HAL Id: inria-00073690
https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00073690
Submitted on 24 May 2006
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
A Framework of Application Generator Design
Scott Thibault, Charles Consel
To cite this version:
Scott Thibault, Charles Consel. A Framework of Application Generator Design. [Research Report]
RR-3005, INRIA. 1996. �inria-00073690�
ISSN 0249-6399
a p p o r t
d e r e c h e r c h e
INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE
A Framework of Application Generator Design
Scott Thibault, Charles Consel
N ˚ 3005
Octobre 1996
TH `EME 2
)+*-,/.0."1235468795.;:=<26?>095@8AB<,DCAE@;9
FGH
IKJLINMBO PQIKR/STIUWV8X?STYZSWIZU
IZ[YK\]UWYK^/U=_`aJb+V8UWSTcd^/I
egf
V8hiIZ[j\8R/kdI
l
\8mdmdV
f
[nkdI
f
IZY G I f Y G
IoRp/q8r8r?stOvuYZ[VDb
f
IxwKy8y?zOv{|md\]X8IZ_
}~K- ]8
mdm/UWSWYK\][SWVDRtX8IKR/I
f
\][V f _ G
\-8IbdIZIKRtkdIKJVDR/_E[
f
\][IZkt\]_\_0^/YZYZIZ__i^/U\8mdm
f
VD\]Y
G
[V\Y
G
SWIZ/SR/X_V][\
f I
f
IK^/_I\8R/kt[i`am/SWYK\]UWUW``/STIZUWkd_
G
SWX G I f m f
V/k^/YZ[SWDSW[i`tXD\]SR/_[
G
\8RtJIZ[
G
V/kd__0^/Y
G
\]_YZVDJmdV/R/IKR8[ibd\_IZk
f
IK^/_I8IZ_0m/SW[I
[ G IZS
f
\]kd;\?R8[0\X8IZ_KdSR/k^/_[
f
S\U_V][\
f
InkdIZ8IZUWVDm+I
f
_"\
f I f
IZU^/YZ[0\8R?[n[EVx\]kdVDm/[[
G
IZ_IJIZ[
G
V/kd_nk^/I[V[
G
I"U\]YZ V][V/V8UW_
¡V
f
YZVDR/_[
f
^/YZ[SR/XX8IKR/I
f
\][EV
f
_K
FG
SW_md\8mdI f m f
IZ_IKR?[_n\
f
\?JIZV
f
BV f [ G
IkdIZ?IZUTV/mdJIKR8[V¢\8mdm/UWSWYK\][SWVDR£X8IKR/I
f
\][V
f
_-
F¤G
ST_¤
f
\8JIZV
f
|m
f
V]DSWkdIZ_\
_[
f
^/YZ[¥^
f
IZk"kdIZ_SWXDR\8mdm
f
VD\]Y
G
\8R/k\8^/[EVDJ\][SWY[V/V8UW_¦¡V
f
kdIZ_SWXDR
FG
I
f
\8JIZV
f
YZVDR/_SW_[_=V]§\[iVUWIZ8IZUdkdIZ_SWXDR"m
f
VDYZIZ__-¨
FG
Ig©
f
_[UWIZ8IZUªST_[
G
ISWkdIKR8[S«©YK\][ESTV/RV]V/mdI
f
\][ESTV/R/_'[
G
\][=IZ¬dm
f
IZ__IZ_g[
G
Ig^dR/k\8JLIKR8[0\UDYZVDJ|md^/[0\][SWVDR/_V][
G
I\8mdm/UWSWYK\][SWVDR
kdVDJ\]SR
FG
I_IZYZVDR/kUTIZ?IZU'SW_"[
G
I|kdIZ_SWXDRV]\kdVDJ\SR?_¥mdIZYZS«©YU\8R/XD^d\]X8I|
G
SWY
G
\UTUWV]_BVDR/I[VIZ¬dm
f
IZ__B;\
f
S\][ESTV/R/_
SW[
G
SR\¤\8JSWUW`V§\8mdm/UWSTYK\[SWVDR/_K
FG
IkdVDJ\]SR?_0m+IZYZS®©YU\8R/X/^d\]X8ISW_'SJm/UWIKJIKR?[IZkSR[I
f
JL_V][
G
IVDm+I
f
\][SWVDR/_kdI¥©§R/IZk
b8`[
G
IL©
f
_[UWIZ8IZU¯°I_
G
V][
G
\][[
G
Ix^dR/S«V
f
J±\?mdm/UTSWYK\][ESTV/R°V]nmd\
f
[S\]UIZ;\]U^d\][ESTV/R°IKRd\8b/UWIZ_\8^/[V/J\][SWY\8mdm/UWSWYK\][SWVDR
X8IKR/I
f
\][ESTV/R|
f
V/Jo\JSWY
f
Vm
f
V8X
f
\?J[EVSW[_¤SJ|m/UTIKJLIKR8[0\[SWVDR
F¤G
ST_²
f
\?JIZV f G
\]_bdIZIKRkdIZ8IZUWVDmdIZk£SR[
G
IYZVDR8[EIZ¬D[V
f
IK\]U\8mdm/UWSTYK\[SWVDR/_nSR\
f
IK\]_'_0^/Y
G
\]_³R?[I
f
R/IZ[_I
f
/SWYZIZ_n\8R/kkdSTX?ST[¥\]U[IZUWIZDSW_SWVDR\8R/kST_b+IZSR/XkdIZ8IZUWVDm+IZkSRYZV/R-h´^dR/YZ[SWVDR
SW[
G
SR/k^/_[
f
S\]Uµmd\
f
[0R/I
f
_K
¶·/¸¹iº»§]¼?
VDJ\]SR?½dmdIZYZS«©Yj\8R/X/^d\]X8IZ_K
mdm/UWSWYK\][SWVDRPIKR/I
f
\[V
f
_K
l
IK^/_EI8
e \ f
[S\]U¾;\U^d\[SWVDR
¿¡ÀÁ
ÂiÃiÄKÅ
Á
ÂÆÇÃÈ5ÉKÊ
Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rennes
IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex (France) T´el´ephone : (33) 99 84 71 00 – T´el´ecopie : (33) 99 84 71 71
·d·
jIZ_XµQIKRgQI f
\][IK^
f
_k«\8mdm/UWSTYK\[SWVDR/__VDR?[^dR/I\8mdm
f
V/Y
G
I[
fZH
IZ_m
f
VDJIZ[E[IK^/_I"mdV/^
f
U\
f QIK^/[SWUWST_¥\][SWVDRUWV8X8SWYZSWIZUWUTI8
¾'Rmd\
f
[ESTYK^/UWSWI
f
=SWUW_L\?mdmdV
f
[EIKR8[kdIZ_"XD\SR/_kdIm
f
VDk^/YZ[EST/SW[dQI_0^dmgQI f SWIK^
f
_\?^/¬JtQIZ[
G
VDkdIZ_bd\]_dQIZIZ_n_¥^
f
U\
f QIK^/[ESTUWSW_0\][ESTV/RkdI
YZVDJm+V8_0\8R?[_=UTV?X8SWYZSTIZUW_KIKm+IKR/k\8R8[-8J\]UWX
f QI'_IZ_\-;\8R?[0\]X8IZ_-KUSR/k^/_[
f
STIk^BkQIZ8IZUWVDmdm+IKJIKR?[UTV?X8SWYZSTIZU
f
IZY
G
STX/R/I
H
\\]kdVDm/[EI
f
YZIZ[[I"\8mdm
f
VDY
G
I"k^|\]SW[kdI"U®\?b/_IKR/YZI"kV/^/[SWUT_k®\]SWkdImdVD^
f
U\|YZVDR/_[
f
^/YZ[SWVDRkdI"XQIKR'QI f
\[IK^
f
_'k«\8mdm/UWSTYK\[SWVDR/_K
I
f
\8mdm+V
f
[m
f QIZ_IKR?[I"^dR£YK\]k
f
IBXQIKRgQI f
\]UmdV/^
f
UWIkQIZ8IZUWVDmdmdIKJIKR?[kdI[EIZUT_XQIKRgQI f
\][IK^
f
_KVD^/_kQIZY
f
SW8VDR/_YZVDJJIKR?[
_[
f
^/YZ[¥^
f I f
UWIkdIZ_SWXDRBkdIZ_XQIKR'QI f
\][EIK^
f
_k®\8mdm/UWSWYK\][SWVDR/_'IZ[=cd^/IZUT_V/^/[SWUT_'\?^/[VDJ\][ESTcd^/IZ_=IKJm/UWV;`?I
f
m+VD^
f
UWIK^
f
YZVDR/_[
f
^/YZ[ESTV/R
jIxm
f
IKJLSTI
f
R/SW8IK\8^£YZVDR/_SW_[I
H
\STkdIKR?[S«©I
f
UWIxR/V]`D\?^kdIZ_V/m'QI f
\][ESTV/R/_VDR/k\8JIKR?[0\]UWIZ_k^kdV/J\]SR/Ik®\8mdm/UWSWYK\][SWVDR/_-jI
_IZYZVDR/kR/ST?IK\8^IZ_[UWI"kdIZ_ESTX/Rk®^dRU\?R/XD\]X8IkQIZkdS0QIca^/Sm+I
f
JIZ[kIZ¬am
f
SJLI
f
kdIZ_]\
f
S\][SWVDR/_
H
\BUSR8[dQI f SWIK^
f
k«^dR/I\8JSWUWUTI
k®\8mdm/UWSWYK\][SWVDR/_KRJSWY
f
V]m
f
V8X
f
\8JJIk\8R/_YZIU\8R/XD\]X8IkQIZkdS0QIIZ_[SJm/U0QIKJIKR?[dQI H
\U®\STkdI£kdIZ_xV/m'QI f
\][ESTV/R/_"kQI¥©§R/SWIZ_
k\8R/_UWIm
f
IKJSWI
f
R/SW8IK\8^V/^/_"JVDR?[
f
VDR/_nmd\
f
\]SWUWUWIK^
f
_"YZV/JJIKR?[nU®^/[SWUWSW_0\][SWVDRXQIKR'QI f
\]UWSW_dQIZIkdI"UiQIZ]\]U^d\][SWVDRmd\
f
[ESTIZUWUWI
mdI
f
JLIZ["U\XQIKRgQI f
\][SWVDR£\8^/[VDJ|\][SWca^/Ik®^dR/I\8mdm/UWSTYK\[SWVDRmd\
f
[0\8R?[k®^dR°JSWY
f
V]m
f
V8X
f
\8J|JImdVD^
f
¡VD^
f
R/S
f
©§Rd\UTIKJLIKR8[
^dR/I"SJm/U¥QIKJLIKR8[0\[SWVDR
IYK\]k
f
IXQIKRgQI f
\]U
H
\£QIZ[dQIkQIZ?IZUTV/mdm'QIk\8R/_'UWIYZV/R8[IZ¬/[Ik®\8mdm/UWSWYK\][SWVDR/_
f QIZIZUWUWIZ_'k\?R/_'kdIZ_kdVDJ\SR/IZ_gYZVDJJIUWIZ_'_EI
f
DSWYZIZ_
_0^
f ³ R8[I
f
R/IZ[xIZ[U\[dQIZU¥QIZDSW_SWVDRtkdSWX8SW[0\]UWI8 ½/VDRtkQIZ8IZUWVDmdm+IKJIKR?[x_ImdVD^
f
_0^/SW[xIKR YZV8UWU\?bdV
f
\[SWVDR \-8IZYkdIZ_md\
f
[IKRd\S
f
IZ_
SR/k^/_[
f
SWIZUW_K
»K¹´! ·
j\?R/XD\]X8IZ_QIZkdS0QIZ_KdPQIKR'QI f
\[IK^
f
k
mdm/UWSWYK\][SWVDR/_K
l QIK^/[ESTUWSW_0\][ESTV/R
Q
¾;\U^d\[SWVDR e \ f
[SWIZUTUWI
q
. /
ª =
u^
f f
\8JIZV
f
¡V f [ G
IkdIZ?IZUTV/mdJIKR8[V]µ\?mdm/UTSWYK\][ESTV/RX?I¥
R/I
f
\][V
f
_"SW__[
f
^/YZ[¥^
f
IZk SR?[V[iVUWIZ8IZUW_K
F¤G
I©
f
_E["UWIZ8IZU
SW_bd\]_IZk V/RIZUWUnIZ_[¥\8b/UWST_
G
IZk SWkdIK\]_V"X8IKR/I
f
SWYYZVDJmdV
R/IKR8[E_10w*2d243=
G
SWY GG
\-8IkdIZ_S
f
\8b/UWIY G \ f
\]YZ[EI
f
SW_[SWYZ_B¡V
f
f
IK^/_Ix\?R/k°_[
f
^/YZ[¥^
f
IZk°kdIZ_SWXDR
FG
SW_"UWIZ8IZU'V[
G
I
f
\8JLI¥
V
f
YZVDR/_EST_E[_V][
G
IkdI¥©§R/SW[SWVDRV]µ\8R\8b/_[
f
\]YZ[J\Y
G
SR/I8
G I f IV/mdI
f
\][ESTV/R/_V][
G
I\8b/_E[
f
\]YZ[J\]Y
G
SR/IxYK\8Rb+IDSWI¥
IZk \_X8IKR/I
f
SWYYZVDJm+VDR/IKR?[_K
b/_[
f
\]YZ[J\]Y
G
SR/IZ_\
f
IL\
IZUTU^dR/kdI
f
_E[VDV/kYZVDR/YZIKm/[
f
VDJ!m
f
V8X
f
\8JJSR/XU\8R/XD^d\]X8IZ_
0wKM53'[
G
\][
G
\-8I_IZ8I
f
\Uµ\]kd]\8R?[0\]X8IZ_kdSW_YK^/__EIZk°SR_IZYZ[SWVDR
2d_0^/Y
G
\_nm
f
V]DSWkdSR/X\8R\8b/_E[
f
\]YZ[SWVDR[EVxJ^/UT[ESm/UWISJm/UWI¥
JIKR?[0\][SWVDR/_K
PST?IKR[
G
IkdI¥©§R/SW[SWVDR°V²\8R°\?b/_[
f
\]YZ[J\]Y
G
SR/I8=
G
SWY
G
kdI¥©§R/IZ_\|YZV8UWUWIZYZ[SWVDRV]'VDm+I
f
\][SWVDR/__¥^/ST[¥\8b/UWI"V
f
bd^/SWUTkdSR/X
\8mdm/UWSWYK\][SWVDR/_"¤ST[
G
SR\kdV/J\]SR[
G
IR/IZ¬/[n_[EIKmSW_[Vxm
f
V
DSWkdI\ JIZ[
G
VDkVLYZV/JmdV8_ESR/X VDm+I
f
\][SWVDR/_£[VtV f J \?R
\8mdm/UWSWYK\][SWVDR VDJm+V8_SR/X[
G
IZ_IVDm+I
f
\][SWVDR/_[
Gdf
VD^/X G [ G I
^/_IV]\BX8U^/IU\8R/XD^d\]X8IYK\8RbdIYK^dJbdI
f
_VDJI\8R/k_SJSWU\
f
\8mdm/UWSWYK\][SWVDR/_SWUWU'V][IKR_
G \ f
I\_SJSWU\
f
_E[
f
^/YZ[0^
f
I8u^
f
\8mdm
f
VD\Y
G
YZVDR/_SW_[_V]^/_SR/Xx\kdVDJ|\]SR?_0mdIZYZS«©YU\8R/XD^d\]X8I8
\]_n\8RSR?[I
f
\]YZI"[EV[
G
I"\8b/_[
f
\]YZ[nJ\Y
G
SR/I8
FG
^/_-d[
G
I"_EI¥
YZVDR/kUWIZ8IZUDVVD^
f f
\8JLIZV
f
SW_[
G
IgkdI¥©§R/SW[SWVDRV+\JSWY
f
V]
U\8R/XD^d\]X8I8
FG
IJSWY
f
VU\?R/XD^d\]X8I
f
IKm
f
IZ_EIKR8[_\8R£SR8[EI
f
\YZI
[V[
G
I\8b/_[
f
\]YZ[nJ\]Y
G
SR/I[
G
\][K\?JVDR/XV8[
G I f [ G
SR/X8_-§\]U«
UWV;¤_
f
IK^/_I\8JV/R/X_SJSWU\
f
\8mdm/UWSWYK\][SWVDR/_\8R/kYK\8RbdI^/_IZk
b8`R/VDR?m
f
V?X
f
\8JJLI
f
_K
FG
I f
IZ_¥^/UT[V[
G
SW_[iV]UWIZ8IZU¤
f
\8JIZV
f
SW_\t_[
f
^/Y¥
[0^
f
IZk\8mdm
f
VD\Y
G
[EV[
G
IxkdIZ?IZUTV/mdJIKR8[V]n\8R\8mdm/UWSTYK\[SWVDR
X8IKR/I
f
\][EV f
R\8mdm/UWSWYK\][SWVDR|X8IKR/I
f
\[V
f
ST_\_V][i²\
f
I'YZVDJ
mdVDR/IKR?["[
G
\][nX?IKR/I
f
\][IZ_"\|\8JSWUW`V]²\8mdm/UWSWYK\][SWVDR/_SW[
G
SR
\kdVDJ|\]SR
kdVDJ\]SR
f
IKm
f
IZ_IKR?[_\ YZU\__V]\8mdm/UWSWYK\-
[SWVDR/_SW[
G
_SJSWU\
f Y G \ f
\]YZ[I
f
SW_[SWYZ_\8R/k£^dR/YZ[ESTV/Rd\]UWST[i`8
JSWY
f
V]U\8R/XD^d\X8I YK\?RbdI°_EIZIKR \]_\
f
IZ_[
f
STYZ[EIZkkdVDJ\]SR?
_0mdIZYZS«©YU\8R/XD^d\]X?I"
G
SWY
G
IZ¬dm
f
IZ__IZ_[
G
SW_n]\
f
S\][SWVDRSRRd\;
[0^
f
\]U¦[I
f
J_V'[
G
I"kdVDJ|\]SR
JSWY
f
V]m
f
V8X
f
\8J%_0m+IZYZS«©IZ_
\8RSR/_[0\8R/YZIBV][
G
I"YZU\]__¤V]¢\?mdm/UTSWYK\][ESTV/R/_
f
IKm
f
IZ_IKR?[IZkb?`
[ G IJSWY
f
V]U\8R/XD^d\]X?I8µ\?R/k \X8IKR/I
f
\][V
f
SW_^/_IZk [EV\8^/[V
J\][SWYK\]UWUW`X8IKR/I
f
\[I \?RtSJ|m/UTIKJLIKR8[0\[SWVDRV]\8RtSR/_[0\8R/YZI
f VDJ [ G
ST_B_0mdIZYZS«©YK\][ESTV/R
FG
^/_K[
G
I\8mdm/UWSWYK\][SWVDRX8IKR/I
f
\;
[V
f
[IZY
G
R/V8UWV8X8`°SW_
f
IK^/_IZk IK\]Y
G
[SJI\R/IZ SR/_[0\8R/YZISW_
Y f IK\][IZk
u^
f f
\8JIZV
f
^/_IZ_'\8^/[VDJ|\][SWYm
f
V?X
f
\8J [ f
\8R/_´¡V
f
J\-
[SWVDR/_[V"[
f
\8R/_U\][I\"_¥mdIZYZS«©YK\][SWVDRd
f
SW[[IKR|SR[
G
InJSWY
f
V]
U\8R/XD^d\]X8I8ªSR8[EV \8RI6xYZSWIKR8[SJm/UWIKJIKR?[0\][ESTV/R
F¤G
I"X8IKR/I¥
f
\][SWVDR£m
f
V/YZIZ__nV/YZYK^
f
_b8`J|\8mdm/SR/X \JSWY
f
V]m
f
V?X
f
\8J%SR
[ G IJSWY
f
V]U\8R/XD^d\X8ISR8[EV"VDm+I
f
\][SWVDR/_SW[
G
SR[
G
In\8b/_[
f
\]YZ[
J\]Y
G
SR/I8
G
SWY G \ f
I[
G
IKJ_EIZUT?IZ_xJ\8mdm+IZk SR?[V°\8RVDm/[S«
JS7ZIZk SJm/UWIKJIKR?[0\][SWVDR
F¤G
ST_J\8mdm/SR/X m f
VDYZIZ__SW_ \?^?
[VDJ|\][IZk[
Gdf
VD^/X G [ G
I^/_IV]md\
f
[S\]UIZ;\]U^d\][ESTV/R80®z/w-r3
e \ f
[ES\UIZ]\]U^d\][SWVDRST_"\m
f
V8X
f
\8J [ f
\?R/_i¡V
f
J\][SWVDR
G
SWY
G
_0m+IZYZS\UTS7ZIZ_\£m
f
V8X
f
\?J SW[
Gtf
IZ_0m+IZYZ[[EV /R/V;!;\]U^/IZ_V
_VDJLIV]µSW[_¤SRdmd^/[-
V/J\]SR?_0mdIZYZS«©Y°U\8R/X/^d\]X8IZ_\8R/k \8mdm/UWSWYK\][SWVDR X8IKR/I
f
\-
[V
f
_\
f
I°bdV8[
G
IZUTU
f
IZYZV8XDR/S7ZIZk \?mdm
f
VD\]Y
G
IZ_$0®q53
FG
IZ`
f
IKm
f
IZ_EIKR8[\:9IZ¬/Sb/UWI¡V
f
J%V]
f
IK^/_EI"[
G
\][R/V8[V/R/UT`\]UWUWV;¤_
[ G I f
IK^/_IV][
G
ISJm/UWIKJIKR?[0\][SWVDR/_|V]n\8b/_[
f
\YZ[^dR/YZ[SWV]
Rd\]U^dR/SW[_K\]_SR[
G
IYZV/JmdVDR/IKR?[ibd\]_EIZk \?mdm
f
VD\]Y
G
IZ_Kbd^/[
\]UW_Vx\UTUWV]_[
G I f
IK^/_IV
G
V][
G
IZ_EI^dR/YZ[SWVDRd\Uµ^dR/SW[_n\
f I
YZVDJb/SR/IZk°[VV
f J \YZVDJ|m/UTIZ[EI_E`D_[EIKJ;0®s53
FG
I"V/R/UT`£UWS®
JSW[0\][ESTV/RSR[
G
IL\?JVD^dR?[nV]kdIZ_SWXDR DR/V]UWIZkdX8I|[
G
\][YK\8R
bdI
f
IK^/_IZkb8`\8R\8mdm/UWSWYK\][SWVDR£X8IKR/I
f
\[V
f
SW_[
G
I"\8b/SWUWSW[`£[V
IZ¬dm
f
IZ__[
G
\][ DR/V]UWIZkdX8In\_\8R\]UWX8V
f
SW[
G
J=<^
f [ G I f
JLV
f
I8
\8mdm/UWSWYK\][SWVDR£X8IKR/I
f
\[V
f
_\]UWUTV][
G
ST_ DR/V]UWIZkdX8I[Vb+I
f
IK^?
_IZkb8`°R/VDR?m
f
V8X
f
\8J|JI
f
_"bdIZYK\?^/_Ix[
G
IxkdVDJ|\]SR?_0mdIZYZS«©Y
U\8R/XD^d\]X?IYK\8Rm
f
V]DSWkdI\8R£SR8[EI
f
\YZI[V[
G
IkdVDJ\]SR?^/_I
f
SR\8JSWUWS\
f
R/V?[0\][SWVDR/_K
IZ_¥m/ST[EI[
G
IZ_IIK\][0^
f
IZ_
G
STY
G
J|\8 ]I[
G
IKJ \X8V/V/k\8m?
m f VD\Y
G
[V
f
IK^/_I8\8mdm/UWSTYK\[SWVDR X8IKR/I
f
\[V f _ G
\-8IUWSJSW[IZk
\8mdm/UWSWYK\8b/SWUWS[i`8
FG
I\8mdm/UWSWYK\8b/SWUWS[i`V]"X8IKR/I
f
\][V
f
[IZY
G
R/V]
UWV8X8`°SW_kdIZ[I
f
JLSR/IZkb?`°SW[_"[IZY
G
R/SWYK\]Ug¡IK\_Sb/STUWSW[i`8\_"IZUWU
\]_kdIZ?IZUTV/mdJIKR8[YZV8_[E_K
FG
IkdIZ8IZUWVDmdJIKR?[nYZV?_[_V]X8IKR/I¥
f
\][EV
f
_YK\8RbdIYZV/R/_SWkdI
f
\8b/UW` JLV
f
I[
G
\?R[
G
IkdIZ8IZUWVDmdJLIKR8[
V]\8R SR/kdST/SWk^d\]U\?mdm/UTSWYK\][ESTV/Rn\8R/k J^/_E[ b+IYZVDJmd\
f
IZk
SW[
G [ G
IUWVDR/X[I
f
J bdIKR/I¥©[_BV]
f
IK^/_EI8
FG
^/_K[
G
IY
f
ST[ES®
YK\]UªkdIZYZST_ESTV/R[V^/_I¤X8IKR/I
f
\][V
f
[IZY
G
R/V?UTV?X8`SW_bd\]_EIZkxVDRLST[E_
kdIZ8IZUWVDmdJIKR?[YZV8_[_K
F¤G
I"V]8I
f
\]UWU=X8VD\]U¦V]'[
G
SW_V
f
|ST_[EV
f
IZk^/YZI[
G
IBI>V f [
V]X8IKR/I
f
\][EV
f
kdIZ8IZUWVDmdJIKR?[K¯°IYK\?R_0^dJJ|\
f
S7ZI"VD^
f
\8m?
m f VD\Y
G
\]_V8UWUWV]_K
mdm/UTSWYK\][ESTV/RX8IKR/I
f
\][EV
f
kdIZ_SWXDR£SW_kdI¥
YZVDJm+V8_IZkSR8[EVn[iVUWIZ8IZUW_K8[
G
IkdIZ_ESTX/R"V§\8R"\8b/_E[
f
\]YZ[J|\-
Y G
SR/I\8R/kx\JSWY
f
V]U\8R/XD^d\]X?I8µ¾g\]Y
G
V§[
G
IZ_IYK\8Rb+IYZV/JB
mdV?_IZk
f
VDJ%_0J|\]UWUTI
f
bd^/SWUTkdSR/X°b/UWVDYZ ?_[V m f
V;/SWkdIB^
f [ G I f
f
IK^/_I8
F¤G
I°YZVDJm/UWIZ[I°X?IKR/I
f
\][SWVDRm
f
VDYZIZ__SW_\]Y
G
SWIZ8IZk
[
Gdf
V/^/X G [ G
I\8mdm/UWSTYK\[SWVDR°V²md\
f
[ES\UIZ]\]U^d\][SWVDRSRV
f
kdI
f
[VxJ|\8m\8R\?mdm/UTSWYK\][ESTV/R_¥mdIZYZS«©IZk°SR[
G
I"JLSTY
f
V]U\8R/XD^d\]X8I
[V\8R\8b/_[
f
\]YZ[J|\]Y
G
SR/Im
f
V8X
f
\8J8\8R/kJ\8mdm/SR/X[
G
SW_
f
I¥
_0^/UW[[Vx\8RSJm/UWIKJIKR?[0\][SWVDR
u^
f
V
f
¤YZVDR?[
f
Sbd^/[IZ_[V[
G
IkdIZ_ESTX/R"V+\8mdm/UWSWYK\][SWVDRLX8I¥
R/I
f
\][EV
f
_nb?` m f
V;/SWkdSR/X \_E[
f
^/YZ[0^
f
IZk£[iVUTIZ?IZU \?mdm
f
VD\]Y
G
[V!kdIZ_SWXDRm
f
V;/SWkdSR/X \ YZVDJm/UWIZ[I$md\][
G f
VDJ JLSTY
f
V]
U\8R/XD^d\]X?IZ_[VSJm/UWIKJIKR?[0\][SWVDR
f
IK^/_SR/XnYZVDJ|mdVDR/IKR?[ibd\]_IZk
[IZY
G
R/V8UWV8X8`8[
G
I^dR/S«V
f J ^/_IVNmd\
f
[S\]U¤IZ;\]U^d\][SWVDR V
f
\8^/[V/J\][SWYm
f
V8X
f
\8J [
f
\8R/_iV
f
J\[SWVDR\8R/k[
G
I^/_IV]\
YZVDJm+VDR/IKR?["JVDkdIZU[EVxYZVDJ|mdV8_I\8R/kIZ¬/[IKR/k°\8mdm/UWSWYK\][SWVDR
X8IKR/I
f
\[V
f
_K
F¤G
IV8UWUTV]SR/X_IZYZ[ESTV/Rm
f
IZ_IKR8[E_n_V/JIbd\]YZ ?X
f
VD^dR/k£VDR
md\
f
[ES\UdIZ;\]U^d\][SWVDR
FG
SW_ST_¢¡V?UTUWV]IZkb8`\8RBIZ¬a\8J|m/UTI¤[
G
\][
SWUWUµb+I^/_IZk£SR[
G
I¡V8UWUWV]SR/Xx_EIZYZ[SWVDR/_Kª
G
SWY
G
IZU\?bdV
f
\[I
??A@CBDFEEHG
2
VDR[
G
I[iVUTIZ?IZUd
f
\8JIZV
f
B\8R/k[
G
In\8mdm/UWSWYK\][SWVDRV]md\
f
[S\]UIZ;\]U^d\][ESTV/R
FG
I¤©§Rd\]U[V_IZYZ[ESTV/R/_X8SW8I\_0^dJJ|\
f `
V]
f
IZU\][IZkV
f
\8R/k_VDJLIYZVDR/YZU^/_SWVDR/_K
¤"(
FG
SW_n_EIZYZ[SWVDRm
f
IZ_IKR?[_[
G
Ibd\]Y ?X
f
V/^dR/kV]VD^
f
\8mdm
f
VD\]Y
G
[V m f V?X
f
\8J _0m+IZYZS\UTS7K\][ESTV/R
e'f
V8X
f
\8J _0mdIZYZS\]UWS7K\][SWVDR SW_
[ G Im
f
V/YZIZ__'V][
f
\8R/_´¡V
f
JSR/XN\X8IKR/I
f
\]Um
f
V8X
f
\8JSR?[V"V/R/I
[ G
\][SW_JV
f
I|_0mdIZYZS«©Y8YK^/_[EVDJS7ZSR/XSW[SR°_EVDJI\K`8³R
VD^
f
\8mdm
f
VD\]Y
G
I^/[SWUWS7ZInmd\
f
[ES\UDIZ]\]U^d\][SWVDR 0®z/Dw-r*3i;\¤IZUTU
IZ_[0\8b/UWSW_
G
IZkt[IZY
G
R/STcd^/IV]²m
f
V?X
f
\8J _0mdIZYZS\]UWS7K\][SWVDR
e \ f
[S\]U'IZ]\]U^d\][SWVDR
G
\]_b+IZIKR°_¥^/YZYZIZ__i^/UTUW`\8mdm/UWSWIZkSRtJ\8R?`
\8mdm/UWSWYK\][SWVDR\
f
IK\]_SR/YZU^/kdSRdXVDm+I
f
\][SR/X_`/_[IKJ_ 0wKq538\?R/k
YZVDJmd^/[I f X f
\8m
G
SWYZ_:0®{53
e \ f
[S\]U IZ]\]U^d\][SWVDR SW_ \ m f V?X
f
\8J [ f
\8R/_iV
f
J|\][SWVDR
G SWY
G
_0m+IZYZS\UTS7ZIZ_$\$m
f
V8X
f
\8J SW[
G f
IZ_¥mdIZYZ[ [V$_VDJLI
DR/V]nR|SRdmd^/[_b8`mdI
f
V
f
JSR/X\]_J\8R?`YZVDJmd^/[0\[SWVDR/_\]_
mdV8_E_Sb/UTI£[
G
\][VDR/UW`tkdIKmdIKR/k V/R°[
G
I /R/V]nRSRdmd^/[-
F¤G
I
m f
V/YZIZ__Vamd\
f
[S\]U?IZ;\]U^d\][SWVDRSW_IZUWU8_0^/SW[IZk[VIK\]Y G m G
\]_I
V]VD^
f f
\?JIZV
f
b+IZYK\8^/_I"IK\Y G m G
\]_EISR?8V8UW8IZ_[
G
ISR/_i
[0\8R?[S\][SWVDRV]'\X8IKR/I
f
\]UYZVDJmdV/R/IKR8[SR8[V\_0mdIZYZS«©YVDR/I8
"¥"("
³R [ G
ST__EIZYZ[SWVDR IkdIZ_Y
f
Sb+I \8R IZ¬d\8Jm/UWI°[
G
\][SWUWU"bdI
^/_IZk SR [ G
IV8UWUTV]SR/X_IZYZ[ESTV/R/_[V°X8SW8I_VDJLIYZVDR/Y
f
IZ[EI
YZVDR?[IZ¬D[[V[
G
IB
f
\8JIZV
f
FG
IIZ¬d\8Jm/UWIYZVDR/YZI
f
R/_"[
G I
kdIZ8IZUWVDmdJIKR?[V]n[
G
IxYZVDR?[
f
V?Um
f
V/YZIZ__V]N\£8IKR/kdSR/X J\;
Y G SR/I8
UW[
G
V/^/X G [ G I f
I\
f
IJ\?R8`kdS>I
f
IKR8[ ?SR/kd_V ?IKR?
kdSR/X J|\]Y
G
SR/IZ_K¦V
f
kdSW8I
f
_I\8mdm/UWSWYK\][SWVDR/_K=[
G
IZ`°\]UWU
G
\K?I
8I
f
`_SJSWU\
f
_[
f
^/YZ[¥^
f
IZ_K
F¤G
IZ_I_SJSWU\
f
SW[SWIZ_xJ\? ]IZ_"SW[\
_0^/SW[0\8b/UWI"\8mdm/UWSWYK\][SWVDR|V f [ G
IN^/_IV]\8R\8mdm/UWSWYK\][SWVDRX8IKR/I¥
f
\][V
f
³ Rm
f
\]YZ[SWYZII\
f
I\8mdm/UW`/SR/XV/^
f
\8mdm
f
V/\]Y
G
[V
f
IK\]U
_YK\]UWI\8mdm/UWSWYK\][SWVDR/_SRYZV?UTU\8b+V
f
\][ESTV/RSW[
G
VD^
f
SR/k^/_E[
f
S\]U
md\
f
[0R/I
f
_K
³ R [ G
SW_IZ¬d\8Jm/UWI8"\ 8IKR/kdSR/X J\]Y
G
SR/I SW_£kdI¥©§R/IZk [V
bdI\xJ\Y
G
SR/I"[
G
\][nm
f
V]/STkdIZ_"\LYZI
f
[0\]SR_EI
f
DSWYZI8
G
SWY
G
SW_
[V_EIZUTUg_VDJIJI f Y G
\8R/kdSW_I_IZUWIZYZ[IZkb8`°[
G
Ixbd^/`8I f
F¤G
I
8IKR/kdSR/XJ\Y
G
SR/I\
f Y G
SW[IZYZ[0^
f
IYZVDR/_SWkdI
f
IZkYZVDR/_SW_[_V]\
_[V/Y ^dR/SW[K\?RSRdmd^/[n^dR/SW[Kd\BYZV8SR^dR/SW[K/VDm/[SWVDRd\]UWUW` \BkdSW_i
m/U\K`t^dR/ST[-µ\?R/k \YZIKR?[
f
\]UYZV/R8[
f
V8U'm
f
V/YZIZ__K
FG
IYZIKR8[
f
\]U
YZVDR?[
f
V8UDm
f
VDYZIZ__YZV/R8[
f
V8UW_[
G
I\]YZ[SWVDR/_V]IK\Y
G
^dR/ST['b?`_IKR?
kdSR/X \8R/k
f
IZYZIZSWDSR/X JIZ_E_0\]X8IZ_K
FG
I¡V?UTUWV]SR/Xt_IZYZ[SWVDR/_
IZU\8bdV
f
\][IVDRL[
G
I[VUWIZ8IZUW_V]§[
G
Inm
f
VDm+V8_IZk
f
\8JIZV
f
\8R/k
G
V;$[
G
IZ` \ f
Ix\?mdm/UTSWIZk[V£[
G
IkdIZ8IZUWVDmdJLIKR8[V][
G
SW_
IZ¬a\?Jm/UWI°X8IKR/I
f
\][EV
f
V
f
8IKR/kdSR/X J\Y
G
SR/I°YZVDR?[
f
V?UNm
f
V
YZIZ__IZ_K
&ª= "¥"g&
FG
IB©
f
_[UWIZ8IZUSR£[
G
I"kdIZ_SWXDRm
f
VDYZIZ_E_nV]'V/^
f f
\?JIZV f
SW_[
G
IkdI¥©§R/SW[SWVDR V]\8R \?b/_[
f
\]YZ[J\]Y
G
SR/I8
G
SWY
G
YK\8m?
[0^
f
IZ_[
G
I^dR/k\8JIKR?[0\]UªVDmdI
f
\][SWVDR/_[
G
\][^dR/kdI
f
UW`[
G
IkdI¥
_SWXDRtV]\8mdm/UWSTYK\[SWVDR/_x¤ST[
G
SR [ G
IkdVDJ\]SR
R\8b/_[
f
\]YZ[
J\]Y
G
SR/IYK\8RbdI_SJm/UW`kdI¥©§R/IZk\]_N\YZV?UTUWIZYZ[SWVDR V]VDm+I¥
f
\][ESTV/R/_x
G
SWY
G
VDm+I
f
\][I£VDR\8R IZ¬am/UWSWYZSW[UW` kdI¥©§R/IZk _[¥\][I8
FG
I^/_IV]\8b/_E[
f
\]YZ[nJ|\]Y
G
SR/IZ_SW_"\Rd\][0^
f
\]U=m
f
V8X
f
IZ_E_SWVDR
f
VDJ IZ_[0\?b/UTSW_
G
IZk
f
IK^/_I m f
\]YZ[ESTYZIZ_- ½/[0\
f
[SR/Xt
f
V/J [ G I
SWkdIK\tV]
G
SWX
G
UW` md\
f
\8JIZ[I
f
S7ZIZk _0^db
f
V/^/[SR/IZ_KVDR/IJSWX G [
YZVDR/_SWkdI f [ G
IZ_I[VbdIX8IKR/I
f
STYBYZVDJm+VDR/IKR8[E_V
f
V/mdI
f
\][ESTV/R/_
[Vm
f
V]DSWkdI"\UWIZ8IZUV]\8b/_E[
f
\]YZ[SWVDR
FG
SW_UWIZ8IZUV]µ\8b/_E[
f
\]Y¥
[SWVDR°m
f
V;/SWkdIZ_SR/_¥^/U\[SWVDR b+IZ[iIZIKR [ G
IkdI¥©§R/SW[SWVDRtV][
G I
VDm+I
f
\][SWVDR°\?R/k \8R£SJm/UWIKJIKR8[¥\][SWVDRxPSW8IKR[
G
IYZV/R8[IZ¬/[
V]µ\BkdVDJ|\]SR?_0mdIZYZS«©Y"_EV8U^/[SWVDRdSW[[
G
IKR_IZIKJ_
f
IK\]_EVDRd\8b/UWI
[ G
\][¤V
f
\X?ST?IKRkdV/J\]SRI"YK\8R£kdI¥©§R/Ix\|YZV8UWUWIZYZ[SWVDR°V
f
IZU\][IZkVDm+I
f
\][SWVDR/_[
G
\][YZV/VDmdI
f
\[I"[V\]YZYZVDJ|m/UTSW_
G
_V/JI
X8VD\U¡ <SRd\]UWUW`8b?`SR?[
f
V/k^/YZSR/XL\?RIZ¬am/UWSWYZSW[_[0\[I88I
G
\-8I
\8R \8b/_[
f
\YZ[LJ|\]Y
G
SR/IJVDkdIZU
FG
I£SR8[
f
VDk^/YZ[SWVDR V]"\8R
IZ¬dm/UTSWYZSW[_[0\[INm
f
V;/SWkdIZ_n\JIK\?R/_V
f
IK\_VDR/SR/X\8bdVD^/[¤[
G I
VDm+I
f
\][SWVDR/_\8R/k
G
V][
G
IZ`SR8[I
f
\]YZ[K
F¤G
Ica^/IZ_[ESTV/Rt[VYZVDR/_SWkdI
f
R/V]%ST_X8SW8IKR\8Rt\8b/_[
f
\]YZ[
J\]Y
G
SR/I
G
V]YK\?Rt[
G
IxV/mdI
f
\][ESTV/R/_V]n[
G
I\8b/_[
f
\]YZ[J|\-
Y G
SR/I"b+INJ|\8mdmdIZkSR8[V\8RI6xYZSWIKR?[SJ|m/UTIKJLIKR8[0\[SWVDR <S«
XD^
f
Iw"kdIKm/SWYZ[_[
G
I"YZVDJm/UWIZ[Im
f
V/YZIZ__nV\8mdm/UWSTYK\[SWVDR£X8I¥
R/I
f
\][ESTV/RSR"V/^
f f
\?JIZV
f
ª
e \ f
[_
\8R/kV]§[
G
I'©X/^
f I
YZV ff
IZ_0mdVDR/kB[V[
G
I[iV¤UTIZ?IZUT_Va[
G
I¢
f
\8JIZV
f
ªK\8R/kmd\
f [
%SR/kdSWYK\][IZ_
G
V]%[
G
SW_ J|\8mdm/SR/X°
f
VDJ \?R\8b/_[
f
\YZ[LJ|\-
Y G
SR/I|[V\8RI6YZSTIKR?["SJm/UWIKJIKR?[0\][ESTV/R[0\8 ]IZ_m/U\]YZI8
FG
I
©XD^
f
I_
G
V]_¦[
G
\][=X8SW8IKR\8R"\8b/_E[
f
\]YZ[J|\]Y
G
SR/ISJm/UWIKJIKR?
[0\][ESTV/R \8R/k \?R \8b/_E[
f
\]YZ[J\]Y
G
SR/Im
f
V8X
f
\8J \]_SRdmd^/[[V
\m
f
V8X
f
\8J _0m+IZYZS\UTS7ZI
f
gIYK\8RX8IKR/I
f
\[I\8RSJm/UWIKJIKR?
[0\][ESTV/R
FG
IxSJm/UWIKJIKR?[0\][ESTV/RV]n[
G I \8b/_E[
f
\]YZ[J\]Y
G
SR/I
SW_KV]YZV/^
f
_I8_ESJ|m/UT` \ G SWX
G
UW` md\
f
\8JIZ[I
f
S7ZIZk UWSb f \ f
`8
FG
SW_UTSb f \ f
`YK\8Rb+I"YZVDR/_ESTkdI
f
IZk \| 8SR/kV]X8IKR/I
f
SWY! 0m
f
V]
X f
\?J#"8SR[
G
I_IKR/_I[
G
\]['SW[kdI¥©§R/IZ_n[
G
InSJm/UWIKJIKR?[0\][SWVDR
V]nIZ?I
f
`°mdV8__ESb/UWI\8b/_[
f
\YZ["J\]Y
G
SR/Im
f
V8X
f
\8J
G I f
IK\_
[ G
ISJm/UWIKJIKR8[¥\][SWVDR|V]\8R\8b/_[
f
\]YZ['J\]Y
G
SR/INm
f
V8X
f
\8J SW_
VDR/I_0m+IZYZS®©Y|SR/_E[0\8R/YZIV]'[
G
SW_K
FG
^/_-[
G
SW__SW[0^d\[SWVDRm
f
I¥
YZSW_IZUW`YZV ff
IZ_¥mdVDR/kd_[V
G
\][\m
f
V8X
f
\?J$_0m+IZYZS\UTS7ZI
f
kdVDIZ_-
[ f
\?R/_i¡V
f J \X?IKR/I
f
\]U'm
f
V8X
f
\8J SR?[V\JV
f
I_0mdIZYZS«©YVDR/I
bd\]_IZkVDR£_VDJIYZVDR?[IZ¬/[K³R[
G
SW_"YK\_I8_0m+IZYZS\]UWS7K\[SWVDRtSW_
SW[
G f
IZ_0mdIZYZ[[V[
G
I\8b/_[
f
\YZ[LJ|\]Y
G
SR/Im
f
V8X
f
\?J
FG
I
f
IZ_0^/UW[V¦m
f
V8X
f
\8J _¥mdIZYZS\]UWS7K\][SWVDR£`DSWIZUWkd_n\8R|I6xYZSWIKR?[²m
f
V]
X f
\?J G SWY
G
SW_"VDm/[ESJLS7ZIZktSW[
Gf
IZ_0m+IZYZ["[V[
G
I\8b/_[
f
\]YZ[
J\]Y
G
SR/INm
f
V8X
f
\8J%$KSW['YK\?R\]UW_VVDm/[SJS7ZISR/I6xYZSWIKR/YZSTIZ_¤SR?
[ f
V/k^/YZIZkb?`[
G
Ib+VD^dR/k\
f
SWIZ_bdIZ[iIZIKRVDm+I
f
\][SWVDR/_K
F¤G
I f Ix\
f
IJ\8R?`\]kd]\8R8[¥\]X8IZ_[V[
G
SW_\8mdm
f
V/\]Y
G
uR/I
V][
G
IZ_I\]kd]\8R8[¥\]X8IZ_"SW_[
G
IVDmdmdV
f
[0^dR/SW[i`°[V
G
\-8IJ\8R?`
&(' ?)&+*