HAL Id: inria-00073443
https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00073443
Submitted on 24 May 2006
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Non-parametric Invariants and Application to Matching
Zhong-Dan Lan, Roger Mohr
To cite this version:
Zhong-Dan Lan, Roger Mohr. Non-parametric Invariants and Application to Matching. [Research
Report] RR-3246, INRIA. 1997. �inria-00073443�
ISSN 0249-6399
a p p o r t
d e r e c h e r c h e
INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE
Non-parametric Invariants and Application to Matching
Zhong-Dan LAN and Roger MOHR
N ˚ 3246
September 5, 1997
TH ` EME 3
0213546578%9:4<;>=@?954A<B36DCFEHGJI%KHB
L'MDN
OQPORTS,UWVYXZO\[^]F_XZ`baFV
M
aFPPOcdP]e_
M
`fVgOFh
`fP]eieO\jhlkgaYVlVnmOQOQjQhg_aFV:Vl]o`fj^jp]eV:_OQj
q
[^aorWOQXsut'vwU
x
]eyly5aF[^X'kgO[ZO\_
M
OQ[p_
M
OzVT{eRF|o}F~SYO\ygXZO\PT5OQ[lh QFYS|oRyl]oiFOQj
*Qlee L'M
`fj[ZO\y:aY[ZXyl[^OQj^OQVYXT]VgaFVyl]F[^]FPOX^[^`f_P]eX^_
M
`fVgiPOQX
M
agkl]FjZO\kaFVVgaYVyl]e[p]ePOXp[Z`f_`fVF]F[Z`f]eVYX^jXZa
iFOaFPOQX^[^]eVlkT`bVYXZO\Vlj^`XdXp[^]FVljWaY[^Pjao`bP]oiFOQjQ
L'M
Olj^Oao:`fVY]F[Z`f]eVYX*P]F oO\j`bXy:aYj^j^`fg¡OnXZaP]oXp_
M
`fP]oieO\j:VlkgOQ[¡f]e[^ieO
iFOaFPOQX^[^`b_(X^[p]eV:jWaY[^PjQ
L'M
Olj^O(aeVlaFVyl]e[p]ePOQX^[^`b_POQ]Fj^l[^OQjP]e eOQj`bX>[ZaYllj^X'XZa¢yl]F[ZX^`b]e¡ag__¡flj^`aYV¤£V]e¡iFaF[^`X M P
X^aaFgXp]o`fVHjpl¥cdyg`¦¥OQ¡yl[^OQ_`fj^`aYV`fj>]o¡fj^aj
M
a§>V
x
O\j^g¡bX^j>aFV@[ZO\]o¡`fP]eieO\j2]e¡`fkl]oX^OX
M
O]Fylyl[^aF]F_
M
¨©YªD«^¬ ®*e
P]eX^_
M
`fVgi:hg`fVY]e[^`b]FVFXpjh¥`fVYXZOQ[^OQj^X>y5ae`fVFXpjhly:]e[^XZ`f]o¡ag__¡blj^`baFVhlVgaYV¥cdyl]e[p]ePOXp[Z`f_ohg[^aFl:jZXpVgOQjpjhgyl[^OQ_`bj^`baFV
¯f°±
²Z³µ´\¶
±
²·*¸f³µ¹»º¼
½¾\¿ÁÀÂDÃÅÄ»Æ'ÂÇÈÀÀ»ÉÊ\ÊeÃÅÄÌË»ÍWÎÏÐ(ÑÒ*ÓÔeÕÖÒÓ×ÖÙØ.ÕÖÒ*ÚÛuÇÈÜÎÝ*ÞÅß
Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rhˆone-Alpes
655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST MARTIN (France)
T´el´ephone : (33) 04 76 61 52 00 – T´el´ecopie : (33) 04 76 61 52 52
© ©
O>[^]Fyly5aF[^X¤yl[gmOQj^OQVYX*:VgOP OXm
M
agkgO>k]eyly:]e[^`O\PO\VYXVlaFVyl]F[^]FP OX^[^`YlOQjYl`5j^O>l]ej^O>j^:[¤kgOQj.PO\j^:[ZO\jVgaFVm
yl]F[^]FP OXp[Z`¥gOQj2`bVY]e[^`f]eVYX']e¥¦Xp[^]FVljZaF[pP]eXZ`baFVlj2imm OaFP OQX^[^`¥gO\j.OQX'ym
M
aeX^aeiY[^]FPP OQX^[^`¥gO\jm
OX^XZOP OXm
M
agkgOOQj^X>[ZaYllj^XZO
]Fu:[^g`bXh]F¥¦OOQX^jVgaYV¡`fVnmO\]o`f[ZO\jk`fVYXZO\VljZ`bXgmOQjOQX]e¥¦ua¥_Q_g¡bX^]eXZ`baFVljTyl]e[^XZ`bO¡b¡O\jwO\jT[gmOQjpg¡bX^]eX^j(O¦lynmO\[Z`fPOQVYX^]F¥¦jpl[
kgO\j`bP]oiFOQj[gmOO¡b¡bOQj]e¡`fkgO\VFX_OQXZX^O@]Fylyl[^a¥_
M
OOXPaFVYXp[ZO\VFX¡]eP OQ¡`baF[p]oX^`aYVjZ`biFVl`5_Q]oX^`FOHyl]F[[p]eyly5aF[^Xm
N
]¡f]P OQXm
M
agkgO
kg`mOQ[^OQVYXZ`bO¡b¡bO|e »
! Q « #" ©
]eylyl]F[Z`bOQPO\VFXQh'`bVY]e[^`f]eVYX^jQh>y:aF`bVYXpjk`bVYXgmOQ[$OXQha¥_Q_g¡bX^]eXZ`baFV y:]e[^XZ`bO¡b¡OFh>VgaFV y:]e[p]eP OXp[Z`¥gOeh[^aFllj^XZO\j^jQhm
yl[lmO\_`fjZ`baFV
R
1 *
2435 Q ® *o76 5 8
F 49.¦g`bj^XZ`fVgiP]oX^_
M
`bVgiPOX
M
agklj$(((( }
F F
aYVYXZaF:['l]ej^OQk@POX
M
a¥k:j ((( }
F F| £w[ZO\]l]ej^OQk@POX
M
a¥k:j (((( }
F FR (OQ]e¡`fVgi§'`bX
M
[^aeX^]eXZ`baFV (((( }
F| q
]F[ZX^`b]e¡Da¥_Q_¡flj^`aYV;:X^[p]eVlj^¡b]eXZ`baFVl]e¡_]ej^O ((( }
F|l
q
]F[ZX^`b]e¡_aF[p[^O¡f]oXZ`baFV ((((
F|l| <waFV
q
]e[p]ePOQX^[^`b_w_aF[p[^O¡f]oXZ`baFV:j((( ~
=>35@?
lA6 5
© 7B ® C
|l UWVYXp[Zagkll_XZ`baFVHXZa`fVY]F[Z`f]eVYXpj (((( D
|l| (`O\[ZO\VFX^`b]e¡`bVY]e[^`f]eVYX ((((
|lRE<waFV
q
]e[p]ePOXp[Z`f_w`bVY]e[^`b]FVYX(((($ GF
|lR: t(lX^]o`fVg`fVgi¢VgaYVHyl]F[^]FPOX^[^`f_w[^O¡f]oX^`aYVlj((($ GF
|lR:| 92¡`fP`bV:]oXZ`fVgi¢[^aeXp]oXZ`baFVO DOQ_X>FH`bVYX^OiF[p]oX^`aYV)((($ GF
|lR:R H]ej^X>yl]oX^XZO\[^V@[ZOZrWOQ_XZ`baFV (((($ \|
|l} ¥XZOQy:j'ao*X
M
OP]oXp_
M
`fVgiyl[Zag_OQjpj(((($ \|
IEJLK;M ©
6 © 5
Q
2-I
R: £wgXZaYP]oXZ`f_O]e¡bl]eXZ`baFVHao*X
M
O[^OQjpg¡bX^j((($ QR
R:| NwOQaFPOXp[Z`f__
M
]eVlieO(((($ QR
R:R UWVYX^OQVlj^`XdH_
M
]eVgiFO (((($ \
R:} L'M
[ZOQOcdkg`bPO\VljZ`baFV:]o¡j^_OQVgO (((($ Q~
8 O
× « M 6K © " g\7BP6
5PQ
© GB ®
2-R
STJLK;M
© 6 © 5
Q "¤ © "\ 5 « M 6K © " gQABP6
5PQ 2-R
l >NwOQaFPOXp[Z`f__
M
]eVlieO(((($ Q
l| UWVYX^OQVlj^`XdH_
M
]eVgiFO (((( |F
lR L'M
[ZOQOcdkg`bPO\VljZ`baFV:]o¡j^_OQVgO (((( |F
U V 5
#"*G6 5 ==
}
¢! n
s]eX^_
M
`fVgi`fj](P]orWaF[*`bjpjpgO`bV_aYPylgXZO\[¥`bj^`aYV Yho}:hl \|¥he| F µhF]ej*`bX`bjVlOQ_O\j^jp]e[^aF[j^XZO\[ZOQaocµ¥`bj^`aYVhPaeXZ`baFVOQj^XZ`fP]oX^`aYVh
aY¥rWOQ_X>[ZO\_aeiYVg`bXZ`baFV¢OQX^_e
"!#$%&!')(*
UdX>`fj>FOQ[^kg`,+¢_g¡bXX^a¢ie`beO]eVaFOQ[^¥`OQ§ aF[>jpl_
M
]§'`fkgO¡bj^yl[^OQ]FkHjpl¥rWO\_X]Fj>P]oXp_
M
`bVli:.-O¡b`fP`bX>aYl[^j^O¡beO\jXZa¢X M O
| `bP]eieOQj'P]eX^_
M
`fVgi_]FjZOF
20/20/2 V 5
¢*:
© ® ©
GB
®*
YaYPO(]FgX
M
aY[^jnyl[^aFy5aFj^OX^alj^O_aFVYX^aFl[pj.]Fj2X
M
O¢_aFVYX^]e`bVjZ`biFVg`5_Q]eVYX2`fV¥aY[^P]oX^`aYV¤t(VgOwae×X
M
O(O\]e[^¡`bOQj^X.§naF[p ¥j._Q]eV5O
aYlVlk¢`fV R µhY§
M
OQ[^Owj^X^[p]o`bi
M
X¡`fVgOjZOQiFPOQVYXpj.]e[^Olj^OQk]ej.P]eX^_
M
`fVgiy:[Z`fP`X^`FO>`bVX
M
[^OOY`bO§>jn_]FjZOw]eVlk¢j^aFPO
M
OQl[^`bj^XZ`f_
_aFVlj^X^[p]o`fVYX^j]e[^Olj^OQk]ej§nO¡b¡.]ejX
M
O¢j^`bP`b¡b]F[Z`bXdPOQ]Fj^:[ZO5OXd§nOOQVuX
M
Oj^OiFPO\VFXpjsaF[^Oj^aFy
M
`bj^XZ`f_]eXZO¢POX
M
agklj]F[ZO
yl[^aFy5aFj^OQkuY21waF[p]elk F µh×§
M
O\[ZO¢[^O¡f]oX^`aYVlj]e[^O:g`¡bXaYVu_aFVYXZaYl[pjh]FVlk]%jZO\]e[p_
M
aF[P]o¦¥`fP]o¡._¡`¥gOQj`fj]Fylyg¡b`O\k
1wa§2OQeOQ[Qhe`bX^j2XZ`fPO(_aFPyg¡bO¦g`bXd`fj.FOQ[^
M
`i
M
hY]FVlkX
M
OQ[^OaY[ZO]Fklkg`bXZ`baFVl]e¡_aFVlj^X^[p]o`fVYX^j¡b`f oOX
M
OO\yg`fy:aF¡b]F[2_aFVlj^X^[p]o`fVYX
M
]eO
X^a¢:O]FklkgOQkH`fVHaY[^klOQ[nXZa¢[^OQkl:_OX
M
O[plVHXZ`fPOe
£wj`bVlkl`b_Q]oXZO\k`bV R »hY]o¡b¡l_aYVFX^aFl[l]FjZO\kPOQX
M
agklj¤_Q]eVaFVg¡bT5O']eylyg¡b`bOQk`DX
M
O>jZOQiFPOQVYX^]eXZ`baFVyl[ZaYg¡bOQP `fj§2OQ¡¡lj^ae¡beO\kh
X M
`bj
M
gy5aeX
M
OQj^`bj`fj
M
a§nOFOQ[2aFVg¡b[^OQ]e¡`fjZX^`b_waY[`bP]oiFOQjae*j^`bPyg¡bOj^_OQVgOF
20/20/=
¢ © l © ® © 7B ®
L'M
O>_aF[p[ZOQ¡b]eXZ`baFVTXZOQ_
M
Vg`¥gO |
M
]ej5OO\V:jZO\kTaY[]¡aYVgiXZ`fPO RY|¥hY¥h: Q~ghl 7D µ*UWVaY[^kgO\[*XZaaFlX^]o`fVj^]eXZ`fjWÌ]F_XZaY[Z[ZO\j^g¡bX^jQh
X M
O_aY[^[^OQjpy:aYVlkg`fVgi§'`bVlkla§>j'j
M
aYg¡fkH5O]eyly:[Za¦g`fP]eXZOQ¡¢jply5OQ[py:aYjZO\kHYH]j^`bPyg¡bOX^[p]eVlj^¡f]oXZ`baFV*UWV_Q]ej^O(ae*VgaYV¥cµX^[^`¥`f]o¡
`fP]oieOw[ZaFX^]oX^`aYVhoX
M
OwV¥lP:O\[aoDÌ]o¡fj^OP]oX^_
M
OQj`fVl_[^OQ]FjZO\j£ POX
M
agkXZaT_aF[p[ZO\_XX
M
O'Ì]o¡fj^OP]oX^_
M
OQj¤]FVlkXZaiFOX.y:[ZO\_`fjZO
P]oXp_
M
OQj'_Q]eV5OaFlVlkH`fV »
twX
M
OQ[POX
M
agkljj^l_
M
]ej31w]FljpkgaF[ kg`bj^X^]FVl_O } µh¥Ì[ZO¥gOQVYXZ`f]o¡POX
M
agk ~lhl| D ×_]FV]o¡fj^a5O:jZO\khg`bV@_]FjZOwaoj^P]o¡b¡
`fP]oieO[^aeXp]oXZ`baFV
20/20/I 4 © "6 5PQ
¬ 6ÌGB \gG6 5
L'M
O']F:aFO.XZO\_
M
Vg`¥gOQj]Fj*_aF[p[ZOQ¡b]eXZ`baFVh51(]eljpkgaF[ ¢kg`fjZXp]eVl_OehÌ[^O ¥gOQVYX^`b]e¡lPOQX
M
agk]e[^Onjpg`bX^]Fg¡O2aF[*ae5X^[p]eV:jZ¡f]oX^`aYVl]o¡¥_]FjZO
aYVg¡F'£ XZa¥ae¡×aF[>P]eX^_
M
`fVgi¢`fP]oieO\j>lVlklOQ[PaY[ZOiFOQVgO\[^]e¡PaFXZ`baFV%]Fj>[ZaFX^]eXZ`baFV@`bjw[ZO¥g`b[^OQk
L'M
`fj>`fjVlOQ_O\j^jp]e[^¢`fV%_]FjZO
ae2]egX^aocd_]e¡`fl[p]oXZ`baFV§
M
`b_
M
`bPyg¡b`O\jkg`DOQ[^OQVYX[ZaFX^]eXZ`baFVlj§'`X
M
VgaYV¥cdyl]e[p]o¡b¡OQ¡]o¦¥O\j§
M
`b_
M
¡O\]ekljwXZa]¢iY[ZO\]oXiFOaYPOQX^[^`b_Q]o¡
_ M
]FVgieO'5OXd§nOO\VTX
M
O'`bP]eieOQjae]jp]ePO'j^_OQVgOF
L'M
ljX
M
O'aF¥rWO\_X`fkgOQVYXZ`5_Q]oXZ`baFV
M
]FjXZa5O>jZXp]eg¡bOXZa[^`iF`bkkg`bjpyg¡f]e_OQPOQVYX
6
[ZaFX^]oX^`aYVH]FVlk@X^[p]eVlj^¡f]oXZ`baFV07¤5OXd§nOO\VHX
M
O`fP]eieO\j
L'M
O(P]oX^_
M
`bVgilVlkgO\[.X
M
OQj^OiFOQVgO\[^]e¡:_aYVlkg`bXZ`baFVlj.`bjnkg`,+_Qg¡bXn]FVlkX
M
lj2`Xn§'`b¡¡D:O(y:O\[WaY[^PO\kaFV`fVYXZOQ[^OQj^X.y5ae`fVYX^j 7F
aYVg¡]ejX
M
O]F[ZO¡ba¥_Q]o¡¤]FVlkX
M
OiF[^O ¡bOFO¡fj(`bVuX
M
O`f[VgO`bi
M
5aF[
M
a¥a¥k_aYVFXp]o`fVPaYjZX`fV¥aF[pP]oXZ`baFV§
M
`f_
M
P]F oOQj(X
M
O`f[
`fkgOQVYX^`5_Q]oX^`aYVHO\]ej^`O\[
L
aaYgX^]e`bV `bVlj^OQV:jZ`fg`b¡`bXdXZau[ZaFX^]oX^`aYV ]eV:k jp_]o¡bOH_
M
]eVgiFOQjQhX
M
O@X^[p]eVlj^¡f]oXZ`baFVgcµl]FjZOX^OQ_
M
Vl`¥gO\j]F[ZO@lj^OQk `fV j^OFOQ[p]o¡
kg`f[^OQ_X^`aYVlj]eVlk]eXj^OeO\[^]e¡.jp_]o¡bOQjQ81( \R 'j^giFieO\jZXpjT]ey:yg¡¥`fVgi X M
OH_aF[p[ZOQ¡b]eXZ`baFVu`bV jZOQeOQ[p]o¡nkg`f[ZO\_XZ`baFV:jT]eV:k9-u R:
yl[^aFy5aFj^OQkulj^`bVli N(]e5aF[ :¡bXZO\[^j`fVjZOQeOQ[p]o¡kg`f[^OQ_X^`aYVlj]FVlk]eXjZOQeO\[^]e¡jp_]e¡O\j
x
l_Å Y¡`fkgieO |} nj^giFieO\jZXpj]eylyg¡b¥`bVli@X M O
1(]eljpkgaF[kg`fjZXp]eVl_OXZaX
M
OX^]ejp ae*¡bag_]oX^`bVli]FVH]:+¢VgOX^[p]eVljZaF[pP]oXZ`baFVh¥:jZ`fVgi][^]FjZX^OQ[^`,;QOQkH]eylyl[^aF]F_
M
X^aX
M
Oj^OQ]e[p_
M
UWVTaF[pkgOQ[XZa]eaF`bk_Q]o¡f_g¡f]oX^`aYVae5jZOQeO\[^]e¡F]o¡fgO\jhF¥_
M
P`fk |Flyl[ZaYy:aYjZO\kXZalj^On¡ag_]e¡gPO\]ejpl[^OQj§
M
`b_
M
]e[^O.`fVY]F[Z`f]eVYX
X^a¢[ZaFX^]oX^`aYV]FVlkj
M
Oyl[^aFy5aFj^OQkHXZalj^O]PTg¡bXZ`cdj^_Q]o¡bO]Fylyl[^aF]F_
M
XZa¢kgO\]o¡§'`bX M X M
Oj^_Q]o¡bO_
M
]eVgiFOe
=< >?A@ BDC')&&C#EFB'3HG? @DFCBB'3DCIJDK%
UWV X M
`bjHjZO\_X^`aYVh2§nO yl[^OQj^OQVYX¢j^aFPO yl]e[^XZ`f]o¡w]eVlk VgaYV¥cµy:]e[p]ePOXp[Z`f_H_aF[p[ZOQ¡b]eXZ`baFVljX^a kgOQ]e¡>§'`bX
M X M O yl]e[^XZ`f]o¡>ag_Q_¡fljZ`baFV
yl[^aFl¡O\PMLgaFX
M
O\[>POX
M
agkljhl]FjX
M
OiFOQVgO\[^]e¡`N;O\kO1(]eljpkgaY[ kg`fjZXp]eVl_O Q} ]F[ZO]o¡fjZay5aFjpjZ`fg¡bOe
s aYjZX_aF[p[ZOQ¡b]eXZ`baFVwXZO\_
M
Vg`YlOQj
M
]eOkg`,+_Qg¡bXZ`bOQj*VgOQ]F[kg`bjpyl]F[Z`bXdwkg`fjp_aFVYX^`bV¥g`bXZ`bOQjQhQaY[`fVyg¡b]F_O\j§
M
OQ[^O
M
`bi
M
¡`bi
M
X^ja¥_Q_l[Qh
]FjX
M
On§'`bVlkla§ lVlkgO\[_aFV:jZ`fkgOQ[p]oX^`aYV`bj*¡bag_]o¡b¡by:]e[^XZ`f]o¡b¡lgX
M
]F[^kl¡_aY[^[plygX^OQk`fV]jpP]e¡¡g]F[ZO\]lae:aF¥rWO\_Xpj
L'M
OQ[^OaY[ZO
`fVj^l_
M
]_]FjZOX
M
O>yg`¦¥OQ¡bj`fV]¡ag_Q]o¡l[^Oie`baFV[ZO\yl[^OQj^OQVYX*jp_O\VgO'O¡bOQPO\VFXpj*Ì[ZaYP Xd§nakg`bj^XZ`fVl_X`bVYXZO\Vlj^`Xdy:aYylg¡f]oXZ`baFV:jYaFPO
aeX
M
OHyl`¦gO¡fjT_aF[p[ZO\j^y5aFV:kX^a X M
OXZOQPyg¡f]oX^OHlV:kgOQ[_aFV:jZ`fkgOQ[p]oX^`aYV]FVlkj^aFPOÌ[^aFP ]FVgaeX
M
OQ[Tyl]e[^X^jTao'X
M
OHj^_OQVgOF£wj
§nO]e¡b[^OQ]FkgHPOQVYX^`aYVgOQkhX
M
`bjw¡O\]ekljXZa]yl[ZaYg¡bOQP aF[wP]FVY@_aF[p[ZOQ¡b]eXZ`baFVHXZOQ_
M
Vg`¥gO\jhDj^`bVl_OTX
M
Oj^X^]FVlkl]e[pk_aY[^[^O¡f]oX^`aYV
X^OQ_
M
Vg`¥gOQjw]e[^Oljpl]o¡b¡@l]ej^OQk@aYV%jZXp]eVlkl]F[^kj^X^]eXZ`fjZX^`b_Qj>POX
M
a¥k:jh§
M
`f_
M
]e[^O5OQj^Xwjpg`bXZO\kXZa]j^`bVlie¡bOy:aYylg¡f]oXZ`baFV.-uO
_Q]o¡b¡X
M
`fj'y
M
O\VgaFPO\VgaFV
$P7'$ '
OFOQVH`X>P`bi M X M
]eO(aeX
M
OQ['y
M
gj^`b_Q]o¡j^aFl[p_O\j]ej
M
`bi
M
¡b`bi
M
X^jQh
20/= /2
gG6 "'
© "gG6
5
H`iYl[^O #:.t(__¡flj^`aYV×OXG:ohl[Z`bi M X : o
$ $
`fkgOQ]
M
]ej5OOQV yl[^aFy5aFj^OQkXZauaeO\[^_aFPOX
M
`bjkg`,+¢_g¡bXde
aYVljZ`fkgO\[X
M
OHXd§na§'`fVlkga§>jaoX M O
H`biFl[^OH FhX
M
OQ P]oX^_
M
O¦l_OQygXwaF[(X
M
O[^`i
M
XWcdlyyl]F[ZX(`fV X M
O`fP]oiFO]FVlkFH-uO
M
]eOTX^a%[ZO\_aeO\['X
M
`bj_aF[p[^lylXZOQk
yl]F[ZXQD-O]Fj^jplPOX
M
]eX¡ag_]e¡¡b¢X
M
OjZ`biFV:]o¡aF5Ogj']FVH]:+VlO[ZOQ¡b]eXZ`baFVÌ[^aFP aFVH`bP]eieOXZaX
M
OaeX
M
OQ[
6
j^OO H`biFl[^O|7:
6
7
6
7
! "!#
§ M O\[ZO
6$%&
7¢`bjHX
M
Okg`fj^y:]e[^`Xd aoX
M
Ouy5ae`fVYX 6$
7Åh
')(*
+-,
]eVlk
/.10'2)354 446387'.
0928:;44 4<:57
h:|
3=
]eVlk|
:>
]e[^OX
M
O§'`fkgX
M
]FVlkX M O M
OQ`i
M
Xae*X
M
OXZOQPyg¡f]oX^O§'`bV:kga§ [^OQjpy:O\_X^`FO¡b¢]eVlk
#
`bj'] N(]e:j^j^`b]FV`fP]oiFOVlae`fjZOF
¥:_
M
]eVH] +¢VgO[ZOQ¡b]eXZ`baFV`bjnX^[pgO(`bVHX
M
Ow§'`fVlkga§ O¦l_OQylX.aY[2X M O
G' $? '
yl]F[ZXpj
6
]ej2X
M
O[^`i
M
XWcdlyyl]F[ZX2`bV:kg`b_Q]oX^OQkH`bV
X M O H`iYl[ZO 7È
£ j^`bPyg¡bOQ['PagkgOQ¡§2aYg¡fkH]e¡¡ba§rZlj^X]j
M `X'`fV@`bVYXZO\Vlj^`XdFhl`OeX
M
Ojp_]o¡bOwÌ]e_X^aF[@H`fj'jZOQX'XZa :
6
7AB
6!&C
7
! "!#4
50 100 150 200 250
50 100 150 200 250
H`iYl[^O|:¤£ +¢VgO[^O¡f]oX^`aYV5OXd§nOOQVD ]FVlkD hgX
M
OjpP]o¡b¡×_`f[^_¡O\j]e[^O(aYgXZ¡b`bOQ[pj
L'M
Oag__¡b:kgOQkyl]e[^X`bj*aYlVlklj^`bVgi
,L &E ) '
|oR µ 1(]¥`bVgiwaF:VlkTX M O
7 $?#
y:]e[^X^jQhoX
M
O'_aF[p[ZOQ¡b]eXZ`baFV`fj
[^OQj^X^[^`b_XZO\k¢aFVHX
M
O[^OQP]e`bVg`fVgiyl]e[^X^jnaeX
M
O(Xd§na§'`bVlkla§>jA-uO_Q]o¡b¡DX
M
`fjXZO\_
M
Vg`YlO
$P $
¤UWV¢Ì]F_X $
'$
`fj>]j^y5OQ_`b]e¡_]ej^OaoGF
/A, )' '$
h]ej§nO¡O\]eOIH 6J(*,
7J
6
`fVg¡b`O\[^j 7.aF[GH 6$(C,
7 F 6
aFlXZ¡b`O\[^j 7È
H5aF[O¦l]FPyl¡OFhgX
M
O§nO`bi
M
XZO\kLKNMAMPO _]FVH5OO¦lyl[^OQjpj^OQk]Fjnae¡b¡a§>j:
~
"!#$&%$')(* "!#$+%)(,
(.-0/2135476
8!#
-0/2135476
8! 9
;:2
£wVgaeX
M
OQ[2yl]e[^XZ`f]o¡l_aF[p[ZOQ¡b]eXZ`baFVho`fVlj^XZO\]ekao]FkrZlj^XZ`fVgi]¡b`bVgOXZaX
M
O>`fVFX^OQVlj^`bXZ`bOQj.y:]o`f[^jQho¡baYaY ¥jaF[¤]FVO¡b¡`fylj^O>aojpP]o¡b¡O\jZX
Fae¡flPOT§
M
]eX_aYVFXp]o`fVlj]eX¡bOQ]FjZX
M
]o¡¤ao¤X
M
Okl]eX^]lhD]eV:k lj^OQjwX
M
`fjOQ¡¡b`fyljZOTXZaOQ¡`fP`bV:]oXZOX
M
OaFgX^¡`bOQ[pj(]ePaFVgiX
M
Okl]oXp]l
L'M
O_aF[p[ZOQ¡b]eXZ`baFVH_a¥O +¢_`bOQVYX`fjOQj^XZ`fP]eXZO\k@:jZ`fVgiX
M
O[^OQP]e`bVgO\kHk:]oX^]:UWVYXZOQ[^OQj^XZO\kH[^OQ]FkgOQ[pj_]FVH[^OO\[XZa 7D µ
q
]F[ZX^`b]e¡*_aF[p[ZOQ¡b]eXZ`baFVlj
M
]eOjZaYPOjpl__OQjpjZO\jwVlOQ]e[(X
M
Okg`bjpyl]F[Z`bXd kg`fj^_aFVYXZ`fV¥g`XdF1wa§2OQeOQ[QhDX
M
OQ lj^Oyl`¦gO¡cµXZaocdyg`¦gO¡
_aF[p[ZO\j^y5aFVlklOQVl_OXZaO¡b`fP`fVl]eXZOX
M
OaYgXZ¡b`O\[^jQh¥X
M
`fj'_aY[^[^OQjpy5aFVlkgO\Vl_OO¦g`bj^X^jn`fVXp[^]FVlj^¡b]eXZ`baFVl]e¡_Q]ej^OQjQh¥]FVlk¢¡baFj^OQjn`fV[^aeXp]oXZ`baFV
_Q]ej^Oe£wVgaeX
M
OQ[k:[^]§>l]F_Å `bjX
M
]oXTX
M
OQ]e[^Ol]ej^OQkuaYVj^aFPO¡b`bVgO\]e[PagkgO¡fjQh*]FVlkX
M
OQ[^OaY[ZO
M
]eOjZaYPO¢kl`+¢_l¡XdXZa
M
]FVlkg¡bOVgaFVH¡b`bVgO\]e[OO\_X^jQ
20/= /= < 5
l © 6Ì% © "Ìg76 5
<waFV¢yl]F[^]FPOX^[^`f_'_aF[p[^O¡f]oXZ`baFV:j RY|¥hgDklaVgaFX.O¡b`fP`fVl]eXZOX
M
OaYgXZ¡b`bOQ[pj.]e_Q_aY[^kg`fVgiX^aT]Tyl]F[^]FPOX^[^`f_'PagkgOQ¡h¥`fVlj^XZOQ]FkhYX
M
OQ
lj^OaFVg¡bVgaYVy:]e[p]ePOXp[Z`f_PagkgOQ¡bjQh§
M
`f_
M
]F[ZO¡bOQjpjjZO\VljZ`bXZ`beOXZaaYgXZ¡b`O\[^jQUWVu]Fklkg`bXZ`baFVh×X
M
OQ_]FV
M
]FVlkg¡bOVgaFV¡`fVgO\]e[
OO\_X^j:O\_]e:jZOVgaYV
M
gy5aeX
M
OQj^`bjae¡b`bVgO\]e[^`XdH]e[^O:jZO\k
5>=
5 ® © 5
5
,? A@
I@=CBED
]Fg`
MHM
]FjkgOFO¡baFy5OQk]FV]Fylyl[^aF]e_
M § M
`b_
M
[ZOQ¡`bOQjnaYV¢¡ba¥_Q]o¡Xp[^]FVljWaY[^Pjnl]ej^OQk
aYV VlaFV¥cdyl]e[p]ePOQX^[^`b_@POQ]ejpl[^OQjQ
L'M
O ]e[^O%kgOQj^`iYVgOQk XZaX^ae¡bOQ[p]oX^OF
#@ $&
<aFV yl]F[^]FPOX^[^`f_Hj^X^]eXZ`fjZX^`b_Qj \ `fj
kg`fj^XZ`fVgiFg`fj
M
OQkY¢X
M
OljZOaeaY[^kgO\[Z`fVgi`bVgaF[pP]eXZ`baFV@]ePaFVlik:]oX^]:hl[^]eX
M
O\[nX
M
]FVHX
M
Okl]eX^]]o¡fgOQjX
M
OQPj^O¡beOQjQ
L
§na ¡ba¥_Q]o¡VgaFVgcµyl]F[^]FPOX^[^`f_%¡ag_Q]o¡Xp[^]FVljZaF[pPj§2O\[ZO`bVYXp[Zagkll_OQk
L'M
O 5[^j^XaYVgOehw_]o¡b¡bOQk
CG
F
h>`bj]
VgaYV¥cdyl]e[p]ePOXp[Z`f_PO\]ejpl[^Oaen¡bag_]o¡`fVYXZO\VljZ`bXde£wVlkX
M
Oj^OQ_aFVlkaFVgOFh_Q]o¡b¡O\k
' !
F
h×`fj]VgaFV¥cdyl]F[^]FPOQX^[^`b_
jplPP]e[^¢ao¡ag_Q]o¡jpyl]oX^`b]e¡jZXp[^l_X^l[^Oe
OX H 5O](yg`¦gO¡»h 6
H7`Xpj*`bVYXZO\Vlj^`XdFhe]eVlk 3 6
H7X
M
O'jZOQXaeyg`¦gO¡fj*`bV`XpjVgO`bi
M
5aF[Q£¡¡lVgaYVTyl]F[^]FPOX^[^`f_.Xp[^]FVljWaY[^Pj
kgO\y:O\Vlk:y:aYVX
M
O_aYPyl]e[^`bj^aFVae 6
H7¤]FVlkX
M
O`fVFX^OQVlj^`bXdaeX
M
Oyg`¦gO¡fj¤`fV 3 6
H7È wO5VgOI 6H
HKJ7XZa:O >`
6
HKJ7ML
6
H7*]FVlkFwaeX
M
OQ[^§'`fjZOF
L'M
O>VgaYV¥cdyl]e[p]ePOXp[Z`f_¤¡bag_]e¡YXp[^]FVljZaF[pPjkgO\y:O\VlkjZaF¡OQ¡aYVX
M
O>jZOQXaoyl`¦gO¡l_aFPyl]F[Z`fjZaYVljQh\§
M
`b_
M
`fj'X
M
OjZOQXnae*aY[^klOQ[^OQky:]o`f[^jG: N O
PQSR7TVUP>W
6H J I 6H H J
77
4
L'M
O CG
Xp[^]FVljZaF[pP `bjklO 5VgO\k]ejX
M
O¢VY:PT5OQ[aoyg`¦¥OQ¡bj`bVX
M
O¡bag_]e¡¤[ZOQie`baFV § M
aFj^O`fVYXZO\VljZ`bXd`fj¡bOQjpjX
M
]FVX M O
`fVYXZOQV:jZ`bXdaeX
M
O_OQVYX^OQ['yg`¦gO¡» H:aF[pP]o¡b¡FhgX
M
O[p]eV: X^[p]eVljZaF[pPYX
6
H72`fj
X 6 H7[Z\Z
0 H J .L3 6
H7Z 6H J7L 6 H7
7
Z]Z
4
H5aF[2X
M
O[p]eVl X^[p]eV:jWaY[^P@h¥X
M
O#^
_aY[^[^O¡f]oX^`aYV
6
P`fVg`bP`N;Q]eXZ`baFVHao×X
M
Oj^lP ae]e:jZaF¡bgX^Ow]e¡bgO(ao*kg`DOQ[^OQV:_OQj 7¤aFV¢X M O
Xp[^]FVljWaY[^PO\k`fP]oieO`fj'lj^OQk@`bV@aY[^kgO\[nXZayl[^OQj^OQ[^eO][^OQjpy5aFVlj^OX
M
]eX>kg`FOQ[^ieO\j2¡b`fVgOQ]F[Z¡b§'`X M X M
OV¥lP:O\['ao*aFgX^¡`bOQ[pj
L'M
O
X^[p]eVljZaF[pP_X`
6
H7(`bj] P]eylyl`bVgiÌ[^aFP$X
M
O¢¡ag_Q]o¡2VlO`bi
M
:aY[jpl[^[^aF:Vlkg`fVgi%] yg`¦¥OQ¡H XZa]%g`XjZXp[Z`fVgi
[^OQyl[^OQj^OQVYX^`bVgiX
M
OjZOQX'ao*VlO`bi
M
:aY[Z`fVgiyg`¦gO¡fj§
M
aFj^O`bVYXZO\Vlj^`Xd¢`fj'¡bOQjpjX
M
]FVX
M
]oX'aeaHPOX 3 6
H7HcbIO § M
OQ[^OcbJ`fj
X M
Ows`bVl ea§>j^ Y`:jplP ]eV:k O `fj2]jZOQX.ao×kl`bjpyg¡f]e_O\POQVYX^jQhY]FVlk¡bOXed<klOQVgaFXZOw_aFVl_Q]oX^OQVl]eXZ`baFV
L'M
Ow_OQVljplj2X^[p]eVljZaF[pP _]eV
X M
OQV5Oj^y5OQ_`:O\k]ejG:
X ` 6
H7 f
ghSijlk
R7m
I 6H H n po
7
4
L
§naHyg`¦gO¡fjae._O\Vlj^:jXp[^]FVljWaY[^PO\k%`bP]eieOT]F[ZO_aFPyllXZOQk%aF[(jZ`fP`¡f]e[^`Xd%lj^`fVgiX
M
OI1(]ePP`bVliHkg`fjZXp]eVl_OehD`»OF(X M O
V¥lP:O\[aonl`XpjX
M
]eXkl`DOQ[`fVXd§na%g`bXj^X^[^`fVgiFjQ
L'M
O]e¡iFaF[^`X
M P _aYPy:gXZO\jwX
M
O¢_aY[^[^OQjpy5aFVlkgO\Vl_OYP`bVg`fP`,;Q`bVli@X M O
1(]ePP`bVgi¢kl`bj^X^]FVl_O]X^OQ[']Fylyg¡bY`fVgiX
M
O_OQV:j^lj>X^[p]eVljZaF[pP@
5 © K M "© L'M
O\jZO>Xd§naX^[p]eV:jWaY[^PjX^ae¡bOQ[p]oXZO'X
M
O>aYgXZ¡b`O\[^jQhF]Fj.kg`fjpyg¡b]FOQk`fVX
M
O'aF¡¡ba§'`fVgi:
aFVlj^`fkgOQ[¤]§'`bVlkla§
aekg`fPOQVlj^`baFV@Rq@Rae*]eVH`fP]eieO§
M
aYjZO`fVFX^OQVlj^`bXZ`bOQj>]F[ZO!:
\|Y |F \|e
\|e~ |D \|e
\|Y \Rl
§ M
O\[ZO F+L |Fo~:
aYVljZ`fkgO\[X
M
OHj^OXTaeO DOQ_X^jaoj^OFOQ[p]o¡.yl]F[^]FPOX^[^`f_¢]eVlk VgaFV y:]e[p]ePOXp[Z`f_POQ]ejpl[^OQjQh_aFPyllXZOQk ]oXTX
M
O@§'`bVlkla§
_OQVYXZO\[hg§
M
O\VJ]F[Z`bOQjaFOQ[n`bX^j>|ee~y:aYj^j^`bl¡O\j]e¡blOQjQ
L'M
O%POQ]FV aeX
M
`bj§'`fVlkga§ ]F[Z`bOQjÌ[^aFP F }XZa }¥|gh.]FVlk X M
O]e[^`b]FVl_O[^]FVgieO\jÌ[^aFP | X^a 7DF|eRl
L'M
O\jZO%VgaYV¥c
yl]F[^]FPOX^[^`f_(PO\]ejpl[ZO\jnO¦
M
`fg`X>_aFVYXZ`fV¥gaF:j2]F[Z`f]oX^`aYVaFOQ[]j^l:jZXp]eVYXZ`f]o¡[p]eVgiFO(]Fj _ M ]eVlieOQjQ
<waFVyl]e[p]ePOQX^[^`b_nX^[p]eV:jWaY[^Pj]e[^O>PaF[^Oj^X^]Fg¡bOe£>¡b¡:X
M
O'O¡bOQPOQVYX^j¤ao
N
O¦l_OQylXaFVgO'§'`b¡¡5[ZO\P]e`bV l¦gOQk]Fj _ M ]FVgieO\j
N
§'`¡b¡×5O : 4F
F
F
§ M
O\[ZO¢`fj `[LJ \| DlhF¢aeX
M
OQ[^§'`bj^Oe
L'M
OT_O\Vljplj>Xp[^]FVljWaY[^P [ZO\j^g¡bX^j
0 F F F 7
]eVlkX
M
OT[p]eVl X^[p]eVljZaF[pP
§'`b¡¡×ie`beO`+L |D:hYaFX
M
O\[Z§'`fj^O(}
L'M
`fjT_aFPyl]F[Z`fjZaYVj
M
a§>jX
M
OX^ae¡bOQ[p]eVl_OX
M
]oXVgaFVyl]F[^]FPOX^[^`f_PO\]ejpl[ZO\j
M
]FOaF[Ì]F_XZ`baFV:]o¡b`bjpP@@£ P`fVgaF[^`bXdao
yg`¦gO¡fj'_]FV
M
]FOw]eOQ[^kg`O\[ZO\VFX]o¡fgOFh¥:gXX
M
OO DOQ_XaFV¢X
M
O[^]FVl ]eVlk@_O\VljpljnX^[p]eVljZaF[pPj.`fjn¡`fP`X^OQk@FX
M
OjZ`N;O(ao
X M
OP`bVgaY[Z`bXde
Bl 5 5 M g © 6H © "Ìg76 5 M
]oX ×[^]FVl ¥jnX
M
O`fVFX^OQVlj^`bXd¢]o¡fgOQjn`fVO\]e_
M
§'`bVlkla§<]eVlkHieOQX^j]y:O\[^P¥c
Xp]oXZ`baFVwj^`bVgi]VgOQ§ kg`fj^X^]eV:_O5OXd§nOOQVHX
M
Oy:O\[^PgX^]eXZ`baFVljQhl]VgO§J_aY[^[^O¡f]oX^`aYV_a¥O +_`O\VYXn`fj'aYgX^]e`bVgO\k
H5aF[>]¢j^OXao§'`bV:kga§ `fVYXZO\VljZ`bXd@]e¡blOQj 6 h
7
h
]FVlk 6 h
7
h
×OX h 6
]eVlk
h
7':OX
M
OT[p]eV: Yj>ao
h
6 OX@
h
7]FPaFVgi
X M O<
6
OX 7nkl]oXp]l
(O 5VlO]H_aFPy5aFj^`X^Oy5OQ[pPTgXp]oX^`aYV ]ej>ae¡b¡a§>jG:
h
66
7 6 nB7#7ÈhD§
M
O\[ZO
kgOQVgaFXZO\jX
M
O`fVYeO\[^j^Oy:O\[^PgX^]eXZ`baFV
ae UWV¥aY[^P]o¡b¡beh h
`fj¡O[p]eVl ae*X
M
Oyg`¦gO¡fj`bVD § M
`b_
M
_aY[^[^OQjpy:aYVlkljnXZaX
M
Oyg`¦¥OQ¡§'`bX
M
[^]FVl n¤`fVD
(VlkgOQ['y5OQ[ZOQ_X>y:aYjZ`bXZ`beO_aF[p[ZOQ¡b]eXZ`baFVh j M
aYg¡bk@5OO ¥l]o¡X^aX
M
O`fkgO\VFX^`b_Q]o¡y5OQ[pPTgXp]oX^`aYViF`FOQV@F
( 6 | 4 44
7Å
kgO5Vg`fVgi¢]kg`fjZXp]eVl_OPO\]ejpl[ZO5OXd§nOOQV
]FVlk
(
§2O`fV@X^l[pVaYgX^]e`bV]VgaFXZ`baFVHao*kl`bj^X^]FVl_O5OXd§nOO\V ]eVlk
L'M
OkgOQY`f]oX^`aYV h
]eXO\]e_
M h
`bjkgO VgOQk ]ejX
M
OV¥lPT5OQ[ao
j 6o 4 44
n7Tg`iFieO\[X
M
]eV nÈ+H:aY[^P]o¡b¡beh
h
h
j gh"!
i!$# g j hl§
M
OQ[^O `bj'X
M
O`fVlkg`f_]oX^aF[nÌlV:_XZ`baFV
<wa§hl]_aF[p[ZOQ¡b]eXZ`baFVHPO\]ejpl[^O&% '%
6 72`bjkgO 5VlOQk]ejG:
% 6
7 2
|P]¦(
h"
h
UµP ]eV:k+ ]e[^Oy5OQ[ZOQ_XZ¡bH_aF[p[ZOQ¡b]eXZOQkhYX
M
OQV)% e*%
M
]FjX
M
OaF¡¡ba§'`fVgiyl[ZaYy:O\[ZX^`O\j :
+ `X'`fj`fVlkgOQy5OQV:kgOQVYX>ae*jp_]o¡b`fVgi]eVlk@j
M `X>aeX
M
O`bVYX^OQVlj^`XdH]o¡fgOQjQ
+ `X'`fj']VgaY[^P]o¡b`N;OQkHPOQ]ejpl[^O : 2
,% e
+ `X'`fj'j^¥PPOXp[Z`f_]e¡hg`»Oe*%
6 7'%
6 7Å
+ % 6.-6
7
0/ 6 77'%
6 7¤`
-
]eVlk
/
]F[ZO(jZXp[Z`f_X^¡`fVl_[^OQ]FjZ`fVgiÌlVl_XZ`baFVljQ
L'M
`fj2y:[ZaYy:O\[ZXd:O\_aYPO\j2:jZOÌg¡D§
M
OQV
VgaFVH¡b`bVgO\]e[OO\_X^j>a¥_Q_l[Q
£wVgaeX
M
OQ['POQ]Fj^:[ZO&1
6
572¡O\j^j'O¦ly:O\VljZ`beO`fj'kgO VgOQk]ej:
1 6
7 2 |
g324k
-uO¢j
M
a§zX
M
O`bVlj^OQV:jZ`fg`b¡`bXdaenX
M
OQj^OXd§2a%POQ]Fj^l[^OQjX^a [^]FVlkgaYP Vgae`fjZO¢]FVlkXZa [p]eVl kl`bj^XZaY[ZX^`aYV§
M
`f_
M
_]eVuag__Ql[
kllOXZa¢jpy:O\_g¡f]e[[^O65:O\_XZ`baFV@]eV:k@kl`bjp_aYVFX^`bV¥g`bXde
D
aYVljZ`fkgO\[2X
M
Oae¡b¡ba§'`bVgiO¦g]FPyg¡Oae][^OOQ[^OQV:_O§'`bV:kga§<ae*kg`fPOQVlj^`aYVRq@R§'`bX M X M
O`fVYXZO\VljZ`bXZ`bOQj@ :
:
GF R#F F
|F F D#F
}#F ~#F 7F F
UdXpj>[^]FVl P]oXp[Z`¦ w`fjG:
R
| TD
} ~
Uµ]eVgaFX
M
O\[§'`bV:kga§<`fV@X
M
Oj^OQ_aYVlkH`bP]oiFO`bjG:
7F R F F
| F FTD F
}0F ~ F
UµJ`bj'5OXd§nOO\V Dl ]eVlk|eFgh( `bj']e¡§]gj : R
| TD
} ~
- M
`f_
M O ¥l]e¡bjX^a hl]FVlk)% J F
UµJX^]F oOQjnX
M
O]o¡fgOolhgX
M
O\V%klOQ_[^OQ]FjZO\jnXZa F 4
DlUµJX^]F oOQj]]o¡fgO5OXd§nOOQV F]eV:k 7FlhgX
M
OQV 5OQ_aFPOQj
| } D
R ~
1wa§2OQeOQ[QhoX
M
O>]o¡fgO>ae %[ZO\P]o`fVlj F 4 D:
L'M
`fj¤`fj¤`fVj
M
]e[py_aFVYXp[^]FjZXX^aX M O
OQVlkl]e¡¡j¢]eV:k¥y:O\]e[pP]eV5hY§
M
`f_
M
Ì]o¡b¡
j^XZOQOQyg¡b¢XZa F 4
ee~]eV:k F 4
}5h¥[^OQjpy5OQ_X^`FO¡be*Uµ*yg`¦gO¡ X^]F oOQj]T]e¡blOF:h¥X
M
OX
M
O(¡b`fVgOQ]F[2_aF[p[ZOQ¡b]eXZ`baFV<
kl[^aFyljnXZa F 4 Rl F e
Y`fP`¡f]e['y:[ZaYy:O\[ZX^`O\j'_]eV5Oj
M
a§>V¢aY[1.UWV_aYVl_¡flj^`aYVhlX
M
OQj^OXd§2a¢POQ]Fj^:[ZO\jn]F[ZO[^aFl:jZXXZa¢jpy5OQ_l¡b]F[Z¡b[^O65:O¦¥`baFV
]FVlkkg`bjp_aYVYXZ`fVYl`X^`O\j
<waFVyl]F[^]FPOQX^[^`b__aF[p[ZOQ¡b]eXZ`baFVlj_Q]eVkgOQ]e¡:§'`bX
M
VlaFV¡`fVgO\]e[OO\_X^j2aoD`fVFX^OQVlj^`bXde
L'M
OkgaTVlaeXO¡b`fP`fVl]eXZOaYgXZ¡b`bOQ[pjhYlgX
lj^Oj^aFPOPaY[ZOj^X^]Fg¡OPOQ]Fj^:[ZO\j
UWV _Q]ej^O¢ao[^aeXp]oX^`aYVhyg`¦gOQ¡cµXZaecµyg`¦gO¡n_aF[p[^OQjpy:aYVlkgOQV:_O¢`fjVlaeXTiF`FOQV]FVlk`bXkga¥OQjVgaFXj^OOQP j^X^[p]o`bi
M
XX^aO¡b`fP`fVl]eXZO
X M
OaFlXZ¡b`O\[^jQ¤UWVlj^XZO\]ekh5`X>j^OO\PjPaY[ZOy5aFjpj^`bg¡bOXZa¢:jZOj^aFPOVgaYV@y:]e[p]ePOXp[Z`f_(`bVY]e[^`b]FVYX^jQhg§
M
`b_
M
]F[ZO¡bOQjpj>j^OQVlj^`X^`FOXZa
aYgXZ¡b`O\[^jQ×OQXj'jZOQO`X'`fV@X
M
OVgO¦gX>jZO\_XZ`baFV
-¢!
UWVX
M
`fj2j^OQ_XZ`baFVhY§2Owj
M
]e¡¡yl[^OQj^OQVYX¤X
M
O>`bVY]e[^`f]eVYX.POX
M
agk H*`f[pjZX^¡§2O(yl[^OQj^OQVYX¤jZaYPO>ieO\VgOQ[p]o¡b`X^`O\jXZa`bVY]e[^`f]eVYXae¡b¡a§nOQk
YX
M
O¢kg`O\[ZO\VYXZ`f]o¡.POX
M
agkj^giFieO\jZX^OQkuF¥_
M
P`bk |eµ£>XZOQ[T]eV]eVl]e¡gj^`bj(aen`bX^jk:[^]§>l]F_Å ¥jh§nOyl[ZaYy:aYjZO]VgaFO¡
VgaYVyl]e[p]ePOXp[Z`f_(POQX
M
agk]eV:k`bX^j>]Fylyg¡b`b_Q]oX^`aYVX^a`bP]oiFOP]eX^_
M
`fVgiyl[^aFg¡bOQP@
<3 K3F@ ')(*E0B'3 ' A@ D
UWV@X
M
`bj>j^OQ_XZ`baFVhg§nOie`beO]j
M
aF[^Xn`fVYX^[^agkll_X^`aYV@ao`fVY]e[^`b]FVFXpj |F|¥h:lh:|YYh5|F¥h:R F »
1wOQ[^O(§nO]e[^O`bVYXZO\[ZO\jZX^OQkH`bV@`fVYXZOQV:jZ`bXd¢`fVF]F[Z`f]eVYX^jQh |e|y:[Za¥`fkgOQj]iea¥agk`fVYX^[^agkll_X^`aYVX^aieOQaFPOXp[Z`f_`fVY]e[^`b]FVFXpj
OXA']eVlk w:O>Xd§na`bP]eieOQj¤ao]j^]FPO>j^_OQVgO'Xp]e oO\VlVlkgO\[¤kg`O\[ZO\VFX.OQVY¥`b[^aFVlPO\VFXpj
6
_Q]ePOQ[p]§'`X
M
aeX
M
OQ[¤y:]e[p]ePOc
X^OQ[pjhgPaeX^`aYV¢aoX
M
O_]FPO\[^]:hF`b¡b¡blP`fVl]oX^`aYV_
M
]FVgieOFhFOQX^_57ÈUWVY]e[^`b]FVFXpj.]F[ZO(yl[ZaYy:O\[ZX^`O\j.X
M
]oX[^OQP]o`fVlV:_
M
]eVgiFOQk¢:VlkgOQ[]
iF`FOQV@jZOQX'ao*]FklP`bjpj^`bg¡bO_
M
]eVlieOQjQ
L
§2aXdgy5OQjao_
M
]FVgieO]e[^O_aFV:jZ`fkgOQ[^OQk :
e
M
]eVlieO`bV@`fVYXZOQV:jZ`bXdehg`»OF
6J
7A -6
6$
7#7È
L'M
`fj.ag__Ql[pj¤§
M
O\VX
M
O(_]FPO\[^][^OQP]e`bVlj l¦gOQk¢]FVlkaYVg¡`b¡¡flP`bV:]oXZ`baFV_
M
]eVgiFOQjQ
-
`fj2_aFVlj^`fkgOQ[^OQk]Fj.]`fVl_Q[ZO\]ej^`bVgi
ÌlVl_XZ`baFVUdX>_Q]eV@lj^:]o¡b¡@:O¡bag_]o¡b¡b]eyly:[Za¦g`fP]eXZO\kY]X^[p]eVlj^¡f]oXZ`baFV:]o¡DaF[']FVH]:+VlOwÌ:Vl_X^`aYVh:`»OF
6$
7A/
6J
7
aF[
6$
7"
6$
7
4
|g
M
]eVlieO`fVieOaYPOX^[^eh*`»OFD 6JC
79
6J6J
77Èh§
M
OQ[^O
`fjT]%P]eylyl`bVgi Ì[ZaYP X M
OXd§naocdkg`bPO\VljZ`baFV:]o¡`fP]eieO
yg¡f]eVgOXZa`bX^j^O¡W
L'M
OHj^`fPyl¡O\jZXT_Q]ej^OQjaF[
]e[^O¢X^[p]eV:jZ¡f]oX^`aYVljh*§
M
`f_
M
_]FV]o¡fjZa 5OXp[ZO\]oX^OQk Y_aF[p[^O¡f]oXZ`baFVh 1w]FljpkgaF[ kg`fj^X^]eV:_O
]eVlkÌ[^O ¥gOQVYX^`b]e¡DPOQX
M
agkljQs aF[^O(ieOQVlOQ[p]o¡b¡FhY`fV@yg¡b]FVl]e[yl]eX^_
M
_]FjZOFhY`bX`bj§nO¡b¡ ¥Vga§ X M ]oX
`fj']
M
aYPaeiF[p]ey
M
FUµ
X M
Oj^XZOQ[^OaHyl]oXp_
M
`bjjpP]o¡b¡O\VgaFgi
M
hDX
M
O\V
_]FV :O¡ba¥_Q]o¡b¡%]Fylyl[^a¦¥`fP]oX^OQk%Y%]eV ]:+VlOTÌlV:_XZ`baFVjZ`fPTl¡b]eXZ`fVgiH]
yl]e[p]o¡b¡bO¡yl[^aorWOQ_XZ`baFV |e µ
YaYPOT§naF[p _]FV 5OTaYlVlk%`fV µh§
M
OQ[^OT_aF¡aY[kg`fjZXp[Z`flgX^`aYV%§]ej:jZO\k ]ej`bVY]e[^`b]FVYXyl[^`bP`bXZ`beOQjQh |Y kgOFO¡baFy5OQk ]
iFOQVgO\[^]e¡FÌ[p]ePOQ§2aY[^ (aFV_aYVlj^X^[pl_X^`bVgi(`fVF]F[Z`f]eVYX^jYT]FOQ[p]oie`fVgiPOQX
M
agkh R#F :lj^OQkPaYPOQVYXXZalg`b¡bk`fVY]F[Z`f]eVYXpj - M
`¡bO
X M OQj^O]egX
M
aF[pjlj^Oie¡baFl]e¡`fVY]e[^`b]FVFXQh |Fyl[^OQj^OQVYXpjn]¡bag_]e¡kg`DOQ[^OQVYX^`b]e¡`bVY]e[^`b]FVYXnPOX
M
agk
UWV]e:jZO\Vl_Oae*iF¡aYl]o¡×j^X^[pl_X^l[^Oehl¡bag_]e¡POQX
M
agkljwj
M
aFg¡fk:OT:jZO\k@]FVlk@§2O`fVYX^[^agkll_OPaY[ZO]F:aYgX |F`fV@X
M
OVgO¦gX
j^OQ_XZ`baFV
<3=< H% @% ACI A@"BD3
£ _ M
]F[^]F_X^OQ[^`,;\]oXZ`baFV¢aoX
M
O`fVFX^OQVlj^`bXd
M
]ej'5OO\Vyl[ZaYy:aYjZO\kY
a¥OQV:kgOQ[^`bV: ]eV:k`fPyg¡O\POQVYXZO\k@Y@g_
M
P`bk |eµhlY
lj^`fVgi@kl`DOQ[^OQVYXZ`f]o¡`fVY]F[Z`f]eVYXpjwlV:kgOQ[(X
M
OiY[ZaYly%ae2jZ`fP`¡b`bX^lkgO5OXd§nOO\V X M
O`fP]oiFOQjQ
L'M
`bj_
M
]F[^]F_X^OQ[^`,;\]oXZ`baFV`fjl]ej^OQk
aYVÌ:Vl_X^`aYVlj'aokgOQ[^`b]eXZ`beO\j`bVY]e[^`b]FVYX2X^a`bP]oiFO([^`bie`fkHPaeX^`aYV
UdX@`bj@§nO¡b¡( ¥Vga§ X M OX
M
O_]e¡b_Qg¡f]oXZ`baFV aoX
M
OklOQ[^`]oX^`FOQj`bj@`b¡¡cµ_aFVlkl`X^`aYVgOQkhw`X@`fj@VlOQ_O\j^jp]e[^ XZa _]o¡f_l¡b]eXZOX M O
kgO\[Z`b]oX^`FOQj(aFVuj^Pa¥aeX
M
OQkukl]eX^]HXZa%jZXp[^lieie¡bO]oiF]e`bV:jZX(Vgae`fjZOF£ _aFPPaFV_
M
ae`f_O`bj(X^a:jZOX
M O N(]FljpjZ`f]eV ÌlVl_X^`aYV]ej
X M
O_aYVFFae¡fgXZ`baFVH oO\[^VgOQ¡
1(]Y`fVgi_]e¡b_Qg¡b]eXZO\kX
M
OklOQ[^`]oX^`FOQjaoD]>ÌlV:_XZ`baFVaFV](y:aF`bVYXlyXZa 3
aF[pkgOQ[
6$3
<R
M
]ej:OQOQVlj^OQk"7Åhekg`O\[ZO\VFX^`b]e¡
`fVY]F[Z`f]eVYXpj'lVlkgO\[X
M
OiY[ZaYly¢ae[^`iF`bk@PaeX^`aYVH_Q]eV:O_Q]o¡f_g¡f]oX^OQk
(`DOQ[^OQVYX^`b]e¡`fVY]e[^`b]FVFXpj
M
]FOw5OO\Vjpl__OQjpjWÌg¡b¡b:jZO\kaF[nP]oXp_
M
`bVli]eV:k[^OQ_aFiFVg`bXZ`baFV*£>XZOQ[
M
]¥`fVgiTO¦gX^[p]e_X^OQkX M O
`fVYXZOQ[^OQj^X¤y5ae`fVFXpj GF `bVX
M
O>`bP]eieOQjQhoX
M
OQj^O>y:aF`bVYXpj¤]e[^O'P]eX^_
M
O\kF_aYPy:]e[^`bVgiX
M
O's]
M
]o¡f]eVgaYg`bjkl`bj^X^]FVl_O>5OXd§nOO\VX M O
Xd§na_aF[p[ZO\j^y5aFV:kg`bVli`bVY]e[^`f]eVYX.FOQ_X^aF[pj
L'M
O[ZO\_aFiFVg`bXZ`baFV`fj]e_
M
`bOFOQk¢:jZ`fVgiX
M
OeaFXZ`fVgiTX^OQ_
M
Vl`¥gOFh
M
]ej
M
`fVgiTX^OQ_
M
Vg`¥gO
]FVlkjZO\P`cµ¡ag_]e¡_aFV:jZXp[^]e`bVYX^j|o~ »
(`DOQ[^OQVYX^`b]e¡`bVY]e[^`f]eVYXnPOQX
M
agk
M
]ej
M
a§2OQeOQ[nX
M
Oae¡b¡a§'`fVgikl[p]§>l]e_Å ¥j :
+ <aF`bj^Oe
L'M
O_Q]o¡f_g¡f]oX^`aYVao2klOQ[^`]oX^`FOQj`bj(lVlj^X^]Fg¡O]oiY]o`fVljZXwVgae`fjZOFhjpPa¥aeX
M
`bVgiHX
M
OjZ`biFV:]o¡*`bPyl[^aeO\j'X
M
Oj^X^]el`¡b`XdFhlgX
]o¡fjZakl]FP]eieO\j'ljZOÌg¡`fV¥aF[pP]oX^`aYV
+ <aYV¡b`bVlOQ]e[OO\_XQ
UWVT_Q]ej^O.aol`b¡b¡blP`fVl]oX^`aYVT_
M
]FVgieOFhjZaYPOnVgaFVT¡`fVgO\]e[O DOQ_X_]FVag__Ql[*£j*`fVlkg`f_]oX^OQk`fV µh§
M
O\VTkg`O\[ZO\VYX*_Q]ePOQ[p]ej
]e[^OljZO\kaF[j^XZO\[ZOQa]FVlk
M
]eOkg`DOQ[^OQVYXT[^OQjpy:aYVljZO\jXZa%`fP]oieO`f[^[p]ekl`b]FVl_OFhOQ]F_
M
j^OQV:jZaY[waYgX^y:gX9`fj[^O¡f]oX^OQkXZa
`bP]eieO`b[p[^]Fkg`f]eVl_O ]ejN
h§
M
OQ[^O
`fjX
M
O_Q]ePOQ[p]¢iY]o`fVh
`fjX
M
O[^OOQ[^OQV:_Og`b]FjwÌ]e_X^aF[Qh]eVlk
]e_Q_aF:VFXpj(aF[`fP]oiFO¢_aFVYXp[^]FjZXQ ×OQXX
M
O`bP]oiFOj^l[ZÌ]e_O¢:O ]eP:O\[ZX^`b]FVh×`»OeX
M
O¢`fP]oieO`f[p[^]Fkg`b]FVl_OÌ[^aFP$]eVY
y:aF`bVYX'`fj'`fkgOQVYXZ`f_]e¡DaF[>5aeX
M
jZO\VljZaY[^jQUWV@X
M
O_Q]ej^O(§
M
OQ[^O `bj>_aFVlj^X^]FVYXhgX
M
OQ[^O`bj>]¡b`bVlOQ]e['[^O¡f]oX^`aYVH5OXd§nOO\V@Xd§2a
jZO\Vlj^aF[(aFgXpylgXpj ]eV:k UWViFOQVgO\[^]e¡h `fjVgaFX_aFV:jZXp]eVYX(]FVlkuX
M
O¡b`bVlOQ]e[^`bXd:OQXd§2OQOQVX
M
O¢j^OQV:jZaY[waYgX^y:gX^j`fj
¡aYjZXQ
L'M
Okg`O\[ZO\VFX^`b]e¡`bVY]e[^`f]eVYX^j'_Q]eV@VgaeX'kgO\]o¡§'`bX
M
jpl_
M y M
OQVgaYPOQVl]:
+ q
]e[^XZ`f]o¡Dag__¡blj^`baFV
UWVX
M
O_]ej^O§
M
O\[ZOX
M
OT_aFVlkg`bXZ`baFVL 6JC
7G -6
6J6JC
77#7 6-
`fj>]eV%]:+¢VgOÌlVl_XZ`baFV%]FVlk
`fj>]¢[^`iF`bkPaeX^`aYV"7
`bjaFVl¡ueO\[Z`:OQk5OHj^aFPOyl`¦gO¡fjQhX
M
O@kg`DOQ[^OQVYX^`b]e¡.`fVF]F[Z`f]eVYXTPOX
M
agkÌ]o`b¡fj
L'M
`bj_]FVa¥_Q_l[]oXX
M
O@kg`bjpyl]F[Z`bXd
kg`fj^_aFVYXZ`fV¥g`XdFhlj^y5OQ_Qg¡f]e['[^O65:O¦¥`baFVhgOX^_e
UWVX^[p]eVlj^¡f]oXZ`baFV:]o¡¤_]FjZOFh×X
M
`bjy
M
O\VgaFPOQV:]%_]eV5OkgO\]o¡bX§'`X
M
yl]e[^XZ`f]o¡¤aY[VgaYVuy:]e[p]ePOXp[Z`f__aF[p[^O¡f]oXZ`baFVuPOX
M
agklj
6
j^OQ_XZ`baFV F|K7Èh¥§
M
`b¡O(`fV¢ieO\VgOQ[p]o¡D_]FjZOFhgyg`¦gOQ¡cµXZaecµyg`¦gO¡D_aY[^[^OQjpy:aYVlkgO\Vl_O>`fjVgaeXnie`beO\V]FVlk¢`bXnj^OO\PjnVlaeXjZXp[^]e`i
M
XZÌg¡
XZaO¡b`fP`fVl]eXZO%X
M
O%aFgX^¡`bOQ[pj <waFV yl]e[p]ePOXp[Z`f_]e¡'POQX
M
agkljjZOQOQPPaF[^O%y:aYj^j^`fg¡OFh2]Fj§2O%j
M
]o¡b¡>jZOQO`bV X M O VgO¦gX
jZO\_X^`aYV
7F
<3 ' >?A@D$% F@" AA@ BD3
UWVX
M
`fj2j^OQ_XZ`baFVhY§2Owj
M
]e¡¡yl[^OQj^OQVYX.]TVlaFVyl]F[^]FPOQX^[^`b_'[^aeXp]oX^`aYVl]o¡l`fVY]e[^`b]FVFX2POQX
M
agk
q
aF¡b]F[¤_a¥aF[pkg`fVl]oX^O>jZgj^XZO\P `fj.:jZO\kh
`fV@§
M
`b_
M X M
O[ZaFX^]eXZ`baFVlj
M
]FO(]j^`bPyg¡bOQ[naY[^P ¡`f oO
J
J 4
= /I /2 *Q65 65 Q(5 5 M g © 6 © "Ìg76 5
¥:yly:aYjZ`fVgi aYVg¡b X M
OaY[^kgO\[^j5OXd§nOO\V yg`¦¥OQ¡bjH[ZO\P]o`fV lVl_
M
]FVgieO\khX
M
]eX¢`bjXZa jp]@:`9 6
7 6 7Èh>X
M
OQV
6 J
7 6 J
7Èhn§
M
OQ[^OL ]eV:k! ]F[ZOXd§nau_aF[p[ZO\j^y5aFV:kg`bVli§'`fVlkga§ Y ][^aeXp]oXZ`baFV aokgOiY[ZOQO
hn]FVlk J
h
h
6
nP
|7Å
H[ZaYP ]eVH`bVYX^OQVlj^`XdH§'`bV:kga§ hl§nOklO 5VgO]_aFPyl]e[^`fjZaYVÌlVl_XZ`baFV
6
7A
U
i W
U 4 i !
W 6
7 6
7
F aFX
M
O\[Z§'`fjZOF
OX>lj'j^OO]eV@O¦g]FPyg¡OF
-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3
-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3
40 30 20
50
10 A
80
60
H`biFl[^OR: <aYVHy:]e[p]ePOX^OQ[^`,;\]oXZ`baFV :aY[Z`bie`fVl]o¡D`fP]oieO 6 7Å
UWV@X
M O :iFl[^ORlhl`
|gh
F
hlX
M
O\V
6
7
`+L 7F
F aeX
M
OQ[^§'`bj^Oe
UµJ`bj'y5OQ[^X^l[p5OXZO\kF¢]F[ZX^`Ì]F_XpjX
M
O\VHX
M
O`bV 55gOQV:_OXZa
6
72`fj¡`fP`X^OQk@XZa]_
M
]eVlieOae]eX'PaYjZX
OQeOQVH`X
M
Oy5OQ[^X^l[pl]oX^`aYV`fj¡f]e[^ieOe
UµDX
M
O>j^OQ_aFVlk`fP]eieOn§'`bV:kga§!>`bjX
M O 5[pjZXaFVlO[^aeXp]oX^OQkF
heX
M O 4 6
7
6
7 4
£wjnj
M
a§>V`fV¢X
M O 5iFl[^O}5hYX
M
O(Xd§2a`bP]oiFO>§'`fVlkga§>j ]eVlk _aF[p[ZO\j^y5aFVlkX^aO\]e_
M
aFX
M
O\[2Y]T[^aeXp]oX^`aYVao×kgOQiF[^OO
]eV:k ]VgaYV ¡`fVgOQ]F[O DOQ_X
-
aYV ¡flP`bV:]eVl_Oe ¥:yly:aYjZO
-
`bj¢`bVl_Q[ZO\]ej^`bVli:h.X
M
OQV
4 6
7D
6
7 4
= /I /= J
"6 65
g76
5PQ
Qg76 5
©.© e ª 65 © Q
g76 5
H5aF[¢]FVF
!
h
#"
h ]FVlk
h'§nO
M
]eOFh
4 6
$
$N
7 2
4 6
!
$N%
!"
$I&
7L
6
7 2 '
6 (
#"
7 4
L
]e Y`fVgiX
M
O]FljZaF¡blXZO`bVYX^OiF[p]oX^`aYV¢X^aOQ¡`fP`bV:]oXZOX
M
O[^aeX^]eXZ`baFVHkgOiY[ZOQO
hlX
M
]eX'`bjX^a¢j^]Fh¥§2OkgO5VgO
3 6
!
#"
)
7
| *
+ Z
6
7 2
6
!
#"
7)Z 4
H[ZaYP kgO Vg`X^`aYV 3
`fj'`bVY]e[^`f]eVYX2X^a¢[ZaFX^]eXZ`baFV]FVlk@`bV:_[^OQ]ej^`fVgiiY[ZOQ¡OQeOQ¡X^[p]eVljZaF[pPj
UWVYXZOQiF[p]oX^`bVgiaFVX
M
OHiY[ZaYlyae>X^[p]eVljZaF[pP]oXZ`baFVuaY[:g`¡fkg`fVgiu`bVY]e[^`b]FVYX`bj]_¡f]ejpjZ`f_]e¡2POX
M
agk Vg`f_OQ¡j^X^lkg`bOQk Y
¥_
M
g¡N;cµs `f[^:]e_
M |Y .aY[¥`bj^`aYV]Fylyg¡b`b_Q]oX^`aYVO1wOQ[^O§2O¢]F[ZO`fVX
M
Oj^`fPyl¡O\jZX_Q]ej^O :X
M
O[^aeX^]eXZ`baFViF[^aFly`fjT_aYPyl]e_Xh
`fVYXZOiY[^]eXZ`baFVH`bjX
M
OQVkg`f[^OQ_X^¡@]eylyl¡`f_]Fg¡OF
e
-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3
-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3
40 30 20
50
10 A
80
60
-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3
-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3
4
6 7 6 7
H`biFl[^O}:UWP]oiFOy:]o`f[n:VlkgOQ[[ZaFX^]oX^`aYV]FVlk@`bVYXZO\Vlj^`Xd_
M
]eVgiFOe
UWV@aF:[2O¦ly:O\[Z`fPOQVYX^jQhl§nO
M
]eO_
M
aFj^OQV
@
I
h "
]eVlk
e
L'M
O\V@§2O
M
]FO
3 6 & )
7
| *
+ Z
6 %
7 2 6$
7)Z 4
YaaY[OQ]e_
M
h:jZOQeO\[^]e¡ 6
7n]e[^O(OQj^XZ`fP]eXZO\kh:lj^`bVli]FV`fVYXZO\[^y5ae¡f]oX^`aYVPOX
M
agk
6
7n]e[^O(_aFPylgX^OQk
aY['kg`DOQ[^OQVYX
ohl]eVlk@X
M
O`bVYXZOQiF[p]oX^`aYV¢aeO\[
_Q]eV@:OklaFVgOXZaOQ¡`fP`bV:]oXZOX
M
O[ZaFX^]eXZ`baFVHO DOQ_XQ
L'M
`fj`fVF]F[Z`f]eVYX
M
]ejX
M
Oae¡b¡ba§'`bVgiyl[^aFy5OQ[^XZ`bOQj:
e`X'`fj'j^X^]el¡OX^aVlaFV@¡`fVgO\]e[niF[^O¢¡bOFO¡Xp[^]FVljWaY[^PjQhgjZ`fVl_OVlaFV@yl]e[p]ePOXp[Z`f_wiF[^O¢¡bOFO¡[^O¡f]oXZ`baFV:jn]F[ZOlj^OQk L
|g`X'`fj¡bOQjpj'jZO\VljZ`bXZ`beOX^aaFgX^¡`bOQ[pjhl]Fjj
M
a§>VH`fVHX
M
OX^[p]eV:jZ¡f]oX^`aYVl]o¡_]FjZOFh
M
gieO]o¡fgOQj
M
]eO(¡`fP`X^OQk_
M
]eVlieOQjnX^aX
M
`fj
`bVY]e[^`f]eVYX L
Rl']eVlkHX
M
OQ[^OaF[^O(`X`fj¡O\j^j'j^OQVlj^`bXZ`beO(XZaVgae`fj^OwX
M
]eV@yl]e[p]ePOQX^[^`b_w`bVY]e[^`f]eVYX^jQhgjZ`fVl_OaYVg¡X
M
OaF[pkgO\[^j2ao*X
M
O`fVFX^OQVlj^`bXd
yl]o`f[pj']e[^O(_aFVlj^`bklOQ[^OQk
£>XZOQ[
M
]¥`fVgi'ieaFXX
M
O2`bVY]e[^`b]FVYXeOQ_XZaY[^jQhQX M O ^
VgaF[pP `bjljZO\kXZawPO\]ejpl[^OX
M
OQ`b[kg`bj^X^]FVl_OFh§2O.]F[ZO¡bOQkXZaP`fVg`bP`N;`fVgi
X M
`bjVgaF[pP ]ePaYVgijZOQeOQ[p]o¡_Q]eVlkg`fkl]eXZOQjX^a 5Vlk@X
M
O5OQj^X'aFVlOe
OXjj^OOX
M
OX
M
OQj^Oy:[ZaYy:O\[ZX^`O\j(Y X M
Oae¡b¡a§'`fVgi@`¡b¡fljZXp[^]eXZ`fVgiO¦l]ePyg¡bO
6
:iYl[ZOao
6
7
6
7N
`P 6 7 ! 6
7
F aFX
M
O\[Z§'`fj^Oe
7
-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3
-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3
1 1 0
1 1
1
+ +
H`biFl[^O-: <aYVHy:]e[p]ePOX^OQ[^`,;\]oXZ`baFV :Xp[^]FVljWaY[^PO\k¢`fP]eieOaoP
6
H*`biF:[ZORK7Å
H`biFl[^O}>j
M
a§>jDX
M
O.[^aeXp]oX^`aYVOO\_X`fjO¡b`fP`fVl]eXZOQkYwX
M
O`fVYXZOiY[^]eXZ`baFV;:
3 6| | 7
3 4 6| | 7È
UWV 5iFl[^OT~lhaY[
6
]F7ÈhDX
M
`bjw]o¡fgOT`fj F LaF[
6
"7ÅhX
M
`fj]o¡fgO`bj F 4
|eL:aY[
6 _ 7ÈhDX
M
`bjw]o¡fgOT`fj F 4
gUdXw`bjw¡bOQjpjwj^OQVlj^`fg¡OTXZa
yl]F[^]FPOX^[^`f_(POQX
M
agkljQ¤£Vlk@`bX'`bj`fVY]e[^`b]FVFXX^a[^aeXp]oX^`aYVHkllOXZaX
M
O`fVYXZOQiF[p]oXZ`baFVH]e[^aFlV:kX
M
O_`f[^_¡OF
|
-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3
-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3
1 1
0
1 1
1
2
-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3
-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3
1 1
0
1 1
1
-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3
-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3
1 1
0
1 1
1
2
6
]:+L 7FK7
6
;:' 7F L D FF7
6_ : D F L 7
H`iYl[^O~: <aYVHyl]F[^]FPOXZO\[Z`N;Q]eXZ`baFV;:*X^[p]eV:jWaY[^POQkH`fP]eieO`fVHkg`DOQ[^OQVYX>_]FjZO\j
= /I /I lQ M gQ © 5 ©Q© eG6 5
L'M
O`fVY]F[Z`f]eVYXweOQ_XZaY[wlj^OQk
M
]ejwaYl[yl]e[p]ePOX^OQ[pj
)
]FVlk
h×]eVlk`Xpjkg`bPO\VljZ`baFVu_]FV5O¡f]e[^ieOF H:aY[wO¦l]ePyg¡bOeh
`fVaYl[O¦ly5OQ[^`bPO\VFXpjh
]FVlk
[p]eVgiFOw]ePaYVgiH ]e¡bgO\j 6 0 44
7
7Åh ]eV:k
]e[^`O]ePaYVgi~]o¡fgOQj 60
44~ 7
7Åhg]eVlkH`Xpj
kg`fPOQVlj^`baFV`fj \ q q~ q~ Dl GF#Fl2UdX>§'`¡b¡5OFOQ[^O¦ly5OQVlj^`beOXZaH_aFPyllXZOT]e¡¡X
M
Okl`bj^X^]FVl_O\j>:OQXd§2OQOQVO\]e_
M
yl]o`f[
ae*`fVY]F[Z`f]eVYXneO\_XZaY[^jQ
1wa§2OQeOQ[Qhgie`beO\V%][ZO¥gOQj^X>`fVF]F[Z`f]eVYX'eO\_X^aF[>]FVlkX
M
OT`bVY]e[^`b]FVYX'eOQ_XZaY[>l]ej^Oeh]o¡fPaFj^X>]o¡b¡×`fVF]F[Z`f]eVYX'eO\_X^aF[pj`bV%X M O
l]FjZOwkgaTVgaFX2[^OQj^OQPTl¡O'X
M
Ow[^O ¥gO\jZX¤aYVgOehYO¦l_OQygX.j^OFOQ[p]o¡laYVgOQjQ¤Ya§nO¡bOQ]ekX^a 5VlkjZaYPOwjZ`fPyg¡OwXZO\jZXpj¤XZa Yl`b_Å Y¡b[^OWrWO\_X
X M
OlVg¡b`b eOeO\_XZaY[^j]FVlkaYVg¡bO§Jkg`fjZXp]eVl_OQj']e[^O_aYPy:gXZO\kaY[X
M
O_aFPyl]F[Z`fjZaYV
L'M
O 5[pjZX(XZO\jZXlj^OQk`bjX
M
O^l[^`i
M
X^VgO\j^jl H5aF[wOQ]e_
M
`bP]eieO§'`bVlkla§h`Xpj(_OQVYXZO\[
M
]ej]@[ZOQ¡b]eXZ`beO:[Z`bi
M
X^VlOQjpj`fVX M O
§'`fVlkga§hl§
M
`b_
M
_]FVH5OkgO VgOQk]ejX
M
Oy5OQ[p_OQVYXp]oieO(aoyg`¦gO¡fj`bV@X
M
O§'`bVlkla§ kl]F[^ eOQ[nX
M
]FV@X
M
O_OQVYXZO\[
L'M
`fjPOQ]Fj^l[^O`bjaYYY`baF:jZ¡b%`bVY]e[^`f]eVYXwX^a [ZaFX^]eXZ`baFV]FVlkuVgaFV¡`fVgO\]e[
6
:gX`bV:_[^OQ]ej^`fVgiF7`b¡¡flP`bV:]oXZ`baFVu_
M
]FVgieOFUdX`fj
]e¡bj^aj^X^]Fg¡bO(X^a¢Vgae`fj^O(]FVlkH[^aF:ljZXX^aaYgXZ¡b`bOQ[pjUµXd§2a`bP]eieO§'`bV:kga§>j_aF[p[^OQjpy:aYVlkY][^aeX^]eXZ`baFVH]eVlk@]eVH`¡b¡flP`bVl]eXZ`baFV
_ M
]FVgieOFhgOFOQVH`jZaYPOy:]e[^X^j'kgaVgaFX>_aF[p[^OQjpy:aYVlkh¥X
M
`fj>POQ]Fj^:[ZOj
M
aFg¡fkVgaeX'kg`O\['Xd§naPl_
M
UWV aF:[O¦ly5OQ[^`bPOQVYXpjh]X
M
[^OQj
M
aF¡bk ao F 4| M
]ej:OQOQV _ M
aYjZO\V aY[X
M O y:]oXZX^OQ[pV [ZOZrWOQ_X^`aYV<UµXd§na§'`bVlkla§>j
M
]eO
l[^`bi
M
X^VgO\j^j^OQjn§
M
`f_
M
kg`O\[>PaF[^O(X
M
]eV F 4
|ghgX
M
O@]e[^O(_aFVlj^`fkgOQ[^OQk@]ej'VgaFX'XZa5OP]eX^_
M
O\k
L'M
O>j^OQ_aFVlkXZO\jZX¤[^O¡b`bOQj*aFV]POQ]ejpl[^O'_]o¡b¡bOQkZXZaFX^]e¡l_
M
]eVgiFO :UµXd§2a(eO\_XZaY[^j 3
]FVlk 3 4
]e[^On_¡aYjZOX^aOQ]e_
M
aeX
M
OQ[Qh
X M OQVX
M
OTjplPj'aoX
M
OQ`b[_aFPy5aFVgO\VYX^j>j
M
aFl¡bkVgaFX>kg`DOQ[XZa¥a¢PT:_
M
-uOTj^yl¡`bX>X
M
O`bVlklO¦%jZOQX'`bVYXZa¢j^OFOQ[p]o¡jpllj^OX^j]eVlk
_aFPylgX^OQkjZOQeO\[^]e¡DjplPjaeO\[nX
M
O\jZOjpllj^OXpjnaF[X
M
OXZOQj^X
L'M
`bj>]e¡¡ba§>jlj'X^a[^OWrWO\_X>PaF[^OlVg¡b`b eOyl]oX^XZOQ[pVljQ
s aY[ZOaF[pP]o¡b¡FhF`
3 n ]eVlk
3 4 n_¡aYjZO>X^aO\]e_
M
aFX
M
O\[hYX
M
OQV hR
Q 3 nD]FVlk hR
Q 3 4 nj
M
aFg¡fk¢VgaFXn5O
X^aYa¡f]e[^ieOFhYaF[']eVYjpllj^OX
JaoX
M
OX^aeX^]e¡`bV:kgO¦jZOQX
¥:yly:aYjZO+F 3 n
%3
4 n :
h>X
M
Okg`O\[ZO\Vl_O
hR
Q
6$3
n 283
4 n7
kl`¥`fkgOQk F
:
"6
J7aF[
VgaY[^P]e¡`N;Q]eXZ`baFV
H5aF[] jpy5OQ_`:O\kX
M
[^OQj
M
ae¡fk
h*`>X
M
OVlaF[pP]e¡`N;O\kkg`DOQ[^OQV:_O5OXd§nOO\VX
M
O¢Xd§na jplPjT]ejpj^a¥_`b]eXZO\kX^a Xd§na%eOQ_XZaY[^j
hR
Q
63
6
nB7 2 3 4 6
n77
6:
"6
J7#7(`fjiF[^OQ]eXZOQ[(X
M
]eV h×X
M
O¢Xd§2a%yl]eXZX^OQ[pVlj]e[^O_aYVljZ`fkgO\[ZO\k]FjVgaeX_aF[p[ZO\jWc
y5aFVlkl`bVgiX^aOQ]e_
M
aeX
M
OQ[QUWV@aFl[O¦gy5OQ[^`fPO\VYX^jQhF 4 4 M
]Fj':OQOQV@X^]F oOQV@]ej']FjX
M
O]e¡bgOae
L'M
OX
M
`b[pkHXZOQj^X'lj^OQj'jpl¥cdyl]oX^XZOQ[pVljQh¥Uµ
3 n×]eV:k
3 4 n×]e[^O_¡baFj^OwX^aO\]e_
M
aeX
M
OQ[]eVlk+
JD`fj'][p]eV:kgaFP jpllj^OXao
X M
OXZaFX^]o¡×`bVlklO¦Hj^OX h:X
M
O\V hR
Q Z3 n
283
4 nZg`bj'ljpl]e¡¡bVgaFX'XZa¥ag`i5
H5aF[]j^y5OQ_`:O\kuX
M
[^OQj
M
ae¡fk
eh×`
hR
Q Z3 n
283 4 nZ
6:
"6
J77
Fh 3
]eVlk 3 4
]e[^O_aFV:jZ`fkgOQ[^OQk
VgaFX>]o¡b`b eOe.Y`fVl_O§nO_
M
a¥aFj^OZ JZ¥Pl_
M
j^P]o¡b¡bOQ[X
M
]eV Z Zhl§nO_]FV¥g`f_Å Y¡[^OWrWO\_X>P]eVYÌ]e¡bj^O_]FVlkg`fkl]oX^OQjQUWVHaYl[
O¦gy5OQ[^`fPO\VYX^jQh M
]ej'5OO\V_
M
aFj^OQVXZa¢5O F 4 e
L'M
O(X
M
[ZOQOwX^OQj^X^j_`bXZO\k]e5aeO(]o¡b¡a§ :j.X^a[^OWrWO\_XP]FVYÌ]o¡fjZO(_]eV:kg`bk:]oXZO\j]eVlk¢P]F oO(X
M
O(¡b]F[ZiFOwj^OXnao×VgaYV¢`fVY]F[Z`f]eVYX
ljp]el¡O`fV@y:[^]F_XZ`f_OF
<3 . %* ' !% "!*@' J% F
-uOnVla§ kgOQjp_[^`b5O¤X
M
Onkl`DOQ[^OQVYXj^X^]eieO\jao5aFl[P]eX^_
M
`fVgi(]o¡bieaF[^`bX
M
P@×£X 5[pjZX`fVYXZO\[ZO\jZX*y:aF`bVYX^j*]e[^O.O¦gX^[p]e_X^OQkt(F¥`baFlj^¡beh
X M
O%O¦gX^[p]e_XZ`baFV Y:]o¡b`Xd `fV(55lOQVl_OQjX
M O P]eX^_
M
`fVgi ¥l]o¡b`bXde
L'M
O%kgOX^OQ_X^aF[lj^OQk j M
aFg¡fk :O`fVY]F[Z`f]eVYXXZa[^aeX^]eXZ`baFVljQh
[^OQy5OQ]eX^]el¡O`fV@y5aFj^`bXZ`baFV
L'M
O 1(]e[p[Z`fj'kgOX^OQ_XZaF[ GF M
]ej'5OO\V_
M
aFj^OQVH]ej`bX
M
]ejX
M
O:O\jZX>[^OQy5OQ]eX^]Fg`¡b`bXde
QR
£>XZOQ[(X
M
OO¦gX^[p]e_X^`aYVhDX
M
O\jZOy5ae`fVFXpj]e[^O_
M
]F[^]F_XZO\[Z`N;O\k%Y@X M O 3
]ejkgO\j^_Q[Z`f:O\k%`fVj^OQ_X^`aYV|lR:|l H5aF[(OQ]F_
M
yl]o`f[
ae.eO\_XZaY[^jQhD]yl[^OQj^O¡bOQ_XZ`baFV YX
M
OX
M
[ZOQOX^OQj^X^j(yl[ZaYy:aYjZO\k%`fVj^OQ_X^`aYV|gRlR`fjkgaFVgOXZa[ZOZrWOQ_XX
M
OTÌ]e¡bj^OP]eX^_
M
O\j
L'M
O
VgaY[^P ^G¢`bjX
M
OQV lj^OQk XZa_aYPy:gXZOX
M
Okl`bj^X^]FVl_O\j5OXd§nOO\V X M
O%[ZO\P]o`fVgOQk yl]o`f[^j]oXZOQ[X
M
O%yl[^OQj^O¡bOQ_X^`aYVh.]FVlk X M O
5OQj^XTaYVgO¢`fjkgO\_`fkgOQk XZa5OX
M
]oXP`fVg`fP`,;Q`bVgiX
M
O@VgaF[pP ^G\
[^aFjpjZcµP]oXp_
M
`fVgi%_]eV]e¡bj^a5OO\V lj^OQkXZa`bPyl[^aeOX M O
P]oXp_
M
`fVgioc¥l]o¡b`XdF
@uQ *
UWV@X
M
`bj>j^OQ_XZ`baFVhg§nOyl[^OQj^OQVYXO¦ly:O\[Z`fPOQVYX^]e¡×[^OQjpg¡Xpj
L'M
OaF¡¡ba§'`fVgi_Q]ej^OQj']F[ZO_aYVljZ`fkgO\[ZO\k¢aY['yg`¦gOQ¡cdP]oX^_
M
`bVgi%:
+ NwOaYPOQX^[^`b__
M
]FVgieOF
+
UWVYXZOQV:jZ`bXd_
M
]FVgieOF
+
L'M
[^OOcdkg`fPOQVlj^`aYVl]o¡jp_O\VgO§'`X M _ M
]eVgiFO(ae¥`bO§'`fVgiy:aF`bVYX
H5aF[OeO\[Z_Q]ej^OehX
M
O_aFPyl]F[Z`fjZaYV§'`X M X M
Okg`DOQ[^OQVYX^`b]e¡¥POQX
M
agk`bjj
M
a§>V]eV:kX
M
On`fPyl[^aeOQPO\VFX`bj*FOQ[^j^`biFVg`5_]FVYX
UWVjZO\_XZ`baFVRlb eh§2Oyl[ZO\jZO\VYXXd§naHPOX
M
agklj>aY[w]FgXZaYP]oXZ`f_OQ]o¡fl]oX^`aYV%ao¤X
M
O[^OQjpg¡bX^j L`bVjZO\_XZ`baFVRlÁ|gh[ZO\j^l¡Xpj§'`bX
M
kg`DOQ[^OQVYX.[^aeX^]eXZ`baFVlj]F[ZO>kg`fjpyg¡b]FOQk&Le`bVj^OQ_XZ`baFVRlR[ZO\j^g¡bX^j:VlkgOQ[.kg`DOQ[^OQVYX¤iY[ZOQ¡bOeOQ¡gX^[p]eVljZaF[pPj]e[^O'j
M
a§>V Le`fVjZO\_XZ`baFV
R:}[^OQjpg¡XpjaFVHX
M
[^OOcµkl`bPOQV:jZ`baFVl]e¡j^_OQVgO\j']e[^Oj
M
a§>V
£wVgaeX
M
OQ[_[^`X^OQ[^`aYV`bjTX
M
O@y:O\[^_OQVYX^]eieOao>X^aeXp]o¡2P]eX^_
M
O\j`fV[ZOQ¡b]eXZ`baFVXZaX
M
O@VY:PT5OQ[aey:aF`bVYXpjO¦gXp[^]F_XZO\k
L'M
`fj
y5OQ[p_O\VFXp]oiFO]F[Z`bOQjklOQy5OQVlkg`fVgi aYVuX
M
O¢`fP]oiFO¢]ej§nO¡b¡.]ejaFVuX
M
OXd¥y5O¢aenXp[^]FVljWaY[^P]eXZ`baFVu:OQXd§2OQOQVX
M
O`bP]oiFOQj&LX M O
]FOQ[p]oieO(y:O\[^_OQVYX^]eieO(aoP]oX^_
M
OQk@y:aF`bVYX^j>`bjiY[ZO\]oXZO\[nX
M
]FV F
L'M
O¢y:]e[p]ePOX^OQ[pj(aF[X
M
OVgaYVuy:]e[p]ePOXp[Z`f_POQX
M
agklj]e[^O¢_
M
aFj^OQVu]ejTkgOQjp_[^`b5OQku`fVjZO\_X^`aYV|lR:R:h×X
M
Oyl]F[^]FPOQXZO\[^j
aY['X
M
Okg`DOQ[^OQVYX^`b]e¡×POX
M
a¥k:j |e]e[^O R]FVlk
g
aYPyl]e[^`bj^aFV:j'ljZ`fVgiaFX
M
O\[>yl]e[p]ePOQXZOQ[pj]e[^O]o¡fjZakgaYVgO
6
aY[
O¦¥O\Pyg¡OFh:jZ`fVgi¢]¢_`b[p_¡bOao¤[p]ekg`flj 7FK7Åh5]eV:k`bViFOQVgO\[^]e¡hlX
M
OTVgaYV%yl]e[p]ePOQX^[^`b_POX
M
agk%ie`beO\jX
M
Oj^]FPOy:O\[^_OQVYX^]eieOao
X^aeX^]e¡×P]oXp_
M
OQj']FjX
M
Okg`DOQ[^OQVYXZ`f]o¡aYVgOehlllX'ie`beOQj']iY[ZO\]oXZO\[
6 GF 72y5OQ[p_OQVYXp]oieO(aoiea¥agk@P]eX^_
M
O\j
) E ' # % DC#EB' ' !% @ % FEC=
UWV aF[pkgOQ[TXZauO]o¡fl]eXZO@X
M
O%P]oXp_
M
`bVli[^OQjpg¡Xpjh.Xd§2aieOaYPOX^[^`f__aYVlj^X^[p]o`fVFXpj5OXd§nOO\V Xd§na`fP]oieO\j]F[ZO@lj^OQk UWV _]FjZO
ae(]yg¡f]eVl]F[jp_O\VgOeh2X
M
O%_aF[p[ZO\j^y5aFVlklOQVl_OHaeXd§2a`fP]oieO\jaowX
M
`fjj^_OQVgO%_]FV 5O Pa¥klO¡bOQk F ] M
aYPaeiF[p]ey
M
F
L'M
`fj
M
aYPaeiF[p]ey
M
kgO5VgO\j]uyg`¦gO¡'XZayg`¦gO¡'[^O¡f]oXZ`baFV :OQXd§2OQOQV Xd§2au`bP]eieOQjQ (jZ`fVgiuX
M
`fj
M
aFPaFiF[p]ey
M
eh¤]uP]oXp_
M
_Q]eV 5O
kgOQXZO\[^P`fVgOQk@XZa¢5O_aY[^[^OQ_X2aY['VgaeXQhl[ZO\j^l¡X^`bVgi`fV@X
M
Oy5OQ[p_O\VFXp]oiFOwae_aF[p[ZO\_XP]eX^_
M
O\j
UWVaYl[O¦ly:O\[Z`fPOQVYX^jQhX M O M
aYPaeiF[p]ey
M
u:OQXd§2OQOQV Xd§2a `fP]oiFOQj
M
]ej:OQOQV OQj^XZ`fP]eXZO\k lj^`bVgiX
M
O@¡bOQ]ej^XWcdj Y:]e[^O¢POc
kg`f]eVuPOX
M
agk |g ¤§'`X M X M
OaFlV:kP]oXp_
M
OQjQ
L'M
]eVl ¥j(XZaX
M
O[ZaYllj^X^VgO\j^j(aonX
M
O¡bOQ]FjZXZcµj ¥l]e[^OPOQkl`b]FVPOX
M
agkh×X M O
M
aYPaeiF[p]ey
M
¢_Q]eV@:O_aF[p[ZO\_X^¡O\jZX^`bP]oX^OQk@`PaF[^O(X
M
]FV
M
]o¡*ae*X
M
OP]eX^_
M
O\j>]e[^O_aF[p[^OQ_XQ
UWVu_]FjZOaoVgaFV¥cdyg¡f]eVl]F[wjp_O\VgOQjQhX
M
OOQyg`fy:aF¡b]F[_aFV:jZXp[^]e`bVYX:OQXd§2OQOQV Xd§na@Y`bO§>j`fjlj^OQku]ej(X
M
OOQ]o¡fl]oX^`aYV_[^`bXZOQ[^`f]l
9n]e_
M
y5ae`fVFXw`bV XM O 5[^j^X>`fP]oieO_aF[p[^OQjpy:aYVlklj'X^a]eV%O\yg`fy:aF¡b]F[>¡b`bVgOT`bV%X
M
Oj^OQ_aFVlkaYVgOew£zP]oXp_
M
6
7'`bjO]o¡fl]oX^OQk
]Fj_aY[^[^OQ_X'`X
M
Oy5ae`fVYX
¡b`bOQj>aYVX
M
OOQyg`fy5ae¡f]e['¡b`bVlOT_aY[^[^OQjpy:aYVlkg`fVgiXZa
'£¡X
M
aFgi M X M
`bjO]o¡fl]oX^`aYV`bjwVgaeXwy:O\[WO\_X
j^`bV:_O]yg`¦gO¡¡b¥`bVgiaFVX
M
O_aY[^[^OQjpy5aFVlkg`fVgiOQyg`fy:aF¡b]F[.ae]eVlaeX
M
OQ[yg`¦¥OQ¡P`bi
M
X:O`bX^jnÌ]e¡bj^O(P]eX^_
M
h¥X
M
Oy:[ZaYl]eg`b¡b`XdX
M
]oX
]P`bjpP]oX^_
M
j^]eXZ`fj 5OQj2X
M
OOQyl`by5ae¡f]e[n_aYVljZXp[^]e`bVYX2`bjneO\[Z¡ba§h¥X
M
`fjO]o¡fl]eXZ`baFV`fjjZX^`¡b¡]iFaYagkOQj^XZ`fP]eXZ`baFVao×X
M
O(V¥lP:O\[
ae_aF[p[ZO\_XP]eX^_
M
O\j
UWVaFl[O¦ly:O\[Z`fPOQVYX^jQhX
M
OO\yg`fy:aF¡b]F[ieOaYPOX^[^ 5OXd§nOOQVXd§naH`fP]oieO\j
M
]ej5OO\VO\jZX^`bP]eXZOQkulj^`bVli@X
M
O¡O\]ej^XWcdj ¥l]F[ZO
POX
M
agk |l ×]o¡fj^a§'`bX M X M
OaFlV:k@P]eX^_
M
O\jUdX'`fj>[ZaYllj^X2X^aaFgX^¡`bOQ[pj'ly@XZa¢ F
)=< % ' %& @ # !A%
L
§nakg`O\[ZO\VFX¤yl¡b]FVl]e[jp_O\VgOQj
M
]FO':OQOQVlj^OQkXZaX^OQj^X¤`fVF]F[Z`f]eVl_O2X^a`bP]eieO>[^aeX^]eXZ`baFV
L'M
O 5[pjZXaYVgO'`fj¤]yl]o`fVYXZO\kTaF¡bklOQ[
_Q]o¡b¡O\k
6
H`iYl[^O7ÈhlX
M
Oj^OQ_aYVlkH`bjX
M
Oyl]o`fVYXZ`fVgiao
/#/A,
6
H`iYl[^ODF7È
H5aF[O\]e_
M
j^_OQVgOFhY]j^O ¥gO\Vl_OaoD}#F`fP]eieO\j
M
]eO>5OO\VX^]F oOQV5OXd§nOO\V§
M
`f_
M X M
O_Q]ePOQ[p]
M
]ej2:OQOQV[^aeXp]oXZO\k]e[^aFlVlk
X M
OaYygXZ`f_]e¡2]¦g`fj
L'M
OHP]eX^_
M
`fVgi[^OQjpg¡bXTkgO\y:O\VlkljaYVX
M
O@[ZaFX^]eXZ`baFVkgOiY[ZOQOeh]ejj
M
a§>V`fV(H`iYl[ZOH
6 7]FVlk GF
6
/#/7,
7È
Q}
H`iYl[^O-:UWP]oieO\j lVlklOQ[ieOQaFPOXp[Z`f_(_
M
]eVgiFOe
H`iYl[^OD:UWP]oieO\jnv¤]eVgiFaei
M
lVlkgO\['ieOQaFPOXp[Z`f_(_
M
]eVgiFOe
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350
Percentage of false matches
Rotation degree
Percentage of false matches vs. rotation degrees Differential method Non-Parametric method
H`biFl[^O:
q
O\[^_OQVYX^]eieOae×Ì]e¡bj^OP]eX^_
M
O\jgjX
M
O[ZaFX^]eXZ`baFV]FVgie¡bO(aF[`fP]oieO\j 6
H`biFl[^O 7Å
\
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350
Percentage of false matches
Rotation degree
Percentage of false matches vs. rotation degrees Differential method Non-Parametric method
H`biFl[^O GF:
q
O\[^_OQVYX^]eieOwao*Ì]o¡fjZOP]oXp_
M
OQjgjQX
M
O[^aeXp]oXZ`baFVH]eVgiF¡O(aY[`bP]oiFOQj
0/0/A, 6
H`biFl[^O DK7Å
L'M
O(`fPy:[ZaFOQPOQVYX2_aFPyl]F[Z`fVgiX^aX
M
Okg`DOQ[^OQVYX^`b]e¡DPOQX
M
agk¢`fjjZ`biFVl`5_Q]eVYX¤aY[nXd§2a`bP]oiFO(j^O ¥gO\Vl_O\jhYOQjpy5OQ_`f]o¡b¡baF[
`fP]oieO\j 0/0 /A,
(`DOQ[^OQVYXZ`f]o¡*POX
M
a¥k%jp DOQ[pj'Ì[^aFP XZO¦gXpl[ZO\j_aFVYX^]e`bVgO\k@`bV`fP]oieO\jh5klgOX^a¢X
M
Ol]ek`fVYXZOQ[^OQj^X>y5ae`fVFXpj
¡bag_]oX^`aYVhD]ej>`fj>X
M
O_Q]ej^OaF[`bP]eieOQj /#/A,
hD§
M
OQ[^OQ]Fj>VgaYV¥cµy:]e[p]ePOXp[Z`f_POX
M
a¥k `bj(PTl_
M
PaY[ZOTj^X^]Fg¡bOe <waeXZ`f_O]o¡fjZa
VgaYV¥cdyl]e[p]ePOXp[Z`f_wie`beOQj]e¡§]gj.OQ§2O\[X
M
]FV%|F Ì]o¡fjZOP]oXp_
M
OQjQ
) K3F% F= "!D %
L'M
Oj^]FPOTXd§2a¢jp_O\VgOQj
M
]eO5OOQV%:jZOX^aXZO\jZXw`bVY]e[^`b]FVl_OX^a¢`¡b¡flP`bVl]eXZ`baFV%_
M
]FVgieOF
L'M
O 5[pjZX'aYVgO `fjkl`bjpyg¡f]eOQk
`fV H*`biF:[ZO e Fhl]eVlkHX
M
OjZO\_aFV:k 0/0/A,
`fj>kg`fj^yg¡f]eO\k¢`fV H*`biF:[ZO \|l
H`iYl[ZO F :UWP]oieO\j lVlklOQ[`fVFX^OQVlj^`bXdH_
M
]FVgieOF
H`iYl[^O |-:UWP]oiFOQj 0/0 /A,
lVlkgO\[`bVYX^OQVlj^`Xd@_
M
]eVlieOe