On the robustness and stability of Connected Dominating Sets

HAL Id: inria-00070398

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00070398

Submitted on 19 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents

On the robustness and stability of Connected Dominating Sets

Cédric Adjih, Emmanuel Baccelli, Thomas Clausen, Philippe Jacquet

To cite this version:

Cédric Adjih, Emmanuel Baccelli, Thomas Clausen, Philippe Jacquet. On the robustness and stability of Connected Dominating Sets. [Research Report] RR-5609, INRIA. 2005, pp.23. �inria-00070398�

ISRN INRIA/RR--5610--FR+ENG

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

Thème COM

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

On the robustness and stability of Connected Dominating Sets

Cédric Adjih — Emmanuel Baccelli — Thomas Clausen — Philippe Jacquet

N° 5609

Septembre 1997

( *)+,-/.01

24365798;:=<>5@?98BA

∗C'DEFEFGIHKJLNMO0G :N:

L6MBM

8† ^{CQP AR ESG T 2 MUGIJT9L6H} ‡^{CQV A8M8;WW L=XYG :NZ JLN[} §

\^]`_9a4bdcegfihkjmlonqpr_9a4bsntuNa4adv`w`xytz{wNpn

|'}~u€bp~n‚ƒx…„Ib}tu{a

†ƒz€„@„ uN}qpƒ‡ob}~b9t]`b9}~t]@bˆwI‰QŠ€‹NŒ{Žhjmb9„oprb9a*`}~b>‘9N6’ghk“€”4„@z{•{b9n

–˜—™9š›œ`ž{š{Ÿ  w¡pr]`xyn˜„ z€„Ib}s¢¤£1b¥x…w6¦Nb9nqprx…•Nz€prb§p~]`bŽb¨Ibst©pnu{ªa0u{`x…«¬x¬pl{¢gtuN«¬«…x…nrx…u{w@nz€w@‡­u{@nru{«…bp~b

x…woª®uN}ra>zp~x¬uNw¯u{w¯pr]`b,„Ib}rª®u{}~a0z{w@tb¤u€ªtu{w`w`bst©p~b9‡˜‡`u{a0x¬w zprx…w`•4nqbp,°Uc1±gj`²³

w˜„@z{}qp~x…tv`«yz€}s¢{£1bgnr]`u£

p~]@zp'w@bx…•{]m uN}q´µ‡obsnqx…•{w@z€prbs‡4c1±,jY¢Nnrv@t]>z{nadv`«¶p~x¬„Iu{x…w6p·}~b«yz¸l˜°¹f§|º†¤²x…w§»“m¢6”¸¼U¢Nz€}~bx…w4•Nbw`b9}~z{«oa0u{}~b

}~u{@v@np0p~]@z€w½nrb«¬ª¾´Unrb«…b9tprb9‡­c1±,j¿nqv t]SzNn>}rv@«¬b

k c1±,jÀx…wˆ»…‘©¼;³Á\^]`x…n¯}ruN`v@nqprbw@b9n~n0x…n>bsnq„Ib9tx…z{«¬«…l t}rv txyz€«`ª®uN}1z{„`„`«…x…t9zp~x¬uNw@n·nrv@t]˜zNn'£x…}rb9«¬bsnrn^e,jm|·Â1¢m£]`b}~bƒp~]`x¬}‡>„@z{}qpldpruN„ uN«¬uN•{l4x¬w`ª®u{}~a0z€prx…u{w¯a>z¸l

bÃo„ b9}rx…bw@tbz€}~`x¶p~}~z{}rl>‡ob9«…z¸lN³

ħÅ6ÆYÇ~È*É ›Ê™{Ÿ f=u{`x…«¬bŽw`bp£1u{}~Ëon¢ƒtu{w`w@b9t©p~b9‡­‡`u{a0x¬w zprx…w`•Snqbp9¢ƒadv`«¶p~x¬„Iu{x…w6p}~b«yz¸lon¢ƒnqp~z{`x…«¬x¬pl{¢

tu{«…«¬xynrx¬uNw@n

∗Ìq́θϹÐÑÌ©ÒÓÎÔ¹ÐÑՀÖÐÑ׸ϹÐØÓsÒمÏ

†ÍqÚڃÓ×۸́ÜyÒݝÓ́́́ÜÑÜÑжÖÐÑ׸ÏBÐØÓsÒÙ¬Ï

‡^Þ Ìß©ÜÑÍ'àoß©Üá9âB́ÌUո׸ÐÑãÛ¸Í'â;ոߩڃÓäqÒ́ÜØÓÛ¸ä;́׀Öå€ß©Üáâ;́ÌUÕ¸×sÐÑã9۸ͩÒÙ¬Ï

§å¸Õ¸ÐÑÜÑÐÑå¸å€Í©ÒÔ;Ó́ã۸͵âµÖÐÑ×sÏBÐØÓsÒÙ¬Ï

&1&·

™ Ÿ ±gz€w n4tb}z€„@„ uN}qp4w`u{v@n p~v@‡ox…u{w@n0«…b9ndb¨Ybpn>‡ob«…zŽa0u{`x…«¬x¬p N¢º‡obsn0tu{«…«…x…nrx¬uNw@ndbp>‡ob9n

x…woª®uN}ra>zp~x¬uNw@n^u{ nquN«¬_prb9n¤nqv`}¤«¬bsn„ b9}qª®uN}ra>z{w@tbsnƒ‡ob9nƒbw@nrbad`«¬bsnƒ‡ouNa4x…w@z{wNpnƒtuNw`w`bst©p sn°;c1±,j`²³'w

„ z€}rprxytv`«…x¬b9}w`u{v`}Qa0uNwNp~}ruNw@n6v`b^«¬bsnºc1±gj,‡ 9nrx…•{w@z€prx…u{w0‡ob^¦{u{xynrx¬w@np~b«yn6v`b^«¬bsn}rb9«…z{x…nadv`«¶p~x¬„Iu{x…w6p~n

°Bf§|·†¤²'‡ 9t}rx¬p~n'‡@z€w@n^»Ñ“o¢{”¼ nquNw6p'bw0• 9w }z€«m`x…bw>„`«…v@nQ}~u{@v@np~b9n6v`b^«…b9nºc1±,j0z€vop~u€´µn 9«¬bst©p~x¬uNw`w@z€w6ps¢

p~b«ynNv@b}rv`«…b

k‡`z{w@n4»¬‘©¼U³4cºbstxb9nqpg„@z{}qp~x…tv`«…x¬_9}rb9a4b9w6p,t}rv@tx…z{«‡`z{w@ng‡ob9n,z€„@„`«¬xytz€prx…u{w@n¤prb9«…n6v`b e,jo|·Âˆa0u{`x…«…buF«…b9n4x…woª®u{}~a>zp~x¬uNw@n0‡obpru{„Iu{«…u{•Nx¬bsn4bwS„`}ru¦Nbw@z{w@tb‡obprx…b}n4„ b9vop¯„`}~bw@‡o}~b ‡ob9n

‡ «yz€xynz€}~`x¶p~}~z{x¬}~b9n9³

%É šs™ Ç ž ™4Ÿ † 9nrb9z{voÃ4a0uN`x¬«…b9n9¢6bw@nrbad`«¬bsn·‡ouNa0x¬w@z{w6p~n·tu{w`w@b9t©p 9n9¢N}~b«yz€xynQadv`«¶p~x¬„Iu{x…w6p9¢onqp~z€@x¬«…x¶p {¢

tu{«…«¬xynrx¬uNw@n

& '

d >&·

f=u{`x…«¬b^z{‡*]`uot1w`bp£1u{}~Ëon }~b«…lu{wd}~zN‡ox¬u pr}z€w nqa0xynrnrx¬uNw@np~]@zpQ•Nbw`b9}~z{«¬«…lgª®b9zp~v`}~b1adv@t]*«…b9n~ntz{„@z{tx¶pl

p~]@z€w¥£x¬}~b9‡¥a4bs‡oxyz`³*e w§pr]@bdu{pr]`b9}gnrx…‡`bdtuNw@nqp~z€w6pga4uN`x…«¬x¬pl§}rb 6v`x¬}~b9n z¯¦Nb}~lª®}~b6v`b9w6p v`„Y‡`zp~bdu{ª

p~u{„Iu{«…u{•Nl,z{w@‡d}ruNvoprx…w`•gx¬woª®uN}ra>z€prx…u{wK³Â`u{}'tu{a0„@z{}rxynquNwK¢¸£x¬}~b9‡0e,jm|·Â¥}rb Nv@x¬}~b9nz€w4v`„Y‡`zp~b1b9¦{b9}rl*“{Œ

a0x…wmvoprbsnº£]@x¬«…b x¬p~n1£x…}rb9«¬bsnrn1tuNv`w6prb9}r„@z{}qpº£ºuNv`«…‡¯w`bbs‡˜z€wv`„Y‡`zp~b b9¦{b}~l4prb9wnrb9tuNw@‡`n9¢Nx¬ª w`u{p1b9¦{b9}rl

nrb9tu{w@‡K³\u{„Iu{«…u{•Nl¯tuNwNp~}ruN«Ipr]`b9}rbª®u{}~bg@v`}~‡`bw@n1p~]`bw`bp£1u{}~ËY¢oz€w@‡£x¶p~]`u{v`pƒ„`}ruN„ b9}ƒnquN«¬v`prx…u{w@n9¢mpr]`b

w@bp£1u{}~Ë*a>z¸l4tu{«…«…z{„@nrbƒz{nQp~]`b pr}z(¯t•{b9w`b}zp~b9‡4x…w¯u{}‡ob}'pru*a>z{w@z€•Nb^pr]`b }ruNvoprx…w`•ª®v`w t©prx…u{w˜u{w¯x¬p~n

u£wxyn^u¦{b}~«…uNz{‡`x¬w`• ³

)

w*x…a4„Iu{}rp~z{w6ptuNa4„Iu{w@bw6pu{ª@z¤nru{«…voprx…u{w,p~uƒpr]@x…n„`}~u{`«…baÁxynz{wu{„op~x¬a0x+*9z€prx…u{wu€ªop~]`b1`}ru6z{‡`t9z{nqp

u¦Nb}~]`b9zN‡³\u0pr]@x…n^b9w@‡¢op~]`b,p~zNnq˯u{ª}~b«yz¸lmx¬w`•0z4`}~uNz{‡@tz{nqp^„@z{tËNbpx…n^•Nx¬¦Nbwpru>z0nqv@@nqbpƒu€ªw`uo‡ob9n

x…wFpr]`bw`bp£1u{}~ËY³ \^]`b§nqa>z{«¬«…b9nqpdp~]`b }rb9«…z¸l nrbp0x…n9¢'p~]`b «¬bsnrn0tuNnqpr«…l £x¬«…«1pr]`b `}~uNzN‡`tzNnp4 bN¢ºz€w ‡

a0uN}rbd@z€w@‡`£x…‡mp~]Žxyn,z¸¦z€x…«…z{`«¬bª®u{},v@nrb},‡`zpztu{a0a*v`w@x…t9zprx…u{w n³‚ƒu£1b¦Nb}s¢Iz`}~uNzN‡`tzNnp z{x¬a>n,zp

z{«¬«w@um‡`b9n1x¬wp~]`b,w`bp£1u{}~Ë>}rbstb9x¬¦mx…w`•*p~]`b,`}~uNz{‡@tz{nqp1‡@zp~z@³'\^]`b}~bª®uN}rb u{w`bnr]`u{v@«…‡w`u€p}~b9‡ov tbgpr]`b

}~b«yz¸l nqbp*prumuŽa*v@t]-,>x…wÀu{pr]`b9}d£1u{}‡`n9¢pr]`b}rb9«…z¸l nqbp4adv@nqp*ª®u{}~a z¥tu{w`w`bst©p~b9‡ ‡ouNa0x¬w@z€prx…w`•Žnrbp

°Uc1±gj@²©³

Âx…w@‡ox…w`• pr]`b¯nra>z€«…«¬bsnp}~b«yz¸l§nqbpx…nz{w/.¤|Q´;] z€}‡¥„`}~u{@«¬b9a³˜e wŽpr]`b>u{pr]`b9}]@z€w ‡¢ z}rb9«…z¸l=nrbp

p~]@zp0xynp~u6u nra0z{«¬«1a>z¸l w`u€p0 b}~u{`v@nqpdb9w`u{v@•{] x…w ª¹zNtb˜u{ª¤«…uNnqp*pr}z€w nqa0xynrnrx¬uNw@n9³  wÀpr]`bª®u{«…«¬u£^´

x…w`• ¢@£1bz€w@z{«¬lonrb,pr]`b„Ib}rª®u{}~a>z€w@tbz0ª®b£ ]`b9v`}~x…nqprxytnƒz{w@‡pr]@bx…}¤}~b9nrx¬«…x¬b9w@tb,p~u¯b}~}~u{}nz€w@‡w`bp£ºuN}rË

v@w@npz€`«…x¬prx…b9n9³

\^]`b9}rb1z€}~b'p£1u¤Ëmx…w@‡`nu€ª@]@bv`}~x…nqprxytn9¢z€x…a0x¬w`•¤pru ª®u{}~aˆtu{w@w`b9tprb9‡d‡ou{a0x…w@zp~x¬w@• nrbp~n0, nrb«¬ª¾´Unrb«…b9tprbs‡

‡`u{a0x¬w zprx…w`•>nrbp~n^uNwuNw`b]@z{w@‡z{w@‡w`bx…•{]mIu{}r´U‡obsnqx…•{w zprbs‡˜‡ouNa0x¬w@z€prx…w`•>nqbp~n^uNw˜p~]`bu€p~]`b}]@z{w@‡³

  w0nqb9«¶ªInqb9«¬bst©prbs‡*‡ouNa0x¬w@z€prx…w`• nrbpn¢€pr]`b1}rb9«…z¸l,w`uo‡obsn 123 465782:9;1 z{n„@z{}qpu€ª@pr]`b^tuNw`w`b9tprbs‡

‡`u{a0x¬w zprx…w`•ƒnrbps³=<^z{nrb9‡gu{w,w`b9x¬•N]m uN}r]`umuo‡gx¬w`ª®u{}~a0z€prx…u{w>°®uNw`b´U]`uN„K¢p£1u€´U]`uN„K¢uN}Ka0u{}~bs² pr]@bl,‡ob9tx…‡ob

p~]@zp·pr]`b9ldIb«…u{w`•,p~upr]@bƒ}rb9«…z¸l4nqbp9³'cº«…zNnrnrxytz€«@bÃ`z€a0„`«…b9nQu{ªKnqv@t]>z{w¯z€„`„`}~uNzNt]dz{}rb^p~]`b¤z€«…•{uN}rx¬pr]@a0n

u{ª=> v@?Kx'»…‘¼U³

e wŽpr]`b>u{pr]`b9}]@z€w ‡¢ x…wŽw@bx…•{]m uN}q´µ‡obsnqx…•{w@z€prbs‡¥‡ouNa4x…w@z€prx…w`•§nqbp9¢ nru{a0b0w`uo‡ob9n 123 z{n

a0b9a*Ib}n>u€ªp~]`b¥tuNw`w`bst©prbs‡½‡ou{a0x…w@zp~x¬w@• nqbpml p~]`bx…}˜w`b9x¬•N]m uN}~n9³ˆ\^]`b¥t«yz{n~nrx…t9z€«bÃ`z{a4„@«¬b=u{ª

nrv@t]¿z€w½z€„@„`}ru6z{t] xyn0p~]`b=f§v`«¬prx…|u{x…wNp˜†ƒb«yz¸l6x…w`• »”¸¼ v@nqbs‡Sx¬w¡e „op~a4x+*bs‡A?Kx…w`ËFj6pzprb=†ƒu{vop~x¬w`•

°UeB?jo† ²»C¼;³,e w pru{„§u{ªQpr]`xyn¤nrb«…b9tprx…u{wK¢Yz¯nrb«¬ª¾´;„@}rv`w@x¬w`•np~}~z€prb•Nl˜xynƒv@nrb9‡ ml b9zNt] w`uo‡ob*x…w§u{}‡ob}

p~u>‡obp~b}~a4x…w`b£1bp~]`b}x¬pƒa*v@nqp}rb9«…z¸lzd}~b9tbx…¦{bs‡¯`}~uNzN‡`tzNnp^„@z{tËNbps¢ou{}^w`u€ps³

\£ºugplm„Ib9nQu{ªInrb«¬ª¾´;„`}~v`w`x…w`•nqpr}zprb9•{x…b9nQt9z€w4 bv@nrb9‡-,º°®x¾²Qz{wdu{¨ ´U«¬x…w`bnqpr}zprb9•{lN¢{‡obp~b}~a0x¬w`bs‡*uNw@tb

z{w@‡ª®u{}¤z{«¬«zpp~]`bprx…a0bu€ª'f§|º†ˆnqb9«¬bst©prx…u{w ¢@u{}°¹x¬x¾²ƒz{w u{wo´U«¬x…w`bnqpr}zp~b•{lN¢@‡obprb}~a0x¬w@b9‡ ‡ov`}~x¬w@•>pr]`b

@}ru6z{‡`t9z{nqp9¢oz{n‡ouNw`b,x¬w§f§|º†ED u6uo‡ox…w`• »”¼U³

F G

&º

  w0Iu€p~]4]@bv`}~x…nqprxytn9¢€x¬p'x…nQzNnrnrv`a0b9‡*pr] zp'b¦Nb}~lw`uo‡obËmw`u£ƒnx¶pnQw`b9x¬•N]6Iu{}w`uo‡obsn¢N¦mx…zg„Ib}~x¬uo‡oxyt1]`b«…«¬u

bÃ`t]@z€w`•Nb{³  p¤xyn¤z€«ynru¯z{n~nqv`a0bs‡˜p~]@zp w`uo‡ob9n¤„ b9}rx…uo‡ox…t9z€«…«¬lz{‡o¦Nb}rprx+*b,p~]`bx…}¤w`b9x¬•N]m uN}ƒ«¬xynqp9¢Ibx¬pr]`b9}¤x…w

]@b«…«¬u6nu{}dx¬w 1?j ) ´U«¬x…Ë{b 4„@z{tËNbp~n9¢z{nx…wSe,jm|ºÂº³\^]`b9}rbª®u{}~b>pr]`bw`uo‡ob9ndz€}~b˜z€«ynru¥z¸£1z{}rb0u{ªpr]`b9x¬}

p£1u€´U]`uN„>w`bx…•{]mIu{}~]`umum‡§°¹`vop^pr]@x…n1x…woª®u{}~a>zprx…u{w˜a0z¸l>tu{a0b¤£x¬pr]nquNa4bg‡ob«yz¸l`²©³QÂ`uN}1z*w`uo‡ob

A^¢m£ºb

t9z€«…«

N(A)x¬p~nuNw`b´U]`u{„ w`b9x¬•N]m uN}r]`umuo‡z€w@‡

N2(A)x¬p~nƒp£ºu{´;]`uN„w@bx…•{]m uN}r]@u6uo‡³H<ºu{pr] ]`b9v`}rxynqprxytn

] z¸¦{bIbb9w¥„`}~u¦{b9w§pru„`}ru¦mxy‡obdz{w=b¨Yb9tprx…¦{b0‡ou{a0x…w@zp~x¬w@•nrbp>°¹z€«…«pr]`b4w`uo‡obsn z{}rb4tu¦{b9}rbs‡@²©¢I£]`b9w

w@bx…•{]m uN}r]@u6uo‡˜x¬woª®uN}ra>z€prx…u{wx…n^bÃozNt©ps¢`z€w@‡pr}z€w nqa0xynrnrx¬uNw@n^z€}~b b9}r}~u{}r´;ª®}rb9b¯£x¶p~]`u{v`p¤tu{«…«…x…nrx¬uNw@n9³

!"$#&%('*)+-,./)+10*2

  w˜pr]`xyn1„@z€„Ib}s¢6pr]`b,]`b9v`}~x…nqprxyt¤£1bg£x¬«…«tu{w nqxy‡ob}ºª®u{}nrb«¬ªnrb«…b9t©p~x¬uNw¯xyn·p~]`bgplm„`x…t9z€«Y}~v`«¬b

k^{u€ª=>Žv z€w@‡}

? xB³d\^]`x…n,]@bv`}~x…nqprxytda0z{Ë{bsn zw`uo‡ob

A nqb9«¬bst©p,x¶pnqb9«¶ª^z{ng„@z€}rp,u€ª'p~]`b0}rb9«…z¸l§nrbpml=‡obp~b9t©p~x¬w@• z{«¬«x¬p~n w@bx…•{]m uN}ºw@um‡`b9nºpr]@z€p1] z¸¦{b z{w   ³±*³o£]@x…t]x…n1•{}~b9z€prb9}·p~]@z€ww`uo‡ob

A^{3n   ³±*³ >} btz{«¬«Ipr]@x…n^nrbp

S(A)^³

\^]@bgw@um‡`b

Anqb9«¬bst©p~n^x¬p~nrb«¬ªQz{n^„@z{}qpu€ªpr]@b}rb9«…z¸l¯nrbpx¬ªp~]`b,ª®u{«…«¬u£x…w`•>tuNw@‡ox¬prx…u{wx…n1ª®v@«54@«…«…b9‡ ,

6

pr]`bnrbp

S(A)xynw`u{pz0‡ouNa0x¬w@z€prx…w`•>nqbpƒu€ªpr]`bw`b9x¬•N]m uN}r]`umuo‡u€ª

A^³

\^]`b0nrb«¬ª¾´Unrb«…b9tprx…u{w§xyn¤„Ib}rª®u{}~a0b9‡§b9¦{b}~l6prx…a0bpr]`b9}rbdx…ngz¯w@u€prx74 t9zprx…u{w¥u€ª·t]@z{w`•{bx…w=p~]`b4w`bx…•{]o´

Iu{}~]`umuo‡0u{}ºx¬w>p~]`bƒp£1u€´U]`uN„>w`bx…•{]mIu{}~]`umum‡K³4> b w`u{prbƒml4pr]@b¤£^z¸l{¢€p~]@zp^zw`uo‡ob

A‡oumbsn'w`u{pº]@z¸¦Nb p~u>nqx…•{w@z{«x¶pnƒnrb«¬ªnrb«…b9t©p~x¬uNw˜p~u>x¶pnw`b9x¬•N]6Iu{}n9³

8 9:)0(;<=%?>@A#BC@)0(+-,.!"$#&%D'E)+1,F/)+-0*2/C

 wFpr]@x…n>„ z€„Ib}s¢'pr]@b§]`bv`}~xynp~x…t£1b£x…«…«¤tuNw@nqxy‡ob9}dª®uN}>w`bx…•{]mIu{}>nrb«…b9t©p~x¬uNwFxyn0p~]`b§f§|·† nqb9«¬bst©p~x¬uNw

zNn‡ou{w@b>x¬wFeB?jo† »C¼U³ >½x¬pr] p~]`xyn]`b9v`}rxynqprxyt>z w`uo‡ob

A t}~b9z€prbsnz€w f§|·†nrbpGŽz nrv`@nrbp*u{ª1x¬p~n w@bx…•{]m uN}r]@u6uo‡Hpr]@z€pa*v@nqpgIb0z‡ouNa0x¬w@z€prx…w`• nqbpgu{ª'pr]`bdp£1u€´U]`u{„=w@bx…•{]m uN}r]@u6uo‡§u{ª

A^³?Kbp,v@n

‡`bw`u{prbºf=|·†

(A)p~]`b^f§|·†Ànrbpu€ª`w@um‡`b

A³f§|·†Fnqb9«¬bst©p~x¬uNwx…np~]`bw„Ib}rª®u{}~a0b9‡£x¬pr]*pr]`bºª®u{«…«…u£x¬w`•

z{«¬•Nu{}~x¶p~]`a ,

‘{³ >Žbnqp~z{}qp£x¬pr]§f§|·†

(A) =∅

“o³ >Žb0z{‡@‡ pru f§|·†

(A) ^z€«…« p~]`b4w`bx…•{]mIu{}¤w@um‡`b9n¤pr]@z€p,z{}rbp~]`b4v`w`xNv@b4tu{w`w`bst©p~u{}ƒª®}~u{a

A ^pru

z€w`u{pr]`b9}w`uo‡ob,x¬w

N2(A)^³

”`³Iƒw6prx…«Kz€«…«Iw`uo‡ob9n1x…w

N2(A)z{}rbgtu¦Nb}~b9‡0ml¯f§|·†

(A)¢@£ºbgz{‡`‡¯pru0f§|·†

(A)pr]`bgw`bx…•{]mIu{}1u€ª

A pr]@z€p¤tu¦Nb}n'p~]`ba0uNnqpƒl{bpr´;v@w@tu¦Nb}~b9‡>w`uo‡obsn^x¬w

N2(A)^³

\^]`xyn1f§|·†­nrb«…b9tprx…u{w¯z€«…•{uN}rx¬pr]@a%]@zNn'„`}~u¦{b9wdp~uIb¤¦{b9}rl4b1(¯tx¬b9wNp1z€w@‡0xynºzNt©p~v@z€«…«¬ldpr]@bª®u{v`w ‡`z´

p~x¬uNw§u€ªpr]@b4eB?jo† „@}ru{pruotuN«S»C€¼U³ .ƒu{prxytbp~]@zp¤£x¬pr]=pr]`xyn¤z{„`„`}~uNz{t] ¢`z>w`uo‡ob]@zNn^prunqx…•{w@z{« f§|·†

nrb«…b9tprx…u{wprux¶pnƒw`b9x¬•N]m uN}ƒw`uo‡ob9n9³\^]`xyn t9z€w  b4‡ou{w@b¦mx…z>z{w=z{‡`‡ox¬prx…u{w z€«J4 b«y‡ x¬w=]@b«…«¬u¯a0bsnrn~z€•Nb9n9¢

ª®uN}bÃ`z€a0„`«…b{³

)

w`uo‡ob

A ^£]`xyt] ]@z{n¤nqb9«¬bst©prbs‡

B ^{zNnƒf§|·†} w@um‡`bx…n^p~]`bw§t9z€«…«¬bs‡z{w§f§|·†ˆnrb«…b9t©p~u{}

u{ªw`uo‡ob

B^³

KJLKJLNM O Å NPÇQ › FRFSNRFT

O

š›œoš Å TUSÅ ™

\^]@b}~b˜z€}~b>p£1u¥tz€prb•Nu{}~x¬bsn,u€ª¤nrb«¬ª¾´;„@}rv`w@x¬w`•Žnp~}~z€prb•Nx¬bsn,4u{w uNw`b˜] z€w@‡ z{w u{wo´U«…x¬w`bnp~}~z€prb•Nl¥p~]@zp

z{„`„`«…x¬bsn¤z€pƒpr]`bprx…a4bdu€ªpr]@b*`}~uNzN‡`tzNnpu{„Ib}zp~x¬uNw@n9¢ z€w ‡ u{w pr]@bu€p~]`b} ]@z€w@‡§z{w§u€¨I´;«…x…w`b*nqpr}zprb9•{l

p~]@zp¤z{„`„`«…x¬bsn^ bª®u{}~b]@z{w@‡³

\^]`buNwo´U«¬x…w`bf§|·† nrb«¬ª¾´;„`}~v`w`x…w`•>nqpr}zprb9•{l>xyn^pr]@b,ª®u{«…«¬u£x…w`•@¢oz{w@‡£1zNn(4 }~nqp¤‡ob9n~t}~x… bs‡˜x…w »C€¼,

6 ) w`uo‡ob˜ª®u{}~£1z{}~‡@nz§`}~uNzN‡`tzNnp„@zNtË{bp*x¶ª¤z{w@‡ uNw`«¬l x¬ªƒx¶p4}rbstbx…¦{bsnx¬p~n 4@}npdtu{„mlŽª®}ruNaz{w

f§|·†ˆnrb«…b9tpru{}s³

\^]`b¤u€¨I´;«…x¬w@bƒnqb9«¶ª¾´U„`}~v`w`x…w`•np~}~z€prb•Nlxynpr]`bƒª®u{«…«¬u£x…w`•z€w@‡4xyn'‡obsnrt}rx… bs‡4x¬w¯‡obp~z{x¬«`x…w »“¼;³ ) w`uo‡ob

AIb«…u{w@•Nn1pru4p~]`b}rb9«…z¸l¯nrbpƒx¬ªu{w`b,u€ªpr]`b,ª®uN«¬«…u£x…w`•>tu{w ‡ox¶p~x¬uNwxyn^ª®v`«74@«…«¬bs‡ ,

6

.ƒuo‡ob

A^{3n   ³}±d³`x…nnra>z€«…«¬b9}^pr]@z{w§z€«…«u€ª p~]`b   ³±*³ u€ªx¬p~nƒw`bx…•{]mIu{}^w`uo‡ob9n

6

.ƒuo‡ob

Ax…nQnrb«…b9tprbs‡*z{nf§|º†Fml,p~]`b^w`uo‡ob^£]`x…t]4]@zNn p~]`bnqa>z{«¬«…b9nqp   ³±d³{z€a0u{w@•¤x¬p~nw`b9x¬•N]6Iu{}

w`uo‡ob9n9³

.¤u€prb ml*p~]`b¤£^z¸l*p~]@zpºpr]`b u{wo´U«…x¬w`b nqb9«¶ª¾´U„`}~v`w`x…w`•xyn'b6v`x…¦z€«…bw6p·p~upr]@b¤u€¨I´U«¬x…w`b nqpr}zp~b•Nl{¢{£]@b}~b

p~]`b   ³±d³Qx…ndp~]`bnrb6v`b9w@tbu{}‡ob}4u€ª¤pr]`b}rbpr}z€w@nra0x…n~nrx¬uNw@nu{ªƒpr]`b `}~uNzN‡`tzNnps³ \^]@b 4@}nqp4b9a4x¬pqp~b}

£1u{v@«…‡ ]@z¸¦Nb   ³±d³Œ@¢ p~]`b˜nrb9tu{w@‡ ba0x¬pqp~b}°Bf§|·†u{ª^pr]`b 4@}~nqpba0x¬pqp~b}©²£1u{v`«y‡ ]@z¸¦{b   ³±*³1‘{¢bpt€³

.¤u€p~x…tbpr] zpgpr]`b9}rbd£x¬«…«Ib4u{w`«…l u{w`bdw`uo‡ob°¹w`uo‡ob4Œ6²^p~]@zp,x…ngz¯«…uotz{«a0x…w`x¬adv`a ¢Ypr]@z€p a>z€ËNb9n¤pr]`b

uNwo´U«¬x…w`bnqb9«¶ª¾´U„`}~v`w`x…w`•0a0u{}~b b(>tx¬b9w6ppr]@z{wp~]`bu€¨I´U«¬x…w`bnp~}~z€prb9•{l=°®«…b9n~n}~b«yz¸l>w`uo‡ob9n²©³

  w,p~]`b'«…x¶prprb}zp~v`}~bpr]`b'uNwo´U«¬x…w`bQ„`}~v`w`x…w`•ƒf§|·† D@umum‡`x¬w`•xyn nrx…a4„@«¬l Ë6w@u£w,zNnYpr]@b·f§|·†^´D@umuo‡ox…w`•@¢

z{w@‡˜pr]`bu{¨ ´U«¬x…w`b,„`}~v`w`x…w`•>xynz€«ynqu0Ëmw`u£wzNn1pr]`bf=|·†^´qc1±gj D@umuo‡ox…w`•@³

>/1)%-C &+-,1C)C

\^]@b>x…‡obsz u€ª^x¬a0„`}~u¦mx¬w@•˜p~]`b¯}~b«…x…z{`x¬«…x¬pl=u€ª^u¦{b9}r]`bsz{‡m´Uu{„`prx…a4x+*bs‡ D@umuo‡ox…w`•§x¬w ª¹zNtb>u€ª^a0u{`x…«…x¶plŽx…n

w@u€p·w`b9£³Q± z{xIz{w@‡ >Žv˜]@z¸¦{bx…wm¦{b9nqprx…•Nz€prbs‡4z{w¯z€«…•{uN}rx¬pr]`a tz{«¬«…b9‡ 9j < )

ºp~]@zpºpr]`b9l0nqprv ‡ox¬bs‡4ª¹z{tx¬w`•

a0uN`x¬«…x¬pl{¢€z€«…u{w@•¤£x¬pr]¯c1±gj $> vo´?Kx ¢€z€w ‡4c1±,j± z{x¶´>Žvd}rv@«¬b

k»ÑŠ¸¼U³\^]@bx…}nqprv ‡oltuNw!4@}~a0np~]@zp z{«¬•Nu{}~x¶p~]`a>n· z{nrb9‡¯uNw‡`l6w z€a0x…tgnrb«¬ª¾´;„`}~v`w`x…w`• °®«…x¬ËNbf§|·†ED@umum‡`x¬w`•m²©¢`z{}rbgw@zp~v`}z€«…«¬l>a0u{}~bg}rb9«¬xyz€`«…b{³

\u*Ib tu{a0„`«…bpr«…ldª¹z€x…}·£x¬pr]˜f§|º† D@umuo‡ox…w`•@¢ >Žvz€«ynqutu{w@nrx…‡`b}~b9‡>z }ruN`v@nqp 1¦{b9}~nrx…u{w0u€ªKf§|·†

D u6uo‡ox…w`• ¢·@zNnqbs‡ÀuNwÀp~]`b§x…‡`b9z ‡ob¦Nb«…u{„Ib9‡Fx¬w½j < ) »¼U¢1£]`x…t]Sxyn0}ruNv`•{]`«…l pr]@b=nrz{a4b§zNn>f§|·†^´

ce º† ) ,“x¬wÀeB?jo† »C€¼U¢ bÃotb„opp~]@zpp~]`b¯nrb9tuNw@‡ tu¦{b9}~z{•{b*pr}z€w@nra0x¶pn,u{w`«…l¥x¬ªºp~]`b 4@}np

tu¦{b9}rb9}~z{•{bª¹z{x¬«yn1pru0p~}~z{w@nqa0x¬p9³

> vFz{w@‡À±gz€x^z€«ynquŽnp~v@‡ox…b9‡ p~]`bx…n~nqv@b˜u€ª u{@nru{«…bp~b¯w`bx…•{]mIu{}4x¬w`ª®u{}~a0z€prx…u{w x…wFz{w`u€p~]`b}d„@z€„Ib}

»…‘9Œ¼;¢1z€w@‡Àx¬w6pr}~uo‡ov@tb9‡Snqb9¦{b}z€«ºx¬w6p~b}~b9nqprx…w`•¥p~]`buN}rx…b9n9³ÀÂ@u{}0bÃ`z€a0„`«…b{¢·p£ºu nrbp~n4u{ª w`b9x¬•N]6Iu{}n4z€}~b

x…w6pr}~uo‡ov@tbs‡Ž°¹xy²ƒt«…uNnrb uNw`b9n9¢@z€w ‡Ž°¹x¬x¾²^w`u{pq´µnqu{´Ut«¬u6nqb u{w`bsn³Q± u{a0x¬w zprx…w`•¯nrbpnz€}~b p~]`bw§t}rbszprbs‡¢@4@}np

v nqx…w`• t«…uNnrb¤w`uo‡obsn €¢N£]@x…t]z€}~bƒ«¬bsnrn1«…x¬ËNb«…l4pru*a0u¦Nb z¸£^z¸l*ª¹zNnps¢mz{w@‡>£]`xyt]¯ª®uN}razda0u{}~b¤}~u{`v@nqp9¢

z{w@‡=‡ob9w@nrb},‡ou{a0x…w@zp~x¬w`•nqbp9³\^]`b9wK¢ ©w`u{pgnrut«¬u6nqbw@um‡`b9n z€}~b*v nqbs‡ pru tuNa4„@«¬bprbdtu{w`w@b9t©p~x¬¦mx¬pl{³

\^]@bu{}~bp~x…t9z€«…«¬lN¢mpr]`xynËmx…w@‡ u€ª·c1±gj nr]`uNv`«…‡Ib«…b9n~n‡obw@nrbp~]@z€wpr]@b„`}~b¦mx¬uNv@nr«¬l>a0bw6p~x¬uNw`w`b9‡ ± z{x¶´

> v¯}~v`«…b

kgc1±gjY¢6`vop^a>z¸lm b a4uN}rb¤}ruN`v@nqp9³

)

w`u{pr]`b9}ºxy‡ob9z*x…n·prudbÃo„`«…x…tx¶p~«¬l>tuNw@nrx…‡ob9}·„@z{}~z{a0bprb9}~n

nrv@t] z{n1p~]`b‡ob«yz¸lon1x¬wpruN„ uN«¬uN•{l¯zNt 6v`xynqx¬prx…u{wK¢`‡`v`b,pru4pr]@b]`b«…«¬u>a0bst]@z€w`xynraª®u{}x…w@nqp~z€w tb{³

  w »‹€¼pr]`b¥z{vopr]@u{}n4z{w@z€«…l#*b§z€w ‡Ftu{a0„@z€}~bpr]`b§„Ib}rª®u{}~a>z€w@tbu{ª,f=|·† D@umum‡`x¬w`• z{w@‡Snqb9«¶ª¾´

nrb«…b9tprbs‡ c1±,jx¬wpr]@btz{nrb,u€ªf

) . ·\ z€w@‡§eB?jo† »C{¼;³

w§p~]`xynƒ}~b„Iu{}rp9¢@£1bx…wm¦{b9nqprx…•Nz€prb,p~]`b}~b9nrx¬«…x¬b9w@tb*u€ªQb9zNt]Ëmx…w@‡§u{ªQz{«¬•Nu{}~x¶p~]`a ¢

nqb9«¶ª¾´µnqb9«¬bst©p~b9‡ u{}

w@bx…•{]m uNv`}r´U‡obsnqx…•{w zprbs‡³Q\^]`bnrx¬adv`«…z€prx…u{w nrtbw@z{}rx…xv@nrb,¦¸z{}rx…u{v n^„ b9}qp~v`}r zprx…u{w n¢`nrv@t]§z{n1p~}~z{w@nqa0xyn´

nrx…u{w˜«…uNn~nºu{}^x¬w`ª®u{}~a0z€prx…u{w¯uN@nru{«…b9n~tbw tb ‡`v`b¤p~uda0uN`x¬«…x¬pl{³ > bg£x…«…«U4 }~nqp1x…wm¦{bsnp~x¬•6zprb¤pr]`b,}~b9nrx¬«…x…bw@tb

u{ª·p~]`b9nrb>z€«…•{u{}~x¬pr]`a>ngx¬wŽª¹z{tb0u€ª1pr}z€w@nra0x…n~nqx…u{w¥b}~}ruN}~ngz€w@‡Ž«…uNn~n¢Kx…w jmb9tprx…u{w C@³0\^]`bw ¢ x…w jmbst©p~x¬uNw

Š`¢m£ºb £x¬«…«x¬wm¦Nb9nqprx…•Nzp~bpr]@b b¨Ibst©p~n^u{ª a0u{`x…«…x¶pl>z€w ‡¯u{ nquN«¬bprbƒp~u{„Iu{«…u{•Nl4x…woª®uN}ra>zp~x¬uNwK³ ) w@‡ 4@w@z{«¬«…l{¢

£1b£x…«¬«•{b9w`b}z€«…x3*9b,pr]`b*„`}ruN`«…ba u€ªQu{@nru{«…bp~bx…woª®u{}~a>zprx…u{w x…wŽjmbst©prx…u{w=‹¯6l nqprv@‡olmx…w`•¯¦Nb}nqx…u{w@n^u{ª

nrb«¬ª¾´µnqb9«¬bst©prbs‡z{w@‡w`bx…•{]mIu{}r´U‡obsnqx…•{w zprbs‡˜z{«¬•Nu{}~x¶p~]`a>n·p~]@zpƒuN„ b9}~z€prbgu{w z0„`v`}~b«…l¯}z€w@‡ouNa@z{nrxyn³

.>) , >

? bp˜v n0p~z{Ë{b=z v`w@x¶p‡`x…nrËF•N}~z{„`]Sa4uo‡ob9«¤uNw¿z

L×H }rbst©pz€w`•N«¬b °

L ^z€w@‡ H z€}~b§bÃo„`}~b9n~nrb9‡¿z{n adv`«¬prx…„`«¬bsn˜u{ª,pr]`b }~zN‡ox…u }~z{w`•{b§v`w@x¶p©²©¢¤£x¬pr]

N w`uo‡ob9n˜}~z{w@‡ouNa4«…l¿‡ox…nr„@z€p~t]`bs‡³ > bŽnrx¬adv`«…z€prb¥z nrx…a4„@«¬x74@b9‡ a0bs‡ox¬v@a zNttbsnrntu{w6pr}~u{«Kn~t]`b9a4b ,'£]`b9w z0@}ru6z{‡`t9z{nqp^uot9tv`}n¢ zp¤z€wml˜prx…a4bpr]`b9}rbxynƒzp

a0u6npu{w@bba0x¶prprb9}ƒx¬wp~]`bw`bp£ºuN}rËY¢m}~z{w@‡ouNa4«…l˜t]`u6nqb9wz{a0u{w`•4pr]@bw`uo‡ob9n£^z€x¬prx…w`•4pru>}~bp~}~z{w@nra4x¬p9³

Âx…•{v`}~b‘nq]@u£ƒn·p~]`b,}rb9«…z¸l¯nrbpƒnrx3*9bgª®u{}‡ox¬¨Ib9}rb9wNpƒw@bp£1u{}~Ë0nrx+*b,x¬w z

2×2^n6v@z{}rb a0z{„K³'Âx¬•Nv`}~b,“

nr]`u£ƒn pr]@b4}zp~x¬uu€ª1pr]@b4}~b«yz¸l=nrbpu¦{b9}¤p~]`b>w`bp£1u{}~Ë=nrx3*9bdª®uN}‡ox¶¨Yb}~bw6pw`bp£ºuN}rË=nrx3*9b0x¬w z

4×4

n6v@z€}~b{³ .¤utu{«…«¬xynqx…u{w n¢z€w ‡=w`upr}z€w@nra0x…n~nrx¬uNw=b}~}ruN}~n¤z€}~b4tu{w@nrx…‡`b}~b9‡³\^]`b0‡ox¬¨Ib9}rb9wNpz€«…•{uN}rx¬pr]@a0n

nr]`u£¡nrx…a4x…«yz€}^„ b9}qª®uN}ra>z{w@tbN³ ) n^bÃo„ bst©p~b9‡¢ouNwo´;«…x…w`b,„`}rv@w`x¬w@•4f§|º†$„Ib}rª®u{}~a>n1 bpqprb9}^pr]@z{wu{¨ ´U«…x¬w`b

„@}rv`w@x¬w`• ¢Kz€w@‡Žnqb9«¶ª¾´µnrb«…b9t©p~b9‡ c1±gjŽnpz€w@‡@n x…w¥Ibp£1bb9wK³*Âx…•{v`}~b4”‡oxynq„@«…z¸lon¤pr]`b>n~z€a0bd„ z€}z€a0bp~b}n

@vopƒu{w z

6×6nNv z€}~b{³

100 80 60 40 20 y

10

8

6

4

2

0

x

Âx…•{v`}~b¤‘ , †b9«…z¸lnrbpQnqx+*b·ª®u{}Qnqb9«¶ª¾´µnrb«…b9t©p~b9‡dc1±,j¯°¹a0x…‡`‡`«¬bN¢€•{}~bb9w ²©¢uNwo´;«…x…w`b·„`}~v`w`x…w`•,f§|·†$°®Iu€pqp~u{a ¢

}~b9‡ ²·uNw

2×2n6v@z{}rbN¢m¦{b}nrv@nºpr]`bw`bp£ºuN}r˯nrx+*b

y 1

0,8

0,6

0,4

0,2

0

x

240 220 200 180 160 140 120 100

Âx…•{v`}~b4“7,ª®}z{t©p~x¬uNw¥u{ª'pr]`b4w`bp£ºuN}rË Ib«…u{w`•Nx¬w`•˜prupr]`b4}~b«yz¸l nrbpgª®u{},nrb«¬ª¾´Unrb«…b9tprb9‡ c1±gjÀ°®a0xy‡`‡o«…b{¢

•N}rb9bw ²¢uNwo´U«¬x…w`b>„`}~v`w`x…w`•=f§|·† °®Iu€pqp~u{a ¢}rbs‡@²©¢u€¨I´U«¬x…w`b¯„`}~v`w`x…w`•=f§|º†i°¾p~u{„K¢l{b9«¬«…u£¤² u{w

4×4

n6v@z€}~b{¢m¦Nb}nqv@nºp~]`bw`bp£1u{}~˯nrx3*9b

&1 *)+ ^

  wŽpr]@b4„@}rb9¦6x…u{v ngnrx…a*v`«yzp~x¬uNw@n¢£1b0z{n~nqv`a0bs‡=„Ib}rª®b9t©pp~}~z{w@nra4xyn~nqx…u{wK¢Y£x¬pr]`uNvopz€wml§b}~}~u{}n³  w }~b9z€«

t9z{nrb9n9¢tu{«…«…x…nrx¬uNw@n¯z{w@‡¿b}~}ruN}~n0uot9tv`}‡ov`b=p~u `v`}nqpl pr}z(¯t{¢^ª¹z{‡ox…w`•@¢a0uN`x¬«…x¬plFuN}nrx¬adv`«¶pz€w`b9u{v@n

p~}~z{w@nra4xyn~nqx…u{w@n9³A>Žb§£x…«…« nr]`u£p~]@zp>p~]`b§w`bx…•{]mIu{}r´U‡`b9nrx¬•Nw@zp~b9‡Àf=|·† z€}~ba0uN}rb§}~b9nrx¬«…x…bw6p0pr]@z{w

nrb«¬ª¾´µnqb9«¬bst©prbs‡­c1±gj¿x…w¿ª¹z{tb=u€ª,p~]`b9nrb§b}~}ruN}~n9³$\^]@b=}rbsz{nru{wFª®u{}˜pr]`xyn˜nrbb9a0n¯pru Ib=p£1u€´;ª®u{«y‡ ,À°¹xy²

bÃo„`«¬xytx¬p˜nrb«…b9t©p~x¬uNw¿x¬w¿p~]`b§w`bx…•{]mIu{}~]`umuo‡Àx…a0„`«¬x…b9n¯pr]@z€pz€wml w@bx…•{]m uN}>]@z{n˜z }rb9«…z¸l w@um‡`b§x¬w½x¬p~n

w@bx…•{]m uN}r]@u6uo‡¢ z€w@‡ °¹x¬x¾²w@bx…•{]m uN}¤‡obsnqx…•{w@z€prx…u{w £x¬pr]=uNwo´;«…x…w`b*nrb«¬ª¾´;„`}~v`w`x…w`•>ª®bszp~v`}rbsn¤z¯nrx…•{w`x74 tz{w6p

}~b9nrb}~¦{b u€ª„ u{prb9wNp~x…z{«}rb9«…z¸lon(¯x¶ªQnru{a0bgª¹z€x…«Ku€p~]`b}nz€}~bgz{vopruNa>zprxytz{«¬«…l˜zNt©prx…¦zp~b9‡˜pru 4@«…«Ypr]`b•6z€„K³

y 1

0,8

0,6

0,4

0,2

0

x

280 240

200 160

Âx…•{v`}~bd”,ª®}z{t©p~x¬uNw¥u{ª'pr]`b4w`bp£ºuN}rË Ib«…u{w`•Nx¬w`•˜prupr]`b4}~b«yz¸l nrbpgª®u{},nrb«¬ª¾´Unrb«…b9tprb9‡ c1±gjÀ°®a0xy‡`‡o«…b{¢

lNb«…«¬u£¤²¢ uNwo´;«…x…w`b¯„`}~v`w`x…w`•=f§|·† °®Iu€pqp~u{a ¢}rbs‡@²©¢u€¨I´U«¬x…w`b¯„`}~v`w`x…w`•=f§|º†i°¾p~u{„K¢•{}~bb9w ²gu{w

6×6

n6v@z€}~b{¢m¦Nb}nqv@nºp~]`bw`bp£1u{}~˯nrx3*9b

- )" > ,+ C@'E)C@C)%(+H> >/%?> ,F!

> b>]@z¸¦Nb4nrx¬adv`«yzprbs‡ `}ru6z{‡`t9z{nqp D u6uo‡ox…w`• £x¬pr] pr]`b>x…w6pr}~uo‡ov@tx…w`• u€ªz€w z{‡@‡ox¶p~x¬uNw@z€«Q„ z€}z€a0bp~b}

p^³

v z€w6prx¬pl

p <sup>xyndpr]`b</sup> }~b9tb„op~x¬uNwÀ„`}~u{@z{`x…«¬x¬pl{¢ pr]@b„@}ruN@z€`x…«…x¶pl pr] zp¯z¥•Nx¬¦NbwÀpr}z€w@nra0x…n~nqx…u{wÀx…n tu{}~}rbst©p~«¬l}rbstb9x¬¦Nb9‡ ml§z¯•{x…¦{b9w=w`b9x¬•N]6Iu{} w`uo‡ob{³B>½]`b9w

p= 1 £ºbd]@z¸¦{bdb}~}ruN}ª®}rb9bp~}~z{w@nqa0xynrnrx…u{wK³

>½]@bw

p= 0 w`upr}z€w nqa0xynrnrx¬uNwŽt9z€w  b>}~b9tbx…¦{b9‡¥ml¥z€wml§w`uo‡obN³ > b¯z{n~nrv`a0bdp~]@zp,p~]`b>w`bx…•{]mIu{}

x…woª®uN}ra>zp~x¬uNwbÃ`t]@z€w`•Nb xyn^w`u{p¤nqv``b9t©p^p~u>b}~}ruN}g°B‡ov`b,pru>}~b9‡`v`w@‡`z{wNp]`b9«¬«…uNn9¢obpt9²³

Âx…•{v`}~b C‡ox…nr„`«yz¸lonpr]`b^ª®}z{tprx…u{w4u€ªIpr]`bw`bp£ºuN}rË}~b9tbx…¦mx¬w`•gp~]`b`}~uNz{‡@tz{nqp¦{b}nrv@npr]`bƒ}~b9tb„op~x¬uNw

„@}ruN@z€`x…«…x¶pl

p^x¬w z˜w@bp£1u{}~Ë£x¬pr]F‘9ŒNŒ¯w`uo‡obsn uNwŽz

4×4 n6v@z{}rbN¢ ª®uN}gpr]`b>‡ox¬¨Ib9}rb9w6pc1±,j§plm„Ib9n9³ .¤u€p~x…tbpr] zpz€«¬pr]`uNv`•{]=nrb«¬ª¾´Unrb«…b9tprbs‡Žc1±gj=x¬wm¦Nu{«…¦{ba0u{}~b*}~b«yz¸lw@um‡`b9n¤pr]@z{w=w`bx…•{]mIu{}r´U‡`b9nrx¬•Nw@zp~b9‡

f=|·†°¹nrbbG4@•Nv`}~b“N²©¢`x¬p~nƒª®}~zNt©p~x¬uNwu{ªtu{}~}rbst©p}rbstb9„oprx…u{w§‡o}~u{„@n^adv@t]ª¹z{nqprb9}^pr]@z{w§£x¶p~]w@bx…•{]m uN}q´

‡`b9nrx¬•Nw@zp~b9‡f§|·†³¸\u¤Ib1a4uN}rb·„`}rbstxynqbN¢¸£]`bw

pxynt«¬u6nqbQp~ud‘ °®£]`xyt]dnr]`u{v@«…‡Ibºpr]`b1tz{nrb'ª®uN}nqp~z{`«¬b w@bp£1u{}~Ëmn²'pr]`b*nrx…a*v`«yzp~x¬uNw@nnqv@•{•{bsnp1pr] zpƒp~]`b‡o}~u{„x…nx…w

O(1−p)ª®uN}ƒnqb9«¶ª¾´µnqb9«¬bst©p~b9‡§c1±gj z{w@‡x¬w

O((1−p)²)^ª®uN} w@bx…•{]m uN}q´µ‡obsnqx…•{w@z€prbs‡f=|·†³\^]`xyn tu{w!4@}~a>nƒp~]`bdzNnrnrv`a0„op~x¬uNw§pr]@z€p,nrb«¬ª¾´U„`}rv@w`x¬w@•

zN‡¸v@nqp~ngx¬p~nrb«¬ªº£]`b9w nru{a0b*}~b«yz¸l w`uo‡ob9ngª¹zN‡ob{³0e¤¨ ´U«¬x…w`b0nqb9«¶ª¾´U„`}~v`w`x…w`• f§|·†  b9]@z¸¦{bsngnrx…a4x…«yz€}~«¬lpru

 z{nrx…t,f§|·† D@umuo‡ox…w`•@¢o£x¬pr]§nru{a0bz{‡o¦z{wNpz€•Nb „`}~u{ z€`«…l˜‡ov`bgp~u¯zd«yz€}~•{b9}^}rb9«…z¸l¯nrbps³

1 0,8 0,6 0,4 0,2 0

y 1

0,8

0,6

0,4

0,2

0

x

Âx…•{v`}~bBC,ª®}~zNt©prx…u{wu€ªpr]`bgw`bp£1u{}~Ë0}rbstb9x¬¦mx…w`•*p~]`bg`}ru6z{‡`t9z{nqpº¦Nb}nqv@n·pr]@bg}~b9tbx…¦{b „`}ruN@z€@x¬«…x¶pl

p^x…w

zw`bp£1u{}~Ëd£x¬pr]¥‘9Œ{Œw`uo‡ob9n·u{w˜z

4×4nNv z€}~b{¢€ª®uN}1nrb«¬ª¾´µnqb9«¬bst©prbs‡˜c1±gj¥°®Iu€prpru{a¯²¢6uNwo´U«¬x…w`bƒ„`}~v`w`x…w`•

f=|·† °®a0x…‡@‡o«¬b¸²©¢ u€¨I´;«…x¬w@bg„@}rv`w@x¬w`•>f§|º†°¾pruN„ ²

.¤u€prxytb^p~]@zp·pr]`bª®}z{tprx…u{w4u€ªtuN}r}~b9tp}~b9tb„op~x¬uNw0x…nQw@u€p'bÃ`zNt©pr«…l *9b}~ug£]@bw

p= 0¢€pr]@x…n·x…n'‡`v`b^pru z{wz{}qp~x¶ª¹zNt©pƒu{ª pr]@b*nqx…a*v@«…z€prx…u{wpr]@z€p¤z€«…£1z¸lon1x¬w t«…v@‡ob,pr]@bx¬w`x¬prxyz€« ba0x¶prprb9}ƒx¬wp~]`btuN}r}~b9tp^}~b9tb„op~x¬uNw

nrbps³

-8 %()C@)%(+ >/,F@

)

«¶p~]`u{v@•{]dpr]`bnrx¬adv`«…z€prx…u{w4a0um‡`b«`‡oumb9nw`u{pQx¬w@t«¬v ‡obƒtuN«¬«…x…nrx…u{w@n9¢£ºb1]@z¸¦Nbºb9a*v`«yzp~b9‡*pr]`bsnqb^b¦Nbw6p~nml

x…w6pr}~uo‡ov@tx…w`•>z€w b9}r}~u{}}zp~b p~]@zpg‡ob„Ibw@‡@nu{wpr]@bwmv`a*Ib}ƒu{ªtu{w6prb9w@‡ox…w`•>w`uo‡obsnx¬w p~]`bD@umuo‡ox…w`•@³

) „@zNtË{bpdx…n4}~b9tb9x¬¦Nb9‡ tu{}~}rbst©p~«¬l £x¶p~]À„`}~u{ z€`x…«¬x¬pl

p = exp(−λk)<sup>¢'£]`b9}rb</sup> k xyn*p~]`bw6v@a*Ib}4u€ª b9a0x¶prprb}n1£1z{x¶p~x¬w@•*p~u*p~}~z{w@nqa0x¬p9¢`z{w@‡

λ≥0xyn^z*„ z€}z€a0bp~b}ºpr]@z€pt] z€}z{t©p~b}~x3*9b9n'pr]`b,„`}~u{„Ibw@nrx…u{w¯u{ª z w`uo‡obºprutuN«¬«…xy‡obº£x¬pr]4z€w`u{pr]`b9}w`uo‡ob{³|Qz€}z€a0bp~b}

λtu{w6pz€x…w@nz{«¶p~u{•Nbpr]@b}pr]`b^u¦{b9}r«yz€„„@}ruN@z€`x…«…x¶pl u{ªpr]`b,}~b9tb„op~x¬uNw˜z€}~b9zNn¢Nx¬wnq„@zNtbgz€w@‡¯prx…a4bN³ >Žb,z{n~nqv@a4b¤pr]@z€pºp~]`b,„@z{tËNbpn·z€}~bƒp~}~z{w@nra4x¬pqp~b9‡>£x¬pr]

z{wbÃo„ uNw`bw6prxyz€«`x¶prprb}s³>½]`b9wpr]`b^x¬pqp~b}¤x…w@t}rbsz{nrb9n9¢ 6v@z{w6prx¬pl

λ nr]`u{v@«…‡‡ob9t}rbsz{nrb{¢`zNnrnrv`a0x¬w@•dp~]@zp

‡@zp~z=pr}z(¯t¯z{w@‡ u{pr]`b9} D@umuo‡ox…w`•=p~}~z{w@nqa0xynrnrx…u{w@nd‡ou{w

3

p0u¦{b}~«yz€„K³  wFtz{nrb˜u{ªƒu¦{b9}r«yz€„ £x¬pr]À‡@zp~z

p~}~z(¯t £1bnq]@u{v`«y‡˜] z¸¦{b

p=p0exp(−λk)^³

Âx…•{v`}~b Š z€w ‡ ‹ nr]`u£ pr]`bŽ}rbstb9„oprx…u{w¿}zprb ª®uN}‡ox¬¨Yb}~bw6p˜w`bp£ºuN}rËSnrtbw@z{}rx…xB³  w 4@•Nv`}rb=‹

£1b ]@z¸¦{bŽx¬w@t«¬v ‡ob9‡­pr]`b „Ib}rª®u{}~a0z{w@tbŽu€ªp~]`b t«yz{n~nqxytz{«¤ª®v@«¬«D@umuo‡ox…w`•@¢ £x¶p~]$£]@x…t]$b¦{b9}rl¿w`uo‡ob

}~bp~}~z{w@nra4x¬p~n,uN}x¬w6p~bw@‡`npru§}~bp~}~z{w@nqa0x¬ppr]`b>@}ru6z{‡`t9z{nqp,„ z{tË{bp9³ .¤u€p~x…tb>pr]@z€ppr]`b˜u¦{b}~£]`b9«¬a0x…w`•

a>zNnrngu€ªº}rbpr}z€w@nra0x¶prprb}ngx…n,tu{v`w6prb9}r z€«yz€w@tb9‡§ml§p~]`b0]6v@•{b0tu{«…«…x…nrx¬uNw¥}zp~b4z{w@‡§p~]`b0x¬a0„`}~u¦{b9a4b9w6p

x…w§„Ib}rª®u{}~a0z{w@tbxynƒw@u€p¤¦Nb}~l˜x…a4„Iu{}rp~z{w6p9³   w=Âx¬•Nv`}rbd’0£ºb*nr]`u£$pr]@z€p z{tprv@z{«¬«…l¯p~]`b*]mv`•Nbwmv`a*Ib}

u{ªtu{«…«¬xynqx…u{w 4@w@z{«¬«…l¯}~bw@‡`b}n1ª®v`«¬«-D@umum‡`x¬w`•0x…woª®b}~x…u{}^pru>f§|º† D@umum‡`x¬w`• ³

1 0,8 0,6 0,4 0,2 0

y 1

0,8

0,6

0,4

0,2

0

x

Âx…•{v`}~bŠ7,dª®}z{tprx…u{w u{ªpr]`bw`bp£1u{}~Ë¥}~b9tbx…¦6x…w`•§p~]`b˜@}ru6z{‡`t9z{nqp¦{b}nrv@np~]`btu{«…«¬xynqx…u{w }zp~b

λ ^x¬wÀz

w@bp£1u{}~Ë=£x¶p~]­‘9ŒNŒw`uo‡ob9n*u{w z

4×4 n6v@z€}~b{¢ ª®u{}*nrb«¬ª¾´Unrb«…b9tprbs‡ c1±,j½°¹•{}~bbwI²©¢u{wo´U«¬x…w`b>„`}~v`w`x…w`•

f=|·† °®}~b9‡@²¢`u€¨I´;«…x…w`b,„`}rv@w`x¬w@•0f=|·†°®lNb«…«¬u£¤²³

\^]`btu{«…«¬xynqx…u{w}zprbsn1a0z¸l>w@u€p bw@b•{«…x…•{x…`«¬bN³   w 4@•Nv`}~b 4£1b,nr]`u£¡z4}~b9z{«Iw@bp£1u{}~˯nqx…a*v`«yzp~x¬uNw

£]@x…t]b9¦¸z{«¬v zprbsnYpr]@b·„@zNtË{bp ‡`b«…x¬¦Nb}~l¤}zprx…uƒ¦Nb}nqv@nIp~]`b·wmv`ad b9} u{ªm@}ru6z{‡`t9z{nqp ‡`zpz D@u£ƒn³\^]`b'w`bpq´

£1u{}~ËxynQ@zNnqbs‡duNw   NŒN“`³¬‘N‘1z{w@‡4x…n'nrx…a*v`«yzp~b9‡0x…w4w n´“o¢N£x¶p~]§‘9Œ{Œgw`uo‡obsnQu{w¯z0‘0CNŒNŒÃ‘C6Œ{Œ{n6}ra ¢

z plm„`xytz{«6}z{‡`x¬ug}~z{w`•{b1u€ª”NŠ{Œƒa ¢Nz{w@‡d}~z{w@‡ou{aˆ£^z¸lm„ uNx¬w6pa0u{`x…«¬x¬pl,·‘´µ“€a€n¢}~b9nqpq´;prx…a0b¤’s´‘sŠ€n9³ \^]`b

y 1

0,8

0,6

0,4

0,2

0

x

1 0,8 0,6 0,4 0,2 0

Âx…•{v`}~b˜‹,dª®}z{tprx…u{w u{ªpr]`bw`bp£1u{}~Ë¥}~b9tbx…¦6x…w`•§p~]`b˜@}ru6z{‡`t9z{nqp¦{b}nrv@np~]`btu{«…«¬xynqx…u{w }zp~b

λ ^x¬wÀz

w@bp£1u{}~Ë=£x¶p~]F“€ŒNŒw`uo‡ob9n*u{w z

6×6 n6v@z€}~b{¢ ª®u{}*nrb«¬ª¾´Unrb«…b9tprbs‡ c1±,j½°¹•{}~bbwI²©¢u{wo´U«¬x…w`b>„`}~v`w`x…w`•

f=|·† °®}~b9‡@²¢`u€¨I´;«…x…w`b,„`}rv@w`x¬w@•0f=|·†°®lNb«…«¬u£¤²¢mª®v`«¬«-D@umum‡`x¬w`•§°¹`«¬v@bs²©³

˜*&º " I

  wFpr]@x…n¯nrb9tprx…u{wS£ºbx…w6¦Nb9nqprx…•Nz€prbpr]`b§Ib]@z¸¦mx…u{}0u€ªc1±gjSnrb«…b9tprx…u{w¿z€«…•{u{}~x¬pr]`a>nd£]`bwSpr]@b§w`bx…•{]o´

Iu{}~]`umuo‡ x¬w`ª®u{}~a0z€prx…u{w xyndu{vop‡`zp~b9‡ ‡ov@b¯pruŽpr]@b˜w`uo‡obsn

3

a0u{`x…«¬x¬pl{³/>½x¬pr] p~]`xyn*}~b9nr„ bst©ps¢p£ºu{´;]`uN„

w@bx…•{]m uN}r]@u6uo‡x…woª®u{}~a>zprx…u{w§xynƒa0uN}rbª®}z€•Nx¬«…b,pr] z€w=uNw`b´U]`u{„ w`b9x¬•N]m uN}¤x…woª®u{}~a>zprx…u{w=nrx…w@tbp~]`bª®uN}q´

a0b9}ºxyn·}~b«yz¸l{bs‡46l ?j

)

„ z{tË{bp~n'pr]@z€p1z€}~bƒ«…b9n~n'ª®}~b6v`b9w6p·pr] z€w˜]@b«…«¬u„ z{tË{bp~n9¢NuN}·ml>nq„Ib9tx54It¤]`b9«¬«…uNn

p~]@zp^tuNwNpz€x…w>pr]@b «…x…nqp~nºu€ªp~]`b9nrbgw`bx…•{]mIu{}n³f§x…n~nrx¬w`•4nquNa0b¤]`b9«¬«…uNn·a0z¸l>t9z€v@nrbƒp~]`b¤«…uNn~n·u{ªpr]`bg«…x¬w`ËY¢

@vop¤a0x…n~nrx¬w`•0„@zNtË{bp~n1pr] zp tu{w6p~z{x¬w@n1p~]`b,p£1u€´U]`u{„x¬w`ª®u{}~a0z€prx…u{w a>z¸l¯u{v`p~‡`z€prb,pr]@bp£ºu{´;]@u{„x¬woª®uN}q´

a>z€prx…u{w>£x¬pr]`uNvop^t9z€v@nrx…w`•pr]@b¤«…uNn~n'u€ªp~]`bgu{w`bƒ]@u{„¯x…woª®u{}~a>zp~x¬uNwK³\^]@b}~bª®u{}~bp£1u€´U]`u{„>x…woª®uN}ra>zp~x¬uNw

xyn^a0u{}~bgª®}~z{•{x…«¬bgpr] z€wu{w`b´;]`uN„x…woª®uN}ra>zp~x¬uNwK³

  wFpr]`bª®uN«¬«…u£x¬w@•Ž£1bzN‡`‡o}~b9n~np~]`b§tzNnqb£]`b}~bp£ºu{´;]`uN„ x…woª®u{}~a>zprx…u{wFx…n4„@z{}qp~x…z{«¬«…l u{ nquN«¬bprb{³

  wFpr]@x…n¯t9z{nrbpr]`b¥c1±,jFz{«¬•Nu{}~x¶p~]`a>n4a0z¸lÀw`u€p˜tu{wm¦{b9}r•Nb˜„`}~u{„Ib}~«¬lN³¿job«¬ª¾´Unrb«…b9tprb9‡½c1±,jFz{w@‡Fpr]`b

w@bx…•{]m uN}q´µ‡obsnqx…•{w@z€prbs‡0c1±,j>Ib]@z¸¦Nbƒ‡ox¬¨Ib9}rb9wNp~«¬l0x…w>pr]@x…nº}rbsnq„Ib9tp9³Q\^]`b9x¬}º b9]@z¸¦mx¬uN}~n'z{«…nru*‡ox¬¨Yb}·£x¬pr]

0 y

1

0,8

0,6

0,4

0,2

0

x

2 1,5 1

0,5

Âx…•{v`}~b’ ,dª®}z{tprx…u{w u{ªpr]`bw`bp£1u{}~Ë¥}~b9tbx…¦6x…w`•§p~]`b˜@}ru6z{‡`t9z{nqp¦{b}nrv@np~]`btu{«…«¬xynqx…u{w }zp~b

λ ^x¬wÀz

w@bp£1u{}~Ë=£x¶p~] CNŒNŒw`uo‡ob9n*u{w z

8×8 n6v@z€}~b{¢ ª®u{}*nrb«¬ª¾´Unrb«…b9tprbs‡ c1±,j½°¹•{}~bbwI²©¢u{wo´U«¬x…w`b>„`}~v`w`x…w`•

f=|·† °®}~b9‡@²¢`u€¨I´;«…x…w`b,„`}rv@w`x¬w@•0f=|·†°®lNb«…«¬u£¤²¢mª®v`«¬«-D@umum‡`x¬w`•§°¹`«¬v@bs²©³

¦z{}rx…u{v@n'x¬woª®uN}ra>z€prx…u{w>u{ nquN«¬bsnrtbw@tbƒnrtbw@z{}rx…xB³=>Žb £x¬«…«Ytu{w nqxy‡ob}·p£ºu*u{@nru{«…b9n~tb9w@tbn~tbw z€}~x¬x;¢N£]@b}~b

p£1u€´U]`uN„˜x…woª®u{}~a>zprx…u{w zp^p~x¬a0b

t tu{a0bsn1ª®}ruNa ,

šsʜ`š Å Ê š È*É`ÇÉÇ R Å S8T — É › ÉKÉ ÊºŸ z{‡`¦{b}rprx+*bs‡*w@bx…•{]m uN}r]@u6uo‡`nQz€pQprx…a0b

tz{}rb^a>z{‡`bu€ªYpr]`b w@um‡`b9n^£]`xyt] ]@z¸¦{bg b9bw w`b9x¬•N]6Iu{}n^‡ov`}~x¬w@•dp~]`b,prx…a0bx¬w6p~b}~¦¸z{«

(t−T, t)^³

FRFSNP É › Æ Ê Å ¹œ Æ Å Ê š È*É`ÇÉ R Å SNT — É › ÉKÉ Ê·Ÿ z{‡o¦Nb}rprx+*bs‡Fw@bx…•{]m uN}r]@u6uo‡¿zp˜prx…a4b

t ^z€}~b

bÃ`z{t©p~«¬l˜a0zN‡ob,u€ªw`uo‡ob9n^£]@x…t]£ºb9}rb,w`b9x¬•N]m uN}1w@um‡`b9nƒz€p1p~x¬a0b

t−T

w>p~]`bƒª®uN«¬«…u£x…w`•£ºb z{n~nqv`a0bp~]@zp1w`uo‡ob9nºz€}~bƒa0u{`x…«…b{¢mz€w@‡4p~]@zp1b¦{b9}rldw`uo‡obª®uN«¬«…u£ƒn·z}z€w ‡ou{a

£^z€«…ËY³\^]`b z¸¦{b}z€•Nb1nr„Ibb9‡4xyn'u{ªIuNw`bv`w`x¬p·u€ªK‡oxynqp~z€w tb„Ib}Qp~x¬a0b{¢Npr]@b}~bª®u{}~bƒ‡ob 4@w`x…w`•,pr]`bƒprx…a4b¤v`w`x¬p9³

e¤ª tu{v`}nrb{¢6w`uo‡ob9n^‡ouNw

3

p1pr}z¸¦{b9«`p~]@zp‡oxynpz€w@tb¤x…w˜u{w@b¤p~x¬a0bgv`w`x¬p9¢m bstz{v@nqb pr]@bl¯z€}~bƒx…w˜„Ib}~a>z€w`b9wNp

*9x¬•{´*sz€• ³

0 10 20 30 40 50

0 20 40 60 80 100

Delivery Rate (%)

Number of CBR streams Reliability with varying number of streams

CF MPRF MPR-CDS

Âx…•{v`}~b7,ª®}z{t©p~x¬uNw0u€ªYpr]`b¤w`bp£1u{}~Ë}~b9tb9x¬¦mx…w`•,pr]@bƒ`}~uNz{‡@tz{nqp'¦{b9}~nrv@np~]`bƒwmv`a*Ib}ºu€ªKnrx¬adv`«¶pz€w`b9u{v@n

@}ru6z{‡`t9z{nqp D@u£ƒngx…w zw@bp£1u{}~˧£x¶p~]S‘sŒ{Œw`uo‡obsn,u{w z

4×4 nNv z€}~b{¢ª®uN}u{wo´U«¬x…w`b0„`}~v`w`x…w`•§f§|·†

°Bf§|·†ƒÂQ²¢@u€¨I´U«¬x…w`b,„`}~v`w`x…w`•>f§|·†°¹f=|·†^´qc1±gj`²¢`ª®v`«…« D@umuo‡ox…w`•§°;c1ÂQ²©³

1!"-,F@." % % +1%?> 'E,F/)%(+

\^]@b nrx…a*v`«yzp~x¬uNw@n0u€ªgu{vop‡`zp~b9‡Àp£ºu{´;]`uN„Àx…woª®u{}~a>zp~x¬uNwFnr]`u£ z{wFx…a0„ uN}qpz€w6p¯‡ob•N}~zN‡`zp~x¬uNw u€ªgpr]`b

ª®}z{tprx…u{wu€ªpr]`bw@um‡`b9n1pr] zpƒbÃo„Ib}~x¬b9w@tbz0tu{}~}rbst©p^}rbstb„`prx…u{w £]`bwpr]@b4c1±gjxynƒnrb«¬ª¾´Unrb«…b9tprb9‡ °¹nrbb

4 •{v`}~b*N²³ >½]`b9w=p~]`b*uNvop~‡`z€prx…w`•‡`b«yz¸lx…w@t}~b9zNnqbsn^pr]@bd}~b9tb„op~x¬uNw§}~z€prx…u>prb9w@‡`n¤pruŒŽ°¹nrbb 4@•{v`}~b¯‘sŒ

ª®uN}

T v@„˜p~u§‘9ŒN²³

\^]`b1}~b«yz¸l nrx3*9bºnr]`u£ƒn z ‡ox¶¨Yb}~bw tb·]@b}~b!,p~]`bºnrb«¬ª¾´Unrb«…b9tprbs‡dc1±gj}rb9«…z¸l,nrbp}~b9‡`v@tbsnKx…wdnrx3*9b·£]`x…«¬b

p~]`b¤w@bx…•{]m uN}q´µ‡obsnqx…•{w@z€prbs‡*}~b«yz¸ldnrbp·}~ba>z{x¬w@n·npz€`«…bd°Bnqb9b4@•{v@}rb‘N‘s²©³·e w`b¤„ u6nrnrx¬@«¬bƒbÃo„`«…z{w@zp~x¬uNw0x…n

p~]@zp1pr]@b bsnp~x¬a>zp~b9‡˜w`bx…•{]mIu{}~]`umum‡0u{ª w`uo‡obsnºz{}rb «…z{}r•Nb}·£x¬pr]£x¬w ‡ou£­‡ob«yz¸l{bs‡>x…woª®u{}~a>zprx…u{w¯pr]@z{w

£x¬pr]˜bÃ`z{tpºw`b9x¬•N]6Iu{}~]`umuo‡³'cºu{w@nrb6v`b9wNp~«¬ldpr]@bgnrb«¬ª¾´Unrb«…b9tprbs‡c1±gj>£x¬«…«Y bgnqa>z€«…«…b}ºpr]@z{w>pr]`bc1±gj

£x¬pr]¥bÃ`z{tpƒp£ºu{´;]@u{„ x¬w`ª®u{}~a0z€prx…u{wK³ƒ\^]@bbÃo„`«…x…tx¶p~«¬l§nrb«…b9tprb9‡¥f§|·† z{}rbz{„`„@z€}~bw6p~«¬l«¬bsnrn nqb9w@nrx¶p~x¬¦Nb

p~u4pr]`xyn^ª¹z{tp¤z€w@‡˜pr]@bx…}ƒ}rb9«…z¸l¯nrbp}~ba>z€x…w@n^}~b«yzp~x¬¦Nb«…l¯npz€`«…b{³

8 +-)%?>U'E #&,(" % :% 9 )0(;<=%?> ;-%%"

\^]@bnqx…a*v`«yzp~x¬uNw@nƒnr]`u£¡«…x¬pqpr«…bd‡`b•{}z{‡@zprx…u{wu€ªpr]@bª®}~zNt©p~x¬uNwu{ªQtu{}~}rbst©p}~b9tb9„oprx…u{w x…w pr]`bw@bp£1u{}~ËI¢

£x¬pr]Fnqb9«¶ª¾´µnqb9«¬bst©p~b9‡Àc1±,jY¢£]@bw pr]@b¯p£1u€´U]`u{„ w`b9x¬•N]6Iu{}dx¬w`ª®u{}~a0z€prx…u{w xyn*v`w@x¶ª®uN}ra0«…l ‡ob9«…z¸lNb9‡¿°¹nrbb

4 •{v`}~b0‘s“{²³ >½]`bw§nrv@t]z0‡ob9«…z¸l˜x¬w@t}rbsz{nrb9nºpr]@b}rbstb„`prx…u{w}~z€prx…u*p~bw@‡`npru>Ib@z{tË0p~u§‘{³

  w¡ª¹z{t©ps¢pr]@bŽ„Ib}rª®u{}~a>z€w@tb¥nqx…•{w@x54 t9z€w6pr«…l¿‡ox¶¨Yb}n]`b}~b=x¬ª*£ºbŽ«¬umuNËSz€p˜pr]@b nrx3*9b¥u{ªpr]`bŽ}rb9«…z¸l

nrbpn³¯\^]@b>x¬w@tu{w@nrxynp~bw@tx¬bsn,u€ª1pr]`b0p£1u€´U]`u{„ x…woª®u{}~a>zprx…u{w a>z€ËNbdp~]`b¯nrb«¬ª¾´Unrb«…b9tprb9‡ c1±,jŽ}rbsz{t©pml

x…w@t}rbsz{nrx¬w`•4x¬p~nƒnrx3*9b,£]`x¬«…b,pr]@bgw@bx…•{]m uN}q´µ‡obsnqx…•{w@z€prbs‡˜f§|·†Á}~ba>z€x…w@n^a0u{}~b,npz€`«…b¯°¹nrbb 4@•Nv`}rb0‘s”N²©³

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

y

0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2 x

Âx…•{v`}~b¯7,¯e vop‡`zp~b9‡ ‡ob9«…z¸lNb9‡ x…woª®u{}~a>zprx…u{w4,ª®}z{t©p~x¬uNw u€ª^pr]@b˜w`bp£ºuN}rˎ}rbstbx…¦mx¬w@• pr]`b`}ru6z{‡`t9z{nqp

¦Nb}nqv nKp~]`b^u{vop‡`zp~b9‡£x…w@‡ou£

T ^x…w4z w`bp£1u{}~Ë,£x¶p~]‘sŒ{Œ w`uo‡ob9nuNwdz

4×4nNv z€}~b{¢sª®u{}Qnrb«¬ª¾´Unrb«…b9tprb9‡

c1±,j °®Iu€prpru{a¯²¢`u{wo´U«…x¬w`b,„`}~v`w`x…w`•¯f§|º† °®pruN„K¢``«yz{tË`²©¢ou{¨ ´U«…x¬w`b,„`}~v`w`x…w`•>f§|·†°®pruN„K¢`•{}~bl`²

> b¯z€«ynqu }z€wK¢ u{vopu{ª^tv`}rx…uNnrx¬pl{¢p~]`b¯nqx…a*v@«…z€prx…u{w v`„ pru

T = 100^¢K£]@bw pr]`b0p£1u€´U]`uN„Žx…w@tuNwo´

nrxynp~bw@tl ‡o}z€a>z€prxytz€«…«…l¥x…w@t}~b9zNnqbsn³  w p~]`xyndt9z{nrb¯b¦Nb}~lŽw`uo‡obnqb9«¬bst©p~ndx¬p~nrb«¬ªƒx¬w p~]`b˜}~b«yz¸lŽnrbp4x¶ª¤z

p~]`bnqb9«¶ª¾´µnrb«…b9t©p~b9‡np~}~z€prb•Nl0x…n^v@nrb9‡K¢o£]`x¬«…bg£x¶p~]w@bx…•{]m uN}q´µ‡obsnqx…•{w@z€prx…u{w0p~]`b,}rb9«…z¸l>nrbp^Ë{bb9„@n^nqx…•{w@x¶ª¾´

xytz{w6pr«…l˜Ib«…u£¡p~]@zp nrx+*b{³^‚ƒu£1b¦Nb}s¢ox¬w§bsz{t] tzNnqbsn¢op~]`b*tu{}~}rbst©p}rbstb9„oprx…u{w }zprx…u¯nqp~z¸lon^¦{b9}rlt«…uNnrb

p~u ‘0°Bnqb9bG4@•{v@}rb0‘sŠN²©³

**) # (

./d)+*­^ " )+&1

\^]@b*a>z€x…w¥tuNw@t«…v@nrx¬uNw pr]@z€p £1bdt9z€w=‡ob9}rx…¦{bª®}~u{a p~]`b*„`}~b¦mx…u{v@n nqx…a*v@«…z€prx…u{w@n¤x…n¤pr]@z€pgnrb«¬ª¾´Unrb«…b9tprbs‡

c1±,jdz€}~b·a*v t]*«…b9n~nnqp~z{`«¬bºpr] z€w4w`bx…•{]mIu{}r´U‡obsnqx…•{w zprbs‡*c1±gj³ ·x¶p~]`b}p~]`bnqb9«¶ª¾´µnqb9«¬bst©p~b9‡}~b«yz¸lnqbp^°¹xy²

nr]`}~x¬w@Ëmnºp~u6u4a*v t]z€w ‡˜‡oumb9n^w@u€p‡ob«…x¬¦Nb}1pr]@bg@}ru6z{‡`t9z{nqpº„`}~u{„Ib}~«¬lN¢mu{},°®x…xy²1bÃm„ z€w@‡`n1nrudadv@t]˜p~]@zp

p~]`bD@umuo‡ox…w`•0u€ªz0nrx¬w@•{«…bg@}ru6z{‡`t9z{nqp1£x…«¬« x¬wm¦{uN«¬¦Nb adv@t]a4uN}rb,@z{w@‡o£xy‡mpr]p~]@z€w£x¶p~]§zdw@bx…•{]m uN}q´

‡`b9nrx¬•Nw@zp~b9‡§c1±gjY³

  w ª¹zNt©p z0a0u{}~b}~b9z€«…xynp~x…tg}z{‡ox…u4pr}z€w@nra0x…n~nqx…u{w a0uo‡ob« £x¬«…« «…x¬ËNb«…l˜bÃm]@x¬`x¬p tu{«…«¬xynqx…u{w§nqpruN}ra>nz€w ‡

zadv@t]Ž}~b9‡`v@tbs‡Žtu{}~}rbst©p,}rbstb„`prx…u{w }~z€prx…u@³ ) w@‡ b¦Nbw £]`bw p~]`b0}rb9«…z¸l=nrbpnz€}~b4nrx…a4x…«yz€}x…w nrx3*9b{¢

p~]`b„Ib}rª®u{}~a0z{w@tbga>z¸l˜‡ox¬¨Ib9}¤nrx¬•Nw`x54Itz€w6p~«¬lN³

  w0p~]`x…n·nqbst©prx…u{w0£1b•{x…¦{bzt«…uNnrb}Q«…umu{Ë*z€pQpr]`b¤x¬w`]@b}~bw6p'a0b9t]@z{w`x…nra>nv@nrb9‡4mlpr]@b¤nqb9«¶ª¾´µnrb«…b9t©p~x¬uNw

z{w@‡˜pr]`bw`b9x¬•N]m uN}q´µ‡ob9nrx…•{w@z€prx…u{wK³ >Žbx…wm¦{bsnp~x¬•6zprb pr]@bx…}x¬a0„@zNt©pƒu{w„Ib}rª®u{}~a0z{w@tbN³Q\ u0p~]`x…n^b9w@‡£ºb

£x…«…« z{n~nqv@a4b pr] zp¤nrb«¬ª¾´Unrb«…b9tprb9‡§c1±,j˜uN„ b9}~z€prbz{n1ª®uN«¬«…u£ƒn0,

x

10 8 6 4 2 0 y

1

0,8

0,6

0,4

0,2

0

Âx…•{v`}~b,‘9Œ,e vop‡`zp~b9‡4x¬w`ª®u{}~a0z€prx…u{w-, ª®}~zNt©p~x¬uNwdu{ª p~]`bƒw`bp£ºuN}rË}~b9tbx…¦6x…w`•gpr]@bƒ`}~uNz{‡@tz{nqp¦{b}nrv@npr]`b

uNvop~‡@zprbs‡¥£x…w@‡ou£

T ^x…w z˜w`bp£ºuN}r˧£x¬pr]¿‘sŒ{Œw`uo‡ob9n,uNw z

4×4n6v@z€}~b{¢Yª®uN}nqb9«¶ª¾´µnrb«…b9t©p~b9‡ c1±gj

°¹ u{pqp~u{a ¢`}~b9‡@²¢ou{wo´U«¬x…w`b,„`}~v`w`x…w`•¯f§|·† °®pru{„ ¢`•{}~bb9w ²©³

y 1

0,8

0,6

0,4

0,2

0

x

2 1,5 1

0,5 0

Âx…•{v`}~b,‘{‘ ,e vop‡`zp~b9‡4x¬w`ª®u{}~a0z€prx…u{w-,†b«yz¸ldnrbp·nrx3*9b^¦{b}nrv@npr]`buNvop~‡@zprbs‡4£x¬w@‡`u£

T x¬w>zgw`bp£ºuN}rË

£x¬pr]$‘9ŒNŒ§w`uo‡ob9ndu{wFz

4×4 nNv z€}~b{¢ª®u{}0nqb9«¶ª¾´µnrb«…b9t©p~b9‡Fc1±,j­°¹ u{pqp~u{a¯²©¢'uNwo´U«¬x…w`b˜„@}rv`w@x¬w`• f§|·†

°¹a0x…‡`‡`«¬b¸²©¢`u{¨ ´U«¬x…w`b„`}~v`w`x…w`•>f§|·† °®pru{„I²

6

·z{t] w`uo‡obnrb«…b9tp~n^x¬p~nrb«¬ª£x¬pr]§„`}~u{ z€`x…«¬x¬pl

ν M

£]`b9}rb

M x…ngp~]`b>z¸¦{b}z€•Nbw`b9x¬•N]6Iu{}~]`umuo‡¥nrx3*9b0u€ª·p~]`b0w`uo‡ob9n,x…wŽpr]`b>w`bp£ºuN}rËY³4\^]`b}~bª®uN}rbdpr]`b

‡`bw@nrx¶pl>u{ª }~b«yz¸ld„Ib}v`w@x¶p‡oxynqË>xyn

ν³'\^]`b,tu{v@wNp~b}1„@z€}rp1ª®u{}^w`bx…•{]mIu{}r´U‡`b9nrx¬•Nw@zp~b9‡>f§|·†$nqb9«¬bst©p~x¬uNw xyn1pr]@b,ª®u{«…«¬u£x…w`•,

6

·z{t] w`uo‡ob,}z€w@‡`a4uNa0«¬l˜nrb«…b9tp~n

ν w`b9x¬•N]6Iu{}^w`uo‡obsnƒz{n^x¬p~nf=|·†

>½x¬pr]4u{wo´U«…x¬w`b^nrb«¬ª¾´;„`}~v`w`x…w`•,f§|·†Snqb9«¬bst©p~x¬uNwK¢¸pr]`bz¸¦Nb}z€•{bQwmv`ad b9}u€ª@}~b«yz¸l,w`uo‡ob9n„Ib}v`w`x¬p'‡ox…nrË

xyn

ν¢N£]`x…«…bª®u{}Qp~]`bƒu{¨ ´U«¬x…w`b¤nrb«¬ª¾´U„`}rv@w`x¬w@•x¶p1x…n

ν+ 1³Âx¬•Nv`}rbsn‘9‹z{w@‡ ‘¸’gnr]`u£Fpr]`b¤„ b9}qª®uN}ra>z€w tbu€ª p~]`b9nrb,}~z{w@‡ouNa c1±gj¦Nb}nqv@nºp~]`b}rb9«…z¸l¯nrbpƒ‡ob9w@nrx¶plN³   p¤t«…b9z€}~«…l¯nq]`u£ƒnºp~]@zpª®uN}^pr]`bn~z€a0b,}rb9«…z¸l¯nrbp

nrx+*b{¢`pr]`b*f=|·†%c1±gjuNvopr„Ib}rª®u{}~a>n1pr]`bdnqb9«¶ª¾´µnqb9«¬bst©p~b9‡=c1±gj³@Â`v`}rpr]@b}~a4uN}rbN¢opr]@b*nqb9«¶ª¾´µnrb«…b9t©p~b9‡§c1±gj

„Ib}rª®u{}~a>z€w@tb xynadv@t]«…b9n~nnqp~z€@«¬bgpr] z€wpr]`u6nqb,u{ªnrb«¬ª¾´;„@}rv`w@x¬w`•>f§|º†³

e¤ªtu{v`}nrb{¢{}z€w ‡ou{ac1±gj˜z€}~bƒw`u{pº}~b9z€«…xynp~x…t{¢6z{w@‡>a>z¸l0 bgtu{w nqxy‡ob}~b9‡>zNn·bÃmpr}~ba0b¤tzNnqbsn·£]@b}~b

y 1

0,8

0,6

0,4

0,2

0

x

2 1,5 1

0,5 0

Âx…•{v`}~b¯‘¸“ ,DI¤w`x¬ª®u{}~a4«…l§‡ob«yz¸l{bs‡x¬woª®uN}ra>z€prx…u{w-,ºª®}~zNt©p~x¬uNw§u€ªQpr]@bw`bp£1u{}~Ë}rbstbx…¦mx¬w@•0pr]`bd`}ru6z{‡`t9z{nqp

¦Nb}nqv nQpr]@bguNvop~‡@zprbs‡¯‡ob9«…z¸l

T x…wz*w`bp£1u{}~Ë0£x¶p~]¥‘sŒ{Œw`uo‡obsn1u{wz

4×4n6v@z€}~b{¢Nª®u{}^nrb«¶ª¾´µnrb«…b9t©p~b9‡

c1±,j °®Iu€prpru{a ¢`•N}rb9bw ²¢ou{wo´U«…x¬w`b,„`}~v`w`x…w`•>f§|·†°®pruN„K¢o}rbs‡@²©¢@u€¨I´;«…x¬w@bg„@}rv`w@x¬w`•>f§|º†°¾pruN„K¢`lNb«…«¬u£¤²

£x¬pr] p~]`b>„`}~b¦mx¬uNv@n,„Ib}rª®u{}~a0z{w@tb>nrx¬adv`«yzprx…u{w }~b9nrv`«¶pn,x¬w z§tu{w6prbÃ6pu{ª1a0u{@x¬«…x¶pl¥u{},pr}z€w nqa0xynrnrx¬uNw

b9}r}~u{}n9³

- .4,

\^]@b˜ª¹zNt©p4pr]@z€pdp~]`b}~u{v`prx…w`•¥xyn4}rbpr}z€w@nra0x¶prprb9‡Àml zŽ«…x¬a0x¬prb9‡Fnqv@@nqbp4u{ªƒpr]@bw@um‡`b9nda0z¸l «…b9zN‡ pru

v@woª¹z€x…}rw@b9n~n¢`x¬ªpr]`bdnqv` nqbp ‡oumb9nw@u€p¤¦z€}~l¯ª®}~b6v`b9w6pr«…l˜bw@u{v`•N]£x¬pr] p~x¬a0b4z€w@‡ nru{v`}tbsn³1Âx…•{v@}rb>‘

‡`x…nr„`«yz¸lmn*pr]@b§„@z{tËNbp4‡`b«…x¬¦Nb}~l }~z€prb£]`bwA?j ) „@zNtË{bp~n0z€}~bD@umuo‡obs‡À£x¬pr]¿z€wSu€¨I´;«…x…w`b„@}rv`w@x¬w`•

f=|·† D u6uo‡ox…w`•4u{}1£x¶p~]z{w˜uNwo´;«…x…w`b „@}rv`w@x¬w`•0f§|·†Áz€«…•{uN}rx¬pr]@a³'e wo´U«¬x…w`bg„`}~v`w`x…w`•dz{«¬•Nu{}~x¶p~]`a«¬bsz{‡`n

p~udz*„ b9}ra>z€w@bw6p1‡ox…¦{b9}~nrx¬pldx…w¯p~]`bgnrv`@nrbp1u€ªK}~b«yz¸ldw@um‡`b9n0,p~]`bg}rb9«…z¸l4nqbp1¦z€}~x…b9n'£x¬pr]˜pr]`b,nru{v`}tbƒu{ª

p~]`b`}~uNzN‡`tzNnpƒnru{v`}tbN³  ªpr]@ba0b9‡ox…v`a z{ttb9n~nƒtuNw6pr}~u{«x…wNp~}ruo‡ov tb9n¤z>tb}rp~z{x¬w }z€w@‡`u{a0w`b9n~nx…w pr]`b

uN}~‡`b},u€ª^}rbpr}z€w@nra0x…n~nrx¬uNw@n¢Yp~]`bw p~]`b¯}~b«yz¸l§w`uo‡ob¯nqv@@nqbp*z€«ynqu¦z€}~x¬bsn,£x¶p~] prx…a0b{¢ b9¦{b9w £]@bw pr]`b

w@bp£1u{}~Ë4xynnqp~zp~x…t{³ºcºu{w@nrb6v`b9w6pr«…l0pr]`b`v@}~‡ob9wu{ª ª®uN}r£^z€}‡ox…w`•*xyn^a0u{}~b¤ª¹z{x¬}~«¬lnq]@z{}rbs‡¯£x¬pr]u{wo´U«…x¬w`b