• Aucun résultat trouvé

Stability of the Krylov bases and subspaces

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "Stability of the Krylov bases and subspaces"

Copied!
25
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00074377

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00074377

Submitted on 24 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub-

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,

Stability of the Krylov bases and subspaces

Jean-François Carpraux, Sergei Godunov, S. Kuznetsov

To cite this version:

Jean-François Carpraux, Sergei Godunov, S. Kuznetsov. Stability of the Krylov bases and subspaces.

[Research Report] RR-2296, INRIA. 1994. �inria-00074377�

(2)

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Stability of the Krylov bases and subspaces

J.F. Carpraux, S. Godunov, S. Kuznetsov

N˚ 2296

1994

PROGRAMME 6

Calcul scientifique, mod´elisation et logiciel num´erique

(3)
(4)

./10/+2436587593;:<>=@?A/BDCFEG:HC6I>=J?A/AKL:MNHOQPRC6I

S@TU6V;TWQX!X!Y[Z]\ ^_Wa`cb8de`gfbihjYkelmhonqp6dY6rX!UsutY8`ohcfWQlvhwU;kxYl$`jU6VQhcbihjY8`kydXztYTmhcp6dY

SJTU6{mYl$|#`cW6s;hjk

}WQ~~FU6Til4seYDTYbi€YTbi€Y%kDe‚6‚6ƒ6Z\ „ƒ6ƒQ…]\†‚„[~FW‡V6Yf

ˆx‰Š‹ŒaFŽQ‹6$€Y!~TU6‘e`jYX’f]UQ“#kedX!YTmhcbWa`#WQkFWa`j”•f–h—f]˜$hjl€™`cWQTV6Yfm~FWQTfmYX’WQlTmhcb8Yf'hwkeš6UQ`jš6Y

UQ“›lYkœW]~TU;{–Yb8lmhjU6kUQ“@l€ehcf$X’WQliTmho’U6kelU!WžTi”6`jUQšŸfvd‘Ffm~FW6b8Y[lULU6‘lWNhwkœWLfmXWa`o`wYTX’WQlTmho

˜#€ehcbi€hcfdFfvYslUfmU‡`wš;Y4l€YhjkehjlmhcWa`>~TU6‘e`jYXœ u$€Y'fvd‘Ffm~FW6b8Y[seY~FYkFsfU6k!l€YX’WQlTvh1xWQkFs

U6kWQk¡WQT‘Tvhwl8WQT”œš;Yb8lU6T L¢£Yb8U6kFf¤hcseYTr+hjk¡l€ehcf~FWQ~FYTrWxX!Yli€U•s¥liUœfmldFse”¥l€Y’fml8WQ‘eho`w¦

hjlm”xUQ“@l€YžT”;`jUQšœfmd‘Ffm~FW6b8Y]l€TU6dV6€¥WLX’WQliTmhoŸ~GYTldT‘FWQlvhwU;kA #$€ehcf#X!Yli€U•sŸhwkFbi`jdFseYf]W

seY8nFkehjlmhjU6k§UQ“Al€Y'b8U;kFs;hwlvhwU;kxkydXL‘FYT8f@“›U6T$l€Y[b8U6X!~dlW‡lmhjU6k!UQ“>li€Y'žT”;`jUQš!‘FW6f¤hcf$WQkFsl€Y

žT”;`jUQš¨fmd‘Ffm~FW;b8Y6 4|©~T8W6b8lmhcbWa`X!Yl€Us“›U6TYfmlmhjX’WQlvhwkVxli€YfmYDkedXL‘FYTfhcf~TUQš;h—seYs ª¤l

hcf‘FW6fmYsxU;kxl€YDfmUQ`jdlmhjU6k§UQ“JW`—W‡TV6Y[lTmhcWQkV;de`—W‡T4fm”fmlYXœ 

«­¬y®A¯m°L±qŒQ²Š6žT”6`jUQš‘FW6f¤hcf4W‡kFsxfmd‘Ffm~FW6b8Y6r+^U6kFs;hjlmhjU6k§kydXL‘FYTar³6lWQ‘eho`ohjl–”6 

´¶µL·

¸m¹mº»

·

¸@¼@½w¹–¾À¿Á

(5)

¬•Š ¬ Yf]~TU6‘e`YX!Yf]sWQkFWa`j”fmY!kedXztYTvh—p;dY’Waš6Yb!seYfV6TWQkFseYfX’WQlTvh—b8Yf]b8TYdFfmYf

TYp;dehYTYkel’fmU;dš6YkyldkYœ~TU;{–Yb8lmhjU6k seYœb8YllY§X’WQlTmhcb8YœfmdTdk fmU6dFfv¦›Yfm~FW6b8Y¨seY¥žT”;`wUQš

~GU6dTDU6‘liYkehwTLdkY!XWQlTmhcb8Y!~e`jdFf]~FYlmhjlYdlmho`ohcfytYY!~GU6dTLTtYfvU6dFseTY[`jY~TU6‘e`YXYLhjkehwlvh—WN` Y

fmU;dFfm¦›Yfm~FW6b8Y[stY~GYkFs’seY`cW[X’WQliTmhcb8Y4Yl$sdk!š6Yb8lYdT$WQT‘ehjlTWNhwTiY6 #kfmY4~TiU6~FUyfvY$hcbih+smtYld¦

s;hjYT[`cW§fmlWQ‘eho`ohjl•tY!seYf‘FW6fmYfYlDfvU6dFfm¦›Yfm~FW6b8Yf[seYžT”6`jUQšx`jU6T8fp6dU6k¥~FYTldTi‘FYL`cWX’WQliTmhcb8Y6 

^YlilYLX Yl€UseY]hjkFbi`wdlLdkYxstY8nFkehjlmhjU6k¡sedb8U6kFs;hjlmhjU6kkYX!Ykelt seYf‘FW6fmYfYlDfmU;dFfm¦›Yfm~FW6b8Yf

seYLžT”6`jUQš #kx“›U6dTkehjl#dk¥Wa`jV6U6Tmhjl€X!YDseYDbWN`—b8de`seYb8Yfb8U6kFs;hjlmhjU6kkYX!YkelfrG‘FW6fetY[fmdT`cW

fmU‡`wdlvhwU;k¨sdk§V6TWQkFsxfm”fmlYX!YlTmhcWQkV6de`cWahjTY6 

±G‹Нެ _W;fmY[Yl4fmU6dFfv¦›Yfm~FW6b8YseYDžTi”6`jUQšqr^U6kFs;hjlmhjU6kkYX!Ykelr+³6lWQ‘eho`ohwltY6 

(6)

4f¤hjkV¡W™b8U6X!~dlYT!liU fvUQ`jš6YœW¥kedX!YTmhcbWa`4~TU;‘e`wYX§r@˜$Yx€FWš;YxlU¥YkFfmdTYxl€YœW6bb8d¦

TW;b8”’UQ“@l€Y]TYfmde`jl#‘e”œb8U6X!~dlmhjkV!l€YLb8U6kFs;hjlmhjU6kœkedXL‘FYTUQ“@l€Y[~TU6‘e`jYXœr h  Y6 lU!V‡hwš;YDW

X!YW;fmdTY!UQ“$l€Y’fmYkFf–hwlvhwš;hjlm”£UQ“_li€Y!TYfmde`jlDliUœWxsWQlW~FYTildT‘FWQlmhjU6kA +ª lhcf]˜$hjl€£l€ehcf]WahjX

l€FW‡l˜$Y4seYWa`r;hjk’l€ehcfu~FWQ~GYTr6˜$hjl€xW[XYl€U•sfmldFse”;hjkVLl€Y4b8U6kFs;hjlmhjU6kxkedXL‘FYT$UQ“>žT”;`wUQš

‘FW6f–h—fLWQkFs™fmd‘Ffm~FW6b8Y6 $€Y’žT”;`jUNšfmd‘Ffm~FW6b8Yf

r‘deho`jl]“¶TU;X WxX’WQliTmho WQkFs

WQkWQT‘ehjlTWQTi”xš6Yb8lU6T rAW‡TYLUQ“¶liYk¨dFfvYs§hjk£kydXYTmhcbWa` WQkFWN`w”f¤hcf[˜ hwli€¥`cWQTV6Y!fm~FWQT8fmY

X’W‡lTmhcb8Yf—„Nr …  ª kFseYYsr hjkœl€YfmY[~TiU6‘e`jYX’frG˜_Y[kYYs­lUL~TU6{mYb8l#l€Y`cWQTiV6Y[X’WQlTvh1xU6kelU

WLfmd‘Ffm~FW;b8Y4lU]U6‘lWahjkxWDfmXWa`o`wYTX’WQlTmho!˜#€ehcbi€h—fudFfmYslULfmUQ`jš6Yl€Y#hjkehjlmhcWa`>~TiU6‘e`jYXœ e¢£Y

VQhjš6Y[€YTiY'W]X!Yl€UslUDX!YW;fmdTYl€Y'fvYkFf¤hjlmhjš6hjlm”xUQ“Al€Y[žT”6`jUQš!‘FW6f–h—fWQkFs’fvd‘Ffm~FW6b8Y[lULW

X’W‡lTmhoŸ~GYTldT‘FW‡lmhjU6kA q €eh—f X!Yl€Ushcf$~TU6~GUyfmYs­‘y”§³F žL U•sedkUQš 

+hwT8fmlrQhjkœfmYb8lvhwU;kœ‚r6˜$YVQhjš6Y[l€Y[seY8nFkehwlvhwU;kFf#UQ“Al€Y[s;hcfmlWQkFb8Y[‘GYlm˜_YYkxlm˜$UD‘FW;fmYf$WQkFs

lm˜$U¨fmd‘Ffv~FW6b8Yfrl€YxseY8nFkehwlvhwU;k UQ“4li€YŸžT”;`jUQš£‘FW6f¤hcfLWQkFszfmd‘Ffm~FW;b8YŸWQkFsli€YŸb8U6kFs;hjlmhjU6k

kedXL‘FYTLUQ“#l€YXœ +|#lDl€YYkFs™UQ“#l€ehcffvYb8lmhjU6kArA˜$Y’fm€UQ˜ l€FWQlDU;ke`w”™l€YŸbW;fmY!UQ“4WxXWQ¦

lTvh1x~FYTildT‘FWQlmhjU6kxU;kœWQkYffmYke‘FYTiV’X’W‡lTmho’˜$hjl€xl€Yš6Yb8lU;T „!#"$!   %!&"('*)œ€FW;f$lU

‘GYl8W+6YkhjkyliU’W6bb8U6dkel ª¤k¨fmYb8lmhjU6k r˜$Y[VQhjš6Y]l€Y[X!Yl€Us“›U6T#l€YDb8U;X!~dlWQlmhjU6k§UQ“@l€Y

b8U6kFs;hjlmhjU6kkedX‘GYTf-,Q˜$Y#fmldFse”Ll€YfmYkFf¤hjlmhjš6hjlm”6ryW‡l@l€Y$nFTfml@U;TseYTrQUQ“l€Y4žT”;`jUNš]‘FW6f¤hcf.

UQ“@s;hwXYkFf¤hjU6k0/b8U6kFfmlTidlYsL“›TU6X1 W‡kFs2relU!W]X’WQlTmho’~GYTldT‘FW‡lmhjU6k3­r6h  Y6 e˜$Y[fmYWQTbi€

4 fmdFbi€xl€FWQl5*6-748'%. hcf_WLžT”;`jUQš!‘FW6f¤hcfuUQ“9 703x 6 €YkAry˜$Y[fm€UQ˜ l€FW‡l:4 hcf$fmUQ`jdlmhjU6k

UQ“@WL³6”;`wš;YfmlYT#Yp;dFWQlmhjU6k;³F =<L žd>kYlfmUQš!~TUQš6Ys l€FWQl4 b8U;de`—s‘GY“¶U;dkFsL“›TU6X l€Y'fvU6¦

`jdlmhjU6kxUQ“>W'`1hjkYWQT#fm”fmlYX hjkyš6U‡`wš;hjkV!W`cWQTV6YlTmhcWQkV;de`—W‡TX’WQliTmho?A@CBEDF#G@b8U;kFfmlTdFb8lYs “›TU6X

l€YY8`jYX!Ykelf$UQ“H] 6¢£Y~TUQš6Y#l€Ykxli€FWQll€Yb8U6kFs;hjlmhjU6kœkedXL‘FYTu“¶U;Tl€Y[b8U6X!~dlW‡lmhjU6k!UQ“

l€Y[žT”;`jUNšL‘FW6f–h—f$WQkFsfmd‘Ffm~FW6b8Y[WQTY4seYsedFb8Ys“›TU6X l€Y4‚Q¦›kU;TX%UQ“Al€Y hwkeš6YTfvY4UQ“H?A@CBEDF#Gi 

ª¤k fmYb8lmhjU6kJIrHKQ¦*$ J^_WQT~T8WQde¥hwX~e`wYXYkylf]l€YxWa`jV6U6Tvhwli€X “›U6T]l€Y’b8U6X!~dl8WQlmhjU6kUQ“#l€Y

b8U6kFs;hjlmhjU6kxkedXL‘FYT$WQkFsLVQhjš6YfufmU6X!Y#‘GU6dkFsfulU[YkFfmdTYl€Y4p;dFWa`ohwlm”!U‡“li€Y#TYfmde`jl (+hwkFWN`1`j”6r

hjk fmYb8lmhjU6k Z rA˜$Y!ho`o`jdFfmlTW‡lYxl€ehcf]X!Yl€Us‘y”¡b8U;X!~dlmhjkV£fmU6X!Yxb8U6kFs;hjlmhjU6kzkedX‘GYTf]“›U6T

fmYš;YTWa`>X’W‡lTmhcb8Yf#WQkFsš6Yb8liU6Tf 

L M N­&![&" &( ,!A PO &"

QHRTS U V*WYXZ\[^]_8`5_XPa2_b_c[ XPa2de`ZW_cWZ[fgWh`^Wji^Z]_cW

Yllk WQkFsnm£‘GY4lm˜$Ufvd‘Ffm~FW6b8YfuUQ“cUQ“>s;hwXYkFf¤hjU6k0/reWQkFsL`jYl-.©WQkFsno ‘GY[lm˜_U[U;T¦

l€U;kU6TX’Wa`‘FW6fmYfJUQ“\k©WQkFspm§TYfv~FYb8lmhjš6Y8`j”6 $€YkAr6li€YTY$Y8yhcfmlfufmU6X!Y$X’W‡lTmhoAq p rs r

fmdFbi€Dli€FWQlHqutPq 6'WQkFsvogwqx.L Ylzy ‘GY_li€YfmYl>U‡“ fmdFbi€DXWQlTmhcb8Yfral€Yk|{\q y r

(7)

l€YTiYDY8eh—fvlf#fmU6XY[dkehwl8WQT”xX’WQliTmhcb8Yfep rs fmdFbi€xl€FWQl

q

t

b8Uyf œf–hwk

f¤hjk b8Uyf      

b8Uyf œf¤hjk

f–hwk b8Uyf „

      „ „

¬—‹j±

!#"$&%('*),+.-/!102!3'*45!6!3+8.7),+8" o9$:%<;,$>=!3+?0(@BA$.l!#oA'2 XLhjk

CEDGF

HII

J

KL&M

N

L

4O P!Q!y

R q p rs %TS-( U'> P),'zou qu.V),+."pq t q 6.WYX

P!E",$&%('*),+8-6!<0Z!'*45!/!+ k9),+8"2m[$:%\;,$>=!+]0(@^A$*k!#m^'^©XLhjk

_ D`

A%.l!#o '\4O !Q! .a),+8"

oV),Q!^Q!(%cb!/-'*$>=!3de@\'*45fUf,Q/'> Pf,+8f,Q6gh),d50Z)G%T!i%jflk km),+8"pmon

ª›“H. W‡kFspo WQTYbi`wUefmY#“›TU6X©YW;b€!U;l€YTrQl€Yk2o qu. ˜$hjl€ q 6l7n4e7Up Tq&4rq N '

˜#€YTiYsq&4rqut „ŸW‡kFs 4 tnvl4z  Ylxw ‘FYxl€YxfmYlLUQ“4Wa`o`#l€YfmYX’WQlTmhcb8Yf 4z A$€Yk

{c4 Bw§r

4 t " y

           

           

y

"

      "

YX

³QhwkFb8YBq&4rq

_ HII

J ‚

KL&M

N

L

!e˜$Y[V6Yl#li€Y“¶UQ`o`jUQ˜$hjkVc,

(8)

£1'8'> P!Q2%('.f,Q",!3QY$>+^q&4rq A$ .l!&o ' %XLhjk

D

„

‚ q&4rq

_ ! 4O !Q!5w1P4 %(S-( U'> P),'oq&4rqt „! 4 t l4

QHR Q TdxWh`^WiZ]_JZ[fg`ZWV*W

Yl œW‡kFs ^Fr5qP5q

N

©„6 $€YžT”;`jUQšœfmd‘Ffm~FW6b8Yf[WQTiY6re“¶U;T„e/r

l€YLfmd‘Ffm~FW6b8Yf

F v!#E'z! " b!# b!# N c!a    !# F$#

UQ“gs;hjX!YkFf–hwU;k%/ 

Yl'&@‘GYli€Y s;hjX!YkFf–hwU;k£UQ“

v!#E'l()* " b!# c!a  a #!& #

,hjk§“ W6b8lrG˜_Y]€FWaš6Y

v!#E'H)! + c!& b! a   !&-,#  

¬—‹j±/.(0f,Q„1g/&2 '> !U+.),'*SQ),dYf,Q/'> Pf,+8f,Q/g )d43\Q/@ def,=B0Z)G%($&%hfk'

F !&E'\$&%

),+ f,Q/'> Pf,+.fQ6gh),d 0Z)G%($&%-.

F R Y!#

N

!a   %!&

F

W^%(SP-i <'> P),' kTf,Q[„5761 /*~. $:%j'> !53\Q/@ def,=

0Z)G%($&%\fk8 Y !&E'Tnc.

F

$:%\SP+8$:93SP!hSibs'*f<'> !h%T$e;,+ n

¬FŒ;0.

F

-/),+#0Z!h-6f+ %('*Q6S-'*!/" 0i@^'> P!' Q6+8f,de",$ b Q f3-6!i%6%Ok(f,Q\!=< ),gb de! n

Yl1>‘GYœWQkU6Tl€U6kU;TX’Wa`$‘FW6f¤hcfLUQ“: fmdFbi€zl€FWQl?> . ,

!#.A@'r˜#€YTY .A@uh—fWQk

U6Til€U6kU6TXWa`>‘FW6f¤hcfUQ“CB

, v!#E'rFWQkFs¥fmdFbi€£l€FW‡lrehjk£l€ehcf‘FW6f¤hcfr~ „!&"!  a %!#"(' ) WQkFs

hcf#WQkYffmYke‘FYTiV’X’W‡lTmhor ˜#€YTY'

,ED D,

w"W‡kFs LD D

LGF

"]“›U6TD„5IHGJI&m 

¬FŒ;LK:k-&MJN< „<'> !+O>V$&%\+8f,'YS+.$P9S! n

QHRPQ R2dE[fV XV*d~[g[ hS`-_! dTUV *duWjh^`WiZ]_JZ[fg`^ZWjVTW

¢£Y’V‡hwš;Y’€YTYxli€YŸseY8nFkehjlmhjU6kFfUQ“#l€Yœb8U6kFs;hjlmhjU6kzkedXL‘FYTf]UQ“4li€YŸžT”;`jUQš¡fmd‘Ffm~FW6b8Y

F !&E'’WQkFs UQ“]hwl8fxkFWQldT8Wa`DU6Tl€U;kU6TX’Wa`[žT”6`jUQš ‘FW6f¤hcfxli€TU6dV6€ WXWQlTmho ~FYTlidT¦

‘FWQlvhwU;k 3x >$€YfvYœb8U6kFs;hjlmhjU6kzkydXL‘GYTf!WQTYseYkU6lYsTYfm~GYb8lmhjš6Y8`j”z‘y”7W

R F v!#E'2WxWQkFs

WYX

R F v!#E'2Wy 

U6TD„5 /ON&mr6`jYl

Z

F v!#E'rFWQkFs. hwl8fkFWQldTWa`U6Tl€U6kU;TX’Wa`>žT”;`jUNš§‘FW6f¤hcf +³QhjkFb8Y2/[&mr. hcf

UQ“s;hwXYkFf¤hjU6k

Z]\

gI

F J783 !#E'rWQkFs

\

. hjlf kFWQldTWa`U6Tl€U6kU;TX’Wa`AžT”6`jUQš‘FW6f¤hcf 

¢£Y’W6ffvdX!Y!l€FWQl<q 3BqhcffvX’Wa`o`_YkU6dV;€£lUxYkFfmdTYl€FWQl

\

. hcfDWa`cfmU§UQ“4s;hjX!YkFf¤hjU6kJ/ 

¢£Y[WQ~~e`j”l€Y4dFfvdFWa`>seY8nFkehwlvhwU;kœUQ“>b8U6kFs;hjlmhjU6kxkedXL‘FYTZ

˜#€YTY[l€YX!YlTmhcb hjkxl€Y'fvYlUQ“

(9)

fmd‘Ffv~FW6b8Yf$hcfseY8nFkYshjkY8nFkehjlmhjU6k„DWQkFs˜$YDbi€UyUyfvY[l€YTU;‘FYkehjdFf#kU;TX hjkœl€YDfv~FW6b8Y

UQ“@X’WQliTmhcb8Yf 

¬—‹j±0f,Q[„ / I&2

W R F !&E'2W| hjke“

fmd~

A22!

\

'

q 3Bq

_

qPhq

_

),+8"

WYX

R F v!#E'2W hjke“

fmd~

A$ .l!

\

.v'

qP3Bq

_

qPhq

_

0|fQ8&MJ/OI W R F !&E'2W NW X R F v!#E'2W

¬FŒ;AŠ

Z

K6'Y$:%\!/)G%T@h'*fE%(!6! '> P),' W R

\Yv!#E'2W IWYX

R

\Y v!#E'2W " X

Z

K&k & o'> P!+ W R v!#E'2W g"1),+8"?WYX

R v!#E'2W (WYX R #

Yv!#E'2WB02!/-6)S,%(!

$~+ '> P$:%\-/)G%T!= '> !^de)G%T'y=!/-'*f,Q$:%\S+.$P9S!de@^",! +.!/"^Sibs'*fU'> P! %T$e;,+ n

QHR zVSeiG*V!:]ZbXV*d~[wdTvX#"^_8iGd~`G*_!S

¢£Y4fWa˜hjk’fmd‘FfmYb8lvhwU;kŸ‚ ‚l€FWQl@l€YTYY8yhcfmlfufmU6X!Y$U6Til€U6kU6TXWa`•‘FW;fmYf> UQ“c ryfmdFbi€

l€FW‡l%$ > t A> hcfWQk#YfifmYky‘GYTVX’WQlTmhoArFWQkFsO> t e„s!#"!a   %!#"('

)

&Q ¢™Y[~TUQš6Y

hjkxl€Y“¶U‡`1`jUQ˜$hjkVLl€YU6TYX l€FW‡ll€Y[b8U6kFs;hjlmhjU6kxkedX‘GYT#seUyYfukU6l$seY~FYkFsU6kl€Y‘FW6f¤hcfJhwk

˜#€ehcbi€0©WQkFs ¥WQTiY[Y8•~TYfifmYs 

')(

¬e±qŒa¬ 0|fQ[„5 /OI&2

W R F

$!*& '2W|IW R F

%!&~'ZW ),+." WYX R F

$!*&&'ZW|IWYX R F

%!&~'ZW

¬FŒ;AŠ,+!'5 02!h),+ f,Q/'> Pf,+8f,Q/g )d 0Z)G%($&%fk:^

Z

+!'4 p s Y'> P!+1qG t 4 q _ q&4rq

_ X

Z

+!'Hoa02!h),+ f,Q/'> Pf,+8f,Q6gh),dY0Z)G%($&%\flk-

F

%!&~' '> P!3+1 oV$:% ),+ f,Q/'> Pf,+8f,Q/g )dY02)G%($:%

fk\8

F v!#E'Tn

(10)

( (

F

$! & ' F > t ->l! > t

E'

)! + E>

t

b! > t b! > t N

b! a  &! > t F$#

> t F !&E'

Yln. WQkFs

\

. ‘FYxl€YU6Tl€U;kU6TX’Wa`‘FW;f¤hcfDU‡“-

F v!#E'4WQkFs7

F

%e7 3 !&E'rAl€Yk > t .

WQkFs > t \

. WQTY[l€Y]U6Tl€U6kU;TX’Wa`A‘FW6f¤hcfUQ“>t F

%!&~'WQkFs >t F J7J3 !#E'zI

F

$7

> t 3?>l!*& 'zI

F

$ 7J3U@!*& '˜#€YTYUqP3U@*q

_ q 3Bq _  

A > t .l! > t \

.v'z XLhjk

YD

„

‚ q q _

!˜#€YTiY

l qBq

_ t „!

t

WQkFsO>

t \

.u 6|7e7 pATqUq

N

_

'>

t

.

l qBq

_ t „!

t

WQkFs

\

.g 6v7V> > t

7sp Tq q N

_ ' .

l qBq

_ t „!

t

WQkFs

\

.g 6v7u7sp TqUq

N_ ' .

A$ > t

.l! > t \

. 'z A$ .l!

\

.v'/XrYkFb8Y'WYX R F

$! &3&'2W|IWYX

R F v!#E'2W

A$ F

$! & '#!

F

$783

@

!*& ' ' A$ > t F

%!&~'&! > t F 7 3 !&E'

XLhjk

_

D

_

A$ > t .l! > t \ .v'

XLhjk

_ D

_

A$ .l!

\

.|'

A$ F v!#E'#!

F 783 !&~'

$€YTiY8“¶U6TiY5W R F

$!*&&'2W|NW

R F v!#E'2WPX

u]( A - O ,*DA -u[&(Ÿ>& &D*Ox$A"

u "+*!",!#-u&( !#"+"

¢£Y[˜#WQkyl$€YTY[liUV‡hwš;YDWDXYl€U•sliU b8U;X!~dlY[l€YDb8U6kFs;hjlmhjU6k§kydXL‘GYT#UQ“@l€YDžT”;`wUQš

fmd‘Ffv~FW6b8Y'

F !&E'JW‡kFsxUQ“AhjlfkFWQldT8Wa`AU6Tl€U6kU;TX’Wa`‘FW6f¤hcf 

(11)

l€FW‡l e„!&"!  a %!#"('

)

 Yl#dFffmd~~FUyfvYDkUQ˜ l€FWQl ‚U / zXLhjk &%! u „'

¬FŒ; &$&%%(S-( B'> P),'4

,ED D,

$:%\'> P! Q2%('(!QfEfk '> P! %(S0Z",$>);,f+.),dflk '> P!3Q ! kTfQ !5&$&%

'> P!u",$~gh!3+ %($~f,+ fk-

!&E'Tn

Yl . GY!  a  !#

F ‘FYl€Y!kFW‡ldTWa`U6Til€U6kU6TXWa`‘FW6f¤hcf]UQ“ F v!#E'#˜#€YTY Gn

„!#"$!   %!&"('*)@rAWQkFs§`jYl

\

.1

\

G!

\

N

! a   ! \ F

‘FY!li€Y!kFWQldTWN`gU6Til€U6kU6TXWa`g‘FW;f¤hcf[UQ“

F \

!&E'4˜#€YTY

\

7 3 7 pATqP3Bq N ' TqP3 qEt „'DWQkFs

\

G G €„!&"! a   !&"('

)  

$€YkAr

. 6 F

" \

.u „

"   

" \ N

!a  a  ! \ F

ª›“_˜$YnFkFs£W!XWQlTmho4 s Tq&4rqjt†„'#fmdFbi€¨li€FWQl

\

. *6v7 4€7 p TqP3 q N ' ' .

˜$hjl€4 t l4zrel€YkArl€FW‡k+•f$liU YX!X’W­„6re˜_Y[˜ h1`o`>‘GYWQ‘e`jY]lULYfmlmhjX’WQlY\A$.l!

\

.|'rGWQkFs

l€YkArGl€YDb8U6kFs;hjlmhjU6k§kydXL‘GYT4UQ“@l€YDžT”;`jUQšŸfmd‘Ffv~FW6b8YWQkFs­‘FW6f¤hcf –fvYY Y8nFkehwlvhwU;k

QzRTS X h](Xhs_8dTvX "_SeZbX sV

¬—‹j± ! +8$~'*$>f,+ fk '> P!hf/b !Q),'*f,Q

F

+!' p

rs

'> P!3+

F R

[W<"!(%($;+ % '> P!GQ2%('~/\„^-/f,deSPgh+ % 0Z!def,4 '> P! %(S0Z",$>);,f+.),d fk

$*n&!Gn

F R [W|

" X(X(X(XX(X(X(X(XX(X(X(X(X3X(X(X(X(XX(X(X(X "

"

D n n n

nnn n n n n n n

nnn F D DF=#

"   a  "

nnn nnn nnn nnn

D  a  

DF=#

"   a  "

¬FŒ;

F

$&%hde$~+8!6),Q)+."B$>'>%G!Q/+.!3d$&%h'> P!u%TS 0/%cb),-/!hfkj!i%6%(!+ 02!3Q*;^gh),'*Q/$~-/!(%ykTf,Qh'> P!

Q2%('H/h „<-/f,deSPgh+ %in

(12)

¢£Yœ€FWaš6YxlU nFkFs 4 fmdFbi€ li€FWQlp4 t 9l4!

\

G!  $$€YTY8“›U6TY 4 €FW6fl€Y

“›UQ`o`jUN˜ hwkVxfmlTidFb8ldTYp,

4 " " X(X(X(XX(X(X(X(XX(X(X(X "

" "

DN

XX(X(X(X(X

DN

  

 

DN "          

                   

D #

" DN

X(X(X3X(X

D # "

œU;TYUQš6YTr(4 €FW6f#liU’‘GY fvdFb€§l€FWQl

\

. u*6v784€7 pATqP3Bq

N ' ' . hcf[WQk§U6Tl€U;kU6TX’Wa`

‘FW6f–h—fUQ“4

F \

v!#E'r‡h Y6 

6 4€7sp (qP3Bq

N ' J783 7 p (qP3Bq

N ' 6v7 4€7sp Tq 3Bq

N ' 7 p Tq 3Bq

N '

˜#€YTiY hcf$WQk #YfifmYky‘GYTVLX’WQlTvh1L“›U6T$l€Y$nFTfvl/ ¥„[b8UQ`jdX!kFf $€ehcfu~TYš;hwU;dFfYp;dFWQlmhjU6k

hcfYp6dehjšNWN`wYkel[lU,

F 6 4€7sp (qP3Bq

N '

J7J3u7sp Tq 3Bq

N '

6v7 4€7sp Tq 3Bq

N ' p (qP3Bq N '

F J7J3u78-4V 4 7 p TqP3 q N ' pATqP3Bq

N '

F R 4 854]W F R

3EW-7spATqP3Bq

N ' „ '

$€YTY8“›U6TYl€Y’~FW‡TlDdkFseYT!li€YŸs;hcWQV6U;kFWa`_UQ“l€Y1 / `cW6fml!b8UQ`jdX!kFfLUQ“-4)bWQk‘FY

WQTi‘ehwliTWQTmho`j”œb€UefmYk ›“›U6T46 /xWQkFsOH /!

LD w"('-,

4 " " X(XX(X(X(X(X3X(X(X(X(XX(X(X(X(X3X(X(X(X(XX(X(X(X(X "

" "

DN

X(X(X(X3X(X(X(X(XX(X(X(X(X3X(X(X(X(XX

DN

  

 

DN                

              "

F D DF

 a  

DF

        F D DF

           

" DN

XX(X(X(X

DF

'

(13)

QzR Q R2d Seih X ZbXV*dE[xdT

¢£YDWQTYDfmYW‡Tb€ehjkVp4 ˜$hjl€xli€YDfmlTdFb8ldTiY

'WQkFs§fmUQ`jdlmhjU6kœU‡“„' $€YTiY8“¶U6TiY6rFWQl

l€YnFTfml$U6TseYT hwk qP3BqQr ˜_Y[WQTYDfvYWQTbi€ehwkVn4fvUQ`jdlmhjU6kœUQ“-,

4 €FW6f$l€YDfmliTdFb8ldTY

'$seY8nFkYsxhjk¥fmd‘FfmYb8lmhjU6k  j„

F R 4 r 54]W|

F R 3 W

–‚r'

Yl

‘FY]l€Y[kedX‘GYT4U‡“>dk+ykUQ˜#k¥b8U6X!~GU6kYkyl8f$UQ“z4 r

e / „' p7 „ /b /v7 „'

‚!

@F&G

DN

! a  %!

DN

D

!a   

  a 

F D DF

!  a  !

DF ' ) p

WQkFs @F&G e

D

ƒ!a    !

D  a  

F D DF$#

! a   !

DF=#

Y') p

$€YkArG˜$YDbWQkx~TUQš6Y –fvYYDfmYb8lmhjU6kx…'li€FWQl

4fmUQ`jdlmhjU6k§UQ“l–‚('

@F&G

fvUQ`jdlmhjU6kœUQ“ ? @B~DF&G @F#G

@F&G

˜#€YTiYx? @B~DF&G p

h—fWLlTmhcWQkV6de`cWQTX’WQliTmho’‘deho`wl[˜ hwli€xl€YDY8`jYX!YkelfUQ“9] 

? @CBEDF#G hcfkU6k¥f¤hjkV6de`cWQT[‘FYbW‡dFfmY]hwl8f4s;hcWQV6U;kFWa`>Y8`jYX!Ykelfv

D D

!u“›U6TD„ 6O /u „'_W‡TY

kU6k>YTUF 

QzRPQ R2dE[fV XV*d~[g[ hS`-_! dTUV *duWjh^`WiZ]_JZ[fg`^ZWjVTW

Yl#dFf˜#TmhjlY|4 4 @ G

F

784

@N G

F

784

@ G

F

˜#€YTiY

4 @ G

F " " X(X(X(X3X(X(X(X(XX(X(X(X "

" "

DN

X3X(X(X(X(X

FPDN

    DN "          

                   

F DF$#

"

FPDN

X(X(XX(X

F DF$#

"

hcffmdFb€§l€FWQll6v7 4 @ G

F

h—fWLTU;lWQlmhjU6k

hjk

F v!#E'

(14)

4 @N G

F "  a   "

F D DN

 a  

DN

       

F D DF

 a  

DF

" F D DN   a 

F D DF

           

" DN   a 

DF

X!UQš6YfG

F v!#E'

4 @ G

F 4v4

@ G

F

4

@N G

F

hcf#fmdFbi€œl€FWQll6v7 4 @ G

F

hcfWLTU6l8WQlmhjU6khwk CB

F v!#E'

¬FŒ; K6+ %TS 0/%(!/-'*$>f,+Pn 45!1",!/-$>",!/" '*f '*) !4

@ G

F ".n K6+8",!/!6"-6 7e4

@ G

F

$&% )

Qf,'*),'*$>f,+1$>+O BF v!#E')5%(f<$>'",f!i% +.f' b!3Q6'*SQ(0^'> P!u-6f,gb S'*),'*$>f,+1fkA

F v!#E'),+."Efkh$~'>%

3\Q/@Gdf=<02) %T$:%in

¢£Y!VQhjš6Y!€YTiY!l€Y’b8U6kFs;hjlmhjU6kkedX‘GYTf[U‡“_l€Y’žTi”6`jUQš£fmd‘Ffm~FW6b8YxWQkFs¥UQ“uhjlf[kFWQlidTWa`

U6Til€U6kU6TXWa`A‘FW6f¤hcf#seY8nFkYs­hjkY8nFkehjlmhjU6k  

')(

¬e±qŒa¬ . +|!3'M& 02!h'> P!h",$>gh!+ %($>f,+ fk8

v!#E')Y'> P!3+ kTf,Q-/ 8‚$!XLhjkb &%! uz„'

Y'> P!

gh),'*Q/$< @B~DF&G ? @B~DF&G

#

!$<G$&%('>% Y),+."E'> P!+

P!h-6f+.",$>'*$~f+#+8SPg^0Z!Qfk\'> !^+.),'*SQ),df,Q/'> Pf,+8f,Q/g )d 0Z)G%($&%fk-

F v!#E' $:%

WYX

R F !&E'2W [q

@B~DF&G

q N qPhq

_

P!h-6f+.",$>'*$~f+#+8SPg^0Z!Qfk8

F v!#E' $:%

W R F

%!&~'ZW q @B~DF&G q N

qPhq

_

4O P!3Q!

@B~DF&G $&%\'> P!hgh),'*Q/$<E-6f,gb fG%T!/"U0(@^) k(!4 Q f4O%\fk @B~DF&G%TS-( B'> P)'

@F#G e

F D DN

! a   ! DN    

F D DF

!a    !

DF ' ) @B~DF&G @F&G

X

]Œ±± Y8nFkehjlmhjU6k VQhjš6Yf$dFfv,

W X R F v!#E'2W hjke“

fmd~

A$ .l!

\

.v'

qP3Bq

_

qPhq

_

(15)

¢£Y€FWaš6Y$lUDTiYX’WQT +Ll€FWQlho“93 hcfWQk2YffmYke‘FYTiVXWQlTmhoL“¶U;Tl€Y / §„unFTfml_b8U‡`wdXkFf-h  Y6 

F R

3EW| "('li€YkBA .l!

\

.v'z " $€YTY8“›U6TY

WYX

R F v!#E'2W hjke“

fmd~

*

A%.l!

\

.v'

q F R 3EW q _

qPhq

_

$€YkArGdFf¤hjkV YX!X’Wx„]WQkFsl€Y[YVyWa`ohjlm”sq s@F&G2q

N q F R 3EWq

_

r˜$YnFkFs

W X R F !&E'2W hwke“

fmd~

*

N q 4 @ G

F

784

@N G

F q _

q @F#G q N

qPhq

_

hwke“

fmd~

*

q @F#G q N

q @F&G q N

qPhq

_ q

@CBEDF#G

q N q q _

$€ydFf r˜$YnFkFs W R F

%!&~'ZW hjke“

fmd~

A$ 2!

\

|'

qP3Bq

_

qPhq

_

hjke“

fvd~

*

A22!

\

'

q F R 3EWq

_

qPhq

_

udlA n!

\

|'z XLhjk

_

D

_

A%.l!

\

.v'z XLhjk

„

‚ q&4

@ G

F 7 4 @N G F q _

rl€Yk

W R F

%!&~'ZW hjke“

fmd~

*

N q&4

@N G

F q _

q @F#G

q N q q _

hjke“

fmd~

q

@F#G2q

N

q @F#G q N

qPhq

_ q @B~DF&G q N

qPhq

_

˜#€YTiY

@F&GWQkFs

A@CBEDF#GuWQTYDseY8nFkYshjk§l€YDl€YU;TYXœ 

O $A! #"%$'&

Yl v!#3 !s@F&G$WQkFs¥l€Y!U;~FYTWQliU6T F

‘GY’seY8nFkYs¡W;fhjk¡fmYb8lmhjU6k  ¢£YWQTY!V6U‡hwkV§lU

~TUQš6Y]l€FWQl 4 fmUQ`jdlmhjU6kœU‡“–‚('

@F#G fmUQ`jdlmhjU6kœU‡“ ? @CBEDF#G @F#G @F&G ˜#€YTY1? @B~DF&G

(16)

hcf4WLliTmhcWQkV6de`cWQT#X’W‡lTmhoŸ‘deho`jl[˜$hjl€xl€Y[Y8`jYX!YkelfUQ“D 

4†€FW;fl€Y¨fmliTdFb8ldTY ' seY8nFkYs hwk fmd‘FfvYb8lmhjU6k  j„6r@li€YTY8“¶U;TYœ˜$Y¨bW‡k ˜TmhjlY

4 4784™˜#€YTY

4 "" "

  

 

DN "

                   

" DN XX

D # "

! 4 " " X(X3X(X(X(X(XX(X(X "

"

DN

X(X

DN

"          

     

D #

"

|'f hcf[WQk0YffmYke‘FYTVX’WQliTmhorG˜$YDfmYYLl€FWQl-4 854 hcf[WQk§d~~FYT[lTmhcWQkV;de`—W‡T

X’W‡lTmhor l€Yk F R 4 854 W|w"rFWQkFsl€YTiY8“¶U6TiY

F R 4 -4]W|

F R 3EW

F R 4 54 W|

F R 3EW

D

K,M LD, ,D

K

,

M8L

# L D, ,D LD {¨„'761 /hz„]WQkFsU6v7¡‚?IH4N

udl5{ H ! LD " r•fvU {¨„'76? /^z„ WQkFs6 7¡‚?IH4NH! ˜$Y[€FWaš6Y ,

#

K,M N ,D LD, 7 D L D

K

,

M.L

# LD, ,D

7 D D LD D

Y'z LD

{"6 0—„!#/ „ ! #

K,M N ,D

#

,ED

# #

,ED D,

   

D,

7 D "    # #

"

D N D D X(X(X(X(XX(X(X(X(X D N D

         

D # D

D D

   

D

7- D D # # D N D D

   

D D

D N D

   

D

Références

Documents relatifs

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex Unit´e de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis, 2004 route des Lucioles, BP

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex Unit´e de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis, 2004 route des Lucioles, BP

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex Unit´e de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis, 2004 route des Lucioles, BP

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex Unit´e de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis, 2004 route des Lucioles, BP

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex Unit´e de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis, 2004 route des Lucioles, BP

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex Unit´e de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis, 2004 route des Lucioles, BP

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex Unit´e de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis, 2004 route des Lucioles, BP

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex Unit´e de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis, 2004 route des Lucioles, BP