Evaluating Network Vulnerability with the Mincuts Frequency Vector

HAL Id: inria-00073564

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00073564

Submitted on 24 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub-

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,

Evaluating Network Vulnerability with the Mincuts Frequency Vector

Stéphane Bulteau, Gerardo Rubino

To cite this version:

Stéphane Bulteau, Gerardo Rubino. Evaluating Network Vulnerability with the Mincuts Frequency Vector. [Research Report] RR-3125, INRIA. 1997. �inria-00073564�

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Evaluating network vulnerability with the mincuts frequency vector

St´ephane Bulteau, Gerardo Rubino

N ˚ 3125

Mars 1997

TH `EME 1

#!$%$ '&( )*,+-/.0 / )"1/)234

57698

:<;3=>@?:BADC3E

6

:<>@CFHGJI:<KL>@KLMNPOQCR3ST?NVU

WXY

Z-[ZB\]_^a`Z-bcZ-dfehgaZjiDbckbci

Y

Z-[Z-b

l/mon<p

Zjiq nr

Z-s

^dHt7t nfm

i r Z m Z-u

X Z m u X

Zwvxzy\-{f|P]}q~d

m

bQ\-f€] {f t‚dHƒfZ-b

„†…2‡jˆŠ‰<‹7ŒfˆDŽ

Zu

n

v7bo

r Z m i X

Z4t mnf‘

s’Z-[

nf“

Zj”Hdfs•e7dHio•vhƒ0i X Z ‘ Z X

dŠ”@

nfm–nf“

d0u

n

[—[˜e7v7•ujdHio

n v

v7Zjiš™

nfmo› “

dfuœZi n i X

Zt

n

bobo

‘

s’Z

r

•b

m

eht‚io

n v nf“

b n [—Z

nf“

•iobu

n

[t

n

vhZ-vziobj

Ž

Zd

m

Z4žvŸicZ

m

Z-boicZ

r

žvi

X

Z ujdfboZ™

X

Z-v˜i X Z m

Zžb2v

n

d-”Hdf•s•d

‘

s’Z bciodHio•boio•ujdfs7•v

“¡nfm

[—dHio

n

vd

‘n

ehii X Z r

ZjtZ-v r d ‘

•s•’i¢k

t

mon

tZ

m

io’Z-b nf“

i X Z4v7Zjiš™

nfmo›

u n [t

n

vhZ-vziobj¤£¥v‚bcicZ-d r—nf“

™

nfmo›

žvhƒQ™4’i X m

Z-s••d

‘

žs•’išk[Zji

m

•ujb–•v

d4bci n u X

dfbcio•u–u

n

vŸicZœgij¦f™Z–dfv7dfs’k@§jZ”e7s•vhZ m d ‘

•s•’i¢k4[Z-dfboe

m

Z-b¨•v0d

r

ZjicZ

m

[—žv7•bcio•u

“¡m

df[Zj™

nfmo›



W4X

•b—dHt7t mon

dfu

X

dfs•s

n

™4b†e7b—i n t

mon

t n bcZ~db

n

s•e7io

n

v©i nªn

i X Z m

ujs•dfbobcZ-b nf“

t

mnf‘

s’Z-[—bP«¬v n i

Z-dfb•s’k

X

dfv

r

s’Z

r

•v

m

Z-s••d

‘

•s•’i¢k­i X Z

nfm

kh®#¯

nfm

•v7boiodfv7uœZf¦™–Z°ujdfv±u

n

v7bo

r Z m i X

Z~t monf‘

s’Z-[

nf“

Zj”Hdfs•e7dHio•v7ƒ²i

X

ZBujdHt‚dfuj•išk nf“

d³vhZji¢™

nfmo›

i

nVm

Z-bo•boi´i

n

ZœgicZ

m

v7dfs/dHiciodfu

›

b-

Ž

Zaujdfvdfsžb

n

d

r‚rhm

Z-bob†i

X

Z°t mnf‘

s’Z-[

nf“˜µ

e7dfvzio

“

k•vhƒ­i

X

Z¶vhZji¢™

nfmo›

d ‘

•sž’išk·i

n

bodHiožb

“

kb

n

[Z¶ujdHt‚dfuj•išk

u n v‚bci

m

df•vziob•v­i

m

dfv7bct nfm

io•v7ƒV•v

“¡nfm

[—dHio

n

v°£¥vªi

X

Zat‚dHtZ

m

¦¤™Zat mon

t n bcZad

r

Zœ¸9v7’io

n v nf“

”e7s•v7Z m d ‘

•s••iškdfsžs

n

™4žvhƒQi

X

Zvze‚[Z

m

•ujdfs‚Zj”<dfs•e‚dHio

n v nf“

i X

Z-bcZdfbctZ-uœiob nf“

d˜u

n

[—[˜e7v7•ujdHio

n v

bok@bcicZ-[³

Ž

Z˜b X n

™¹i

X

dHiD’i4”fZ

m

º¸‚Z-bb

n

[ZžvŸioe7•io’”fZ-s’k

r

Z-bo

m d ‘

s’Z´t mon

tZ

m

io’Z-b-¦h™

X

•u

X

•bv n i

i X Z4ujdfbcZ

nf“

t m Zj”

n

e7bs’kQt mon

t n bcZ

r

[—Z-dfv7b nf“

”e7s•vhZ m d ‘

•s•’i¢kQdfv7dfs’kbo•bj»¨dfbcij¦z™–Z

r

•bouje7bbi X Z

dfs•ƒ

nfm

’i

X

[—žuDžboboehZ-b

m

Z-sždHicZ

r

™4’i X i X

Z0Zj”<dfs•e‚dHio

n v nf“

i X ZQt

mon

t n bcZ

r

[—Zji

m

•uH

¼V½Ÿ¾¿oÀ Á ‰<Â2‡f

u n

[—[˜e7v7•ujdHio

n

v³vhZjiš™

nfmo›

bj¦7”e7s•vhZ m d ‘

•s•’i¢kf¦

m

Z-s••d

‘

•sž’iškf¦vhZjiš™

nfmo›²r

Z-bo•ƒv

ÒĘÅ

Æ¢ÇÉÈ-Ê

Å

Ɩ˨̒ÇÉÍÏÎjÐ

Ѥ҂ÓÔÕ×֕Ø7ÙÏÚÜÛ<ÖÞÝÉßcÔÛfà2ÕÞáÉÕ×ÙÉԊâãäá

å

҂ÓÔÕ×֕ØháÉÛÜÚ<Õ×æ<çœà2ÕÞáÉÕèÙÉÔ-âãäá

o )2/ )¤D /*,& & o*

½ ‡ ½  n

e7bu

n

v7bo

r `Z mon

v‚bQs’Zt monf‘

sY Z-[Z

r

Z—s¥`Zj”Hdfs•e7dHio

n v r

e¶u

n

[t nfm

icZ-[—Z-vŸi

r

×e7v

m `Z-boZ-dfe

r

Zu

n [ [e7v‚•ujdHio

n v “

dfuœZ

Y

dDs•d r `Z “

df•sžs•dfv7uœZt

n

bbo

‘

s’Z

r

ZuœZ

m

iodf•v7b

r

Z bcZ-bu

n

[t

n

bodfvŸiob-

n

e7b´v

n

e‚b´•vŸi@`Z m Z-bb

n

v7bQdfe°ujdfb n Y

e°v

n

e7b´vhZ

r

•bct n b n

v‚b4t‚dfb

r

א•v

“¡nfm

[—dHio

n

v7bDbciodHio•boio

µ

e7Z-b

be

m

s•Z-bu

n

[t

n

bodfvziob

r e m `Z-bcZ-dfeDe­sž’Z-e

r

ZBi

m

dŠ”<dfžs•s’Z

m

d-”fZ-u

r

Z-b˜[Z-boe

m

Z-b r Z ¸9d

‘

•s•’i@`Zf¦

r

dfv7b e7v²u

n

vŸicZœgicZ0bci n u X

dfbcio

µ

ehZf¦7v

n

e7bB`Zjioe r n

v7b

r

Z-b[Z-boe

m

Z-b

r

Z”@e‚s•v–`Z m d ‘

•sž’iz`Zf¦

r

dfv‚be7v

u n vzicZœgicZ

r `ZjicZ

m

[—•v7žbcicZfZjicicZdHt7t mon

u X ZtZ

m

[Zji

r

Z˜t mon

t n bcZ

m

e7vhZ˜b

n

s•ehio

n v Y

d r

×dfehi

m

Z-b

i¢kztZ-b

r

ZDt monf‘

s Y Z-[—Z-bj¦

r

Buj•s’Z-[—Z-vŸi–i

m

df’iz`Z-b

r

dfv7bs•di X `Z

nfm

’Z

r

Zs•dQ¸3d

‘

•s•’i@`Zf

l d m

Zœg@Z-[t9s’Zf¦

v n e7bt

n

eh”

n

v7bu

n

v‚bo

r `Z m Z m

s’ZQt monf‘

sY Z-[Z

r

Z0s¥`Zj”Hdfs•e7dHio

n v r

Z0s•d

m `Z-bo•bciodfv7uœZ

r e m `Z-bcZ-dfe

“

dfuœZ

Y

d0e7vhZ4dHƒfƒ

m

Z-bbo

n

v—ZœgicZ

m

vhZf´vtZ-ehi˜`Zjƒdfs’Z-[Z-vzi—`Zj”Hdfs•ehZ

m

s X d ‘

žs•’iz`Z r e m Z-bcZ-dfe`

Y

d0bdHio•b

“

df

m Z

uœZ

m

iodf•vhZ-bu

n

vŸi

m

dfžvŸicZ-b

r

ZujdHt9dfuj’iz`Z r

dfv‚b/s’Zi

m

dfv7bct nfm

i r ZDsא•v

“¡nfm

[—dHio

n

vdfv7buœZ4t‚dHt9’Z m ¦

v n e7bt

mon

t n b n v‚be7vhZ

r `Zœ¸9v‚’io

n v r

Zs•d ”@e‚s•v–`Z m d ‘

•sž’iz`ZQdfehi nfm

•bodfvzi4s¥`Zj”Hdfs•e7dHio

n

vVvze‚[­`Z m µ ehZ

r

ZBuœZ-b dfbctZ-uœiob

r

×e7vbok@bci

Y

Z-[Z

r

ZBu

n

[—[˜e7v7•ujdHio

n

v

n

e7b˜[

n

vŸi mn

v7b

µ

eÞZ-sžs’Z—”`Z m

º¸‚Zae7v

uœZ

m

iodf•v·v n [

‘7m

Z r Zat

mon

t m

L`Zji@`Z-b—žvŸioe7•io’”fZ-[Z-vzi˜b n e X

df’iod

‘

s’Z-b-¦uœZ

µ

e7v¥`Zjiodf’i—t9dfbs’Z†ujdfb

r

Z-b/[Z-boe

m

Z-b¤t m `Z-u9`Z r

Z-[—[—Z-vŸit mon

t n

b@`ZjZ-bj¯•v7dfs•Z-[Z-vŸij¦@v

n

e7b

r

•boujehi

n

v7b/s×dfbctZ-uœi/dfs’ƒ

nfm

•i X

[ µ e7Z

m

Z-s•dHio

“ Y

d s¢`Zj”<dfs•e‚dHio

n v r

ZQsžd[Z-boe

m

Z´t mon

t n bz`ZjZf

! Á ˆŠ‡ ¿ Œ#" ½  m `Z-bcZ-dfe

r

ZDu

n [ [e7v‚•ujdHio

n

v¦z”@e7sžv–`Z m d ‘

•s••iz`Zf¦Ÿ¸9d

‘

•sž’iz`Zf¦@u

n

v7uœZjt‚io

n v r Z m `Z-bcZ-dfe

y

6 7 D3 — )2oD

W4X

Z ‘ Z X dŠ”@

nfm nf“

d4u

n [ [e7v‚•ujdHio

n

v˜vhZjiš™

nfmo›

™ X Z-vb

n

[—Z nf“

’iob u n [t

n

vhZ-vziob

“

df•sz•b¨e7v‚df[

‘

’ƒe

n

e7bos•k

X

dfv

r

s•Z

r ‘ k i X Z b n

ujdfs•s’Z

r89/:;<=! "#

i X Z nfm

kf

WX

Z

“Tm

df[Zj™

nfm›

žb´d

boi n u X

dfbcio•u

n

vhZf¦•vª™

X

•u X i X

Z²dfv7dfs•k@bci

‘

e‚•s

r

bd~[

n@r

Z-s d mon

e‚v r i X

Zau

n

v‚uœZjt7i nf“

ƒ m dHt

X

dfv

r

•v‚ujs•e

r

Z-b0i

X

Z†dŠ”<dfžs•d

‘

s’Z†bciodHio•bcio•ujdfs•v

“¡nfm

[—dHio

n

v­d

‘n

ehii X Z r

Zjt3Z-v r d ‘

•s••išk~t mon

tZ m

io•Z-b nf“

i X Z˜u

n

[t

n

vhZ-vziob «¬v n@r

Z-b-¦9u

X

dfv7vhZ-s•b®dfv r t n

bbo

‘

s’k nf“

i X Ze‚bcZ

m

b « n>

Z m Z r i m d †uŠ®

W4X

•b

r

dHiod i n

ƒfZji X Z m

™4’i

X i X Z › v n

™4s’Z

r

ƒfZ nf“

i X Z

-?? +2'0nf“

i X Z0vhZji¢™

nfmo›

s•Z-d

r

bi n i X Z

r

Zœ¸9v7’io

n v nf“

[—dfvzkVe‚bcZ

“

e‚s

0@ @<#A(B?+-

dfv

r i n i X Z r

Zj”fZ-s

n

t‚[Z-vzi nf“

dfs’ƒ

nfm

’i

X

[—•u

b n s•ehio

n

v7bi n i X

Z/t monf‘

s’Z-[

nf“ X n

™i

X

Z-boZ–[Zji

m

žujb¨ujdfv

‘

Z¤Zj”Hdfs•e7dHicZ

r

2q nfm

Z–bot3Z-uj’¸9ujdfs•s’kf¦Üi X Z

v7Zjiš™

nfmo›

ujdfv

‘

Zf¦

“¡nfm

•v7bciodfv7uœZf¦

m

Zjt

m

Z-bcZ-vŸicZ r~‘

k³dfv e7v r m

Z-uœicZ

r

[˜e7s’io

ƒ m

dHt XDCFE

«GIH;J2®

™ X Z m

ZKG •bi

X

ZbcZji nf“

v

nr

Z-bdfv

r

Jª•bi

X

ZbcZji nf“

Z r

ƒfZ-b

m

Zjt

m

Z-bcZ-vzio•vhƒi

X Z ‘  r m

Z-uœio

n

v7dfs

u n [ [e7v‚•ujdHio

n

vPu

X

dfv7vhZ-sžbj/£!v³i

X

Z˜bcZ

µ

ehZ-sϦ7™Z0™4žs•sbctZ-d

›

b•[t‚s’k†d

‘n

ehiƒ

m

dHt

X

bj¦

‘

ehidfs•s

i X Z m

Z-boe‚s’iobQb X n

™4v

X Z m Z d m

ZB”<dfsž

r

•vujdfbcZ nf“

[

nfm

Z i X dfv

n

vhZ Z r

ƒfZ

‘

Zjiš™ZjZ-v­i

X

ZBbodf[—Z

t9df

m4nf“

v

n@r

Z-b-

Ž

•i

X

Z-dfu X Z r

ƒfZ)L ™Z˜ujdfv~dfbob

n

uj•dHicZdBt monf‘

d ‘

žs•’iškM2N¥¦3•iob4O

@P@(B@Q5/#?R

0@=! @<#



WX

•b [Z-dfv7b—i

X

dHi—Z-dfu

X

s••vhZ²•bZ-•i X Z

mn

tZ

m

dHio

n

v7dfs0«¬boiodHicZVu nr

Z

r·‘

k±\Š®

nfm

v n v n tZ

m

dHio

n

v‚dfs«¬bciodHicZ³u nr

Z

r­‘

kTS٨0dfv r i X

dHi˜i

X

ZBt monf‘

d ‘

•sž’išk~i

n

¸3v r Z r

ƒfZUL•v­i X Z

n

tZ

m

dHio

n

v7dfs‚bciodHicZ•bM2N!¯‚e m i X Z m [

nfm

Zf¦z™Zdfboboe7[Zf¦@dfb e7boe7dfsϦŸi

X

dHi–i

X Z r > Z m

Z-vzi

m

dfv rhn

[

”Hd

m

•d

‘

s’Z-bKVcbciodHicZ nf“

s••v7ZWLYXQd

m

Z4•v

r

ZjtZ-v

r

Z-vzi2dfv r ¦

“Tnfm

bo•[t‚sž•uj’iškf¦Hi

X

dHi–v n@r

Z-bd

m

ZtZ mo“

Z-uœij

W4X

ZP[

n

bci ™4

r

Z-s’k bcioe

r

’Z r m

Z-s••d

‘

•s•’i¢k[Z-dfboe

m

ZV•v©be7u

X

d¶u

n

vŸicZœgi²dfboboe7[—Z-b—i

X

dHi—i¢™

n

t9d

m

io•uje7s•d m v

nr

Z-bWZ «¡i X Z

-'+?

®/dfv r4[

«¡i X Z

\/(*3

®d

m

Z4¸‚g@Z

r

dfv r i X

dHi™–Z´d

m

Z•vzicZ m

Z-boicZ

r

•v i X ZDu

n

[—[˜e7v7žujdHio

n

v7b

‘

Zjiš™ZjZ-vai

X

Z-[²

WX

žb–s’Z-d

r

b–i n u n

v7b

r Z m i X

ZZj”fZ-vŸiV!i X Z m Z

žb´dHis’Z-dfbciQd³t‚dHi X ‘

Zjiš™ZjZ-v]ZBdfv r^[ X

dŠ”@•v7ƒ³dfs•s¤’iob´Z

r

ƒfZ-b

n

tZ

m

dHio

n

v7dfs4«¬dfv

/_,@;=3

_,%

®`X

W4X

Z³t monf‘

d ‘

•s•’i¢k nf“

i X

•b—Zj”fZ-vŸi†•b—i X Z m

Z-s••d

‘

žs•’išk]acb0de nf“

i X

ZPbckbcicZ-[²¦ujdfsžs’Z

r

-'+?@f5f\@?(g3h0@! "#



WX

Z m Z0d

m

Z0[ dfvŸk²d-”Hdf•s•d

‘

s’Z0dfs’ƒ

nfm

•i

X

[—bi n u n

[t‚ehicZQi

X

•b

[—Zji

m

•ua«¬bcZjZ&iº\f¦{j¡®Q£

“

™–Z—d

m

Z u

n

v‚uœZ

m

vhZ

r

™4’i X i X

Z t

n

bobo

‘

s’Z0u

n

[—[˜e7v7•ujdHio

n

v7b

‘

Zji¢™–ZjZ-v

dfsžst‚df

m b nf“

v

nr

Z-bj¦2i

X

Z-v¶™Z

r

Z-dfs™4’i X i X Z

"f`\/(*3W;<=! "#

acklml¡¦™

X

•u

X

•b0i X Z

t

monf‘

d ‘

•sž’išk²i

X

dHi´i X Z m

Z—•bdHi0s’Z-dfbci

n

vhZ

n

tZ

m

dHio

n

v7dfst‚dHi X m

Z-s’k•vhƒadfvzkVt‚df

mDnf“

”fZ

m

io•uœZ-b-

Dv•[t nfm

iodfvzi2t monf‘

s’Z-[,™4’i X i X

Z-boZ[Zji

m

•ujb¤dfv

r

™4•i X i X

Z-

m

Zœg@icZ-v7b

n

v7b¤•b2i

X

dHi•v dfs•[

n

bci

dfsžsi

X

Z0u

n

vzicZœg@iob nf“

žvŸicZ

m

Z-boij¦7i

X

Z-

m

Zj”Hdfs•e7dHio

n

v‚bd m Z l

šX

d

mr

t

monf‘

s•Z-[—bj

bobe7[Z0v

n

™,i

X

dHiDbciodHiožbcio•ujdfs2•v

“¡nfm

[—dHio

n

v³d

‘n

ehii X Z ‘ Z X

dŠ”@

nfm4nf“

i X Z u

n

[t

n

vhZ-vziob

žbv

n

i d-”Hdf•s•d

‘

s’ZfV£!v­i

X

•b˜ujdfbcZf¦™Z†bcZjZai¢™

n

dfs’icZ

m

v‚dHio’”fZ-b˜i

n

boio•s•stZ mo“¡nfm

[(dfvªdfv‚dfs’k@b•b

nf“

i X

Z²bckbcicZ-[² ´vhZ²ujdfv

‘

e7•s r t n

bobo

‘

s•ZBbouœZ-v7d m n b ‘

kªbcZjicio•vhƒ i X Z²bcZji

nf“

Z-s’Z-[Z-vziod m k

m

Z-s••d

‘

•sž’io’Z-b i nr

> Z m

Z-vzi”Hdfs•ehZ-b/dfv

r

dfv7bc™Z

m

V!™

X

dHi–

“ X µ

ehZ-boio

n

v7bj

WX

•b/ujdfv—ƒ’”fZD•v7bo’ƒ

X i

žvŸi n i X

Z0t mn

t3Z

m

io’Z-b nf“

i X Z˜bcioe

r

•Z

r

bckbcicZ-[²¦

“Tnfm

•v7bciodfv‚uœZdfs•s

n

™4•vhƒ i X Ze7boZ

m i n r

Z-vzio

“k

™Z-d

› t n

•vŸiob•v i

X

ZvhZjiš™

nfmo›

i n t n sn

ƒfkf

WX

Z n i X Z m dHt‚t

mon

dfu

X

¦Ÿ™

X

žu

X

•bi

X

Z[—dfžvboe

‘p

Z-uœi

nf“

i X

•b–t‚dHtZ

m

¦@žb/i n nf‘

iodf•v†e7bcZ

“

e7s3•v

“¡nfm

[—dHio

n v

“Tmn

[wi

X

Zi n t n sn

ƒfk nf“

i X ZvhZjiš™

nfmo› n

v‚s’kf¦

‘

kabcioe

r

k•vhƒ

n'@;! "#

[Zji

m

žujb•v7bcicZ-d r³nf“ m

Z-sž•d

‘

•s••išk

n

vhZ-b-

»JZjie7b¤u

n

v7b

r Z m i X

Zu

n

[—[˜e7v7•ujdHio

n

v7b

‘

Zjiš™ZjZ-v—v nr

Z-b Zdfv r*[

£¥vzioe7’io•”fZ-s’k0bctZ-d

›

•vhƒh¦

d­vhZjiš™

nfmo›

•b—”e7s•vhZ m d ‘

s’Z²™4’i X m

Z-bctZ-uœi i n b n e m uœZŸicZ

m

[—•v7dfsDu

n

[—[˜e7v7•ujdHio

n

v7bj¦

“

’i†•b

V!Z-dfbokX~i n°r

•bou

n

v‚vhZ-uœi0i X n

boZ†v nr

Z-bj¦i

X

dHi•b-¦2

“ i X Z “

dfuœi i

X

dHi˜d V “ Zj™ X u n

[t

n

vhZ-vŸiob nf“

i X ZBvhZji¢™

nfmo›

d m Z rhn

™4v[ d ›

Z-bi

X

dHii X Z m

ZBd

m

Z†v n [

nfm

Z n tZ

m

dHio

n

v7dfs/t‚dHi X b ‘

Zjiš™ZjZ-v Z

dfv r [ 

WX

Zt monf‘

s’Z-[

m

Z-sž’Z-b nf“

u n e m bcZ •v~i

X

ZB[Z-dfv7•vhƒai

n

dfbbo’ƒv i n i X Z ™ nfmr

bAV!Z-dfbckX

dfv r V “

Zj™ X n

v‚bo

r Z m ¦

“Tnfm

•v7boiodfv7uœZf¦i X Z i¢™

n

Zœghdf[t‚s’Z-b•v¯’ƒe

m

ZV\H

Zjiš™

nfmo›

\ ‘

Ô Ú

¯’ƒe

m

Z—\¹¸

m

bci Zœgdf[—t‚s’Z

žbDd²[

n@r

’¸9ujdHio

n v nf“

\jd nf‘

iodfžvhZ r ‘

k~u

X

dfv7ƒ•vhƒai

X

Zt

n

bo’io

n v nf“

s••vhZ-bIL4dfv r

 De7Zi

n

i X Z

‘7m

r

ƒfZ •vV\jd¦dfvzk

n

vhZ™4•sžst m Z “Z m

vhZji¢™

nfm›

\ ‘

¦dfb

“d m

dfb–u

n

[—[˜e7v7žujdHio

n

v7b

‘

Zji¢™–ZjZ-v

Zadfv rT[

d m Z†u

n

v7b

r Z m Z r  WX

ZBt monf‘

s’Z-[ b0d

m

Za[—df•v7s•k~i¢™

n ¸ m

bcij¦

X n ™ i n µ

e7dfvzio

“

k°i X Z

r > Z m

Z-v7uœZ-b

‘

Zji¢™–ZjZ-v†i

X

ZDi n t n sn

ƒ’Z-b•v nfmr

Z m ¦

“¡nfm

•v7bciodfv‚uœZf¦zi n u n

[t‚d

m

ZDiš™

n

dfs’icZ

m

v7dHio•”fZ

n

t‚io

n

v7b 7bcZ-u

n v r ¦ X n

™,i n rhn

™4•i

X

s’Z-bobi

m

•”@•dfsujdfbcZ-b-

WX

žb•b i

X

ZQƒ

n

dfs nf“

i X Z0t‚dHtZ

m 

Ž

ZD™•s•s

r

Z-v

n

icZ

‘

k"!B«

C

®–d”@e‚s•vhZ m d ‘

žs•’išk˜[Z-dfboe m Z

nf“

dfvae7v r m

Z-uœicZ r ƒ m

dHt XUC

¤£

“

™Z

u n v‚bo

r Z mJn

v‚s’ki

X

Z/u

n

[—[˜e7v7•ujdHio

n

v7b

‘

Zjiš™ZjZ-v˜v n@r

Z-bpZdfv r [

¦<™–Z–™4•s•sfbctZ-d

› d

‘n

ehi

-'+?@f

5f`\/(*3

”e7s•v7Z m d ‘

•s••iškf¦

nfm$# f`\/(*3

”@e7sžvhZ m d ‘

•sž’iškf¦dfv r i X

Z²dfbob

n

uj•dHicZ

r

[Z-dfboe m Z

™•s•s

‘ Z r

Z-v

n

icZ r¶‘

k%!'&)(*L«É®†£¥vujdfbcZ nf“‘

Z-•vhƒ²u

n

v7uœZ

m

vhZ r¶‘

k°u

n

[—[e‚v7•ujdHio

n

v7b

‘

Zji¢™–ZjZ-v

dfvzk†t‚df

mnf“

v

nr

Z-bj¦hi

X

Z0[—Z-dfboe

m

ZQ•b i X Z

<f\@?(*"3

”e7s•v7Z m d ‘

•s••iškf¦

r

Z-v

n

icZ r²‘

k$!QklmlÉ«É®

WX

Zu

n

vzicZ-vziob nf“

i X

•b–™

nfmo›

¦@™

X

žu

X

•b–dfvBZœgicZ-v7bo

n v nf“

dt

m

Zj”

n

e7b/™

nfmo›

t m Z-bcZ-vzicZ

r

•v

iÞyjɦ9•b i X Z

“¡n

s•s

n

™•vhƒh£¥v²v7Zœg@ibcZ-uœio

n

v¦h™–Z

r

•bouje7bobi

X

ZQ[ df•vat mon

tZ

m

io’Z-bi

X

dHid ”@e7sžvhZ m d

‘

•s•’i¢k³•v

r

ZœgPb X n

e7s r X

d-”fZf£¥v+@Z-uœio

n

v¶y@¦™Z

‘7m

’Z,9k

m

Z-ujdfs•s2t

m

Zj”

n

e7bDdHicicZ-[t7iob´i n ™

nfmo›

™’i X i X

Z˜”e7s•v7Z m d ‘

•s••išk²u

n

v7uœZjt7ij

WX

Z t monf‘

s•Z-[

X Z m

Z žb4i

X

dHiQv

n

vhZ nf“

i X Z[Zji

m

žujbi

X

dHi

X

d-”fZ

‘

ZjZ-v²t mn

t n boZ

r

•v²i

X

ZQs••icZ

m

dHioe

m

ZQbodHiožb

“

k†i

X

Z0[ •v7•[—dfs3bcZji nf“

t

mn

t3Z

m

io’Z-b

r

•bouje‚bobcZ

r

žv-+Z-uœio

n v {@.+@Z-uœio

n v t m

Z-bcZ-vziobd´vhZj™·”e7s•vhZ m d ‘

•s•’i¢kQ[Z-dfboe

m

Zdfv

r

™Z4b X n

™·i

X

dHi/•i

X

dfb

i X Zt

mn

t3Z

m

io’Z-bsž•bcicZ

r

•v/+@Z-uœio

n

v°{@Q£!v0+@Z-uœio

n

v¶|@¦™–Z t mon

”fZ i

X

dHii

X

Z[Z-dfboe

m

Z˜”fZ

m

º¸9Z-b

dfv

n i X Z m t mon

tZ

m

iškf¦z™

X

•u

X

•b/t‚d

m

io•uje7sžd

m

s’ke‚bcZ

“

e‚s

“Tnfm

i X

ZDdHt7t‚s••ujdHio

n

v7bj2£¥v1+@Z-uœio

n

v32@¦’i•b

r

•bouje7boboZ

r X n ™ n

vhZujdfv ZœgicZ-v r i X

Z[Zji

m

žu4•v—d˜v7dHioe

m

dfsh™dŠkf¦hi n X

dfv

r

s’Z

n i X Z m t monf‘

s’Z-[—b