Performability analysis of fault-tolerant computer systems

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00074417

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00074417

Submitted on 24 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires

Performability analysis of fault-tolerant computer systems

Hédi Nabli, Bruno Sericola

To cite this version:

Hédi Nabli, Bruno Sericola. Performability analysis of fault-tolerant computer systems. [Research Report] RR-2254, INRIA. 1994. �inria-00074417�

(2)

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET AUTOMATIQUE

Performability Analysis of Fault-Tolerant Computer Systems

H´edi Nabli, Bruno Sericola

N˚ 2254

May 1994

PROGRAMME 1

Architectures parallèles, bases de données, réseaux et systèmes distribués

(3)

(4)

12304

5!6

798;:=<>@?AB:CEDGFHIJLKNM37OH:QP9K@AQ>RC

S0TVUXWYT[Z\,\,]^`_ abT[c[dfehgi]cjgVk9TV]l0mnZT[Zpoqosr]toq]ljuwvnZYlQ]lbxO]yxOUYzfz|{]t]ljufT9{]l}]~Zpkf,]gbl}9l}gr]\,]lxwel}giTVeqvfk{]l

S0TVUYQ]tgbUwxw]to

bZpmfmnUXTVg=xO]TV]c[df]tTcdf]bz4wXY_ Zt^tXp_ XmnZWY]l

,%fY S%]T}UYTi\2Zpv9ehoheqgQelbZ,cjUY\mUEl}eqgV]\,]ZXl}kfTi]UXTRgVd9]4mn]tT}UXTV\2Zzncj]yZpzxTV]toqeZpv9ehoheqgQu dfec[d

\2Zt4vn]`eqzOgi]tTVm9TV]tgi]x4ZXlGgVd9]bcjkf\ kfoZgVeh¡]mn]tTQUYTV\)Zpzncj]U¡]tT;Z=¢zfehgi]`\,e£lVlQehUYzgieh\,]E¤¥df]=cjUY\,m9kfg[ZgVehUXz

Upeqg[lRxwel}giTVeqvfkfgVeqUYz¦ZohohU bl`gidf]knlQ]tTRgVU2]tzl}kfTi]gVdnZg§gidf] l}9l}gi]t\¨ eqoho3ZYc[dfeh]¡]4Z,WXeh¡]tz©m]T}UYTi\2Zpzcj]

oh]t¡]tos¤ª¥df]yl}9l}gV]\+elZXlVl}k9\,]x,gVUvn]\,UwxO]toq]x,ZXl`Z ZpTi«Up¡ mfTiUwcj]lVl ehgid,¢nzfehgi]l}gZpgi]l}mZYcj]yZpzxZ

TV]t |ZpT[x,TZpgV] ¬m]T}UYTi\2Zpzcj]`\]ZYlQkfTV]Y3elLZYlVlQUwcjeZgV]x2 ehgid®]~ZYc[d2l}gZpgV]E¤0¯#]mfTiUYmnUlQ]ueqz,gVd9elmnZm]TtunZ

zf]t !ZohWYUXTVeqgVdf\°gVUcjUY\,m9kfgV]gVd9]4mn]tT}UXTV\2ZvfehoqehgQxOelQgVTVeqvfkfgiehUYz2UGsZkfohgi±²giUYoq]tT[ZzOg=cjUY\mfkfgV]Tbl}9l}gV]\2lj¤

¥df]\2Zehz³ZXxO¡XZpzwg[ZWY]UgVd9el4zf]t ´ZpoqWYUXTVehgidf\ el4eqg[l4ohU µmnUYohwzfUX\,eZocjUX\,mfkfgZpgVeqUYznZobcjUY\mfoh]twehgQ¤

UYTV]Up¡]T`eqgRxO]~ZpolUYz9oh eqgVd©zfUYz¦zf]tWEZpgVeq¡]zOkf\ vn]tT[lvnUXkfznxO]xvw®UXzf]¤¥dfe£leq\,mnUYTig[ZpzwgbmfTVUXm]TVgQ

ZpohoqU blGknlgVU xO]tgi]tTV\ehzf]LgVTVk9znctZpgiehUXz2l}gi]tmnlZznx2l}UygVU4eq\,mfTiUp¡]gidf]b]tO]~cjkfgVeqUYz gVeq\,]Upªgidf]ZpoqWYUXTVehgidf\¤

¶·¸¹Vºy»np¼ªY ½nZpkfoqg§giUYoq]tT[Zzncj]uTV]mnZpeqT[Zpv9oh]l}9l}gV]\2ljuZTV«U¡m9TVUwcj]lil}]lu0mn]tT}UXTV\2ZvfehoqehgQufmn]tT}UXTV±

\2Zpznc]uOTi]tohe£ZpvfeqohehgQukfzfe¾UYTi\,eh¿ZgVeqUYz

ÀÂÁÃ

ÄÆÅQÇÈ

Ã

ÄGÉªÊhÅQËÌÍ

ÎÏpÐÒÑÓ@ÔÕ²ÖÏX×[ÑØYÙQÙQÚ§ÛX×[Õ²ÜÝßÞbÑ²àÛÛYÔÕÜ²ÙiáRØtÞbÜ²ÏÙâjã3äätÎ¦åÑÛÕ²ÐÒÜÛpÕÔiæBÙVçBÜ

è[é[êRëÙiá~Ð£ìîí%×[ØÝßÐhï éð ÕàpÚÔXìîätÙQÕ²Ð¾çBÔÝ¾×tï[ñ%ÐÒÕ²ÐßÑs×ìòqÕ

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rennes

IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex (France)

(5)

/3 t - L .p 4 034

G"/4µ0,) 4-¦#/4

·O·2Zm]T}UYTi\2Zpv9ehoheqg9{]]lQgkfzf]R\,]~l}kfTi]bcjUY\,mnUElO{]t]bmnUYkfTLoZ§mn]tTQUYTi\2Zpznc]`]tgo£Z¢'Zvfehoqehg9{]Eu k9e

m]kfg]tgVTi]eqzOgi]tTVmfT9{]tg9{]] cjUY\,\]§o£Z,m]T}UYTi\2Zpzcj] cjkf\ kfo{]]l}k9T§k9z.gV]t\mnlRxO] \,elil}eqUYz¢nzfes¤@],ctZocjk9o

xO],c]tgVgi] xOelQgVTVeqvfkfgiehUYz¦mn]tTV\]tgrZ2okfgVeqoheliZpgi]tkfT=xO],lßZXlVl}k9TV]tTkf],lQUYz³lQflQgr]t\]ZpgigV]teqznxOTZ)k9z³cj]tTig[Zpeqz

zfeh¡]ZkxO]mn]tTQUYTi\2Zpznc]¤@]blQflQgr]t\]G]~l}g0\,UwxL{]tohe£lO{]mnZpT3kfzm9TVUwcj]lil}knlxO]|ZpTi«Up¡)rZ`]lQmnZYcj]bxV{]tgZpg¢nzfe

]tgkfz2gZpkf2xw]RT9{]cUY\,mn]tznlQ]4¬\,]lQkfTV]bxO]mn]tTQUYTV\)Zpzncj]X%]~l}gZXlVlQUwcje{]rZc[dnZkf]©{]tg[Zgt¤`UXknlGmfTiUYmnUlQUYznlu

xfZpznl cj]tg ZTVgiecjoq]u%kfz³zfUXkf¡]tobZohWYUXTVeqgVdf\,] mnUYkfT)ctZpo£cjkfoh]T4oZxwel}giTVeqvfkfgVeqUYz(xO]2oZmn]tTQUYTi\2Zpvfeqoheqgf{]xO]l

l}9l}gr]\,]l%eqzOUYTi\2Zpgie kf]l%giUYo{]T[Zpzwg0oq]l0mnZpzfz9]lj¤!"ßZt¡XZpzwg[ZpWX]RmfTiehzncjeqmnZpoxO]Rc]`zfUXkf¡]tonZohWXUYTVeqgVdf\]]l}gLlVZ

cjUY\,m9oh]twehg9{]4xw] ctZpo£cjkfoªmUXohwz"UY\eZpoq]§sZehvfoq]¤$#b]mfohknlu@eho3zf]gVTZpehgi]% k9] xO]l`zfUX\v9TV]l`mnUEl}ehgiesl`vnUXTVz|{]l

mnZpTy^Y¤'&]tgVgi]mfTVUXmfTVe{]tg9{]eh\mUXTVgZpzwgV]zfUYklmn]tTi\,]tgxw]xL{]tgi]tTV\ehzf]tTLxO]~ll}]tkfeqolxO]ygVTiUYznctZgVkfTi]4]tgbxwUYznc

x$ßZ\ ]toheqUYTi]tToh]Rgi]t\,mnlLx${ ]tL{]cjk9gVehUXz2xO]oÒZpoqWYUYTiehgidf\,]

( »f¹[)·#(¥ UXot{]tTZpzncj]yZkf,mnZzfzf]lu@lQflQgtr]t\,]~lGT9{]mnZpTZpvfoq]ljufmfTiUwcj]lil}knlbxO]ZTV«U¡'uOmn]tT}UXTV\2Zvfehoqehg9{]u

m]T}UYTi\2Zpzcj]u ¢Zpvfeqohehg9{]uOk9zfeUXTV\,e£lVZpgiehUXz

(6)

5 6

20L

"87bG)

aRl`TV]~cjUYWXzfeh¿t]~x®ehz¦Z oZpTiWY]zwkf\ v]TUp|l}giknxOeh]~lju@gidf]% kZpzwgVehgZpgieh¡]]t¡XZpoqknZpgiehUYzUsZpkfoqgV±gVUYoq]tT[ZzOgcjUY\,±

mfkfgV]Tl}9l}gi]t\2l%Ti]kfehTi]l0gVUxw]Zpo'l}eq\k9ohg[Zzf]tUXknl}oq4 ehgid2ZYlQmn]cjg[lUpªvnUYgid2m]T}UYTi\2Zpzcj]bZpznx TV]toqeZpv9ehoheqgQ¤

½UXTgVdfe£lmfkfTimUEl}]un]]tT9^;: xO]t¡]toqUYmn]xgidf]ycjUYzcj]tmfgLUp3m]T}UYTi\2Zpv9ehoheqgQuY dfe£cd,\)Z~vn]ehzwgV]TVmfTi]tgV]x

ZYl§gidf]cjkf\ kfoZgVeh¡]mn]tTQUYTV\)Zpzncj]U¡]tTyZ,¢nzfehgi]\,elil}eqUYzgVeq\,]¤ ¥df] ehzncTV]ZXl}ehz9W®z9]t]xehz¦]t¡XZpohkZpgVeqzfW

cjkf\ kfoZgVeh¡]=\,]ZYlQkfTV]~lRcjUY\]l|TiUY\ gidf]4sZYcjg=gVdnZg§eqzdfehWXdfoh/Zt¡YZeho£Zpvfoq] l}9l}gV]\2ljulQgV]ZXxOlQg[ZgV] \,]Zp±

l}kfTi]lctZpz³vn]2¡]tTVmnUUXTtu]t¡]z#e¾bgVdf]2\,e£lVl}eqUYz¦gVeq\,]e£l§zfUXg l}\2Zohos¤¥df]2knl}]Up=]tOmn]cg[ZpgiehUXznlZpo£l}U

l}k,<']tTl|TiUY\°l}eq\,eho£ZpTLxOT[Zt vnZXc«9lj¤ &UYznlQexO]tTiehzfW9uOUYTbehznlQg[Zzncj]uncjTiehgiectZoZpm9mfohe£ctZpgiehUYzljufehge£lcjTVkcjeZo@UYT

gVdf]Rkl}]tTLgVU]tznlQkfTV]=gVdnZggVd9]RmfTVUXvnZpv9ehoheqgQgVdnZgehg[lLl}9l}gi]t\ ehoqo@ZXcd9eh]t¡]=Z§WXeh¡]tz mn]tT}UXTV\2Zzncj]boh]t¡]to9el

dfehWXd]tzfUXkfWYd ¤

½fUXTV\2ZohohEu0gVdf]©l}9l}gi]t\ sZkfohgi±²Ti]tmnZpeqTvn]tdnZt¡OeqUYT elZXlVl}k9\,]x.gVU¦vn]®\UwxO]toh]~x#vOZdfUX\,UYWX]tzf]tUXknl

ZpTV«U¡2mfTiUwcj]lVl¤=Ægl`lQg[ZgV] l}mZYcj]yelbxOeh¡wexO]~x)eqzOgiU,xwelÂQUXehzwgRlQkfvnlQ]tg[lu dfe£cd©TV]tm9TV]lQ]tzOglgVdf] xOe<']tTi]tzwg

cjUYzO¢WYkfTZpgVeqUYznl,UgVdf]/l}9l}gi]t\¤ am]T}UYTi\2Zpzcj]2oh]t¡]to=¬²Ti]t ZT[x TZpgi]Y4e£lZXlVlQUwcjeZgV]x eqgVd ]~ZYc[d Up

gVdf]lQ],cUYzO¢nWXkfT[ZgVeqUYznl¤¥dfelRTi]t ZT[xT[Zpgi] knZpzwgVe¾¢n]lRgVdf]Zpv9ehoheqgQUpbgidf]l}9l}gV]\ gVUmn]tTQUYTi\ ehz¦gVdf]

cjUYTiTV]lQmUXznxOeqzfW©cjUYzO¢WYkfTZpgVeqUYz¤ S%]tT}UXTV\2ZvfehoqehgQ el`gidf]tzgVd9] ZYctcjk9\kfo£Zpgi]x,TV]t |ZpT[xU¡]tT=gVdf]y\,elil}ehUXz

gVeh\]¤

¥d9]RxOe£l}giTVehv9kfgVeqUYzUp gVdfe£l%T[ZznxOUX\ ¡YZTVe£Zpvfoq]dnZYl0vn]t]tzl}giknxOeh]~x4ehzmfTi]t¡OeqUYknlªmnZpmn]tTlj¤?>UX\,]Up'gVd9]l}]

mnZpmn]tTl@9A:suB9A:BuC9D:BuC9E:BuC9A:suB9GF:3ZpTi]TV]lQgVTVe£cjgV]~x)giU,gVd9] ctZYlQ]4Up|ZXcjfcohecZTV«U¡2mfTVUwcj]~lVl}]~l` dfec[dZTV]

knl}]x2gVU\,Uwxw]to@zfUXzTi]tmnZpeqT[Zvfoh]yl}9l}gi]t\2l¤

¥U\,UwxO]o0gVdf]TV]tmnZehTUpbsZpk9ohgQ¦cjUY\mUXzf]tzwg[lRehz¦TV]mnZpeqT[Zpv9oh]2lQflQgV]t\2luªcjfcohecyZpTi«Up¡¦mfTiUwcj]lVlQ]l

ZpTV] zf]t]~xO]x@¤½UXTyZpvnlQUYTVv9ehzfW¦ZTV«U¡mfTiUwcj]lil}]luBH]ZknxOTVI9KJA:0WEZt¡],Zz³ZpoqWYUYTiehgidf\ gVU/cjUY\,m9kfgV]ygVdf]

xOelQgVTVeqvfkfgiehUYz UpZYctckf\k9oZpgi]x.TV]t |ZpTx kfzwgVeqol}9l}gi]t\ sZehoqkfTV] df]z gidf]#Ti]t ZT[x T[ZgV]l2ZpTi]¦l}giTVecgVoh

mUEl}eqgVeh¡]Zpznx &eZT[xOU]gZpos¤9E:@]twgV]tzxO]xgVdfe£l\,]tgVd9UwxgVU l}]t\,eq±BZTV«U¡4m9TVUwcj]lil}]lGUXTzfUYz9±²zf]WZpgieh¡]

TV]t |ZpT[x,TZpgV]~lj¤

½fUXTG¢nzfeqgV]\,e£lVlQehUYzgieh\,]|Zpznx df]tz gVd9]`Ti]t ZT[xT[Zpgi]lZpTi]`]teqgVdf]T.L§UXT`^XugVdf]=ZYctckf\k9oZpgi]x§Ti]t ZT[x

Up¡]TRgVdf] \,e£lVl}eqUYzgieh\,]yelRgVdf] ehzwgV]TV¡XZpoZt¡XZpeqoZvfehoqehgQ¤¥df]xOe£l}gVTiehvfk9gVehUXz#UeqzOgi]tTV¡XZpo;Z~¡XZehoZvfehoqehgQ2dnZYl

v]]tz©l}gVkxOeh]x ehz89¾^LA:'knl}eqzfWgVd9]Rkfzfe¾UYTV\eh¿ZgVehUXzgi]c[dfzfe kf]¤ª¥df]ycjUX\,mfkfgZpgiehUYzZpo'cjUY\mfoh]twehgQUp3gVd9el

\,]tgVd9Uwx)dZYlv]]tz2eh\,mfTiU¡]xeqz89^X^:B¤

¥d9]4xwel}giTVeqvfkfgVeqUYz2Up;ZYccjkf\ kfoZgV]xTV]t |ZpTxU¡]tTZ§¢nz9ehgV]\,e£lVlQehUYz©¬² eqgVd2WY]zf]tT[Zo@Ti]t ZT[x,T[ZgV]l[el

\,UYTi]cjUY\mfoh]t gVUUXvfg[Zehz¤M=ÆzN9¾^tA:suO=B]tT]tgbZoB¤mfTVUXmnUl}]~xZpz/ZpoqWYUYTiehgidf\gVU cjUX\,mfkfgi]RTV]ckfT[lQeh¡]toqgVdf]

\,UY\,]zOglGUp|gVdf] ZYctckf\k9oZpgi]x,TV]t |ZpTxUp¡]T`gidf]4\,e£lVlQehUYz©gVeq\,]uO eqgVd¦ZmnUXohwzfUY\,e£Zpo3cjUY\mfkfg[ZgVeqUYznZo

cjUY\,m9oh]twehgQehz©gVdf]zwkf\ v]TUpLlQg[Zpgi]lj¤=BzP9¾^tE:BufgVd9]xOe£l}gVTiehvfk9gVehUXzUgVdfe£lTZpznxwUY\¨¡XZTVeZvfoh]dnZXl`vn]t]tz

xO]tTVeq¡]xknl}eqzfW Zpmfo£ZYcj]gVT[ZznlÆUXTV\ Zznx.zOk9\,]tTVe£ctZpoªehzw¡]tTl}ehUXz#m9TVUwcj]xwkfTV]l4giUWX]tggVdf]TV]lQkfohgehz gVdf]

gVeh\]xOUY\)Zpehz ¤#`]Q>UXkf¿Z]@>eqoh¡XZZznxSR=ZpeqoT9¾^j:ªmfTiUYmnUlQ]xZ\,]tgidfUwx®vZYl}]~x®UYzgidf]4k9zfeUXTV\,eq¿ZpgiehUYz

(7)

gV]c[dfzfe kf]EupdfU L]t¡]tTgVd9]tehTª\,]tgidfUwx§]twehv9ehg[lªZ`]twmnUYzf]zOgieZpo9cjUX\,mfkfgZpgVeqUYznZofcUY\,mfoq]twehgQ`eqz4gidf]zOk9\vn]tT

UpTi]t ZT[xTZpgV]~lj¤Rl}eqzfW,gVd9] lVZp\]gV]c[dfzfe kf]Eu#`UYznZgVeq]tohoqU2Zpznx RbT[ZXlVl}e9¾^tA:3UYvfgZpehz9]xZpz ZpoqWYUYTiehgidf\

ehgVd©Z4mnUYoqOz9UY\,e£Zpo'cjUY\mfkfg[ZgVeqUYznZocjUX\,mfoh]Oeqg}E¤`U ]t¡]T0gVdfe£lZpoqWYUYTiehgidf\l}]]t\2l0gVUvn]zOk9\,]tTVe£ctZpoqo¾

kfznl}gZpvfoq]lQehzncj]=gVdf]ycjU])cjeq]tzOg|cjUY\mfkfgV]~xehz2gVd9]tehTTi]cjkfTl}ehUXz©ctZpz2dnZt¡]mnUl}eqgVeq¡]Zpznx2zf]tWEZpgVeq¡]yl}ehWXznl

Zpznx³ZpTi],kfzwvnUYkfznxw]x. dfec[d³ctZz.oh]ZXx#gVU¦lQ]t¡]tTi]zwkf\,]tTiectZo%]TVTVUXT[lZznx.Up¡]TnU m9TVUYv9oh]t\2l¤UXTV]

TV]cj]zOgiohu #`]>UXkf¿Z] >Eehoh¡XZZznx R=Zpeqo 9^A:UYv9g[Zpeqzf]x2Zpo£l}UZpz/ZpohWXUYTiehgVd9\+ ehgidZmnUYoqOzfUX\,eZocjUX\,mfkf±

g[ZpgiehUXznZpoªcjUX\,mfoq]tOeqgQ4 dfe£cd,e£lGoqehzf]ZTeqzZ4mZpT[Z\,]tgi]tTgVdnZgell}\)Zpohoq]tTgVdnZz2gVdf]Rzwkf\ vn]tTUp3TV]t |ZpT[x9lju

vfkfggVdf]ehTZohWYUXTVeqgVdf\ l}]t]t\)lgiU®dZ~¡]gidf] lVZ\,]4k9znl}gZpvfeqohehgQ©mfTVUXvfoh]t\ xOkf]gidf]knl}] UpLvnUYgid.mnUlQehgVeq¡]

Zpznx.zf]tWEZpgieh¡]2cjU]2cjeq]tzwg[lj¤©S0ZgVgVeqmnZpgie]tgZoB¤I9^EF:LUYvfgZpehz9]x.gVdf]2xwel}giTVeqvfkfgVeqUYz.URgidf]2ZXctcjkf\ kfoZgV]x

TV]t |ZpT[xUXTzfUYzf±dfUX\,UYWX]tzf]tUXknlZpTi«Up¡ mfTiUwcj]lVlQ]lZYlgidf]lQUYohk9gVehUXz2Up;Zl}9l}gV]\ U0oqehzf]ZTdwOmn]tTivnUYohe£c

mnZpTigVeZoªxOe<']tTi]tzwgVeZo@]knZgVehUXznl dfec[d,elzwkf\,]TVecZpohoqlQUYoh¡]~x)vw knl}eqzfW,Z xOe£lVcjTi]tgVeq¿ZpgiehUYz)ZpmfmfTiUZXcd¤

=Bz2gVd9elmnZm]T` L]xO]t¡]toqUYm2Z4z9]t !ZpoqWYUXTVehgidf\µgVUcjUY\,m9kfgV]bgVdf]yxOe£l}giTVehv9kfgVeqUYz2Up;ZYctckf\k9oZpgi]xUp¡]T

Z ¢zfehgi]\,e£lVl}eqUYz³gVeq\,]¤ aRleqz 9^A:RUXT89^A:Bugidfel\]tgVdfUwx³knl}]~x elvnZYlQ]x UXz gVdf]k9zfeUXTV\,eq¿ZpgiehUYz

gV]c[dfzfe kf]E¤¥df]y\2Zpeqz©cjUYzwgVTiehvfkfgiehUXzUp;gVdfe£lmnZmn]tTRelgVdZpgbUYkfTZohWXUYTVeqgVdf\e£lzwkf\,]tTiectZohoq l}g[Zvfoh]yvO

gVdf]4sZXcjg`eqgxO]ZolUYzfoq eqgVdz9UYz¦zf]tWZgVeq¡]4zwkf\vn]tTlvnUYkfznxw]xvw¦^Y¤UXTV]tU¡]tTgidf] cjUY\mfkfg[ZgVeqUYznZo

cjUY\,m9oh]twehgQ,e£leq\,mfTiUp¡]~x®vwgVdf] knl}] UpbgiTVkfzctZpgiehUYz l}gi]tmnlyZpznx#gidf] mfTV]cel}eqUYzUbgVdf] TV]lQkfohgyctZz#vn]

WYeh¡]z®eqz2ZYxw¡YZzncj]¤

¥d9]#Ti]t\2ZpeqznxO]tTUgidf]mnZpmn]tT2e£l)UXTVWEZpzfeq¿t]x ZYlUXohohU bl¤ =Bz gVdf]zf]Og2lQ]cjgiehUYz u` ]eqzOgiTVUwxOkcj]

gVdf]\2ZgVdf]\2ZpgiectZo\UwxO]to3Zpznxgidf]4zfUXg[ZgVehUXz¤¥df]gidfehTxl}]~cjgVeqUYzWXeh¡]lgVd9]mfTVUXmUEl}]x¦l}UXohkfgiehUXz¦Zpznx

xO]lVcTVehvn]lRgidf]2ZpoqWYUXTVehgidf\ Zpzxeqg[lcjUX\,mfkfgZpgVeqUYznZoLcjUY\,m9oh]twehgQ¤=Bz¦gVdf] UYkfTigVd³lQ]cjgVeqUYzuªZ2\,UwxO]toUp

Z)sZpk9ohgV±gVUXoh]tTZpzwgcjUX\,mfkfgi]tTl}9l}gi]t\¨e£lRmfTV]lQ]tzwgV]xZznx.l}UXoh¡]x®UXTyZ)WXeh¡]tzmn]tTQUYTi\2Zpvfeqoheqg}2\,]~ZYl}k9TV]¤

¥df]oZYlQgRlQ]cjgiehUYz2e£lxO]t¡UYgi]xgiU,lQUY\,]cUYzncjoqknl}eqUYznl¤

/ GE7b³ 4

¯#]=cjUYzl}exw]tTl}9l}gi]t\2l%gidnZpgLctZzvn]b\,UwxO]toq]x4vwZRdfUY\UYWY]zf]tUYklGZTV«U¡4m9TVUwcj]lilG eqgVd Z¢zfehgi]bl}g[ZgV]

l}mnZXcj]¤Ra mn]tTQUYTV\)Zpzncj]yoh]t¡]o@UYTbTV] ZpTxT[ZgV]4e£l`ZXlVlQUwcjeZgV]x eqgVd]~ZYc[dl}gZpgi]Upgidf]4mfTiUwcj]lilj¤R¥d9]l}]

TV]t |ZpT[x T[Zpgi]lZTV]ZXlVlQkf\,]xgiU4vn]Rgieh\,]eqznxO]tmn]tznxw]tzOgLZXlknl}knZoBu9Zpznxgidf]RTZpznxOUX\ ¡XZTVeZvfoh]=UpªehzwgV]TV]lQg

elgVd9]4ZXctcjkf\ kfo£ZpgV]~xTi]t ZT[x®U¡]tT|Z ¢zfehgi]R\,elil}eqUYz,gieh\,]¤

UXTV]4UXTV\2ZohohEufoh]tg "!$#&% L('vn] Z,dfUY\,UXWY]tz9]tUYknl=ZpTV«U¡2mfTiUwcj]lVlbUp¡]TRZ¢nzfeqgV] l}g[ZgV]

l}mnZXcj]2xO]tz9UYgV]~x#vO*)+,^-!t¤t¤t¤!/.0'¤a TV]t |ZpT[x¦T[Zpgi]21f¬43QRelyZYlil}Uwcje£ZpgV]~x eqgVd.]~ZYc[d.lQg[Zpgi]53U6) ¤

>ehznc]§gQ LU,xOe<']tTV]tzwglQg[ZgV]l`\)Z~ dnZt¡]Rgidf]liZp\,]TV] ZpTx,T[Zpgi]uf ] xO]tzfUXgV]vw278:9:78;=<>9 ¤t¤t¤?9@7A

gVdf]6BDC ^RxOe<@]TV]tzwgTV]t |ZpT[xT[ZgV]lb¬4BFEG. [¤¥df]=l}gZpgi]l}mnZXcj]6)ctZpz,vn]Rgidf]tz2xweh¡wexO]x4eqzOgiUxOe£lÂQUXehzwg

l}kfvnlQ]tg[lH 8 !$H 8;"< !t¤t¤¤!$H A d9]tTV]HJIsu LLKG3K@B el3cjUY\,mnUEl}]x4vw4gidf]bl}gZpgV]~l%UpM) dnZt¡OeqzfWZXl;Ti]t ZT[x

(8)

T[Zpgi]7 I uOgidnZpgbel

H I D ) 1f¬f:7 I '

¥df]4zwkf\ v]TUpGl}g[ZgV]lehz©lQkfvnl}]g6H I elbxO]tz9UYgV]~x®vw2. I ufUYT 3 L(!t¤¤t¤!$B¤L¥df]4mfTiUwcj]lil elWYeq¡]tz

vO.eqg[l4eqzO¢nzfeqgV]lQeh\2ZoGWX]tzf]tTZpgiUYTtuLxO]tz9UYgV]~xvw 4uehz³ dfe£cd gVdf]53²gid xweZpWXUYznZo`]zOgiTV 4¬ 3 !$3}b¡]tTie¢n]~l

4¬43 !/3}

I

y¬43 !f;Zpznx2vO,eqg[leqzfehgieZpo'mfTVUXvnZpv9ehoheqgQ2xOelQgVTiehvfkfgiehUXz¦ dfUlQ] 3²gid®]zOgiTV,e£lxO]tzfUXgV]x

vO I ¤bUYTi]tU¡]tTtuOUXTRZzO©l}k9vnl}]tg³Up ) u L]xO]tz9UYgV]yvO/^¬²Ti]l}m¤LLgVdf] cjUYoqkf\,z,¡]~cjgVUXT`ULl}eq¿t]

gVdf]zwkf\vn]tTLUp;l}gZpgV]~leqzLuf eqgVd©Zpoqo@]toq]t\,]tzwg[l0]knZpogiU2^¬TV]lQm¤.L ¤

@]g`knlbxO]tz9UYgV]vw gVdf]kfz9eUYTi\,eh¿]xZTV«U¡2c[dnZpeqzN9^JE:U¡]tTgVdf]ylQg[Zpgi]yl}mnZXcj] ) eqgVd2TV]lQmn]cjg

gVUgVd9],kfzfe¾UYTV\eh¿ZgVehUXzT[ZgV]Zpznx#vw! eqg[lgVT[Zznl}eqgVeqUYz.mfTiUYvnZvfehoqehgQ\2ZgVTVeq dfUlQ]¦¬43 !fb]tzwgVTiel

xO]tzfUXgV]x vw" ¬43 !f[¤¥df]kfzfe¾UYTV\eh¿ZgVehUXz³T[Zpgi]# ¡]tTie¢n]l %l}kfmª¬$% 4¬ 3 !$3}/!$3 ) Zpznx& el

TV]to£ZpgV]~xgVU' vw )( C* +,'u df]tTi]-(®xw]tzfUYgi]lRgVdf]e£xO]tzwgVeqg}\2ZpgiTVeh'¤ =²/. 0.6 !$# % L('e£lRZ

S%UYe£lVl}UXz,mfTiUwcj]lVl ehgidmnZT[Z\,]tgV]T1'uOehzxO]tmn]tznxO]zOg0UªgVdf]bmfTiUwcj]lVl2ugVdf]zeqgGe£l0 ]toqoh±«OzfU z gVdnZggVdf]

g} LUm9TVUwcj]lil}]l Zpznx&,4365 !$# % L"'§dnZt¡]gVd9]4liZp\,]mfTiUYvnZvfehoqelQgVecRvn]tdnZt¡wehUXTe3gVdf]tdnZt¡]§gidf]ylVZ\,]

ehzfeqgVeZofxwel}giTVeqvfkfgVeqUYz¤ =BzgVd9]GUYoqohU ehz9WfuYgiUl}eq\,mfohe¾RzfUXg[ZpgiehUXzuY ] eqoho9cjUYzl}exw]tT ZYl0gVdf]Lkfzfe¾UYTV\eh¿t]x

mfTVUwcj]~lVlj¤¯¦]2xO]cUY\,mnUlQ] °Zpznx.gidf],ehz9ehgVe£ZpomfTiUYvnZvfehoqehgQ¡]cjgiUYT7 ehgid.TV]~l}mn]cjgygVUgidf],mnZTVgiehgVeqUYz

HJ8!$HJ8;"< !¤t¤t¤!$HJA 'Up ) ZXl|UXohohU bl8

9::;

=<?>@<?> AAAB C<?>?<ED

¤¤¤ ¤¤¤

=<EDF< > AAAG =<ED<ED HI

I

J

!K !¬=< > !t¤t¤t¤!=<EDj/!

df]tTV]bgVd9]RlQkfvf\2ZgVTVeqL =<?MN<POu L K:3 !QLK:BuwcjUYzwg[Zehznl0gVd9]`giT[Zpzl}ehgiehUXzmfTiUYvnZvfehoqehgieh]l%TVUX\µl}gZpgV]~l;U H I

gVU2lQg[Zpgi]l`U H

Zznx#lQkfvw¡]cjgVUXT% <?Mu L K 3 K Bu'cjUYzwg[Zehznl`gidf]4eqzfehgieZomfTVUXvnZpvfeqoheqgVeh]~l`cjUXTVTi]l}mnUYzxOehzfW

gVUl}g[ZgV]lUp HJIs¤

¥d9]T[ZznxOUX\ ¡XZTVeZvfoh]2UehzwgV]tTi]l}gy dfec[d.e£lxO]zfUYgi]x.vORES=Zpznx³TV]tm9TV]lQ]tzOgl4gVdf]©ZXctcjkf\ kfoZgV]x

TV]t |ZpT[x,U¡]tTgidf]ehzwgV]tTi¡YZo@U0gieh\,] 9KL(!UT :'elxO]j¢zf]x,vO

R S WV

S

A

1f¬ wFX #=

Rl}eqzfW,gVd9]xO]cUY\,mnUlQehgiehUYz©Up ) eqgVdTV]~l}mn]cjgbgVU,gidf]mnZTVgVeqgVeqUYz H 8

!$H 8;"<

!t¤¤t¤!$H

A

'u@gVd9el`TZpznxOUX\

¡YZTVe£Zpvfoq]4cZpzZolQUv]y TVeqgVgV]z2ZYl

R S 8 YI A 7 I V S

A[ZP\]

5_^<?MN` X #!

(9)

df]tTV]

Z \

` ^ e3cUYznxOeqgVeqUYzRelgVTikf]

L UYgidf]tTi el}]E¤

¥df]#TZpznxwUY\ ¡XZpTieZpv9oh] RES4gZp«]leqg[l¡XZohkf]l,eqz gVdf]eqzOgi]tTV¡XZpo 97 A T!/7 8 T :=Zpzx L]# e£l}d gVU(ctZocjk9oZpgi]

=îS 0R S 9 '¤¥df]TV] ZpTxT[ZgV]l 7 I ZpTi]yZpTVv9ehgVTZpTiTi]Zpo'zOkf\ vn]tT[luvfkfg ]ctZpz2ZXlVlQkf\,]R eqgVdfUXkfgohUElVlUp

WY]tzf]T[ZpoqehgQ gVdnZg7A LO¤L¥dfelcZpz2vn]4xwUYzf]vwTi]tmfoZXcjehz9W 7 I vw 7 I 7ARZznx§vw 7A$Tj¤?>EUfufehzgVdf]

l}]kf]tosuO ]ylQ]tg7A LO¤

½fUXTRZ§¢nw]x,¡XZpoqkf] P9L"!$78 T9fZpznx23 )uf L]yxO]j¢nzf]RUXTbZpzw,ehzwgV]tWX]tT % LOu

I ¬ !UT! =îS 0R S 9 !. S A@3 '

¯#] xO]zfUYgi]vO4<¬ !UT!gidf] cjUYoqkf\,z©¡]cjgVUXT`U|xOeh\,]znl}eqUYz .%Zznx d9Ul}] 3gVd]tzwgVTi®e£l`]knZpo3gVU

I ¬=!$T! %UXT>3 &H¤ &UXznl}]kf]tzwgVoquO eqgVd2gVd9elzfUXg[ZpgiehUXz ]dnZt¡]

=îS 0R S 9 '>

YI < I

Y

A I ¬=!$T!

8

Y A

C<

Y

A

4< ²¬ !UT!

¥df]UYoqohU ehzfW gVdf]tUXTV]t\ WXeh¡]lgVdf]2UYTi ZpTx Ti]tzf]t |Zpob]knZpgiehUYz u`liZpgielÆ¢]x vO³gidf]¦cjUYoqkf\,z³¡]cjgiUYTl

4<?MB¬ !UT![uwgVdnZg ehohovn]knlQ]x,ehz2gVdf]zf]OgblQ]cjgVeqUYz2gVUWX]tgbgVdf]yxOe£l}gVTiehvfk9gVehUXz2Up R S ¤

!#"ª·O»n· $&%

Z

!# ('A*)=*EL(!t^-!t¤t¤t¤!/B ' 0 4('A# %!^ ,+X-*.'A

< ¬ !UT! 8

Y

/ A V10

2

A < < 3 < 3 ¬ 7 #!UT #! ^U4

;65 X # Z \87:9.;

S`

C 8

Y

/ A V 2

>=<?>

0

2

>@>

2

A

=<< 3 < 3 ¬ 7A#!UT #! ^U4

;65$

X # Z \87:BC;

S`

C 4

;65 S

@D

¬ T

7A

w^_<

Z \87:9.;

S`

+E-O3"F-OHG QI-O"F-* 3;4 3KJ$ L+E-OL) L F-O E \ @ KJ$ L

+E-OL) :BNM

O»»QP%y¥df]RkfzncjgiehUYz I ¬ !UT!xO]j¢zf]x,mfTV]¡OeqUYknlQoh2ZXl

I ¬ !UT! =îS 0R S 9R !. S SN AJ:3 '

(10)

lVZpgielB¢n]lgVdf]ycjo£ZYlVlQectZoUXTV ZT[x2TV]tzf] Zpo] knZgVeqUYzuUYT % ^YungVdnZgel

I ¬=!$T!

Y

^

¬43 !Q V S

A

¬ 7 I#!UT #! ^U4

;65 X #= ¬i^p

¯ df]tz% 7 I# E Lwuf ]dnZt¡]

¬ 7 I

#M!$T #! ^ =îS 0.

S ; S ^ A#?'6 4

;65S;

¬F'¬ T #@i

;"<

¬ ^D

Zpznx2 df]tz 7I# %:7 8 ¬ T #@[uf L]§dZ~¡]

¬ 7I#!UT #! ^ LO¤

=BgUXohohU blgidnZpgb df]tz E@7 ITuO L]§WX]tg

I ¬ !UT! Y

^

¬43 !f

V 0 2M

A

¬ 7 I #M!$T4 #! ^U4

;65$

X #

C Y

^

¬43 !f V S

0

2M 4

;65S ;

¬ '¬ T # i

;"<

¬ ^D

4

;65 X #

Y

^

¬43 !f V 0 2M

A

¬ 7 I #M!$T4 #! ^U4

;65$

X #

C 4

;65

S

@D

¬T4

7 I !

Zznx® d9]tz 6%:7 ITuO L]WY]tg

I ¬ !UT! Y

^

¬ 3 !f

V 2> <?>

0

2> > 2M

A

¬ 7 I#!UT #! ^p$4

; 5 X #

l}ehzcj]ehz2gVdfe£lctZYlQ]uf ]=dnZt¡]

7 8 T

78*7 I

K*T_

S;k9gVgVeqzfW zfU giUYWY]gVdf]tTbgVd9]§gQ LU ctZYlQ]ljuf L]§WX]tg

I ¬=!$T! F

Y

^

¬43 !Q

V 0 2M

A

¬ 7 I#!UT #!(^pU4

;65$

X # Z \879.;

MS`

C Y

^

¬ 3 !f V 2> <?>

0

2> > 2M

A

¬ 7 I#!UT #M! ^p$4

; 5 X # Z \7B.;

MS`

C 4

;65 S

D ¬T

7 I Z \87:9.;

MS`

(11)

¥df]gVdf]tUXTV]t\µUYohoqU blvO,Ti]t TVeqgVeqzfWgVdfe£loZXl}gTV]oZpgiehUXz®eqz2¡]cjgVUXTzfUXg[ZgVehUXz¤

4 0,"t, t# E7b 0-³ 7bG

=Æz(gVdfe£llQ]cjgiehUYz uG L])¢T[l}gWYeh¡]gVdf]©\2Zpeqz Ti]l}k9ohgUpgVdfe£lmnZmn]tTtu d9ec[d e£lgidf]xwel}giTVeqvfkfgVeqUYz³UpgVdf]

ZYctcjk9\kfo£Zpgi]xTV] ZpTx®U¡]tTLgVdf]¢nzfehgi]\,elil}ehUXz,gVeq\,] 9KL(!UT :Bu R S ¤`]twgtu9ZpzZohWXUYTVeqgVdf\giU,cjUX\,mfkfgi]RgVd9el

xOelQgVTVeqvfkfgiehUYz2e£lmfTVUXmUEl}]xZznx2ZpznZohw¿t]x,gVd9TVUYk9WYdehglcjUY\mfkfg[ZgVeqUYznZocjUX\,mfoh]Oeqg}E¤

!#"ª·O»n· =%

Z

=îS 0R S 9 '>

Y

A 4

;65 S ¬ T[

@D

Y

/ A 8 Y

<

/

¬i^

; /

¬ ! Z \;

O

>

S

7:9C;

O S`

+E-O3 7

;"<UT

¬47

7

;=<jT

2\G(,

¬ ! 3 F'A8

¬!

8

Y A

C<

<

¬!

2\$, 'E ;

<

¬!

3 F'A3S I-OB.+B \ $ F'A\/1\ \ %

PQ»n K ) K@B%¼ ^6K

K

<

¬ !\L

^< L!^

;"<

<

¬ ! 9 ^

<

¬ !

7A 7

7 P 7

;"<

<

¬!

^pC

7 7

;"<

7AP 7

;"<

8

YI A

C<<?M

< M

¬ ^-!

^p

PQ»nQL K ) K ^ ª¼ L K

K ^

<

¬!

7

;"< 7

7 7A

<

¬!

C ^p C 7 7

;"<

7 7A

8

YI A

=<<?M

<?M

¬ ^-!

<

¬ !

<

¬!\L E@B

L < :B

(12)

O»»QP% ¬ >]t]a`mfmn]tznxOeq2a§¤

abz®eq\,mnUYTig[ZpzwgUYvl}]tTi¡YZgVeqUYzd9]tTV]Re£lgVdnZgUXT1 K )K:B L]dnZt¡]

LLK

7A 7

7 P 7

;"<

N^2

7 7

;"<

7 P 7

;"<

K ^-!

UYTL K ) K 7 ^ ]dnZt¡]

LLK 7

;"< 7

7 7A

N^2

7 7

;"<

7 7A K ^-!

Zpznx,UYTL KS) K@B L]§dZ~¡]

8

YI A

C< <?MB^_< MM!^<

½UXT]t¡]tTi % LwufgVdf]ehz9ehgVe£Zpon¡XZpoqkf]

<

¬!\Lel]knZo@gVU©^_< @e ) % ^yZpznx,gidf]R¢nznZpo¡XZohkf]

8

<

¬!

el]knZpogiUQL0<@e )K:B ^Y¤¯¦]§gidf]tz2]ZXl}ehoqUXvfg[Zehz©vO,Ti]cjkfTiTV]tzcj]RgVdZpg

L < K

<

¬!

K!^ <

UYTV]Up¡]Ttu UXT4]t¡]TV' °^-!t¤t¤t¤!/Buª ],dZ~¡] L K

E^Y¤¦¥df]~l}],Ti]t\2ZpTi«flZTV],]lil}]tzwgVe£ZpoTVUY\Z

cjUY\,m9kfg[ZgVehUXznZponmnUYeqzOgU¡weh]t l}ehzcj]gVdf]b\2Zzfehmfk9oZpgiehUXzUpªzfUXzf±²z9]tWZgVeh¡] knZpzwgVeqgVeh]~l0Zpznx vUXkfznxO]~xvO

^ZpohoqU blknlGgiU Z~¡UXexgidf]kfznlQg[Zpv9ehoheqgQmfTVUXvfoh]t\)l; d9ec[d,\2Zt Zpmfmn]ZTehz2gVd9]ZpoqWYUYTiehgidf\2lxO]licjTVeqv]~xehz

9^t: ZpznxN9^:B¤

@]g`knlz9Up NxO]j¢nzf]RUXT]t¡]tTV7L!^-!t¤t¤t¤!$BunZ4mnZTVgVeqgVeqUYzU0gidf]yl}gZpgV] l}mnZXcj]) ZYl

:H8 AAA H

Zpzx

:H

;"< AAA HJA0

½UXT`]¡]tTVLN^ !t¤t¤¤!$BuO L]4ZolQU,xO]¢nzf]gVdf]RUXohohU eqzfWcjUXohkf\z,¡]cjgiUYT[l

O¬ !

< >

¬ !

!t¤t¤t¤ !

< O

¬!

Zznx

O¬!

< O >

¬ !

!t¤¤t¤!

<ED

¬ !

df]tTV] xw]tzfUYgi]lgVd9]§giT[Zznl}mnUlQ]UYmn]tTZpgVUXTt¤

¯ eqgVdgidfelzfUYgZpgiehUYz u%½ªehWf¤ª^Zznx½%ehW9¤@ ehohoqknl}giT[ZgV]4gidf]lQ]kf]tzncj]yUp|cjUX\,mfkfgZpgVeqUYznl¬BxwT[Zt zUYzfoq

UYT L"!t^ !(![gVdnZgdnZt¡]RgiU4vn]xOUXzf]RehzUYT[xw]tTgiU4]t¡XZpoqknZpgi]RgVd9]

<

¬!

ßl¤"`UXgV]RgidnZpgLgVdf]=kfmfmn]tT

(13)

mnZpTig§ULgVdf] xOe£ZpWXUYznZoGU]ZXcdgiTVe£ZpzfWXoh]Up|cj]oholelbTV]tmnUYTigV]xehz©gVdf]k9mfmn]tTmnZpTig§ULgVdf]4¢nTl}gycjUXohkf\,z

UpLgVdf]z9]tOgbUYz9]Zpzxgidf]4oqUp L]tTbmnZpTigRUpLgVd9]§¢nTl}gcjUXohkf\z®]~ZYc[dgVTieZzfWYoq]UpLcj]oholelTV]mUXTVgi]xehz©gVdf]

ohU ]tTmZpTVgUgVd9]4xweZpWXUYznZo%U0gidf]mfTV]¡OeqUYknlgiTVeZzfWYoq]UpLcj]ohol¤

¥d9]l}giknxO,UgVd9]§Ti]cjkfTiTV]tzcj]Rxw]lVcjTiehvn]x,ehz©¥df]UYTV]\O¤q^Roh]ZXxflgiUgVdf]RUXohohU eqzfWTV]t\)ZpTV«9lj¤

=Bz©gVdf]yctZXl}]4 d9]tTV] :BufehoqohknlQgVT[ZgV]x,eqz½ªehWf¤nwugidf]gVTieZpz9WYoh]ULcj]toqolctZzvn]yctZpo£cjkfoZgV]x,]teqgVdf]T

ehz2ZyxOeZWYUYzZpo@vwxOeZWYUYzZpo@\)Zpzfzf]TGm9TVU¡Oe£xO]xgVdnZggidf]¢T[l}g|cj]toqofUp;Z4xOe£ZpWXUYznZo@el«Oz9Up zUYTeqz,Zoheqzf]

vO,oqehzf]=\2Zpzfz9]tTt¤

=Bz¦gVdf]ctZXl}] df]tTi] ^Xu gidf] gVTVe£ZpzfWXoh]Ubcj]toqol`e£lcjUY\,m9kfgV]x2ehz Z,ohehz9]vO©ohehz9]\2Zpzfz9]tTRvfkfgeqg

ctZpz©v] ZolQU,ctZocjk9oZpgi]x,ehz/ZcjUXohkf\z®vw2cjUXohkf\z®\)Zpzfzf]TmfTVU¡wexO]x,gidnZpgbgVdf]¢nT[lQgRc]tohoULZ,cjUXohkf\,z

el«wzfU z¤

¥d9elGe£lGzfUXgmnUlil}eqvfoh]RUYTLgVdf]bUYgidf]tTLgVTVe£ZpzfWXoh]lUp3cj]ohol¬gVdnZgel0UYT L (!¤t¤t¤!$B ^p[¤L¥df]lQ]Rc]toho£l

ctZpz©v]yctZocjk9oZpgi]xUXzfoh,eqz©Zoqehzf]Rvw,oqehzf]R\)Zpzfzf]Tt¤

bUYgV] gVdZpg B ^Yu0gidf]mn]tTQUYTi\2Zpvfeqoheqg}©xOe£l}giTVehv9kfgVeqUYz xO]lVcTVehvn]x¦ZpvnU¡] elRgVdf]lVZ\,]ZYl§gidf] UYzf]

WYeh¡]z§eqz 9¾^Y^;:sup d9]tTV]LgVdf]LehzwgV]tTi¡YZowZt¡YZeho£ZpvfeqohehgQ=xOelQgVTiehvfkfgiehUXz4elcUY\,mfk9gV]x@¤ =BgUYohoqU bl gidnZpgªgVdf]L\,]tgidfUwx

mfTV]lQ]tzwgV]x,df]tTi]Relgidf]znZpgikfT[Zo%]Ogi]tznl}eqUYz2Up3gVd9]§\]tgVdfUwx,eqz 9¾^Y^:B¤

¥d9]4 Zt,eqz, dfe£cd2gVd9]4cUY\,mfk9g[ZpgiehUXz®U0]~ZYc[dc]toho3¬!

elmn]tTQUYTV\]xellQdfU zeqz½ªehWf¤9O¤

¯¦]zfU lQdfU gidnZpggVd9]bcjUY\,m9kfg[ZgVehUXzUp'gVd9]oZYlQggVTVe£ZpzfWXoh]Uc]toho£lju dfec[d cjUYTiTV]lQmnUYznxflgVU2 :Bu

ehz2ZxOe£ZpWXUYznZovO xOe£ZpWXUYznZo\2Zpzfz9]tTelG¡]TVknlQ]jkfo@giUTV]xwkncj]bgVdf]cUY\,mfoq]twehgQehz gVdf]cZYl}] df]TV]bgVdf]

¡YZohkf]U §e£lzf]ZpTTiUY\gVd9]§¡XZohkf]Up 78 T¤

Rbeq¡]tz©Z4gVUYoq]tT[Zzncj]]tTiTVUYTyl}mn]cje¾¢n]x,vw,gVdf]knlQ]tTtuw ]yxO]j¢zf]ehzwgV]tWX]tT2. ZYl

. \,ehz

=

Y

A 4

;65 S ¬ T[

D % ^

¬s

¥df]yxOelQgVTVeqvfkfgiehUYz2U R S

WXeh¡]tz2ehz)¥df]tUYTi]t\w¤h^yctZpz2gVd9]tzvn] TVeqgVgV]zZXl

=îS 0R S 9 ' 3

Y

A 4

;65

S ¬ T[

@D

Y/ A 8

Y

< /

¬i^2 ; /

¬ ! Z \;

O > S

7:9.;

O S` C4X¬Q.

df]tTV] 4X¬.¡]tTVe¾¢n]l

4Y¬Q.

Y

3 < 4 ; 5 S ¬ T[

D

Y

/ A 8

Y

<

/

¬i^

; /

¬ ! Z \;

O > S

7:9.;

O S`

K

Y

3 < 4 ; 5 S ¬ T[

D

(14)

L^ L ^

L ^

^

L ^

L

L ^

^

½%eqWYkfTi]^8.=Bzc]toho3¬!

gVdf]¡]cgVUYTl

O¬!

LZpznx

O¬!

[¤

^ 3

Y

A 4

;65 S ¬ T[

@D

K ,

a`zfUYgidf]tTgVTikfznctZgVeqUYz2ctZzvn]Rmn]tTQUYTi\,]x4 df]tz gVd9]R¡XZpohk9]`U Rell}kcd gVdnZg 78;"<UT E E@78 T¤C=Æz gVd9el

ctZYlQ]uf ]dnZt¡]

=îS 0R S 9 ' 3

Y

A 4

;65 S

¬F T

D

Y

/ A

/8

¬i^ 8

; / 8

¬!

C4X¬.

3

Y

A 4

;65 S

¬F T

D

Y

/ A

; /

8

¬i^ 8 / 8

¬!

CR4X¬.

(15)

L^

L ^

L:B ^ L:B

L > >

^ >

>

^ >

L >

L > L > L >

½%eqWYkfTi]4 8.=Bzc]toho3¬!

gVdf]¡]cgVUYTl

O¬!

LZpznx

O¬!

[¤

3

Y

/ A 3

Y

/ 4

;65 S

¬F T

@D

; /

8

¬V^2 8

/ 8

¬ !

C4X¬Q.

Y

/ A 3

Y

/ 4

;65 S

¬F T

@D

; /

8

¬V^2 8

/ 8

¬ !

C4 <t¬Q. !y CR4Y¬Q.

df]tTV] 4 <j¬Q. !4L¡]tTVe¾¢n]l

4<¬.2!4 3

Y

/ < 3

Y

/ 4

;65 S

¬F T

@D

A

; /

8

¬V^ 8

/ 8

¬!

K 3

Y

/ < 3

Y

/ 4

;65

S

¬F T

@D

; /

8

¬V^ 8

/

(16)

^

^ C ^

½ªehWYk9TV] 8 &UX\,mfkfgZpgVeqUYz2UpGcj]tohoª¬!

¤

3

Y

/ < 3

Y

/ 4

;65 S7 > ¬ TK8

; /

¬

D

4

;65 S < ; 7 >

¬F Tj¬i^2 8i

/

D

3

Y

/ < 4

;65 S < ; 7> ¬ T¬V^2 8 V

/

D 3

Y

/ 4

;65 S7 > ¬ TK 8 ; /

¬

D

K 3

Y

/ < 4

;65 S < ; 7> ¬ T¬V^2 8V

/

D

K ^2

Y

/ A 4

;65

S < ; 7 > ¬ T¬V^ N8`i

/

D

\,ehz

% = Y

A 4

;65 S< ; 7 >

¬V¬ T¬V^2 8V

D

%!^2

¬s

=Æz2mfTZYcjgielQ]§gidf]R¡XZpoqkf]Up \kl}gvn]§¡]TVcjohUEl}]gVU 78 T|l}ehzcj]RgVd9]§Ti]kfehTi]t\,]tzwg0elWX]tzf]tTZpoqoh gVdnZggVdf]

T[ZpzxOUY\ ¡XZpTieZvfoh] R S

dnZt¡]

^2 8

78 T N

¬478! 78;=<jT

!

gVdf]b¡XZpohk9]Up ehoho9v]=l}\)Zpohow ehgidTi]l}mn]cg0gVUgVd9]`¡XZpoqkf]UpC.#u df]tz `e£l%zf]ZT;TiUY\78 T¤0¥d9]`WXohUYvZpo

cjUY\,m9kfg[ZgVehUXznZpo'licdf]\,]knlQehzfWygVdf]bgVTikfznctZgVeqUYz2lQgV]tm e£lGlQdfU z,ehz½%eqWf¤fuw df]tTV]bUYz9oh gVdf]bWYTZ~ mnZTVg

dnZYlgVU vn]4cUY\,mfk9gV]x@¤