Accuracy barriers in mesh adaptation

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00072060

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00072060

Submitted on 23 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub-

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,

Accuracy barriers in mesh adaptation

Y. Coudière, Bernadette Palmerio, Alain Dervieux, D. Leservoisier

To cite this version:

Y. Coudière, Bernadette Palmerio, Alain Dervieux, D. Leservoisier. Accuracy barriers in mesh adaptation. RR-4528, INRIA. 2002. �inria-00072060�

(2)

ISRN INRIA/RR--4528--FR+ENG

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

THÈME 4

Accuracy barriers in mesh adaptation

Y. Coudière — B. Palmerio — A. Dervieux — D. Leservoisier

N° 4528

August 12, 2002

(3)

(4)

#%$&('*),+-/.1032547698$;:=<?>A@B2C03-A'ED69FG$;H2C0JIK-A2C)LNMO6;HG$;P2CQJ2C0JI?'*-AQ3-A2C0SR

TVUXWY[Z\(]_^a`bYdcXegfihj`lk1mnZ!hkpoqhj`lY[`grsfths`bkpm

u Z rsvarwhsWJY[ZJrx!k1Y[oXelZyqZJr

z9{jkt|}Z!h~^aYf1rwU

~ftoXo?kp{sh u Z{sZ3xUXZ{xUXZm?,\Cpp5]cX1crwh 3qppC=]1doftpZ3r

JiXpp TVUXZxkpmapZJ{s1ZmxZO{fihjZkp~hsUZnfpoXoX{jkyq`lYfihj`lk1mBkt=f5mkpmqrwY[kakthjU9h}vaoX`gxfpelebv u `gr}

xkpmChs`bmacXkpcrcXmx!hs`bkpm xJftm¢¡ZYf u ZU`l1UXZ{dhsUfpm%crwcfte£UZmBftmBf u ftoXhjfihj`l1ZY[ZJrsU%{sZ¤mXZY[ZJm1h

rwhs{fihjZ1vS`br fpoXoXeb`lZ u¦¥`bmBx!kpmChj{jf1r}h=hsknhjUXZcXmX`lkp{jY§Y[Z3rwU¢{jZ!¤mXZJY[ZmCh¨!©OªcqhJkp{`grwkphs{jkpoX`gx(Y[ZJrsU

{jZ!¤mXZY[ZmCh3qhsUX`grk1{ u Z{~xJftmn¡Zdel`bY[`«hjZ u hsk¬a!®¯/¬d°E±p²;kp{hsUXZd³;´"mXk1{sYµftm u frsofpxZ u `bY(ZJmrs`lk1m

¬©

¶S·C¸*¹jºd» i¼p Y[Z3rwUf u fpoqhs`bkpmXfpoXoX{jkyq`lYfihj`lk1ma`lmChjZ{jok1ebfths`bkpm

½¿¾ÀÁÂ!Ã}ÄAÅÆÁÇ/ÈÉ3Ã;ÊËÀ!ÇÆÃ}ÅsÌiÍËjÇÆÎÈ}ÏËjÇ/ÁÑÐJÒ3ÃwÅwÌtÓÕÔÖØ×Ø×ØÙØÚ3ÌtÛØÛ!ÜØ×Ø×VÊËÀ!Ç/ÃwÅ,Ý*ÃwÉ3Ã}Þ=Ü

ß

¾ÀÁÂ!Ã}ÄAÅÆÁÇ/ÈÉ3Ã;ÊÁÑà}ÃØÌiÍËjÇ/ÎÈ}ÏËjÇÆÁÑÐÒÃ}ÅsÌtÔXËÄAà,á*ËâÑÄAãØÅÆÃØÌtÙØä3åwÙØÚÊKÁÑà}Ã!Ìæçè,ÊÝÕé

ê,ë

Êç

ë

è¿ÌtÓÕÔÖØÜ3ÌtÙØäØÖØÙØ×ìJãØí3ÎÁîËèÀ!Ç/ÁÑípãØâÑÁÑÅÝ*Ã}ÉÃÞ1Ìæçè,ÊÝÕé

ï

ì3Êé?ÝÍèÌtÝ*Ã}ÀÇ/ÄAÃÉ3Ã,á,ÁÑâÑâîËÄAãJàðÎ3Ã!ÌtñØñòØòØÙÍãØÁÑÅÆÅ/óôÝ*Ä/ËÏËwó!Ã}âgÌæçè,ÊÝéËÀÉ

ë

Êç ëè

(5)

Zhjfpcqy u Zx!k1mapZ{jpZJmx!Z[o?kpcX{"eftooX{skyq`bYfihs`bkpm u cXmXZOkpmx!hs`bkpm u `grsxkpmChs`bmacXZk1c

`b{j{JpcXeb`lWJ{sZôoZJcqhoX{JrsZmChsZJ{VcXmnkp{ u {sZ=oXebcrebZp{px!Z(ecqhj`leb`brjfihj`lk1m u cXmZ r}hj{jfth1`lZ u Z{fmXZ!

Y[ZJm1h f u ftoqhfihj`«}egfoebf1x!Z u cmXZ[Y hsUXk u Z u Z({fmXZJY[ZmCh=cmX`«k1{sY[Z1© !=ftmrôhjkpcrebZJrxJfprJx!Z!h

k1{ u {sZ u ZxkpmapZJ{s1ZmxZ"Z3r}h"xZo?Zm u ftmCh el`bY[`«h"S¬qØ®¯Æ¬° ±p² ¥ZJm%mXkp{jY[Z[³ ´ ZhdZm u `bY[Zmrs`lk1m%¬C¨

o?kpc{elZ3rf u fpoqhjfths`bkpmrV`grwkphs{jkpo?ZJrJ©

# »

3

¹

%$

Yft`belegft1Zpqf

u

ftoqhfihs`bkpmKXftoXoX{jkyq`lYfths`bkpmC`lmChjZ{jok1ebfths`bkpm

(6)

& '

d nO! "

(mrwo`«hjZ~ktKhsUXZ=Z!yahs{ftk1{ u `lmfp{sv"oX{jkpp{jZJrjr9`bmOZx`lZJmx!v[kphsUXZx!k1Yd¡X`bmfths`bkpmktmCcY(ZJ{s`gxfpeY[ZhsUXk u r

fpm u x!k1Y(ocqhsZJ{jrJpY[k1rwh;ktÕ`bm u crwhs{j`gfte)ki£¦rs`lY"cXebfths`bkpmrft{jZo?Z{skp{jY[Z u £`lhsUX`bmpZJ{sv"okakp{¿fpxxcX{fpx!v

xkpm u `«hj`lk1mr©9TVUXZYfiyq`bYfte?hsUXZJkp{jZ!hj`bxJfte*kp{ u Z{VkpfpxJx!cX{fpxv[`brVkphsZmebZJrjrhjUftmh}£k©+*9pZJm£UZmn`«h

`gr~h}£¿khjUX`gr`brômXkthkp¡rwZJ{s1Z u kpm7hsUXZ({jZJrscXe«hr u cZdhjkOhjUXZ"egfpx,nkp¿rwY[kakthjUXmXZ3rsrôkt;hjUXZ-)ki£ ¤Zeu r

cm u Z{=r}hjc u v1©*9`lhsUXZJ{~hjUXZJrsZ)ki£N¤Zeu r~fp{sZ {j`bpkpc{sk1crwebvOrs`lmpcXegft{ ¥`bmCa`grsx`u rsUXkqx,qr?rw`bmX1cXebfp{s`lhs`bZJr

fth=fpmXpcXegft{~£fpelegrj¨!*kp{hjUXZvSfp{sZ"{sZJpcXegft{3¡XcXhô£`lhsU5rsofths`gfte,rsxJftebZJrhjkakrsY[fpelekp{ô¡ZJ`lmxfpoqhsc{sZ u

£`lhsUOhsUXZ~hsUXZJkp{jZ!hj`bxJfte?kp{ u Z{¿ktKfpxJx!cX{fpxvp©.(mO¡?kthsUxfprsZJrJ1hsUXZftoXoft{jZmChkp{ u ZJ{ktKf1xxcX{jf1x!v[xfpm¡Z

k1mXZkp{ZJpZmebki£¿ZJ{J©

/GZ~mXkphsZ`bmof1rsrs`lmhsUfthkpcX{{sZJY[fp{0,(ftoXoel`bZJr;fpebrskhsk hsUXZ~rsktxfpelebZ u UX`bpU{jZJrskpebcqhj`lk1m[rjxUXZJY(Z3r

`bmapk1ela`bmX~eb`lY[`lhsZJ{jrJt£UX`gxU"`bm u ZJZ u oX{jkipZ u hsUXZJ`l{;fp¡X`bel`lh}v `bm(xJftoqhjcX{s`bmX=Yftmavdrs`lmX1cXegft{j`«hj`lZ3rK`bmfhjUX`lm

rscX¡X{jZ1`lk1m[ktÕhsUZôY[ZJrsUOfpm

u

£`«hjUXkpcXh21=`b¡X¡r¿oXUXZJmXkpY[Zmkpm©9TVUXZJv"UXki£Z1Z{

u

kdmXkphrsUXki£ f ¡?Z!hwhjZ{

f1x!cX{fpxv[hsUfthV¤{jrwhwðkp{

u

ZJ{k1m

u

`brjx!k1m1hj`lmacX`lhs`bZJr

¥

kp{~fpmavcrwcfteY[ZJf1rwc{jfp¡XelZôcXmx!hs`bkpmrmXkp{jY¨Ø©

3

mXZ[£VfvhsknZJrjxfpoZ({jkpY hsUZ(eb`bY(`lhjfths`bkpmGktVfpxxcX{fpx!vnk1mGrs`lmpcXegft{j`«hj`lZ3r~`gr=hskSf

u

kpoqhfY[ZJrsU

f u ftoXhjfihj`lk1mfpoXoX{jk1fpxUK©

(m54b6ðahsUXZmXkphs`bkpmkt9fpxJx!cX{fpxvktf u ftoXhjfihj`l1ZôY[ZhsUXk u r`gr u `grsxcrjrwZ u ©+(ðh`brrsUXki£mhsUfth~rwk1Y[Z

kp*hsUXZ3rwZY[ZhsUXk u r¿ft{jZft¡XebZVhskdxJftoqhjcX{jZ! u `brjx!k1m1hj`lmacX`lhs`bZJr£`«hjUkp{ u Z{r9kp*f1xx!c{jf1x!vdZ87Ccfteqhjkh}£k

k1{¡ZhwhjZ{3©;TVUX`brY(Z3ftmrhjUfih~f(1elk1¡fte*Y[ZJrsUSf u fpoqhjfths`bpZ=Y(ZhsUXk u ?x!k1Yd¡X`bmX`bmXftmnftoXoX{jkyq`lYfths`bkpm

rjxUXZJY(Zftm u f7£Zebe u Z!¤mXZ u f u fpoqhjfths`bpZO{jZY[Z3rwUX`bmX;okCrsrsZJrjrsZJr `lhjr[ki£m kp{ u Z{(ktôf1xxcX{jf1x!v5kp{

rskpY[Z=AftY[`belvOkt u `brjx!k1mChs`bmCc`«hj`lZ3r©9(u ZJm1hj`«va`bmX[hsU`brk1{u Z{Vkt,fpxxcX{fpx!v£`bebe{sZJelvOkpmh}£¿kftmftebvarsZJr;:

<

{sk1Y kpmXZ(rw`u ZpÕ`lhô`gr=mXZJxZJrjrsfp{svOhsknftmfpelvqrsZhsUZ(f1xx!c{jf1x!vO`bm hjUXZ({sZJpcXegft{~xJfprsZp?hsUfihô`grôhsUXZ

fpxJx!cX{fpxvkp{ u Z{VkthsUZ ftoXoX{jkyq`lYfths`bkpmOrjxUXZY[Z1qkpmSf(mXkpmqðcXmX`lkp{jY Y[ZJrsU>=

<

{sk1Y hjUXZkthjUXZ{drs`u Zp£¿ZftegrskmZZ u hjk ftmfpelvqrsZ"hjUXZY[ZJrsU%f u fpoqhjfths`bkpm¢r}hj{jfthsZ1vp©?/GZxfpm

`lmChjZ{joX{sZhsZhjUX`grdrwhs{fihsZJpvGfpr f rsvqr}hjZY x!k1m1hj{sk1e9kpmXZ1©S rsZmrskp{ k1{dxfpoqhsk1{ £`bele

u

Z!hjZJxØh"hsUXZ

{sZJp`bkpmktY(Z3rwUhjk({jZ!¤mXZkp{x!kCft{rwZJmqftmnfpx!hscfthskp{V£`beleK¡XcX`be

u

hsUZmXZ£ Y[ZJrsU©

@nkCr}hVktoXcX¡Xeb`brsUXZ

u

£kp{ ,qr`bmhjUXZel`lhsZJ{jfthscX{jZ~ZyqfpY[`lmXZôhsUZxJftoqhjkp{31`Æ©Zp©,hsUZôZJ{s{jkp{¿ZJrwhs`bY[fthsZ1©+(m

k1cX{£kp{ ,*q£¿Zdf1rsrscXY[Z£ZUfpZ f[o?Z{sZJx!hôxfpoqhsk1{J©A/5Zkqxcrk1mhjUXZd`grjrwcXZhjUfihôZpZJmncXm u ZJ{hsU`br

f1rsrscXY[oqhj`lk1m1YfpmCv({jZY[ZJrsUX`bmX r}hj{jfthsZJp`bZJrxJft{j{s`bZJr;£`«hjUhsUXZJYf r}hj{sk1mX eb`lY[`lhjfths`bkpmkpÕhsUXZôkp{ u Z{;kp

f1xxcX{jf1x!vkpKhsUZpebkp¡fpe*f u ftoXhjfihj`l1ZftoXoX{jk1f1xU©

@nk1{sZdoX{sZ3x!`grwZJelv1XhjUXZ Yft`bm B ?hsUXZ Zyq`brwhsZJmx!Z kp;£UX`gxUS£¿Z £VftmCh~Z3r}hft¡Xeb`grwU`br u ZJrjx!{j`b¡Z u

¡avhjUXZkpebebki£`lmX(ebZY[YfC:

DFEGHGHIKJ!LJ

MON>PRQTSVUXWZY"[\O]9^`_PYUa^`Wcbd[`Y#e!^CfgUXhVP]C]i_jUa[8f?Y"^PF]ZUa[8k[Bl+UXh[A\[ mon_pP\+NOnWik;Y#U^BWq.rsft[uCW![8fc^BWv+wCrCPBW>f

UXWZx`^B_#x`UXWm5fUXhk^BWZYUXW!nU#Y#U[hrVYe![WyYe![zk^`WZx`[\{mC[Wik[-^B\f[\|yUXWB³ ´~}±N®5dl+eZ[WHbd[h0e5UXh

\[usW![8fl+U#Y#ePBWPtfP;]9YPCYUx`[TUXh^tY#\^]ZU#kVbd^Cft[gkPW[W!^Y[`Y0Y"[\YeoPW

|

±

® ¬

¬d°E±.

(7)

^acxU ¡fp{s{j`lZJ{jr"ft{jZO{fihjUXZ{[rw`bY[oXebZOhjk5oX{jkaktôfpm

u

kp~pZJmXZ{fteVftoXoel`gxfths`bkpm©5(m oft{shs`gx!cXegft{"£¿Z

u

kmXkphxkpmrs`

u

Z{fofp{whj`bxcXegft{z !*©>(m

u

ZJZ

u

*hjUXZ"eb`bY(`lhjfths`bkpmGoXcqh`lmGZa`

u

Zmx!Z k1{`lmChsZJ{so?kpegfihj`lk1m

rsUXk1cXe

u

Z!yahjZm

u

hskz !R* ftooX{skyq`bYfihsZ

u

rskpebcqhs`bkpmr©

TVUXZ7`lmqk1{sYfths`bkpm u ZJel`bpZJ{sZ u `grfpebrskBfBrs`lY[oXebZ kpmZ: % ! `grwkphs{jkpoX`gxnY[ZJrsU f u fpoqhs`bkpm rscxU fpr

R@S ¥s¥! #B K !s `bm £U`bxU xcX¡X`gx1kpebcXY[ZJrdfp{sZOelkqxfpelebv u `la`u Z u `lmB`u ZJm1hj`bxJfte

rsYftebelZJ{(xcX¡X`gxOk1mXZJr¨"ft{jZOmXkph[rsZJxkpm u ðkp{ u ZJ{dfpxJx!cX{fihjZp9`Æ©Z1©%Z`bpUCh"hj`lY[Z3r"Y[k1{sZpkpebcXY[ZJr u kGmXkth

va`bZeu k1cX{hj`lY[ZJrrsYftebelZJ{Z{j{sk1{J©

(mE^qZJxØhj`lk1mEn£Z{jZJxfpele¿UXki£ hsUXZfpxJx!cX{fpxv7kp{u ZJ{ kt~fSY[Z3rwU f u ftoXhs`bpZ ¥kp{dmkth¨ Y[Z!hsUk u `br

u Z!¤mXZ u ©9(m^aZJx!hs`bkpm % 1£¿ZZ3r}hft¡Xeb`brsU(hsUXZ~el`bY[`«hj`lmXdkp{ u Z{9kp*f1xx!c{jf1x!vk1{9`brskthj{sk1oX`bxVY[Z3rwUf u ftoqhj`l1Z

Y[ZhsUXk u rJqkp{ u `*Z{jZmChF,a`lm u kp,rs`bmXpcXegft{j`lhs`bZJr`lmv+w?kp{¬ ±X©;TVUZebf1r}hrsZJxØhj`lk1mn`lebelcr}hj{jfthsZJr

hjUXZJrsZ¡ft{j{j`lZJ{jr£`lhsUSf(Y(k u ZJ{smY[ZJrsUSf u fpoqhs`bpZ=hskak1e/©

d¿ " O

/GZ~xkpmrs`u Z{9hjUXZ~`bmChsZ{jo?kpegfihs`bkpm[kp*Y[k1{sZk1{;elZ3rsr¿rwY[kakthjU[cXmx!hs`bkpmr u Z!¤mZ u `bmOf{sZJpcXegft{¡k1cXm u Z u

u kpYft`bm! kt9v w ¥¬"±1qqk1cC¨Ø©

TVUXZ"`lmChjZ{jok1ebfths`bkpmSY[Z!hjUXk u r~cm u Z{=r}hjc u vSft{jZ ¡Xc`lelh~{jkpY f u `grjx!{jZ!hs`$#Jfths`bkpmSkp9hsUXZ(x!kpY[oXcXhjfi

hj`lk1mfte u kpYft`bm% =hsUZY(Z3rwUK'& ÕhjUfih {jZeb`bZJrkpm%fofp{whj`«hj`lk1m5kp( `lmChjk!) o?kpebvapkpmfte,ZebZY[ZmChr

hjUfih£Z u ZmkthsZ+* Xftm u hsUfih~ft{jZfprjrwcXY[Z u hjk¡Z xkpmapZy*ak1oZJmrsZ!hrrscxUhsUfth-,/.10*230 =©

/GZZ!yXftY[`bmXZ(hsUXZxkpmapZJ{s1ZmxZdoX{jkpo?Z{shs`bZJr=kpVfpm5`bmChsZ{jo?kpegfihs`bkpm5Y[Z!hsUk u ki1Z{fnrwZ871cZmxZ(kp

Y[Z3rwUXZ3rd¯4&

´ ²

´6587

©/GZ(f1rsrscXY[ZhjUfih`lm7hsUX`gr=rwZ871cZmxZdkt;Y[Z3rwUXZ3r?hjUXZ"rs`9#JZdkp;ZebZY[ZmChjrôhjZm u r~hsk

#JZ{jk©9xxkp{

u

`bmXpebv[hsUXZmacXY"¡ZJ{ktZebZY[ZmChjrhsZm

u

rhsk`bmq¤mX`lh}vp©

: E;/<>=@?A=CBD<E>L#JGFH:I=IsG~ED?EJzI<LKGJMBONP<QKO< E8R6RTS

UZ^`\2PBWMV-] ^B_WVmC^`WX* UjW v9worUY#hfUPBbd[`YO[\ZY\[ UphRYe![ fUPBbd[`YO[\T^`N+Y#e![h{bP_j_a[h;Y.h"]Ze![\[ k^`WZY"PBUXWCUjWCm

UY PBW>fcUY#h2\^tnWifW![h0h][ Uph Ye![gfUPBbd[BY"[\^BNAY#e![_PB\0m[h;Y9h]ZeZ[\[FUXWsh0Uf[U#Y_^

TVUZ={fihj`lk][=Y`[ Y(Z3fprscX{jZJr¿hsUXZrsUfto?ZktQ* :9£UZmn`«h`grx!ebk1rsZ=hskn±p* `grx!ebk1rsZ~hjk[f[rsoXUXZJ{sZkp{

mZJft{jebv`brskthj{sk1oX`bxpq£UXZm`lh`brxelkCrwZ=hjk"a* `brY"cxUnr}hj{sZhjxUXZ u k1{r}hj{sk1mXpebvftmX`grskths{jkpo`bxp©

: E;/<>=@?A=CBD<E>LbEcFedINoIDRT=f6NP<'=ghBDJBG G~ERji+ERRElk/NiE<LmERTS

n h[6on[Wik[ ^BN bd[h0e![h¯4&

´ ²

´j587

Uph-onPh0Up nWsUjN#^B\0bUXN

qsr-t avua®w x rzy"{|

.T}

Y\[ y~b

.}

]D[

eZ[W

Y y{|

. } Y\[

UphFP-bd[Ph;n\[ ^`N Y#e![bd[h0eh{U$`[TN#^`\TPWMV[_a[bd[WZYA^BN YeZ[Rh[jotnt[Wik[8^

(m[frwZ87CcXZmxZ¿kpcXm`«k1{sY Y[Z3rwUXZ3rpmXkZebZY[ZmCh9Ufpr9f={jkpcXm

u

mXZJrjr,rwYfpelebZ{hsUftm

r

YK©TVUZZJelZJY[ZmChjr

fp{sZZJrjrwZJm1hj`bfpelebv=ktrjftY[Z¿rs`9#JZftm

u

{sk1cXm

u

mZJrjr©TVUXZ1elk1¡fte1Y(Z3rwU ¤mXZmZJrjrKk1{rs`9#JZ`gr

u

Z¤mXZ

u

{sk1cXpUelv

(8)

¡avOf[rs`lmpebZ=macXY"¡ZJ{J©+(mnkphsUXZJ{£kp{

u

rJahsUXZmacXY"¡ZJ{ktZebZY[ZmChjr ) ´

`grV{sZJebfthsZ

u

hjk"hjUXZ rs`9#JZ Y ´ :

qIr t

avuq®Iw!x

r Y w´ r

Y[ZJfpr¯C ô²

) ´ Y w

´ ¥

3¨

rs`bmx!Z ]tw

[ r Y(Z3fpr¯H*%²F Y!w

[

kp{=ftmav * ¥r `br~hsUXZ[x!k1mrwhjftmChôfp{s`grs`lmXO`lm !ôZ!¤mX`«hj`lk1mGX©1¨Ø©ôTVU`br

xJftm¡Z fpebrsk(£{s`lhwhjZm>:

Y ´

±

)

´ S

w

: E;/<>=@?A=CBD<E>L FER6i =RB\?AJMB'S

n h[6on[Wik[ ^BN bd[h0e![h¯4&

´ ²

´j587

UphUph^Y\^]ZU#kVUXN U#Y hPY#UXh0u![h

qIrzt avuq®Iw!x r y~$

. } ]D[

Y [

TVU`br,oX{jkpo?Z{sh}v ZJmrwc{sZ3r9ft1fp`lmr}h9ftm[`bmq¤mX`lhsZrwhs{jZ!hxUX`lm=`Æ©Zp©hsUXZ{fihj`lk ] [ Y [ xftmmXkth,hsZJm u hsk+#JZ{jk

a©ki£ZpZJ{JC`bmxkpmChs{fprwhhjk(cmX`«k1{sY Y(Z3rwUZJrJC`bmnftmnft{j¡X`«hj{jfp{sv(`grwkphs{jkpoX`gx~Y[Z3rwUhsUXZZJelZJY(ZJmChjrVxfpm

¡?ZktpZJ{sv u `*Z{jZmChrw`$#Z1©

/GZ{sZ3r}hj{s`gxØhmXki£ hjk"Y[Z3rwUXZ3rV`lma1kpebC`bmX(rw`bY[oXelZyqZJrJq`/©Zp©,`bmS%!dChj{s`gftmX1elZ3rqfpm u `bm % !"ahsZ!hj{jfpUXZ!

u {jf©

¿V ¿ ¦d d7 ! "

(m(hjUXZr}hftm u ft{ u hjUXZk1{sv1ihsUXZôftoXoX{jkyq`lYfths`bkpmdZJ{s{jkp{,`gr9Y[ZJf1rwcX{jZ u fpr9fôcXmxØhs`bkpmkp?ebkqxfpeqY(Z3rwUrs`9#JZp©

TVU`brmXkphs`bkpm¢`gr£¿ZJelef u ftoXhsZ u hskncXm`«k1{sY rwZ871cZmxZJrktY[ZJrsUXZJrJ©?(ðh Z!yahsZJm u r fpebrskhsk rsZ;7CcXZmx!ZJr

hjUfih~fp{sZ=cXmX`lkp{jY[elv{sZ¤mXZ u ©

(mY[Z3rwUf u ftoqhj`lk1m(Y[ZhsUXk u r;hsUXZY[Z3rwUXZ3rfp{sZVmXkphcXmX`lkp{jYn1ftm u hsUXZ~rsZ;7CcXZJmx!Z3r;ft{jZVmXkth¿cXmX`lkp{jY(ebv

{jZ!¤mXZ u ©

(mdhsUXZxebf1rsrs`bxJfteaftoXo{skyq`bY[fths`bkpmhjUXZk1{sv1hsUXZVY[ZJrsU ¤mXZmXZ3rsr`gr9f~Y[Z3fprscX{sZ¿ktXhjUXZx!kCr}hhsk=¡ZVofp`u `bm

k1{

u

Z{hjkôxkpY[oXcqhjZkpm hsUXZVx!k1mrw`

u

ZJ{sZ

u

Y(Z3rwUK©TVUXZ`

u

ZJfkpx!k1mrw`

u

ZJ{s`bmXVkp{,f

u

ftoqhjZ

u

Y[ZJrsUXZ3rrs`lY[oXebv

hjUXZ"hskthfte,macXYd¡?Z{=kt

u

Z1{sZJZJrôkt;{jZZ

u

kpY `gr=fmfthscX{fteZ!yahsZJmrs`lk1mShsUfth`brôpZhwhs`bmXoX{jkpp{jZJrjrs`l1Zebv

Y[k1{sZo?kpoXcXegft{j`lh}vp©

"!$#&%('*),+-&.,' 0/1!2&34'5

/GZ=kqx!crkpmOhsUXZ`bmChsZ{jo?kpegfihs`bkpmOktKcmxØhj`lk1mrkt-687C¯H ô²:9[³<;¯C ô²9£`«hjU>=Iw x©ôm`lmChsZJ{so?kpegfihj`lk1m

Y[ZhsUXk u `gr=fYftoXo`lmX£UX`gxU u Z!¤mXZJrô{jkpY ftmavY(Z3rwU1&kt¿fpm kpo?Zm5rwZh+ `bmv+wftm k1oZJ{jfthsk1{

? . rwcxUOhjUfih

?

.1@ q w>6

7

¯C ô²9³

;

¯H ô²°A

? . q w³

;

¯H ô²

(9)

Z!h~crôx!k1mrw`

u

ZJ{VhsUXZ `bmChsZJ{so?kpegfih

u

cmxØhj`lk1mrki1Z{kpc{~rwZ87CcXZmxZkt,Y[ZJrsUXZJr;: q ´ ?

.}q© (ðhô`br

mfihsc{jfpe*hsk[`lmChj{sk

u

cxZ=hsUXZk1elebki£`lm"oX{jkpo?Z{sh}vZ:

qIr-t

a uq®wx uZqw 6 7

¯C ô²9³

;

¯C ô²

q ´ rzy~b ¯ q

q ²_

q ´ ° q ° A

´ ; a ¥p¨

T£¿kxebf1rsrs`bxJfte*Z!yXfpY(oelZ3rrsfths`gr}vhjUX`groX{jkpo?Z{sh}v!:

<

hsUXZ

ft1{jfpmXpZô`lmChsZJ{so?kpegfihj`lk1mk1mrs`bY(oelZ3xØhs`gxY[ZJrsUXZJr 4B6A=

<

hsUXZ ³Øðkp{shsUXk1pk1mfte*ftm u oX`bZJxZ£`grwZx!k1mrwhjftmChoX{jkt|}Z3xØhs`bkpm ¥k1{ftmav,a`bm u ktY[Z3rwUXZ3rj¨!©

TVUZ~¤{rwh¿Z!yXfpY(oelZ=`brf"crwcfte?kpmXZô`lm¤mX`lhsZ=ZebZY[ZmChhsUXZJkp{jvpC£UX`belZôhsUXZrsZJx!k1m u k1mXZ~`grVf u fpoqhsZ u hsk

¤mX`«hjZpk1elcXY[ZY[Z!hjUXk u r©

! "4#&+# $ '*# 54! #

: E;/<>=@?A=CBD< ZL#J

n

WUXW!YO[\O] ^B_pPCYUa^`Wbd[`Y#e!^CfdeoPhRPBW^B\f[\R^BN+Pkk8n\Pk@V ^`N }PCY _a[Ph;Ya | N#^B\RP?h[6on[Wik[g^`N9bd[h0e![h

¯4&

´ ²

´6587 UXN

qIr-t a u!q!w 6 7

¯H ô²29O³

;

¯H ô²_ua®w x

q°q

´

r ±

)

´

% w

l+eZ[\[ ) ´

e!^B_fhN#^B\ Ye![WZnb t[\^`N [_a[bd[WZYhT^`N'&

´ ^

&{sk1Y r}hfihsZJY[ZmCh ¥3¨ØahjUX`gr u Z!¤mX`lhs`bkpm`brVxkpUXZJ{sZJm1h¿£`«hjUOhjUXZ=xebf1rsrs`gxftekpmXZ~kp{VcXmX`lkp{jY Y[ZJrsUXZJr

k1{VcXmX`lkp{jY {jZ!¤mXZJY[ZmChJ©

' '*/1! !)( +/1% )!+*-, .,&3/.0" +1*".324" .65' # / /1!+*"3 !+*

(m hsUXZVx!egfprjrw`gxfpeihsUZkp{jvp3hjUXZh}£kF,1ZvfprjrwcY(oXhs`bkpmrK`lmdhsUXZfpxxcX{fpx!vrwhjfihjZY[ZmChktftmd`lmChsZJ{so?kpegfihj`lk1m

fp{sZc:

<

hsUXZ{jZ1cXegft{j`«h}vkpY[ZJrsUXZJr=

<

hsUXZebkqxfpe ¥fihZJelZJY[ZmChelZJpZJeg¨fpxJx!cX{fpxvkthsUXZ`bmChsZ{jo?kpegfihs`bkpm=

TVUXZ;kpebelki£`bmXVcXm u ftY[ZmChjfpep{jZJrscXelh ¥rsZZF4B6¨*`grKfx!k1mrsZ;7CcXZmx!Z9ktahjUXZª{jfpYd¡XebZ! `beb¡ZJ{whebZY[YfC:

7 i+ElBDJEG iLJ F98< ?EJ ZB:I ?h=BD<gNP<QK>ICG~E< ?0I:*QJMBTE8Jl?'S

MON

?

r>PBWUXW!YO[\O] ^B_pPCYUa^`W ^]9[\PYO^`\^BW!*Kr`grZyqf1xØhk1{~ftmavOo?kpebvamXkpY[`gftekp u Z1{sZJZelZ3rsrk1{Z;7CcfpeÕhsk

=<; arsUXN>= wxArAY#e![W5Y#e![\[ [@?UXh;Y#hFPdk^`Wsh;YPW!Y r-t a-UXWift[{] [Wift[W!YA^BN/* h;nkeYeoPCY

u!q w>6 7 S

¯4*B²ABAq°

?

q1ACED[ r GFH 7 S

GF S C Aq1A

7 SGD[

l+eZ[\[

F

UphAP bPY#\0UI?ch;nk eY#eoPYAYe![RxP\0UPCB_a[TkeoPWm[J FLK

JEMONTY#\PWsh0N#^`\ bh PWz[_a[bd[WZY

K

* UjWZY"^

* ^1PR[\[8r>ARQSAT DU ft[W!^tYO[h YeZ[Rh[bcUpW!^`\ b ^`N-6

T

¯WV²_^

(10)

TVUX`gr{jZJrscXelhôftooXel`bZJr`lmSofp{whj`bxcXegft{Vhskrw`bY[oXelZ3xØhj`bxY[Z3rwUXZ3r£UX`gxUSft{jZ ftebeK`bYftpZ3rVkt;ftmScmX`X7CcXZ

rs`bY(oelZy*ahjUXZ rsktxftebebZ

u

{jZ!ZJ{sZJmx!ZZJelZJY(ZJmCh

K

*%©+/5Z fpebrsk({sZJY[fp{0,[hjUfih8:

][

K

] F

Y\[

K

] K

]

] [ F S K

Y

] [

TVUZmhsUXZk1elebki£`lm[rwhjfthsZJY(ZJmChV£`bebeUXkpeu

F 7 S F S C r

Y\[

] [ C Y\[

7 S C r Y`[

7 S C

`bmOf1rY"cxUOfpr;hsUXZ=Y[ZJrsUXZJr¿pZJ{s`lv"hsUXZ=`brskthj{sk1oav"oX{jkpo?Z{sh}vq©% © ki£ZpZJ{fdxkpmxelcrw`bkpmxkpmxZ{jmX`lm

hjUXZôf1xxcX{jf1x!v k1{ u Z{;£`bele?mXkph¡Zôkp¡qhft`bmXZ u cmXelZ3rsrkpmXZôxftm{jZegfihjZ Y`[ hjkhsUXZômacXYd¡?Z{¿ktÕZebZY[ZmChr

£U`bxU`brY(k1{sZ=ZJf1rw`bebv u kpmZ=£`lhsUScmX`«k1{sY Y(Z3rwUZJrJ©

687 S

¯C ô² Kp»

&kp{{jfthsUXZJ{¿{jZ1cXegft{;cmxØhj`lk1mrXfth¿ebZJf1r}hV`lm 6 S

¯C ô²sXfpm u k1{V7Ccf1rw`lÆcmX`«k1{sY Y[ZJrsUXZ3rChsUZ~k1elebki£`lm

{jZJrscXelh`br u ZJ{s`bpZ u :

7 i+ElBDJEG iL$E

9[`Y,¯

? ´ ²

´j587

[VPFNPbUj_V^`NoUjWZY"[\"]9^`_PY#U^BW^] [\PCY"^`\h Y#eoPY>P\[V[@?sPtk8YoN#^B\ PBWMVR] ^B_WVCW!^BbUpP_NOnW>k;YUa^`W

^BNTf[ m\[[_a[h h-^`\-[jotnPB_2Y"^>=H^BW Y#e![ch0Ujb]Z_a[8k8YU#kc[_a[bd[WZY#hc^`NRYe![-bd[h0e![h¯&

´ ²

´j587

rYe![WUXN Ye![

rsZ;7CcXZJmx!ZOktY[ZJrsUXZJrO¯&

´ ²

´j587

`brdcXmX`lkp{jY Pkk^`\;fUjWCmKY"^ [uCWsU#Y#U^BW^trl+[eoPx`[zY#e![N#^B_j_a^l+UjWCm

]i\^] [\;Y$V

u!q w>6

7 S ua®w x AqO°q

´ ACED

r Aq#A

7 SGD

Y 7 S C

´ r Aq#A

7 S D ±

) ´ 7 S C w

&kp{f(Y[kp{jZ=1ZmXZJ{jfpe*{sZ3rwcXelh ¥`bm CED

´ ¯C ô²ð¨ØrwZJZc4\6ð©

³t¯C ô² t» K

7

i+ElBDJEG iL

9[`Y¯

? ´ ²

´j587

[TPNPBbUj_V^`N UjWZY"[\"]9^`_PY#U^BW ^]9[\PYO^`\h hPYUph0N$VUXWm Ye![h;YPCUj_XU#Y$V-]Z\^]9[\8Y$V }Bro^`WzP

rsZ;7CcXZJmx!ZkpY[ZJrsUXZJr ¯&

´ ²

´j587 r YeZ[W

u!q wn³

¯H ô²9³

;

¯C ô²Auq®Iw!x

qO°q

´

r q

b[Ph¯C ô² S

TVUX`grV{jZJrscXe«hr`brVmXkph u `l{jZJx!hsebvcrsZ!cXe ¥ftoXoel`bZ u `lm ¨Ø©;ªcqh`lhxftm¡?ZxkpY"¡X`lmZ u £`«hjUTVUXZJkp{jZY

% ©lôkp{~kp¡qhft`bmX`lmdhjUXZ x!k1mC1Z{jpZJmx!Zôkp{u Z{Vk1{VcXmxØhj`lk1mrhsUfih~ft{jZoX`bZJx!ZJ£`brsZ(6 7 S :

<

`lmn{jZ1cXebfp{s`lh}v{jZp`bkpmrqTVUXZJkp{jZY

%

©bxfpm¡?Z ftoXoel`bZ u

<

`lm7mXkpmqð{jZpcebfp{s`lh}vO{jZ1`lk1mrXhsUXZ[ft¡?kipZ{jZJrscXelhô`gr~ftooXel`bZ u ?¡cqhô{jZoXegfpx`lmI N¡CvSfmZ`bpUa¡k1{w

UXkak u kpKhjUXZ rw`bmX1cXebfp{s`lh}v[hsUZY(Z3fprscX{jZ=kp£UX`gxUhsZJm u rVhjk#JZ{jk©

(11)

i

·

$

·

SØ¹j·

Xt ?

·

»

$X

»

Z!h=crôxkpmrs`u Z{~hsUXZ fpp{ftmX1Z`lmChsZJ{so?kpegfihj`lk1mSkt u ZJp{jZZ±dkp{x!k1m1hj`lmacXk1crcmxØhj`lk1mr u Z!¤mZ u k1m

0 ftm u k1{rw`bY[oXelZ3xØhj`bxY[ZJrsUXZ3r©

<

&Xk1{9cXmx!hs`bkpmr9kp6Ot¯H ô²j1£U`bxUft{jZV`lmoft{shs`gx!cXegft{;xkpmChs`bmacXkpcr,`bmn! fpm u !"pftm u o?k1rjrs`l¡Xebv

u `grsxkpmChs`bmacXkpcrfthftm`lmrscXegfihjZ u ok1`lmCh`bm % !"ahsUXZ rsZJxkpm u kp{ u Z{xkpmapZJ{s1ZmxZ~UXk1eu r;:

u!q w>6

q°q

´

r q

±

)

´ w

<

&Xk1{KcXmxØhs`bkpmdkt 6 S

¯H ô²si£U`bxUdfp{sZ`lm oft{shs`gx!cXegft{x!kpmChj`lmacXk1crÕ`bmO!"3okCrsrs`l¡elv

u

`grsxkpmChs`bmacXkpcr

kpm¢o?kp`bm1hr`lmB%!do?k1rjrs`l¡Xebv u `grjx!kpmChj`lmXk1cr=kpm%x!c{s1ZJr=`lm % !dk1mXebvS¤{r}hkp{ u ZJ{xkpmapZJ{s1ZmxZ

UXkpeu r;:

u!q w>6

S

q°q

´

@

r q

±

)

´ S

w

· » K¼ · $· ¹j· Xp ? · » $q»

/GZ x!k1mrs`u ZJ{VmXki£ hjUXZ ³!Æk1{whjUXkp1kpmfpeoX{jkt|}Z3xØhj`lk1mOkpmChjk"hjUXZZebZY[ZJm1h}£`grsZxkpmrwhjfpmChcmxØhj`lk1mr©

uZq w³

¯C ô²A

? ´

q¯WJK² ±

Y[ZJfpr¯H*%² [

q¯WJK²1¬9J ¯u J w* u * w&

´

²A

k1mY[Z3rwU!&

´

©9ªvfpoXoXeb`bxJfihj`lk1mkpTVUXZJkp{jZY % ©l1ahsUXZ f1xx!c{jf1x!vr}hfihjZY[ZmCh£{j`«hjZJrfprk1elebki£r;:

<

&Xk1{46

S

¯C ô²9cXmxØhj`lk1mrJq¤{r}hk1{ u ZJ{x!kpma1Z{jpZmx!Z~Ukpeu r:

u!q w>6

S

q°q

´

r q 6

±

) ´ S

w

kpmncXmX`lkp{jY rs`lY[oXebZJx!hs`gxY[ZJrsUXZJr ¥!~Z¤mX`lhs`bkpm7q©Ñp¨

i¼ · $· · ·Cº A · 6

S

Kp»

TVUZôcmxØhj`lk1mrVhsUfih£Zxkpmrs`u Z{mXki£ ft{jZ~cmxØhj`lk1mrkt q wn³t¯C ô²9³<;¯C ô²9hsUfth~ft{jZôoX`bZJxZ£`grwZ

6 S

`bm =©; h}vaoX`bxJfteÕZyqfpY[oXelZ`bm¢!"X`/©Zp©,k1{ aÕ±î aa

î ba

*±«X`br

q¯J²

J rs`)J w

J° a

rs`)J w

£U`bxUG`brfOcXmx!hs`bkpmG{jkpY a*±hjkv¿¿¡ZJelk1mXp`bmXhsk 6 S

¯H

²~fpm u hjk 6 S

¯H

²s¡XcXh ¡ZJ`lmX

u `brjx!k1m1hj`lmacXk1crVfih J a

¥qEw 6 S

¯H ô²¨Ø©~mX`«k1{sYY[ZJrsUXZJr¯4&

´ ²

´6587

f1xx!k1{ u `lmX"hsk !ôZ!¤m`«hj`lk1m7q©Ñ

fp{sZ

&

´

T* w&

´

=a

w!*L

&

´

! * w!&

´

=P*#"c %$'& &

´ &

´

( M* w!&

´

=*" )$*& &

´

(12)

/GZ

u

Z¤mXZhsU{sZJZ=k1oZJmrsZ!hr

´

P

´

P

´ :

´ ,

.

} 0*

´ ,

.} *0 ´ ,

.} *0

TVUZm£¿Z xJftm£{s`lhsZ:

q°

? ´ q }

r q

%

}

Y ´ r q

±

) ´

q°

? ´ q } r q

}

Y ´ r q

±

) ´

q°

? ´ q } r q

0

xfp{ u &

´ Y ´

S

r q

0

Y

S

´

rs`bmx!Z ¥`lm !¨xfp{ u &

´ ±1©Vôrôf[{jZJrscXelhJhsUXZd`lmChsZJ{so?kpegfihj`lk1mSY[Z!hsUk u Ufpr~fpm fpxJx!cX{fpxvkp{ u Z{

kpk1mXelv7±C:

q°

? ´ q

r y"{8|

G

q

q ±

)

´ S

TVUXZ¿rsfpY(Z9fp{s1cXY[ZmChZ!yahsZJm u r*hjkftmav u `lY[Zmrw`bkpm¬? V£`«hjU aÕ±wp8 aa

a*±w S

%a

*± baÕ±w S

ftm u :

q¯WJ² J S rs`)J w!

J S ° a

rs`)J w!

£UZ{jZ JI ¯WJiS8

;

J

w

&

´

6* w!&

´

=P* 9L

£U`lebZ &

´

D&E

´

P

´

E

´

Z!hz

´

q°

? ´ q

r y"{8|

q q q

±

) ´ S w

rs`bmx!Z`bmhjUfih~xJfprsZpqY[ZJf1r &

´

cY

´ ±

) ´ S w ©

EGHIDJ iLJ

MOWKfUjbd[Wsh{Ua^`W ¬sriUjN2Y#e![cfUXhk^BW!Y#UjWZnUY$VeoPhRPfUXbd[Wsh0U^BW = ¬sr Y#e![W~Ye![h[BY

´

^`W[Pkebd[h0e

l+UX_X_ e!Px`[Pbd[Ph;n\[g^BNFYe![c^`\;ft[\ ^BN Yow C

´

r.PWifY#e![k^`WZx`[\{mC[Wik[ ^`\;ft[\cl+UX_j_2[-^BN¯/¬(° =5²

}UjW5Y#e![ PC^x`[`rZl [TeoPx`[ = ¬ ° ±j^

(13)

EGHIDJ iL$E

eZ[Rbd[h0eh[jotnt[Wik["¯&

´ ²

´j587

bPV5[?nUX_Y UXW^`\;ft[\ YO^h PCYUph{N$V

´ }uq® w x.

UY UphR[W!^tnBme

YO^nUX_#fYe![b UXWdh;nkePl+PV Ye!PY Y#e![RfUphk^`WZY#UjWZnUY$V ]9^`UXWZY+JI a

t[[@?sPtk8Y_V?PY Ye![t^nWifP\@V

^BN YOl ^gW![Ujmei^`\ UjWmd[_a[bd[W!YhUjWZYO[\8xP_Xh6^

MOW YeoPCYgkPh[Y#e![UjWZY"[\"]9^`_PY#U^BWK\[8k^xB[\PK[`Y{YO[\dPkk;n\Pk@V~^`\;ft[\j^-PR^l [`x`[\r+UXW5]i\Pk;YU#k[`rFl+[

nhnP_j_V ft^gW!^YtW!^l YeZ[_^CkPCYUa^`W^`NVYe![gfUXhk^BW!Y#UjWZnUY$V]9^`UXWZYA^

d d7 ! d

/GZ,pZJZo7xkpmrs`u Z{j`lmXoX`bZJx!ZJ£`brsZ({sZJpcXegft{ôcXmx!hs`bkpmrJ©/GZ[rsUfpele,`bmC1ZJrwhs`b1fthsZdUki£ hskn`lY[oX{jkipZdhsUXZ

fp¡ki1Z"eb`bY(`lhd¡av5xUkCkCrw`bmXmXki£ f u fpoqhjfths`bpZrwZ87CcXZmxZJrkpY[ZJrsUXZ3rKhsUfth `br rsZ;7CcXZJmx!Z3rktVY[ZJrsUXZJr

hjUfih~fp{sZ

u

Z3rw`bpmXZ

u

`bmSf(Y[fpmXmXZJ{f

u

fpoqhsZ

u

(mdf¤{jrwhrwhsZo£ZrsUftebe1xkpmrs`

u

Z{KrsZ;7CcXZJmx!Z3rÕktq`grwkphs{jkpoX`gx

¥

%

¨*f

u

+#*!

(m !d;f u ftoqhj`l1ZnY(Z3rwU¦`bmChsZ{jo?kpegfihs`bkpmEY[Z!hsUk u rxfpm ¡?ZSYf u Znkp=k1{ u ZJ{?|fpr[egft{jpZhsUftm hsUXZ

hjUXZk1{sZhs`gxfpe1k1{ u ZJ{KkpXhsUXZ`bm1hjZ{jok1ebfthsk1{J3kpmdcXmxØhj`lk1mrhsUfthUfpZ;`grwk1ebfthsZ u u `grsxkpmChs`bmacX`«hj`lZ3rtf1rrwhjfthsZ u

`bmhsUXZk1elebki£`bmX"ebZY[YfC:

DFEGHGHI LJ F/¬ ±S

9[`YFnhPh h;nbd[-YeoPCYFYe![ UjWZY"[\"]9^`_PY#U^BWb[BYe!^Cf"VCUa[_#fhR^] [\PCY"^`\h Ye!PYAP\[ ^BN+Pkk8n\Pk@V^B\f[\F|

UXW 6 7dl+U#Y#enWCUjN#^B\0b h[jotnt[Wik[hT^`N bd[h0e![h6^

9[`Y! CSc

N] ^BUjWZYh ^BN v PBW>fzq w%³p¯PN Ñ² 9n³<;¯`N Ñ²FP?NOnW>k;YUa^`W

h;nk eYeoPCY

q w 6 7 ¯

S8 Ñ²_ ¯ ±

;

²_ qEw *

7 ¯` N Ñ²

e![W Y#e![\[[@?UphYhRPdh[jon[Wik[^`N+bd[h{e![hd¯4&

´ ²

´6587

ft[ ` N oh;nk eKYe!PY~¯

? ´ ²

´j587

]Z\[h[WZY

PW^B\f[\T^`N+Ptk;k;n\PtkhV[6onPB_+YO^-|~^`W ^

»»

/GZ xftm f1rsrscXY[Zn£`«hjUXkpcqhebk1rjrkp=1ZmXZJ{jfpel`lh}v¢hsUfth

±p( aÕ±«Vq w 6 S

¯H ²s

q w 6 S

¯H ²jX£`«hjU aa

aftm u ba

Õ±«©

ôrft¡?kipZ1C`l & ´

`brf(Y[ZJrsUnktL £`lhsU )

´

`bmChsZJ{siftegrJq£¿Zxfpm u `brwhs`bmXpc`brsU>:

&

´

T* w&

´

=a

w!*L

&

´ * w!&

´

=P*#"c

$ & &

´ &

´ * w!&

´

=*"

$ & &

´

fpm

u

rwcX¡{sZJp`bkpmr(

´

P

´

P ´

rwcxUOhjUfih

´ ,

.

} 0*

´ ,

. } 0* ´ ,

. } 0*

(mnk1{ u ZJ{hsk[{sZ u cxZôhjUXZZ{j{jkp{V¡avOf"AfpxØhjkp{ %

q£Z ftoXoXebvhjUXZkpebelki£`bmX[r}hj{jfthsZJpvZ:

(14)

<

`lm

´ ¥

{jZJrso© ´

¨!hsUXZ5ZebZY[ZmChnrw`$#Z Ufprhjk ¡?Z

u

`ba`

u Z u

¡av¦f¢Afpx!hskp{!%rs`lmxZ7`bm hsU`br

{sZJpcXegft{j`lh}v{sZJp`bkpmChsUZhsUXZJkp{jZ!hs`gxfpefpxJx!cX{fpxvkp{

u

Z{VkthsUXZ`bmChsZJ{so?kpegfihj`lk1mfpoXoXeb`lZ3r=

<

kpm hsUZ7x!k1m1hj{jfp{sv1k1mc

´

VZebZY[ZmChrs`$#ZSUf1r(hskB¡?Z u `bC`u Z u ¡Cv R

%

rs`lmxZSkpm hsU`brmkpmq

/GZrwUfpele*rsUXki£ UXki£¦hsU`brrwhs{fihjZpv[ftebebki£r;hjkd¡XcX`beu fpmf u Z;7CcfihjZôrsZ;7CcXZJmx!ZôktKY[ZJrsUXZ3rChsUfihV`br

/GZ r}hft{sh£`«hjU& pXYf

u

a a

±

&

P

&

S

P

S &

S

P

S &

S

P

S

&

P

&

P

&

P

&`l1cX{jZ(:¿kpY[oXcqhfihj`lk1mfte

u

k1Y[fp`lm Nftm

u

Y[ZJrsUXZJr(& i& S &

· ? `lmSxf1rwZ=£UXZJ{sZ1D&

& t&

qD&

qq£Z=o{sk1okCrwZôhskxUXkakCrwZ:

&

S

S S $

rsk(hsUfth

Y[ZJf1r S

Y[ZJf1r=¯C

² ±

%

fpm u kp{Z!yXfpY(oelZ

S ±

° ±

±

% S ±

M ± ±

%

TVUZ"ft¡?kipZd`lY[oXeb`lZ3rôhsUfth+

S a S $

ftm u S

S

±

$

¥{sZ3rwoK©G S

ftm u S

`grdhjUXZm

cmX`«k1{sYftm u Z;7Ccfpe*hsk

Y S Y S ± ±

±°

±

%

· £¿ZxUXkak1rsZ

&

$

rsk(hsUfth

Y[ZJf1r

Y[Z3fpr¯H

S ² ±

% ¡ZJ`lmY(Z3fpr

±

%