Formal Validation of Data-Parallel Programs : a Two-Component Assertional Proof System for a Simple Language

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00073660

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00073660

Submitted on 24 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Formal Validation of Data-Parallel Programs : a Two-Component Assertional Proof System for a Simple

Language

Luc Bougé, David Cachera, Yann Le Guyadec, Gil Utard, Bernard Virot

To cite this version:

Luc Bougé, David Cachera, Yann Le Guyadec, Gil Utard, Bernard Virot. Formal Validation of Data- Parallel Programs : a Two-Component Assertional Proof System for a Simple Language. [Research Report] RR-3033, INRIA. 1996. �inria-00073660�

(2)

ISSN 0249-6399

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Formal validation of data-parallel programs:

a two-component assertional proof system for a simple language

Luc Boug´e, David Cachera, Yann Le Guyadec, Gil Utard, Bernard Virot

N ˚ 3033

Novembre 1996

TH `EME 1

(3)

(4)

*,+-/.)012!3''!)2 4$#'65'7!

890':0 !; %<%!

=>?A@BC>DFE

G/HJIKMLN7OQPSR&L

?UT

GWVXL,HJI7Y&L[ZZ

=

G]\

>^

LCP6G

?J_

I\$Oa`"b$cXL/VXPHJI

@

GJV:ZdL[VXP#eOaV

B

cXf

ghi

jlkmjMno prqjXs jlt/u,v1jXwsxCs w

i

jlkjXs

y"z|{/}

jXwpjX~t

y

pt[

{Cz

wj

z

jX

h j z h

j,///o

{J

jlk

z

jAnl[/2o/AtJ/jXs

)XXl7JM

j

z

jXsjl[w&t

z{,{J

sx,swjlk

Q{Cz

t$skA, j$7tJw¡t8¢£t

z

tJ ¤jX¥Jj

z

,jXt/,CutJ/jltJ jX4¦§

gh

s&

z{,{J

s xCsw jlk¨ stJsjX

{

4tw©

{

¢ª

{

kA

{

,jl/wtJssj

z

w

{

«t/,CutJ[j/§

jj:¬,jAtA©jlt/¥jXsw&

z

jX

{

, w

{

,s$ltJ lu,u,s

t[,t[tJ xCsj¤w sj:¬t/, w£xS

z{

j

z

w jXsl§

gh

s$ltJ lu,u,s sMu,s jXw {

z{J

j$w

h

jA

{

kA, jXwjl,jXs s {J

w h j1

z{,{J

s xCsw jlk«§

jrtJ s { z

jXsjl[wMt«w©

{

¢£

h

tJs jm

z|{C{J

kjXw h,{

{ {

[x/®¯x, jX ,S

z{C{

s$sk t z w { w

h,{

s j

°{,z

sltJt

z

t/,,utJ/jXsl§

j¬tJ ¤x slu,ss { w h j z

t/

z|{

tJ

h

jXsl§

±]²C³´µ¶7J·¯ ¸{

,lu zz

jl[w1

z{

z

t/kAk,7®s:jXX

x,,¹t/,

j z

x,,¹t/,

z

jlts

{

,,ºt/

{

u,w»

z|{

z t/kmsl®

s jlkAt/[w Xs {J

z{

z

t/kAkm,St/,CutJ[jXsl®7tJw¡t8¢£t

z

tJ ¤jXt/,,utJ/jXsl®

z{,{J

s xCsw jlk«®&¼ { t z

j#

{

/ /®©jlt/¥jXsw

z jX

{

, w

{

,sl§

½¿¾À

Á|Â£ÃlÄ

À

Á"ÅÆ Â£Ç°ÈlÉ

ÊËJÌ¿ÍWÎ ÏªÐ¯ÑÎ ÒlÌQÓ¡ÑÌÔ¯Õ[ËWÑ×ÖÎËJØÙ

ÚÛaÜ ÝWÞß¿àlá ÝlâlãXä:åJæèçéßQã êlëXì¡å:ílá|êßïîXðlñèò7ó

ÍlôõÐ)öÎ ÏQ÷&ÍJÓ¡Ðùø

ÚÚ

Ò$úWÓ ÏªÌ¿ûõüÐ¿Ëlú8úÎ ÏªÌ

Úý ølüÌ¿Í

Ú"þ ÏÚ

ÒWÑÿÍ

ÎXÎ Ï

ý ôÒWÓ:Ì Úý

Ú Ð Ú

Ó ÏªÑQÍéÏªÎ¡Ø ÏªÓ FÐ×ÎÒÓ ÏªÓûûÚ ûôõÐ ÓÒ

ý

Ì¿Í

Úþ Ï Ú

ÒWÑQÍ

Ú ÐÚ

Ó ÏªÑQÍÎ ÒlÌ¿ÏªÓ:Ñ£ÌÓÏªÓ

ùôõØ

Ú

JÓÒ

ý Ú

úJÓÏªÌ!

Ú

ÒlÌ¯Î"

Ú "Ú ÒWÐ

Ú ó

ÑÎ ÒlÌ¿ÏªÓ¡ÑÌ#%$&$$(')

ò

* Õ,+-./0Õ,ü:ÎÒ1324ÊûûÙ

ÚÚ"ý65 +ïÌQÓûôÚ þ

74#8942Õ,ü¡Î Ò Ñ

ÚýlÚ;:

)=<>

þ

ÏªÓ ÒWÑ

Ú:ò

?@

ÊÕBA+Ê&'"ÏQË

Ú

ÎÒlÌQÓ ôõØ Ò

Ú

CÖCD$9$;)92%

þ

FE4)%$(2

@

ÓÒ8Ò

Ú

Ð;

þ

ÏªÓ ÒWÑ

Ú:ò

G

Õ,+

þ

A/HùÒlôJI

ò

AùÏQû£Ù

Ú

ÓÒJÐ;32KË

Ú

Õ)Ù

Ú

Î ÒWÓ Ï

ýýlÚ

@ ôÒWÑèô-/ÖCL4=<E#%

þ

72=E)4=<MAùÏQûÙ

Ú

Ó ÒWÐ0

ÚýlÚ;:ON þ

ÏªÓ ÒWÑ

Ú:ò

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rhˆone-Alpes

655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST MARTIN (France) Téléphone : (33) 76 61 52 00 – Télécopie : (33) 76 61 52 52

(5)

< '65'7!!¨! $d!<&!09''!)2'*!< .)01'!×'

r2< ¨< 2%%! ': !

²²S

{

u,s z jXsjl[wq

{

,s&u]sx,sw

i

jlkmjjm

z

jlu

jM

{ u z

ut[,CtJ/j$7tJw¡t8¢£t

z

tJ

i

jX jskA, j/® jt/,CtJ[j

§ ¸

jsx,sw

i

jlkjj

z

jlu

j$jXsw

Q{

,Fqjs¡u

z

u«t/,CtJ[jõtJs sj

z

w

{

,s

i

tmjlu,v«

{

kA

{

s¡t/[wjXsl§"

{

u,sqj:¬,¤s s

{

,s

ultJ lu,jXs,u,s

tJ, jXs&

z qjX

{

,¤w

{

,sFjXwt/tJ x,s

{

,ssjXsF

z|{

z

¡qjXwqjXs)j&qj:¬, ss¡t/, w j/§q

{

u,sFu,w s

{

,sXj

lt¤lu,

{ u z z{

u j z

t

{

kA,:qjXw:u,jF7u2sx,sw

i

jlkmj)jF

z

jlu

j/§)

{

u,s)

z qjXsjl[w

{

,sqjXCtJ jlkjl[w¯u,jkSqjXw h,{

{ {

/ j

jr

z

jlu

jAjl#jlu,v

h

tJs jXsl§

jXsM

z

jlu

jXs

{

,w jlCu,jXs$s

{

[wsjlk,t[,¤jXs

i

trXjX jXs

{

"qjXjXs

{ u z

jXst/,CtJ/jXs

s ltJtJ

z

jXsl§"

{

u,s slu,w

{

,s¬tJ jlkjl[wõt/u,w

z

jXst/

z{

h jXsl§

¶7lU´² y×z{

z

t/kAkAtJw

{

t

z

tJ

i

jX j/®×s¡×qjXX¬7ltJw

{

SjXw

tJ 7tJw

{ j4

z{

z

t/kAkjXsl®sqjlkAt/[w u,jrjXs

t/,,tJ/jXsj

z|{

z

t/kkAtJw

{

®8t/,CtJ/jXs7tJw¡tW¢£t

z

tJ

i

jX jXsl®[sxCs w

i

jlkj)j

z

jlu

j/®J

{

/ u,jj¼ { t z

j/®/,u,s

tJ, jXs

z qjX

{

, w

{

,sl§

(6)

' (

7<.

)

tw¡t8¢£t

z

t¤ jX/t/,,utJ/jXs h t j z

jXXjl[w xjlkj

z

/jXtJs)tkAt }{Cz

w

{C{

Q{Cz

t

z

/j)sltJ jt

z

t¤ jX

z{

z

t/kAk,7§+*

kA

z

jXss

jj, {,z

w¯ slu zz

jl[w xAjX,1u,w

{

$j

jX

{

,,Aj-1X jl/w×

{

kA, j z s

Q{Cz

¼¤

hAy

j

zèQ{Cz

kAt/,Xj/.

{Cz

w z t/

0 ¼ y

.21X§

)y"¸4365

n879£®7t7tw¡t8¢£t

z

t¤ jXjXv,wjl,s

{ {J"¸

z

kAt

z

¤x:u,jl,XjXº/x gh

¥[,~tJ

h

,js

¸<;

® s

lu z z

jl/w ¤xAu,j

z

sw¡t/,7t

z

=ltw

{

§2>u z {

tJ s"w {

z|{W

j&tJ 7w

h

jXsj&,jX©¹j

jX

{

kjl/w s"© w h w h

j&,jXXjXss¡t z x

s jlkAt/[w »tJs jXsl§

gh

jXsj4tJsjXst

z

jr

z

u,XtJw

{

jXs CSs¡t

j»t[,

{

,w km=XjX { kA, ¤j

z

sl®Ft[,

z{

z

t/kAkm,

jl

z|{

kjl[ws,Xu,,«t

z

tJ jX =X,7®7tw¡t8¢ª sw

z

u,w,1t[,1jlu,/[,w {,{

sl§

gh

jXx1t

z

j&t¤s { w h

j©tlxw

{

s:t

j z z{

z

t[kAk,&w jX

h

,u,jXsl®Js

{

tJs¯w { t

/{

w

h

j×

{

kAk

{

©tswj {

wkjt/,k

{

,jXxs¡éjl/w$jlu,//,7§

3

vC sw ,$7tJw¡t8¢£t

z

tJ jX7t/,CutJ[jXsl®Js¡u,

h

tJs"¼

y

.®

¸<;

®/¼xj z¸ {Cz

~ y

®J,Xu,jts km¤t z

{Cz

j

{

7tJw¡tW¢

t

z

tJ jX7

{

[w z{

s w

z

u,Xw¡u

z

jXs8§@?ªr

z j {

u,sFt/éj

z

sl®,©j h t

js h,{

©&$w

h

tJw) w" s

{

ss, j&w

{

j:¬,j ts k,¤ju,w

z

jl

z

jXsjl[w¡tJw

j7tJw¡tW¢£t

z

tJ jX"¥Jj

z

,jX)t/,Cut/j 0w h

j¦ t/,,utJ/jA1t/,#w

{

/

jA wt

Q{Cz

kAtJ

{

éj

z

tJw

{

tJ

5

7A9

t[,«jl

{

w¡tJw

{

tsjlkAt/[w Xs

5

B9£§

?è#w

h

sAt/j

z

®©jj:¬,j»t«

z{,{J

sxCs wjlk

Q{Cz

w h

st/,,utJ/j/®#w

h

jAswxC j {

w h

j1u,s:utJ"¼ { t z

js

{

/

t[

z{

tJ

hC5

nD89§

gh

j

{Cz

/tJ wx {J{

u z t/

z{

tJ

h

jXs"$w

h

jw

z

jltJw:kjl/w {J

w h j

BEFAGHI! A J%K

®8w

h

tJw sl®

w h

j)s¡u,sjXw {J

lu z z

jl/w ¤xtXw

j", XjXs"tJw©

h

h t

jXXw {Cz

,sw

z

u,Xw

{

$¤sw

{

jt/, jX§

y×z

j { u,s)t/

z{

tJ

h

jXs

jXw

{

kAt[,u,tJw j1 sws {J

,¤XjXsjXv , X w x

0

jX w h j z

[x kt/,u,tw, s jXws {J

tJXw

jr

z{

XjXs s {Cz

s 5 nLC®nl9

{,z

[x«s¡jXX

xC,t/#tJXXjXsssj u,jl,Xj

Q{Cz

jlt

h

t

z

t¤ jX

t z

t/, j 5NM

91X®

{,z

w { {

,s j z {

/w jXvCwjXv z jXss

{

,s

tsMtJss j

z

w

{

,sAk

{

õ¬7j z s 5

LB9£§?ªS

{

[w

z

tJs wl®

{ u z z{,{J

s xCsw jlk

Q{Cz

¦3jXs

z

jXsrw

h

j«tJXw

wx

{

[wjXv,wA/xºt

jXXw {Cz

{,{

jlt/jXv

z

jXss

{

# sw,Xw

ÿz{

k*w

h

jAu,s¡utJ"

z

jX ltJwjXs

{

#

z{

z t/k

t z

t/, jXsl§

gh

jmu,s j {J

s:u,

h

w©

{

¢ª

{

k

{

,jl[wMtJs sj

z

w

{

,s sAt

z

w lu,t

z

x ©jX õ¢ªs:u,¤w jX¹w

{

t/[w¡u, w

j u,j

z

sw¡t/,,

{J

w h j»tssj

z

w

{

,s

t[,4

z{J

jXstAtJs s

Q{Cz

tw©

{

¢£

h

tJs jPO¡

z|{C{J

[x»t/

{

w¡tJw

{

,sRQAkjXw h,{

§

?èsjXXw

{

SD®/©j/

j&tjXs

z

,w {

{J

w h

j¦St/,CutJ/j/®Jw

{

/jXw h j z

© w

h

¤w sFtJw¡u

z

tJCs jlkAt/[w Xsl§UT,jXXw

{

1

jXs

z

jXs4t#s

{

u, z{,{J

sxCs wjlk tJsjX

{ { u z

w©

{

¢ª

{

k

{

,jl[wAtJssj

z

w

{

,sl§VT,jXXw

{

W7jltJ sr© w h w h j

j:¬, w

{ {J

t ©jlt/¥JjXsw«

z

jX

{

, w

{

,s«lt¤lu,u,s#t/, © w h w h

jtJs s

{

XtJw jX¹j:¬t/, w£x u,jXsw

{

§

gh

s

©jlt/¥jXswM

z

jX

{

,¤w

{

,sAltJ lu,u,s1 sAw

h

j«¥JjXxw

{

jXs w¡t/, s h w h

j«

{

kA, jXwjl,jXs s {J&{

u z z{,{J

sx,swjlk«® © h

h

s$w

z

jltJwjX#XT,jXXw

{

ZY§*9w©

{

¢£

h

tJsjA

z{,{J

kjXw h,{

{ {

/x/®x, jX ,

z

jlt7t/, j»t/,#sw

z

u,Xw¡u

z

jXº

z|{C{J

sl® s

jXs

z

jX#[T,jXXw

{

§H*&st

{

,Xu,s

{

®6©j

z

jXsjl[w&t slu,ss

{

#t/,«s

{

kjj

z

s¡jXXw

jXs8§

\ ] ': !* !" %<%! ' '!0 .)'

^H_a` bdc2egfihkj lUm@nojpmHe

?è«w

h

j7tw¡t8¢£t

z

t¤ jX¯

z|{

z

t/kk,1k

{

jX°®6w

h

jtJs ¤

{ }

jXXws&t

z

jt zz

t8x,sF©¤w

h

t

z

t¤ jX)tJXXjXssl®6tJ s

{

ltJ jX

rq#%

§ g © {

¥/,s {J

tJXw

{

,s$lt/#j1t[,¤ jXSw { w h

jXsj { }

jXXwsAs

q/IpAGtU%8A{

j

z

tJw

{

,sl®

{Cz

/

{

tJ

!"$Ap%

§P**

z{

z

t[k0 s1t«s j u,jl[wtJ

{

k

{

s w

{ {J

s:u,

h

tJXw

{

,sl§

3

tJ

h

tJXw

{

sAtJss

{

XtJwjX

©¤w h w h

j$sjXw {J

t

z z

t8xA,¤XjXstJw©

h

¤w st/, jX§4*4,jXv#tJw©

h

t[«tJXw

{

« st/, jX# ss¡tJ 4w

{

éj q

§u>w h j z

,¤XjXst

z

js¡t¤w

{

éj §

gh

jsjXw {J

tJXw

j, XjXs sltJ ¤jX#w h j

qAAvdqrG8E"{Cz

w h j

BEFp4wI A %8 °{

¤

{

©,4w

h

jAwj

z

k*

{

,jX

°{,z

w h

jC*Xw¡u,st/,CutJ/j 5n M

9£§C?Qwlt[jAs jXjlºtJst

{C{

¤jlt[4t zz

tlx©

h j z j x$

jl

{

w jXs tJXw

wx»t/,

K N%8

jl,jXssl§

>,s j z

jw

h

tJwtJ ¯u,s¡utJ7tJw¡tW¢£t

z

tJ jX¯t/,,utJ/jXss¡u,

h

tJsu*Xw¡u,sl®

¸<;

®C~

y #{Cz

¼ y . t z jjXwj

z

k,¤s w /§

gh,{

u,

h w h

jXxs¡éjXX

xMt

z

tJ jXtJXXjXss jXs¯w

{

7tJw¡t©

h,{

s j"s

h

jX7u, ,AkAt8xéj

{

[¢ªjXwj

z

k, sw /®,w h j z

jXs¡u, w,

s jlkAt/[w Xs

%

jXwj

z

k, sw /§

jAt z j {

, x {

w£©

{

jXv,Xjl,w

{

,sAs$t

z

tw h j z

s:jXXtJFu,s j {

w h jy!z{|

{

éj

z

tJw {Cz

¸};

h j z

jXXjX

j z

ktlx z j u,

z

j1t«

{

[¢ªjXwj

z

k, sw r

{

k,,,

{

j

z

tw {Cz8~

s { kjwjX

h

, ltJ× ss¡u,jXs

{

,jXXwjX#© w

h

t

z

t/kjXwj

z

tss,«4 j

{

[wjXvCw sl§¼

{

©j

j z

®é©Fjt

z

j

{

w

{

,Xj

z

,jX © w h w h

s j

jX

{J

jXw:tJ «w

h

st/j

z

®6t/,«©j

{

,s j z{

,¤x«jXw j

z

k, sw 7tJw¡t8¢£t

z

tJ ¤jXù

{

,sw

z

u,Xw sl§

gh

j¦t/,CutJ[jF s×jXs C,jX1tJs"t

{

kAk

{

M¥j

z

,jX

{J

7tJw¡tW¢£t

z

tJ jX7t/,Cut/jXs) ¥j

¸<;5

D/9£®J¼x éj z¸5

n889

{,z

~ y 5

nlB9£§

jr

{ {

w

{

,s j z w h

jrsltJt

z

t z w

{J

w h

jXs j«t[,CutJ/jXsl®)kAt, x kA

{Cz

wjX

ÿz|{

k w h j ¸

t/,,utJ/j/§

gh

jl®7tJs

t z

tsw

h

s t[j

z

¤s

{

,Xj

z

,jX®6©jlt/4tss¡ukjw

h

twsltJt z

tJu,jXst z j z

jl, ltJwjXtJw

(7)

7

t¤ù

{

ltJw

{

,s8®7s { w h

tJw©jlt/]¤jl[w

x4tAsltt z

t z

t[,¤j© w h t

jXXw {,zh

t

,Aw

h

j$s¡t/kj

tJu,j

z

jl, ¤ltwjX

twt¤ù

{

kA

{

,jl/ws8§

* s { ®

Q{Cz

w h js¡t/¥Jj

{J

skA, X w£x/®6©j

{

, xA

{

,s j

z

/wjX[j

z

t[,1

{,{

jlt/

tJu,jXs h j z

jw

h

st/j

z

®Ct/,

©j

{

,s j z w h

tJw"t¤t

z

tJ jXt zz

t8xCss h t z

j&tu, u,j/j

{

kjXw

z

x/§

gh

s" s

z

jlk, sXjl/w {J

w h j~

y

t/,CutJ/j/®

h

j$

{

kAk

{

«/j

{

kmjXw z x

{J

w h

j

t z

t/, jXs sw

h

jM

h

xCs ¤lt¯/j

{

kjXw z x

{J

w h ju,j

z

xC, t z h ¢

w jXXw¡u

z

j/§~u,¤w , j$/j

{

kjXw

z

¤jXs8® tsFtJ

{

©FjX4[xAw

h

j<y"!#Fz8s

{J ¸<;{Cz

w h

j$%&z$')(%{8s {

¼xj z ¸

®/

{

u, «jltJs ¤ x

éj

h

t/, jXºtJww

h

jm

z

¤Xj {J

jXv,w

z

t«

{

w:tJw

{

#t/,#ltJsjAt/tJ x,s sl§

gh

sMu,u,jA/j

{

kmjXw

z

x4 s$lt/,w¡u

z

jX

h j z j

w

hz{

u,

h

t*

p

{ kAtJ

{J

, XjXs,+j u,jX#© w

h

tsjXw {J

/j

{

kmjXw

z

{

j

z

tJw {Cz

ss¡u,

h

tJs4y"!(-.'X®/%'01'az/®

jXw /§C.

{,z

,s w¡t/,Xj/®)#~

y

®2+*©

{

u,¤ jrt«s ut z j 5

4353nlD/926

5

4373nlD/F9£®7t/,w

h

j1tJss

{

XtJwjX[j

{

kjXw

z

{

j

z

tJw {Cz

s©

{

u,¤AéjFw {Cz{

7tJw

z

t/,stJw

{

,s)tJ

{

,w

h

jtJv,jXsl§

gh

j

z

jXX sjsw

z

u,Xw¡u z j

{J

w h j/j

{

kjXw

z

{

kAtJ

+3t/,Aw

h

jjXw¡tJ jX1j:¬, w

{ {

w h j[j

{

kjXw

z

{

j

z

tJw {Cz

s"t z j

{J

ww j

z

jX j

t/,Xj h j z

j/§2?èw

h

jjXvt/kA, jXs {J

w h

¤st/j

z

®6t

{

,j:¢ªkmjl,s

{

tJ

{Cz

w©

{

¢ªkjl,s

{

tJ

{

gh

j {

,¤x«kA

{Cz

w¡t[/w

{

[w

sw

h

jjXvC sw jl,Xj {

w©

{ { j z

s {

u,Xw

{

,sAs

8:9<;

('=%y 0 >

1kAt/,st/r,jXv

>

[w

{

ts ltJt z

tu,j 9 ~

8 > ;

y?'@%4(

0 9

1kAt/,stsltJt z

tJu,j[w

{

t/],jXv

tJu,j/§

gh

jXsj

u,Xw

{

,st z j z

jlk, sXjl[w {J

w h

j,#$%A%A|

u,Xw

{

,s

¸};

®

{Cz

w h j,(/%B$

u,Xw

{

rr~

y § gh

j {

, x

h

x

{ w h

jXs ¤s sw

h

tJw

0

y0'@%4(DCE('@%yR1 sw

h

j jl[w wx

u,Xw

{ {

],¤XjXss

> ;

y?'=%4(

0 ('@%y 0 >

1R1X§u?

+¨ s

5

4353GFIH¹nK9£®

w h jlrw

h

¥

{J

('=%ytJsjlkMéjX,

5

4353FJH n9/w { w h

j[wjX/j

z

s&t[, y0'@%4(7tJsw

h

jLK% | 0 F1

{

j

z

tw {Cz

§

* )w h j t z

t/, jXs {J

¦ t z jt

z

tJ jXQ®¯t/,#tJ ¯w h j { }

jXXwst z j

jXXw {Cz

s

{J

sltJt

z

s8®7© w h]{

,j

{

kA

{

,jl[w

twFjlt

h

,jXv§o*&s&tm

{

jl/w

{

®éw

h

jt

z

tJ jX

{ }

jXXws&t

z

jjl

{

wjX© w

h

uéj

z

ltJsj$,¤w t¯ jXwwj

z

sAsNM ®AO»®

jXw /§ ?è, XjXs&t

z

jjl

{

wjX

>

®4P7®[jXw/§

gh

j&

{

kA

{

,jl[w {

tt

z

tJ ¤jX

{ }

jXXwNM0

{

ltJwjX«tJw",jXv

>

sjl

{

wjX

M:QR§

*

AqA8E# 8%%KTS

lt/4éj {J

w h j

Q{

{

©,

Q{Cz

ksl§

8 *

jXXw {Cz×

t z

t/, jM §

8 *

jXXw {Cz

{

,sw¡t/[w {J

[wjX/j zù{Cz

{C{

jlt/$wxj/§

¸{

,sw¡t/[w)n)jl

{

wjXsw h j

jXXw {Cz

©

h,{

sj"tJ /

{

k

{

,jl[ws

h t j

tJu,jAn/®NU rx

t/,

%K

jl

{

wjw h j

jXXw {Cz

s"©

h,{

s j tJ

{

kA

{

,jl[wst z j z

jXs¡jXXw

jX¤xrw

z

u,jt/,

tJ sj/§

¸{

,sw¡t[/wjXv

z

jXss

{

VU

$J%

jl

{

wjXsw h j

jXXw {Cz

©

h,{

s j

tJu,jMtwF,jXv

>

¤s,('@%y 0 >

1Bs¯w

h

¤s sw h j

(W%A$

{J

~ y

®w

h

jX

{

j

z

tw

{Cz×{J"¸<;

§

8 * {

kA

{

,jl[w£©¤s j4

{

k,tJw

{ {J

jXXw {Cz

jXv

z

jXss

{

,sAs

Q{Cz

,s w¡t/,Xj/®YM[Z\O«§6*& u,s¡utJsltJt

z

{

j

z

tw {Cz

s&t z j

{J

j z {

tJjX4© w h w h

jX

zz

jXs¡éjXXw

j

jXXw {Cz

jXv,wjl,s

{

§

8

?Qw s1u,sj

u,Fw

{

j:¬,j4t[ºtJ w

{

tFwxj {J&

jXXw {Cz

jXv z jXs s

{

,sAs

qGG 2rqPBER B%r%8%

§

0/]^

S

s`_&1jl

{

wjXsw h j

jXXw {,z

©

h,{

sj

{

kA

{

,jl[w&tJw,jXv

>

s

S QR {,{

jlt/

jXXw {Cz

jXv z jXs s

{ ]

¤sw

z

u,jtw,jXv

>

®7t/,T_QR { w h j z

©¤s j/§

8 * Kq

jXv

z

jXss

{

s S QaF§

¸{

,s j

z

tm¬7vCjX,jXv

>

§u.)

z

s wl®7w h j

jXXw {,z

jXv z jXss

{

Tb sj

tJutJwjX®

w h jl#w

h j

jXXw {Cz

jXv

z

jXss

{ S

§.)tJ x/®w h j z

jXs¡u, w$¤s

z

jlt zz

t/,/jX#s { w h

tJww h j

tJu,j«tJw,jXv

>

s

jXw

h

jXtJww

h

j,jXv#©

h

¤sw h j

tJu,j {J

b9tJw

> 0 { j z

wjXw hz{

u,

h«

u,Xw

{ y?'=%4(18s 0S Qa

11QR ;

S Q

y?'=%&(dc afegih

§ ?è t

z

w lu,t

z ® S QU %

¤skmj

z

jX x

S

§4?ª~

y

®6w

h

s s&jl

{

wjXjW%4i'kz=klnm?X5o§}?è

¸<;

t/,

¼xj z¸

®7w

h

s sjl

{

wjXpklnm0o§

*s&t/]jXv t[kA, j/®

{

,s j

z

twx , ltJ

ªz

tJ,kjl/w {J

t {

,j:¢ªkjl,s

{

tJ¯

{

/{

u,w

{

«

{

js

0

DqMJZjM:Q

U

$%irs ZtM:Q

U

$J%us 1Dv7

{ wjw

h

tJw8®/sw

z

¤Xw ¤xrs¡éjlt/¥/,7®éw

h

jwZ

{fxy{z@|

Z¹n s G

w h

js¡t[kj tsFw

h j {

u,w j

z

Z®6tJs¤wtJXws

{

rw

h

j&,jXv

{

kAtJ}+1§~u,ww h j z

jM s

{«z

jltJ

z

jltJs

{

«w

{

sw

z

jXs sw

h

s,dj

z

jl,Xj1t/[x«

{

,/j

z

x { w h

{

j

z

tJw {Cz

s k {

swltJs jXsl§

{

wj»t¤s { w h

tJwAtJ F

{

,sw

z

u,XwsS¦&® ,Xu,, {

kAku, ltJw

{

,s 0

jXw

h

1X®)t z j

AAG%8q

§

jlt/«

{ © sww

h

j,sw

z

u,Xw

{

,s {J

¦&§