HAL Id: inria-00110085
https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00110085v2
Submitted on 30 Oct 2006
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Scheduling Issues on Thermally-Constrained Processors
Pierre Michaud, Yiannakis Sazeides
To cite this version:
Pierre Michaud, Yiannakis Sazeides. Scheduling Issues on Thermally-Constrained Processors. [Re- search Report] RR-6006, INRIA. 2006. �inria-00110085v2�
a p p o r t
d e r e c h e r c h e
INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE
Scheduling Issues on Thermally-Constrained Processors
Pierre Michaud , Yiannakis Sazeides
N˚6006
Octobre 2006
Systèmes communicants
0(13254647298:13;=<?>A@B
∗ CED 1F>AGEG?>AH*1JILK>AM52N1JB2NI
†
OQPSRUTWVYXZ6R[Y\]XX^`_bac[6de_5TWR
fhg \eiUZTkjml f O
n d]o`oA\ g Tp`Z g Z7[rq`Z g [rq`Z_sNt]u]uNtwvyxk["TW\]z g Z/{eu]uNt/v}|7~obdeNZ6R
E6 Y=`] ] q`Z g ZYcZY_5TWZ7RRac_b[ g Z6dNRZ\]koA\=.Z g pSZY_RaTUPqbdNR g Z6_bpSZ g Z7pTWZYXoZ g deT^ g Zdo g a
X-d g PpSZ6Rac]_[Y\]_bRTg deac_5T\ g Xac[ g \No g \Q[YZ6RWR\ g R6lTqb\]^`NqdoA\=mZ g p`ZY_bRaTUPac_b[ g Z7d]RZpS\QZ6R$_`\eT
_bZ6[Z7RRWd g acPcZ6d]pT\dq`ac]q`Z g TacXZYFd NZ g deNZ-TZ6XoAZ g d=TW^ g Z]¡¢mZ£Rqb\=¤a_¥TWq`acR-RT^pSPTqd=T-aTLac_S
[ g Z7d]RZ6R$TqbZdeXo`caTW^bpSZ£\ekTZ6XoZ g deT^ g Z£\NRW[ac¦d=TWa\N_bR6§l¨RLd[\N_bRZ7©5^`ZY_b[YZ]¡.Tq`Z gX-d]Tq g \eTTca_`
X-d PzZZY_bNdeNZ6pX\
g
Z\]ªTZY_de_bpp`ZY
g
d]p`ZLoZ
g
\
g
X-d]_b[ZN«wZZ6RTWd]z`cacRqTqbdeTdo\5RRazbZmd P
TW\9pSZ7[
g
Z6d]RZTqbZdeXo`caT^bpSZ\eTWZYXoZ
g
deT^
g
ZL\5R[YaccdeTac\]_bR(acRT\ac_b[
g
Z7d]RZ-Tq`Z6a
g g
Z7©5^`ZY_b[YP]¬_d
X$^`Taco g \N g deXXZ6p-Z6_Q5ag \]_`XZY_5T7¡NZY®QZ7[^STWa_b$X$^`TWaobZkTq gZ7d]p`R"¯ o g \S[Z7RRZ6R.deTZ g _bdeTZYcP-[Yd]_ g Z6R^`T
ac_LTWZYXoAZ g d=T^ g Zk\NRW[ac¦d=TWa\N_bR.ap`a°Z g ZY_5TmTq g Z6dNp`Rm]ZY_bZ g d=TZkpSa°AZ g Z6_NToA\=.Z g pSZ6_bRaTWaZ7RY«Z¨TWq`Z g Z
\ g ZLR^`N]Z6RT±TqbdeT6¡d]R/oA\=mZ g pSZ6_bRaTUPwa_b[ g Z7d]RZ6R/d]_bpo g \S[YZ6RWR\ g Rk]ZYT(²d]RTZ g ¡Tq`ZLTacXZRcac[YZL[Yd]_
d]_bp¥Rq`\N^`¦pzAZpSZ6[ g Z7d]RZ6p&§³´Rac_`dRq`\ gTTacXZRca¦[Z£de¦R\ZY_dez`cZ6RTWq`Z£\]oAZ g d=TWa_`RPQRTZ6XµT\
Trde¶NZd]p` d]_5TWdeNZ-\e¨dN["TWaQaTUPXac g d=TWa\N_aTWq`\]^ST-RoZ7[a¦ded g [rq`aTWZ6[T^ g demR^`obo\ gT7w¬_bp`ZYZ6p*¡h\]_d
TWq`Z g X-decP[\N_bRUT g d]a_bZ6pX^`TaF[Y\ g ZL· jm¸wj¹¡dN["TacQaTUPXa g deTac\]_[Yde_zAZ(cZY]Z g d]]Z7pLTW\LpSZ6[ g Z7d]RZ
TWZYXoAZ g d=T^ g ZzQPzZYTTZ g p`acRT g azb^STac_`(q`Z7d=T¢\=NZ g TWq`Z¨pSa°Z g ZY_5T.[\ g Z7RYEº`^ gTqbZ g X\ g ZN¡]mZRqb\=TWqbd=T
²d]ag RW[rq`Z6p`^`ac_`±aTq-pSa°AZ g Z6_NTTWq g Z7d]p$o g a\ g aTacZ6R[Yd]_zAZd][rq`acZYNZ6pz`^ST g Z6©5^`ag Z7RR\]XZTWaXZ7RET\ g ^b_
RacX^`TWd]_`ZY\N^bRcPZYmZ g Tq g Z7d]p`R¨Tqde_[\ g Z6R¨q`Z6_ZYmZ g TWq g Z7d]p`R±d g ZR^`»-[YaZ6_5T¨TW\X-deac_5TWd]a_wTq`Z
jm¸jd=T±TWq`Z g X-dehRWd=T^ g deTac\]_*«Zo g\No\5RZd£R[rqbZ6pS^`cac_`XZYTq`\SpwTqbdeT(aXo`cZYXZ6_NTrR/d][Tac5aTUP
Xac g d=TWa\N_q`acZ$TWd]¶5ac_`a_5T\[\N_bRacpSZ g deTac\]_pSa°Z g ZY_5T±Tq g Z6dNp£o g a\ g aTacZ6R6±«wZ-Rq`\=,TqbdeT6¡&^`_pSZ g
d$TWZYXoZ
g
deT^
g
Z([\N_bRT
g
deac_NT7¡QTq`a¦RRW[rq`Z6p`^`ac_`XZTWq`\Spo
g
\=Qa¦pSZ6Rd$²dea
g
obd
g
TWaTWa\N_`ac_`\eETq`Z/\=NZ
g
dec
[Y\]Xo`^STWa_b£o\=mZ
g
\]d jm¸wj¼q`acZLp`ZYcaNZ
g
a_`£dN\Nzbde?ZY®QZ7[^STWa\N_Tq
g
\]^`Nq`o`^ST[Y\5RZTW\£Tq`Z
X-de®QacX^bXTq
g
\]^b]q`o`^`T6
½£¾5¿ÀWÁÂ =ÃE] ¸^`TWa[\ g Zo g \S[Z6RWR\ g ¡TZYXoAZ g d=TW^ g ZN¡hTWq g Z7d]pR[rq`Z7pS^`ca_bb¡?TWaXZRa¦[ZN¡¢d][Tac5aTUP
Xac g d=TWa\N_
ĦÅ&ÆÇFÈ6ÉÆÊEËcÇFÌJÍÎ
∗Ï ÐÑÓÒFÔ=ÕrÖ ×=ØEÑÓÙ3ÑÓÚJÕ7ÛÜcÙ
†Ý ÕrÞ ß"ÚØEÒUÚÛÖ7Ò Ý ÛÕrÒ"ÛÒÝ
Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes
m($)E$) )
Zobd g d]^`]XZ6_NTrd=TWa\N_[\N_NTWa_Q^`ZmpSZcd¨pSZY_RaTpSZmo`^`a¦RRWde_[Z.p`acRWRacoYZ]¡]cd´TZ6Xo g d=
TW^ g Z(Z6RTkpSZ6]Z6_5^bZ(^`_`Z[Y\]_5T g deac_5TZ/acXo\ g Trde_5TZpbde_bR¨cd[\]_[ZYo`Tac\]_pSZ7RXac[ g \No g \Q[YZ6RWRZ6^ g RYmaZ6_
©5^^`_`Z±de^b]XZY_5TWdeTac\]_p`Z¨¦dpSZ6_bRaTkpSZko`^`a¦RWRd]_b[Z¨_d]^`]XZ6_NTWZ¨od]R._6[YZ6RWRd]ag ZYXZY_5T¢¦d$X\=PNZY_`_bZ
TWZYXoA\ g ZYcZ¢p`Z¢¦dTZ6Xo g deT^ g Z]¡ _`\N^bR*X\]_5Tg \N_bRp`d]_bR[YZTTZYT^bp`Z.©5^`Z.[YZY¦dde^b]XZY_5TZ¢deXo`caTW^bpSZ
p`Z6R/\5R[YaccdeTac\]_bRpSZ-TZ6Xo g deT^ g Z]h_[\N_bR6©5^`ZY_[Z]¡Z7R(X6[6de_`a¦RXZ7R(de^`T\]X-deTa¦©N^bZ6R(pSZ g 7pS^b["
TWa\N_pSZcd£ob^`acRWRWde_b[YZpSa¦RRaoYZN¡h©5^`amp`aXac_5^bZY_5T$¦doAZ g \ g X-de_b[YZ]¡?RZp6[YZ6_b[rq`ZY_5To`^R$R\]^`NZY_5T6
\]^bR.X\]_5T g \]_R¢©5^de^`NXZ6_5TZ g cdg 6©5^`ZY_[Z¨p`Z6R.\NRW[ac¦d=TWa\N_bRhZ7RUT^`_p`Z6R.X\=PNZY_bR¢oZ g XZYTTWd]_5TpSZ
g 6p`^`ag Z-cZY^ g deXo`caTW^bpSZ] d]_bR(^`_ZY_QQag \]_`_bZYXZY_5T(X^bTWao g \] g d]XX N¡ZY®6[^`Tac\]_deTZ g _!YZpSZ
ob^bRacZY^
g
R±o
g
\Q[YZ6RWR^R¨oAZY^`T("Y_!
g Z g
pSZ6R/\5R[Yac¦d=Tac\]_Rkp`Z$TWZYXo
g
d=T^
g
Z-Ra?Z7R/pSa°#
g
ZY_5TrR±o
g
\S[YZ6RWR^bR
o g
\SpS^`a¦RZY_5T(pSa°#
g
ZY_5TWZ6R(pSZ6_bRaT6R(pSZo`^`a¦RRWde_b[YZ]
\]^bR/Z6_p6pS^bacR\]_bR©N^bZ-de^`NXZY_5TWdeTac\]_pSZ-cd
p`ZY_bRaTkp`Z¨o`^bacRWRd]_b[Z¨ZTpSZkcdoZ
g
\
g
X-de_[Z¨p`Z6Rmo
g
\Q[YZ6RWRZ6^
g
R¢pS\NaTZToZ6^STRd][6[\]Xobd]]_`Z
g
p$^`_`Z
p`aXac_5^`Tac\]_pS^©5^bd]_5T^`X p`Z¨TWZYXobR6 Z±o`c^bR6¡S^`_oZYTaT´©N^de_5T^`X pSZkTZYXobRoAZ g XZTde^RPSRTV6XZ
pZY®Qob\NaTrd=Tac\]_pSZz6_&%A[acZ g p`ZLcdXac g d=TWa\N_p$d]["TWaQaTRWde_R/X-d=T g acZYmRo6[Yacd]3'¢_Z°ZT7¡R^ g
^b_£o g \S[YZ6RWRZ6^ g X^bTWa[\QZY^ g R\]^bR[Y\]_5T g deac_5TZ±TWq`Z g Xac©5^`Z· jm¸wj¹¡¦d-Xa g deTac\]_£p$d][Tac5aToZ g
XZYT¨pSZ$p`aXac_5^bZ g ¦dTWZYXo g deT^ g Z(Z6_ g 6obd gTa¦RRWde_5T¦dLpSa¦RRaod=Tac\]_p`Z[rqbdecZY^ g Y5decZYXZY_5T´R^ g cZ6R
p`a°# g ZY_5TWR[Y\QZY^ g RY Z/o`c^bR6¡`_`\]^RX\N_5T g \]_bR©5^^`_\ g pS\]_b_bde_b[YZYXZY_5T6©5^`aTWd]z`Z(d NZ6[kpSa° gZ6_NTWZ6R
o gac\ g aT6R.pSZ´o g \S[Z7RR^bRh_!6[Z7RRaTZobd g \NacR.p$Z®6[Y^STZ g RaX$^`TWde_!YXZY_5T.X\Na_bRmpSZ¨o g\S[YZ6RWR^bR.©5^`Z¨pSZ
[Y\QZY^ g R±\ g RW©5^`ZL[Z6cdZ7RUTR^S»LRWde_5T(o\N^ g X-deac_5TZ6_`ag Z jm¸j¼Z6_RdeT^ g d=TWa\N_wTWq`Z g Xac©5^`ZN \]^bR
o g\No\5R\N_bRm^`_`Z/XTWq`\SpSZ(p$\ g pS\]_`_de_b[YZYXZY_5T©5^`a*^STWacacRZ/¦d$Xac g d=TWa\N_p$d][TacQaT/ZY_o g ZY_bd]_NTZ6_
[Y\]XoSTWZcZ6RLo g ac\ g aT6RpSZ£o g \S[Z7RR^bR6 \]^RX\N_5T g \]_bR©5^`Z]¡R\]^bR-[Y\]_5T g deac_5TZTq`Z g Xa¦©5^`Z]¡[ZYTTZ
XYTq`\SpSZ/p$\ g pS\]_b_bde_b[YZYXZY_5T g 6obd g TaTcdo`^bacRWRd]_b[Z±pSZ([6de¦[^`&p$^`_ jm¸wj(7©5^`aTrdez`cZYXZ6_NTTW\]^ST
Z6_pYca g de_5T^`_£pYz`aT´p$Z®6[Y^STac\]_N\Nzbdeo g \S[rq`Z/pS^pYz`aT´X-d=®SacX^`X
)'Â 7 À "* fhg \S[YZ6RWRZ6^ g X$^`TWa[\QZ6^ g ¡NTZ6Xo g deT^ g Z]¡Q\ g pS\N_`_bde_[ZYXZ6_NTmpSZ´o g \S[Z7RR^bR6¡5©5^bd]_NTW^`X
p`Z¨TWZYXobR6¡`Xa g deTac\]_p$d]["TWaQaT
0
A$)- ¢)(
ZYXoAZ g d=TW^ g Z±qbdNRzZ7[\NXZ(d]_acXo\ g Trde_5T´pSZ7Rac]_[\N_bRUT g d]a_5T\ g Xa¦[ g \]o g \S[Z7RR\ g RY q`Z±TZ6XoZ g
deT^ g Z-o g \]z`cZYX acRX-deac_`Pd£[\N_bRZ6©5^`ZY_[Z-\e[Yag [^`aTXac_`acdeT^ g a216d=TWa\N_de_bp[Y\]_bRTg deac_`Z6pN\]TWdeNZ
RW[Yd]ac_` ZYXoZ g deT^ g Z\]_Ld/[rqbao-a¦Rh_`Z6aTWq`Z g ^`_`a\ g X _b\ g [Y\]_bRTWd]_NT7¬_-obd g TWac[Y^`¦d g ¡]aT.pSZYoAZY_p`Rh\N_
d]o`o`cac[6d=TWa\N_bR[rqbd g d][TZ g a¦RUTWac[6RY¡S\N_Tq`Z(_Q^`X$zZ g \e g ^`_`_`ac_`TWq g Z7d]p`R43 ¡d]_bp\]_TqbZ g \Q\NX¤TZ6XoZ g
deT^ g Z]¢j.^ gWg ZY_5To g \S[YZ6RWR\ g R¢Z6deT^ g ZkTq`Z g X-de*Tq g \eTTca_`XZ6[rqde_`a¦RX-RmTWqbd=To g ZYNZY_5TmTZYXoAZ g d=TW^ g Z
g \]X ZY®`[ZYZ7pSac_`d %`®SZ6p9=dec^`Z65tS¡78J$« q`acZTq`Z g X-d]TWq g \eTTWac_`a¦Rkp`Z6RaN_`Z6pwd]R±de_wZYXZ g ]Z6_b[P
XZ7[rqbde_`a¦RX \]_w[Y^ gWg Z6_NT±o g \S[Z6RWR\ g RY¡AaT/ac?zAZ6[Y\]XZX\ g Zde_pX\ g Zd_`\ g X-deZ6]ZY_5T±a_w^STW^ g Z
TWq`Z g X-decP[\N_bRTg deac_`Z6po g \S[Z6RWR\ g RY¡`Z7RoAZ6[Yacd]cPRZ gNZ g F[YcdNRRX$^`TWa[\ g Z7Rq`a¦[rq9d g Z(pSZ7Rac]_`Z7p\ g
X-de®QacX^bXTq
g
\]^b]q`o`^`T6
q`ZTZYXoAZ
g
d=TW^
g
Z£[Y\]_bRT
g
deac_5TLqbd]R-RZYNZ
g
deacXoba¦[YdeTac\]_bR-\N_¥Tq
g
Z6dNp¥RW[rq`Z7pS^`ca_` q`Z£N\Nde
\]/Tq`a¦RRUTW^bpSP§acRT\Z®So`c\ g ZR\NXZ9\e/TWq`Z6RZ9acXo`cac[6d=Tac\]_RY¼¬_ OQZ6[Tac\]_:{`¡.ZwRq`\= TWqbd=TTq`Z
TWq`Z g X-de¢p`Z6RaN_\]Tq`Z gX-deccPw[\N_bRT g deac_`Z6po g \S[Z6RWR\ g RkRq`\N^`cp_b\eT(zAZR\NZ6Pwzbd]RZ6p\N_RUTWZ6d]p`PN
RTWdeTZ£TWZYXoAZ g d=T^ gZN¡z`^STde¦R\\N_§T g de_bRacZY_5TLTZ6XoZ g deT^ g Z]¼¬_ obd g Ta¦[^`¦d g ¡aTa¦RacXo\ g Trde_5TLT\
Trde¶NZac_5T\d][6[\N^`_5T$TWZYXoZ g deT^ g Z\NRW[ac¦d=TWa\N_bRpS^`ZpS\TWq g Z7d]p¥R[rqbZ6pS^`cac_`b§«ZRq`\= TqbdeT-Tq`Z
d]Xo`aT^pSZ¨\]*TZ6XoZ g deT^ g Z´\5R[YaccdeTac\]_bR¢a_[ g Z6d]RZ6R¢aTWqoA\=mZ g p`ZY_bRaTUPN¡Sde_bpLTqbdeTdo\5RRazbZ¨md P
TW\£[\]^b_NTWZ g d][T¨TWq`acR±ZY°AZ7["T(a¦RkT\ac_b[ g Z6dNRZ$Tq`Z-\5R[Yac¦d=Tac\]_9g Z7©5^`ZY_b[YP] q`a¦R±Z7d]p`Rk^bR/T\£d g ]^`Zac_
²d N\ g \]¢RX-decx±OTWaXZRcac[YZ6R6´OQZ6[Tac\]_9/LRT^bp`aZ7RTWq`Z(acXod]["Tk\e?oA\=.Z g pSZY_RaTUPd]_bpTacXZ$Ra¦[Z
\N_TWq`Z-oZ g\ gX-d]_b[Z\edLTWq`Z g X-decP9[Y\]_bRT g deac_`Z7p£o g \Q[YZ6RWR\ g OQZ6[Tac\]_:7\S[Y^bRZ7Rk\]_wTq`Z gX-deccPN
[Y\]_bRT g deac_`Z7pX^`TaF[Y\ g Z6R69« q`Z6_dN["TacQaTUPXac g d=Tac\]_a¦R^bRZ6p;5<Q¡m| 78F¡hX$^`TWa[\ g Z7R(\]°AZ g d9md P
TW\ %bNqNT¨Tq`ZTZ6XoAZ g d=TW^ g Z(o g \]z`cZYX¬_£TWq`acRk[YdNRZN¡`TWZYXoZ g deT^ g Z\5R[Yac¦d=Tac\]_RX\NRTcP[Y\]XZ/g \]X
[Y\ g Z6RzAZYac_`deTZ g _bdeTZ6PdN["TWaNZd]_bp¥a_d]["TWaNZ] fhg ZYQac\]^bRm\ g ¶dezA\]^`Td]["TWaQaTUPXa g deTac\]_¥qbd]R
[Y\]_bRa¦pSZ
g
Z6pTq
g
Z6dNp`RaTWq§Z6©5^bde´o
g
ac\
g
aTUP] OQZ6[Tac\]_7d]p`p
g
Z6RWRZ6R$Tq`Z©5^`Z7RUTWa\N_§\e¨qb\=¤T\Trde¶NZ
dNpS=de_5TWd]]Z\ed][Tac5aTUPXac
g
d=Tac\]_q`Z6_wTWq
g
Z6d]pbR±qbd ]Z-pSa°AZ
g
Z6_5T(o
g
ac\
g
aTacZ6R6«ZLRq`\=¼TWqbd=T/²d]a
g
RW[rq`Z7pS^`ca_`
g
Z7©5^`a
g
Z6R6¡R\NXZYTacXZ6R6¡TW\
g
^`_9ZYmZ
g
Tq
g
Z6dNp`RTWqbde_[\
g
Z7RYk«wZo
g
\]oA\NRZdR[rq`Z7pS^`ca_b
XZYTq`\Sp&¡Nzbd]RZ6p\]_Rq`\ g TETacXZRca¦[Z6R6¡=TWqbd=Thd][rqbaZ6]Z6R²d]ag _`Z6RWREq`acZX-deac_5TWdeac_`ac_`/[\ g Z7RdeTETWq`Z g X-de
RWd=TW^ g d=Tac\]_m«Zd]cR\Lo g \]oA\NRZ(de_d]TWZ g _bd=TWaNZ/XZYTq`\Sp£qbZ g Z/Tq g Z6dNpXa g deTac\]_acR´X-de_bd]]Z6pzQP
TWq`Z % g Xd g Z±\]_TWq`Z(zbdNRa¦R\eTWq`Z g X-deRZY_R\ g a_S\ g X-deTac\]_*¡bTq`Zx±OzAZYac_` g Z6RoA\]_bRazbZ/\N_`P\ g
p`Z6[a¦pSac_`q`a¦[rqTWq g Z6d]pT\ g ^`_£d=Td]ac]Z6_TWaXZ]
='>?= @BACDFEHGFEJI?E'KML
l´
g
Z6R^`TrRac_£Tq`a¦RkRUTW^bpSPd
g
Z(zbd]RZ6p\N_RacXo`ca%bZ7pX\Qp`ZY¦RY«Z(X\SpSZYTqbZoA\=.Z
g
pSZY_RaTUPX-d]o
aTq§RW©N^d
g
ZLo\=mZ
g
R\]^
g
[Z7RY
f
\=mZ
g
_5^bXzAZ
g
R$d
g
ZRPQ_5TqbZTa¦[elc.TWZYXoAZ
g
d=T^
g
Z_Q^`XzAZ
g
Rd
g Z
\NzSTWd]a_bZ6paTWql ¸£¬N5| 8J q`ZLl ¸£¬±o`qQPSRac[6dehX\SpSZY¢acR$pSZYo`a¦["TWZ6p\N_ºEac]^
g
Z£|]¡Eq`Z
g
Z-¦d P]Z
g
| g ZYo
g
Z6RZY_5TrRTWq`ZRacac[Y\]_§pSacZd]_bp¥cd PNZ
g
{9Tq`Z[Y\]o`oAZ
g
qbZ6d=TFRac_`¶zbd]RZFo`¦d=TWZ] q`Z£obd
g
d]XZYTZ
g
=d]^`Z7R^bRZ6pac_TqbacRkRUTW^bpSPd g Z/]ac]Z6_£a_ dez`cZL|N q`Z(Z®So g Z6RWRa\N_:O"()PQ(R!TS *"() *^bRZ7p£ac_
\Nc\=ac_`/RZ7["Tac\]_R?pSZY_`\]TZ7RTq`ZTZYXoAZ g d=TW^ g Z g a¦RZdezA\=]ZmTWq`Z´deX$z`acZY_5T?TZ6XoAZ g d=TW^ g Z]¡eq`a¦[rqacRhTq`Z
TWZYXoAZ g d=T^ g Z±\eTq`Z(d]ag qbaTTac_`Tq`Z/qbZ6d=TFRac_`¶9·aJZ]c¡`a_Ra¦pSZ±TqbZ([\]Xo`^`TZ g zA\ ®b¹"
UWV
ÞTXJÔ ÑÓÚ*ÚYXJÖ ×
Ý Z[\
× ßÞ ßX× ÑÓÚYXJÑÓÞ^]"Ö7ÑÓÚJÔT_
\X [\W\
Þ`X3Ô Ù
\
Õr× ÚEÕrÞ ×kÏ7Ù3ßYÒ
\
Ú3Ú
\
ÚÛ
conductance h2 (W/m K)2
conductance h1 (W/m K)2
Tamb z= z2
heat flux q(x,y,t) (W/m )2 conductivity k2 (W/mK)
conductivity k1 (W/mK) z= z1
z= 0
x=−L/2 x=+L/2
ºEac]^ g Z| (R !FS"( *`!#e
obd
g
d]XZTZ
g
=d]^`Z ^`_`aT obq5PSRac[6de&XZ6d]_`ac_`
k1 110 W/mK Racac[Y\]_Tq`Z g X-d][\N_bpS^b[Tac5aTUP
k2 400 W/mK [Y\]o`oAZ g TWq`Z g X-de*[Y\]_bpS^["TacQaTUP
α1 6×10−5 m2/s Raca¦[\]_TqbZ g Xd]*pSa°A^bRac5aTUP
α2 1.1×10−4 m2/s [\]oboZ g Tq`Z g X-de*p`a°^bRaQaTUP
h1 3×104 W/m2K a_5TZ g ²dN[Z±X-d=TWZ g acd]Tq`Z g X-de*[Y\]_bp`^b["Trde_b[YZ
h2 700 W/m2K qbZ6d=TFRac_`¶Tq`Z
g
X-d][\N_bpS^b[TWde_[Z
z1
ub
mm pSaZkTWq`ac[r¶Q_`Z7RR
z2−z1 mm q`Z6deTRac_`¶Lzd]RZkobcdeTZ±Tqbac[r¶Q_`Z7RR
L < cm q`Z6deTRac_`¶Lzd]RZkobcdeTZ±acpSTq
dez`cZ| -S"*"!N (R
V V
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160
0.001 0.002 0.003 0.004 0.005
relative temperature (kelvins)
square side length (meter) power = const pow. dens. ~ 1/length pow. dens. = const
ºEac]^ g Z9{ (R" $% (R"(R9O"()P ( !TS *"( *:"^ " + ()Y !#Y N("()W (
^(FY *! "
5mm×5mm "*N * S"( J"()() F"+ " ( M (R
1mm×1mm W( O(Y " ( * ( " : +"Y:(R" (JSJ
( "( SJ ($ "+4SJ ($ + *"^ "`( P Q O(
E/) +,E
qbZ´ac_b[
g
Z6dNRZ\]*o\=mZ
g
pSZY_RaTUPacRm\eªTWZY_LXZ6_NTWa\N_`Z6p-T\Z®So`¦deac_-q5PTWZYXoZ
g
deT^
g
Z´a¦R.zZ7[\]Xac_`$d
o g
\Nz`Z6X \N_qbaNqoAZ
g
\
g
X-de_b[YZ/[rq`aoRY
f
\=mZ
g
pSZ6_bRaTUPacR´a_bp`ZYZ6pd]_acXo\
g
Trde_5Tobd
g
d]XZYTZ
g
m^ST
qbZY_o\=mZ
g
pSZ6_bRaTUP/ac_b[
g
Z6dNRZ7RzAZ6[6de^bRZ[a
g
[Y^`aTrR?Ra21YZma¦R
g
Z7pS^b[Z7p&¡=TWq`acR?p`\5Z7R_`\eT_`Z7[Z6RWRWd
g
acP/aXo`cP
d9q`ac]q`Z
g
RTZ7d]pSP5RUTrd=TZLTZYXoAZ
g
d=TW^
g
ZNx¨_Tq`Z\eTWq`Z
g
qbd]_bp&¡¢d9q`aNq`Z
g
oA\=.Z
g
pSZ6_bRaTUPac_b[
g
Z6dNRZ7R
TWq`ZdeXo`caTW^bpSZ9\](TZ6XoZ g deT^ g Z9\5R[YaccdeTac\]_bR6'«ZzZ6acZYNZ9\]_bZw[Yd]_`_`\]T^`cP ^b_bpSZ g RTWde_p§Tq`Z
TWZYXoAZ g d=T^ g Zko g \]z`cZYX¤d]_bpLd PSRhTW\$Trd][r¶QcZ¨aTaTWq`\]^ST^`_pSZ g RUTrde_bp`a_`$TqbZka¦RWR^`Zk\eTZYXoAZ g d=TW^ g Z
\5R[Yac¦d=Tac\]_RY¬_$TWq`a¦RhRZ7["TWa\N_mZpSa¦R[Y^bRR?Tq`ZTWZYXoZ g deT^ g Zo g \]z`cZYX de_bpq`\=¥aT¢[6de_zAZXaTacNdeTZ7p
zQPLac_Q]Z7RUTWa5d=Tac_`$Tq`Z/ZY°AZ7["TrR\eEo\=mZ g pSZ6_bRaTUPL\N_TWZYXoAZ g d=T^ g ZN
H>?= -CAMGHL-CbCA
ºEac]^
g
Z${-Rq`\=RTWq`Z
g
Z6R^`T¨\]ETrde¶Qac_`d
5mm×5mm R©5^bd g Z(R\]^ g [Z(p`acRWRacobdeTac_`{-mdeTTWR´^`_`a
\ g XcPd]_bp-RW[Ydecac_`(aTWR¢p`aXZY_Rac\]_bRmpS\=_TW\
1mm×1mm¡5d][6[\ g pSac_`±T\Tq g ZYZ¨pSa°Z g ZY_5TR[YZY_bd g ac\NR oA\=.Z g a¦R´¶NZYoST±[\N_bRUTrde_5T6¡oA\=.Z g pSZ6_bRaTUPa¦R¨¶NZYoST±[\N_bRUTrde_5T6¡\ g oA\=.Z g pSZ6_bRaTUP£ac_b[ g Z6dNRZ7R´d]R
TWq`Z´ac_Q]Z g RZ\e&TWq`Z±R©5^bd g Z´Ra¦pSZ´cZY_`]Tq* q`a¦RmZ®`deXo`cZ´Rq`\=R?TWq`ZkaXobdN["T\e[ag [^`aT.Xac_`acdeT^ g a216d=
TWa\N_*/l´R¨acc^bRUT g deTZ7pac_£Tq`Z g deobq*¡¶NZYZ6o`a_bLT\]TWd]oA\=.Z g [Y\]_bRTWd]_5T6¡Az`^ST/[\]_[ZY_5T g deTac_`LaTkac_wd]_
d g Z7d¨TqbdeTh]ZTrRhRXd]cZ g de_bpRXd]cZ g ¡]cZ6dNp`RET\$d/p g d]X-d=Ta¦[ac_b[ g Z6dNRZ\e&RTZ6dNpSP5FRTWdeTZmTZ6XoZ g deT^ g Z]
x¨_TWq`Z\]Tq`Z g qbd]_bp&¡A¶]ZYZ6o`ac_`LoA\=.Z g pSZY_RaTUP[Y\]_bRTWd]_5T´z g a_`5RTZ6XoZ g deT^ g ZpS\=_* qbZ(Xacp`p`Z
[Y^ g ]ZacR?\ g d±oA\=.Z g pSZY_RaTUP(TWqbd=Tha¦R?¶]Z6oSTho g \]oA\ g Tac\]_bd]QT\±TWq`Za_QNZ g RZ\ecZY_`]Tq* q`a¦R g Z6R^`TrR?ac_
TWZYXoAZ g d=T^ g ZkzZ6a_b g \]^`Nq`cPL[\]_RUTrde_5T6¡Q\]_bPLRac]q5TWP-pSZ7[ g Z6d]Rac_`aTqZ6_`eTWq* Z6_b[Z¨TqbZ g ZYNa\N_
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
199.97 199.98 199.99 200
relative temperature (kelvins)
time (seconds) 2mm*2mm, 12W
1mm*1mm, 7W
ºEac]^ g ZJ/ T O"( P ( !TS *"( *H" " (YN( !N F" "bSJ- S YeY"$
:"+ - P "
2mm×2mm " "( J"(() b:( *
'(Q( P "
1mm×1mm "*4 + *"() J"( (Yb ( *
\]¢TWq`Z g deo`qwPQac_`zAZTUmZYZ6_9TWq`ZTUm\p`dNRqbZ6p9[Y^ g ]Z6Rka¦R/d g Z6]ac\]_\].q`ac]q`Z g o\=mZ g pSZ6_bRaTUP]¡P]ZT
c\=mZ g TWZYXoAZ g d=T^ gZN qbacRRq`\=RhTWqbd=Td]_La_[ g Z6d]RZ´\]oA\=.Z g pSZ6_bRaTUPLpS\QZ7R._b\eT_`Z6[YZ6RWRd g acPXZ6d]_
dq`ac]q`Z g TWZYXoAZ g d=T^ gZNE¬_Tq`a¦Rmobd gTa¦[^bcd g ZY®Sd]Xo`ZN¡Qq`ZY_.ZkR[6decZkpS\=_LTq`Z/RW©N^d g ZZ6_`eTWqzQP
dL²d][T\
g λ <1¡ARTZ7d]pSP5RUTrd=TZ(TZYXoAZ
g
d=TW^
g
ZpS\QZ6R¨_`\eTka_[
g
Z6d]RZdNR´c\]_`d]R¨o\=mZ
g
pSZY_bRaTUPa¦R¨_`\eT
ac_b[
g
Z7d]RZ6pz5PX\
g
Z±Tqbd]_
λ−1.1 ·3deo`o g \ ®SaX-deTZYcP`¹"h¬F?oA\=.Z
g
pSZY_RaTUPac_b[
g
Z6dNRZ7Rm²d]RTZ
g
Tqbd]_TqbdeT6¡
RTZ7d]pSP5RUTrd=TWZTWZYXoZ
g
deT^
g
ZX-d PzZ7[\NXZLdo
g
\]zbZ6X¡^`_`cZ6RWRkTq`Z-obdN[r¶=de]ac_`acR±acXo
g
\=]Z6p* qbacR
g
Z6dNR\N_`ac_`a¦R±\
g
d£Rac_`NZL[Ya
g
[^`aT(q`\5RZ-pSacXZY_bRa\N_bR(d
g
ZLRW[Yd]Z7pwpS\=_\=mZYNZ
g
¡&a\N_`ZTWd]¶]Z6R
dNpS=de_5TWd]]Z¨\eXac_`acdeT^
g
a216d=TWa\N_LTW\$o`^`TX\
g
Zk[a
g
[Y^`aTrRma_dNaNZY_d
g
Z6d`¡NTqbZ¨TWZYXoAZ
g
d=T^
g
Zko
g
\]z`cZYX
zAZ6[Y\]XZ6Rm\ g RZ]
H> QAA bCA?I*I CWE
qbZoA\=.Z g pSZY_RaTUPa_9d g Z6]ac\]_£\e?TWq`Z$[rqbao9p`ZYoAZY_bp`R¨\]_wdeo`o`ca¦[Yd=TWa\N_bR g ^`_5TacXZ[rqbd g dN["TZ g a¦RTa¦[YR6
ºb\
g
Z®`d]XobZN¡`j
f
³Fz\N^`_bpdeo`oba¦[YdeTac\]_bR.]Z6_`Z
g
d=TWZkd$q`ac]qo\=mZ
g
pSZY_RaTUPLac_TWq`Z±Z®SZ6[Y^STac\]_[\
g
Z]¡
qbacZXZ6X\
g
PNFzA\]^`_bpdeobo`a¦[YdeTac\]_bRkNZY_`Z
g
deTZdc\=mZ
g
o\=mZ
g
p`ZY_bRaTUPN¬_dX$^`TWao
g
\N
g
deXXZ6p
Z6_Q5a
g
\]_`XZY_5T7¡7qbZ
g
Z¢pSa°AZ
g
Z6_NT?deobo`a¦[YdeTac\]_bRZ®SZ6[Y^STZmdeTZ
g
_bdeTZ6PN¡6TWq`Z6RZ.p`acRobd
g
aTacZ6R]ZY_bZ
g
d=TZhTZYX
oA\
g
deoA\=.Z
g
pSZY_RaTUPL=d
g
acdeTac\]_bR6¡Qq`ZY_[Z±TZ6Xo\
g
d]TZYXoAZ
g
d=TW^
g
Z±=d
g
a¦d=Tac\]_RY
ºEac]^
g Z /9Rq`\=R±TWZYXoAZ
g
d=T^
g
ZLNaNZY_zQPl ¸£¬(d]R$d^`_b[Tac\]_\]TacXZL\
g
dRW©5^bd
g
Z-o\=mZ
g
R\]^
g
[YZLzZ6a_bwoAZ
g
a\SpSa¦[Yd]cP\]_d]_bp\]°Ex¨_`Z[^
g
NZLacR$\
g d
2mm×2mm R©5^bd g Z]Z6_`Z g d=TWa_`
| {£d=TTWRq`ZY_TqbZR\]^ g [YZa¦R$\N_*¡?TWq`Z\eTqbZ g [^ g ]Z\ g d
1mm×1mm RW©N^d g ZNZY_`Z g deTac_`:<
d=TTWR/qbZY_TWq`ZR\]^ g [Z-a¦R(\N_*l´RZ®SoZ7["TWZ6p&¡?d£oAZ g a\SpSa¦[-oA\=.Z g pSZ6_bRaTUP\NRW[ac¦d=TWa\N_NZY_`Z g deTZ7R
dTWZYXoZ g deT^ g Z-\NRW[acccdeTac\]_aTWqTq`ZLRWdeXZ-oAZ g a\Sp&OS\Tq`Z-oAZ g a\Spa¦R±Tq`ZRd]XZac_z\]Tq[YdNRZ7RY
´\=.Z6]Z g ¡TWq`Z£deXo`caTW^bpSZ\e¨Tq`ZTZ6XoZ g deT^ g Z\NRW[ac¦d=TWa\N_acRX\ g Zo g \]_`\N^`_b[Z7p\ g TWq`Z£RX-d]
V V
R\]^ g [YZ]¡]zAZ6[6de^bRZ´\]&Tq`Z¨q`ac]q`Z g oA\=.Z g pSZ6_bRaTUP£·
7W/mm2SR6 12/4 = 3W/mm2¹"¡SpSZ7RobaTWZ¨zA\eTWq [Y^ g ]Z6Rmqbd Qac_`-deo`o g \ ®SacXdeTZ6PTqbZ(Rd]XZkTWaXZd ]Z g d]]Z¨ d]^bZ]
x¨_`Z([6de_ gZ7d]R\]_dezA\]^STTZ6XoZ g deT^ g Z±\NRW[ac¦d=TWa\N_bRm^bRac_`TWq`Zk\]c\=ac_` g ^bZ±\eETqQ^`X$z 5| {.8
"!FS() :" (R !FS"( * O"()Y NS+S(Y+"`( ( O."'SJ
($ M ;"+ P $ S+*S()Y+"( ( "*:*.( ( ^ O"(Y
* + $
qbacR
g
^`cZh\e5TqQ^`X$z/acR=decacpk\
g
q`ac]q±\NRW[ac¦d=TWa\N_k
g
Z7©N^bZY_b[YaZ7R&\]_`cP$·²a3Z]c¡7\
g
doAZ
g
ac\Qp±_b\eTZY®S[YZYZ7pSa_b
dXaca¦RZ6[\N_bpb¹
ZYNZ
g
Tq`Z6Z7RR6¡]aTmqbaNq`ac]q5TrRhTWq`Z²dN["TmTqbdeT.c\Q[6deAo\=mZ
g
pSZY_RaTUPacR¢Tq`Zkobd
g
d]XZYTZ
g
qb\NRZaXobdN["T¢\N_-TZ6XoZ
g
deT^
g
Z\NRW[acccdeTac\]_bR?a¦R¢Tq`Z¨X\5RUTmRac]_`a%[6de_5T6¡Qde_bpTWqbd=Td/oA\NRWRacz`cZ´d P(T\
p`Z6[
g
Z6dNRZ¨TqbZ(deXo`caTW^bpSZ/\eTZ6XoAZ
g
d=TW^
g
Zk\5R[Yac¦d=Tac\]_RacRmTW\ac_b[
g
Z7d]RZ¨TWq`Z/\NRW[acccdeTac\]_L
g
Z6©5^`Z6_b[PN
H> :DFA I :D EMCCI FK
¬_\ g pSZ g T\/¶NZYZ6o$TWZYXoAZ g d=T^ g ZzAZYc\=TWq`ZTWq`Z g X-de`caXaT
Tmax
¡NX\SpSZ g _o g \S[Z7RR\ g RZ6d=TW^ g ZTq`Z g
X-d]Tq g \eTTca_`XZ6[rqde_`a¦RX-RkTWqbd=T g Z6pS^[Zo\=mZ g [Y\]_bR^`XoSTac\]_q`Z6_9TWZYXoZ g deT^ g Z-deo`o g\5d][rq`Z7R
Tmax
ºb\ g a_bRTWd]_b[ZN¡bTWq`Z¬_5TWZY f Z6_NTWa^bX 7^bRZ7R´d]_£\]_SF\e°XZ7[rqbde_bacRX TWqbd=TkRUTW\]obRTq`Z[c\Q[r¶\ g
RZYNZ g de*Xa¦[ g \NRZ6[Y\]_bp`RqbZY_`Z6]Z g Tq`Z$\]_S[rq`acoTq`Z gX-d]RZY_bR\ g ac_bpSa¦[YdeTZ7RTqd=T´TWq`Z(TWq`Z g X-deacXaT
Tmax
a¦RZ®`[YZYZ6p`Z6p:5t8J.¬_Tq`Z gZ6Xd]a_ba_`¡S.Z$d]RWR^`XZ/de_\N_SJ\]°TqbZ g Xd]&Tq g \]TTcac_`LXZ6[rqbd]_`a¦RX
aTq dp`^STUP¥[YPS[cZq`a¦[rq d]p iU^bRTWRde^STW\]X-d=TWac[6decPT\TWq`ZX-d=®SacX^`X o\5RRazbZ=d]^`ZN qbacRacR
dN[rq`acZY]Z7pRacXo`cPz5PRT\No`o`ac_`TWq`Z£[c\S[r¶w\ g d %`®SZ6p\e°A3TWaXZq`ZY_`Z6]Z g TWZYXoZ g deT^ g Z gZ7d][rq`Z7R
Tmax
^ g a_`Tq`Z¨\e°A3TWaXZN¡5pSPQ_bd]Xac[´o\=mZ g [Y\]_bR^`XoSTWa\N_LacR. g Z6deTcP g Z6pS^[Z6p*l¨R?\ g RTWdeTa¦[o\=mZ g
ac_c\]Nac[/[Yag [^`aTWR6¡AaT±[Yde_£zAZ$p`Z6[ g Z6dNRZ7pz5P^bRa_bq`ac]qS
Vt
RZ6ZYo£Tg d]_bRacRT\ g R`5c|^<e8F¬_£TWq`Z g ZYX-d]a_S
ac_`¡mZ(a¦pSZ6d]a21YZ/TWq`a¦R¨RaTW^bd=TWa\N_zQPdNRR^`Xac_`d-_Q^`cE[Y\ g Z/o\=mZ g [\N_bR^bXo`Tac\]_pS^ g ac_`L\e°TacXZ6R
·3d][T^bd]cP]¡`R\]XZ/RUTrd=TWac[koA\=.Z
g
acRRTacpSacRWRaobdeTZ7pac_£[Yd][rqbZ6Rde_p\]Tq`Z
g
Xa¦[
g
\Nd
g
[rqbaTWZ6["TWZ6pLTWdezbZ7RW¹
x¨_SF\e°TWq`Z
g
X-deTq
g
\]TTcac_`$NZY_`Z
g
deTZ7RmdTZ6XoZ
g
deT^
g
Z¨\5R[Yac¦d=Tac\]_E¬FE.Zkde_5T.TWq`Z(deXo`caT^bpSZ
\]TWq`a¦R\NRW[acccdeTac\]_T\-zAZRX-d]*[Y\]Xobd
g
Z6pTW\
Tmax−Tamb
·3R\Tqd=TTWaXZd ]Z
g
d]]Z´TZYXoAZ
g
d=TW^
g Z
a¦R-d]R-[Y\5RZT\
Tmax
d]RoA\NRWRacz`cZ7¹¡¢TWq`Z\e°A3TWaXZRq`\]^`¦pzZRX-decZY_`\N^`]q*§l[Y[Y\
g
pSac_`9TW\Tq`Z
g
^`cZ´\]*TqQ^`X$z\
g
TWZYXoZ
g
deT^
g
Z´\5R[Yac¦d=Tac\]_RY¡5q`ZY_o\=mZ
g
pSZ6_bRaTUPLpS\N^`z`cZ6R6¡NTWq`Zk\e°A3TWaXZ±Rq`\N^`¦p
zAZTWd]¶]Z6_ 7TacXZ6R(Rq`\
g
TZ
g
¬_
g
Z6X-deac_`a_bZY®QoAZ
g
acXZ6_5TWR6¡*.ZLdNRR^`XZde_\e°A3TWaXZ-\e
2µs de_pwd
X-de®QacX^bXTZ6XoAZ g d=TW^ g Z
Tmax= 85j¨
%'=/ -() 6 Y.
« qbZY_TU.\TWq g Z7d]p`Rd g Z±Z®SZ7[^STWZ6pdeTZ g _bdeTZYcPL\N_do g \S[Z6RWR\ g ¡QdoA\=.Z g pSZY_bRaTUPL\NRW[ac¦d=TWa\N_X-d P
zAZNZY_`Z g deTZ6p§deTR\NXZ9o\Na_5TWRL\e±Tq`Zw[rq`ao¡aTWq doZ g ac\Sp¥Z6©5^bde´T\TWq`Z9R^`X \]±TacXZwRcac[YZ6R
\]Z6d][rqTWq g Z6d]p* q`acR\S[Y[^ g R(TUP5obac[6decPq`ZY_\]_`Z-TWq g Z6d]p^RZ7Rd£^`_baT$TqbdeTTqbZ\eTWq`Z g Tq g Z6dNp
^RZ7RLac_Sg Z7©5^`ZY_5TcP]¡´Z]bc¡Tq`Zb\NdeTac_`eFoA\]ac_NT^`_`aT6¡´\ g q`Z6_ Tq gZ7d]p [rqbd g dN["TZ g a¦RTa¦[YR-NaNZX\ g Z
\No`oA\ g T^`_`aTacZ6R\ g [c\S[r¶5d=Tac_`£·ZN¡b\]_`Z±TWq g Z7d]pZ®SoAZ g aZ6_b[Z7Rd\]T\e?[YdN[rq`Z±Xa¦RWRZ7RW¹.ºEaN^ g Z47
Rq`\=Rkde_dezbRT g d][T¨QaZ6¼\edo g \S[Z7RR\ g [\ g ZN¡Aqbac[rqw.Z g Z6o g Z6RZY_5TkdNRkd
5mm×5mm R©5^bd g Z
oA\=mZ
g
R\]^
g
[YZpSa¦RRaod=Tac_`
1W/mm2 *ZT±^bRk[\N_bRa¦pSZ
g
d^`_`aT6¡&q`a¦[rq9mZ
g
ZYo
g
Z6RZY_5T¨dNR¨dRX-d]
5mm
1mm
4 W/mm^2 1 W/mm^2
0.5 mm 2.5 mm
2.14 W/mm^2 4*2.14 W/mm^2 length scaling *1/2 power density scaling *2.14
ºEac]^ g Z`7 ()*" ( !N. b -S+*. *
0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25 0.3 0.35 0.4 0.45 0.5
1e-04 0.001 0.01 0.1
% CPU
slice (seconds) 5 mm 2.5 mm
ºEac]^
g Z *" ( Y & , ()!# `(*" #"" (Y (()!#4Y (6"^
SY(R J *
V V