Revisiting the bicriteria (length,reliability) multiprocessor static scheduling problem

HAL Id: inria-00177117

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00177117v2

Submitted on 8 Oct 2007

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub-

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,

Revisiting the bicriteria (length,reliability) multiprocessor static scheduling problem

Alain Girault, Hamoudi Kalla

To cite this version:

Alain Girault, Hamoudi Kalla. Revisiting the bicriteria (length,reliability) multiprocessor static

scheduling problem. [Research Report] RR-6319, INRIA. 2007, pp.36. �inria-00177117v2�

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

Thème COM

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Revisiting the bicriteria (length,reliability) multiprocessor static scheduling problem

Alain Girault — Hamoudi Kalla

N° 6319

October 2007

*,+

-./ .01 & $2

+

3-$.0&

*

46587:9<;>=?9<@A7:B5<C

∗

^DFE 7(GIHJBK$9L?7:5<587

†

MNPORQTSVUWYX[Z]\_^a`cbdORQTSe`fgQTQVhPiPjkf&lmib`

nFopgrqsS&bp`n/Wtnvuxw$M

wylrzPz:gmodby{aS0opSRfNPSRopfNPS|iJ}$~m€R‚ƒZ„WYfbpgm…:S&ox†m‡m‡‰ˆYZ m~ zlrŠSR`

‹ŒŽR&’‘P“mm”

WthPoƒ`cbplrodbdj•iPŠvz:gmj•i‰bƒj•`–lv{aS&z:S&i({aS&if&^>blm`d—˜ŠoplmzPN™lri{|lmišNSbdSRodgŠmSRiPS&gh`›{ajk`sœ

bpodj•…PhabpSR{˜QS&Qgmop^žbplmodŠSb›lrofNPjŸbpSRfbdhPopSm ¢¡£S"odSR¤_j•`djŸbbdNS£¥/S&¦•¦%`cbdh{aj•SR{˜zPopgm…P¦•S&Q§gm¨V…Pjkfopj©bdS&opjkl

ª

¦©SRiPŠrbpN1«odSR¦©jklr…Pj•¦•jŸbs^P¬TQ­h¦Ÿbpj©zPopgafSe`d`dgmo`cbpl’bpj•f›`pfNPSe{ahP¦•j©iPŠ"gm¨tbpNPj•`bplm`d—®ŠoplmzPN¯gmi‰bdg£bdNj•`°lmopfNjŸbpSRfœ

bphPopSm žWtho­±o`cbf&odj©bdSRodjkl?opS&Qlmj©i`VbpNPS›`sbl’bdjkf`dfNPSe{ahP¦•Sm²`T¦©SRiPŠrbpN1³bpNPjk`j•`fophf&j•lm¦bpg´lm`p`cSe`d`­bdNPS

`d^a`sbpS&Q²`xopSRlm¦Ÿœµbdj•QSVzPopgmz:S&odbs^m 0¶gmoYgmhPo `cSefgi{ƒf&odj©bdSRodjklP«J¥/SVfgi`dj•{aSRoxbpNPSŠm¦•gm…lm¦`d^a`sbpS&Q¨·lrj•¦•hPodS

ol’bpSm«m`dS&SRiTl`$jŸ¨:bdNS¥NPgm¦•Sy`c^a`cbdSRQ¸¥SRodSl `dj©iPŠ¦©S/blm`d—­`dfNSR{ahP¦•SR{Vgmi‰bpg l0`dj•iPŠm¦•SzPodgaf&SR`p`cgoR«Aj•i`sbpSRl{

gm¨¹bdNPSYh`dhlr¦:opS&¦•j•lm…Pj©¦•j©bs^m«‰…(Sef&lrh(`cSyj©b{ag_SR`iPgrb{aS&z:S&i{gmibpNPS `dfNPSe{ahP¦•Sx¦•S&iPŠmbdN°¦•j•—mSybpNPSYodSR¦©jklr…Pj•¦•jŸbs^

{Pg‰Se`

ª

{PhPS%bpg°jŸb`xf&gmQzPhabl’bdj•gmi›j•ibdNSVf¦klm`p`dj•fRlr¦¹opS&¦•j•lm…Pj©¦•j©bs^Qga{aS&¦gr¨º\_Nlrbd»­lmi{¡"lriPŠ_¬ MNPS&opSœ

¨¼godS«_¥S0fgi‰bdopgm¦J…(S&bcbpS&obdNSYopS&z¦©jkf&lrbdj•gmi°¨·lfbpgmogr¨SRlmfN6j©i({aj©¤_jk{ahlm¦¹bpl`c—gm¨ bdNS {PS&z:S&i{aSRif^bpl`c—

ŠoplmzPNŠj©¤S&ilm`l`dz(Sefj©±(f&lrbdj•gmi1«a¥j©bdNopSR`dz(SefbbdgbpNPS%{aSR`dj•odSe{°¨·lmj©¦•hPopSYol’bpSm 

Mg0`cg¦©¤SFbdNj•`$…Pjkfopj©bdS&opjklygmzPbdj•QTj•»Rlrbdj•gmiTzPopgm…P¦•S&Q«’¥/Sºblr—mSbdNS¨·lmj©¦•hPopSol’bpS/l`$ltf&gmi`cbdolrj•i‰bR«rlri({

¥/S Qj©iPj•Qj©»RS bdNPS%`pfNPSe{ahP¦•SY¦•S&iŠrbdN  ½¡–S%lmodStbdN_h`ylm…P¦•StbpgzPodga{ah(fSm«_¨¼goylTŠmj•¤mS&ilrzzP¦©jkf&lrbdj•gmi6bpl`c—

ŠoplmzPNƒlmi{?QVhP¦Ÿbpj©zodgafSe`d`dgmo lrofNPj©bdSefbdhodS«Jl6n½lropSbpg6fhod¤SVgm¨ºiPgmiPœ8{agQj©ilrbdSe{?`cg¦©hPbdj•gmi`R«1lrQgmiŠ

¥Nj•fN6bdNPS0h(`cSRoyf&lrifNPg_g`dSYbdNPS%f&gmQzPopgmQjk`cStbdNlrb±Pbp`Nj•`opSR¾‰hPj•opS&QS&i‰bp`/…:SR`cbR 

¿›À‰ÁJÂpÃ­Ä ’ÅŽm” Æ jkfopjŸbpS&opj•l¯gzabdj•Qj©»el’bdj•gmi «YopS&¦•jklr…Pj•¦©j©bs^m«Yn½lropSbpg¯gzabdj•QlP«0`cbpl’bpj•f"QVhP¦©bdj•zPodgaf&SR`p`cgo

`pfNPSe{ahP¦•j©iPŠ(«aodSR¦©jklr…j©¦•jŸbs^…P¦©gaf—{Pj•lmŠmolrQ`& 

∗

ÇÈÊÉËÍÌ­ÎËÍϵÉÐAÈÑËÍÒÓ ËÑ<Ô0Õ¼Ö×1ÕØÇ´ÉÌAÙ­ÎÏ·ÚcÌeÛÜAÈÍÚÝÌeËÞÚcÏ·ÒµËÑØßTàká:â$á6Ç$×aãƒäAÏ·Ûå<Úsæ#Ñ·çkѵÚcÉè˜ÉÌAÙ0é_Õ·Î"ÈÊÉÜrÛϵÉpÑ<Ûϼߒê8ë

ì

ϵÉÌAæsÚëmí(èyÉËÍÈkî_ÇÈÊÉËÍ̉ïÎËÍÏ<ÉÐAÈÑ8ðËÍÌAÏ<ËÊÉeïñ©Ï

†

ò ÉèÛÐAÙAˉó½ÉÈÍÈÊÉËÍÒ¹Ó ËѵÔxѵÔeÚFÝÌAËÞÚsÏ·ÒµËÑØßtÛñô¹Épѵ̒ÉeëAÇÈÍõÚsÏ<ËÊÉeë’í(èyÉËÍÈkî ò ÉèÛÐAÙAËkïó½ÉÈÍÈÊÉðËÍÌAÏ·ËÊÉÈÍärÚcÒcïñ•Ï

* * +

*,+

-./

+

$¢„.%

+ +

! 0Y)

Ž ” gmbdopSºz:gmj•i‰b{aS{&z(lrodbSR`cbhi­ŠmolrzNPSº{aS{&z:S&i({aS&if&SR`${aSºbmfNSR`Sb$hPiPSlmopfNjŸbpSRfbphPopS

f&j©…¦©SQ&Qgmj•odSºoRzlrodbdj•Sm  gmh(`1opS&¤_j•`dj©bdgmi(`1¦•SºzPopgm…P¦•O&QSºf&¦•l`d`djk¾hSº{aSº¦µ²gmo{agmiPi(lrif&S&QS&i‰b `cbpl’bpj•¾‰hPS

QVhP¦©bdj•zPodgaf&SR`p`cSRhPop`t…PjkfopjŸbpO&opS

ª

¦©giPŠmhPSRhPoe«±(lm…Pj•¦©j©bA¬x{aSf&SVŠoplmzPNPSV{PSVbmfNPS`dhPoYf&SbdbdSlrofNPj©bdSRfbdhPopSm 

grbpodS0zPopS&Qj•O&opS%fopjŸbpO&opS0odSe`sbpS%¦kl¦©giPŠmhPSRhPox{aS­¦<²gmo{agmiilrif&S&QS&i‰bx`cbplrbdjk¾hSm³f&SRf&j SR`cbtf&odhf&j•lm¦ l’±(i

{1²&bplr…¦©j•o%¦kl›zPopgmzPopj&bTbdSRQz`sœ8o&S&¦{ah `c^a`cbdORQTS 6n$ghPo­iPgmbdopS°`cSefgi{"fopjŸbpO&opSm« igmh`Vfgmi(`cjk{&opgmi(`

¦•S?blrhv{aS£{¨·lmj©¦•¦•lmifS–{ah˜`d^a`sbpO&QS?Šm¦•gm…(lr¦µ«¤‰h f&gmQQS–`djt¦•S–`d^a`sbpO&QSƒ{Plmi``dgmi>S&i‰bdj•S&obplmjŸb

hiPS­hPij•¾‰hPS­bmfNS%gmo{agmiilrif&S%`dhPoxhi?hPiPjk¾‰hPS­zPopgafSe`d`dS&hPoe«¦•lz¦•lfS­{aSV¦<²h`dhPS&¦•¦•S%±(lm…Pj©¦•j©bV{Ph

`d^a`sbpO&QSm«(zlrofS%¾‰h1²j•¦ iPS­{ &z:S&i{›z(lm`y{aSV¦•l¦•gmiŠmhPSRhPox{aS%¦µ²gmo{agmiPi(lrif&S&QS&i‰bxfgQQTSVfr²SR`cbx¦©SVf&lm`

{PSV¦kl°±:lr…Pj•¦©j©b

ª

S&iƒolrjk`dgmiƒ{aS`dgmi–fRlr¦kfhP¦!6¦<²lrjk{aS{ah£QTga{aOR¦©S{aSV±(lr…j©¦•jŸbf¦klm`p`cjk¾‰hPSV{aS\_Nlrbd»Sb

¡"lriŠ‰¬ £uyj•i`dj<«½iPgh`Tfgmi‰bpo"¦©gi`0…:SRlrh(fgmhz Qj©SRh´¦©S6iPj©¤SRlmh®{aSo&z¦©jkf&lrbdj•gmi {aSfNlm¾‰hPSbmfNPS

j•i{aj•¤_j•{PhPS&¦•¦©S{ah£ŠmolrzPNSV{aS{&z:S&i({aS&if&SR` {agiPi fgmQQS`cz#Rf&jŸ±(fRl’bpj©giƒzlmotolrzPz:gmodbYlmh?blrhƒ{aS

{ ¨·lrj•¦•¦•lmifS0{e`cj•o 

uy±iV{aS/oR`dgmh{aopSºf&SºzPopgm…P¦•O&QS/{¹²gzabdj•Qj•`pl’bpj©gi%…PjkfopjŸbpO&opSm«’iPgh`zPodSRiPgmi(`1¦klbplmh­{aS/{¨·lmj©¦•¦•lmifS

f&gmQQSthiPS0fgmi‰bpoplmj©i‰bdS«S&b/igmh`/Qj©ij©Qjk`cgi`¦•lV¦•gmiPŠhPS&hPo{aSY¦<²gmo{agiPilri(fS&QSRibe  gmh(`/`dgmQQSR`

lmj©i(`cj fRlrzlm…P¦•SR`{aS0zPopga{ahPj•odS«Pz:gmhPoyhiŠoplmzPNPS0{aS­{ &z:S&i{aSRifSe`y{agiPi 0Sbtz(ghPoyhPiPS%lmopfNjŸbpSRfbphPopS

QVhP¦©bdj•zPodgaf&SR`p`cSRhPop`/{agiPi &S«ahPiPS0fghPop…(S {aS n½lropSbdg{aS `cg¦©hPbdj•gmi`/iPgiaœ8{PgmQj©i&SR`R«_zlropQj¹¦©Se`d¾‰hPSR¦©¦•SR`

¦µ²habdj•¦©jk`pl’bdSRhPoz:S&habtfNgmjk`cj•o¦©S0fgQzPodgQj•`¾‰hPj1f&gmopodSe`cz:gmi{¦©S0Qj•S&h$`cSe`Saj©ŠS&if&SR`R 

% Ä eŽ  “& Ž6” Wtzabpj©Qjk`dlrbdj•gmi…PjkfopjŸbpO&opSm«_±(lm…Pj©¦•j©bm«gmzabpj©Ql{aS0n½lropSbpg«agmo{agiPilri(fS&QSRib`cbpl’bpj•¾‰hPS

QVhP¦©bdj•zPodgaf&SR`p`cSRhPop`R«_…P¦•g_fœ8{Pj•lmŠmolrQQSR`/{aS ±(lr…j©¦•jŸbm 

; < V $.2

+

º.%

Æ jkfopjŸbpS&opj•l

ª

¦©SRiPŠrbpN1«odSR¦©jklr…Pj•¦•jŸbs^P¬$QVhP¦Ÿbpj©zodgafSe`d`dgmoF`pfNPSe{ahP¦•j©iPŠ0N(lm`FopSRf&S&i‰bd¦•^l’bcbpoplfbpSR{l0¦•grbºgm¨¹lrbcbpS&iaœ

bpj©gi>=ˆ « € « ? « €m€ « †m† « †m‡ @8 MNPSzPhPopz(g‰`cS°jk`0bpgƒ`pfNPSR{ah¦©S°`cbplrbdjkf&lr¦•¦•^£lŠoplmzPN"gr¨bpl`c—a`

ª

lr¦k`cg?fRlr¦•¦©Se{

gz(SRoplrbdj•gmi`¬xgmi‰bdg›l{ajk`sbpodj•…PhabpSR{–QTSRQgmop^?Q­hP¦©bdj•zPopgafSR`p`dgmo lrofNPjŸbpSRfbdhPopSm« `dhfN–bdNlrb0bs¥gfopj©bdS&opjkl

gm¨bpNPS0gm…Pbplrj•iPSe{6`pfNPSR{PhP¦©S%lmodS gzabdj•Qj©»RSR{¹³Fj©bp` &ÀACB 2D ªfophfjklr¦Jbpg°lm`p`cSe`d`bpNPS%`c^a`cbdSRQ²`opSRlm¦Ÿœµbdj•QS

zodgz(SRocbs^P¬lri{j©bp`  À &E<‘aŒFE &E·Á ªf&odhf&j•lm¦Jbdg°l`d`dSR`p`bdNPS%`d^a`sbpS&Q²`{PS&z:S&i{Plm…Pj•¦©j©bs^P¬ 

¡£S%h`dS bdNPS0¥jk{aSR¦©^lmfRfS&zPbdSR{6opS&¦•j•lm…Pj©¦•j©bs^Qga{aS&¦1gm¨½\aNl’bp»­lri{¡"lriPŠG=†r @µ«P¥NS&opS0SRlmfNNlmop{_œ

¥lropStf&gmQz:gmiPSRib

ª

zPodgaf&SR`p`cgogof&gmQQ­hiPj•fRl’bpj©gi¦•j©iP—P¬jk`fNlrolmfbdS&opj•»&SR{°…‰^6l “ ÄHA Ž&e‘ A JI8‘E&  À

’‘a ÀLKºÀ 02E À A E¼

λ

«‰`ch(fN­bpNl’bFj©bp`$opS&¦•j•lm…Pj•¦©j©bs^­{ahPopj•iPŠYbdNPSj•ibpS&op¤’lr¦agr¨:bdj•QS

d

^(S

e ^−λd

ª

bdN(l’bFjk`&«

bpNPS0gaf&f&hPodopS&i(fSR`gm¨bpNPS ¨·lrj•¦•hPodSe`/¨¼gm¦•¦©g’¥™lfgi`sblri‰byzlmoplmQTS&bdSRo/n$gj•`p`cgi6¦klA¥x¬ MNPS%fNPg`dS&iQSRlmi

bpgj•ifopSRl`cS%bdNPSTodSR¦©jklr…j©¦•jŸbs^gm¨l`d^a`sbpS&Q j•`xbdNS ‘P“m2EM À  À!K &E·“‘a2E ÄHAIgr¨½bpNPSVgz(SRoplrbdj•gmi`tlri{?bdNPS

{l’bplrœ8{PS&z:S&i{aSRifj•SR`R«1¥NPjkfN"fgmi(`cjk`sb` j©i"S_Sefhabpj©iŠ`dS&¤S&olr¦½fgzPj•SR` gr¨l`dlmQTSgz(SRoplrbdj•gmi£gmi‰bdg›lm`

Qlmi‰^?{Pj•`cbdj•ifb%zodgafSe`d`dgmo`

ª

opSR`dz1 ¹{Pl’bl’œ#{aS&z:S&i{PS&if&j©Se` gmi‰bdgfgQTQVhPiPjkf&lrbdj•gmiƒ¦•j•iP—a`p¬ N#i‰bphPjŸbpj©¤S&¦•^m«

l{P{aj•iPŠQgmopS0odSRzP¦•j•fRlm`j•ifopSRl`cSe`/bdNPS%opS&¦•jklr…Pj•¦©j©bs^m«…Phabtlm¦•`dgbdNPSV`dfNPSe{ahP¦•S0¦©SRiPŠrbpN1 ON#igmbdNPSRoy¥/gmo{P`&«

l{P{aj•iPŠTQTgodS opS&zP¦•jkf&lm`/j•QzPodg’¤SR`ºbdNPS0opS&¦•jklr…Pj•¦©j©bs^…Phabyz:S&i(lr¦•j©»RSR`/bdNSY¦•S&iŠrbdN ³½j©i6bdNPjk`y`dS&i`dSm«_¥/S0`dlA^

bpNl’bbpNPS bs¥/gTf&odj©bdSRodjkllropS ‘ A e‘ B:ÄHA E·ŽR2E<“  

Æ habVbdNPj•iPŠ`VlropS°iPgmbV`cgƒSRlm`d^0P¡–S`cNPg’¥ bdN(l’bVh(`cj•iPŠ›bpgmŠmS&bdNPSRo%bpNPS°opS&¦•j•lm…Pj©¦•j©bs^£f&odj©bdSRodj•gmi´lri({

bpNPS"`dfNPSe{ahP¦•Sƒ¦•S&iPŠmbdNšfopjŸbpS&opj©gi oplmj•`dSR`°bdSefNPiPjkf&lr¦0{aj Q°fhP¦©bdj•SR`R«x…:SRfRlrh`dS?bpNPS"odSR¦©jklr…j©¦•jŸbs^v{aSRz(SRi{P`

j•i‰bdopj©i(`cjkf&lm¦©¦•^°gmibpNPS%{ahPol’bpj©gigm¨bpNPS%gz(SRoplrbdj•gmi`lri({f&gmQQ­hiPj•fRl’bpj©gi`& ¶Pgmoj•i`cbplmifS«fNPg_g`dj©iŠ

l°zPodgaf&SR`p`cgox`ch(fNbdNlrbxbdNSV{ahPol’bpj©gi

d

gm¨ºlŠmj•¤mSRi›gmz:S&ol’bpj©gijk`x`dQlr¦•¦©SRo

ª

¥NPj•fNƒj•`xŠmg_ga{¨¼gmotbdNPS

¦•S&iŠrbdN6fopjŸbpS&opj©gi(¬½j•i{ahf&SR`/l%NPj•ŠmNS&oºopS&¦•jklr…Pj•¦©j©bs^ ª¥NPjkfN°jk`lm¦•`dg%Šg‰ga{¨¼goºbpNPSxopS&¦•jklr…Pj•¦©j©bs^fopjŸbpS&opj©gi(¬ R

bpNPjk`yjk`…(Sef&lmh`cS%bdNPS

d 7→ e ^−λd

¨¼hPifbdj•gmi?jk`y{aSefopSRl`cj•iPŠ /MNPjk`j•`tfghPi‰bdS&odœ8j©i‰bdhjŸbpj©¤StbpNPgmhŠmN1«:`cj•ifS bpNPjk`%QSRlmi` bdN(l’b­opS&zP¦•jkf&l’bpj©gi"j•`­…lm{£¨¼go%odSR¦©jklr…j©¦•jŸbs^0P+N8b%¨¼gm¦•¦•g’¥y` bdNlrb­j©b­j•`V{aj Qf&hP¦©b%bdgƒ{PSR`dj©Ši"l

`pl’bpj•`c¨·lmfbdgod^–…Pj•f&odj©bdSRodjkl?`pfNPSR{PhP¦©j•iPŠ?NS&hPopj•`cbdjkfr SN#i®zlmocbpj•f&hP¦klroe« bpNPj•`TNl`0bpNPodSRS6{aolA¥…lf—_`R³%±(op`cbR«

bpNPST¦©SRiPŠrbpN£f&odj©bdSRodj•gmi?g’¤S&opz(g’¥/S&o`bpNPSVopS&¦•jklr…Pj•¦©j©bs^?fopj©bdS&opj•gmiTR1`dSRf&gmi{¹«Jj©b0j•`Y¤mSRod^bpodjkf—_^6bpgf&gmi‰bdopgm¦

zodSefjk`cSR¦©^–bdNPSopS&zP¦•j•fRl’bpj©gi"¨·lmfbpgmoVgr¨bdNS6gz(SRoplrbdj•gmi`­gmi‰bdg›bpNPSzPodgaf&SR`p`cgop`R« ¨¼opgmQ bpNPS…:S&Šj©iPij©iPŠ

bpg"bdNPSƒS&i{¯gr¨YbdNSƒ`dfNSR{ahP¦•S

ª

j•ižzlrodbdjkfh¦•lmoR«/jŸbf&lrižf&lmh`dS?lVU#¨¼hPiiPS&¦%WSX:Sefb¬ Rtlmi{IbdNPj•o{¹«bdNPS

opS&¦•jklr…Pj•¦©j©bs^j•`igrbl­QgmigrbdgiPgmh(`F¨¼hPi(fbdj•gmigr¨ bdNPS0`pfNPSR{ah¦©S Y ZFSbe«abdNPjk`/j•`/bpNPS lrzPzPopglfNbdN(l’bNlm`

…:S&SRi¨¼gm¦•¦©g’¥/SR{6`cgT¨·lroj•ibdNPS0¦•j©bdS&ol’bphPopSm 

¶gmobdNj•`opSRl`cgi1«¥/S zPopgmz:g`dStlTiPS&¥šfopjŸbpS&opj©gi°j•i6zP¦klmf&S gr¨ bpNPS0`dfNSR{ahP¦•SYodSR¦©jklr…Pj•¦•jŸbs^«a¥NPj•fN6¥S

fRlr¦•¦bpNPS9B &Ä Œ$‘ &½Ž Á Ž& À [I8‘E& À ’‘a À]\$^`_ba +c’ _MNS4d0\a¶$w>j•`bdNSx¨·lmj©¦•hPopStol’bpSxz:S&o/bdj•QSthPijŸb

gm¨PbdNSg…abplmj©iPSe{%QVhP¦Ÿbpj©zodgafSe`d`dgmo`dfNSR{ahP¦•Sm«`cSRS&i­l`j©¨(j©b$¥SRodS/l5 !" gz(SRoplrbdj•gmi­`pfNPSe{ahP¦•SR{%gi‰bdgtl

3 zPodgaf&SR`p`cgoR \aj©if&S/bdNPS/¨·lrj•¦•hPodS/ol’bdS/jk`TUsz:S&obdj•QShPiPj©beW«rjŸb½jk`$j©i‰bpodj•i`dj•fRlr¦•¦©^0j•i{aSRz(SRi{aS&i‰b½gr¨(bdNPS

{PhPoplrbdj•gmi›gm¨½bdNPSVgmz:S&ol’bdj•gmi(`& xut`tlfgmi(`cSe¾hS&if&Sm«:gmhPotiPS&¥™bpNPS&godS&bdjkf&lr¦ ¨¼oplmQS&¥/gmop—jk`tf&gmi`dj•`cbdSRi‰b

¥j©bdNbdNPSYj•ibphPj©bdj•gmibpNl’bodSRzP¦•j•fRl’bdj•gmij•`Šmg_ga{¨¼gmo/opS&¦•j•lm…Pj©¦•j©bs^V…PhPb/…l{¨¼go¦•S&iPŠmbdN1 ½MNPjk`j•`/gmhoF±o`sb

f&gmi‰bdopj•…Phabdj•gmi ³½\aSRfbpj©gi f Qgmbdj•¤AlrbdSe`/bdNPSgd0\a¶$w™lri({S_z¦•lmj©i`Ng’¥ bdg°f&gmQzPhabpS jŸbe 

ht`cj•iPŠbdNS-d0\a¶$w™j•`xlr¦k`cg¤S&op^`dlrbdjk`s¨·lfbpgmop^j©ibpNPS­lropSRlVgr¨½z:S&opj©ga{ajkf&lm¦©¦•^°S_SefhabpSR{›`pfNPSR{PhP¦©Se`& 

MNj•` j•`JbpNPSfRlm`dS½j©i0Qg‰`sb opSRlm¦Ÿœµbdj•QS½S&QV…(Se{P{aSR{0`d^a`sbpS&Q`R«R¥NPjkfN%lropS½z:S&opj©ga{ajkf&lm¦©¦•^t`plrQzP¦•SR{ `d^_`cbdSRQ`& 

N#i6f&lm`dSR`R«lmzPzP¦•^_j©iPŠ­…PodhPbplr¦•¦•^­bpNPSY\_N(l’bd»Ylri{°¡£lmiPŠ%opS&¦•j•lm…Pj©¦•j©bs^VQga{aS&¦:^_j©SR¦•{`F¤mSRod^T¦•g’¥¯opS&¦•jklr…Pj•¦©j©bdj•SR`

{PhPS½bdg¤S&op^x¦•gmiPŠSaSRfhPbdj•gmiYbdj•QSR`

ª

bdNPS`dlmQTS½opS&Qlmod—xlmzPzP¦•j©Se` lm¦•`dg/bdgy¤S&op^y¦©giPŠy`pfNPSR{ah¦©Se`p¬ CiySRifS

j

Õkñ

S ⁰

ËÍÒ(ÉFäeÏ<Úkml/Òµæ8ÔAÚsÙAÐeÈÍÚÛñ

S

ëÑ<ÔAÚsÌѵÔeÚÏ·ÚsÈÍËÊÉÜAËÍÈÍËÑØß/Ûñ

S

ËÍÒ(ÌAÛÑ:ÌAÚsæsÚcÒ<Ò8ÉÏ·ËÍÈßõÏ·ÚcÉpѵÚsÏJÑ<ԒÉÌѵÔeÚÏ·ÚsÈÍËÊÉÜAËÍÈÍËÑØß/Ûñ

S ⁰

^ï

giPSTNlm`tbdgfgQzPhabdST…:S¨¼gmopS&N(lri{?bdNPS{aSe`cj•odSe{?opS&¦•j•lm…Pj•¦©j©bs^gr¨/l`dj©iPŠ¦©STj©bdS&ol’bpj©gi›¨¼opgmQ bdNSTŠ¦©g…lr¦

opS&¦•jklr…Pj•¦©j©bs^gr¨$bdNPST`c^a`cbdSRQ{ahodj•iPŠ°j©bp`x¨¼hP¦•¦Qjk`d`dj•gmiTR:…PhabtbdNPjk`tf&gmQzPhabl’bpj©gi?{aS&z:S&i{`xgibdNPS­bdgrblr¦

{PhPoplrbdj•gmi°gm¨1bdNStQjk`d`dj©gi

ª

¥NPj•fN6j•`—_iPg’¥i(¬lri{gmibpNPS0{ahPol’bpj©gi°gr¨ giPSt`dj•iPŠm¦•Stj©bdSRoplrbdj•gmi

ª

¥NPjkfN

QlA^?igrb%…:S—‰ig’¥i–…:SRfRlrh`dSjŸb­{PS&z:S&i{P`%gmi£bdNPS¦•S&iŠrbdN"gm¨bpNPS°`dfNSR{ahP¦•ShPi{PS&o­f&gmi`cbdophfbpj©gi(¬ 

N#i?f&gmi‰bdolm`cbR«bdNPSLd0\a¶$w|opS&Qlrj•i`g)1o7 37y{ahPopj•iPŠbdNS­¥NPg¦©S­`d^a`sbpS&Q²`y¦•jŸ¨¼S R(bpNl’bYj•`R«PbpNPSd0\P¶w

{PhPodj•iPŠ­lV`cj•iPŠ¦©StjŸbpS&ol’bdj•gmijk`/…_^f&gmi`cbdophfbdj•gmijk{aS&i‰bdjkf&lm¦bpg%bpNPS d0\a¶$w˜{ahPopj©iPŠ­bdNPSY¥NPg¦©SyQjk`d`dj•gmi1 

g’¥0«P¦©S&bxh`yl{P{aopSR`p`/bdNPS0jk`p`chPSe`olrjk`cSe{…_^…j•f&odj©bdSRodjklTgmzabpj©Qj•»Rl’bpj©gi1 º¶j•ŠmhPopS € `cNPg’¥y`l`dSbygm¨

`dgm¦•habpj©gi`¨¼gmoFlY…PjkfopjŸbpS&opj•ltQj©iPj•Qj©»el’bpj©giVzPopgm…¦©SRQ³ bdNPSz:gmj•i‰bp`

x ¹

^«

x ²

^«

x ³

^«

x ⁴

^«lmi{

x ⁵

^{lropS ‘a À  Ä}

ÄHK

2E®‘

=‡ @RJbdNPSz:gmj•i‰bp`

x ¹

^lmi{

x ⁵

^{lmodSTíÀ ‘ Ä7K 2E ‘} ¥NPj•¦©STbpNPSVz:gmj•i‰bp`

x ²

^«

x ³

^«1lmi{

x ⁴

^lropS

ŽR& Ä:ACB¯ÄHK E ‘  0MNPS`dSb gr¨lm¦©¦n½lropSbdg6gmzabpj©Ql6j•` fRlr¦•¦©Se{bdNPS ‘a À  Ä “M À: VMNPSRi1«1`cSR¤mSRoplm¦

lmzPzPopglfNPSR`$S_jk`cbFbdg0blmf—_¦•Sy…PjkfopjŸbpS&opj•l gzabdj•Qj©»el’bdj•gmizodg…P¦©SRQ` ªbpNPSR`dSxQSbpNPga{P`FS_bdS&i({il’bphPolr¦•¦©^

bpgQ­hP¦©bdj©œ8f&odj©bdSRodjkl¬=m‡ @µ³

€m  ‹ B:B  ÀB ‘a2EÄHA£Ä ID À  Ã­Ä “roE¼ À oE<‘EA  Ä ‘6Ž2EACB &ÀVÄHAÀ:«r`cg lm`bdgYbpoplmi`s¨¼godQšbpNPSzPopgm…P¦•S&Q

j©i‰bpg°lTf&¦•l`d`djkf&lr¦¹`dj©iŠm¦•S f&odj©bdSRodj•gmi6gmzabpj©Qj•»Rlrbdj•gmigmiPS 

†a  ’‘ A ŽIÄ  ‘aEÄ:A˜Ä I ÄHAÀ “roE¼ À mEÄHA EA  Ä ‘I“ Ä:A ŽR&’‘EA  «1¥Nj•fN£lr¦•¦©g’¥y`ybdNPS`cg¦©¤_j•iPŠgm¨

bdNPS0zodg…P¦©SRQ¢…_^gzabdj•Qj©»Rj©iPŠTbpNPS0grbpNPS&oyf&odj©bdSRodj•gmi6hPi{aSRobdNPS%f&gmi`cbdolrj•i‰b/gm¨bpNPS ±o`sbgiPSm 

P  EÀ ’‘a’“mDCEm‘aEÄ:A®Ä IºD À “roE¼ À oE<‘ «_¥NPj•fN°lm¦©¦•g’¥y`$bpNPSybpgrbplm¦(gop{PS&opj©iPŠ0gm¨JbdNPSYfopjŸbpS&opj•l«lri({

bdNPSRibdNPS%`dgm¦•¤_j©iPŠgm¨ bdNS0zPodg…P¦•S&Q¢…_^gzabdj•Qj©»Rj©iŠTgiPS0fopjŸbpS&opj•lTl’bxlVbpj©QSm 

f A  À ’‘P“m2EÄ:Avà E¼Dž2D À Ž À  «Pj©igop{aSRo/bdgŠmhPjk{aS bpNPS0`cSelrofN°¨¼gmotlVn½lmodS&bdgTgmzabpj©QVhPQ 

Z 1

!

Z 2

x ⁷

x ³ x ² x ¹

x ⁶

Z 1 (x ⁶ ) Z 2 (x ⁶ )

x ⁴ x ⁵

"

#

#$!&%

¶j©ŠhPodS€³n½lmodS&bdgTgmzabpj©Qllri({n½lropSbpgfhPop¤mSt¨¼gmoylT…PjkfopjŸbpS&opj•lTQj•iPj©Qj•»Rlrbdj•gmizPopgm…P¦•S&Q 

WthPo`dSRf&gmi{°f&gmi‰bdopj•…Phabdj•gmi…(SR¦©giPŠ`bdgVbdNSY`dSRf&gmi{°fRlm`dSm³$¥/SxzPopgmz:g`dStlViPS&¥˜`sbl’bdjkfY`dfNPSe{ahP¦•j©iŠ

lm¦©ŠgmopjŸbpNPQbdNlrb bplr—SR` lm` l )1o $oHtl6Šmj•¤mSRi?¨·lrj•¦•hPodSTol’bdSTz:S&o bdj•QShPiPj©bR« lmi{?bpNl’b%lrbcbdSRQzabp`

bpg]*7*2bpNPS`pfNPSR{ah¦©S°¦•S&iŠrbdN´gi´lri´NPS&bdS&opgmŠS&iPSRgmh`0lmopfNjŸbpSRfbphPopSm« …_^£h`dj©iPŠ–l›`cQlrodb­fg‰`sb

¨¼hifbpj©gi1  Æ ^SaSRfhPbdj•iPŠbdNPjk`ylm¦©ŠgmopjŸbpNPQ¢¥j©bdN?`dS&¤mSRoplm¦:¨·lrj•¦©hPopS0ol’bdSe`&«aj©bxjk`z:g`p`cj•…P¦•S bdggm…Pbplrj•ibdNPS

n½lmodS&bdgfhPop¤mS ¨¼goylŠmj•¤mSRi6j•i`cbplmifS0gm¨bpNPS0zPopgm…P¦•S&Q

ª

jµ S ©«:lŠmj•¤mSRilm¦©ŠgmopjŸbpNPQ¢ŠoplmzPN›lri{lŠmj•¤mSRi

{Pj•`cbdopj©…habdSe{´lrofNPjŸbpSRfbdhPopSe¬ ¡£S°zPopSR`dS&i‰b­j•i {aS&bplrj•¦k`0bdNj•`­iPS&¥¢lm¦©ŠgmopjŸbpNPQ

ª

\_SRfbdj•gmi ¬%lri{´`dNPg’¥

S_bdS&i(`cj•¤mS0`dj©QVhP¦•lrbdj•gmiodSe`ch¦Ÿb`

ª

\_Sefbdj•gmi ~ ¬ 

& 2 .0

hPQS&opgmh`F¥god—a`$NlA¤Sy{aSRlm¦Ÿb`dz:SRfj©±(fRlr¦•¦©^V¥jŸbpNbdNPSt…Pj•f&odj©bdSRodjkl

ª

¦•S&iPŠmbdN1«opS&¦•j•lm…Pj©¦•j©bs^a¬F`sbl’bdjkfy`pfNPSR{PhP¦Ÿœ

j•iPŠšzPopgm…P¦•S&Q ¨¼gmo´{ajk`cbdopj©…PhPbdSR{ QS&Qgmop^™NPSbpS&opgmŠS&iPSRgmh`–lrofNPjŸbpSRfbdhPopSR`R §MNPSžQTg‰`sb´lm{P¤AlmifSe{

lmodS =ˆ « € « ? « †† « €m€ @y…:SRfRlrh`dSm«ºj©ivfgi‰bdolm`cbV¥j©bdNžQlri_^´grbpNPS&oopSR`dhP¦©bp`R«½bdNPSR^I{ag£iPgmbl`d`dhPQSbdNPS

f&gmQQ­hiPj•fRl’bpj©gi6iPS&bs¥god—bpg…(SVlmf^af&¦©jkfr FMNPSRodS0lmodS0lr¦k`dgVbpNPS0¥/gmop—_`gm¨½\aodj•iPj•¤Al`dlmilmi{ mNlG=†3? @µ«

…habVbpNPS&^"giP¦©^´lmj©Q,l’bTQl aj©Qj•»&j•iPŠ?bpNPSodSR¦©jklr…Pj•¦•jŸbs^"lri{ iPgrbl’bTQTj•iPj•Qj©»Rj©iPŠƒbdNPS¦•S&iPŠmbdN gm¨ybdNPS

`pfNPSe{ahP¦•Sm 

UgQTzhabdj•iPŠ6bdNPSTodSR¦©jklr…j©¦•jŸbs^›gm¨l`pfNPSe{ahP¦•SVopSR¾‰hPj•odSe`bpgf&gmQzPhabpSm«J¨¼gmoYSRlfN–{Plrbplrœ8{aSRz(SRi{aSRif^

¨¼opgmQ gz(SRoplrbdj•gmi bdggmz:S&ol’bdj•gmiGZ

ª

igrbdSe{

.

Z ¬«:bdNPSTzPopgm…lm…Pj©¦•j©bs^6bpNl’btbdNPSRodSTSajk`sb`tlmi?gmz:S&ol’œ

bpj©gilr¦_zlrbdN­¨¼odgQ™bdNPS`dgmhPofSzPodgaf&SR`p`cgo

ª

¥NPj•fNVSaSRf&habdSe`Y¬ bdgYbdNS/{aSe`sbpj©i(l’bdj•gmiTzPopgafSR`p`dgmo

ª

¥NPjkfN

SaSRfhPbdSR`Z0¬  MNPjk`YzPopgm…P¦•S&Q«1—_iPg’¥i£lm`tbdNPS  À  ]EA ‘& K ‘E¼ K  Ä Œ &À = @8«¹jk` n½œ8Nlro{–j©i–bdNPS

fRlm`dSgr¨/lŠS&iPSRoplm¦½iPSbs¥/gmop—J T¶gmo bdNj•`0opSRl`cgi1«¹i_hPQS&opgmh` ¥/gmop—a`YNlA¤mSTodSe`sbpodjkfbpSR{ƒbdNPSRQ`cSR¦©¤SR`Ybdg

lf^af¦•jkfiSbs¥/gmop—_` =†r «†of «€ « €e~ «€e « €e† @µ«R…(Sef&lmh`cSbpNPSbdj•QSyiPSefSR`p`plrop^0bdg%f&gmQzPhabpSbdNPSyzodg…lr…Pj•¦•jŸbs^

bpNl’bxlTzlrbdNj•`ygmz:S&ol’bdj•gmi(lr¦J…(SefgQTSe`¦©j•iPSelroj•i6bpNPS0¦•S&iPŠmbdNgr¨bdNPS0zlrbdN1 

MNPS›w\¯lm¦©ŠgmopjŸbpNPQ

ª

UdwS&¦•j•lm…P¦•St^_ilrQjkf1S&¤S&¦y\afNPSe{ahP¦•j©iŠoWc¬­zodgz(g‰`cSe{ …_^xgŠlmiIlri({

»RŠPiS&oºj•i=ˆ @Jjk`lmiS_bpS&i`dj©gi°gr¨¹bpNPSx^_ilmQTjkf1S&¤S&¦¹\afNPSe{ahP¦•j©iPŠ

ª

\P¬lr¦•Šmgodj©bdNQ gm¨\_j•N6lri({

S&S+=† @8 %MNPST¦•lrbcbdSRo j•` l6¦©jk`sb0`pfNPSR{ah¦©j•iPŠNPS&hPopjk`sbpj•f­bdNlrbtblr—SR`Ylm`Yj©izPhab%lxu d gr¨ºgz(SRoplrbdj•gmi`

Alg

lmi{£lri£NPSbpS&opgmŠmSRiPS&gh` `cS&b%gr¨/zPodgaf&SR`p`cgop`

Arc

 °u/b%SRlfN£`cbdSRz1«1bpNPSNPS&hodjk`sbpj•fTSR¤Alm¦©h(l’bdSe`0lr¦•¦

bpNPSz(lrj•op`

h

gmz:S&ol’bpj©gi

,

zPopgafSR`p`dgmo

i

lri{´fNPg_g‰`cSe` bdg–zP¦•lfS°gi´zPopg_f&SR`p`cgo

p

bdNSgmz:S&ol’bpj©gi

o

^`chfN

bpNl’bbdNPS fg‰`sb¨¼hPifbdj•gmi

DL(o, p)

^:SxQl aj•Qlr¦µ tgmŠ‰lri°lmi{

»&ŠPiPSRolm{{°lril{P{aj©bdj•gmilm¦bpS&opQ bdg

bpNPS

DL

f&g`cb¨¼hPifbpj©gi?`cg°l`/bdgblr—mS0j•i‰bdg°lf&fghPi‰bbdNPS%opS&¦•jklr…Pj•¦©j©bs^gm¨bpNPS­`pfNPSR{PhP¦©j•iPŠ

ª

hi{aS&oxbdNPS

f&¦•l`d`djkf&lr¦aopS&¦•jklr…Pj•¦©j©bs^%Qga{aS&¦(gr¨1\_Nlrbd»ylri({V¡"lriŠ‰¬  ixS&if&SbdNPSbs¥/g0fopjŸbpS&opj•l«r¦•S&iPŠmbdN°lri({VopS&¦•jklr…Pj•¦©j©bs^m«

lmodSf&gmQ­…j©iPSe{%bpg0…(SefgQTSyl `dj©iŠm¦•SyfopjŸbpS&opj©gi1 MNPSy`dj•Q­hP¦kl’bpj©giVopSR`dhP¦©bp`½`dNPg’¥ bpNl’bw\­jk`Flm¦©¥lA^a`

…:SbdbdSRobdNlmi \¥0 oe bR _bdNSYopS&¦•jklr…Pj•¦©j©bs^°fopj©bdS&opj•gmi1«_…Phabxlm¦©¥lA^a`º¥/gmo`dSx¥0 oR bR _bpNPS ¦©SRiPŠrbpNf&odj©bdSRodj•gmi1 

grbpStbpNl’bbpNPS&^{agiPgrbyopS&z¦©jkf&lrbdS gmz:S&ol’bpj©gi`/iPgmoy{Plrbplrœ8{aSRz(SRi{aSRifj•SR`R 

N#i =? @µ«tgmŠ‰lri lmi{

»&ŠPiPSRozPopgmz:g`dSƒl …j•f&odj©bdSRodjkl´S_bpS&i`dj©gi gr¨0bpNPS\>lr¦•Šmgodj©bdNPQ«…_^

…hPj©¦k{aj•iPŠlrbySRlmfN›`pfNPSR{PhP¦©j•iPŠ°`cbdSRzbs¥g¦•j•`cbp`xfgmi‰blrj•iPj©iŠ°lr¦•¦¹bdNPS­zlrj•op`

hv i , m j i

gr¨$bpl`c—a`

v i

odSelm{a^

bpg…(S%`pfNPSR{PhP¦©Se{6lmi{gr¨QlfNPj•iPSR`

m j

³$bdNPSY±o`cby¦©jk`sbjk`gmo{aSRodSe{°…_^{aSefopSRlm`dj•iPŠVgop{PS&ogr¨bdNPS

DL

¨¼hifbpj©gi?bdgblr—mSVj©i‰bpglf&fghPi‰bxbpNPSj©if&odSelm`dS­j•i?bpNPS¦©SRiPŠrbpNƒgr¨ºbdNPS`dfNSR{ahP¦•STodSe`chP¦©bdj•iPŠ6¨¼odgQ bdNPS

{PSRfjk`dj©gi–bpg?zP¦klmf&S

v i

gmi

m j

R$bdNPS`cSefgi{£¦©jk`sbVj•`0gop{PS&opSR{£…_^ƒj•ifopSRl`cj•iPŠ›gmo{aSRo0gr¨bdNPS

∆COST

¨¼hifbpj©gi–bpgbplm—mSj©i‰bpglf&f&gmhPi‰b bdNPS°{PSRfopSRl`cSTj•i£opS&¦•jklr…Pj•¦©j©bs^?opSR`dhP¦©bdj•iPŠ¨¼odgQ bdNPjk`%`plrQS{aSRf&j•`dj•gmi1 

MNS&opS¨¼gmopSm«’SelmfNVzlrj•o

hv i , m j i

Nlm`$lYolriP—%j•iTSRlmfNTgr¨(bdNPg‰`cS¦•j•`cbp`R«ropSR`dz(Sefbpj©¤S&¦•^%iPgrbpSR{

Rank _i,j ¹

^lri({

Rank _i,j ²

 °MNPSe`cSTbs¥/goplmiP—a`YlmodSTbpNPS&i´fgQ­…Pj•iPSe{–l`

Rank i,j = δ ¹ Rank _i,j ¹ + δ ² Rank ² _i,j

« ¥NS&opS bpNPStbs¥gVi‰hQ­…:S&o`

δ ¹

^lri({

δ ²

lropStfNPg‰`cSRi°S&QzPj•odjkf&lm¦©¦•^°`dgVlm`ºbdgT…lm¦•lmifSxbdNPSYbs¥/gVfopj©bdS&opjklP $¶j•ilm¦©¦•^m«

bpNPSxz(lrj•o

hv i , m j i

NlA¤_j©iŠ0bdNPSY`cQlm¦©¦•SR`cb

Rank i,j

jk`/`dS&¦•SRfbdSe{°lri{

v i

jk`ºz¦•lfSR{°gmi

m j

  iyS&opStlmŠlmj©i1«

bpNPS&^{agiPgrbopS&zP¦•jkf&l’bpS gmz:S&ol’bdj•gmi(`igmoy{Plrbpl’œ#{aSRz(SRi{aS&i(fj•SR`R 

N#i =€m€ @µ«9ixlm—mSRQ lri({ Æ habpS&¦•¦©S®NlA¤mS"zPopgmz:g`dSR{šlri|lr¦•Šmgodj©bdNQ3¤mSRod^>`dj•QTj•¦klro›bpg w\J³xj•iaœ

{PS&SR{1«¦©j•—mSžj•i =ˆ @8«bdNSžbs¥g™fopjŸbpS&opj•lšlropSvlrŠŠmopS&ŠlrbdSe{|j©i‰bpg™l™`dj©iŠm¦•SI…Pj©œ8gm…aqsSefbdj•¤mSvf&g`cb£¨¼hifœ

bpj©gi1«tbdNPS´opS&¦•j•lm…Pj•¦©j©bs^vQg_{PS&¦0jk`bpNPS´gmiS–gm¨\_Nlrbd»´lri({>¡"lriPŠ(«Ylmi{vbpNPS"bpl`c—a`lropS£iPgrb›opS&zP¦•jŸœ

fRl’bpSR{´bpg–j•if&odSelm`dS°bdNSopS&¦•jklr…Pj•¦©j©bs^m  MNS¨¼hPi(fbdj•gmi

f (t, p)

{aS&iPgmbdSe`%bpNPS±iPjk`cNIbdj•QSgm¨ybdNS6blm`d—

t

^¥NPS&i jŸb"jk`´`dfNPSe{ahP¦•SR{ gmi¸bpNPS¯zPodgaf&SR`p`cgo

p

  MNSI¨¼hifbpj©gi

σ(t, p)

{aS&igrbdSe`–bdNPSžopS&¦•j•lm…Pj©¦©œ

j©bs^vfg‰`sb¥NS&i bpNPS?blm`d—

t

j•``dfNSR{ahP¦•SR{ gmivbpNPSƒzPopgafSe`d`dgmo

p

  MNPjk`…jŸœ8gm…aqsSefbpj©¤S›¨¼hPifbdj•gmi>jk`

D(t, p) = r

θ

f(t,p) max p f(t,p)

2

+ (1 − θ)

σ(t,p) max p σ(t,p)

2

 TMNPSiPgmopQlr¦•j©»el’bpj©gi?¥jŸbpNƒbpNPSQl ƒzPopSœ

¤S&i‰bp`tgmiSTf&odj©bdSRodjkl¨¼opgmQ[{agQj©ilrbdj•iPŠ6bdNPSgrbpNPS&oYgmiSm«¹¦•j©—SVj•i =€ @8 VUgmQzlmodSe{bdg›w\¹«Tixlr—S&Q

lmi{ Æ hPbdS&¦•¦•S%f¦klrj•Q bdgNlA¤St…:SbdbdSRoyodSe`ch¦Ÿb`j©iopS&¦•j•lm…Pj©¦•j©bs^°…Phaby¥/gmo`cSYj•i`pfNPSe{ahP¦•SY¦•S&iŠrbdN  

MNPS"Se¶U/w,lm¦©ŠgmopjŸbpNPQ

ª

U Q°fj•S&i‰b?¶lrh¦Ÿbdœ8Mgm¦•S&olri‰bwyS&¦•j•lm…Pj©¦•j©bs^˜Ug`cbcœxopj©¤S&i>ux¦©ŠgmopjŸbpNPQ-Ws¬

zodgz(g‰`cSe{ƒ…_^tj©i´S&bVlr¦µ 1j•i>=†† @ºzPopga{ahf&SR`%`cbplrbdjkf¨·lrhP¦©bcœµbdg¦©SRoplmi‰b0`pfNPSe{ahP¦•SR`0…_^£odSRzP¦©jkf&lrbdj•iPŠ›SRlfN

gz(SRoplrbdj•gmi0bs¥jkfS

ª

giPSºzodj•Qlrop^YopS&z¦©jkf&ltlri{­gmiPS`cSefgi{Plrop^YodSRzP¦©jkf&lybdNlrb$`dgmQS&bdj•QTSe`g’¤mS&op¦klrz`¹¥j©bdN

gmbdNPSRo½gmz:S&ol’bpj©gi`p¬RrNPSRifSSPlfbd¦•^%giPSzPodgaf&SR`p`cgo ¨·lmj©¦•hPopS/jk`$bpgm¦•S&ol’bdSe{¹ $UgifSRodij©iPŠtbdNSodSR¦©jklr…Pj•¦•jŸbs^

ª

\_Nlrbd»xlmi{¡£lmiPŠ0Qga{aS&¦Ø¬«‰SR¶$U/w bpodj•SR`½bdg­`pfNPSR{PhP¦©SxSRlmfNzPopj•Qlmod^­odSRzP¦©jkf&l gi°l0zPopgafSR`p`dgmo½`ch(fN

bpNl’bbdNPStj©i(fopSRlm`dSgr¨¹bpNPSxopS&¦•jklr…Pj•¦©j©bs^fg`cbº…:SxQj•iPj©Qlm¦:lmi{TbdNlrbºbpNPSt{aSelm{a¦•j•iPSxgm¨:bpNPSyblm`d—V…:SxQS&bR 

ixg’¥SR¤mSRoR«bdNPS0opS&¦•jklr…Pj•¦©j©bs^°gm¨bpNPS%fgQTQVhPiPjkf&lrbdj•gmi¦•j•iP—a`j•`igrbbplm—mSRi6j•i‰bdglmfRfgmhibe 

n$gmz S&b lm¦<  NlA¤mS l{P{aopSR`p`cSe{ bpNPS bpodjkfopj©bdS&opjkl gmzabpj©Qj•»Rl’bpj©gi zPopgm…P¦•S&Q

ª

¦©SRiPŠrbpN1«odSR¦©jklr…Pj•¦•jŸbs^«SRiPS&opŠm^P¬ =†m‡ @8 

Æ

grbpN bdNPS ¦•S&iPŠmbdN,lri{bdNS odSR¦©jklr…Pj•¦•jŸbs^[lmodS bplm—mSRi l`šl

f&gmi`cbdolrj•i‰bR«1opSR`dz:SRfbpj©¤S&¦•^ƒ¥j©bdN´lŠmj•¤mSRi"hPzPz:S&o­lmi{£¦©g’¥/S&o0…:gmhPi({¹ 6MNPSSRiPS&opŠm^–fgmi(`chPQzabpj©gi"j•`

Qj•iPj•QTj•»&Se{?bpNlri—_`Ybpg›{a^_ilrQjkfV¤gm¦©bplmŠmSV`pf&lm¦©j•iPŠ(«1…Phab%`dj©if&STbdNPjk`0j•ifopSRl`cSe`ybpNPSSaSRf&habdj•gmiƒbdj•QSm«

j©btlm¦•`dgNlm`ylmij©QzlfbygmibpNPS0opS&¦•j•lm…Pj©¦•j©bs^6{ahPS%bdgbdNS

e ^−λd

opS&¦•j•lm…Pj•¦©j©bs^¨¼gmopQ­h¦•l ux`xlodSe`chP¦©bR«bdNPS f&odj©bdSRodjklTlropSYj•i‰bdopj©i(`cjkf&lm¦©¦•^°{aS&z:S&i({aS&i‰bxlri({bpNPS0zPopgm…P¦•S&Q`QS&i‰bpj©giPSR{6j©ibpNPS0j©i‰bpodga{ahfbdj•gmilropj•`dSm 

N#i"lzodSR¤‰j•gmh(`xzlmz(SRoL=€ @µ«1¥/STNlA¤mSVzPodgz(g‰`cSe{?l6…Pj•f&odj©bdSRodjkl`dfNPSe{ahP¦•j©iŠ6NPSRhPopj•`cbdjkfr«¹¥NPSRodSTSRlfN

fRlri{Pj•{PlrbdSgmz:S&ol’bpj©gi

o

j•`0bdSR`cbdSe{£gmi‰bdglr¦•¦Fz:g`p`cj•…P¦•SR`0`dhP…`dSbp` gm¨zPopgafSe`d`dgmo`

p

 °¶Pgmo0SelmfN"fNPgmjkfS

ho, pi

«1¥/STf&gmQzPhabpS­bpNPSj©i{PhfSe{ƒ¤’lropjkl’bdj•gmiƒj©i£¦©SRiPŠrbpN

∆l

lri{ƒodSR¦©jklr…j©¦•jŸbs^

∆r

«1…:grbdN£iPgodQlr¦•j•»&SR{

¥0 oe be 1bdNS°¦©SRiPŠrbpN hPzPz:S&oV…(ghPi{ lmi{£bdNS°odSR¦©jklr…j©¦•jŸbs^–¦©g’¥/S&o­…(ghPi{ f&gmi`cbdolrj•i‰bp`

ª

…:grbpN zPopg’¤_j•{aSe{

…_^›bpNPSh`dS&o¬ LN#i£bdNPS…j•f&odj©bdSRodjklzP¦•lmiPSgr¨¶j•ŠmhodS € «¥SzPopgrqsSefb0SRlfNƒz:gmj•i‰b

h∆l, ∆ri

^gibpgbdNPS

{Pj•lmŠmgmi(lr¦¦•j©iPS›gm¨ lmiPŠm¦•S

θ

«lri({¯fNg‰g‰`cSbpNPS?z:gmj•ib6¥NPg`dSzPodgmqsSRfbdj•gmižj•`f¦•g`dSR`cbTbpg

h0, 0i

^ªbpNPjk`

lmQgmhPi‰bp`%bdgƒlmŠmŠodSRŠl’bpj©iŠ6bpNPS°bs¥/gƒf&odj©bdSRodjkl¬  Æ ^£¤’lrop^_j©iPŠ

θ

«½¥S6f&lri´Šj©¤S°QgmopS°¥/S&j•ŠmN‰b%bdgƒbdNPS

¦•S&iŠrbdNgmo/bpNPS0odSR¦©jklr…j©¦•jŸbs^°f&odj©bdSRodj•gmi   grbdSYbpNl’by¥NPSRibpNPS0`ch…`cS&b

p

jk`l`cj•iPŠ¦©S&bdgmi «_bdNPS gmz:S&ol’bpj©gi

o

j•`yiPgrbopS&zP¦•j•fRl’bpSR{¹«a¥NPj•¦•SY¥NS&ijŸbjk`yl`cS&b

{p 1 , . . . , p k }

«_bpNPS0gmz:S&ol’bpj©gi

o

j•`lfbdj•¤mSR¦©^odSRzP¦©jkf&lrbdSe{

gi‰bdgTbdNPS zPopgafSe`d`dgmo`

p 1

bdg

p k

 

uxQTgiPŠbdNSF¥god—a`JzPopSR`dS&i‰bpSR{ `cg¨·lmoR«RgmiP¦•^g=€ «†m† @ropS&z¦©jkf&lrbdS$bdNS½bpl`c—a`:bdgxj©if&odSelm`dSbdNPSFopS&¦•jklr…Pj•¦©j©bs^m 

N#ižfgi‰bdolm`cbR«O=ˆ « ? « €m€ « †r‡ @yf&lriiPgrbj•ifopSRl`cSbdNPSopS&¦•j•lm…Pj©¦•j©bs^´gr¨xbpNPSgm…ablrj•iPSR{¯`d^_`cbdSRQ lr…:g’¤mS6bdNPS

opS&¦•jklr…Pj•¦©j©bs^¯¦©SR¤mS&¦Ygr¨0bpNPS£Nlro{a¥lropS›zP¦•lrbc¨¼godQ bdNS–`d^_`cbdSRQj•`6SaSRf&habdSe{vgmi   MNPS£lrzPzodg‰lmfNž¥S

zodSe`cSRibyj•ibdNj•`tlrodbdjkf¦•S%h`dSR`bpNPS­lmfbdj•¤mS%opS&z¦©jkf&lrbdj•gmigr¨bpl`c—a`xlmi{{Pl’bl’œ#{aS&z:S&i({aS&if&j©Se`bpg°lmfNPj•S&¤S

lmi_^opS&¦•jklr…Pj•¦©j©bs^›¦•S&¤mSR¦opSR¾‰hPj•opSR{?…_^bdNSTh(`cSRoR«1lrbtbpNPSVzodjkfSTgr¨`dgmQS`dfNSR{ahP¦•ST¦©SRiPŠrbpNƒg’¤mSRodNSRlm{gm¨

f&gmhPo`dSm 

ux¦•`dg«½lr¦•¦bdNPS6¥god—a`0zPopSR`dS&i‰bpSR{´`dg›¨·lro =ˆ « € « ? « €m€ « †† « †m‡ @`ch.XJS&oV¨¼opgmQ bdNPSbdNPopS&S{PoplA¥…lf—a`

QSRibpj©giPSR{j•ibdNSyj©i‰bpodga{ahfbdj•gmi1³±o`sbe«mbpNPSy¦•S&iPŠmbdN°f&odj©bdSRodj•gmig’¤mSRodz:g’¥/S&o`1bpNPSxopS&¦•j•lm…Pj•¦©j©bs^Vf&odj©bdSRodj•gmiTR

`dSRf&gmi{1«j©bj•`¤mSRod^Tbdopjkf—‰^TbpgTf&gmi‰bdopgm¦(zPodSefjk`cSR¦©^TbpNPStopS&z¦©jkf&lrbdj•gmi¨·lfbdgogm¨1bdNStgz(SRoplrbdj•gmi`gmi‰bdg­bdNPS

zodgafSe`d`dgmo`R«m¨¼opgmQ bpNPS …(SRŠmj•iPiPj•iPŠTbdgTbdNS0S&i{6gr¨bdNPS0`pfNPSR{PhP¦©S RPlri{bdNj©o{¹«abpNPS0odSR¦©jklr…j©¦•jŸbs^jk`iPgmbl

QgiPgrbpgmiPgh`¨¼hPifbpj©gigr¨:bdNPSy`pfNPSR{PhP¦©S MNSylrzPzPopglfN­¥/SzPodSe`cSRi‰b$j•i°\_SRfbdj•gmi`  « f «mlri{ `dgm¦•¤mSR`

bpNPSR`dSYzPodg…P¦•S&Q`FbpNlri—_`ºbdgVbdNSYopS&z¦•lfS&QSRib/gr¨¹bpNPS odSR¦©jklr…Pj•¦•jŸbs^fopj©bdS&opj•gmi°…_^l­iS&¥>f&odj©bdSRodj•gmibpNl’b

{Pg‰Se`iPgrbx{PS&z:S&i{gmi6bdNS0SaSRf&habdj•gmi6bdj•QSR`gm¨bpNPS gmz:S&ol’bdj•gmi(`lri{{Pl’bl’œ#{aS&z:S&i({aS&if&j©Se`& 

¶j•ilr¦•¦©^«j•i>=†r « †of « € « €R~ « €R « €e† @µ« bdNPS6fgmQQVhPiPjkf&l’bpj©gi–iSbs¥/gmop—?Q­h`cb­…:Slmf&^af¦•j•fm« ¥NPjkfN"j•`

lmi´j©Qz:gmodbplmibTodSe`sbpodjkfbpj©gi1 

Æ

SR`djk{aSR`R«$j©i =†r « †3f « € « €R~ « €e† @µ«bpNPS6`d^a`sbpS&Q bdg–…(S{aj•`cbdopj•…PhabdSe{ lri({

`pfNPSe{ahP¦•SR{fgi`cjk`cbp`gr¨½l`dSbygr¨½`dgr¨Øbs¥lropSYQga{ahP¦•SR`bdNlrbxfgmQQVhPiPjkf&l’bpS0…(S&bs¥SRS&ibdNS&Q«…PhPbybdNPSe`cS

f&gmQQ­hiPj•fRl’bpj©gi` {ag›iPgrb0j•ihPSRifSbpNPSgmo{aSRoYgm¨/SaSRfhPbdj•gmi£gr¨/bdNPSQga{ahP¦•SR`R« jµ S ©« bdNPSR^ƒlropSiPgrb

{l’bplrœ8{PS&z:S&i{aSRifj•SR`2RFol’bpNPS&o­bdNPSR^ lropSlm`p`chQTSe{"bdg–…(S…Pj©œ8{Pj©opSRfbdj•gmilm¦fgQQ­hPiPjkf&lrbdj•gmi`Vlri{®lropS

lm…`cbdolmfbpSR{ l`6lmi EA  À  Â Ä Å&À “ Ä A E<“m‘aE Ä:A E À = @8  X?gmopS&g’¤mSRoR«lm¦©¦YbdNSR`dS–¥/gmop—a`

SazP¦©godSYbpNPSV`cbplrbdS%`dzlmf&S0S&i‰bdj•odSR¦©^j•i›gmo{aS&obpg±i{bpNPS­gzabdj•Qlr¦ lm¦©¦•gaf&l’bpj©gigr¨$bdNPS­QTga{ah¦©Se`ygmi‰bpg

bpNPSzPopgafSR`p`dgmo`&«J¨¼go bdNPSopS&¦•j•lm…Pj•¦©j©bs^ƒfopj©bdS&opj•gmi1  F¤S&i£¥jŸbpN `cz(lmfSopSR{ah(fbdj•gmi–bdSefNPiPjk¾‰hPSR`J=€ « €R~ @µ«

bpNPjk`FSaNlmh`cbdj•¤mSSazP¦•gmol’bpj©giVopS&Qlmj©i`F¤mS&op^Vf&g`cbd¦•^m«NPS&if&SbdNS&^lropSgmiP¦•^TfRlrzlm…P¦•Sgr¨JbdopSRlrbdj•iPŠ0¤mSRod^

`dQlr¦•¦F`cj•»&SzPopgm…¦©SRQ`

ª

¦©Se`d` bpNlri ?Qg_{PhP¦©Se`p¬ ¶j•ilm¦©¦•^m« =†r « € « €A† @bdopSRl’b bpNPSzlrodbdjkfh¦•lmo fRlm`dSVgm¨

opSR{PhPi{Plmib{aj•`cbdopj•…PhabdSe{0`c^a`cbdSRQ`R«A¥NPS&opS½SRlfN%fgQTzhabdj•iPŠyiPga{aSfgmi(`cjk`sb`1gm¨

n

jk{aS&i‰bpj•fRlr¦mzodgafSe`d`dgmo`R«

lmi{?SelmfNƒf&gmiPiSRfbpj©gi?…:Sbs¥/S&S&iƒbs¥gfgQTzhabdj•iPŠiPga{aSR`Yfgi`cjk`cbp`tgr¨

m

jk{aS&i‰bdjkf&lm¦½fgmQQVhPiPjkf&l’bpj©gi

¦•j•iP—a`& $X›gmopS`cz:SRf&jŸ±(fRlr¦•¦©^«AbdNPSR^­fgi`dj•{aSRo½`c^a`cbdS&Q`$¥j©bdNlxopSR{PhPi{Plmif^%¦•S&¤S&¦_gr¨¹†ygo½P«r…PhPbF¥jŸbpNPgmhab

`dgr¨Øbs¥lropSYodSe{ahPi{Plmif^ 

&

*

0&

uxi–lm¦©ŠgmopjŸbpNPQ ŠoplmzPN

A lg

^{j•` lri ‘P“ Á “ &E·“ Ä mEÀA  À Å B ’‘ K D}

(O, D)

 9N8b`xiPga{aSe`

ª

bdNST`dSb

O

^¬tlropS

`dgr¨Øbs¥lropS$…P¦•g_f—a`f&lr¦•¦•SR{ Ä7KÀ ’‘aEÄ:A Ž   MNPSR^Y{PgyiPgrbNlA¤mSFlmi_^t`dj•{aSºSXJSRfbe«ASPfSRzab ¨¼go1j©izPhab’gmhabpzPhab

gz(SRoplrbdj•gmi`R³tlmiƒj•iPzPhab%gz(SRoplrbdj•gmi–j•` lf&lm¦©¦bdg›l`cSRi`dgmo0{aopj©¤S&oe«:¥Nj©¦•Slri£gmhabpzPhab0gmz:S&ol’bpj©giƒjk`Yl

fRlr¦•¦bpgVlmilmfbdhlrbdgmo/{aopj©¤S&oe  ºlfNlrofygm¨

Alg

^ªbpNPS `cS&b

D

<sup>¬ºj•`/l őaR‘  ŠÀ KÀ!A Å À!A “</sup> Á£…:Sbs¥/S&S&i°bs¥g gz(SRoplrbdj•gmi`R TN8¨

.

Zvjk`$lt{Plrbplrœ8{aSRz(SRi{aSRif^«’bdNPSRi žjk`$l K  À Å À “ À ŽeŽ Ä  gmz:S&ol’bpj©gi­gr¨(gmz:S&ol’bdj•gmigZV«

¥Nj©¦•S9Z jk`yl Ž ““ À ŽRŽ Ä  gz(SRoplrbdj•gmigr¨½gmz:S&ol’bpj©giV JWtz:S&ol’bdj•gmi¸jk`xlm¦•`dgf&lm¦©¦•SR{6bdNS Ž Ä A“ Àgm¨

bpNPS{Plrbplrœ8{aSRz(SRi{aSRif^

.

^{ZV«lmi{ Z jk`%j©bp` Å À ŽR2EA ‘aE}Ä:Aº MNPS`cS&b­gr¨ylr¦•¦ºzodSe{aSRf&SR`p`cgop`Ygr¨ j•`

igrbdSe{

pred(X)

  MNS6`dSbgr¨xlr¦•¦`chfRfSe`d`dgmo`0gr¨ jk`VigrbdSe{

succ(X)

 "MNSŠmolrzN

Alg

j•i{ahf&SR`

l K ‘aA2E<‘ & Ä ’Å À ® À &·‘aEÄ:A ŽDCE K™…(S&bs¥SRS&iIbdNPSgmz:S&ol’bpj©gi`2RbpNPjk`zlrodbdjklr¦gop{aSRoodSRzPodSe`cSRi‰bp`VbdNPS

z:grbpS&i‰bdjklr¦¹z(lrolr¦•¦©SR¦©jk`cQ gr¨ bpNPS%lr¦•Šmgodj©bdNQ¢`cz:SRf&jŸ±(fRl’bpj©gi1 

MNPS

Alg

ŠoplmzPN?jk`0lmf^af&¦©jkf­…hab%jŸb%jk`Yj©iP±iPj©bdS&¦•^ƒopS&z:SRlrbdSe{ƒj•i–gop{PS&oYbdg6bplm—mSj©i‰bpglf&fghPi‰b bdNPS opSRlfbpj©¤_j©bs^?gr¨bdNS°Qg_{PS&¦•SR{"`c^a`cbdSRQ«bdN(l’b­jk`&«j©bp`%opSRlfbpj©giƒbpg?S_bdSRodi(lr¦F`cbdj•Q­hP¦•jºzPopga{ahf&SR{£…_^–j©bp`

SRi_¤‰j•opgmiPQS&i‰be  ºlmfN£SaSRf&habdj•gmi"gm¨

Alg

jk`%f&lm¦©¦•SR{£lri E·

À

’‘a2E

ÄHA °MNPSgmz:S&ol’bpj©gi` ¥j©bdN"iPg›zPopSœ

{PSRfSe`d`dgmotlropS%f&lr¦•¦•SR{ EAbK  gmz:S&ol’bdj•gmi(`&³bdNPSR^›lropS%`cSRi`cgot{aopj•¤mS&oxj©i_¤mgafRl’bdj•gmi(`bdg°opSRl{›{Pl’bl¨¼opgmQ

bpNPS0S&i_¤_j•odgiPQS&i‰bR ½MNPS0gz(SRoplrbdj•gmi`/¥j©bdNiPg°`dhf&f&SR`p`cgo/lmodS0f&lm¦©¦•SR{Ä  K  gmz:S&ol’bpj©gi`&³bpNPS&^lropS

lfbphl’bpgmo{aopj©¤S&oj©i_¤g_fRl’bpj©gi`bdgS&Qj©bx{Pl’blVbdg’¥lro{P`FbpNPS0S&i_¤_j•odgiPQS&i‰bR 

¶j•ŠmhPopS­†a³/uyi›SalmQzP¦©S0gm¨Flr¦•Šmgmopj©bdNPQ¢ŠoplmzPN

Alg

^³ N€m«7Nc†P«lri({GNslropS0j©iPzhabtgz(SRoplrbdj•gmi`R«(WV€%lri{

W †VlropS gmhabpzPhabygz(SRoplrbdj•gmi`R«auœed lmodS opS&Šmh¦•lmogz(SRoplrbdj•gmi`R 

MNSlmopfNPj©bdSefbphPodS6ŠmolrzPN

Arc

^{j•`l AÄ:A1ÂÄ oEÀ!A  À Å Œ EK ‘aA2E· À>B ’‘ K D}

(P , L, A)

¥Ng`dS`dSbgr¨

ig_{PSR`0jk`

P ∪ L

lri({–¥Ng`dS`dSbVgr¨SR{aŠSR`0jk`

A

^R

P

j•` bpNPS`dSb%gm¨zodgafSe`d`dgmo`Y¥NPj•¦©S

L

jk` bpNPS`dSb gm¨$f&gmQQ­hiPj•fRl’bpj©gi¦•j•iP—a`& u K  Ä “ À ŽRŽ Ä  jk`xfgQz(g‰`cSe{6gm¨FlfgmQzPhPbdj•iPŠhPiPj©bR«:¥NPjkfN?lr¦•¦©g’¥y`j©bybdg

SaSRfhPbdSYgmz:S&ol’bdj•gmi(`&«‰lri{gmiPSYgmo/QgmopStfgQQ­hPiPjkf&lrbdj•gmi°hiPjŸb`&«a¥Nj•fNlm¦©¦•g’¥vj©b/bpgV`dS&i{gmo/odSefSRj©¤S

{l’bplTbpg A¨¼odgQ fgQTQVhPiPjkf&lrbdj•gmi¦©j•iP—a`& u KºÄ EA    āÂ$KÄ EA T“ Ä A E<“m‘aEÄ:A &EA jk`xf&gmQz(g‰`cSe{

gm¨ l­`dSR¾‰hPSRibpj•lm¦(QSRQTgod^VbdN(l’blr¦•¦©g’¥y`ºjŸb/bdg­bdolri`dQjŸb{Pl’bl0¨¼opgmQ gmiPStzPopg_f&SR`p`cgo½bdgTlriPgmbdNPSRoR  ºlfN

Se{aŠmS gm¨

Arc

f&gmiPiSRfb`iPSRf&SR`p`dlmodj•¦•^gmiPS zPopgafSR`p`dgmolri{gmiS f&gmQQ­hiPj•fRl’bpj©gi6¦•j©i—: 

! "

# $

%# &'$

&$'#

)(*

! "

# $

&$'#

%# +'$

¶j•ŠmhPopS P³FuyiSPlmQTz¦©S gr¨$lrilrofNPj©bdSRfbdhPopSYŠmolrzPN

Arc

^{³ ª}l¬j©bp`…Pj•zlrodbdj©bdS opS&zPopSR`dS&i‰bl’bdj•gmibR

ª

…(¬/j©bp`

f&¦•l`d`djkf&lr¦JopS&zPopSR`dS&i‰bl’bdj•gmi  

u>K ‘aD …:Sbs¥/S&SRiTzodgafSe`d`dgmo`$ny€xlmi{TnFi°jk`Fl%`dSR¾‰hPSRifSny€&œ8u­€œ F€&œ8uY†Aœ8n†Aœ#uxrœ†Aœ#u frœ

· · ·

^œ8nFi1«

`dhfNTbdN(l’bºnFj

∈P

^{« j}

∈L

^«‰uxj

∈A

^{«au­€-, ªnx€m«F€e¬«uY†., ªº€m«}n†m¬«mux/,

ª

n†P«†m¬«u f,

ª

†a«nº¬«lri({`cg

gi1 MNSŠmolrzPN

Arc

<sup>j•` “ ÄHAFAÀ “m À Å</sup> j©¨(bpNPS&opSSaj•`cbp`½lYzlrbdNT…(S&bs¥SRS&ilri_^ bs¥gYiPga{aSe`RmbdNPjk`$iPgrbpj©giVjk`

h(`chlm¦©¦•^{aS&±iPSe{¨¼goiPgmiPœµ…Pj•zlmocbpjŸbpSYŠoplmzPN`R«_…Phabxj©bxlrzPz¦©j•SR`lm¦•`dgTbdg…Pj•zlrodbdj©bdS0giPSR`2Ra¥Nl’bQl’bdbdSRop`

NS&opStjk`bdNlrbj•ilVf&gmiPiPSefbpSR{

Arc

ŠmolrzPN1«‰bpNPS&opStSaj•`cbp`lVzl’bpN6…:Sbs¥/S&SRi6lri_^bs¥/gVzodgafSe`d`dgmo`

ª

lri{

igrbxgiP¦©^6…(S&bs¥SRS&i?lmi‰^6bs¥/giPga{aSR`¬ 

Æ

^lmilr¦•gmŠ^°¥j©bdN›iPgiaœµ…j©zlmocbpjŸbpS%ŠmolrzN`&«PbdNPS%ŠoplmzPN

Arc

^jk`

“ Ä K &À  Àj©¨ºbpNPS&opSTSaj•`cbp` lfgQQ­hPiPjkf&lrbdj•gmi?¦•j•iP—?…:Sbs¥/S&S&i£lri_^bs¥/gzPopgafSR`p`dgmo`

ª

lmi{–iPgrb gmiP¦•^

lmi›SR{aŠS%…:Sbs¥/S&S&i–lri_^bs¥/g°iPga{aSe`p¬ xMNPS­lmopfNjŸbpSRfbphPopS%j•` “ Ä K &À  À &Á “ Ä:ACAÀ “r À Å j©¨FjŸb`xŠoplmzPN

Arc

j•`yf&gmQzP¦•SbpSm 

MNPSY…Pj•zlrodbdj©bdSYŠmolrzNodSRzPodSe`cSRi‰bpl’bpj©gij•`SR`p`dS&i‰bdjklr¦(bdgTQg_{PS&¦:j©il­hPijŸ¨¼godQ ¥lA^Tz:gmj•i‰bcœµbdgmœµz:gmj•i‰b

f&gmQQ­hiPj•fRl’bpj©gi¦•j©iP—a`ylmi{6Q­hP¦©bdj©œµz:gmj•i‰bxfgQTQVhPiPjkf&lrbdj•gmiQTSe{ajklTlmi{…Ph`dSR`R 

+

ux¦©giPŠ¥jŸbpN"bdNPS°lm¦©ŠgmopjŸbpNPQ[ŠoplmzPN

A lg

lmi{–bdNPS°lmopfNjŸbpSRfbphPopSTŠoplmzPN

A rc

«¥/SlmodSlm¦•`dgŠmj•¤mS&i"l blr…P¦•S

E xe

gr¨FbpNPSVÃVÄ ’ŽR  “‘PŽ À´À 1À “ EÄ:A E À Ž ª

¡vU My¬xgm¨lr¦•¦bdNPSTgmz:S&ol’bpj©gi`xgm¨

A lg

^gi‰bdg

lm¦©¦xbdNPS–zPopg_f&SR`p`cgop`Tgm¨

Arc

«ylmi{¯bdNSƒÃ­Ä ’Ž&  “m‘Ž À “ Ä A E·“‘a2EÄHA 2E À Ž ª

¡vUU/My¬°gr¨%lr¦•¦

bpNPSV{l’bplrœ8{PS&z:S&i{aSRifj•SR`xgr¨

Alg

gmi‰bdglm¦©¦bdNSVfgQQ­hPiPjkf&lrbdj•gmi›¦•j©i—_`xgr¨

Arc

 tuxi?j•ibpoplrœµzodgafSe`d`dgmo f&gmQQ­hiPj•fRl’bpj©giƒblr—mSe` iPgbdj•QSbdgSaSefhabpSm MNPS¡ U ºM lrilm¦©^a`dj•` jk` bpNPSbdgzPj•fgm¨/QVhfN£¥god—

ª

`cSRS-=†a€ « €? @:¨¼gmo`dhPod¤S&^a`¬  iPg’¥j©iŠ%bdNSYSaSRfhPbdj•gmi6fN(lrolmfbpS&opj•`cbdjkf&`jk`igrbylVf&odj©bdjkf&lm¦¹lm`p`chPQzabpj©gi

`dj•ifS›¡ U ºMlrilm¦©^a`dj•`Nl`…(SRS&i lmzPzP¦•j©Se{I¥j©bdNv`dhf&f&SR`p`Tbdg´opSRlm¦Ÿœ8¦©j©¨¼SzPopg_f&SR`p`cgop`lfbdh(lr¦•¦©^ h(`cSe{

j•i>SRQ­…:SR{P{PSR{>`d^a`sbpS&Q`R«y¥jŸbpN>…Polri(fN zPopSR{ajkfbpj©gi =~ @Ygo6¥j©bdNšf&lfNPSR`6lri{>zPj©z:S&¦•j•iPSR` =†r‚ @8  N#i

z(lrodbdjkfhP¦klroe«JjŸb%Nl`Y…(SRS&i"lrzPzP¦•j•SR{ƒbdgbdNPSQg`cb0fopjŸbpj•fRlr¦½S&QV…(Se{P{aSe{–`d^a`sbpS&Q«1ilmQTSR¦©^bpNPS

ut"?‡VlA¤_j•gmiPjkf&``dgr¨Øbs¥lropStophPiPiPj•iPŠgmi6bdNS –X?n/Uˆ %zPopgafSe`d`dgmo4=‚ «†ˆ @µ 

¶j•ilr¦•¦©^«‰bdNPSYlrofNPjŸbpSRfbdhPopSyjk` D Ä ÄHB:ÀAÀ_Ä Ž j©¨lr¦•¦(j©bp`zPopgafSR`p`dgmo`½lri{°lm¦©¦:j©bp`/fgmQQVhPiPjkf&l’bpj©gi

¦•j•iP—a`yNlA¤StbpNPSV`plrQS%fNlmoplfbpS&opj•`cbdjkf&` ª`cz:S&Se{¹«QS&Qgod^«opS&¦•j•lm…Pj©¦•j©bs^m«…(lri{a¥jk{_bpN1 © • Í¬ xWxbdNPSRod¥jk`dS%jŸb

jk` D À  À  Ä:B(ÀAÀ_Ä Ž  WthPo zPodgz(g‰`cSe{?QSbpNPga{–lmi{?…j•f&odj©bdSRodjkl6`pfNPSe{ahP¦•j©iPŠlr¦•Šmgodj©bdNQ¥/gmop—a`x¥j©bdN

NSbdSRodgŠmSRiPS&gh`lmopfNjŸbpSRfbphPopSR`R 

! "/ #

MNSŠoplmzPN`

Alg

^lmi{

Arc

lropSFbpNPS Ž KºÀ “ E $$“m‘aEÄ:A6gm¨bpNPS`c^a`cbdS&Q CN8bp` E K &À À!A e‘a2EÄHA°j©i_¤mg¦©¤SR`

±(i{aj•iPŠIl®Q­hP¦©bdj•zPopg_f&SR`p`cgo6`pfNPSR{PhP¦©S–gr¨

Alg

^gmi‰bdg

Arc

«tfgQz(g‰`cSe{žgmi>giPSƒN(lri{vgm¨Vl®`dzlrbdjklr¦

lm¦©¦•gaf&lrbdj•gmi¨¼hPifbdj•gmi1«¹lmi{gmi›bpNPS­gmbdNPSRotN(lri{gm¨ºlbdSRQz(goplm¦lr¦•¦•g_fRl’bpj©gi¨¼hPifbpj©gi1 tMNS

Ž K

‘aE·‘ &

‘&&Ä

“m‘aE

Ä:A I A

“rE

Ä:A

Σ

Šmj•¤mSR`R«(¨¼gmoxSelmfN?gz(SRoplrbdj•gmi›gm¨

Alg

^ªopSR`dz1 (¨¼gmoYSRlfN?{Pl’bl’œ#{aS&z:S&i{PS&if&^a¬«

bpNPS­`dhP…`dSbxgm¨½zPodgaf&SR`p`cgop`gm¨

Arc

^ªopSR`dz1 PbpNPSV`dhP…`dSbygm¨FfgmQQVhPiPjkf&l’bpj©gi›¦©j•iP—a`¬/bdNlrbx¥j•¦©¦SaSRf&habdS j©bR 

MNPS  À KºÄ ’‘ &‘&&Ä “m‘aEÄ:A I A “rEÄ:A

Ω

Šmj•¤mSe`/bdNPS­`cbplmocbpj©iŠ°{Pl’bpS%gr¨½SRlfNgmz:S&ol’bdj•gmi ªopSR`dz1  SelmfN?{Plrbplrœ8{aSRz(SRi{aSRif^P¬gi›jŸb`xzPopgafSe`d`dgmo

ª

odSe`cz  j©bp`YfgmQQVhPiPjkf&l’bpj©gi›¦©j•iP—P¬  N#i?ŠmSRiPS&olr¦µ«P¨¼goybs¥/g

Šj©¤S&i6ŠmolrzPN`

A lg

^lmi{

A rc

«_bpNPS&opS0Sajk`sby`dS&¤S&olr¦Jz(g‰`d`dj•…P¦©S0`pfNPSR{PhP¦©Se`& 

u `dfNPSe{ahP¦•S›j•` Ž&e‘a2E<“ j©¨YbpNPS?¨¼hifbpj©gi

Ω

jk``cbplrbdjkfr ™MNPjk`°QSRlmi`bpNl’b6lm¦©¦ybdNPS£`dfNPSe{ahP¦•j©iŠ

{PSRfjk`dj©gi`NlA¤mSY…:S&S&iQlm{PSYg"X(œ8¦•j©iPS WxbdNPSRod¥jk`dStbpNPS0`dfNSR{ahP¦•S0jk` Å ÁTA ‘ ]E<“  

u¢`cbplrbdjkf`dfNSR{ahP¦•Sjk`0à E¼2D Ä › À!K &E·“‘a2EÄHAžj©¨¨¼gmo0SRlfN"gmz:S&ol’bdj•gmi ª

lmi{£¨¼gmo0SelmfN´{Plrbpl’œ

{PS&z:S&i{aSRif^P¬«FbdNS`dSb

Σ(X)

jk`lƒ`dj©iŠm¦•Sbdgi1«FgoVj•iIgmbdNPSRoV¥/gmo{P`R«

|Σ(X)| = 1

  N#i¯fgibpopl`sbe«Fl

`pfNPSe{ahP¦•Sxjk`ºÃ E¼D \‘P“rEM Àc  À!K &E<“m‘aEÄ:Aƒj©¨1¨¼gmo`dgmQSxgz(SRoplrbdj•gmi ª

gmo/`cgQSt{Plrbpl’œ#{aSRz(SRi{aS&i(f^P¬«

|Σ(X)| ≥ 2

 tMNPSTi_hPQ­…:S&o

|Σ(X)|

jk`Yf&lr¦•¦•SR{bpNPS  À!K &E·“‘a2EÄHA Iµ‘“r Ä  gm¨ ­ 0N#iƒl`pfNPSe{ahP¦•S%¥jŸbpN opS&z¦©jkf&lrbdj•gmi1«PlŠj©¤S&igmz:S&ol’bdj•gmif&lmi›`sblrodbj©bp`ySaSRf&habdj•gmi›lm``dg_gmi›lm`j©bxNl`odSefSRj©¤SR{lr¦•¦1jŸb`j•iPzPhab

{l’bpllrb¦•SRl`sb¨¼opgmQ¢giPS0lmfbdj•¤mS odSRzP¦•j•fRlVgm¨SelmfNgr¨j©bp`yzPodSe{aSRf&SR`p`cgop`R bN#igmbdNPSRo¥gop{P`R«_jŸbx{Pg‰Se`iPgrb

iS&SR{bdg¥lrj©b¨¼gmobpNPS0odSefSRzabdj•gmigr¨jŸb`j©izPhabt{Plrbpl`dS&i‰b…‰^6lr¦•¦¹bdNPS opS&zP¦•jkf&lm`gm¨j©bp`zodSe{aSRf&SR`p`cgop`R 

u™`pfNPSR{ah¦©Stj•`OK ‘aA2E·‘& j©¨iPgmblm¦©¦:bpNPStgz(SRoplrbdj•gmi`ºgr¨

Alg

NlA¤Sy…:S&S&i`pfNPSR{ah¦©Se{¹«_…Phabgr¨f&gmhPo`cS lm¦©¦:bpNPStgz(SRoplrbdj•gmi`ºbdN(l’bylropSt`pfNPSR{PhP¦©Se{lmodSY`chfNbdNlrbylr¦•¦(bpNPS&j•ozPopSR{aSefSR`p`dgmo`ºlropStlm¦•`dgV`pfNPSe{ahP¦•SR{¹ 

¶j•ilr¦•¦©^«FbpNPS &ÀACB 2D gmo ‘ À Ž K ‘ Ašgr¨ l–`cbplrbdjkf6`pfNPSR{PhP¦©Sjk`­bpNPS

max

gr¨xbpNPS6bdS&opQj©i(l’bdj•gmi bpj©QSe`gr¨bdNPS0¦klm`cbgmz:S&ol’bdj•gmi`pfNPSR{ah¦©Se{gi6SelmfNgr¨bdNPS0zPopgafSe`d`dgmo`ºgm¨

Arc

 ½¡£S0iPgrbpSYj©b’ 

Æ gmbdNzPodgaf&SR`p`cgop`lri({6f&gmQQ­hPij•fRl’bdj•gmi¦•j©iP—a`yfRlri6¨·lrj•¦<«(lri{6bdNS&^6lmodS I8‘E& ŽE&ÀA   ºU¦•l`d`djkf&lr¦•¦•^m«_¥S

l{agmzPbxbdNS­¨·lmj©¦•hPopSVQga{aS&¦$gm¨/\_Nlrbd»lri{›¡"lriŠS=†r @µ³¨·lmj©¦•hPopSR` lropS RA‘ A ŽEÀA  «1lmi{bpNPSQl aj©Qlr¦

{PhPoplrbdj•gmi gr¨Pl¨·lmj©¦•hPopSFjk` `dhfNYbdNlrbj©bloXJSRfbp`1giP¦•^xbpNPSºfhodopS&i‰b gz(SRoplrbdj•gmi SaSRf&habdj•iPŠgibpgbdNS½¨·lrhP¦©bs^

zodgafSe`d`dgmoe«(lmi{›iPgmbtbpNPS`chP…(`cSe¾hS&i‰btgz(SRoplrbdj•gmi`

ª

lri({ƒ`dj©Qj•¦•lmod¦•^¨¼goxbpNPSfgmQQVhPiPjkf&l’bpj©gi?¦•j©iP—a`¬ R

bpNPjk`%jk`0—_iPg’¥i´lm` bpNPS-UcNPgrbtWT¨·lmj©¦•hPopS°Qg_{PS&¦µ ufRfgmo{aj•iPŠbdg›bpNPjk`0¨·lrj•¦•hPodSQga{aSR¦<«bdNPSg_fRfhPopopS&if&S

gm¨¨·lrj•¦©hodSe`%gmi lƒzPopg_f&SR`p`cgo0n

ª

opSR`dz1 $l?fgQQ­hPiPjkf&lrbdj•gmi´¦•j©i— ¬ ¨¼g¦©¦•g’¥y`­l›n$gj•`p`cgi´¦•lA¥ ¥j©bdN®l

f&gmi`cbplmi‰b$z(lrolrQSbpS&o

λ

«f&lm¦©¦•SR{Tj©bp` I8‘E& À ’‘a ÀJKÀ ­2E À A E·  ½X›godSRg’¤mS&oe«e¨·lrj•¦©hodSgaf&f&hPopodSRifSe`

lmodS `cbpl’bpj•`cbdjkf&lm¦©¦•^°j•i{aSRz(SRi{aS&i‰bxSR¤mSRib`& ½MNPSe`cS0l`d`dhPQzabdj•gmi(`lropSxbpNPS%`dlmQS l`/bdNPg‰`cS0Ql{aS j©i =†r «

†3f « € «€e~ «€e « €A† «†† «ˆ «€ «? «†m‡ @8  grbdSYlr¦k`cg%bdNlrbºbdolri(`cj•S&i‰bF¨·lmj©¦•hPopSR`ºlmodSybdNPStQTg‰`sb/fgmQQgmi°¨·lrj•¦©hPopSR`

j•iQg_{PS&opi6SRQ­…:SR{P{aSe{`c^a`cbdS&Q`R 

MNPS  À &E·‘PŒFE&E¼ Á¸gm¨­l®`d^a`sbpS&QQSRlm`dhPopSR`jŸb`f&gmi‰bdj•i_hPj©bs^¯gm¨­`cSRod¤_jkfS  N8bj•`{aS&±iPSR{˜lm`bdNPS

zodg…lr…Pj•¦•jŸbs^–bdNlrbTj©bT¨¼hPifbpj©gi`fgodopSRfbd¦•^–{ahPopj•iPŠ–l–Šmj•¤mSRi"bdj•QTSj•ibpS&op¤’lr¦ =† @µ "uf&f&gmo{aj©iŠ›bdg£gmhPo

Qga{aSR¦<«ebdNSºopS&¦•j•lm…Pj©¦•j©bs^tgm¨abdNPSzPodgaf&SR`p`cgo1n ªopSR`dz1 &bdNPSfgQTQVhPiPjkf&lrbdj•gmi ¦©j•iP— ¬ {ahPopj©iŠybdNS{ahPol’bpj©gi

d

^j•`R³

R = e ^−λd

Ugi_¤mS&o`dS&¦•^m«AbdNS K  Ä Œ$‘aŒFE&E· Á£Ä I I8‘E&  À%gm¨JbdNPStzPodgaf&SR`p`cgon

ª

opSR`dz1 ’bdNStfgQQ­hPiPjkf&lrbdj•gmi¦•j©iP— ¬

{PhPodj•iPŠTbdNS%{ahPol’bdj•gmi

d

^jk`&³

F = 1 − R = 1 − e ^−λd

ixS&if&Sm«bpNPS£odSR¦©jklr…Pj•¦•jŸbs^žgr¨0bpNPS£gmz:S&ol’bdj•gmivgo6{Plrbplrœ8{aSRz(SRi{aSRif^ zP¦•lfSe{vgmi‰bdg bdNPS£Nlro{a¥lropS

f&gmQz:gmiPSRibtU

ª

…:S0jŸbxlTzPopgafSe`d`dgmo/gmoylfgQQ­hPiPjkf&lrbdj•gmi¦©j•iP—P¬/jk`&³

R(X, C) = e ^{−λ C E xe (X,C)}

^{ª €e¬}

X?g_{PS&opi®¨·lmj©¦©œ8`dj•¦©SRib°zodgafSe`d`dgmo`f&lmiINlA¤S›l£¨·lrj•¦©hPopSoplrbdS›lropgmhi{

10 ⁻⁶ /hr

 š¶Pgoj©i`cbplmifS«/bdNPS zodg…lr…Pj•¦•jŸbs^VbdNlrb/l­zPodgaf&SR`p`cgoR«r¥Ng`dS¨·lrj•¦©hodStoplrbdSyjk`ºSe¾‰hlr¦(bdg

10 ⁻⁶ /hr

«‰…:Sxgz(SRoplrbdj•gmilm¦({ahodj•iPŠV†

NgmhPo` jk`

e ^{−10 −6 ∗2} ' 0.999998

 1UgifSRodij©iPŠtjŸb`zPodg…lr…j©¦•jŸbs^ gm¨P¨·lrj•¦©hodS/{ahPopj©iPŠtbdNS/`plrQS{ahPol’bdj•gmi « j©byjk`SR¾‰hlr¦Jbpg

1 − e ^{−10 −6 ∗2} ' 0.000002

 

/ #

À $ A E¼EÄ:A Ž 6À &E·‘aŒ E&E¼Á &Ä “  E·‘ B ’‘ Ž ªw Æ ¬ºN(lA¤mSy…:S&SRij•ibpodga{ah(fSR{°bdgfgQTzhabdStbdNPS

opS&¦•jklr…Pj•¦©j©bs^Tgr¨ l%`d^a`sbpS&Q =€e‚ @8 $¶gmopQlr¦•¦©^«lri6w Æ >jk`ºlmiÄ oEÀ!A  À Å B ’‘ K D

(N, E)

«‰¨¼gmo¥NPjkfN°SRlfN ig_{PS/gm¨

N

<sup>j•`$l Œ&Ä “</sup> opS&zPopSR`dS&i‰bpj©iPŠYlriVS&¦•S&QS&i‰b½gr¨(bdNPS`d^_`cbdSRQ«rlri{VSRlfNVlrofgr¨

E

^j•`½l “m‘Že‘ &E· Á

&EA …:Sbs¥/S&S&i–bs¥/g6…P¦•gaf—a`& -N#i£lmi‰^?w Æ V«JbdNS&opSlmodSVbs¥/g6zlmocbpj•f&hP¦klro …P¦•g_f—a`R³xj©bp` Ž Ä ’“ Àƒ\–lri({

j©bp` Å À ŽR2EA ‘aEÄ:AV :uxi?w Æ ¸opS&zPopSR`dS&i‰bp`xl°`c^a`cbdSRQ lri({j•`xh`cSe{bdgf&gmQzPhabpS%j©bp`yopS&¦•jklr…Pj•¦©j©bs^J³lmi

w Æ jk`0ÄHKºÀ A‘P2EÄ:A ‘ & j X´bdNS&opSTSaj•`cbp` l’b0¦•SRl`sb gmiPSTgmz:S&ol’bpj©gilr¦$zlrbdN–¨¼odgQ\›bpg­ 1u zlrbdN£j•`

gz(SRoplrbdj•gmilm¦ j©¨/lmi{?giP¦©^j©¨/lm¦©¦bdNSV…P¦•gaf—a`xj•iƒbpNPjk`tz(l’bdN£lropS­gz(SRoplrbdj•gmilm¦< 0MNPSTzPopgm…lm…Pj©¦•j©bs^6bpNl’b

l…P¦•gaf—?…:Sgmz:S&ol’bdj•gmi(lr¦½jk` jŸb`0odSR¦©jklr…j©¦•jŸbs^  Æ ^ƒfgi`sbpodh(fbdj•gmi «¹bdNPSzodg…lr…Pj•¦•jŸbs^›bpNl’b­lmi£w Æ …(S

gz(SRoplrbdj•gmilm¦Jj•`/bpNPS&opS¨¼godS SR¾‰hlm¦JbdgTbdNS0odSR¦©jklr…Pj•¦•jŸbs^°gm¨bpNPS0`c^a`cbdSRQ j©byodSRzPodSe`cSRi‰bp`R 

N#igmho$fRlm`dSm«’bpNPS`c^a`cbdSRQ¸j•`½bdNPSQ­h¦Ÿbpj©zPopgafSe`d`dgmo½`cbpl’bpj•f`pfNPSR{PhP¦©S«rz:g`p`cj•…P¦•^%zlrodbdjklr¦µ«’gr¨

Alg

^gmi‰bdg

Arc

  ºlfN°…P¦•g_f—opS&zPopSR`dS&i‰b`Flri°gz(SRoplrbdj•gmi šzP¦klmfSe{gmi‰bpg­l%zPopgafSe`d`dgmoFn®gmol­{Plrbpl’œ#{aSRz(SRi{aS&i(f^

.

^Z zP¦•lfSe{›gmi‰bdglf&gmQQ­hPij•fRl’bdj•gmiƒ¦©j•iP—F ¹MNPSVodSR¦©jklr…Pj•¦•jŸbs^gr¨ºl…P¦•g_f—jk`ybpNPS&opS¨¼godSTfgQTzhabdSe{

lf&f&gmo{aj©iŠ­bpgV¨¼godQVhP¦kl ª€ ¬ 

UgQTzhabdj•iPŠ›bpNPS°opS&¦•j•lm…Pj©¦•j©bs^ƒj•i"bdNPjk`%¥lA^ƒlm`p`dhPQSR` bpNl’b%bpNPS°gaf&f&hPopodSRifSe` gr¨bdNPS°¨·lrj•¦©hPopSR`­lropS

ŽRR‘P2E·ŽR2E<“m‘ &&Á EA Å À KÀ!A Å À!A  À M À!A eŽ  ƒ¡vjŸbpNPgmhabVbdNPjk`VN‰^_z:grbpNPSR`dj•`R«bdNPS¨·lmfb­bdNlrbT`dgmQS°…P¦•gaf—_`

…:S&¦•gmiŠ­bpg`dS&¤S&olr¦:zl’bpN`¨¼odgQ \°bdg |Qlr—mSe`FbpNPS%fgQzPhabplrbdj•gmi6gr¨ bpNPS odSR¦©jklr…j©¦•jŸbs^¤S&op^fgmQzP¦•S¹ 

UgifSRodij©iPŠNlmop{a¥lropS%¨·lmhP¦©bp`R«¹bdNPjk`0N_^_z(gmbdNPSe`cjk` jk` odSelm`dgmilm…P¦©S«J…Phab0bdNj•`0¥/gmh¦•{ƒiPgrb%…:STbdNPS°fRlm`dS

¨¼goy`cgm¨Øbs¥/lmodSt¨·lrh¦Ÿb`4=€’ˆ @8 

MNPS›Qlmj©iž{aolA¥…lmf—´gm¨xbdNj•`°lmzPzPopglfN®jk`TbdNlrbbdNPS?f&gmQzPhabl’bdj•gmi¯gr¨tbdNPS›opS&¦•jklr…Pj•¦©j©bs^ jk`&«/j•i

ŠS&iPSRoplm¦<«Saz(giPS&i‰bpj•lm¦ j•i›bdNPST`cj•»&S­gr¨$bdNPSTw Æ ­ :¡vNPSRi›bdNPST`dfNSR{ahP¦•S%jk`x¥j©bdNgmhabxopS&z¦©jkf&lrbdj•gmi1«(bdNPS

w Æ ™jk` Ž À oE·‘&

ª

jµ Sm •«abdNPSRodSYjk`/lT`dj©iPŠ¦©SYzlrbdN°¨¼opgmQ \°bdg ¬`dgVbdNPS0fgQzPhabplrbdj•gmi6gr¨1bpNPS odSR¦©jklr…Pj•¦•jŸbs^

jk`F¦•j•iPSRlmoFj©i°bdNPSY`cj•»&Sygm¨JbdNPSxw Æ V  Æ hPb¥NPSRibdNPSY`dfNPSe{ahP¦•Syjk`F¥j©bdNopS&zP¦•j•fRl’bpj©gi`&«mbdNPSYw Æ >N(lm`½iPg

z(lrodbdjkfhP¦klro/¨¼gmopQ«P`cgVbdNS%fgmQzPhPbpl’bpj©gi6gm¨ bpNPS odSR¦©jklr…Pj•¦•jŸbs^°jk`Saz:gmiPSRi‰bdjklr¦¹j•ibpNPS%`cj•»&S gm¨ bdNS%w Æ ­ 

ux¦•`dg«_lri6w Æ >jk` K ‘a’‘ &&À & j©¨lr¦•¦j©bp`…P¦•g_f—a`lropSyj©i6zlrolr¦•¦•S&¦µ ¶j©i(lr¦•¦©^«_lmi°w Æ šj•` Ž À oE·‘ &Â$K ‘a’‘ &&À &

j©¨j©bp`xfgmi(`cjk`sb`/gr¨l`dSR¾‰hPSRifSYgr¨$zlrolr¦•¦•S&¦:z(gocbpj©gi`&  N#ibdNg`dSt¦klm`cbbs¥gf&l`cSe`&«‰bpNPS0fgmQzPhPbpl’bpj©gi6gm¨

bpNPS0opS&¦•j•lm…Pj©¦•j©bs^j•`ylm¦•`dg+&:)oTj•i6bpNPS0`cj•»&S0gm¨ bpNPS%w Æ ­ 

¶j©ŠhPodS f³Fu|`dj•QTz¦©S

Alg

^ŠmolrzN1 

2

$

$

! &-$ " # # &'#

1

.

2

.

.

1

.

¶j•ŠmhPopS a³½u|`dj©QzP¦•S%`dfNSR{ahP¦•S ¥jŸbpNPgmhPbyodghabdj•iPŠ 

ut`Ylmi?SPlmQTz¦©S«Jf&gmi`djk{aS&otbdNPS`dj©QzP¦•S

Alg

ŠmolrzPNƒgr¨¶j•ŠmhPopS f  Yu z:g`p`cj•…P¦•SV`pfNPSR{ah¦©j•iPŠ¥j©bdN opS&z¦©jkf&lrbdj•gmigm¨bpNPjk`

Alg

ŠmolrzPN6j•`x`cNPg’¥˜j©i¶j©ŠhPopS «P¥NPSRodS gz(SRoplrbdj•gmi |jk`opS&zP¦•jkf&l’bpSR{bs¥j•f&S

ª

j©bp`

opS&z¦©jkf&l`…:S&j•iPŠiPgmbdSR{

1

^lmi{

2

¬/lri({gz(SRoplrbdj•gmiZ|jk`lr¦k`cgTopS&zP¦•j•fRl’bpSR{bs¥jkfS

ª

jŸb`odSRzP¦©jkf&l`/…(SRj©iPŠ

igrbdSe{ Z

1

^{lmi{ Z}

2

^{¬ ´MNPSw Æ} fgodopSR`dz(gi{aj•iPŠ›bpg?bdNj•``pfNPSR{ah¦©Sj•`T`dNPg’¥i j•iI¶j©ŠhPopS ~ «½¥j©bdN

`dgmhopf&S \lri({6{aSe`sbpj©i(l’bdj•gmiV MNPjk`w Æ |Nl`iPgzlrodbdjkfhP¦klro¨¼godQ

.

1

2

.

.

.

1

2

!

"

#

¶j©ŠhPodS ~P³FMNS%w Æ ™gr¨bdNPS%`pfNPSR{PhP¦©S gm¨$¶j•ŠmhPopS  

% EA E ‘ &(“yŽ À eŽ À D Ä Å MNS&opSºlropS½bs¥/gyQlrj•i%`cg¦©habpj©gi`¹bpgyg’¤mSRopf&gmQS$bdNj•` zPodg…P¦•S&Q ¶j•op`cbR«

giPS°f&lmi–h(`cSbpNPS ]EA E ‘ &y“ ƒŽ À RŽ À D Ä Å =€f « f @8 6MNPjk`0QSbpNPga{£j•`0h(`cSe{–…_^£fgmQQS&ofjklr¦

bpg_gm¦k`y`ch(fN?lm`ywSR¦©jklr…j©¦•jŸbs^¡£gmop—‰…:S&i(fN6¨¼opgmQ%$ '&)(!* + go N8bdSRQMg_gm¦•—‰j©by¨¼opgmQ%$, - .  u “ 

Ž À  j©i°lmi°w Æ jk`ºl%`dSbgr¨¹…P¦•g_f—a`

C

`chfNbpNl’bºbdNPSRodSySaj•`cbºiPg0zlrbdN¨¼opgmQ \Vbdg >jŸ¨1¥/SopS&Qg’¤mSlr¦•¦

bpNPS%…P¦•gaf—a`ygr¨

C

^{¨¼opgmQ bdNSVw Æ V (u f&hab}

C

<sup>j•` ]EA E®‘ &</sup> j©¨s«(¥N(l’bdSR¤mSRobdNPSV…P¦•g_f—bdNlrbtjk`yopS&Qg’¤mSe{

¨¼opgmQj©bR«JbdNS­opSR`dhP¦Ÿbpj©iŠ`cS&bYjk`yigrbYl6fhab0lri_^_QgmopSm yMNPSVodSR¦©jklr…j©¦•jŸbs^gr¨½bpNPS`sbl’bdjkf%QVhP¦©bdj•zPodgaf&SR`p`cgo

`pfNPSe{ahP¦•S

S

jk`ylrzPzodg aj•QlrbdSe{…_^°bdNS0odSR¦©jklr…Pj•¦•jŸbs^gm¨bpNPS%w

Æ

¸fgQz(g‰`cSe{°gr¨½lr¦•¦JbdNS0QTj•iPj•Qlr¦ f&habp`

zhabj©i`cSe¾hS&if&Sm ½MNPSYodSR¦©jklr…Pj•¦•jŸbs^gm¨l­Qj•iPj•Qlm¦¹fhaby`dSb

C i

jk`bdNPS opS&¦•j•lm…Pj©¦•j©bs^Tgm¨lr¦•¦JjŸb`…P¦•g_f—a`zPhab

j•izlrolr¦•¦•S&¦µ³

R(C i ) = 1 − Y

(o,c)∈C i

1 − R(o, c)

ª

†m¬

ixS&if&Sm«_j•i°gmo{aS&oºbdgTlrzPzPopg aj©QlrbdSbpNPSxopS&¦•j•lm…Pj•¦©j©bs^

R(S)

^{gm¨ lriw Æ} V«_jŸb`chQf&SR`FbdgfgmQzPhPbdStlm¦©¦:j©bp`

Qj•iPj•Qlm¦fhPbº`cS&bp`

C i

«i_hPQ­…:S&opSR{V¨¼opgmQ¢€/bdg

n

«‰lri{VbpNPS&iTbdg%f&gmQzPhabpSbdNPSopS&¦•jklr…Pj•¦©j©bs^

R ⁻ (S)

^gr¨:bdNPS

`dS&opjklr¦©œµzlmoplm¦©¦•S&¦(w Æ šf&gmQz:g`dSR{gm¨ lr¦•¦(bpNPSR`dS fhab`& ½MNPjk`fgmQzPhPbpl’bpj©gi°jk`¦•j•iPSRlmoj•ibdNSYi_hPQV…(SRogm¨

Qj•iPj•Qlm¦ fhPbx`cS&bp`R³

R(S) ≥ R ⁻ (S) = Y n

i=1



1 − Y

(o,c)∈C i

1 − R(o, c)





ª

¬

MNPjk`$lrzPzodg aj•Qlrbdj•gmi%jk`$ly¦•g’¥SRo…:gmhi{¹«m`dgxj©¨:lt`dfNPSe{ahP¦•S

S

j•`$`dhfN%bpNl’b

R ⁻ (S) > R obj

«r¥NS&opS

R obj

jk`$bdNSxopS&¦•j•lm…Pj©¦•j©bs^­gm…PqsSRfbpj©¤SbdNlrbFbdNSbplmodŠSbº`pfNPSR{ah¦©SQVh`sbQTSRSbe«mbpNPS&i°j©bºzPopg’¤mSe`bdNlrb

R(S)

jk`ŠmopSRlrbdSRo­bpNlri

R obj

«¥Nj•fN¯j•`z:S&od¨¼SRfbd¦•^ ±iSm žMNPS›Qlrj•iIzPopgm…¦©SRQ,gr¨YbdNPjk`QSbdNg_{¯jk`TbdNlrbR«

/0213546879;:

î <==> ?A@@BBB CEDFGHIJ><8KLFGM=BLJILNCPOGQCR<=Q ï

S 0ETVUXW

î <==> ?A@@BBB CED=NQ;YZ CQVO2Q[JXD\]CPOGQ8@I^L_!CR<L=Q8\

{PS&z:S&i{aj•iPŠgmi6bdNS `cbdophfbdhPopS gr¨ bpNPS0w Æ ­«_bpNPS bdgmbplm¦:i_hPQV…(SRogr¨QTj•iPj•Qlr¦1fhPbp`jk`…(S&bs¥SRS&i

n − 1

lmi{

2 ⁿ⁻²

«’¥NPS&opS

n

j•`bpNPSi‰hQ­…:S&o$gr¨ig_{PSR`gr¨PbpNPSw Æ ­ r¶gmoj©i(`sblrif&Sm«’bpNPS/w Æ žgm¨(¶j©ŠhPopS ~ Nlm`

€€xQj•iPj©Qlm¦Jf&hab`cS&bp`R³

{1, 2}

^«

{3, 4, 5, 6}

^«

{7, 8}

^«

{1, 5, 6}

^«

{2, 3, 4}

^«

{3, 5, 8}

^«

{4, 6, 7}

^«

{1, 6, 7}

^«

{1, 5, 8}

^«

{2, 4, 7}

^«Flmi{

{2, 3, 8}

 žux`°l"fgi`dSR¾‰hPS&i(fSm«ºbdNPS–lrzPzPopg aj©QlrbdS6f&gmQzPhabl’bpj©gi¯gm¨tbpNPS opS&¦•jklr…Pj•¦©j©bs^¥jŸbpN?bdNSVQj•iPj©Qlm¦$f&hab0`cS&bp`tQTS&bdNPga{ƒj•`Ylr¦k`cgSaz(giPS&i‰bpj•lm¦j•i?bpNPST`dj•»&S­gm¨

S

 0MNPjk`xjk`tl {PoplA¥…lf—gr¨bdNPS0…Pjkfopj©bdS&opjklV`pfNPSR{PhP¦©j•iPŠlr¦•Šmgodj©bdNQ zPodgz(g‰`cSe{j•i =€ @µ 

_ À oE·‘ &Â$K ‘a’‘ &&À &tŽR“mD À Å&À À D Ä Å ¶gmo bdNj•` opSRl`cgi1«J¥SzPopgmz:g`dS%bpgzodga{ahf&ST`pfNPSe{ahP¦•SR` j•i

`dhfNl ¥lA^%bdN(l’bFbpNPSxfgodopSR`dz:gmi{aj•iPŠ0w Æ ¥j•¦•¦…:Sm«‰…‰^Tfgi`sbpodh(fbdj•gmi «`dS&opj•lm¦Ÿœ8zlrolr¦•¦•S&¦µ  MNPjk`Flr¦•¦©g’¥y`

h(`Tbdg"fgmQzPhPbdSjŸb`odSR¦©jklr…j©¦•jŸbs^®j©ižlƒ¦•j•iPSRlmoVbpj©QS›¥0 oR bR $bpNPS›`cj•»&Sgm¨

S

 žMNPS›{aoplA¥…(lmf—"j•`TbpNl’b bpNPS`dfNPSe{ahP¦•SR`Y¥/S­zPopga{ahfSTNlA¤SVl°ŠodSel’bpS&o «JbdNlrbYjk`&«1lNPj•ŠmNPSRoYg’¤S&opNPSRl{ R:NPg’¥SR¤mSRoR«:¥ST¥j•¦©¦

`dS&S j•i\aSRfbpj©gi ~P Êˆ bpNl’bbpNPS%lm{P{PjŸbpj©gilr¦¹g’¤S&opNPSRl{j©i(fhPopodSe{°…_^°bpNPjk`{aSR`dj©ŠifNgmjkfS j•`opSRl`cgilr…¦©S 

N#i({aS&Se{¹«mhPi¦©j•—mS¥NlrbF¥SN(lA¤mS`dlmj•{Tj•i\aSRfbpj©gi P f opS&Š‰lro{aj•iPŠxbpNPSx`pfNPSR{PhP¦©Se`$¥jŸbpNodSRzP¦•j•fRl’bdj•gmi «rgmhPo

zodgz(g‰`dlm¦(¨¼gopf&SR`SelmfNgmz:S&ol’bpj©gibpg¥/lmjŸb¨¼gobdNPS­odSefS&zPbdj•gmigr¨½lr¦•¦1jŸb`yj•iPzPhabY{Pl’bl`cSRiby…_^lr¦•¦¹bdNPS

opS&z¦©jkf&l`Fgr¨jŸb`ºzPopSR{PSRfSe`d`dgmo`F…:S¨¼godSY`sblrodbdj•iPŠ%j©bp`/SaSefhabpj©gi1«_grbdNS&op¥j•`dSbdNStg…abplmj©iPSe{°w Æ š¥ghP¦k{

igrb…(S%`dS&opjklr¦©œµzlmoplm¦©¦•S&¦µ 

1

2

1

1

2

1

2

3

2

1

2

1

2

2

1 1

3

2

¶j•ŠmhPopSˆa³

ª

l‰¬%u bdolri`c¨¼gmopQSR{

Alg

^ŠoplmzPN ¥j©bdNIodSRzP¦©jkf&lrbdj•gmi lmi{´¥j©bdNIlƒodghabdj•iPŠ–gmz:S&ol’bdj•gmi w

¥NS&i >lri({gZšlropS/opS&z¦©jkf&lrbdSR{Vbs¥jkfS R ª

…:¬º\almQTSyl`

ª

l‰¬$¥jŸbpNPgmhPb½bdNPSyopgmhPbdj•iPŠ0gmz:S&ol’bpj©giTR

ª

fe¬F\almQTS

l`

ª

l‰¬º¥NS&i+Z¸j•`yodSRzP¦©jkf&lrbdSe{bdNodjkfS R ª

{¬\PlrQS%lm`

ª

fR¬/¥j©bdNPghabbdNPS0opgmhPbdj•iPŠVgz(SRoplrbdj•gmi1 

UgifSRodiPj•iPŠ bpNPSx`pfNPSR{ah¦©j•iPŠ%lr¦•Šmgodj©bdNQ«rbdNPjk`FQSbpNPga{j©i_¤gm¦•¤mSR`$j•i`dS&odbdj•iPŠ%lri°l{P{aj©bdj•gmilm¦

 Ä



Â

E

ACBÄHKºÀ

’‘a2E

ÄHA«A¥NPg`dSF¡ U ºM"j•` SR¾‰hlm¦rbdgt‡bdj•QSºhPiPj©bR«’…:Sbs¥/S&SRi bdNPS/{Pl’bl’œ#{aS&z:S&i({aS&if&j©Se` f&gmQj©iŠ

ghabygr¨$bpNPS­`dgmhPofS gmz:S&ol’bpj©gi›lri{6bdNS­{Pl’bl’œ#{aS&z:S&i({aS&if&j©Se`Šmgj©iŠVbpg’¥/lmop{`/bdNPS­{PSR`cbdj•il’bpj©gigz(SRocœ

lrbdj•gmi1 MNPS%opSRlm`dgmi6gr¨bdNPjk`xfNgmjkfS j•`ybdNlrbbdNPSVw Æ |gr¨F`dhfN›`dfNPSe{ahP¦•SR`¥j©bdN›opgmhabpj©iŠTgz(SRoplrbdj•gmi`

lmodS­ŠmhlmoplmibpS&Se{°bpg…:SV`dS&opj•lm¦Ÿœ8zlrolr¦•¦•S&¦µ«PNPS&i(fS­Qlm—‰j•iPŠbpNPSVf&gmQzPhabl’bpj©gi›gr¨½bdNS­opS&¦•j•lm…Pj©¦•j©bs^6¦•j©iSRlro

j•i`cbdSelm{gr¨1Saz(giPS&i‰bdjklr¦(j©i°bdNPSY`cj•»&Sygm¨JbdNPSYw Æ ª

`cSRSY\_Sefbdj•gmi  ~ ¬ F¶j©ŠhPopS ˆ ª

l‰¬F`dNPg’¥y`$bpNPSxŠoplmzPN

bpoplmi`c¨¼gmopQlrbdj•gmi6bdNlrbtgaf&f&hPo`¨¼odgQ bpNPS

Alg

ŠmolrzPNgr¨F¶j•ŠmhPopS f ¥NPSRi¸jk`yopS&zP¦•jkf&l’bpSR{bs¥jkfS ª

1

lmi{

2

^¬Ylmi{VZ jk` odSRzP¦•j•fRl’bdSe{›bpNPodjkfS ªZ

1

^{« Z}

2

^{« lri{Z}

3

¬ N#i´`chfN£lf&lm`dSm«1l6opgmhabpj©iPŠgmz:S&ol’bpj©gi w˜jk`j©i`dS&odbdSe{…:Sbs¥/S&SRibpNPSYbs¥gTopS&zP¦•j•fRlm`/gr¨¸lri{bdNStbs¥/gTodSRzP¦©jkf&l`/gr¨bZT MNPjk`Šmhlmoplmi‰bdS&Se`FbpNl’b

SelmfNodSRzP¦•j•fRlgr¨ Z¸¥j©¦•¦ opSRf&S&j•¤mS j©bp`yj•iPzPhPbt{Pl’blT¨¼odgQ …:grbpNodSRzP¦©jkf&l`gr¨¸…:S¨¼godS%`cbplmocbpj©iPŠj©bp`xSaSœ

f&habdj•gmi  MNPSxŠmolrzPNgr¨1¶j•ŠmhPopS ˆ ª

l¬$Nl`$¨¼gmhofgQQ­hPiPjkf&lrbdj•gmi`R bN#i°f&gmQzlmodjk`cgi1«r¥NPSRiiPg%opgmhabpj©iŠ

gz(SRoplrbdj•gmi?jk`Yj©i(`cSRocbpSR{¹«¹¶j©ŠhPopS ˆ ª

…(¬t`cNg’¥y`ybpNPS­bpoplmi`c¨¼gmopQTSe{

Alg

ŠmolrzPN1³xjŸb%lr¦k`dg°Nlm`t¨¼ghPo0fgmQTœ

QVhPiPjkf&lrbdj•gmi`R«_…Phab/bdNPSR^lropS)1o0,. 6H<«‰¥NPj•¦©S j•i6¶j©ŠhPopS ˆ ª

l¬«‰bdNPS opgmhabpj©iPŠVgmz:S&ol’bpj©gi°¦©j•QjŸb`/bdNPS

f&gmif&hPopodSRif^J³/j©i{PS&SR{1«(bpNPS%bs¥/gf&gmQQ­hPij•fRl’bdj•gmi(`yopSRfSRj©¤SR{…_^›w|Q­h(`sbY…(ST`dfNPSe{ahP¦•SR{›…:S¨¼godS­bdNPS

bs¥/g fgmQQVhPiPjkf&l’bpj©gi`$`cSRi‰b$…_^­w% rMNPj•`½{Pj%XJS&opS&if&Sj©ifgifhodopS&if&^ SazP¦klrj•i`bdNPSl{P{aj©bdj•gmilm¦a¦©SRiPŠrbpN

g’¤S&opNPSRl{Tj©if&hPopodSe{…_^VbpNPSxopgmhPbdj•iPŠ­gz(SRoplrbdj•gmi`R ¶j•ŠmhPopSR` ˆ ª

fR¬Flmi{ ˆ ª

{¬º`cNg’¥ l­`dj©Qj•¦•lmo`djŸbphl’bpj©gi