HAL Id: inria-00070178
https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00070178
Submitted on 19 May 2006
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub-
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
A Biologically-Inspired Model for a Spiking Retina
Adrien Wohrer, Pierre Kornprobst, Thierry Viéville
To cite this version:
Adrien Wohrer, Pierre Kornprobst, Thierry Viéville. A Biologically-Inspired Model for a Spiking Retina. [Research Report] RR-5848, INRIA. 2006, pp.78. �inria-00070178�
a p p o r t
d e r e c h e r c h e
Thème BIO
INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE
A Biologically-Inspired Model for a Spiking Retina
Adrien Wohrer — Pierre Kornprobst — Thierry Viéville
N° 5848
Février 2006
0 132547698;:=<?>3256@2
∗ A3B 47692C256ED<2C83F32C<G3HCI
† AKJ >347692C2CLNM4PO@Q47RPRP6
‡
SUTWV*X(Y Z[]\_^a`cbedgf]VCXhY5dUijlknmlknonjqp9rYCd
sutvkxwyY*fz\|{bcdvd]}*Y
~nk@tgf{eYtvYC TYCtv TWY?3xn@ ^'}*ctvjYCtnn@$^xxonY5d
C*#nn SUTYrtvk9dgYknUf]TjqdtvYCd]YCntv Tjqd$f]kEt]k#cjq{eY ?kxf]YC9f]jqxm WY*rtvk@dvjlY*9f]jqdgfvd nW{¡k@X£¢
Wref]YCtzd]*jYC9f]jqdyf dU¤j¥fvT¦x§xt]f]j¨jqxm©tvYfvj£X(ke{eYCm7ªW{Y*mlj@Y*tvjo d]jl«nYCdfvk TjlonTYCtg¢¬mYCnYCm?cjqdgrxm©f nd]«cd
d]jlXrmq#fvjk@Wd*|SUTY(xt Tj¥fvYCf]rtvY kxuk@rt|t]Y*f]jlWX(ke{eY*m3jqdzind]YC{§k@¦t]Y5YC@f|Tcbedgjlknmlkno@jlCxmdgf]rW{jY5d*ª
d]k§fvTW#fhYCn T®Y5#f]rWt]Yjldt]YCmlxf]YC{fvk¦tvYCxm¯t]Y*f]jlW¦ TWntv@°fvY*tvjldgf]jq*dC§SUTYX(ke{eY*mjmlrW{eYCdh§mljWYCxt
¨m¥fvY*tvjot]ke*YCdvd*ªW®knmlmk#¤YC{icb§dyf #fvjl$Wkne¢¬mjlY5xtvj¥fyb@ªx{±f]TYCEd]jl«nY o@Y*YCtvxf]jlkn±tvkc*YCdvd*[¬f
fvTcrWd3dgjlXrmq#fvYCd/f]TWYk@ref]WrefukxfvTYUsKxtvnkeYCmmlrmqxt#f]Tc¤U²b$kxWWt]jlX #f]YtvYf]jlW@d*ª#?k@dvdgjlimlb$®knt3mqxtvonY*¢
dv*nmYd]jX£rmq#f]jlknd*3S¤k$dgYCt]jlYCd3knfvYCdgfvd ¤¯YCt]YU?Y*t]®kntvXhY5{©³´¨tvdgf]mlbk@(d]jlonmlYY*mlmqd3®kntu¤TWjl T(ontvknrWW{
fvt]rf]TEjqd²#xjlmlnimY@ª?d]YC*knW{mb±knEt]Y5xmljldgf]jq cjqdgrWnmdvYCYCdC$SUTYht]YCk@tgfdgY*fvdµf]TYhiW@dgjqd®k@tz®rWtgfvTY*t
X(ke{eYCmjloW¦SUTWjldjW*mr{eYCd£knWmjlYCnt Y¶YCfvd f]TWxfhk@rmq{"kcCrth{erYf]k§fvTY*knW{er°fvnWY*¢Pind]YC{
#f]rWt]YkxKd]b9xefvjljl9f]Y*t nf]jlknWdCu·Wkxf]TWY*t®refvrtvY Y¸cf]YCWd]jk@jqdX(ke{eY*mljWo kxf]TY¹ExonWkc*Y*mlmrWmlnt
#f]Tc¤U²bknWt]jlX #f]Yµt]Y*f]jlWndC[¬f¯jqduknrWt¯k@c9jq°fvjk@(f]TWxf¯irWjmq{ejlo£d]rW T$ijlkx¢¬jlWdgWjtvYC{(X(ke{eY*m?¤jlmm
TWY*mlºjl"iY*fgf]YCt$rW{eYCtvdgfvnW{ejloTk#¤fvTY(t]Y*f]jlWYCtg®k@t]X dxW{xmqd]kjl"t]YCmlxf]jlok@iWd]Y*tv²xf]jlknWdzf]k
iWjk@mk@onjq*xmX(YC TxjqdgX dC
»§¼9½¾v¿À #Án ~Yf]jlWWª©ÂzjqdgrWnmKdgbedgf]Y*X±ª´`cjl«nY5d*ª©s T9bed]jk@mk@onb@ª`cjlXrWmlxf]knt5ª©~YfvjWkxf]k@cbnª/ïkn{erW°¢
f xW*YCdC
∗ÄÅ5Æ7ÇÉÈyÊ9ËÌͰβÆÏÈyƬÐÑ7ͰҲβÇÔÓ5ËÇÉʲÆÏÇÔÓ5ËÕlÆ
†ÖÇÉÈyÆ7ÆÏÈ°Ë×/Í°ÆÏʲҲÆÏͰزÑ7Ù¬ÐÑPÍ°Ò5βÇÔÓ5ËÇÉʲÆÏÇÔÓ5ËÕlÆ
‡Ú Î5ÇÉÈgÆÏÆ®Û*ËÜÇÉÈÞÝ5ÇÉßÉßÉÈ]ÐÑPÍ°Ò5βÇÔÓ5ËÇÉʲÆÏÇÔÓ5ËÕlÆ
ïY$t x?knt]fz(k@rtirfzml *t]}5#fvjk@{r§X(ke{eV*mlY {eY tv}fvjWY xt]f]j¨jlY*mlmY@ªW*nWxiWmY {eY
*kncnYCtgfvjt$mje®k@t]X xf]jlkn"cjld]rY*mlmlYY* d]}*tvjY5d {}*X(jqd]d]jk@Wd {eYknf]Y*9fvjYCmld£{@°fvjk@´EïYX(kc{V*mlYdgY
@Y*refµr§knrefvjm{eYd]jX£rmq#f]jlkn§?knrWtmY5dYCrtvk@dvjlY*9f]j¨p9rYCdCªX xjqd}Co@nmYCXhYC9frY ?k@dvdgjlimlY Y*9fvt]}CY
?knrWt|{eY5dµd]bedyfv}*X(YCdµ{eYcjqdgjlknºxt]f]j¨jlY*mlmY£iWnd]}CdµdgrWtµ{erke{xo@Y Wntf]YCX(Wd{ejldvtvYf d*´Y£Xhke{eVCmY
Wrjld]Y(dgk@¦jdgjlt #f]jlknº{ejtvYCf]YCXhYC9f{nWdµmlTcbcd]jlknmlknonjlYnª?Yf$ TW@rY({eYhdgY5d|*knX(?k@dvx9f]Y5d?Y*ref
f]tvYt #fgf n T}CY§rYmkeCxmljldv#fvjk@WT9bed]jk@mk@onjqp9rY tv}Cjqd]YnºÃ¯YCd£k@Xh?k@dvx9fvYCdd]kn9f£nr¡knX£itvY
{Y$f]tvknjqd*³r§¨m¥fvtvnonYd]W#fvjkn¢7fvY*X(?knt xmPªWdgrWjcj/{rWYk@e¢Pmljl}Cnt]jf]} dgfvxf]jqp@rWYrjqdz{rEt]ke*YCdvdgrWd
{}CXhjqdvdgjlknh{eYdgjl«nY5d*´YX(kc{V*mlYtv}Cd]rmfvn@fKd]jX£rmYmlY¯®k@W°fvjk@YCXhYC9fK{Y¯mq|nknjlY sKnt]@kc*Y*mlmrWmlnjtvY
{YCd¯t]}*f]jlYCdU{eY5d tvjlX(xf]Y5d*3s3knrt¯f]Y5dyfvY*tUmlYzX(ke{eV*mlYnªek@rWddgjlXrmlknd mlY|*knX(?knt]f]Y*X(YC@fU{rYdgYCrmY
*Y*mlmrWmY£YfµmlY(knX(Wnt]k@Wd{eYCdµY*tvY*o@jldgf]YCX(Y*9fvdzTcbcd]jlknmlknonjqp9rYCdCªrWjld|k@rWdµd]jlXrmlknWdzmlt]}Ck@Wd]Y
{rWYhtv}fvjWY£YC@fvjVCt]Y {eYCddgf]jlXrmq#fvjk@Wdcjld]rYCmmlYCdC"!k@rWdtvkn?k@d]knWdµr"*@{et]Yf]T}Ckntvjlp9rYh?knrt
mlYCdUWY*rtvknY5d{eY$knf]tvY|X(ke{eVCmY@ªp@rWj´YCt]X(Y*fgf]t ({}f]r{ejYCtmlYCdU?kxf]YC9f]jlY*mqdY¶Yf dkn¢PmljW}CxjltvYCdU{erWd
mq#f]rWt]Y({eYCd*knrt x9fvdµjlknjqp9rYCd${nWd|mY5d|Y*rtvknWYCdCª´p@rWjudgk@@fn}CTjqrml}Cd|Wnt{YCdknrWnY*t]f]rWt]Y5d
{Y*knW{er°fvnWY5d*#!k@rWdhtvkn?k@d]knWd}*o@nmYCX(Y*9fh{eY5dhjldgf]Y5d?knrWth}*f]YCW{etvYmlYX(ke{eV*mlY$¦mqE@knjlY
¹ExonWkc*Y*mlmrWmlnjtvY{eY±mqt]}*f]jlY§{erNt]jlX #fvYn%!knrd dgk@XhX(Y5d£?Y*t d]rWn{e}5d(p@r&rNX(ke{eV*mlY§#f]fvn TW}
nrefvn9fp@rWYuk9d]d]jlimY'UmlWT9bed]jk@mk@onjlY3YCt]X(Yf]f]t {eYuX(jlY*re¸tvY*mljYCt´mY5d´k@iWdgYCt]#xf]jlknWdY*¸c?}*tvjlXhYC9fvxmlYCd
hmntv TWj¥fvYC°fvrtvYµijlknmlkno@jlp9rY$p9rj©mlY*rt{knY$xjqd]dvxW*Yn
(À
5
¾
*)
$
~}*f]jlYnªn`ebcdgf]VCX(YcjqdgrWY*mPªn`cjl«nYCdCª#suTcbedgjlknmlkno@jY@ªx`cjX£rmq#f]YCrt5ªx~}fvjknf]k@jY@ª9ïkn{erW°¢
f xW*YCdC
" ..
#%$&
¼ ¼ ('*)©$,+ Àc¿¼ .-) (
&
'*) ¼ ½ /
0
1)/e À ½ 2)/Á43 5)x('À )/ )6'®½ À -
& ¼ ¼ '*) 7
8 jlm¥fvY*tvjWo `cf]tvrW°fvrt]Y $$$$|$$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$
8@8 \µnY*tvcjYC¤ $$$$$|$$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$
8@ \µt]o9xj:9Cxf]jlknjlEïknY5°fvYC{²bnYCtvd $$$|$$$$$$$|$
8@! /jlnY$S¯bcY5dUkx ïY*mlmld£$$|$$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$
8@ ´jlYCnt]jfyb kxf]TY S/¤k(jlm¥fvY*tvjWo `cfvxo@YCd<;-$$|$$$$$$$|$=88
?>µj¶?YCt]YC@fsKxf]Tc¤²bedN$$$$|$$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$=8²
! ~zn{ejqxm/\µtvo@nj95#fvjk@ $$$$|$$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$=8C
@BA ¼ / À ) (À Á ¼ )*'6)5C,'*) & ¼ ¼ ('*) # 7
!W8 [Þ9fvY*tvWxm´¹§ke{eYCm©®knt!zY*rtvkn $$|$$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$=8#
!W8@8 SUTY[Þ@fvY*o@tvxf]jlknED¯p@r#f]jlkn $$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$=8#
!W8@ ´jlYCntU·ztvk²¸ejX #fvjk@¤jf]T±tvYCd]Y5°fUf]k(fvTY[Þref$$$$$$|$=8(F
!W8@! !kn¢PmljWYCxtvjfyb jf]TWY£Ã¯[y ¹§ke{eY*m($$$$|$$$$$$$|$ n
!W8@ `cknmlref]jlkn¤jf]T¦`cjl«nY5d $$|$$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$ G8
!W8@ ïknW*mrWd]jlkn®k@tf]TWY|s t]Y5dgYC@fz~Yf]jlW(¹§ke{eYCm7 $|$$$$$$$|$ @
!W¹¦kc{Y*mljoïTYCX(jlCxm/`cbcWnWd]YCd $|$$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$ H!
!W8 `cjX(mlY ¹§ke{eYCm®kntz `cbcWnef]jq~YC*Y*efvknt $$|$$$$$$$|$ H!
!W !Y*rWt]knf]t xWd]X(j¥f]f]Y*t~YCmY5nd]Y $$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$ @
!W! Sk#¤Uxt {d(`eb9xefvjl$¹§ke{eYCm $$$$$|$$$$$$$|$ n
!W ·`cbcWxefvjl¹§ke{eYCm $$|$$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$ n
!W!?D mY5°f]tvjq*xm/ïk@rmljWo iY*fy¤¯YCY*¦Ã¯Y*mlmld $$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$ n
I ¼
('*)
(À Á ¼ )
@J#
8 ~YCYCef]k@tvdC³Kx±·{xf]jlo`cWxf]jlkx¢Pf]Y*X(?knt xm©jmf]YCt $|$$$$$$$|$K!28
8@8 \µWdgjlWdnW{s Tkxfvkxf]t xd]{er°f]jlkn¦Ãndv*@{eYa$|$$$$$$$|$K!28
8@ suTkxfvkxfvtvnWd]{rW°fvjk@jl§Ã¯k@YCd±$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$K!9
8@! suTkxfvkxfvtvnWd]{rW°fvjk@jl~kc{Wd $$$$$|$$$$$$$|$K!c
8@ ~YC*Y*efvkntµÃ¯knrWmjlo-$$|$$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$K!c
?Lzkntvj9Ckn9fvnmïY*mlmldC³ ´ke*nm´·@Y*t xo@Y*t d$$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$K!@
! Zjlk@mlntµÃ¯Y*mlmldC³KZUxW{c¢¬W@d]dUjmf]YCtvd|$$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$ 9
!W8 Z¯jl?knmqxt ´jlYCntjmf]YCt§$$|$$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$ 9
!W `9f]rW{bkx/f]TY jlm¥fvY*t $$|$$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$ M8
!W! St xWd]jlY*9fUnW{§`crWdgfvnjY5{Zjlk@mlntµÃ¯Y*mlmld $$|$$$$$$$|$ c
`ej«@YN|Y*YCtvxf]jlknjf]TWY$[Þs $$|$$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$ O!
8 Nxo@mjlknWntïYCmmqd-$$$|$$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$ O!
·X n*t]jlYïY*mlmld³3®rWtgfvTY*tz·{Wxef #f]jlkn±x{`cjlonxm`cTWnjlo¦$$$|$ @
·µd]d]Y*X£imljohfvTY ~Yfvj$$$|$$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$ 9
/ ¼ )®C
I 7
8 Du¸c?Y*tvjlXhYC9fvxmsut]knf]kek@m$$$|$$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$ e
`ejo@mY£Ã¯YCmm`ejX£rmlxf]jlknWd£$$$|$$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$ OF
8 >ztvj¥fvjWoEN|tvxf]jlo@d$$$|$$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$ OF
`9fvxf]jqN|tvxf]jlo $$$|$$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$ OF
! `ejX£rmlxf]jlknkn§x±·tvt ²b kx ïY*mlmld|$$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$ n
!W8 ·Wnt]jf]jlknkx3`9fvxf]jq|[ÞX(nonY$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$ n
!W ~YCd]k@Wd]YµfvkN|t]jq{d $$|$$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$ H!
!W! ¹§k#cjo `cY5p@rWY*W*Y $$$|$$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$ @
'Ï5*C('À ) À )N & ¼ + ¼ ¼ ) (À Á ¼ ) / 7
7 3 ¼À G)Á + ¼ # ¼ x('! ¼ #"
e8 SUTWY£Ã¯[y X(ke{eY*m´nW{¦Ã¯kn9f]t ndgf Nnj¦Ã¯kn9fvt]k@m $$|$$$$$$$|$ @
e [ÞX(tvk#cjWoh~Y*f]jlWxm3ïknY5°fvjcjfyb;|$$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$ 28
e!?Du¸9fvY*Wd]jlknf]k hX(kc{Y*m´kn/fvTY 5N ! $$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$ 9
$&%
À )/ )'À )
M@
% À )' À )/'À ) À -(*) À ) ¼ )('Ï ) 3 ')Ï ¼ #
2I
·8 Du¸e@°f|Ãnml*rmlxf]jlknWd $$$$|$$$$$$|$$$$$$$|$ 9
· ·z§·tvk²¸ejX xf]Y$S¤kx¢¬WntvnXhY*f]YCtjlm¥fvY*t5 $$$$|$$$$$$$|$ @
+-, '*) ¼ (À Á ¼ )*'6)5C À -
& ¼ 3 ¼c¼ Á/3 -P À /. À .'0 À )C ) % ¼ ))Ï 7 #
+-./ U!
U/
/jlonrWt]Y 8@³ LrWX(n tvYf]jlW d]Y*YC
f]Ttvknro@T x(knT9f xmlXhk9d]*kn?Y®tvknX
n
SUTWYcjld]rWnmd]bedyfvY*X xW{¦f]TY(ndvd]kc*jlxf]Y5{±Y*bnY*¢¬*kn9f]tvknmXhknf]k@t
d]bedyfvY*X f x«@Yh±d]jo@j¥¨?*x9fYCtv*Y*9fvnonYÏ®Y*¤ f]YCWdkxYCtg¢
*Y*9fvdkn¯fvTY¤Tk@mY*knt]f]Y*¸ºjl"f]TYTcrX n¡itvnj[Þ"fvTjld
dvk@Y@ª©f]TWYjWref$f]k¦nmm3fvTYCd]Yd]bcdgf]YCX d*ª/j7Yn(fvTY t]Y*f]jlWª/jld
mljl«nY*mlbfvk*nt]tvbknrfµ(mknfzkxKjle®kntvX #fvjk@´¯· TcrX ntvYfvj
7jo@rt]Y 8¯k@WYC@fvtvxf]Y5d xi?knrf
108WTkxfvkntvYCYCef]k@tvd ¤j¥fvTjl
{ejqxX(YfvY*tkxxi?knref$@*X
!@uxW{Ef]TWYfvtvnWdgX(jqd]d]jlknEt #fvY
kn fvTY(t]Y*f]jlWjldY5dyfvjX #fvYC{ºiY*fy¤¯YCY*
105 nW{ 106 ijfvd$?Y*t d]YC*knW{´
SUTY tvYfvjjqd$dgf]tvkno@mb¦dgf]tvrW°fvrtvYC{©!zkxf knWmb¦jqdjf knt]¢
o9xj:9*Y5{;jl mq²bnY*t dCª¤j¥fvT ¨W@YEonYCY*tvjq§fybcY5dkxYCmmqdCªziref
nmld]kµ{j¥¶Y*tvY*9f kn¢PY*¸ejldgfjlWd]jl{Y¯fvTYCd]Yml²b@Y*t d*SUTWYCd]Y
#f]Tc¤U²bed©kntvtvYCd]k@W{µf]kjle®kntvX #fvjk@ dyfvt]Y5xX d{eY5xmljWo¤j¥fvT
{j¥¶Y*tvY*9f dgWxf]jqxmUxW{ f]YCXh?knt xmUdv*xmlYCd£kxzf]TYcjld]rWxmWr¸
Wrt]f]TYCt]X(kntvYnª5jl$f]TY*@dgYukntvjX #fvYCdkntX nXhX nmjqxWd´¤j¥fvT
®tvkn9f xm©cjld]jlkn´ªcfvTY$t]Y*f]jlWhk9d]d]YCdvd]YCdU(tv@{ejqxmkntvo@nj95#fvjk@´³
jfvd(*Y*9f]YCtCªK«ck#¤ @d fvTY .¡j t]jlX #fvYCdCªKjld(d]riewyYCffvkº@Y*tvb"{YfvnjmlYC{ Ïx{¡f]TcrWdCªuYCY*tvonb
{Y*X xW{jo!¯t]ke*YCdvdgjloWªed]rW T§ndtvYCn{jo
SUTY*Y*mlmld jf]TWY t]Y*f]jlW±*x"i?Yk@Wdgjq{eYCt]Y5{º@dY*rtvknd*ª{rY(f]k±fvTY*jlt Y*mlYCf]tvjlCxmKtvkn?Y*t]f]jlYCd
nW{§fvTY*jlt k@Y5°f]jlcj¥fyb@Lk#¤Y*@Y*t5ª©nd|kn?k@d]YC{§f]k§k@tgfvjlCxmY*rtvknd*ª©X(k@dgft]Y*f]jlWxmKYCmmqd${ekkxf
¨t]Y$xcb"$#*.G 2%. ªknt U\µmbf]TY*Y*mlmldUjlf]TY$mqndgfml²b@Y*tÏCxmlmY5{o@xWonmljk@WxtUYCmmqd
¨t]Y$x{d]Y*W{fvTY$Y*W*ke{eYC{cjld]rWxm©jle®k@t]X #fvjk@fvkhf]TY$it xjl9jq£f]TY$k@ef]jq*nm©Y*tvnY@
SUTY jW*t]Y5{ejlimYu*knX(mlY¸ejfybzkxcknrWt©Y*ccjtvknX(YC@f®f]t n{ejf]jlknxmlmbtvY®YCt]tvYC{zf]kµnd&gW#fvrtvnmxd]*Y*Y5d(')
tvYCp9rjltvYCdµWxt]f]jqrmqxtµYCtg®k@t]X nWY5d®tvknX fvTY(t]Y*f]jlW SUTYhrci?knrW{YC{p@rx9f]jfyb§kx jle®k@t]X #fvjk@
Tnd|f]kEiY*knX(tvYCdvdgY5{¦fvTt]k@ronT"k@rt$cjld]rWxm¯dgbedgf]Y*X±ª/¤Tjl T"TW@d ¨Wjf]Yje®k@t]X xf]jlkn"*xnjfybn
·zW{©ª{eYCd]jf]Y(f]TWjldjqd$X xjlmlb¦tvk#9jq{eY5{¦icb§f]TWY5N ! x{º*knt]f]jq*xmudgf]tvrWf]rtvYCdCª´dgr TWt]keY5d]d]jlo
*knX(YCdµknrfµfvTknro@T¦fvTY(ijo@onY5dyfdyfvY*jºje®k@t]X xf]jlknº*knX(tvYCdvdgjlkn³Uf]TY(tvYf]jlWW ·zd¨j¥fvY *#¢
njfybº TxYCmK®tvknX fvTYYC9cjlt]k@X(Y*9ffvTYWxf]rt xm¯d]*Y*Y5dªfvTYtvYf]jlW§d]Yf d$f]TWYp9rWx9f]jfybEkn
jle®k@t]X #fvjk@fvk(iY$tvkeY5d]d]YC{i9bf]TY$¤TWknmlY|cjqdgrxm´d]bcdgf]YCX±
Wt]k@X f]TWY k@j9fzknK9jlY*¤ kxKjle®kntvX #fvjk@fvTY*k@t]b@ªef]TWY t]Y*f]jlW d]Yfvdf]TY Wt]keY5d]d]jlo*nWn*j¥fybkn
fvTY¤TknmlYcjqdgrWnmd]bedyfvY*X±"·zdh§¨Wjf]Y±*nWn*j¥fyb¡ TWnYCm ®tvknX x Y*ccjtvknX(YC@f£¤j¥fvT jle¨Wjf]Y
jle®k@t]X #fvjk@*fvTY£#f]rWtvnm/dvY*WYCd°ªf]TYht]Y*f]jlW Y5Y5d]dvxtvjmlbYCtg®k@t]X dz*knX(tvYCdvdgjlkn±knKf]TYhcjld]rWxm
jle®k@t]X #fvjk@nW{©ªe®k@tUf]TY9jqd]rWxm´d]bedyfvY*X fvk iY$Y,+jlY*9fCªefvTjqdzk@X(t]Y5d]d]jlknX£rWdgfiY @{xefvYC{f]k
fvTYY*¸cf]Y*tvWnmY*ccjlt]k@X(Y*9fCSUTY£t]Y*f]jlW*knX(tvYCdvdgY5dj®kntvX(xf]jlkn¦xff]TtvY*Y£mYCnYCmldCjt dyf5ª© mk#¤U¢
ndvdu¨Wmf]YCt]jlohkx´fvTY|9jqd]rWxmjlrefjqd¯Wt]k#cjq{eYC{ icb(fvTYµtvYC*Y*efvknt d*ªcd]jW*YzfvTY*bj9f]YCont #fvY-Ïd]W#fvjlnmmlb
nW{¡fvY*X(?knt xmlmb£xW{ . *7dg#f]jqxmlmlbnª¯@d£"{ejlonjfvnm*xX(YCtv/f]TWYmljlonT9fhWt]knwyYC°fvYC{ kn9f]kºf]TY
in «kxf]TWYY*b@YnSUTY* *knX(YCdhxWkxf]TWY*t£ TxmlmYConY fvTYtvYfvj¦TW@d$f]k{eYCnm¯¤jf]T³(f]TY±²nYCtvnonY
mlrX(jlWxW*Y$kxu(Wxf]rt xmdvYCY$#xtvjY5d{et ndgf]jq*nmmlbnCk@tv{ejlohf]kmke*xf]jlkn´ª{²b9f]jlXhY@ªWY*fvx[Þ±ÏnfCª
d]jlonmlY tvYCYCef]k@tz*n±t]Y5Y*jlnY @d®YC¤ @dknWY Tknf]kn§YCnYCt]bf]Y*§X(jlcref]Y5d*ª?rW{eYCtµdgfvntmjlonT9f5ªx{
@dXrW T±nd
105 TkxfvknWdU?Y*td]YC*knW{rW{eYCtitvjo@T@fd]rmljo@T@f5uSUTYmrWXhjlWnWYt xo@YzfvT9rdU²nt]jlYCd jl ¦Ïn°fvknt£kx
108 xf£mlYCndgf10"2ºYxjlX xmqd£{k¦kxfhY*Y5{ X£rW T jle®kntvX #f]jlkn nik@ref£mlrX(jlWxW*Ynª
iWref$tvxf]TYCtnik@reff]TY k@iewyYCfvdtvY.WY5°fvjof]TWYhmljlonT9fC ·zd$±*knWd]YCp9rYCWY@ª©knrttvYf]jlWtvk#cjl{eY5dµ
mqxtvonY$jlc#xtvjlnWY$¤jf]T¦tvYCd]?YC°fzf]kmlrX(jlWxW*Yn³t]Y*f]jlWxm/knrefvref|TWndµdgjlX(jmqxtµknt {eY*t dkxKX xo@jf]rW{eY
jlnmm?mlrX(jWnWYk@W{ejf]jlknWdC3SUTjldjlc²nt]jqxYjqdXhk9dyfvmb(tvk#cjl{YC{ icbhf]TY|mljo@T@fUtvYCYCef]k@tvd jf]TY
tvYfvjª©xmf]Tk@ronTºn{{ejf]jlknxm3n{nefvxf]jlkn§fvkmlrX(jk9dgjfyb§jqdµnmld]ktvk#cjl{YC{§icbf]TYhY*¸9fmq²bnY*t dkn
fvTYht]Y*f]jlW jlWxmlmb@ª´#f$ fvTjt {¦mlY*@Y*mPª©j®kntvX(xf]jlkn¦jlºf]TYht]Y*f]jlWjqdk@XhWt]Y5d]d]YC{§jlº¤U²bfvTW#f
dgf]tvYCdvd]YCdf]TWY rW{eYCt]mlbcjWo #
$kx3knrWtcjld]rWxm/dyfvjX£rmlxf]jlkn´³ ¤TW#fz¤Y *nmmkniewyY5°fvdC`cfv#fvjldgf]jq*nmmlb
nW{ o@Y*knX(Y*f]tvjlCxmlmb@ªnX(k@dgf¯k@iewyYCfvdtvYC#fvY <O |kn fvTYztvYfvjª@f]TWxfjqd mqxtvonYµxW{ mlke*nmW#xtvjlxf]jlknWd
knef]TY¯mjlonT9fj9f]YCWd]j¥fyb@/SUTWn«ed´fvkf]TWY¯d]Y5j¨ *knY5°fvjcjfyb|knt]Y*f]jlWxm@ml²b@Y*t d*ªCf]TWY ijlono@YCdgf/xX(knrW@f
kn/jle®kntvX #fvjk@tvkeY5d]d]YC{i9bf]TY$tvYfvj£jqdUmlkcC#fvYC{kn±kniewyY5°fYC{onYCdC
`cY5°fvjk@(µtvYCd]Y*9fvd/fvTYxWxf]k@Xhjq*nmct]k@YCtgfvjY5dkxWfvTYtvYf]jlWW`cY5°f]jlkn!{eYf xjlmld3k@rt3X(kc{Y*mljo
®t xX(YC¤¯k@t]«®kntztvYfvjxmY*rtvkndzx{±f]TYCjt|jl@fvY*t nf]jlknWdCµ`cY5°f]jlknºtvYCd]Y*9fvdzknrt|X(ke{eY*m/®kntµf]TY
k@ref]Wrefkno@nonmljk@Wxt/Y*mlmqd´®tvknX f]TWY #<
.#f]Tc¤U²bnª#x{f]TY¤U²bµ¤Y TW²@YujlXhWmYCXhYC9f]YC{
jfC;SUTY±mlrX(jxW*Yjlc#xtvjlnWY@ª YC{onY±{eYfvYC°fvjk@´ªUxW{ k@XhWt]Y5d]d]jk@ X(YC TxjqdgX dCª ¤jlmmn?YCxt
#f]rWtvnmmlbºjl fvTjqd£X(ke{eYCm7¡rWtgfvTY*tvX(kntvYnª3f]TWY®k#@YC#fvYC{¡dgf]tvrW°fvrtvY¤jlmmi?Yf x«nYC jl@fvk@**knr9fC
`eYC°fvjk@±£tvYCd]Y*9fd]jX£rmlxf]jlknWdnW{²nmjq{xf]jlknWdUknf]TWjldX(ke{eYCm7ªe®k@tdgjlo@mY$YCmmqdx{(d]jX£rmlxf]Y5{
tvYfvjª5¤j¥fvT£d]Y*nYCtvnm#cjld]rWxm9dyfvjX£rmlj73· {ejqdvrWdvdgjlkn$k@f]TY¯tvYCd]Y*9fX(ke{eY*m9jldtvk#9jq{eY5{j£`eYC°fvjk@ ª
nW{ ?k@dvd]jimlY{eY*@Y*mlknX(YC@f d/nt]YY¸e?k@d]YC{j `cYCf]jlkn9ªxjlWmlrW{ejloX(ke{eY*mljWoµknWf]TWY 1#<
.
#f]Tc¤U²b kx/f]TY$tvYfvjWW
." a ./ * . ! . +%./*
0*#*# ¼ J'¼9¿
SUTWY|o@k@nm?knfvTjldzdgY5°f]jlknjldfvk {eYCdvtvji?Y|f]TY$tvYfvjxm©X(YC TWnjqdgX @d¨m¥fvY*tvjo(dgf]tvrW°fvrt]Y@ªxW{f]k
Wt]k#cjq{eY x±k#nYCt]cjlY*¤_kx3f]TY£mjl«edi?Yfy¤Y*YC¦xWxf]k@XbnW{f]TY£t]YCmlxf]Y5{®rWW°fvjk@Wxm/iYCTW²cjk@tCU·zd
tvYCd]rm¥f5ª©¤¯Y(tvkn?k@d]Yjl"/jlonrWt]Y dv TY*X #fvjl£cjYC¤knuf]TY(tvYfvjWWª´¤Tjq TE¤jlmmKi?Y(rWd]YC{ºjºf]TY
tvYCdgfkx/f]TY$WnYCtCuSUTWjldd]YCf]jlkn±dgTk#¤dUTWk#¤ jfjldUtvY*mq#fvYC{f]k xWxf]k@Xhjq*nmÏnfvdC
jlonrtvY e³%`e TWY*X #fvjlhcjYC¤kxf]TWY£¨m¥fvY*tvjo±ke**rtvt]jlojlf]TY(tvYfvjWW /²bnYCtvdµkxUY*mlmqd$xtvY£tvY*e¢
tvYCd]Y*9fvYC{ºi9bEik²¸eYCd*knY5°fvYC{ºf]TtvknrWonT"dgbcWnef]jqhj9f]YCtv@°fvjk@Wd*
VR(x, y, t)ª/Yfvn t]YCtvYCd]Y*9ff]TY
?kxfvY*9f]jqxmqd$knfvTY*Y*mlmld$jl¡YC@ T"ml²b@Y*t #f$fvjX(Y
tª3¤jf]T (x, y) i?Y*jlo§fvTYd]W#fvjlnm kcknt {ejlW#fvYCdkn
fvTY*knWd]jl{Y*tvYC{§YCmmPS/¤¯k{ejqdgf]jlW°fdgbcWnef]jq$mq²bnY*t dCªef]TY(\µs x{±f]TY[Þs uª{eY¨Y$fy¤kdgr*Y5dy¢
d]jlnY£¨Wm¥fvY*tvjWo±dgfvnonY5d*
VG(x, y, t) {eY¨YCd|fvTY(XhYCXit xWYh?kxfvY*9f]jqxmqd|kxxmlmKo@nonmljk@Wxt|YCmmqd*([¬f
*kn9fvnjdzfvTY jle®kntvX #f]jlkn"d]Y*9ff]kf]TY iWtvnjicb§f]TY(tvYfvjWWª/*knWd]jldgf]jlokxknY d]j«@Yhf]t xjlº?Y*t
o9xo@mjlknxtUY*mlmP
0*#0 .C2)5'0ne('À )4'*) % À )) ¼ n ¼ Á , ½¼ #
SUTWY$t]Y*f]jlW(kn9f xjlWd¨WnY {j¥¶Y*tvY*9ffybcY5dkx3cjld]rWnm´Y*mlmqd* jlonrtvY !Ï/d]Tk#¤dU dgY5°f]jlknkxK(tvYCxm
X nXhX nmjqx¦tvYfvjnW{§jfvd$x#f]k@X(jlCxmjl9f]YCt]tvYf #fvjk@´£Ã¯Y*mlmldµkx f]TY dvxX(Y fybc?Y®k@t]X ,H°ª
²9jlo$fvTY|¤TknmlYztvYfvjWW ²bnYCtvd xtvYzk@YCf]Y5{nd¯{eYCdvtvjliY5{jljo@rt]Y ! Ïi °ªex{d]rX(X(nt]j:9*Y5{
jljlonrtvY|3~Yf]jlWnm?*Y*mlmldUxtvY
G°ª@f]TWxfYCWke{eY|dgjlonWnmfvTt]k@ronTf]TYCjtY*mlYCf]tvjlCxm?XhYCXit xWY
?kxfvY*9f]jqxmP 2ºYh¤jlmmKk@Wd]jl{eYCtfvTY*X @d 2.M
.2°ª?X(Y5xjlofvTW#f|f]TWY£?kxfvY*9f]jqxm3kx YCmmK#f
fvjX(Y
t jld{Y¨WY5{i9b£rWjlp9rY$crX£iYCt
V(t)
2YºCxNf]TWY* nYCW{ f]TWYºnf]jlcj¥fvjY5d ®kntxmlmf]TWYºYCmmqd¤jf]TWj ml²b@Y*t5_[¬*Y*mlmµ{eYCWdgjfyb jld
{Y*Wd]YY*k@ronTªxf]TWYµnf]jlcj¥fvjY5dKkx´xmlmfvTYz*Y*mlmld j(fvTYmq²bnY*tu{Y¨WYµ dg#f]jqxmlmlb£k@9f]jl9rWknrWd®r°f]jlkn
tvY*Wt]Y5dgYC@fvjWofvTY nf]jl9jfybknf]TWY$ml²b@Y*t#fUf]jlX(Y
tuk@tY¸xX(mlYnª
(x, y)→VB(x, y, t)t]YCtvYCd]Y*9fvd fvTY@°f]jlcj¥fvjY5dkn3iWj?knmqxt|Y*mlmqdz#fzf]jlXhY
t Ïd]Y*YjlonrtvY£ zSUTY tvYfvjW Cx§i?Y£d]Y*YC¦ndzh¨m¥fvY*tvjo dv TYCXhY f]TWxff]t xWdg®kntvX djfvdmljlonT9fµjlref|j9fvk f]t xjlWdkn dgjl«nY5dUf]Tx«edfvk ¨W@Ydgr*Y5d]d]jlnY$mq²bnY*t dCª
Y5n Tml²b@Y*tiYCjWo{eYCdvtvji?YC{icbh?knrmq#fvjk@®rWW°fvjk@´
[Þ9f]YCtv@°fvjk@WdzCx§ke**rtzi?Yfy¤Y*YCEYCmmqd®tvknX {ej¶?YCt]YC9fµmq²bnY*t dCªWxW{Exmqdgki?Yfy¤Y*YC¦YCmmqdzknKf]TY
dvxX(Ymq²bnY*t53Z¯rff]TY$Wxf]rtvYkx/f]TY5dgY$jl9f]Y*t nf]jlknWdUnt]Y${ej¶?YCt]YC9fC³
% & ¼ 'Ï@ )
½
)/
¼
ïTWY*X(jlCxmdgbcWnWd]YCd¯mjl«YCmmqd¯®t]k@X {ej¶?YCt]YC@fUmq²bnY*t dC/·mlm´ TYCXhjq*nm?d]bcWxdgY5d ke**rtjfy¤¯k
ml²b@Y*t d 7/jlonrWt]Y !Ï/)°³fvTY$\µrf]Y*tsumlY¸ej®kntvX /²bnYCt P\µs' ¯xW{(fvTY|[ÞY*tsumlY¸ej®kntvX /²bnYCt
Ï[Þs /SUTY5dgY(fy¤k§mq²bnY*t d|kxd]b9xWd]YCd${eY*¨WY . 2H2 1#<<< (O °ªKnd
tvY*Wt]Y5dgYC@fvYC{£j/jlonrWt]Yzcu`cY5°fvjk@!É|t]Y5dgYC9fvdKk@rtuX(ke{eY*mW®knt TWY*X(jlCxmWd]bcWxdgYjl(f]TYzt]Y*f]jlW
()¼ n*.'Ï@ )¯ ½ ) ¼ 3 )7 À n ))¼ Á4C? 5)x('À )/
SUTWjldh«cj{ kn|d]b9xWd]YCd£mjl« WY*jlonTcik@t]jloY*mlmqd ) 2 ,. H°ªUxmlmk#¤jlodgk@XhYjl@fvtvx¢Pmq²bnYCt
*knX(XrWjlC#fvjk@5 `erW TwyrW°fvjk@Wdnt]Y±tvYCd]Y*9f¤jf]T {ej¶Y*tvY*9fdyfvt]YCoxfvTWd(jl;YCn T kxfvTY±¨WnY
mq²bnYCtvdCªxW{ t]Y5dgrmfjl_¡mlke*nmµd]TWxtvjWo kx$fvTYEjle®kntvX #fvjk@ iY*fy¤¯YCY* *Y*mlmldkx$fvTYºdvxX(Y¦fybc?Yn
`eYC°fvjk@ !W!htvk#cjl{YCdU(dgjlX(mY ntvk²¸ejX #fvjk@®k@tUf]TjqddgTxtvjo(kn/jle®kntvX #f]jlkn
0*#:@
3 '! ¼ $ ½ ¼ À - % ¼ ))Ï
[Þf]TWjldz`eYC°fvjk@´ª¤Yit]jlY.b{eYCdvtvjliY|f]TWY¨WnYmq²bnY*t d¯kxf]TY$tvYfvjWW 2ºY$¤jlmm´*knX(YiWn «f]khf]TYCX
¤TWY*Xhke{eYCmjlo(fvTY$t]Y*f]jlW7`cY5°fvjk@/°
¼ ¼ / À #
~YCYCef]k@tvdUtvYC*Y*jlnY@ªWd]nX(mY nW{±jl@fvY*o@tvxf]Y|f]TYmjlonT9fµnt]tvjcjlo(#ffvTY iW@ «kxf]TWY Y*b@Yn¯SUTWY*b±xtvY
kn©fy¤¯k«9jlW{dC³ # µx{ . Ïiknf]TtvY*tvYCd]Y*9fvYC{(kn(fvknknjo@rt]Y ! ®i °¯Ã¯k@YCd¯xtvYznf]jl²xf]Y5{
xf TjlonT"jmlmlrX(jWxf]jlkn"mlY*nYCmld 7{²b9f]jlX(Y°SUTY*bxtvYhf]TYX(k9dyf rWd]Y®rWm dgk@rt Y(kxUj®kntvX(xf]jlknº®knt
Wt]Y5jqdgYd]TWnYxWnmbed]jldCºSUTYCt]YxtvY f]TWt]YCYfybcY5dhkxzk@YCdCªud]Y*Wd]j¥fvj@Y f]k"{ej¶?YCt]YC9f£¤U²nY*mlY*Woxf]Td
7~YC{´ªMN|t]YCY*xW{ZmrY°³u*knY5dUY*W*kc{Y*knmlknt5jlonrtvY|(d]Tk#¤dUhW²cjWo£icb*knY5d¯jl§Wt]jlX #f]Y
YCbnY#
2
Í ÙPÈ3Ù7Î#ÓvÙÑPÍÈÓ Ò5ÊÞÙPÇÉͰʲÑ/Ó ßÉÑPͯÈ5ÇÉÑÏÙ/ØxÈÞÙ©ÈyÈyÊŲÇnÈyÆ7ÈyÊÙyÈyßÉß@ÙÛCÒxÈyÑ! ²ÕͰƩȲÓ"Ò²ßÉÈØnÈÞÙ©ÈyÈyÊ|Ù7Î²È Ó"Ó"yÆ7ÇÉʲÈ
gÈyßÉß@Ä 11
Ó Ê²Å#yͰʲÈKزÇÉÒxÍ°ßÔÓ Æ$yÈyßÉßÉÑ&%' R '()Ë
*+
Î5Í°ÆÏÙ,´ÓyÝÈyßÉÈgÊ ÙPÎ- cÍ°Æ/.0ß1²È.2yͰʲÈyÑ3 eÓ ÆÏÈ/4PÎ$ÑPÒ#Ó ÆÏÑPÈyÆ3Ù7Î#Ó ÊÙ7βÈUÍ Ù7βÈyÆ3٩ͲË
Ú
βÈÞÛÓ Æ7ÈUÓ"yÙ#Ó ßÉßÛÙ7βÈUÍ°ßÉÅ5ÈgÑÏÙ
.gÍ°ßÉÍ°Æ5yͰʲÈyÑ!.ÉË56Í°Ñ7ÙÓ"7Ó ßÉÑWÒxÍ°Ñ7ÑPÈyÑPÑ©ÓKØ#Ó Ñ7Ç1زÇ89¬Î²ÆÏÍÓvÙPÇ1´Ý5ÇÉÑ7ÇÉÍ°Ê- :ÇÙPÎÓKŲÍÇÉÊ#Ó ÊÙ.ÇÉŲÅ5ßÉÈ;´ÓgÝÈyßÉÈyÊ Ù7Î-.5ÙÛCÒxÈ
Í Õ5yÍ°Ê²È @Ó Ê²Å$ÓUÑ7Ò#Ó ÆÏÑPÈyÆ.زß15È:.gÍ°Ê5È: nÑ7ÒnÈ<yÇÔÓ ßÉÇ1=yÈyÅÇÉÊ>yÍ°ßÉÍ°ÆÇÉÊCÕlÍ°Æ?ÓvÙPÇÉÍ°Ê@Ë$@ʲßÛµÇÉÊ|Ò²ÆÏÇ1ÓvÙ7ÈgÑ/Î#Ó Ñ/Ù7βÈ7.ÇÉŲŲßÉÈgÍ°Ê5È:.
Ï/¯ÂKY*t]f]jq*xm´d]YCf]jlkn±kx3ht]Y*f]jlW ®i /jlnYtvYfvjWnm´YCmmfybc?YCd
jlonrtvY !W³ 7$KÂKYCtgfvjlCxmdgY5°fvjk@ kx$tvYfvjWWKSUTY*tvYzxtvY¨W@YzYCmmfybcY5d*ªc¤Tk9dgYz9rmlY*jnt]Yzmke*xf]Y5{
jl¡fvTt]YCYmq²bnY*t dCªnW{f]TWxf£X x«@Y f]TWY*jlth*knY5°fvjk@Wd jl¡fy¤k¦mlY¸ej¥®k@t]X mq²bnY*t dC±Wt]k@X
!9P ®i
` TY*X #fvjl|cjlY*¤ kn/fvTY¨W@Y*Y*mlm©fybcY5dxW{f]TWY*jltzk@YCf]jlknWdCKk@rW{±#f
¬
jlonrtvY|W³¡sK²cjohkxtvjlX(xf]Yµ®k#nY5 icbk@YCdC !kxfvjl*YTk#¤ d]Wxt dgY|dgTWknt]f¤U²nYCmYCoxfvT ÉZ¯mlrY
*knY5dxtvYn3tvknX
nPªetvY*Wt]ke{erW*YC{®t]k@X . #
\µf]TY$*kn9f]t xtvbnª9t]ke{dY*¸cjqdgfjlhd]jo@mY|nYCtvd]jlkn´³/f]TYCbknWmbd]Y*Y &gjiml@ «xW{¤Tjf]Y.' K~ke{d
nt]YU@Y*tvbdgYCWd]j¥fvj@Y¯fvk$mrWXhjlk9dgjfybnª9xW{£f]TWY*jltut]Y5dg?kndgYdv#fvrtvxf]Y5dxfuTjlonT(jmlmlrX(jWxf]jlkn 7{²b9f]jlXhY°
SUTWY*bxtvYzX£rW TX(k@t]Y|crX(Y*tvknrWd f]TWn*knY5d*ª9Y¸*Y*ef#ff]TWY|@Y*tvb Y*9fvY*tkxfvTY|Y*bnYfvTY|®k#nY5$°
SUTWYhtvke{ºd]jlonWnmKjldX(k@dgf rWd]Y®rm¯#f$jlonT9fCª/knt®knt$X(k#@Y*X(Y*9f${eYfvYC°fvjk@´ suTcbcmk@onYCYfvjlCxmlmb@ª´t]ke{d
d]Y*YCX f]k T²nYx?YCnt]Y5{mq#fvY*tUjfvTY$Y*@knmlref]jlkn´
SUTY£j9fvY*ont #fvjk@±kxKmjlonT9fzicbt]Y5YCef]k@tvdjqd«ck#¤¦@d G. . G
#6* 7dgYCYh`cY5°fvjk@§W:8n:81°
SUTWY knrefvrefµd]jlonWnm´kx3f]TWY t]Y5YCef]k@tvdUjqdfvTY*±fvtvnWdgX(jfgfvYC{f]kTkntvj9Ckn9fvnm´YCmmqdx{±ij?knmqxtµY*mlmqd*ª
jlf]TY£\µs'u
. À .'0 À )5 )¯ ¼ ))Ï
Lzkntvj9Ckn9fvnmYCmmqdKtvY*mq²b f]TWYzdgjlonxme®tvknXf]TYtvYC*Y*efvknt d fvTtvknro@T( TWY*X(jlCxmWd]bcWxdgY5d3j(fvTY\µs °ª
nW{$xtvYuxmqd]kTjo@Tmlb|*knrmlYC{µfvkf]TYCjt/Y*jlonTci?kntvjWoTkntvj9Ckn9fvnmxYCmmqd®f]Ttvknro@T$Y*mlYCf]tvjlCxmnd]bcWxWd]YCd°
SUTWjld¯knrWmjlo$X x«@YCd3fvTY*X d]Y*Wd]j¥fvj@Yf]k£Xhk@t]Yd]Wxf]jqxmlmb
<#ªnk@tumlk#¤U¢PW@d]d]YC{´ªxnYCtvd]jk@(kxf]TY
jlX xo@YfvTWxf]TWY t]Y5Y*f]knt dÏd]Y*Y`cY5°f]jlknWÉ rt]f]TYCt]X(k@t]Y@ªdgjlW*Y£fvTY*jlt X(Y*X£it xY 2
fvTY|jWrefU®t]k@X f]TY|t]Y5YCef]k@tvdCªnfvTY*bnmld]kE 2. mlk#¤U¢PW@d]duf]TY$d]jo@Wxm®tvknX t]Y5YCef]k@tvdCSUTWY*b
X n«nYµ®Y*YC{iWn «*knWYC°fvjk@Wdf]k tvYC*Y*efvknt d*ªenW{nmld]kh®Y*Y5{c¢7®k@t]¤Uxt {*knY5°fvjk@Wdf]k(ijlk@mlntYCmmqd*
+ '! À )7e ¼ ))7
`cf]jlmm´xf¯fvTYmYCnY*mkn´f]TY\µs ªcij?knmqxt*Y*mlmldUxtvYknWYCf]YC{¤j¥fvTi?kxfvTtvYC*Y*efvknt d nW{TWkntvj9Ckn9fvnm
*Y*mlmldC¯Zrefzf]TYd]jlon±kxf]TY5dgY fy¤¯k(fybc?YCdkn3*knY*¸ejk@WdxtvY$xml¤²bed{ej¶Y*tvY*9fC³¯j¥u(ijlk@mlntzYCmmjld
{Y*?knmqxtvj9CYC{i9bf]TWYdgjlonxm´kntvYC*Y*efvknt d*ªjfzjqdTcbcYCt]?knmqxtvj9CYC{icbfvTYd]jo@Wxm´knTWkntvj9Ckn9fvnm´Y*mlmqd*ª
nW{¦cjqY*¢P@Y*t d]WLY*Ynª/ijl?knmqxt$YCmmKjqdxml¤²bed|dgYCWdgjf]jlnY£f]k±±{ej¶?YCt]YCWYhiY*fy¤¯YCY*ºf]TY d]jo@Wxm
®tvknX t]Y5Y*f]knt dUxW{jfvdimlrtvt]Y5{@Y*t dgjlknicb f]TY$TWkntvj9Ckn9fvnm*Y*mlmldC
`cr T Y¸*j¥f #f]k@t]b#jTWjijf]k@t]b j9fvY*t n°fvjk@Wdnt]YEnY*tvb;mqndvdgjq*nmzjl YCrtvnmµWYfy¤kntv«cdxW{ xtvY
«ck#¤ @d . %# %H ° SUTYdgbcWnef]jq§fvt]jqn{;X n«nYCdijlk@mlnt*Y*mlmlddg#f]jqxm|xW{ f]YCXh?knt xm
: < ¨m¥fvY*t d*³f]TWY*b±iYCTW²nYmjl«nY£YC{eo@Y{eYfvYCf]knt dCz·**knt {ejWo f]k fvTYht]Y5dg?YCf]jlnYd]jo@WdknKf]TY
*knWY¸ejk@Wd®t]k@Xt]Y5YCef]k@tvdxW{£Tk@t]j:9*k@@f xmcYCmmqd*ªxf]TYCt]YU¤jlmmei?Yz\!¢ÞY*9fvY*tKYCmmqd3xW{ \|3¢ÞYC9f]Y*t
*Y*mlmldP`cYCf]jlkn±W!
Zjlk@mlntU*Y*mlmldUnt]Y|xmqdgk£f]TYjlrefUfvkfvTY$dgY5kn{ ¨Wmf]YCt]jlo(dyf xonY|kxf]TYtvYf]jlWWª@fvTY[Þs uSUTWY*b
?k@dvd]YCdvd xY*mlkno9#fvYC{dgf]tvrW°fvrtvYz¤jf]Tfy¤k£{Y*W{etvjf]jqfvt]YCYCd Ïjo@rtvY ! ®i °ªcf]T#fUo@²nYf]TYCX f]TYCjt
xX(Ykx ijl?knmqxt
n '6)
¼ ¼ ))Ï
`eb9xefvjl§Y*¸ TWxo@YCd(jlNf]TYE[Þs xtvY§tvY*mq#f]jlnYCmb dgjlX(jmqxt fvk¡f]TWk@d]Y§jNfvTY"\µs ªuirefmY5d]d¤¯YCmm
rWW{eY*t dgf]kcke{©£[Þ{eY*Y5{©ª/nX(@tvjWYh*Y*mlmldCª©f]T#f mq²b±f]TYdvxX(Y(jl@fvY*t dyfvj¥fvjlnmKt]k@mY(ndTWkntvj9Ckn9fvnm*Y*mlmld
jlf]TY£\µs ªWxtvY£@Y*tvb ..<£mqndvdUkx3Y*mlmqd*u·zX(@tvjWY|*Y*mlmldUTW²@Y${ej¥¶Y*tvY*9fd]j9CYCdCªeTcbcd]jlknmlknonb
nW{h®rWf]jlknWduf]TWxf¯xtvYknf¯xmlm¤Y*mlmWrW{Y*t dyfvk9ke{© 2Yz{ek knf Y¸emljqjf]mlb£X(ke{eY*mWf]TYCX±ª@irf¯tvY*?knt]f
d]knX(Ykx/f]TYCjtµdgrWk9dgY5{®r°f]jlkndj¦`cY5°fvjk@c
ŲÇÝ5ÇÉÅ5ÈgÅzÇÉÊÙ©ÍÈ #Ó ßÉßÛ 8Ò²ÆÏÈyÑPÈyÊÙ/ÝÈyÆÏÑPÇÉͰʲÑ3 5Ù7βÈ7.
P
ÈyÅ-.²Ó ʲŵÙ7βÈ/.ÆÏÈgÈyÊ-.gÍ°Ê5È: 5ÙPÎ#ÓvÙ Ó°ÈÙ7βÈβͰßÉÈ,yͰʲÈKÒ#ÓvÙ7Î ©ÓgÛ
¬Î²ÆÏÍÓvÙPÇ1 ÇÙ7ÎzÙ7βÆÏÈgÈ&¬Î#Ó Ê5ʲÈyßÉÑ]Ë
+
ÈyÈ/% )Ë
2)5C )*'À )e ¼ ))Ï
NnonmljlknWntU*Y*mlmldUtvYC*Y*jlnYdgjlonxm®tvknX iWj?knmqxtx{nX ntvjlY|*Y*mlmldCuSUTYCbxtvY|f]TY$k@ref]Wrefkxf]TY
tvYfvjª´x{¦fvTY*bEnmm¨WtvY (f]kf]TWY itvnj£SUTYCb¦xtvYfvTY(knmlbEd]j«cjlo±Y*mlmqdµkn fvTY(t]Y*f]jlWª
nmk@oh¤j¥fvT±d]knX(YxX n*t]jlY$YCmmqdC3SUTWY*jltdgjl«nYo@Y*YCtvxf]jlkntvkeY5d]dUjqdUX(kc{Y*mlYC{j¦`cY5°f]jlknWW:8x
0*#I , '*) ¼ e.'® ½NÀ - & ¼ $ ¿À 3 ')® ¼ .'6)5C©5GC ¼
SUTWYµfy¤k(mlY¸ej¥®k@t]X ml²b@Y*t d ?Y*t]®kntvX xmlX(k@dgfjW{Y*?Y*W{eYC9f¨Wm¥fvY*tvjWo(dgfvnonY5d 7jo@rt]Y $°u·tvY|f]TY5dgY
¨m¥fvY*tvjo dgfvnonY5d(mjlYCnt<; jPY@_{ekcYCd f]TY¦k@ref]Wrefkx$"o@nonmljlknWnt(*Y*mlmz{eYCYCW{NmjlY5xtvmb k@Nf]TY
jlW*knX(jWo mjlonT9f ;SUTWYµxdg¤Y*tujqduWk$®knt fy¤¯k$tvYC@dgk@Wd*jt dyf¯t]Y5nd]kn(jlduf]TWxf¯mljo@T9f t]Y5YCef]k@tvdu{k kxf
tvYC@°fmjlYCnt]mlb#fxmlmf]k£f]TWY|jlW*knX(jWo£mljo@T9fjl9f]Y*dgjfybnªeknf]TYCt]¤jqdgYµknrtUtvYfvjW£¤knrmq{i?Y
105f]jlX(YCd
X(k@t]Yhn°fvj@Y£jlit]jlonT9f${²bcmjlonT9fµf]TWnºjlºtvkcknX mljo@T9f7dgYCY(`cY5°fvjk@º81h`cY5k@W{¦tvYC@dgk@¦jld|fvTW#f
tvYfvjxm´YCmmqdxtvYmjl«@YC{f]Ttvknro@Td]bcWxdgY5d*ª9f]T#f?Y*t]®kntvX kn±mljWYCxtUk@YCtvxf]jlknWdC
Lzk#¤¯YCnY*t5ªW(mljWYCxtµxtvk²¸ejX xf]jlknTWndzTcbcd]jlknmlknonjq*nm²nmjq{xf]jlkn±¤TY*¦f]TY o@Y*YCtvnm©mjlonT9fzjle¢
fvY*Wd]jfybjqdµxfµ(¨¸eY5{§mYCnYCm fvkjlWd]rt]Y£dgk@XhYmjlYCnt]jfybjl§fvTY£*kncnYCtvd]jk@®tvknX-mljo@T@f|j9fvY*Wd]j¥fybf]k
tvYC*Y*efvknt(nf]jl9jfyb°ª nW{¡®k@thºWntgfvjl*rmlnt£#f]Tc¤U²bºknµo9xo@mjlknWntYCmmqdC `cYCf]jlkn;eɧtvYCd]Y*9fvd
fvTY(fy¤kX nj, .!! knjle®k@t]X #fvjk@ k#¤jo±k@ref kxf]TY tvYfvj³$knWYhkn¯fvTY*X fvTYsKxtvnkn¢
*Y*mlmrWmlnt|#f]Tc¤U²bjqd$ontvk@dvd]mb±mljY5xt5ª´¤TYCt]Y5ndµf]TY knf]TYCt fvTY¹¦xo@keYCmmlrmqxt|W#fvT9¤U²bµjldknfC
Zref¤T#f]YCnYCtUf]TY #f]Tc¤U²bk@Wd]jl{eYCt]Y5{©ªeX(k@dgft]Y*f]jlWxmXhke{eYCmldrWdgY$mljlYCnt¨Wmf]Y*t dxfzdgk@XhY$?knjl9fCª
i?YCCxrWd]Yµf]TYCbxtvY|XrW TiY*fgfvY*trW{Y*t dyfvk9ke{©ªnW{YCnd]jlY*tf]k(jlXhWmYCXhYC9fCK[Þ§`cYCf]jlkn !ªe¤Y{Y¨WY
h®t xX(YC¤¯k@t]« fvkX(ke{eY*mY*rWt]k@WdUf]T#fµnmmlk#¤dUf]TWY t]Y*f]jlWhf]k¤¯k@t]«mjlYCnt]mlbjl¦*Y*t]fvxjl±tvnonY$kn
xt xX(YfvY*t d*
SUTY¯mjlY5xt/ntvk²¸ejX #fvjk@z®k@to9xo@mjlknWnt©TWndmk@oi?Y*YC tvkn?k@d]YC{
M8 ¬ª#jWd]jlt]Y5{icbµtvY*cjlknrWd
dgf]r{eb§knºo@xWonmljk@Wxtµt]Y5Y*f]jlnY ¨Y*mq{d
H!P£SUTY1 #< Ï~ µkxufvTY(Y*mlmKjqd|{Y¨WY5{¦icb
fvTYxtvYCknfvTY cjld]rWnmK¨WY*mq{"¤TYCt]Y ±mljo@T@fdgf]jlXrWmlxf]jlkn"TWndx"jWrY*Yk@ºfvTY ¨Wtvjlo±kxUf]TY
*Y*mlm7ª¤TY*±fvTY tvYCdgfkx3f]TWY cjld]rWxm¨WY*mq{±jqdkxf|dyfvjX£rmlxf]Y5{ ®ont ²b ¨WYCml{ @UjlonrtvY££onjlnY5dx±jq{eYC
knfvTY dgj:9*Y5dUkxf]TY$tvYC*Y*efvj@Yz¨Y*mq{djlfvTY$tvYf]jlWW
N|jlnYCE*Y*mlm*Y*9f]YCt]Y5{±j
x0
kn§fvTYtvYfvjWWª?nW{§¤jf]Tºt]Y5Y*f]jlnY$¨WYCml{E~ªmjlY5xtµntvk²¸c¢
jlX #fvjk@ºkn¯jfvd$nf]jlcj¥fyb¦*knWd]jldgfvd|jl¨WW{ejlof]TY(«@Y*tvY*m
K ®knt¤Tjq TEfvTY(®knmlmlk#¤joYCp9rWxf]jlknºjld i?YCdgfnYCt]j¨WY5{©³
·
(x0) = Z
~
(x0)
I(x0+x)K(x) dx,
¤TWY*tvY
I jqdµf]TY(mlrX(jk9dgjfyb§tvkx¨WmlYhkx fvTY(jX nonYnª´nW{E·=jqdX(Y5nd]rt]Y£kxUn°fvjcjfyb¦xWt]k@t]jq#fvY fvk±f]TY(fybc?YkxYCmm ®jfvd$X(Y*X£it xY(?kxf]YC9f]jqxmujj¥fjqd k@e¢¬d]jl«cjo§*Y*mlm7ªknt$jfvd$jlWdgfvn@f xYCknrWd
¨t]jlox¢¬t #f]Yj¥zjf jld(ºdgjl«cjWo*Y*mlm Z¯b"Y*¸9fvY*9fCª
K jqdhkxf]YC {eY5d]*t]jli?YC{ @d fvTY . #< 6. :±kx3f]TWY£YCmmPz·µdtvY*X xtv«nY5{icb
28 »
K *x§i?Y£*kntvt]Y5°fvmbxtvk²¸ejX xf]YC{icb± # ) % G 6>\ N >µY*?Y*{ejWok@§f]TY£onmlkniWnm/d]jo@¦kx
Kª?f]TYhY*mlmjld|*nmmlYC{¦n\!¢ÞYC9f]Y*t|YCmm 2
Í ÙPÈÙ7Î#ÓvÙÙPÎ5È "!|Í ÕnÓ´Ý5ÇÉÑ#Ó ßyÈyßÉß5ÇÉÑWÓ Í°Æ7ÅÙ7Î#ÓvÙ yÍ°Ê*ÝÈÞÛCÑÝ Ó Æ7ÇÉÍ²Ñ ÈgÓ Ê²ÇÉÊ°ÑgË
Ú
βÈ$#&%#')(*+-,.,0/1(.+-*
Æ7È<yÈyÒ5ÙPÇÝÈ32#ÈyßÉÅŲÈyÑyÆÏÇÉØnÈyÑuÙPÎ5ÈÝ5ÇÉÑ#Ó ß?ÆÏÈ<°ÇÉÍ°Ê£Ù7Î#ÓvÙ Î#Ó Ñ54%6879#6:/"+-*?ÇÉÊ; ²ÈyÊyÈÍ°Ê ÙPÎ5È<2#Æ7ÇÉÊ|Í Õ©Ù7βÈ/yÈyßÉß9 eÓ ßÙ7βͰΠÓ
ßÉÇ1°Î*Ù¯Ñ7Ù7Ç14²ßÔÓvÙ7ÇÉÍ°ÊhÇÉÊ£ÙPβÇÉѯÆ7È<°ÇÉÍ°Ê Å²Í*ÈyÑUÊ²Í Ù4ÍCŲÇÕ¥Û$Ù7βÈ2²Æ7ÇÉÊ ÇÕ´Ù7βȵÆÏÈyÑ7ÙÍ Õ/Ù7βÈzÑyÈyʲȵÇÉѯÓ#°Æ7ÓgÛ=2#ÈyßÉÅ9Ë
1
ÙÇÉÑUÓ
ÑPÈ<yͰʲÅ#Ó Æ®ÛÇÉÊ; 5ÈgÊgÈ #ÆÏÈ 5ÇÉÆ7ÇÉÊÑÏÙPÇ1²ßÔÓvÙ7ÇÉͰʵͰÊzÙPβÈ,yßÔÓ Ñ7ÑPÇ1gÓ ßcÆÏÈ3yÈyÒ5Ù7ÇÝÈ52#ÈyßÉÅ9Ë
Ϥj¥fvTE\| dgrtvtvknrW{ °ªckntx¦\|3/¢¬*Y*9f]YCtU*Y*mlm®¤jf]T¦\! dgrWt]tvknr{ °3[Þ¦`cYCf]jlkn£¤Y¤jmlm©¨W{
fvTjqddyfvt]r°f]rWt]Ykx/f]TY$tvYC*Y*efvj@Y|¨WY*mq{f]k x?YCntnYCt]b Wxf]rt xmlmlb#fUf]TWY$mYCnY*m©kn/fvTY£\µs
·µdh¤¯YTW²nYwyrWdgf(dvxjq{©ªuk@mb Ek@tgfvjk@ knzo@nonmljk@WxthYCmmqdhTW²nYnWd]¤¯YCtvd£¤¯YCmmntvk²¸cjlX #fvYC{
icbmljlYCntdgrX(X #fvjk@´3[ÞW{eYCYC{©ªW{j¥¶Y*tvY*W*YCdUjl§xWxf]knX£bxW{Tcbedgjlknmlkno@b {eY¨WWYfy¤¯k(X xjlfybc?YCd
knzo@nonmljlknWntYCmmqd
8²P SUTYCd]Yfy¤k¦fybc?YCd(xtvY@°fvrWxmlmb"fvTYknrefvref kxfy¤kº{j¥¶Y*tvY*9f(t]Y*f]jlWxm
3e
& ¿ ½ ªf]T#f|{kkxf|jX(mlbf]TYhd]nX(YYCmmqd*zsuTcbcd]jlknmlknonjq*nmmlbnªf]TjqdzX(Y5xWdf]TWxfzf]TWYiW@dgjq²¢
mq²bnYCtvd3ntv Tjf]Y5°fvrt]YtvYCd]Y*9f]Y5{(xi?k#nYjldKxt xmlmYCmj:9*Y5{jl(Xrmf]jlmlYnYCtvd]jk@WdCª#Tcbcd]jq*xmlmlb jX£itvjlC#f]Y5{
iWref|¤jf]TºmjfgfvmY(jl9f]Y*t nf]jlknWdz®tvknX knY£W#fvTc¤²bf]kxknf]TYCtn2ºYht]Y*®Y*tµf]k !28xª´x3®k@t|X(kntvY
Wt]Y5jqdgYcjYC¤$
WrW°fvjk@Wxmlmlbnªek@t]tvYCd]k@W{eYCWYY*¸ejldgfvd¯iY*fy¤¯YCY* fvTYµfy¤¯k tvYfvjxm?W#fvT9¤U²bed nW{(f]TWYzfy¤k Wxf]Te¢
¤U²bedhkxµjle®k@t]X #fvjk@ jl f]TY§iWtvnj´³5. W#fvTc¤²b nW{ 6* Wxf]Tc¤²b@N[Þ fvTY§it xjl´ª¯
@Y*9f]t xmt]k@ref]Y kntvX$ jqd¯{eY5{ejq*#fvYC{(fvktvYC*jld]Y*mlb dyfvrW{ebcjlo fvTY|d]TWnY5dukx/kniewyY5°fvd Ï@Y|t]Y5kno@j¢
fvjk@´ª9f]Y*¸9fvrtvYµtvYC*knonWj¥fvjk@´ª@Y*fvnªe¤TjmlY£{ek@tvdvxm?tvknrefvY ¹§k#@Y*X(Y*9f°ªcjlcnknmlcjWo£{ej¶?YCt]YC9fUnt]Y5ndCª
jqd d]?YCjqxmlj:9*YC{(jlX(k#nYCX(Y*9f¯xxmlbcd]jqd ®X(k#nYCX(Y*9fvdKkn´kniewyY5°f d*ª9dgYCm¥¢¬X(kxf]jlkn kn©f]TYµkniWd]Y*tvnYCtCª#Y*fvn
·zm¥fvTknrWonT f]TYCt]Y§jqd kfvt]jlcjlnmzk@t]tvYCd]k@W{eYCWY@ªuf]TWY§t]Y*f]jlWxmsKnt]@kc*Y*mlmrWmlnt£Wxf]Tc¤U²b W#fvrt xmlmb
Wt]k#cjq{eYCdhonkcke{jlrefUf]khfvTYitvnj&dUk@t]X W#fvT9¤U²bnªcx{fvTYt]Y*f]jlWxm´¹¦nonke*Y*mlmrmqxtWxf]Tc¤²b
Wt]k#cjq{eYCd W#fvrtvnmmlb( onkcke{(jlref®knt¯f]TYµit xjld¹§knf]jlknWxf]Tc¤U²bnªx®k@t¯tvYC@dgk@Wd3fvTW#f¤¯YµY¸emqxjl
Wk#¤$
+µe À ¼ )))Ï & ¿ ½+
SUTWYsKxtvnkeYCmmlrmqxtµW#fvT9¤U²b±kndgjqdyf dzknuo@nonmljk@Wxt|YCmmqdz¤jf]TdgX nmmt]Y5YCef]jlnY¨WY*mq{dxW{¦YCtg¢
d]jqdyfvY*9f tvYCnf]jlknhf]kj9f]YCWd]j¥fyb( TWxWonYCdCªn¤TWk@d]YonY*WY*tvjlxX(Yzn*t]k9d]dKd]?YCjlYCd jld
β ¼ ))Ï SUTWY*b(xtvY
«ck#¤ @d *O *Y*mlmlduj(fvTYztvjlX(xf]YtvYfvjWWª@nW{ nd%YCmmqdujl(f]TWYz*xf t]Y*f]jlW3·zd¯*nhi?Yzd]Y*YC
jl¡jo@rt]Y7· ª´f]TWY*bºnt]Yh¤Y*mlmuX(kc{Y*mlYC{ºi9bmjlYCnt$t]Y5YCef]jlnY£¨WY*mq{©SUTWY*b¦TW²@Y d]jlonj¨*n9f
H= . ®¤jf]TWknref(cjld]rWxmdgf]jlXrmq#fvjk@ °ª3fvTW#f xmlmlk#¤d fvTY*X fvk*kc{Yd]jo@Wxmqdi?kxfvT icb
jlW*t]Y5nd]Yµk@t{eYC*t]Y5nd]Yµknf]TWY*jlt¨WtvjoKSUTY*bY*¸ejldgfj±i?kxfvT¦\! nW{¦\| nY*t d]jk@Wd*
SUTYCt]YµxtvY{ej¥¶Y*tvY*YCduj
β *Y*mlmld¯nCknt {ejlo|f]k$fvTYzd]Y5jlYCd¯kndgjq{eY*tvYC{´sutvjX xf]Yz¹§jq{eo@Yf¯*Y*mlmld T²nYd]X(nmmlY*tt]Y5Y*f]jlnY(¨WYCml{d f]TWn *xf%YCmmqdCªfvTW#f£nmmlk#¤=nY*tvbº@**rtvxf]Yd]W#fvjlnmutvYCd]knmlref]jlkn´
·zmld]kWªcX(k@dgf*#fïY*mlmldUd]Y*Yzjliml@ « xW{¤Tj¥fvYnªc¤TYCt]Y5ndxmlm¹¦jl{eo@YfYCmmqdUxtvYµk@mk@t k@k@Y*9f d*³
fvTY*jlt tvYC*Y*efvj@Y¨WYCml{dgf]tvrWf]rtvYzk@Wd]jldgfvdKkn YC9f]t xmWY*¸jfv#fvjk@9*k@Yzd]Y*Wd]j¥fvj@YUf]k£knYz*knmlknt ÏYnoW
~YC{ ªxW{?Y*tvjlTY*t xmjlTjlijf]jlkn 9*k@Y|d]Y*dgjf]jlnY|f]k(xWkxf]TWY*t®Y@o N|t]YCY* 3SUTWY*tvY|nt]Y|t]k@ronTWmb
fy¤k {ej¶?YCt]YC@fz*knmlkntk@k9dgjf]jlkn§d]jo@WxmqdUjlWt]jlX #f]Y$tvYfvjndC³u~YC{ HN|t]YCY*§x{uYCmmlk#¤ #ZmlrYn !zkx¢
fvjl*Y fvTW#f3fvTjld3Wt]k@YCtgfybtvYCp9rjlt]Y5d´fvTW#fu¹§jq{eonY*f3*Y*mlmld/f x«nY¯f]TWY*jltjlrfuX(njWmb®tvknX*knY5d*/jlWnmmlbnª
¹¦jl{eo@YfYCmmqdnt]Y|XrW T±X(kntvY|9rWXhYCt]k@rWdUjlWt]jlX #f]YtvYfvjW£fvTWxïY*mlmldzxtvYµjl§*#ftvYfvj
2;TWxf]YCnY*tfvTYd]Y5jlYCd$k@Wd]jl{eYCt]Y5{©ªd]W#fvjlnmKtvYCjqd]jk@nW{"knmlknt$d]Y*Wd]jf]jl9jfyb¦X x«@Y
β *Y*mlmld$
o@kckc{ jlref fvkºfvTY kntvX$KW#fvTc¤²b¡knzf]TWY§itvnjN·zW{ j{eY*Y5{©ªf]TYCjt ?Y*t dgjqdgf]Y*9fxdg¤Y*thf]k
jlmlmrX(jlW#fvjk@ TWxWonYCd3tvYCp9rjltvYCd3fvTYzdvY*WYkxfKfvk X(k#nYUfvk9k ÏndgfC³´fvTYCd]Yz*Y*mlmld¯xtvYXhk9dyfvmbh{eYCd]jlonY5{
Ú
βÇÉÑ/ÇÉÑ/βÍ3©ÈÞÝÈyÆKÓUÝÈgÆ®ÛѬβÈ<ÓvÙ7Ç1 ÝCÇÉÈ Ë
1
ÊÙPÈyÆ7Ó"ÞÙPÇÉͰʲÑuÈCÇÉÑ7Ù/ØnÈÞÙ©ÈyÈyÊ Ó Ê*Û yÈyßÉßcÙÛ5ÒxÈyÑ! @Ó ÑKÓ/°ßÔÓ ÊyȯÓvÙ©ÈyØ
ÑPÇÙ7È/%'() yßÉÈgÓ Æ7ßÛzŲÈ<ͰʲÑÏÙPÆ7ÓvÙPÈyÑgË
®k@t ¨W¸exf]jlok@iewyYCfvdCª@¤TWjl Txmqdgk Y*¸emlnjdufvTY*jltUT9rWonYzcrX£iYCt¯jlWt]jlX #f]Y|xW{T9rWX(nWdCªcnjlX(nmld
jlcnk@m@YC{jl±tvYCjqd]YµcjqdgrWnmfv@dg«edC
β¢¬*Y*mlmldnt]Yµf]TWY$o@xWonmljk@WxtUYCmmqdX(ke{eY*mlYC{jfvTjldt]YCk@tgf5
jlonrtvYh³=S/tvjlnm¥¢Þ²nYCtvnonYC{¨WtvjWot #f]Y5dzkn¯*#f\|3/¢¬*Y*9f]YCt YCmmPª´xW{Ekx¯n"\|3/¢¬*Y*9f]YCt
*Y*mlm7ªjlEtvYCd]k@Wd]Y f]kf]TWY£jl9f]tvkc{rW°fvjk@ExW{Et]YCX(k#²nmkn¯dgfvxf]jq jlX(nonY@ª{jld]mq²b9jlod]jcrWd]knjq{xm
o@tvxf]jlo¤jf]T"{ej¶?YCt]YC9f$d]Wxf]jqxmkx¶©dgY*fvd ®tvjlonT9f [¬ fvTY Y*mlmu*nEjlW{eYCYC{ºiY(X(ke{eY*mlYC{Ei9bºmljWYCxt
«@Y*tvY*mPªxfvTY*(fvTY*tvY¤jlmmiY|x(kx¶©d]Yf kn?fvTYzo@tvxf]jlo|®knt¯¤Tjl T jfvd¯xWd]¤Y*tKjqdKf]TWYµdvxX(Ynd ¤j¥fvTknref
ncbdgf]jlXrmlrWdCªW¤TYCfvTY ?k@d]j¥fvj@Y xW{±WY*o@xf]jlnYWntgf dkxKjfvdd]jo@Wxm/knrW@fvY*tviWxmqxYYC@ Tknf]TYCtC
Y*mlmqdnYCt]j®bfvTjqdtvkn?Y*t]fybnª¤TWY*tvYCnd=Y*mlmqdz{ek@f5ªWX(YCnjlo f]T#ffvTY*tvY$jldµdgk@X(Y dgWxf]jqxm´Wkne¢
mljlYCnt]jfyb±jEf]TYCjttvkeYCdvd]jo !kxfvYhnmld]kfvTW#f Y*mlmqd|nt]Y£X(kntvY f]t xdgjlY*9fzfvTWx Y*mlmqd 7dgTk@tgf
?YCn«kxKxdg¤Y*t °3Sknfvnm©Y¸eYCt]jlY*Y|f]jlX(YxdC3Wt]k@X
85¬
( GCM) À ¼ )))Ïe 3e
& ¿ ½ (
SUTWYh¹¦nonke*Y*mlmrmqxtµW#fvTc¤²b±k@Wdgjqdgfvdµkx mqxtvonY*Y*mlmldCª¤Tk@d]Yo@Y*YCt]jq xX(Yh@tvk@dvdd]Y5jlYCd|jld
α
¼ ))Ï SUTYCb*kntvt]Y5dg?kn{fvk(f]TY Wt]jlX #f]Y d . ..uYCmmqdCªWxW{fvk f]TY£*#f dYCmmqd*USUTYCbTW²@Y
hX£rW T±¤jl{eYCttvYCYCef]jlnY|¨WYCml{fvTWx
β *Y*mlmldCªWxtvYknmlbd]Y*Wd]jf]jlnYf]k t xWjl{j9fvY*Wd]j¥fyb TWxWonYCdCªx{
fvtvnWd]XhjfdgWj«@YCdUnYCt]b t xWjl{emlb fvk£fvTY$it xjl´uSUTYCbxmqdgkhY¸ejqdyfjl±iknf]TE\! xW{¦\|3¡@Y*t dgjlknWdC