Distributed Application Configuration

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00073571

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00073571

Submitted on 24 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Distributed Application Configuration

Luc Bellissard, Slim Ben Atallah, Fabienne Boyer, Michel Riveill

To cite this version:

Luc Bellissard, Slim Ben Atallah, Fabienne Boyer, Michel Riveill. Distributed Application Configura-

tion. [Research Report] RR-3119, INRIA. 1997. �inria-00073571�

(2)

ISSN 0249-6399

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Distributed Application Configuration

Luc Bellissard, Slim Ben Atallah, Fabienne Boyer and Michel Riveill

N ˚ 3119

Fevrier 1997

TH ` EME 1

(3)

(4)

% & ')(+*-,.,0/2131547698;:=< >?,./0@A(+*CBEDFG4H,.,I47J K5< L 4HM;/.*-BB;*N(+OHP?*-6GQR4HB 8ESE/I'TJ;*C,VU/.W?*C/.,.,IK

XY?Z

[\][+^_a`b[cd[3eGfHgh[ijcdk-cli

Z

[m\][c

npolq3r

[mijs-t

o

eGu

`jeTvHv qwo

ix7[

o

[u Y [ o u Y

[zyR{C|7^w^5}h_~[

o

t[

o

^5}w}=$_^+veG=[c

pm5GG= XY

tcveGv[

o v o

[cl[y-idc#eGyeeTyHwfeGw[eGyHxe

o

fHyidt\h[clfHv7v q=o

i]ty-il[myHxH[xi

q

eTuttieGid[i

Y

[NxH[mcltwyu

q

y-wf

o

eGilt

q

yeTyHx[

q

fHidt q y q

x7tcdi

o

t7fHil[x eGv7vHtu5eGilt

q

yHc¡\eGxH[fHv q

Y

[mil[

odq

w[myH[

q

f7cc q

i2¢£e

o

[+u

q

\hv

q

yH[y-ilc5¤¦¥

q

y-=f

o

eTilt

q

yNu

q

w[

o

c¡i2¢

q v Y

eGcl[mc3§

qwo

i Y

[]eTvHvHtu3eGidt q y

Hf7txH[

o

Hi

Y

[$txH[y-ilt¨u3eTilt q y q iY

[$c q

i2¢e

o

[$u

q

\]v

q

yH[myCidc£eTyHxi

Y

[$xH[mclu

o

tv7ilt q y q i Y

[mt

o

tyCid[

o u q

y-©

yH[muilt

q

y7cjeGyHxhu

q

\h\fHyHtu3eGidt

q

yHc5ª

qwo

iY

[$eGvHvHtu3eTilt

q

y]eTxH\]tyHtcli

o

eTi qwo

Gi

Y

[«eGumuf

o

eTil[Rf7cl[

q

cdkCcdil[\

o

[c q f o

u[mc«v olq

-txH[x-ki

Y

[$i¬e

o

=[ij[y--t olq

yH\][y-i5ª

q=o

iY [$xH[vH

q

k-\][myCi q i Y

[¡eTvHvHtu3eGidt q y q

yhi Y [

ie

o

=[ij[myC-t olq

yH\][myCi5¤

XY

[R\eTtyh[myH[i q

eGyNtci q v

odq

CtxH[+e+cltyHw[Rf7yHt¨[xNxH[mclu

o

tv7ilt q y q

xHtcli

o

tHfHid[x)eTvHvHt¨©

u3eTilt

q

y7c3eTxH[-feGid[

qwo

u q yHcdi

o

f7uilt

q

y\eGyeTw[\h[y-i3HeGy7xN[

q

fHilt

q

y¤

XY

[ q

w[

o

eG;xH[cdu

o

tvHidt

q

y®tc

tyHxH[mv[y7xH[y-i

odq

\¯i

Y

[¡u

q

\]v

q

yH[myCidc3°t\]vH[\h[y-i¬eTilt

q

y=c q i Y

eGi$i

Y

[¡u

q

y-=f

o

eTilt

q

yNv olq

u[cdc3;[w¤¤

i Y [¡v

olq

xHfHuidt q y q

xHt¨±?[

o

[myCi$=[

o

cdt

q

yHc q

eTyNt\]vH[\h[y-i¬eTilt

q

y-tcjxH[mu

q

fHv7[mx

odq

\¯i

Y

[¡v olq

o eT\©

\hty7Rv olq

u[mclc3¤

XY

[ [3eGidf

o

[c q i Y

[u

q

y-=f

o

eTilt

q

yeGy7wfeTw[eTyHxi Y [

f7yHuilt

q

yHc

q iY [ o

fHy-ilt\][hclfHv7v q=o

i

cdkCcdil[\e

o

[$tf7cli

o

eGid[xi YHodq

fH

Y iY

[$[gHeG\hvH[

q

e+xHtcli

o

tHfHid[xil[[u q y [ o

[yHutyHNeTvHvHtu3eGidt

q

y¤

²h³-´µ¬¶R·w¸;G ¹

tcdi

o

t7fHil[xºvHvHtu3eGidt q y

n;odq

o

eG\h\]tyH3º o u Y

til[muilf

o

eG

¹

[yHtidt

q

y»eGyH=feG=[

¼½¾

¿ÁÀ2Â3Ã

¾

¿ÅÄÆÀ2Ç.ÈÉ

ÊËÍÌ.ÎÏGÐGÑGËÍÒÍÌ.ÓGÔlÕVÒÍÖj×.ÓGÔVØlÙ×.ÓÚÖ3×.ÔlÛ.ÖGÜ×.ÒÍÎÖ5ÜË3ÝÎÖ5ÞÔlÛ.ÔlÖGßlÔÎÖjà;ÒÍÌ.×0Û.ÒÍÑGÐG×.ÔlÕÝÎáÏGÐG×.ÒÍÖGâã5ä5Ì0×.ÔláÌdåÏGÏ-æçèéê9çìë3ç5å

íÎÖGâîï;ÎÖGâGåð$ÜäRØléémÙ

ñ

ÚÖGÌ0×.ÒÍ×.ÐG×HòÜ×.ÒÍÎÖGÜËGó7ÎËÍä3×.Ôlß2ÓGÖGÒÍô5ÐGÔåõ;Û0ÔdÖGÎÑGËÍÔî?öCÐGßmæ÷?ÔlËÍËÍÒÍÌ.Ì0ÜmÛ0ÕwøÒÍáVÜâGæÞÛ

ùú

ÖGÒÍûÔdÛ0Ì.ÒÍ×3üÔ?ÕGÔVã5Ü¬ûmÎÒÍÔåÝÓGÜáVÑýüÔlÛ.ä îð$ÒÍß2ÓGÔdËæþÒÍûÔdÒÍËÍËÿøÐGÖGÒÍûìîÌ.ÜûÎÒÍÔæÞÛ

ú

ÖGÒÍûÔdÛ0Ì.ÒÍ×3üÔìÎÌ0ÔdÏGÓGÎÐGÛ.ÒÍÔlÛdå3õ;Û.ÔlÖGÎÑGËÍÔîGÜÑGÒÍÔlÖGÖGÔmæ÷?Î¬ämÔlÛ2øÒÍáVÜâGæÞÛ

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rhˆone-Alpes

655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST MARTIN (France)

Téléphone : (33) 04 76 61 52 00 – Télécopie : (33) 04 76 61 52 52

(5)

³ ³E

¥V[

o

eTvHv q=o

iv

o b[cl[myCid[N[]eGy7CeG=[]$»?º¯[mic q y clfHv7v

q=o

ix°[gVb[uf7ilt

q

y¤ `b[3eTtcHb[

xeTyHc$[Ru3eGx

o

[+xHf)v olq3r

[mi«s-t

o

eTuw?u[mi«[myC-t olq

yHyH[\h[y-i

eGumttil[ e+x7[clu

o

tvHilt

q

y?e+u

q

y-wf

o

eGilt

q

yN[i

2°lb[

q

fHilt

q y xH[ceTvHvHtu3eGidt

q

yHc o b[ve

o

ilt[cVu

q

yHcli

o

fHtil[mcve

o

eGclcd[\HeG=[x7[u

q

\hv

q

c¬eGy-idc Y b[iHb[

olq

Z [y7[c3¤

»e+u

q

y-wf

o

eGilt q y o

[

odq

fHv[+xH[fHgNeGcdv[muilc$[cdcl[y-ilt[c§;2°tx7[y-ilt¨u3eTilt

q

yhxH[cju

q

\]v

q

ceGy-ilc

q

wtut[c

[i$ex7[clu

o

tvHilt

q

yxH[¡[f

o

c$tyCid[

o

eTuilt

q

yHcjv q f o

[Ru

q

yHcli

o

fHumil[f

o

x°ÍeGv7vHtu5eGilt

q

yHc«ª [ij[+vHeGu[\h[y-i

[i[$xb[v7

q

t[\][y-i x7[«2°ÍeGv7vHtu5eGilt

q

y¡cdf

o

[cxHt¨±«b[ o [y-ilcy

q

[mfHxHcjx7f]clk-cdi

Z

[\h[«ve

o

I°ÍeTxH\]tyHtcli

o

eTil[f o ¤

» []v

o

tyHutveGVb[yb[u[Nx°eGy [mclixH[

q f o

yHt

o

fHyH[xH[mclu

o

tv7ilt q y fHyHt

qwo

\][xH[mc¦eTvHvHtu3eGidt

q

yHc3

fHidttceGH[v q f o

e u q yHcdi

o

fHuilt

q

yj2°tyHclieGeGidt

q y vHfHtc]2°ÍeGx7\]tyHtÿcdi

o

eGilt

q y xH[c b[

q

fHilt

q

y7c3¤ ¥V[idil[

xH[mclu

o

tv7ilt

q

yh[cli tyHxb[v[myHxeGy-id[jxH[e\]tcl[V[y

q

[fH

o

[jxH[u

Y

eTufHyxH[cVu

q

\]v

q

c¬eTy-ilc§ev odq

x7fHuilt q y

xH[mcRxHt¨±«b[ o

[y-il[mc¡=[

o

cdt

q

yHc$x°fHyH[eGvHv7tu3eTilt

q

y[y

q

yHuilt

q

y)xH[mc«x7tÿ±$b[ o

[y-il[c+utH[c$[cli xHtclc

q

ut5b[[+xH[

e+v odq

o

eG\h\e5ilt

q

y¡xH[$u

Y

eTufHyxH[cNb[3b[\][y-idcxH[$I°ÍeTvHvHtu3eGidt

q

y¤

E·9ìµì³®

¥ q y-i

o

fHuidt

q

y]x°eTvHvHtu3eGidt

q

yHc o b[ve

o

idt[c37v olq

o

eT\]\eGilt

q

y¡u

q

yHcli

o

fHumiltw[

(6)

|

& '

R ]]V

¹

tcli

o

tHfHid[xc q

i2¢e

o

[clk-clid[\]ce

o

[fHclfeTk u q

\hv

q

cl[x q

e®y-fH\[

oq

\f7ilfeTk®tyCid[

o

eTuiltyH

c q i2¢e

o

[«u

q

\]v

q

y7[y-ilc3¤$( [ q umfHc

q f o ¢ q=o%)q

yeGvHv7tu3eTilt

q

y7c i

Y

eTity-

q

w[cl[mw[

o

eG?fHcd[

o

c¢

q=o%)

tyH

q

y]e$cl[i q ¢

qwo*)

cli¬eTilt

q

y7c3=c Y e o

tyHRty

q=o

\eGilt

q

y¡eGyHxty-il[

o

eGumiltyHRty

o

[5eGilt\][w¤$+;gHeG\]v7[mc q

clfHu

Y

eTvHvHtu3eGidt

q

yHce

o

[id[[u q y [ o

[yHutyHG[[ui olq

y7tuVxHte

o

t[c35c q

i2¢e

o

[ÅxH[w[m

q

vH\][myCi[y--t odq

yH\h[y-ilc53eGy7x

¢

qwo*),q

¢ eTvHvHtu3eGidt

q

yHc3¤

XY

[

-./0 q

eGy]eGv7vHtu5eGilt q y o [ [ o

ci q i Y

[xH[cdu

o

tvHidt q y q i Y

[jc q

i2¢e

o

[[y-iltilt[cVtyC

q

¨©

=[x-i

Y

[jxH[yHtilt q y q i Y

[t

o

\f7ilfeTHtyCid[

o

eTuilt

q

yHceGy7xi

Y

[[

q

f7ilt q y q

[y-iltilt[ceTyHx]ty-il[

o

eGumilt

q

yHc

i

YHolq

fH

YHq

fHii

Y

[«t

[idt\][

q i Y

[+eGvHvHtu3eTilt

q

y¤$1

2#/34/2

xH[3eGc¢ti Y i Y

[+eGuuf

o

eGid[RfHcd[

q

cdkCcÁ©

id[\

o

[c q f o

u[mc£eTuu qwo

xHtyH$i q i Y

[£eTvHvHtu3eGidt

q

y°c o [-fHt

o

[\][y-idc365[w¤¤ vHeGu[\h[y-i q u q

\]v

q

yH[myCidc q y

exHtcli

o

tHfHil[mxNyH[i2¢

qwo*)

q

Hcl[

o

weGidt

q

yeTuu[cdcRu

q

yCi olq

87 qwo

iY [¡u

qwolo

[ui$cl[mililtyH

q

ve

o

eT\][id[

o

cyH[©

u[mclc¬e

o

ki q v

olq

xHfHum[eTy][g-[umfHi¬eTH[«t\eGw[

q i Y

[«eTvHvHtu3eGidt

q

y95[w¤¤;i

Y

[jy-fH\[

o q

clt\fHi¬eTyH[

q

fHc

fHcd[

o

c$ty]i

Y

[¡eTvHvHtu3eGidt

q

y7¤

XY

[cl[ eGvHv7tu3eTilt

q

y7c¦e

o

[Nu

q

y-w[yHt[y-idkxH[mclu

o

t[xu

q

yHcli

o

fHuid[x eGy7x\eTyeG=[x tyil[

o

\]c q

i Y [t

o

w

q

eG?c q

i2¢e

o

[$e o u Y

tid[uidf

o

[w¤:

q

¢[=[

o

7i

Y

[$uf olo

[myCiil[u

Y

y7t-fH[mc«e5weGteG7[

q

y]xHtcdi

o

tHf7il[x

vHeTi

q=o

\]c;5clf7u

Y

eGc

o

[\

q

il[$v odq

u[xHf

o

[Ru3eT2=\fHiltu3eTcli3=ut[y-i2©2cl[

o

w[

o \ q

xH[07 Y e o

x7k

Y

[vtyhi Y [

=

q

eG;xH[mcltwy®v olq

u[mclc q

xH[u

q

\]v

q

cltyHeGy eGvHv7tu3eTilt

q

yty-i

q

ehcd[i q

ty-il[

o

eGuidty7u

q

\]v

q

y7[y-ilc3¤

XY

[mk eGc

q

twy qwo

[\eGyeTw[\h[y-ieTclv[uidc]clf7u

Y

eGc+i Y [ q

y7[c]cdi¬eGid[x[

qwo

[w¤`fHy-idt\h[clfHv7v q=o

i

tc$fHclfeGk\htclcltyH

qwo

i Y [u

q

yHcli

o

fHuidt

q y eGy7xNi

Y

[\eGyeTw[\h[y-i q

eGv7vHtu5eGilt

q

yHcji

Y

eGi$[g

Y

tHti«e

cdi

o

f7uilf

o

[¡¢

Y

tu

Y

tcjeGy-k\

q=o

[u

q

\hvH[gi

Y

eTyNeRcdt\hvH[jut[y-i2©2cl[

o

w[

o e odo

eTyHw[\h[y-i3¤

<#q

x7fH[>=2y-il[

ou q

yHy7[uilt

q y »eGyH=feG=[c«e

o

[¡ec

q

fHidt

q

yi qY

eTyHxH[R

q iY u q

y7cli

o

fHuidt

q y eTyHxN\e5©

yeTw[\h[y-i3=u

q

[uidtw[k o[ [

odo

[xNi

q

eGc

"?#%0

¤

XY

[mk¡tc

q

eGil[i

Y

[jv olq

o eT\ cdi

o

fHuilf o[ odq

\

i Y []u

q

y-il[g-i q

[g-[umfHilt

q

yeT

q

¢tyHhi

Y

[xH[mw[

q

v[

o i q u q

yHu[y-i

o

eGid[

q

y®i Y [

fHy7uilt

q

yeG

o

[-fHt

o

[©

\h[y-ilc q c q

i2¢e o [ \ q

xHfH[c5¤

<

=l» c«e o [ Y

t

Y [ o

[=[;eTyHwfeGw[mcty¢

Y

tu Y i Y

[¡ty-il[

o u q

y7yH[uidt

q

yHc

[i2¢V[[y u q

\]v

q

y7[y-ilcRe

o

[xH[clu

o

t[mx tyHxH[v[yHx7[y-ilk q i Y

[xH[v7

q

k-\h[y-ijvHeGi

qwo

\)¤$º

o

f7yCidt\][

cdfHvHv qwo

i+[yHu5eGvHcdfHeGil[mcu

q

\h\fHyHtu3eGidt

q

y[mi2¢[[my \ q

xHfH[cReGcR¢V[eGcRxeTi¬ei

o

eTyHc

q=o

\eGilt

q

y?c

q

i Y eGi$i

Y [ Y

eTyHxHtyH

q

ty-il[

o

eGumty7

o

[mCf7t

o

[\][myCidcjtc$xH[u

q

fHvH[x

olq

\ i Y eGi

q

fHyHuidt

q

yeG

o

[-fHt

o

[©

\h[y-ilc3¤

n;odq

o eG\h\][

o

ce o[ o

[[x

olq

\ iY [u

q

yHcdi

o

eGty-ilcVt\hv

q

cl[x+-kRi

Y

[jfHyHx7[

o

k-tyH¡e o u Y

til[uidf

o

[=

i Y

[eGyH=feG=[ v olq

u[mclc q=o

c5

qwo

i Y [Vu

q

\]\fHyHtu3eTilt

q

y\][x7te7¤?~Hf o iY [ o \

q=o

[w

q

yHu[jeTy¡eGv7vHtu5eGilt q y Y

eGc

[[y®u q y wf

o

[x

q=oq

yH[R[g-[umfHilt

q

y[y-Ct odq

yH\h[y-i3=i

Y

[yi

Y

[Rx7[vH

q

k-\][y-i

qwo

eTy q i Y [ o

[g-[uf7ilt q y

[y--t olq

yH\][y-iVtci

o

[3eTil[xNcd[ve

o

eGid[kCHeTfHi

q

\eTiltu3eGkReGyHxhtyHxH[v[yHxH[myCidk q i Y

[$t\]v7[m\][y-i¬eTilt

q

yHc

q \ q

xHfH[c5¤A@

BC/0D E

|-Ftc$eGy[gHeG\hvH[

q

clfHu

Y

e+eTyHwfeGw[ReTyHx

o

f7yCidt\][w¤

!G04EIH

FeTyHx\

q=o

[

o

[u[y-ilk

>-J!0KE

-F[g-il[yHx i Y [eGvHv

olq

eTu Y v

olq

v q

cl[x CkK@

BC/D

-k)[myeGHtyHi

Y

[]xH[cdtwyH[

o i q

xH[mclu

o

t[eTy)eGv7vHtu5eGilt

q

y°ccli

o

fHuidf

o

[]eTce

Y

t[

o e ou Y k q

ty-id[

o u q

yHyH[umil[x u q

\hv

q

yH[y-ilcty7clil[5eGx q

e ,

eTilid[yH[xu

q

[umilt

q y q \ q

xHfH[c3¤ jf o ¢

q=o%)LEIM

Fj[g-id[yHxHchi

Y

[v odq

v q c¬eTc

q ¹ e o

¢ty ¢ti Y e

eGy7wfeTw[ji

Y

eGijeTxHx

o

[clcd[c$i Y [ q

q

¢ty7«tcdclfH[c5§

N [yHu3eTvHclf7eTilt q y q v o

[©2[g-tcliltyH

qwo

uf7cli

q

\©2\eTxH[;c q

i2¢£e

o

[[y-iltidt[mc3=¢

YHq

cd[

o

eTy-fHe

o

ti2kR\e5k

we

o

kC

N [g-v

o

[mclclt

q y q 02/%/0

[mi2¢[[my)c q

i2¢e

o

[R[y-iltilt[c5Htyil[

o

\]c q

fHyHuidt

q

yeG?x7[v[myHxH[y-©

ut[c«eTyHxu

q

\h\fHyHt¨u3eGidt

q

y¡i2k-v[c3

þþ¯Ö!OPGØØdé

(7)

1

Existing Applications Existing

Applications Existing

Applications Session

Node 2 Session

Node 1

Session

Node 3

Cooperation Cooperation

Controller

Cooperation Controller

Controller

~t=f

o

[^=§ ¥ qCq

vs-u3eTyw[yH[

o

eG;e o u Y

tid[uidf o [

N xH[u

q

fHvHtyH

q

ty-il[

o

eGuidt

q

yHc

olq

\ u q

\hv

q

yH[y-i3°c;t\]vH[\h[y-i¬eTilt

q

yReGy7x¡u

q

yHcli

o

fHumilt q y q u q

\©

vH[g]ty-il[

o

eGumilt

q

yHc¢ti Y iY

[$tyCi olq

xHfHumilt

q y q 22 / >E

Fl

N xHk-yeG\htu[

q

f7ilt q y q iY

[ReTvHvHtu3eGidt

q

ycli

o

fHuidf

o

[]eTyHx]i

Y

[Rty-il[

o

eGuidt

q

yHc5HeGyHx

N \eTyeG=[\][y-i q

xHtcli

o

tHfHid[xNeGvHvHtu3eTilt

q

yHcÅ¢ti

Y

\h[u

Y

eGyHtcd\]c;i

Y

eTijeG

q ¢ vHeTu[\][myCi q

[y-©

iltilt[c5H\

q

yHti q=o

tyH

q

[g-[ufHidt

q

yHc5[miluw¤

s [uilt q y H v o

[mcl[y-ilcRexHtcli

o

tHfHil[mx)eGvHv7tu3eTilt

q

yhclu[mye o tq

fHcl[mx)eGc$e+il[cdil[x

qwo

i Y

[ReGy7wfeTw[

eTyHxi Y [ o

fHy-ilt\][=¤s-[muilt

q

yN| xH[cdu

o

t[c$i

Y

[Ru

q

yHu[mvHilc q i Y

[ReGyu

q

y-wf

o

eGidt

q

y]eTyHwfeTw[w¤

XY

[

o

fHy-©2ilt\][;[y--t olq

y7\][y-i

q=oq

f o \ q xH[mwtcv

o

[cl[myCid[xty$cl[uidt

q

y+«eGy7xRi Y [ o

[mclfHi q q f o

[g-v[

o

t\][myCi

tcxH[cdu

o

t[x®tyhcl[umilt q y M ¤

h¡+E] j m$m

XY

tc;cl[muilt

q

yx7[clu

o

t[cecdt\]vH[eTvHvHtu3eGidt

q

y$clu[ye o tq ¢ Y

tu

Y

tceGid[

o

fHcl[xi

q

tfHcdi

o

eTil[Vi

Y

[Vu3eTve5©

Httilt[c q i Y

[Rv olq

v q

cd[xeGyH=feG=[w¤

XY

tcjeTvHvHtu3eGidt

q

y=yeG\h[x]¥

q-q

vs u3eGy

E

/FlHeGt\]ceTiv olq

-txHtyH

eclfHvHv qwo

i q=o

il[[u q y [ o

[yHumty7[i2¢V[[y®xHtcli

o

tHfHid[xN¢

qwo%)

[ o c5¢

YHq

ty-il[

o

eGuii YHodq

fH

Y

eGy)eTfHxHt

q

u Y

eTyHyH[jeTyHx c Y e o [xx

q

uf7\][y-ilc5¤Nºzu

q

\]v7[mil[xH[cdu

o

tvHidt

q y q i Y

[eGvHv7tu3eTilt

q y \e5k[

q

fHy7x

ty EIM

Fl¤)~

qwo

clt\hvHtumti2k

o

[3eGc

q

yHc5¢V[

q

yHk)x7[clu

o

t[Neclt\]vH[+clu[mye o tq o

[cli

o

tuid[xi q x q

ufH\][myCi

c Y e o ty7¤e

otq

fHc;i2k-v[c q x q

ufH\h[y-ilce

o

[je5weTteTH[i YHolq

fH

Y

eTvHvHtu3eGidt

q

yHc;tyHtilteGkjx7[cltwy7[x

qwo

cdty7w[©2fHcl[

o

fHc¬eTw[w7clfHu

Y

eTc! $~t +;\eGuc5#"

ot

-[iduw¤¥

q-q

vs-u5eGyv olq

-txH[c

fHyHuidt

q

yHcji

q

[yeTH[

(%$Rs=(L=ls+ty-il[

o

eGuidt

q

yHc 50(

Y

eGi$

q

f]s-[[;=2cA(

Y

eGi!= s-[[/7¤!=2iVeGc

q

eT

q

¢c;xHk-yeT\]tuVve

o

iltutveGidt q y

q u q y [ o

[[c$eGyHx\eGyeTw[c olq

[mcjeGyHxNeGumu[clc

o

t

Y

idc3¤

&

eGcdtu3eGkC=eRfHcd[

o

¢ttyH$i

q

[y-id[

o

e$u qCq

v[

o

eGidt

q

yeGfHyHu

Y

[mc£e

-0

Hi

Y

eGiVwt=[c

Y

t\zeTuu[cdc

i q iY [¡c

Y e o

[x)x

q

umfH\][y-idc3¤º

0

tcj\eGxH[

q

i2¢

q )

tyHxHc q

[y-iltidt[mc3§Vi Y [

0 0

i Y eGi

v[

o qwo

\hcjeGuidt

q

yHc

q

yi

Y

[«c Y e o

[xNx

q

uf7\][y-ilc5HeGyHxNe

! /%K!2* 0

iY

eGi\eGyeTw[cÅi Y [

u

q-q

v[

o

eGidt

q

y¤

6 0 e o

[$fHcdfeGk]

q

u3eGid[x

q

yhxHtcliltyHumiy

q

xH[c45u

¤ ~t¤?^/7¤

XY

[u q-q

v[

o

eTilt

q

yh¢

q=o%)

ceGc

q

¢c3§eTy¦eTuilt

q

yv[ oqwo

\][x

q

y]e$x

q

ufH\h[y-i;CkeGy]eTvHvHtu3eGidt q y

tc

o

cdi$veGcdcl[x

q

yNi q i Y

[+

q

u5eG

!2%B0/

7¢

Y

tu Y u Y

[u ) c t i Y

[eGuidt

q

yNtcReG

q

¢[mxi q i Y

[¡f7cl[

o ¤

= c q

i

Y

[]eGuidt

q

y®tcReTuilfeTku3e odo

t[x

q

f7i

q

y-i q i Y

[

q

u3eT fHcl[

o

tyCid[

o

eGu[]eTyHx)veGclcd[x

q

y)i q iY [

ÚòþÚÊ

(8)

Node 1

Application Controler

Owner : User

Node 1

Application Distant agent

Controler

Owner : User Local Agent

Local Agent

Distant agent

requirement

component provision

~twf o [ H

§;º u

q

\]\fHy7tu5eGilt

q

y+[gHeG\hvH[jty¥

q-q

vs-u3eGy

o

[\

q

il[

!G* 0 i Y

eTi¡eGc ) i Y

[t o u

qwolo

[clv

q

y7xHtyH eTvHvHtu3eGidt

q

y®ty7cli¬eTyHu[hi qNo

[vHe5k)i

Y

[eTuilt q y

tyi

Y

[)ceG\h[¢e5k-¤

XY

tc]tc Y7q

¢ (%$Rs=(L=lstch[yHclf

o

[x¤

<#qwo

[®xH[ieGtc

q

yi Y [

!2%B0/

°c

odq

[c+\e5k[

q

fHyHx ty

E Fl¤ºi¡ehyH[

o

[mw[2i Y [

!2* 0

tcR\eTxH[

q

i2¢

q u q

\]v

q

yH[y-idc3§¡e

B#/2

eTyHx]ecl[i

q >8 G#/2

¤

XY

[

olq

[

q i Y

[

/B.#/2

tc i qRo

[mu[tw[$eGuidt

q

yHc

odq

\

i Y [

q

u3eTeGv7vHtu5eGilt

q

yHc3i

q

weGtxeGid[¡i

Y

[\ eTyHx i q odq

eGx7u3eGcdi¦eTuilt

q

y7c

q

yCi q i Y [ o

[m\

q

id[]y

q

xH[mc3¤

XY

[

odq

[

q i Y [

>2#/2

tc$i qo

[um[tw[]eGumilt

q

yHc

odq

\ o

[\

q

il[ y q

xH[c¡eTyHx)i

q

eGc ) iY

[

q

u3eG

eTvHvHtu3eGidt q y q=o

i Y [mt

o q

u3eGÅ[g-[ufHidt

q

y¤

XY

[ o []tcRe

2#2

eTclc

q

umteTil[x ¢ti

Y

[3eTu

Y q iY [

o

[\

q

il[$fHcl[

o

c3¤~t¤ H c

YHq

¢cje+u

q

\h\fHyHtu3eTilt

q

yveGi

Y

[i2¢V[[y /

eGv7vHtu5eGilt

q

y]i q i Y [ o

[\

q

id[

eTvHvHtu3eGidt

q

yK5 Y [ o

[¡[

q

y7wtyH]i

q /

7¤$¥V[5e

o

k-Hi

Y

[¦eTuilt

q

yv[

o qwo

\][xN-k

tcjveTclcl[mx q y

i q tilc

/ #2

eGyHxi

Y

[yh

olq

eGxHu3eTcliVi q i Y [ o

[\

q

il[jeTvHvHtu3eGidt

q

yHc;-ki

Y

[¢e5k q

tilceTclc

q

uteTil[x

2#2

¤

XY

[¦eTvHvHtu3eGidt

q

yN¢eGcRtyHtilteTkxH[mw[

q

v[x

q

yjyHtgfHcltyHuf7cli

q

\©2\eTxH[Ru

q

eT

q=o

eGidtw[Rv odq

©

i q u q

c$HfHti

q

y®c q u )

[milc 5fHcl[x eTc$u

q

\h\fHyHtu3eGidt

q

y]i q-q

c 7¤=2i

Y

eGc$[m[y

o

[[myHwtyH[[

o

[x fHcltyHhi Y [

eGyeGyH=feG=[jxH[mclu

o

t[x®ty]i Y [ q

q

¢ty7Rcl[umilt

q

y¤

+ )]$R R; +]"]R"¡

ºyeTvHvHtu3eGidt

q

y®¢

YHq

cd[u

q

y-=f

o

eTilt

q y tc+xH[cdu

o

t[x¢ti

Y

jeTy u3eTy []-t[¢[mxeTc¦e

Y

t[

o e ou Y k

q

tyCid[

o u q

yHyH[muil[x

G· ·;³9

¤A+ÅeGu

Y

[w[m

q i Y [ Y

t[

o e o u Y

ktcjecd[ve

o

eGid[¦eGyxH[mclu

o

tv7ilt q y

xH[

o

tw[x

odq

\

G· ·;³N05

¢ Y tu

Y

[yHu3eTvHclfHeTil[cu

q

\]v

q

yH[myCidcR©$ty

eTui¡u

q

\]v

q

y7[y-ilc3°

tyHcdi¬eGy7u[c© u

q

y-i¬eGtyH[mxtyhi

Y

[$yH[g-i[=[2¤

XY

[$[5e5w[c

q i Y [ Y

t[

o e o u Y

ke

o

[«u

q

\]v

q

y7[y-ilcV¢ti Y y q

eGyhxH[clu

o

tvHilt

q

yH¢

Y

tu Y e o

[u3eG[x

; 0³G· ·³9

eGyHxh[yHu3eTvHclf7eTil[]°

o

[3eG2°=vHt[u[c q

c q i2¢e

o

[w-t

)

[j¥

q r

[uilc q=o

¥\

q

xHfH[c5¤

XY

[mk]e

o

[$xH[

o

tw[x

olq

\ze

; 07³¦T· ·;³

05

¤A( [ Y e5=[Rty-i

olq

xHf7u[xNi

Y

[¡u

q

yHu[mvHilc q

ueTclc«eTyHxNtyHcdi¬eGy7u[RtyNe

<q

xHfH[ =2y-il[

o u q

y7yH[uidt q y

þþ¯Ö!OPGØØdé

(9)

1

»eGyH=feG=[]i

q

[\]v

Y

eGclt[hi

Y

[hxHtclidty7uilt

q y [i2¢V[[yi

Y

[f7yHti q o

[fHc¬eTHtti2k eGy7x [yHu5eGvHcdfHeGilt q y

5i Y [Ru

q

\]v

q

y7[y-iueTclc7eGyHxhi

Y [ [±ý[muiltw[ fHyHtityHclieGy-ilteGid[xeTi

o

fHyidt\h[45i Y [Ru

q

\]v

q

y7[y-i7¤

ºc ty q r

[ui q=o

t[y-il[mxv olq

o

eT\]\htÿyHVeGyH=feG=[c3Gu

q

\]v

q

y7[y-ilc e

o

[xH[mclu

o

t[xhCk+eGy+ty-id[

o

eTu[jeGy7x

eTyt\hvH[\][y-ieGilt

q

y¤

5³- lG³H

XY

[ty-il[

o

eTu[

q

eu

q

\hv

q

yH[y-iumeTclc;u

q

yCieGtyHc;ty

q=o

\eTilt

q

yi

Y

eGi eT

q

¢cfHcltyHi

Y

[u

q

\]v

q

yH[myCi¢t¨©

i

YHq

fHi ) y q

¢[mxHw[

q

tilcÅt\hvH[\][myCieGidt

q

y¤2( [ Y

e5=[[g-il[yHx7[xi

Y

[fHcdfeGu

q

yHu[vHi q

eGyty-il[

o

eTu[w

eTcjxH[yH[x

qwo

[gHeT\]vH[$tyi

Y

[¡¥$`

& º = ¹

» -i

q

tyHufHxH[Ri

Y

[RxH[mclu

o

tv7ilt q y q

eG?i

Y

[Rv odq

v[

o

idt[mc

o

[-fHt

o

[x

olq

\e]u

q

\]v

q

y7[y-iji q ¢

qwo*)

v

olq

v[

o

kC¤+ºy ty-id[

o

eTu[+u

q

y-i¬eTtyHc

0 -

G"! 0

eTyHx ¤

!?³- 2G³H

e o[ fHyHumilt

q

yHc qwo

v

olq

u[mxHf

o

[mci

Y

eTiu5eGy[[g-[ufHid[x q=oo

[-fH[cdil[x-k¡eu

q

\hv

q

yH[y-i3¤

@

* /0 /0 -

e o

[£eT¢e5k-c

q

±?[

o

[x-kRi

Y

[t\]vH[\h[y-i¬eTilt q y q

eu

q

\]v

q

yH[y-i;ueGcdc ¢

Y

t[

*#"$

* /0 -

e o [$i

Y

[Rcl[

o

-tu[c$[g-v[muil[xi

q

[Ru3eG[xhCkhi

Y

[$t\]v7[m\][y-i¬eTilt

q y q i Y [ u q

\hv

q

yH[y-i

ueTclc3¤

%h·'&GH.·

e o

[+[w[myCidc$¢

YHq

cd[¡

odq

eTxHu3eGcdiltyHhu3eGy®i

o

t=w[

o iY

[+[g-[uf7ilt q y q o

[3eGumilt

q

yHc q y

cd[w[

o

eG u

q

\]v

q

y7[y-ilc3¤$º u q

\]v

q

yH[myCi¢

Y

tu YNo

[um[tw[c¡ey

q

idt¨u3eGidt

q

yN\e5k

q

v7ilt

q

yeTk

o

[3eGumiRi

q

ti

-k][mgC[mufHiltyHeRu

q

x7[Rcl[-fH[myHu[+u3eG[xNe

³-G0·

¤

q idtÿu3eGidt

q

yHc¡e

o

[]y

q

iRyH[mu[clce

o

tk u q

yHy7[uil[mx i q e o [3eTuilt

q

y y q=o

tc¦e

o

[3eGumilt

q y yH[u[cdc¬e

o

tk

i o tw=[

o

[x ¢ Y [y ti

o

[u[mt=[c]ehy

q

idt¨u3eGidt

q

y¤

XY

tcRtcRi

Y

[ty-i

o

tyHcdtuv olq

v[

o

i2k i Y

eTi¡x7tcdiltyH=fHtc

Y

[c

cd[

o

-tu[c

odq

\zy

q

ilt¨u3eTilt

q

y7c3¤

+550;³H

e o

[Vi2kCv[x+we

o

teTH[c?¢

YHq

cl[VweGfH[c;e

o

[Vcl[mipeTityHcdi¬eGy-idteTilt

q

y$idt\h[ eGyHxRu5eGy+u

Y

eGyH=[

xHf

o

tyH[g-[uf7ilt

q

y¤

XY

[$weGfH[

q e wt=[yNeGili

o

tHfHid[$u3eGy[«t\hv q=o

il[mx

odq

\zi

Y

[$t\hvH[\][myCieGidt q y

q=o

cl[i

olq

\ q

fHidcltxH[$i

Y

[Ru

q

\hv

q

yH[y-i3¤

)(

0³ ³5H·

º u q

\hv

q

yH[y-iumeTclct\hvH[\][myCieGidt

q

y¡tc[ti Y [ o

\eGxH[

q e Y

t[

o e o u Y k q

*

cdfH-©2u

q

\hv

q

yH[y-ilc

*

q=oq

* o

[3eT

*

v7t[mu[c q c q

i2¢e

o

[w¤ ( [$i

Y

fHcxHtclidtyHwfHtc

Y

i2¢

q )

tyHx7c q u q

\]v

q

y7[y-ilc3¤

º

; 0³]T· ·;³

ueGcdcjtci Y [ fHyHti

q

[myHu3eGv7clfHeGidt

q

yNeGyHx

o

[fHcd[

q

[g-tcdiltyHhu

q

xH[w¤

XY

[Vt\]vH[\h[y-i¬eTilt q y q

ev

o

t\]tiltw[;u

q

\]v

q

yH[myCi?umeTclc;tc;\eGx7[

q

vHt[u[mc q cq

i2¢e o [ 50¥®\

q

xHfH[c3

¥ ueGcdcl[c5¤G¤m¤%7hi

Y

eTit\hvH[\][myCiÅi

Y

[Rv olq

-txH[xcl[

o

-tum[c$xH[ue

o

[x®tyhi Y [ ty-id[

o

eTu[wfHcdty7i Y [

o

[-fHt

o

[xNcd[

o

-tu[c5¤

º

G· ·ý .3³G· ·;³

ueGcdc3Åtc+i

Y

[]\eTty)cdi

o

f7uilf

o

tyH i q-q

2¤ =2ilc+t\hvH[\][myCieGidt

q

ytc

\eGxH[

q +*

cdfH-©2u

q

\hv

q

yH[y-ilc

*

eTyHx¡ty-il[

o

eGumilt

q

yHc;[i2¢V[[yi

Y

[\)¤

*

s-f7-©Iu

q

\]v

q

y7[y-ilc

* e o

[tyHcdi¬eGy7u[c

q u q

\]v

q

y7[y-iueTclcl[mc«x7[clu

o

t[x[cl[¢

Y [ o

[w¤j¥

q

\]ve

o

[xhi

q

fHcdfeGv olq

o

eG\]\htÿyH$eGy7wfeTw[c5-i Y [

t\]v7[m\][y-i¬eTilt

q

y$xH[ìyH[c¢

Y

tu Yq

i Y [ o u q

\]v

q

yH[myCidc£e

o

[yH[[xH[mx#eTyHx YHq

¢i

Y

[kc YHq

fHxu

q

\]\fHy7tÿ©

u3eTil[$i q+o

[5eGt[ji

Y

[$ty-id[

o

eTu[

o

eTi Y [ o i Y

eGy YHq

¢i Y [

f7yHuilt

q

yHc q i Y

[$ty-il[

o

eGum[e

o

[i

q

[$xHt

o

[muilk

t\]v7[m\][y-il[mx¤

ÚòþÚÊ

(10)

UserSession CoopControler

SendOp RecOp

SharedApplication

Init

SendOp (in op encodedOp) RecOp (in op encodedOp) Init

SendOp RecOp

~twf

o

[|7§;º u

q

\hv

q

cltil[u

q

\hv

q

yH[y-i

s ilt

o[ [ olo

tyHNi q i Y

[¡id[[u q y [ o

[yHutyH eGvHv7tu3eTilt

q

yý~t¤|hc YHq

¢cRehu

q

\hv

q

yH[y-ijumeTclcRi

Y

eGi

u q

y-i¬eGtyHcje

!2% / ¢ Y

tu

Y

il[

o

c«eTuilt

q

yHcu

q

\htyHRtyeTyHx

q

fHi q iY [

D2* 0 0

eGy7x

i o

eGy7cl\]tidcRi

Y

[eG

q

¢[mx eGuidt

q

yHcRi

q

tilc

*

cdfHv[

o

©2u

q

\hv

q

yH[y-i

*

¤)`

q

fH

Y

kC?i

Y

tc¡umeTclc

o

[v

o

[cd[y-ilce

fHcd[

o

tye+u

q

eT

q=o

eGidtw[jcd[clcdt q y q iY

[¡eGvHv7tu3eTilt

q

y¤

XY

[

YHqwo

t)

q

y-i¬eT?u

q

yHy7[uiltyHhty7[c

o

[v

o

[cd[y-i

u q yHyH[umi

qwo

c3?¢

Y

tu

Y e o[ xH[clu

o

t[mxNtyi

Y

[$yH[g-ijcd[uidt

q

y¤

¥ q yHyH[ui

qwo

c£e

o

[ji

Y

[fHyHtidc i

Y

eTi \][mxHteGil[Vi

Y

[ty-id[

o

eTuilt

q

y7c [mi2¢[[my]u

q

\]v

q

yH[y-idc3¤

XY

[k[cdi¬eG7tc

Y

i Y [ o fH[c+i

Y

eTiRx

o

t=[]u

q

\]v

q

yH[myCi ty-id[

o

eTuilt

q

y7c¡eGyHx clv[ut

k i Y [ o

[-fHt

o

[x v olq

i q u q

jeTi

o

f7yCidt\][

[=[2¤ `fH[ceGi+i

Y

[]u

q

yHyH[ui qwo

[mw[VtyHufHxH[w§hi

Y

[]ty-il[

o

eGu[u q y

q=o

\]ti2k

o

fH[c 5[=¤¤®ve

o

eG\][ì©

id[

o

i2k-v[mc¡u q y q=o

\]ti2k-

YHq

\ q

w[yH[mti2k q u q

y7yH[uidt

q

yHc3¤5¤¤ 7?i

Y

[v olq

iq u q

c fHcl[x

qwo

i Y

[+[±?[uidt=[

u q

\]\fHy7tu5eGilt

q y 50eTclk-yHu YHolq

y q

f7cCc5¤;clk-yHu YHodq

y q fHcu

q

\h\fHyHtu3eTilt

q

y5[w[myCi

olq

eTxHu3eTcliVCc5¤

o

[\

q

id[

v

odq

u[xHf

o

[ju3eTI¤¤¤ 7weTyHxRi

Y

[cdv[mut¨u3eGidt q y q

eTyR[g-v[muil[xh[

Y

e5-t q=o

5clf7u

Y

eGc ecl[i q u q

yHcdi

o

eGty-ilc

[g-v

o

[clcdtyHfeTti2k q s [ o

-tu[

o

[-fHt

o

[\h[y-ilc>5[=¤¤

qwo

\fHilt\[x7teu

q

\]\fHy7tu5eGilt

q

y¡cdfHvHv qwo

i 7¤

XY

[«u

q

yHyH[mui q=o

xH[cdu

o

tvHidt

q

yNyH[m[xHcji

q

xH[y7[w§

N i Y [

02q u q

yHyH[umi qwo

i

Y

eGi$xHtcdiltyHwf7tc

Y

[c$i Y7q

cl[f7cl[x

q=o

ty-il[

o u q

y7yH[uidt q y vHf

o v q

cl[]eGy7x

i

YHq

cl[Rf7cl[x

qwo

iY

[R\eGvHv7ty7

q i Y

[$ty-il[

o

eGu[$i

q

eGyt\]vH[\h[y-i¬eGidt

q

y

N i Y [+eG

q

¢[x

.* q iY

[Ru

q

\]\f7yHtu3eGidt

q

y

N i Y [+eG

q

¢[x

020 «q

iY

[$u

q

\h\fHyHtu3eGidt

q

yGeGy7x

N i Y [

2 "! 0q i Y

[R[g-v[uil[mx)[

Y

e5-t qwo

-i

Y

[$u

q

yHcli

o

eGty-ilc$eGyHxi

Y

[$v olq

i q u q

2¤

XY

[ju

q

yHu[vHi q

eu

q

yHy7[ui q=oY

eGceG

o

[3eGxHk+[[y]ty-i odq

xHfHu[xhtyi

Y

[tid[

o

eTilf

o

[w¤ =2y

E

}-Flwu

q

yHyH[mu©

i

qwo

ce

o

[clv[ut¨[xhfHcltyHRe$cdfHHcd[i q i Y

[j¥s n v

odq

u[clcjeTw[

o

ei

q

xH[ue

o

[ji

Y

[[g-v[uil[mx[

Y

e5-t qwo

eTyHx)i

Y

[]eGcdc

q

uteGid[x u q yHcli

o

eGty-ilc5¤

XY

tc3 u q

\HtyH[mxN¢ti Y i Y

[tyHufHcdt q y q cq

\][+¥s

n

clv[ut¨u3e9©

idt

q

yHcty]i

Y

[Rty-il[

o

eGu[

q u q

\]v

q

yH[y-idc3HeG

q

¢cVu

q

\hveGidt7tti2k$u

Y

[u

)

ty7[i2¢V[[y®u

q

yHyH[ui qwo

c«eGy7x

u q

\]v

q

yH[myCidci

q

[$v[ o qwo

\][x¤

XY

[jjeTyvHeGi

qwo

\ qwo y q

¢cdfHvHv qwo

idccd[w[

o

eG

)

tyHx q u q

yHyH[umi qwo

c3¤

XY

[t o o

f7[mc£e

o

[clidtw[

o k

cdt\hvH[jeGyHxhx q y q

iVkw[ity-il[m

o

eTil[u

q

yHcdi

o

eGty-iclv[ut¨u3eTilt

q

yHc5¤ ¥Vf olo

[y-ilk--i Y [ o

[Rtcy

q

eGy7wfeTw[

qwo

q=o

\eGtcl\i

q

[mgCv

o

[cdc i YHq

cl[u

q

yHyH[umi qwo

c«ªTi

Y

[k+e

o

[VHfHtx-©2tyRu

q

y7yH[ui qwo

cÅv olq

-txH[x+-kRi Y [ o

f7yCidt\][

þþ¯Ö!OPGØØdé

(11)

1

! "#

$&%'()*+,'+,-$/.0213)+45(6,77

.013)+48/6 77 9:*30;-<*304 =9,>>'?/@*+A<404 +,'B9C*6,'4+ .7%()+ $D0'(+ .@+ '0' 1E

$F0*3A<(0 $D0*A<(0 @6*36 .010*G(+ .@61<H<7<1I%

H*3+ 6 4(6 $I1J013)+48/6 77 9:*30;-<*304 =9,>>'?/@*+A<404 $I%'(3)K*3+ '+ -$/.013)+4L(6 77E

$F0*3A<(0 $D0*A<(0 $F0;-0' 1<6 77%*306,7<M04

HK*3+ 6,4(6 $I13NA 0' 1 9O'+1<P<(61<+ ' =QK>>'?*306,(1<+ '$ 6,$&%'()*+,'+,-$

0A 0' 1GH*+,6 4(6 $I1

(*30613<+,'R+P/6(+,.@+,'0'1

(*306130SI'8/+ 770(1<+ ' 9:*30;-<*304 9O@K*3+A<404 +P13)0:(+,770(1<+,'T13)0'

$F0*3A<(0 $D0*A<(0L+PU6 $&%'()*+,'+,-$/.0213)+45(6,77

(+ 770(213<+ ' +,'T13)<$G(+ .@+ '0' 1

~twf

o

[$§ºjweTteTH[ju

q

yHyH[ui qwo

c q=o

ty-id[

o

©2u

q

\hv

q

yH[y-iVu

q

\h\fHyHtu3eGidt q y

VWXYWZ[ Z\]V^ _``ba` [cd[``e,WfZ]g

eZ\[c h_VK[

c[i j!ec[kd[ ZlmYoneZkWY[c_\e,WZ!p!q

YcW rel[ks[V [er[mYtneZkWY[c_\e,WZ#pq

uuu

eXY^ [ X[ Z\_\efWZ

\ v[wWZ\kxyeZ` \zwWWYwWZ\cW^[c#q

\ v[{ YY^|xyeZ` \zd v_c[l{ YY!^!q

}}

X_ YY!eZ~j`eZ~X[\ vW lV _^^

}}

VWZZ[V \W c

s[V [er[m Yx\W\ v[wWZ\

u

s[V [e r[mYq

\ v[wWZ\

u

d[ZlmY]xd[ ZlmYUq

}}

eZ\[c_V \efWZ

\ v[wWZ\

u

_jZ!Vv]x\ v[{ YY^

u Z!e \#q

\ v[wWZ\

u

d[ZlmY]x\ v[{ YY^

u

s[VK[e,r[mYGq

\ v[{ YY^

u

d[ZlmY]x\ v[wWZ\

u

s[VK[e,r[mYGq

q

~twf

o [ M § =2y-il[

o

eGuidt

q

yNeGyHx

<

eTvHvHtyH+[gHeG\]v7[

q

xH[ue

o

eGidt q y

cdfHvHv qwo

i+eGyHx e5weGteGH[$tyNi

Y

[]jeTyNeGyH=feG=[w¤

XY

[ q

q

¢tyH+i¬eTH[ 5.~t¤7

o

t[

,

kxH[clu

o

t[mc

c q

\][$e5weGteGH[u

q

yHyH[umi qwo

c3¤

5³CGG0·

e o []i

Y

[[±ý[muiltw[u

q

\]\fHy7tu5eGilt

q

yHci

Y

eTi¡ie

)

[vHeGu[h[i2¢V[[yecl[mi q u q

\©

v q yH[myCidc3¤

XY

[k e o [ tcdclfH[mx

odq

q

\hv

q

yH[y-ilc®cl[

o

-tu[c qwo

y q idtÿu3e5©

idt

q

yHc

o

[3eTuilt

q

yHc3Gf7cltyHu

q

yHyH[ui qwo

c i

Y

eTi?xH[cdu

o

t[

YHq

¢)i

Y

[Vty-id[

o

eTuilt

q

y$c YHq

fHxR¢

qwo*)

¤ =2y-il[

o

eGuidt

q

yHc

\e5k«i

Y

fHc;[cd[[yeTc

* i Y

[ty7cli¬eTyHu[c

* q

eu

q

y7yH[ui qwo

q

y-il[g-i5wt2¤[w¤ty+ejcdv[mut¨u

t\]v7[m\][y-i¬eTilt

q

y+¢ti

Y

tidcc q f o

u[mceTyHx]x7[clidtyeGilt

q

yHcjcdv[umtÿ[x¤

XY

[

i q i Y [¡ty-il[

o

eTu[Rtcji

Y

[Rv odq

um[clc q

HtyHxHtyHi

Y

[RtyCid[

o

eGu[

o

[-fHt

o

[\][y-idc«eGy7x

v

odq

-tcdt

q

yHc q i Y

[t\]v7[m\][y-i¬eTilt

q

y¤

* » tyH[c

* x o

e5¢y¡[i2¢V[[y]ecl[

o

-tu[©

qwo

y q ilt¨u5eGilt

q

y

o

[3eGuidt q y

q

\]v

q

y7[y-i3?\e5k[cl[m[y eTiR[g-[ufHidt

q y ilt\h[¡eGc¡e#u

q

\h\fHyHtu3eGidt

q

yty

)

[i2¢[m[y

i Y [[yHu

q

cltyHu

q

\hv

q

\]v

q

y7[y-ilc3¤

XY

eGi$tc$¢

Y

kN¢[f7cl[u

q

yHyH[ui qwo

c Y [ o [eGc

¢V[2HeGcje+\][5eGyHc q

HfHtxHtyHRi Y7q

cl[ ty

)

c5¤

XY

[u

q

\hv

q

yH[y-i$xH[clu

o

t[mx ty ~t¤|]\e5ky

q ¢ [u

q

\hvH[il[mx)-kNi

Y

[]xH[mclu

o

tv7ilt

q y q q i Y

i Y [$ty-id[

o

eTuilt

q

y7cjeGyHxhi

Y

[$\eTvHvHtyH$i q i Y

[«ty-il[

o

eTu[w¤ ~t¤ M c

YHq

¢ci

Y

[$eTy]cdkCy-ieGg

q=o

i Y [$fHcl[

q u q

yHyH[mui q=o

c3¤

XY

[ ) [k-¢

q=o

x

m

tcVi

Y

[Rx7[ue

o

eGilt q y q

cdfH-©2u

q

\hv

q

yH[y-ilc5¤

ÚòþÚÊ

(12)

}

+p z

XY

[eTy u q y wf

o

eGidt

q y eGyH=feG=[¡tcRve

o i q e o

eG\][m¢

q=o%)

i Y eTiRv

odq

CtxH[mc¡i qCq

cRi

q

7fHtx eGy7x

\eGty-i¬eGtyxHtcdi

o

tHf7il[xNeGv7vHtu5eGilt

q

yHc3¤

XY

[ o eT\][¢

qwo*)

tcxHt-txH[xty-i

q

i2¢

q

u3eGid[

q=o

t[c q i

q-q

c3§

N B qwo

v

olq

o

eT\]\]t¨yH 5jtclfeT

n;odq

o

eG\h\]tyH4+pyC-t olq

yH\][myCieGy7xNu

q

\hvHt[

o

7VeGyHx\eGye5©

w[\h[y-i 5ºjxH\hty X;qCq

07weTyHx

N /

fHyHtidci

Y

eGi;e

o

[[ti Y [ o

=[yH[

o

tu>5

o

fHy-idt\h[;clfHvHv qwo

i7

qwo

eGCeTvHvHtu3eGidt

q

yHc qwo

cdv[mut¨u

5[g-[umfHi¬eTH[Rt\eG=[

q q

y7[eTvHvHtu3eGidt

q

y7m¤

=2yi Y [ o

[cli q i Y

tc$cd[uilt

q

y?¢V[

q

uf7c

q

y)i

Y

[+eTyHwfeGw[

eGuttilt[c$eGyHxNi Y [ o

fHy-ilt\h[RclfHv7v q=o

i

e ou Y til[umilf

o

[¡i

Y

eGi[yeGH[$i Y [ v

olq

xHfHumilt

q

yNeGy7xi

Y

[$\eTyeG=[\][y-i q

eTyeGv7vHtu5eGilt

q

y¤

&

fHtxHtyH]eGy)eTvHvHtu3eGidt

q

y]¢ti

Y

eTy

o

[-fHt

o

[mcj

o

cliRe+u

q

y-=f

o

eTilt

q

yNx7[clu

o

tvHilt

q

y[g-v

o

[cdcl[x ¢ti

Y

i Y [ eGyH=feG=[v

o

[cd[y-il[x ty cl[uidt q y |H¤

XY

[)u

q

\]vHt[

o i Y

[yEv olq

xHfHum[c eTy[g-[uf7i¬eG7[ t\eGw[

i Y

eGiu3eTy ¢ qwo*) q

yi Y [ o

fHy-ilt\][NcdfHvHv qwo

i3¤ : q

¢[mw[

o

ji

Y

[)eTyHwfeTw[

q

yHk u3eTilu

Y

[ci

Y [ cdi¬eGidtu

eTclv[uilc q iY

[£eTvHvHtu3eGidt

q

ym¢

Y

t[VeGyR[g-[umfHilt

q

y+tc

q

--t

q

fHclkxHk-yeG\htu=¤=2y i Y

[VclieGiltuVxH[cdu

o

tvHidt

q

y

u q

\]v

q

yH[myCidc¡e

o

[v

o

[mxH[yH[mx ty-il[

o

eGuidt

q

yHc¡e

o

[cd[i¡f7v

q

yHu[

qwo

[=[

o

;[miluw¤¥V[3e

o

k-?i

Y

tcRtcRy q i

ceGiltc

eGui qwo

k][cdv[umteTk

qwo

i Y [«i2k-v[c

q

eGvHv7tu3eTilt

q

y7c¢V[ReGt\zeGiu

q

yHcli

o

fHuidtyH¤ XY

[ o

[$tcje yH[[x

i q eT

q ¢ xHk-yeT\]tu¡tyHcdi¬eTyCidteGilt

q y q u q

\]v

q

yH[y-idc3;i q u o

[3eGid[cd[ilc q u q

\]v

q

yH[myCidc¡eGy7x i q®Y

e5=[

xH[mcliltyeTilt

q

y7c q

tyCid[

o

eTuilt

q

yHcjeGyHx\eGvHvHtyH$yeT\][xeGuu qwo

x7ty7i

q

xHk-yeT\]tuv olq

v[

o

ilt[c5¤¤

pm5 07·

tci

Y

[ReGui q

xH[cdu

o

tHtyHi

Y

[$cl[i q

cdfH-©2u

q

\hv

q

yH[y-ilctyeTy]t\]v7[m\][y-i¬eTilt

q

y¤

XY

[ o [e

o [ cl[=[

o

eT¢e5k-c q

ty7cli¬eTy-ilteGidty7¦e+u

q

\]v

q

yH[myCi5eTuu qwo

xHtyHi q i Y

[Ridt\h[j¢

Y

[myNtic YHq

fHx

[R[±?[uidt=[ku

o

[3eTil[x®eGi

o

f7yNilt\][=¤

XY

[ ) [k-¢

q=o

x

mjo

[ [ o c«i

q

eRv

o

[xH[ìyH[x®tyHclieGyHu[ i Y eTitc

u o

[3eGid[x i q

=[i Y [ o

¢ti Y i Y

[[yHu

q

cdtyHu

q

\hv

q

yH[y-i3¤

X;q

[g-v

o

[cdc\

q=o

[RxHk-yeT\]tuc5ýe#u

q

\hv

q

yH[y-i

u3eTy[$v

o

[xH[y7[xNty]i

Y

[jueTclct\]vH[\h[y-i¬eTilt

q

y¡7fHitceGuidfeGk+u

o

[3eTil[x®eGiVi

Y

[

o

clity-

q

u3eGidt q y

q q

yH[

q

tidccl[

o

-tum[c3¤

XY

tcVtci Y [

"!/C 0200

cdu

Y

[\][

q ¹ e o

¢ty¤

}}

eXY^ [ X[KZ\_\eWZ Wha` [cd[``e,W Z

\ v[wWZ\ x l$# ZkeZ` \wWWYwWZ\cW^ [c#q

=2y i Y [&%

6 0

u q

\]v

q

y7[y-i 5.~t¤|7m;i Y [

!2%B0/

tcRxHk-yeT\]tu3eTkhty7cli¬eTy-ilteGid[x eGc

i Y [ o[ tcy

q

yH[[x i

q

tyHcdi¬eTyCidteGil[tih[

qwo

[ i Y [®fHcl[

o

xH[utxH[mcNi

q

[y-il[

o i Y [ s-[cdclt

q

y¤ s q iY [

u q

\]v

q

yH[myCitcVu

o

[5eGil[mx)i

Y

[

o

cdijilt\h[je+cl[

o

Ctu[

q %

/ -0

tcjeGumiltweGid[x¤

'$· .³HG0·

e o [ty-i

odq

xHfHu[x+i q

eTuttieGid[

Y

eGyHxHtyH

q

\fHiltvH[u

q

\]v

q

y7[y-ilc q

eceG\h[ ueGcdc3¤

º¯u

q

[muilt

q y tc¦ecl[i q u q

\]v

q

yH[myCidc¡¢

Y7q

cl[y-fH\[

o

eGi+[g-[ufHidt

q

yilt\h[t[c+¢ti

Y

tye

o

eGyH=[

xH[ìyH[x-k¦e\]tyHt\¡f7\ eTyHx]e$\eTg-t\+fH\Eu3e

o

xHtyeGti2k-¤ý¥

q

[muilt

q

y7ceG

q ¢ i Y

[[3eGcdk\eTyHtvHfHeGidt q y

q

e$cl[i q

[myCidtilt[cV¢

Y

tu

Y

u5eGy[

q

w[xHk-yeT\]tu3eTk$eGyHx]e

o

[«eTuu[cdcl[xi YHodq

fH

Y

e$cltyH=[ty-il[

o

eTu[w¤

}}

\ v[{ YY^ d[\ xzVW^^ [V \e,WfZ)(+*

uu Z,

Wh|d v_c[l{ YY!^!q

þþ¯Ö!OPGØØdé

(13)

^ 1

=2y q=o

xH[

o i q

eG

q ¢ \fHidtv7[VeGvHvHtu3eTilt

q

yHc;i

q

[¡°cY e o

[mx°wty]e$ceG\h[£s-[mclclt

q y 5[=¤¤ eGy ¡eGy7x

eTy +pxHti qwo

77¢[$

odq

fHvhi

Y

[m\ tyNe+u

q

[uidt

q

yeTcc YHq

¢yty]i

Y

[Rv

o

[-t

q

fHcjeGytyH[c3¤

ºcu

q

[uilt

q

yHce

o

[ji Y [ )

[k-cli

q

yH[

q

xHk-yeT\]tu tyHcdi¬eGy-idteTilt

q

yGi

Y

[$v

o

[xH[yH[xcl[

o

-tum[c

'«G³-H5³

eTyHx

³ 0³-5³

e o [Rv

odq

-tx7[xtyNeTyCkhu

q

[uidt

q

y¤=2yNeGxHx7tidt

q

yHe+cdv[umteT;u

q

yHy7[ui q=o

u3eGy

q

v[

o

eGil[eGc

e+u

o

[3eGi qwoq

e+y7[¢ u q

\]v

q

y7[y-i q e u q

[umilt

q

y[

qwo

[ReGuu[mclcltyHhi

Y [ clv[ut¨[xNcd[

o

-tu[w¤

}}

l[ h!eZ!e\ e,WZ Wh|\ v[yeZ\[c_V \!e,W Z`

\ v[wWZ\

u _KjZV v

x\ v[{ YY^ d[\

u

Z!e\

j`eZ~ V c[_\[

ZwW^^[VK\efWZUq

=2yi

Y

[Rt\]vH[\h[y-i¬eTilt q y q iY

[%

/ - 0

u q

\]v

q

yH[y-i5H¢

Y

[yi Y [

!2% /

eGc ) c q=o

iY [

eTvHvHtu3eGidt

q

yNi

q

[eGfHyHu

Y

[mxi

Y

tc$u

q

yHy7[ui q=o

tyHx7fHu[cRi Y [ o

f7yCidt\][Ri q o

cdiRu

o

[3eGid[ehyH[¢ u q

\©

v q

yH[myCity]i

Y

[Ru

q

[uidt

q

yeTyHxi

Y

[my#eTuiltweTil[$i

Y

[ 20

cl[

o

Ctu[

q i Y

tcve

o

idtumfHe o u q

\hv

q

yH[y-i3¤

XY

[RtyCi olq

xHfHumilt q y q u q

[muilt

q

y7c

o

eGtcd[c$yH[¢ tclcdfH[cju

q

yHu[

o

yHtyHi Y [

230#9 > 3 2/20

=2y)exHtcli

o

tHfHid[x)cdk-clil[m\)

q r

[uidcRe

o

[+w[myH[

o

eTkhyeG\h[x-ki

Y

[t ojq

r

[ui$txH[y-idtÿ[

o

50tx7¤

XY

tc

yeT\]tyH$clu

Y

[m\][jcd[[\hcc

q

\][

YHq

¢ o [cdi

o

tuidtw[ReGyHxhtyHu

q

\hveGidtH[ ¢ti Y u q

[uilt

q

yHc3=¢

Y

[yi

Y

[jxH[cÁ©

idtyeGilt q y q

ehu

q

\]\fHyHtu3eTilt

q

yhtc¡ehv o t

qwo

t y q i ) y q

¢y¤

XY

[ o [ qwo

[w;¢V[fHcl[eGclc

q

uteGilt=[¡yeT\]tyH

eTuttidt[ci

q

cdv[umt

k]i

Y

[RxH[cdiltyeGidt q y q

eGyty-il[

o

eGuidt

q

yK5 q=o

e \eGv7vHtyH.7m¤ºclc

q

uteTiltw[RyeG\]tyH tc

eTcl[x

q

yNi

Y

[[g-tcdil[y7u[]eGyHx®i Y [ o

fHy)idt\][RweTf7[

q

eTili

o

tHfHid[c3¤+ºj\

q

yHi

Y

[cd[]eGili

o

tHfHid[c3

q

y7[

u3eTy eT¢£e5k-cVyHx®efHyHt-fH[

q r

[ui$txH[y-idtÿ[

o

c

q

exHt

o

[ui$yeG\htyH¡tccliltv

q

cdcltH[w¤;:

q

¢V[w[

o

ty

i Y [Ru3eTcl[

q u q

[umilt

q

yHc5HtiVtc q

il[my\

qwo

[jfHcd[

fHi

q

xH[yH[Ri

Y

[«ty-il[

o

eGumilt

q

y°cxH[mcliltyeTilt

q

y$5c7V¢ti

Y

i Y [ Y [v

q \ q=o

[j=[yH[

o

eG;eGyHxcl[m\eGy-idtu5eGk

o

tu Y [ o

eGili

o

tHfHid[c3¤

}}

l[ h!eZ!e\ e,WZ WheZ\[c_V \e,WfZ`

}}

e\ v _``WVe_\e,r[yZ_ X!eZ~

\ v[wWZ\

u

d[KZls[ X!W \[mYnWfY[c_\ e,W Zc[ XW \[{ YY^

lp

x\ v[{ YY^ d[\

u

s[V [!er[m YUnWfY[c_\eWZ!p

v[c[y\ v[{ YY^ d[\

u

{YY!^

l|xbs[ XW \[{ YY^

l

j`eZ~bX[\ vW lw_^!q

s ilt

o [ [ odo

tyH i q i Y [ %

0

u q

\]v

q

y7[y-i3 i Y [

!2%B0/

¢ Y tu

Yo

[mu[tw[cNe

o

[\

q

id[

eTuilt

q

yK5

olq

\ eTy

q i Y [ o v q

cdcltHk

o

[\

q

il[

-

7 ) y q

¢cji q ¢ Y

eGi

)

tyHx q

eGvHv7tu3eTilt

q

yhtic YHq

fHx

i o

eGy7cl\]tiRtiR7fHi¡y

q

iRi q ¢ Y

eTiRve

o

iltuf7e o u q

\]v

q

y7[y-iRty i Y [hu

q

[uidt

q

y¤)~

qwo

i Y tc

o

[3eTc

q

y;i Y [

!2* 0

io

eGyHcd\]tilci

Y

[]eTuilt

q y i q i Y [

D2* 0 0

¢

YHq

cl[

eTili

o

tHfHid[+ilcR¢ti

Y

i Y

[RtxH[y-ilti2k q i Y

[$i¬e

o

w[mijeGvHvHtu3eTilt q y q i Y

[¡eTuilt

q

y¤

XY

[ o

fHy-ilt\h[jclf7vHv q=o

itci Y [ q

fHyHxeTilt

q y q i Y [ o

eT\][¢

qwo*)

eGyHxi

Y

[$eGcdtc

qwo

iY

[$[g-[ufHidt q y q

eu

q

\hv

q

y¤!=2iv olq

-txH[c

eGumttilt[c

qwojY

eGyHxHtyH+u

q

\hv

q

yH[y-ilc5u

q

yHy7[ui q=o

c5

\eGyeTw[\h[y-i v

q

tumt[mc3-[iduw¤

XY

[mcl[

eTuttidt[ctyHumf7xH[w§

N ) y q

¢[xHw[

q iY

[¡eGvHv7tu3eTilt

q

ycdi

o

fHuilf

o

[eGyHxu

q

y-wf

o

eGidt

q

y-ty]id[

o

\hc q u q

\hv

q

yH[y-ilc5

N ` n

¥EeGy7x#eTclk-yHu YHodq

y q fHcxHtcli

o

tHfHid[xN[=[y-ilc

eTuttidt[mc3-yH[[mxH[x

q=o

u q y7yH[ui

qwo

c5

ÚòþÚÊ