Ad hoc communication between intelligent vehicles

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00126674

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00126674

Submitted on 30 Jan 2007

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Ad hoc communication between intelligent vehicles

Laurent Bouraoui, Philippe Jacquet, Anis Laouiti, Michel Parent, Laurent Viennot

To cite this version:

Laurent Bouraoui, Philippe Jacquet, Anis Laouiti, Michel Parent, Laurent Viennot. Ad hoc communi-

cation between intelligent vehicles. 5th International Conference on ITS Telecommunications - ITST

2005, Jun 2005, Brest, France. �inria-00126674�

(2)

-". /0%132547689/0:. 89/;=<>@?;BAC;CD&DE1GF9.IH3JK/1L43<NMO2;BP-#.I89/;B4:;Q<RS;CHT?1LA">. 0%13254U<V-". /0%13254W;B13228I4

XY7Z[X\M]Z8^HLJ_/&132HL89/0%43<N6+>a`cb9d^<Ne f&`cd gh-"1ji?&13P:2.ckli1Lm1onE<EpN0:. 2HL1

q@rs. ;BAQtvuwD?;BAC;CD&DE1Ixy:. HLJK/1L43<z. 2&;CP3x{A|.I89/;B4:;=<{rh;BHT?&13AQx{D}. 0%13254U<{A|.I/0:1L2K43x{WO;C1L228 4L~I;B20:;B.&x0

_&}@

7Qow: BV=TQs"S¡ ¢£o¤

T¥c¦T9T£T¥U£ :o§@ jV=G}vw¥c¨©*ª&«UQ

% =T\B\¥B¥cQa C=T{¬%CB©o® ¯G=T°T§

©±T=²oo C°³T9³ ´¡T:ª^µo¥c=TC3µ3® ¶9w

T9·¡ ¸ BV=TQhV@\¥c|j T¢¦\´¦°U¹

T¥cI¹QB¹T9% \+B¹sQ«UQT3µ3jºC¥U@

|´¦BQ»+ %µL+ T¼Q«3"9½®¿¾¦w 3µ

Ta!Q¦=«LB§¼T£! ÀvwÁ% T\£TC¹TÂ9Q

|!¤SI¸|!T{+Tl BV=§¼T9ÃTvw

% \+B¹S9Q¸¦¤GI*¦h¸\£T\¥¤\¡

°U¹®¢Ä 7[}Q=¥c=Å7°\©T=§

cÅÁo|±TÆ"¥U¹=T¥c±¤!oT9Ç ²VT©³|

T°T·¤T9T}¹TvÃTs¥Q!Tj\¹¤%® ¶9cÅQ

o\¹¤hBV·¥c{B¹\* =|:TÈ[ h¦\´¦°U¹

T¥cI¹QB¹ ®À¯¢ÉNÊÄUË! owG \¹§£

Ä¯¢ÉVÊ&ÄcË T@:T¬:[ \¹®

ÌÍ3Î5Ï*ÐIÑTÒ^ÓLÔCÉNÊÄUË§IÄ¯¢ÉVÊ&ÄcË§I¯¢ÉVÊ&ÄcË§9¦{µ3

°U¹§E¦\´¦°U¹+T¥cI¹QB¹ ®

Õ Ö3×SØÙÚÛ¼ÜlÝÞØÖcÚ×

ß¦àáQâwãäQã%åã%à3á+æLã%çoäQèé+êoëwìzízãOîìzäQãízã%èQèåêoé+é*ïàwìzå%çTáQìêLà

âçðoã¨ñwäQêoòLä=ã:è=è=ã%ó[îì{áQâòoìÅçà3á"íÅçñè%ôEõöâwã@é+êLëwìízã*çLó7âêUå

àwãáîêoäQ÷cèNø¹ùjú#û#üEõ"ý_çoíízêTî¸âwìzòoâwízæ¨ëwä=ê3çoócëIçàó¨åêLé+é*ïcþ

àwìÅåçTáQìêLàèNëIçoè=ã%ó+êoà[âwìòLâè¡ñ ãã:ó£äçoócìzê*åêLé+é*ïwàwìÅåçá=ìzêoàè

è¡ïIåâÿçLè ì çàólßüVüEü wô ãLôcìàåã¢á=âãhäQçLócìzê

äQçoàwòoã:è ê(è¡ïIåâízìàw÷cè+çäQã[ìzàsòoãàãäçíVìzàsìàUðoã%äQè=ãvïwàIå\þ

á=ìzêoàhê"íìzàw÷¢åçoñçoåì{áæ &ówæ3àIçé+ìzå[ìà3áQãäQàçíEä=êLïcá=ìzàwòGìÅèç

ä=ã3ïwìäQãé+ã%àLá7ìà¼êLäQówãäáQêçLåâwìã%ðoãjçhñIã%ä=é£çàãà3áOåêoàcþ

àwã%åá=ìzðUì{áæLôêLïcá=ìzàwòìzè^á=âãVáçoè=÷êwá=âãEìzà3á=ãäQàwãá&ñwäQêáQêcåêoí

çàóáQâwã#ß¦à3á=ã%ä=àãáEüVàwòoìzàwãã%ä=ìzàwò@õ&çoè=÷wêLäQåã øvßüEõý}âçoè

èáçàóçäócì%ã%óÞðoã%ä=æãåìzãà3áñwä=êoá=êcåêLízè@è=ïåâhçLè

¨çoàó ú!"#

¨ìàáQâwãjîêoäQ÷Uìàwò¸òLä=êLïwñ ùGú#û(üVõ¨ô

õöâwã%è=ãGñwäQêáQêcåêoíÅè+ãàIçëwízãjç¢îìzä=ã%íã:è=èéêLëwìzíãGàãáîêoäQ÷Uè

é£çoócãÞê$*âãá=ã%ä=êLòoã%àwãêLïè[é+êLëwìízã¸åçàlèáçæ¼åêLàwàwã%åá=ã:ó

ëUæ+á=âwã@è=ìé+ñwízã@åêoà3áQìàUïwìáæ£ê$KáQâwã¨ðTçäQìêLïèäQçLócìêäQçoàwòoã:èô

üNðLãäQæá=êLñIêLíêLòoæåâIçàwòLã%è çoä=ãé+êLàwì{áQêoäQã%óÞìzàhä=ã:çí}áQìé+ã

çàó[á=âã@ä=êLïcá=ìzàwò+ñwäQêá=êcåêoí9ïwñ9ówçTáQã%èìzàä=ã:çí9á=ìzé+ãoô

cìàåãöá=âwãäQã%è=êoïäQåãEê9åêoé+é*ïwàìzå%çTá=ìzêoàìÅèðoãäQæ*èQåçoäQåã

åêLéñIçäQã%óá=êîìzä=ã:ó@àwãáîêoäQ÷cè%êLàwãVâçLèKáQê#ë ãöðoãäQæ¨åçäQãþ

vïwí&ìàáQâwã*ëIçàócîìÅóUáQâGîçLèáQãoô&êoä#ã%'wçé+ñwízã@á=âwã*á=êLñIêLí{þ

êoòLæé+êoàì{áQêoäQìàwòìzèízìé+ìá=ã:ó¢á=êÞìáQè+èáQä=ìÅå\á+é+ìàìéïwé è¡ê

á=âçá#áQâwã*áQêoñ êoízêoòLæOåâçoàwòoã:è#ócêUã:è(àêáè=îöçé+ñá=âãàwãá¡þ

îêoäQ÷£îì{áQâ7áQêUêéïåâåêLàLáQä=êLí á=äç(åô)(àOá=âwã åêoïwà3áQãä=þ

ñçoä¡áVìáEìÅèVçoízè=ê àwã%ã%ócã:óá=âçáVáQâwã"áQäQç$£å"ê$_ówçáQç ócã%íìzðoã%ä=æ

ë ã£êoñcáQìé+ì*ã%ó¸ìzà¢êoäócã%ä¨á=êGèQçðoã+ëçàIócîìzócá=âKô+wïwä=á=âwã%ä¡þ

é+êoäQã"îâwã%à£á=âwãè=çoé+ã#ìzà,vêoäQé£çTá=ìzêoà£âIçoè}áQê*ë ã(ócã%íìzðoã%ä=ã:ó

á=êè¡ã%ðoãäçí"ówã%è¡á=ìzàçTáQìêLàá=âwã%ä=ãìÅè[ç¢òLä=ã:çTáñ êáQãà3á=ìÅçí(ê$

ïè=ãízã%èQèówïwñwízìzå%çTá=ãOáQäQçoàè¡é+ìÅè=è=ìzêoàèëIãáîEã%ãàá=âwãé+êoëwìzízã

àwêcócã:è%LîçLèáQìàwò@é+êLä=ã"ëIçàócîìÅóUáQâKôß¦à+á=âwìÅèVå%çoè=ãì{áìzèVìàcþ

á=ã%ä=ã:èáQìàò£á=êOé*ïwíá=ìÅåçLèá(á=äçàè=é+ìzèQè=ìêLàè ø-väQêoéêLàwã*àêUówã

á=ê*é+çoàUæàwêcócã:èQý}á=âçáVáç÷oã:èVçLócðTçà3áQçoòoãê$5áQâwã#ìzàwâwã%ä=ã%à3á

ëwäQêLçLówåçLèáöàçTáQïwäQãê^äçoócìzêá=äçàè=é+ìzèQè=ìêLàèô

.}çñ ãä+ìà3áQä=êcócïåã%è+áQâwãGçññwíìÅåçá=ìzêoàçàósìzé+ñwíã%é+ãàcþ

áQçá=ìzêoà£êKé*ïwíá=ìÅåçLèá/vêoäVìzà3á=ã%ä¡þ|ðoã%âwìzåíã(åêoé+éïwàwìÅåçTáQìêLàè%ô

õöâwãñwíÅçàjêNê$NáQâwã+ñçñ ãäìÅè#áQâwãvêoízíêTîìzàwòô¨ß¦àÞç0äè¡á

ñçoä¡áöîEãîìzíí9ëwäQìã%1æ£ñwäQã%è=ãà3áQèEáQâwã(ðTçoä=ìzêoïèçññwíìÅåçá=ìzêoàè

á=âIçTá"åçoà7ë ãàwã%wáväQêoé ìzà3á=ãä=þ|ðoãâìzåíãé*ïwíá=ìÅåçLèá2vêoäã%'3þ

çé+ñwízã@áQâwã*ócìÅèáQä=ìzëwïcáQã%óOáQãízãþCá=äç(å¨ìàvêoäQé+çá=ìzêoàKôöõöâwã%à

îã(îìzíí^ócã%èQåäQìë ãìàé+êoäQãówãáQçoìí9áQâwã@äQêoïcáQìàwò+çàIó[éïwí{þ

á=ìÅåçLèáEñwä=êoá=êcåêLízèNëçoè=ã%ó+êLà3,ñwäQêáQêcåêoí4áQâçTáöçñwñíæ

á=êðLãâwìÅåízã£åêoé+éïwàwìÅåçTáQìêLàè%ôÞã5àwìÅè¡âÞáQâwã£ñçñ ãä@ëUæ

ñwäQã%è=ãà3á=ìzàwòè¡êLéã(ã'cñ ãäQìé+ãà3áöä=ã:è¡ïí{áè%Uçàó7åêLàåízïócìzàwòô

6 7 Ü98EØÖcÝ;:=<Ø :?>@>A8*ÖcÝ;:jØjÖwÚh×B<

C

Ú¢Ù Ö3×SØADÙFEHGIDJ·ÖwÝ;8KDA< ÝhÚL7ME

7 Ü·×·ÖwÝ;:GØÖcÚ×N<

ß¦àÀáQâwìÅè¢è¡ã:å\á=ìzêoàÁîEãsñwäQã%è=ãà3áÞáîEêlñIê3è=è=ìzëwíãsé*ïí{áQìzå%çoè¡á

çññwíìÅåçá=ìzêoàè%ÔO"(ìzè¡á=äQìzëwïcá=ã:ó áQãízãþCá=äç(å ìzà,vêLä=é£çTáQìêLà

øP"õöß¡ýQIçàóRã%éêoá=ã¨ðUìzè=ìzêoàOêoàâwìzòoâUîçæcèçñwñíìÅåçá=ìzêoàKô

SUTWV

ÛIXZY[,\]XW^`_&[2ab [,adcWaeEH[,\fhgji XWk!lnmo\]pqfE

[Xrm)kts:Û¼ØÖ,u

v ãà3áQäQçoíì*ã:ójáQãízãþCá=äç(å£é£çàIçòoã%é+ãà3á*ìzàhòoã%àwãäçíNñä=êoþ

ðUìzówã%èíêTî²ïwñ óçTá=ã:ósìà,vêLä=é£çá=ìzêoàçoëIêLïcá+á=äç(åOåêoàIócì{þ

á=ìzêoàIè[êLàá=âwãÞä=ê3çoówè%ôxw#ãäQãGîEãñwäQêoñ êLè=ãá=âçáOçoà·çñcþ

ñwízìzå%çTáQìêLà[ëçLè¡ã:óêoàOçoó7âwêcå#àãáîêoäQ÷3ìzàwòçàó7ñIã%ãäQTñ ãã%ä

çäåâwìá=ã:å\á=ïä=ãEñwä=êTðUìÅócã%è&ç(éêLä=ãEïwñ9ówçTáQã%óåêoé+ñwízãé+ã%àLááQê

ã'cìÅèáQìàò*áQãízãþCá=äç(å#é£çoàçòLãé+ãà3áEëUæ[è=âçoä=ìzàwò*ïñ ówçá=ã:ó

ìzà,vêoäQé£çTá=ìzêoà_ô

õöâwãjåçoäQèëwïwìzízóìzà,vêoäQé£çTáQìêLà ñçòLãGçë êoïcááQâwãìzä[ízêþ

åçoíá=äç(åjêLà¼áQâwãäQêLçLó¼ñ êoä=á=ìzêoàè[á=âãæ áQäQçðLãíêoà·ëUæ

åêLé+ñçäQìàò·ócãàIè¡ìáæ£è=ñIã%ã%óÀðLã%åá=êoäèjçoàóÀízêcåçoíì*%çá=ìzêoà

ê$¨àwã%ìòLâ3ë êoäQìzàwò¢åçäè%ô¼õöâwãñçòLã%è£çoä=ãówçá=ã%ósìzàá=âwã%ìä

ówçáQçëIçoè=ãoôy#(ìzç"ç"ñIã%ãäQTñ ããä&çñwñíìÅåçá=ìzêoà¨êoà*ç"éêLëwìzíãVçLó

âwêcåàwãáîêoäQ÷cè(á=âwã%æè=âçäQã£çàóÞïwñ9ówçTáQã+á=âwã%ìä*ìà,vêLä=é£çþ

á=ìzêoàówçáQçëIçoè=ã7ëUæhïwñ9ówçá=ìzàwòÞá=âwã%ìä£ìzà,vêoäQé£çTáQìêLàñçoòoã:è

(3)

é£çàIçòoã%é+ãà3á"ìzè#ócêoàwã*êoàç+ñIã%ä(åêoàwàwã:å\áQã%óåêLéñ êoàãà3á

ëçLè¡ìÅè%ô õöâwìzèîöçæ[áQâwã+ïè=ãäîìízíòoãáá=âãé+ê3èáïwñ óçTá=ã:ó

ìzà,vêoäQé£çTáQìêLà¸çoëIêLïcá áQâwãìzäè=ïwäQä=êLïwàócìzàwòä=ê3çoóÞñ êoä=á=ìzêoàè%ô

v

ízã%çoä=ízæá=âãåízêLè=ãä@ìÅè¨á=âwã£äQêLçLóGñ êoä=á=ìzêoàÞá=âã£éêLä=ã+ïwñwþ

ówçá=ã:óîìzízíNëIãá=âwã£ìzà,vêoäQé£çTáQìêLàKôõöâwãè=ñIã%ã%ó¸çTá îâwìÅåâ

áQâwãöìà,vêLä=é£çá=ìzêoàîìízícñwäQêoñçoòLçTáQãVìÅèvïwàå\áQìêLà+ê$Iå%çä}ócãàwþ

è=ì{áæøvêoàçízí9ízçoàwã%èýçàó7ê$&åçäè=ñIã%ã%ó5ô}ß^á=âwã@é+êLëwìízã¨çoó

âwêcå£àãáîêoäQ÷âçoè çòLìzçoà3á*åêoààwã%åá=ã%ó¸åêoé+ñIêLàwãà3á_áQâwã

ìzà,vêoäQé£çTáQìêLà îìízí#ë ãè=ñwäQã%çoó çoíé+ê3èáìzàè¡áQçà3áçàwã%êoïè=íæLô

#áQâwãäQîìzè=ãáQâwã#ìzà,vêoäQé£çTáQìêLà£îìízíIé+êTðLã#çTáEç*è¡ñ ãã:óçàUæ3þ

âwêTîSé*ïåâ3¹çoè¡á=ã%äá=âçoàå%çäè=ñIã%ã%óÞøvé£çTáQâwãé£çTáQìzå%çízíæ[êoà

äQêoïwòLâGé+êcócãíÅè"áQâwã+è¡ñ ãã:óGìÅè îâwã%ä=ãOìzè#á=âwã+åçoä

ócã%àè=ì{áæ ìzèEáQâwã¨äQçLócìêäQçoàwòoãçàó ìzèáQâwã@çðoã%äQçoòoã"åçoä

è=ñIã%ã%óýô

SUT4S

Ù?adpqm [,aXZY2Xrm)k m)k!X;fY

ô v çäèöçàóOã%è=ñ ã%åìÅçízízæ£á=äQïå÷cèâçðoãðUìzócã%ê£åçé£èöîâwìÅåâ

áç÷oã vêoäQîçoäQóçàIó ëçoå÷UîöçäóháQäQç$åô ùGçæUë ãGíÅçTá=ã%äQçoí

áQäQç$£åvêLä åäQêLèQè#äQêLçLówèôõöâwã+é*ïwíá=ìzé+ã%ócìÅçè¡á=äQã%çé£è¨çäQã

è=âçäQã%óOìzàjç+ñ ñîçæ Iè=ê+á=âçá(åêLàwàwã%åá=ã:óåçäè"å%çàGçoåþ

åã%èQèá=êçàUæäQã%çíáQìé+ã+ðUìzówãêèáQä=ã:çé£è%ôõöâwìÅè¨îöçæïè¡ã%ä

å%çàðUìä=á=ïçoíízæ %êUêoé vêLä=îöçäó[á=âwã@áQäQç$å@åêoàIócì{áQìêLàè%ôEß

áQâwã+á=äQïå÷cèëwíêcå÷áQâwã£ðUìã%îÁçoàìzà3á=ãízízìòLãà3á@ð3ìÅócã%êOé£çoàcþ

çoòoãé+ã%àLá å%çàówìzè=ñwíÅçæá=âwãáQä=ïå÷cè¨çoè¨ìVáQâwãæîEã%ä=ãâçoí

áQäQçoàè¡ñIçäQãà3á#è¡ê+áQâçTá#á=âwã@áQäQç$å@ðUìã%îlâìzówówãàëUæ[áQä=ïIå÷

ëwïwá[çàUæUâwêTî²ëwäQêLçLówåçLèáQã%óë3æhá=âwãáQä=ïå÷åçàsë ãGè¡ã%ãà

áQâwä=êLïwòoâá=âwã7á=äQïå÷9ôLUïå%åã:è=è=ìðLã[áQä=ïIå÷Uèåçoàë ã7é£çLócã

âçoí&á=äçàIè¡ñçoä=ã%à3áEáQâwã è=çoé+ãîöçæoô

>jÙÚØhÚsÝÚ 8<

UTZV

Ø&a Ú![,XZp X adbt8 XZk! </[,fh[,aÃÙ m/_[ E

XZk!sTÚL8<Ù=u

õöâwãK¼ñwäQêáQêUåêoí ìzèöñIçä=á=ìÅåïwíÅçäQíæ+çoóçñcáQã%ó£áQêówãàè=ã

èQåã%àçäQìê3èöîâwãäQã àwêcócã:è#çoä=ã@é+êoëìízã*çàIóówçTáç+á=äç(å¨ìÅè

ócã%àè=ã+çoàóé*ïwíá=ìþ|ówìäQã%åá=ìzêoàçoíBô+õöâwã ,ÁñwäQêáQêUåêoíìÅè

ëçLè¡ã:ó+êoàç@ëä=ê3çoówå%çoè¡áNêoñcáQìé+ì*%çTáQìêLàåçoíízã%ó+ùïwíá=ì.êoìzà3á

ã%ízçæÇø¹ù ./#ý "

|ôÂüNðLãäQæ¼àwêcócãhã%íã:å\áQèjì{áèjù ./Âè¡ãá

îâwìÅåâ ìÅèç#è=ïwëè=ãá^êcá=âwãàwêcócã$#è^àwãìzòoâUë êoäQâwêUêcóá=âçá&êLñcþ

áQìé£çízízæåêTðoã%äQèáQâwã àwêcócã$#è"áîEêoþCâwêLñàwãìzòoâUë êoäQâwêUêUó_ø¹è=ãã

òLïwäQã&:ýô^õöâwãù .)¢è=ãá&ìzè_ðoãäQæ¨è¡é£çízíLåêoé+ñçoä=ã:ó#áQê"áQâwã

àwã%ìòLâUëIêLä^è=ì%ãoôKß&%('NìzèKá=âwãè¡ì*ãNêcá=âwãù .)¢è=ãá&çàó)%

ìÅèNáQâwã(è=ì*ã"ê5á=âwã(àwãìzòoâUë êoäQâwêUêUó+Uêoàã"âçoè*%('!+%

-,/.

ìzàè¡ìzé*ïwíÅçTáQìêLàèçàIó0%('1+ íêLò% ìàè=êoé+ã¨éêcócã%ízè%ô

âwãàhçàêUówãîçoà3áQèá=êjëwä=ê3çoówå%çoè¡á çà¸ìàvêoäQé+çá=ìzêoà

áQê+á=âwã@ã%àLáQìäQã¨àwãáîêoäQ÷e3á=âwã vêLíízêTîìàòâIçñwñ ãàè%Ô

LôEáQâwã àwêcócã*ëwä=ê3çoówå%çoè¡áQèEá=âã ñçoå÷Lãáöá=ê[ì{áèàwãìzòoâUë êoä=þ

âê3êcó32

wôöõöâã+ù@.)"èê$Eá=âwã+àwêcócã+äQãíÅçæOá=âwã+ñçLå÷oãáá=êOáQâwã

áîê+âwêoñàwã%ìòLâUëIêLäQè42

" ôöõöâã ù .)Sê$&á=âwã ù@.)Sä=ã%ízçæçoàóè¡êvêoä=á=â

multipoint relays of node m m

&ìòLïwäQãLÔ}ùïwíá=ìzñIêLìà3á#äQãíÅçæcèVê&àwêcócã65

ß¦àá=âwã(ízçLèáEè¡áQçá=ã%éã%à3áEìáEé*ïIèáVë ã#àêá=ã:ó+á=âIçTáVáQâwã"äQãíÅçæ

ìÅèOócêoàwãïwñ êoà áQâwã äè¡á7äQã%åã%ñcá=ìzêoàdUvïwä¡áQâwãäOäQã%åã%ñcá=ìzêoà

çoä=ãócìÅèQåçäócã:ó5ôsõöâãäQãvêoäQãOì@çÞàwêcócãìàsáQâwãàwãáîêoäQ÷

äQã%åãìzðoã:è5á=âãEñçLå÷oãádvêoä^á=âã)äè¡á_á=ìzé+ã)väQêoéÀç#àwêoàù .)

è=ãízã%åá=êLäàwêcócãá=âwã%àOìá#ócêUã%è"àwêáäQãíÅçæì{á:ô

õöâwãàUïwéëIã%ä ê$öäQãá=äçàIè¡é+ìÅè=è=ìêLàèìzè ã'cñIã:å\áQã%óÞá=êë ã

äQã%ówïåã:ó@ëUæçU¹çLå\áQêoä87:9

7

åêLéñIçäQã%ó(á=ê#á=âwãåíÅçoèQè¡ìÅåh1êUêcóUþ

ìzàwò¸îâwã%ä=ãçízíàwêcócã%è+äQãáQäQçoàè=éìáQè*á=âãGè=çoéãOìzà,vêoäQé£çTþ

áQìêLàKô

TS 7 _!cr[,XZief Y[(`\m [,miem)cWY

õöâãäQãçäQã@áîê7åízçLè=è=ã%è#ê$Né*ïí{áQìzå%çoè¡á(ñwäQêáQêUåêoíÅè"ã:çoåâê$

áQâwãé åêLä=äQã%è=ñIêLàócìzàwòá=êócìÅèáQìàIå\á#èQåãàIçäQìê3èÔ

;

õöâwã@ïwàwìvêoäQé²èQåãàIçäQìê

;

õöâwã@íêcå%çízì%ã%óOè=åãàçoä=ìzê

ß¦à·á=âwã¸ócã%àè¡ãÞè=åãàçoä=ìzê]"á=âwãÞé*ïwíá=ìÅåçLèáOòoäQêoïwñ·ìzè7ïwàwìþ

vêLä=é+ízæOówãàè=ã ìzàá=âwãîâwêoízã àwãáîEêLä=÷9ôöß¦àá=âìzèåçLè¡ã@áQâwã

wùA,ÿø4Uìé+ñwízã#ùïí{áQìzå%çoè¡á ,#ý&ñä=êoá=êcåêLícîìízíwá:ô

wùA,³è¡ìzé+ñwízæhïè=ã%è*á=âwã+1êUêcócìzàwòjðUìÅçù ./ àwêcócã

çoñwñwízìzå%çTáQìêLàè íá=ãäöáQâwã@ìzàåêLéìzàwò£ñçLå÷oãáQè¨ø¹è=ã%åá=ìzêoà0<3ý\ô

ß¦àá=âãjízêUå%çízì%ã%óèQåãàIçäQìê VáQâwãjéïwí{áQìzå%çoè¡áòoäQêoïwñìÅè

òLä=êLïwñ ã%ó¢ìzàðTçäQìzêoïèíêcå%çTá=ìzêoàIèçoàóhçäQã7çoëè=ãà3áìzàháQâwã

é+ê3èáêáQâwãäOñçä=áê$ áQâwãàãáîêoäQ÷ ôÇß¦à¼áQâwìÅèåçoè=ãGáQâwã

ù;,¼øBùïwíá=ìÅåçLèáo,#ý5ñwä=êoá=êcåêLíîìzíí wá%ÔKá=âwãEé*ïwíþ

áQìzå%çoè¡áNòoäQêoïwñëwïwìzíÅówèNç@è=ñçàwàìàwòáQä=ã%ãëçoè=ã%óêoà£è=âwêoä=á=ã:èá

ñIçTá=âçoàó+ù .)#èôõöâwãñwäQêáQêUåêoíçLå\áQìðTçTáQã%è}ç@è=é£çízíè¡ïëcþ

è=ãáOê$@äQãíÅçæUè£á=âçáOåêTðLãäèá=âwãÞçäQã%ç¸êáQâwãjéïwíá=ìÅåçoè¡á

òLä=êLïwñKôöõöâçTá(îçæ£áQâwã*äQãáQäQçoàè=éìÅèQè¡ìzêoàè/vêLä"á=âìzè#é*ïwíá=ìþ

å%çoè¡á&òLä=êLïwñ*ócêLà#á}ç>= ã:å\á&á=âwãöêoá=âwã%ä&ñIçä=áQè^ê$áQâwãàwãáîêoäQ÷

øBè¡ã:å\áQìêLà@?Lý\ô

A <U7 ÚL8<Ù ÛID@<(ÝÙÖ>ÞØjÖwÚh×

wùA,ÿìÅè"çáQäQçoàè¡ñ êoä=áñwäQêá=êcåêoí vêLäé*ïwíá=ìÅåçLèá(åêoéþ

éïwàwìÅåçá=ìzêoàhìzàhé+êoëwìzízãOçLóUþCâêUåàwãáîêoäQ÷cèø¹ùGú(û#üEõèQýô

ß|á"ìÅèöîãízí_è¡ïì{áQã%ó[á=ê£íÅçäQòoã¨çàóOócãàIè¡ã¨é+êoëwìzízã@àwãáîêoäQ÷cè%

çLèöá=âã@êoñcáQìé+ì*%çTáQìêLàçoåâwìzãðLã%ó7ïè¡ìzàwò+áQâwã ù .)#èîEêLä=÷cè

îãízíìàjá=âwìÅèåêoà3áQã'Uá¨çoàóîâwã%ä=ãé*ïwíá=ìÅåçLèá¨òoäQêoïñè#çoä=ã

àêáEè=ñIã:åìIåçoíízæíêcåçoíì*ã:ó5ôõöâwãízçoä=òLãäNçoàó+é+êoäQã"ócãàè=ã

ç¸àãáîêoäQ÷ Vá=âwãé+êLä=ãêoñwá=ìzéì*%çá=ìzêoà åçoàë ãGçoåâìã%ðoã%ó

(4)

cùAh, ïè¡ã:è+âwêoñwþCëUæ3þCâêoñsä=êLïcá=ìzàwò]EìBôãoô·ã%çoåâàwêcócã

ïè=ã%èöìáQèízêcåçí5ìzà,vêLä=é£çTáQìêLà[áQê+ä=êLïcá=ã¨ñçLå÷oãáèô

wùA,±ìÅè£îãízí(è=ïwìá=ã%ó vêLä[àwãáîEêLä=÷cèHEîâãäQãá=âwã

á=äç(åsìzèhäQçoàócêoé çoàó!è¡ñ êoäçoówìzåsë ãáîããàoè=ãðLãäçí

àwêcócã%è#äQçá=âwã%ä"áQâçàGë ãìzàwòOçízéê3èá(ã'wåízïè=ìðLãízæ7ë ãáîãã%à

ç+è¡é£çízíKè=ñIã:åìIå@è¡ãá"ê$&àwêcócã%è%ô

wùA,sé+ìzàwìé+ì*ã:èá=âwãêTðLãäQâwã%çLó väQêoéx1êUêUówìàwò@ê

ëwäQêLçoóåçoè¡áóçTáQç[á=äç(åëUæGïè=ìàwòOêoàíæGè=ãízã%åá=ã%óàwêcócã:è%

åçoíízã%ó¢ù ./"èH^áQêGäQãá=äçàIè¡é+ìá á=âwê3è¡ã7ówçTáçwôGõöâwìÅè@áQã%åâcþ

àwìLïãè=ìòLàwìIåçoàLáQíæ¨äQã%ócïIåã%è^áQâwãEàUïwéëIã%äê$äQãáQäQçoàè¡é+ìÅèþ

è¡ìzêoàIèöä=ãLïìäQã%óá=ê51êUêcóçé+ã:è=èQçòLã#áQêçízí5àwêcócã%èöìzàOá=âwã

àwãáîêoäQ÷9ô³ú(å\á=ïIçízíæ ìáGìÅèOá=âwãhèQçé+ãá=ã%åâàwì*3ïwã¢ïIè¡ã:ó

ëUæIh, á=êL1êUêcó ì{áè7åêoà3á=äQêoí(é+ã%èQè=çoòoã%èá=ê¢áQâwãÞãàcþ

á=ìzä=ã(àwãáîêoäQ÷+ìàOçà7êoñcáQìé+ì*ã%ó[é£çàwàwã%ä%ô v êoàIè¡ãLïãà3á=ízæ

cùAh,·ócêUã:èöàwêáöàwãã:ó7çoàUæçoówócìá=ìzêoàIçí5åêLàLáQä=êLíIé+ã:èþ

è=çoòoã(á=ê£ã%àè¡ïä=ã¨ìáQè vïwàåá=ìzêoàwìzàwòIô

õöâãsè=ìé+ñwízãùïwíá=ìÅåçoè¡á¸ñwä=êoá=êcåêLíëIçoè=ã%ó êLà

øcù;,#ýìzèGè=ïwñwñ êLè=ã%óSáQê îEêLä=÷¼êLà çízí ðoã%äQè=ìêLàSê

,Kñä=êTðUìÅócã%ó ì{áå%çàÁçLååã%èQèjáQêSâêLè¡á¢è=æUé+éãá=äQìzå

àwãìzòoâUë êoäQâwêUêcóSçoàó·âêLè¡ájù .) è=ãízã%å\áQêoäízìzè¡áøvìCôã¸á=âwã

íìÅè¡á#ê$àwãìzòoâUë êoäèöá=âIçTá#âçðLã åâwêLè=ãà7á=âãåïä=äQãà3á"çàGçoà

ù .)(ý\ô

7 ÚL8<Ù ÛID@<(ÝÙÖ>ÞØjÖwÚh×

õöâwã ùïwíá=ìÅåçoè¡á (ñwá=ìzéì*ã:óO_ìàw÷OUáQçTáQã "êoïcáQìàwò

ø¹ùAh,#ý"ñwä=êoá=êcåêLí

<( áQço÷oã:è"ë ãàwã%wáê}á=âwãá=êLñIêLíêLòoæ

÷UàwêTîíã:ócòoãòLçá=âwã%ä=ã:óGëUæGáQâwã3 ñwäQêáQêcåêoíîìá=â¸ìáQè

õ_êLñIêLíêLòoæ v êoà3á=äQêoíNé+ã:è=èQçòLã%è@ã%'cåâIçàwòLã+á=êGëwïìíÅó¢é*ïí{þ

á=ìÅåçLèáá=äQãã:èôù;,²ìzè+ócã%ðoãízêoñ ã%óçoè+çàã'Uá=ã%àè=ìêLà

á=ê,@ôIß|áå%çàGîêoäQ÷cèãðLãàîâwã%àjàwêoá(çízí^àêUówã%èçäQã

é*ïwíá=ìÅåçLèá¨åçoñçëwízã ñwäQêTðUìzówã%óOá=âIçTá¨é*ïwíá=ìÅåçLèáàwêcócã%è(ê$þ

vãä^á=âwãé+ìàìé£çíUåêLàwàwã:å\á=ìzðUì{áæ¨ë ãáîãã%à@á=âwãöè=êoïwäåã:è_çàIó

á=âwãVéã%é*ë ãäèKê3áQâwãNéïwí{áQìzå%çoè¡á_òoäQêoïñKô_ú¢éïwí{áQìzå%çoè¡áKá=äQãã

ìzè ëwïwìzí{áçoàóÞé£çìzàLáçìzàwã%ó@vêoäçàUæá=ïñwíãø¹è=êoïwäåã _é*ïí{þ

á=ìÅåçLèá£òoäQêoïñIý ìzàçÞówìzè¡á=äQìëïcá=ã:óé£çààwãä£îìá=âwêLïcáçàUæ

åã%àLáQäQçoíKãà3áQì{áæçàóñä=êTðUìÅócã%è"è=âwêLä¡áQã%è¡á#ä=êLïcá=ã:èUväQêoé³á=âwã

è¡êLïwäåã£áQêGá=âã[é*ïí{áQìzå%çoè¡áòoäQêoïñ¢éã%é*ë ãäèôÞõöâwãáQä=ã%ã%è

çäQãEïñ ówçá=ã:ó+îâwãàwã%ðoã%äçáQêoñ êoízêoòLæ åâçàwòLãöìzè}ócãá=ã:å\á=ã:ó5ô

õöâã é*ïwíá=ìÅåçLèáêoñcáQìé+ì*ã:óíìzàw÷èáçTáQã ä=êLïcá=ìzàwòñä=êoá=êþ

åêLíNø¹ùAh,#ýë ãízêoàwò3èá=êá=âwã è=êoïäQåã(ëçLè¡ã:ó0¹çoé+ìízæoô}ß|á

é£çìzàLáçìzàèêoàwã¨éïwí{áQìzå%çoè¡áöá=äQãã¨ñIã%äöá=ïwñíã£ø¹è=êoïäQåãcé*ïí{þ

á=ìÅåçLèá}òoäQêoïñIý\ô&õöâwêLè=ãVáQä=ã%ã%è}çoä=ãêoàwízæ åêLé+ñIê3è¡ã:ó*êIé*ïí{þ

á=ìÅåçLèá(å%çñçoëwízã@àwêcócã%è%ôõöâwä=ã%ã èáQãñè(çäQã ócìÅèáQìàwòLïwìÅè¡âwã:ó5Ô

á=âwã#á=äQãã"ëïwìíÅócìzàwò]3áQâwã"áQä=ã%ã"é£çìzàLáQãàçoàåã 3çoàóá=âã"á=äQãã

ócãáçoåâwé+ã%àLá:ô}üVçoåâè¡á=ãñìÅèócãáçìzíã:óOìàç+è¡ïëè¡ã:å\áQìêLàKô

UTWV

Ø\aya ^`_!XZcWb`XWk!

(àåã"ç@è=êoïäQåãîöçà3áèá=ê*è=ãàIóóçTáQçáQê*ç@è=ñIã:åìIåöé*ïwíá=ìþ

åçLèá#òLä=êLïwñ ì{á¨è¡ã%àówè#ç+]! v ü v ^ú"ßùÂé+ã:è=èQçòLã

ãàçoëwízìàwòOàwêcócã:è(îâìzåâÞçäQãé+ãéëIã%äQèêVá=âìzèòoäQêoïñGá=ê

ócãáQã%åá ì{áè@ñwäQã%è=ãàåã+çoàójá=êGçTá=áQçLåâjáQâwãé£è=ãízðoã%èáQêOá=âwã

çoèQè¡êcåìzçá=ã%ó[é*ïwíá=ìÅåçLèááQä=ã%ãoô

õöâìzè}é+ã:è=èQçòLãìÅè 1êUêcócã:óîìá=âìà+áQâwã"çoóâwêcåöàwãáîEêLä=÷

ïè=ìàwòSá=âãsêLñcá=ìzé+ì%ã%óx1êUêcócìàò·áQã%åâwàwì3ïwãsê$h,@ô

Source_claim flooding Tree building with Confirm_parent message

Source multicast data Client group

Source group Mulitcast tree participant

^ìzòoïä=ãKcÔNõ^äQãã¨ëwïwìzízówìàwò£é+ã:åâçàwìÅè=é

äQçoàåâwã:èOçoä=ãÞëwïwìzíáGìà çsëçoå÷Uîöçäó é£çàwàãä:ÔsòLä=êLïwñ

é+ãéëIã%äQè*îâwìzåâócêGàwêoá÷UàwêTî!æoãáçë êoïcáá=âwìÅèè¡êLïwäQåã

á=äQæ¸á=ê¢çá¡áQçLåâháQâwãé£è=ãízðoã%èáQêjáQâwãåêoäQäQã%è=ñIêLàócìzàwòGáQä=ã%ã

ø¹è=ããòLïwäQã Lý\ô

ùêoäQãè¡ñ ã%åì åçízízæ&îâwãàhçòLä=êLïwñé+ã%é*ë ãä*äQã%åãìzðoã:è

ç0]` v ü v _ú"ßùaé+ã%èQèQçòoã@çoàóOì{á#ìÅèàwêoá#çízä=ã:çoócæ7ç

ñçoä¡áQìzåìñçoà3á(ê$}áQâwìÅèøBè¡êLïwäåã é*ïí{áQìzå%çoè¡áòLä=êLïwñIýáQä=ã%ã9ì{á

çTá=áQçLåâwã%è_ì{áè¡ã%íwáQê#áQâwã¨ø¹è=êoïwäåã :éïwíá=ìÅåçoè¡áòoäQêoïwñIý¦á=äQããNëUæ

ñwäQêcåãã:ócìzàwòçLè vêoízíêTî"è%Ô

;

ìáGíêUêL÷UèGìà3á=êáQâwãF äQêoïwá=ìzàwòsáQçëíã vêLäá=âwã

àwã%'Uá7âwêLñÁøvìCôãGá=âãñçoä=ã%à3á7ìzàLáQãäZ¹çoåãjçoówówä=ã:è=èý+áQê

äQã%çLåâGá=âãè¡êLïwäQåãOøvá=âwã3h,Çä=êLïcá=ìzàwò7áQçoëwíã£ñä=êoþ

ðUìÅócã%è^è¡âwêLä¡áQã%è¡á_äQêoïcáQã%è5áQê(çoííoá=âwãEàwêcócã%èý\ôõöâwìÅèKàwã%'3á

âwêLñ7ë ã%åêoé+ã%èöìáQè"ñçäQãà3áìàOáQâwã@é*ïwíá=ìÅåçLèáöáQä=ã%ãoô

;

õöâwã%àìá*è=ãàówè@ç

v

û`^ßr#ù .5ú!"üEû#õ éã:è=èQçòLã

áQêì{áè ñçoä=ã%àLá@àwêcócãLô7õöâwìÅè é+ã:è=èQçòLãìÅè è=ãà3á ïè=ìàò

áQâwã*åêLä=äQã%è=ñ êoàócìzàwòìà3áQãäZ¹çoåã¨áQêäQã%çoåâ7á=âìzè#àwãìzòoâcþ

ë êoä:ô

;

õöâwãñçoä=ã%àLáàwêcócãöäQã%åã%ìðUìzàwò"áQâwìÅèéã:è=èQçòLãçá¡áçoåâwã:è

ìáQè=ãí}á=ê£áQâwã7øBè¡êLïwäåã é*ïí{áQìzå%çoè¡á#òoäQêoïwñ ýá=äQãã IìNì{á

ìÅèöàwêá#çoíäQã%çLócæçñçä=á=ìÅåìzñçoàLáöáQê+á=âwìÅèá=äQããLô

õöâwã v û`&ßr"ù .5ú!#üVû#õhéã:è=èQçòLãVìÅè&âçàówíã:ó*âwêLñ

ëUæÁâêoñyOëUæÇìzà3á=ã%ä=é+ã%ówìzçá=ã¼éïwí{áQìzå%çoè¡áäQêoïcáQãäèhîâwìÅåâ

ëwïwìzíÅó[áQâwã åêLä=äQã%è=ñ êoàócìzàwòëwäçàåâKô

UTS

Ø\aya pqf XZk/[2ak&f k!iea

õöâwã³á=äQãã:èÃçäQã²ñ ãäQìêcócìÅåçoíízæÂä=ã%vä=ã:è¡âã%ó lëUæÂéã:çàè

ê$áQâwã=]` v ü v _ú"ßù é+ã:è=èQçòLã¼çàóÇáQâwã v ûþ

&ßr"ù .5ú`"üVû(õ é+ã%èQè=çoòoãoô&û"êoá=ìÅåã(á=âçáEáQêoñ êoízêoòoæ£çoàó

àwã%ìòLâ3ë êoä¨åâçoàwòoã:è#çäQãè¡á=ìzízíówãá=ã:å\áQã%óGëUæáQâwãã%'wåâçàwòLã

ê$ á=êLñIêLíêLòoæåêoà3áQä=êLícéã:è=èQçòLã%è}îâìzåâ+ìÅèVócêLàwã"àçá=ïwäçízíæ

ëUæA, ôKõöâ3ïIè%5áQä=ã%ã%èïwñ9ówçTáQã%è@çoä=ãá=äQìòLòoã%ä=ã:óGëUæá=âwã

ócãá=ã%åá=ìzêoàê5á=êLñIêLíêLòoæ+åâçàwòLã%èNçoàó3h, äQêoïcáQìàwò áQçTþ

ëwízã@ä=ãþ|å%çíÅåïwíÅçTáQìêLàKô

UT

Ø\aya b&a [,f i `pqadk/[

ßVç£àwêcócãîçoà3áQèöáQê[ízã%çðoã¨áQâwã*éïwíá=ìÅåçoè¡á#áQä=ã%ã*çàIóì{áìzè

ç ízã%ç$rLìáócãáçoåâwã:èNìáQè=ãíyvä=êLéÇá=âwã#á=äQããoÔìáïè¡áè¡ã%àówèç

(5)

ßì{áèöñçäQãà3áë ã%åêLé+ã%èçíã:ç(rwçoàóáQâwìÅèñçäQãà3áöìzèöàêá"ç

òLä=êLïwñé+ãéëIã%äHUìáöócãáQçLåâwã%èìáQè=ãíyvä=êLéÇá=âwãá=äQãã(êoà7ì{áè

áQïwä=à_ô

õöâwã _üVú#(ühéã:è=èQçòLã"ìÅèVñwäQêcåã:è=è=ã%ó+âwêLñëUæ+âwêoñ[çoàó

ïwàUïè=ã%óOëwäçàIåâwã%èöçäQã@ócãízãáQã%óçïwá=êoé£çá=ìÅåçízízæoô

D >ADÙsÖ 7 D×SØ <

ÞãñwäQã%è=ãà3á}àwêTîháQâwãä=ã:è¡ïí{áè^ê9è=êoé+ãöã'cñ ãäQìé+ã%àLáè}åêLàcþ

ócïIå\á=ã:óçáßû`ßúÇîì{áQâé+êLëwìízãðoãâìzåíã:èô õöâwãòoê3çí&ê$

áQâwìzèã%'cñIã%ä=ìzé+ãà3áQè&ìÅè_áQê¨éã:çoè=ïwäQãNá=âãöçðTçoìíÅçëwízãNáQâwäQêoïwòLâcþ

ñwïwá#ëIãáîEã%ãà7áîEê£åêoé+é*ïwàìzå%çTá=ìzàwò+ðoã%âwìÅåízã%èöîâwìzíã¨áQâwãæ

é+êTðoãáQêTîçoäQówèEã%çLåâ7êoá=âwã%ä%ô

UTZV

<ieadk&f \]XWmqb!adY2ie\]X![Xrm)k

êoä+êoïwä+ã%'Uñ ãäQìzéã%à3áîã7âIçðoã[ïIè¡ã:ó¢áîê

v

æcåçoëðLãâwìþ

åíã:èøBç v æcåçoëìzè¨ç0vêoïwä(îâwãã%íã:óGãízã%åá=äQìzå*ðoã%âwìzåíã*á=âçá

âçðLã¸ä=êLëIêoá=ìÅå¢çëwìzíìá=ìzã%èH çàIólåêoïwíÅólëIãä=ïwà vïwízízælçoïcþ

áQêoàwêLéêLïè=íæwý@çoàó¸êoàwã 'cã%ó¸îìzä=ã%íã:è=è*é£çoåâwìzàwãoôGüEçoåâ

ðLãâwìÅåízãâIçoèOç . ¼ócã%ð3ìÅåã¸çàIó¼çízìzà3ï'¼ëIê '¼äQïwàwìzàwò

h,ÃãéëIã:ówócã:ó5ô ã7âçðoãïIè¡ã:ó cô*ë¢å%çäówèKvêLä

îìzä=ã%íã:è=èåêoé+é*ïàwìzå%çTáQìêLàèô

õöâwãîìzä=ã%íã:è=è&é£çoåâwìzàwãöìÅèñwízçLåã:ó*ìzà*áQâwã"èQçé+ãöä=ê3çoó*çLè

áQâwãEðLãâwìÅåízã%èçá^âçoíIówìzè¡áQçoàåãìàêoäócãä_á=êä=ã%ízçæ(á=âãEáQäQç$þ

IåEë ãáîããà*á=âwã%éôúá&á=âãë ãòLìàìàwòê$á=âwãã'cñ ãäQìé+ãà3á

îããàIè¡ïwäQã+á=âIçTá@á=âãáîêOðLãâwìÅåízã%è*çäQã+áîEêâwêLñè çîöçæ

väQêoé!ã%çLåâêáQâwãäìzàá=ã%ä=é£èEê$_äQêoïwá=ìzàwò*âwêLñKô}õöâwãàdLáQâwãæ

è¡áQçoä¡á*äQïwàwìzàwòáQêTîçoäQówè¨ã:çoåâ¸êáQâwãäócïwäQìàwòè=ã%åêLàówè%ô

(àwã@ê^áQâwã@ðoã%âwìÅåízã%èè=ãàówè#çõ

v

.áQäQç$£åáQêá=âwã êoá=âwã%ä

ðLãâwìÅåízã[îâwìzízã7ìáé+êTðLã%è%ô@Þã[ïè=ã7ìzñ ãäZá=êUêoí vêoä+õ v .

áQäQç$£åòLãàwã%äQçá=ìzêoà7çoàó7á=âwäQêoïòoâwñwïwáöé+ã:çoè=ïwä=ã%é+ãà3áQè%ô

UT4S

Ù?adY2_`c[Y

&ìzòoïwäQã

"

è¡âêTî"è"áQâwã*áQâwäQêoïwòLâwñwïcávïwàåá=ìzêoàjêEócìÅèáçàåã

ë ãáîãã%àá=âwã áîEêäQïwàwàìàwò[ðoãâìzåíã:èôõöâwãócìzè¡áQçoàåã*ëIãþ

áîãã%àá=âwã*áîEê[ðoãâìzåíã:è"ìÅè#åêLàè=ìzócã%ä=ã:óçoè#àwãò3çTá=ìzðoã*ëIãþ

vêLä=ã@áQâwãæåäQêLèQèöã%çLåâêá=âãäIçàIóOá=âwã%àì{á#ìÅè#åêoàè=ìÅócãäQã%ó

çLè*ñ êLè=ì{áQìðLãoô "(ïwäQìàwòjá=âwãã%'Uñ ãäQìzéã%à3áîã[àwêoá=ìÅåã7á=âçá

áQâwã"áQâwä=êLïwòoâñwïcáEìÅèçTáEízã%çLèá ?$o÷Uëwñè%ô&õöâwìÅèNé+ã:çàèVá=âçá

îã¨âçoóåêLàwàwã:å\á=ìzðUì{áæ7ócïwäQìàwòáQâwã@âwêoízã¨á=äç ã:å\áQêoäQæoôõöâwã

áQâwä=êLïwòoâñwïcáìàåä=ã:çoè=ã%è[îâwãäQãGáQâwãócìÅè¡áQçàIåã¸ócã%åä=ã:çoè=ã%è

áQêä=ã:çoåâ¢çOé+ç$'cìéïwé ê

" ô?oùëwñè îâwãàÞá=âãðoã%âwìzåíã:è

çoä=ã£êLàwã£âwêoñhçîöçæRväQêoéaã%çoåâ¸êoá=âwã%äH&çàóÞáQâwãà¢ìáócãþ

åä=ã:çoè=ã%è&çòLçoìà*îâwìízãEá=âwãðoã%âwìzåíã:è&éêTðLãEçîöçæ!väQêoé ã:çoåâ

êoá=âwã%ä%ôû"êoá=ìÅåã"áQâçTáEìà[è¡áQçá=ìÅå"èQåãàIçäQìê3è%îã"êLëcáQçoìà£ë ãá=þ

áQãä@áQâwä=êLïwòoâñwïcá@ä=ã:è¡ïí{áè¨îâwãàÞá=âã£àwêcócã%è@çoä=ã+êoàãâêoñ

çîöçæ"ã%çLåâ¨êá=âãä:ôdÞãNã'cñwíÅçìzà¨á=âwìÅèKëUæ(á=âwãVízçLå÷#ê$cã%'3áQãä=þ

àçoíKçà3á=ã%àwàçLèôß¦à3¹çoå\áUá=âwã¨äQêoïcáQìàòë ê 'cã%èîEã%ä=ãñwíÅçoåã%ó

ìzàè=ìzócã¨áQâwã@ðoã%âwìÅåízã%è%ô

ÝhÚ×=8£ÝÞÜ <ÖwÚ×

ÞãÃñwäQã%è=ãà3á=ã:óáîê³éïwíá=ìÅåçoè¡áÀñwäQêáQêUåêoíÅèlëçoè=ã%óêoà

h,±ñwäQêá=êcåêoíöá=âIçTá7å%çà ë ãGïè=ã%óFvêoä7ìà3á=ã%ä¡þ|ðoã%âwìÅåízã%è

&ìzòoïwäQã

" Ô öçàówîìzóUáQâ

åêoé+é*ïàwìzå%çTáQìêLàèôaõöâwã äèáGêLàwãcùA ìÅèîãízí

è=ïwìá=ã:ó vêLä}ízçoä=òLãçàóócãàIè¡ãàwãáîEêLä=÷cè%ôKß|áVçoóówè}àwê¨ã'UáQäQç

êTðLãäQâwã%çLó çàó¢ïIè¡ã:è êoàíæLÃåêoà3áQä=êLíVìzà,vêoäQé£çTá=ìzêoà

ìzàêoäócã%äöá=ê[ócì=9ïè¡ãówçTáç+ñçoå÷LãáQè%ôVùAh,lìzè"á=âwãè¡ã:å\þ

êLàó¸ñwäQêáQêUåêoíCôß|á*ìzèócã%ówìzå%çTá=ã:óÞá=êGízêcåçoíì*ã:ó¢è=åãàçoä=ìzêLè

îâãäQãé*ïwíá=ìÅåçLèá£òoäQêoïñè+é+ãé*ë ãäè£çäQãè¡ìá=ïIçTá=ã:ósìà ç

vã%îÃíêcå%çTá=ìzêoàIèôGùAh,ÃëwïìíÅówèé*ïwíá=ìÅåçLèá áQä=ã%ã%èKvä=êLé

è=êoïäQåã%èáQê[òLä=êLïwñé+ãé*ë ãäè"ïIè¡ìzàwòáQâwã+è¡âwêLä¡áQã%è¡á#äQêoïcáQã%è

ñä=êTðUìÅócã%óëUæ@@ôeãâçðoãçíÅè¡ê[è=âwêTîàáQâwãä¡á¨äQãþ

è=ïwíáQèê$#á=âwäQêoïwòLâ3á=ñwïcá+é+ã%çLè¡ïwäQã%èìzàsçè¡ìzé+ñwíãèQåã%àçäQìê

îìá=â¸áîêé+êoëwìzízã£ðoãâìzåíã:èô[ùGêoäQã£ìà3á=ã%àè=ìðLã+á=ã%è¡áQè*çàó

é+ã:çoè=ïwä=ã:è"çäQã@ñwíÅçàwàã%óáQê[èáQïócæ7á=âwãëIã%âçðUìêLïwä"ê&áQâwã

ñä=êLñIê3è¡ã:óé*ïí{áQìzå%çoè¡áöäQêoïwá=ìzàwò*ñwäQêáQêcåêoí9îìá=âOé+êoëwìzíã¨ðLãþ

âìzåíã:èô

"}#"

% K.ô3çoåHLïãáH(.ôTùïwâíãáQçízãä(.ôùGìàwãáHú*ôçæUæUïwéR

ú ô^çêLïwì{áQì}õ¨ô v ízçoïè¡ã%ày Nôd#(ìã%àwàwêoáH¨É^ C¬:

ÊUsÄI¦T¦Ë#T¥cC3µö=T¦%¨ßüVõj& v "

å\á=êLëIã%ä!$

" ô

( v ô.ã%ä=÷Uìzàè%Lü"ô Eã%ízówìàwòoþ "êTæoãäçàIó09ô"çoèH#*:

ÉI´¹¾£T ¾*Å\| I¦TTºÉN¾w½Ë#T¥cC3µ

ßüVõ & v " ?

Lïwízæ3$

" ô

" ú ôçæUæUïwéRú*ô0_çoêoïwìá=ì4 Nô5##ìzãààwêá¢¯¥cB´

+%µLG·£o¤}=QG9CVT=TQ&w"ß v 5Ô

w#çîöçìcß¦à3á%ô v êoà,vã%ä=ã%àåãöêoà0Uæcè¡á=ã%é cåìã%àåã:è%Lçoàcþ

ïçäQæ3$ w(çîçoì cú ô

< ú ô _çêLïwìá=ì4h.ô&ùìàãáH

v

ôú#ó ìzâyo.ô LçLå%3ïwãáhVô

##ìzãàwàwêoáHU¯¥cC¹\VÉVÊ&ÄcË H#çñwñ êoä=á&ócãäQã%åâwã%äQåâwã

ßû!ßúN&þ<!$,