• Aucun résultat trouvé

Computation of the singular subspace associated with the smallest singular values of large matrices

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "Computation of the singular subspace associated with the smallest singular values of large matrices"

Copied!
22
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

HAL Id: inria-00074608

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00074608

Submitted on 24 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Computation of the singular subspace associated with the smallest singular values of large matrices

Bernard Philippe, Miloud Sadkane

To cite this version:

Bernard Philippe, Miloud Sadkane. Computation of the singular subspace associated with the smallest singular values of large matrices. [Research Report] RR-2064, INRIA. 1993. �inria-00074608�

(2)

ISSN 0249-6399

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

a p p o r t

d e r e c h e r c h e

1 9 9 3

PROGRAMME 6

Calcul scientifique, modélisation et logiciels numériques

Computation of the singular subspace associated with the smallest singular values

of large matrices

Bernard Philippe and Miloud Sadkane

N˚ 2064

septembre 1993

(3)
(4)

-

. /0 /1#.2 3! 4'5' .&6(

78:9;<=9?>A@*BDCFEFCHG%G8<=;+>ICFEHJLK>AMN<L>2OP<Q;%8

RTSVUQWQSX:YZY[]\^ _`XbaHcedLagfVcVhi[jLklhnmDo=dp[Qq%YUsr(t[eanhufVX:klhvUQjw[k*aiU=W:hHcVhi[eaTjLdpYxt[SlhHo=dp[

RTSVUQyl[k`z{%z|}~

€!X:pNUQSVk]rL[S.[‚cVƒp[ScVƒp[j„L…Q†Q\:‡ˆ^ fl[pk.[Y‰pS.[Š‚‹Q‹=Œ^ Š‚\NX:W=[‚f

Ž/’‘‚“‚”N•–‘Q—'˜A[™ceU=YNX:S.[kVƒp[‰LavUscVšP›œ{#X:jNceUPfX:jNržk.ƒp[|XbŸ=hHrpflUQjAY[kVƒpUsrpf] ¡UQS

ceUQYpdpklhvjpW¢X£‰NX=f¤hHfU: 'Xf¤hvjpWQdLaHX:Sfldp‰NflNXQce[™X=f.flUpcVhuX–k.[‚r¦¥hvk.ƒAk.ƒp[™f§Y™Xbanav[‚flkf¤hvjp›

WQdLaHX:SŸ:Xbavdp[‚fU– 6aHX:S.WQ[ZY™X:k.SlhHce[‚f¨˜©[hvjPk.SVUsrLdNce[™X¦f¤hvYLav[™YZUsr=hnmDcX:klhvUQjUQjªk.ƒp[

pS.[‚ceUQjNr=hvklhvUQjLhvjpWwflk.[U: T|X‚Ÿ=hHrpflUQj«¬f*Y[k.ƒpUpr£¥'ƒLhHc.ƒwX:p2[‚X:SfkVU‰N[[e­cVhv[jLk®U=j

XSX:jpWQ[U– /aHX:S.W=[flNX:Sfl[Y£X:k.SlhHce[‚f¨

¯°L±²l³´%“:µ/=—·¶¸avUscVšL›œ{X:jNceUPf¹Y[k.ƒpUpr%q|X‚Ÿ=hHrpflUQj«¬fYZ[k.ƒpUsr%qºQ»|q2pS.[‚ceUQjNr=hv›

klhvUQjLhvjpWNqDf§NX:Sfl[Y™X–k.SlhHce[‚f¨

¼¡½¾

¿lÀÁbÂ

¾

¿TÃÄnÀšƂÇ

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rennes

IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex (France) T´el´ephone : (33) 99 84 71 00 – T´el´ecopie : (33) 99 38 38 32

(5)

&*, %"%'&6#¹ '%%&* ] £

( . 34'! # ,Z) &(65&6 #'D ,

,Z)

°p °— ~'UQdNfZceUQYNX:S.U=jNfˆaHXAY [k.ƒpUprL[¢rL[¢{#X:jNceUPfZNX:S‰LavUscf£[kt auX©Y t

k.ƒpUsrL[wrL[w|XbŸ=hHrpflUQjNUQdpS™cX aucedLav[SZav[¢flUQdNf§›[‚flNXQce[f¤hvjpWQdLanhi[SwX=f.flUpcVh?t[X–d LavdNf

N[klhvk.[‚f¹Ÿ Xbav[dpSff¤hvjpWQdLanh[SV[‚frL[Y™X:k.S§huce[‚fceSV[dNfl[‚frL[WQSX:jNrL[ˆkXbhnanai[Q¨~'U=dNf!hijLk.S.U=›

rLdLhuf§UQjNfdpjp[YUsr=hnmDcX:k§hiU=j fldpS!auXZY [k.ƒpUsrL[rL[|XbŸ=hurpf§UQjAoQdLh6fl[Sptt [Ÿ[eav[[e­cXQce[

NX:S'SX:p2UQS.k®X–d rL[dwY [k.ƒpUprL[‚f6pSptt [‚c2t[‚rL[jLk.[‚f¨

´N‘‚².•° — Y t[kVƒpUsrL[™rL[{X:jNceULfNX:S‰LavUpcfqTY t[k.ƒpUprL[™rL[|XbŸ=hHrpflUQjq(ºQ»]|q

pSst[‚ceUQjNr=hvklhvUQjpjp[YZ[jPk‚q2Y™X:kVSlhHce[‚f'ceS.[dNfl[‚f¨

(6)

( )

+ #,£&¸

}œj£k.ƒLhHf6NX–N[S‚qL¥[]ceU=jNf¤hHrL[S`kVƒp[®pS.U=‰Lai[Y U: /ceUQYZpdpklhvjpW™X [¥·flY£Xbanai[‚f§k®f¤hvjpWQdLaHX:S

Ÿ Xbavdp[‚fX:jNr£k.ƒp[XQf.f§UscVhHX:k.[‚rfhijpW=dLauX–S®ŸQ[‚cekVUQSf(U: 6XaHX:SVWQ[flNX:Sf§[*,+.-0/1*324-65

S.[‚cekX:jpWQdLaHX:S(Y™X:k.S§h¨7*ƒLhuf¸pS.UQ‰Lav[Y ƒNXQf6X–k.k.SXQcekV[‚rX¹WQS.[‚X:k6rL[‚X aDU: %hvjPkV[S.[‚flkT  S.UQY

X£Ÿ X:Slhv[k8ªU: `2[Sfl2[‚ceklhvŸQ[‚f:9vŠ:q/…Lq%‡Nq<;Pq6=?>¤¨NzYUQjpW¦k.ƒp[[ X:YZLai[‚f¹Y[jLklhvUQjp[‚rªhvj

k.ƒp[‚fl[6SV[e ¡[S.[jNce[‚f’q‚UQjp[cX:jcVhvk.[fl[ehHflYhHc(k.UQYU=WQSX:pƒ8®¥!ƒp[S.[6k.ƒp[6f§Y™Xbanav[‚flk6f¤hvjpWQdLaHX:S

Ÿ Xbavdp[‚fX:jNr¦k.ƒp[ehvSceUQSVS.[‚flNU=jNr=hijpWªf¤hvjpWQdLaHX:SŸ=[‚cek.UQSfX:S.[S.[‚o=dLhvS.[‚r%¨}¤jAk.UQkX aav[‚XQflk

f.oQdNX–S.[X:pLanhHcX:klhvUQjNf’qUQjp[¹huf!hvjLk.[S.[‚flkV[‚rhvjAflU:avŸ=hvjpWk.ƒp[anhvjp[‚X:Sf@8sflkV[Y ACBEDGF

‰8 k.SeX:jNf¤  UQS.YhvjpW¦hvk™k.U©k.ƒp[£anhijp[‚X–SƒpUQYUQWQ[jp[U=dNff8pflk.[YH9IAKJ'FL>NM

B

O

ŠEP D †pq

¥'ƒp[S.[£UQjLaQ8¢kVƒp[ceUQYZpdpkX:klhvUQjAU– `k.ƒp[£SlhvWQƒLkf¤hvjpWQdLaHX:SŸQ[‚cek.U=SfU: 'k.ƒp[™X:p2[jNrL[‚r

Y™X:k.SlhR9IAKJ'FL>QXQfVflUscVhHX:kV[‚r¥*hikVƒhvkf[S.Uf¤hvjpWQdLaHX:STŸ X aidp[*huf#S.[‚o=dLhvS.[‚r¨?S'U:¥[ŸQ[S‚qek.ƒp[

XbavWQUQSlhvk.ƒpY™fr=hHf.cedNf.fl[‚r¦k.ƒp[SV[X:S.[[ehvk.ƒp[SjpUQk®f§dLhikeX:‰Lav[  UQSaHX:S.WQ[ˆY™X:k.S§huce[‚f*UQS'W:hvŸQ[

[e­cVhv[jPkX:ppS.U PhvY™X–klhvUQjNfTUQjLaQ8¹ ¡UQSTkVƒp[aHX:S.WQ[‚flk6fhijpW=dLauX–S6Ÿ X aidp[‚f’¨Q} k.ƒp['f¤hv['U– Dk.ƒp[

Y™X:k.SlhAxhuf#[ pk.S.[Y[eaQ8aHX:SVWQ[QqhvkhHfjpUQkNUPfVf¤hv‰Lai[!k.U'S.[eaQ8dp2UQjk.ƒp[º:hvjpWQdLaHX:ST»6Xbavdp[

|[‚ceUQYNULf¤hvklhvUQj™XbavWQUQS§hikVƒpYT9;>NrLdp[k.Uk.ƒp[[ s2[jNfl[U: +flkVUQSX:WQ[(S.[‚o=dLhiSV[Y[jPkef6X:jNr

k.ƒp[ƒLhvWQƒªceUQYpdpkX:k§hiU=jNXbagceUPflkb¨Pzj¢X aikV[S.jNX:klhvŸQ[¥'XU8™kVUpS.Upce[[‚r£ UQS®flU:avŸ=hvjpW™UQdpS

pS.UQ‰Lav[Y hHfk.UX:pLaQ8k.ƒp[{X:jNceUPfY[kVƒpUsrV9vŠ‚†U>Qk.Uk.ƒp[6Y£X:k.SlhWXDYM

† A

AZ †[P

¨

7ƒp[[ehvWQ[jPŸ:Xbavdp[‚f'U– \W"X:SV[]C^`_/1Aa5LJ'bcD ŠJb¨‚¨‚¨JL-k.ƒp[f¤hvjpWQdLaHX:SŸ Xbavdp[‚fU: NAqL¥hvk.ƒ

* O

-XQrpr=hvklhvUQjNXbap[S.UPf¨U7ƒLhHf/X:ppSVUPXQcVƒ®YhvWQƒLkjpUQk#‰N[6[e­cVhi[jLkTf¤hvjNce[`kVƒp[6flY™Xbanav[‚flk

f¤hvjpWQdLaHX:S'Ÿ X aidp[‚f*U: dA anhi[hvj£k.ƒp[!hijLk.[SlhvUQSU: k.ƒp[®fl2[‚cek.S.dpY U: \WZqsX–jNrk.ƒLhHf(NX:S.k(U: 

k.ƒp[fl2[‚cek.S.dpY hHf!dNfldNXbanaQ8wk.ƒp[ˆYUPflk'r=hn­cedLavkk.U™ceU=Ypdpk.[ UQS®{X:jNceULf«NYZ[k.ƒpUsr%¨

7ƒp[™fl[‚ceUQjNrX:ppS.ULXQc.ƒ¦hHfkVU¢X:pLaQ8ªk.ƒp[™{X–jNceUPfY[kVƒpUsrªkVUmNjNrªk.ƒp[£flY™Xbanav[‚flk

[ehiW=[jpNXbhvSf¦U: k.ƒp[ªY™X:k.SlhGA

Z

Aˆ¨C7*ƒp[ASX:k.[ªU: ceUQjLŸQ[S.WQ[jNce[ª UQSk.ƒp[flY™Xbanav[‚flk

[ehiW=[jPŸ:Xbavdp[e^6f

g

U– hA Z A hHfW=U Ÿ=[S.jp[‚rA‰8Ak.ƒp[£WPX:©SX:klhvUjikDmlUn

no lUnp

l nq o l nn

9vŠb†r>(¥'ƒp[S.[

^ f

X–jNrs^%twX–S.[S.[‚f§N[‚ceklhvŸQ[eaQ8wkVƒp[ f§[‚ceUQjNrwX:jNr¦k.ƒp[¹aHX:S.WQ[‚flkf¤hvjpWQdLaHX:SŸ:Xbavdp[‚fU: uA¨

7ƒp[®flY™X aav[‚flk(hHfTkVƒLhuf¸WPX:SeX:klhvUNq:k.ƒp[®faiU:¥[ShHf(k.ƒp[®ceUQjLŸQ[S.WQ[jNce[Q¨=} d^

g

X:jNrV^

f

X:SV[

ŸQ[Sv8™flY£Xbana+ceUQYNX–S.[‚rkVU^%t%qQkVƒp[jRi£hHf(YdNc.ƒflY™Xbanav[S'k.ƒNX–j

l n o l p

l q o l n

¥'ƒLhHc.ƒ¥UQdLaHr

‰N[k.ƒp[ˆhHrL[‚Xba6WPX:ªSX:k§hiU2¨w7ƒp[S.[e UQS.[k.ƒp[flY™X aav[‚flk[ehvWQ[jLŸ X aidp[‚f¹U: xA Z A ‰2[‚ceUQY[‚f

flY™Xbanav[S]X–jNrcVaiULfl[S]X–jNr£hvjwk.ƒLhHf'cX=fl[UQjp[cX–jpjpUQk'[ pN[‚cek! XQf§k*ceU=jPŸQ[SVWQ[jNce[Q¨

zjUQk.ƒp[S'X:ppS.UPX=c.ƒ¥'ƒLhHcVƒwYhvWQƒLk‰N[ˆU: hvjPkV[S.[‚flkhHf|X‚Ÿ=hHrpflUQj«¬f(Y[kVƒpUsrj9IyU>œq

9¬‹?>œq%9¬ŒU>%X:pLanhi[‚r£kVUA Z A¨L|XbŸQhHrpflUQj«fY[k.ƒpUpr™rLUL[‚f([ sƒLhv‰Lhvkk.ƒp[]fVX:Y['‰2[ƒNX‚Ÿ=hvUQdpS

XQfT{X:jNceUPf’«QY[k.ƒpUpr%q:‰pdpkThvk¸hufgav[‚f.f6fl[jNfhik§hiŸ=[®k.UkVƒp[®r=hHflk.Slhv‰pdpklhvUQj£U: D[ehvWQ[jLŸ X aidp[‚f’¨

S'U:¥[ŸQ[S‚q#k.Uw‰2[[e­cVhv[jPk‚qT|XbŸ=hurpf§UQj«¬fˆY[k.ƒpUprAjp[[‚rpfZXWQULUsr©pS.[‚ceUQjNr=hvklhvUQjp[Sb¨

7ƒp[wY™X hijr=hz[S.[jNce[ª‰N[kl¥[[j·{X–jNceUPfX:jNr3|XbŸ=hHrpflUQj3YZ[k.ƒpUsrpf hHfkVƒNX:kk.ƒp[

(7)

XQrpX:pkff§[NX:SX:k.[eaQ8k.ƒp[wŸ=[‚cek.UQSf¹  S.UQY ¥'ƒLhHcVƒ3k.ƒp[[ehvWQ[jLŸQ[‚cek.U=Sf™X–S.[ceU=Ypdpk.[‚r%¨

7ƒp[XbhvY)U: `k.ƒLhHfNX:2[ShHfk.UceUQYNX:SV[kVƒp[‚fl[k¥U£Y[k.ƒpUprpfq2jNX:Y[eaQ8ªk.ƒp[‰LaiUpcVš

{X:jNceUPf£X:jNrk.ƒp[‰LavUpc.š3|XbŸ=hurpf§UQj Y[k.ƒpUprpfX:pLanhv[‚r k.UA Z A  UQSceUQYpdpklhvjpW

k.ƒp['SlhvWQƒLk6f¤hvjpWQdLaHX:SŸQ[‚cek.UQSefTceUQS.S.[‚fl2UQjNr=hvjpWk.Uk.ƒp[®flY£Xbanai[‚f§k`f¤hvjpWQdLaHX:SŸ X aidp[‚f(U: %z¨

'jp[XQrLŸ X:jLkX:W=[®U: Tk.ƒp[‚fl[kl¥UYZ[k.ƒpUsrpf(U:ŸQ[Sk.ƒp[cVaHXQf.fhucX a6ºQ»]| Y[k.ƒpUprZhHfk.ƒNX:k

k.ƒp[:/aHX:S.WQ[?5UQSlhvW:hvjNXba6Y™X–k.SlhhHfjpUQkXbavk.[S.[‚rªX:jNr¦k.ƒNX:k!anhvk.klav[™flk.U=SX:WQ[hHfS.[‚o=dLhvS.[‚r

f¤hvjNce[U=jLa8£‰LavUscVšY™X:kVSlhŸQ[‚cekVUQS'YdLavklhvLahHcX:k§hiU=jNfX:S.[ceUQYpdpkV[‚r%¨

º:hvjNce[k.ƒp[flY™X aav[‚flk[ehvWQ[jLŸ X aidp[‚fˆU: uA Z A cX:jª‰N[‚ceUQY[cVavUPfl[Sbq%¥`[c.ƒpULUPfl[k.U

dNfl[`X!‰LavUscVšŸQ[Sf¤hvUQj¹ ¡U=S/k.ƒp[(kl¥`U'XbavWQU=Slhvk.ƒpY™f¨r7*ƒp[6‰LavUscVšf§k.SX:k.[W8®Xbavk.ƒpUQdpWQƒˆYdNc.ƒ

YUQS.[[ pN[jNf¤hvŸQ[ˆk.ƒNX:jk.ƒp[f§kX:jNrpX:Sr£U=jp[QqLhHf'XQcce[pk.[‚r ‰N[‚cX:dNfl[ˆU: Tk.ƒp[ ¡U–aavU:¥hvjpW

S.[‚XQflUQjNf

›T}œk!Y™XU8hvYpS.U:ŸQ[k.ƒp[jLdpY[SlhHcXba/[e­cVhi[jNcL8{X:jNceULf¥hvk.ƒ‰LavUscVšwf¤hv[cX:j

ceUQYpdpk.[®cVavUPf§[`[ehvWQ[jLŸ X aidp[‚f!X:jNrˆ[ehiW=[jPŸ:Xbavdp[‚f6U– DYdLavklhvLahHcVhvk8av[‚f.f¸k.ƒNX:j2¥'ƒp[S.[‚XQf

k.ƒp[flkeX:jNrpX:Sr{X–jNceUPf®X aiW=UQSlhvk.ƒpY Y™XU8£jpUQk‚¨pU=S®|XbŸQhHrpflUQj«fY[k.ƒpUpr%qpUQjLaQ8k.ƒp[

‰LaiUpcVšŸQ[Sf¤hvUQjXbanavU:¥®fTk.ƒp[ceUQYpdpkX:k§hiU=j™U: /fl[Ÿ=[SXbaN[ehvWQ[jpNXbhvSf'X–kTk.ƒp[]fVX:Y['klhvY[Q¨

›}¤k£hvjPŸQU–aiŸ=[‚f¶`{+zº·Œ©pSlhvYhvklhvŸQ[‚f ¥'ƒLhHc.ƒX:S.[ªYU=S.[w[e­cVhv[jLk£ ¡U=S™Y[YZUQSv8

Y™X:jNX:WQ[YZ[jPk®X–jNrZ ¡UQS!NX:SXbanav[eanhuf§Yw¨

7ƒpS.U=dpWQƒpUQdpkk.ƒLhHfNX–N[SAXD[Z3rL[jpU=k.[‚fk.ƒp[™f¤hvjpWQdLaHX:SˆŸ Xbavdp[rL[‚ceUQY›

NUPf¤hvklhvUQj¦U: Tk.ƒp[Y™X:k.S§hsA ¥'ƒp[S.[

kDG9

g

J‚¨b¨‚¨J |>/X:SV[k.ƒp[UQS.k.ƒpU=jpUQS.Y™Xba2av[e ¡kf¤hvjpWQdLaHX:SŸQ[‚cek.UQSf’q

D"!b$#&%/^ _5Tk.ƒp[r=huX–WQUQjNXbaY™X:kVSlhU: 6f¤hvjpWQdLaHX:SŸ Xbavdp[‚fa^

g('

^ f '

¨‚¨b¨

'

^%t

X:jNr) DG9+*

g

Jb¨‚¨‚¨ J* t?>/rL[jpUQkV[‚fk.ƒp[UQS.kVƒpUQjpUQS.Y™X a+S§hiW=ƒPk®fhijpW=dLauX–S®ŸQ[‚cekVUQSf¨

˜A[¥hnanaD‰2[*ceU=jNce[S.jp[‚rU=jLa8ˆ¥hvk.ƒk.ƒp['ceUQYZpdpkX:klhvUQjU: NSlhvWQƒLk6f¤hvjpWQdLaHX:S(ŸQ[‚cek.UQSf

f¤hvjNce[k.ƒp['av[e  kUQjp[‚f6cX:j£‰N[UQ‰pkX hijp[‚rZ UQS([ X:YZLai[‰8jpUQklhHcVhvjpWk.ƒNX:k6kVƒp[8™f.X:klhHf¤ 8

_ D g

l-, A.*

_

¨7ƒLhHf( UQS.YdLaHXY™XU8Qq=ƒpU ¥[ŸQ[Sbq:jpUQkW:hvŸQ[]Xˆf.X:klhHf¤ œXQcek.U=Sv8XQccedpSXQcL8U=j

k.ƒp[Tav[e kgf¤hvjpWQdLaHX:STŸ=[‚cek.UQSf2hn /* _ hHf#jpUQk¥`[eanaNX:ppS.U LhiY£X:k.[‚r%¨'jp[S.[Y[‚r8r=hHf.cedNfVfl[‚r

hijj9¬…U>DceU=jNf¤hHflkfhvj£dNf¤hvjpWk.ƒp['UQ‰pkX hijp[‚r av[e ¡kX:ppS.U LhiY£X:klhvUQj™XQfTf§kX:S.klhvjpWˆNU:hvjLk`X:jNr

S.[emNjLhvjpW™k.ƒp[X:ppS.U LhvY™X:klhvUQj£U: /k.ƒp[av[e k'f¤hvjpWQdLaHX:S®Ÿ=[‚cek.UQS6dNfhijpW hijLŸQ[Sf§[hikV[SX:klhvUQj

UQjsACA Z UQS!UQjGM

† A

AZ † P ¨

7ƒLhHf'NX:2[ShHfUQS.WLX:jLhv[‚rwXQf¸  U:anaiU:¥®f’¨p}œj10…¥[‰pSlhv[32w8S.[‚cX aak.ƒp[®‰LavUpc.šw{#X:jNceUPf

XbavWQUQSlhvk.ƒpYwqghij40Œª¥[™SV[‚cXbana]|XbŸQhHrpflUQj«fY[k.ƒpUpr X:jNrW:hvŸQ[ªflUQY[ceUQjLŸQ[S.WQ[jNce[

X:jNXbaQ8sfhuf*  UQS®ceUQYpdpk§hijpWZk.ƒp[flY£Xbanai[‚f§k]f¤hvjpWQdLaHX:SŸ X aidp[‚f’¨N˜A[X auf§U™r=hHf.cedNf.ffl[ŸQ[SXba

pS.[‚ceUQjNr=hvklhvUQjLhvjpWAk.[‚cVƒpjLhHoQdp[‚f] ¡UQS|XbŸ=hHrpflUQj«¬fY[kVƒpUsr%¨50.‡£hufˆrL[ŸQUQk.[‚r¦k.UjLdpY[›

SlhHcXbag[ pN[S§hiYZ[jPkfX–jNr¢ceU=YNX:SlhHflUQj¦‰N[kl¥[[jwk.ƒp[ˆkl¥`UZY[k.ƒpUprpf UQSceUQYpdpklhvjpW

k.ƒp[flY™Xbanav[‚flkf¤hvjpWQdLaHX:SŸ Xbavdp[‚f¨

(8)

)$£ˆ&&6" .

z‰LavUscVš™Ÿ=[Sf¤hvUQjU: /{X:jNceULf'XbavWQUQSlhvk.ƒpY ¥hvk.ƒ£‰LavUscVšf¤hv[ UQS6kVƒp[h* + -Y£X:k.Slh

A Z A cX:j‰2[¥'Slhvk.kV[j£hij¦k.ƒp[  U:anavU:¥hvjpW

 2´D“v‘

!

ºQ[k#"%$ D·†%J[W

g

D·†

_6ƒpULUPfl["

g'&

t)(+*

¥hvk.ƒ,"KZ

g " g D.-

A g D/"

Z

g A Z A'"

g

!  UQS0:D ŠJe…%J‚¨b¨¨vJ'*)#Bwb214365

798 D A Z A'":8

O

":8

o g W Z

8

A 8 D/" Z

8 7 8

;<8>=

g

D?7:8

O

":8#A@8

":8A=

g

W@8A=

g

D/;<8>=

g B ; !+3DCFE?*HGIEJrb211bKE?-

7ƒp[Y™X:k.SlhA Z A hHfU: *ceUQdpSefl[jp[ŸQ[S ¡U=S.Y[‚r[ pLanhHcVhik§a8Qq¸UQjLaQ8¢fldNcce[‚f.fhiŸ=[ceUQYZ›

pdpkX:klhvUQj U: ]kVƒp[  UQS.YmA Z /1A /4" 5 5X:S.[jp[[‚rL[‚r%¨|7ƒp[¦Y™X:k.S§huce[‚fL"MJN7MJO;PM ¡UQS

0:D ŠJe…%J‚¨b¨¨ X:SV[C-:+ lqAQ8®X:jNr:W@8]X:S.[( + lqQ¥hvk.ƒ A@8!f@8PYYZ[k.SlhHc:¨%7ƒp[Y™X:k.S§huce[‚f

" 8>=

g

X:jNr W 8A=

g

X:SV[]rL[emNjp[‚r ‰8kVƒp[

B ;   XQcekVUQSlhv‚X:klhvUQj£U: R; 8>=

g

qpflUk.ƒNX–kxW 8A=

g

hHf

dppN[Sk.SlhHX:jpWQdLaHX:S®X–jNr£k.ƒp[ceU:avdpYjU: S":8A=

g

X–S.[UQS.k.ƒpU=jpUQS.Y™Xbaœ¨7ƒp[‰LavUscVšw{X:jNce›

UPfŸQ[‚cek.U=Sf'cX:j¦‰N[W=S.UQdpN[‚r k.UQWQ[kVƒp[S*X=fk.ƒp[ceU–aidpYZjNf'U: 6X:js-j+,0Y£X:k.Slh,TM

¥'ƒp[S.[#TM DG9U"

g

JO"

f

Jb¨‚¨‚¨ JO"VML>KWbhvk(huf¸[‚XQf8k.UflƒpU:¥ k.ƒNX–k6k.ƒp[®ceU–aidpYZjNfTU: TM!S.[Y™Xbhvj

UQS.k.ƒpUQjpU=S.Y™Xba'pS.U:Ÿ=hurL[‚r jpUQjp[U: k.ƒp[dppN[S£k.SlhHX:jpW=dLauX–S™Y™X–k.SlhHce[‚f W 8 X:SV[SX:jpš

rL[emDcVhi[jLk‚¨/ dpS.k.ƒp[S.YU=S.[k.ƒp[ceU:avdpYjNf!U: XTM¹ ¡U=S.Y X:j¦UQS.k.ƒpUQjpU=S.Y™Xba‰NXQf¤hHfU: Tk.ƒp[

{Sv8QavU:Ÿ fldp‰NflNXQce[,YZM?/1A Z AJ["

g 5 D\7G #-^]_"

g

J'A Z A'"

g

Jb¨‚¨b¨vJ/1A Z A 5 M o g "

g6`

¨d7ƒp[

S.[‚flk.SlhHceklhvUQjZa M U: k.ƒp[Y™X:k.SlhRA Z A5k.UHY M /1A Z AKJO"

g

5hHf(k.ƒp[b0 +c0#‰NX:jNrY£X:k.Slh

aM D/Td

M A Z A#T^MaD

effffffffg A g W d

f † ¨b¨‚¨ †

W f A f W d

h ¨ ¨ ¨ ¨¨¨

† ¨ ¨ ¨ ¨ ¨ ¨ ¨ ¨ ¨ †

¨¨¨ ¨ ¨ ¨ ¨ ¨ ¨ ¨ ¨ ¨ W dM

† ¨‚¨‚¨ † W'M A#M

ikj

jjjjjjj

l

/Š?5

¥hvk.ƒwƒNXban T‰NX:jNr %m3Š=¨

7ƒp[ªceUQjPŸ=[S.WQ[jNce[¢X–jNXbaQ8sf¤hHf£U: kVƒp[w‰LavUscVš3{X:jNceULfXbavWQUQSlhvk.ƒpYwq(k.ƒNX:k hufZk.ƒp[

(9)

XbavS.[‚XQr8 ‰N[[jflkVdNr=hi[‚r hvj 9vŠ‚ŒU>9vŠb…r>¤¨T˜A[wSV[‚cXbana]UQjp[¦U: k.ƒp[wY™X hij5ceUQjLŸQ[S.WQ[jNce[

S.[‚fldLavk‚¨

%°P´%“‚°

V U

g' f '

¨‚¨b¨

'

DM[*a!v RUrU PaME!vU3

&r' # rCj?L : .:# @w .!U&

w& ? L 3U

!vLrE&'LL3R rKVD ŠJb¨‚¨‚¨J3

† ' f 8 O ^ f

8

^

ft

O

^6f

8 '

1#-c/#*5

a M o

g

g

=

g o

f

rXi8|D

^ f

*U=

g O ^ f

8

^

ft

O

^6f

8

/…5

† ' ^ f t o

8>=

g O f M[*

o

8A=

g

^ f

t o 8A=

g O ^ f

g ' 1 #-c/X*5

aM

o

g

g

= !

g o

! f

/Œ5

r i 8D

l

n"$#

p o l n

l nq o l n

J&% 8D l n

q' # p o l n

q'

"

l n

q(' # p o l np

)#*0/4536J>G+*,Q*Q5)Uw s :L-

&r!vU

'U J G#-]"

g6`

K rLw <"!#$%&'a 'r&U 3

:

/. 1 $+0| # 21j3rsRA0 aM

o g s N?!4UL5

",4?w 6 r#0

O

Š60

7“b´%´8 ºQ[[R9vŠbŒr>¤qsX–jNr[‚fl2[‚cVhuX aaQ8 9vŠ‚…?>2 UQS®X:j£hvYpS.U:ŸQ[‚r£SV[‚fldLavk‚¨ 9

}œkThHf[‚XQf@8kVU]fl[[!k.ƒNX:kTk.ƒp[‰NU=dpjNrpf /…5/X–jNr /lŒ5/X:S.['o=dLhikV[®f.X:klhHf¤ œXQcek.U=Sv8hvjk.ƒp['cXQfl[

U: /ceUQjPŸ=[S.WQ[jNce['k.UX–j[ skVS.[Y™XbaDf¤hvjpWQdLaHX:SŸ:Xbavdp[U:  Aˆ¨S!U:¥`[Ÿ=[S‚qbhvjpSXQceklhHce[Qq=hvkThHf

jpUQk®Xbav¥'XU8sf(k.S.dp[ˆk.ƒNX:k‰NU=k.ƒ[jNrpf'U– gk.ƒp[f§N[‚cek.S.dpY)X:S.[[‚o=dNXbanaQ8wX:ppS.U LhiY£X:k.[‚r%¨

}œj5k.ƒp[AcXQf§[¢U– k.ƒp[AflY™Xbanav[‚flk¢fhijpW=dLauX–SwŸ X aidp[Qq‰2UQdpjNr /…"5 flƒpU:¥®fZk.ƒNX:k£k.ƒp[

ceUQjPŸ=[S.WQ[jNce[SX:kV[U: /‰LavUscVšw{X:jNceULf'Y[kVƒpUsrrL[2[jNrpf'UQjkVƒp[WPX:‰N[kl¥[[jk.ƒp[

f.oQdNX–S.[U: ®k.ƒp[wf§Y™Xbanav[‚flk™f¤hvjpWQdLaHX:SŸ:Xbavdp[e^ _t X:jNrk.ƒp[wfVoQdNX:SV[™U: k.ƒp[£jp[ sk

d;:

f¤hvjpWQdLaHX:S'Ÿ X aidp[ ^I*= g

qpX:jNr£U=j™k.ƒp[flpS.[‚X=r ^ f=<>

O ^ f

*U=

g

U: k.ƒp[dpjP¥'X:jLk.[‚r£f¤hvjpWQdLaHX:S

Ÿ Xbavdp[‚f¨ 7ƒp[aHX:SVWQ[Sk.ƒLhHfZWPX:3X:jNr k.ƒLhHf™flpSV[‚XQrk.ƒp[aHX:SVWQ[Sk.ƒp[¦WPXbhvj hvj·f§N[[‚r%¨

~'UQkV[k.ƒNX:k!k.ƒp[WPX:ªX:jNrk.ƒp[f§pS.[‚XQr¥UQdLaHr ‰N[ ^ f

f O ^ f _t

X:jNrs^ f

=<>

O ^ f

f

hn 6¥[

ƒNXQrAdNf§[‚rk.ƒp[f§kX:jNrpX:Sr©{X:jNceUPfˆY[k.ƒpUpr%¨˜A[ceUQjNcVavdNrL[wk.ƒNX:k¹hn ®k.ƒp[flY™Xbanav[‚flk

f¤hvjpWQdLaHX:S'Ÿ X aidp[‚f!X:S.[cVaiULfl[QqL‰LaiUpcVš{X–jNceUPf(¥hvk.ƒ™‰LavUpc.šf¤hv[XQf¸aHX:S.WQ[XQf¸k.ƒp[®jLdpY›

‰N[SU: 'f¤hvjpWQdLaHX:SŸ Xbavdp[‚f]hijX£W:hvŸQ[jAcVaidNf§k.[ScX:jª‰N[ƒp[eavL dLa6 UQSXQcce[eav[SX:klhvjpWk.ƒp[

ceUQjPŸ=[S.WQ[jNce[Q¨

}œj 7ƒp[UQS.[Y /… ¨vŠ?5q hvkhHfjpUQkX=f.fldpY[‚r¦k.ƒNX:kz!avWQUQSlhvk.ƒpY ŠS.[‚flkX–S.kf!N[SlhvUpr=hi›

cXbana8Qq2k.ƒLhvjpW£k.ƒNX:khHfŸQ[S 8™U:  k.[jdNfl[‚r¦XQfS.[YZ[‚r8™k.UZk.ƒp[WQS.U:¥'k.ƒZhvj¢flkVUQSX:WQ[ 9vŠQŠL>œ¨

7ƒp[S.[!huf’qPƒpU:¥[ŸQ[S‚q=jpUr=hn­cedLavk8hvjpS.U:Ÿ=hvjpW ceU=jPŸQ[SVWQ[jNce[®U– +z!avWQUQSlhvk.ƒpY0Š'¥'ƒp[j

S.[‚flkX:SVklhvjpW£hufdNf§[‚r%q‰pdpk‰NU=dpjNrpff¤hvYhnaHX:Sk.UE/…5'X:jNr /Œ5S.[Y™X hij©k.U™‰2[™rLUQjp[hvj

(10)

˜A[®rLUjpUQk(¥'X:jPkTkVUrL[ŸQ[eavUQwX:j8ˆ ¡dpSVk.ƒp[S6k.ƒp[pS.UQ2[S.klhv[‚f(U: k.ƒp[‰LaiUpcVš™{X:jNce›

UPf'X:jNr pS.[e ¡[S!k.US.[e ¡[S!k.Uk.ƒp[anhvk.[SX:kVdpS.[R9vŠb†r>+ ¡UQSk.ƒp[rL[kXbhnaHf¨

'` #O6, T4,ZD¹ 6 #, ‚

|X‚Ÿ=hHrpflUQj¦pdp‰LahHflƒp[‚ržƒLhufX aiW=UQSlhvk.ƒpY hvjAoQdNX–jPk.dpY)cVƒp[YhHflk.Sv8£mN[eaHr 9IyU>/XQfX:j[e­™›

cVhi[jLk¥'XU8k.UceU=Ypdpk.[k.ƒp[ˆavU ¥[‚flk[jp[S.W8£av[ŸQ[eaHfˆX:jNr¦k.ƒp[ceUQS.S.[‚fl2UQjNr=hvjpWw¥'XbŸQ[

 ¡dpjNceklhvUQjNf(U: %k.ƒp[ºPcVƒpSUpr=hijpW=[S6UQ2[SX:k.UQSb¨7ƒp['Y™X:kVSlh rL[‚Xbavk6¥*hikVƒYdNflk6‰2[®flk.S.U=jp›

W:aQ8žr=hHX:W=UQjNXbanaQ8 rLUQYhvjNX:jLkhvjk.ƒp[™fl[jNfl[Zk.ƒNX:khvkf[ehvWQ[jLŸQ[‚cek.U=SfX:S.[™cVavUPf§[k.Uk.ƒp[

cX:jpUQjLhHcXba6ŸQ[‚cek.U=Sf¨ 7ƒp[XbavWQU=Slhvk.ƒpY)dNfl[‚fk.ƒp[jªk.ƒp[r=hHX:WQUQjNX a¸XQf!pS.[‚ceUQjNr=hvklhvUQjp[Sb¨

}œj 9ŒPq2‹?>/|XbŸQhHrpflU=j«¬f(Y[k.ƒpUprƒNXQf‰2[[jwdNfl[‚r ¥hvk.ƒWQ[jp[SX a/pS.[‚ceUQjNr=hvklhvUQjp[S‚¨

pSVUQY jpU:¥UQjqMflkX:jNrpf# UQSTX®fl[kU: 6- +C-pSV[‚ceUQjNr=hvklhvUQjLhvjpWY£X:k.SlhHce[‚f¥'ƒpUPf§[

c.ƒpU:hHce[ˆ¥hnaaT‰N[r=hHf.cedNf.fl[‚r aHX:k.[S‚¨

7ƒp[£ ¡U–aavU:¥hvjpW XbavWQU=Slhvk.ƒpY ceUQYpdpk.[‚fkVƒp[ flY™Xbanav[‚flk[ehvWQ[jpNX hiSefU: ®k.ƒp[Y£X:k.Slh

A Z A Wd*hufZXW:hvŸQ[j©hvjPk.[W=[S¥!ƒLhucVƒ©ahvYhvkf k.ƒp[r=hvY[jNfhiU=j U: 'k.ƒp[™‰NX=f¤hHf¨H7

flkX:jNrpf(  UQS! ¦Upr=hnmN[‚r"®SeX:YºPc.ƒpYhHrLkRTS.Upce[‚rLdpS.[

_6ƒpUPULfl[X:j£hvjLhvklhHXba6UQS.k.ƒpU=jpUQS.Y™Xba%Y™X:k.S§h,"

g

D[9$#

g

J%%&%vJ'#*> &

t)(+*

W

8œ´D“H0:D ŠJ%&%%Qµ#´

ŠQ¨_6U=Ypdpk.[k.ƒp[Y™X–k.Slh M D A#" M W

…p¨_6U=Ypdpk.[k.ƒp[Y™X–k.Slh M D A Z M W

Œp¨_6U=Ypdpk.[k.ƒp[€'XU8=av[ehiW=ƒ¢Y£X:k.Slh)(cM D/"

Z

M M W

‡N¨_6U=Ypdpk.[k.ƒp[ TflY£Xbanai[‚f§k'[ehvWQ[jpNXbhvSfK/+* f

M-,_ J/. M _ 5

g/0

_0 * U: 1( M W

yp¨_6U=Ypdpk.[k.ƒp[ŸQ[‚cekVUQSf BIM-,_ D/"VM.M-,_ qL UQS|b D ŠJ%&%%JkW

\p¨_6U=Ypdpk.[k.ƒp[S.[‚fhurLdNX aufP56M2,_ D M.M2,_ O * f

M-,_

B%M2,_   UQS|b<D ŠJ&%%&%vJkW

8`ceUQjLŸQ[S.W=[jNce[‘ %°43ª[ PhvkDW

;P¨_6U=Ypdpk.[k.ƒp[jp[¥ r=hvS.[‚cek§hiU=jNf'14M-,

_ D5M

_

56M2,

_

qs ¡UQS b<D ŠJ&%%%J3kW

=p¨8`r=hvYE/4"VM?5

' * O

‘ %°43 "VMO=

g D6H7 /4"VM?J>1kM2,

g

J&%%%J 14M-,*5OW

° H’° " M[=

g

D78 7/1B M2,

g

J%&%%vJLB M-,*J>1 M-,

g

J%%&%vJ>1 M2,*5OW

°93+µ 8

(11)

°43µ 8œ´D“

S![S.[ X:WPX hijqX:j5hvY2UQS.kX:jLk¢cVƒNX:SX=cek.[SlhHflklhHc©U: k.ƒp[ XbavWQUQS§hikVƒpY hHf¦k.ƒNX:kk.ƒp[

Y™X:k.Slh[A Z A hHfjpUQkS.[‚o=dLhvS.[‚r5[ pLanhucVhvklaQ8Q¨z!anak.ƒNX–k£hik£hHf S.[‚oQdLhvS.[‚r·huf kl¥`U fldp›

‰pS.UQdpklhvjp[‚fkVƒNX:kceU=Ypdpk.[A X:jNrkA d #© UQSW:hvŸQ[j5ŸQ[‚cek.U=Sf)X:jNr #2¨6z'k

flk.[?0%qk.ƒp[ª‰NXQf¤hHfN"VMO=

g

hHfUQ‰pkeXbhvjp[‚r  ¡SVUQY"VMª‰8 hvjNceUQSVNUQSX–klhvjpW k.ƒp[ªŸQ[‚cek.UQSf

14M-,_ D M2,_ 5DM-,_ J b<D ŠJ‚¨b¨‚¨vJ3Xb k.[SUQS.k.ƒpUQjpU=S.Y™Xbanhv‚X:klhvUQj¨%7ƒp[fldp‰NflNXQce[flNX:jpjp[‚r

‰8 "VM hHfjpU=kXs{S 8QavU:Ÿ fldp‰NflNX=ce[X:jNržhn ®k.ƒp[Y£X:k.SlhHce[‚f M-,

_

X–S.[jpUQkr=huX–WQUQjNXbaœq

k.ƒp[j %anhvjp[‚X:Sf8pflk.[Y™f(YdNflk‰N[flU–aiŸ=[‚rX:k[‚XQc.ƒZhvk.[SX:k§hiU=j¨w7ƒp[ƒpUQ2[huf*k.US.[‚XQcVƒ

k.ƒp[ceU=jPŸQ[SVWQ[jNce[ŸQ[Sv8Ao=dLhHc.š=aQ8 ¥hvk.ƒXwflY™X a Xbavdp[U: |*ªqk.ƒLdNfSV[¥*X–Sr=hvjpWwk.ƒp[

[ sk.SeXceUPflkThvjLŸQU:avŸQ[‚r‰8k.ƒp[‚fl[®f@8sflkV[Y S.[‚flU:avdpklhvUQjNf¨Lz5rL[kXbhnav[‚rceUQjPŸ=[S.WQ[jNce[®X:jNX–›

a8pf¤hHfU– `k.ƒp[™X–‰NU:ŸQ[X aiW=UQSlhvk.ƒpYcX–j¢‰2[ UQdpjNr¦hvj 9¬ŒU>œ¨2˜A[W:hvŸQ[ƒp[S.[£Xf¤hvYLanhmN[‚r

ceUQjPŸ=[S.WQ[jNce[SV[‚fldLavk ¡U=S'k.ƒp[flY™X aav[‚flkf¤hvjpWQdLaHX:SŸ Xbavdp[Q¨

4 9 &

pUQSsb D ŠJ…%Jb¨‚¨‚¨J3Jhvk£huf¦cVav[‚X:Sk.ƒNX:kk.ƒp[Afl[‚o=dp[jNce[] * f

M-,_ `

hHfrL[‚ceS.[‚X=f¤hvjpW·X:jNr

‰NUQdpjNrL[‚r¦‰N[eavU:¥ ‰8 ^ f

_

qpƒp[jNce[hvkceUQjPŸ=[S.WQ[‚f¨

pU=S'k.ƒp[f.X:šQ[ˆU: `f¤hvYLanhHcVhvk18ª¥[SV[‚flk.SlhHcekk.ƒp[flk.dNr8wkVUk.ƒp[cXQfl[ ND"Šˆ¥'ƒp[S.[

UQjLaQ8k.ƒp[flY™Xbanav[‚flkf¤hvjpWQdLaHX:SŸ Xbavdp[hHf'f§UQdpWQƒLk‚¨%7ƒp[jLdpY[SlhHcXba/[ pN[S§hiYZ[jPkfrL[‚Xbaœq

ƒpU ¥[ŸQ[Sbq:¥hvk.ƒk.ƒp[cXQfl['¥!ƒp[S.['YUQSV[`kVƒNX:jUQjp[f¤hvjpWQdLaHX:SŸ Xbavdp[!hHf6ceUQYpdpkV[‚r%¨Q˜A[

f¤hvYLanh 8£k.ƒp['jpUQkX–klhvUQjˆhij£z!aiW=UQSlhvk.ƒpY1…X–jNrrLS.UQkVƒp[®fldp‰Nf.ceSlhvpk|b.¨:˜©[®rL[jpUQk.['‰8

/1^ f J'B 52k.ƒp[`flY£Xbanai[‚f§kT[ehiW=[jpNXbhvS6U: wA Z Aq?^LX:jNr^

=<>

rL[jpUQk.[(k.ƒp[`fl[‚ceU=jNrX–jNrk.ƒp[

auX–S.WQ[‚flkf¤hvjpWQdLaHX:SŸ Xbavdp[‚fU: uAˆqp‰8 ]/+*%f

M

J'BIM 5 `

Mˆk.ƒp[fl[‚o=dp[jNce[U: `€(hvk.Ÿ X aidp[:€(hvk.

ŸQ[‚cek.UQSU=‰pkXbhvjp[‚r X:k™flkV[ yAX:jNr‰8 1 M D M 5 M ¥'ƒp[S.[,5 M D /1A Z A O * f

M - 51B M

k.ƒp[flkV[ ;L¨p˜A[mNjNX aaQ8ArL[jpUQk.[ˆ‰8 JDMˆk.ƒp[ŸQ[‚cek.U=SCBIM

O

1kMX:jNr¦‰8 MkVƒp[X:jpW:av[

! /4"VM?JOJ6M?56‰2[k¥[[jk.ƒp[fldp‰NflNXQce[f§NX:jpjp[‚r¦‰8N"VMX:jNr£k.ƒp[Ÿ=[‚cek.UQS#J6MQ¨

˜A[ƒNXbŸQ[k.ƒp[ U:anavU:¥hvjpW™S.[‚f§dLaik

"T° A” #

$5 ZM

<MD5DM

$

'&%

JDM

%

f'

% A #_M[=

g(%

ff O * f

M[=

g ' * f M O * f

MO=

g $

f¤hvj /) M 5 $

/œ‡%5

7“b´%´8k7ƒp[6jp[¥©ŸQ[‚cek.UQS#M[=

g

U: skVƒp[T‰NXQf¤hHf/ceU=jNflk.S.dNcek.[‚rX–k/flk.[0U: pz!aiW=UQSlhvk.ƒpY

…ˆhHf®fldNcVƒk.ƒNX:k # M[=

g D *)+

# p

,* + # p ,n

¥'ƒp[S.[- MO=

g D /K-

O " M " Z

M

5+ M 5 M ¨

º:hvjNce[ * f

MO=

g

hHf(k.ƒp[]f§Y™Xbanav[‚flk'[ehvWQ[jLŸ Xbavdp[U=‰pkXbhvjp[‚r S.UQY "VM[=

g

qLk.ƒp[UQpklhvY™Xbanhvk8

U: ¸€!Xbav[ehiW=ƒp›œ€(hvk.pS.Upce[‚rLdpS.[R9uŠ‚†U>[jNfldpS.[‚f!k.ƒNX:k

* f

M[=

g '

/BIM

O/.

#MO=

g 5Z A Z A /1B%M

O/.

#_M[=

g 5

Šm

f 0 . &

(12)

D

*%f

M O … . # Z M[=

g A Z A B M m . f2# Z

M[=

g A Z A!# M[=

g

ŠQm

. f 0 . & *

S'[jNce[Qq  ¡U=S*X–j8

.

D·†pqNfldNcVƒk.ƒNX:k'J3%w-6/

.

5ND/J %`-c/+# Z

M[=

g A Z A BIM5

$

…#

Z

M[=

g A Z A BIM

$ ' Š

$. $ /+* f

M O * f M[=

g

5m

$. $

/+#

Z

M[=

g A Z A #MO=

g O * f M[=

g 5

¶8cVƒpUPUPfhijpW

$. $

D n

+ o n+ # p

+ # p

+ # p o n+ #

p

p

n

¥[ƒNXbŸQ[

$# Z

M[=

g A Z A BIM

$ '

/+*

f

M O * f M[=

g 5 pn /+#

Z

M[=

g A Z A #MO=

g O * f M[=

g 5 p

n *

7ƒp[pS.ULU:  ¡U–aavU:¥®f‰8£jpUQklhHcVhvjpWk.ƒNX:k

# Z

M[=

g A Z

A BIM D 5 ZM MD56M

% - M[=

g % f

X:jNrk.ƒNX–k

% - MO=

g % f D % /K-

O " M " Z

M

5kJ M % f D % J M % f $

fhij / M 5 $ 9

%°P´%“‚° #

x L&' a L M Q "? r/.| 1 r1 (-

w N U L :&' rU 50

7“b´%´8 }  'k.ƒp[£pS.[‚ceUQjNr=hvklhvUQjLhvjpWAY™X–k.Slh M hHf2UPf¤hvklhvŸQ[rL[emNjLhvk.[Qqk.ƒp[jA  S.UQY

/œ‡%5X:jNr k.ƒp[AceUQjLŸQ[S.W=[jNce[¢U– c] *%f

M `

qT¥[ªƒNXbŸQ[anhvY M 5 ZM M 5D †X:jNr k.ƒPdNf

ahvYNM 5DM D5†p¨p˜A[ceUQjNcVavdNrL[k.ƒNX:k(anhvY M7*M¹hHf®Xf¤hvjpWQdLaHX:SŸ:Xbavdp[U: Aˆ¨ 9

¹&6® &6¹,£. ¹

˜A[jpU:¥"r=hHf.cedNf.fflUQY[cVƒpU:hHce[‚fU: k.ƒp[pS.[‚ceU=jNr=hik§hiU=jLhijpW©Y™X:k.Slh MQ¨~!UQk.[k.ƒNX:k

h jpU©pS.[‚ceUQjNr=hvklhvUQjLhvjpW hHfdNfl[‚r%q(k.ƒNX:kˆhHf h  <MD,i -J i D † qTk.ƒp[j k.ƒp[¦‰LaiUpcVš

{X:jNceUPfYZ[k.ƒpUsrZhHfSV[‚ceU Ÿ=[S.[‚rdpjNrL[SX:jceULflklaQ8hvYLav[Y[jLkX:k§hiU=j¨'jk.ƒp[UQk.ƒp[S

ƒNX:jNr%q6XQf¥'XQfXbavS.[‚X=r8 NU:hvjLk.[‚r UQdpk£X¢r=hHX:W=UQjNXba®pS.[‚ceU=jNr=hik§hiU=jLhijpW U– ]k.ƒp[£  UQS.Y

MaD /

O * f

M

-w5

o g

¥*hikVƒYD"!b$#&%/A Z Aa5#huf(k.ƒp[f¤hvYLav[‚flk'cVƒpU:hHce[Q¨P}¤k(huf([Lz[‚ceklhvŸQ[

UQjLaQ8hn /k.ƒp[[ehiW=[jPŸQ[‚cekVUQSfTU– \A Z AX–S.[®cVavUPfl[k.UkVƒp[]cX:jpU=jLhucX a+Ÿ=[‚cek.UQSf¨:}  /¥['kX:š=[

XWQULUsrX:ppSVU LhvY™X:klhvUQjkVURA

Z

Aˆqpk.ƒp[j¥[X:S.[ œXQce[‚r£k.UZk.ƒp[pS.UQ‰Lav[YU: ¸f§U:avŸQhvjpW

/fl[ŸQ[SX a5(anhvjp[‚X:Sf8pflk.[Y™f'X–k®[‚XQcVƒhvk.[SeX:klhvUQj¢X–jNrk.ƒp[X:YUQdpjLk'U: 6¥UQS.šceUQdLaHr¦‰N[

(13)

}œj¦UQSrL[Sk.U£U Ÿ=[SceUQY[k.ƒLhHfr=hn­cedLavk8Qq%¥[pS.UQNULfl[k.UkX:š=[ MKD8

o g XQf®X

pS.[‚ceUQjNr=hvklhvUQjp[Shvjz'avWQUQS§hikVƒpY™…pq¥!ƒp[S.[ hHfX WQULUsrAX–ppS.U PhvY™X:k§hiU=jAk.UsA Z

z®jAXQrLŸ:X:jPkeX:WQ[ˆhHfk.ƒNX:kk.ƒp[ceUPflkS.[Y™X hijNf!avU:¥"f¤hvjNce[k.ƒp[Y™X–k.Slh hHfceUQjNflkeX:jPk

rLdpSlhvjpW™k.ƒp[¹hvk.[SX:klhvUQjNf’¨pdpS.kVƒp[S.YUQS.[hvk!hHf'cVav[‚X:S®kVƒNX:k'k.ƒp[ceUQjPŸ=[S.WQ[jNce[S.[‚fldLavkU: 

7ƒp[UQS.[Y Œp¨vŠ'f§klhnaaƒpU:aHrpf'X=f6flULUQjXQf hHf(NULf¤hvklhvŸQ[/¤UQS6jp[WPX–klhvŸQ[?56rL[emNjLhikV[Q¨P˜ hvk.ƒ

k.ƒLhHfYUpr=hmDcX–klhvUQj,J M B M O 1 M D[/K-

O o g A Z

Aa5B M m * f

M o g B M ¥'ƒLhHc.ƒwflƒpU:¥®f

k.ƒNX:khn  hHf(XWQUPUprX:ppSVU LhvY™X:klhvUQjZk.UA|Z6AˆqPX:jNr¹hn ¥['¥'Slhvk.[CB%MaD

.

MUBQmM&.MPq

¥'ƒp[S.[ .M¹hHfU: TjpUQS.Y ŠX–jNr .M B#qpk.ƒp[ceUQYNU=jp[jPkf!U: SJDMˆ¥hnana6‰N[rLUQYhvjNX:k.[‚r

‰8kVƒpUPfl[U: /1A Z Aa5

o g B%MaD

+

l n

BPmM?/A Z A 5 o g

._ML¨L~'U:¥ hn \^ huf!flY™Xbana/ceUQYNX:SV[‚r

k.Uk.ƒp[UQk.ƒp[Sf¤hvjpWQdLaHX:SŸ Xbavdp[‚fq k.ƒp[j™kVƒp[®ceUQY2UQjp[jPkef6U– cBZ‰N[‚ceU=Y[‚f(hvjNceS.[‚XQf¤hvjpW:aQ8

rLUQYhvjNX:jLk‚¨

%°P´%“‚°

L# u N#& w # @5

% o g O

/1A Z Aa5

o g 56M

% f D

/L5 r

† ' * f MO=

g O ^ f

* f

M O ^ f '

^

^ f /1^

f O ^ f 5

^

<>

O ^ f ^

f

^

<>

O

f¤hvj f M /1^

<>

O ^ 5

m /L5 /1y5

r)6MaD ! /1B%MJLB 5C ! r

Lr:BIM B 0

7“b´%´8 14M D o g

5DM¥!ƒp[jNce[ JDM BIM

O

14M D * f

M

/1AZ6Aa5

o g B%M

O

%M¥hvk.ƒ

IM D[/+

o g O

/1A Z A 5 o g 5456M

~!U ¥ h ¥[wrL[‚ceUQYZNUPfl[¦k.ƒp[wŸ=[‚cek.UQSRB M X=f B M D CFEJ5 M B mf¤hvj M . M ¥'ƒp[S.[

._M

& ] B

`

qpk.ƒp[j J6MaD * f

M

g

l n

CFEJ56MrBHm f¤hvj DM/1A Z Aa5

o g

.MQm IM=¨

7ƒp[UQpk§hiY£Xbanhik8£U: 6€'XU8Qav[ehvWQƒp›œ€(hvk.pSVUsce[‚rLdpS.[ˆ[jNfldpS.[‚f!k.ƒNX:k

* f

M[=

g ' J ZM A Z A'JDM

%

JDM

% f

/\5

flUk.ƒNX:k

* f

MO=

g O ^ f ' J ZM

/1A Z A O ^ f - 54JDM

%

J6M

% f

/v;5

D *

M

f¤hvj f M . Z

M /1A Z Aa5

o g O

^cf/1A Z A 5 o f . M m /vfU5

* f

M g

l CFE_J

f

DM<m Jrb- f DM

%

/1A

Z

Aa5

o g .M

% f

m /L5

/1=5

D

*

M

f¤hvj f 6M. Z

M /1A Z Aa5

o g O ^ f /1A Z A 5 o f ._M

* f

M g CFEJ

f

DM<m JUb$-

f

DM

%

/1A

Z

Aa5

o g .M

% f

m /L5 /‹5

(14)

' g

l n O l n

l

g

l CFE_J

f M m g

l

JUb$-

f M Jrb- f

DM<m /#5 /Šb†5

D ^

^ f ^ =<>

O ^ f ^ f

^

=<>

O

f¤hvj f M /1^

=<>

O ^ 5

f¤hvj f DM<m /L5 /Š=Š?5

7ƒp[pS.ULU:  U:anavU:¥®f'‰8£dNf¤hvjpW™k.ƒp[cVaHXQfVf¤hHcXba/hvjp[‚o=dNXbanhvk18 9vŠ‚†U>f¤hvj

f

6M

' n + o

lrn

l n o l n ¨ 9

}œk+huf+hvYNU=S.kX:jLkk.U®f§k.S.[‚f.f%kVƒNX:k‚qedpjLanhiš=[`kVƒp[UQS.[Y …p¨vŠQqek.ƒp[UQSV[Y‡N¨vŠpS.U:Ÿ=hurL[‚f#[‚fl›

klhvY™X:k.[‚f#UQjkVƒp[`f¤hvjpWQdLaHX:STŸ:Xbavdp[‚f¥hvk.ƒLhvjUQjp[Thvk.[SeX:klhvUQj¨?7ƒp[‚fl[6[‚f§klhvY™X:k.[‚fX:S.[(U: ¡kV[j

N[‚f.f¤hvYhHflk§hucZX:jNr * M Y™XU8ceUQjLŸQ[S.WQ[ˆk.U:¥*X–Srpf ^AYdNcVƒw‰N[kVk.[S®kVƒNX:jk.ƒLhHfk.ƒp[UQS.[Y

pS.[‚r=hHcekf¨S!U ¥[ŸQ[Sbqk.ƒp[8X:S.[XQcce[pkX:‰Lav[(hvjk.ƒp[ThvY2UQS.kX:jLkTcXQfl[6¥!ƒp[S.[6k.ƒp[flY™Xbav›

ai[‚f§k]f¤hvjpWQdLaHX:SŸ X aidp[ ^ hHf®f§Y™XbanagceUQYNX–S.[‚rk.Uk.ƒp[ˆUQk.ƒp[Sf’¨N_(UQjNf¤hHrL[S' UQS'[ NX:YLav[

XªY™X:k.S§h©hij ¥'ƒLhHc.ƒk^ DŠb†

o g ^ q/kVƒp[j

l

o l n l n

l

o

n+

l

o l

hHf‰NU=dpjNrL[‚r3‰8

ŠSm 1% f

DMX:jNrZhHf[ pN[‚cekV[‚rk.Ufl[k.k§ai[rLU:¥'jwX–S.UQdpjNrªŠ¥'ƒLhnav[

l

l n l n o l n

Š‚†

o ¨

7ƒp[Ac.ƒpU:hHce[AU– k.ƒp[ªpS.[‚ceUQjNr=hvklhvUQjLhvjpW5Y™X:k.Slh5 LauXU8pfX ceSVdNcVhuX aS.U:av[¦ ¡UQS£k.ƒp[

fldNcce[‚f.fU: 6k.ƒp[Y[kVƒpUsr%¨2˜A[ƒNXbŸQ[fl[[jªk.ƒNX–k®k.ƒp[‰2[k.k.[Sk.ƒp[X:ppS.U PhvY™X–klhvUQjwk.U

/1A Z A 5 o g

qTk.ƒp[wcVavUPfl[SZk.ƒp[ŸQ[‚cek.UQSZJDMkVU B#¨7ƒp[[ pk.S.[Y[wcX=fl[ƒNX:pN[jNfZ¥'ƒp[j

D /1A Z A 5 o g

¨7*ƒLhufcX=fl[QqDX aikVƒpUQdpWQƒªdNfldNXbanaQ8¦hiYZNUPf.fhi‰Lav[Zhvj¢pSeXQceklhHce[Qq%Y™XU8‰N[

dNfl[‚rk.UZ[jLahvWQƒLk.[j¦k.ƒp[k.ƒp[UQSv8Q¨

7“b´´%Du‘Dv´ 3

L# | 4 D[/A

Z A 5 o g r &L %@ "VMa&L` -

'&r 3s!4 L #L,j' wL N!v?h 4?K"!#$%&'

YZM?/v/1A Z Aa5

o g J["

g

5D\7VG#-^]_"

g J /1A Z A 5 o g " g

Jb¨‚¨b¨vJ/1A Z A 5 o M[=

g "

gF`

rc"

g

r L&r a 'R#3R uL& . L 0

7“b´%´8 pU:anavU:¥®f S.UQY k.ƒp[ œXQcekTk.ƒNX:kS"VM D 8 7/4"VM

o g J>1kM

o g ,g Jb¨‚¨b¨1J 14M

o g ,*5/X:jNr hijˆk.ƒLhHf/cX=fl[ ¡U=S b D ŠJb¨‚¨b¨1J3JI1kM

o g ,_ D[/A|ZdA 5 o g 5DM

o g ,_ DkBIM

o g ,_ O ^ fM o g ,_ /1AZ6Aa5

o g B%M

o g ,_ D

" M o g ,_. M o g ,_ O

^6f

M o g ,_

/1A Z A 5 o g " M o g ,_. M o g ,_ 9

˜A[®cX–jk.ƒLdNfq:hvj£k.ƒLhHf`cX=fl[QqPrL[SlhvŸQ[UQpklhvY™X aN‰NUQdpjNrpf¸ UQS`|XbŸ=hurpf§UQj«¬fTYZ[k.ƒpUsr%¨

7ƒp[flY£Xbanai[‚f§k®f¤hvjpWQdLaHX:SŸ Xbavdp[U: Tk.ƒp[Y™X:k.S§h (cMˆf.X:klhHf¤mN[‚f

* f

M

D3Y hij

# Z A Z A!#

# Z #

¥!ƒp[S.[ Y D/YZM

/1A

Z

Aa5

o g J["

g *

{%[k * D[/1A Z Aa5

p

n

#Zk.ƒp[j

Š

*

fM

D Y™X g * Z /1A

Z

Aa5

o g *

* Z *

¥'ƒp[S.[ Y Š D Y M /A

Z A 5 o g

J/A

Z

Aa5 pn " g *

Références

Documents relatifs

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rennes, IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rh ˆone-Alpes, 46 avenue F´elix Viallet, 38031 GRENOBLE Cedex

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rennes, IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rh ˆone-Alpes, 46 avenue F´elix Viallet, 38031 GRENOBLE Cedex

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rh ˆone-Alpes, 46 avenue F´elix Viallet, 38031 GRENOBLE Cedex

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rennes, IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rh ˆone-Alpes, 46 avenue F´elix Viallet, 38031 GRENOBLE Cedex

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rennes, IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rh ˆone-Alpes, 46 avenue F´elix Viallet, 38031 GRENOBLE Cedex

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rennes, IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rh ˆone-Alpes, 46 avenue F´elix Viallet, 38031 GRENOBLE Cedex

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rennes, IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rh ˆone-Alpes, 46 avenue F´elix Viallet, 38031 GRENOBLE Cedex

Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rennes, IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex Unit´e de recherche INRIA Rh ˆone-Alpes, 46 avenue F´elix Viallet, 38031 GRENOBLE Cedex