HAL Id: inria-00071574
https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00071574
Submitted on 23 May 2006
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub-
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
Optimal risk control and dividend pay-outs under excess of loss reinsurance
Mohamed Mnif, Agnès Sulem
To cite this version:
Mohamed Mnif, Agnès Sulem. Optimal risk control and dividend pay-outs under excess of loss rein- surance. [Research Report] RR-5010, INRIA. 2003. �inria-00071574�
ISRN INRIA/RR--5010--FR+ENG
a p p o r t
d e r e c h e r c h e
THÈME 4
INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE
Optimal risk control and dividend pay-outs under excess of loss reinsurance
Mohamed Mnif and Agnès Sulem
N° 5010
November, 25 2003
1234!5 )*6 0!
728:96;=<?>A@B7DCEGFIH*;=C@2JKLC+MANOPQR>A<S
T5U(VWXZY\[ ]_^`Wa(bdcfeg^`hjiXe%hjkleg^`Wm^`ngcfeo^phji
q XZnsrAnsegV WmX n%t hjWmk(b`Xu_X n
vxwghzysX3e|{#}xT"~
%ck(khjw e q XZwgX tUlX wgtUlXi=xl[ hjXW\X w :j'j[ fY'kcjXn
*3 ¡
Xnsega
q
r¢eoU(X\hkleo^pW£cbwsX ^`ilnga(wgci(t Xkhjbp^`tr¢ci q¤q
^pA^
q
X i q n q
^`n eowg^p(aleg^`hji¢h¥¦ci¤^`ilnga(w¨§
ci(tX0t hWkcfi©rZali q X w+X3u_tX ngnxhf¥(b`hngn+wgX ^pi(ngalwoci(tXªT5U(X0^pi(nga(wsX w+j^pX n+kcw ehf¥^pegn+klwgX Wm^`alW«nsegwgX¬cfWegh
ci(hegU(X w%t hWkcfi©r^pi¢Xu_tUci(jXh¥xcfi®hj(bp^` czeo^`hi£eohnga(k(khjw eegU(X q ^p¯:X wgXi(t XXe±°X X iegU(XcWha(i e
h¥"eoU(Xtbdc^pW²ci q nghWX*wsXegX i eo^phji³b`X3jX b´ªµT5U(XhjAysX t3eo^¶jXh¥"eoUlX*^`i(nsa(wgXw^`neghWczu_^`Wm^`ngXmeoU(X£X3u©§
k:XtegX q³q ^pngt ha(i eoX q³q ^pA^q Xi q nª ¡ X*nga(klk:hjnsX£eoU(cfe\^pi·eoUlXc(nsX i(tXh¥ q ^¶_^q X i qq ^`n eows^`(aleg^`hjiL+egU(X
wgXngX w jXZk(wsh_tX ngn0h¥eoU(X^`i(nsa(wocilt X|thjWk(ci r¥Ghjbpb`h°"nct hjWmkhja(i q v+hj^`nsnghjiklwghAt X nsn ª ¡ X¸wsnse5k(wshjX
X3u_^`n eoXi(t X#ci
q
a(il^`¹©a(X ilX ngnmwgXnga(b¶eon\¥GhjweoU(^pnhjkleo^pW^pnocfeg^`hjiºk(wshj(b`XW» r³a(ns^`i(¤ns^`i(a(bdcwnsegh_tUcfnseo^pt
t hji egwghjb:WX3eoU(h q n5ci q eoU(X|egU(X hwsrh¥A^`ngthjng^¶e±r£nshjb`a_eo^`hi(n ª ¡ XegU(X ithjWklaleoXegU(X|hjk_eo^`Wcb=nsegwocfegX r
h¥wgX^`i(nsa(wocilt X egU(X-hjkleg^`WcbAnseowgcfeoXr\hf¥ q ^pA^ q Xi q nxkc¬r §±hale¼ci q egU(X-fcb`a(X¥Ga(i(teg^`hji©r\nghjb¶_^pi(egU(X
cngnsh_t^dcfegX q ^`i egX jwshf§ q ^¶¯LXwgXi©eg^dcb:~cfW^pbpeohi_§ ½jcthj(^¾§¨¿0Xb`b`WcfiÀ¦cws^dcfeg^`hji(cb:±ilX ¹©acbp^pe±r*i©a(WmX ws^`t cb`b¶r^pi
eoU(XZt cngXZh¥6cmv+hj^`nsnghji#k(wsh_tX ngn5°"^¶eoU#t hji(n eci e%^`i egX i(ns^pe±rjª
Á¢Â ÃLÄsÅ\Æ zÇf ]_^`i(a(bdcwIn eohAtUcn eo^`tmt hi©egwghjb´lysa(Wk q ^¶¯La(ns^`hjiL q r_i(cW^pt'k(wghjwocWmW^pi(*k(ws^`i(t^`k(bpX
A^`ngthjng^¶e±rnghb`aleg^`hjiÈl~h°0cw q cb`hjwg^¶eoU(W#_^pi(ngalwoci(tXwsX ^`ilnga(wgci(t Xfª
É6ÊGË+ÌÊGÍÎdÌÏÐsÑÒzÓ ÔzÐ Ï3ÒÕ´Ös×Ó Î`Ø5ÙÚÜÛ`ÝlØ-ÏÞzÙØ-Ósß©àØ-ÔÚâá`ãÚâÔzÕ´ÚäÙàá¾Õ
å
ÊGË+ÌÊGÍÎdÌÏÐsÑÒzÓ ÔzÐ Ï3ÒÕ´Ös×ÓsØ-Ù3ÚâÛ`Ý=ÙæÔÓsçsàçRÒÛÜÓ Ø%ãÚÜÔÕèÚÜÙzàá¾Õ
0 ¨) 06 I.!² " +)* 0!» %!" 3+ I3 ±!0/*"4!
¤!-+!"
iega q ^`Xmbdckhjb`^¶eo^p¹AalXhjkleo^pW£cfb`X q Xmw cngnsa(wocfi(t X*X3e q X q ^pnsegwg^`laleo^phji q X q ^pA^q Xi q Xn
qali(XthjWk(cji(^pX qcnsnga(wgci(tX¹Aal^wsXjXwgnsX\a(i(X\k(cwseg^`X q X nk(wg^pWXn¹©a X bpb`XwgXhj^pealiw cngnsa(wgXa(w
¹Aal^n X il cjX£k(crX wIb`c q ^p¯ wsX i(tX\X i egwgXbdcmec^pb`b`X q XtUc¹©a(Xng^pi(^`n eowsX¹©a(^6nsa(wsA^`Xi eZXeIa(i¤tX w ec^pi
i(^pX¬ca
q
X%wegX i eo^phji
q
hji(i!fª#"0X%t hji eowgcfe¦X n e0thji(i©a£nshja(n¦b`X"i(hjW
q
Xw$¬cnsnga(wgci(t X q
X3u_t Vn
q
X"kX wsegX nª
%
hjAysXteg^p¥
q
X-b
cfngngalwgX alwxX nse
q
X-Wczu_^`Wm^`ngXwb
Xngk& wgci(t X
q
aWhi©eoci e
q
Xn
q
^pA^
q
X i
q
X n¼ct3eoacbp^`n$ n ª i
Wh q bp^`nsXbpX n5ng^pi(^`n eowsX n-kcfw-a(ik(wghAt Xngnsa(n q XZvhj^pngnshjit hjWmk:hnª ik(wshjaljXIb Xu_^`nsegX i(tXIXe"ba(il^`t ^¶e'
q Xbdc¤nghjbpaleo^phji q XA^`nst hjns^pe' q Xb ^pi! ¹©acfeg^`hjifcws^dcfeg^`hjili(X bpb`Xcngnsh_t^( XXi aleg^`b`^pnoci e q X nmW)3eoU(h q Xn
q Xt hi©egw*jbpXnsegh_tU(cnseg^`¹©a(Xns^`i(jalb`^`Xw ª,+ci(na(i(X®ngX thji q Xµkcfwseo^pX5hji2w$ nshja q i©a(W)wg^p¹AalX WmX i eb`X
k(wghjlb`V WmX£Xi?aleo^pb`^`ngci e\a(icbpjhjws^peoUlWX'cn$nga(wb cbpjhjws^peoUlWX q~h°0cw q?q cilnb`X*t cnkcw eo^`ta(b`^pX w
q
ali¢k(wsh_tX nsnga(n
q
Xvhj^pngnshjiȪ
-Æ Ä /. # "0hi©egw*jbpXZnseohAtUcn eo^p¹AalXng^pi(ja(bp^`Xw q ^¶¯Lalng^`hi¢c¬X tngcalegn k(wg^pi(t ^pk:X q Xk(wshjjwocfWWcz§
eo^`hi q rAicWm^`¹©a(Xnshjb`a_eo^`hi q XI_^pngthjng^¶e'(cb`jhwg^pegU(WmX q X~h°0cw q =cngnsa(wocilt X=w$¬cnsnga(wgci(t Xfª
2 3
m)
} cns^`t-klwghj(bpX W ^`i\^pi(ngalwoci(tX5^`n+eoU(X5k(wshj(bpX W h¥=hjkleg^`Wcb_ws^`n-4thji eowghb(ci qq ^pA^q Xi q n q ^`nsegwg^p(aleo^phjiȪ
±i q XX q egU(Xnsa(wgklb`a(nk(wghAt Xngnh¥-eoUlX^pi(nga(wsX wt hjilng^`n eonh¥5c#k(wgXW^pa(W n eowgX cW °"U(^ptU t hWWm^pegnIU(^`W
eoh#kc¬r¤eoU(XcWmhja(i eZh¥eoU(Xmt b`c^`WmnIcfeZeoUlX ^`wZcfwgwg^¶fcb`n|°"U(^ptU·^pn#4Ailh°"i·eoh#:Xmcwg^`n-4 rºcteg^pA^pe±rªmT+h
wgX
q
a(t X%eoU(X"ws^`n'4= eoUlX^pi(nga(wsX w¼j^¶jX n¦kcw e¼h¥LegU(X%k(wgXW^pa(W n eowgX cW eohci(hfeoU(Xw¦thjWmkci r^`imX3u_tUcfi(jX
h¥xcfi®hj(bp^` czeo^`hi*eohmt hjXw|ck(cwseh¥egU(Xt bdcf^`W#ªT5U(X^`i(nsa(wgXwU(cncfb`ngh'eohmkc¬r¢c65(h°hf¥
q
^¶_^
q
X i q n
eoh\nsUcwsX U(hjbq X wsn ªxT+hW£c74X|cfi*hjkleg^`WcbtU(hj^pt X|h¥egU(XIcWmhja(i e¦eoh\^pi(ngalwgX|cfi q eoU(X q ^pA^q X i q n0eoh\k(cr
hjale nseohAtUcn eo^ptIt hji eowshjbWmXeoUlh q n"cfwg^`nsXZicfeoalwocbpbprjª
±ieoU(X£b`^pegX wgcfeoa(wsX+cfwg^`ha(ntwg^¶eoX ws^dc¢cwgXa(ngX q egh®¥GhjwsW\a(bdczeoX'eoU(Xk(wghjlb`X W h¥5hkleo^pW£cb¼ws^`n'4µthji eowghb
ci q98 hjw q ^pA^q X i q n q ^`nsegwg^p(aleo^phjinsa(tU·egUcfe;:R^=<Wczu_^`Wm^`ng^pi(£Xu_k:XteoX q aleg^`bp^pe±r¢h¥egX wsW^picbnsa(wgklb`a(n¨§
k(wghAt Xngn>:G^`^=<W^pi(^`Wm^`ns^`i(eoU(XZwsa(^`ik(wshjc(^pb`^¶e±r£h¥eoU(XZ^pi(nga(wsX w"hjw?:R^p^`^=<¦Wczu_^`Wm^`ng^pi(egU(XZt a(Wa(bdcfeg^pX
X3u_kX tegX q¢q
^`nst hja(i egX q®q
^pA^
q
Xi
q
kc¬r §±hjalegn ª
ThaA@ ^:èfjjB<n eoa q ^`X q eoU(X"k(wshj(bpX W h¥:Wczu_^`Wm^`ng^pi(egU(X"X3u_k:XtegX q aleg^`bp^pe±rh¥:egU(X"eoX wsW^picb_wgX nsX w jX^pi
eoU(X5t cngX"h¥Lc|k(wshjk:hwseo^phjicbAwgX^`i(nsa(wocfi(t X"t hi©egwoct3e¬ªx~%X5Wh q Xb`b`X q eoUlX5wgX nsX w jX%k(wghAt Xngn¦©r\c +hjb( ci(n¨§
+|c q X'Xulkhji(Xi eo^dcfb6h¥ysa(Wkµk(wsh_tX nsncfi q tUcwocfteoXwg^pngX q eoUlXmhkleo^pW£cb+nsegwocfegX rh¥¦wgX ^pi(ngalwoci(tX_^`c
c q acb¥GhjwgW\albdcfeg^`hjiȪT5U(Xt ws^peoXwg^phjih¥¦Wczu_^`Wm^`ng^pi('eoU(XXulkX t3eoX q aleg^`bp^pe±r#h¥¼eoU(XeoX wsW^picb+wgXngX w jX
^`n'i(hemwsX b`X3fci eUlX wgX#ng^pi(t XeoUlX¢^pi(nga(wsX w°"U(h·^`n'^`i A^pegX
q
eohºt hjXw*cµbdcwsjXwg^pn'4 °0ci eonmeohº:X#wg^pn'4
i(X a_eowocfbC:RnsX X'}|cnsXD:èjjE<'<ªT5U(X'nsX t hi
q
twg^¶eoX ws^`hji®^`nIa(nsX¥Ga(b6¥Ghjwt hji(nsa(WmX wgnci
q
nsa(kX wsA^pnghjwsnZci
q
X3uAeowsX WmX b¶r thji(nsX wsfcfeg^pX®X nsk:Xt ^`cb`b¶r¥Ghjwmwg^`tU t hjWmkcil^`X nª ]_tU(Wm^ q bp^*:èlF<\nsega q ^`X q eoUlX¢hjk_eo^`Wcb
k(wghk:hjw eo^phjicb+wgX^`i(nsa(wocilt X'k:hb`^`t3r¢°"Ul^`tUµW^pi(^`Wm^`nsX n"eoU(X'wsa(^`i¤k(wshjcl^`b`^¶e±r#^`i¤^`i_¸i(^pegX\U(hjws^@hjiȪ\~%X
q X ws^pX q eoUlX\cnsnghAt ^dczeoX q ~cWm^`b¶eohjiA§ ½jcthj(^¶§±¿0X bpb`WmciX ¹©acfeg^`hjiÈk(wshX q egU(XXul^pnsegX i(tX\h¥¦cnshjb`a_eo^`hi
ci q cjXwg^¶¸t¬cfeg^`hjimeoU(XhjwgXW^`imeoU(X q ^p¯:a(ns^`hjimt¬cnsXª¼~%Xk(wshX q egUcfe¦eoU(Xwga(^piklwghjcf(^`bp^pe±r q X t wsX¬cnsX n
X3u_khji(X i eg^dcbpbpr ci q eoU(Xµhjkleg^`Wcbklwghjkhjwseg^`hji egh?^`i(nsa(wgXµ^`nthji(n eci e¬ª4{¢hwgX hX w IUlXºjcX·nshjWmX
t hjiysX tega(wgX£^`iµeoU(X"0wocW w¨§ %a(i q X wst¬cfngXª#T5U(XmeoU(^pw q twg^¶eoX ws^`hjiº^`nk(wsX¥GX wgc(bpX¥GhjwngUcfwgX Ulhjbq Xwgnª
½X¬ci©(b`ci(t£ci q ]_U(^pwoc¬rjX3G:¨ HEH <Zn eoa q ^pX q egU(X*k(wshj(bpX W²h¥"hjkleg^`Wcb q ^¶_^q X i qq ^`n eows^`(aleg^`hjiºkhjb`^ptr
°"^pegU(hjalehjkleg^`Wcb-wg^pn'4³thji eowghbèª T5U(X3r Wmh q X bpb`X q egU(X¢X3jhjbpaleo^phji hf¥eoUlX®t¬cfk(^peocbJI K LI6MNOM=P"Q*h¥
c·thjWk(ci r?©rSRBI6M/KUTVRBWYX[ZVR.\]M_^`R7abM°"U(XwgXDTBci q Z«cfwgX#t hji(n eci egn c\ K Ld\]MN1M=P"Q^`nc
nseoci q cw q ¿0wgh°"i(^`ciWmheo^phjicfi q aeKfLdabMN1M=P"Q^pn|c£ilhji(i(X cfeo^¶jXfÈi(hji q X t wsX¬cns^`i(ws^`jU e §±t hi©eg^`i©a(hjaln
ci q c q ckleoX q k(wghAt XngnªIT5U(Xk(wghAt Xngn*a wsX k(wsX nsX i eonIeoUlX\nsegwocfegX r¢h¥¼kc¬rAWXi eZh¥ q ^pA^ q X i q n| r¢egU(X
t hjWmkci rª-T5U(Xr#nsU(h°0X
q
eoUcfe"egU(X wsXX3u_^pnseoncmegU(wgXngU(hb qhgji
nga(tU¢eoUcfe%X3jX w r®Xu_t X nsn|h¥eoU(XwgXngX w jX
chX gVi ^`n q ^pnsegwg^`laleoX q cn q ^¶A^q Xi q ^pi(nseoci ecilX hja(nsbprª0~ckzys cjcw q ci q Tc4©ngcw/:¨ HEHEHE<0nseoa q ^`X q egU(X
k(wgh(b`XW4h¥ws^`n-4thji eowghbÈci q£q ^pA^q X i q n0kc¬r©§ hjale ªxT5U(XrWmh q X bpb`X q eoUlX|Xhjb`aleg^`hji£h¥eoU(X|klwghAt X nsnJI
h¥eoU(X"t hWkcfi©r\©r6RBI6MVKmlBMnLTVRBWEXhZVR.\]MN$^R7abM± °"U(X wsXol6KeLlBMN1M=P"QwgXk(wgXngX i egneoUlX%ws^`n-4X3u_khjngalwgX
°"^pegUqp6rGlBM>rts¥Ghjw5cbpbWJumplª6T5U(X3r£¥Ghjali q eoU(XIhkleo^pW£cb=n eowoczeoX fr°"U(^ptUW£cul^pW^pngXn¦egU(XIX3u_kX tegX q
eoheocb q ^`ngthja(i eoX qq ^pA^ q X i q n°"U(X ieoUlX wgXI^pn-i(hwsX nsegwg^pteo^phji*hji*egU(X|wgcfeoXIh¥ q ^pA^q Xi q kc¬r §±hja_e¬ªxT5U(X3r
ngU(h°X q egUcfe¼eoUlX wgX%X3u_^pnseon g Q0cfi q;gVi °"^pegU g QCr gVi nsa(tU£eoU(cfe¦XjXwsrmX3u_tX ngnh¥LegU(X"wgXngX w jXIcf:hjX gVi
^`n q ^`n eowg^p(alegX q cfn q ^pA^q X i q ci q egU(X0hjk_eo^`Wcb©wg^pn'4ZX3u_khjngalwgX-^pnj^¶jX i©r?lLvwNxKzy{
|+}
s-°"U(XwgX~v'^pnegU(X
t a(wswgXi©eZwsX nsX wsXªZ}nsW\a(nsngX iL~ckzys cjcfw q ci q Tc74Angcw:èfjjB<5t hjilng^q X wgX q eoU(X\^pngnsa(X\h¥¼hjk_eo^`Wcbwg^pn'4
Y
t hji eowshjb6cfi q¤q
^pA^
q
X i q¤q
^`nsegwg^p(aleo^phji®khjbp^`t ^pX n%a(i
q
XwIX3u_t Xngnh¥¼b`hngn|wsX ^`ilnga(wgci(t X\°"Ul^`tUµ^`n%eoU(XWmhjnse
t hjWmWhi^`i\eoUlX%wsX ^pi(nga(wgci(tX%^pi q a(n eow rjªxT5U(X"^`ilnga(wsX wxj^¶jX n¼kcfwse¼h¥eoU(X"k(wsX Wm^`a(W nsegwgX¬cfW eohci(hfeoU(Xw
t hjWmkci rj^`i#X3u_tUcfi(jX\h¥xci®hjlb`^`jcfeo^phji£eohnga(klk:hjw eegU(X q ^p¯:X wgXi(t X:X3e±°0XX iegU(X\cWmhja(i eh¥6X ctU
t bdcf^`W4ci q nghjWmX|¸lu_X q b`X3jX bt cb`bpX q wsXeoXi eo^`hi#bpXX bèªxT5UlXcfaleoU(hwgn"a(ngX q c q ^¶¯Lalng^`hi¢cfk(k(wgh¬u_^`Wcfeg^`hji
¥GhjweoUlXwgX nsX w jX'k(wghAt Xngnci q wsX kcwgcWmXeows^@X q eoUlXk(wghjlb`X W r¤t hi(ng^ q X ws^`i(*egU(X q wg^¶¥eegX wgW cn|eoUlX
cng^ptthji eowshjbk(cwocWmXegX w=°"Ul^`tUbpX¬c q n"eoh£c£Wm^¶u_X q wgXja(bdcfw 8 ns^`i(jalbdcw5n eohAtUcnseg^`tt hji eowshjbk(wgh(b`XW¢ª
T5U(Xr q X wg^¶jX q cim~cW^pbpeghji½jcthj(^¿X b`bpW£cfiÀ¦cwg^`cfeo^phjicbA±i(X¹Aa(cb`^¶e±rq:´~½j¿À|+^`insU(hjw e<6^`i\egU(X5t¬cnsX
h¥0aliAhja(i q X q wgcfeoX'h¥ q ^pA^q X i q ncfi q klwghjX q eoUczeegU(Xfcb`a(X¥Ga(ilteo^phjiµ^`nct bdcfngng^pt¬cbnghjbpaleo^phjiµh¥
eoU(XcnsnghAt ^dczeoX q ~½j¿À|ª=T5U(X3rt hji(n eowsa(tegX q egU(XZnghjbpaleo^phji^`ieoUlXt cngXZh¥a(i©:ha(i q X q ci q hja(i q X q
nga(k(khjw e*h¥IegU(X q ^pnseows^`(a_eo^`hi h¥IegU(X®tbdc^pWnª ±i eoU(^pn£kckX w5°0Xn eoa q r egU(XnocfWX¢k(wghjlb`X W (a_e
°0XºWh q XbeoU(XºwgXngXwsjX·k(wghAt Xngn¢h¥egU(Xº^`i(nsa(wgXw# rDa(ns^`i( c?t hjWmk:ha(i q vhj^pngnshjiBk(wsh_tX nsn ª +a(X
eoh¤eoU(X#{¢cw'4fhA^`ci thji eoXu_e 0hjalwk(wghjlb`X W W£c¬r :Xnsega q ^pX q rc q ^`wgXte q rAicfW^pt*k(wghjwocWmWm^`i(
ck(k(wsh ctU³b`X c
q
^pi(¢egh¤ci³^`i egX jwshf§
q
^¶¯LXwgXi©eg^dcb¼~cWm^`bpeghji ½jct hjl^-¿0Xb`b`WciµÀ¦cwg^`cfeo^phjicbx±ilX ¹©acbp^pe±rjª
±imX i(Xwocb´eoU(X-fcbpa(X0¥Ga(ilteo^phjih¥t hi©egwghjb_k(wgh(b`XWn6^pn6i(he¼nsWhAhegU\X i(ha(jUeohIX"c|nsegwghji(Znshjb`aleg^`hji
h¥0egU(X£cfngnghAt ^`cfeoX q ~½j¿À|ªT5U(Xmi(heg^`hjiµh¥A^`ngthjng^¶e±rµnghjbpaleo^phjiȸwsnse^`i eowsh q a(t X q r"0woci q cb`b¼cfi q
%^phji(nq:¨ HjE<36^pn/4©i(h°"iegh¤:Xckh°0Xws¥Ga(b-egh_hjb¼¥GhjwegU(^`n\e±rAkXh¥%k(wgh(b`XWnª ¡ Xk(wshXU(X wsXci
X3u_^`n eoX ilt X5ci q a(i(^p¹AalX i(XngnxwgXnga(b¶e¥GhweoUlX-cnsnghAt ^dczeoX q ~|½j¿Àci q egU(X i\nshjbpX-^pe+ ra(ng^pi(IciXmt ^pX i e
iAalWXwg^`t cbWX3eoU(h q eoU(Xt hji jXwgjXi(t X'h¥x°"Ul^`tU^pnX ilnga(wsX q r¢egU(X\a(i(^p¹©a(X i(XngnIwsX ngalbpe¬ªT5U(X\kcfk:Xw
^`nhwg cil^`ngX
q
cn¥Ghjb`bph°"nªT5UlXk(wghjlb`X W ^pn¥GhjwsW\a(bdczeoX
q
^`i]_X t3eo^`hiµ_ª|±iº]_Xteg^`hji¤_:°X\k(wghXeoUcze
eoU(Xcfb`a(XZ¥Ga(i(t3eo^`hi®^`ncA^`nst hjns^pe±r#nghb`aleg^`hji#h¥6egU(X\cnsnghAt ^`cfeoX q ~|½j¿Àª:±i¤]_X t3eo^`hiY°X\k(wshXeoUlX
a(i(^`¹©a(Xi(X nsn£h¥%eoUlXA^pngt hng^pe±r?nshjb`a_eo^`hiȪ]_X t3eo^phji µ^pn q XheoX q eoh¤eoUlX¢i©a(WmX ws^`t¬cfb5cicb¶rAng^`nhf¥eoUlX
~|½j¿Àx^`i£egU(Xt cngX|hf¥+c\vhj^pngnshji*k(wsh_tX ngn-°"^¶eoUt hji(n eci e5^pi eoX ilng^pe±r6°X|kX ws¥GhwgWc¸i(^¶eoX q ^p¯:X wsX i(tX
ck(k(wshu_^pW£cfeg^`hji£h¥eoU(X~|½j¿¦À|-cfi q eoU(Xi¢nshjbpXZegU(XIk(wshj(b`XW, ra(ns^`i(mci¢cbpjhjwg^¶eoU(W cfngX q hjieoUlX
~h°0cw q cbpjhjwg^¶eoU(Wª a(WmX ws^`t cb-wgXnga(b¶eonmcwsX#klwgX nsX i eoX q ª T5U(X3r?k(wghA^q XegU(Xhjkleg^`Wcb0khjb`^ptr h¥
wgX ^pi(ngalwoci(tXci
q
eoU(XZhjkleg^`WcbnseowgcfeoXrh¥
q
^¶_^
q
X i
q
n"kc¬r©§ hjale ª
Z ) Z3 1 ! #3!"
%X3e6L! ?N5:X'c£thjWmk(b`X3eoXklwghjcf(^`bp^pe±rngk(ct Xfª ¡ Xcnsnga(WmX\eoUczeeoUlXt bdcf^`WmncwsX\jXi(X wgcfeoX q ©r
ct hWkhja(i q vh^`ngnshjik(wsh_tX nsn ª{¢hjwsXk(wsX t ^pngXbprj=°Xt hi(ng^q X wci^pi©egX jXw §ècfb`a(X q wgci q hjW.WmX¬cfnga(wsX
T_LRBW"R$#$N'°"^pegU2t hjWmkX i(ngcfeohjw&%_LR$#AN1RBWª ¡ Xµcngnsa(WmXeoUcfe'%_LR$#ANDK ()LR$#AN'°"U(X wsX*)LR$#$Nm^pnc
k(wghj(c(^`bp^pe±r q ^`n eows^`(aleg^`hjiµhji*+-,/.01 ci q ( ^`nc#khjns^peo^¶jX't hi(nseoci e¬ª*±iºeoU(^pnt cngXfegU(X^pi eoX wocb
°"^peoUwgXngkX te0eohegU(Xwgci q hWWX cnga(wsX T_LRBW"R$#AN^pnns^`Wmk(bpr'ct hjWmkhja(i q vhj^pngnghi*k(wghAt Xngn6°0X|U(cX
2 M
Q
243
T_LR
g
'R5#$N K7698;:
<>=
i@?
<
È°"U(XwgXBA KDCEA*MF-W u pHGm^pnIcvhj^pngnghiºklwghAt X nsnI°"^peoU¤^pi eoX ilng^pe±r( cfi
q
C ? <
IJK.ALG£^pnIcngX ¹©a(Xi(t Xh¥¦woci
q
hjW fcws^dc(bpX n%°"^peoUµthjWWmhji
q
^pnsegwg^`laleo^phjiM)4°"U(^ptUµwgX klwgX nsX i e
eoU(XZng^@ Xn%hf¥egU(XZt bdcf^`W#ª ¡ Xnsa(k(khjngXZeoU(cfeNA²ci q C ? <
IOJP.ALGcwsXI^`i q X kX i q Xi e»
¡ X q Xi(heoXZ r'.QtK LRcMNOM=P"Q%egU(XI¸bpegwocfeg^`hjijXi(X wgcfeoX q r*egU(XZwoci q hjW WmX¬cnsa(wgX#T_LRBW"R$#ANª
}wgXegX i eo^phjiºb`XX bxk(wsh_tX nsn^pnZciScM`§±c q cklegX q k(wsh_tX ngnUTGK LTjMV'W*u pBN|wgXk(wgXngXi©eg^`i(¢ciºX3u_t Xngnh¥
b`hjnsnegwgX¬cze±rnsk:Xt ^¶¥ r_^pi(egUcfe¬Ah¥cfi©rt b`c^`Whf¥ng^@ X #mcfeeo^pWX W_egU(X
q
^`wgXte0^`i(nsa(wgXw0^`n¦eoht hjXw # } TjM
ci q eoU(XZwsX ^`ilnga(wsX w"^`n-eghmthjX w"eoUlXXu_t X nsn|cWmhja(i e*LR#+^ TjMN1ª
^¶jXi¤cwsXeoXi eo^`hib`X3jX b TMxcfeeg^`WmX#W°0X q X i(hfeoX rLTjMN-eoU(X q ^p¯:X wgXi(t X:X3e±°0XX i¤eoUlXk(wsX Wm^`a(W
wocfegX|kX w-a(il^pe-hf¥eo^`WmXwsX tX ^pX q r£egU(X|t hWkcfi©r£ci q egU(XIk(wsX Wm^`a(W woczeoXkX w0a(i(^pe-h¥eo^pWXkc^q ©r
eoU(XZthjWk(ci r*eoheoUlXwsX ^pi(nga(wsX w%cfe5eg^`WmX Wª
wghjW i(h° hjiÈÈ°Xmt hji(ns^q XwZck(wgXW^pa(W wgcfeoXh¥¦eoUlXmngcWmX\¥GhjwgW cnZ^`i¤}nsW\a(nsngX iL6~okys cjcw q ci q
Tc74Angcw?:èjB<
L TM)N K L-sYX i NF(/^ Lns~X N (L ? < ^ TM)N1 ¥Ghw"cb`bW~u p@ :´_ªp <
°"U(X wsX i ci q |cwsXk(wshjkhjwseg^`hjicfbÈ¥Rcteghjwgn%nocfeg^`n ¥r_^pi(;pr i r ª"±ix¹©acfeg^`hji :è_ª¶F<3egU(XegX wgW
(wsX k(wsX ngXi eonegU(XX3u_k:Xteocfeo^phji¢hf¥egU(XcWha(i ehf¥egU(Xtbdc^pWn q a(ws^`i(ca(i(^pe%h¥+eo^pWXfªxT5U(XngX thji q
eoXwgW h¥eoUlX%wªâULªân¼h¥x¹Aa(cfeo^phjiD:è_ª¶F<^`n6egU(X5k(wsX Wm^`a(W kc^q eghZegU(X5wgX^`i(nsa(wocfi(t X%t hjWmkci reohZnga(klk:hjw e
eoU(X q ^¶¯LXwgX ilt Xm:X3e±°0XX ieoUlXcfWhjali©eh¥eoU(Xmt b`c^`WmnZci q eoUlXwsXeoXi eo^`hi·bpXjXb T¦ q a(wg^pi(¢c#a(il^peh¥
eo^pWXfª%Xja(b`cfeo^phji(nZbdc¬r q h°"i egUcfek(wgXW^pa(WnZW\alnse:Xnga@mt ^pX i eegh®thX w\Xu_k:Xi q ^pega(wgXn °"Ul^`tU
WX ci(n5eoU(cfe
L TMN>^ (
? < }
TjMjump ¥Ghjw"cbpbwWJu p :´_ªä<
"0hji q ^¶eo^phji :è_ªÜE<0^pn5X ¹©a(^pfcbpX i e5eoh
TjM>u T ¥Ghjw"cbpbbL)W" N-clªX :´_ªÜE<
°"U(X wsX T (eoUlXbph°0Xnsec q Wm^`nsng^`lb`X|wsXeoXi eo^`hiÈ(^`n-egU(XZa(i(^p¹AalXnshjb`a_eo^`hih¥
LT N>^ (
? < } T wK`p
*Â (! #"%$ !! O$ "!JC!'(9!'#1 + K C'& G)( &)* p ! ( !$ !o h!-,
!-, ! 10 T ( " ! T K,+.-0/21234/576
/ 1 8
¡ X q Xi(heoX r:9 K L;9bMF'WCu pBN0eoU(X oM`§±c q ck_eoX q k(wghAt Xngnh¥6eoUlXta(W\a(b`cfeo^¶jXcWmhja(i ehf¥ q ^¶_^q X i q n
kc^q hale' reoU(X^pi(nga(wsX wª
^pX ici^`i(^¶eo^`cb¼wgX nsX w jXDv ci q cµk:hjbp^`t3r L T<9 N3¼eoUlXwgX nsX w jX®hf¥egU(X
^`i(nsa(wocfi(t XZt hWkcfi©rcfe5eo^pWX W0a(i
q
Xw5eoU(^pn5X3u_t Xngnhf¥bphjngn"t hi©egwoct3e%^`n-eoUlX i#j^pX i#©rP
I
|>=?@=A
M K v XCB
M
Q
jLT
y
NnR
g
^B
M
Q B 3 L# } T y N$TbLR
g
R$#ANj^B
M
Q
R9
y :´_ªâYB<
}nseowgcfeoXr L T<9 N0^`n5ngc^
q
eghmXc
q
Wm^`nsng^`lb`X^¶¥ T K LTjMV'WJu pEN0nocfeg^`ns¸(X n+:è_ªâB<0ci
q
9 ^pn5wg^pjU es§±thji eo^piAalhja(n li(hji q Xt wsX¬cns^`i((D9
QFE
Kmpmcfi q 9
MHG
^I9_Mr I
|>=?@=A
M
¥Ghw#LW" N-clªâX :´_ªä<
T5U(X"bdcn e¼U r_khegU(X ns^`n¼WX ci(nxeoU(cfexeoU(X"^pi(nga(wsX wx^pnxi(he¦cbpb`h°0X q eohZkc¬rhjale q ^pA^q Xi q n¼cfexeg^`WmX~W°"Ul^`tU
X3u_t XX q egU(XZb`X3jX bhf¥U(^pn5wgXngX w jXcfe5eoU(^pn-eo^pWXfª
^¶jX ici¤^`i(^¶eo^`cbÈwgXngXwsjX vL°X
q
Xi(hegX\ r+L)vwN%eoUlXngX3eZh¥¦cbpbc
q
W^pngns^`(bpXkhjbp^`t ^pX nª|hjw/LT<9 N J
+LvwN(°0X q X3¸i(XZeoU(XZwsXeoalwgi¥Ga(i(teg^`hji#cn
_Lv T<9 NxK | B
Q 3
M
R49bMF
°"U(X wsX\^pn"c
q
^`nst hja(i e"¥Rct3eohjw"ci q
^`n-egU(XZwga(^pieo^`WmX
q
X3¸i(X
q
r
K"C WJu p@'I
|>=?@=A
M r pHG
T5U(XIcfb`a(X|¥Ga(ilteo^phji^`n q X3¸i(X q cn
L)vwN K
-
?@=A
6 -| 6
_L)v !T9YN :èAª <
Z ¦!- Z3 1³! I Z)! 1f) »+$ Z&
)* 1 "!$#&%
3
±i#egU(^`n"ngXteg^`hjiÈ°XklwghjXeoUcfe"egU(Xfcbpa(X|¥Ga(i(t3eo^phji q X¸i(X q ^`i :´_ª <5^pn%c'A^`nst hjns^pe±rnshjb`a_eo^`hi#hf¥eoUlX
^`i eoXjwghf§ q ^p¯:X wsX i eo^`cb:~cWm^`b¶eohji½jcft hj(^¿X b`bpW£cfi£À¦cwg^`cfeo^phjicb±i(X¹Aa(cb`^¶e±r
')(+*-,/.
Lv
10 N" sC^
0
L)vwN+2hK`p'^pi .043
1 :´_ªpF<
°"^peoU +^pwg^ptU(b`X3e5:ha(i
q
cw rt hi
q
^peg^`hjiln
LpBN_K`pH :´_ªäE<
°"U(X wsX
.
Lv
0
N6578
? P ? 9
^:
L)vwNjX L TbN
0
LvwNjX B 3 L
Lv;^ # } T>N>^
LvwN-NF%xLR5#$N<;
¡ XZ:Xj^`i rn ecfeg^`i('nghWXIa(nsX¥Ga(bk(wshjkX wseg^`Xn-¥Ghjw-eoU(XIfcbpa(X|¥Ga(i(t3eo^`hiȪ
=-> ÂAÆ Â ? "A@ !# (!_0("
*"!!' 56 .01 6 CBJ!
L)vwNJr v XDP
(
!!
D
+ # !+$d
8
E ÆÈÆGF T5U(X5¸wgn e¼nseocfeoXWXi©e¼^pn6hj A^`hjaln ª %Xe6D K -i 1 / 5
6IHKJ ci qq X¸i(XML£hji.0 31
rNLL)vwN KGvYXODª
]_^`i(tXPL^`n5i(hji q Xt wsX¬cns^`i(ci q LT>N0^`n5hja(i q X q ©r LnsYX i N (:_°0XUc¬jX
.
L)v QLQL
0
NJrR7
? P ? C ^:$L)v6XSD NjXLT>N"G?r p'¥Ghw"cb`bvPJP.0 31 :´_ªÜB<
{¢hjwsX hjXw
sC^L
0
L)vwNxK`p¥Ghjw"cb`bvPJP.0 31 :RlªâYB<
%Xe#L T<9 N JBX|j^¶jX icfi q vMJP.0 31 ª ¡ X q X ilheoXI r
eoU(X|¸wsnse5Xu_^pe-eg^`WmXh¥ .0 31
h¥eoU(Xk(wghAt Xngn
I |>=?@=A ci q#q X¸i(X
K 9 u p@ B 3
3 LLI
|>=?@=A
E ^ # } T
N>^LL)I
|>=?@=A
E
N%xLR$#ANBu ;
}k(klbprA^`i(' e* n5¥GhjwsW\a(b`ceoh
3
M
LL)I
|>=?@=A
M
N3l°XXe
3 - M
6 L LI
|>=?@=A
M
N :Rlªä<
K L LvwNjX B
M
Q
^M
3 LL)I
|>=?@=A
NjX
3
L T N L 0 L)I
|>=?@=A
NnR
X B
M
Q B 3
3
LL)I
|>=?@=A
E ^ # } T
N>^L LI
|>=?@=A
E
N T_LR
'R5#$N
^ B
M
Q
3 L 0
LI |>=?@=A
N1R9
X
M
= Q
3 L LI
|>=?@=A
E
^ 9
N>^ L LI
|>=?@=A
E N
°"U(X wsX)9
^`n5egU(Xthji eo^piAalhja(n"kcw ehf¥ 9
ci q 9 K 9 ^ 9 E
ªTc4©^pi(eoU(XX3u_kX teocfeo^phji#^`i :´lªÜE<3
a(ng^pi(D:´lªâB<:´lªY <-ci q egU(XZW£cw eo^pi( cbpXk(wshjk:Xwse±rhf¥
B
M
Q B 3
3 LLI
|>=?@=A
E ^ # } T
N>^ LL)I
|>=?@=A
E
NT_LR
R$#$N
°0Xhjleoc^`i
L LvwNJu
B
M
Q
3
R49 X "!
3 - M
6L LI
|>=?@=A
M
N#
]_X i
q
^`i($¤eoh'^pil¸i(^¶e±rci
q
a(ns^`i( LL)I
|>=?@=A
M
NJu pl_°0XjXe
LL)vwN u B
M
Q
3
R49
Tc74A^pi(eoU(XZnsa(k(wgXW\a(W.hjXw%cb`bÈkhjbp^`t ^pX n LT9YN J?LvwN(°0XZhjleoc^`i
LvwNJr v/XSDª %
¡ X q X3¸i(Xi(h°BeoUlXalk(k:Xw%ci q eoU(XZb`h°X w5nsX Wm^`t hi©eg^`i©a(hjaln%Xi jX bphjkXhf¥egU(XI¥Ga(i(teg^`hji
ª
Â
GÆ
?! " @ !#( B! ! (( /!!!?10#!x0("
3 LvwNxK
'
|
0
|
L)vN 0 *
vPJP.01 :´_ª <
@ !# ( ! ! &'(9(B/!!!/10 !x0("
3
L)vwNxK' 8
| 0 |
L)v N 0 ?
vMJ.01 :´_ª <
]_^`i(tX#egU(X#t hji eo^pi©a(^pe±r?h¥eoU(X¢~cfW^pbpeohi(^dci
.
^`iU(^pncfwgja(WmX i egn^pnmilhe£h©A^phja(n °0X q X¸ilX¢eoUlX
a(k(kX w|cfi q eoUlX\b`h°X wnsX Wm^¶§ t hji eo^pi©a(hja(n%X i jXb`hjkXh¥
.
©r
. 3
L)v 0N K
'
| 0 | .
L)v
0 Ncfi q
. 3
Lv 0
N_K' 8
| 0 | . Lv
0 N3ª
6uAegX i
q
^pi(eoU(X
q
X¸i(^¶eo^phjih¥¼A^`nst hjns^pe±rnshjb`a_eo^`hi(n|^`i egwgh
q
a(t X
q
©r "0woci
q
cb`bci
q
%^`hjiln6: H jB<cfi
q
eoU(Xi³©r]_hjilX wq:¨ H <Zci q ]_crjcUm: HEHlF<|eoh®¸(wgnse\^`i eoXjwghf§ q ^p¯:X wsX i eo^`cb¼hjkX woczeohjwsn °X q X3¸i(X*eoUlX
_^pngthjng^¶e±rnghjbpaleo^phjicn-¥Ghjbpb`h°"n
 GÆ ?! G0("
* %/( !& (" 10 :´lª¶F< .0
31 0
')(<*
, . 3
Lv N
0
N" s ^
0
L)vwN 2 r p :´_ªB<
(
!!!
J
i
LA
| N A |
? !E(. 10
v 3
^
$ ? Y ("
vPJP.0 31 8
0("
* %/( & (. 10 :´_ªpF< .0 31 0
' (<* , . 3 Lv N
0N sC^
0
L)vwN
2
ump :´_ªHB<
( !!! J
i
LA
| N A |
? !E(" 10 v 3
^ $ * U x ,E ("
vPJP.0 31 8
0("
%+ (. 10
:´lª¶F<
.0 31 0 x q ( !# ( & (.
.0 31 8
¡ X q X3¸i(X
i L .01VNxK C "! .01 ^$# .0 %¤^pn5i(hji q X t wsX¬cns^`i(ci q
|
'&
G
LvwN
sYXSv)(*
G
*Â (S? "+ !' %O!!6$
3 3
!* i L .01jN
8
¡
X|cfngngalWX"eoUczeegU(X
q
rAicfW^ptk(wshjjwgcWWm^`ilIk(wg^pi(t ^pk(b`X5U(hb
q
n_nsX XXfªâlª¼b`XW^pi(f§ ]Ahji(X w : HEHB<3ª
=hw5ci rnseghjk(k(^pi(eo^`WmX
ci q WYu`p_
L)vwNxK 78
-
?@=A 6K
3 - M
6 I
|>=?@=A
M
X B
M
Q
3 R49
g :´lª¶B<
°"U(X wsX?l
}-,
K ' VLl , N3ª
H
=-> 婮
 ?! @ ! (9!x0("
* %/ (" 10
8
.0
31
8
E ÆÈÆGF *¡ X¸wgn eklwghjX'eoUcze
^`nZcA^`ngthjng^¶e±r¤ngalk:Xw §±nshjb`a_eo^`hi¤h¥#:Rlªp <^`iL.0 31 ª)%X3e
J .0 31 ci q
J
i L .0 31
N-nga(tUeoU(cfe"°"^peoUlhjale"b`hngn5h¥jX ilX wocfb`^pe±r
p*K L 3 ^ JNLvwNxK
'
&
G L 3
^~N
wghjW egU(X q X¸il^peo^phji h¥
3
|eoU(XwgXºX3u_^`n eon®cnsX ¹©a(X ilt XGL)v
N J .0 31
nga(tU eoUcfehv
^ # v ci q
Lv
N ^ # 3
L)vwN°"U(X i ^$#
* ª
hjwT u T ci q & *tp_:°X\ngX3e 9 K &cfi q T K T¥Ghjwcb`b
u p_ª|T5U(X i]I
| =?@=A
Q G
Ktv
^ &©ªIT5U(X
q rAicWm^`tIk(wshjjwgcWWm^`ilk(ws^`i(t^`k(bpX6:´lª¶B<rA^pX b q n
oLv
NjX
u
3 - M
6 I
|>=?@=A
M
X B
M
Q
3
R9 g :´_ªpj <
°"U(X wsXIeoU(XInsX ¹©a(X ilt X
!K 3 Lv
N ^ L)v
N0^pn q X3eoX wsW^pi(^`n eo^pt|ci q thji jX wsjX n"eoh @X wsh'°"UlX i ®eoXi q n
eoh'^`i_¸i(^pe±rª¦]_X i q ^`i($ ^ # *
ci q WJ^ # p 1
^`i :´_ªpj <3l°XXe
oLvwNJu oLv;^I&NjX &
]_X i
q
^`i('i(h° &?^$# p 1
(°XZhjleoc^`i
sC^
0
L)vwN r p :´_ªp<
e%wgX Wc^pi(n0eoh'k(wshjX
. 3
L)v N
0
N~r p :´_ªpE<
¡ XZtU(hAhjnsX 9 K p'ci q T
K9T ¥Ghjw"cfb`b
u plª ¡ XZnsXe
K8 C W~u p@'I
| =?@=A
M
JM+ Lv
AN!G$
°"U(X wsX¤^pnc#khjng^¶eo^¶jXt hi(nseoci eci q +L)v
$N K C v vh^ v
rG©ªm}k(klbprA^`i( e* nZ¥GhjwsW\a(bdc£egh
3 - M
6 L)I
| =?@=A
M
N-ci q a(ns^`i(D:´_ªpj <3l°XZjXe
sW B M
Q
^M
3 L)I
| =?@=A
NjX
3 jLT
N 0 LI
| =?@=A
NnR
X sW B
M
Q B 3
3 L)I
| =?@=A
E ^ # } T
N>^ L)I
| =?@=A
E N T_LR
R$#AN
r
W
:´_ªp¬YB<
wghjWeoU(X q X3¸i(^peg^`hjihf¥
(e±°0hmt¬cnsX ncwgXIkhjnsng^`lb`X
"-cngXs
K p_ªng^pi(eoU(XZWcwseg^`i(jcb`X%k(wghk:Xwse±rh¥
B
M
Q
3 oLI
| =?@=A
E ^ # } T
N>^oLI
| =?@=A
E
NT_LR
R$#$N