®-.„f~thQz,oprfƒc.q8ƒ{U„ f”Frfzxq}up{F„ ²}£ [ #acbF²U¶cfhzxhdcbžo·~th f„ hT~

 ˆv.uxc h8zxhŽžq›up{F„

cb

#

#

!

uxc h„°uxc h`„Arfg/ Yhz8{}£ƒhQŽŽžo‘¶c žƒc „AuphQzxophQƒukuxc h.c {Uzpº{U„Uuq}ŽNoªž~thTo‘{}£,XŸo8hs qFƒuxŽv $+e- ² ¶¥uxc

~ h f„ hT~´qUokqF ={›¡UhF®‘¬±£ [gf b ²\upc žo‘„ˆr g/ Yhz‘žo U+

'

®8bdc h.oxq}g`h"qFzp”Ur g`h„AuC”U¡UhQoSupc h«„ˆr g/ Yhz

{F£·ƒhQŽŽžo„AuphzophQƒux„f”.upc h«¡FhQzªuxƒQq}Ž2opž~thQoC{}£ XY® .Coª„ ”.uxc h/„f~thQ‚=hQ„f~th„=ƒh`q}„f~%uxc h/rf„ ¥£¦{Uzpg`uwvF²Y¶,h

{U tuxqF„uxcfq›uS¶upc´‚ zp{U fq} fŽ¥uwv

E

}²fupc h"„Arfg/ Yhz{F£KƒhŽŽoS„AuxhzoªhTƒup„ ”Xo /+a- /}®d¯ h

{U tuxqF„upcfh8{}upcfhz‚Y{F„Uug.qUopophQo{}£upcfh8ŽqV¶R{F£*¡ˆq`opg`ŽqFzq}zx”Fr g`h„Auo®

¯°h8„ {›¶¢”U¡Uhkupc h8‚ zx{ˆ{}£{}£2uxc hophQƒ{U„f~$£¦{Fzxg/r Žžq ®N¯°h8cfqV¡Fh

R

¶cfhzxhSuxc h‘zxqF„f~t{Fg ¡›q}zxžq}  ŽhQo

”F¡FhCupcfhk„ˆr g" =hQzxo{F£‚fqFzªuxƒ‚fqF„Auxo,„upc h8ƒhŽŽo¶c žƒc„AuphQzxophQƒu

XY®KXqFƒc${}£ uxc hQophS¡›q}zxžq}  ŽhQo,oy{Fžopop{F„.¶upc‚fq}zq}g`huphz,#FU®N¬­„qF~f~t¥ux{U„ ²Aupc hkzq}„f~t{Ug ¡›qFzpžq}  ŽhQo

qF„f~’q}zxh„=~th‚Yh„f~ h„AuQ®Xbdc hQzph£¦{FzxhF²U¶,hSƒQq}„_qF‚ ‚ Žv/uxc hSzxr ŽhS”F¡ˆ„f”‘upc hC”Fh„fhzq›up„ ”‘£¦r „=ƒup{F„

{F£Sq‹zq}„f~ {Fg oªr g {F£zxqF„f~t{Fg ¡›q}zxqF  ŽhQoQ²¶cfƒc oªuxq}uphTouxcfq›u"upc h”FhQ„ hzq›ux„ ”%£¦rf„fƒux{U„ {}£ o

_=`YX¶cfhzxh žoupc h8”Uh„ hQzxq}up„ ”/£¦rf„fƒux{U„{F£;

R

q}„f~ upcfq}u{}£ &iQŠ(±® ,hQzphU²t¶,h‘cfqV¡Uh

_=

?BADCFEHGJIQRJADSJO

qF„f~

= = IKMLNPOQG +1-

' = IK@L)RYO\IKMLDJO +e

' = IKML_RYOQG

qF„f~$upc hophQƒ{F„f~$£¦{Fzxg/r Žžq"£¦{FŽŽ{›¶og`g«hT~tžq›uphQŽv$£¦zp{Ug upcfoQ®

ÈCo~tzphTƒuƒ{U„foªhAr h„fƒhQod{F£2upcfhQoph‘£¦{Fzxg/r ŽžqFoQ²ˆ¶,h‘{F  uxq}„upc hk£¦{UŽŽ{›¶„f”«hst‚ zphTopop{F„fo,£¦{Fz

iF®bdc h8g`hQqF„¡›q}Žr h8{F£;*qF„f~¥uo¡›q}zxqF„fƒh>9

<3 6

/5+9- +1-

' /0+

' *5+1-

+U

'

*5+

'

/5+9- +1-

' /0+

'

/5+9-

+U

'

*5+

' < 3 6

‰t®bdc h8g`hQqF„¡›q}Žr h8{F£ 9 <3 6 #FW< 3 6 ®

† ®bdc h8¡›q}zxqF„fƒhk{}£ Ŧ¶upc%upcfh‘qF ={›¡Uh‘„ {}uq›up{F„=oxÆ9

<3 6

R + < 3 R 6

<3 6 # +

4 # Å ‡}Æ

1f®bdc h‘‚ zx{F fqF  Žuwv`upcfq}ud odŽhQoxo,upcfqF„q/upcfzphToªc {UŽ~K²t¶c hzxh´žoq"„ {U„A„ hQ”Uq}up¡FhS„AuphQ”Fhz 9

23 # 6

Y/5+9- Å=UÆ

+0-

' Y*5+

' *5+1- :

+U

'

:*5+1- :

¶c hzxh

!

?BADCFEG#"

b # !

$&%

ÅOŠUÆ

0 5 10 15 20 25

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

Average Number of Subscribed Groups / Participants

CellArea / IArea

”Ur zxh«i>9XÈ2¡Uhzq}”UhC€rfg/ Yhz{F£Nˆr  =opƒzp =hT~ŸÄkzp{Ur ‚fod‚YhzyNq}zpupžƒ‚fq}„Auo

20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6

% of Superfluous Traffic

CellArea / IArea

”Ur zph‰9XyhQzxƒh„AuxqF”Fhk{}£Kˆr ‚Yhz4*fr {Fr=ob2zq›»_ƒ

1 2

3 4

Participants Intensity 0

1 2 3 4 5 6

CellArea/IArea 0

10 20 30 40

Avg Traffic

”Ur zxh‘†19XÈ2¡Uhzq}”UhCbzxq}».ƒ`ÅO„Arfg/ Yhz{}£Kop{Fr zƒhToxÆ"yqFzªuxƒ‚=q}„Au

1 2

3 4

Participants Intensity 0

1 2 3 4 5 6

CellArea/IArea 0

20 40 60 80 100

Max Traffic

”Ur zxh1 9Xǟq›sbzq›»_ƒ‘bdc zphToªcf{FŽž~ ÅO„Arfg/ Yhz{}£Kop{Fr zƒhToxÆ"yqFzªuxƒ‚=q}„Au¶¥uxc‚#I ®ŠU“

8'* 3)K)

³Crfz”U{UqFŽU„/uxc žoKoªhTƒup{F„«žoup{‘q}„fqFŽvˆºh,upcfhg`‚fqFƒuK{}£fuxc h

?

?

# ²}{F„"upc huxzxq}».ƒ zphTƒh¡FhT~

 ˆv ‚fq}zpupžƒ‚fq}„Auo²2upc h$qV¡Uhzq}”Uh"„ˆr g" =hQz/{}£opr  foxƒzx YhQ~+g"r Ž¥uxƒQqFoªu”Fzx{Fr ‚=o‘‚=hQz/‚fqFzªuxƒ‚fqF„AuxoQ²q}„=~

uxc hS‚YhzƒhQ„Auxq}”Uh{}£2opr ‚Yhz4*fr {UrfoKuxzxq}».ƒSzphTƒhQ¡UhQ~®¬­„${Fz~thQzKup{" =h‘qFo·”Fh„fhzxƒqUoX‚Y{Uoxoª  ŽhF²A¶,hS£¦{tƒrfo

g`{Uzphk‚fq}zpupžƒrfŽqFzpŽv`{F„upc h‘g«‚=qFƒu{F£2upcfh8zxq}up{" Yhuw¶hhQ„$uxc h

?

?

qF„f~_uxc h0X

?

²  ®hF®²tupc h

opr zp£OqFƒh_{}£dupcfhq}zxhQq%{F£„AuxhzxhQoªuQ®´bdc žozq›ux{´oJ9 EHG

V G

®´€{Fuph_uxcfq›u«¶,hqFoxoªr g`h_cfhzxh.upcfq}u«qFŽŽ,upc h

‚=q}zpupžƒ‚fq}„Auxo”Uh„ hQzxq}uphkupc h8oxq}g`h8q}g`{Frf„Uu{F£uxzxq}».ƒF®

”Fr zxh´i%opc {›¶ouxcfq›u`uxc hqV¡Uhzq}”Uh.„Arfg/ Yhz`{}£Copr  foxƒzx =hT~9g/rfŽ¥uxƒQqFoªu«”Uzp{Ur ‚fo"‚=hQz«‚=q}zpupžƒ‚fq}„Auxo

< 3 6 ~thQƒzphTqFophQoopc {FzpupŽvqUoupcfh ? ? q}‚f‚ zp{AqFƒc hToupc hX ? ® ,{›¶h¡UhzT²fqFoupc h ? ?

„fƒzphTqFophQo,£¦r zpupc hQzQ²ˆuxc hqV¡FhQzxqF”FhS„ˆr g" =hQz{}£Koªrf fopƒzp YhQ~”Fzx{Fr ‚fod~thTƒzxhQqUoªhToopŽ{›¶ŽvU®

”Fr zxh"‰`‚fŽ{FuxoSupc h«qV¡Fhzq}”Uh‘‚=hQzxƒh„AuxqF”Fh8{}£·opr ‚Yhz4*fr {Urfouxzxq}».ƒ/{FrtuC{}£Kupcfhup{FuxqFŽ2uxzxq}».ƒzphTƒh¡FhT~

 ˆv‹q‚fq}zpupžƒ‚fqF„UuT®/ÈSokuxc h`‚fq}zpupžƒ‚fqF„UuoCqFzph«Ž{ˆƒQq›uxhQ~‹{U„‹uxc h`‚ ŽqF„ h.qFƒQƒ{Fz~t„ ”.ux{%qzq}„f~t{Ug c {}¨

g`{U”Fh„fh{Fr=oy{Fžopop{F„¹‚Y{F„Au"‚ zx{tƒhQoxoQ²2uxc o"‚Yhzƒh„Auq}”Fh$oJ9

' V G

E G

®´¯°h${F =oªhQzp¡Uh`upcfq}u"¶c hQ„

uxc h

?

?

žo‘  ”F”UhzkupcfqF„´uxc h$X

?

²g«{Uzph"upc=q}„9‡ I {F£·uxc h«upzq›»_ƒ/žo8opr ‚=hQz *=r {FrfoQ®"bdcfo

zxhQopr Žu·oªrf”F”FhTowuoupcfq}uX¶c h„`uxc h

?

?

o·oªg.q}ŽŽhzNupc=q}„«upc hdX

?

²Aq8opŽ”UcUuX~tg`„ˆrtux{U„.{}£Yupc h

?

?

~thTƒzxhQqFophQooª”F„f=ƒQq}„AupŽvkupc huxzxq}».ƒ,zxhQƒhQ¡UhQ~8 ˆv‘uxc hdzphTƒh¡FhQzQ®/,{›¶h¡FhQzQ²TuNžog`‚Y{FzpuxqF„Uu

ux{$„ {Fupžƒh"upcfq}u‡<I {}£oªr ‚Yhz4*fr {UrfoSupzq›»_ƒžoCqUƒƒh‚tuq}  Žh"ƒ{Fg`‚fq}zxhQ~Ÿup{upc h`oªupr=q›up{F„´¶c hzxh"qFŽŽ

uxc h8rfophzodƒ{Fg`g"r „ žƒq›uxh‘{F„Ÿq`oª„ ”FŽh‘g/r ŽupžƒqUowu”Uzp{Ur ‚ &†(±®

”Fr zxhŸ†+oªc {›¶o«uxc h‹qV¡FhQzxqF”Fh$upzq›»_ƒzphTƒh¡FhT~  ˆv q+‚=q}zpupžƒ‚fq}„AuQ²~th‚Yh„=~t„f”¹{F„¤upc hŸ„AuphQ„foªuwv

{F£‚=q}zpupžƒ‚fq}„Auxod„upc h8©k²=qF„f~upc h8zq›ux{` Yhuw¶hhQ„uxc h

?

?

q}„f~uxc h8X

?

®bdc h8‚fq}zpupžƒ¨

‚fqF„UuC„AuphQ„fop¥uwvzphQ‚ zxhQoph„Auxodc hQzphupc h/qV¡Uhzq}”Uhk„ˆr g" =hQz{}£K‚fqFzªuxƒ‚=q}„AuxoS‚=hQzX

?

9d A®ˆrfƒc‹q

¶dqVvup{hst‚ zxhQoxouxc h`~th„fopuwvŸ{}£,‚=q}zpupžƒ‚fq}„AuC„+q_©C žo‘¡Fhzxv%rfoph£¦r Ž² qFoku‘qFŽŽ{›¶oSr=oSux{%g«{t~t£¦v

uxc h

?

?

¶upc {UrtudcfqV¡ˆ„ ”«q}„g`‚fqUƒu{F„.uxc h‘¡›q}Žr hC{F£ upcfh‘~ h„fop¥uwvU®Kbdc hCzxhQopr Žuxodopc {›¶oXuxcfq›u

£¦{Uz.q´”U¡Uh„ ¡›qFŽr h%{F£C‚fqFzªuxƒ‚fqF„Au«„Auph„=oªuwvF²,¥u.žo`‚={Aopop fŽhup{#f„f~ upcfh f”U”FhQoªu`zxq}up{  Yhuw¶hhQ„

uxc h ? ? qF„f~+uxc hX ? ²Xoª{%uxcfq›u"upc hqV¡Fhzq}”Uh/uxzxq}»_ƒ.zphQg.q}„for „=~thz«q‹oªr ».ƒhQ„AupŽv°Ž{›¶

uxc zxhQopc {FŽž~®Kbdc hqV¡FhQzxqF”Fhuxzxq}»_ƒCžo”U¡Uh„$ ˆv9# < 3 6®

„fq}ŽŽvF²(”Frfzph;1$‚ zp{U fq} fŽv%oªcf{›¶odupc h"g`{UoªuC„UuxhzxhQoªup„ ”.zxhQopr Ž¥uo®S¬­„‹{Fz~thzup{oxq›uxoª£¦vupc h"rfoªhQzxo

{F£kq°©C²X¥u_žo. Yhupuphz`ux{9~thuxhzxg`„ hŸqF„¤qF‚ ‚ zx{F‚ zxq}uph

?

?

op{°upcfq}u.upc hŸ„fƒ{Fg`„f” uxzxq}»_ƒ

zxhg.qF„fo«¶upc q°c ”Fc¤‚ zp{U fq} fŽ¥uwv¹ YhŽ{›¶ uxc h%g.q›stg"r g uxzxq}».ƒuxcfq›u`upcfhv;ƒQq}„;cfq}„f~ ŽhU®µbdcfo

fsˆhT~%‚ zx{F fqF  Žuwvzxh)*fhTƒuoupcfh8upzqF~thQ{ 3° =huw¶,hQh„Ÿuxc h"oxq›uxoª£OqFƒup{F„%{}£Kuxc hrfophzoSqF„f~upc h"„ˆr g/ Yhz

{F£Sg/rfŽ¥uxƒQqFoªu«”Uzp{Ur ‚fo"„ hhT~thQ~® ”Fr zxh 1 opc {›¶ouxcfq›u`£¦{Uz«q ”F¡FhQ„9„Auxh„fop¥uwv¹{F£S‚fqFzªuxƒ‚fqF„AuxoQ²X¥u

žoC‚={Aopop fŽh/up{f„f~Ÿuxc h/ f”U”FhQoªu

?

?

Ŧ®hU®²\uxc h`oªg.q}ŽŽhQoªuC„ˆr g/ Yhzk{}£Xg"r ŽupžƒqFoªu‘”Fzx{Fr ‚foƲ\op{

uxcfq›u8uxc h_„fƒ{Ug`„ ”uxzxq}».ƒ`zxhg.qF„fo‘ YhŽŽ{›¶ qŸoprt»_ƒh„AupŽv´Ž{›¶ uxc zxhQopc {FŽž~°¶¥uxc+q%‚fzp{U fq}  Ž¥uwv‹{F£

If®ŠA“t®NÇ%{Fzxh{›¡UhzT²V£¦{Fz,q”F¡Fh„

?

?

²F¶h{F =oªhQzp¡Uhdupcfq}uXupc žo·upzq›»_ƒ„fƒzxhQqUoªhToNŽ„ hQqFzpŽv«¶¥uxc.upc h

„AuphQ„foªuwv_{F£‚fqFzªuxƒ‚=q}„AuxoQ®

'*3'7 08 0 3'*8 0 . ' 8 .Y)KY8%(!

bdcfokoªhTƒux{U„Ÿ„Aupzx{t~trfƒhQokq.g`{ˆ~ hŽN{}£Xg`{F fŽ¥uwv%¶c žƒc‹žoSƒ{Fg`‚fq›ux fŽh"¶¥uxc‹upcfh"qFoxopr g`‚tup{F„Ÿuxcfq›u

uxc h‚={U„AuN‚ zp{tƒhQoxo2{F£f‚fq}zpupžƒ‚fqF„Uuo2žoNy{Fžopop{F„q}uNqF„Avkuxg`hF²Uq}„f~/¶c ƒc«q}ŽŽ{›¶orfo2up{‘~thzx¡Fh·¡›qFzp{Frfo

g`hTq}„¡VqFŽrfhQod{}£N„UuxhzxhQoªu„%zxhŽžq›up{F„¶¥uxc%g«{U  ŽuwvF®Xbdc žo„fƒŽrf~thToArfq}„AupuphQooprfƒcŸqFo

bdc h‘cfq}„=~t{›¡FhQz,„qF„f~{Frtuq"g/r ŽupžƒqUowu”Fzx{Frf‚ ²t~th f„fhQ~qFo,upc h8„AuphQ„foªuwv.{}£upc hkuxg`h8‚Y{F„Uu

‚ zx{ˆƒhQoxo{F£uxc h"ƒzp{Aopop„ ”Uo{F£Nupc h" ={Ur „f~ qFzpv{}£Kuxc h"ƒ{FzxzphToª‚Y{F„f~ „ ”.ƒhŽŽ ˆvg«{›¡ˆ„ ”_‚fqFzªuxƒ¥¨

‚fq}„Auo%"

bdc h$g`hTq}„9zxhQop~ h„fƒh.upg`h{F£SqŸuwvˆ‚ žƒq}Ž,‚fq}zpupžƒ‚fqF„Uu"¶¥uxc „¤q‹g"r Ž¥uxƒQqFoªu"”Uzp{Ur ‚ ²„fq}g`hŽv

¶¥uxc „%upc h8ƒ{UzpzxhQop‚Y{F„f~t„ ”`ƒhQŽŽ®

bdcfh«qUopopr g`‚tup{F„ o‘oªupŽŽuxcfq›u‘‚fq}zpupžƒ‚fqF„UuoCqFzph«„ ¥uxqFŽŽvŸŽ{ˆƒQq›uxhQ~´qUƒƒ{Fz~t„f”.up{%qy{Uoxoª{U„‹‚Y{F„Uu

‚fzp{tƒhTopo2{}£f„AuphQ„foªuwv5 ®N€{k‚fqFzªuxƒ‚fqF„Auh„Auxhz{FzŽhTqV¡FhKuxc h,”Aq}g`hF®€hQ¡FhzpupcfhŽhQoxo²VhQqUƒc‚fqFzªuxƒ‚fqF„Au

g`{›¡UhQoN{F„«uxc h‚ Žžq}„ hCqFƒƒ{Fz~t„ ”kup{q}„.„f~thQ‚=hQ„f~thQ„Uu,zxqF„f~t{Fg g`{}up{F„.~thTopƒzp YhQ~.qFoK£¦{FŽŽ{›¶oJ92q8‚fqFz

{F£zq}„=~t{Fg ¡›qFzpžq}  ŽhQo

p²fžoqFoxop{ˆƒq}uphT~$¶upc%‚fqFzªuxƒ‚fqF„Au

$

² ¶cfhzxh X

L

žodupc h8zq}„=~t{Fg

¡UhŽ{tƒuwv«{F£ upcfhC‚fqFzªuxƒ‚=q}„AuqF„f~

3" - uxozxqF„f~t{Ug ~ zxhQƒup{F„ ®N¬±udodqFoxopr g`hQ~`uxcfq›uq}ŽŽ\‚fq}zxo

dqFzph«„f~th‚Yh„=~th„Auq}„f~´~ h„AupžƒqFŽŽv‹~tžowuxzp  rtuxhQ~°q}„f~‹upcfq}ukuxc h`zxqF„f~t{Ug ¡›qFzpžq}  ŽhQo

R

R

qFzphS„f~ h‚Yh„f~thQ„AuQ²ˆ¶¥uxc R

{F£2~th„=oªuwv{U„X

L

qF„f~`¶¥uxc

r „ £¦{Fzxg {U„^3"` - p®Nbdcfq}„f¸ˆo·up{/upc h

op{`ƒq}ŽŽhQ~~top‚ ŽžqFƒhg`h„Audupc hQ{Fzxhg ÅoªhQh+&i]=(²f‚ ®/; iVƲAupc h8‚Y{F„Au‚ zp{tƒhQoxo,”U¡ˆ„ ”«upc h‘Ž{tƒq›ux{U„{F£qFŽŽ

‚=q}zpupžƒ‚fq}„AuxooCowuxŽŽq.y{Uoxoª{U„Ÿ‚={U„AuS‚fzp{tƒhTopo{}£K„Auxh„fop¥uwv q›uCqF„Av$upg`h²\oª{`uxcfq›uCupc h"zphToªr Žuxo

{F£2uxc h8‚ zxh¡ˆ{UrfoophQƒux{U„qFzph‘oªupŽŽ ¡›qFŽž~%q›uq}„ˆv$oprfƒcupg«hU®

§2hu_ Yhdq sthQ~"oªhQ”Fg`h„AuN{}£fŽh„ ”Fupc²›¶c žƒc/¶h,ƒQq}„«qFoxoªr g`h·up{k =hdŽ{ˆƒQq›uxhQ~8{U„upcfhcf{FzxºQ{F„AuxqFŽ

q}sto‘¶upc {Urtu/Ž{Uoxo‘{}£”FhQ„ hzq}ŽuwvF®_bdc h$ophu{F£‚=q}zpupžƒ‚fq}„Auxo¶¥uxc+q%g`{Fup{F„+‚fq}zhUr=q}ŽKux{

qF„f~%¶c žƒc´ƒzx{Uoxo+ Yhuw¶hhQ„Ÿupg`hU"_qF„f~oSupc=q›uC„ upžq}ŽŽv%Ž{tƒq›uxhQ~%„´q.‚fqFzxqFŽŽhŽ{F”UzxqFg {}£XqFzphTq

!"¥®«bdcfh`ophu8{F£,‚fqFzªuxƒ‚fqF„Auxok¶¥uxc°qg`{}ux{U„´‚fqFz‘„´uxc h_ophu3 +$#%

6 Z

3 +$# 6

o

y{Uoxoª{U„´¶upc+„Uuxh„fopuwv & #%!')(

+*

2bdcfhzxh£¦{FzxhF² upc h.g`hQqF„ „ˆr g" =hQz8{}£d‚fq}zpupžƒ‚fqF„Uuo8ƒzx{Uoxoª„ ”,

 Yhuw¶hhQ„$uxg`h5"`q}„=~,,žo

-/.

b -

*

b 0 1"" 2 #3

#

-4

- 5 <3 6

à {U„foªž~thQzdq/uwvˆ‚ žƒq}ŽƒhŽŽ²ˆ„fqFg«hQŽvq"o Arfq}zxhS¶upc‚=hQzpg`huxhz16 #U®* zx{Fg ¶cfq}u‚fzphTƒhQ~ hQoQ²A¶hk”Fhu

uxc h‘£¦{FŽŽ{›¶„ ”`hsˆ‚fzphTopop{U„$£¦{Uzupcfh8g«hTq}„%¡›q}Žr h8{}£upcfhcfq}„=~t{›¡FhQz„Ÿq}„f~{UrtuupcfoƒhŽŽ ‚Yhzr „f¥uS{F£

uxg`h>9 7

98

#W< 3 6

ŪiJIUÆ

Cr hCup{/upc h‘~tžoª‚ ŽžqFƒhg`h„Au,upc hQ{Fzxhg%²ˆ¶,hkƒq}„owuxŽŽ\rfoªhSupc h‘y{Fžopop{F„.ŽžqV¶µ£¦{Fz,upcfhC„ˆr g" =hQz,{F£2‚fq}zpupžƒ¨

‚fqF„Uuo„%upc žokƒhŽŽq}ukqF„Av$upg`hF®¬±uog`hQqF„Ÿ¡VqFŽrfh/žo:9d#FF®Cˆ„fƒh8uxc h/„AuphQ„foªuwv{}£Kupcfhh„Aupzq}„=ƒhQo

„Aup{«upcfhƒhŽŽ žo;:

²f§ uªuxŽh oŽžqV¶ ”F¡FhQo,uxc h‘£¦{FŽŽ{›¶„ ”`hst‚ zxhQoxop{U„_£¦{Fzduxc h8g`hQqF„zxhQopž~th„fƒhkupg«h8{F£

q«‚fqFzªuxƒ‚=q}„Au„Ÿq"uwvˆ‚ ƒQq}Žg"r Ž¥uxƒQqFoªu”Fzx{Fr ‚ 9

<3< 6 - #F

7 #

6B<3 6

ŪiFiTÆ

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2

Mean Residence Time per Cell (sec)

Velocity (CellSize/sec)

”Frfzph“$9XÇ%hTq}„%lhQopž~th„fƒhbdg`h

”Fr zxh«“oªcf{›¶oupcfh«g`hTq}„‹zxhQop~ h„fƒhupg`h"‚Yhz8ƒhŽŽ;< 3< 6

qFokq$£¦r „fƒux{U„´{F£Xupc h«‚fqFzªuxƒ‚fqF„Au

g`hTq}„´¡UhŽ{tƒuwv.<3 6

®«¯°h«hst‚ zphTopoCuxc h`¡FhŽ{tƒuwvŸ„+ƒhQŽŽ¨­oªºh«‚=hQzoªhTƒ{U„f~®/¯°h`{F fophzx¡Fh/upcfq}u8upc h

g`hTq}„´zxhQopž~th„fƒhuxg`h`~thQƒzphTqFophQoChst‚={U„ h„AuxqFŽŽvŸqFoSupc h`g`hQqF„´¡FhQŽ{tƒ¥uwv%”FhuxokƒŽ{UophzCup{°i«ƒhŽŽ¥¨­opºQh

‚YhzCoªhTƒ{F„=~®Xbdc žozphToªrfŽ¥uSqFzp”Ur hQo„%£OqV¡F{Fzd{F£Nq`Žg`uphT~¡UhŽ{tƒuwv_„‹§ˆ©C²=op{"uxcfq›uuxc hzxhQop~ h„fƒh

uxg`h8‚YhzƒhŽŽ zphQg.q}„fodc ”Fc hQz ˆv{Fz~thzo{}£g.qF”F„ uprf~ hCuxcfq}„uxc hd|w{F„Ÿq}„f~ŽhTqV¡FhkŽq}uphQ„fƒvU®

/5( !/›! 2/ !/5 5 &‘!/&m·

¬­„upc žoNoªhTƒup{F„2²›¶,h~thQoxƒzx Yh,q£¦zxqFg`h¶{Fzx¸S£¦{UzqCopƒQq}Žžq}  Žh·ƒ{Ug`g/r „ žƒq}up{F„/qFzxƒcf¥uxhQƒuxr zxhK£¦{FzN§ˆ©k®

¯°hd =hQŽh¡Uh·uxcfq›uNux{ˆ~fqVvF²Foprfƒc/g.qF„AvA¨up{F¨g.q}„ˆv8q}‚f‚ Žžƒq}up{F„foQ²V¶¥uxc`‚={Fuph„AuxqFŽŽv‘upc {Urfoxq}„f~ o{F£=rfophzo²

zxh Ar zxh"g`„ g.qFŽXg.q}„fqF”Fhg`hQ„UuqF„f~ qU~tg`„foªupzq›ux{U„°opr ‚ ‚Y{FzpuQ®.¬­„f~ hhQ~ ²2uxc h.„ˆr g/ Yhz8{F£‚fqFzªuxƒ¥¨

‚=q}„Auxo,„%oprfƒc$q}‚f‚ Žžƒq}up{F„fo,žo·ux{ˆ{"Žžq}zx”Fhux{/uxzxqF„fopg«uq}ŽŽY~ q}uxq/up{`q}ŽŽ=r=oªhQzxodq}„=~`up{«Žhu,uxc hg fŽ¥uxhz

{Urtu/uxc h$‚=q}zpu"{}£uxc h~fq›uxq‹upc hQv¹q}zxh_„AuxhzxhQoªuphQ~9„ ®°bdc žo/¶{Fr Žž~¹„ {Fu"{U„ Žv°¶dqFoªuph$„fhuw¶{Fzx¸ q}„=~

hQ„f~ˆ¨±c {UoªuxoCzxhQop{Fr zƒhTo²=  rtu8q}Žžoª{zphToªr ŽuC„‹uxc h"£OqFoªu‘~thQ”FzqF~ q}up{F„Ÿ{F£Kupc h`q}‚ ‚fŽžƒq}up{F„‹‚Yhzp£¦{Fzxg.q}„fƒh

q}uupc h8hQ„f~ˆ¨±rfophzT®X¯ h8‚fzphToªhQ„UuSq«uxzxqF„fop‚={Uzªup¨ŽžqVvFhQzop{FŽrtup{F„¶upcŸg/rfŽ¥ux‚ Žhq}”Uh„AuxoQ²fqUopopr g`„f”"uxcfq›u

qFŽŽ upc hr=oªhQzxoqFzphƒQq}‚fqF  Žhk{F£KzphTƒh¡ˆ„f”.g/r ŽupžƒqUowuuxzxqF„foªg`žopop{F„foQ®,bdc h8”U{UqFŽ {}£upc žoSqFzxƒcf¥uxhQƒuxr zxh

žoKux{/g.q}¸Uh§ˆ©k9oxƒq}Žžq} fŽh¶upc_upc {UrfopqF„f~ o·{}£c huxhzx{F”Uh„ hQ{FrfoNrfophzoX{U„`upc hC¬­„Auphzx„ huQ®XÇ%{Fzxh{›¡UhzT²

¶h8ƒŽžq}g upc=q›uupcfoop{FŽrtux{U„¶{Fzx¸to,¶upcŸq«Žg`uphQ~„ˆr g" =hQz{}£NqV¡VqFŽžq} fŽhkg/r ŽupžƒqUowu”Uzp{Ur ‚foQ®

¬­„"{Fz~thzux{kqFŽŽ{›¶¹‚fq}zpupžƒ‚fqF„Uuoup{‘oªhQŽhTƒuNupc h„t£¦{Fzxg.q›up{F„/upc hQv¶{Fr Žž~Ž¸Uh·ux{‘zphTƒh¡FhU²V¶,h‚ zx{F‚Y{Uoph

g`hTƒcfq}„ žopg`orfoª„ ”‹g"r Žup‚ Žh$g/r ŽupžƒqUowu/”Uzp{Ur ‚foQ®·qFƒc¹‚fqFzªuxƒ‚fqF„Au|w{F„fo/qF„f~+ŽhQqV¡FhTo‘g/r ŽupžƒqUowu

”Uzp{Ur ‚foQ²t~th‚Yh„f~ „ ”.{U„$uxc hz„AuphzxhQoªu„uxc hƒ{U„Uuxh„Au{}£upc h~ q}uxq"upzq}„=oªg`uªuphT~®