Spatial discretization issues for the energy conservation in compressible flow problems on moving grids

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00071845

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00071845

Submitted on 23 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub-

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,

Spatial discretization issues for the energy conservation in compressible flow problems on moving grids

M. Vázquez, B. Koobus, Alain Dervieux, Ch. Farhat

To cite this version:

M. Vázquez, B. Koobus, Alain Dervieux, Ch. Farhat. Spatial discretization issues for the energy conservation in compressible flow problems on moving grids. RR-4742, INRIA. 2003. �inria-00071845�

(2)

ISRN INRIA/RR--4742--FR+ENG

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

THÈME 4

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Spatial discretization issues for the energy conservation in compressible flow problems on

moving grids

M. Vázquez, B. Koobus, A. Dervieux, Ch. Farhat

N° 4742

February 14, 2003

(3)

(4)

-./0213 0 &.4567.48+9:$';'!#

<>=#?A@CBEDFGHBJILKNM=#OPPRQ#F#SUTVKXWY=XZGE[:\]^GEF_`EKbadce=fNgC[:cXgihVj

kelnm opqdrtsJuvownxzy {|u~}Ep{}L{|u~ouzyV{uv}

p!J{m:op:}Eonx~p Lp:

X|}Vp{8sJo9yEl

&yVi}E{ p|p:lnp:|lpCqJ qHrp n|wyV|:qnVE!r* qdyVEp:

:¡ ¢ £n¤¡¥ kelp-n|p uv{uv}d}V¦uvH{p y{uv}6nlnp }op y§Cp{¨p p y,}on|p:|u~nxvp-©} ¨ªuvdy§o} «E¬

uvn }Eo9yVuvyV }V{|lnp bod} p:xvbx~uv®p&{|w{wnyVxn}Enp:NpU¯Ewu~|p:#{|ly {}Eodp& }p |« y {|u~}E6n|}Cp {uvp:

p p {}ipyV{uz°ip J{lp6Jwnop |uz yVx#|lnp op::±,²³{luv,yip:,¨puvJ«pU{|u~Hy {p!{lnpdu~oC}{|yE{

}Enx~p:o%}V¦&{|lnp¨}|®H¬´p:np |µ}Ep:« yV{uv}¶¨u~{lnuv·{|lnp©wnu ¦¸}d{|lnp uv||p{|p¦¸}|owxvyV{uv}ª}E

o} «JuvnEu :±²³Y{|lnp yEp}¦ey}EonpUuvnx~p6©} ¨)¹{|lnp9¨}|®ip:¦¸}Eop }E{|lnp©wnu H{lnp

o} «JuvnuvE{|p ¦ºy plyE{}Cpn|}Cp |x~{||yxzy {|p uvYy$«»yuzy {|u~}EA}V¦X{|lnp{|}V{yVx©wnu p p |±§¼Yp

pUp:E{,yJwnop |uv:yVxo} p x{lyV{|y {|uv°p:8{luv§p np:E }p |« y {|u~}EAn}Eip:{¨u~{ln}EwL{,xv}J}Eu~

}op}V{|lnp & }p |« y {|u~}E$n|}Cp {uvp:ewlyE{lnp½,p:}op{|uz!¾-}p |« y {|u~}E¿y»¨)±

ÀAÁHÂRÃ|ÄÅ ¢ Æ ¥ÈÇ nu~{yV|¿yVyVuzyVÉXwx~p:uzyVµ¦¸}|owxvyV{uv}Ê }on|p:|uvnxvpd©} ¨)y {|uvyx uz¬

p {uvË:yV{uv}ÊJp p |$ }p |« y {uv}E©iwnu ¬Ì{|wÍ{|wn|p,uvH{p:|yEÍ{uv}

ÎbÏ¸ÐÑÊÏÓÒ-ÔVÕÍÖÍÖ×ÑÊØÍÙUÚ^ÛNÜ»ÛÝÞJÙUßàáØÍâáÛÝÔ ã¹äLåVæÍçUÔ ÖÍèÍæÍÖÍÕ&é:ØÍêUë»àíì|îÓÒïÚ^àáêØÍâáàáÝÔ»ð ñ^ìï»ßÛ

òXó

ÛêUÚ#ô)ì|Ú^ë»õö&ì|Ú^àá÷:Ù»ÛÝÔVøÊøåÖÍùUúNç×ÖÍæÍùô!û#ÐüäCýÞJÞJÏ¸ýiÑø¹ÛÜ»Û³þ,ùUÔ»ð ñ^ìï»ßÛ

ÿ

Ï¸ÐÑÊÏÓÒ-ÔVÕÍÖÍÖ×ÑÊØÍÙUÚ^ÛNÜ»ÛÝÞJÙUßàáØÍâáÛÝÔ ã¹äLåVæÍçUÔ ÖÍèÍæÍÖÍÕ&é:ØÍêUë»àíì|îÓÒïÚ^àáêØÍâáàáÝÔ»ð ñ^ìï»ßÛ

8ó

Ûê ìñ¸Ú^öÛïÚØÒÊÛñºØÍÝ´ê»ìßÛ,ýiïÍàáïUÛÛñºàáïdé:ßàáÛïUßÛÝï»àÛñ^Ý^àÚ 9Ø#ø¹ØÍâáØÍñ^ìÜ»Øì|ÚãRØÍÙUâáÜ»Ûñ&ø¹ìöê»Ù»Ý-ãRØþ×ÕÍæ

ãRØÍÙ»âáÜ»ÛñÔVøûÍÖÍçÍÖÍæ|î¸Ö×ÕÍæ

(5)

&.4& -./0 &7.4: !'!2.4!0

¥

¿yuvownxzy {|u~}E p9xu~H{p:|yEÍ{|u~}Ep H{|pwnµ©wnu p }on|p:|uvnxvp ywn }Eoyu~pdo}Enu~xvp9p{

ywL{|p:od} m:x~pU6 }oop pU6{|w{wn|p:: p:|u~{pxw|yVp p|l o9yE!Jwno |uv¯HwnpU!« |u°iyH{

p {|yu~npU&|p xzy {|u~}E pd}Ep:« yV{uv}Ê±,yVi8p6yVu~p:§pU{{w u:pxzy$ }p |« y {uv}p: }Eoyu~p

« yuzyVnxvp pdxzy}Eodop np:Eu~p ¬^{||y»« yu~x´±§yx~p yE wU}wx~p:odp:H{y»«Ep: }on|p:|uvnuvx~u~{E¹x~p

{||y»« yu~xi¦¸}wn|nuRy-xvp,©wnu p }u~{n|} «p:nuv-uvH{ E|yx~p:op H{ wnnp,« yV|uvyV{uv} p,} np:Eu~p8{}V{yVxvp±

8}wn:p H{}Ewn·|l o9yJwno |uz¯Ewp¯Ewu-|y {uz¦ºyVu~{6p {{p$n}En|u {|yVip: |p9xvp:ywL{|p:

}p |« y {|u~}E- wiuzyVxvp:}Eoodpxzy¿Ê}u p6¾-}p |« y {uv}½ }Eo {|uv¯HwnpE±

>Å ¡U Ã ¤! ¥ n}|owxvyV{uv} ÉNwnx~p:§¿yVyVp Ç u{||yu~|pU}Ewnx~p:op H{&}on|p:|u~nxvp uv|{|u¬

|y {|u~}EyV{uzyVxvpL}Ep:« yV{uv} p)x np:Eu~pELu~H{|p yÍ{|u~}E©wu p ¬Ì{|w{wn|p

(6)

% &

9$b6

kelpdo}{uv«»yV{uv}µ}V¦-{lnuz){|w uz,{lp9u~on|} «p:odp:H{,}¦b©wnu Hwodp:uz yx#od} p:xvuvo} «Huvn }V¬

o9yu~6¨u{|l{|lnpenwn|i}Hp}V¦iynnxvuv:y {|u~}E!{}}Eonx~p !u~H{|p yÍ{|u~}E!n|}nxvp o9#wl6yEÊ©wu ¬³{|wÍ{|wnp

w{|p:y u~H{p:|yEÍ{|u~}EÊ±8¿Êp {,wi8p Jxvyu~uv p {|yu~x{lpn|}nxvp o98{lyV{,yuzpu~{lnuz8®Juv }¦-}Eo6¬

C}w Jyoduz yxJ{p:o9NJd } p H{y {|u~)}y)yEuzuzwnp('{|lnp8Jwnop |uz yVxnp uzÍ{uv}9}¦¹{lnp

w{|p:y Au~H{|p yÍ{|u~}ECp{¨p p:µy}EodpUu~x~p©} ¨5y y{|wiÍ{wp|p:¯HwnuvpU&{|ly {{lpdEx~}EyVx

Jwnop:uz yxR|lnp:odp)|y {|uv°p:}op)}Ep |«»yV{uv}n}Eip:{|u~pU ±

k}µ{|y{¨u~{lÊb°nLp opUl yVxzwxvyV{uv}d}Eodwnxv}|uvx~|p:¯Hwnuvp)$+*!,.-/0

1

o9y| Lo}op:E{ Lp:np |2N¦¸}{lp©wnu o} p:x^±Xk¨-}o9yVuvo}{uv«»yV{uv}¦¸}E{lnuz&ln}Euv p8¦¸}Ex~xv} ¨& ±

uv|{xvHnlJLuz yxC}w npUb}V¦Êo9yVJ9}EodwL{|yV{uv}bpU¯Ewu~|p:N{lyV{-uvodC}{|yH{-pJ{|p u~«Ep§¯HwyE{|u¬

{|u~pU&yV|p!}Ep |«p wn|u~n{|u~op!p:«}Ex~wL{|u~}EÊ±-sJpU}E xvy p {|yu~xzy|}V¦X}Ep |«»yV{uv«p)|lnp op:

yx~xv} ¨ {lnpyVnx~uz yV{uv}A}V¦X{|lnp6¿y J¬Ì¼Yp:

|}3{|lnp }Ep:o }¦b}EH«Ep |p:p,{} ¨eyV

¨p:y®}xvwL{|u~}E ±

kelpp3Rp:{}V¦e{luv6}J«Ep |p ipyVnCp:y|n}{}x~Yu~{|lnp:yVL{|wnp9}¦eln}L®L)nwL{dyVxz}Auv¶«p:

uv|p:wnxzyVdop:lnp::± ²³·{|lnp yEp}V¦o} «Huvnµop:lnp::N{|lnp}¬Ì:yVxvx~p

·Ç

¿É5¦¸}|ownxzy {|u~}E·}¦548u~{:

Ç o9 p:AyV ¾-}J}®Hy»«pyVyV¨-p:{}d{lnp°i|{8yVC} «p}Ep:« yV{uv}$uz|wnpE±

Ç p:}E n}{uv} }¦6}Ep |«»yV{uv} y}Hpy {|lnp p:yxv ¦¸}o} «Huvn odpUl op{l} ± kelnp

6 798:$<;=>

1

½!¾¿=2

1

u~H{|} w p J keln}Eo9yy ¿Ê}o6yV @?:qA2yV u~{|

uv||p{|p«Ep uv}ip:wnp{|ly {Nywnnu~¦¸}|o ©} ¨ uvNn}V{XCp {wn|ip H6yVnn|}»Lu~o9yV{uv}p:|} wn|u~n

{|lnpop:l·o}V{|u~}EÊ±CBAyH¶uvoi}E{yVH{9yV|wnop H{6:yV ipu~J«E}®p ¦¸}d{|lnp p:u~E·}¦,|lnp op:

|p:Cp:Í{|u~6{|lnuz&}E u~{uv}Ê±

¬9²Ì{9¨yE!°{dln} ¨ÊX¦¸}E6p Lyonx~puv ?D A?AÌN{|ly {u~{|dnyÍ{|uv:yVxu~oyEÍ{} y wnyyV

{yVnuvxvu{uve}¦y|yo}wnH{eu~oC}{|yVip±

¬$sJuvp p Ep:p!Ë p:}i}Ex~Jn}Eouvyx}xvwL{uv}i8yV|pp nyÍ{|x~}EL{|yu~np C{lnp9½!¾¿·:yVYip6wn p:¬

{|}J} y-y}Euv{p:9}E u~{uv}

1)E

-/GF-yVo6nxvp¬H4&uvx~Cp {2± Ç o9y {|lnp o9y {|uv:yVxCyVyx~Luv-ly

p o}E{||yV{p

{lp§|}xvp8}¦Ê{lnp)½!¾¿¦¸}{uvop¬³yEp,y wnyd}

p:b¦¸}E

Ç

¿É lnp:op:

?I

A´±

¬ Ç xz}!{lnp)¾e½¿Awy|yH{p pU{lyV{b{|lnp&wnnu~¦¸}|o}Ex~wn{uv}¨u~xvxCn}V{-ln} ¨ wnuv}wiNwn p ln}J}{

}6} «p ln}J}V{:Ê{lyV{6uz!p ||}np:}wo9y Luvo9yKJ»ouvnuvoy±²³ ?A´{lp$yVwL{|ln}!} «Ep6{|ly {6{lnp

uz p {p§¾e½¿uzbywL9 u~p:H{-}E u~{uv}u~}E p:#{lyV{-}oplnp:op:N|y {|uv¦¸!{|lnpo9y Lu~o6wno

n|u~ u~x~p¦¸}Ey|uv«pipUuvp::±Nkelnuveuze{|lnp Aydn}x~uvnp:y{yVnuvx~u~{ } u{|u~}EÊ±

Ç {lnuv u~oC}{|yE{e}Ep:« yV{uv}yCp:Í{u~{lnp uz p {uvË:y {|u~}E9}V¦¹©wu ¬³{|wÍ{|wnp§u~H{|p yÍ{|u~}E

uz,{lp+M" +0± Ç {lnp:}|p{uz yxXp:«Ju~p:¨¦¸} uN3Rp |p H{)o} p xz)uv:Ê¦¸}E)u~i{yV pÊ{|ly {

}¦ ?O A´±n|}o yAJwnop:uz yx-C}uvH{6}V¦§«Huvp ¨)#{|lnp$Ex~}EyVx-p np:Eµ }p |« y {|u~}E¶uv|wp yªCp wL¬

uvyx^¹iyV{uzwnxzyV|x~Auvµn}Enxvp o9,¨lnp |p{|lnpp np:E{yV¦¸p |p {}{lp{|w{wn|p6uzn|} wp J

{|lnp |o} JyVouz!p3Rp:{|:±k¨-}oyu~µ}Ewnp:§}V¦nwuv}w§xv}E|8}¦bp np:EA yVipu p H{u~°p yV

uv{uvnwuvlnp '

yn±kelnp{uvopy «»yuvnop{|ln} ±@Feyuz yVxvxvN{|lnp{uvopuvE{|p E|yV{uv} :yV Cp }npAuv {ln|p p

u/3Cp:p:E{§¨y»L:±É#Lnxvuzu~{xv

1

P2ÍCuvodx~uzu~{xvy xv}H}Hp:x~}Ewnnxvp 1

(2}8u~onxvuv u{|x~yV 1

(2

{|}Enxvª}Ewnnxvp

¨lnuzl uzyxv}µ:yVxvx~p

yµo}}xvu{|lnuvynn|}Eyl

1

p p¦¸}9p nyVonxvp

?

:A´±

(7)

BAyVJ {uvop::& yp

1

$29lyE9n|} «p: {|}ªCpA{}J}ªp JCp iuv«puv {p:o9$}V¦6¾ {|u~opE±§

{lnp6u~onxvuzu~{§u

pEwn{|}}wn8®H} ¨x~p

pEn}nxvy9o9yVxvxwnp{8}¦Xod}En}xvu~{lnuz!|lnp op:

1

(2

yVxvx~} ¨&6y{|uv{xvp np:Eµ }p |« y {uv}¶uvH{p:y {uv}±Ykelnp

|y»¨iy®µuvdyVHyVuv{lnp:u~d«p:

lnuvl$ }onwL{y {uv}iyVxi }E{:±#n}EN{liy {-|p:yE}EÊVxv}J}Ep xvd }wnnxvp uvonxvuv u{elnp:op:

1

"2byV|p{lnp

o}E{&¨u pUpUy l}uzp± Ç o}nd{lp on|p:p:H{xvn|}C}Ep HPK #yx~E}|u{|lno9|y {|uv¦¸

{lnp8p np:E}Ep:« yV{uv}6{ln|}wnEl{|lnp&uvH{p ¦ºy pn}V{Np nyÍ{|x~6nwL{bw6{|}6 ±}E p Xuv6{|u~op

1

p:«p A ±#}E p:'#p p,{lnp)|p: p H{yVCp ?:A2±

Ê±kelnpy pAu~H{|p y {|u~}EÊ± ByVJ ywL{ln}E|ly»«pA¨u p xv {w u~p yV uvoi}E{yVH{$yipUÍ{$}¦

{lnuzA¯Hwnp:{uv} '¶{lnpµp p | }Ep:« yV{uv} uv {|lnpp3R}{${yViou~{{p Cp{¨p p: ©wnu 1 y {

o}op H{wo p:¯HwyV{uv}x~p:«p:x2yV {|w{wn|p

1

p:p§¦¸}Eu~i{yV p ?qA2Í±

8 p b{lnuz-x~uvlH{:E{lp8{|w d}V¦R{lp8p p |w p {N¦¸}-o} «Huvn)C}wn yV|n|}x~p:o:E }wnx~p

}E}V{:V}xv«p J)op:yVi}¦ Ç ¿ÉY|lnp opU:yVCpe yV||u~p }wL{¦¸}xvxv} ¨u~n8{¨-}§x~uvnpU ±§!}p-ly

{|lnp |p)uz{lp!¨-}E®p:xvyV{uv}lnuvip {¨-p:p ¤ Å !Á Æ ©wnu yV {|wÍ{|wn|p"'buz{|lnp!¨}|®*#

{lnp©iwnu J¶{|lnpo} «Ju~µuvH{p:¦ºyEp{lnp|yVop9#( ${|lnp}xvu {ln|}wl {lnuz9uvE{|p ¦ºy p

§{lnpd}V{|lnp ,ly R{lp |p6uz§{lnp¨}|®E¬Ìp p |$|p xzy {|u~}Elnu~¨u{|lnu~{lnpd©wu ¢ Á"! £L¢ Æ!Á U {lnp

{|w{wn|p"'uvb{lp§¨}|®#*7)# {lnp§©wnu J{lp8o} «Ju~n6u~H{|p ¦ºyp§n|}Cp |x~6{yVxzy {p uv

y * $. HH- M" ,}V¦{|lnp©wnu

kelnp6°{,x~uvnp6uv,}Eu p:p u~YyVCp &xvu~®Ep ?qA#} ?U$A´±5F}V{|lL{p:o,yV|p){|pUy {p J{lnp:u~

} ¨µp:¯HwyV{uv}:ÊyV y{|lnu~ }npuz)u~ixvw p ¨lnuzl} «p:i&{|lnpiy {uzyVx#Eu o} «Ep op H{:± Ç xvx

{|ln|p pyV|pA}Ewnnxvp {ln|}wl {lnpo} «Juvnu~H{p:¦ºyEpE± ²³ ?qAÌ{lnpYyEp uz p {uvË:yV{uv} uv|wpAuv

yyVxvJË p V¦¸}Lwiuvn!}E{lnp&xv}Ey ¦¸}pU uz{|uvnwL{|u~}Ey {N{|lnp8uvH{p ¦ºy pHybp p:9p u~{lnp:bJ6{lnp©iwnu

}Ee{lnp6}Ex~u ±b²³ ?:A´p «Ep yVx¹u p:yE}{|lnp){uvop!uvE{|p E|yV{uv}lnp:opyp)}Ei}Hp Lyp }Ey

{|yEp |p ¦¸}Eo6wnxvyV{uv}Ê±

kelnp8npUp:H{NyVCp #¦¸}LwipUN}d{|lnp&pU}E x~uvnp±Xkelnp&yEÍ{|u~}Ed}¦R{lnpo} «Ju~)i}Ewn y!}E{lnp

©iwnu L{|p o n|} wpUby« yV|uvyV{uv}uv9u{bp:np |d{y {wi ±²Ì{buzbxvp:yN¦¸}EX{lnp,}EE{|u~Jwnwo>n|}nxvp o

wL{{|lnp uz||p{p¦¸}|o |p o9yVuv!¦¸wnx~x}V¦8¯HwnpU{|u~}E:±kelnp$}Ep$}V¦e{lnuz6n}Enxvp o p:oyu~i!uv¶{lnp

©i} ¨>p:¯HwyV{uv} uz||p{uvË:yV{uv}yVxv}npE±74&} ¨5:yVyV Ç ¿É lnp:op }Cp¨u{|lY{|lnuz)p:¯Hwnuv« yVxvp p

48} ¨ :yV{|lnp&¨}|®!ip:¦¸}Eop }d{lnp,L{p:o>Cp8n|}Cp |x~ p°p 48} ¨ }HpU#{lp&©wnu p p |

p°np yEyVp J{p iuv«pL{p:o2n|}Cp {y p:xvyV{p {}{lnp¨}|®RRliyVnEp Ç |p{|lnp |p¦¸wx~xv

p:np |§n|p:p |«Huvn&|lnp opU¹{liy {XyVxz}«Ep |u¦¸§{lnpe}Ep |«»yV{uv}¹y {|lnp½,p:}op{|uz¾-}Ep:« yV{uv}

¿y»¨% §p§{lnp)¯HwnpU{|u~}EeyV|p§}xv«p E{|lnp uv}Exvwu~}Ee yVip,p:yEuvxvy yL{p {}6{lp }wnx~p

|lnp:odpU ±

kelnp)iyVCp &uz}|EynuvË p y¦¸}Ex~xv} ¨& ±Nuv|{:n{lnp! }H{uvJwnwno }Enx~p:o uz&p {'X{|lnp!ÉXwnxvp 8p:¯Hwy ¬

{|u~}E:n{liy {§uz{|}$|y»${|lnp 8y»«Juvp ¬³sJ{}®Ep:epU¯Ewiy {uv}ie¦¸},}on|p:|u~nxvp)uvH«Juz u ©i} ¨)iyV|p!¨|u{{p:

} ¨yV {|lnp8p:np |dnw p{uv-n|p:p H{p ±#kelnuv-uz }Enp8uv$y!°nLp JÉXwnxvp |uvy|p¦¸p |p ip8L{|p o

wL{,y9o} «Juvn }o9yu~'&)(+*,buv,}Eu p:p ±kelnp n{lp!©} ¨ p:¯HwyV{uv}8yV|p uv||p{|u~Ë:p uvy p

¦¸}Ex~xv} ¨uvny Ç ¿É ynn|}EylA¨luvl p:yxv,¨u~{l{|lnpdod} «Juvn$C}w yV| u/Lwnx~{Êy |y {|uv°p:

yxv}6{lnp6½!¾¿b±nkelnp)« yV|uvynxvp:yVn}»Luvo9y {uv}$}{lnp!wn¦ºy p,uz yp ¦¸wnxvx~ p:||u~Cp ± 8pJ{:{lnp

yyVxvLuzd} {lpAp np:Eª}ip:« y {|u~}E·uzwnpAuz9}E w{p |p:wnx~{uvnu~ yµnp:¨ Ç ¿É lp op±

uvyVxvxvL¨p!}ixvw p,{lnuzyip:u~sJpUÍ{|u~}E O ±

(8)

AÅ

¡:£n¡

Å

£ Æ ¤

ÅiÁ

¡

Å

kelnp,¦¸}Ex~xv} ¨u~d}V{|yV{uv}ey

}J«Ep H{uv}eyp,lnp |p)y

}EL{p

'

¥

yuzyVnxvp:n}{|yV{uv} '

sL yxvy|'i9np {|±

p:{}'§enp {|±

kp:}'e,Xp{V±¶sJy p$uv uzuzyVxn}V{y {|u~}E¦¸}d«p:{}E|!y {|p }!uzlp |p| yVp:x~

n|p¦¸p ||p L}Enx~¦¸}npUy {p:||u{|p |uvy±

É#J{p:uv«p)« yuzyVnxvp:'N §np{V±vLu~wnnCp § yp) uvL{&{Hxvp±

yV|uvynxvp: p°p yV{} p:'!#"$" p{V±XsJwnnuv uzpU -> $|p¦¸p {},n} yxEJwno6ip:: wnx~pU

{lnp! }H{yV|9uzepLnxvuv u{|x~yu ±

yV|uvynxvp: p °np yV{ p xvxÊC}wn yV|u~pU'&%"('E)"('ELp{V±vnxvyip:x~xvp ¨u~{l{¨}wnnuv uzpU ±

yV|uvynxvp:

p °np

yV{{|lnp

}Eoyu~C}wn

yV|u~pU'*8 ,+*

-

"('

np {|±~LxzyVCp xvx~p

}n}{:±

ÉNu~{p:u~ ,wodo9yV{uv}}EAp:ipUy {p uv uzp:

1

uv p A }H{y{uv} 2uv§np «Ep 8yEwnop iwnx~pU8{lnp

}H{yV|uv&pLnxvuv u{|x~$|yVu ±

. ¥ ¾-}iu p |uvnuvH{p:yVxz C{lp¦¸}xvx~} ¨uvnn}V{y {uv}Yuv)y }n{p Êwnnxvp:|}V{|lnp |¨uvpduv,pJ¬

x~uzu~{xv|yVu ±Xn}E&yVJ9°p:x0/

12

/4365 12

/87#9;:

¨lp |p 9 :yV!Cpb«E}xvwnop w¦ºyEpN}E¹{uvop-uvH{p |« yVx´ yV <7#9 xzyVCp xz¹{|lnp- }|pUC} u~ uN3Rp |p H{|uvyx^±

= >

" "6(9!0 &.@?"$BA ,C 4 ! .ED

0 1&3

kelpnlJLuz yx}Enx~p:o wn p:,{w Auv8{lnpduvH«Juz u }on|p:|u~nxvp!xzyVouvyV§©} ¨)±,²Ì{|§nlJJuz §uv

o} p:x~xvp JA{lpÉXwnxvp !pU¯Ewiy {uv}i Êiyuv:yVxvx~{|lnp 8y»«Juvp ¬§sH{|}®pU)p {!¨u{|ln}wn{!«Huz|}wi8{|p |o9 ±

}b }on|p:|uvnxvpe©} ¨&:V{luv-p {b}V¦¹p:¯HwyV{uv}-}EoduzpU{yVC}{Np:¯Hwy {|u~}EX¦¸}EX{lp8o9y| {lnp

o}Eodp:H{wno yV {|lnp&p p |

1

p:pe¦¸}Nuv{|yVip ?F A2Í±b¾-}on|p:|uvnuvx~u~{!uvH{|} wpUNyo9y }NliyVnEp

uvd©} ¨ ip:ly»«Ju~}Ewn'npUwn|p&Ê p u{GyV {|p oCp y {wp,H lynpUyp} ¨·|p xzy {p {ln|}wnEl

y{|yV{pp:¯HwyV{uv}ÊL¨lnuzlA}Ewnnxvp:{lp)p np:E9nw Ep{&¨u~{l{lnp)o9yEy ¦¸}E| pyVxzyV p::±

sJwni}Hpy©wnu uv6}EE{yVuvnp uvªyuv«p:ªyV{uzyVx }o9yVuv &JILKNMR#¨lnp:pPO uz{lpy p

u~op iuv}Ê± Ç xvxb{|lnp$« yV|uzyVnxvp:{|ly { p:||uvipu~{|6Cp ly»«Juv}wnyp{lnp:¶¦¸wn{uv}6}V¦&C}Eu{|u~}EQ

y {|u~op *Jip:u~n *RTSU :WV ,|±#²³}Ep |«»yV{uv«p¦¸}EoH{lp§wn®H} ¨}V¦Ê{|lnp,ÉNwnx~p:ep:¯Hwy {|u~}EyV|p

|p:Cp:Í{|u~«Ep xv{lnp p:u{0C¹{lpdo}Eodp:H{wnoX 5 #&y {lnpd{}{|yxp:np |ACp wnu{!«E}xvwnop

(9)

5

E±kelp9«p xv}Lu~{A«pUÍ{}E)uv}V{p

y yV

5

uz,{lnp{|}V{yVxXp p |Cp )wnu{

o9yE:Lip:u~§{|lnp,©wnu

&u~H{p:iyVx¹p p |$y

5

&±:4&p:pEL{lp!}ip:« y {|u~}E¦¸}Eo uz

*

"

( ", 5 U :

'

*

" ( " ' "6' , 5 U :

*

" ( " ( , , 5 U : 1

P2

¨lp |pN{lp-wnnuv uzp:n}{peyEpb }oC}np:E{ »u´±pE± : 5 :: Oy |p Cp:yV{p u~ uv p:}H{||yEÍ{:±

Ç 8«Juz }w8¦¸}pU8ypdyVp H{:C{|lnpd{|p:|{|p },uz! "6' 5 " "6'±)k} x~}Hp{lnpdp:¯HwyV{uv}:Cy

{|yV{pdxvy»¨>uv,np:p p '&{|lnpu pUyVx#EyE§{|yV{pdxvy»¨ 5 $# H ¦¸}E,uv{|ypE±#& p ,{lnuz,lJHC}V{|lnp:uz

{|lnpuvH{p |yxXp np:Euv% 5'&)( H!±*# uv!{lnp9wnu~«Ep yxXEy}i{yVH{!yV +&)( yV +&-, yV|p{lnp

Cp:u~°i,lnpUy {8y {& }{|yE{«E}xvwnopy y {8}E{|yVH{n|p:|wp,pUCp:{uv«p:x~E±

²³µy n u~{uv}{|}

1

P2Í¹yp {§}V¦N}Eip:xv p°np C}wn yV|

1 uv|wip xzy {|p 2&y u~u{|uvyx# }L¬

u{|u~}EyV|pnp p p {}d{y®Jx~p,{|lnp!}Ex~wn{uv}}V¦{|lnp)n|}nxvp o±X²³nu~{uzyVxÊ } u{|u~}EyV|p}V¦{|lnp)®Ju~

( : U , 365 ). ( ,: ¦¸}E&yVxvx! R&

( : U , 365 . ( , : ¦¸}&yVxvx R&

H ( : U , 3(5

H/. ( , :

¦¸}&yVxvx! R & 1

"2

y {lnp)|p:{}V¦{lnp)uvnu~{uzyVx¹« yV|uvynxvp: yCp p:uv«p ¦¸|}o{|lnp o±

00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000

11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111

11111111111111111111111111111111FW

IO MW

Γ Γ

Γ

Ω(t)

s

uvwn|p"'bsJ®Ep{l}¦{lp)p p |uv,n|}nxvp o±

2354 687:9<;5=?>A@?7)BACD;5=?E

kelp }|p§}¦{|lnp©wnu ¬³{|wiÍ{wp,u~H{|p yÍ{|u~}E}Enx~p:o9-uze{|lnpi}Ewn y$ } u{|u~}E${|ly {8 }wnnxvp:

C}V{|lL{p:o:± F-du~{|No}{uv}Ê{lnp8}xvu .* > GFyVHyVuv{{|lnp&uvH{p |yxn¦¸}pU#}V¦R{lp©wnu

(10)

}

w u~ylyVnEpuvYu~{|,p:np |p {uz6{|yV{w:±!k}¦¸}Lw}E{|lnuv,uzwnpEÊy$Ep np:uz!n|}x~p:o uv§{}

Cp6 }u

p |p

C®Ep{lnp

uvu~Ewn|p"'wnnC}Ep){lyV{ & 5

&)( *,|i¨ln}Hpi}Ewn

yuv

uv«Ju

p

uv

{|ln|p p

uz¸}Eu~H{!wp {|')y )# > -- yV

y 7PK > -- (*,|y

yV ,. ,. ,.

i}Ewn y

1y n u{|u~}EyVxvx~Enxvp{8yVxvx¹C}wn yV|u~pU-Cp!y uvyy {|uv,}p:2'

& 5

+

(*,

1

(2

8

p:N{lp:p8y|wodn{uv}:V{|lnp8C}wn

yV|6 }

u~{uv}ibln}wnx

Cp§}Eoy {|u~nxvp&¨u~{l9C}V{|l9{lnp§¨yx~x

1o} «Huvn9}E8n}{2euvoip:op:ynuvx~u~{y y uvyy {|uv u{Ei{|}nEx~u~oC}Ep y 8uv|uvlnxvp{ 1}E}Eop

«Ep xv}Lu~{}oC}np:H{|2,}¨-pUyV®Jxvu~oC}Ep y8p wno9yV 1}Y{lp{yÍ{|u~}EY}E{lnp9lp:y {©} ¨ 2

48p |p8¨u~xvxHn}V{|p ¡ Á;CÁ !Å ¤ ¸¡ Â Æ¸ :¡ ¢$¸ Ê¡ ÅÌÅ ¢§£!!R¡ Á Å ¡: & Á !Å! ! ¡ Å ¡ Á Å !

Ä £!! op:yEwn|p u~y°nLp ÉNwnx~p:uzyV$¦¸|yop±Nn}E{lnp)|yV®p,}V¦#xzyV|u{EJu~{lnp)|p:{e}V¦{|lnp)yVyx~Luv

°Jp i}Ewn yuvp:xvu~®Ep yV yV|p6{|}Aip9}V{p y yV o} «Juvn¨yx~xzx~uv®p #(*,#y

(*,|±

kelnp}Ep:« yV{uv}§¦¸}|o }¦L{lnpX©i} ¨µpU¯Hwy {|u~}EÊuz p:uv«p ¦¸}Eo y&uvodx~pb¦ºyÍ{P'}opXu~oC}{|yE{

}Eip:{|u~pUXyV|pe }p |«p yE©wnu Ep{Xu~9y }wL{N}¦Cyuv«p:6«E}xvwnop±#k}p:«»yx~wiy {pe{|lnuzXyVxzyVip

yx~x¹}¦{|lnp u/3Cp:p:E{|uvyx¹p:¯HwyV{uv}

1

$2e yCp)u~H{|p y {|p u~iyp)yE¦¸}xvx~} ¨&:±¿p{&we¨|u~{p,{lnp:o

Ep np:uz yx~xvy

1

pU yx~x .n}V{y {|u~}E 2

*

( , 5 U :

¨lp |p y |p n|p:p H{|{lnp{yVi}E{|p ¯HwyE{|u{yV u{©wn|p:Cp:Í{|u~«Ep xv±²³H{p:y {|p uv

yEpLu~{&uze}L{yVuvnp 1 !

* 1

"!

$# 5 U : 1

qK2

yV¦Ó{p:wu~nª{lnp u~«Ep |p ip½yVwi X{lp }|p o± kelnp«Ep:Í{|}%# uz9{lppJ{p:uv}$n}|o9yVx{|}¶{lnp

C}w

yV|

&,±X²³{luve¨ey» (H0$-©} ¨ ¯HwyH{u~{uvp:e y$Cp{w

u~p

±X¼ lnp:y6x~}L:yVxvx~

p °np

« yuzyVnxvp&xvu~®Ep

uv-uvE{|p E|yV{p

} «Ep X{|lnp8«E}xvwnop & wn

p {|w

J¨p8}EL{|yu~$y9pJ{p:u~«Ep§¯HwyVH{|u{

G'

5 1 !

kelp$p «E}xvwL{uv}¶}¦{lnppJ{p:u~«Ep¯HwyVH{|u{|u~pU!uzo} p xvp HpU¯Ewiy {uv}i!xvu~®Ep

1

q 2Í±Y²Ì¦&u~

1

qK2#{lnp

uvH{p:y {uv} }Eoyu~uz!lynuvnAuvY{|u~opEu´±p±& 5 &)(*,{|lnpy{|uvyxX{uvop p |uv«»yV{uv«p9 y¶ip

{yV®Ep }wL{}V¦{lp)u~H{p:yVxRJop:ye}V¦{lnp!}9 yx~xvp p Jn}Ex J¦¸}Eo6wnxvy0'

77 * 5 7

7 * & 1

!')(+*

-, 5 1

!')(+*

* 1

".!')(+*

/# 1O 2

Ç Eyu~Ê0#uv){lnppJ{|p |u~}E,}|oyxXyV uz)y{lnp9Ep np:uz«Ep xv}Lu~{}V¦-{lnp9o} «Ju~C}wn yV|u~pU ±

Fwiuvn

1O 2u~

1

q 2Ínu~{&uze}L{yVuvnp

77 * 1

"!')(+*

.# " 1

"!'1(+*

/# 5 U : 1I 2

(11)

¨luvluzb{lnp,yuzN}V¦yJ

Ç

¿Éª¦¸}|ownxzy {|u~}EÊEy¨-p:x~x~¬Ìwnu~{p

u

o} «JuvnC}wn

yV|u~pU ±,kelnp6pU¯Hwy {|u~}E

1I

28uz&{|lnp6®Ep {}wn

p:|{|y

{|lnpd }p |« y {|u~}Euvuvnxvp:

w

p ,{|w

u~{|lnuz8yip:'yVJ

Ç

¿É |lnp:odp6ln}Ewnx

«p |u~¦¸{lp!p np:E }p |« y {uv}Ay

{lnp

}V¬³ yx~xvp p:}op{|uz§ }p |« y {|u~}EÊ± F}{lAyV|p§uvH{|} wp u~{lnp)pJ{{¨-}9p:{uv}:±

232 := > ?@?>

¼ lp $ynnxvu~p

{}){|lnp&{|}V{yVxCp np:Ep:¯HwyV{uv}ÊJyb¨u~{{|p uv9{|lnp§p{

1

P2EJdu~H{|p y {|u~!} «p:X{lnp

L{|p o J{lp}xvu «Juvy${lpdopUlyVnuz yxXyÍ{|u~}E}¦N{lnpo} «Ju~C}wn yV|±6sL}xvp{ uv 1O 2§ip

5 5 Q

J{lp{}V{yVx¹p:np |E±#kelp Ênu~{|&pJ{p:uv«p) }wnH{p:iyV{uz

5 1 ! :

¨luvlu~{|wn«Ep |u°pU-{lnp!p:Jn}x J¦¸}|ownxzy 1O 2

1

!')(+*

*

T

5 7

7 * " 1

"!')(+*

T

/# 1

2

kelp |p¦¸}|pH{|lnp)p np:E{yVC}{epU¯Hwy {|u~}E:yVip)¨|u{{p:yE

7

7 * 5 " 1

".!')(+*

Q

$# " 1

"!')(+*

$#

1

".!')(+*

Q

/# 1F 2

sLu~ p,{lnp)uvoip:op:ynuvx~u~{ }

u~{uv}

$# 5 /#

$# 5 U 1D 2

uzy|wodp

C}V{|lY}E{lpdo} «Juvny

°Jp

¨eyVxvxz R{|lnp Å

¢ £!

ÅJÄXiÁ

!Å ¤ Ó¡

Â #uz§{lnp:p

pU¯HwyVxC{}6{lp<Å ¢ £ !- Å !¸Æ Ä £!! iÁ !Å ¤ Ó¡Â!#±Nkelnuvey n u~{uv}yxR } u{|u~}Euzwp {|}9 yVip x

}op,{p:o9euv

1F 2}E${|lnp)o} «Ju~ndC}wn yV|L¨lnuzln} ¨ Cp: }op:

7

7 * 5 " 1

T

$# " 1 $# " 1 $# 1 :(2

kelnpep:np |« yV|uvyV{uv} }on|uvp:{lp 6{ln|p peC}wn yV|§{|p |o9 ln} ¨!uvÉN¯Hwy {|u~}E

1

U(2±kelnp

(12)

!{|lnp8©iwnu

J6{|lnp,od} «Juvn!¨eyVxvx^±NsJp:p&{|ly {eyVxvxi{|ln|p p§yp§}V¬Ìxvu~npUyV-¨u{|l{lp8«p:x~}L u{9yV

u{e¨uvx~x

Cp)n|p:p H{p:Ey

xvp:|-p u~{lnp:«Huz|}Eu~{9}&}EonpUuvnu~xvu~{±

ÉN¯HwyV{uv}

1

:(2¹ly¹Cp p: yxv wnxzy {p

¦¸}Eo {|lnpby pNu~H{|p y {|u~}E§}¦J{lnpX{|}V{yVxp:np |8{yVC}{

G

(

( 5 1 (

( 7

7 * : 1

P2

Cp{¨p p:${|u~opU * yV

* 1

Cp uvn *

*

2±N²Ì{&ln}Ewnx

«Ep |u¦¸

G

(

( 5 ( , (

( 5 (

( 1

U"2

¨lp |p (

(

ln}x 8¦¸}§{lnp6{lnp:o9yx# }H{|uvnwL{uv}{}{lnpdEyE¦¸|}o }wn{|u pE¹yV (

(

¦¸},{lnp

±6¼Yp9y|wnop

{|ly { 5 U± Ç )lnuvlx~uvlH{p u~Y{lnp$u~H{|} w{uv}ÊÉb¯EwiyVxvu{

1

U(2§uv{|lnp9®p:}V¦{lp9npUp:H{

¨}|®M'{|u~«JuzyVxu~{lnp}EE{|u~JwnwoRu~{ln}Ewnx ipyVyx~JË:p ¨lnp:{uvopdy y p uz||p{uvË:yV{uv}

yp,p J«Juzyp {}}xv«p§{lnp)}Enx~p:o±

(

yCp!nx~u~{8y¦¸}Ex~xv} ¨&'

(

( 5 ( , (

( 1

:(2

keluvuvxvw pU{|lnp{ln|p pe}EH{|u~nwn{uv}}V¦iÉb¯Ewiy {uv}

1

U(2Í±#keln}Hp}ouvn§¦¸}Eo {lnpu~nwL{J }wL{|nwL{

}o9yVuv$C}wn yV|J|}wip uv nyxv}yVnCp:y¨lp yVxvx¹i}Ewn yuvp:eyV|p&°Jp y {lnp:p ¦¸}|p

n|p:p H{|§n}yV{uzwnxzyV u/Lwnx~{uvp:,uvµy Ç ¿É }H{p H{U±kelnp u/3Cp:p:E{|uvyx¦ºyÍ{uz§} ¨ {lnp

δ Ω d_i

δΓ(t) n_i

δΓ(t+δt)

Ω(t)

u~Ewn|p)'#¼Y}E®Cp ¦¸}|op J9{lnp)o} «Juvn¨yx~x´±

Ç x{|p |y {|u~«Ep xv9{}

1

EP2n yVxzwxvyV{p ye|yVu yi} «Ep,yEey }o9yVuvuvH{p:yVxR}V¦{lnp)p:np |{||y¬

C}{ep:¯Hwy {|u~}EÊH{lnp|u~ElH{ly u p}V¦

1

p:uvn,{lp&o} «p op:E{X}¦ (*,E{lp¨-}E®Cp H{Nu~{|lnuzXo}V{uv}9y {lnp&p:np |H¬Ì¨-}E®uvH{p lynpU