Biologically plausible regularization mechanisms

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00071960

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00071960

Submitted on 23 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents

Biologically plausible regularization mechanisms

Thierry Viéville

To cite this version:

Thierry Viéville. Biologically plausible regularization mechanisms. RR-4625, INRIA. 2002. �inria- 00071960�

(2)

ISRN INRIA/RR--4625--FR+ENG

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

THÈME 3

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Biologically plausible regularization mechanisms

T. Viéville

N° 4625

Novembre 2002

(3)

(4)

')(*+-,/.!+-0-021

3465798 :; <>=/?@8A@BDC?@EGFH=I46FD7J798LK>7JBDCM46EG=68DN

EG7JBDOH8PNRQ6FH=S=6T8PNUCFH=S=RBDEGPVP@BW=6C8P

XYAZFW[\8?^]_QS`aPVPZ88

bcBDdSdeFHA\?Q68AV8CM468AZCM468f=Ugh/i/jDkl; mcFonH87 p6AZ8qjDrHrHj; h/jqd6BDOH8P

sutvwyx{z6|Dw/} 34SE~PPZ?@SQS`BDE~79PBW?dSAVFHdFHPVEG=6OBD=EG79d6~8798=/?MBW?VE~FD=FD_AZ8OH6~BDAZE~B{K

?@EGFH=97J8CM4RBD=6EGPV79PCFH79dRB{?@EGp6~8$E?@49p6EGFHGFHOHEGCyBD6FDde8A@BW?VFHAVP&)FHAZ8d6AV8CEGPV8G`DNSCFDAZ?@EGCyBW

7BWd6P CFaQ68nH8C?VFHAVE~BDdRBWA@BD798?VAVEGCqRBD=/?@E?@EG8PN!CFH79d6S?V8Qp`I=68?>FHAZlFD=68SAVFH=6P

<>= CFD7JdSS?@8AnaE~PZE~FD=NHPVEG79E~~BDA!RBD=/?@E?@EG8P&BWAV88JCEG8=/?@`CFH79d6S?V8QSPVEG=6O_EG7JdS~87J8=K

?MBW?VE~FH=SP FDdRBDA\?@E~BDQ6EGe8AZ8=/?@E~BD8RBW?@EGFH=6P$46E~CM4Q68R=68AZ8OH6~BDAZE~BW?@EGFH=d6AZFC8PVPZ8P

BD~GFo$E~=SOJ?VFJFDpS?MBDEG=8~ K>QS8R=68Ql8P\?@EG7JBW?@EGFH=6PFD!?@468PV8a6BD=/?@E?@EG8P

]_=68FDR?@468PV8798?V46FaQ6PEGPpRBDPZ8QqFH=9BD= E~=/?@8OHA@BW6BDd6dSAVFy¡E~7JBW?VE~FH=qFWR?@468QSEGe6PVEGFH=

FHde8A@BW?VFHA6PV8Q¢EG=AV8OH6~BDAVEGyB{?@EGFH=¢798CM4RBW=6E~PZ79P)£UFD~GFo$E~=6O?@46EGP¤FDAV7 S¥BW?VE~FD=N!?V468

d6AV8PV8=/?Q68nD8GFHd6798=/?Q68R=68PuB¦PVFH7984SF§¨FDdS?@EG7JBDE~79d6G8798=?@BW?@EGFH=©FW_PVSCM4BD=

E~=/?@8OHA@BWªFHde8A@BW?VFHA$E?@4?>FJE~=/?V8AV8PZ?VE~=6Od6AVFDde8AZ?@EG8P«

¬

E¥Y$4S8=6PV8QFH=P@BD79d6G8QQRB{?MBPVSCM4)BWPE~7JBDOD8_d6E ¡S8~PFDA:H®¯QRBW?@BnHFy¡8GPNUE?

d6AVFonaE~QS8PcBD=6=p6E¥BWPV8QIQ6E~PZCAZ8?@8EG7JdS~87J8=/?MBW?VE~FH=)FDPV6CM4IBD=)FDde8A@BW?VFHA°

¬

E~E¥$468=6PV8QBWPBI79FaQ68FD$p6EGFH~FDOHE~CBDdS¥BDSPVEGp6~87J8CM4RBD=6EGPV79PNE?CFDAVAV8LK

PVdFH=6Q6P$?@FBJPZE~79d6G8GFCBD¤88Q6pRBDCMQ686=68QlFonD8A_B9PV7JBDG!peFHS=6Q68Q)AV8OHE~FD=IFDBD=/`

PV4RBDd8E~=SPVEGQ68?V468dRBDAVBD798?@AZE~CPZdRBDC8W

± P_PVSCM4²EG? 7JBy`)pe8~EG=6D8Q²?@F$4RB{?_EGP_d6AVFaC8PVPZ8Q¦E~=lBCFHA\?@EGCyBDCFHG679=²FD?V468

p6A@BDEG=BD=6Qd6AVFonaE~QS8PBD=uEG=/?@8AZ8P\?@EG=6O97JFaQ68³FDOH8=68AVBD³FDde8A@BW?VFHAVPCFHAVAZ8PZdeFH=SQ6E~=SO?@F

PV6CM4IB9=S86AZFH=RBDªP\?@AVSC?@SAV8D

34S8 d6AZ8PV8=/?_Q68nH8GFHd6798=?EGPE~G~SPZ?@AVBW?@8Qlp/`PVFH7988¡de8AVEG798=/?@P_FWnaE~PZRBD79FWK

?@EGFH=8PZ?VE~7JBW?VE~FD=

´)µ/¶³·Z¸¹ x{ºvD} b8OH6~BDAVEGyBW?VE~FD=)798?V46FaQ6PNU®^Ee6PVEGFH=IFDde8A@BW?VFHANR»E~FHGFHOHEGCyBW79FQ68

(5)

)$

v } 8?V?V8IT?V6Q68d6AVFDdeFHPZ8)S=68)EG79d6GT798=/?MB{?@EGFH=©Q6879TCyBW=6E~PZ798PuQ68AVTLK

OH6~BDAVEGP@BW?VE~FD= CFH79dRBW?VE~p6G8PBynH8C)Q68P9FHdeTA@BW?V86AZP9p6E~FD~FHODE~68PXYG6P9d6AZTCEGPVT798=/?yN

~8PJCBDAZ?V8PJCFHA\?@EGCyBDG8P9Q6 C8AZnD8yBD8=6CFQ68=/?Q68PRBW=?VEG?VTP9nH8C?@FDAVEG8G~8PCyBW~C6~T8P

dRBDA~8AVTPV8yBWlQ68Pc=68SAVFH=68P&=InaE~PZE~FH=IdRBDAFHAVQ6EG=RBW?V86ANUQ68P_RBW=?VEG?VTPcPVEG7JEG~BDE~AZ8P

PVFH=/?CBDGC6GT8Pq8JCyBDC8798=/?98=¢E~79d6GT798=?@BD=/?9Q68PTRBW?VE~FD=6PqBD¡ Q6TAVEnHT8PqdRBDA K

?@EG8G~8PaSE³Q6TR=6EGPVPV8=/?^Q68Pd6AZFC8PVPZ6P$Q68_AZTOH6~BDAZE~PVBW?@EGFH=d8AV798?V?MBW=?QFDpS?@8=6E~AQS8P

8PZ?VE~7JBW?VE~FD=6PcpSE~8=)Q6TR=6EG8PQ68C8PcRBD=/?VEG?VTP

6=68Q68 C8P$79T?@4SFQ68PNREG=/?@AVFaQ66E?@8dRBWA$bcBynaE¥B{?$d66EGPQ6TnD8GFHd6dT8dRBDA$®^8OHFH=6Q

8?IBDP\KBW~GE~CWNS8PZ?p6BDPVT8^PVSA6=68^BDd6d6AZFy¡SEG7JBW?@EGFH=EG=/?@TODA@BDG8^Q68cFHdTAVBW?@86AQS8^Q6EK

¤6PVEGFH=qS?VE~GE~PZTdRBDA~879TCyBD=6EGPV798$Q68AZTOHS¥BDAZE~PVBW?@EGFH=&=JPZ6EnDBW=?C8?Z?@8¤FHAZ7 6~BW?VE~FH=³N

~8$d6AZTPV8=/?Q6TnH8~FHdSde87J8=/?Q6T6=6EU6=68$E~79d6GT798=?@BW?@EGFH=u8=68~68cPVFHA\?@8$FHdS?VE~7JBDG8

QS=?V8ªFHdTAVBW?@86AE~=/?VTOHAVBDBy`/BD=/?cQ68¡d6AVFHdSAVEGT?@TPcEG=/?@TAV8PZP@BD=/?V8P«

¬

E¥cQRBW=6P_G8qCyBDP_QS8qQ6FH=6=6T8P TCM4RBD=/?@EG~GFH=6=ST8P

¬

dSE¡8GPQ6=68qEG7BWOH8FHlnDFo¡8~P

QS=68cEG7JBDOH8$nHFHG679EGaS8oNC8d6AVFaCTQ6Tde8AV798?QFHpS?@8=6EGA6=S8^EG7JdS~T7J8=/?MBW?VE~FH=Q6E~P K

CAV5?@8=6FH=p6E~BDEGPVT8Q68FHdTAVBW?@86AN

¬

EGE¥QRBW=6PG8JCyBDPQ68J¥B79FQ6T~EGP@B{?@EGFH=¢Q68J79TCyBW=6E~PZ798Pp6EGFHGFHOHEG68798=/? d6¥BWK

PVEGp6~8PNC8¥B_CFHAVAZ8PZdeFH=SQJPZE~79d6G8798=?^S=JCBDGC6EG?VTA@B{?@EeGFaCyBDaQ6T6=6E6QRBD=SP&6=qde8?@E?

nHFHEGPVEG=RBDOH8Q68 ¤FHAZ7J8 68~CFH=6689E~=/?@TAVEG86AQ688PVdRBDC8 Q68P$dRBDA@BW7J5?@AZ8PN

C8aSE8= ?@BD=/?JaS8?V8-Nd8S?\K?@AV8AZ8GE~T ²C8aSE8PZ?CyBW~C6~TBD PV8E~=Q6=68

CFHGFH=6=68CFHAZ?VE~CBDG8Q6qC8AZnH8BDN¤FH6AZ=6E~PZP@BD=/?Y!_6=979FQ65~8EG=/?@TAV8PZP@BD=/?QFHdTA@B{?@8SAVP

BDPVPZ8OHT=6TA@BDa¡8?CFDAVAV8PVdFH=6QRBW=?96=68PZ?VAV6C?@6AZ8=S86AZFH=RBDG8D

ª8ldSAVTPZ8=/?79TCBD=6EGPV798²8P\?E~GG6PZ?VAVT²dRBDA68G68P8¡dTAZE~8=6C8PQ"8PZ?@EG7JBW?@EGFH=

nEGPVS8G~8Q67JFDSnH87J8=/?y

# ¹ w§v · |%$ v} )T?V46FaQ68)QS8IAVTOH6~BDAVEGP@B{?@EGFH=N]_deTA@BW?V86AJQ68)Q6EGe6PZE~FH=³N)FQS5G8P

p6E~FD~FHODE~68P

(6)

/ 0 "9! !"

1 ¹ xow32-|Hz $ z54v

X8AZC8dS?@RBWd6AZFC8PVPZ8PNEG=¢CFH79d6S?@8AFHAp6EGFH~FDOHE~CBDYnEGPVEGFH=N&AZ86EGAV8?V468CFH79d6S?@B{K

?@EGFH=FD76 7JBDdSP98^FDRBD=/?@E?MBW?VEGnD8 nDBW~68P&3468 AZ8?VE~=RBW³EG7BWOH8_E?@PV8GEGPB:6 AZ8?@EG=6FD?VFHd6EGC

7BWd;8M«¤FHA&8yBWCM4C8GRFDU?@468$AV8?@EG=RB FHA&8yBWCM4JdSE¡8UFDU?V468$E~7JBDOH8?V468AZ8$E~P&4RBynD8^B^nWBDG68

CFHAZAV8PZdeFD=6Q6EG=6O?@F ?V468_EG7JBDOH8_EG=/?@8=SPVE?>`BW??V46EGP~FaCyB{?@EGFH=&346EGPnWBDG68_EGP$BnH8C?@FDAVE~BD

nDBW~68¤FHA^CFH~FDA^EG7BWOH8P ± PZ?V8dl¤6A\?@468ANEG=²8yBDAZG`/K nEGPVEGFH=Ne?@468AZ8?VE~=RBWEG7BWOH8CFD=K

?@A@BWPZ? EGP_CFD7JdSS?@8Q B{? 8yBDCM4²GFaCyBW?VE~FH=³NªBDG~Fo$EG=6Ou?@FQ68?@8C?EG7BWOH88QSOH8P AZ8~BW?@8Ql?@F

peFHS=6QRBDAZE~8P p8?>88=EG7JBDOH8BDAV8BDP3468AZ8BDAZ88QSOH8Q68?@8C?@FDAVPEG=pFD?@4¢BDAZ?VEGRCE¥BW

nEGPV6BDP\`aPZ?@879P

¬

PZ888WO6=<?>orA@¤FHABJOH8=68A@BD!EG=?VAVFaQ66C?@EGFH=U$BD=6QlEG=)?V468pSA@BDEG=l=68K

AVFH=RBWP\?@AZ6C?V6AV8PE~=/nDFHGnD8QEG=naE~PZE~FD=de8AVC8dS?@EGFH=

¬

8DO6<?>yhA@¤FHAB PVEG79d6G8^FonH8AZnaE~8c

<>=peFD?V4uCyBWPV8PN6PVSCM47JBDdSP8=6CFQ68^=6FD?FD=6G`J?@4S8_CFH=/?VA@BDP\?$7BWOH=6E?@6Q68WNSp6?PV8nH8AVBD

FD?@468A_CS8P«^CFH=/?@AVBDPZ?_FHAVEG8=/?MB{?@EGFH=²AV8¥BW?V8Q²?@F8Q6OH8FDAVEG8=/?MBW?VE~FD=NPV46BDde8qC6AZnWBW?V6AV8WN

p6E~=SFC6¥BWAQSE~PZdRBDAVE?>`AV8¥BW?V8Q?@F9?@468 naE~PZRBD!Q68d?@4NUCFD~FHA$C68PN?V879deFDA@BDªQ6EGPVd6BDAVE?>`

pe8?>88=?>FqCFH=6PZ8C?@EnH8E~7JBDOD8PEG=AV8¥BW?VE~FD=$EG?V4unaE~PZRBD79FD?VE~FH=Q68?V8C?VE~FD=N68?VCDG

B 6CM47JBDd6PBDAV8c=6FD?FH=6`dRBWA@BD798?V8AZE~8Qp/`AZ8?VE~=6FW?@FHd6EGC^GFaCyBW?VE~FH=SPNap6S?BW~PZF6PVEG=6O

:H®GFCBW?@EGFH=6PNHFHA!dRBDA@BW7J8?@8AVEG8Q9p/`FD?@468AdRBWA@BD798?V8AZPPV6CM49BWPFHAVEG8=/?@BW?@EGFH=NHAZ8?VE~=RBW

nH8GFaCE?>`HNU8?VCDG

C.D

µ)E z6xow32¤z $GFH2I µ x µ;J w32-z $LKM"!zSw%2 ¹JONPE FQKSRz54T4!x ¹ zR|

D

<>=²CFH79d6S?V8A_naEGPVEGFH=NªBuAZ8G8nWBD=/?BD=6Q²8JCEG8=/??@468FHAZ`)E~P^=6Fo BynWBDEG¥BDpS~8AZ8O/BWAVQ6EG=6O

?@468QS8R=6E?@EGFH=JBD=6QqCFH79d6S?@BW?@EGFH=qFDUPZ6CM47JBDdSPFDURBD=/?@E?MB{?@EnH8nWBD~S8P

¬

PZ888WO6U<>V@

¤FHA&B Q6EGQRBDC?VE~CEG=?VAVFaQ66C?@EGFH=JBDpeFDS?&?@468U6 B{¡E~FH7JBW?VE~BW?@EGFH=;8FD?@46EGPYdRBDA\?YFD³CFH79d6S?V8A

nEGPVEGFH=UL&346EGP¤FHAV7JBDGE~PZ7f=6FD?FD=6G`Jd6AZFonEGQ68P$B CG8yBDApRBDPZE~C_FW76>$4RBW?EGP?@Fp8^QSFH=688

¬

E-8WAV86EGAV8798=/?@PE~=FHAZQ68Aq?@F²46BonD8)CFH468AV8=/?BD=6QCFD=6PVEGPZ?V8=/?QS8R=6E?@EGFH=6P@9pSS?

BD~PZFlFDU6>46Fo?@FIQSFlEG?98PVEG=6C8u?V468?V468FHA\`EGP 8³8C?VEGnD8EG=?V468PZ8=6PZ8u?@4RBW? 8JCEG8=/?

E~79d6G8798=/?@BW?@EGFH=6P7JBo`©pe8¦Q68AVEnH8Q

¬

PZ88¦8DO6W<j@_¤FHAB¢AZ8C8=/?)?VAV8yB{?@EGPV8¦FH=?@46EGP

PV6p[\8C?M 34S8X6 $4RBW? EGP_?@Fp8qQ6FH=S88 ~8nH8&EGP_¤FHAZ7BW~EG8QEG=²?@8AV79P FDBuCAZEG?V8AVEGFH=

?@F²79E~=SE~79EG8BD=6Q?@4S8Y6 46Fo ?@F²Q6F¦E? 8~8nH8EGPqAV8¥B{?@8Q?VF¦?V468DNYPZFCBDG~8QN YS~8A\K

!BWOHA@BD=SOH8)8RBW?@EGFH=6P$46E~CM4 BDGGF§ ?VF¢EG7JdSAVFonH8²BW=©E~=SEG?VE¥BDOH68PVPFD^?@468)PVFHGS?@EGFH=

BD=6Q OH8?JCGFHPZ8Aq?@F¦?@468FHd?@EG7BWPVFHGS?@EGFH= ± ?Bl?@8CM4S=6E~CBD~8nH8-NBDP9AZ8naE~PZEG?V8Q©EG=

?@46EGP$dRBDd8AN?@468PV8RBD=/?@E?@EG8PcBDAV8 8JCEG8=/?@`CFH79d6S?V8Q6PVEG=6OJE~79d6G8798=?@BW?@EGFH=6PFD

dRBDAZ?VE¥BWQ6E³8AV8=/?VE¥BD8a6BW?@EGFH=6P$46EGCM4IQ68R=68AV8OH6~BDAVEGyBW?VE~FD=)d6AZFC8PZPV8PcBDG~Fo$EG=6O9?@F

(7)

FHpS?MBWE~=8~ K>Q68R=68Qq8PZ?VE~7JBW?VE~FD=6PFD6?V468PZ8RBD=/?VEG?VE~8P&346EGPdFo8AZ¤67J8?@46FaQ6FHGFHOD`

E~PBDGPVFnH8AZ`9OH8=68AVBDRE~=9?@4S8PZ8=6PZ8c?V4RBW?B ¥BWAVOH8nWBDAVEG8?>`FDCFH79d6S?MB{?@EGFH=RBDRd6AZFHp6G879P

BDAV8 PZFHGnWBDpS~8$EG?V46EG=?V46E~P¤AVBD798FHAV

¬

PV888WO6 < NRiA@ª¤FDA$B9AZ8naEG8c

v2 Jµ x ¹J z $ )µ w ¸¹ x N R ¹ º µ $-v

<>= p6EGFHGFHOHEGCyBD_naEGPVEGFH=¯79FQS8GE~=6OSN_?@468 PVE?@RBW?VE~FD= EGP)Q6FD7JEG=RBW?V8Q p` ?V468 EGQ68B ?@46BW?

6 CFDAZ?@EGCyBW7JBDd6PcCFaQ68 nD8C?VFHAVE~BDdRBDA@BW7J8?@AZE~Ca6BD=/?@E?@EG8PBDAZ8 CFD7JdSS?@8Q²p`)=68?>FHAZ

FD =686AVFH=SP98MN$7JBDEG=6`=S86AZFH=RBDc=68?>FHAVP {K ¥BcFHdR8GQ

¬

8WOS <?>>@¤FHABAV8C8=/?

AV8naEG8cL

B

6CM479FaQ68GP9BDG~Fo ?@F¦BD=RBWG`a8EG=Q68?@BDEG~P?V468p6EGFH~FDOHE~CBDPZ6p6P\?@A@B{?@8FD

PV6CM4CFH79d6S?@BW?@EGFH=6P

¬

8WOS <@ LNaEG=JFD?@468A&FHAZQ6PY?@FA@BDEGPV88JCE~8=?4/`adeFD?V468PZ8PBDpeFDS?

6 46Fo EG?qEGP9Q6FH=68#8M

±

?@8AZ=RBW?VEGnD8Pq?@Fl?V468PZ879FaQ68GPJBDGPVF¦8¡EGPZ?

¬

8WO6 <:Dr@$468AV8B

PVd6EGD8CFH79d6S?MB{?@EGFH=RBD7JFaQ68E~P CFH=6PZE~QS8AV8QU B 6CM479FaQ68GP9BDAV88E?@468ApRBDPZ8QFH=

PVFH798H6 BDQK>4SFC#87J8CM4RBD=6EGPV79PN_79FHAV8)d6AV8CEGPV8`PZde8CERC²Q68PZCAZE~dS?VE~FD=6PFD=686AVFH=6BD

CFH=6=S8C?VE~FD=6P$4SE~CM4BDAV8U6 dS¥BDSPVEGp6~8#8$AV8O/BDAZQ6E~=SOFH=S8FDAYBD=6FD?V468AYFHd8AVBW?@EGFH=

¬

8WO6 <>yhA@

¤FHA&8Q6OD8cBW=6QQSE~PZdRBDAVE?>`9CyBW~C6¥B{?@EGFH=6PM&FHA&79FHAZ8cBWp6PZ?VA@BDC?798CM4RBD=6EGPV79P

¬

8DO6 <j;>DNaj@

$468AZ8)BlCFH79d6S?@BW?@EGFH=RBDQ68PZCAVEGdS?VE~FH= FDc8yBDAZG`/K nEGPVEGFH= BD=6Q79FD?VE~FH=CFH79d6S?MB{?@EGFH=6P

E~=l?V8AV79P FDBDQ6BDdS?@EnH8qGEG=68yBDAcRG?V8AZE~=6OEGP_d6AZFHdeFDPV8QR

±

?@46FHSOH4l?@468PV8JBDd6dSAVF/BDCM4S8P

BD~AZ8yBDQ`BW~GFo BQ688d6=6Q68AVP\?MBD=6QSE~=6O9FD³$4RBW?EGPd6AZFC8PZPV8QEG=uEG7JdFHA\?MBD=/?BWAV8yBWPFD

?@468pSA@BDEG=NH?@4S8AV8E~P&=6F^CG8yBDA&GE~=S$E?@4?@4S8CFH79d6?@8AnaEGPVEGFH=JBDGOHFHAVE?@4S7JP7J8=/?@EGFH=68Q

pe8¤FHAV8W

2$2ºT2J z $!2J t µ w ¸µµ"J E FQK z J º

B 6CM49B_GE~=6UNDFH6GQ9E~=SQ688QJ46BonD8PV8nH8A@BDRBWQSnWBD=/?MBDOH8PN/d6AZFonEGQ6EG=6OB^798?V46FaQ6FHGFHOD`?@F

AV8~BW?V8?V468 6 $4RBW?EGP?VFp8cQSFH=688$BD=6Q?V468 6 46Fo?VF Q6FE? 8$G8nD8GPBD=6QBDGPVF dSAVFonaE~Q6EG=6O

BnH8AZ`uOD8=68A@BDCFH79d6?MBW?VE~FH=6BDe¤AVBD798FHAV9¤FHAPZ6CM4CyBW~C6¥B{?@EGFH=6P ± PZ?@8du¤6AZ?V468AN

X® CBD~C6~BW?@EGFH=6PAZ8OHS¥BDAZE~8?@4S8EGAE~=Sd6S?yN&E-8Dld6AZFonEGQ68B8~ K>Q68R=68QBD=SQ¢PZ?@B{K

p6~8q8PZ?VE~7JBW?VE~FH=²8nH8= EG=²?@468CBDPV8qFW=SFHE~P\`lFHA^dRBDAZ?VE¥BW~`IQS8R=68Q Q6BW?MBS34RBW=6P_?@F

?@46EGP d6AVFDde8AZ?>`HN!BDGOHFHAZEG?V4679P 4RBynH89d8AZ¤FDAV7JBD=6C8PCGFHPV8A ?@Fu?@4SFHPV89FDp6EGFHGFHOHEGCyBDP\`aP\K

?@879P&?@46BD=JBDAZ?VEGRCE¥BW6=68SAVFH=RBW6=68?>FHAZaP£USAZ?@4S8AV79FHAZ8DNH?V468~EG=6 8BW=?Y?VF p66EG~Q

FHS~Qd6AVFonaEGQ68BY6>CFH7979FH=¦¤A@BD798FHAZ 8qpe8?>88=¢CFH79d6S?MB{?@EGFH=RBD&BW=6Q pSE~FHGFHOHEGCyBW

nEGPVEGFH=uEG=FDAVQ68AY?VF Q68nH8~FHdCFH7979FH=79FaQ68GPBW=6Qp6EGFHGFHOHEGCyBDRdS¥BDSPVEGp6~8_BD~ODFHAVE?@4679P

cFo8nH8AN!p66EG~Q6EG=6OPV6CM4 B~EG=6lEGP=6FD?EG797J8Q6E~BW?@89p8CyBW6PV8q?@4S8AV89EGP_`H8?=SFC~8BDA

6=6Q68AVPZ?@BD=6Q6EG=6O9FD!46Fo PV6CM4CFD7JdS~8L¡Q6E³8AV8=/?VE¥BD³=6FH=K ~EG=68yBWA798?@4SFQ6PCFH6GQCFHA K

(8)

AV8PZdeFD=6Q ?@Fc=68SAVFH=RBW798CM46BD=6EGPV79PYBD?@46FHSOH4 ?@4S868P\?@EGFH=q4RBDPpe88=qBW~AZ8yBDQS`AVBDE~PZ8Q

<> aNjWh@2

4$

µ µ;J

w32

J E F KfzRv

<>=FHAVQ68A?VFp66EG~Qu?V46EGP~EG=6UNS8_7 SPZ?$4RBynH8B7J8?@46FaQu$46EGCM4BD~GFo$P?@F E~79d6G8798=/?

?@468CFH79d6?@8AcnEGPVEGFH=ld6BDAZ?VE¥BDQ6Ee8AV8=/?@E~BD8RBW?@EGFH=6PN³6PZE~=SOu=68?>FHAZaP FW=686AVFH=6BD

6=6E?@P ± P!EG?!$EG~7JBDQ688¡d6GE~CEG?E~=?@468PV868-NH?@468Q6EJC6?dFHEG=/?EGP!?V468BD=6EGPVFD?VAVFHd6EGC

Q6EGe6PZE~FH=FHd8AVBW?@FDAVPEG79d6G8798=/?MB{?@EGFH= FH=6CAZ8?V8`HNRPVSCM4S=6EG?VP7 6P\?$E~=/?V8OHAVBW?@8^?V468

E~=S¤FDAV7JBW?@EGFH=9EG=B pFH6=6Q68Q=S8EGOH4peFHAZ46FaFQ9PVF?@46BW?&?@468$CFFHd8AVBW?@EGFH=9p8?>88=?@468PV8

6=6E?@PBDGGF§ BOHGFHpRBWeCFH79d6S?MB{?@EGFH=FDª?@4S8_RBD=/?@E?MBW?VEGnD87BWdY£R6AZ?V468AZ7JFDAV8DNa?@Fqp8

p6E~FD~FHODE~CBD~`ldS¥BDSPVEGp6~8WNPZ6CM4798CM4RBD=6EGPV79P7 6P\? p8qpRBDPZ8QFH=¦PVEG7JdS~8J~FaCyBWGE~=68BDA

¤88QSpRBDCM <SN>>V@ !<>=FD?@468AFDAVQ6PN{8Y7 6P\?dSAVFonaE~Q68BG6 d6BDAZ?VE~C~8&EG79d6~8798=/?MBW?VE~FD=;8YFD

PV6CM4=6798AVEGCyBWªCFH79d6S?@BW?@EGFH=6P B 6CM4)B7J8?@46FaQN6SPV8QEG=66E~QQS`a=RBW7JEGCPCFD7JdSK

?MBW?VE~FH=J4RBDPYp88=EG=?VAVFaQ66C8Qp/` ª8FD=RBDAVQ <jDrA@R¤FHG~Fo8Qp`JbBynaE¥BW?BD=6QIBDP K BDG~EGC

<jHk%@YBD=6Q¦Q68nH8~FHd8Q p/`¦®^8ODFH=6Q BD=6Q IBDP K BD~GEGC <k@2 < ?EGPpRBDPZ8QFH=BD=²E~=/?V8OHAVBD

BDd6d6AZFo¡EG7JBW?@EGFH=uFD³?@468cQ6EGe6PZE~FH=FHde8A@BW?VFHA6PV8QE~=?V468^AZ8OHS¥BDAZE~BW?@EGFH=u798CM4RBD=6EGPV7

34S8OHF/BWaFWS?@4SE~PdRBDd8A!E~P!?@F^QS8PVCAVEGpe846FoCFH79d6S?V8A!nEGPVEGFH=d6BDAZ?VE¥BDQ6Ee8AV8=/?@E~BD

8RBW?VE~FH=SPCBD=pe8EG7JdS~87J8=/?@8QI6PVEG=6OJ=68?>FHAVPcFD=S86AZFH=RBDª6=SEG?VP

D zSwY2-vqw D µ 4z54 µ xuzSt ¹ ªw

£UFD~GFo$E~=6Oq?V46E~P?VA@BDCMUNUE~=?V468=68¡a?cPV8C?@EGFH=N68 BWAV8 OHFHEG=6Oq?@F9AZ8naE~PZEG??@4S8CFH79d6S?V8A

nEGPVEGFH=²dRBWAZ?@E~BDQ6EGe8AZ8=/?@E~BD8RBW?VE~FH=¦798?V46FaQ6FHGFHOD`E~=l?V468CBDPV8qFD&nD8C?@FHAZE¥BD7JBDd6P

BD=6QBDGPVFQ6E~PZC6PZP4SF§ EG?7JBy`²p8JOD8=68A@BDGE~8Q?@F=6FH=K ~EG=68BDA CFHA\?@EGCyBD&7JBDdSPCFH7K

d6S?MB{?@EGFH=6P

8)?V468=©BDAV8)OHFHEG=6O ?VFAV8LK>Q68AVEnH8²BW=EG7JdSAVFonH8Q nD8AZPVEGFH=FD_?V468l®^8OHFH=6Q©BD=6Q

IBDP\KBW~GE~C7J8?@46FaQNCFH=SPVEGQ68AZE~=6O BlPVFD7J846Fo FHd?@EG7BWE~79d6G8798=?@BW?@EGFH= FDPV6CM4

BD=E~=/?@8OHA@BWªFHde8A@BW?VFHA$E?@4?>FJE~=/?V8AV8PZ?VE~=6Od6AVFDde8AZ?@EG8P«

¬

E¥Y$4S8=6PV8QFH=P@BD79d6G8QQRB{?MBPVSCM4)BWPE~7JBDOD8_d6E ¡S8~PFDA:H®¯QRBW?@BnHFy¡8GPNUE?

d6AVFonaE~QS8PcBD=6=p6E¥BWPV8QIQ6E~PZCAZ8?@8EG7JdS~87J8=/?MBW?VE~FH=)FDPV6CM4IBD=)FDde8A@BW?VFHA°

¬

E~E¥$468=6PV8QBWPBI79FaQ68FD$p6EGFH~FDOHE~CBDdS¥BDSPVEGp6~87J8CM4RBD=6EGPV79PNE?CFDAVAV8LK

PVdFH=6Q6P^?VFBPZE~79d6G8q~FaCyBW!¤88Q6pRBWCMIQ68R=68Q¦FonH8ABPV7JBDGpFH6=SQ68Q²AZ8OHEGFH=²EG=6PVEGQ68

?@468dRBDAVBD798?VAVEGCPZdRBDC8D

8_R=RBW~`u$EG~ªEG~G6P\?@A@B{?@8 FH6AQSE~PZC6PZPVEGFH=Ip/`PZFH7988L¡de8AVEG7J8=/?@PFDnEGPV6BDª79FWK

?@EGFH=8PZ?VE~7JBW?VE~FD=

(9)

)¹ wozSw32 ¹J v 8l$AVE?@8 & BD=6Q ( &!# EG=peFHGQ ~8?V?V8AVPN^7JBW?VAVEGC8Pp8EG=6O

$AVE?V?@8=$E?@4CyBDd6E?MBW/~8?V?@8AVPBD=6QPVCyBW¥BDAZPEG= E?MBW~EGCD!3468Q6RBDFD6BRBD=/?VEG?>`E~P!AV8dK

AV8PZ8=/?@8QBDPYE?@PY?@A@BW=6PVdFHPV8!N/?@4S8QSFD?ZK d6AVFaQ66C?p8?>88=nH8C?VFHAVPpe8E~=SO$AVE?V?V8=BDP

8^AV8dSAV8PZ8=/??@4S8_CFH79dFH=68=?VPFD!B 7JBW?VAVE ¡uFHABnH8C?VFHA6PVEG=6OqPZ6de8AVPZCAVEGdS?VPN

8DO6~«

B E~79EG¥BDAZG`8_$AZEG?V8 & ',% E~=pFH~QG8?Z?@8AZP$EG?V4)CFonDBWAVE~BD=/?BD=6QCFD=?VA@BynWBDAVE~BD=/?

E~=6QS8¡8PY$AVE?V?V8=BDP&E~=SQ6E~C8PBD=6Q98¡dFH=68=?NAZ8PZde8C?@EnH8G`D£RFHAE~=6P\?MBD=SC8DN?@4S8¤FH~GFoK

E~=6O: '7 _PZ`a7peFH !" E$#%'&?@468=)(8~PZ8+*SN!4RBDPCFonWBDAZE¥BD=/?E~=SQ68¡)#cBD=6Q

CFH=/?@AVBynDBWAVE~BD=/?EG=6Q68L¡,&R<>=9?@46EGPYCFH=/?@8L¡a?yNaB,-'.+/7JBW?VAVE ¡102!34#$'(65758/$&9'(:5;5<- EGP

B >K CFonWBDAVE~BD=/?>= >K>CFH=/?@AVBonWBDAZE¥BW=??@8=6PVFDA ± ?@46FHSOH4NU?@4686 &E~=SPZ?@8E~="8 =SFD?MBW?VE~FD=lBD K

~Fo$PYE~79d6GEGCE?PZ6797B{?@EGFH=6PFDe?V8=6PZFHAYE~=SQ68¡8PNE?BDd6d8yBDAZPYCG8yBDAZ8AN468AV8WN?VF8¡d6GE~CEG?

?@468PV8PV6797JBW?@EGFH=6P

£RFHAnD8C?@FHA$FDE~=/?V8OH8AcEG=6Q6EGC8P@?A?

CBBB

?ED6GFIH

D

8$AVE?@8W«

J? J

K?

LMBBBNL

?EDqBD=6QO?QPRK?

P BBB

?ED3P

PVF9?@4RBW?8CyBD=$AVE?@8CFH=6CEGPV8G`«

ES+M SUT

BBB SV

D

BD=SQXWS

Y[Z

\]^]`_

\a

^ T

T"bcbcb

\a

^ V

V

$46E~G8 ?@4683By`GFHA8¡dRBD=SPVEGFH=)FW&B¤6=6C?@EGFH= dfe:g Dih

g p8CFD7J8P«

djkjQldjk

Lnmpoq

S qr \

^Ns

S:t

fuv

S Lnw

o d

$468AZ8?V468 AV87BWE~=6QS8A

w>x

d7JBy`p8_$AVE?V?@8=I6PZE~=SOBD=EG=/?@8ODA@BD¤FHAZ7«

w o dy

m qS qr

o{z o{z

S:t%|~}

c

Xu)

S(uC

o

WSdj

L

"pu

R

8BD~PZFCFH=6PVEGQ68Ac?@4S8 B FHpFHG8n¤6=SC?@EGFH=)PVdRBDC8"{9kg

D

$dSAVFonaE~Q68QI$E?@4)?V468

=6FHAV7«

JJ

Z

JJ

{ PV6d

3 3Q

PVSdI8PZP

qS qr

YU

V J WS

Z

J

$468AZ8 PV6d)8PVP

Y

$kjE~P?V468 PV7JBDGG8PZ?CFH=6PZ?@BD=/?yN6EBD=/`HN6¤FHA$46EGCM4X$kjE~PpFH6=SQ68Q

8¡C8dS?^EG=)B9=S8OHGE~ODE~p6G8PV8?^FD798yBDPZ6AV88AVF6

" "ª " ² G

8?6Pp6AVEG8 6`AV8naE~PZEG??V468^CFH79d6S?V8AnaEGPVEGFH=dRBDA\?@E~BDeQSEGe8AZ8=/?@E~BD³8RBW?@EGFH=798?V46FaQK

FH~FDOD`IEG=l?@4S8CyBDPZ8qFDYnH8C?@FDAVE~BD7JBDd6P BW=6Q²Q6EGPVCSPVP46Fo E? 7JBy`lp8OH8=68AVBD~EG8Q²?@F

=6FH=KYSCGE~Q68BD=²CFDAZ?@EGCyBW7JBDd6P_CFH79d6S?@BW?@EGFH=6P34S8OHF/BD!FD&?V46E~P^PV8C?@EGFH=¦E~Pc?@FuQ68LK

R=68_?@4S8 d6AVFHpS~87 BD=6QdFHEG=/?$FHS??V468 E~79dFHAZ?@BD=6C8_FDBCFHAZAV8C?$EG7JdS~87J8=/?MBW?VE~FH=FD

Q6EGe6PZE~FH=FHd8AVBW?@FHAZP

(10)

sl} 4$ µ µ"J w32 J x µ $¤z6x2/zSw32 ¹ J µ | D z J 22v¢v

c8AZ8DNBDP9AV8aSE~AZ8Q E~= PVFH798PVE?@6BW?@EGFH=6P

¬

8WOS <>DN&iSN >§j3@LNY8CFH=SPVEGQ68A9¤6=6C?@EGFH=6P

$46E~CM4nWBD~S8PBDAV8=6FW?$PVCyBW¥BDAZP$p6S?$nH8C?@FDAVP

x ¹

J

|Dw32

¹J

z $ª|Hx2w µ x2

¹J

w ¹ K $

µ x

· z

x{z

JUµ9µ M!zw32

¹J £RFHABcnH8C?@FDAVE~BD

7BWd«

e6g D h

g

8CFD=6PVEGQ68A$?@4S8¤FD~GFo$E~=6O9nWBDAVE~BW?VE~FH=6BDd6AZFHp6G87«

+- # /k kj

$468AZ81

\ Y

\a"!

E~P^B1- . / 7B{?@AVE ¡$46EGCM4lCFHAZAV8PVdFH=6Q6P^?VF?V468#HBDCFHp6E~BD=

FD?V468 ¤6=6C?@EGFH= BW=EGP$CyBDGG8QEG?VP %$'-&-

<>=)FHAZQ6PN?@468 - & &!'JFD?V46EGP^7JBDdlFDnDBW~68P^CFHAVAZ8PVdFH=6QSP^?@FBD= 6>FHp[\8CLK

?@EnH88 FHA$BX6>CAZEG?V8AVEGFH=;8^?@FJBW?Z?MBDEG=NRBDP$E?$E~Gpe8 EGG~6P\?@AVBW?@8QIEG=?V468PV8682

± =68C8PVPVBDAZ`CFH=6Q6E?@EGFH=u¤FHAB ¤6=6C?VE~FD= ?@Fp8BD=8L¡?VAV87 67 FW!?V46EGPCAZEG?V8AVEGFH=

E~PJ?@4RBW??@468)PVF¢CBDG~8Q 6 =6FHAZ7JBD?8FDA &6G8A KBDOHAVBD=6OH8)8RBW?VE~FH=E~PnD8AZEGR8Q¯346EGP

8RBW?VE~FH=PVEG79d6`)P\?MBW?V8P?@46BW?yNUBW?BW=)8L¡?VAV87 67NU?@468CAZEG?V8AZE~FH=EGPGFaCyBDGG`*6 UBW?98_E-8W

EG?VP:>PZ?$FHAZQ68AnWBDAVE~BW?VE~FH=nWBD=6EGPV4S8P

8AZ8DNR?@468AV8¥B{?@8Q &6~8Ac8RBW?@EGFH=)E~P$FHp/naE~FD6Pc?VFQ68AVEnH8

¬

8DO6 <('@ª¤FHABD=)EG=/?@AZFWK

Q66C?VE~FD=UBD=6Q7By`p8 $AVE?V?V8=«

W)

W

u+*-,.0/

W1

W1 32 l*

$468AZ8

\4

\56

EGPBX- .v/7B{?@AVE ¡$46EG~8J?@468Q6EGnD8AZOH8=6C8E~P?@F)pe86=6Q68AVPZ?VFFaQ¢BWPB

nH8C?@FHAZE¥BWª8¡dRBD=6PZE~FD=NUE28D&¤FHA$B - . /²7JBW?VAVE ¡87 k_«

*-,.

97 D

:

r W)7

W

<; '(6575<-

F µ%= J 2J x µ $¤z6x2>/zw32 ¹J zRvqz J¹ 4w32 2>/zw32 ¹J 4!x ¹ t$ µ ª8?$6P=SF§ CFD=K

PVEGQ68A$BqdRBDA\?@EGC6~BDACBDPV8W«?@468 !;#$%&' FDBD=*6 EG=6d6? 8c¤6=6C?VE~FD=@? kL&< ?

E~P$Q68R=68Q³NeBWPQSE~PZC6PZPV8QI8DO6&E~= <iA@NRp/`u?V468 ¤FHG~Fo$EG=6OFDdS?@EG79E~BW?@EGFH=d6AVFHpS~87«

9- #A/

(A

J;J

u ? J;J

B

L@C@D JJ

J;J

EGF

(11)

$EG?V4 J;J

J;J

E m ! 4 ! k

!

4

kj 4

BD=6Q J;J

u ? JJ

B D u ? F

D u ? F

8AZ8DNRFH=FH=684RBD=SQ«

e3g

D h g

F"kg

D

EGP_BNePZFCyBW~G8QN (*; (*'-&G' ( &'

(*&!#NS$4SE~CM4NR¤FHA?V468d6AV8naE~FHSPcQ68R=6E?@EGFH=?@FJpe8 CFH468AZ8=/?yNUEGP«

KPZ`a79798?@AZE~CE-8W

²BD=SQ

K 6 dFHPVE?@EnH8#8E-8WPZFq?@4RBW? 1.vFOg

.

. *S

346EGP798?@AVEGCBD~GFo$P?@F9AV8d6AV8PV8=/?«

¬

E¥9?V468ld6AZ8CEGPVEGFH= FD ?V468lEG=6d6S?u¤S=6C?VE~FH=³«?V468I46EGOH468A?@4SE~Pd6AZ8CE~PZE~FH=EG= B

OHEnH8=Q6EGAV8C?@EGFH=N6?V46846EGOH468A?V468 nDBW~68FD

EG=?V46E~P$Q6EGAV8C?VE~FH=

¬

EG=)B9P\?MBW?VE~P\?@E K

CyBD¤A@BD798FHAZUN

CFHAZAV8PVdFH=6Q6P?VF?@468_EG=/nH8AVPV8FD!BCF§nWBDAZE¥BW=6C8 7JBW?VAVE ¡RpSS?

BDGPVF

¬

EGEdRBDAZ?VE¥BWFHpSPV8A\nWBW?@EGFH=NYEG=¢?@468uPZ8=6PZ8?@4RBW?EG$?@4S8uE~=Sd6S?q¤6=6C?@EGFH= ? kEGP

=6FD? QS8R=68Q¤FDA_PVFH79898qPVEG7JdSG`²46BonD8q?@FPZ?@BW?@8

*BW?_?V46E~P GFaCyBW?VE~FH=³

B

EG7JEG~BDAV`HN?V468 -BDC?_?@4RB{?_?@468qEG=6d6? ¤6=6C?VE~FD=? ^E~P^FH=6`lQ68R=68QEG=²PVFH798

Q6EGAV8C?@EGFH=CFDAVAV8PVdFH=6Q6P?@F7JBW?VAVE ¡

deFHPZEG?VEGnD8_p6S?=6FD?Q68R=SEG?V8_E~=u?V46EGPQ6EGAV8CK

?@EGFH=

¬

¤FHAE~=6P\?MBD=SC8DNEG ? kjEGPFH=SG`Q68R=68QEG= ?V468QSE~AZ8C?VE~FD= B{?BOHEGnD8=

~FaCyB{?@EGFH=8 $AVE?@8

; ¤FHAPZFH798 ;6N

BD=6Q79FHAV8OH8=68AVBDGG`

¬

EGE~E¥GE~=S8yBDAqAZ8~BW?@EGFH=6Pqp8?>88=798yBDPZ6AV8PJBD=6QdRBDAVBD798?@8Aq8P\?@EG7B{?@EGFH= NPVBy`

7 N³$46EGCM4EGP FHp/naE~FD6PV`l8aSEGnWBDG8=/??@FuAZ86EGAV8 J;J

u ? JJ

B

*$E?@4

7K 7 BD=6Q@? 7K

¬

8DO6 <:Hi3@ª¤FHA$BqQ68nD8GFHd6798=/?M

]_=?@468FD?V468A46BD=6Q«

e g

D)h

g

D

D F {+kg

D

EGP9BSN&PVF²CBDG~8QN $' &P',%N

$46EGCM4IEGP«

KPZ`a79798?@AZE~CE-8W

!

4

!

4 BD=6Q

K 6 dFHPVE?@EnH8#8E28DPVF9?@4RB{? 7 F g

D

7 7 m ! 4 7 ! !

4 7 4

l*JEG=

FHAVQS8A?@4S8dSAV8naEGFH6PQ686=6EG?VE~FD=)?@F9p8CFH468AV8=?NR$46E~G8

C e$g

z h g z

QS8R=68P?@468 & FD?@46EGP AZ8OHS¥BDAZE~BW?@EGFH=N&E?EGPqBIP\?@AZE~C?@`

E~=SCAV8BDPVEG=6O9¤6=6C?@EGFH=$E?@4

C

A*6Ql*SN

?V468uCFH7 p6EG=68Q EG= RS8=6C8FD?@468PV8?>F²~BDPZ?q8~8798=/?@Pqp8EG=6O²Q6EGPVC6PVPZ8Q E~=?V468

=68¡a?dRBDAVBDOHA@BWd64

(12)

»AVEG8 6`DNS?@468?@8AV7

C JJ

J;J

E

EGP?V468X !;#$%&' ?@8AV7 <:;>V@³$4SE~CM4BDGGF§$P?@F

CFHAZAV8C?@`Q68R=68Q)E~G K>dFHPV8Q)d6AZFHp6G879PNBDP$7JBDQ688L¡SdS~EGCE?^=SF§

<>=PV6CM4B CBDPV8WN6B¤8 BW~OH8p6A@B~8BDQ6P?VF ?@4S8_AV8¥BW?V8Q &6G8A8RBW?VE~FH=u$4SE~CM4EGPB

nH8C?@FHAZE¥BWªQ6EGe6PZE~FH=)dRBDA\?@E~BDQ6E³8AV8=?VE¥BW!8RBW?@EGFH=NRE-8DG«

u ? u

E l*

¬

>§

$EG?V4

E

* ,.

C D JJ

JJE F : 4 !

4 4

?@468?V46AV889?V8AZ7JPp8EG=6OAV8PZde8C?VEGnD8`?V4689Q68¤FDAV7JBW?@EGFH=

¬

E-8D

Nª?@4689FDePV8?

¬

E-8W

? BD=SQ?V468Q6EGe6PZE~FH=

¬

E-8D

E

L

! "#$% &('*),+.-0/2143,5678:9;<7!=>?7@A@A@CBD7!=E#$FAGH#0E0>F$I#J7

7>IHBK#$=L7!@MNKFO7!MPQFA=@R$S>T"$@JU#$WV,FA=%NFO7!X! Y7ZE6B

\[]H[^#$Z>=EFA_PQFA=@`$a9"*=L7!@X07!`TAEbEcd7!eE6[

G8yBWAV`HN$E?@4SFHS??V468$?@8AZ7fFDªQ6E³SPVEGFH=N?V468PVFHGS?@EGFH=uEGP ? $46E~G8^?V468?V8AZ7

FDQ6EGe6PZE~FH=f

E

BD~GFo$P ?@FY6 dSAVFHdRBWO/BW?@8#8PVFH798qEG=S¤FHAV7JBW?VE~FD=¦BDpeFDS? ¤AZFH7 FD=68

deFHEG=/? ?VFJBD=6FD?V468A34S8W8`EGQ68yB9EGP$?VF46BonD8 ?@468EG=S¤FHAV7JBW?VE~FD=)d6AZFHdRBDOHBW?@8Q«

¬

B/c$468AV8q?@4S8JEG=6d6?¤S=6C?VE~FH=EGPd6BDAZ?VE¥BDG`lFHABDdSd6AVFy¡E~7JBW?V8`¦Q686=68Q°E~=¦PVSCM4¢B

CyBDPZ8DNSPZE~=SC8_?@4S8_7JBW?@AZE¡

nWBD=6EGPV4S8PFHA4RBDPB PZ7JBD~CFD=?VAVEGp6S?VE~FH=BD=SQ EGP8=?VE~AZ8`

FHA7JBDE~=SG`QS8R=68QIp/`?@4S8QSEGe6PVEGFH=?@8AV7N

¬

pU$468= ?V468¦d6AVFHpS~87 E~PEG~ K>dFHPZ8QNcE28DfE?V468AZ8 BWAV8¦7JBD=/` BD=6Q =6798AVEGCyBW~`

6=6PZ?@BDp6G8 PZFH~?@EGFH=6P°eE~=)PV6CM4¦BJCyBDPZ8DN8~FaFHu¤FHABPZFHGS?@EGFH=I$46EGCM4lnWBDAVE~BW?VE~FH=SP^BDAZ8

7JEG=6EG79E~8QNBDP$FHpS?@BDEG=68Qp/`u?@468AZ8OH6~BDAZE~BW?@EGFH=?@8AZ7

)¹Jª· $2 Jµ z6xRg µ xWvv $!2J!µ z6xº 2I v2 ¹J¢¹ 4 µ x{zw ¹ xWv ª8?SP=6Fo AV8naE~8 4SF§

C

BD=6Q E~= R68=SC8?V46EGPQSEGe6PVEGFH=FDE~=S¤FDAV7JBW?@EGFH=

£RAZFH7 BqPZ?VA@BDEGOH4/?V¤FDAZBDAVQQ68AZEGnWBW?VE~FD=«

h E

,i

m ! 4 \

\aj D C

JJ

J;J

E

!

4 \ k

\a ! F

C

JJ

J;J

E

ml

m 4 lm ! \ E j! k

\aj6n

\ k

\a ! L2m

! 4 !

4

\do k

\aj\a ! n

L C

JJ

E m ! 4 h JJ

JJ

E i! !

4

\k

\a !

BD=6QE~=?@468dRBDA\?@EGC6~BDA$CyBDPZ8$468AV8 E~PCFH=SPZ?MBW=?^BD=6Q$EG?V46FHS?^BD=/`EG= R68=6C8WNeE-8W

! 4

PVF?V4RBW?

JJ

J;J

E JJ

JJ

¬

8lCFD=6PVEGQ68A4S8AV8)?@468qp

=6FHAZ7q?@46EGP

(13)

AV8QS6C8P?VF6«

h

,i

C

J;J

m !

\do

}\aj

o L A C

JJ

J;J

m !

\do

\aj\a !

\

\aj

\

\a !

C

J;J

4 L A

qcq

56 qcq

o

qcq

56 qcq

o

: 1

$EG?V4

56

qcq

56 qcq

NRPVFq?@46BW?$8FHpS?@BDEG=«

¬

E¥B ?@8AZ7 AV8¥B{?@8Q?@F

C

$46EGCM4ICFHAVAZ8PZdeFH=SQ6P?@FJBD=EGPVFD?VAVFHd6EGCQ6E³6PZE~FD=

¬

468AZ8J

E~P?@4S8 BDdS¥BDCE¥BW=FW?@4S8;K ?V4)CFH79deFH=S8=/?FD BD=6Q

¬

EGEB?@8AV7 AV8~BW?V8Qu?@F

C

$46EGCM4CFHAZAV8PVdFH=6Q6P?VFqBD=BD=SE~PZFD?@AZFHd6EGC_Q6E³6PZE~FD=d6AVFaC8PVP

E~=?@468Q6EGAV8C?VE~FH=

FD!?@4S8ODA@BDQ6EG8=/?

£R6A\?@468AV79FHAZ8DNREG=?V46E~P$CBDPV8BDGªCFH79dFH=68=?VPcFW BDAZ8 Q68CFH6d6G8Q³

± =RB{?@6AVBDAV86E~AZ8798=/?X<>HN @E~P?VFJFDpS?MBDEG=«

¬

?EGPVFW?@AVFDd6E~CQ6Ee6PVEGFH=)¤FDAPV7JBDGªOHA@BDQSE~8=?c7JBDOH=6E?@SQ68pe8CyBD6PZ88BD=/?$?@FJ7JB{¡K

E~79EG8?@468d6AVFDdRBDO/BW?VE~FD=)FDEG=S¤FHAV7JBW?VE~FD=IEG=)6=SEG¤FHAZ7

¬

?V4aSPcEG=S¤FHAZ7B{?@EGFH=)G8PZPM$dRBDAZ?VP

FD?V468dRBDAVBD798?@AZE~CPZdRBDC8BD=SQ

¬

CyBD=6C8?@468d6AVFDdRBDO/BW?VE~FD=)FDE~=S¤FDAV7JBW?@EGFH=¤FHA$46E~OD4lOHA@BWQ6E~8=/?^7JBDOH=SEG?V6Q68 EG=)?V468

Q6E~AZ8C?@EGFH=uFD?V468^ODA@BDQ6EG8=/?E~=FHAVQ68A?VF d6AZ8PZ8AZnD8 ¥BWAVOH8

¬

?V4aSPPVEGOH=6ERCBD=/?LnWBDAZE¥BW?VE~FD=6P

FD?V468E~=Sd6S?$¤6=6C?@EGFH=

<>=FD?V468AFHAVQ6PNR8BW=?$?VFJ8~EG79E~=6BW?@8PV7JBDG2NR?V4aSPGEGD8`=6FHEGPZ`DNUnWBDAZE¥B{?@EGFH=6PFD

?@468dRBDAVBD798?VAVEGC7JBDd³NRp6S?$d6AZ8PV8AZnD8 ~BDAVOH8 nWBDAZE¥BW?VE~FD=6P

± Q6BDdS?@EG=6O²$4RBW?946BDPp88= d6AZFHdeFDPV8Q¢¤FDAE~=SPZ?MBW=6C8EG= <j3@2N&?@468CFH=6P\?@A@BWE~=/?

¬

?

PVEG7JdSG`798yBD=6P?@4RB{?yN¤FHAPZ7JBD~OHAVBDQ6EG8=/?7JBDOH=SEG?V6Q68PN?V468 jW=SQ?@8AV7fp8CFD7J8P=68OWK

~EGOHEGp6~8 $E?@4AV8PVd8C??@Fq?V468 >yPZ?FH=68WNRE28DG«

GE~7

qcq

56

qcq hA C JJ

J;J

JJ

Ii

C JJ

J;J

QM*

$46E~G8u?@4S8CFH=6P\?@AVBDE~=/?

¬

798yBD=6Pq?V4RBW?yN¤FDA 46EGOH4OHA@BWQ6E~8=/?97BWOH=6E?@6Q68PN&?@4S8jW=6Q

?@8AZ7 7 SPZ?pe8q?@4S8JFDd6deFDPVE?@89FD?@468 >yP\?FD=68DNEG= FHAZQ68A ?VFCBD=6C8YQ6E³6PZE~FD= EG=?V468

OHA@BDQSE~8=?Q6EGAV8C?VE~FH=³E-8DG«

~EG7

qcq

56

qcq z C JJ

JJ

hA C JJ

J;J

JJ

Ii 'u,(

346E~P^E~P^?V468 CBDPV8WN8DO6_FW

C C ¦BD=6Q²PV8nH8A@BDFD?@468A_d6AZFDRG8PNBDP^AZ8naE~88Q EG=

<j@2

± PYB_CFH=SCG6PVEGFH=N/?@4S86PV8FW?V468=6FD=K>GE~=S8yBDA¤6=SC?@EGFH=

C

PVEG79d6G`BDG~Fo$P?@F EG=/?@AZFWK

Q66C8JBD=SE~PZFD?@AZFHd6EGCqQ6EGe6PZE~FH=¦$E?@4¦AV8PVd8C??VFu?@468q¤6=6C?@EGFH=¦OHA@BWQ6E~8=/? FH6GQ

EG?^pe8deFHPZPVEGp6G8 ?@FFHpS?MBWE~=I?V468 PVBD798d6AZFHde8AZ?>`p6S?^d6AV8PV8AZnaE~=SO?V468 GEG=68yBDAZEG?>`)FD?V468

Q6EGe6PZE~FH=8RB{?@EGFH=

(14)

¬

AZ8O/BWAVQ6EG=6O ?V468

8PZ?VE~7JBW?VE~FD=)FDEG7BWOH87JFW?@EGFH=U?@4S8AV8EGPcBqdFHPVE?@EnH8BD=6P\8A?VFq?@46EGP$aS8PZ?VE~FD=

ª8? 6PCFD=6PVEGQ68A?@46BW?

C

E~P?@4S8JEGQ68=?VEG?>`¤6=6C?@EGFH=¦?@46P 46BDP=6FIEG= R68=6C8WNE-8W

C C lN6PVF9?@46BW?yNS$E?@4)Bq¤8 BW~OH8p6A@B«

h E

,i

:4 7 4 W 4

W

L :! 4 !

4 W 4

W !W

$E?@4 7 4 : ! W !

4

W ! ¬

jH

£RFHGGF§$EG=6OY<jDj@U~8?6PYCFH=6PZE~QS8AY?@4RBW?Y8c46BonD8^BW=EG=6E?@E~BDRFHAYd6AV8naE~FHSP8PZ?@EG7JBW?@EGFH=

346E~P 8PZ?VE~7JBW?VE~FD=¢7JBo`4RBynD8uPV8nH8AVBDPZFH6AZC8P«?@468E~=Sd6S? ¤S=6C?VE~FH= ?

¬

E-8W+ ? NB²d6AVEGFHAZEE~=¤FHAV7JBW?VE~FH=³NY?V4688P\?@EG7B{?@EGFH=FDpS?MBDEG=68Q p/`dSAV8naEGFH6P

PZ?@8d6P9FD$?@468BW~OHFDAVE?@467NBDPQ68?MBDEGG8Q E~=?@4S8=68¡a?9PVSpK>PZ8C?VE~FD=¢<>=FD?@4S8AFHAVQ6PN

8 $ "?@4S8EG=6EG?VE¥BW8PZ?@EG7JBW?@EGFH= ?@F)FHpS?@BDE~=BD=¢EG79d6AVFonH8Q8P\?@EG7B{?@8DNE28D)BD=

8PZ?VE~7JBW?V8 $46E~CM4)CGFHPV8G`nD8AVER8P?V468Q6EGe6PZE~FH=8RB{?@EGFH=

£RAZFH7 ?V46E~P$8PZ?@EG7JBW?@8WNU~8?cSPCM4SFFHPZ8D«

!

4 D

F

D

JJ J;J

F ! 4 L qcq

D

JJ

J;J

F

u

D

JJ

F

J;J J;J

h

! i h 4

i¬

:/

$468AZ8 J;J

J;J

BD=6Q

qcq

JJ

$BW~GFo$Pc?@FBDQW[\6P\?c?V468PV79FFW?@46EG=6O-BWC?@FDAEG=)?V468

=6FHAV7JBDBD=6Q?MBD=6OD8=/?@E~BDªQ6EGAV8C?@EGFH=6P$$E?@4AV8PZde8C?$?@F9?@4S8ODA@BDQ6EG8=/?

FHAV8d6AZ8CEGPV8G`DNe=S8OHG8C?@EG=6OJ?V468PVdRB{?@E~BDnWBDAVE~BW?@EGFH=

\ E j!

k

\a j

FD 8FHpS?@BDEG=«

h E

,i

b

L

qcq u

:

L

JJ

W

J;J

$EG?V4

J;J J;J

$46EGCM4 E~=6QS88QCFHAVAZ8PZdeFH=SQ6Pu?@F$46BW?4RBDPpe88=FHpS?@BDEG=68Q

6PVEG=6O9?@468=6FH=aK>GE~=68BDAd6AZFDRG8DNR$EG?V4«

C

CBD=6Q

qcq

C k[

L A C ¬

h

87JBy`8nD8=ICM4SFFHPZ8 Bq79FHAZ8OD8=68A@BD¤FHAZ7 ¤FHA

qcq

kCE~=?@468d6AZ8PZ8=/?^CBDPV8W

<>=?@4S8GE?@8AVBW?@SAV8

¬

8WOSBWPAZ8naEG88QIEG= <>HNRj@LN6$468=CFD=6PVEGQ68AZE~=SOuBq=6FH=K ~EG=68BDA

d6AVFD6~8WNUBW??@468EG79d6~8798=/?MBW?VE~FD=IG8nH82NB9PVEG79E~~BDA='7: ( &!'9EGPSPV8Q³

<>=?@4SE~PJCFH=/?V8¡a?yNE?JE~Pq?V4aSP6PZ8G8PZP?@F¦CFD=6PVEGQ68AJ=6FH=aK>GE~=68BDA9d6AVFWR~8P

C

A9pSS?

PVEG7JdSG`6PZ8BD=SE~PZFD?@AZFHd6EGCQ6Ee6PVEGFH= d6BDA@BD798?@8AZE~8Qp/` 34RBW=6P?@F$?@4SE~P!Q68AZEGnWBW?VE~FD=N

8BDGPVFJFHpS?@BDE~=BD=8¡SBD79d6G8FDCFH468AV8=/?¤FHAV7 ¤FHAN6¤AVFH7

¬

:/BD=SQ

¬

h

(15)

8^?V4aSP$E~GCFD=6PVEGQ68AEG=?@468^PV868?@4RB{?

C

E~P?V468_EGQ68=/?@E?>`u¤6=SC?@EGFH=BD=SQu$E~G

E~=/?@8OHA@B{?@8JEG?VPEG= RS8=6C8EG= ?@4S8BD=SE~PZFD?@AZFHd6EGCQ6Ee6PVEGFH=FDde8A@BW?VFHA dRBDAVBD798?@8AVEG8Q¢p/`

c

4$ µ µ;J wozSw32 ¹J¦¹ Yw D µ x µ $¤z6x2>/zSw%2 ¹J 4x ¹ t$ µ £UAZFH7 ?V468$d6AV8nEGFH6P &K

~8A 8RBW?VE~FH=

¬

jHNªB{?_?@468qEG79d6G8798=/?MB{?@EGFH= G8nD8-N!BuAV8C6AVAZ8=/?8RBW?VE~FD=EGP Q68AVEnH8Q

$46E~CM4IBDG~Fo$P$?@468EG?V8AVBW?@EnH8=6798AVEGCyBWCFH79d6S?MB{?@EGFH=)FW?@4S8¤S=6C?VE~FH= nWBD~S8P$¤FHA

B9798PV4IFWPVBD79d6~8P

¬

PV888WO6<iA@ B 6CM4)BD=8RBW?VE~FD=)EGP$6PVRBW~`FD!?@468 ¤FHAZ7«

L

? L

E u ¬

kH

$468AZ8?V468AV8OD6¥BWA7JBW?VAVE ¡

NS$E?@4v(

JJ

*JBDG~Fo$P?@FJCFD=?VAVFH?V468EG?V8AVBW?@EGFH=

CFH=/nH8AVOH8=6C8W9<>= PZ6CM4BdRBWA@BDQ6EGOH7 E

EGPBW= ((*'-& ( &'FD

?@468CFD=?VE~=6FD6PcPZ8CFH=6QIFDAVQ68AQ6EGe8AZ8=/?@E~BDFHd8AVBW?@FHA?

E

±

?c8yBWCM4IE?@8AVBW?@EGFH=NR?V468=S8 8PZ?@EG7JBW?@8 E~PCFD7JdSS?@8QI¤AVFH7 ?@468d6AV8naE~FHSP^8P\?@E K

7B{?@8 N!6PV6BD~`6PVEG=6O? BWPEG=6E?@E~BDnWBD~S8D£R6A\?@468AV79FHAV89?@4S8Q6Ee6PVEGFH=¢FHd8AVBW?@FDA

E~PBDGPVFAZ8CFH79d6S?@8QB{? 8yBDCM4¦P\?@8d³N!PZE~=SC89BDP 7JBDQ68q8L¡d6~EGCE?¤FHA_EG=6PZ?@BD=6C8qE~=

¬

:HNE?

7By`²QS8d8=6Q FH=²?@4689d6AZ8naE~FD6P8PZ?VE~7JBW?V8JFW 9<>=FDAVQ68A?V46EGPQS8d8=6Q68=6C`=6FW? ?@F

BW³8C? ?V468qPZ?@BDp6EG~E?>`lFD?@4S8qEG?V8A@B{?@EGFH=²798CM4RBD=SE~PZ7N?@4SE~P d6AZ8naEGFH6P8P\?@EG7B{?@89CyBD=¦p8

6 PV79FaFD?@4S8Q;8c?@FqFHp?MBDEG=BPVSJCE~8=?VG`P\?MBW?VE~FD=RBDAZ`nWBD~S8_FD cY346EGP$BDPZde8C?$EG~=SFD?

pe8 ¤6A\?@468AQ6E~PZC6PZPV8Q²468AZ8pSS?$8AV8¤8A?@FH<jHj@ª¤FHA$BqQ68nH8~FHdS7J8=/?y

±

P9=6FD?@EGC8Q ¤FDAE~=SPZ?MBW=6C8E~= <?>'A@2NE

JJ

J;J

*²¡S8QdFHEG=/?@P9FD?@46EGP9EG?V8A@B{?@EnH8

8RBW?VE~FH=BDAZ8PVFHGS?@EGFH=FD?@468 &6G8A98a6BW?@EGFH=NY$46EG~8E

J;J

JJ

h

*l8FHpS?MBWE~= B

PZ?MB{?@EGFH=RBDA\`²nDBW~689¤FHA $46E~CM4EG=6Q6SC8P?@468JCFH=/nD8AVOD8=6C8u?@FoBWAVQ6P BPZ6pK>FDdS?@EG7JBD

nDBW~68W

£R6A\?@468AV79FHAZ8DN?V468)7JBW?VAVE ¡

CFH79d6S?V8?V468=S8nWBDG68FW ¤FHAV7 ?V468Jd6AV8nEGFH6PnWBD~S8FD %%' (

'7*3& ( '-W346EGPEG=6CG6Q68P BD6PZP\K

B

8EGQ68FHA #HBDCFDp6E$EG?V8A@B{?@EGFH=798?@46FaQ6P

BD=6QPV8879Pc?VFJp8BqOH8=68A@BDªPZCM468798W

34S8JW8`²dSAVFHp6G87 468AZ8qE~P ?@46P_?VFFHpS?MBWE~=¦BAV8~8nWBD=/? BWd6d6AVFy¡EG7B{?@EGFH=f

E

FD

?@468 ?V8AZ7 FDYQSEGe6PVEGFH=f

E

E~=²FHAZQ68Ac?@FuCFHAVAZ8C?VG`lBD=6Q²8CE~8=/?@`²E~79d6G8798=? ?V468

d6AV8nEGFH6P PZCM468798W ± =¦8PZ?@EG7JBW?@EGFH=¦FD EGPBD~PZFAV8aSE~AZ8Qp6S?yNBDP^naE~PZE~pS~89EG=

¬

jHLN

?@46EGP$PV8CFH=6Q)d6AVFHpS~87 E~P$dRBWAZ?@EGCS¥BDA$CBDPV8$EG?V4 7 4 4 BD=6Q

!

4

l*NRPVFq?@4RB{?8

$E~G¤FC6P$FH=?@468 >yP\?d6AVFHpS~87