Specification and Verification of various Distributed Leader Election Algorithm for Unidirectional Ring Networks

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00073712

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00073712

Submitted on 24 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Specification and Verification of various Distributed Leader Election Algorithm for Unidirectional Ring

Networks

Hubert Garavel, Laurent Mounier

To cite this version:

Hubert Garavel, Laurent Mounier. Specification and Verification of various Distributed Leader Elec- tion Algorithm for Unidirectional Ring Networks. [Research Report] RR-2986, INRIA. 1996. �inria- 00073712�

(2)

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Specification and Verification of various Distributed Leader Election Algorithms

for Unidirectional Ring Networks

Hubert Garavel, Laurent Mounier

N ˚ 2986

Septembre 1996

TH `EME 1

(3)

(4)

$ #%&'")(* ',+.-/102-!34576'89#

:4<;='!7/7!-?>@3BACDFEG7HI#

JKLNMPOQSRUTVOWTYXFMPZ\[P]^TVKO_MP`aQSbdcFK`efMPOWg

hDiaj

klmkmnpoBqSrkWstkWu:vxwIkystzxsty

j

k_l{kWs

|}~:

k!yYVk_!y } k

qu:

~}

yxk

}

kW

i k } i

k:oBYk_xyk_l4

}

kn_ oBuk_s

I_: hDi

s } k

~}

y{k_u: s¡

y i y i

k£¢

~}

lu:Ds¤kW

¦¥

u:y

§~

¨u*©k }ª¥

_u«y

¦~

~

¢p

sty }

vyk_¨¦kWuxk

}

k§k_y

¦~

Su¦

~}

y i ls/¢

~}

umsk!y

~

¢lu i

k_s

~

k_yk_Yzu{v

§}

kWy

§~

¤u:

}

mky¬¡

~}F®

Pyu } y

¢

}~

l2u:¯u:§

~}

y i l<

}~

~

stkWUYz±°%k°²u

³n_Y´´xµ²u:

ys ©«u }

u:Py }~

~

sk_Pz¯¶

i

u:u

q ~

Vk

}

ys

n_P´:µ:¡/kpstyv¤xz{y i k

}~

vstykWss

~

¢ay i

s/! uss

~

¢²u:§

~}

y i ls

I

}

k_skk

~

¢%v

}

k_

u:¦k

~

lmlvx·

_u«y

¦~

SlmkW

vl¸u¤¹

~}

v

}

k

u§k lmu

i

k_s

®º

k4stvkWs¬y©«u }§~

vs

lm

}~

©klmk_y5s

~

¢»y

i

kWstku¦

~}

y i ls

~}

xk } y

~~

xy5u

Su¢¼v§§zI¢½u:vªy·fy

~

§k

}

u:Py

}~

y ~ ~ ®

hDi

k_sk'u:§

~}

y i lsmu

}

kS¢

~}

lmu¦§z¨xkWs

}

Vk_?vs

±y

i

kU¾5¿WÀ.s¤kW

¦¥

u:y

§~

Á§uvuk'ÂÃÀ²Ä%ÀÅ¿SuÁ©k }¦¥

k_

Æ¢

~}

u ¥

wYkW±Pvl4Vk }~

¢Ãlu i

kWsÇvs

Sy

i

k'ÈÉÅÊ²Ë

Æ

ÈÌp¿É²Í²¹ÎÏPÊ4Ð ÑÒ

É²ÍFÉÅÓVÇÔy

~Y~

§

~ w

®Õ'~

xk_ª·Ö

i

k_

Y

u:±

s

l4v§u:y

§~

±ykW

i

×

vk_su¦

~

¡y

i

k©k }¦¥

u:y

§~

~

¢/y

i

kWstk

~

x·\y }

~}

y i lsy

~

VkIu }}

kW

~

vxy

u:vxy

~

lu«y

_u:§¦z

®

Ø'ÙÚFÛÜ4Ý Þ» ß s

lv§u:y

§~

s_µpà

s¬y }

vxyk_.á§

~}

y i ls_µpâ

~}

luÔàpk_s

}

xy

§~

h kW

i

×

vk_s_µâ

~}

lmu

Õ

k!y i~

sµa°Åu:Vk§¦kW

h²}

u:s

y

§~

UYzxstykls_µV°²k_uxk }ã

§k_y

¦~

%µaÂÃÀ²ÄaÀ»¿µ Õ'~

xk_ª·Ö

i

k_

Y

µ

|}~

!k_ssá¦k

}

us_µ

|}~

y ~ ~ ã

kk }

µYVk_

ª¥

_u«y

¦~

%µ hÅ~

k_q

¤µäu:

u«y

§~

²µxä7k }ª¥

_u«y

¦~

®

å æ{ç

èéëê_ì

ç

èí»î éëïfð!ñ

ò_óôõfö%÷!ø¬õ\ùfúûôüô5ýYö\óWúûù²õfø¬þôõ½ö%úûüÿ

è è ì»ð:êWî èì/ì

ù\þ:øtúúûù\ùøôü ü"!"ù½ö\õfú#$&%%ø'ûøÖ÷5üö)(»þWþ"ûú#'+*

öfúûôüù²ô5ý-,«ôõ.&/(»ü0$_ù\úûù1xøëóüWú#2ø¬ù

/3

5ü*4,«õ\úûùfô5»õ\ôô5öfø65ü7!98:5õföfúûü;%²ø.

ø!úöfôõ\ù

=<'>>?7@

A6B*4.&5ú#DC=EFGIHJK-LDMNJNOHPQ7RS"NT-LDUJ

V üõfú%²óXWôüWø*D(Yûþ:ø¬ù[Z6\¤øtõfú#.&]

8Ôúûüúûþ05õ^*_úûõfùfö

õøa`X¬÷!ôúûù\úûø¬õ

,-*4bcbbd 8Ôôü!öeôüWüô5öNò75úûü!ö*48:5õföfúûü

,«õf5ü"¬ø

@

Bg*4.&5ú#DC

h

N+FJH+iK-LkjlFi0R'HJQ7RS"NT-LDUJ

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rhˆone-Alpes

655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST MARTIN (France)

(5)

!#²»_&'"# -!/!{)#","' #Å")'" "''!7/'-

Ù Ù

¶Ãk

}

u:

~}

yp

} rkWstk_yk u£s/rk_

ª¥

u«y

¦~

'k!yÔ§u©Nrk }¦¥

u:y

§~

S¢

~}

lmk§¦kmu:§

~}

y i lmk_sp

s¬y }

vDrkWs

¬rk§k_y

¦~

Ssv

}

v

} rk_sk_uvIk'uk_uvv

¦}

k_!y

§~

k_

®

á*u } y

¦}

vu:§

~}

y i lmk7

}~

~ sxrk7u

}

°%k/°²u: kn_Y´´Ãky»xkNsu©«u }

u:Pyk7

}~

~ srk_k»¤u

} ¶ i

u:kyÅq

~

¤k

}

y5s

k£nWP´:µ

~ rkyv

k u }~

vstyk_sskNxkÃk!yykD! usstkNu¦

~}

y i

lmk_s%k_4

} rkWstk_!kxkDuu:vwÔxkD

~

lml4v

u:y

§~

k!y¹

~ v xklu i

k_s£

~ ¥

u:§k_s

®~

vs£sv7rk }~

s

r

k }

k_Pyk_s£u:l¨rk

§~}

u«y

§~

¤sxkk_s£u¦

~}

y i lmk_sIu

¥

~

xyk_

§}

v

}~

y ~ ~

¦k } rk_s

s¬y5u:Py

j

um!kWsuk_s

®

¶Ãk_s*u¦

~}

y i lmk_s

~

Py kyrr kÁ¢

~}

lmk§§klmkPy¨/rkW

}

y5s

j

u u

xk xv u:Pu:k³k stDrk_

ª¥

_u«y

¦~

GÂÃÀ²Ä%ÀÅ¿³

~}

·

lmu

sxrk u

}

¾¿WÀ k!yU©Ãrk }¦¥

r

kWs Æ ~ v }

v ~ l4

} k ¥

wÃrk¯xk¯lu i

kWsÇ

}

uk

j

u? u³

~

yk

j

u ~ vy

§s±ÈÉ²ÊÅË

Æ

ÈÌp¿É²Í²¹ÎÏPÊ Ð ÑÒ

É²ÍFÉ²ÓFÇ

®ã

vxy

su:PyÔxk_syk_

i

§×

vkWs¢

~

/rk_k_ssv

}

u7rkDrk } u«y

§~

£k!w

i

u:v¤s¬y

©kk!y§k_s

}

k_§u:·

y

§~

sÃxk

s

l4v§u:y

§~

%µ§u ©Ãrk }¦¥

_u«y

§~

mxkk_su¦

~}

y i lmk_s7

~

x·\y }

©

u:vxw¤k_vxy

ky

}

kDk

k_yvDrk_ku:vxy

~

lu«y

§×

vk·

l{k_Py

®

Ý W Û Ù

á§

j

k_

}

k_sDxk }~

!k_ssvsµá¦

~}

y i lmk_s

sty }

vDrk_s_µ ß s

lv u«y

§~

¤sµ

ã

¦kWy

§~

²µÖ7rk

k }

kÔxkWs

}~

y ~ ~

¦kWsµaÂÃÀ²Ä%ÀÅ¿:µ Õ rky

i~

xkWs¢

~}

lmk_¦§k_s_µaqrk_sk_uv

j

u ky

~

%µ²qSrkWstkWu:v'k_u:k_uv%µ%YDrkW

¦¥

u:y

§~

%µ%Yzxsty

j

k_l{kWs

xkÔy

}

u:s

y

§~

s£rky

×

vk!yrkk_s_µ

h

kW

i

×

vk_sxkk_s

}

xy

¦~

£¢

~}

lmk_¦§kµxäu

u«y

¦~

%µxä'rk }ª¥

_u«y

¦~

®

(6)

< =

{7I"/

¤!kIy

i

k£kWu

}

¦z u«yyk_l{ys

~

¢u:vy

~

lu:y

I

}~

y ~ ~

Ã©u

u:y

§~

*u }}

k_

~

vyYz¯¶

®»º

k_sty5>

º

kWs5´:!?ëµ¢

~}

lmu

©k }¦¥

u:y

§~

£k_k

}

u:\µYu:Iy

i

kÔs

~

·ë_u:§¦kWml

~

ka

i

k_

Y

u

}~

u

i

u } y

!v u } µ

s/s

~

lmk!y

lmk_sD

~

Py }~

·

©k } s

u@

A â }~

l.uDy i k

~}

ky

u

~

y

~

¢x©

k_¡ µy i

sÅ

}~

§kl u: VkÃ

~

s

xk

}

k_ us²s

~

§©k_p¢

~}²¥

ykÃstyu«ykNszYstyk_ls

s

¤!kÔ©k }¦¥

u:y

§~

Su:§

~}

y i lsDu

}

kÔ

~ ¡ ¡/k§ª·

~

¡CB

A â }~

l¸u£u

©k

~

Py

~

¢©

k_¡ µ¤¢

~}

lu²©k }¦¥

_u«y

§~

spvstk_¦kWss_µFs

!k

~£}

k_u

sty

u:

u:y

§~

U_u:'Vk

¢¼v§§z£©k }¦¥

kWaµu:£y i

s

}~

¦k_l

sDvPy

}

uy5u:§k u:YzY¡/uzVk__u:vsk

~

¢Åy

i

ks

ED

k ~ ¢ } kWu:

sty

Ôstzxstykls

®

â

~}

yvu«yk§zµ

}

kWu:

y¬z

s4l

~}

kIs

i

uxk_C@

}

u!y

uk!wxVk }

lmkPy5s4u:

}

k_uzs i~

¡ÃkWy

i

u:yy

i

kWstk£l{ky i~

s{u } k

~ ¡ u:

u:¦k

Uu

xvsty }

uÅ

~

PykwPyWµau:Sy

i

u«yy

i

k_z'u:'

}~

©

xk4u:

lm

~}

yu:Pyu

'y

i

k{xk_s

~

¢7u u

}

kÔ! uss

~

¢u:

u:y

§~

s_µstv¤

i

us

sty }

vxykWstzxstykls

~}

~ lmlv

u«y

¦~

}~

y ~ ~

§s

®

hDi

s } k

~}

y

§¦v¤s¬y

}

u:yk_spy

i

kIu:

u:y

§~

~

¢/styu:yk!·

~ ¢·\y

i

k!·Öu

}

yp©k }¦¥

_u«y

§~

lmk!y i~

sy

~

u£

~

x·\y }

s¬yvxzµ i u }

x¦zy

}

u!yu¦kSs

lm§z±Yz

i

vlu:

}

k_us

~

®

Py5u }y

¢

}~

l2y i k

~}

u:Nk_s

}

xy

¦~

~

¢y¬¡

~

¢½u:l

~

vsu:§

~}

y i lms_µy

i k ~

k

}~

~

stkWYzGF

®

°²k°²uH>°²uV´´?u:¤

y5s©«u }

u:Pyp

}~

~ stkWPz

ã®

¶ i u

u:q

® q ~

Vk

}

ysI>¶/q´«!?ëµ

~ v }~

k_y

©k4¡Dusy

~

xk_s

UuI¢¼v¦§z'¢½uvªy·fy

~

§k

}

u:Py§k_uxk

}

k§k_!y

§~

u¦

~}

y i lµ

y ~ stVk_

¢¼z

yv¤s

my

i

k4ÂÃÀ²ÄaÀ»¿p u:vu:kµxu:£y

~ ¢

~}

lu¦§z©k }

¢¼z

yvs

{y

i

kmÈÉ²Ê²Ë£y

~Y~

¦

~ w ®

hDi

s } k_

~}

y s

~}

Pu:

3D

kW?usm¢

~

§

~

¡s

®

xk_y

¦~

±

}

k_skPysmy

i

kÂ/À%Ä%À»¿S§uv¤u:k'uYk_!y

§~

©kWs

u:

~

©k } ©

k_¡

~

¢Ãy

i

kÈÉÅÊ²ËUy

~Y~

§

~ w

®mº

kmy

i

k_¯s¬yvxzUsk©k

}

u:©k } s

¦~

s

~

¢Ãy

i

k§k_uxk

}

k_¦kWy

§~

u:§

~}

y i l

vxk }

¤

}

k_us

§z£sk©k

}

kp¢½u

§v

}

kussvlmxy

¦~

s@

}

k

u:§k

su

}

k_

u:§kÔlu i

k_s

Æ

YkWy

§~

5JYÇµv

}

k·

u:§k

su:

}

k

u¦klu

i

k_s

Æ

xk_y

¦~

HKÇÔuaµ

¥

u:§§zµ»v

}

k

u¦k

su: v

}

k_

u:¦klu i

kWs

Æ

YkWy

§~

'PÇ

®

L M

6ON489- $ #Å_!{

M

N6''P" (RQ

M

Q@

Õ

u:Yz'¢

~}

lu:

stls

i

u©k{Vkk }~

~ sk_¢

~}

xkWs

}

u

}

u:§¦k_7stzxstykls_µ²u:l

~

¡

i

i µ²y

i

kstyuu } ·

D

k_ â

~}

lmu7àkWs

}

xy

§~

h k_

i

×

vk£ÂÃÀ²Ä%ÀÅ¿TS

i

us

}

k_k

©kWUu

~

s

xk

}

u¦ku:ytyk_Py

§~

¢

}~

l,y i k }

k_sk_u } i

~ lmlv

y¬z

®

ÂÃÀ²ÄaÀ»¿

s7u¢

~}

lu:x u:vuk

Pyk_xk_¢

~}

y i ks¤kW

¦¥

u:y

§~

~

¢V

~

lml4v

_u«y

§~

{

}~

y ~ ~

su:

sty }

vxykW

stzxstykls

®

ëyÔ¡Dus k©k_

~

¤kWUxv }

Sy

i

kzk_u

}

sn_nUx

±y

i

km¢

}

u:lmk_¡

~}~

¢Ãy

i

k£

ã

àWVÔ+X{

}~

k_!y u

s¬y5u:u }

ED

k_{Yzm¾¿WÀZY

'n_[>tV7?

®

Yk©k

}

u:xyvxy

~}

u: s¢

~}

ÂÃÀ²Ä%ÀÅ¿u

}

ku©u

u:¦kµ:k

® ® >

ßDß

µ h v }

!?

®

hDi

k4xkWs

~

¢Â/À%Ä%À»¿Ô¡Dusl

~ y

©u:ykWPzy

i

k4k_k_S¢

~}

u u:vu:k¡

y i u i

i u:¤s¬y

}

uy

§~

§k©k²u'u

s¬y }~

4lu«y

i

klu:y

u:Fus

s_µP¡

i

i ~

v§£¤kÔvsk_I¢

~}

y i kÔxkWs

}

xy

§~

Su:u:u¦zxs

s ~

¢»

~

lm§k!w£szxs¬ykls

®

ÂÃÀ²ÄaÀ»¿¢¼k_u:yv

}

k_s/y¬¡

~

!§k_u

}

§zIstk_u

}

u«yk_u

}

ysT@

\^] Ù ÞÅxW_»x ~

¢ÂÃÀ²ÄaÀ»¿

s/xkW

_u«yk_y

~ y i

k xk_s

}

xy

§~

~

¢Åu:yu4sty

}

v!yv

}

k_s

®

ëy

s/usk_

~

Iy

i

kp¡/k§¦·

~

¡Sy i k

~}

z ~

¢u:§k

} u

Ôu:¤s¬y

}

uyu:yu{y¬zY¤kWsµ¤l

~}

kstVk_

ª¥

_u:§¦z

~

Sy

i

k{Î'`¤Ä.aÓ Ñ s¤kW

¦¥

u:y

§~

u:vu:kI>

ãNÕ

7KPµ

Õ

q%äpPb?

®

Öy i

su

}~

u

i

µ%u«y5usty

}

vyv

}

k_s u

}

kmxk_s

}

Vk_±Yz

##

µ%¡

i

i } k_

}

~

lmu

¤sµ²u

cd)#

µ¡

i

i u } klu«y

i

klu«y

_u:x¢¼vy

¦~

sNxk

¥

kW

~

{y

i

kWstkp

~

lu

s

®»hDi

klmk_u:

~ ¢ ~

¤k

}

u:·

y

¦~

s

sNxk

¥

k_mYz4u:§k_

} u

e")#

®

~}

y5sµ

~

Vk

}

u«y

§~

¤sµ:u{k

×

vu«y

¦~

s7u

}

kD

}~

vVk_

ml

~

xv¦kWs

fg

!ê"!è1hji:ètì»ðkCh lè'

ÿ

ðWè m

î

n ÿ

Öî3o ½èqp«ï

«ìDè'«îîErWètsNèté

jhxð_è s

éëîD 3u

ê_îè,l ÿ/v

éëîètì/éf

BaòTw %)41'þõfôx½ø'Öözy

< d