Automatic Generation of Safe Handlers for Multi-Task Systems

Texte intégral

(1)Automatic Generation of Safe Handlers for Multi-Task Systems Eric Rutten, Hervé Marchand. To cite this version: Eric Rutten, Hervé Marchand. Automatic Generation of Safe Handlers for Multi-Task Systems. [Research Report] RR-5345, INRIA. 2004. �inria-00071252�. HAL Id: inria-00071252 https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00071252 Submitted on 23 May 2006. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés..

(2) INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE. Automatic Generation of Safe Handlers for Multi-Task Systems Éric Rutten — Hervé Marchand. N° 5345 21st October 2004. ISSN 0249-6399. ISRN INRIA/RR--5345--FR+ENG. THÈME 1. apport de recherche.

(3)

(4)

(5)

(6) "!# %$%&(') *,+-%&.

(7) 0/213 '54687'9(: ' ;*<>=@?BADC(EFEHGJIKMLONGJ<PRQTSVUW<F? XYUWIZY[ \ ]_^H`BaBb8cedf gaihJjRk3aHlgnmRgnl^H`Ba g opqJr.aHlgsout8owv8d\xaHly:aHpnla z g d8hJ{9{(qMpnl|9apa z]_aHpz]_a~}J cRb gnl8t8zHlqMaHpsJcB{5hJa g. iJ9% ahJpa}2laHpa gnla |}ln]_a{9pqMphJ``}9qJpaihJ ¢¡£ln`Baz qM}2lnpqM ¤gnmRgnlaH`Bgi¥5gnj_z]¦hMg} pqMqMln§z¥ hJj9lqM`BqMlnäqMp©hi¨2§qM}9§zgnmRgnlaH`Bgiªs\ ]_aHmhJpa%|9a gn}_a |¬«*ln]`j9 ln{9 §alhMgWgi¥(aihMz]¦«*ln]¬`j9 ln{9 §a`BqW|9a giª ®¯l§g°z qM`{9 §a>klqD|9a gn}lhMgn]5hJ}_|R §aHpg°ln]5hJluz qM}2lnpqM 5ln]_agn«*lz]9}9%qJOhMzHln¨Wln§a g:}±qMp|9aHpulq}_gnj9pagh²³aHl´m {9pqM{aHpnln§a gqJ ln]_a §qM5hJ ugnmRgnlaH` ª a{9pqM{qga±hT`BqW|9aH °qJ lhMgnRg}µlaHpn`BgqJ lnphJ}_gnln§qM}¶gmWgnlaH`Bg·¥O|9a>¡ gn}_a |a gn{a zH¸hJ m%«*ln]ln]_a {9j9pn{(qga qJOhJ{9{9 m2}9Da>kR§gnln}9D|R§gzHpaHla*z qM}2lnpqM §aHpugnmW}ln]_a g§gla z]9}9§¹2j_a giª\ ]9§g {9pqi¨W§|9a guj_g:«*ln]ThDgnmWglaH`±hJln§z*`BaHln]_q2|9qM §qMm¥2³qMp:ln]_ahJj9lqM`±hJln§zsaH}_aHphJln§qM}TqJOgh²³a*lhMgn%]5hJ}_|R §aHpgi¥2«*ln] ln]_agnj9{9{qMpnl°qJYgnmW}_z]9pqM}_qMj_gu ¸hJ}9j5hJa guhJ}_|±hMggq2zH¸hJla |lqWqM §g³qMp:z qM`{9 ¸hJln§qM}hJ}_|ºqMpn`±hJ z qM`{9j9lhJln§qM}Oª »¼½¾¿À JÁ¤ dsaihJ ¢¡£ln`BaBgnmRgnlaH`Bgi¥ÂgFh²ºaB|9a g}O¥|R§gzHpaHlaz qM}lnpqM gnmW}ln]_a gn§gi¥gnmW}_z]9pqM}_qMj_g{9pqMphJ`¡ `}9_ª. ÃÚÂÄÛ ÅiÌFÅHÆHÜÇWÌ9È¸É>È¸ÊÝ ËHÏ>ËÅ·ÌÇnÍ·Þ·ÎÏÍiÆnÍiß Å·ÎiÆFÆÅiÏHÐÆHÑ·ÒFÌiÏ9ÒWÈÖÓ>È¸ÓHÅJÅJÔ2ÔÕ>ÕHÕHÕHÕ5Õ5È³ÆÈ³ÅiÆ.ÍiÆHÅ·ÒFÏ9ÆFÏ ÈÖÓ>ÐnÑ·ÅiÌi×FÜÒWÌ>ÈÖÓ>Å>ÅiË Ìi×Ñ²ÇHØÒ ÑMÙÏ>ÅHË. Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4 76 61 52 00 — Télécopie +33 4 76 61 52 52.

(8)

(9) (

(10) ©"$%'_

(11) %%

(12) n' '(')$"'_7'_ : ' &n

(13) 0/

(14) %' qMj_g*}_qMj_g*}2lfHpa ggqM}_g% ¸h%{9pqMphJ``±hJln§qM}¬|9agnmWgl^H`Ba g laH`{_g.¡£pf aH OlaH §g*¹2j qM} §a g*lnpqMj9ä |_hJ}_g© §a ggnmRgnl^H`Ba g©pqMqMln§¹j_a gi¥OhJj9lqM`BqM9 §a gqMjµh ¨W§qM}9§¹j_a giª%®¯ gqM}lDz qM}Hj_gDh ä z±|9a`j9 ln{9 §a gDlMz]_a gi¥ z]5hMzHj9}_a|9qMlf a |9a`BqW|9a g`j9 ln{9 §a g·ª ®¯ a gnlBz qM`{9 §a>k9a |9a z qM}_z aH¨qMp± §a gBa gnln§qM}9}5hJpa g|9a lMz]_a g±¹2j9 z qM}lnpM §aH}2lD ¸hz qM``j9lhJln§qM}¶|9a ghMzHln¨Wlf g8|9a£h qM}!ThMggnj9paHp|9a g8{9pqM{9pn§fHlf g|9a%g#"9paHlfgnj9ps §a%gnmRgnl^H`Ba §qM5hJ £ª}_qMj_gÂ{9pqM{qgqM}_gh*`BqW|9^H §a gÂ|9a:lMz]_a gaH}laHpn`Ba g¤|9a°gnmRgnl^H`Ba gÂ|9a°lnphJ}_gnln§qM}O¥Mz qM}Hj_gg{(f zH¸hJ §aH`BaH}2l |_hJ}_g §a9j9l|$ hJ{9{9 §¹2j_aHpB|9a g%la z]9}9§¹2j_a gBa>kR§gnlhJ}la g|9a3gnmW}ln]_^ gaT|9a3z qM}lnpM §aHj9pgB|R§gzHpaHlgiª&% a zH }_qMj_g |9qM}9}_aBj9}_aB`BfHln]_q2|9qM §qM§agnmWglfH`±hJln§¹j_a{qMj9pD ¸h3fH}_fHphJln§qM} hJj9lqM`±hJln§¹2j_a±|9aa gnln§qM}9}5hJpa g%|9alMz]_a g g#"9pgi¥9gj9p* ¸h5hMga|9a g* ¸hJ}9hJa gsgnm2}_z]9pqM}_a gaHl|9a gqMj9ln §gshMggqWzH§f g*|9aDz qM`{9 ¸hJln§qM}¬aHlzihJ §zHj9 YºqMpn`BaH £ª ' À i ¾ )( * mWgnl^H`Ba g laH`{_g.¡£pf aH £¥9z qM}_z aH{9ln§qM} g"9pa¥2gnmW}ln]_^ gas|9a©z qM}lnpM §aHj9pg*|R§gzHpaHlgi¥W{9pqMphJ``±h²¡ ln§qM}gnmW}_z]9pqM}_aª.

(15) +-%&.

(16) ./M( '_4 '_7'_: ' .

(17) !" #$. a hJpa°}2laHpa gnla |%}ln]_au|9a gn}%qJpaihJ ¢¡£ln`Ba z qM}2lnpqM 9gnmWglaH`Bgi¥²gj_z]hMgÂ}%pqM(qMln§z¥hJj9lqM`BqMlnä qMph ¨W§qM}9§z gnmRgnlaH`Bgi¥·«*]_aHpaln]_a:z qM}lnpqM §aHp`{9 §aH`BaH}lgz qM}lnpqM 2 ¸h «giª\ ]9§gO}2¨qM ä g|R&%YaHpaH}lhMg{(a zHlgY a°aª _ª¥²|9aH¨W§z a ' gaH}_gqMp°hJ}_|hMzHlnj5hJlqMp)(¤`±hJ}5hJaH`BaH}li¥W}j9`BaHpn§zihJ (z qM`{9j9lhJln§qM}O¥WhJ}_|ln]_a|R§gzHpaHla¥aHäH}2l.¡£5hMga |Bgn«*lz]9}9 aHl´«ua aH}`Bq2|9a gqJhMzHln¨Wl´mª * j_z]gnmRgnlaH`BghJpaD|9a g}_a |«*ln]h%}j9`(aHp8qJ¤lhMgWgi¥9a>k9a zHj9la |}hzHmRzH §z « him¥:aihMz] z qM`{9j9ln}9µh zH §qga | §qWqM{z qM}lnpqM £ª¬vs}Va>k_hJ`{9 §aqJgj_z]Vhz qM}lnpqM *gnmRgnlaH` hJpz]9la zHlnj9pa3§g *,+.-/-.0132 5 4´7 ª 6°hMz] lhMgnVzihJ}w]5h ä |R& %YaHpaH}l`Bq2|9a gi¥u«*]9§z] zihJ} a|R& %aHpaH}2l±{9]5hMga g ' }9ln¸hJ 9 8·hJln§qM}O¥ }_qM`}5hJ £¥_a>k9z aH{9ln§qM}]5hJ}_|R }9: (>¥_qMp äHpgn§qM}_g*`{9 §aH`BaH}2ln}9±ln]_a©ghJ`Ba8ºj9}_zHln§qM}5hJ l´mT«*ln] |R& %aHpaH}2l §aHäH §g qJ¹2j5hJ l´m ' aª _ª¥z qM`{9j9lhJln§qM}whJ{9{9pqikW`±hJln§qM.} (>¥°hJ}_|Vz qgnl ' aª _ª¥z qM`{9j9lhJln§qM} ln`Ba¥aH}_aHpnm¥`BaH`BqMpnm¥ 5hJ}_|R«*§|Rln]BqJz qM``j9}9§zihJln§qM}O¥gn§|9a>¡á %Ya zHlgqM}ln]_a aH}2¨2pqM}9`BaH}2)l ( 2<; ¥J ; ¥J" 4´=ª 6 ¸hJqMphJla*z qM}lnpqM _gnmRgnlaH`Bg 5q %YaHp:`j9 ln{9 §a@j9}_zHln§qM}5hJ ln§a gi¥2`±hJ}5hJa |B2mBh©}j9`(aHp qJYgj_z]BlhMgnRgi¥«*]9§z]zihJ}Ba }¨qMa |}Bga ¹2j_aH}_z a qMp{5hJphJ §aH £ª\ ]_aHmµ`±h m ln]_aH}V]5h älq¬gn]5hJpaB{9pqWz a ggqMpg%qMp|9aH¨W§z a gi¥hJ}_|¶lq(a±`±hJ}5hJa |V«Dª piª liªln]_aHp }laHphMzHln§qM}_g·ª°®¯}_gnlhJ}_z a gqJgnj_z] gmWgnlaH`Bg}hJ{9{9 §zihJln§qM}_g8hJpa > ? z qM}2lnpqM *gnmWglaH`Bg ' aª _ªpqMqMln§z )g (©«*]_aHpalhMgnRgD`{9 §aH`BaH}2l%ln]_az qM`{9j9lhJln§qM} qJhz qM}lnpqM ¸h «"qMp ºj9}_zHln§qM}O¥9}hzHmRzH §z« h m¥_paihM|R}9gaH}_gqMp*}9{9j9li¥hJ}_|3{9pqW|Rj_zH}9ThMzHlnj5hJlqMpsz qM``±hJ}_|qMj9ln{9j9liª v~}_qMln§qM} qJ ¹2j5hJ l´mqJ gaHpn¨2§z a%}¦ln]_a gagnmRgnlaH`Bg8§g8ln]5hJlln]_a}2j9`BaHpn§zihJ °z qM`{9j9lhJln§qM}_g}2¨qM ä |Y¥ aª _ª¥`±hJlnpn¢k%z qM`{9j9lhJln§qM}³qMpW}_aH`±hJln§z `Bq2|9aH Wj9{|_hJla¥zihJ}(au{(aHp.³qMpn`Ba |%«*ln]|R& %aHpaH}2l¤ §aHäH §gqJ hMz zHj9phMzHm¥m`±hJW}9©hJ{9{9pqikW`±hJln§qM}_gaª _ª¥Jm `ln}9sln]_a |9aHäH §qM{9`BaH}lqJ5gaHpn§a gi¥MqMph ¨qM§|R}9©ln]_a z qM`{9j9lhJln§qM}BqJ_laHpn`Bg¤ln]5hJl¤]5h ä*h*}_aH 9 §a ¨hJ j_a°j9}_|9aHpgqM`Ba z qM}_|Rln§qM}_g 2 " 4´ª\ ]_a z qM}lnpqM R ¸hi«g zihJ}3hJ §gq|R& %YaHp°2mln]_a« h m±aH}_aHpnm§guz qM}_gnj9`Ba |±2m±hMzHlnj5hJlqMpguqMp gn§|9a>¡á %Ya zHlguqM}ln]_aaH}¨WpqM}9`BaH}liª ? laH §a z qM``j9}9§zihJln§qM}VgmWgnlaH`BghJ}_|¦{qMpnlhJ9 §a|9aH¨2§z a g© az aH j9 ¸hJplaH §aH{9]_qM}_a gD{9pa gaH}lD`±hJ}2mºj9}_z>¡ ln§qM}5hJ ln§a g @°aª _ª¥gn}5hJ u{9pq2z a gg}9¦hMg}¨qM§z apa z qM}9ln§qM} qMpaH}_z qW|R}9g³qMplnphJ}_g`§ggn§qM}O¥zihJ} ]5hiä|R& %aHpaH}2l`{9 §aH`BaH}lhJln§qM}_g%hMz z qMp|R}9lqln]_a%« h m¦aH}_aHpnm§g©gn{aH}li¥YqMp©¨qM j9`BaqJu|_hJlh3hJ}_| j_gaqJ¤5hJ}_|R«*§|Rln]Oª ? hJj9lqM`BqM9 §aaHà |9|9a | a ¹j9{9`BaH}2lgi¥:} aHäHpnmqJsln]_aHphMzHln¨hJln§qM} z qM} A_j9phJln§qM}_gi¥u]5h ähäH} aH}_aHpnm z qM}_gnj9`{9ln§qMB} >ln]9§g ¸hJlnlaHp]5hMglqa(qMj9}_|9a |Y¥(a zihJj_gaBqJ ln]_aB5hJlnlaHpnm¥gq3ln]5hJlln]_a±hJjR¡ lqM}_qM`mTqJOln]_a©zihJp §gu}_qMlrna qM{5hJp|R9 8ia |Yª:v l ln]_a8ghJ`Ba8ln`Ba¥2{9pn§qMpnl¯m±lhMgnRg ' aª _ª¥WpaH ¸hJla |lqgh²³aHl´ m ( ]5hiäDlqa©pa gn{a zHla |Yª ®¯l§gDz qM`{9 §a>k lq3]5hJ}_|R §aBlhMgnRgDhJ}_| lqz qM}lnpqM uln]_aBgn«*lz]9}9qJu`BqW|9a gD}µqMp|9aHplq}_gnj9pa{9pqM{aHpnln§a g z]5hJphMzHlaHpn9 8 }9wln]_a¬gFh²ºaHl¯mwqJln]_a¦z qM}lnpqM DgnmRgnlaH`Bgiª\ ]9§ggh²³aHl´mw§gTqJºlaH}xzHpnln§zihJ ©} ln]_aºphJ`BaH«uqMpn qJDlnphJ}_gn{qMpnlhJln§qM} gmWgnlaH`Bg·¥*aH}_aHpnm {9pq2|Rj_zHln§qM} hJ}_|Y¥ } aH}_aHphJ £¥*} hJ ©gnmRgnlaH`BgB«*ln]xhµgnlnpqM}9 hJ}_| {qggn9 m ]55h 8·hJp|9qMj_g©}2laHphMzHln§qM}µ«*ln]¦{(a qM{9 §aqMp©ln]_aaH}¨WpqM}9`BaH}liª\ ]_a%{9pqM{aHpnln§a g©lqT(a%aH}_gnj9pa |¦zihJ} z qM}_z aHpn}Tln]_asgh²³ashMz z a gg°lqpa gqMj9pz a gi¥RhMz z qMp|R}9%lq{5hJpnln§zHj9 ¸hJp*z qM}_gnlnphJ}lg*qJOga ¹2j_aH}_zH}9%qMp a>k9zH j_gn§qM}_gi¥ qMp`±hJ}5hJ}9T`BqMpa¹2j5hJ}lnlhJlnähMgn{a zHlgi¥9 a(qMj9}_|R}93z qgnls«*]9 §aD`±h²kR`9 8 }9T¹2j5hJ l´m ' £ª aª¥ `ln}9 |9aHphM|_hJln§qM.} (>ª ChJj9 l%lqM §aHphJ}_z a3}Vln]_a ga3gnmRgnlaH`BgzihJ}aTga aH} hMg%g«*lz]9}9 aHl´«ua aH} z qM} A_j9phJln§qM}_g·¥ j9{qM}ln]_aqWz zHj9pnpaH}_z a%qJ£hJ j9paqJuaª _ª¥(pa gqMj9pz a gi¥(«*]9 §a%`±hJ}lhJ}9}9hz aHpnlhJ}¦ §aHäH qJ°@j9}_zHln§qM}5hJ l¯m¥ {qggn9 mT} |9aHphM|9a | `BqW|9a giª vs Oln]9§ggj9a gnlgln]5hJls}h`j9 ln¢¡£lhMggnmRgnlaH` ¥9ln]_aDz qM}2lnpqM ¤qJ°hMzHln¨hJln§qM}_gshJ}_|qJ`BqW|9aDgn«*lz]9}9_¥ }¦qMp|9aHp8lqagh²³a¥5`j_gnl©pa gnlnpn§zHl8ln]_agnmRgnlaH` «*ln]9}¦hJ §q·«ua | z qM`9}5hJln§qM}_gi¥Y«*ln]¬pa gn{(a zHl8lqTgnlhJln§zihJ qMp|RmW}5hJ`§zihJ z qM}_|Rln§qM}_giª. DDFEHG#IKJ)LMI.

(18) . ! : /: #

(19) ! . * j_z]VgnmRgnlaH`Bg{9pa gaH}2l¨hJpn§qMj_ghMgn{a zHlghJ}_| ¸himaHpg > §qi« ¡£ §aHäH °}2laHp.³hMz a g«*ln]¶ln]_a±z qM}lnpqM §a |{9]mRgn§zihJ ng mRgnlaH` ¥pa gqMj9pz a g ' z qM`{9j9lhJln§qM}O¥9z qM``j9}9§zihJln§qM}O¥9qMpuz qM}lnpqM §a |T{9]mRgn§zihJ gmWgnlaH` (>¥2z qM}lnpqM (lhMgnRg ' «*ln] {qggn9 m±|R&%YaHpaH}l äHpgn§qM}_g «Dª piª liª{aHp.ºqMpn`±hJ}_z a (>¥_hJ}_|Y¥RqM}3lqM{3qJ¤hJ ln]9§gi¥9hJ{9{9 §zihJln§qM}_g*ga ¹j_aH}_zH}9gnj_z] lhMgnRg }3qMp|9aHp lqºj9 &A_ gqM`Baºj9}_zHln§qM}5hJ l´mª C¤j9pa%b©|9aH{9§zHlghaH}_aHphJ OhJpz]9la zHlnj9paDqJ¤ln]_a©z qM}_gn§|9aHpa | gnmRgnlaH`Bg 2 " 4´¥W«*]9§z]ln]9§g {5hJ{aHp z qM}_g§|9aHpg }Tln]_a©`BqMpa8{5hJpnln§zHj9 ¸hJpzihMga©qJz qM}lnpqM OgnmRgnlaH`Bg*hJ}_|TlhMgnWg·ª¤®¯} ln]9§g@phJ`BaH« qMpn(¥ln]_a± 9phJpnmµqJz qM}lnpqM lhMgnWg§g`±hJ}5hJa |m¶h lhMgn¦]5hJ}_|R §aHpi¥ln]5hJlpa z aHä gpa ¹2j_a gnlg ºpqM` ln]_ahJ{9{9 §zihJln§qM}O¥:hJ}_|¶`BqM}9lqMpga>k9a zHj9ln§qM}V}¶paH ¸hJln§qM}V«*ln]¶ln]_aB{9]2mWg§zihJ ugnmRgnlaH` ' }{5hJpnln§zHj9 ¸hJpi¥ ln]_alaHpn`}5hJln§qM}¬qJ¤lhMgnR)g (>ªdsa gqMj9pz a g*`±hJ}5hJa |2mTln]_aDlhMgn]5hJ}_|R §aHp8hJpaDqJ¤l¯«uqW}_|9g >

(20) !

(21) "$#.

(22) . 6&%7& 0810:9/9;< 08=- >(1')%. ?@> A%&0. 0'>02%&0. $%&')(+*,

(23) -/.102 340./02')5. ¤j9paBb>:\ ]_az qM}_gn§|9aHpa |aH}_aHphJ ÂgnmRgnlaH` hJpz]9la zHlnj9paª ? {9]2mWg§zihJ 2pa gqMj9pz a g}ln]_auz qM}lnpqM §a |gnmRgnlaH` >ÂhMzHlnj5hJlqMpg ' «*]9§z]gn]_qMj9 §|l´mW{9§zihJ mD}_qMlÂa°z qM}2lnpqM §a | 2mBl´« q|R&%aHpaH}2l lhMgWgi¥2qMp g]_qMj9 §|hJ « himWg aj9}_|9aHp z qM}lnpqM YqJÂgqM`BaslhMgn¥2qMp gn]_qMj9 §|(aj_ga |qM}9 m j9}_|9aHp z qM}_|Rln§qM}_g°z qM}_z aHpn}9}9%ln]_aHp:{9]mRgn§zihJ _}2laHphMzHln§qM}«*ln]qMln]_aHp°{5hJpnlg°qJln]_agnmRgnlaH` (>¥gaH}_gqMpg ' «*]9§z]`]2lspa ¹2j9paDlqB(aj_ga | «*ln] {5hJpnln§zHj9 ¸hJp8{5hJphJ`BaHlaHp8gaHlnln}9g`±hJW}9±ln]_aH` j9}_gn]5hJphJ9 §a 2mgaHäHphJ lhMgnRgi¥WqMp «*]9§z]`]l*}2¨qM ägqM`Ba8z qM}lnpqM Oln]_aH`BgaH ä g «Dª piª liª¥9aª _ª¥RqMpn§aH}2lhJln§qM.} (>¥9ln]_a « h m ln]_aHm z qM}_gnj9`BaaH}_aHpnm¥¤qMpln]_a{(aHp.³qMpn`±hJ}_z a±qMp¹j5hJ l¯m «*ln]¶«*]9§z]ln]_aHm zihJ}VhMz]9§aHä±ln]_aHp ºj9}_zHln§qM}O¥Oªªªª ? z qM`{9j9ln}9¬hJ}_| z qM``j9}9§zihJln§qM}¶pa gqMj9pz a g©ºqMp©ln]_alhMgnRg >s{9pq2z a ggqMp ' )g ( ' «*]9§z]µ]5hiälq3{(aHp.³qMpn` zHmRzH §zz qM`{9j9lhJln§qM}¦qJ:z qM}lnpqM ¤«*ln]9}¦h(qMj9}_|9a |{(aHpn§qW|Y¥_«*]9§z]¬zihJ}]5h ä|R& %YaHpaH}l©z]5hJphMzHlaHpn§gn¡ ln§z g (>¥R`BaH`BqMpnm ' «*]9§z]zihJ}asqMj9}_|9a |lqWq (>¥9z qM``j9}9§zihJln§qM}_g ' «*]9§z]³qM §qi« h%äH}lqM{(qM §qM m (>¥ 5hJ}_|R«*§|Rln]O¥ªªªª vs Wln]_a ga hMg{(a zHlg}2¨qM ä*}laHphMzHln§qM}_g hJ}_|%z qM}_glnphJ}lg:lq8a `±hJ}5hJa |mln]_a lhMgnD]5hJ}_|R }9z qM}2lnpqM §aHpiª \ ]_az qM`{9 §a>kRl´m¦qJuln]_apa gnj9 ln}9 gnmRgnlaH` zihJ §g8³qMp©gqM`Bagnlnpnj_zHlnj9pn}9_¥ÂhJ}_|µhMggn§glhJ}_z a} ln]_a|9a gn}µqJ z qM}lnpqM §aHpg·ª ahJpa §qWqMW}9ºqMp°« h mRg qJYgaH{5hJphJln}9z qM}_z aHpn}_gu(aHl¯«ua aH}T §q2zihJ £¥W|9aH¨2§z a>¡´|9aH{aH}_|9aH}l*hMgn{a zHlg qJsz qM}2lnpqM £¥uhJ}_|V`BqMpaT §qM5hJ £¥:gnmRgnlaH`¡£ §aHäH }laHphMzHln§qM}_gi¥°«*]9 §a3a aH{9}9¬ln]_ahJ{9{9 §zihJln§qM}R¡£}_|9aH{aH}_|9aH}l hMgn{a zHlghMgzHpzHj9`BgzHpna |hJ}_|pa>¡£j_gFhJ9 §ahMg*{qggn9 §aª C. B. !FEE B . CD. a « hJ}l lqhMggn§gnl:}ln]_as|9a gn}TqJOgh²ºalhMgn]5hJ}_|R §aHpgi¥Wm{9pqM{qgn}9%hD`BaHln]_q2|«*]9§z]hJj9lqM`±hJla g ln]_aHp aH}_aHphJln§qM}Oª tsj9p{9j9pn{(qga§g{9phMzHln§zihJ £¥ hJ}_| ln]_aºqMpn`±hJ 98·hJln§qM}w«ua3äqJsln]_a3{9pqM9 §aH` §g`BaihJ}2lBlq a]9§|9|9aH}ºpqM` h%j_gaHpi¥5«*]_q«* O`±hJ}9{9j9 ¸hJla%a ggaH}ln¸hJ mh³aH« {5hJpnln§zHj9 ¸hJp89j9l`BaihJ}9}9Mºj9 Â`BqW|9aH hJ}_| {9pqM{aHpnln§a g{5hJlnlaHpn}_giª v l ln]_as §aHäH qJhJ_gnlnphMzHln§qM} qJÂln]_aslhMgnB]5hJ}_|R §aHpi¥R«ua8}_a a |Tlq`Bq2|9aH Oh|R§gzHpaHla8(aH]5hi¨2§qMpi¥9z]5hJphMzHlaHp.¡ 98ia |3mln]_a|R§gzHpaHlagnlhJla g*qJ¤ln]_a©pa gqMj9pz a g ' aª _ª¥9qWz zHj9{9§a |qMp @pa a ( hJ}_|qJln]_a©lhMg ' hMzHlnäqMp*}_qMli¥R} =DIGKJ. GH.

(24) *« ]9§z]`BqW|9a¥_ªªª (>¥hJ}_|hJ §gq8{qggn9 mqJ(ln]_a aH}¨WpqM}9`BaH}l°qMpqJ(gqM`Ba a>kRlaHpn}5hJ 9j_gaHp}laHphMzHln§qM}Oªvw}_qMln§qM} qJu §qM5hJ :glhJlazihJ} (a|9aHpnä |¬ºpqM` §q2zihJ gnlhJla giª%\ ]_a|RmW}5hJ`§zihJ (aH]5hi¨2§qMpDqJ ln]_agnmWglaH` ¥YqM_gaHpnä | ºpqM` ln]5hJlB{qM}l±qJ©¨2§aH«D¥ {9pqWz a a |9gºpqM`gnlhJlalqµglhJla¥:³qM §qi«*}9lnphJ}_gnln§qM}_gBln]5hJl±qWz zHj9pBl¯m2{9§zihJ m j9{qM}ln]_aq2z zHj9pnpaH}_z aqJgn}9& A5zihJ}l8aHäH}lgi¥R a©pa ¹2j_a gnlg ºpqM` h%j_gaHp*qMphJ{9{9 §zihJln§qM}O¥5gaH}_gqMp*aHäH}2lgi¥Oªªª \ ]_aHpa>³qMpa¥R«uas«* (j_ga8hDºqMpn`±hJ 9 8·hJln§qM}}TlaHpn`Bg qJB A_}9la©gnlhJla©hJj9lqM`±hJlhR¥R«*ln]T ¸hJaH §a |lnphJ}_gnln§qM}_gi¥Rlq `BqW|9aH Oln]_agnmRgnlaH`Bg*j9}_|9aHpgnlnj_|Rmª \ ]_alhMgnWgB]5hJ}_|R §aHp]5hMg±lq pa z aHähJ}_|w]5hJ}_|R §a pa ¹2j_a gnlgºpqM`ln]_ahJ{9{9 §zihJln§qM}O¥«*]9 §azihJpn}9µ³qMp {9pqM{aHpnln§a gsqJln]_az qM`{9j9lhJln§qM} hJ}_|{9]mRgn§zihJ pa gqMj9pz a gi¥9lq±(aghJln§g A5a |YªuopqM{aHpnln§a gsaH}_aHpn§zDlqBz qM}2lnpqM gnmRgnlaH`BghJpaDqJln]_a©³qM §qi«*}9±W}_|9g > ? ³qMpTln]_a {9]mRgn§zihJ 8pa gqMj9pz a g ' l´mW{9§zihJ m hMzHlnj5hJlqMp)g (>µ`j9lnj5hJ a>kRzH j_g§qM} qJz qM}lnpqM ©«Dª piª liªhMzHlnj5h²¡ lqMpg·¥{aHpn`±hJ}_aH}l z qM}lnpqM qJOaihMz]ThMzHlnj5hJlqMpi¥W §qM§zihJ (z qM}_gnlnphJ}lg aHl´«ua aH}hMzHln§qM}_g z qMpnpa gn{(qM}_|R}9%lq {9]2mWg§zihJ hMgn{a zHlg ' aª _ª¥_z qWqM }9hMzHln§qM} aHl´«ua aH}l´« qBlaH`{aHphJlnj9pa>¡£}laH}_gnähMzHln§qM}_)g (>¥Oªªªª ? ³qMp©ln]_az qM`{9j9ln}9pa gqMj9pz a g ' {9pq2z a ggqMpi¥`BaH`BqMpnm (>(qMj9}_|9a |R}_a ggqJuln]_a §qM5hJ zHmRzH §a%ln`Ba ' ³qMp h ln`Ba>¡´gn]5hJpn}9a>k9a zHj9ln§qM.} (>¥ gn«*lz]9}9(aHl¯«ua aH} äHpgn§qM}_g±qMp`BqW|9a g±qJ©ln]_a z qM}lnpqM slhMgnRg ' «*ln] |R& %YaHpaH}l8z]5hJphMzHlaHpn§gnln§z g8qJz qgnl*} ln`Ba¥_aH}_aHpnm¥9`BaH`BqMpnm¥¹j5hJ l¯m¥Oªªª ( ®¯}¬qMp|9aHp©lqT(ahJ9 §a%lq3aH}_gnj9paln]_a ga{9pqM{aHpnln§a gi¥« a]5hiälq|9a g}¬ln]_a% §qWzihJ z qM}lnpqM §aHpgDqJ°ln]_a%lhMgnRg }gj_z] h« himµln]5hJl%ln]_aHmµ5q %aHp%ln]_ahJ{9{9pqM{9pn¸hJla3z qM}lnpqM *gnlhJla ghJ}_|VaHäH}lg%lq paH{9pa gaH}2lln]_aB{qggn9 §a aH]5h ¨W§qMpgi¥ÂhJ}_|¦lqaH}5hJ9 §aln]_a9j9 §|R}9qJ*hTz qMpnpa zHlD §qM5hJ :aH]5h ¨W§qMpm hJ{9{9pqM{9pn¸hJlaH m¦gm2}_z]9pqM}99 8 }9 ln]_aH` ª\ ]_az qM}2lnpqM lhMgWg°`j_gnlu(asgnlnpnj_zHlnj9pa |hJ}_|Ta ¹j9{9{a |±gqln]5hJl°{9pqM{aHpnln§a guzihJ}(asaH}RºqMpz a |Yª\ ]_aHm ]5h äTh3 §qWzihJ :(aH]5hi¨2§qMpln]5hJlzihJ}µa|9a gzHpna |hMgh A_}9la±gnlhJla`±hMz]9}_aTqMphJj9lqM`±hJlqM}O¥¤paH{9pa gaH}2ln}9 l´mW{9§zihJ m > ? hMzHln¨Wl´m glhJla >} paihMzHln§qM}lq}2¨q2zihJln§qM}O¥pa ¹2j_a gnlg ºpqM` ln]_ahJ{9{9 §zihJln§qM}¬ §aHäH £¥5hJ}_|pa z aH{9ln§qM}qJ laHpn`}5hJln§qM}¬gn}5hJ §gi¥5h%lhMgTzihJ} aDhMzHlnäDqMp}_qMl @ ? ]5hJ}_|R }9 qJ*pa ¹2j_a gnlg >%ln]_aB`BqW|9aH u|9a gzHpna g%|R& %aHpaH}2l%pa g{(qM}_ga g·¥Â«*]_aHln]_aHp%ln]_aHmµzihJ}¶a±|9aH ¸hima | qMp8}_qMli¥hJ}_| ¢:ln]_aHmhJpa¥(«*]_aHln]_aHp8gaHäHphJ ¤zihJ}(a`BaH`BqMpn9 8ia |¦hJ}_|¬¹2j_aHj_a |Y¥5«*]_aHln]_aHp8ln]_aHmzihJ}a ³qMpz a | qMp*}_qMl @ ? hMzHln¨Wl´m`Bq2|9a g¤hJ}_|z qM``j9lhJln§qM}_g >«*]_aH}ln]_a°ghJ`Ba°lhMgnzihJ}a{aHp.ºqMpn`Ba |hMz z qMp|R}9slqs|R& %aHpaH}2l äHpg§qM}_g*qJ¤hJ}3hJ qMpnln]9` ¥5qMp z qM} A_j9phJln§qM}_gqJhJ}Ta>k9a zHj9ln§qM}{9 ¸hJl.ºqMpn` ¥Wln]_ahJj9lqM`±hJlqM} |9a gzHpna g ln]_aH` ¥hMg*«uaH hMg*ln]_a©« him z qM}lnpqM zihJ}agn«*lz]_a |ºpqM`ln]_aDqM}_alqqMln]_aHpiª 8&%aHpaH}2l{5hJlnlaHpn}_g³qMpDlhMgnRgzihJ}µa`±hJ}_a |Y¥z qMpnpa gn{qM}_|R}9lq|R& %aHpaH}2l}2laH}_|9a |¶aH]5h ¨W§qMpgiª3\ ]_a §qM5hJ (aH]5hi¨2§qMpDqJuln]_a%gmWgnlaH` §g©|9a gzHpna |¦m ln]_az qM`{qgnln§qM}µqJ hJ gnj_z]¦lhMgnRgiª % qM}2lnpqM }9 ln]_a ga §qM5hJ (aH]5hi¨2§qMpg}Tgnj_z]hD« h mTln]5hJl ln]_as{9pqM{aHpnln§a g `BaH}ln§qM}_a | (a>³qMpa8hJpa©ghJln§g A5a |§g qMj9p*`BqMln¨hJln§qM}Oª äH}Tln]_az qM}2la>kWl a>kW{9 ¸hJ}_a |3hJqiä¥Wln]_a{9pqM9 §aH` «ua©hM|9|Rpa ggu]_aHpa§guln]_agh²³a]5hJ}_|R }9qJhMzHln§qM}_guqJ z qM}lnpqM OgmWgnlaH`Bg·¥äH}haH}_aHphJ ÂhJpz]9la zHlnj9paDz]5hJphMzHlaHpn9 8ia |m3h%gaHl qJ¤lhMgnRgi¥WhJ}_|h%gaHl qJÂ{9pqM{aHpnln§a g lqaH}_gnj9pa¥_z qM}_z aHpn}9}9ln]_aHp §qM§zihJ z qM}_glnphJ}lgshJ}_|gqM`Ba©`BqMpaD¹2j5hJ}lnlhJlnähMgn{(a zHlg·ª tsj9pshJ{9{9pqhMz]z qM}_gn§glgqJ > ? 9j9 §|R}9 hJ} hJj9lqM`±hJlqM}R¡£5hMga |¬`Bq2|9aH qJ:ln]_a{(qgg9 §aDaH]5h ¨W§qMpg8qJ:ln]_a%gaHl8qJ:lhMgnWg·¥hJ}_|¬|R§gnln}R¡ j9§g]9}9_¥_} ln]_aDz qM}_|Rln§qM}_gs ¸hJaH }9±ln]_alnphJ}_gnln§qM}_g·¥9(aHl¯«ua aH}¦aHäH}lgsln]5hJlzihJ} aDz qM}lnpqM §a |m ln]_aD]5hJ}_|R §aHpi¥hJ}_|3ln]_aDqMln]_aHpgi¥_j9}_z qM}lnpqM ¸hJ9 §a%qM}_a g @ ? ³qMpn`j9 ¸hJln}9 ln]_a{9pqM{aHpnln§a gqM} ln]_a5hMgn§g3qJDln]9§gT`Bq2|9aH £¥} laHpn`Bg3qJgnlhJlalqV(apaihMz]_a |xqMp hi¨qM§|9a |Y¥5qMpqJga ¹2j_aH}_z a g*lqa©`{(qga |qMp*ºqMpn9§|9|9aHB} @ . DDFEHG#IKJ)LMI.

(25) ?. . hJj9lqM`±hJln}9¦ln]_a9j9 §|R}9 qJln]_a±]5hJ}_|R §aHp%mµj_g}9|R§gzHpaHlaTz qM}lnpqM §aHpBgnmW}ln]_a g§g @lz qM}_g§gnlgqJ aH}_aHphJln}93ln]_a@j9}_zHln§qM}_g8«*]9§z]¬ä¥³qMp8hzHj9pnpaH}lgnlhJlahJ}_| j9}_z qM}2lnpqM ¸hJ9 §aBaHäH}lgi¥(ln]_a%gaHlsqJ z qM}2lnpqM ¸hJ9 §aaHäH}2lggnj_z] ln]5hJlln]_a{9pqM{aHpnln§a gshJpagFhJln§g A5a |Yª # / B

(26) . \ ]_aD« qMpn{9pa gaH}la |}ln]9§g{5hJ{(aHpsj9}9&A5a g A_pgnlspa gnj9 lgqM9lhJ}_a |} `BqMpaD{5hJpnln§zHj9 ¸hJp©z qM}la>kRlgiª ohJpnln§z>¡ j9 ¸hJpn m¥_ln]_azH ¸hMggqJlhMgnRgz qM}_gnlnlnj9ln}9Tln]_aDgnmRgnlaH`Bg« aDz qM}_gn§|9aHpslhJa glg*}_g{9phJln§qM}} pqMqMlz qM}2lnpqM gnmRgnlaH`Bgi¥M«*]_aHpah8z qM}lnpqM 5 ¸h «D¥|9a gn}_a |%³qM §qi«*}9la z]9}9§¹2j_a g:qJ(z qM}2ln}j_qMj_g°z qM}2lnpqM _ln]_a qMpnm¥§ga>k9a zHj9la | zHmRzH §zihJ mª * j_z]µz qM`{9j9lhJln§qM}_gzihJ}¦(az qM}lnpqM §a |µhMz z qMp|R}9lqäH}¦aHäH}2lgDhJ}_|glhJla gi¥z qM}lnpqM {5hJl.¡ laHpn}_gi¥YhMg©{9pqM{qga |} aª _ª©ln]_aBt8d % % v #pqMqMls{9pqMphJ``}9aH}2¨2pqM}9`BaH}2l 2 " 4´ªv z qM`{9 §aHlagnmRgnlaH` ]_qgnlg8h}j9`(aHp©qJgj_z]lhMgWgi¥_«*]9§z]zihJ}(aDhMzHln¨hJla | }¬z qM`{9 §a>k ga ¹j_aH}_z a g·ª ¬qgnl*³qMpn`±hJ Â`BaHln]_qW|9g hJ{9{9pqhMz]_a g3hJ{9{9 §a | qM} gnj_z] `BqW|9aH §gBz qM}_z aHpn} äHpn& A5zihJln§qM}Oªw®¯} qMj9p±hJ{9{9pqhMz] «ua a>kR{9 §qMpaln]_a3j_gaqJ |R§gz aHpaHlaDz qM}2lnpqM §aHpsgnmW}ln]_a g§gi¥5hMgh%`BqMpaDz qM}_glnpnj_zHlnäDla z]9}9§¹2j_aª v A_pgnlhJ{9{9pqhMz] }_gn{9pa |32m±pqMqMln§zgnmRgnlaH`Bg « hMg*{9pqM{qga |Y¥Rj_gn}9BhlaH §a qM{(aHphJln§qM}¬hJ{9{9 §zihJln§qM}hMg j_gnlnphJln§qM} 2 R¥_Rb 4´ª°v}_qMln]_aHphJ{9{9pqhMz]z qM}_gn§|9aHpa |lhMgnRg «*ln]`j9 ln{9 §a`Bq2|9a g*qMp*äHpg§qM}_gi¥_hJ}_|3ln]_aHp z]5hJphMzHlaHpn9 8·hJln§qM} m«uaH]lgThMggqWzH¸hJla |Vlq¬glhJla gi¥°hJ}_|Vj_ga |V} qM{9ln`±hJ gnm2}2ln]_a gn§g 2 " 4´ª¶\ ]9§g{5hJ{aHp {9pqM{qga gshBj9}9& A5a | ³qMpn`±hJ 9 8·hJln§qM}O¥(hJ}_|z qM`{9 §aH`BaH}lg©}ln]_aD`BqW|9aH £ª * j_z]¬hJ}¦hJj9lqM`±hJla |z qM}_glnpnj_zHln§qM} qJOln]_aslhMgn]5hJ}_|R §aHp zihJ}TaaH}_aHphJ 9 8ia |hMg hD« himqJÂz qM`{9 }9BhDz qM}2lnpqM §aHpuºpqM`h`¢k9a |± ¸hJ}9j5hJa 2 5 4´ª * j_z] hz qM`{9 ¸hJln§qM}V§g}_qMlzH ¸hMgg§zihJ £¥O}¶ln]5hJllD`±hJa gDj_gaB}_qMlqM}9 m qJ*h3ºqMpn`±hJ :`BqW|9aH uqJ aH]5h ¨W§qMpg qJln]_aTz qM`{9 §a | {9pqMphJ` ¥«*]9§z] §ghJ paihM|Rmµln]_azihMga±}Vln]_az qM`{9 ¸hJln§qM} qJgm2}_z]9pqM}_qMj_g ¸hJ}9j5hJa g z qM}_z aHpn}9}9±}2¨MhJpn¸hJ}2lg 2 bb 4´¥_9j9lqJh`BqW|9aH OqJlg|RmW}5hJ`§z g 2 b "4´ª % qM}_z aHpn}9}9hJ{9{9 §zihJln§qM}_guqJ|R§gzHpaHla*z qM}lnpqM §aHp°gnmW}ln]_a g§gi¥paH ¸hJla |±hJ{9{9pqhMz]_a g:«uqMpnW}9D«*ln]`BqW|9aH §g qJÂlhMgnTgnmRgnlaH`Bg zihJ}TaºqMj9}_|Y¥9qJºlaH}3j_gn}9ln`Ba |`BqW|9aH §ghJ}_|3gnmW}ln]_a gn§g la z]9}9§¹j_a g 2 b ; 4´ª\ ]_a©qMpn§aH}2lh²¡ ln§qM}¦ln]_aH}§g8`BqMpa%lqi« hJp|9gln]_agnmW}ln]_a gn§g©qJ hJ{9{9 §zihJln§qM} gn{a zH& A5zgz]_a |Rj9 }9g8³qMpspaihJ ¢¡£ln`BalhMgWg 2 bi5 4´ª az qM}_z aH}2lnphJlasqM}phJln]_aHp° §qM§zihJ YhJ}_|B|R§gzHpaHla8hMgn{(a zHlg ' aHäH}«*]_aH}Tz qM}_gn§|9aHpn}9glhJln§z«uaH]2l)g (>¥W«*]_aHpa «uas³a aH ln]_a8hJ qMpnln]9`§zDz qM`{9 §a>kRl´mTz qgnlghJpas`j_z] §a ggi¥9hJ}_|3hJ §q·« ºqMphpaihJlaHpgzihJ ¸hJ9 l´m{(qMlaH}2ln¸hJ £ª ®¯}ThDz qM`{qM}_aH}l.¡£5hMga |T|9a g}TgaHlnln}9 2 " 4´¥Wgnm2}2ln]_a gn§g zihJ}±aj_ga |±lqz qM`{9j9lasln]_a8hJ §q·«ua |T}laHphMzHln§qM}_g·¥ äH}¶z qM}_gnlnphJ}2lg%hJ}_|µ{9pqM{(aHpnln§a glq3(a±aH}RºqMpz a |Y¥¤qJ z qM`{qM}_aH}lg%ga aH}µln]9pqMj9]VhJ}µ}laHp.£hMz a±z]5hJphMz>¡ laHpn9 8 }9¶ln]_aHp±}9{9j9lhJ}_| qMj9ln{9j9lz qM}_|Rln§qM}_g @lB{9pqW|Rj_z a gh³qMpn`qJ©{5hJpnln¸hJ {9pqMlqWz qM £¥u §aihi¨2}9VgqM`Ba }_qM}R¡´|9aHlaHpn`}9§gn` lq(a©pa gqM ämhJ}qM}R¡£ }_aDgz]_a |Rj9 §aHp}h£hJp*`±hJ}9}_aHpiª . . . CD. !. ®¯}ln]_as³qM §qi«*}9Bga zHln§qM}_gi¥W« as«* / A_pgnl {9pa gaH}2l*ln]_a³qMpn`±hJ (@phJ`BaH« qMpnTqJqMj9p*hJ{9{9pqhMz]} * a zHln§qM}%hMg «uaH °hMgDhJ}¦`{9 §aH`BaH}2lhJln§qM}5hMga |¬j9{qM} gnm2}_z]9pqM}_qMj_glqWqM §giª aln]_aH} |9a gzHpnaln]_a%{5hJlnlaHpn}_g©ºqMp©lhMgn aH]5h ¨W§qMp} * a zHln§qM}Rª R¥_hMg*« aH hMg*ln]_a©`BqW|9aH §g ºqMp*l¯m2{9§zihJ Â{9pqM{(aHpnln§a g*} * a zHln§qM}¦Rª hJ}_| Rª _ª!C¤}5hJ m¥ hzihMgaDglnj_|Rm j_gnlnphJla gln]_aDhJ{9{9pqhMz]¬} * a zHln§qM} _ª ( $ ws5(&&#87s

(27) %'5

(28) ' \ ]_a*5hMgn§z`Bq2|9aH §g°hJpa|R§gzHpaHla>¡áHäH}l gnmRgnlaH`Bgi¥hJ}_|BzihJ}±(a ³qMpn`j9 ¸hJla |ThMgi¥aª _ª¥ºqMpn`±hJ _ ¸hJ}9j5hJa g·¥o¤aHlnpn }_aHlgi¥qMp A_}9lagnlhJla%`±hMz]9}_a 2 4´ª®¯}ln]_a% ¸hJlnlaHpzihMga¥gnlhJla gz qMpnpa gn{qM}_|ºqMp©a>k9hJ`{9 §a%lqTäH} z qM} A_M¡ j9phJln§qM}_gqJln]_apqM(qMlgnmRgnlaH` ¥:hJ}_| JqMpqJln]_a3hMzHln¨MhJln§qM} gnlhJlnj_gqJlhMgnRg%z qM}lnpqM }9µliª¦\OphJ}_gln§qM}_g z qMpnpa gn{qM}_|¬lq±ln]_aqWz zHj9pnpaH}_z a%qJn¥aª _ª¥YaHäH}lgi¥Yz qM``±hJ}_|9g·¥ln]9pa gn]_qM §|9giª\ ]_aHmhJpa% ¸hJaH §g8qM}¬ln]_a%lnphJ}R¡ gnln§qM}_gi¥_«*]9§z]¦zihJ}}¨qM äz qM}_|Rln§qM}_g©qM} ln]_aHp A_paihJ9 l¯mª*®´} ln]_aga ¹j_aH £¥5«uagn]5hJ Âz qM}_gn§|9aHpslnphJ}_gnln§qM} gnmRgnlaH`Bgi¥} «*]9§z]waHäH}lgBzihJ} qWz zHj9pBgn`j9 lhJ}_a qMj_g mª 8aH}_z ah¬lnphJ}_gnln§qM} aHl´«ua aH}wl´«uq¶z qM}_ga zHj9lnä.

(29) . . . . =DIGKJ. GH.

(30) gnlhJla gTzihJ} a ¸hJaH §a |w2mwhµä zHlqMp3qMpz qM}Mr.j9}_zHln§qM} qJaHäH}lgiª,\ ]9§g±§gpaH ¸hJla |wlq¶ln]_agm2}_z]9pqM}_qMj_g z qM`{qgnln§qM} «uaD«* O(a©j_g}9_ª äH} h{9pqM{aHpnl´m±}2¨qM ¨2}9BglhJla g*qMp aHäH}2lgi¥RäHpn&A5zihJln§qM}z qM}_gn§gnlg }|9aHlaHpn`}9}9_¥9«*]_aHln]_aHpqMp }_qMl ln]_aHm±hJpalnpnj_aºqMp häH}ThJj9lqM`±hJlqM}O¥RpaH{9pa gaH}ln}9%ln]_a{qggn9 §aaH]5h ¨W§qMpg qJOhD{9pqMphJ`#qMp gnmWglaH` 2 4´ª 8&%aHpaH}2ln m¥|R§gzHpaHla*z qM}2lnpqM 5gnmW}ln]_a gn§g°z qM}_gn§gnlgqJ(|9aHlaHpn`}9}9ln]_a*z qM}_gnlnphJ}lg°ln]5hJl`±hJa ln]_a pa gnj9 ln}9 hJj9lqM`±hJlqM}xghJln§g.ºm ln]_a{9pqM{aHpnl´m¥*2m }9]99ln}9 ln]_a lnphJ}_gnln§qM}_gT«*]9§z] « qMj9 §| §aihM| lqlg±¨W§qM ¸hJln§qM}Oª 8aH}_z a¥Yln]_agnmW}ln]_a gn§gDqJ*hTz qM}lnpqM §aHpz qM}_g§gnlgqJ hJj9lqM`±hJln§zihJ mµz qM`{9j9ln}9 ln]_a

(31) M>DhTpaH ¸hJln§qM} ln]5hJli¥äH}VhgnlhJlaThJ}_|µj9}_z qM}lnpqM ¸hJ9 §aaHäH}2lgi¥ä g%ln]_aB¨hJ j_a±qJz qM}2lnpqM §a |VaHäH}2lggnj_z]Vln]5hJl%qM}9 m lnphJ}_gnln§qM}_g3pa gn{a zHln}9Vln]_a¬qMRrna zHlnä g3zihJ} (alhJaH} ' }xqMln]_aHp3«uqMp|9g >µz qM}lnphM|R§zHln}9 aH]5h ¨W§qMpghJpa }9]99la #| (>¥shMg j_gnlnphJla | } C¤j9pa¦ } ln]_azihMgaqJhµ|9aHlaHpn`}9§gnln§z¦z qM}lnpqM §aHpiª \ ]9§g{9pq2|Rj_z a gh z qM}_gnlnphJ}_a |¦`BqW|9aH £¥£ª aª©`Bq2|9aH :hJ}_|¦z qM}lnpqM §aHplqMaHln]_aHpDgFhJln§g.@mln]_a{9pqM{aHpnl´mª®´l8}¨qM ä gpa glnpn§zHln§qM}_g qM}hM|R`§gg9 §a©}9ln¸hJ gnlhJla gi¥_hMg«uaH hMgqM}lnphJ}_gnln§qM}_giª ®¯}µln]_a³qM §qi«*}9_¥¤«uaBä±|9a A_}9ln§qM}_g}_gn{9pa |µ2m 2 b ¥ ¥Â" 4´¥¤hJ}_|µ}lnpqW|Rj_z a±phJ{9]9§zihJ u}_qMlhJln§qM}_g «*]9§z]«* Y(a©j_ga |3ºqMpz qM}2äH}9§aH}_z aDºj9pnln]_aHpiª . . . !. ! !I ! . . äH}hgaHl qJÂqWqM §aihJ}¨hJpn¸hJ9 §a g !"¥2« a A_pgl |9aA_}_ah$#&% (')%* +,qJln]_asgaHl qJO¨hJpn¸hJ9 §a g hMgh ºj9}_zHln§qM}B>.-0/214357698 :0;=<)>?A@2B0C2DE>2"ªV\ ]_a3¨MhJ j5hJln§qM}F-2/01©hMggn}_glq aihMz] ¨MhJpn¸hJ9 §a }Gh ¨hJ j_a¥5aHln]_aHp8lnpnj_aqMp£hJ §gaª \ ]_agaHlsqJ¨MhJ j5hJln§qM}_g8qJ5x§g}_qMla |/21 HIKJ>ª äH}¬hqWqM §aihJ}a>kR{9pa ggn§qM} LMHIKJ8hJ}_O | NPQR/01 HISJ>¥«ua|9aH}_qMla2m LMHINTJln]_a%{9pa |R§zihJlUa L ¨hJ j5hJla |µhMz z qMp|R}9lqTln]_a¨MhJ j_a g©qJV©ª ¬qMpa qiäHpi¥Y« a|9aH}_qMlam LUW ln]_agaHl8qJ ¨MhJpn¸hJ9 §a g©ln]5hJlhJ{9{aihJpDhMg©{(qglnä%aH §aH`BaH}2lg}¦ln]_a%{9pa |R§zihJla L3¥£ª a5ª L W !XYPMZX[\LMHIKJY]LMHISJ"ªda gn{a zHlnäH m¥2«ua8|9aH}_qMla2$m L_^ ln]_agaHl qJO¨MhJpn¸hJ9 §a guln]5hJl hJ{9{aihJpshMg*}_aHhJlnäDaH §aH`BaH}2lg} ln]_a©{9pa |R§zihJlà L3¥R£ª a5ª L ^ XYPaZ)b?!Xc[dLMHISJ]LMHISJ"ª qi«D¥ ln]_a gmWgnlaH` qM} «*]9§z] z qM}lnpqM 8«* ahJ{9{9 §a |w§gB`Bq2|9aH §a |wmwGh ef9hg=i*9'0j%'2k*lU%Ek5¥ ¸hJaH §a |m3a>kW{9pa ggn§qM}_gqM} gn`j9 lhJ}_a qMj_gsaHäH}2lgi¥9ln]5hJl§g|9a A_}_a |hMg ³qM §qi«g > mE¼ n5oqp p@rÀ ots]uvjfwrg= 9'0j`%')klx%*k.y7+zj{Ig) | '~}9 yaaH ,irI _AxJ j')gIg2%E E +zj|%?+ j hV µgnlhJla hg K TP+zj|%xj hRi¦}9ln¸hJ ÂgnlhJla hg . . . %94%A Ìg) {j hIjì %*}9'2%9R'2}9')V#&%+ %= h j 2 ¡0 r |3\ 468 ¢V££1 HIKJ+

(32) j.Ig) ¦}9ln¸hJ sz qM}_|Rln§qM}_gQ%*,k%Ehg) k¤+

(33) ?+ +,% jk%* j`¢£w£1 HISJM+

(34) j.Igc j h x A %¥ ¦}9A jj+,cj$#w _Ig) \j hi4#&%*+,%= jU+IS+zj{§= r hi%* AQ fIg) `§i%*l\lx%{¨x33 ©«ª ¨{/0¬!M¨ ª ¬!£w®¨~¯°Yg) A © Px±S lnphJ}_gnln§qM}_g d½ ®¾H ¿2ALMHIKJÀUA¿&Á

(35) J¯«¿0¯«¿wÁ%A xIgc ²9 ´³µa¶·¢V££1 HIKJ¶¹¸*º]¶»¼+zjUIg) Uj hiV j'2i \%rxIg) |k%,§= h5jhk%* j¯ÂLMHISJRP¢££w1 HISJ+

(36) j Ig) { +§§= h+I0§dA9+ +,OiIg) { i%*cj+ + *c¯5%*9 Àv³»+zjIg) {j hRi|')}9')Ij\ l4+I, A$°Ygc r #w hÌg) ` %cj+ +,+

(37) j{ +§§= A qi«D¥ºqMph gnlhJla_ ¿ hJ}_|Vh¨MhJ j5hJln§qM}GNtPFR/01 HISJ qJln]_aB¨hJpn¸hJ9 §a gi¥¤«uaTghim¬ln]5hJl\N §g_%E*l\+

(38) jj+, h D }Ã¿ «*]_aH}_aHäHpln]_aHpa±a>kW§gnlgh3lnphJ}_gnln§qM}ÄH ¿2ALMHISJÀ4A¿wÁzJ\P gnj_z]µln]5hJl|LMHINTJ®ÆÅÇrÈ @¤hJlln]_aBgFhJ`Baln`Ba¥ ln]_aDgaHlqJ¨hJpn¸hJ9 §a g À §g*aH`lnla |Yªu\ ]_alnphJ}_gnln§qM} §gshJ §gqghJ§|lqaDhM|R`§ggn9 §aª ÉÊ QË ( ¼¤s ½ +§'0A +I

(39) ('0j %* jdIg0+zjd0 I?+ + *c¯°5+ IgÃ%M§ %}g=+,A% jfk%~¦O°Yg=+ hgQ°5+

(40) I A M'=j ·+IIgc A lx%+

(41) r= ì{Igc R}c%}c ÌU |j A `jhk%* j{~ÍÀLdÎ\"*¯°5+IIg+I?+ + % Tjhk%* j{~ÍÀL_"*¯Ig) 4+

(42) }r'2V#&%+ %0 j4%A `~/9¨~AÏÐw"O%*9dIg) |j hKi ')}9')«#&%*+,%= j{+

(43) j A 'c k$Igc j+

(44) 0§* hk*~Ï&"*¯«+I?+ + % !A*9+ + ?jr H ÍJ«ÄÑcÒ:ÔÓ2Õ.%9{rkH LxJ5 Ó2Õ*¯4%r¤ %cj+I +,cj.+

(45) r+ %* F fÃ%* °Yj %=gg2%wj%Qjh'2i ¹%9G%¹j+

(46) ?Öjhk%* ¯4%*9Ã%¤ %= A °5+IIgF% DDFEHG#IKJ)LMI.

(47) a and b / c A. not c1. B. b/c. a. c1. C. ¤j9pa>:vs} a>k9hJ`{9 §ahJj9lqM`±hJlqM}Oª C. %Ã ¦}r jj+,QO#&%+ %= h j§*+

(48) #+I0§_+ Ij + §~§= +

(49) 0§.A*9+ + ?¯V%9. l4+zjj+,cj l}9 (+ h+ %cj+I +,cj¯ 9*qA }9A j h . fx% °Yj¯5%A Ig) {r j§=+

(50) 2§R lµ %Eg_jk%* k\+IIj °Yg) M9U9+ + *M %= +I0§_% ')§E+I0§d i%*cj+ + *+

(51) j{ '? m¼En5oqp @p Àr o uvjfwrg= 9'0j`%')klx%*k.yavH i _AxJ{+zj |9aHlaHpn`}9§gln§z_°Ygc r #w h ¿ A¿wÁ P NPMR/01 HISJ , H ¿ JhHINTJ[_ H ¿wÁ JhHINÂ J

(52) ¿ ]¿wÁ 'b( ¿0A¿wÁIA¿wÁ ÁÂP NP/21 HIKJ H ¿2AL_ÀUA¿wÁJ~H ¿2AL\Á À Á A¿wÁ ÁzJP kLMHINTJ![ML Á HINTJ

(53) F À À Á [´¿ Á t¿ Á Á . 8aH}_z a¥_hgnm2}_z]9pqM}_qMj_gshJj9lqM`±hJlqM}§g*|9aHlaHpn`}9§gnln§z«*]_aH}_aHäHpäH}hJ}}9ln¸hJ Â¨MhJ j5hJln§qM}N¬qJln]_a¨hJpn¢¡ hJ9 §a gR©¥Rln]_aHpa©§g*qM}9 mqM}_a©¨hJ §|}9ln¸hJ OglhJlaDhJ}_|äH}h%gnlhJlaDhJ}_|h%¨hJ j5hJln§qM} qJln]_a8¨hJpn¸hJ9 §a gi¥Rln]_aH} qM}9 m3qM}_aD|9a gnln}5hJln§qM}glhJlazihJ} (a©paihMz]_a |hJ}_|ln]_aqMj9ln{9j9lg8hJpa§|9aH}ln§zihJ £ª mE¼ n5oqp p@rÀ o!uvjfwrg= 9'0j`%')klx%*k.yavH i9 _AxJ{+zjpaihMzHln¨da °Yg) hr #w ' ( N·P.R/01 HISJ " r,H ¿JhHINÂJ«103254 #%$'&($*),+.-$*&/$*) ' ( ¿\P N·PM/21 HIKJ " L.HINÂJ103254FG #76,+8-9;:<#= >?= @A= #76'BC+ED v gnmW}_z]9pqM}_qMj_g:hJj9lqM`±hJlqM}§gpaihMzHlnä «*]_aH}_aHäHp³qMphJ WgnlhJla g·¥²«*]5hJlaHäHpln]_au¨hJ j5hJln§qM}qJ_ln]_au¨hJpn¸hJ9 §a gi¥ h%lnphJ}_gnln§qM}¬zihJ}(a©lnpnaHpa | ' {(qgg9 m±ºpqMµ ` ¿%lxq ¿%lgaH ¢ (>ª HJI ¼ ¼ µ o p À K o O À µR 9À oML y ¼HON;PQN Ri.N;PQN R _AxJ§g©ln]_a%³qM §qi«*}9_ªvsggnj9`B\a y §g }9ln¸hJ 9 8ia |}VgnlhJl_a ¿SN;PQN Rµ¿UT.PaON;PQN R8«*ln]¨MhJ j5hJln§qMG} NTgnj_z]Vln]5hJ{l .N;PQN RH ¿SN;PQN RiJhHINTJ{ ®ÆÅÇrÈª C_j9pnln]_aHpi¥ «*ln] ln]_a¨hJ j5hJln§qM¥} Nri¥ y aH¨qM ä g±}lqgnlhJlMa ¿hJ}_| aH`l.g À±gj_z] ln]5hJ·l H ¿UT~AL`À{A¿JP hJ}_| L HIN J«Ä® ÅÇTÈªvsggnj9`Ba*}_qi« ln]5hJl°ln]_asgnmWglaH` ]5hMg°aH¨qM ä |Tgq©£hJp:}lq%gnlhJlSa ¿ X ' £ª aª:h²ºlaHp°ln]_apa z aH{9ln§qM} qJ V¨hJpn¸hJ9 §au¨MhJ j5hJln§qM}_)g (>¥Jln]_aH}%j9{(qM}ln]_a:pa z aH{9ln§qM\} N)X W ·¥²ln]_a°gmWgnlaH`,«* 2aH¨qM äu}lqsgnlhJl«a ¿X W ¤hJ}_|aH`l ÀX ·¥Wgj_z]3ln]5hJ{l H ¿X ALX ÀX A¿X JKPM§ghJ}3hM|R`§ggn9 §a©lnphJ}_gnln§qM}3}3ln]_a8gm2}_z]9pqM}_qMj_ghJj9lqM`±hJlqM} yW hJ}_M| LX W &HIN)X W J5Ä®ÆÅwW ÇTÈ ' £ª W aª LX W W *¨MhJ j5hJla glMq '? «Dª piª liªln]_a©¨MhJ j5hJln§qM } N)X )(>ª qi« äH} hgm2}_z]9pqM}_qMj_ghJj9lqM`±hJlqMM} yT¥Wlg (aH]5hi¨2§qMp §g z]5hJphMzHlaHpn9 8ia | }W laHpn`Bg*qJOlnphMz a g*|9aH{aH}_|W¡ }9¦qM}¨hJpn¸hJ9 §a giXª WOaH4l y H N;PQN R i N;PQN R _AxJhJ}_Ã| NY N NZS N SP]/21 HIKJaThJ}V} A_}9la ga ¹2j_aH}_z a©qJ¨hJ j5hJln§qM}_g*qJÂln]_a8¨MhJpn¸hJ9 §a Kg ©ªv v %E D§ghga ¹j_aH}_z a©qJlnj9{9 §a Rg ®0HIN)XiA¿XÆÀSXJ"X\[ Y «*]_aHpa ¿ X P)hJpaDgnlhJla ggj_z] ln]5hJl ¿3TPON;PQN RT[_.N;PQN RH ¿UTJhHIN Y J5Ä®ÆÅwÇTÈV[À Y

(54) ]hJ}_| VA^ÂH ¿XÆALX W ÀSX W A¿X W JRP [ LX W ~HIN2X W J5Ä®ÆÅÇrÈ ' : ( . =DIGKJ. GH.

(55) a }_qMlaÅ*/2ÏÈ=HIyxJln]_a*gaHl:qJhJ 9lnphMz a g:qJTy3ªC_qMpV¿\P¥«ua }_qMla e'? Æ i%E &HIydA¿EJln]_a*gaHl:qJ(gj9R¡£lnphMz a g qJY y#ln]5hJlaH}3ºpqM`¼¿> e'? %E wHIydA¿EJ5*® # 0HIN)XÆA¿XÆÀXJ"X\[FT{Zw¿UTRt¿U[ ' ( V )`H ¿ X AL X W À X W A¿ X W JRP [ L X W HIN X W J5Ä®ÆÅÇrÈ. L sLIs

(56) À Q Ë À p p@9À o Ë ¼ ²R À ² WOaHl y\X!aHKX.!¥ ON;P N R X i.N;PQN R X XÆXiA)X,J>¥ºqMp V5 Ð¸©a*l´« qhJj9lqM`±hJlhRª a*« hJ}l°lq|9a A_}_aln]_aqM{aHphJln§qM} ln]5hJl°|9a gzHpna gln]_a*{5hJphJ §aH (z qM`{(qgln§qM}O¥zihJ §a |ln]_agm2}_z]9pqM}_qMj_g:{9pqW|Rj_zHliª\ ]9§g:z qM}_gn§gnlg°}Bz qM}9}_a zHln}9 ln]_aqMj9ln{9j9l:¨hJpn¸hJ9 §a g°qJT y lq©ln]_a}9{9j9l:¨MhJpn¸hJ9 §a guqJr y Z «*]_aH}_aHäHp°ln]_aHm%]5h äln]_a*ghJ`Ba*}5hJ`BahJ}_|¨W§z a>¡ äHpghRªtsj9pDz qM`{(qgnln§qM} «* :hJ §gqT{aHp.ºqMpn` h±³qMpn` qJ aH}_zihJ{_gnj9 ¸hJln§qM}O¥Â}¬ln]_agaH}_galn]5hJlln]_a}9{9j9lgqJ aihMz]ThJj9lqM`±hJlqM}±«*]9§z]ThJpaqMj9ln{9j9lg°qJ(ln]_aqMln]_aHp:«* 9a*aH}_zihJ{_gnj9 ¸hJla |B£ª aª¥}_qMl:z qM}_gn§|9aHpa |lqa }9{9j9lg qJln]_aDz qM`{(qgln§qMB} @_]_qi« aHäHpsln]_aHm3paH`±hJ} ¨W§gn9 §ahMgqMj9ln{9j9lgiª qMlaln]5hJl« a`j_gnls]5h ¨à 4 Z

(57) ]Rª \ ]_a{5hJphJ §aH °z qM`{qgnln§qM} «* a%|9aH}_qMla Q| y$ ª y Z ªv ln]_aqMj9ln{9j9l¨hJpn¸hJ9 §a gpaH`±hJ} ¨W§gn9 §a}¦ln]_a z qM`{qgnln§qM}O¥]_qi« aHäHpi¥Oln]_a%}9{9j9l©¨MhJpn¸hJ9 §a g©qJV y ª y ZhJpa%äH}¦Gm HI ZJ`Hk Z~Ja zihJj_ga¥ äH}hJ} qMj9ln{9j9lqJY y Z ¥_hJ}}9{9j9lqJY y$zihJ}a©|9a A_}_a |}ln]_az qM`{(qgln§qM} ' ghJ`Ba©]_qM §|9g ³qMp*ln]_a©}9{9j9l qJY y Z (>ª WOaHlj_g}_qi« ³qMpn`±hJ m3|9a A_}_aDln]_\a jf9hg=i*9'0jR}9i~')OaHl´«ua aH}l´« qhJj9lqM`±hJlhRª mE¼ n5oqp p@rÀ o gc ½ o I 9À oÀ | Ë¤ À Á Â °«_%'2k*lU%Ek%y\XÂaHKXÆ¯ X ir X !XÆ XiA)XkJ¯ch VYaÐ¸+

(58) j{Ig) \%'2k*lU%Ek_y_ ª y Z H ,i9 _AxJ`= IT M f= Z %h j+,%$}9 'cKj hIj&S ? ¶ Z Ä¶ \ Z %*9\] HI5 Z J %9.°V 4= h9* x f!¤ Hk4 Z J¤HI5 Z J\Igc `j hKi . w# %+,%= jÌg)%*°V A U *IgM+I}9')V%rd*'2}9')V#&%+ %= h j r,H#" ¿*hA¿ Z%$ J»r H ¿J![$r Z H ¿ Z J ¿XqP X ¯VY Ð¸0 +

(59) j|= IT M f & H ¿XÆALXAHI!XkJÀXiA¿&XÁ JKP)X Vq Ð¸ ')( H L`q[.L Z Ji* W +¤³» #H " ¿A¿ Z%$ ^.VH L`~HI5J![dL Z HI Z J JÀ{ À Z %" ¿ Á A¿ ZÁ $ JRP H L`q[.L Z J ^ +,Mv

(60) ] ®a#H " ¿ A3¿ Z $ AL HI J[dGL ZEHI ZJ% " ¿wÁ A¿&ZÁ $ JRP + / VY Ð¸ H ¿ X AL X HI X JA¿wXÁ JRP X . \ ]_a°z qM}_|Rln§qM}_gqM}lnphJ}_gnln§qM}_ggln{9j9 ¸hJla°ln]5hJl¤gn]5hJpa |D{qgnlnä°aH §aH`BaH}2lggn]_qMj9 §|Da°qMj9ln{9j9lgi¥J«*]9 §augn]5hJpa | }_aHhJlnä©aH §aH`BaH}lg gn]_qMj9 §|}_qMluaqMj9ln{9j9lg £ª aª¥WqMln]±{5hJpnln§a g*hJpa asqM}Tln]_a{9pa gaH}_z a8qJÂg]5hJpa |±aH §aH`BaH}lg·ª \ ]_aDgnmW}_z]9pqM}_qMj_g{9pq2|Rj_zHlsqJgnmW}_z]9pqM}_qMj_g8hJj9lqM`±hJlh§g*qMln]hMggqWzH¸hJlnähJ}_| z qM``j9lhJlnäª Ë ( X¼ ½ +§'0A ¡ +

(61) I '0j %* j|Igc jf9g= 9'0jÀl})j+ + ÉÊ Q g) ` IhÂ})%*Vjg)°YjÌg) § %}g0+ A%* jfw9k%¦ +I9h ('=j+ *¹ | °«M%')klx%*k%d+

(62) Q%_ '0r0ÆA*r h. · ¦¯°5+ Ig j })% %* + * f4%U=%wjg) A\ +Ir g) + §wg2c})%* jg)°YjIg) A j'2 +

(63) 0§U%*'2klx%*k*c¯ °5+ IgU9*k%= (f4Ig) h%=YIg2%*. jf9hg=i*9'0jÀl})wj+I +,OlU%Ö j| %cj+ +,cjj+Il\'2 k%r '0j (f$+I· A*Ig%')klx%*k% a>kWl©«ua±|9aA_}_aln]_a §aHphJpz]9§zihJ % qM`{qgnln§qM}Oª äH}hTgnmW}_z]9pqM}_qMj_g%hJj9lqM`±hJlqM}¤y218hJ}_|µh3gnlhJlaqJ y21>¥4¿ 3sln]_a§|9aih§glqBpaA_}_aDln]_aaH]5h ¨W§qMpsqJ54¿ 3©m3`BaihJ}_gqJ°hJ}_qMln]_aHp8gnm2}_z]9pqM}_qMj_g8hJj9lqM`±hJlqM}5y 3Mª°\q gn`{9 ¢ºmln]_a|9aA_}9ln§qM}O¥O« aBhMggnj9`Ba%ln]5hJlln]_alqM{R¡£ §aHäH °hJ}_|¦ln]_a% §qi« §aHäH |9q3}_qMlgn]5hJpa¨hJpn¸hJ9 §a g ' £ª aª HI 1 6 17J ·HI 3 3 J5

(64) ](>ª . DDFEHG#IKJ)LMI. .

(65) not c1 a and b / c A. not c1. B. b. a/c. S1. a and b / c. A S1. B S2. c/d. c. b. a/cd. c1 C. S2. C S1. c1. ¤j9pa>:vs} a>k9hJ`{9 §aDqJgnmW}_z]9pqM}_qMj_g{9pq2|Rj_zHl ' §a>ºl)(>¥9«*ln] ln]_aDpa gnj9 ln}9hJj9lqM`±hJlqM} ' pn]2l)(>ª Ë À p p@rÀ o y21«vH 1h 1 i 1 161A 1AJ` A 4%5hMgn§gU%' m¼En5oqp p@rÀ op@¼ ²9J I p (

(66) À ¤ klx%*k?¯ hR¿ 3 Pv 1. A .*r .ix+ Ij4jk%* jdk· d r w¯{%9 hy 3 7H 3 3 i9 3 3 3 A 3 J A QIg) pa A_}_aH`BaH}2G l %')klx%*k '=j FkA IT .¿ 3 g) OA j'2 $i·Ig=+zj I«r l$ 4+

(67) jOIg) Q%'2k*lU%Ek C. y21 `H ¿ 3 y 3 J5aH,ir A_ KJ{°Yg) A Ä 1~¿ 3 "

(68) .~¿ 3 ¿UZ¿4P 3 "*

(69) S¿ 3 P 1 ¯«Igc ¿ 3 P 3 ¿ 3 ¿* 3 PI¯ j x 1

(70) ¥Ä 1 3 %94a 1 3 ®aH ¿ALdÀUA¿ Z JRP + / k¿A¿ Z P 1~¿ 3 "[d®RP 1 k¿ P 1[dU¿ Zt4¿ 3 ¿ 3 [¹H ¿ AL\Á À4A4¿ 3JP 1 [.La]L\Á*[_ 3 H ¿ 3 J ¡ ^)¿2A¿ Á P 3 j ¿*«t¿ 3 ¿K[.¿ Z P 1~¿ 3 "U[ H ¿ 3 AL\Á

(71) ÀÁ

(72) A¿ Z JKPM 12[dH ¿2AL`Á ÁIÀ Á Á A¿wÁJRP 3 [vLv]L\Á[|L\Á Á[4À ÀÁ À Á ÁJ ² 7^)¿\P 3 j ¿Ä¿ 3 ¿S[ ^c¿ Á P 3 j ¿ Z ]¿ 3 ¿ Á [ ^ÂH ¿2AL\ÁIÀ4A¿wÁJKP 3 [dLv]L\ÁE[ : #= > 6 = # 6 BC+ED L\Á Á . \ ]_a ¸hMgnl±9j9 §aHl|9aH{9§zHlgT«*]_aH} hµlnphJ}_gnln§qM}xa>kW§glg±} ln]_az qM`{qga | hJj9lqM`±hJlqM}B> ' b (B|9a gzHpn(a gln]_a lnphJ}_gnln§qM}_g qMj9lgn§|9asqJOln]_apaA_}_a |TgnlhJla¿ 3 ¥ ' (z qM}_gn§|9aHpguln]_alnphJ}_gln§qM}_guaH}2laHpn}94¿ 3 «*]_aHpaihMg ' (°|9aihJ §g «*ln] ln]_a©lnphJ}_gnln§qM}_g §aih ¨W}9$¿43Jª ' :( |9a gzHpna g*ln]_a©lnphJ}_gnln§qM}_g}_g§|9a¿435>gj_z]h%lnphJ}_gnln§qM}a>kR§gnlgqM}9 m ¢}_qlnphJ}_gnln§qM} §aihi¨2}9$ ¿ 3 }ln]_a5hMg§ghJj9lqM`±hJlqM}§ghJ §q·«ua |¬hJlln]_aDghJ`Ba©ln`Baª vs{9{9 m2}9ln]9§glqaihMz] gnlhJlaBä g%ln]_aB«*]_qM §a]9§aHphJpz]9§zihJ *qM{aHphJlqMp >@pqM` ln]_a±5hMgn§g%hJj9lqM`±hJlqM} y 1H¥ aihMz]TgnlhJlKa ¿XYP 1§gpa A_}_a |B}2lqDln]_ahJj9lqM`±hJlqM_} y`X.ª¤\ ]_a*pa gnj9 l:§gln]_agnm2}_z]9pqM}_qMj_g hJj9lqM`±hJlqM}}_qMla | y21 `HIy$ y Z S y - J*hJ}_|z qM`{9j9la | 2Q m H%9H HIy 1 `H ¿ y$J J |H ¿ Z y Z J J ?H ¿ - ( y - J>ª Ë ( ¼ ½ +§'0A ² +

(73) I '0j %* j|Igc g0+, % g=+,A% YAl})wj+I +, ÉÊ Q g) IhS}c%`jg2°YjIg) M§*i%}9g=+ % jfk%¦F+I9h ('0j+, iIg) OA IT l$ U%')klx%*kt+I]Igc i'290 Ar A A¦Mi{Ig) |A Ir $jhk%* g) {+§wg0!})%h«jg2°Yj{Ig) |A j'2 +

(74) 0§.%')klx%*k . L sL H ¼ ¤Ë À J( D À Ë ¼ · p@¼ Àro Â À µRi. * j_z]lnphJ}_gln§qM}_ggnmRgnlaH`Bg*zihJ}]5h ä©{9pqM{aHpnln§a g*paH ¸hJla |3lqln]_a©paihMz]5hJ9 l¯mqJ¤gqM`Bagnj9_gaHl qJ¤ln]_agnlhJla ng {5hMz a¥qMplq©ln]_a*a>kR§gnlaH}_z a*qJ({5hJln]_g°hJ §qM}9D«*]9§z]Thsz aHpnlhJ}ga ¹j_aH}_z a*qJaHäH}lgua>kW§gnlg·ª\ ]_aHmzihJ}Bz qM}_z aHpn} }¨hJpn¸hJ}lg*qM}Tln]_a8gnlhJla g°ln]_aH`BgaH ä g ' £ª aª¥Wln]_as¨MhJpn¸hJ9 §a g qJO«*]9§z]ln]_as¨MhJ j5hJln§qM}|9aA_}_a g*hDglhJla (>¥WqMpuln]_a {5hJln]_gln]5hJlzihJ}(a©lhJaH} }ln]_a©lnphJ}_gnln§qM}gnmRgnlaH`"ºpqM` gnlhJlalqgnlhJla¥5aHlzª =DIGKJ. GH.

(75) S1. a and b and not c / e a t( no. c/d. S2.A. d an. c. c. d. a. tc no. B. S2.B. c/. d an. a and b / e A. c and c1. d an b). S2. 1. d an. c/d. b. c1. S1. d c/. a. b/e. an. not c1. e. a a nd no tc. b and c / e d. /e. not b and c / d. d. tc no nd ba. C. S2.C. ¤j9pa >vs} a>k9hJ`{9 §aqJ¤]9§aHphJpz]9§zihJ ¤z qM`{qgnln§qM} ' §a>ºl)(>¥9«*ln] ln]_a©pa gnj9 ln}93hJj9lqM`±hJlqM} ' pn]2l)(>ª WOaHl y¼ HON;PQN Ri.N;P N R _AxJ(ahJ}µhJj9lqM`±hJlqM}O¥Y §aHl ³µ,ah±gaHl©qJ glhJla g©hJ}_|¬ §aHl¿.Pt ah glhJlaTh yTª a}_qi«|9a A_}_aTgqM`BaBlaH`{qMphJ {9pqM{(aHpnln§a gln]5hJl%«* uaBj_ga>ºj9 }¶ln]_a}_a>kWl%ga zHln§qM} lq3a>kW{9pa ggln]_az qM}lnpqM :qMRrna zHlnä g©ln]5hJl©«* ]5h ä%lq3aH}_gnj9pa |¦qM}¦hTgnmRgnlaH` `BqW|9aH §a | hMgDh±gm2}_z]9pqM}_qMj_g hJj9lqM`±hJlqM}Oª a°gFh mln]5hJl¤hgnlhJl«a ¿§g A %Eg2%0 ¤ºqMp y «*]_aH}_aHäHp¤ln]_aHpa a>kW§gnlg¤h*lnphMz «a ®50HIN)XiA¿XÆÀXkJ"X\[ Y P+Å*/0ÏÈ=HIyxJ ln]5hJllnphiäHpga g ¿R¥R£ª aª ^8V )A¿ X ]¿Rª mE¼ n5oqp p@rÀ o h yaaH ,i9

(76) _AxJ` 4%Ujfwrg= 9'0j`%')klx%*k¹%9 ³ ¯«Ig) h y j%* +

(77) j

(78) j{Ig) sdsaihMz]5hJ9 l´m qJ °Yg) T #w \Ig) A \ A¦+zjhIj¿4P7Ig2%*«+zjA %Eg2%0 RhKy x¯°Ygc r #w h_%*

(79) V. %=g2%= Mjk%* j\¿=¯Ig) A ¦*+zjhIjd% y jh%* +

(80) j

(81) R j$Ig) * lnpqM}9 daihMz]5hJ9 l´mqJ % kfd+

(82) ?+ +,% + ~ Ax+I_¿Ig)%*«A %Ehg) j