• Aucun résultat trouvé

From Synchrony to Asynchrony

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "From Synchrony to Asynchrony"

Copied!
22
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00073032

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00073032

Submitted on 24 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

From Synchrony to Asynchrony

Albert Benveniste, Benoit Caillaud, Paul Le Guernic

To cite this version:

Albert Benveniste, Benoit Caillaud, Paul Le Guernic. From Synchrony to Asynchrony. [Research

Report] RR-3641, INRIA. 1999. �inria-00073032�

(2)

ISSN 0249-6399

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

From synchrony to asynchrony

Albert Benveniste, Benoˆıt Caillaud, Paul Le Guernic

N ˚ 3641

mars 1999

TH ` EME 1

(3)
(4)

!#"%$%#"'&)(*+-,.#"/10)2431&))365'78,9:365'<;=?> 5'#@"'&)A

B=CEDGFIHKJML NPO*QRH*SUTWV HXPQZY#QZXRDGFIH*Q

[.\^]U_`HX^Qa[6bdce[6bf6gh[-bhBiN

N:SUjEj-]k\RX8lEHd\^H*m^CEHG\^m^CEHonpkqkrEJsL FSU\RQdJ+tututL J@vjwSkxuH*Q

yz|{}+~€wk}ƒ‚ „ HjE\RH*QRHn…XS†nˆ‡‰nWŠ‹lWHGjEXZCŒlW‡QZmGTwQZQZ‡]UnŽ]U:XZCwH\^H‘SUXZ‡]knEQZCE‡‰jwQ!’-HGX‹“”H*Hn•QZY…nwm^CW\^]kn…YˆSUnwl

SkQZY…nwm^CW\^]kn…Yu–˜—…‡™FšjEHFI]#lEHG™Q]k›’-]kXRCˆj1SU\^SklW‡™xkFQ4S†\^HjE\^HGQRHn#XRH*l fPS†nwlˆ“”HeQ`XœSUXRHXRCwHG]k\^HFQ4“iCE‡m^C

xkT1SU\^SUn…X^HGHeœž†ŸŸ^ œ¡:¢# œ£¤†¥%œ¦#Ÿ^ž†¥w§©¨+ªk¡)§«ž†¥wf1FH*SUnE‡‰nwxIXZC1SUX¬XZCwH]k\R‡™xk‡™nwSUQZY…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTEQQZHGFSUn…XR‡™m*Qdm@S†n­’%H

\^HGm*]knwQ`XR\ZTwmGXRH*l4‘\^]kF®XRCEH=\^HGQZTE‰X.]kwXZCE‡Q.lWH*QZY…nwm^CW\^]knE‡™¯@SUXZ‡]kn –.B=CwHG]k\^HFQS†\^H8xk‡‰°uHn±]k\|’-]kXRCXRCwH8lWH*QZY…nWŠ

m^CE\^]UnE‡¯*SUXR‡™]kn ]k.Q`‡™nwxk™HdQZY…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTEQ<jE\R]uxk\œS†FQGf1SUnwl±]k\PnwHGX‹“”]k\R²#Q<]k.Q`Y#nEm^CE\^]knE]kTwQ<jW\^]uxk\^SUFIQ8X^]4’%H

‡™FšjEHFHn…X^H*lTwQ`‡™nwxšSkQ`Y…nwm^CE\^]Unw]kTwQ<m*]kFšFsTEnE‡™m@SUXZ‡]kn –.b›QZQZTEFšjEXR‡™]knwQP±]k\iXRCEH*QRH³XRCEH*]k\RHGFIQ:mG]k\R\RH*Q`j%]knEl

X^]djE\R]]k1]U’E™‡™xƒSUXR‡™]knwQXRC1S†Xhm@SUn4’-H8m^CwH*m^²kH*l]UnšXZCwHi]k\Z‡xk‡‰n1SU#QZY…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTEQ”lEHGQZ‡™xknwQ*–|´µ-XZCwHim*]k\Z\^HGQZj-]knwlŠ

‡™nwxIm*]knElW‡™XZ‡]knwQ:SU\RH!nw]UX›QRSUXR‡™QZ¶wHGl f-Q`TE‡™X^SU’E™H!Q`Y#nEm^CE\^]knE]kTwQ›Fš‡™nE‡©ŠµjE\R]uxk\^SUFQ”“iCE‡m^C·“i‡‰™HnwQZTE\RHsm*]U\R\^HGmGX

lEH*Q`Y…nwm^CE\^]UnE‡¯*SUXR‡™]kn¸m*SUn¹’%Hm*]kFšj%]kQRH*l­“i‡‰XRC¹XRCwH]U\R‡xU‡™n1SU]knEH*Q*–sB=CE‡Qdm*SUn¹’%HQZH*HGn¸SkQ³SQ`YQ`X^HFSUXZ‡m

“8S@YºXR]­xuHGnEHG\œS†X^HI»¼mG]k\R\RH*mXsjE\^]UX^]#m*]k™Q`½š±]k\sXZCwHSkQZY#m^CE\R]knw]kTEQšl‡QZXZ\R‡‰’ETEXR‡™]knº]U<Q`Y…nwm^CE\^]Unw]kTwQ4lEHGQZ‡xUnwQ*–

B=CwH“iCw]k™HSUjEjE\R]ƒSkm^C¹C1SkQ¬’-H*Hn¹‡™FšjEHFHn#XRH*l f6‡™n­XZCwHs‘\œSUFIHG“”]k\Z²e]khXZCwH4¾W¿.ÀÁ'ÂW¾­jE\^]†_`H*mGX*f “i‡™XZCE‡™n

XRCwHÃ6đÅ#Æ|ÇEȸXR]]U FS†\R²uHX^HGl ’…Y É:Ê=ËÌfwSkQ8“”HG™SUQP‡‰nXRCwHÃ6đÍÎÏ|Å4m*]kFšjE‡‰HG\*–

ÐeуÒ%ÓZÔsÕ ~†Ö'{U‚ QZY…nwm^CW\^]knw]UTwQ<SUnwxkT1SUxuH*QGfElEH*Q`Y…nwm^CE\^]UnE‡¯*SUXR‡™]knז

ØÌÙڼۋÜ+Ý8ÚhÞ'߉ۋàáGâ

ã×ä+åçæ-è-é*ê)ëìåíæ-éGê-ä€îæ-ï†ðZðZñ:æ«ò€ó€óUéGê)ôðRõ8åíñ:ó€îê)ô-ï*ö=ô)ä+ð'÷Ìéøíøùéœè×åçñ+úìó†êéû±ðZü¼ô«æ`ýþ6æ«ó€êåíô6ÿ ©þ-æ)ó€ê)åíô%ó€ê)é û±ðRü¼ô

þGþ-æ)ó€ê)åíô €ã ÿ ! "$#%‰þ6æ«ó€êåíôó€ê)é û±ðRü¼ô þ&')(

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rennes

IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex (France) T´el´ephone : 02 99 84 71 00 - International : +33 2 99 84 71 00

T´el´ecopie : 02 99 84 71 71 - International : +33 2 99 84 71 71

(5)

{

‚

H.\œS†jEj%]U\RX×mG]kn…XR‡Hn…X×TEnwHOGXZTwlEHhlEOXœSU‡‰™OGH|lEHGQא™‡HnwQ Hn#XZ\^HQ`Y#nEm^CE\^]knEH”HXSkQZY…nwm^CE\R]knwHU–›H*Q

F]#lEDH*QQZ‡‰FIjWH*QQR]Un#X'jE\^]Uj%]uQZO*Qj%]kTW\.m*HGQ.lEHTWVjwSU\œSkl‡xkFIH*QG–|—#]kn…X.O*xuSUHFHn#XjE\R]kj%]kQRO*Q'TEnHGnEQRHGF’EH

lEHXRCwOG]k\^DFHGQšj-HG\ZFHXRXœS†n#X4lWH xƒS†\œSUn…XR‡‰\‘S·mG]k\R\RH*mGXZ‡]knŽlEH‘S­lEOGQZY…nwm^CE\R]knE‡QRSUXR‡™]knŽlTWn jE\R]uxk\œS†FIFIH

QZY…nwm^CE\R]knwH‡™QR]k™O4]kT¸’E‡™HGn¸lTWn¸\^OGQRH*SUT lEH4jE\^]kxk\œSUFšFIH*Q³QZY…nwm^CE\R]knwHGQ*– H*Q!XZCwO*]U\^DGFIH*Q!QR]kn…XSkQRQZ]k\RXZ‡Q

lC#Y…j-]kXRCED*QRHGQƒTE‡Wm*]knEQZXR‡‰XRTwHn…XlEH*Q]U’E™‡™xƒSUXR‡™]knwQlEH=jW\^HGTW°uH*Q°kOG\R‡‰¶1SU’E™H*Q.Q`TE\.S›m*]kFšj-]uQZ‡‰XR‡]UnQ`Y#nEm^CE\^]knEH

lEH*Q¬jW\^]uxk\^SUFšFHGQ›m*]UnwQZ‡™lEOG\RO*Q*–—#‡mGH*QdmG]knwlW‡‰XR‡]UnwQ<nwHQR]kn…Xdj1SkQ¬°kOG\Z‡™¶wOGH*Q*f×´µ|H*Q`Xdj%]uQZQZ‡‰’EHslíSkl†_`]k‡™nwl\^H

m^C1SkmTEn lEH*Q”jE\^]uxU\œSUFšFHGQ”Q`Y…nwm^CE\^]UnwH*QGf1TWnnw]kTE°kH@SUTjE\R]uxk\^SUFIFIHPQZY…nwm^CE\R]knwHdj-HG\RFIHGXZXœSUn…X=líSUQRQZTW\^HG\

‘SmG]k\R\RH*mGXZ‡]kn¹lWHs‘SlEOGQZY…nwm^CE\R]knE‡QRSUXR‡™]knז H*mG‡j-HGTWXGXR\RHm*]knEQZ‡lWOG\^OmG]kFšFHsOXœSUn…XdTEnEHsFOXRCw]#lEHlEH

xuOGnEOG\œS†XR‡]Un¸lEHjE\R]kX^]#m*]UH*QdlWHIQ`Y#nEm^CE\^]knW‡Q^S†XR‡]Un¸Hn¸Hn#°…‡‰\^]knEnEHGFIHGn…XsSUQZY…nwm^CE\R]knwHk– ¬SUnwQ³Hm*SklW\RHIlWT

jE\^]†_`HGXi¾¿À.Á|¾%fWmGHGXZX^H¬S†jEjE\^]#m^CwH›SOGXRO<‡™FšjESUn…X^O*HPlwS†nwQ”!ù]kTWXR‡™%Ã6đů'ÇEÈ#"m*]kFšFIHG\^m‡‘SU‰‡QZO8j1SU\=É<ʔË%$HGX

O*xƒS†HGFIHGn…XPlwS†nwQiHdm*]UFIjE‡‰‘SUXRHGTE\›Ã6đÍÎÏ'Åw–

&aÕ }+{

Ó

'

‚

‘SUnExƒSkxuHGQ8QZY…nwm^CE\R]knwHGQ*f%lWO*QZY…nwm^CW\^]knE‡™Q^SUXZ‡]kn

(6)

! P4

}+~ Õ Ök} Õ

Ñ Ñ {@{ Ñ

} ± '{ Õ } Ñ { Ò  ~ Õ Õ {E~€wÖ

Ò  ~ Õ Õ {

~€

{‘} Õ

Ò {G} Ñ Œ{ !#" $

% Ñ { Ò  ~ Õ '&( ) !+*' Ö } ÔÕ) Ö Ñ }+ ',~ Õ z 'Ñ Œ{ -

. Ö Õ  ~ Õ Ò  Ö ~ ÑuÓ { Ò  ~ Õ

'&ƒW} Õ /

0 –‰J 11]U\RFSU%\RH*QZTW™X^Q –!–––!––³–!––!–––!––!––³–!–––!––!–––!–³––!––!–––!––!–³– v

0

–32 [\^SkmGXZ‡m*SU×m*]UnwQRH …TEHGnwmGH*Q –³–!––!–––!––!––³–!–––!––!–––!–³––!––!–––!––!–³– JuJ

$ { Õ  ~ Õ Ò

*'

Ö { Ò  ~ Õ Õ '{š

Ö54#{

Ò  ~ Õ Õ {

Õ

6

Õ

{‘}

Õ {

7

- 8 Ñ }@} Í.Ï|Å E~† ±} Ñ k} ~ Ñ { $

/ 9 Õ ' { Õ $

(7)

4 ìG!

—#Y…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTwQ8jW\^]uxk\^SUFšFI‡‰nwx0 f-J #f-J*r"!6C1SkQ”’-H*HnjE\R]kj%]kQRH*lSkQ8SUnH$#šmG‡™HGn…XiS†jEjE\^]uSkm^C±]k\ìXRCwH<lEH*Q`‡xkn

]k|\RH@SkmXR‡‰°uHSUnwl\^H*SU‰Š«XR‡™FIH›Q`Y#QZX^HFQG–”´µXPC1SUQP’-H*Hne“i‡™lEHG‰YjETE’W™‡m‡¯GH*l fWTEQZ‡™nEx4XZCwH³‡lEH*SU™‡™¯*H*ljW‡mGXZTE\^H³]k

»¼¯GHG\^]šXR‡‰FH ½dm*]UFIjETWXœSUXZ‡]kn SUnwl ‡™nwQ`XœSUn…X^SUnwH*]UTwQ:’W\^]ƒSklWm@SkQ`X›mG]kFIFTEnE‡m*SUXR‡™]kn%ùt&!«–Pg'#šmG‡™HGn…X:X^H*m^CWnE‡ ƒTwHGQ

±]k\Pm*]#lEH³xuHnwHG\^SUXR‡™]kn SUnwl°uHG\Z‡™¶wm*SUXR‡™]knC1S@°uHd\^HGQZTE‰X^HGl(ÌJ Wf 2#f 0 f×J 0 !«–

\Z‡™XZ‡mG‡™QZFIQ=C1S@°uH’%HGHGn·SklElW\RH*QRQZH*leXR]šXZCE‡Q:SUjWjE\^]ƒSUm^Cז=´µXPC1SkQP’-H*HGn·SU\^xUTwH*lXRC1S†X@fE°uH\RY‘\^H ƒTwHGn…XR‰Yuf

\^H*SU‰Š«™‡™±H›SU\^m^CW‡™X^HGmGXZTE\^HGQ<lE]nw]UX<]U’%HYXRCwHd‡™lEH@SU%F]#lEHG ]k'j-HG\Z±H*mX›Q`Y#nEm^CE\^]kn…Yk– ]kTEn…XRHG\ZеHVWSUFšjEHGQ:SU\^H

n…TEFH\^]kTEQ*)š]kj%H\œSUXZ‡™nwx QZY#Q`X^HGFIQs“i‡™XZCºFsTE‰XR‡‰XRCE\RH@SklW‡‰nwx]k\FTE™XZ‡™XœSUQZ²…‡™nwxWfl‡QZXZ\R‡‰’ETEX^HGl SU\Rm^CE‡™XRH*mGXZTE\^HGQ*f

SkQZY…nwm^CW\^]knw]UTwQ<C1S†\^lW“=SU\^HUfwHGXRmk–

+:]+“=H°uHG\*f…QZ‡™Fš‡™SU\R‡‰XR‡™H*Q×SUnEls±]k\RFSU…™‡‰nE²#Q'’-HGX‹“”H*HGnIQZY…nwm^CW\^]kn…Y4SUnElSkQZY…nwm^CW\^]kn…YsC1S@°kHPSU™\RH@SklWY³’-H*Hn

lW‡QZmGTwQZQRHGl!‡™ndXZCwH.™‡‰XRXRHG\œS†XRTE\RHkf*XZC#TEQƒTwHGQZXZ‡]knE‡‰nwx8XRCEH]€°kHG\RQZ‡™FšjE‰‡™¶wHGl¬°#‡™QZ‡™]kn³]ku»¼¯GHG\^]iXZ‡™FIH½'m*]kFšjETEX^SUXR‡™]kn

SUnwl•‡‰nwQZX^SUn…XœSUnwHG]kTwQ’W\^]ƒSklWm@SkQ`Xm*]kFšFsTEnW‡m@S†XR‡]Unז ghSU\Z™YŒj1SUj-HG\,ùq&!›‡™nW±]k\RFSU™‰YºlW‡™QRmTwQRQZH*l XRCwH ™‡™nW²

’%HX‹“=HGHGn·j-HG\Z±H*mX›Q`Y#nEm^CE\^]kn…YeSUnwlX^]k²kHGnWŠ«’1SkQZH*l·SUQZY…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTwQ›lwSUXœS-w]+“ nwHX‹“=]k\Z²#Q*f6QRH*H‡™nj1SU\ZXR‡™mGTESU\

QRHGmGXR‡™]kn/.˜XRCEHG\^H‡™nזhB=CEH:¶E\RQZX”±]k\RFSU1SUnEllEHGHGjQ`XRTwlWYšm*SUn’-H<±]kTWnwlš‡‰n,ÌJ+p!)–´µX”H*QZX^SU’E‰‡QZCEH*Q”S³jE\RH*m‡QRH

\^H‘SUXZ‡]kn³’-HGX‹“”H*HGn4QZ]UŠ‹m*SU™™H*l³“=H™©Š‹mG™]m^²kH*lQZY…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTEQ|‘TEnwmXR‡]Un1SU…jE\^]kxk\œSUFIQSUnwlXRCwHìQZTE’EQRHGX.]k0³SUCEn

nwHGX‹“”]k\Z²Q›SUFIHGn1SU’WH›XR]»µ’ET21-HG\R™H*QZQ`½dH°USU™T1S†XR‡]Unז

:‡QZXZ\R‡‰’ETEX^HGlŽmG]lWH xuHnwHG\^SUXR‡™]knˆ‘\^]kF Q`Y…nwm^CE\^]Unw]kTwQjW\^]uxk\^SUFIQ4\RH ƒTE‡‰\^H*Q4X^] SklEl\^H*QZQIXZCwH ‡™QRQ`TwHe]k

XRCwH!\^HGSUXR‡™]knwQ`CE‡™j ’%HX‹“=HGHGn QZY…nwm^CE\R]kn…Y¹SUnwl¹SkQ`Y…nwm^CE\^]Un#Ye‡™n¹SlW‡31%H\^Hn#X<“8S@Yk–sceS†jEjE‡™nExQZY…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTEQ

jE\^]kxk\œSUFIQ|XR]!S›nEHGX‹“”]k\R²]U SUTWX^]kFSUXœSfkm*]UFIFsTWnE‡m*SUXR‡‰nwx¬SkQ`Y…nwm^CE\^]Unw]kTwQ`™Ys°…‡‘S¬TEn…’-]kTEnwlWH*l 1|´ 1 4dQGfuC1SkQ

’%HGHGn·‡‰FIjWHGFIHGn…XRH*l±]k\PXRCwH5 TwQZXZ\^H³‘SUnExkT1SkxuH³S†nwl ±]k\ZFS†™‡¯GH*l‡‰n6ÌJ 2&!)–PceS†jEjE‡™nEx Ã6đÍÎÏ'ŚjE\^]kxk\œSUFIQ

X^]lW‡™QZXZ\R‡™’WTEX^HGlSU\^m^CW‡™X^HGmGXZTE\^HGQ8“8SkQ8jW\^]kj-]uQRHGl‡™n7ÌJ+tWfr!)f’1SkQZH*l]knS†nH@SU\Z™Yš°uHG\RQZ‡™]kn]k×XRCEH¬XRCwHG]k\RYš“=H

jE\^HGQRHn#X›‡™neXZCE‡Qij1S†j%H\@–:B=CwHIÃ98Î;:=<”ÈŒXR]]U>2 2#f 2#J$!|SUQZ]š‡‰FIjE™HGFIHGn…X^QPSšQZ‡‰FI‡‰‘SU\PS†jEjE\^]uSkm^Cז:N:HGm*Hn#X

“=]U\R²?©JuJ$!%]knXRCwH@A.Å#Ä QZY#QZXRHGF jE\^]kj-]uQZH*Q=XR]\^HTwQRH›XZCwH:»‹m*]knwQ`XR\ZTwmGXZ‡™°uH›QRHGFSUn…XR‡™m*Q¼½¬S†jEjE\^]uSkm^C±]k\”XRCwH

< ÇCBÇ1ÅIQZY…nwm^CW\^]knw]UTwQi‘SUnwxUT1SkxuHUf“i‡™XZC 1—Ec " ]#lEH*Q`‡xkn 1‡™nE‡‰X^Hd—…XœSUXRHceSkm^CE‡‰nwH*Q $8SkQPSsF]#lEHG-±]k\

QZY…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTEQFSkm^CE‡‰nwH*Q¬“iCE‡™m^C?m@SUn¹’-HšlWH*QZY…nwm^CW\^]knE‡™¯*HGlED'XZCE‡Q¬m*SUn¹’%HQZH*Hn SkQ³S\RHG¶EnwHFHn…X!]UÌJ+p"!)f

SU™XZCw]kTwxUC XZCwHd\^H±HG\R\RH*lF]#lEH×]k|SkQZY…nwm^CE\R]kn…Y‡Q8nw]kXi‘TW™™YIQZX^SUX^HGl –

´µnElEHGj-HGnwlWHGn…XR‰Yuf-SUnw]kXZCwHG\<SUjEjW\^]ƒSkm^C \^H‘SUXZ‡™nwx4Q`Y#nEm^CE\^]kn…Y SUnwleSkQZY…nwm^CW\^]kn…YC1SkQP’%HGHGn ±]k™™]+“=HGl –”´µn

GF#f%J+v"!-‡™X”‡Q8Q`Cw]+“in CE]€“ ¥%ž†¥6¢# ¡‹ Ÿ §‘¥w§™£¡§«iÃ6đÍÎÏ'ÅjE\R]uxk\^SUFQ”m@SUn’-H¬TwQZH*lX^]sFI]lWHG%SkQZY…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTEQ

m*]kFšFsTEnW‡m@S†XR‡]UnºFHGlW‡‘S QZTwm^C SkQ ƒTwHGTEH*QISUnwl ’ET21-HG\RQ*–IH< Rª#¡)§k =J¸ž*¢K™ œ£L©J$!8“=H\^HjE\R]kj%]kQRH*lˆSkQ4S

QZY…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTEQ³SUnwxkTwSkxuH³±]k\<CwSU\^lW“=SU\RHF]#lEH™‡™nExEfE‡™n·“iCW‡m^C¹SkQ`Y…nwm^CE\^]Un#Ye‡Q:HGFsTESUX^HGle’…Y XZCwH!“=S@Y·]k

nw]knwlWHGX^H\RFš‡™nE‡™QZF –ºb<‰XRCw]UTwxkCŒXRCE‡™Q‡Q]k:‡™n…X^H\^HGQZX@fì“=H’-HG™‡™HG°kHXRCE‡™QIS†jEjE\^]uSkm^Cއ™Qsnw]kX4Q`TE‡™XRH*lŒX^]¹XRCwH

SUn1SU‰Y#QZ‡Q4]k<XR\ZTwH SkQZY…nwm^CE\R]kn…Yuf8‡‰nŽ“iCE‡™m^CŽnE]?nw]UXR‡]Un ]k<xk™]k’1SUiQ`Y…nwm^CE\^]UnE‡¯*SUXR‡™]kn Q`XœSUXRH ‡™QšS+°USU‡‰‘SU’WHkf

TEnE‰‡™²uH¬±]U\PQZY…nwm^CE\R]kn…Yu–

´µn¸XRCE‡™Q!j1SUj-HG\!“=HjW\^]+°…‡lEHSUn HV#XRHGnwQ`‡™°uHUf‡™n lEHjEXRC fhSUn1SU‰YQ`‡Q]kiXRCEH™‡‰nE²#Q’-HGX‹“”H*Hn Q`Y#nEm^CE\^]kn…Y

SUnwlISkQZY…nwm^CW\^]kn…Yu–M4›TE\°…‡Q`‡]knI]k%SkQZY…nwm^CE\R]kn…YšHGnwmG]kFIjwSkQRQZH*Q=l‡QZXZ\R‡‰’ETEX^HGl4QZY#QZXRHGFIQ*f‡‰n4“iCE‡m^CInw]³xk]k’wSU

QZY…nwm^CE\R]knE‡™¯@SUXZ‡]knŽQZX^SUX^H‡QšS@°USU‡™SU’E™HkfhSUnwlˆm*]UFIFsTWnE‡m*SUXR‡™]knwQNUSkmGXZ‡]knwQSU\^HnE]kX4‡™nwQ`XœSUn…XœS†nwH*]kTEQ*–ŽB=CE‡Q

HV#X^HnwQZ‡™]kn­S†™]+“PQiTwQPX^]4C1SUnwlHd‡™nwmG]kFšjEHX^HdlEHGQZ‡xUnwQ*f1QZj-H*m‡™¶wm*SUXR‡™]knwQGf1jW\^]kj-HG\ZXR‡HGQ*f1SU\Rm^CE‡™XRH*mXRTE\RH*Q*f-SUnwl

HVH*mTEXœS†’EHhjE\^]kxk\œSUFIQ*f+‡‰nSiTEnE‡‰¶wH*l³‘\œS†FH“=]k\Z²6f€±]U\’-]kXZC!Q`Y…nwm^CE\^]Unw]kTwQ|SUnwl!SkQZY…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTEQ|QRHFS†n#XZ‡mGQ*–

´µnQRH*mXR‡™]kn 2“”H›‡™nW±]k\RFSU™‰Yl‡QRmTwQRQ”XRCwH¬HGQRQZHGn…XR‡SUQ”]kQZY…nwm^CE\R]kn…YSUnElSkQZY…nwm^CW\^]kn…Yu–=—#Y…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTEQ

B\^SUnwQ`‡™XR‡™]kn —#Y#QZXRHGFIQ³SU\^HlWHG¶EnwHGl?‡‰n¹QRHGmGXR‡™]kn pWf×SUnEl¹XZCwHG‡‰\³SkQ`Y#nEm^CE\^]knE]kTwQ³m*]kTWn#XRHG\Zj1SU\RX³‡™Q¬lEHG¶WnwH*l¹‡™n

QRHGmGXR‡™]knrEf…“iCwH\^HdSU™QR]!lEH*Q`Y#nEm^CE\^]knW‡¯@S†XR‡]Un‡Qh±]k\RFSU‰™YslWHG¶EnwHGl –ìB=CwH›\RH*QZX=]k XZCwH<j1S†j%H\=‡QìlEH°u]kXRH*lX^]

XRCwHSUnwSU™Y#QZ‡™Qi]k'lEH*Q`Y#nEm^CE\^]knW‡¯@S†XR‡]Un·SUnEl ‡‰X^Q8‡™n…°kHG\^QZHkfwn1SUFIHG‰YI\RH*Q`Y#nEm^CE\^]knW‡¯@S†XR‡]Unז

(8)

P P4G*K ! ' !

B=CwHG\RHšCwS+°kHš’-H*Hn¸QZHG°kHG\œS†=S†XRX^HFIjWX^Q¬X^] m^C1SU\^SkmGXRHG\Z‡¯*HXZCwH4H*QRQZHGn…XR‡SUQ³]kìXRCEHQZY…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTwQj1SU\^SklW‡xUF

0 fJ@r!)– „ ‡‰XRC QR]kFIH4HV#j%H\R‡™HGnwmGHSUnEl¸SU‘XRHG\³FSUn…Y¹SUXRXRHGFšjEX^QdXR]eSklWlW\^HGQRQ³XRCwH4‡QZQZTwHš]kìF]+°…‡™nwx‘\R]kF

QZY…nwm^CE\R]kn…Y•X^]¸SkQZY…nwm^CW\^]kn…Y ")SUnwl ’wSkm^² $fi“=H ±H*HG<XRCwH ±]k™™]+“i‡™nwx­±H@S†XRTE\RH*QSU\RH ‡‰nwlEH*HGl•H*QZQRHn#XZ‡‘SU<±]k\

m^C1SU\^SkmGXRHG\R‡™¯G‡‰nwxXRCE‡™Q8j1SU\œSUlW‡xkF )

Ju–P[.\^]uxU\œSUFIQijE\^]uxU\^H*QZQ<°…‡‘SšSUn ‡™nE¶EnW‡™X^H³QZH ƒTwHGnEm*H]k=Ÿœ Rª#¡§«ž†¥W£ ) -fw“iCwH\^H lEHGnw]UX^H*Q<XRCwH

SUFš‡™‰YI]U'j-]uQRQ`‡™’E™H¬\^H*SkmGXZ‡]knwQ –

2– „ ‡™XZCE‡™nˆS­\^H*SkmGXZ‡]kn fìlWH*mG‡™QZ‡™]knwQ4m@SUnˆ’-HXœSU²kHGn•]UnˆXZCwH’1SkQ`‡Q4]k:XRCwH ª£+ ¥%œ !]k<QR]kFIHHG°uHn…X^Q*f

SkQ³HVHFIjE‰‡™¶wHGl·’…Y­XRCwHs±]k‰]+“i‡™nExX‹Y…jE‡m*SUQZX^SUX^HFHn…X^Q*fXœS†²uHGn?‘\^]UF < Ç BÇ1Å BÇ fSUnwl

Ã6đÍÎÏ|Å4\^H*Q`j%HGmGXZ‡™°uH™Y )

"!$#%'&")(*+!',-!/.

021$354 " "!76

098:1;47< -=, 4 &>!@?

B=CwH³¶E\^Q`X:QZXœS†X^HGFIHGn…Xi‡™QiQRHG‰Š‹H VjW‘SUn1S†X^]k\ZYu–hB=CwH›»

354 A "!

½]Uj%H\œSUXR]k\ilEH™‡™°kHG\RQPXZCwHdF]kQZXi\^HGm*Hn#X

°USU™TEH]U

6

SUXPXZCwH!m]#m^²]k'XRCwHm*]knEQZ‡lWHG\^HGl nw]#lEHUf1‡‰XiXRC…TwQPC1SkQPX^]4X^HGQZX:±]k\<SU’wQRHnwm*H!]k

6

’%H±]k\^H

jE\R]lWTEmG‡™nEx

0

–:B=CwH³»

< -=', 4 &>!

½]Uj%H\œSUXR]k\›lWHG™‡‰°uH\^QP‡™X^QP¶E\RQZXdS†\^xkTEFIHGn…X:“iCwHGne‡™X:‡QijE\^HGQRHn#X*f×SUnwl

]kXZCwHG\Z“i‡QRHd‡‰X^QiQRHGm*]knEl·SU\RxkTEFIHGn…X@–

pW–P[|S†\œSU‰HGmG]kFIj-]uQ`‡™XR‡™]kn‡Q:xk‡™°kHGn·’…YXœS†²#‡‰nwxIXZCwH!jwSU‡™\Z“i‡QRHm*]Unk_¼TEnwmXR‡]Un­]khSkQZQR]#mG‡SUX^HGl \^H*SkmGXZ‡]knEQ*f

“iCwHnwHG°kHG\dXRCEHGY SU\^Hm*]UFIj-]uQ^S†’EH")BDC5EGF@ HICKJLMFON

–PBY…jE‡m*SU™‰YufE‡‰.QZj-H*m‡™‘Y…‡™nExš‡™Q:XZCwH‡‰nWŠ

X^Hn…XR‡]Un×fkXRCEHGnXRCEHiSU’-]€°kH=±]k\ZFsTE‘SP‡Q|S<j%H\R±HGmGXhlEH¶EnE‡™XZ‡]kn]kwj1SU\^SU™™HG#m*]UFIj-]uQZ‡‰XR‡™]knז´µnm*]Un#XZ\œSkQ`X@f

‡™jW\^]uxk\^SUFšFI‡‰nwx‡Q›XZCwH‡™n…XRHGn…XR‡™]kn×f-XZCwHGn­XZCwHnwHGH*l­±]k\<XRCE‡™Q¬lEHG¶WnE‡™XZ‡]kn X^]’-Hsm*]kFšj1SUXZ‡™’E™Hd“i‡™XRC

SUn ]kj-HG\œS†XR‡]Un1SU QZHGFSUn…XR‡™m*Qim*]UFIjE‰‡m*SUX^HGQ=°uH\RYFsTwm^C XRCwH›»µ“iCwHGn ‡™X8‡™QilEHG¶WnwH*l½³jW\^HG\RH ƒTE‡™QZ‡™XRHQP@–

4›×m*]kTW\^QRHUfQ`Twm^CSm^C1SU\œSUmGX^H\R‡™¯@SUXZ‡]knš]k-XRCwH:QZY…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTEQ=j1SU\^SklW‡xUF FS†²uH*QhXRCEH<m‘SkQZQ”]k%QZY…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTEQ

±]k\RFSU‰‡QZFIQ³FsTwm^CŒ‘SU\RxuHG\XRC1SUn TEQZT1SU‰™Y m*]knEQZ‡lWHG\^HGl –SR”TWX‡™XCwSkQs’%HGHGnŽ]kTE\H V#j%H\R‡Hnwm*HXZC1SUXXRCEH*QRH

“=H\^H XRCwH²uHY ±H@SUXZTE\^HGQš±]k\4XZCwH XRH*m^CEnW‡ƒTwH*Qš“=HC1S@°uH lEHG°kHG™]kj%HGl QZ] SU\*– ™H@SU\Z™YufhXRCW‡Q4m@SU‰Qs±]k\šS

QZ‡‰FIjE™H*Q`Xj%]uQZQZ‡‰’EH8±]k\ZFS†™‡Q`F®“i‡™XRC4XZCwH:SU’%]+°kHP±H*SUXRTW\^H*QGf]Unš“iCW‡m^Cš‘TEnwlwSUFIHGn…X^SU ƒTwH*Q`XR‡]UnwQhQZCw]kTWl4’%H

‡™n…°uHGQZXZ‡xƒSUXRH*lE):B=CwHlEH*Q`‡xkn­]UXRCwH ! ±]k\ZFSU‰‡Q`FUTPlEHGQRmG\Z‡™’-H*l·‡‰neXRCEHnwHV#XdQZH*mXR‡]Un·C1SkQ:’%HGHGn¹xkTE‡™lEH*l

’…YXRCwHGQRH]k’W_`H*mXR‡‰°uH*QG–

0dHGHGjE‡‰nwx‡™neFI‡‰nwleXRCEHsH*QZQRHGn…XZ‡‘SU™Qd]kXRCwHQZY…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTwQ³j1SU\^SklW‡™xkFefw“”H4SU\^H!nw]+“ \RH@SklWY X^]l‡QRmTwQRQ

‡™nE±]U\RFSU™‰Y·Cw]+“ SkQ`Y…nwm^CE\^]Un#Y \RHGSUX^HGQX^]­Q`Y#nEm^CE\^]kn…Yk–ŒN:H±HG\R\Z‡™nwx·XR]·j%]U‡™n…X^QJkf 2#f”S†nwlˆp­SU’%]+°kHkfhXRCwH

±]k™™]+“i‡™nwxsm*SUn ’%H³QZX^SUX^HGleS†’%]kTWX:SkQZY…nwm^CE\R]kn…Y )

Ju–PNPH@SkmXR‡]UnwQ8m@S†nEnw]kX8’-H¬]k’EQRHG\Z°uHGleSUn…YIF]k\RH).Q`‡™nwmGH›nw]xk™]k’1SU-mG™]m^²IHV#‡™QZX^QGfExk™]k’1SU-QZY…nwm^CE\R]knE‡™¯@S†Š

XR‡™]kn’1S†\R\R‡™HG\RQ=“iCE‡m^C‡‰nwlW‡™m@SUXRH<XRCEH›XR\^SUnwQZ‡‰XR‡™]kn‘\R]kF ]UnwH›\^H*SkmGXZ‡]knX^]sXRCEH›nwHV#XP]knEHdSU\^H<nw]sF]U\^H

]k’wQZHG\Z°kS†’EHU– ´µnwQZXRH@Skl f=S·\^HG‰‡‘SU’WHmG]kFšFsTEnE‡™m@SUXZ‡]kn FHGlW‡™TEF ‡Q4SkQZQZTEFIH*l%f쇉n “iCE‡m^CˆFHGQRQRSkxuH*Q

SU\RH¬nw]kXi]kQZX@fWSUnwl±]k\iH*Skm^C ‡™nwlW‡‰°…‡lWT1S†%m^C1S†nEnwHG«fWFIH*QRQRSkxuHGQ<S†\^HdQRHn…X›S†nwl\^H*mGHG‡‰°uH*l‡™nXZCwHdQ^S†FH

]k\RlEHG\*– „ Hm@SU‰SWVPž>XˆXZCwHsX^]kX^SU™‰Y ]k\^lEH\^HGl?QZH ƒTwHnwm*Hš]kh°USU™TwHGQdQRHn#X]k\›\^H*mGHG‡‰°uH*l?]kn Sxk‡‰°uHGn

m*]UFIFsTWnE‡m*SUXR‡™]knm^C1SUnWnwHG«–

Y

O±ñ|÷©îGü¼ô [Z)ê)ðZîü`ôåíéGñO\Eåíæîæ)øùåíúGä*ôøíö.êðRæô«êåçü¼ô)å^]GðwôðZê`_œîæ…è%ð6æ«ä€î øíøGæ)ð`ð6åíñ.ô«ä+ð-æ)ðba@ò+ðZøô)ä†î ôZ)ê)ðZîü`ôåçñ+ú×ôéô)ä+ð-ðZñO]@åíê)éGñ+_=ðRñGôc\

åçæñ+éGô%ô«ä+ðéGñ€øùö:óUéGæ«æ)åíï+øíðhë*åíñ†õ:é÷Wåçñ*ôðZê«îü`ôåíéGñ<îiæö+ñ€ü‹ä€ê)éGñ€éGò€æ%æö+æ)ôðd_e_8î^ö:ä€îf]ð.è×åíô)ä›åíô)æ ðZñO]@åçêé*ñ+_=ðZñ*ô (

g:h

éGê åçñ€æô«îñ€ü`ð>_=é*æô é ÷Eô)ä€ðð:iuéGê)ôêðZøíîôðZõ<ôé8ô«ä+ðìæ)ðb_8îñ*ôåçü`æ é÷jlk:mn+on+pPä€îæ×ïUð`ðRñ›õ€åíê)ðZü`ôðZõ›ô)éœè%îGê)õ<æéGø^]@åçñ+ú8ô)ä+åçæ

åçæ)æ«ò+ðhæ«î ô)åíæ÷©îü`ôéGê)åíøùörq= *s(

t:u

ðìô«ä€îñ€ëQv_=åçê-ñ*ò€ð`øíå#÷Ìé*êä€îf]@åçñ+ú:ó€ê)éGóUéGæ)ðZõ¬ô«ä+åíæ÷ÌéGê`_8î øíåíæ`_†åçñdô)ä€ð”ü¼é*ò€ê«æðé÷1ô)ä+ð ¬êðRæðRîê«ü‹ä¬ó€êéû±ðZü`ô

îGæ×îB_=åçñ+åw_=îøƒ÷©ê«î_=ð`è%éGê«ëiü`îGó+ô)ò€ê)åçñ+ú”ô«ä+ðhó€îGê)îGõ+åùúO_ é ÷Eó†ðRê±÷ÌðRü¼ôæ)ö+ñ€ü‹ä€ê)éGñ*ö(

(9)

2–ib<’EQRHGnEm*Hm*SUnEnw]UXi’%H³lEHX^H*mX^HGl f6SUnwlXRC…TwQ:m@SUnEnE]kXi’%HdTwQZH*l X^]4HVHG\RmG‡™QRHm*]kn…XR\R]kµ–

pW– ]kFšj%]kQZ‡™XZ‡]kn ]#m*mGTW\^Q<’…Y FH*SUnwQ<]k.TEnE‡‰‘Y…‡™nwxIH@Skm^C -E]€“MQ`C1SU\^HGle’-HGX‹“”H*HGn¹X‹“”]jE\^]#m*HGQRQZH*Q*–¬B=CE‡Q

FI]lEHQ‡™nºj1S†\RXR‡™mGTESU\XRCwHmG]kFIFTEnE‡m*SUXR‡™]knwQ³°…‡‘S·SkQ`Y…nwm^CE\^]Unw]kTwQTEn…’-]kTEnwlEHGl 1|´ 1 4dQGfQZTwm^C SkQ

XRCE]uQRHs‡‰n70³SUCEn­nwHX‹“=]k\Z²#Q*–sNPHGnElEH*¯ е°u]UTwQdX‹Y#j-H]khmG]kFIFTEnE‡m*SUXR‡™]kn·m*SUn?SU™QR]’-HSU’wQ`XR\^SkmGXRH*l­‡™n

XRCW‡Q8“=S+Yk–

—#Y…nwm^CE\R]kn…YºSUnEl¸SkQ`Y…nwm^CE\^]Un#Y SU\RH±]k\RFSU™‡™¯*HGl·‡™n?QRHGmGXR‡™]knwQ!p S†nwl rWf\RH*Q`j%HGmGXR‡‰°uH™Yu–—H*mXR‡™]kn FlEHXœSU‡‰Q

Cw]+“ XRCEH*QRHd\RH*QZTW™X^QPm*SUn ’-HdjETEXP‡™n…XR]sjE\œSkmXR‡™m*Hk–

'!!

P

Ò  ~ Õ Õ { ~€ {±} Õ Ò {G} Ñ Œ{ !#" „ HeSkQRQ`TEFH S?°k]m*SU’ETESU\RY “iCE‡m^CއQIS QRHX]k

X‹Y…j%HGl °USU\R‡SU’EHGQ*–Œb<‰8X‹Y…j%HGQSU\RH‡™FšjE™‡™mG‡™XZ™Y¹H VXRHGnwlWH*l “i‡‰XRC S?Q`j%HGmG‡‘S†PHGHFHn…Xf”‡‰n…X^HG\ZjE\^HX^HGl•SkQ

ª£+ ¥%œ –b<FI]knwxXRCEHIX‹Y…j%HGQ!“”HmG]knwQZ‡™lEHG\*f'XZCwHG\RHSU\RHšXZCwHIX‹Y…j-H]k Ÿ^ 4£§k¥6ªí£¬“i‡‰XRCºlW]kFS†‡™n f

SUnwl4XRCwH ž+ž™ Rªk¥³X‹Y…j%Hi“i‡™XZCšlE]kFSU‡™n "±\^H*m*SU™W’%]kXZC4X‹Y#j-H*Q”SU\RH:H V#X^HGnElEH*l“i‡‰XRC4XRCEH:l‡QZXZ‡™nwxUTE‡Q`CwH*l

HG™HGFIHGn…X $ – „

HPlEH¶EnwH<S£¡«ªk¡‹ :XR]³’-H:S³X‹Y…j-Hеm*]knwQ`‡Q`X^HGn…X쇙n…X^H\RjE\RHGX^SUXR‡™]knš]k ›fSUQRQZ‡™xknE‡‰nwxSd°USU‰TwH8X^]

H@Skm^C °USU\R‡SU’E™Hk– „ HdlEHnw]kX^Hd’…Y"! XRCwHdQZHGXP]k'SU‰ Q`XœSUXRH*Q*– 1w]k\PSsQ`TE’wQZHGX:]k°USU\R‡SU’EHGQ$#&%'¬fwS(#dеQZX^SUX^H

‡Q:SX‹Y#j-Hеm*]knEQZ‡Q`X^Hn#X:‡™n…XRHG\RjW\^HGX^SUXR‡™]kn ]k#š–=B=C…TwQ›S)#¬Š‹QZX^SUX^H*SUQRQZ‡™xknwQ<Ss°kS†™TwH*,+-/.×XR]IH*Skm^Ce°USU\Z‡‘SU’E™H

-‡™nQZHGX0#DEXZCwHdXRTEjE™Hd]k°kS†™TwHGQPSkQRQ`‡xknwHGl XR]XRCwH³QRHX›]U'°USU\Z‡‘SU’E™H*Q$# ‡™QilEHGnw]UX^H*l’…Y1,+2#3.)–

„ H³lEHG¶WnwHS41¤†¥%œ¦#Ÿ^ž†¥%ž…£"5WŸRªk¥W£§‘¡§«ž†¥141¤+£¡‹  " ! $”X^]4’-H!SsXZTEjEH*6 &78# 9:<;>= m*]knwQ`‡Q`XR‡™nExI]k

XRCwHš±]k™™]+“i‡™nwxmG]kFIj-]knwHn…X^Q*)?# ‡Q!S ¶WnE‡™XRHIQZHGXs]U=X‹Y…j%HGl †ªkŸ §ª*™ œ£f 9 ‡™QS†n SkQZQRHG\ZXR‡™]knº]kn@#³Š‹Q`XœSUXRH*Q

m^C1SU\^SkmGXRHG\R‡™¯G‡‰nwxXRCEHQRHGX¬]kP§‘¥w§‘¡)§ª£¡µªk¡‹ œ£3ACB2"B 9D SUnwl ; ‡™Q<XRCEH¡)ŸZªk¥W£§‘¡§«ž†¥¸Ÿ^  ©ªk¡§«ž†¥\^HGSUXR‡‰nwxIjwSkQZX

SUnwlmTE\R\RHGn…XE#³ŠµQZX^SUX^HGQ*fAF S†nwl"uf#’…Yš\^H±HG\R\Z‡™nwxX^]’-]kXZCj1SkQ`XHGPSUnElmGTE\Z\^Hn#X=°kS†™TwHGQ=]k×°USU\Z‡‘SU’E™H*Q‡™n#I–

1w]k\³HVWSUFšjEH!XRCwHšSkQZQRHG\ZXR‡™]knJI KILF)MON4QZX^SUX^HGQ³XZC1SUXdXZCwHs°USU™TwH]UPI?‡™nQ4‡™Q¬xk\RH@SUXRHG\d’…YNsXRC1S†n ‡‰X^Q

°USU™TwH¬‡‰nRSFז´µ H8AF N$B ; XRCwHn “”H³Q^S@YXRCwSUXPQZX^SUX^H*AFe‡™QPS ;T-Ÿœ R¢# œœ œ£œ£+ž†Ÿì]k'QZX^SUX^H*u–

{S b Ÿ ¥0UWVXZY C QF Z[\[Z[ ‡Q'S<QZH ƒTwHGnEm*Hi]kWQZXœS†X^H*Q'QZTwm^CXZC1SUXZY3B 9 ] ^`_a'b3 HcZd

F C \dIN$B

; –

9 Õ 6

Õ

{‘}

Õ

B=CwH­œže1ž+£§‘¡)§«ž†¥]k”X‹“=]

!

6 f6 C;Eg6BF³‡Q³lEHG¶WnwH*l¸SkQ±]U™]+“PQ$)36 h78#

#KCjik# F@f

9 9

CJ

9

F@f

; ; C J ; F =

–hB=CwHdmG]kFšj%]uQ`‡™XZ‡]knš‡Q=XZC…TwQ8XRCwH¬jwSU‡™\Z“i‡QRH<m*]knU_¼TEnwmGXZ‡]kn]U‡‰nE‡™XZ‡‘SU

SUnwl•XZ\œSUnwQ`‡™XZ‡]knŽ\^HGSUXR‡™]knwQG– ´µXQ`Cw]kTE™l•’%HenE]kXR‡™m*H*lŽXRC1SUX*fi‡™n ! m*]kFšj-]uQZ‡‰XR‡]Un×f=‡™n…XRHG\œSUmGXR‡™]kn•]#m*mTE\^Q

XRCE\R]kTwxkC m*]UFIFI]kn°USU\R‡SU’E™H*Q8]knW™Yu–

leÕ }+W}

Õ { µÕ

~ !/

1w]k\|XZCwHim*]kn…°kHGnE‡™HGnwmGH:Q`j%HGmG‡‰¶wm@SUXZ‡]kn f !

“i‡‰™#C1S@°uH:S›QZHGXh]kŸ^ Rª#¡)§k ”°USU\R‡SU’E™H*Q

“i\R‡‰XRX^Hn1#nmGf‡‰FIjE‰‡m‡™XR‰YSUTExkFHn…X^H*l“i‡‰XRCSUQRQR]#mG‡SUX^HGl?ªSou§§ªkŸ ¤:°kS†\R‡‘S†’EHGQ*)'XZCwH›“iCw]UH¬mG]knwQZXZ‡™XZTEX^HGQ8XRCwH

QRHXp# ]k°USU\R‡SU’EHGQ*– „ H³QZC1S†™ TwQZHdXRCwHd±]k‰]+“i‡™nwxxuHGnwH\R‡™m³nE]kXœSUXZ‡]knEQ=‡™nXRCEHQZH ƒTwH )

qgr

st - vuDZ[\[Z[ lEHGnE]kX^Hš\^H@SUmGXR‡‰°uHš°kS†\R‡‘S†’EHGQ*fSUnwl

r

s SU\RHšTwQZH*lºXR] \^H±HG\X^]e°USU\Z‡‘SU’WH*Q³]k=’%]#]kH*SUn

X‹Y…j%HU–

q

±]k\$-S4°USU\Z‡‘SU’E™HkfwxzyQ lWHGnw]kXRH*QP‡™XRQ ™ž+<{)z+2wCx?|}p.n~ +-R|Op.

€

æ)ò€îøùøíö-]œîê)åçîï+øíðZæ|îñ€õ

áA‚„ƒÝ†…8‡

]œîGêåçîï+øíðZæ'îê)ð”ò€æ)ðZõôé¬êð`÷ÌðZê'ôé¬ü`ò€ê«ê)ðZñ*ô'îGñ€õ‰ˆ

…‹ŠGß

æô«î ôðRæ (ã×ä+åçæ|åíæ|ðda*ò€å^]œî øíðZñ*ô'ôé

é*ò€ê×ó€ê)ðZæ)ðZñ*ôñ+éô«î ô)åùé*ñ ( u

ðhä†îf]ðó€ê)ð¼÷ÌðZê«ê)ðZõPô)éPü¼é*ñ€æåçõ+ðRꍌŽ4îGñ€õzŒœûò†æôïUðZüZîò€æ)ð.ô)ä+ð.÷Ìé*êI_”ò+øçîæ è%ð.æ«ä€îøùø…èê)åíôð _=éGæ)ôøíö

åçñO]éø]ðüZò€ê)ê)ðZñ*ô ]œîê)åçîï+øíðZæ €ê)îô)ä+ðRê×ô)ä†îñdó€îGæô×é*ñ+ðZæ ( €

æåçñ+úiô)ä€ðìæô«îñ€õ†îê«õ›ñ€éô)îôåíéGñ›è%éGò+øçõ¬ä€îf]ðê)ðZæ«ò+øùô)ðZõ›åçñdîiï€ò€ê«õ+ðZñ

é÷Eó€ê)åw_”ðRõ ]œîGêåçîï+øíðZæ åçñ<ô)ä+ð.÷Ìé*êI_”ò+øíîGæ (

(10)

q

±]k\$-S4\RH@SkmXR‡™°kHd°kS†\R‡‘S†’EHUf\x›lEHGnE]kX^HGQP‡‰X^QPSkQZQR]#mG‡SUX^HGl¹£¡«ªk¡¼ ³°USU\Z‡‘SU’WHkflEHG¶WnwH*l ’#Y )

wCx \x -

\x ,F

x

.ìSU‰TwH*Qm*SUn4’%Hixk‡‰°uHnX^]*ZYA+ x.wSkQ.j1S†\RXh]k1XRCEH8‡™nE‡‰XR‡‘S†mG]knwlW‡‰XR‡™]knז'B=CwHGn×f x”‡™QSU™“=S@Y#QhjW\^H*QZHGn…X”SUŠ

X^H\hXRCwHP¶E\^Q`X=]#m*mTE\R\RHGnwmGH<]UL-1– 1'‡‰n1SU‰™Yuf x€fƒXRCwH\^HG±]U\^H8»¼QZX^SUX^Hi°USU\Z‡‘SU’E™H*Q]k-QZX^SUX^HP°USU\R‡SU’E™H*Q`½

nwHGH*l nE]kXi’%H³mG]knwQZ‡™lEHG\RH*l –

b›Q=FI]#lWTE‘S†\R‡™X‹Y‡Q=lWH*QZ‡‰\œSU’WHkfHG°kHG\RY !

Q`Cw]kTE™l’-H›j%H\RFš‡™XZX^H*lšX^]slW]snw]kXRCW‡™nwx“iCE‡™™H<‡™XRQ=Hn#°…‡‰\^]knEFIHGn…X

‡Qsj-]uQRQ`‡™’E‰Y “”]k\Z²#‡‰nwxE– B=CW‡Q±H@SUXZTE\^HCwSkQ’%HGHGnŒYuHXš‡™lEHGn…XZ‡™¶wHGlŒ‡‰nŒXRCwH‰‡™XRXRHG\^SUXRTE\RHSUnwl ‡™Q²…nw]+“in SkQ

£¡ #¡¡¼ Ÿ §‘¥X‡™n…°USU\R‡SUnwm*HI]k\s\R]k’ETwQ`XRnwHGQRQ ©J@qf8J&F !«– 1w]k\4S ! 6›fhQZXZTEXRXRHG\R‡‰nwx·‡™n…°USU\Z‡‘SUnwmGHI‡™QlEH¶EnwH*lŽSkQ

±]k™™]+“PQ*).´µUL tY C QF Z[Z[Z[ ‡Q:Ss\RTEn ]k6›fwQR]‡Q

U'}ZY \[Z[Z[\

!

Y#"%$'&)(+*

-,/.0

C 21 Z[Z[Z[ 1 QF 43 Z[Z[Z[ 43 Z[\[Z[

“iCwHG\RHkfE±]k\$SUn S†\R’E‡‰XR\œS@YšQZX^SUX^HUfEQZY…Fs’-]k ”lWHGnw]kXRH*Q8XZCwH£§™ ¥w¡|£¡µªk¡‹ =SkQRQZ]m‡‘SUXRH*l“i‡‰XRC1ufElEH¶EnwH*l’…Y

^ - y #nm V65

+-/.

Z+ x. ,+ x<.

FH*SUnE‡‰nwxXRC1S†XdQZX^SUX^Hs°USU\Z‡‘SU’E™H*QdS†\^Hs²uHjEX³TEnwm^C1S†nwxuH*l¹“iCwHnwHG°kHG\XRCwH‡™\SkQZQR]#mG‡‘S†X^H*l·\RH@SkmXR‡‰°uHs°USU\R‡SU’E™H*Q

SU\^HìSU’EQRHGn…X*–.´µXQZCw]kTWl³’%Hnw]kXZ‡mGH*l³XRC1SUXQ`XRTEXZX^H\R‡™nEx:‡‰n#°USU\Z‡‘SUnEm*HhSU‰]+“PQ ±]k\\RTEnEQj-]uQZQRH*QZQZ‡‰nwx›]knW™Y³S8¶EnE‡‰X^H

n…TEFs’-HG\i]k×jW\^H*QZHGn…XPQZX^SUX^HGQ*– „ H¬QZCwSU™6\^H …TW‡™\^H:‡™nXZCwH›QZH ƒTwH XRC1S†XiSU‰ ! “”Hdm*]knwQ`‡lEH\iSU\RH›Q`XRTEXZX^HG\Z‡™nwx

‡™n…°USU\R‡SUn…X@–|B=CwHGYQ`Cw]kTE™l‡™nwlEHGH*l4Q^S†XR‡Q`‘Y ) H8 F N$B ;87 Hc F 9 N$B ; SUnwl H8 29 N$B ; – „ CwHn

XRCE‡™QPm*]knwl‡™XR‡™]kn‡Qinw]kX<Q^S†XR‡Q`¶wH*l%f1“”HHV#X^Hnwl ; Fš‡™nE‡‰FS†™™Y4QZ]IXZC1SUX:QZXZTEXRXRHG\R‡‰nwx4‡™n…°USU\R‡SUnwm*Hd‡™Q:QRSUXR‡™QZ¶wHGl –

R”Y m*]kn…°kHGn…XR‡™]kn×f-“”HsQ`C1SU™Q`‡™FšjE™Y“i\Z‡™XRH: ‡™nEQZX^H*Skl·]k8“iCwHn­FHn#XZ‡]knW‡™nwxšSIj1S†\RXR‡™mGTESU\PQZX^SUX^H:‡Q

nw]kXP\^H ƒTE‡™\RH*l –

:

P ! <;G >=! /? P '@ P

1E\^]kF XRCwHlEHG¶EnW‡™XR‡™]kn­]kìS\ZTEn¹]kìS ! f-“”Hm@SUn¹QRS@YeXRCwSUXdS\ZTEn­‡Q›SQRH ƒTwHnwm*H4]khXZTEjEHGQ¬]k°USU‰TwH*Q

‡™n­lW]kFS†‡™nwQ:HV#X^HnwlEHGl¹“i‡‰XRC·XZCwHsH VXZ\œSQ`Y…Fs’%]U– ›H*Q`Y…nwm^CE\^]UnE‡¯‡™nwxSI\ZTEn?SUFI]kTEn…X^Q:X^]l‡QRm*SU\^l‡™nwx

XRCwH!QZY…nwm^CE\R]knE‡™¯@SUXZ‡]kn ’1SU\R\Z‡H\^QPlEHG¶WnE‡™nwxšXRCwHQZTEm*m*HGQRQ`‡™°uHs\RH@SkmXR‡™]knwQ*–+<HGnEm*Hkf6±]k\:H@Skm^Ce°kS†\R‡‘S†’EHp-"y #If

“=H]knE‰Y²…nw]+“ XZCwH³]k\^lWHG\^HGl QZH ƒTwHnwm*H!]k-Ÿ^ œ£+ ¥w¡ì°kS†™TwHGQ*–hB=C…TwQ:lEH*Q`Y#nEm^CE\^]knW‡¯G‡‰nwxIS4\ZTEn SUF]UTEn…X^Q8X^]

FS†jEjE‡™nExS £+ #A*1 ¥%œ Iž2Bs¡t ™ œ£š]Uì°USU‰TwH*Q<‡™n¹lE]kFSU‡‰nwQ›H VXRHGnwlWH*l “i‡‰XRC­XZCwHHV#XR\^SQZY…Fs’-]kf ‡™n…X^]S

¡ Z ™ ž2B¬£+ #A*w ¥%œ œ£]k'jW\^H*QZHGn…X:°kS†™TwHGQ*fE]knEHQZH ƒTwHnwm*Hj%H\:°USU\Z‡‘SU’WHk–.B=CE‡Q8‡™Q8±]k\RFSU™‡™¯*HGl’%H]+“³–

1w]k\pUefZY C QF \[Z[Z[ S\RTWn ]U†6›f“=H4lEHGm*]kFšj-]uQRH4QZX^SUX^H DC4SkQ3DC H8DCX+-/. NcxFEHG–4B=C…TwQ³“=Hšm@SUn

\^H“i\R‡™XRH\RTEn UŒSkQd±]k™™]+“PQ*)pUS HcU+-/.cN8xFEHGhf “iCwH\^H U+-/.fZYA+-/. Ct+-/. [Z[Z[ DCX+-/. [Z[Z[–JI<]+“³fH@SUm^C

U+->.h‡™QmG]kFšjE\^HGQRQRHGl¸’…Y¹lEHG™HGXZ‡™nwxXRCE]uQRHHC/+->.hXZC1SUX!SU\^H4H …TwSU”XR] –1w]k\ZFSU‰™Ykf-HXLK/Y

KC

K-F Z[Z[\[

’%H

XRCwH4Q`TE’wQRH ƒTwHGnwmGH]kMK bC N ONXZ[Z[Z[ QZTwm^C XRC1S†X*HC>+-/.0| –šB=CwHGn?“”HšQZHGX*)*UP HcUQP/+->.cN8xFEDGf“iCEHG\^H

UQP/+-/. }DC +->. DC 1 +->. DC 3 +->. Z[Z[\[–.B=CE‡QìlEHG¶WnwH*Q”]kTE\›¢# œ£¤U¥%œ¦#Ÿ^ž†¥w§©¨+ªk¡§«ž†¥šª/-§‘¥XEUSRTU UQPUfSUnwlšH@SUm^C

U P +-/. }DC +->. DC 1 +->. DC 3 +->. Z[Z[\[ ‡Qim*SU™™H*l S V:ž>X˜‡™nXRCEHQZH ƒTwHµ–

B=CEH!SUQZY…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTwQ›SU’wQ`XR\œSUmGXR‡™]kn]k.S ! 6 &78# 9:<;>= f‡QilEH¶EnwH*leSkQ8±]k‰]+“PQ*)

6 P

WV-XZY 78# O[

P

=0 "ZJ $

(11)

“iCwHG\RH

[

P|‡Q XZCwH.SUFš‡™™YP]UESU‰ ")SkQZY…nwm^CW\^]knw]UTwQ $ \RTEnEQUP†f+“i‡‰XRC*U\œSUnExk‡™nwxi]+°kHG\XRCwHQZHGX]k ")Q`Y…nwm^CE\^]Unw]kTwQ $

\RTEnEQ<]k6›– 1w]k\E6PdKK78#d9 d <; d=Lv_ N ON fW“”HlEHG¶EnEH)

6 PC E P 6 PF

WV-XZY 7c# O[

P

=p “iCwHG\RH 5 # #KCLi # F

[ P [ PC J P [ PF " 2 $

SUnwl J P lEHGnE]kX^HGQm*]Unk_¼TEnwmXR‡]Un ]U8QRHX^Q!]k8SUQZY…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTwQ\RTEnEQ*f'“iCW‡m^C¸“”HšlEHG¶EnEHšnw]+“³– 11]U\DUPd y

[ Pd

H_ N ON f-“=H4Q^S@Y XRC1SUX3UP

C

SUnwl UQP

F

SU\^H #¥w§ ª*™ “i\R‡‰XRX^Hn UQP

C P*UQP

F

f ‡™hXZCwHs±]k™™]+“i‡™nwxIm*]knwl‡™XR‡™]kn

Cw]k™lEQ*) ^ - yJ# C?# FRVUQP

C +->. }UQP

F +-/.)–.´µUQP

C

S†nwlUQP

F

SU\RHiTEnE‡™¶wSU’EHUfƒXRCwHn“”H›lEH¶EnwH0UP WV-XZYUQP

C J P"UQP

F

SkQ*)

^ -yJ# C1# F V U P +-/. }U

PC +-/. U P

F +-/.

^ -y#KC E# F V U P +-/. }U PC +-/.

^ -y# F E#KC V U P +-/. }U

P

F +-/.

1'‡™nwSU™‰Yuf [ P¬‡™Q:XZCwH!QZHGX<]k.XZCwH!QZ]lEH¶EnwHGlUQP†–iB=C…TwQ¬SkQ`Y…nwm^CE\^]Unw]kTwQ¬mG]kFšj%]uQ`‡™XZ‡]knjE\R]mGH*HGlEQ<°…‡‘STEnE‡‰¶WŠ

m@SUXZ‡]kn ]k'QZCwSU\^HGl -w]+“PQG–

Ò  ~ Õ Ò {S!y{

Ò  ~ Õ Ò b8XPXRCE‡™Q8j%]U‡™n…XiX‹“=]4n1SUXZTE\œS† ƒTwH*Q`XR‡]UnwQ›S†\R‡QZHkfWnwSUFH™Y )

Ñ

{}

Õ

Ñ { Ò  ~ Õ

&(

? {

'Ñ !#"

´‹Q=\RH*Q`Y#nEm^CE\^]knW‡¯@S†XR‡]Un±H@SkQ`‡™’E™H¬SUnwlTWnE‡ƒTwH™YIlEHŠ

¶EnwHGl J¸ž†Ÿœ 3-Ÿ^ œ§™£+  ¤&¬§™£§‘¡P1ž+£œ£§ *™ I¡‹ž·Ÿ^ œœž†¥W£¡Ÿ w¡ #¥w§A*1  ¤?ªe£¤†¥%œ¦#Ÿœž†¥%žƒ£IŸ ¥QU ž2Bž#Ÿ !

B Ÿ^ž ª¢# œ£¤…œ¦#Ÿ^ž†¥w§™£+ R¢IŸ #¥"UQP

Ñ {} Õ

RÖ Ñ { Ò  ~ Õ

&(

?  Õ

)u} Õ " ›]#H*Qm*]kFšFsTEnW‡m@S†XR‡]Un›’-HGC1S@°uHhH …TW‡™°USUHn…XR™Y

±]k\¬’-]kXRC¹XZCwHQZY…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTEQSUnEl¹SkQZY…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTEQ!mG]kFIj-]uQ`‡™XR‡™]knwQ Jºž†Ÿ^ e-Ÿ^ œ§™£+  ¤ <¢#ž+ œ£¡‘¦w  B@ž™ž>X§‘¥X

-Ÿ^žv1 Ÿ¡¤¦wž©¢

6 PC E P 6 PF H86 C E*6BFON P

"«p$

´µƒTwH*Q`XR‡™]kn J³C1Skl·S4j%]kQZ‡™XZ‡™°kH!S†nwQZ“”HG\*f-XRCEHGne“”HmG]kTE™lelEHGQZY…nwm^CE\R]knE‡¯GHSš\ZTEn·]U|XRCEHm*]UnwQZ‡™lEHG\RH*l ! f

SUnwlšXRCwHnQ`XR‡™‰E\^HGm*]+°uH\=XZCwH<]U\R‡xU‡™n1SUQZY…nwm^CW\^]knw]UTwQ=\RTWnזB=C…TwQ8Sdj-]uQZ‡‰XR‡™°kHPSUnwQ`“=H\=X^] ƒTwH*Q`XR‡™]kneJP“”]kTEl

xkT1SU\^SUn…X^HGHPXZC1SUXXZCwHPQZY…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTwQìQRHFS†n#XZ‡mGQh‡™Q.jE\^HGQRH\R°uHGlI“iCwHnlEHGQZY…nwm^CE\R]knE‡™¯@SUXZ‡]knš‡Q|j-HG\Z±]k\RFIH*l4]kn

SšQ`‡™nwxUH ! –

4›n XRCwH]UXRCwH\!C1S†nwl f|‡‰ ƒTwH*Q`XR‡]Un 2C1SUl S j-]uQZ‡‰XR‡™°kHS†nwQZ“”HG\*f.XRCwHnº“=Hm*]kTE™l ‡‰n#XRHG\ZjE\^HXs]kTE\ !

m*]kFšj-]uQZ‡‰XR‡]UnH ƒTE‡‰°kS†HGn…XZ™YSUQ:Q`Y…nwm^CE\^]Unw]kTwQ<]k\:SkQZY…nwm^CW\^]knw]UTwQ*–

PnE±]k\ZXRTEn1S†X^HG‰Yuf|nEHG‡™XZCwHG\Jnw]k\ 2 C1S@°uHj-]uQZ‡‰XR‡‰°uHISUnwQZ“”HG\RQ‡™nºxkHGnwH\œSU«f.lWTwHXR]eXRCEHj%]kQRQZ‡‰’E‡™‰‡™X‹Y¹]k

HVHG\RmG‡™QZ‡™nEx<mG]kn…XR\^]Uƒ’#YdXZCwH“8S@Y³]kWSU’wQZHGnwmGH”‡‰n!Q`Y…nwm^CE\^]Unw]kTwQ'm*]kFšj%]kQZ‡™XZ‡]kn$E”–|´µnXRCwH±]k‰]+“i‡™nwx=QRH*mXR‡™]kn×f

“=HQZCw]+“ XRC1SUX ƒTwH*Q`XR‡]UnwQJS†nwl 2C1S@°kHj%]uQ`‡™XZ‡™°uHISUnwQ`“=H\^QsTEnElEHG\mGHG\ZXœSU‡‰n QZT2#šm‡HGn…XmG]knwlW‡‰XR‡™]knwQ*f‡™n

“iCE‡m^C¸XRCwH4X‹“=] nw]kXZ‡]knwQ³]k ¥6¢#ž+œ¦#Ÿ^ž†¥w¤"±]k\³j-]k‡™n…XšJ $dSUnwlާ™£+ž+œ¦#Ÿœž†¥w¤"±±]k\³j%]U‡™n…X 2 $›jE‘S@Y?Sm*HGn…XZ\œSU

\^]k™Hk–

š w <;idG!

"! #%$'&)(+*',-&).0/1%,32/

´µn XZCE‡QiQZH*mXR‡]Un×fE“=HdTwQZHnE]kXœSUXZ‡]knEQ=‘\^]kFKQRH*mXR‡™]kn pW– 1w]k\:SUn ! 6 K7c# 9:<;>= fwSUnwlR!SUneSkmGm*H*QZQZ‡‰’EH

QZX^SUX^H³]k6›fEXRCwH³m]#m^²…Š‹SU’wQ`XR\œSUmGXR‡™]kn ]k ")lWHGnw]kXRH*l ’#Y"54 $”‡™QilEHG¶WnwH*leSkQi±]k™™]€“PQ$)

^ -)yJ# V

4 +-/. yQA 76?> SUnwlR

4 +->. } ~ C+-/. } ")r $

(12)

1w]k\¬S !

6 78#

<9?v;>=

f`SF¹SUn­SkmGm*HGQRQZ‡‰’EH!QZX^SUX^H±]k\p6›f-SUnwl

% % #If1“=H!Q^S@Y XRC1SUX

‡™Q›S

 ™ž+<{§‘¥DB@ Ÿ^ ¥%œ šž2B k§k ¥ F f%“i\R‡‰XRXRHGn

U

9

f%‡‰±]k\dH*Skm^C?QZXœS†X^H‰]k6›fSkm*mGH*QZQZ‡™’WH‘\R]kF

F f-²…nw]+“i‡™nExXRCwHjW\^H*QZHGnwmGH NkS†’wQRHnwm*HšSUnwl¹SUmGXRTwSU'°USU‰TwHm*SU\R\Z‡HGle’…YeH*Skm^C­°USU\R‡SU’EH³’-HG]Unwxk‡™nExšXR]

f

SU™™]+“PQ”TwQ8XR]lEHGXRHG\RFš‡™nEH›HVWSkmXR‰YXRCEH›jE\^HGQRHnwm*H NkSU’wQZHGnwmGH]kH*Skm^C°kS†\R‡‘S†’EHP’%H]knExk‡™nwxX^] –´µn]kXZCwHG\

“=]U\^lEQz,+

.×TWnE‡ƒTwH™YlWHGX^H\RFš‡™nwHGQe54X+}.)–

´µ=’%]kXZC

U 29 CSUnwl

U 29 FCw]Ul fXRCwHn

U 9 H Ci F N›±]U™]+“PQGfXZC#TEQ!XRCEHG\^H

HV#‡Q`X^Q³Sxk\RH@SUXRH*Q`X Q`Twm^C?XRC1SUX

U 29 Cw]UlEQG–+:HGnwmGHs“=Hm*SUn?m*]knEQZ‡lWHG\¬XZCwHsTEnE‡ …TEHFS€V‡‰FS†

‡™nwm\^H*SkQZ‡‰nwx4QRH ƒTwHnwm*H!]k'QZTE’wQZHGXRQ›]k#šfE±]k\:Sxk‡‰°uHnAFf

#UH b N U 29 # H N N

U 29 #UH N N U 29 [Z[\[ " 0 $

‡™n¹“iCE‡™m^C×f±]U\³H@Skm^C K aKb

f#UH4K NP‡QdXZCwH4xk\^H*SUX^HGQZXQRHX!]U=°USU\R‡SU’E™H*Q¬Q`Twm^C¸XZC1SUXD# H4K T}N N U 9 # H)K N

Cw]k™lEQ*–b<Q

#UHb Nœf#UHN N<m*]knEQZ‡Q`X^Q³‡™n?XRCwHšQZTW’wQRHXs]k”°kS†\R‡‘S†’EHGQ³XZC1SUX!SU\RHšjE\RH*QZHGn…XSkQ³QZ]]knºSkQ³XRCwH

m*]knEQZ‡lWHG\^HGl ! xuHX^QdSUmGXR‡‰°USUX^HGl·]k\¬“iCE‡™m^C?SU\^HSU™“=S@Y#Q³SU’wQRHn…X¬‡™n­Q`Twm*mGH*QZQR]k\QZX^SUX^HGQd]kP F – 4›hm*]kTW\^QRH

QRH …TEHGnwmGH"

0

$=FsTwQ`X<’-H*mG]kFIH!Q`XœSUXZ‡]kn1S†\RYSUX<QR]UFH³¶EnE‡‰X^H K) # H4KM N ND # H)K5Nœ–8´µn·xuHGnwH\œSU«f

“=H]UnE™Y²…nw]+“ XZC1SUX3# H)K+Ne%K#4–—H ƒTwHnwm*H " 0 $:‡Q<m@SU‰HGleXRCwHš£¤U¥%œ¦#Ÿ^ž†¥w§©¨+ªk¡§«ž†¥­£+ #A*w ¥%œ :]k6 ‡™n

QZX^SUX^H*AF–

%

Ñ

±} Õ Ñ Ö Õ  ~ Õ Ò " ! 6 §™£d£*ªk§¢¡‹žU <HGnwlE]#m^CE\R]knw]kTwQ§B B@ž†Ÿs Rª#œ¦eª#œœ œ£œ£§*™ ¬£¡«ªk¡‹ 

AF•ž2Be6# H4K+NlO# ì§ *h§B³¡‘¦w d£¤U¥%œ¦#Ÿ^ž†¥w§©¨+ªk¡§«ž†¥ £+ #A*w ¥%œ 

O# H b N U 9

#UHN N

U 9 # H N N U 9

[Z[Z[ œž†¥k Ÿ‹# œ£³¡‹ž$# "«q$

]knwlW‡‰XR‡™]kn "«q$%H V#jE\^HGQRQRHGQ|XRCwSUX×jE\^HGQRHnwm*H NkSU’wQZHGnwmGH8]kWSU™U°kS†\R‡‘S†’EHGQ m@SUn’-Hh‡‰nE±HG\Z\^HGlš§‘¥%Ÿ^   ¥w¡«ª¤'‘\R]kF

SU™\RH@SklY¬²…nw]+“in°USU™TEH*Qm@SU\Z\R‡™H*l³’#YdjW\^H*QZHGn…X|°USU\Z‡‘SU’WH*Q SUnwlQ`XœSUXRH°kS†\R‡‘S†’EHGQ×]kXZCwH ! ‡™nm*]knEQZ‡lWHG\œS†XR‡]Unז

+<Hnwm*H¹nw]ºX^HGQZX±]k\jE\RH*QZHGnwmGH NkSU’EQRHGnEm*H¸]Un˜XZCwH­HGn…°…‡™\R]knEFIHGn…X‡QnEH*H*lWH*l –oB=CwH­±]k‰]+“i‡™nEx XRCEH*]k\RHGF

_¼TwQZXZ‡™¶wHGQP]kTE\<SUjEjE\R]ƒSkm^C)

Ñ…Õ ~ Ñ

”ž†¥W£§¢# Ÿª ! 6 &78# 9:<;>=

”ž†¥6¢k§‘¡§«ž†¥W£`ªIªk¥6¢[ Dk§k ¥   ™ž>X ªkŸœ  #A*§†ª™ ¥w¡

`ª 6 §™£ ¥6¢#ž+œ¦#Ÿ^ž†¥%ž…£*

[ |ž†Ÿ! Rª#œ¦"!Dy [ P X= sRªk¥·Ÿ^ œœž†¥W£¡Ÿ 1¡ì¡±¦w œž†ŸŸ^ œ£81ž†¥6¢k§‘¥Xs£¤U¥%œ¦#Ÿ^ž†¥%žƒ£dŸ ¥"UŒ£ 1œ¦¡‘¦Wªk¡

UQP #! h§‘¥?ª/#¥w§A*w  Xìªk¤Z ¡‹ž£§™ ¥w¡ìŸ^ Rª#¡§«ž†¥W£*

$ ' ¡ …£4ª†£œ£   6 §™£ ¥6¢#ž+œ¦#Ÿ^ž†¥%žƒ£4ªk¥6¢£¡ #¡)¡‹ Ÿ §‘¥X §‘¥†ªkŸ §ªk¥w¡ &%B 6 78# 9:<;

= §™£Iªk¥%ž†¡‘¦w Ÿ

 ¥6¢#ž+œ¦#Ÿ^ž†¥%ž…£ªk¥6¢4£¡ #¡¡¼ Ÿ §‘¥X§‘¥†ªkŸ §ªk¥w¡ ! ¡‘¦w ¥

Hc6 N P O6

P 7 6 O6 " F $

' ~ Õ Õ

‚ „

HdjE\R]€°kH³QZTwmGm*H*QZQZ‡‰°uHG‰Yj%]k‡‰n…X^QdJ!SUnwl 2–

Ju– „ H<mG]knwQZ‡™lEHG\8S³jW\^HG°…‡™]kTwQìQZXœS†X^HpAFSUnwlšjE\^]+°uH<XRCwHP\^HGQZTE‰X”’…Y‡™nElWTwmGXZ‡]kn – „ H<jE‡™m^²4]kTEX=S&!Dy [ P†f

SUnwl SkQZQZTEFIHd±]k\iXRCwHdFI]kFIHGn…X8XRCwSUXP‡™Xim*SUn ’-H³lEH*mG]kFšj%]uQZH*l‡™n)

C QF [Z[Z[ )(

!

*,+-*./*

021X435'X

+6.7 Y8

7

Y90X + 3

./:

( !;( "«v$

(13)

‡µ–Hk–©fƒ‡™n…X^]!S³QRH ƒTwHnwm*H›]k%™HGnwxkXZC'fƒFSklWH:]U%nw]knŠ‹QZ‡‰Hn#XìQ`XœSUXRH*QZd "±XRCwHPCwH@SUl]k-XRCwH:QZY…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTEQ

\RTWnJU?“”H“i‡Q`CeXR]I\^HGm*]knEQZXR\ZTwmGX $f%±]U™]+“”H*l’…Y XZCwH!X^SU‡™]U.XRCwHSkQZY…nwm^CW\^]knw]UTwQ¬\RTEn!…f1“iCE‡™m^C·“=H

lEHnw]kX^Hd’…Y!;(f1SUnwl“”HSUQRQZTWFHdXRCwSUXPQZTwm^C·SlEH*mG]kFIj-]uQ`‡™XR‡™]kn‡Q8TWnE‡ƒTwHU–”B=CEHGne“”H³mGSU‡™F XRC1S†X

"«v$=‡™QPSUQZ]s°kS†™‡l“i‡‰XRC¹QZTE’EQZXR‡‰XRTEXRH*l’…Y(M Nu– "«t$

B]¸jE\^]+°kH "«t$ f=“”H nw]kXRH XZC1SUX@f”“iCwHGnwH°uH\ ! 6 ‡™QSkmXR‡‰°kS†X^H*lˆ‡™nˆXRCwH m*]knEQZ‡lWHG\^HGl QZX^SUX^HUf8XRCwH

jE\RH*QRHnwm*H NkSU’wQZHGnwmGHs]k'H@Skm^C °USU\R‡SU’E™H›’%H]knExk‡™nwxsXR] # H N>Nh‡Q8²…nw]+“inז R”YSkQZQZTEFšjEXR‡™]kn×fWXZCwH³QZX^SUX^H

4

( C +#UHN N8.¬\RH*Q`TE™XZ‡™nwx ‘\^]UF mG™]m^²ƒŠ‹SU’wQZXZ\œSkmXR‡™]kn×f<CwS+°…‡‰nwxg#UH N NISUQ°USU\Z‡‘SU’WH*QGf:‡™QTEnE‡…TEHG™Y•lEHŠ

X^H\RFš‡™nwHGl – ´µn•XRCEHeQRH ƒTwHG¬“”He“i\Z‡™X^HR 4(

C

HN Ns±]U\Q`Cw]k\RXI‡™nwQ`X^H*Skl ]k 4(

C

+2# H N Nc.«– B=C…TwQ*fijE\RHŠ

QRHnwm*H NkSU’wQZHGnwmGH]k=°USU\Z‡‘SU’WH*Q¬±]U\!Q`XœSUXRH)( CH N N:‡™Q³²…nw]+“in×f'XRCwH4°USU™TwHGQ³m@SU\Z\R‡HGl?’…Y¹jE\RH*QRHn…X°US†Š

\R‡SU’E™H*QiQZXZ‡™‰%C1S@°uH³X^]’-H³lEHGXRHG\RFš‡™nEH*l –

1w]k\PSUn…Y -yJ# C fW“”HdQZ‡‰FIjE‰YXœSU²kH¬XRCwH¬°USU‰TwH›m*SU\R\Z‡HGl’#YIXRCwH¬Fš‡™nW‡™FSUwHG™HGFIHGn…Xi]kXZCwH¬QRH ƒTwHGnwmGH

SkQZQR]#mG‡‘S†X^H*l “i‡™XZC °USU\Z‡‘SU’E™Hp-‡™n !;(–M.ìSU‰TwH*Q:m@SU\Z\R‡™H*l’#Y mG]k\R\RH*QZj-]knwl‡™nwxIQZXœS†X^H³°kS†\R‡‘S†’EHGQPSU\^H³TEjWŠ

lwSUXRH*l4SkmGm*]k\RlW‡™nExk™Yk–|B=C…TwQ.“”H8²…nw]+“ˆXZCwH=jE\RH*QZHGnwmGH:]U\SU’wQZHGnwmGH:SUnwlXZCwH=°USU™TEH=]k1H*Skm^C4‡™nwlW‡‰°…‡lWT1S†

°USU\R‡SU’E™H›‡™n QZX^SUX^H*)( CH N N^–

I<H V#X“”H4F]+°uH]Un mG]knwQ`XR\RTEmGXR‡‰nwxR ( CHN Nœ– 1E\^]UF )( CHN NP“”H4²…nw]+“ 54

( C H N N^–B=C…TwQ³“=H²…nw]+“

Cw]+“ X^]QZjW™‡™X# F”‡‰n#XR]jW\^H*QZHGn…XPSUnElSU’wQZHGn…X=°USU\Z‡‘SU’WH*Q±]k\hXZCwH<mG]knwQ`‡lEH\^H*lQZXœS†X^Hk– „ HPjE‡m^²TEjXRCwH

jE\RH*QRHn…X›]knEH*Q*f6SUnEl\RHGj-H@SUXPXZCwH³Q^SUFIH³SU\^xUTEFHn…X›SUQ8’%H±]k\^HdX^]4xuHXz ( CH N Nœ–

NPHGj-H@SUXZ‡™nwxšXRCE‡™Q›SU\RxkTEFIHGn…X:TEn…XR‡™#UH4K N #o±]k\<QR]UFH³¶EnE‡‰X^H K "’…Y HGnwlE]#m^CE\R]kn…Y·SkQZQZTEFšjEXZ‡]kn $ f

jE\R]€°kH*Q:mGSU‡™F"«t$ –

‡™°uHnXZCwH:‡‰nE‡™XZ‡‘SUEm*]knwl‡™XR‡™]kn4±]k\ !…fƒ“”H›xuHX”‘\R]kF "«t$ fƒ’#Y4‡‰nwlWTwmXR‡]Un×fƒXRCwH:lEH*Q`‡™\RH*ljE\R]]U%XRCwSUX&`ª

7 [ †–

„ HQZC1SU‰|nw]+“MjE\^]+°kH [ 7 `ª „ H4SkQRQ`TEFIHsXRC1SUX*6 ‡Q<nw]kXdHnwlE]#m^CE\^]knE]kTwQ*fSUnEl?Q`Cw]+“ XZC1SUX

m*]UnwlW‡™XZ‡]kn "±’ $|m@S†nEnw]kX’-HPQ^SUXZ‡QZ¶EH*l –.´µL6º‡Q.nw]kXhHnwlE]#m^CE\^]Unw]kTwQGf…XZCwHG\RHiFsTwQZX’-HPQR]kFIHPSkmGm*H*QZQZ‡‰’EH

QZX^SUX^H AF•±]k\4“iCE‡™m^C QRH …TEHGnwmGH "«q$slE]#H*Qšnw]kXIm*]kn…°uH\^xuH X^] #I– B=C…TwQ*fPSkxuSU‡™n×fì“=H jE‡m^²Œ]UTEXS

!Dy

[

P†fwlEH*mG]kFšj%]uQZH*l‡™nXZCwH³Q^SUFIHd“8S@Y SkQ8‡‰n ±]U\RFsTES"«v$ )

C QF [Z[Z[ )(

!

( F

*,+-*.* 0 1X35'X

+6.7 Y8

! (

SUnwl4“”H<SUQRQZTWFHi‡™nISklWlW‡™XZ‡]knsXZC1SUX)(O F fuXZCwHPxk‡™°kHGnIQZXœS†X^Hi±]k\.“iCE‡™m^CHnwlE]#m^CE\^]Un#Y‡™Q.°…‡]kSUX^HGl –

„ H·nw]+“ QZCE]€“ XRC1S†X "«t$I‡™Qnw]kXQ^SUXZ‡QZ¶EH*l – 5×HX K b ’-H·XRCwH­Q`FS†™HGQZXI‡™nwlEH V Q`Twm^C XZC1SUX

#UH4K N # H)K MWN N^fh“”H²…nw]+“ #+C #I–ºB=C…TwQ4“”Hm@SUn| SUjEjE‰Y XZCwHSU™xu]k\R‡‰XRCEF ]k:m*SkQRH¹J±]k\

\^HGm*]knEQZXR\ZTwmGXZ‡™nwx XRCwH4\^H*SkmGXZ‡]kn fTWn#XZ‡™h°USU\R‡SU’E™H*Qd]k†#/C*–B=CwHn¸jE\RH*QZHGnwmGH NkSU’EQRHGnEm*H±]k\³°USU\R‡SU’E™H*Q

’-HG]Unwxk‡™nEx³XR]?# #/Chm*SUnEnw]UX”’-H<lWHGX^H\RFš‡™nwHGlI’1SUQRH*l]knIXZCwH<²…nw]+“i™H*lExuH:]k °USU\Z‡‘SU’WH*Q.’-HG™]knwxk‡‰nwx

X^]R#+C –IB=CE‡Q³FIH@SUnwQdXZC1SUX³XRCwH\^HšHV#‡Q`XQRHG°kHG\^SU”j-]uQZQZ‡™’WHHV#XRHGnwQ`‡]knwQ!]k 4

( C

H)KMON N›SUnwl?XRCwH

HzMQN N)еXRCI\^H*SkmGXZ‡]knš‡Qnw]kXìlEHX^H\RFš‡™nwHGlI‡™nSdTEnE‡ƒTwHP“=S+Yk– +<Hnwm*H<m*]knwl‡™XR‡™]kn "’ $.lE]#H*Qhnw]kXìCw]k™l –

2– 5×HGXiTwQ:SkQZQZTEFIH36 ‡™Q8HGnElE]m^CW\^]knw]UTwQ*f6SUnwlmG]knwQZ‡™lEHG\e6

SkQ8‡‰nj%]U‡™n…X 2s]kXRCwHdXZCwH*]k\RHGF –b›Q8’-]kXRC

6 S†nwl 6

SU\RH³QZXRTWXRX^H\R‡‰nwx‡™n…°USU\R‡SUn…X@fj-]k‡‰n#X 2‡™QPSUn‡™FšFHGlW‡‘SUXRH›mG]knwQRH ƒTwHGnwmGHs]kj%]U‡™n…XdJu–

AdÇ1Î !

Ju–Pg.nwlE]#m^CE\^]Un#Y­‡™Q›nw]kX³lWH*mG‡™lwSU’E™H‡™n¹xkHGnwH\œSU«– +<]+“”HG°kHG\@f‡™X<‡QdlEHGmG‡lESU’EH!±]k\ ! ]knW™Y ‡™n…°u]k‰°…‡™nwx

°USU\R‡SU’E™H*Q!“i‡‰XRCº¶WnE‡™XRHlE]kFSU‡™nEQ!]kP°USU‰TwH*QGfhSUnwlºFI]lEH=m^CEH*m^²…‡™nwx¹m*SUn ’%HITwQRHGlŒ±]U\sXRC1S†X@– 1w]k\

xuHnwHG\^SU ! fhFI]#lEHGim^CEH*m^²…‡™nwx?m@S†nˆ’-HTwQZH*l f쇙nŒm*]UFs’E‡™nwSUXR‡™]kn¸“i‡‰XRCŽSU’wQ`XR\œSUmGXR‡™]kn X^HGm^CEnE‡…TEH*Q*–

(14)

B=CwHPm@SUQRHP]k1‡™n…X^H\^HGQZXh‡Q|“iCEHGnšXRCwHPm^C1SU‡‰n #UH

b N # H N N Z[Z[Z[

lE]#H*Qnw]kXhlEHj%Hnwl4TEj%]UnšXZCwH8j1SU\ZXR‡™mGTESU\

QZX^SUX^H? F f%SUnEle“=H!“i\R‡™XRHQ`‡™FšjE™Yk# H)K N U #UH4KDM N N=‡™n XRCE‡™Q›m@SUQRHk–›B=CE‡Q¬SU’wQZXZ\œSkmXR‡™]kneY…‡HlEQPX^]

SQZT2#šm‡HGn…X<m*]knElW‡™XZ‡]kn]k'HGnElE]m^CW\^]kn…Yu–

2–PB=CwHjE\R]]UP]kiXRCE‡™QXRCEH*]k\RHGF ‡™nºSkmXsjE\R]€°…‡™lEH*Q4SUnºH$1-H*mGXZ‡™°kHSUxu]U\R‡™XZCEF ±]k\!XRCwH]UnWеXZCwHŠ -EY \RHŠ

m*]UnwQZXZ\RTwmXR‡]Un ]k8XZCwHIQ`Twm*mGH*QZQZ‡™°kH\^H@SUmGXR‡™]knwQ³‘\^]kF S lEH*Q`Y…nwm^CE\^]UnE‡¯GH*l \RTEnº]kiSUnºHGnwlE]#m^CE\R]knw]kTwQ

jE\R]uxk\œS†Fe–

Ç B^ÇwÈ'Ï 6Å#Ç

Ñ  6 ' Ñ {k‚

q

SQZ‡‰nwxkH Š‹m]#m^²uH*l ! –

q

! »

r H i½œfU“iCEHG\^H

r ISU\RH”XRCEH8X‹“=]¬‡‰nEjETEXRQ*fƒSUnEl

r

‡™Q|’%]#]k™H@SUnזB=CwHim]#m^²

]k

r

mG]k‡™nEmG‡lWH*Q³“i‡™XRC?XRCEHSkmXR‡™°USUXZ‡]kn?m]#m^²­±]k\³XRCE‡™Q ! f|S†nwl XZC#TEQ?#UHN N h

r –B=CEHGn×f

²…nw]+“i‡™nwxPXRCEHh°USU‰TwH±]k\

r

‡™nElW‡m*SUX^HGQ “iCwHGXZCwHG\']k\nw]kX!‡™Q×jE\^HGQRHGn…X*fUXRC…TwQ#UH N Nl r #I–

 Õ } Ñ ~ ÓRÑ  6 'Ñ ‚ ! » MH+ ~ Ñ { Ñ

} .$E + ~ Ñ { Ñ } r

.cN } Ñ

[Z[Z[½³‡QPnw]kX<HGnwlE]#m^CE\R]knw]kTwQGf×SkQ

XRCEHsHGn…°…‡™\R]knEFIHGn…X¬‡QP‘\^HGHX^]]1%H\dSUn…Yem*]kFs’W‡™n1SUXZ‡]kn ]kjE\RH*QZHGnwmGH NkSU’EQRHGnEm*H±]k\›XZCwHX‹“”]‡™nEjWTEX^Q

r

–ìB=C#TEQ

K#UHb NlK#UHN NlK# H N Nl [\[Z[|}#šf1SUnwlHGnwlW]m^CE\R]kn…YlE]#H*Qinw]kXPCw]k™l –

&)*2 *', $ /. 1 .!" .0/

ba¶E\^Q`X:TEQRH³]k.HnwlE]#m^CE\^]Un#Y‡™QiQZCw]+“in ‡™nXRCEH³±]U™]+“i‡‰nwx¶wxkTW\^H)

1 Φ 2

Ψ 1,2 Φ

´µn4XZCE‡Q|¶ExkTE\^HUf…S›j1SU‡‰\ H86 C 6BFN]k ! ‡Q|lEHGjE‡™mGXRH*l fƒ“i‡™XZC" SUQ.XRCwHiQZHGXh]k-QZC1S†\^H*l°USU\Z‡‘SU’E™H*QG–|B=CwH‡™\

m*]kFšj-]uQZ‡‰XR‡]Un ‡™Qi\^HG“i\Z‡™XZX^HGn·SkQ<±]U™]+“PQ$) 6 C Ep6BF 6 C E$# C%F E36BF+fw“iCwH\^H&#WC%F<‡QiXRCwH\^HGQZXR\Z‡mXR‡]Une]k

6 CEp6BF:XR] fECwHnwm*H'# C%F:FI]lWHGQPSQ`Y#nEm^CE\^]knE]kTwQ›mG]kFšFsTEnE‡™m@SUXZ‡]knFIH*lW‡‰TEF – „ H³]k’EX^SU‡™n’…YTwQ`‡™nwx

jE\^]Uj%H\RX‹Y16 E06 }6 ±]k\PH°uH\RY ! 6)

6 CWEp6BF H/6 CE(# C%FKN

2 !

)*

1

EeH+#WC%F E06BF N

!

) * 3 )

6 C E )

6BF "`J $

B=CE‡QFI]lWHGw]k-m*]UFIFsTWnE‡m*SUXR‡™]knsFIH*lW‡‰TEF,# C%Fh‡QHGnElE]m^CW\^]knw]UTwQ*fSUnwlšm*]kFšj-]uQZ‡‰XR‡]Un(6 C E 6BF쇙Q‡™FšjEH Š

FHn…X^H*l’…YXZCwH "H ƒTE‡™°USU™HGn…X $hm*]kFšj-]uQZ‡‰XR‡]Un

)

6 CE

)

6BF+–ì—#‡™nEm*HdSU‰-\ZTEnwQi]k# C%FPSU\RHdSU™QR]\ZTEnwQi]k

)

6 C=SUnwl

XRCwH4±]k\ZFH\d‡Q³HGnwlW]m^CE\R]knw]kTEQ*f'XZCwHGn¸m*]kFšFsTEnW‡m@S†XR‡]Un¹m@SUn ’%H4H ƒTE‡‰°USUHn#XZ™Y·‡‰FIjWHGFIHGn…XRH*l?Skm*mG]k\^l‡™nwx

X^]4j%H\R±HGmGX:QZY…nwm^CE\R]kn…Y ]k\i‘TE™×SkQZY…nwm^CE\R]kn…Yu–

B=CW‡QhSUnwQ`“=H\^Q…TEH*QZXZ‡]kn 2fuCw]+“”HG°kHG\=‡‰XhlE]#H*Qnw]kXhH VXRHGnwlšX^]³nwHGX‹“”]k\Z²Qì]k ! ‡™n…°u]U™°…‡™nwx¬FI]k\RH8XRC1SUn

X‹“=]šnw]#lEH*QG–”B=CEH³±]U™]+“i‡‰nwx¶wxkTW\^H³QZCw]+“PQ<Sm*]kTEn…XRHG\ZеHVWSUFšjEH")

1 Φ 2

Φ Φ

Ψ

Ψ 1 2

B×\œS†nwQZ‡‰XR‡]Un QZY#QZXRHGFIQ-# CSUnwl.# FeSU\RH¹SkQRQ`TEFIH*l XR] ’%H­HnwlE]#m^CE\^]knE]kTwQ*– B=CwHn m*]UFIFsTWnE‡m*SUXR‡™]kn

’%HX‹“=HGHGn 6 CiSUnwlR6 ]kn XRCwH]knwHdC1SUnEl f6SUnwlR6 SUnwlR6BF¬]kn XRCwH³]kXZCwHG\:C1SUnEl f1m@SUn ’%HlEHGQZY…nwm^CE\R]knE‡¯GH*l –

(15)

:nE±]U\RXRTWn1SUX^H™Ykf.m*]kFšFsTEnW‡m@S†XR‡]Un?’-HGX‹“”H*Hn 6 CSUnwl6BFs°…‡S 6 m@SUnWnw]kX@f|SkQ!‡‰X!‡™Q!nw]UX!XZ\RTwH‡‰nºxuHnwHG\^SU

XRC1S†X # C E6 E # FI‡QšHGnElE]m^CW\^]knw]UTwQ*–˜B=CwH jE\^]k’WHGF ‡™QšXZC1SUXšHGnElE]m^CW\^]kn…Yˆ‡Q4nw]kXIm*]kFšj%]kQZ‡™XZ‡]knwSUµf

CwHGnEm*H HG°uHn HGnEQZTE\Z‡™nwx­‡™nŽSklWlW‡™XZ‡]kn XZC1SUX 6o‡‰X^QZHG™P‡™QšHnwlE]#m^CE\^]Unw]kTwQ4lE]#H*Q4nw]kX“”]k\R²º]kTEX@–ˆB=C…TwQ4“=H

“=]UTEl¹nwH*HGl XR] HnwQZTW\^H4XRC1SUX'# C # F!SkQd“=H™ìSkQ$# C E‰6 E# FS†\^H4SU‰HGnwlW]m^CE\R]knw]kTEQ*–IB=CE‡Q³m@S†nEnw]kX

’%Hšm*]UnwQZ‡™lEHG\RH*lºSUQSUn¸SklEH ƒT1SUX^HIQR]k‰TEXR‡™]kn¹“iCwHGn nwHGX‹“”]k\Z²Q]k=jE\R]mGH*QZQRH*QSU\^Hšm*]UnwQZ‡™lEHG\RH*l –B=CEHG\^H±]k\^H

“=H¬FI]+°uH¬]Un‡™n…XR\R]lTwmG‡‰nwx!XZCwHdSU‰X^HG\Zn1SUXZ‡™°uH:nw]kXZ‡]kn]kh§™£+ž+œ¦#Ÿ^ž†¥w¤&1“iCE‡™m^C±]mTwQRQZH*Qi]knmG]kFšFsTEnE‡™m@SUXZ‡]kn×f

SUnwl‡QimG]kFIj-]uQ`‡™XR‡™]kn1SU«–

×IL= '! K <×'! K=! ­

B=CwHenwH V#X\^HGQZTE‰XSklWlW\^HGQRQRHGQXRCEH ƒTwH*Q`XR‡™]kn ]k¬“iCEHGn jE\R]kj%H\RX‹Y "«p $Cw]UlEQG– „ H·S†\^HexU‡™°uHn X‹“”] !

6Pd W78#d 9 d v; d=Lv_ N ON – 5HX #KC # F’-H.XRCEHìQZHGX]k…XZCwHG‡‰\m*]kFšF]Un¬°USU\R‡SU’EHGQ*f+S†nwl*6 O6 C E6BF

XRCwH‡™\”QZY…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTEQ8m*]kFšj-]uQZ‡‰XR‡]Unז 1w]k\”H@SUm^CSkm*mGH*QZQZ‡™’WH:QZXœS†X^Hp›]U 6›f#“”H›lWHGnw]kXRH<’…Y) C WV-XZY,+#KC .-SUnwl

QF WV-XZY ,+# Fv.×XZCwH³\^H*Q`XR\Z‡mGXZ‡]knEQ:]UQZX^SUX^HD\^HGQZj-H*mXR‡™°kHG‰Y XR]6 CPSUnwlR6BF+–8´µX›Q`Cw]kTE™l ’-H³\^HGFš‡™nElEH*lXRC1S†X@f

±]k\ _ N ON f\d.‡™QdSUn Skm*mGH*QZQZ‡™’WHQZX^SUX^H]U 6Pdµ– ]k\Z\^HGQZj-]knwlW‡‰nwxnw]kXœS†XR‡]UnwQpAF FC F

F

±]U\¬j1SkQ`X³QZXœS†X^H*Q

SU\^HdTwQZH*leSkm*mG]k\^lW‡‰nwxk‰Yu–

% Ñ ±} Õ ){ Õ  ~ Õ Ò " | ¡ Hc6 C 6BF N  ªEªk§‘Ÿ ž2B ! ªk¥6¢k6h6 CLE6BF  ¡±¦w §‘Ÿ EªkŸRª™ 

œže1ž+£§‘¡)§«ž†¥ 15WŸZªk¥W£§‘¡)§«ž†¥W£ž2B06Pd v_ N ON PªkŸ^  XŸ §‘¡)¡‹ ¥ Hc

F

d \dIN 5 ¦w  B@ž™ž>X§‘¥X œž†¥6¢k§‘¡§«ž†¥W£ " ªk¥6¢

" ªkŸ^ !¢#  ¥% R¢ž†¥(Eªk§‘Ÿ^£ HdHc

FC C*N H8

F

F QF NbNž2Bd¡ŸZªk¥W£§‘¡)§«ž†¥W£ž2BrH86 C 6BFON7

"

0

FC F +#KC„.›ªk¥6¢ F

F F +2# Fv.8¦wž©¢†£MB@ž†Ÿ£+ž ª#œœ œ£œ£§ *™ !£¡«ªk¡‹ * F ž2B 6:§‘¥EªkŸ ¡)§« ©ªkŸ

FC

ªk¥6¢:

F

F

ªkŸ^  #¥w§ ª*™ 

$ !¥%ž†¥% šž2B¡‘¦w £¡«ªk¡¼ œ£ \d v_ fN ON ªkŸ^ £§™ ¥w¡:ž†¥¸¡‘¦w œž ž†¥7†ªkŸ §ª*™ œ£8§  *8§‘¡:§™£¥%ž†¡i¡‘¦w 

Rª†£+ ³¡‘¦Wªk¡R/B@ž†Ÿ¬£+ž 

_ N ON

"\d +-/.O ¦wž©¢†£ B@ž†Ÿ!ª-y

0 C!ªk¥6¢:QFœž†§‘¥%§¢# žk Ÿd¡‘¦w d£+ ¡iž2BijE\^HGQRHGn…Xœž ž†¥?†ªkŸ§ª*™ œ£ì§ *

^ -y V$H> CZ+-/.| SUnwl1QFS+->. |OeN 7 CZ+-/. }QFS+->.

" 41¡«ªk¡¼ œ£* C4ªk¥6¢)QF œž†§‘¥%§¢# šžk Ÿs¡‘¦w ¬“iCw]k™HQRHX ž2Bšœž ž†¥%†ªkŸ §ª*™ œ£i§ *=£¡µªk¡‹ œ£* Cšªk¥6¢ 5F

ªkŸ^  ¥w§

ª*™ §  *

CD},+2# C .'SUnwlRQF O,+# F .'Cw]UlEQ8±]k\PQZ]kFIH!SUm*m*HGQRQ`‡™’E™HQ`XœSUXRH3±]k\e6 [

5 ¦w DEªk§‘Ÿ H86 C

6BFON§™££*ªk§¢?¡‹ž  s‡QZ]m^CW\^]knw]UTwQe§B ªk¥6¢ºž†¥¤¹§B B@ž†Ÿe Rª#œ¦1Eªk§‘Ÿ HbH8 FC

CfN

H8

F

F

5FNdN ž2B

¡)ŸZªk¥W£§‘¡§«ž†¥W£ž2B H86 C 6BFON 8œž†¥6¢k§‘¡§«ž†¥ " §e §« œ£œž†¥6¢k§‘¡)§«ž†¥ "

AdÇ1Î N:]kTExkCE™YºQZj-H@SU²…‡™nExEf8m*]UnwlW‡™XZ‡]knŽ]k<‡QR]#m^CE\R]kn…YŽH V#jE\^HGQRQRHGQXRC1S†XITEnW‡™‘Y…‡™nwx¹]+°uH\ -Ÿ^ œ£+ ¥w¡

m*]kFšFI]kn¹°kS†\R‡‘S†’EHGQ¬‡QdHGnE]kTwxkC X^] xkT1SU\^SUn…X^H*HXZCwHšTWnE‡™¶wm*SUXR‡™]kn?]kìXRCwH4X‹“=] m*]knEQZ‡lWHG\^HGl¸Q`XœSUXRH*Q* C³SUnwl

QF+–

]knwlW‡‰XR‡]Un]k'‡™QR]#m^CE\^]Un#Y‡Q8‡™‰™TwQ`XR\^SUX^HGl]knXRCwHd±]k‰]+“i‡™nwx!¶wxkTE\RH)

1 s [w] 2

s [w]

ö:ü`éGñO]ðRñGô)åùé*ñPô«ä+åíæåíæ×æ«î ô)åíæ†ðZõ<åù÷Eô«ä+ðæðZô×é ÷wó€ê)ðZæ)ðZñ*ô%ü`é _ _=éGñ]œîê)åíîGï+øùðRæ åíæ ðd_8ó+ô‘ö(

(16)

B=CEH:¶wxUTE\^HPlEHjE‡mX^Q*f…±]k\TEnW‡™¶1SU’WHijE\^H°…‡]kTwQhQ`XœSUXRH*Q FC F

F

fƒXRCwHPm*]U\R\^HGQZj-]knwlW‡‰nwxQZXœS†X^H*Q C

QFì“iCEHG\^H

H8

F

d \dN›‡™QS°kS†™‡l¹XR\^SUnwQ`‡™XR‡™]kn?±]k\?6Pd«– B=CwHI¶wxUTE\^HIlEHGjE‡™mGXRQ!XRCEHI‡™n…XRHG\RjW\^HGX^SUXR‡™]kn ]kE C ")m‡™\RmGH4]kn¸XRCwH

H‘X $¬SUnwl QF ")mG‡‰\^mH]kn¹XRCEH4\Z‡xkC…X $<]+°uHG\!QZCwSU\^HGl?°USU\Z‡‘SU’E™H*Q – „ CE‡‰X^H4SUnEl lwSUQZCwHGl¸SU\RH@SkQd\RHGjE\RH*QRHn…X

SU’wQZHGn…X¬S†nwl jW\^H*QZHGn…X:°kS†™TwHGQ*fE\^HGQZj-H*mXR‡™°kHG‰Yu–”B=CwHdX‹“=]šHG‘X:S†nwl\R‡xUC#XPm‡™\RmGHGQ:SU\^HdQ`TEj%H\R‡‰FIj-]uQRHGl ‡‰nXRCwH

FI‡™l m‡™\RmGHU–=´µnexuHGnwH\œSU«fE°uH\RXR‡™m@SU‰™YS†nwl CE]k\R‡™¯*]kn…XœS†™™YlwSkQ`CwH*l­S†\^H@SUQ<lE]4nw]kX<m*]U‡™nwm‡lEHUfwHG°uHn·‡™ CPSUnwl

QFìTEnW‡™‘Ys]+°kHG\ìXRCwHiQ`TE’wQRHX=]U%Q`C1SU\^HGlš°USU\Z‡‘SU’WH*Q'XRC1SUXìS†\^HijE\^HGQRHn#X쏱]k\’-]kXRC4XZ\œSUnwQ`‡™XZ‡]knwQ ")lE]kTW’EH Š‹lwSkQ`CwH*l

SU\^H*S$–4[.‡™mGX^]U\R‡‘S†™™Ykf-TEnW‡™¶wm*SUXR‡™]kn¹]+°uHG\!lE]kTW’EH Š‹lwSkQ`CwH*l SU\RH@SlE]#H*Qdnw]kXd‡‰FIjE‰Y ‡‰n?xuHGnwH\œSUXZC1SUX³lwSUQZCwHGl

SU\^H*SkQ›mG]k‡™nEmG‡lWHk–i´‹QR]#m^CE\R]kn…Y ‡‰nwlEH*HGl \RH ƒTE‡™\RH*Q:XRC1SUX:TEnE‡‰¶wm@S†XR‡]Une]+°uH\dlE]kTW’EH Š‹lwSkQ`CwH*leSU\^H*SIlE]#H*Q:‡™FšjE™Y

XRC1S†X<lESkQZCwHGleS†\^H@SUQ:mG]k‡™nEmG‡lWHkfWCwHnwm*H³TEnE‡‰¶wm@S†XR‡]Un]k C8SUnwlRQF:±]k‰]+“PQ*–

B=CEH³±]U™]+“i‡‰nwxXRCEH*]k\RHGF _¼TwQ`XR‡‰¶wH*Qi‡™n…XZ\^]#lWTwmG‡‰nwxsXRCW‡Q8nw]kXZ‡]kn ]k‡QZ]m^CW\^]kn…Yu–

Ñ…Õ ~ Ñ

%B¬¡±¦w  Eªk§‘ŸH86 C 6BF Nd§™£§™£+ž+œ¦#Ÿ^ž†¥%žƒ£¡‘¦w ¥­§‘¡h£*ªk¡§™£

 œ£-Ÿ^žv1 Ÿ ¡)¤

$

”ž†¥k Ÿ^£+  ¤&rX=  ª†£œ£  §‘¥•ªƒ¢ƒ¢k§‘¡)§«ž†¥ˆ¡±¦Wªk¡E6 Cªk¥6¢R6BF·ªkŸœ  ž†¡‘¦  ¥6¢#ž+œ¦#Ÿ^ž†¥%ž…£*%BI¡±¦w 3Eªk§‘Ÿ

H86 C 6BFON<£*ªk¡§™£  œ£-Ÿ^žv1 Ÿ ¡)¤ 족¦w ¥e§‘¡”§™£§™£+ž+œ¦#Ÿ^ž†¥%žƒ£*

5 ¦ …£=§™£+ž+œ¦#Ÿ^ž†¥w¤§™£sª£ §« ¥w¡<œž†¥6¢k§‘¡§«ž†¥ ž2B -Ÿ^žv1 Ÿ ¡)¤ 8ªk¥6¢§‘¡8§™£ªí£+ž§‘¥JBGª#¡8¥% œœ œ£œ£*ªkŸ ¤UX|¦w ¥

¡±¦w œže1ž†¥% ¥w¡‘£!ªkŸ^ s ¥6¢#ž+œ¦#Ÿ^ž†¥%žƒ£*

AdÇ1Î !

Ju– „ HšC1S@°kHSU™\RH@SklY­lW‡QZmGTwQZQRHGl¸XRCwHš‡™Fšj%]U\RXœS†nwm*H]k=HGnE±]U\^mG‡‰nwxjE\^]kj-HG\ZX‹Y#"«p$ – I<]+“³f'“iC…Y¹‡QdXZCE‡Q

XRCEH*]k\RHGF ‡™n…X^H\^HGQZXR‡‰nwx c SU‡™nE‰Yº’-H*m@S†TwQRH ‡™Xš\^HGjW‘SkmGH*Qšm*]knwl‡™XR‡™]kn "«p$ f=“iCE‡m^Cއ™n…°u]U™°uHGQI‡‰nE¶EnE‡‰X^H

\RTWnwQ*fג…Y­m*]UnwlW‡™XZ‡]kn "7 " ]kh‡QZ]m^CW\^]kn…YufדiCE‡™m^C?]knE™Y ‡™n…°k]k™°kH*Qdj1SU‡‰\^Q¬]kì\^H*SkmGXZ‡]knEQ¬]kìXRCwH

m*]UnwQZ‡™lEHG\RH*l jwSU‡™\i]U ! –

]kFšFHn…X³J!S†’%]kTWX<HnwlE]#m^CE\^]Un#Y S†QR]4S†jEjE™‡™H*Q8±]k\i‡™QR]#m^CE\^]Un#Yk–

' ~ Õ Õ ‚ „ H³QZTEm*m*HGQRQ`‡™°uH™YjE\R]€°kHdj%]k‡‰n…X^QdJ!SUnwl 2–

{ Õ  ~ Õ Ò 'Ñ { '~ Õ Ñ ~+} Ò " B=CwH³jE\^]#]kjE\^]#m*HGH*lEQi‘\^]UFKX‹“=]šQZXRHGjwQ$)

Ju– 5×HGX*6

P

’-HsXRCwHlWH*QZY…nwm^CW\^]knE‡™¯@SUXZ‡]kn ]k6›flEHG¶WnwH*l¹‡™n?H ƒT1S†XR‡]Un "ZJ $ fSUnwl!ky [ P

’-HšSUn SkQZY…nWŠ

m^CE\R]knw]kTwQh\RTWnI]U 6 P†–B=CwH\^HP‡QSUX™H@SkQ`Xh]knwHPm*]U\R\^HGQZj-]knwlW‡‰nwx³QZY…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTEQ”\RTWn)U]kL6ŒQ`Twm^CXZC1SUX

!W UQP†–Pb<n…Y QZTwm^C U¹‡Q:mG™H@SU\Z™YXZCwHQ`Y#nEm^CE\^]knE]kTwQ¬mG]kFIj-]uQ`‡™XR‡™]kn ]k.X‹“”]TEnE‡‰¶1SU’E™Hd\RTEnwQzU C:SUnwl

UF³±]k\*6 CdS†nwl 6BF+f \RH*Q`j%HGmGXR‡‰°uH™Yu–+:HGnwmGHISUQRQR]#mG‡SUX^HGl?SkQZY…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTEQ\ZTEnwQ*UQPC SUnElQUQP

F

SU\^H4SU™QR]

TEnE‡‰¶1SU’E™HkfWSUnwlXRCwH‡™\PSkQ`Y…nwm^CE\^]Unw]kTwQ:m*]kFšj-]uQZ‡‰XR‡]UnUQP

C J PUQP

F

’-HG™]knwxuQ”X^] [ PC J P [ PF

–hB=C…TwQP“=H

SU‰“8S@Y#QiC1S@°uH³XRCwHd‡™nEmG™TEQZ‡]Un)

6 PC E P 6 PF

H86 CE06BFON

P

"`JuJ $

[.\^]+°…‡™nwx "«p$|nw]+“˜SUFI]kTEn…XRQhXR]!XZCwH:jW\^]#]k ]k-XRCwH<m*]kn…°kHG\^QZH›‡™nEmG™TEQZ‡]Unז—]³SU\ì“=HPC1S@°uH›]knE™YTwQRHGl

XRCEHdlEHG¶EnW‡™XR‡™]kn]klEHGQZY…nwm^CE\R]knE‡™¯@SUXZ‡]kn SUnEl SUQZY…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTwQPmG]kFIj-]uQ`‡™XR‡™]kn×fƒ‡QZ]m^CW\^]kn…YšC1SkQ8nw]kX=YuHGX

’-H*HGn TwQZH*l –

(17)

2–P[.\^]+°…‡™nwxXZCwHs]kjWj%]uQ`‡™XRH!‡™nEmG™TEQZ‡]Un×fw\^H ƒTE‡‰\^HGQ¬X^]jE\R]+°uHsXRCwSUX@f6“iCwHGn­FI]+°#‡‰nwx‘\R]kF SkQZY…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTEQ

m*]UFIj-]uQZ‡‰XR‡™]kn4X^]XZCwH<Q`Y…nwm^CE\^]Unw]kTwQi]knEHkfXZCwH¬SUlElW‡™XZ‡]knwSUwm*]UnwQZXZ\œSU‡‰n#XRQ”\RH*QZTW™XR‡‰nwx!‘\R]kF S\RH@SkmXR‡™]knWŠ

j-HG\ZŠ«\^H*SkmGXZ‡]kn FSUX^m^CW‡™nwx ]kTEnE‡‰¶1SU’E™He\RTWnwQ“i‡™™<nw]kX\RH*QZTW™X‡™n \RH`_`H*mXR‡‰nwx j1SU‡™\RQ]k³\RTEnEQXZC1SUX

]kXZCwHG\Z“i‡QRHd“”]kTE™l ’-H¬TEnE‡‰¶1SU’E™H¬‡™nXRCwHSkQ`Y…nwm^CE\^]Unw]kTwQ:QRHnwQRHU–=B=CE‡™Qi‡Q8“iCwH\^H³‡QR]#m^CE\R]kn…Y‡Q8TwQZH*l –

bŒj1SU‡™\/H!5C !FON-]kwSUQZY…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTwQ\RTEnEQ‡™QjW‡m^²uHGl]kTWX'Q`Twm^CsXZC1SUX !5C

P !F )×XRCEHGY³m@S†n’-HìmG]kFs’E‡‰nwH*l

“i‡™XZCXRCwHPSUQZY…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTwQìm*]UFIj-]uQZ‡‰XR‡™]knXR]¬±]k\RF QR]kFIH8\RTWn !M !5C J P !F "mG¼– " 2 $ $ –R”YlEHG¶WnE‡™XZ‡]kn

]kdlWH*QZY…nwm^CW\^]knE‡™¯@SUXZ‡]kn ")mG¼– QZH*mGXZ‡]kn r $f”XRCwH\^HeH V#‡QZXS "QZY…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTwQ $š\RTWn U C4]k36 Cf8SUnwl•S

")Q`Y…nwm^CE\^]Unw]kTwQ $\ZTEn UF]kD6BF+fPQZTwm^C XRCwSUX !d›‡Q]k’WXœSU‡‰nwH*l ’…Y lEH*Q`Y#nEm^CE\^]knW‡¯G‡‰nwx UCdµf _ N ON

"«SUQ“”H¹lE] nw]kX SkQZQZTEFIH¹HGnwlW]m^CE\R]kn…Y˜SUXXRCW‡Qj-]k‡™n…X@fP\RTWn}UCd³‡™Qnw]kXTEnE‡ƒTwHG‰Y•lEHX^HG\ZFI‡‰nwH*l $–

B=C…TwQH*Skm^C?\RTEn UCd쇙QSQ`Twm*mGH*QZQZ‡]Un ]k”QZXœS†X^H*QG– ™H@SU\Z™Yuf ‡‰nwQRH\RXZ‡™nwx¶EnE‡‰X^H™YeFSUn…Y­Q`‡™Hn…X³QZXœS†X^H*Q

’-HGX‹“”H*HGn QZTEm*m*HGQRQ`‡™°uHQZX^SUX^HGQi]k UCdד”]kTElS†QR]!jE\^]+°…‡lEH<°kS†™‡lm@SUnwl‡lwSUXRH*Q=±]U\=\^HGm*]+°uH\R‡‰nwx"!dSU‘XRHG\

lEHGQZY…nwm^CE\R]knE‡¯*SUXR‡™]knז „ HQ`C1SU‰×QZCw]+“³fw’…Y‡™nElWTwmGXZ‡]kn ]+°uH\PXRCwH³QZTEm*m*HGQRQ`‡™°uHQZXœS†X^H*QGfEXRC1S†X )

jE\R]kj%H\R‰Y‡™nEQRHG\ZXR‡‰nwxQZTwm^CeQZ‡‰HGn…XPQ`XœSUXRH*QP‡™nXRCEH!S†jEjE\^]UjE\R‡SUX^HdmG]kFIj-]knwHn…X

jE\R]lWTEm*H*QPX‹“”]š\ZTEnwQi“iCE‡m^CeSU\RH#¥w§

ª*™ ”‡™nXRCEHQ`Y…nwm^CE\^]Unw]kTwQ<QRHGnEQRHk–

"`J 2 $

B=CE‡™QìFIH@SUnEQìXZC1SUX@f…‘\^]UFoSj1S†‡™\H!QC !FON|QZTEm^CXRC1S†X !QC

P !F+f#“”H<m*SUn\RH*m*]UnwQZXZ\RTwmX "«S†X쐙H@SkQ`X $]knwH

j1SU‡‰\rH‹U C

UFON]U×\RTEnwQ=]k6 C=SUnwl"6BF8XZC1SUXPSU\RH<TEnW‡™¶1SU’WHP‡™nXZCwH¬QZY…nwm^CW\^]knw]UTwQiQRHnwQRHUf1SUnwlXRC…TwQ”‡™X

jE\R]€°kH*QPXRCwH³mG]kn…°uHG\RQRH‡™nwm™TwQ`‡]kn)

6 PC E P 6 PF % Hc6 CWEp6BFON

P [ "`J+p$

1E\^]kF "ZJuJ $4SUnwl "ZJ@p$“”HXRCwHn lEH*lTwm*H jE\^]kj-HG\ZX‹Y "«p$ – B=C…TwQI“”H FI]+°uH ]kn jE\R]+°#‡‰nwx#"ZJ 2 $’…Y

‡™nElWTwmGXZ‡]kn ]+°uH\:QZTwmGm*H*QZQZ‡‰°uHsQ`XœSUXRH*Q*–

5×HGX HcU C

UFON›’%HS j1SU‡‰\]Ui\RTEnwQ!]ke6 CSUnEl6BF+–·ghSkm^CŒ]k=XRCwHF ‡™Q!lEHGm*]kFšj-]uQRHGlº‡™n…X^]eS ¶EnE‡‰X^H

QRH ƒTwHGnwmGH¬]k-HGnExkXRC ]U QZX^SUX^HGQ \d%C K WN Z[Z[Z[ |f…±]k‰]+“=HGl’#Y4XZCwH:X^SU‡™UCd%(³]k%XZCwH:m*]knwQ`‡lEH\^HGl

\RTWn)

\d%C \d%F [Z[Z[ \d%(

!

*,+-*./*

021X435'X

+6.7 Y 8

7

Y90X + 3

./:

( UCd%( "`J@r $

B=CE‡™QP‡™QilE]knwHd‡‰n Q`Twm^C­Ss“=S@YXRC1SUX ^ K WN \[Z[Z[ |fwQ`XœSUXRH*Qe C%C³SUnwlR5F %C³S†\^H¬TEnE‡‰¶1SU’E™Hk–

I<H V#X@f×XRCwHsX^SU‡™UCd%(‡™QdlEH*mG]kFIj-]uQZH*l­‡™n…X^]"UCd%( \d%( C UCd%( C –s´µXd‡™Q¬xuHGnEHG\œS†™™Y nw]kXdXZ\RTwHsXZC1SUX

QZX^SUX^HGQ0 C%( C8S†nwl QF %( C8S†\^HdTEnE‡‰¶1SU’E™Hk–B=CwH³±]k‰]+“i‡™nwx!m@SkQZH*Q:m@SUn ]#m*mGTW\ )

Ï Ç )³nE]knwH4]kìXRCwHX‹“”] Q`XœSUXRH*QDC%( C›SUnwlQ5F %( CdS†\^HQZ‡‰Hn#X³]+°kHG\XRCwH4m*]UFIFI]kn­°USU\R‡SU’E™H*Q

– „ Hm*]knwmGHGn…XR\^SUX^H]kn XRCw]kQRH³°kS†\R‡‘S†’EHGQ†-y XRC1S†X›S†\^HdjE\^HGQRHn#X<‡™n’-]kXRC QZX^SUX^HGQ0 C%( C

SUnwl)QF %( C –|b›Q !5C

P !FhCw]klWQ*fƒXRCwHn“”H:FTwQZXhC1S@°uHz C%( CZ+-/.OQF %( C\+-/.w±]k\ìSUn…Y4Q`Twm^C-1–

B=C…TwQ.j-]k‡™n…X^Q”Juf2›SUnwlp<]k1m*]knElW‡™XZ‡]kn " ]kE‡™QR]#m^CE\^]kn…YSU\^H=Q^SUXZ‡QZ¶EH*l –;+<HGnEm*Hkfu’…Y!‡QR]#m^CE\R]kn…Yuf

C%( C=SUnwlRQF %( C=SU\RH³‡‰nwlEHGH*lTEnE‡™¶wSU’EH<‡™nXRCE‡™Qim@SkQZHk–

Ï

Ç )'’-]kXRCQZXœS†X^H*Q C%( C.SUnwlQF %( ChSU\RH<Q`‡™Hn…X”]+°kHG\=XZCwH:m*]kFšF]UnI°USU\Z‡‘SU’E™H*Q –B=CwHYISU\^H

TEnE‡‰¶1SU’E™Hk–

Ï Ç )”]knEHSUnEle]knE‰Y]knwH]k'XRCwH³X‹“=]IQZX^SUX^HGQ0 C%( CiSUnwlRQF %( C8‡™QPQZ‡™™HGn…X:]+°uHG\<XRCwH³mG]kFIFI]kn

°USU\R‡SU’E™H*Q –RìYsQZY…FIHGXZ\RY4SUnEl4“i‡‰XRCw]UTEX]uQ`‡™nwx›xuHGnwH\œSU‰‡™X‹YkfuQZX^SUX^He C%( C‡Q.SkQRQ`TEFHGlšXR]d’%H

QZ‡‰Hn#X:]+°uH\ f ^ -1y V C%( CZ+-/.K 4–P´µn·XZCE‡Q:m@SkQZH!“”H!TEnW‡™‘YQZX^SUX^H: C%( C8“i‡‰XRC XRCwH

QZ‡‰Hn#XhQ`XœSUXRHP]k 6BF+fu‡«–ùHU–‰fƒXZC1SUnE²#QX^]³QZXZTEXRXRHG\Z‡™nwx³‡™n…°USU\R‡SUnwmGHkf/UF %(d‡™Q.\^H*lWHG¶EnwHGlSUnElIQ`XR\^HX^m^CwHGl

SkQi±]k‰]+“PQ*)

UF %( V QF %( C UF %( C

!

XV-X

+

XV

. * 028 31

OP'ÿORQ

(18)

“iCwH\^HD lEHGnw]UX^H*QiXZCwH³QZ‡™™HGn…XPQZX^SUX^HU–

B=CE‡™QPjW\^]+°uHGQ:XZC1SUXi‡™nElWTwmGXZ‡]knC…Y…j%]UXRCwHGQZ‡Q "ZJ*r $ìCw]k™lEQi“iCwHGn ­‡Q8\RHGjESkm*HGl ’…Y M Nk–

Ö Ñ ~ Ñ Ö Õ  ~ Õ Ò Õ } Ñ  Õ 6 Õ Ñ

}€{ * '~ Õ Ñ ~+} Ò " 6 ' Ñ { ){ Õ  ~ Õ Ò 1E\^]UF

B=CwH*]U\^HGF Jš“=H4²…nw]+“ XRC1SUX*f‡‰n¸]UTE\!jW\^]#]k=]U8j%]U‡™n…X4J]k”XRCwHG]k\^HF 2fXRCwHIQZY…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTwQ\RTEnEQ:UCd=SU\^H

TEnE‡…TEHG™Y•lEHG¶EnEH*l f¬TEj XR]ŽQ`‡™Hn…XQZXœS†X^H*QGf›‘\^]UF XRCEHG‡™\lWH*QZY…nwm^CW\^]knE‡™¯*HGl m*]kTWn#XRHG\Zj1SU\RXRQkUQP

d – „ H·nw]+“

±]mTwQ›]Un

Ï Ç 4]U.XRCE‡™Q:SU\^xkTWFHn#X*–i´µ.‡QZ]m^CW\^]kn…Y‡Qinw]kX<Q^S†XR‡Q`¶wH*l%f6XZCwHGn×f1±]k\<QR]kFIH³j1SU‡™\ H‹UQP C UQP

F

N8]k

TEnE‡‰¶1SU’E™H¬SkQ`Y#nEm^CE\^]knE]kTwQi\RTEnEQ*fwSUnEl QZ]kFIH›lEHGm*]kFšj%]kQZ‡™XZ‡]kn "ZJ@r$”]k×XRCEHGF fW‡™X”±]k™™]€“PQhXRCwSUX8j-]k‡™n…X^Q›Juf32#fíp

]km*]knElW‡™XZ‡]kn " ]k‡QR]#m^CE\R]kn…YSU\RHdQ^SUXZ‡Q`¶wH*l f#’ETEXPQ`XœSUXRH*QE C%( C”SUnElk5F %( C”SU\^H¥%ž†¡%TEnE‡‰¶1SU’E™Hk–.b<Q8]kTE\

]knE‰Y j-]uQRQ`‡™’E‡‰™‡‰X‹Y·‡QX^]·XR\ZY XR]e‡™nEQRHG\ZXQZ‡‰Hn#XQZX^SUX^HGQs±]k\s]knEH]kiXRCEHX‹“=]¹mG]kFIj-]knwHn…X^Q¹nE]kXs±H@SUQZ‡™’WH

‡™n

Ï Ç e]kTW\¬jE\^]#m*HGQRQ³]kh‡™nEmG\^HFHn…XœSU.TWnE‡™¶wm*SUXR‡™]kn­]kn Sj-HG\d\RH@SkmXR‡]Un­’1SkQZ‡™Q¬SU‡™™Q*–B=C…TwQ "ZJ+p $<‡Q

°…‡]kSUX^HGl fwSUnwlQZ]š‡™Q8jE\^]kj-HG\ZX‹Y "«p $–hB=CE‡™QP¶WnE‡Q`CwH*QiXRCEH³jW\^]#]k|]U'XZCwHdXRCwHG]k\^HFe–

b:ne‡‰n#XRHG\RH*QZXZ‡™nwx4‡™FšFIH*lW‡SUX^H¬’…Y…jE\^]#lWTwmX›‡™QPXZCwHH V#X^HGnEQZ‡]Un­]k|XZCwH*QZH!\RH*QZTW™X^Q<]kn·lWH*QZY…nwm^CW\^]knE‡™¯@SUXZ‡]kn

X^]4nwHGX‹“”]k\Z²Q:]k'm*]kFšFsTEnW‡m@S†XR‡™nExsQZY…nwm^CE\R]knw]kTEQ›m*]UFIj-]knwHn#XRQ*)

9 Õ ~ Õ ' 'E~

Ò RÖ

Ñ { Ò  ~ Õ

&(

 Ñ }

ÔsÕ

~

Õ  Õ 6

Õ Ñ }€{"

' ¡GH86 C+N C C% %  <ª BGª §¤ž2B

!

' ¡>…£ª†£œ£  ³¡‘¦Wªk¡P Rª#œ¦*Eªk§‘Ÿ Hc6 C 6 CcN¬§™£³§™£+ž+œ¦#Ÿ^ž†¥%ž…£¡±¦w ¥

|ž†Ÿ Rª#œ¦ ¢k§™£@ž†§‘¥w¡.£ £+ ¡‘£ ªk¥6¢˜ž2B›£+ ¡>N Z[\[Z[\Q ¡±¦w  Eªk§‘Ÿ

E C E

6 C E

CE

6 C "`J 0 $

§™£§™£+ž+œ¦#Ÿ^ž†¥%ž…£*

$ í£+ž ”¢# œ£¤†¥%œ¦#Ÿ^ž†¥w§©¨+ªk¡)§«ž†¥¹  ou¡¼ ¥6¢†£¡‹žš¡±¦w d¥% ¡IX=ž†Ÿv{

H86 C E [Z[Z[

E*6 N P 6 PC E P

[Z[Z[

E P 6 P [

"`J+q$

' ~ Õ Õ ‚

Ju–i´µXP‡QiQ`T2#šmG‡Hn…X<XR]4jW\^]+°uHdXRCEH³±]U™]+“i‡‰nwx\^HGQZXZ\R‡mX^HGl m*SkQRH]k "ZJ

0 $ )

H # 6 CdN8S†nwl H # 6BFON”SU\RH³‡™QR]#m^CE\^]Unw]kTwQ 7 H # 6 CWE06BFONh‡Q8‡™QR]#m^CE\^]Unw]kTwQ "`J&F $

SkQ "`J 0 $:±]k‰]+“PQ<°…‡S]k’…°#‡™]kTwQ¬‡‰nwlWTwmXR‡]Un­]kn¹XRCwHm*SU\^l‡™n1SU‰‡™X‹Y]k”QRHX^QeSUnwl|–B=C…TwQd“=H±]#mGTwQ

]knjW\^]+°…‡™nwx "ZJ&F $ – 5×HGX H8AF N.SUnwl H vF fN.’-H<X‹“”]sj1SU‡‰\^Qì]k×Q`Twm*mGH*QRQ`‡™°kHQ`XœSUXRH*Q”]k# SUnwl"6 C E$6BF

\^HGQZj-H*mXR‡™°kHG‰Yuf“iCE‡m^C Q^SUXZ‡Q`‘Y·m*]UnwlW‡™XZ‡]kn " ]U”‡™QR]#m^CE\^]kn…Ykf‡‰n?lEHG¶EnW‡™XR‡™]kn 2–5×HGX<’%HsXZCwH4m*]kF4Š

j-]uQZ‡‰XR‡]Un "±TEnE‡™¶Em@SUXZ‡]kn $d]k8XZCwHIX‹“”]­QZX^SUX^HGQ‰ CSUnwl@5F]ke6 CSUnwl@6BF+f|\^HGQZj-H*mGXZ‡™°kHG™Yk– R”Y¹j-]k‡™n…X

2·]k " fhSUXH*SkQZXs]knwH]kPXRCwHGQRHX‹“”] Q`XœSUXRH*Q‡Qsnw]UXQZ‡‰HGn…X*f”S†nwl “=H SkQZQZTEFIH1C‡™Qsnw]kX4QZ‡‰Hn#X*–

1E\^]kF j%]k‡‰n…X=p]k " fX<SUnwl C.m*]k‡‰nwmG‡™lEHP]€°kHG\”XRCwH:QRHX=]kj-Ÿœ œ£+ ¥w¡wmG]kFšF]kn4°USU\Z‡‘SU’E™H*QGf…SUnwlIXZC…TwQ*f

QZ‡‰nwm*H!j1SU‡™\WH # 6 CdNi‡QP‡QZ]m^CE\R]knw]kTEQ*f Q`XœSUXRH*Q SUnwlC:mG]k‡™nEmG‡lWH!]+°uH\dXRCwH X|¦wž™ :QRHXd]kmG]kFIFI]kn

°USU\R‡SU’E™H*Qh]k# SUnEl"6 C –hB=C…TwQ$¬SUnEl CìSU\RH:TEnW‡™¶1SU’WHk–R”TEX@f#]knIXRCwH<]kXRCwH\”CwSUnwl fC CìSUnwl5F8SU\^H

SU™QR]4TEnE‡™¶wSU’EHdQ`‡™nwmGHdXRCwHYeS†\^H8_¼TwQZX:\^HGQZXZ\R‡mXR‡™]knwQi]k'XRCwHQ^SUFIH³xk]U’1SU×Q`XœSUXRH 8]k6 CWE 6BF+–8B=C…TwQ

QZX^SUX^HGQ0SUnwl 8S†\^HdTEnE‡‰¶1SU’E™HkfwSUnEljwSU‡™\H # 6 CWE06BFONh‡Q8‡™QR]#m^CE\^]knE]kTwQ*–ìB=CE‡™QijE\^]+°uHGQ "`J&F $ –

2–PB=CwHQRHGm*]knwl QZX^SUX^HFHn…X:‡™QijE\^]+°uHGl °…‡S‡‰nwlWTwmXR‡™]kn ]knXRCwHdn…TEFs’-HG\:]k'm*]kFšj-]knwHGn…XRQ*)

H86 CWE [Z[\[ E06 N P H H6 CWE [Z[\[ E06

F C N E067N

P H6 CWE [Z[Z[ Ep6

F C N P E P 6 P f

SUnwlXRCEH³‡‰nwlWTwmXR‡™]knQZXRHGje±]U™]+“PQ=‘\R]kF "`J 0 $ –

Références

Documents relatifs

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rhˆone-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rhˆone-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rhˆone-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rhˆone-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rhˆone-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rhˆone-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rhˆone-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rhˆone-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST