• Aucun résultat trouvé

Approximations of shape metrics and application to shape warping and empirical shape statistics

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "Approximations of shape metrics and application to shape warping and empirical shape statistics"

Copied!
65
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00071766

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00071766

Submitted on 23 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub-

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,

Approximations of shape metrics and application to shape warping and empirical shape statistics

Guillaume Charpiat, Olivier Faugeras, Renaud Keriven

To cite this version:

Guillaume Charpiat, Olivier Faugeras, Renaud Keriven. Approximations of shape metrics and appli- cation to shape warping and empirical shape statistics. RR-4820, INRIA. 2003. �inria-00071766�

(2)

ISRN INRIA/RR--4820--FR+ENG

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

THÈME 3

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Approximations of shape metrics and application to shape warping and empirical shape statistics

Guillaume Charpiat — Olivier Faugeras — Renaud Keriven

N° 4820

Mai 2003

(3)
(4)

(*)+,-"#., !$(/01!

243 5768689:3 ;=<(>@?A9:B%C 5D9FEHGJILK,685NMO58<PBQL9:3 R:<SBT9VUTWI X<PYA9:3 Z\[4<SB]5NM^<PYA_

`badcegfhi'jlkSmnf%oqpPrsmqtvuPkaduPe@egfwDexpyrzaFtvkdfP{

t|exp~}Pf%%{€duykdkd‚%f%%{druPkdkFp~tƒqnpykFrf]

„Aoqu~…†fmˆ‡‰€dŠqn‚f

‹.p~ŒFŒVuPom.€Žfoqf%rzadf%oqrzaFfk:‘P’S“~”(i–•4pyt“~”P”yhi–—d˜&ŒFpy}yf%

™š›%œHždŸyœy  `baFt| pyomqt|r¡vf&ŒdoquyŒ:uPnf%p£¢Noqpye@f%¤¥uPon¦@¢NuPob€df%p~¡|t|kd}g¤ t§mqanf¨Pfozp~¡:ŒdonuP©d¡|fexbonf%¡|p~mnf]€xmnu

mqadfgp~kFpy¡vŠŽnt|ªu~¢¥naFpyŒVf]«`¤¥uoqf¡ƒpHmnf]€Jn¬FrzaŒdoquy©F¡vf%eg&pyonfmnadfg€Žf­Vkdt§mqtvuPk(uy¢LmnaFf£oqf¡|f¨Hp~kSmfm‰uy¢

naFpyŒVf]pykF€mqaFpHm u~¢V€df­Fkdt|kd}&pˆegfmnoqt|r¥uyk£t§m]«®Fuy¡|¡vuH¤ t|kd}ˆpªonf]rf%kPmonf]f]p~ozrzaeguykduP}yozp~Œda©Š¯ªf¡v¢Nuy¬do

pykF€±°:uy¡|f%nt|u³²|˜y˜´D{ ¤fJruPkFtƒ€Žf%ogmnadfrzaVp~ozpyrsmqfoqt|mntƒr¢N¬dkFrsmqtvuPkFµuy¢ªmqadfn¬d©Fnfmzµu~¢¶ ·¸pykF€¹mnadf%tvo

€dt|mqpykFrf¥¢N¬dkFrmnt|uykF%«`baFfº¥·»kduPone¼uy¢dmnadf €Žtv½^foqfkFrf¥uy¢VrzaFp~ozpyrmnf%ontƒ†mqt|rA¢N¬dkFrsmqtvuPkF%{Hmnadfbº¾¿p~kF€mnadf

À¿Ás·bkduPonexAuy¢Vmqadfˆ€Žtv½:f%onf%kFrf uy¢1€Žt|mqpykFrfb¢N¬FkFrsmqtvuPkF»€Žf­Fkdf t|kSmnfoqf%mnt|kd}&mquyŒ:uy¡|uy}yt|f%%{~t|kgŒFp~onmntƒr¬d¡ƒp~o

mqaFpHmµt|kF€Ž¬Vrf%€©Š¸mnadf4¤f¡|¡§wækduH¤ kĈp~¬Vn€ŽuPo½Å€Žt|mqpykFrfP«ÇÆf%r%p~¬Fnf4u~¢&Œdozpyrsmqt|r%p~¡.ruykFnt|€dfozpHmnt|uykV

pyontƒntvkd}J¢NonuPeÈmqadfµ¢7pPrsm@mnaFp~m@¤f€df%p~¡¤ tvmna=t|exp~}yfaVp~Œ:f%@€Žf­FkFf%€=uPkÉ­Fkdtvmnf}yoqtƒ€duy¢.Œdt§ÊŽf%¡|£¤¥f

oqf%mnoqtƒrsmuy¬FopHmnmnfkSmqtvuPk(mqun¬d©Fnfmqu~¢.¶ ·Ju~¢ Œ:uPnt§mqtv¨Pfxonf]pyrzaËt|kËmnadfnfkVfxuy¢ ®Ff%€Žf%onf%oµ²|˜%—T´Ã{¤ tvmna

neguu~mnag©:uy¬dkV€dp~oqtvf]Au~¢^©:uy¬dkF€df%€xr¬Fon¨HpHmq¬doqfy« ®duyoLmnadtƒLŒFpyomqt|r¬d¡ƒp~oLnfmLu~¢1naFp~Œ:f%L¤¥f.naduH¤¹mnaFp~mLmnadf

mqadoqffˆŒFonf%¨St|uy¬VAmnuPŒVuP¡vuP}yt|f%Lpyonfˆf%ÌS¬dt|¨Tpy¡vf%kSm%«A`badfˆkFfʁmŒFonuP©d¡vf%e+¤fªruykFntƒ€Žfo¥t|»mnaFp~muy¢1¤pyonŒFtvkd}p

naFpyŒVf¥uykSmnu‰p~kduymnadf%oO©Š&tvkŽ­Vkdt§mqf%ntvexpy¡S}PoqpP€Žt|fkSm€Žf]nrfkSm%{Hegt|kdtvegt|Ít|kd}ªmnadfbruPonoqf%nŒVuPkF€Žt|kd}.€Žtƒ†mzp~kFrfy«

Æf]rp~¬Vfmnadf,€Žtƒ†mzp~kFrf¢N¬dkVrsmnt|uyk¹tvk¨Puy¡|¨yf%@p~kÇÎÐÏ%Ñz{»tvmxt|@kduymg€dt§½^foqfkSmntƒp~©F¡vf¤ t§mqa¹oqf%nŒVf]rsm@mnu(mnadf

naFpyŒVfP«Ò(fgŒdoquyŒ:uPnfgpµ¢7pye@t|¡|Š4u~¢neguu~mnaÓp~ŒdŒFonuTʎt|egp~mnt|uykFªu~¢»mnadfx€Žtƒ†mzp~kFrf¢N¬FkFrsmqtvuPk(¤ adtƒrzaËp~oqf

ruykSmnt|k¬duy¬V»¤ tvmnaonf]Œ:f%rm¥mqumqadf&Ĉp~¬Vn€ŽuPo½,mquyŒ:uy¡|uy}yŠP{SpykF€µaFfkFrf‰¤ tvmnaonf]Œ:f%rm¥mqumqadf&u~mqadfom†¤u

mquyŒ:uy¡|uy}Ptvf]«£Ò(fxruPegŒd¬Žmnf@mqadfxruyoqoqf%nŒVuPkF€Žt|kd}Ô&Õ~mnf%py¬ŽÊ(€Žf%ont|¨HpHmqtv¨Pf%%«£`badf%Š€Žf­Vkdfx€Žf¢NuPonexpHmqtvuPk

Ö uH¤.‰mnaFp~mrp~kÓ©:fx¬Ff]€(mnu4¤bp~oqŒ(p4naFp~Œ:fguykSmnu4p~kFu~mnaFfo©Š(nuy¡|¨tvkd},p~kËt|kdtvmntƒp~¡L¨Hp~¡|¬dfgŒdoquy©d¡|fe,«

ÒÓfnaduH¤Çnf¨yf%oqpy¡^fÊdp~egŒd¡|f%buy¢OmnaFt| ¤bp~oqŒdt|kd}gp~kF€ŒdoquH¨yf‰ŒdonuPŒVf%omqtvf]u~¢ uy¬do p~ŒFŒdonuTʎt|expHmnt|uykV»mqaFpHm

oqf¡ƒpHmqfxmnuJmnadffʎt|mnf%kFrfu~¢.¡|ur%p~¡¥e@t|kdt|expd«JÒÓfµmqadfk=¬VfxmqadtƒmquSuP¡LmquŒdoquŽ€Ž¬FrfruyegŒd¬dmqpHmqtvuPkFp~¡

€df­Fkdtvmnt|uykVuy¢.mnadffegŒdt|ontƒrpy¡¥egf]p~k¸pykF€¸ruH¨Tpyontƒp~kVrfxu~¢ˆp(fm@uy¢ˆaVp~Œ:ffÊdpye@ŒF¡vf]«Ë`badfŠËŠt|f¡ƒ€

pykJp~kFpy¡vuP}gu~¢ mnadf£kdu~mqtvuPk4u~¢AŒdoqtvkVrt|ŒFp~¡1eguŽ€Žf].u~¢L¨HpyontƒpHmqtvuPk1«¥ÒÓft|¡|¡v¬FmnozpHmqf&mnadf%euykJpx¨Hp~oqt|fm†Šuy¢

fÊdp~egŒd¡|f%%«

×ØÙ]Ú]Û8ÛD܆ÝAގßzà~ásâ8ßqãDásâNÚäåVæ çyä]èéâ8ê]ÝAÙSëìíïî&äTðzésñsñsébòdßzâ8óïۍäHôHâ8ßzõTö†Ý÷0øêTóïíïíùßzêTî Ýs÷ú^ûHßzâ7üTóùßqãlý݆õTۍ÷þ|â

ÿ

ØÙ%Ú]Û8ÛD܆ÝAގßzà~ásâDßqã8ásâNÚäNæÓç%ásüTûTóùßõã8óïü~ásíïóïÛnä sñsñzèâ8ásê]ã8Ý»ÙT݆Ûށê]öóïásíï݆ۍä 0òñsñ]äPç%ásüTûTóùßõã8óïü~ásíïóïÛ

ú0݆ÙTÝyäHôHâ8ßzõTö†Ý÷Vþƒßzêsݍâ8ßzÛlýÛ8ásüTûTóùß]÷óïõTâ7óùß]÷þvâ

ØÙ]Ú%ÛDÛ8܆Ýގßzà~ásâ8ßqãDásâNÚäHåVæò^úäLß^íùßzóïÛ8ÝòdßzÛ8önßzíƒä]ðsðqèéséßzâ7õTÝíùß:ßzíïíï܆Ýsä%ôHâ8ßzõTö†Ýs÷O݆õHßzêTÙP÷ ݍâ7ó݆õ~ý݆õTÛn÷þvâ

(5)

! "$#&%('

)›y +*

aFp~Œ:fLegfmqontƒr%{TrzaFp~ozpyrmnfoqtƒ†mqt|r¢N¬dkFrmnt|uykF%{H€Žtƒ†mzp~kFrfA¢N¬dkFrmnt|uykF%{H€Žf¢NuPonexpHmqtvuPk

Ö

uH¤.{

¡|uH¤fo¥nfegt^ruPkPmqtvk¬duP¬F¥fk¨yf%¡vuPŒVfP{SnaFp~Œ:fˆ¤bp~oqŒdt|kd}F{SfegŒdt|oqt|r%p~¡:e@f]p~knaFpyŒVfP{Sf%egŒdtvoqtƒrp~¡^ruH¨Hpyontƒp~kFrf

uPŒVf%oqp~mnuPo%{ŒdoqtvkVrt|ŒFp~¡0eguŽ€Žf%buy¢¨HpyontƒpHmqtvuPk1«

(6)

$ " H $† 1'"/1&0

.,

›   uP¬FŒFonuPŒVuSuPkF€dpykF£rfmxp~onmntƒr¡|fµ¬dk³rpy€donfŒVuP¬domqoqpyt§mqfo£¬dk¹rfonmqp~t|kÉkduPe©doqf€Žf

ŒFonuP©d¡vc%egf%µ¡|t|‚%É¡p~kVp~¡|Šnf€Žf¢Nuyoqegf%%« uP¬FruyegegfkuykFŒFp~o,rf%¬ŽÊ €Žf¡ƒp¸€Ž‚­Fkdtvmnt|uykǀ¬dk

f]ŒVpyrf@€Žf£¢Nuyoqe@f]‰fm€¬dkdf@e@‚mnoqt|ÌS¬dfgn¬dorf¡|¬dtvwÃrt8« ŒFpyomqtvo&€¬dkdfgeguykduP}yozp~ŒdaFtvf€df@oqf%rzaFfozrzadf

oq‚%rfkSmnf%o£€Ž¬Ff(¯ˆf%¡§¢NuP¬dogfmx°^uy¡|‚%ntvu=²|˜y˜´D{AkFuy¬F@ruPkFtƒ€Ž‚%onuPkF¡|f%£¢NuykVrsmnt|uykV£r%p~ozpyrsmq‚oqt|mntƒÌS¬df%€Žf%

nuy¬V†wÃfkFnfe£©d¡|f%@€Žf¶ ·Ëfmg¡|f¬Foq£¢NuykVrsmnt|uykVx€Žt|mqpykFrfP« pkduPonegf,º»·€Žf,¡|pˀŽtv½^‚oqfkFrf€Žf4€Žf%¬ŽÊ

¢NuPkFrsmqtvuPkFArpyoqpPrsmq‚oqt|mntƒÌS¬df%%{H¡vf]AkduPonegf%Aºb¾fm¥À¿Áz· €df ¡|p€Žtv½^‚oqfkFrf.€Žf.€Žf¬dÊ¢NuykVrsmnt|uykVA€Žt|mqpykFrf

€d‚­Fkdtƒqf%kPm€df%mquyŒ:uy¡|uy}Ptvf]&tvkSmn‚%onf]nqp~kSmqf%%{OfkɌVp~onmntƒr¬d¡|tvf%orf%¡v¡|fxt|kF€Ž¬dtvmnfŒFp~o¡ƒp4r‚%¡vc%©doqfµ€Žt|mqpykFrf

€dfĈpy¬Fn€duyon½«b¯ˆf]ˆruykFnt|€d‚ozpHmnt|uykV €uPoq€donf&ŒdozpHmqt|ÌS¬df¡|tv‚%f%ªp~¬¢7p~tvm‰ÌS¬dfkduP¬F.kFuy¬F t|kSmn‚%onf]nnuykF!

€df%‰¢Nuyoqegf%&t|exp~}yfg€Ž‚­Fkdt|f%n¬do€Žf]&}yoqtv¡|¡vf]ª­Fkdt|f%€ŽfgŒdtvʎf¡ƒ{kduy¬VruykVrfkSmqonuPkFˆkFu~mnoqfxpHmnmnfkSmqtvuPk

n¬do€df%nuy¬V†wÃfkFnfe£©d¡|f%€Žf¶·(€Žtvmq@€Žf®df]€Žfoqfo²v˜]—T´D{ApT¨Pf%rg¬dkdfµ¢NonuPkPmqtvc%onfx¡|tƒnnfµfm@€ŽfruP¬doq©d¬doqf

©:uyoqkd‚%fy«

uy¬V»€Ž‚%e@uPkSmnoquykFLÌS¬dfªŒVuP¬do¥rfm»f]ŒVpyrfª€Žf ¢Nuyoqegf.¡|f%AmqonuPt|LmnuPŒVuP¡vuP}yt|f%AŒdoq‚%r‚%€Žf%kSmnf%¥uPkSm

‚]ÌS¬dtv¨Hpy¡vf%kPmqf%%« OfŒFonuP©d¡vc%egf,n¬dt|¨Hp~kSmxf%mxrf¡|¬dt.€Žf,¡ƒpӀd‚¢NuyoqexpHmqtvuPk¹€¬dkdf¢Nuyoqegf,fk³¬dkdfJp~¬dmnoqf

¢NuPonegf£ŒFp~o&¬dkdfg€Žf]nrfkSmnfg€Žf@}yozpy€Žt|fkSmªt|kŽ­FkFt§mq‚%ntvexp~¡|fy{0f%kegt|kdtvegtƒnpykSm‰¡"¬Fkdf@€df%ªmnoquytƒª€dt|mqpykFrf]«

p‰Œdon‚]f%kFrf.€¬dk4ÎÐÏ]Ñ €dp~kF ¡ƒp€Ž‚­Fkdtvmnt|uykµ€Žf ¡ƒp‰¢NuykFrmnt|uykx€Žtƒ†mzp~kFrf onf%kF€grf%¡v¡|fwlrtdkFuykŽwl€Žtv½:‚%onf%kPmqt|py©d¡|f

ŒVp~o ozp~ŒdŒ:uyonm#£¡ƒp£¢Nuyoqegfy« uy¬FbŒdoquyŒ:uPnuykV€duykFr&¬dkFf&¢7p~egtv¡|¡|f€pyŒdŒdoquTʎtvexpHmqtvuPkF¥on‚%}y¬d¡|tvc%onf]b€Žf¡|p

¢NuPkFrsmqtvuPkµ€Žtƒ†mzp~kFrfy{PruykSmnt|k¬df%LŒFp~oLozp~ŒFŒVuPom$¡ƒp€Žtƒmqp~kVrf.€ŽfˆÄªp~¬Fq€ŽuPo½ {yfm€ŽuPkFrbŒFp~o¥oqpyŒdŒ:uyonmApy¬ŽÊ

€df¬ŽÊpy¬Žmnoqf%€Žtƒ†mzp~kFrf%bruPkFtƒ€Ž‚%on‚%f%%« uy¬Fbrpy¡|r¬d¡|uykF¥¡vf]b€Ž‚oqtv¨P‚f]¥€ŽfÔ&ÕHmqf%py¬ŽÊµruyoqoqf%nŒVuPkF€dp~kSmqf%%«

% f%¡v¡|fwlrt€Ž‚­Vkdt|qnfkSm@€Žf]£rzaVp~egŒF€df€Ž‚¢Nuyoqegp~mnt|uyk¸pT¨Pf%rg¡|f%qÌS¬df¡ƒuPkɌVf%¬Žmx€Ž‚¢NuPonegfo£¬dkdf¢Nuyoqe@f

f%k=¬dkdfp~¬Žmqonffk=oq‚%nuy¡|¨Hp~kSm¬dk¹Œdoquy©d¡|cegf€Žf % p~¬FrzaŠP« uP¬F£tv¡|¡v¬V†mqonuPkFrfmmqftƒ€Ž‚%fJ¡"p~tƒ€Žf€Žf

ŒF¡v¬Fnt|f¬dozLfʁf%egŒd¡vf]»fm¥Œdoquy¬F¨yuykV»€Žf]LŒdoquyŒdoqt|‚mn‚]»€Žfªkdu~mqonf‰p~ŒdŒFonuTʎt|egp~mnt|uykgoqf¡ƒpHmnt|¨yf]$¡"fʎt|mnf%kFrf

€df e@t|kdt|exp¡vuŽr%p~¬ŽÊ0« uy¬F»¬Žmnt|¡|t|nuykFLfkFn¬dtvmnf.rfm»uy¬dmnt|¡dŒVuP¬do»€Ž‚­Fkdt|o»€Žf.expykdtvc%onf ruyegŒd¬ŽmzpHmnt|uykFkdf¡|¡vf

¡ƒp@eguHŠyfkFkdf&fegŒdt|ontƒÌS¬dffm.¡ƒpgruH¨Hp~oqt|pykFrf&€¬dk,fkFnfe£©d¡|f&€df&¢Nuyoqe@f]«

%

f]rtOruykF€d¬dt§m&@¬dkFfkdu~mqtvuPk

pykFp~¡|uy}P¬df&@rf%¡v¡|f‰€df%egu€df%¥Œdont|kFrtvŒFpy¬ŽÊ€Žf&€Ž‚¢NuPonexp~mnt|uykÌS¬df‰kduy¬V¥t|¡|¡v¬FmnoquykV¥n¬dob€Žf%fʎf%e@ŒF¡vf]«

' ' œ]› # Ÿ)( ›É  •,‚mnoqt|ÌS¬df]€Žfx¢NuPonegf%%{¢NuykFrmnt|uykF£rp~ozpyrmn‚%ontƒ†mqt|ÌS¬df]&€f%kFnfe©F¡vf]{¢NuykVrsmnt|uykV€Žtƒ†w

mzp~kFrfy{ Ö u~mz»€Žf‰€Ž‚¢NuPonexp~mnt|uyk1{Pfk¨yf%¡vuPŒdŒVfªf%e@t^ruPkSmnt|kS¬Ff.tvkd¢N‚oqtvf%¬donf%egfkSm%{€Ž‚¢NuPonexp~mnt|uykµ€Žfˆ¢Nuyoqe@f]{

eguHŠPfkdkdf‰fegŒdt|oqt|ÌS¬df€Žf‰¢NuPonegf%%{ŽuyŒ:fozpHmqf¬dobf%e@ŒFtvoqt|ÌS¬df€df&ruH¨Hp~oqt|pykFrfP{SeguŽ€Žf] €Žf€Ž‚¢NuPonexp~mnt|uykF%«

(7)

x" !ȣ

Of%pyonkdt|kd}naFpyŒVf£e@uŽ€Žf%¡|ˆ¢NoquyefÊdp~egŒd¡|f%%{:¬Ft|kd}mnadf%e mquoqf%ruy}ykFtvÍ%fkdf¤t|kFmqpykFrf]ˆuy¢Amnadfgnpyegf

r¡|pPnLu~¢OnaFp~Œ:f%¥p~oqf ¢7pyqrt|kFpHmqtvkF}ŒdonuP©d¡|fexAmqaFpHmaFpT¨yfˆp~mmqoqpPrsmnf]€£mnadf‰pHmmqfkSmnt|uyku~¢0exp~kŠ@qrt|fkSmqt|mq

¢NuPoexp~kŠÓŠyf]p~oz« % f%kPmqoqpy¡LmquJmnaFt|£Œdoquy©d¡|fe/t|mnaFfkduymnt|uyk=uy¢ˆp4oqpykF€ŽuPe/naFp~Œ:f¤ aFt|rzaÉt|k=tvmqnf¡v¢

aVpy&uŽrr¬dŒdt|f%€(ŒVf%uyŒd¡|fg¢Nuyo€Žf]rpP€Žf%%«x®doqf%rzadfmg²|˜H´»t|&ŒFonuP©Fp~©d¡|ŠJuPkdfgu~¢»mqadfg­Foz†mexp~mnadf%egp~mntƒrtƒp~kF

mqu€Žf%¨yf¡|uyŒÉnuyegfµt|kSmnfoqf%m¢Nuyomnadfp~kFpy¡vŠŽnt|u~¢ oqpykF€ŽuPeÈnaFp~Œ:f%%{tD«fy«Jr¬Fon¨Pf%%«Äˆf¤bpy&¢NuP¡v¡|uH¤¥f]€

©ŠË•4pHmqadfoquyk²hyhT´¤ adu,¢Nuy¬dkV€Žf%€Ë¤ tvmna * f%onozpmnadfµ¢Nonf%kFrza=nrzaFuSuP¡Au~¢ expHmqadfexpHmqt|r%p~¡LeguPonŒdaFuy¡|uy}yŠ

pykF€¹©SŠ=¯‰pT¨t|€&fkV€dp~¡|¡&²“~‘d{»“~—Ž{“%´ˆpykF€=adtƒxruP¡v¡|f%py}y¬df]{»fy«}F« * exp~¡|¡²‘“]´D«³jlkpy€d€Žtvmnt|uykO{¥p~kV€

t|kF€Žf%ŒVf%kF€Žf%kPmq¡vŠP{0pµoqt|rzaJ©:uŽ€ŽŠ,u~¢LmqadfuPonŠ,p~kV€4Œdozpyrsmqt|rf¢NuPo.mnaFf@mqp~mntƒ†mqt|r%p~¡ p~kFpy¡vŠŽnt|ˆu~¢»naFp~Œ:f%ªaFpy

©:ff%k=€Žf¨Pf¡|uyŒ:f%€Ó©Š(Æuuy¦Žmnft|k²‘~´D{A¯ªonŠŽ€Žf%kËpykF€=•4pyoq€ŽtƒpÓ²v˜]hT´Ã{

%

pyonkdf4² T´Ã{

%

uSuymnf]{`pTŠ¡|uyop~kV€

ruy¡|¡vf]p~}P¬df%£²’~´D« Êdrf%ŒŽm&¢Nuyo&mqadfge@uS†mq¡vŠJmnadf%uyoqfmntƒrpy¡ ¤¥uPon¦,u~¢b®doqf%rzadfmp~kF€Ë•4pHmqadfoquykO{^mnadf@mnuuP¡|

€df¨yf%¡vuPŒVf]€©Šmqadf%nf.p~¬Žmqaduyoz p~oqf¥¨PfoqŠe¬Frza£mnt|f%€£mquªmqadf Œ:uyt|kPmnwD¤ tƒnf¥oqfŒdoqf%nfkSmzpHmnt|uyk£u~¢Vmnadf naFp~Œ:f%

mqadfŠ±mn¬V€ŽŠ¸uy©d…†f%rsmz,p~oqfoqfŒdoqf%nfkSmnf]€ ©Š±p=­Vkdt§mqf(k¬de£©Vf%o,u~¢£qp~¡|tvf%kSmŒ:uyt|kSmquyo¡|pykF€Žexp~oq¦Ž«

`baFt|‰tƒªpykt|e@Œ:uyonmqpykSm‰€Žtv½:f%onf%kFrf@¤ tvmnauP¬do‰¤¥uPon¦,¤ adtƒrza€Žf]p~¡ƒˆfʁŒF¡vtƒrtvmnf%¡vŠ4¤ tvmnaËr¬doq¨yf]ˆpPªn¬Frza1{

t|kF€Žf%ŒVf%kF€Žf%kPmq¡vŠu~¢mnadf%tvo.qp~egŒd¡|t|kd}guyo f¨PfkŒFp~ozp~egfmnoqtvÍ]pHmnt|uykO«

jlkÓf½^f%rm%{0uy¬Fo‰¤uyoq¦©Vf]p~ozªeguPonf£onf]f%e©d¡ƒp~kFrf¤ tvmnamnaFp~m&uy¢¥nf¨yf%oqpy¡Ouymnadf%o&py¬ŽmnaFuyoz« 1t|¦yf@t|k

ԉoqfkVp~kF€Žf%o  mqadfuPonŠu~¢¥ŒFpHmnmnfoqkF£²“d˜~{0“y“]´Ã{^¤¥f@ruykVtƒ€Žfo&naFp~Œ:f%ªpyªŒVuPtvkSmqªu~¢p~kJt|kŽ­Fkdtvmnfg€Žt|egfkŽw

nt|uykFpy¡dexp~kdtv¢Nuy¡ƒ€@©d¬Žm¥¤f.€Žukduym»eguŽ€Žf¡Fmnadf.¨HpyontƒpHmqtvuPkF u~¢^mnaFfˆaVp~Œ:f%A©Š£mnadfˆpPrsmqtvuPk@uy¢1t|f }yoquy¬dŒF

uPkmnadtƒˆexpykdt§¢NuP¡|€1{FfÊdrfŒŽmˆt|k,mnaFfrpPfuy¢An¬Frza,­FkFt§mqfwl€Žtvegf%kFt|uykVp~¡ Otvf}PonuP¬dŒF pP.oqtv}Pt|€,€ŽtƒŒF¡|pPrfw

egf%kPmzÐmnozp~kV¡ƒpHmqtvuPk(p~kV€Joqu~mqp~mnt|uykˆuyo&pxkdf£mnozp~kV†¢NuPonexpHmqtvuPkFNt|kFr¡|¬F€Žt|kd}4nr%p~¡|tvkF}s«®Fuyo&t|kŽ­Fkdtvmnf

€dtvegfkVt|uykFpy¡¥}PonuP¬dŒF£¬Frza³py@€Žtv½:f%uyeguyoqŒdadtƒex²v˜%‘d{ ‘T´ ¤ adtƒrza¹neguu~mnaF¡vŠ=rzaFpykd}yfµmnadfuy©Ž…†f]rsmz

naFpyŒVf]bŒdonf%¨tvuP¬F p~¬ŽmqaduyozbaFpT¨Pfª©:ff%kJ€ŽfŒ:fkF€dfkSm.¬dŒ:uykmnadf£rzaduytƒrf&u~¢ ŒFpyoqpye@fmnoqtvÍ]pHmqtvuPkF¥pykF€uyoqt§w

}PtvkVLu~¢ruuyoz€Žt|kFpHmqf% ² ~”Ž{d˜~{P‘S’Ž{S‘S{Žh~‘F{“yhT´D«A®Fuyo¥mnadf%e{¤bp~oqŒdt|kd}pnaFpyŒVfªuykSmnupykdu~mqadfo¥onf]ÌS¬dtvoqf%

mqadfruykFmnoq¬Frmnt|uykËu~¢b¢7p~egt|¡vt|f%£u~¢.€Žtv½^fuyeguPonŒdaFt|nexmnaVpHm¬Fnfxmqadf%nfŒFpyoqpyegfmnoqt|Í%pHmqtvuPkF%«4‡ª¬do@p~ŒŽw

ŒFonuSpyrza1{Ž©FpPf]€¬dŒVuPk,mnadf¬Ffu~¢mnadf€dt|mqpykFrf¢N¬FkFrsmqtvuPkF{:€Žuf% kFu~mˆoqf%ÌS¬dt|onf‰mqadfp~oq©dtvmnozp~oqŠrzaduPt|rf

uy¢1ŒFp~ozp~egfmnoqtvÍ]pHmnt|uykV»p~kV€xuyoqtv}PtvkV« ®doquyeuy¬Fo¥¨t|f¤ Œ:uyt|kPm¥mnadtƒt|p~¡|oqf%py€dŠ£¨PfoqŠ@kFt|rfˆt|kµm†¤u£€Žt|egfkŽw

nt|uykFA©F¬Žm»©:f%ruPegf%Af%¨yfkgkdtƒrf%oLt|kgmnadoqffˆ€dtvegfkVt|uykF»p~kF€gadt|}yaFfoA¤ adf%onf ­VkF€Žt|kd}ŒFp~ozp~egfmnoqtvÍ]pHmnt|uykV

pykF€mnozpyrz¦t|kd}xuyoqt|}yt|kF u~¢»ruuyoz€ŽtvkVpHmnf].rpyk4©Vf@pxoqf%p~¡Œdoquy©d¡|fe¥mnadtƒˆtƒ.kFu~mªoqf%ÌS¬dt|oqf%€tvkuy¬do‰rpynfy«

kdu~mqadfoŒdtvf]rfµuy¢oqf¡ƒpHmqf%€Ó¤uyoq¦Jt|mnaFp~mu~¢ * uSpHmmquJp~kF€Lf%ÍÍtª²‘ShT´¥¤ aFu,mqpyrz¦¡|fgmnadfŒdonuP©d¡|fe uy¢

…†uPtvkSmq¡vŠgfʁmqoqpPrsmnt|kd}pykF€µrzaFpyoqpPrsmqfoqtvÍ%tvkd}&mqadfˆeguymnt|uykµuy¢pnaFp~Œ:fªpykF€xtvmqb€Žf¢NuPonexp~mnt|uyk1«jlkµuyoz€Žf%oLmnu

€duxmnadtƒˆmnadf%Š­VkF€4t|kFŒFtvozpHmqtvuPkt|k4mqadf£py©VuH¨Pf¤¥uPon¦uyk,mnaFf¬Fnfuy¢A€dt§½^fuPe@uPonŒFadt|nexˆpykF€,ŒdoquyŒ:uPnf

mqadfµ¬Fnfµuy¢ p€Žt|mqpykFrfx©:fm†¤ff%k=aVp~Œ:f%7©Fpynf%€ËuPkÓmnadffmwlŠegegfmnoqtƒrx€Žt§½^foqfkVrf€Žf]nront|©:f%€Ët|k

nf%rmnt|uyk,“Ž«ï“s« `badtƒ €Žtƒ†mzp~kFrfªŒ:uPnf%pk¬de£©Vf%obu~¢ŒFonuP©d¡vf%exLmqaFpHm ¤fªpy€F€Žonf]n¥t|kmqadfnpye@f‰f]rsmqtvuPk

¤ aFfoqf‰¤f&ŒdoquyŒ:uPnfˆm†¤ugu~mnaFfo.€Žtƒ†mzp~kFrf%b¤ adtƒrza,¤¥f&©:f¡|tvf%¨yf‰mnux©:feguyoqf‰n¬dtvmqpy©d¡vfP«

* uPegfAu~¢mnadf]fLpy¬ŽmnaFuyoz^aFpT¨yfAp~¡ƒnubmnoqtvf]€ˆmqu ©d¬dt|¡|€p ‹.tvf%egpykdkdtƒp~kmnoq¬Frsmq¬donfAuPk‰mnadf»nfm1uy¢naFpyŒVf]{

tD«fy«mnug}yu¢NonuPe p~ktvkd­Fkdtvmnf%nt|egpy¡^e@fmnoqt|r&mnoq¬Frsmq¬doqfˆmqu@p£}y¡|uy©Fpy¡VuPkdfy«A`badf&t|kŽ­Fkdtvmnf]t|exp~¡1mnoq¬Frsmq¬doqf

tƒ&€Žf­Vkdf%€(©ŠJp~kt|kdkdf%o&ŒdonuŽ€Ž¬Vrsmtvkmnadf@mzp~kd}PfkSm&nŒFpPrfÐmnaFfgnfm&u~¢kduyoqexp~¡ €Žf¢NuPonexp~mnt|uykJ­Vf¡ƒ€d

pykF€£aFpymqu‰¨HpyonŠruykSmnt|k¬duy¬V¡|Š&¢NonuPe¿Œ:uyt|kPm mquŒVuPtvkSm%{yt8«fy«¢NonuPe+naFp~Œ:fmnunaFp~Œ:fy« `badf ‹ t|fexp~kdkFt|pyk

egfmnoqt|r&tƒbmnaFfk4¬Fnf%€mnuµruyegŒd¬Žmqf}yf%uŽ€Žf%nt|r&r¬don¨Pf%b©:fm†¤ff%km†¤uµnaFp~Œ:f% mnadf]f}yfuŽ€Žf]tƒr €df­Fkdf

p£¤bpTŠxu~¢¤bp~oqŒdt|kd}@ftvmnadf%o.aFpyŒVf&uPkPmqumqadf&u~mqadfo]«A`badt|btƒ €Žf]p~¡vmb¤ tvmna,t|kmqadf¤uyoq¦@uy¢`onuP¬d¨y‚&p~kV€

LuP¬dkdf]b²y”Ž{d˜~{~‘d{~‘P’Ž{y‘S{P“]´VpykF€0{~eguyoqfbonf]rf%kPmq¡vŠP{yt|k@mnadf ¤uyoq¦u~¢&¡|pPnnfkgp~kV€ * oqt|¨TpP†mzpT¨Hp£²ï“H´D{

py}PpytvkËpHmmqadfruPmu~¢ ¤¥uPon¦t|kd},¤ t§mqaɌFp~ozp~egfmnoqtvÍ]pHmnt|uykV«`baFfxŒdonuP©d¡|fe ¤ tvmna=mnadf]fµpyŒdŒdoquPpyrzaFf%%{

(8)

©:f%ntƒ€Žf‰mnaFp~m.u~¢aVpT¨St|kd}£mnux€Žf]p~¡0¤ tvmna,ŒFp~ozp~egfmnoqtvÍ]pHmnt|uykV»uy¢OmnaFfaFpyŒVf]{tƒbmnaVpHmbmnadf%onf&fʁtƒmb}P¡vuP©Fp~¡

egfmnoqt|r&mnoq¬Frsmq¬donf]uykmnadfnfm.uy¢naFp~Œ:f% 8f%f&nf%rmnt|uyk4“Ž«ï“»¤ adtƒrza,pyonf‰¬Fnf¢N¬d¡p~kF€onf%¡vf%¨Hp~kSm¥mqugmnadf

ŒFonuP©d¡vf%eu~¢1mqadf‰ruyegŒFpyontƒuPkxu~¢OnaFp~Œ:f%©d¬dm¥mqaFpHm €ŽukFu~m €Žfoqtv¨Pf.¢Noquye p~ktvkd­Fkdtvmnf%nt|egpy¡:mnoq¬Frmn¬doqfy«

‡ª¬Fo.p~ŒdŒdoquPpPrzar%p~k,©Vfnff%k4pymqpy¦tvkd}@mqadfŒdoquy©d¡|fe ¢NonuPe fÊdpyrmn¡|ŠµmqadfuyŒdŒ:uPntvmnf¨tvf%¤ ŒVuPtvkSmb¢Noquye

mqadf4Œdoqf¨t|uy¬FguPkdfJ¤fJmqp~onmx¤ t§mqa±pÓ}y¡|uy©Fpy¡ e@fmnoqt|r,uPk³mnadfnfmµuy¢&naFpyŒVf]µp~kF€³©d¬Ftv¡ƒ€eguu~mqa

¢N¬FkFrsmqtvuPkF Nt|kxf½^f%rm»eguu~mqaxp~ŒdŒdoquTʎtvexp~mnt|uykFu~¢:mnadf]f egfmnoqt|r%mqaFpHm»pyonf €Žtƒnnt|e@t|¡ƒp~oqt§m†Šegf]pyn¬donf]{

uPofkdf%on}PŠJ¢N¬dkVrsmnt|uykVA¤fgmnadf%kÉegtvkdt|egtvÍ%fxmnaFf%nfg¢N¬dkFrsmqtvuPkF¬Vt|kd},mnf]rzadkdtƒÌS¬df%u~¢mnadfr%p~¡ƒr¬d¡|¬Fuy¢

¨HpyontƒpHmqtvuPk(©ŠËruyegŒd¬dmnt|kd},mnadf%tvo£}yozpy€Žt|fkSmp~kV€ËŒVf%o¢NuPonegt|kd}4tvkd­Fkdtvmnf%nt|egpy¡L}yozpy€dtvf%kPm€df%qrfkSm mnaFt|

egt|kdt|e@t|Í%p~mnt|uyk€df­Fkdf]¥pykdu~mqadfo¥¤pTŠ@u~¢0¤bp~oqŒdt|kd}ftvmnaFfobaFpyŒVfªuykSmnumnadfªu~mnaFfo]«jlkµmnadtƒ»f%kF€Žf]pT¨yuy¬Fo

¤f@©d¬dt|¡|€(uykmnadfxnfegtvkVp~¡ ¤¥uPon¦4uy¢¥¯ªf¡v¢Nuy¬dopykF€Ó°:uP¡vf]t|u¤ aFuaFpT¨Pf£t|kSmnoquŽ€Ž¬Frf]€Jkdf%¤¿¢7pye@t|¡|tvf]ªuy¢

nfmz{VruyegŒd¡|fmqfegfmnoqtƒr‰mnuyŒ:uy¡|uy}Ptvf]{dpykF€4ruPegŒFpyrmnkdf]nmqadfuPonf%eg%«»`badtƒ ¤uyoq¦µtƒ kduH¤¼pT¨Tpytv¡ƒp~©F¡vf&t|k

©:uuy¦@¢Nuyoqe*²|˜y˜s´Ã«A`badfª©:uuy¦xŒdoquH¨t|€df%»p¢7p~t|on¡|Šx©doquPpP€xruH¨yf%oqpy}yf.pykF€p£ŠkSmnadfmntƒr.mqonf]pHmqe@f%kSmuy¢1mnadf

­Vf¡ƒ€p~¡|uykF}¤ tvmnaexpykSŠ,kdf%¤¿t|e@Œ:uyonmqpykSm‰oqf%n¬d¡vmq%{:fÊdp~egŒd¡|f%%{^pykF€ruykFmnoq¬Frmnt|uykFˆ¤ adt|rza(aFpT¨yf£kdu~m

©:ff%kˌd¬d©d¡|t|nadf]€(f%¡|nf¤ aFfoqfy«xjÃmq¢N¬d¡v¡»tvegŒFpPrsmuykËt|exp~}yfgŒdoquŽrf]nntvkF}pykF€ÓonuP©Vuymntƒr&aFpP&Šyfmmqu4©Vf

¢N¬F¡v¡|ŠpPnnf%qf]€0«

jlkÉmqadtƒ£pyomqt|r¡vfµ¤fpy¡|nu4oqf¨t|ntvmmnadfŒdoquy©d¡|feu~¢.ruyegŒd¬Žmqtvkd}(fegŒdt|ontƒrpy¡¥mqp~mntƒ†mqt|r%uyk¹fmquy¢

“y¯aVp~Œ:f% p~kV€ŒdoquyŒ:uPnf&p£kFf¤¼p~ŒdŒdoquPpPrzaµ©ŠruPe©dt|kdt|kd}xf%¨yf%oqpy¡:kFu~mnt|uykV ¬Frza,py¥mquyŒ:uy¡|uy}yt|f%uPk

nfm uy¢naFp~Œ:f%%{Žrp~¡ƒr¬F¡v¬Fbuy¢O¨Hp~oqt|p~mnt|uykF%{Žp~kF€nuyegfªegf]pyn¬donfªmnaFfuyoqŠy« * f]rsmqtvuPk,“£fmqmqadf†mzp~}yf&p~kV€

t|kSmnoquŽ€Ž¬Frf] uPe@f¥kdu~mzpHmqtvuPkF p~kF€mnuuy¡ƒ%«Ojlk@ŒFp~onmntƒr¬d¡ƒp~ot|k£nf%rsmqtvuPkg“d«“.¤¥fb€Žtƒnr¬FqOmqadoqffbu~¢dmqadfbexp~t|k

mquyŒ:uy¡|uy}Ptvf]LmqaFpHm.rpyk©:f€Žf­Vkdf%€uykfmqbu~¢ aVp~Œ:f%bp~kF€egu~mnt|¨HpHmqfªmqadfrzaduytƒrf‰u~¢m†¤¥u@u~¢mnadf%e,«Ajlk

nf%rmnt|uykÓh¤f£t|kSmnoquŽ€Ž¬Frf@mqadfgŒFp~onmntƒr¬d¡ƒp~o&nfmu~¢¥naFpyŒVf]ª¤fg¤¥uPon¦,¤ tvmnaÓtvk(mnaFt|&ŒFpyŒVf%o%{1naduH¤mqaFpHm

tvmxaFpy@kdtƒrf4ruyegŒFpyrmnkdf]n@ŒdoquyŒ:fonmnt|f%@p~kV€=mqaFpHmgmnaFfmqadoqffmnuPŒVuP¡vuP}yt|f%@€Žf­FkFf%€¹tvk¹mnadf,Œdoqf¨t|uy¬F

nf%rmnt|uykxp~oqfbtvk@¢7pPrsm»f]ÌP¬Ftv¨Hp~¡|fkSmLuPk£mqadtƒLfm»u~¢0naFp~Œ:f%%«jlkxnf%rmnt|uykg‘¤¥f t|kSmnoquŽ€Ž¬Frf uPkdf u~¢:mnaFf.©Fpyntƒr

mquuy¡ƒ ¤¥fb¬Fnf¢NuyoLruPegŒd¬Žmnt|kd}naFp~Œ:f †mzpHmqt|mntƒr%{~tD«fP«v{P}yt|¨yfkgp‰egf%pyn¬doqf¥uy¢Vmqadf.€Žtƒnnt|e@t|¡ƒp~oqt§m†Š©:fm†¤ff%k

m†¤u4aVp~Œ:f%%{Omqadfr¬Fon¨Pf@}PoqpP€Žt|fkSm Ö uH¤ mqaFpHm£t|¬Vf]€ÓmnuJ€Žf¢NuyoqeÈp4naFp~Œ:fxtvkSmquJp~kduymnadf%o%«ÄˆpT¨tvkF}

eguymnt|¨Tp~mnf]€@mnadf.t|kSmnoquŽ€Ž¬FrsmqtvuPkgu~¢^mnadfˆe@f]pyn¬doqf% u~¢1€Žtƒqt|egtv¡ƒp~oqt§m†ŠP{~¤f.Œdoqurff]€£t|kµnf%rsmqtvuPk ‰¤ t§mqaxmnadf

ruykFmnoq¬Frmnt|uykxu~¢Or¡|pPnnf%»u~¢On¬Frzaµegf%pP¬Fonf]A¤ adtƒrzap~oqf.©FpPf]€guykxmqadf‰t|€Žf]pu~¢OpyŒdŒdoquTʎtvexpHmqtvkF}uPegf

uy¢OmqadfaFpyŒVf€Žtƒmqp~kVrf%¥mqaFpHm aFpT¨Pfª©:ff%kŒdoqf%nfkSmqf%€tvk,f]rsmqtvuPk“Ž«ï“Ž¤f&p~¡ƒu@ŒdoquH¨yf.mqadfruPkSmnt|kS¬Ft§m†Š

uy¢1uy¬dop~ŒdŒFonuTʎt|egp~mnt|uykF ¤ tvmnaonf]Œ:f%rm»mnumnadf]fª€Žt|mqpykFrf]¥pykF€xruPegŒd¬Žmnfˆmnadf‰ruPonoqf%nŒVuPkF€Žt|kd}r¬Fon¨Pf

}PoqpP€Žt|fkSm Ö uH¤.«`badt| ©:ft|kd}nfmmq¡vf]€0{y¤f p~oqf¥t|kxp‰ŒVuStvmnt|uyk£mnu&¤bp~oqŒ£p~kŠ}Ptv¨PfkgaFpyŒVfbuPkPmqu‰pykdu~mqadfo

©Š@uP¡v¨t|kd}‰mnadfˆ„ pyomqt|py¡d¯ˆtv½:f%onf%kSmntƒp~¡ LÌS¬Fp~mnt|uyk 7„»¯ ¥pHmnmqpPrzadf%€mnu&mqadf.ŒFpyomqt|r¬d¡|pyoLr¬doq¨yfb}PoqpP€Žtvf%kSm

Ö uH¤«`badtƒŒdoquy©F¡vf%e tƒmn¬F€Žt|f%€Ët|k=nf%rsmqtvuPk=—,¤ adfoqfxfÊdpye@ŒF¡vf]p~oqfµp~¡ƒu4ŒFonf]f%kPmqf%€0«jlk=f]rsmqtvuPk

Ž«v˜¤¥f¬Vf@p~¡|¡Omqadf%nfmquSuP¡|.mnu€Žf­FkFf£pxegf%pykŽwlaFpyŒVf£p~kF€,mquŒdoquH¨t|€dfp~¡|}yuyoqtvmnadex ¢NuPoªruyegŒd¬Žmqtvkd}

tvm‰¢NonuPe npye@ŒF¡vfgaVp~Œ:f£fʎpyegŒd¡vf]«jlkӍf]rsmqtvuPk «ï“Ž{^¤f£fʁmnfkV€4mnaFf@kFu~mnt|uyku~¢ruH¨Hp~oqt|pykFrfexp~mnoqt§Ê

uy¢ pxnfm.uy¢Lnpye@ŒF¡vf]mnugmnaVpHmˆuy¢ pxruH¨Tpyontƒp~kVrf u~¢Apxfm.u~¢Lqp~egŒd¡|faFpyŒVffÊdp~egŒd¡|f%¢Noquye

¤ aFt|rzamnaFfkdu~mqtvuPkuy¢ŒFont|kFrt|ŒFpy¡1egu€df% uy¢¨Hp~oqtƒpHmnt|uyk¢Nuy¡|¡|uH¤.bkFpHmq¬doqpy¡v¡|Šy«»Ò(f€Žtƒqr¬Fq.nuyegf€Žfmzp~t|¡|

uy¢uP¬do tvegŒd¡|fegf%kPmzpHmqtvuPkuy¢Omqadf%nfp~¡|}yuPontvmnadext|k,nf%rmnt|uyk,’gp~kF€ruPkFr¡|¬F€Žft|knf%rmnt|uyk

( " ($-

`u,€Žf­FkFf¢N¬d¡|¡|Š,mnadfgkduymnt|uykuy¢¥paFpyŒVf£t|‰©:fŠPuykF€JmnadfxqruyŒ:fuy¢LmnaFt|pyomqt|r¡vf£tvkÓ¤ adtƒrza¤f¬Fnf@p

¡|t|e@tvmnf]€0{dtD«f&Œd¬Fonf%¡vŠ sÎ {F€Žf­Vkdt§mqtvuPk1«AjÃm.ruP¬d¡|€©:fp~oq}y¬df]€xmnaVpHmbmnadf&Œ:fozrf%ŒŽmn¬Fpy¡1aVp~Œ:f‰uy¢pyk

(9)

uP©Ž…†f%rmpy¡|nu€Žf%ŒVf%kF€d¬dŒ:uykxmqadf‰€dt|mnoqtv©F¬Žmnt|tvuPkµu~¢1t|¡|¡v¬degt|kFpHmqtvuPk1{Smnadf‰oqf

Ö

f]rsmqpykFrfªp~kF€gmqfʁmn¬Fonf‰u~¢1tvmq

n¬don¢7pyrf Vmnadf]f@pynŒVf]rsmq‰p~oqfkduym‰€Žtƒqr¬Fqf]€4t|k4mnadtƒªŒFp~Œ:fo]«ˆjlk(uy¬do‰ruykSmqfʁmª¤f€Žf­FkdfgpµaVp~Œ:fmnu

©:fµpegf%pyn¬dozp~©d¡|fx¬F©Ffmu~¢ ¶

· « *

t|kFrfx¤¥fxp~oqfx€Žoqtv¨PfkÓ©SŠ(tvexpy}yfxp~ŒdŒF¡vtƒrp~mnt|uykF&¤fxp~¡ƒu4pyqn¬degf

mqaFpHmˆpy¡v¡Ouy¬do.naFp~Œ:f% pyonfruykSmqpytvkdf]€t|k4pgaduy¡ƒ€wlp~¡|¡0uyŒ:fk,©:uy¬dkF€df%€,¬F©Ffm.u~¢A¶ ·x¤ adtƒrza¤f€ŽfkFu~mnf

©ŠJ«L`badfonf]py€Žf%o rp~kmnaFtvkd¦u~¢ pPmnadftvexpy}yf~«

jlk mqadfJkdfʁmnf%rsmqtvuPk¤¥fJ¤ t|¡|¡ªoqf%mnoqt|rmµuy¬dotvkSmnf%onf]†mmnu¸pÉeguPonf4¡|tvegtvmnf]€±fmuy¢naFpyŒVf]x©d¬Žm

ŒFonf]f%kPmq¡vŠµmnadtƒbt|ˆ¬ µrtvf%kPmbmquµp~¡|¡vuH¤±¬Vbmnugt|kPmqonuŽ€Ž¬VrfuPegf‰egfmnaduŽ€db¢NuPo onf%Œdoqf%nfkSmnt|kd}gaFpyŒVf]«

*

tvkFrfy{pP,e@f%kSmnt|uykdf]€\t|kÅmnadfÉt|kSmnoquŽ€Ž¬FrsmqtvuPk1{¤fÓ¤bp~kSm4mqu³©:f=t|kF€Žf%ŒVf%kF€ŽfkSmJuy¢gpykSŠÇŒFp~onmntƒr¬d¡ƒp~o

ŒVp~ozp~egfmqontƒnp~mnt|uykÓu~¢ mqadfnaFp~Œ:fy{ ¤fµ¬Fnfµm†¤u4exp~t|k=tvkF}yoqf%€Žt|fkSmq%{mnadf DÎ Ñ ŽÏ DÎHÏuy¢

pgnaFp~Œ:f

! #"%$!&(' tv¢

"*)

p~kV€ + tv¢

"-,) .

pykF€mnadf/~Î »Ñ ŽÏ DÎHÏgmqugpxnaFpyŒVf

0 1"2$&436587

9;:

=<>=?

" <

&@365A7

9;:

0 #"

. > $

tv¢BDC

&FE

p~kF€ GIH tv¢J

&KEAL

u~mqfªmqadft|e@Œ:uyonmqpykSmbŒFonuPŒVf%om†ŠJ²|˜y˜y{FrzaFp~Œdmnfob‘V{Žmnadf%uyoqfe “d«v˜´

˜ 0

NM&

0

NOQPSR

Á & ·

¡|nuˆuy¢Ft|kPmqfoqf%mtƒOmnadf €Žtƒ†mzp~kFrfL¢N¬dkVrsmnt|uyk£mnuˆmnadf ruyegŒd¡|fegfkSmuy¢dmnaFfbnaFpyŒVfP{ 08T

pykF€mqadfb€Žt|mqpykFrf

¢N¬FkFrsmqtvuPkmqugt§mz ©VuP¬dkF€dpyonŠP{

0U

«AjlkmqadfrpPf&¤ adf%onf

&V

±pykF€W±tƒ.r¡|uPnf%€1{S¤faFpT¨Pf

0

X&

0 U 0AT

& +

ÒÓf,kdu~mqfWY[Z $

mqadf4fm@uy¢‰€Žtƒmqp~kVrf¢N¬dkFrsmqtvuPkF@u~¢‰kduykdf%egŒŽm†Š=fmq@u~¢4« * t|egtv¡ƒp~oq¡|Šy{L¤fkFu~mnf

Y]\

Z $

mnadfnfm.uy¢€Žtƒmqp~kVrf&¢N¬dkFrmnt|uykF mnu@mnadfruyegŒd¡|fegfkSmzbu~¢ uyŒ:fk,¬d©Vfmq uy¢^ ТNuPobmnf%rzaFkdt|r%p~¡

oqf%pPuPkF¥¤ adt|rza4pyonf‰tvoqoqf¡|f¨Hp~kSm adfoqfy{Žtvm.tƒ ¬ µrtvf%kPm mquxruykVtƒ€Žfo uPŒVf%k4fmq

kdu~mqadfo ¢N¬FkFrsmqtvuPkuy¢}Ponf]pHm tvkSmqfoqf%mbtƒmnaFf sÎ Ï _/`/HÎ ÑŽÏ DÎHÏba

€Žf­Vkdf%€,py

a

*&

0 ? 08T

u~mqfªmqaFpHm ¢NuPo.r¡|uPnf%€fmq n¬FrzamnaFp~mc

&FV

‰{ŽuykdfaFpPQa

& 0 «

ÒÓf&©dont|f Ö Š@oqf%r%p~¡|¡:nuyegf‰¤¥f%¡v¡:¦kduH¤ koqf%n¬d¡vmqp~©:uy¬ŽmmnaFf%nfˆm†¤u¢N¬dkVrsmnt|uykV«L`badf‰t|kPmqf}Poqpy¡Vuy¢1mnadf

rzaVp~ozpyrsmqfoqt|mntƒr ¢N¬FkFrsmqtvuPktƒ f]ÌP¬Vp~¡^mnu@mqadfegf%pyn¬doqf 7p~oqf%ped $ uy¢!

f #"%$

0

"g&

d $

u~mqfˆmqaFpHmbmnaFt|bt|kSmnf}Poqpy¡:€duSf]kdu~m rzaFp~kF}yfˆtv¢¤f&py€d€µmnuguyob¬F©Žmnozpyrm¥¢NoquyehÇpegf%pP¬Foqpy©d¡vf‰fmuy¢

Of©:f%n}y¬df&egf%pP¬Fonf&”7p~¡ƒnugr%p~¡|¡vf]€p@kdf%}y¡|tv}Ptv©F¡vfnfm «

(10)

%

uPkFrf%onkdt|kd}4mqadf€dt|mqpykFrfx¢N¬FkFrsmqtvuPkF{ mqadfŠÉpyonfruykSmnt|k¬duy¬V{tvk¸f½^f%rsm1t|ŒFqrzadtvmnÍruykSmnt|k¬duy¬F

¤ tvmna4p 1t|ŒFqrzadtvmnÍruPkF†mzp~kSm f%ÌS¬Fpy¡^mnu4˜g²d{1˜y˜s´

<0 #"%$

? 0 > $

< <" ? >2<

" . > . ) L

`baVp~kd¦Ž»mnumqadf&‹.py€Žf%expyrzadf%oLmnaFfuyoqfe²|˜ ]´Ã{SmnadtƒtvegŒd¡|t|f%»mnaFp~m 0

tƒb€Žt§½^foqfkSmqt|py©d¡vf‰p~¡|eguPm¥f¨PfoqŠSw

¤ aFfoqf‰t|k 4{FtD«fy«LuP¬Žmqnt|€dfu~¢Ap£kFf}y¡|t|}yt|©d¡vfnfm]{Fp~kV€mqaFpHm mqadfexp~}Pkdt§mq¬F€Žfuy¢tvmq }PoqpP€Žt|fkSm%{Ž¤ adf%k4t§m

fʎt|mq%{Žt|b¡|f%qbmqaFp~kuyo f]ÌP¬Vp~¡^mnu,˜

< 0 e 1"2$

<

'

pd«fy«

L

`baFf&qp~egf&tƒbmnoq¬df&u~¢ 08T

p~kV€Wa

7t§¢

V

DC

&FE

¢NuyobmnaFff]ruykV€ s{1²|˜y˜y{ % aFp~ŒŽmqfo d{Žmnadf%uyoqfe ’F«v˜´D«

% ¡|uPnf¡|Šoqf¡ƒpHmqf%€mquµmnaFf¨Hp~oqtvuP¬Fˆ€dt|mqpykFrf¢N¬FkFrsmqtvuPkF 7eguyoqfŒdoqf%rtƒnf¡|ŠmquµmnaFft|oˆ}yozpy€dtvf%kPmz.p~oqf

mqadfŒdoqu~…†f]rsmnt|uykV pyquŽrtƒpHmqf%€¤ t§mqa ÇpykF€ ‰«»`badf]fpyonfpy¡|nugonf%¡|p~mnf%€mqugmnadfkduymnt|uyk,u~¢An¦yf¡|fmquyk1«

ÒÓfoqf%rpy¡v¡0nuyegf€Žf­Vkdt§mqtvuPkF%«L`badf&­Foz†m uykFf‰tƒ.pP€dp~ŒŽmqf%€¢NonuPe ²|˜y˜~{

%

aVp~ŒŽmqfo ‘x€Žf­Vkdt§mqtvuPk4hd«|˜´

œ '  ' Ÿ~œ ' ›µž ) › ( œ ' ›

ÎÏX"!F$#! C

& E&%

(') C

& E*

# Ñ ,+ 8Î~Ï Ñ

" ) HÏ*

%

'HÏ

* Î~ÎÏ.-0/

1 1"2$32465&87:9W)

<;

<9 ? " < & 0 1"2$=

(':1 T

1"2$ 2465&87:9W) >;

<9 ? " < & 0 T 1"2$= $

? 0@ Ï ÑA1

1"2$B%

('C1 T

#"%$D*

& @E@_/ ,+ DÎHÏ %

' * '

ÎÏ F! $#c C

& E>%

('& C

& E*

# †Ñ ~ÎÐÏ HG ,+ 8Î~Ï HÏ-

%

('A * Î ŽÏFÎDI @E@ / (

%

('ˆÎÐÏ

*

KJL@~ÏNMOJPRQTS

$U%

('

MOJLVXWS

$D*

'ZY /R[LÏ \MOJ

$&

MOJPRQTS

$(]

M^J0V_WS $ '

`badf¢Nuy¡|¡vuH¤ t|kd}xŒdoquyŒ:fonmnt|f%ˆu~¢ mnadf£¦Pf¡|fmnuPkF.r%p~k4©:f¢Nuy¬dkV€4fy«}F«bt|kɲv˜P˜~{

%

aVp~ŒŽmqfoˆ‘V{dmqadfuPonf%eg

hF«v˜&p~kV€hF«“H´

 '` ' › œ ' ?

%

& '±ÎÐÏ

*

KJ0@ Î R@_/ ^- †Ña %

('

Ñ\bdcfe

$R*

G ‰Ñ ŽÏ 8Î~Ï 0 %

' 0 T * ÎÏ ]/HÎg Ï DÎ h-0@i'&j !

~ÏN/ËÎÐÏ KJ0@ ~ÏN/ k-ŽÏN/ T/

V Î l@X/ ^- ÑSmG 08U

ÎÏ

/~Îg Ï 8Î -T@'

mf%pPrza

"

uy¢A on

*

¦hpdqTr $

{0mqadfg}yozpy€Žt|fkSm&u~¢Lmqadfµ€Žtƒ†mzp~kFrf¢N¬FkFrsmqtvuPk 0 U

tƒ&¤f¡|¡§wl€Žf­Vkdf%€0{0uy¢

¬Fkdt§m¥kduyoqe,{Pp~kV€£Œ:uyt|kSmq¥pT¤pTŠ&¢Noquye mnadf.ŒFonuy…†f%rsmqtvuPk

> & 1 e 1"2$

uy¢

"

uykSmnu=‰{Sf%f ­F}y¬Fonf&˜y«

*

t|egtv¡ƒp~o

ruykFntƒ€ŽfozpHmqtvuPkF¥pyŒdŒd¡|Šµmqu£mqadfrpPf&¤ adf%onf

" )

‰«

ÒÓftvkSmqonuŽ€Ž¬Frfp~k4py€d€dt§mqtvuPkFp~¡1€Žf­Fkdtvmnt|uykmnaVpHm ¤ tv¡|¡1©:f¬Fnf¢N¬d¡1t|kmnadfnf%ÌS¬df%¡8«

œ 'ts

ÎÏW<! $#%DC

&KE

# ~ÏN/ &&u@0Ï v-& w$x +# yw{z ^- @ªÏ$Î- /

ÑQ Î=/R[LÏ /

|3} $ 2465&87

> )

~; 0

e

>

$C

w =

(11)

®t|}y¬doqfg˜

kfÊdp~egŒd¡|f‰uy¢n¦yf%¡vfmnuykV«

1 [ ! #"%$](A&$]('&)%

`baFfªkdfʁmÌS¬df%mnt|uyk¤¥fª¤pykSm»mnugpy€F€Žonf]n»t|¥mqaFpHmbu~¢0mqadf€Žf­FkFt§mqtvuPku~¢0mqadf&t|egtv¡ƒp~oqt§m†Šg©:fm†¤ff%kµm†¤u

naFpyŒVf]«»`baFt|.ÌS¬df]†mqtvuPk,u~¢At|egtv¡ƒp~oqt§m†Št|ªr¡|uPnf¡|ŠruPkdkdf%rmnf]€mqugmnaFp~m.u~¢AegfmqontƒrbuPk,nfmz u~¢AnaFp~Œ:f%

¤ aFt|rzaËt|kËmn¬doqkÓmnuy¬Vrzadf%&mqaFpHm£u~¢b¤ aFpHmtƒ¦kduH¤ kËpynaFpyŒVfgmquyŒ:uy¡|uy}yt|f%%«µÒÓfµkduH¤ ©doqtvf Ö Šoqf¨t|f¤

mqadoqff&exp~t|k,nt|e@t|¡ƒp~oqt§m†Šxegf%pP¬Fonf]¥©:fm†¤ff%k4aFpyŒVf]b¤ adtƒrzamq¬donk,uP¬Žm mnux€Žf­Fkdf&mnaFonf%f&€dt|mqpykFrf]«

s s *,+ žŽHždŸyœ  ›œ Ÿ.- Ÿyœ ' ›

`baFf&nt|e@t|¡ƒp~oqt§m†Šµegf]pyn¬donf&¤fp~oqf&py©VuP¬Žmbmnuµ€Žf­Fkdftƒb©Fpynf%€¬dŒ:uykmnaFfrzaFp~ozpyrmnfoqtƒ†mqt|rˆ¢N¬dkFrmnt|uykF uy¢

mqadfªm†¤¥u@aFpyŒVf]¤¥f‰¤pykSm»mnugruPegŒFp~oqfy«Ò(f&€Žf%kdu~mqfª©Š0/ $

mqadffmuy¢rzaFpyoqpPrsmnf%ontƒmntƒrb¢N¬dkFrmnt|uykF

uy¢egf%pP¬Foqpy©d¡vf&n¬d©Fnfmq.u~¢^J«

ԉt|¨yf%km†¤ug¬Frza4nfmzQ

Á

p~kF€W

·

{d¤f€Žf­Vkdf&mnadf%tvoª€Žt|mqpykFrf

1 · Á . · $ &32 M ? O425

O

&76 f8

1 M #"2$

? O #"2$ $· 0

"9 Á;:n·

`baFt|.€df­Fkdtvmnt|uyk4py¡|nuxaduH¤.mqaFpHmˆmnadtƒ egf%pP¬doqf€Žuf% kFu~m nff8ˆ€dt§½^foqfkFrf% ©:fm†¤ff%km†¤¥uxnaFp~Œ:f%

mqaFpHm p~oqfLu~¢degf]pyn¬donf¥” 7nff»­F}y¬Fonfb“ py€dpyŒŽmnf]€&¢Noquye²v˜P˜~{ % aFpyŒŽmnf%ohd{~®t|}y¬doqf»hF«v˜´Ot|kFrf»mnadf¥tvkSmqf}yozp~¡

€duSf] kduymˆrzaFp~kd}Pf&t§¢ ¤¥feguŽ€Žtv¢NŠmqadf¨Hp~¡|¬df%.u~¢

%NM uyo

%NO

uH¨yf%okFf}y¡|t|}yt|©d¡vfnfmz«»jlk4u~mnaFfo ¤uyoz€d{

mqadtƒgt|gkduymµpӀdt|mqpykFrf,©:fm†¤ffk¹mnaFfm†¤uˍaFpyŒVf]b

Á

p~kF€ ·

©d¬Žmx©:fm†¤ffk¹mnaFft|oxf%ÌS¬dt|¨Tpy¡vf%kFrf

r¡|pPnnf%<

Á>=?

pykF€@<

·=A?

u~¢»egf%pP¬Foqpy©d¡vf£fmq%«Ô‰t|¨yf%kpe@f]pyn¬dozp~©d¡|fn¬d©Fnfm u~¢ 4{^¤f@€df­Fkdf

tvmq‰f]ÌP¬Ftv¨Hp~¡|fkVrfgr¡ƒpyq< =?

pPB< =? & 7 DC

<

DCtƒ egf%pP¬dozp~©F¡vf&p~kF€ FEIDCtƒ kdf}P¡vt|}yt|©d¡|f

=

{0¤ aFfoqf

FE DC0tƒmnadfnŠe@egfmnoqt|r&€Žtv½:f%onf%kFrf

GE C & C ]

H

`baFfŒdoquu~¢ mqaFpHm@mnadtƒ@€Žf­FkFf%gp€Žtƒmqp~kVrfµ¢NuP¡v¡|uH¤.¢Noquyemqadfµ¢7pPrsm@mnaFp~m£mqadf,º»·µkFuyoqe€df­Fkdf]£p

€dt|mqpykFrf‰uH¨yf%o¥mqadffm u~¢f]ÌS¬dtv¨Hpy¡vf%kFrf&r¡ƒpyqf]u~¢qÌS¬Fp~oqfˆt|kSmnf%}yozp~©d¡|fˆ¢N¬FkFrsmqtvuPkF 7nff&fy«}F«b²hŽ{0˜

(12)

®t|}y¬doqf“ L`¤¥uµnaFpyŒVf]b¤ aduPnf€Žt|mqpykFrf

1 ·

tƒ f%ÌS¬Fpy¡0mnux” N

Á

t|buP©ŽmqpytvkFf%€©ŠoqfeguH¨tvkd}£¢Noquye@

·

mqadf&mnaFonf%f&r¬doq¨yf%Y

Á { Y · { Y

1 · Á . ·

$&

+

`badtƒxtƒgkdtƒrf4p~kF€¹uykFfaVpygf¨Pfk¹e@uPonf ²v˜P˜~{

%

aVp~ŒŽmqfoµhd{`badfuPonf%e “Ž«|˜´mnadfJnfm0/ $ t|

r¡vuSf]€=p~kV€É©VuP¬dkF€Žf]€=t|k¸º»· $ p~kV€

1 · . $

€df­Fkdf]£p(ruPe@ŒF¡vfmnfe@fmnoqt|r†mqon¬Vrsmn¬FonfuykÉmqadfnfm

uy¢.f%ÌS¬dt|¨Hp~¡|fkFrfr¡|pPnnf%u~¢ˆegf%pP¬Foqpy©d¡vf¬d©Vfmq£u~¢4«

u~mnfmnaVpHm

1 ·

t|@r¡|uPnf¡|ŠËonf%¡|p~mnf]€Ëmnu(mnadf

nŠege@fmnoqt|r&€Žtv½^foqfkFrf

1 · Á . ·

$=&

d Á E · $ MO

`baFf‰ruyegŒd¡|fmnf%kdf%qt|t|egŒVuPomzp~kSmt|kpyŒdŒd¡|t|r%pHmqtvuPkF p~kŠ % py¬FrzaŠgnf%ÌS¬df%kFrfªu~¢ rzaFp~ozpyrmnfoqtƒ†mqt|rb¢N¬FkFrsw

mqtvuPkF

7 =

ruPk¨yfoq}yf]¢NuPoxmnaFt|µ€dt|mqpykFrfmnu=pËrzaFpyoqpPrsmqfoqt|mntƒrµ¢N¬FkFrsmqtvuPk

u~¢&pË¡vt|egt§mnfm`‰«

ˆkŽ¢Nuyonmn¬FkFpHmqf¡|Š@t|kpyŒdŒd¡|t|r%pHmqtvuPkFLkduymbpy¡v¡^nf%ÌS¬dfkVrf%¥p~oqf % py¬FrzaŠ@nf%ÌS¬df%kFrf]{P¢NuyofÊdp~egŒd¡|f.mqadf‰e@t|kŽw

t|egtvÍ%tvkF}@nf%ÌS¬df%kFrf]¥uy¢Omqadf&fkdf%on}PŠg¢N¬dkFrsmqtvuPkF €Žf­Fkdf%€t|knf%rmnt|uyk d{dp~kF€uykdf‰u~¢Ðmqfkonf]ÌS¬dtvoqf%eguyoqfy{

tD«fy«mnaFp~m¥p~kŠgf]ÌS¬dfkFrf.u~¢OrzaVp~ozpyrsmqfoqt|mntƒr¥¢N¬dkFrmnt|uykFruPkPmzp~t|kFLpn¬d©Fnf%ÌS¬df%kFrf.mnaFp~mruPk¨yfoq}yf]mnup

rzaVp~ozpyrsmqfoqt|mntƒr»¢N¬dkFrsmqtvuPk1«L`badtƒLmnoquykd}PfoAŒdoquyŒ:fonm†Šy{Srp~¡|¡|f%€ z{:ÎˆÏ FqpHmqt|­Ff%€@©Š/ $

8f%fg²v˜P˜~{

%

aFpyŒŽmnf%o.hH´

s s s Z

›%œ%ž

Ÿ -

Ÿ~œ

'

›

ÒÓfmqadfoqf¢NuPonfmn¬doqkJuP¬doqnf¡|¨yf] mquH¤pyoq€,p€dt§½^foqfkSm‰nt|e@t|¡ƒp~oqt§m†Š,egf%pP¬doqf¤ adtƒrzaJtƒˆ©Vpynf%€4¬dŒ:uykmnadf

€dt|mqpykFrfˆ¢N¬dkFrsmqtvuPkµmqu£pnaFpyŒVfP« ¥t|kxmqadf‰r%pynf.u~¢rzaFp~ozpyrmnfoqtƒ†mqt|r¢N¬dkVrsmnt|uykV{¤fª€Žf­Fkdfˆf]ÌS¬dtv¨Hpy¡vf%kPm

nfmz p~kF€qpTŠxmnaFp~m m†¤¥ugn¬d©Fnfmq

Á

pykF€ ·

u~¢ pyonf‰f%ÌS¬dt|¨Hp~¡|fkSm.tv½ Á & ·

«AÒ(fkFu~mnf < =Z mnadf

ruyoqonf]Œ:uykV€ŽtvkF}f%ÌS¬dt|¨Hp~¡|fkFrfªr¡ƒpyq¥u~¢^‰« 1fm $

©:fˆmqadf‰nfmbu~¢Omnadf]f‰f%ÌS¬dt|¨Hp~¡|fkFrfªr¡ƒpyqnf%%«`badf

pyŒdŒd¡|t|r%pHmqtvuPk

< =

Z 0 $ Y Z $ ! Y $

tƒ t|kH…†f%rmnt|¨yf pyr%ruyoz€Žt|kd}ªmnu †˜ s«Ò(f.r%p~k£mnadf%onf¢Nuyoqf¥tƒ€ŽfkSmqt§¢NŠmnadf nfmY Z $

u~¢0€Žtƒ†mzp~kFrf¢N¬dkFrsmqtvuPkFmnu

nfmzbu~¢! ¤ t§mqamqadfb…†¬Fmˆ€Žf­Vkdf%€,nfm.u~¢f%ÌS¬dt|¨Hp~¡|fkFrf&r¡|pPnnf%buy¢nfmz«

*

t|kFrf=Y Z $

tƒ p@n¬d©Fnfm.uy¢

(13)

mqadfnfmcY $

u~¢ruykSmnt|k¬duy¬V¢N¬dkFrsmqtvuPkF uPk 4{Vp@ÆbpykFpyrzaŒFpPrf.¤ aFfk,fkF€duH¤¥f]€¤ tvmnamnaFfkduyoqe

2&2 8

&

: 8 <

^ #"2$

<.

tvmˆrpyk©:fnaduH¤ k 7fy«}F«b²|˜y˜s´s{ŽmqaFpHm mqadfntvegt|¡|pyontvm†Šµegf%pP¬doqf

1 < Á =Z . < · =Z $ & 2 0 M ? 0 O42 8

&

: 8 <0 M #"2$

? 0 O #"%$

<.

tƒ&p€Žtƒmqp~kVrf@uykJmqadfgfm‰uy¢»f%ÌS¬dt|¨Hp~¡|fkFrf£r¡ƒpyqnf%ªu~¢¥nfmzª¤ aFt|rza(tvkF€d¬Frf]ªuPk4mnaFt|nfm&pruyegŒd¡|fmnf

egfmnoqt|ry«\•,uyoqfuH¨Pfo]{L©:f%rpy¬Fnf¤f4aFpT¨Pf,pPnn¬degf%€ ©VuP¬dkF€Žf]€0{mnadfJruyoqonf]Œ:uykV€ŽtvkF}mquyŒ:uy¡|uy}yŠ¸t|

tƒ€Žf%kPmqt|r%p~¡^mqugmnadf&uykFftvkF€d¬Frf]€©Šxmqadf¤f¡|¡§wækduH¤ kĪp~¬Fq€Žuyon½Jegfmqontƒr7nffx²hyhŽ{Ž‘S”Ž{1˜y˜´

8h

1]

<

Á=

Z . <

·=

Z $ &

: O 0 NM #"%$

. : M 0

NO #"%$

jlk±¢7pyrsm¤¥f(aFpT¨yf4f%¨yfk eguPonf4mqaFp~k±mnadf(t|€Žf%kSmntvm†Š³uy¢mnadfm†¤¥u=mnuyŒ:uy¡|uy}Ptvf]{ nff=²|˜y˜y{ % aFp~Œdmnfo‘F{

`baFfuyoqfe “d«“H´

 '` ' › œ '<s Ñ u@/zu@E@ Î - ŽÏ // 1 & 1 '

k(t|egŒVuPomzp~kSm‰t|egŒdoquH¨yfegf%kPmª¤ t§mqa(oqf%nŒVf]rsm‰mnumnadfgnt§mq¬FpHmqtvuPkt|kJmnaFf@ŒFonf%¨St|uy¬Vªnf%rmnt|uyktƒªmnadf

8f%fg²v˜P˜~{ % aFpyŒŽmnf%o ‘F{d`badf%uyoqfe “d«“H´

+ '  ! { ? Y[Z $ Î ÎÐÏ cY $

Ñ @&u/-/ D[»Ï / -T/

" / g /HÎ &i'

jlk(ŒFp~onmntƒr¬F¡|pyo%{V¢NonuPe p~kŠ4f]ÌS¬dfkFrf

7 0 =

uy¢¥€Žtƒ†mzp~kFrf¢N¬dkVrsmnt|uykVˆmqunfmz]$#4uykdfgrpykJfʁmqoqpPrsm‰p

nf%ÌS¬df%kFrfruyk¨yf%on}Ptvkd}mnuH¤bp~oz€xmqadf€Žtƒ†mzp~kFrfª¢N¬FkFrsmqtvuPk 0

mnuµpgn¬d©Fnfmc±uy¢J«

jÃm¤¥uP¬d¡|€pyŒdŒ:f%p~o1mnaFp~m¤fLaFpT¨yfAoqf%pPrzadf%€&pyktvkSmnf%onf]†mqtvkF}ˆ†mzp~}PfLp~kF€‰mqaFpHmmnadfĈp~¬Vn€ŽuPo½@€Žt|mqpykFrf

tƒ£¤ aFpHm@¤¥f¤pykPm£mnu(e@f]pyn¬doqfnaFp~Œ:fntvegt|¡|pyontvmnt|f%%« ˆkŽ¢Nuyonmn¬FkFpHmqf¡|ŠËmnadtƒtƒ@kdu~mgu(©Vf]rpy¬Ffmnadf

ruyk¨yf%on}PfkFrfLu~¢^p~oqf%pPpykF€Œ:foqtvegfmnfozt| ¡|uPm tvk£mnadf Īp~¬Fq€Žuyon½xegfmnoqtƒr~{ypPnaduH¤ k£tvk£mnadf¢NuP¡v¡|uH¤ tvkF}

fÊdp~egŒd¡|fªmzp~¦Pfk¢NonuPe ²v˜P˜~{ % aFpyŒŽmnf%o ‘F{ Êdpye@ŒF¡vf‘V«v˜&p~kF€,®t|}y¬doqf&‘F«hH´

% uPkFtƒ€Žf%obmnadfnf%ÌS¬df%kFrf

7

$#

=

uy¢nfmqbt|kmnadfuPŒVf%k4nÌS¬Fpyonf

= ? ' .&%<·

$#

&7 1"

. >

$e)

~;

%('

%uc

"

%)'G

'

%c

. + '  c =

®t|}y¬doqfªh@naduH¤.Lmqadffmq+*&p~kF€g$,y«A`badtƒb€Žf­FkFf%cJ¨yf%omqt|r%p~¡^†mqont|Œ:f%u~¢f%ÌS¬Fp~¡:¤ tƒ€mna

';,

%c4f%pPrza

€dt|mqpykPm‰u~¢

' ,

%cA«ªjÃm‰tƒªf%pynŠmnu¨yfoqtv¢NŠmqaFpHm]{^¢Nuyoªpy¡v¡ c.-

' { d $#

$ & ';,

%xp~kF€

<V

$#

< &

%cG

' «

•4uyoqfuH¨yf%o%{Vt§¢0/³t|ªmqadf£¬Fkdt§mqÌP¬Vp~oqf <+.

' =· {^¢Nuyo&p~¡|¡

"-)

/{ 0 1"2$ ';,1

cA{:adfkVrf 0 032 t|k

Y $

«4`badff]ÌP¬FfkFrf

7

$#

=

ruPk¨yfoq}yf].mqu4/±¢NuyomnadfĪp~¬Fq€ŽuPo½¸€Žtƒmqp~kVrfµ©d¬dm£t|kFrf d 0#

$&

d $#

$e& ';,

%65

'&

d / $ { 5 2

t|kJº»· $

pykF€adfkFrf¤f€Žuxkdu~m.aVpT¨yfruPk¨yfoq}yf%kFrfˆ¢Nuyo

mqadf

1 ·

mnuyŒ:uy¡|uy}PŠy« uymnfp~¡ƒnumqaFpHm

<V # < &

%ucSG

' 5 <V / <

&71

«

8 0ßzõHßzöÃû‰ÛDüHßzö†ÝAóïÛOßö†ásî üTíïÝlãDÝAõ]ásâ8î ݆٠݆ölã8ásâÛDüTßzöÝs÷

(14)

®t|}y¬doqfhL`¤¥ugnaFp~Œ:f% t|kmnadfnf%ÌS¬df%kFrf

7

$#

=

{df%f‰mnfʁm N¡|f¢Ðm +*p~kF€ Noqt|}yaSm { $,~«

s s Z›%œ%ž Ÿ - Ÿ~œ ' ›µž + FHž ) œ%›

jlkuyoz€Žfoˆmnuoqf%ruH¨yf%oˆruPkPmqtvk¬dtvm†Š,u~¢Amqadf@pyonf]pguykdf@rpykJŒdoqurff]€Jpy.¢Nuy¡|¡vuH¤.%«ˆj⻤foqf%r%p~¡|¡1mqaFpHm‰mnadf

}PoqpP€Žt|fkSmLu~¢1p€Žtƒ†mzp~kFrf ¢N¬dkFrmnt|uykµtƒLuy¢0egpy}ykdtvmn¬V€Žf.f%ÌS¬Fpy¡dmquµ˜ fÊdrf%ŒŽm»uPkµp¬F©Ffm»u~¢0egf%pP¬Fonf.”uy¢

J{FuykFfruykVr¡|¬F€Žf% mnaFp~mˆt§mªt|.qÌS¬Fp~oqf&tvkSmqf}yozp~©F¡vfuPkWJ«ÄˆfkFrfmnadf£€Žt|mqpykFrf&¢N¬FkFrsmqtvuPkFˆpykF€mnadf%tvo

}PoqpP€Žt|fkSmqp~oqfªqÌS¬Fp~oqfwÃtvkSmqf}yozp~©F¡vfP{~mnaFfŠµ©:f¡|uykd}£mnu£mnaFf * uy©:uy¡|f¨µnŒFpyrf&À¿Ás· $

{dp@Æbp~kFpPrzanŒFpyrf

¢NuPobmnadf¨Pf%rmnuyobkduPone

2

? 2

M O 8 & 2

? 25

O 8 G 2

? 2

O 8 .

¤ aFfoqf»·

$&

º»·

$ º»· $

«¥`badt| €df­Fkdf].pgt|egtv¡ƒp~oqtvm†Šµegf%pyn¬doqfˆ¢NuPobm†¤¥uxnaFp~Œ:f%

1 8 < Á =Z . < · =Z $ & 2 0 M ? 0 O42 M O 8

¤ aFt|rza£mn¬doqkF uP¬Žm mnu€Žf­Vkdf.p&ruyegŒd¡|fmqfbe@fmnoqt|rbmnoq¬Frsmq¬doqfuPk $

« `baFfbruyoqonf]Œ:uykV€ŽtvkF}.mnuPŒVuP¡vuP}yŠ

tƒrp~¡|¡|f%€gmqadf&À Ás·

wDmnuPŒVuP¡vuP}yŠP«®Fuyo¥mnadtƒe@fmnoqt|ry{Smnadf&fm[Y[Z $

uy¢O€Žt|mqpykFrfˆ¢N¬dkFrmnt|uykFtƒr¡vuSf]€xt|k

À¿Ás· $

{Vp~kF€mnadfexpyŒdŒdt|kd}

0

&D'

? < 0 < ; Y Z $

Ás· $ º · $

tƒOtvŒVnrzadtvmnÍruykSmnt|k¬duy¬F;

2 M ? O 25

O 8 2 0 M

?.

0 O 2

O 8 2 0

NM

? 0 O42 M O 8 .

¤ aFt|rza=t|kF€Žf%f%€¹aduH¤.mnaVpHm@pyonf]py£p~oqfruPkSmnt|kS¬Fuy¬F¢Nuyo£mnadf4À¿Áz·w8mquyŒ:uy¡|uy}PŠy{Af%f²|˜y˜P{

%

aFp~ŒŽmqfo@‘F{

`baFfuyoqfe ‘V«v˜´D«

Y[Z $

tƒˆkFu~mruyegŒFpPrsmª¢NuyoªmnadtƒªmnuyŒ:uy¡|uy}PŠ©F¬Žmpn¬d©Fnfm&u~¢Ltvm‰uy¢»}yoqf%p~mˆŒdozpyrsmqt|r%p~¡tvkSmqfoqf%mªtƒ{

nffnf%rmnt|uyk,hd«

/ $$Ó( " z O

ÒÓfkduH¤\aFpT¨yf&p~¡|¡^mnadfkFf%rf]nqp~oqŠxt|kd}yoqf%€Žt|fkSmzmnug©VfeguPonf&Œdoqf%rt|nf&tvkmnadf€df­Fkdtvmnt|uyk,uy¢ naFp~Œ:f%%«

Références

Documents relatifs

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes : IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu - 35042 Rennes Cedex (France) Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes : 655, avenue de l’Europe -

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes : IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu - 35042 Rennes Cedex (France) Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes : 655, avenue de l’Europe -

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes : IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu - 35042 Rennes Cedex (France) Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes : 655, avenue de l’Europe -

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes : IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu - 35042 Rennes Cedex (France) Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes : 655, avenue de l’Europe -

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes : IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu - 35042 Rennes Cedex (France) Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes : 655, avenue de l’Europe -

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes : IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu - 35042 Rennes Cedex (France) Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes : 655, avenue de l’Europe -

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes : IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu - 35042 Rennes Cedex (France) Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes : 655, avenue de l’Europe -

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes : IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu - 35042 Rennes Cedex (France) Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes : 655, avenue de l’Europe -