HAL Id: halshs-00304283
https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-00304283
Submitted on 22 Jul 2008
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Learning from experience or learning from others?
Inferring informal training from a human capital
earnings function with matched employer–employee data
Guillaume Destré, Louis Lévy-Garboua, Michel Sollogoub
To cite this version:
Guillaume Destré, Louis Lévy-Garboua, Michel Sollogoub. Learning from experience or learn- ing from others? Inferring informal training from a human capital earnings function with matched employer–employee data. Journal of Socio-Economics, Elsevier, 2008, 37 (3), pp.919-938.
�10.1016/j.socec.2006.12.085�. �halshs-00304283�
(*)'+-,/.'.'(*)102(3)'+54.'6718%9:.;71(3)<(3)10=+-.14 67#> ?'671)#@A71B-(C9D718,E7F.')'(3)10HGH+I?<)1@'9E(J4 )
KL(C9:>267M9/@N>O,/P,/6QBI8;4 R',A.'ST,/6QBI8;4 R',E,QP;719U7
VW5XZY[Y]\^WU_a`Fb`dc*eCfhgdikj1l^W5XmcAj1gon^prqsV\^futvl^W5\^i^wxXmyz5`hY5{Il|YZY]l^}^l^W5t ♦
~H`desfh` Ugydl^vl^_aXm` 5`FY]\{Il^fht5l^55` \^v /\^fuXTc<{Iyz5l^l|Y-l|Fydl^vl^_aXmyc
5XnI`fcJX[e3gF/\rfhX]cA
71rhJC OUdA M¡h^¢T ¡h£|¤¦¥'§|©¨o§¦¨u ª^«¬'ZC¡h T«¤T ®¥'*¯°±J ZJ«¨uF¡h«¦[J¡u ²³¤
T x¢T§«J ¬:[¬U°« u°^¬3HM¢´§«[¬U°«¡o°«C Jµ¶[¢v·Z[¬E¡F¨u[¬*«¸mT ¹¬º»d¢T[M¢m§¡C¢v J¼«[¬*½¬:¾a|¨uJ ¸m¿3¼¡o«¼«¨«À[¬
ÁJÂCÃ|ÄÅÂ3Æ ¢T C¡J¢mOJu¢¢Jd»| =L¢m§|#§»|M¡oǨ¡o°«È¢T¡u¡u ²£É¤É¬Qm»|¨3¢[rµ'Ê=#¬T¢T³M¡J¢¢²§«#¬T¢T ²»«¨3¢m»« ¡u
°«¡h T¡Oº¢J ¬:dÅ¢m§«[¬:««¸T«J¡u UOÅO¡F©¡h T¤«;ËÅ J¨§¨ ¬3¬3¸T¬*C¨3¢²[O¥F¢²§O ¡C¢²¨J§«OJ °^[·«J ¸²J °«[·|u
¡C¢T¡|µCÊÌ/³«Í¢´§¡J¢-¥1 ²Î«C º¬U ¡u¼|C ¡¤«A¨¡u [J¡u ²OT xh¢m§«J ¬-¢TJF°±J ¨hJu¢5^¢m§« U¥' §»|M¡h ¨¡°«È¢T¡h^
Ju¢J ³¤O«A°^©¡ou¢Ï¡o«F¨¡C¢T¨o§ §¡h5^¢T§|© v[C¡h T«³¤MT x¢²§«C º¬ÀÉ°«¢Ju¢¡u^/뱬T¢^¢²¥1F·«J¡u º¬µÑv§«E°| ¼¡C¢
¡u T¤|¡u| º¢m»« T«¬-¢T h»«¨¡J¢T[ ¡u /¨Z«¤ ¥1È¢²§OCh»^¨¡C¢T[M¡¬vOd ;u»|¨¡C¢'¥1 ²Î«C º¬v§¡u¼|/[¬3¬-¢1[J¡u ²
T ®¢T§|C º¬'¡o ¬§¡u '¢T§|O¬3¨¡h5 º¢m»| T«¬F¢²§« Í¥'Òh»^¨¡C¢T¥1È¢²§¢m§« '[¬3¬FÓh»«¡h©ZT[¨h¸m¥1 TÎ|C º¬µ
Ñv§°^¢Ju¢T¡h1T [J¡u T|¤%T ¢²§«C º¬¦¢T§|Oкhª¼«¡u ©¬¡u¨ ¬3¬<кhª±¬¦¡o«½¬T¢²¡ª«[[¬§ÉOJd¢¬3Ï;¡oa¢T§|³¬
°« u¼|[¬U¡;«J¥L[¬T¢¨3¢T[Fª^¢²¥1J³O¢²¡C¢T[h/Ð3hª±¬U¡o« *¯°±J ZJ«¨u-Ð3hª±¬µJÊ=d ²Î«J ¬UOOÈ¢T¡J¢T[h/Ð3hª±¬3Ï¥'§^
[J¡u ²O¬T¢ T ¢T§|C º¬3ÏU¢TJa¢T§¡¼| ¨u«¬*©ÉC ¡ª«·[¤«J 1¢²Jd»| ¢²§¡o¥1 TÎ|C º¬%J¯°^J [J¨uHÐ3hª±¬µ
1È¢m§«h»|¤§¥1 TΫJ ¬3¯°^J [J«¨h1Ð*uª^¬O¨¡h[C¡h T[È¢[¢TZT Ô¢²§«J ¬3ÏD¥1« ¢m§¡C¢;¢m§«J·[J¡u ²¡ [¢<ª^·
¢m§«JO¬*¼«u¬µJÊ#<dɨJ»«OJu¢¬*J¼«J ¡h«¡o¡h[¤«Z½¬Dª±º¢T¥FJ1¢m§«;O£¢T¡J¢T/Ð3hª±¬ÕT*¯°±J ZJ«¨u-Ð3hª±¬AÖh»«¡uZ³¬sO×;¡^
¢m§«A°« ¡u T·Õ´¬*J¨u«¡h T·/Ð3hª±¬:¡OT ¬oÀrh»«¡h[[¬ºx³1°^[[ª·1¢m§«'h»«¡hr¡ª|d v ¡u TÎ|¢Å¢T§« ²·kµhØF¥1J¼«J Ï|h»«
ª«¡h T·¨¡¬3¬º¨¡C¢²[EÐ3hª±¬*°±¨3¢¬F¢²§«d¡J¢T¡O º¦¨u[¬*·Ò¢²§¡ ¢T§«h»«¡uU¢T§|d ²·¨¡C¢TJ¤« ©Ù¡J¢T[u¢
°« M¡h T·«¸¢m·°^¡o«¬3¨|d¡h T·«¸¢²·d°^ ¬T¢T¡ª|©[¬s§OJd¢¬oµDÚ:h °±º¢TÈ¢Z°« J¼¡uZ³¬ª±º¢m¥1J кuª^¬¡«© O¬Hª»d¢
Ð3hª±¬U[TC -ªÉ·N¢m§|© v[C¡h T¤'¢T¨o§«[¤·rµ
ÛOÜJÝÉÞMßà^ Ø<»« ¡ha¨¡°«È¢T¡h/J¡u Tɤɬm»«¨3¢TZ«¬3ÏU ¡C¢T¨J§|aJ °^[·«J ¸²J1°^[·«d¡J¢T¡dÏU ¡u5¢T ¡u¤«Ï
[J¡u ²³¤aT á¢T§|C º¬3ÏUC¡h T«É¤aT âJ¯É°±J [J|¨uÏU º¢m»« T«¬<¢T¦¢J»« ºÏE¬º¨u¡uE ¢´»« T«¬H1h»^¨¡C¢T«ÏU¡ª^
¡u TÎ|¢vu»|¡u[¬º¦µ
ã,A8%@'ßà|Ü ¿3äåÏ¿Jæ
Â
϶Tärµ
Ífh`hqsçUfuXm-eUnI`fucJXml^5irç5Wvt-Y]XmcCz5`èX]éez5`<êrë^ì-íî5ï^ð-ëmñ¦òë^óômë|õö óë^î5ë^÷ ô]óhø'ùrúûürý^ý^þ|ÿ|q|ùrþ
♦ ! "$#%'& %(%")*+ ,.-!/0 %1"2& 343653%%7849:;<,.=">@?., ,BADC1 FEGHIJ@ E;
K@L
>"M
K
!FNPO&8Q SRT,SU;WVXY 3Z
"!# %$'&( )*!+ %,!&-!./0 %,1 2!)-3# %$45',76983# ,1 :,<;' 8')=3
&- $2)>?@ &-A!CBED&=FDG C H'..'6I %!6I&-J 76K83FL+&-!'%,M%N:OP4QRS!FTJUWVX%!'Y6
%!C6Z&5X&[)-)';2!CCD! 4\HC^]L+&-!':,_&` "!aS7 %,<!&-!.bc=!'H&-!/deEC^GfHbDG&-6)[34H&- 6hg%,i&-2! 2
H&=X '6)j&kX)>&-!' %,X&-!J6 <&-!J !C6J@ 64, H&>&-!J)= 8', %,<;'lm$'%,&>!Cn2&(&>oj )>)[3?7 ")>)>6
H*@ 764, H&-S %,!&-!./ck!&-!/d4pS!%m4%!C66GgA%,&5! /H&kl@ <&-!B4D &>D c$,$/768'3
L+&-!'%,q "!C6Fr4g' !4g'&>1M%N:O2sjNRB )5&-!)t6Cq J@f 64, H&-15!&-!F2c%!',1&-!uH'1&-!'8!
<&t,?dYEC0L+&-!'%,&> !I %,<!&-!.jh5!H&-!vC h8A!I"HH&=&>!q&[!I%m4H,w H&-!4.g' )t 78')>J&-!2H,1 H&-2!
8ACcHf5q %!6?,5,!2qAX76 &-A!x !6yH,w %&-!&[!.5,'z%m$'%,&>!7{< %,!&-!4.j|$,wAH&=)>}djE'
,7%! gA &=)> %8'&=)=&~392S)- %,<.'F %C6W $2)-3'%,{" $')-A3CF6 &-!W u!/8%, S4'!H,&-4
Mp*8'4D 6? %!C60S, %,<"BN:OOO4R|G %;'&(oDG,kH? ;2&-!e.F4DH&5X$'$4')- %,)\7C')-6J8' %m4%!C66
HmeH, 664&(&-! )c&[!H, <&`A!x %8'4oHC1 4'!4 %!6H,5', AX&-!H,_ )c)=7 %,!&[!e.!yH'
A8fdp!' 5',w %)'6A&,H&-! 2j,w %,hDG c 64g'' 76q83L+&-!':,cM%N:OP4QR&-yi)-}n
]e
*# 78% YF$7 J@%Y$ " : \ ." =0* % B`a4@ $#'YJ3`a43 S*4% %`F#8J% Ya?a3#%%E4]*7
3 S\ %b
*% 3E:@" B* S$E) a4 .(E4-<%1 ": 7D(6%`+`% Y7 6%`<Y78S D#": 78 13 SJ $ EZ
p u 5%,S*< Bo %76KDGA,<;':,{H&t,6 y3&>)>6g' )t 78')>F&-!HA, &-!v %8AC^%'{
DGA,<;':,* :!6F<&t,J:EH, :&[!&-!.$')[&>%3FD &>F ;'S&tX$/&t8')>ZHv:$' %, 1)-7 %,!&[!.H,CHC%,
%!C6)> %,!&-!.+5,ACD!W%m$':,_&>!74dcE&5J<CC)-6+!H,<&t841H+ y8A=%,*'!6:, %!C6A&-!e.+2|H
$,'i2*/ !I :$2&( )X 7G)> &-A!FY6839<&-,y !6WS&-,J:C%,.'%!&(H3W&-!H&
,$'idC ")>)8'j&-!.'%,+ v/!&>@j,!'%%,/{&-!A!)= %8AA,x/? :!6DG %.
H,H}5',M5?UcN:OO4R%$,&5&-!.N e¡ ¡¡¡hDG %.'* %,<!C%,c&-!FN:¢ ¡¡¡ 8')>&51!d
LI"£H¤&-!H,_G ")vH,w %&-!&[!. %;2&-!e.¥$2)` 7¤4!{5H{ 48¦ %3§8¨ %$45',6z83¦
8'&[!' <&-!2)> %,!&-!4.JH,2©CD!%m$'%,&>!SM<,Bfw)[{<)> %,!&-!.R %!C6y)> :,<!&-!.J,ªHC%,lM<,<B
)> %,!&-!.«83«D %&-!.Rd¬q %,,A!CBq¬)- %; %!C6®l2DZ%!/&-!M%N:O2seO4R?:A!H&t,¯HW&[ $', %!CWA
Hh&-!H,_ )/)> %,<!&-!.1$,w24l&[!HCqT0d-Ubde<!H|H4,S A!H2lH2)-)-CDG&[!. H*,%,H/&( !EA
!D¯D ,<;'%,wBO¢4° J!{kHC{
C8H, :&[!&-!.&5?.2&tgf%!«HC"±&[! !&-!HA, )hDG 7383H%,
DGA,<;':,*M:NQ/ 'd²x4',* ZH %)*N jNd5N 4',RS %!6F ,ZH :!A!C{kH&t,w6A!C{kH7{
C8FH,w %&-!&[!.
M_ e³/d5NvCC',i<R?&k?$,4g'&-66He,4'. +])> %,!&-!.83DG &-!4.'a$,w2dX®l %,!&-!.83!4w")5
H4,wC'.m$'%,&>!W !6)> :,<!&-!.5,2´4H:,F7 %$5',FHWii!H&> )h&-!.,6&>!?2
H%,q .'2'6u6%,&t$4&-!?2&-!2H, ")A!C{kH7{
C8?H,< &-!&-!.jd/'%3u8ACH?HA, H 1&>%,'! &5
4'!%,$' %,k|HF H! CjG %!6W7 %{5'$W.,DhHI$,<'i%$ %, 683¬*!C 78'&t8# !6
U$2&`%.') M%N:OO4QRF&-! :,27A!CA &>W.,CDSHG26%)5wBGH')[)`CD &-!. '..'H<&`A!21)5! !6
Y)-$/cM%N:O¢¢4Rd
uG26)X2*&-!'HA, )X'!{kHC{
C89)> %,!&-!.W,¯)- !C6v4H%,Mk®U*Rh$,w!76v&=!
7<&`A!W+ 4HF!&>< 5',Fh3&>)>6A&-!.# )-/i6{H,¯2)(&-!<dG%!CB|&(&= $'/&t8/)>u
&>6!&[53+&(H,5', %)$' :, 1%,*D &(HI1 %'6v $')-A3':,{<$')-A3'?6 ? "!C6v&-!2%,5,' H'
)> 5%,|HCF% :, %,&5H&>GAS&-!HA, )H, %&-!&-!.vD &(&[!
48j !6WH&[,JBX)-&[;'JHu,)- <&tg'JjiFA
8'4HJ)> %,<!&-!.J%!C2)-.2&-4wBfH $')>"! :,<&(H3?,^H8/H<&(5 8'&[)>&(H3?2l6 &-!? !61H, %&-!&-!.'B
H %.'!&(56A<$'&[)>)-Ag%,H<A/ !+ %$'&( )* '!4.#2{5D 4,<;':, %!6«'&- )|, A
,5C,<!6 H&-!/dW6' W %!6!2GH,&- :$$,2 7% %,HC!6&5jw6&-!H&-!³/d
U'H&-!JQ'$' %,H' 7A!C2 H,&- 4&-1 AHCG!CA!C{<)=&-!' %,X®U© %,!&-!./*@ <&-!1D &(
H/ 6%,&tg'6¤5,w2 L+&-!'%,&> ! $'')`3C!2&> ")5&-!¤%!',M<)-&-!' %,Bx@ 64, H&-©A,#@ %,5H&-%R !6
&-!%,$,hHCu,H/)~dXU&[!CyHu$':!H&- )|H, )- %,<!&-!.+5,2¦4H%,i &= F!4g')6&kH<&-!e.4/&5&-!2.
5',|8'5DG%!
A8X !6 8')>&51!&-!C',l %!' )t3/&5B\7<&`A!J %mA "&-!'HhC%,.'%!&(3
A8* !6?H 78')-&5'1! ")`2!4.JH&5|!CD 6A&-!/&-2!/dE&5q%m'%,&5 $,4g'&-64 Z!'Dª$' :,<&~H&-2!
A8/S83H&-,)> %,!&-!.%!C2)-.A3fn)=7 %,!&[!.W5,wA¦4D!v%mC$/%,&-!'?&[! 0 "!'6
)> %,!&-!. 5,2 4H%,iv&-! "!$#%!&'()"d45DG53e$'4I2 8/9 %,!H, H6 %!6H
,,w<$'!6%!C 8'5DG! H &>1&( <&-! A8j+*HmC$'%,&>"!C A8 ]6 )=&5 a !6 H
$,&-1 :,w3,*w!6 %,<3
A8 !C6<&t,J:X6 )=&5¥&>Z$')=&6u8396 ")l)= %8AA,S %,<;'HC,3M"- '%,&-!4.'%,
%!C6.&-A,w N:OP\N:B/- &>%;'!29 !6 ®l !4.N:O2s Rv&5I@4H&`A!'6/dEC H/ %,<3©2F<&-!'6&-!./I "!'6
!)(Y&-2!'\D &-)=)28A^H4'!6 &-!1i&-! ¢/d
0 21cZOw43j j'53SHiV ZOq76'q+8':9 1¦w {Å'j1 3Hb 176 X{<;
76Z>=
A,;'%,W %3 @&-,
48'{<$'&-<&>H,w "&-!&-!.'BZD&5% &59 46 8'.'%!:, )JM<&5dted
H, %!'H%, %8')>K«HC%,JH&[,JJ&-!H'Wi "
8RB*&(HC%,JHA, )-)[3A,J&-!H,_ )=)-3d¬q4H;'&-!62?2
H, %&-!&-!4.I %,w1/H)t3I H%3u :;'GH&-J D %3H,2zGA, $,'6H&tg'G <;/dj'1 &[!K6A&>%,!
@?
#"78%"ER 178%"E<%`E$S Y\ ("bBA 3#\')DC<CE -6J@c"*S ("bBC "b?FF (%:@ 8).,HGGM -;"( b
3%YJ% ."\ E`]?[E4 Y"\'% E4 Y \ `a%7 RJa43WZX$%:2a][ %`#C<CE 78% SE % 4%:F S$ c.a
# .F J"J@ SD8Q6# %:"`];IC b?FF (%:@ S@ / % 478 9:.4*).,HGG
K
-];KJD%71 )4A"= = ="-a; S@LDY4)[A ="=@U-Z
!2H/+ "!43,iwC',7F5,' CHC%,JD ,<;',dp W,)(B $')-A3'7C?DC %,W./=H&-!4. ,
'$$')t3'&-!.&-!H,_ )hH, &-!&-!. %,w!4? )(DG %3/7A!/w"&`CjJH 1H%3 %,+62&-!4. w}d|<!5',HC%,
!H, kXkv&[!4g !&-!+'A)-&-!.+ !6vH, )oH, &-!&[!.'BHF'$$')[392*&-!2H, )oH, &-!&-!.W&
H&-6J&-!ZHC^D 4,;'%,)- %8',X:A!H, id4pq/%!0M%NOP4Rl,% %,;'6y)`A!e.? %.'2Bj 7%J&,_ª$,4g'&-6'
y$'&=<&> $/ :;' %.'JAM<&-!HA, )tR|H, %&-!&-!.W%,<g'&>H&~DGA,;'%,SuH cH1)> >%,BYA!CGHC"3
%!%,6I u&,_GBC %gy!CWH%,%'&-1H !FW @"&t,?&(S;2!CCD )`64.'4dVX!27@"!<)t3ABED ,<;'%,i
D &-)=)j8' %,H /5XEHC&t,|&-!H,_ )/H, &-!&[!.x %!C6y,7 %$yHC,}5',!2d'<!? 66&(H&-!B/D i1hH'
m'&5!C*2/5DZ&-!H,_ )')= %,!&[!.:!2)-.'&-4cA!'{5H{
C8bnC)> :,_!&-!.5,2 4D! %mC$'%,&=!C*M<,B
)-{w)> :,_!&-!.RX !C6y)> %,<!&-!.F5,'ªCHC%,M<A,wBf)` %,!&=!e.y83JDG %&-!.Rd']4U')-<{<)> %,!&-!.a !{kHC{
A8
%!C "!'71$,w26H&tg'&(H3+83 KH,<&` ")>{< !C6{<%,<,,1$e,<'idXI2$')>"! :,<&(H3#2 6 <&-!# "!'6
mC$'%,&=!Ch !C6HC|$,$'%!2&(H32/HC^ ,*@ )=&><&>6DG,<;'%,jH 6A$Y&t!!4g H&-!/c< H%,cM<Xdd
U'%)(HN:OP2 Ru'..'SH SH4&5J&50 vh/)~<&t$')=&> H&tg'$,'}do %&-!.Hv ,$,<'6}H&tg
DGA,<;':,64KHC&t,4D!
48/ )5W&[!C%, 4wC*HCy$,6H&`g'&~39* u)>S$,'6}H&tg1D ,<;'%,*83I
&- $2)>h&>1&( &-! $,27wB/ !CJ%/5H,oC%,c] 7"':,<adCE&5&5l *;2&-!'61%me%,<! )>&(3 D &>B/H,
5DJ &[!, 4!2wBj62l!l :)[)jH,X 6&t,l%$'!2i H&`A!02\H^7 %:,d4Y&t,HBf&~c&k 6&[H5\i
$,'i|&-!1D &>u !43J :%, %3F&-!:, cD &(HFG "!43H56%!DG&(<CCeXg'!J, )-&-4&-!.yHC
H%3I'$$')[3?H, &-!&[!e.W%,<g'&>4B H%3vH/<%,*!Cf5idU':A!C6BbH'6 3j5H56%!XD &=)-)c!, )=)=3
8'72 ,<,<4D0k\7 %:,c %!C60wZ,:$' 73SD jH%3,&tg6 &[!SH|$' Hid
3 0 'z5` `\^fh5X]v}^c/ºW55yhe3X]l^
<!WHFL+&-!'%,&> "!WH, 64&~<&-!BDG %.', 0 %,I H'176@ %)HCKg )(fv 1 :,<.2&-! )
$,'6}l)> %8',X!? Z72$'&(H&tgZ %,<;'id/jBj.,/ %,!&[!./X,w"H)>/ !? %$'&( )HdA®lcj
6&-.'! %!',1&-!uHC1&-!'78!&,_£ 2!>B%m$,i6&-!6A&5i%,wGH&-
=
B :!6 A8'{<$'7"&-<&> 1 !0 %$'&( )\'\D ,<;'%,7&-!JH&-,_¨ !6
A8 831HCZ!C6JAc$'%,&-'6 !\
d4&~< H4
!4 H&-A!'B/HZ!CC H&-!
,%$,w!HCZ)>%g')' A8{_$'&-<&>Z !F :$2&( )A!x!%,<&-!e.yH'
<&t,B4H &kwB2 =%,$':,_&`262l%m$'%,&>!*!H*)> 78AA,c %,;'&-!/! <&-,Jdeo :)/%m$':,_&>!
oD ,<;&577!d/A,<;':,B&-!:, XD &(HxCHC%,DG,;'%,i*5,2ªHu J&-,¥ !C6
A87F8e*<'
@&t,4#%m'&5&[!e.¤;!CCD )>64.' 5,2 H/DC¤$'fii« ,;!4D )-64.HC %!¤C%,)-d_
C (@F`%78 E4 "\@;" `Y%a78 SE$ \13%]:@786%?4E4 (%6%:3%`<#2`a47 ZE # 1%?4E4 (%63% Ya3S D(
\ E43B*S@; "`a%78 E $Y @\ 2`aEb ]: J"J@E448( bT`a47 2` AD%=2: "$Y \ J bT`a%2*# `a%\"% E:@1%`
$# % A *78Z
?
#3%c*]"A4#84#@F`Y \ )*C Y%;"CE 3< 1C\; , GG
K - $#" <71J E4%b"6:@"Y78 .F$# 78%: "
%`<4"`a%71 E"$Y @\$#b1S3( b A =! SE$ B*2%D71JE4%bBZ
8''6A&-76&-!# !«$')-A3AuHC 1Cv&5J%m$'/769k« %!6+ !«)> %,!+5,2¯&-!WHw 1vH&-,Jd
%,&["CYH*<&t,?;'!4D )>64.'* H :,c CYD ,<;'%, j&=l!:,_!C6B4H &=B4H* "!G %$'&( )/2
DGA,<;':, k] :'%,<adJ¬|36<&-!'&(&-2!BFD ª %g'Cn
≥
dF¨28'&-!'6"HA#CD!mC$'%,&=!C !C6)= %,!&[!.5,w2 4H:,xA! vD ,<;:,k?$,'6H&`g'&~3&[!$'%,&-'6 ! %,+ H/6
66&(&`gA^&-!hHCh ")>)' !6.2&tg!83fn
M%NR
−−−−
−
+ +
=
−
HA,
≥
d
<!SH&kE@ H&-!B4H*H<)-<{<)> %,!&-!.1&5$,wA$C4,H&-! )4hHhk2:; Aj/ ! %$'&(w )
D!ZHCh$'%,&-'6Z8'%.'&-!/d'EC< 4,&=!'c\Hh$43&= )j6%$,w&= <&-!1,w hc1 !0 %$'&( )
%!C6y&(l&5X 4H/6Z18'A!' %!id45cZ&-.'8AG!C%.' H&tg&-EHCh, c6%$,7"&> &-!J%m'76'6ZH
!2H %!Y, |)=H{<)> %,<!&-!.'BA84jDG*m$'7Y&(jHG8A|!, )[)-3 $'/&(<&tg4d&>)=*%mC$'%,&=!C%!6/
H«&-!:, 4FH'v1 !7 %$2&~ ")S' )=)*D ,<;'%,0 G v!2H %!G, BH$,w!'I2 4H%,0&
$,H/G 78')-3FGA,8'!<&>&> )bu)-4i@ ")>&=<&>61DGA,<;':,DCu' %g' Z)`CcHu)` %,!B\&- KM Y¡4RBfHC
, ;'!4D )>64.'16&=HkY&-2!JD &(&-!uH'1H&[,B&kS&>6'%!&- )cHA,S )-)EDG,<;'%,}d2YA,S&-Z$')=&>&(H3CBH&5
iZ$4&-!hD &-)=)'8'|;'%$4Y:,dL9A,:4g'%,B &5c&-!4g' %,&5 :!jD &(H,w<$'/H^:!',4d
1,7',<,%!CJ@ &-!M%NRS :!K8Au2)tgA6 "=:,*$'f55')- &-!4.FH HuHH,}5',w1
48'{
<$'7"&-<&>«;'!4D )-64.'M< "! 7 %$2&~ ")Rv !C6HC6&-<5j&-2!$,'iFD &(H&-!H<&t, %,w#H&-{
&-!4g %,&> "!id\,<X %,S.2&tg!J&-!? %$$'!6&`m+Nd4¬3? )5? H/&[!.1HC HS&-,?;'!4D )-64.'S.,CD
D &(H0%m$'%,&>! YH!2H %!c,w YB/&(c&5|CCD!1H
C8A{_<$'&><&>G/ !J7 %$2&~ ")j.,4DoD &(
%!',|&-!hH*H2)-)-4D &-!.GDG %3fn
MR ' "#$
=
!+
( $[
& $' "#+
!−
& $ % "#]
D&(H += (
,,+ +
**( )(
,,+ +
))) )
1 0<
2<
/- .@ H&-! MR %3 )58'D,_&~=%! :n
3465798:798;=<?>A@B;=CDCFEHGJI=>6;K8ML?NM7AI=@O8QPBNMISRJCTLVUW7DX6YZLZ5[E[P\I=>95JL]8M7A^=L>T5;?>_>A5JL`N;?>9LZI=X6abGJI=YZCTLVcBdJLZcB7eX9X9@\8M79I[GfcBLgPbLSGcb8h8I[CTLVCDEHI[G
>T5JLZ8M<S5JI[I[CA7AGJdKCALjiJLVClkbYm5J7A<?5KNMLVUH;S7DG\8n<SI[G\8>9;SG>_ISiJLVNCA7eXoL?>97AUHL[p[465B798n7987AGcBLSLScq;PJCT;V@O87FRJCTL;[8j8@JUqPB>A7AI[GrRJLS<S;V@O8LZ7D>s7l8t>95JL
NMI[CALuI=XrLSc[@\<S;V>97AI[Gv>9IwLVGB5J;SGJ<SLf>T5JLf;xRJ7ACA7F>DEy>lIvCALS;=NoG\knGJI=>h>T5;S>I[XrI[G\zA>A5JL]z{|I]R}>9NM;S7DGJ7eGBd\pt~jiBEJzo;=N9RJI=@b;][ Ah9BB
cBL|i\LSCAI=PH;>T5JLSI[N9EqIXLSc@b<S;V>97AI[Gb;VC_89EJ8>9LSU8sRJ;[8MLScqI[Gq>A5B798nc[798>97DGJ<|>97TI[Gp
M<³4R
[
]
λ
− + + =
D&(H
−
=
λ
Mλ
≥
Rd%,<
λ
6&-.2!C \HC
8'{_$'&=<&>! "$#&%')('*+(!,.-!/021435(!,"6," "!BCD&>Z&5l&[!'6:$'"!C6!
f:!',4d@ }H&-!2EMRc %!6 M<³4RH,<HCq8A &5c2/5C®UG26)5deE'%38A2&-)'6CDG!hHhH®¬
M<)- %,!&-!4.83D %&-!e.RF '62)$,$/7683®87%g3'{:9S %,<8'4 +M%N:OO4QRF&-;#=<Y¡/d|<!.'!C%, )-BhH
!v %$'&( )l2* !43I.2&tg!DG,<;'%,S&[!C%, 4whD &~HK:!',? !6W!g%,.'*CDG %,62|HCuH&[, (
A8A{_<$'7"&><&>1;2!CCDG)-64.'4d 4DG7gA%,B\HJ)- 5%,*&5S J Ag'&-!.F %,<.'HB\D&>&[!':, wC^ q u 63
, oHe,C'.Gm$'%,&>!ed
Y,WH$4',<$'/ +!2 H,<&> &- <&`A!CBxDG !gA%,#@ H&-A! M<³4R«&-!z! 5', )
)-.' %,&(HJd>#x&= )=)>B4D |.'}n
MQR HJILK F @A?
=
HJILK F @A M+
CED+
HJILK[
G+ λ
@A(
G−
B ?) ]
<\DG l :!18')> %,!6J5,2 CHC%,X&-!ZHC',<,:!cH&[,ª&5 Z )=) %,wA\HC^DGA,<;':,
&-!2&~<&> )bHH'%; j1 ! 7 %$2&~ ")>B'MQRc %!S8'*=',H%,&- $')=&-<&>6 !6 %$$,4m'&-1 6h83Yn
M_ R VJWLX T OPN
=
VJWLX T OP Y+
RES+ λ
OP(
U−
Q N)
D&~HZZ [J\!]
^_
^_
^_ `
a
λ ≅
d@ H&-!M_ RS&k^ 0H 8')-uH,2H1®U .,/ %,!&[!.jSk!<&-!/dYJ)-A. %,&(H£2X.,/
%,!&[!./I&5uHCH/ 2x «)=&-!' %,w{w&-!C{k%!',w«%m$%,<&>!x %!C6 !%mC$'A!C"!<&` ")0x2
)> %,!&-!.«5,2 HC%,H :A!g'%,.'CH 4*kCDG %,62SHF&-,? C8A{_<$&-<&>)> %,!&-!.+$'%!H&> )Hd
*!HC^)> >%,&=$'&=<&>6B48'4H)- %,<!&-!.c :!G8A^&`6"!<&-<&>6hD &~H @ &-! M_ Rd
bdc
e5f=gdh/g/ikjEhlnm&ipo;ipgql=j=h/g
MH.,fi<RX %,.2&-!' )j,5',<!'o1%!',H,X ^DGA,;%,sr$2)`A3'6J&[!?<&t, "!C6
A82t?M"uwvxzyR
%,*6:&-!'6 4:n
{
| {
|
−
−
−=
}~
}
~
~
}
~
}
H,
≥
NM<¢4R
( )
− + +
+
=
−−
λ λ
&57@ <&`A!&-.2)>&-.2^HC !J$' %,qHJ,5,<!'*x:!',u&>H&[,£62:$'"!C6!d\p
DGA,<;':,v8'%!C"&(+5,2 H&-, DG&=¨$')-A3/#%,wBu&-!¤ 766A&(&-2! D +<C.'+5,2
mC$'%,&=!CB|&-!/2H :,u !)> :,_!H&-!4.5,¯4H%,DGA,;'%, &-!«:,
A8#7 %.',3d&
$,6&-&-!FoHC1 26)7gAA;'*! $' %,loH6 ")jH,3HA,3JHC c%)-)kXH oHCZ,5',!2H
%!', %,F!&-)*&[!i!6 :,w3C{kH3e$'
8jB|&-!vD &>$, 7H&- )=)-3«!C !+ %$'&( )* /)= <&-!
%;'$')- BbDG&=)>GHC73 %,Z$'/&(&tg'1&-!F$,&= %,<3C{kH3$'
48j*M"- &>%;'!2S !6u®l !4.'B|N:O2s R}d/<!676B
M<¢4R?&-!6&=7 1HC Hv,5',!21%!',W %,W1&-!&= ) !6«,769kD!'%g'%,
λ
<Y¡B r
<
BfHC l&kwBfD'!1H%, &5|!C$'ZH,|)` %,!&=!e.F5,2 H%,!{5H{ 48jd 4D g'%,B\&-!JH
$,w%!0 '6")`BqHCW%,&- )6&5&-!&-!8A5DG%!«$',&[ %,<3C{kH3e$'
8/? !6w7A!C6 %,<3{53e$'
A8j
6'!4j8' :,cA!*H&t,,<$&`gA^)>%g')5c2Y "!G :$2&( )84!hHd "!$#"$"%&('*)+%-,."%/,10$)2'*3465.7
%8!6Jr4)&-!HCv&-,¯H,A¦HW !64$'&-! WD,<;',0M&5d~4d~B
99 :;
:;
<
=
RdX)> =%,&=0C8g'&-4j)=3
&>6A&`f<3C!'%, &-B'6%$'!6&-!4.'$'A!SH ;/bkG8'|$':,<HA, 76Z :!6$'%,wA!C ") %8'&=)>&(<&>}d
1 %,<.'&-! ),5',!2XHy%!',1 :,y4D!u83K@f H&-!FM¢4RHJ8'1 ! %g'1&-!'%,w &-!2.
5/!C<&`A! /H
48'{_$'&=<&>*)- %,<!&-!. $'%!H&> )Hn
>
> ?
?
∂ <
> ∂
∂
∂
@A@ACB
@A
@ACB D
D
λ λ
c&> ")5wH, :&t.2<H,DG %,6ZkK4DHC XM¢Rm&t8&(q Z:!g%mx6%,7 &-!.u,)- <&-!?EH'
%,<.'&-!' "),w5',<!hk^%!',wD &(Hh%!',n
E
E F
F
∂ >
< ∂
∂
∂
H GIJLK G H IJCKMONQPSRUTWVYXLZ/[\RU]6XC^1_a`1PUbcPedL`"RUd.bcPfdCg6b4^h[+d Vid PU^"g6bcP7RUbcPejXCbkml4[4n1PUoUXpjXCorq1P8oURUg.[cP7si`1RUd.siP7`RfT1PedtV/[\RU]/X [uPU^"dtXpbcPUvw]/o8VY^.[cX [4d Pf^"d
'$$',56Z83 D Xw1X S, wA!' %8')>6w%,&[$4H&`A!?o&-!H, )\)> %,!&-!4.J$,'i4X DA,<;!{
H7{
C8fdL+&-!7%,?M%N:OP4QRJ,% %,;'6H 0 9*$%,H+',Hg'v &-.213&>)>6 8'5%,&~ZHC !H
&- $2)> @ 64,w <&` 5!&-!/d1L+,,7%!H)t3ABxLI',$43 !6¤)>zM%N:OO¡4R!CH&=76 H IH
@ 64, H&-1',<gAG!6'%,H<&- XH1 %,<.'&-! ),5',!yy:!', X)-4D "!C6ug'%,<3&-.'ug' )t4*2
%!',B* %!C6H%3#,2 !66 I@ %,H&-W :,_!&-!e.bJ=!<&-!/dX'H%$67")>&-!'v2EDG&(
%!',v&51,<$'!/&`8')>WHA, HI ")~%,! &-!4.&-.'!A
∂
∂
n&-!&(&= )>)[3#$'f&(&tg'W )-4D¦g )(jJ2%!',M&-!)t6A&-!."<XNRB| :!6+7gA!5 )-)[3#!%.' &tg'4d!%,7 &-!.HCH<&>&=!'%3#)> %,!&-!.«5,2
H:,A!C{kH{
48D &=)>)8'!<&(S)`CDG{k%!',6KDG,<;'%,*DD &>)[))> %,!v :,BE84S&~|D &-)-),i6
D Y,% &-!/\H8'|)> %,!'6Z5, 4H%,&[!SH*=5',4d
Y&[!' )>)[3CB2&( %!8Ah4D!hHC }n
(
)
= = ≥ ≥
∂ ≥
∂
!"$# % !" !"&
'
λ λ
<!:, &-!.HCJ<<&>&=!C732*%m$':,_&>!7y&-!'&(<&> )=)-3I&=!:, 4*HCKw")-{<)=7 %,!&[!.984
H&=\DG&=)-)2$,wCgAA;'* |h)(&-$2)-&>%,cY&-!1'8/w@j!j$'%,&-'62\83,w "&5&-!.H*&,_ ;2!CCDG)-64.4d
()(+*
,-/.0-1-324,15687/297/:;5.=<
(
6?>A@B56 (DC0(
6E-F.
(
7/2
- *
.HGJIKMLONPL
0jwu&-!FH&kS$' %$':,S u)> %,<.'1j,!%,wfiZw&-!uD &(v %C6v$')-A3A%,{< $')-A3'
6 BJH§N:OO4z5?U4o ',Hg'%3!z)> 78AA,fH+ %!C6 DG %.'HH,5C,4d?EC )- 5%,:! %&-!/
&-!2H, &-! %8'4XN e¡ ¡¡¡^DA,;'%,c :,</*N:¢ ¡¡e¡ 8')[&5'"!d
&5*',gA73y2)> %8',X/5X&= %,<,&-76JCl!',<,!)`3?&-!? )=)/c',$' %!ZTG!&-2!?4'!H,<&`A
gA%,<3JH4',o3' :,B/ !C6J "&-Jo1$,4g'&-6h72$' %, %8')>h)> %8', %,;'H }H&5H&> %,/cT©4'!H,<&-4}d
Y,^HCN:OO4vDG g'F'|H&k',<g'%3CB5?UCc©1 %'6Hx6 yD&(HHCfwFA!HH5,5,?A
DG %.'xM< JH'8
7J >%,?A Hv5D H',g'%3yDG x48g'&-Cj)-3 &-1&>)> %,<Rd*W$'$4/)- <&-!
MkD&>",/)`c4Y %.,<&-/)(5',wB2H&kC%,&>B!!{kH,w 661%,Hg'&=7CwB27%!H, )' %!C6Z)-' ).'4g%,<!!HRd
Y,HCZ,:.,&`A! !C ")-3/&5B\DG1!/H,6F !8%,*2gA %,&= %8')>}djowy&-!')t6GH'
H :)h!/8%,?Z3A %,?'176 &-A!CBqk %)*$'4%!&= )%m$'%,&>!W&-!HC)> %8',J %,;'0M< %.'
!8%,Ac3' %,iAl6 H&-!v&tm'RBj4',<)t3x %,!&=!e./M.,/*w ")> %,<30$2)tjX$' %3'"!|&-!J;'&-!'6B\ )=)
6&`g'&>66183 H!8%,X$' &=6J4',CgA%,EHCh37 %,RBj %!6ZHC g':, %.'!8%,X$' "&`6yCC',A
H, %&-!&-!4.$'%,\DGA,<;':,o&-!H*4 8')=&5"!MkHDG&[.'76Z %gA%, %.'*2/HCh!8%,c2\CC',icAY$' &=6
H, %&-!&-!4.183 DGA,;'%,E83Z2'$' <&`A!C ")f %.'4,3ZM<%m'%H&tg'SA,c!!{m'<&tg':R6&tg/&>66Z83HCq )
!8%,cfDG,<;'%,\83G''$' H&-! )' %.'4,H34R}d
p vH,FH6 H&-A!g' :,_&> %8')>By&-!' %g' &=)> %8')>&=!H, &-!D 4FH&-.2Cx$' %$'%,
%,HH&[H&> )>6 83HD ,<;'%,wBDGC 66, &-!'HH7A,H&- )1!/8%,'y3A %,2
6 H&-A!I$/:,hD ,<;'%,}d6eH&5BoD x )=/)> 6HCF 6&= !+!8%, ^3A :, 2S76 &-2!
MkD&>"&5S)>!'&(<&tgZ44H)-&-%,<RSH,S %@ )-&=&=7 <&`A!7A!'&=6:,6B\j&[!.I uH28A{_ $2)>J2
,GHC %!s?¡¡¡yDGA,<;':,|5,wAªHyw 1J',<g'%3x,D HCZ!/8%,qA3'7 %,q2X6 <&-!
DG X %g' &>)= %8')>4d'o&5X&-!'6A&-,7GH'6yH,X )-/)> &-!.1H)>"!e.4HJ76 &-A!JC 4oH 6CgA ! %.'
b$' :,H&- )=)-3, g'&[!.HC*%!6.'%!&(H3/H*6 %H&-!hgA %,&= %8')>4d
c 8')>vNJZ %,&-4|HCJ %,!43JS !6 J6H&[!'&(&-2!HJ &-!g' :,_&> %8')>|jw6&-!uH'
$'&[,&> )' !' )[3/&5wB2 !6$,4g'&-6E6%,&-$4&`gAh H&>&=d
*
5 I NJI LON
¬qHA,wJ&-1 <&-!4.FHCJ %,!&-!./=!'H&-!vM RBDG1!'6uW<$'%&-3ICCD
%!C6
λ
%,,)- 76#kC8%,gA %8')=4}d|$'&=<&> &-!14H 8')=&5! A8'{_$'&=<&>W)> %,!&-!.$':!H&> )
,H!hHC*%$'&[,&> )'6'"H&-!2&~<&-'!2c/HDGA,<;':,k 48 )> 66%,c %!C6Z/HDGA,;'%,5 /@ %)-&=<&>6
:%,dj<!uHC1$,4!$' %$':,BDGJ 6$q Z8'&-!' %,<396A&tg'&5&-2!'
A8jS&-!]%mAH&`g:a? "!C6]!C2!
mAH&`g:a
A8 d)> 5%,&5;2!CCD! DG&(<CCe:,<,<,HA,I )-)ZDGA,;'%,B %!6©6%, &[!'W !
mAA.'%!CCj$' :,H&(&-A!
8 )> 66%,iv&-!j,!$')= !d G4D gA%,Bg'%!DG&(< «$' %,HH&(<&`A! 2
DGA,<;':,8'5DG%!
48jBAHCqDG4,<;'%,}kl fH@ %)-&=<&>6 %C%,7 "!!CCj8Ah&-6!&-&>6 l G&-!.')=S'{
!#"
`1X [yoUVYb4bcP-[nVY^1Z[ d V dL`1P%$2bcPf^1o` [4d RfdCg"dtV8b ] Z"X [4d Xx^1ofd XCVY^ V8j#&zo-R8ZYbcP-[(' RU^6Z)&^1VY^QoUR8ZYbcP-[('*vLVYV6[\PUvx]QoURzn6dCg6bcPUZ q"] d `1P
+
^1_6vpXt[4` siVYbcZ[,&UP.-6P8ofg6d XwT1P-[(' R-^1Z/&U^1V8^ P-"PUofg"dtXwT1P-[0'6{21YgoU`QZYXL[d Xx^1ofd XCV-^ nvpR]1[yR n1bcPUoUX [cP bcVYvCP Xp^ dC`P ozRUvCofgvCRfd XCVY^ VYj
6&[H%,! ;2&-)=)55,2¦6&=H%,!'{kD,<;'%,SDCC g'F ,v<;'&-)=)>{_$/&-<&>/ !W7 %$2&~ ")HC !
H1i)tg}do<!+,6%,hk«6 %)D &~H;2&-)=)*C%,.'%!C"&~3CBDG6&-!'uD ,<;'%,k ]:,%$,! H&tg
:%,<aG X H&=<&(&-4joDGA,;'%,:!64D 6ZDG&(H\3 %,Ac67 <&`A!CB \3' :,Ac%mC$'%,&=!C&=!
H:,&-,JBj !6 $'%,&-'62X2\%!',&-!1H&-!'/ 8'!lH&t,¤ !C6
8B\H" H }n
≥
B≥
B≥
¡/d!vDG6H&-!'xHCF1 !+ %$'&( )2^8ACHvHCuDA,<;':, M
R %!C6':,1 /G@ %)-&-<&>6
:%,M
RD C!vHKDG,<;'%,%!:,6W$2)> !+M!'7BD &(H+%,w%!',w%R83W<C %,!&[!.j
$,6&-7683 S@ 764, &-*M<&[!Gm$%,&-!'* %!C6:!',%Rc7 %,<!&-!4.jc=/!C<&`A!fn
M<P4R
!
"
#
!
$
!
%
&
& '
(
(
)
*,+- ./ ./ ./ ./ ./ ./ ./ ./ 0 ./
1
0
1
2
1
2
1
3
1
1
0
2
3
4
+ + + + + =
BD &(H
65
B
798 :
;
>
<
!C6
=
B >
?
<
@
B' %!C6
M_sR
A
B
A
C
D
D E
F
G
G
H
I,JLK MN M M MN M M O M
P
O
P
Q
P
P
R
O
Q
S
+ + + = ≡
T
U,VWYXZ
≡
®l [
\
\
] ^_^^
^_ `
a
b
c
≡
%!C6 deef ghghghgh ijkl≡
6%!CC1HF/ !W :$2&( )Xg,AmS !6:,,:$,! H&tg' %,#&[! 8')=&5"!+ !6
48on/dJ :,# %, 7%,&=&-4# %,
'!48/i:,g' %8')>v&-!C',06 } qpB8eD I64«48/w%,gAKH'w 1Fg' %,&> %8')>C0!« , %!6' $')=IA
$')-A3'7CX5,w2 H1
A8x !6J4 8')=&5"!idjU2&-!&-!'6&`g&>6 )k7 "!?!)[3?)> :,_!JH,¤ ,
@ )-&=H&=6hDGA,<;':,&-!hHhw 1
48 :.'A,3CB' ^ &-!'&= )/ H/ $4H&-! HA,,w4g'%,&-!4.H'!e;2!CCD!
%C %, :,_&>&-4+AFDGA,;'%,rm<5v :%,+!{=H{
48z&>vª H/ HC H%3ª)-&>8A5DG!H
H 8')-&k'!S %m'&[ "!C6&-!'6&tg'&=6f )g' )tCGA*H?)- 5%, AGKH&tm6v,)> &`gAu$'/&(<&`A!CB
H:! %$$,4m'&= ZHCZ5,1 %m'&>G§83FHCu $2)>5h %m'&=Jdb®l5H&-!e. st
t
s
t u
v
=
wyx{z∈ 8ZH%m'&=/}|~q ~|gA ")t*HA,\HC*% :, %,&kHH&>|&-!hH*4 8')[&5'"!ikl $2)>B4D D,<&(Cn
M<O4R
(
)
β β − + =
D&(H ¡≤ β
≤
N?'"HH&=&>!
β
&-!'6A&> ^HCy,w")` <&tgAu6&5 !1D &%Wi%$' %, ^HCu g'%, :.'0DGA,;'%, 5,2©%,GfHc@ )-&=H&=6 %C%,d4j %;' |g' )(fSA:,1&-bH:,h&5!CJA$$CA,55'!&(53HA,l)=7 %,<!&-!2./1:;<.=>$ *?<& @'$BA4'C &(DE2F# ?G',HIJKMLONQPR SLTPVU8/11K<WR7Q @H*:X
&('KC<$*$'&V Y$BZ['',.\/;<WX] C<&'$^R_?a`ab
Lc.dP
( ) ( ) ( )
( )
g f e eh e
e
h
e
i
jj k
lm<n
o
p
o
p
q
q
o
r qo
r
q
o
r
q
o
s
q
qo
qo
t
u
t
u
v
v
w
u v
w
u
v
w
u
x
y
u
z
{
β β
β
β β
β λ
+ +
− +
− +
− +
−
=
≅
|
C<}GKLNQP"FLc.dP"$*FLO~QP*U^/11F?*'V:J:%($#%3&[]RQ *H?<&(}@'$<
_:?8` <<9]<RK*8B['*JGK['!$#%H*<U$\/(,3"/4'1*9b
LccWP
( ) ( ) ( )
( ) ( ( )( ) )
+
+
+ +
+
− +
+ +
− +
− +
− +
+ −
+ +
+ +
=
¡ ¢£ ¢£
¤
¥
¤
¥
¦
¦
§
¥ ¦
§
¥
¦
§
¥
¨
©
¥
£«ª
¦
¥
¦
¥
¨
¥
¥
¬ ®
δ
β β
β
β β
β
¯ ¯¯
¯
¯
°
±²³
´
´
µ
¶
· ´
´
·
´
¸ ´
·
´
¸
¹
/»º J¼ M½,' &5#%¾<+,H*:¿:@,'$V:&4<(?<&$À3
δ
¼ M/Á:',H*7@,' ' (,'('$$B<,30H*')/15Â'Q,'Â $BÀ:9?<&($ÃD>Ä" GK6,'$*:&UR<V3&=%?<&(V,?%¿<
/1K<\'1'KÅC< &(,2Æ<Ç\OS'@:-Å+$#<$X"<VK<-'#Q[X:@'& K
C<'À?27@$ *W?<&9 @'$[Æ1/1;<ÃA}X_V?Â,+H*K 2%DaÈX$#a#<$J@H*Q4VÅ&J;<'&J27*
,'C#<VÅJ@3&XKaD«È><ÆÉ&<' #%,#<Æ=-+!$#%H0:6C<.O@5"(3Q(,$WF
M #%,#<&"C<'H*.M:Æ&Q*JK«b Ê
Ë
Ì
Ì
Ì
Í
Î
β β
ÏÏÏÏÏÏ ÐÑÒ D ÓÔÕQ *J@H*½LccWPÆ#aK:É&9<'.\&(' "V!$#%$"L(Ö1×Ø<Ù4PWDZØ<,'ÅÆ?<<7ÚCQ )$W #%@$4HRÆK<5#%Æ =<
&('KC<*$03&RÆ@'&9&R'/16,''?<6 #<B¿H(CCÚ<@H0:»\%'&(U>/@7'&}V
$J@H*+4HÚ<+,H«:\#%&(4L aC:*'\PÃD
ÓÛܽ,V8BÉOV',H½H*6'»FÉ&<$.Ý1 '&U=/6,Q'$+,','#<$"\#<?a:$
<:%($#%3&:@ OÁ<W*K<'52½Þ<FÅ'Æ-Ä4?</U=ß"'Å.àQUâáã.K<:&¿3ÕÈX;<
L ä<dddPWDQE4Q$U\&(K<"$#%1?%.=X *W?<&J<@3[@#<åH*-H« #<&0å#a4C<8B?<9&(5 2¿
,'$*:&&KÕ-æ<H*K<'52F?2»$V $#%,'K½7$#@Ý2Â<(?<&97:'','»Q *H?<&(}<@'$
ç[èÅé4ê9ëWììëHíÔîëWïRïRëWðÝñ.ò9óBîôõîéRö÷@éø9ôõïRóôõ5ð.ù-ôú+é4ùWòë.ø ø=éóò(ðõÜð'ù+øâéûWü'óôõëWðÝò(óOôú'éòZôú.óOðð'éô«éóò9ð'õÜðù+øýþú'é4ìóôôé*ò
éûHü+óOô0õëðóîîëü+ðô(ø>ê(ëWòXôú'é ê(óBîVôaôú.óOôaí^ëWò9ÿ'éòøÇö'éóòXôú'éîë.ø9ôXëWêÇôú'éõÜòZù.éð'éòóìôò(óõÜðõÜð'ù'ýè@éóBìø}ëéø9ôõïRóôé\ôú'éð+éVô
éóò(ðõÜð'ù+ø éûHü.óôõëWð0òéBø9ü'ìÜô(øð'ëôø9ú'ëíXðóOð=ù.ëô'éò÷Rø}õï õìóòòéø9ü'ìÜô(ø:íXõÜôú=ó^ø}ìõ5ùWúôì÷XöQéôôéò:ê(õ5ô(ý
W*K<'52\/19,'K Q ?<($«4$@H*','< (,'(3QU/4+'&K<4$#%-?%[:«,'$* &
<.O(?<&($Û* #<ÛK$BWDÓÛS,Q,;<+ H» &H* ,'.C#S K< ''&»Õ
$*H?<&}<@'$[W*K<'52Å?2M$@H*KÅ!$#%$VH,'ÉÉ}*.$#<-+JK9#%,H*U /(,'Æ
&9<'. 75B=C<'@H*BU ?<Ý/Ü7$ *H?<&( @'$å Ú<'7' *',HâL}/5*#Ç-,'$*:&(P'Ý/5*
4,+:Q&9[&2aDGÈ>4,' -C< .K <'&W#<Ç@'$#%,'HUO1[ÚC<(','4'
*Q#<HÚ<?Ü*' &(5&(:*',+ ?:H/+3Y$B / $ÅW*$WD-E2 'JK V3C<&(A
@Ú<9-# <'&#%$R<['$#%,'H*U RÚC<9','Ý*Q#<-Å á½<,'('Æ'!$#%WÉJ<,Q
2@.\<,'&0#%+ÀÝ\É&<Q=<'&ÉU:$":( *',$Q>/1"}#< ['$#%,''@L $#&Ü=
/1PWD«ÈX',+,#<$ ÅQ,HåHR/5Q *H?<&(}@'$?V <W"VÅC<''$*U
/9,'\/19&9&<a?<Ç4Q *J@H*Q[:C<'H*B>?G#«}[&;<'&J2-*C* $#%,'\*.*:aW
4\#%,'Å@'&9&(Ç3"2Æ#%&\?%'U/1: *#aV4'CCCH*4H L}áÞ#<&ÜUXcdPWD
: #<H*&2<U É&<'YH#<V : #< <'&ÕC+,3&#%$ #« < É}'ÉO3&
*',G(!$#%ÃD 1/1H:U8/1,'7$B #%@HX9W#%Ý9J:4<,'\Å*V*:B=/#<&
+'1*Ý?:#%B *H*'-?2@\*',H*ZK >'aDÜd ~@:VZX' *Ý?:\ K<9(,''$>Ha
c &<'&Uâ/19,'½-%2#%&9;<'&J2%D +'Uâ/'»/F,'-C<)V$ #%&5@ !$#%.},+ÉVÉ
*Q#<Å'.K4}#%,WML}/5M'À/Ü#,.&5#a *KF@H PU À *.MÝH<'
<,'V'\?2@ +,H*:«K<<ÇMcQD0N<D
!"#"$ %'&)(* %,+-. / 0- 1 2 &!(3 054
# 60-7#8&90
8:<;=?>@=?ABC?=?DFEG>IH=JBK:=JL3E'MJNPO?;>RQS:TEGNP:=?LBHDU>@:TVS;UNFEGC?;=?BEGHNUL?C?DU:TEG>@H=
È[H?<&( ä CQ'$6¾Q *J@H*+ C<V31H*ÂÀÛ$.K#,H*:Y<,'C<JK
&('KÆ V'&Jå'@åL}×Ø-W På'&KÝ/15@:#<å$[<3&å ^'KWDÈX+ %<
X è@õ5ôúôú+é\éGY.îOéñ.ôõëWð@ëê=ìëWù@ú'ëü+òø[Z%ôú'é"îëWðôòëWì 'óò(õóö'ìéBøRóOò(é\õÜð WõøîòéVô0é ê(ëWòïóð õ5ð+îOìüé4ôú+é ê(ëWììëWíXõð'ù 0ôú'é
òéê(éOòéð'îéXîóOô0éOù.ëWò÷Rõøõ5ðRñ.óOòé*ðôú+éøéBø]\'øéGY íXëWïRéð [Z'ëWîîüñ+óOô0õ5ëWð 0ð+ëWð_^JéGY.éOîü.ôõ'éBø óð =òéùWõëWð óìÜì$òéùWõëWð3ø%í^õ5ôúâôú'é
éGYîéñ.ôõëWðÅëWê`óBò9õø=óð õ5ô(øRø9üWöü+òöQø [Z ôú.òéé Hü+ïRï=õéBøZêëWò=ð+óVô0õëWðóBì5õÜôÜ÷ baGòéOð+îOú@Z ê(õ'é Hü+ïRïRõéBøåê(ëWò=ïRóòõ5ôóì^øIôóOôü3ø
JïRóò9ò(õé cZ3ôúòéé Wü.ïRï=õéBø ê(ëWòÇìó*ö'ëWòÇîëWðôò9óBîVô Jëñ+éð_^Jé*ð é4îëWðWôòóBîVô@ZëBð'é Wü'ïåïZ÷4ê(ëWò ôú'éZñ.òéBø}éð'îé=ëWêôò(ó .éZü.ð.õëWð
òéñ.òéBø}éðôóOôõ'éBøÇõð4ôú'éåéø9ôó*ö'ìõøúïRéðô ð'ë [Z$ôú.òéOé Hü+ï=ïRõéBø êë.ò ôú'éZñ.òéBøéOð+îOéåëHêaõð õ'õHü+óì:ñ.òë Wü+îVô0õ'õ5ôÜ÷"é 'óìÜü'óôõëWð
ñ+òëWîOéWü'òéBøXõ5ð4ôú'éRéø9ôóö'ìõø9ú+ï é*ðô Ü÷éÃøcZê(ëü+ò Hü.ïRï=õéBøÇê(ëWòÇôú.é=ñ'òéBøéOð+îOéRëê«õð'îéðWôõ'éBø^êIëWòXîëWëñ'éòóOô0õëWð\óïRëWð'ù4îë^
í[ëWò9ÿ+éOòødZ$ôúòéé Wü'ïåï õéø êIëWò ôú'éZñ+òéBø}éð'îé=ëWê^ø9÷QøIô0éOïRóôõîfeëö-ôü.ò(ð'ë'éòÇóïRëWð'ùí^ëWò9ÿ'éòøÇëWêôú'éåéø9ôó*ö'ìõøú'ïRéðô 0ð+ë [Z
ê(õQé Hü+ïRï õéøZê(ëWòZôú+é éùWòééôë-íXú'õîOúíXóBùé4õÜð'îòéóWøéø=óòé=ö'éõð+ùÝõÜð .õ'õWü.óìÜõbgé JìÜõ5ôÜôìé[Z ê(õ'é Wü'ïRïRõéBøZê(ëWòZôú'é
õï=ñ+ëWòJôóð'îéRëHêaôéðü+òé=ê(ëWò[ø}éôôõð'ù ôú'éRõÜð Wõ'õWü'óìõhgé4íXóBùéõðîòéóWøé Jð'ëWð+é cZê(õ'é Wü'ïRïRõéBøÇêëWòÇôú'éRõï=ñ+ëò9ôóð'îéëWê
í[ëWò9ÿ+éOòGiø ñ.òë Hü+îôõ'õ5ô÷ù.óõÜðQøê(ëWò"øéôôõÜðùÆôú+é-õ5ðWõ'õWü'óìõhgéÆíXóù.éõ5ð+îOòéóÃø}é 'éò÷7ú'õùWú[Z ê(õ'é Hü+ïRïRõéBøê(ëWò ôú'é
õï=ñ+ëWòJôóð'îéXëWê í[ëWò9ÿ+éòGiø ôò(óõÜðõÜð'ùRéê9êIëWò9ô(ø ê9ëWò8ø}éôôõð'ù=ôú'éXõÜð Wõ'õHü+óìÜõbgé=íXóBùéXõð'îòéOóÃø}é ó 'éòóù.éIZ+ê(õQé Wü'ïRïRõéBø êëWò
ôú'éZõÜï=ñ'ëWò9ôóð'îéZëê%í[ëWò9ÿ'éòGiøéGYWñ'éòõéð+îOéXê(ëWò«ø}éôôõÜð'ù=ôú'éXõ5ðõ'õWü'óBì5õbgBé íXóBùé[õÜð'îòéóWøé ó 'éò9óBùécZ3ê(ëü'ò Hü+ï=ïRõéBø8ê(ëWò
ó 'éòóBùé[ðü.ï[ö'éòÇëêñ+óõú'ëü.òøÇëêêIëWòï óìôò(óõÜðõÜð'ùõ5ðôú'é=éBø9ôóö'ìõøúïRéðHô%ë'éò ôú'éZñ+óWøJô÷éóò ð'ëRú'ëü'òøÇëê%ôòóBõ5ð.õ5ð+ù [Z
ôí^éOì'é«õð WüQøJôò÷ Hü+ïRï=õéBø ôò(ó .é âø}éò'õîéBøóð åøõbYZéBø9ôóö'ìõø9úïRéðWôøõhgé Wü.ï=ïRõéBø ìéBø øôú+óOðKjFkXíXëWò9ÿ+éòøý
L,'&5#%6cWPU[!$#%'H,Æ*Q#<ÆL,'&5#%ÝäPU[!#% 0,À*Q#<ÆL,'&5#%PÃD8áÞ:.<U
C#< &0'K<É*?2É}/ÝH*,K <3&)L}×ZEÓ Pã} </ ,' &5#% aDÆÄ\&(&F F $@H*'
á½<,''Æ+!$#aH0:â-&J<QRÆ+$#%,$W:¿'Æ!#%'H,-7:â+ÚC<'<,'D<ÈX-'W_#a *'
(4'!$#%'&*dDXcæR#< 1 '&D<Ä\&(&X XÅ'M+ÚC &('W*: 2Æ:(+?<&($.ÅJK<9*9,+3QRW
@:ÝC<V,'$&:3&[6'&(&['!$#%H*:ÃDÄ\1 KÝá½,'('6+JK}#%,H* VU /@,':
ÔÞCV$'$ÀH*H@½!$#% ,Õ#%,H* <Å*$#<»2<9'&( F»?<H*75Å3Û#a #8$&
!$#%'W,-'Ý1&(<'R'!$#%WDáÞ:+:U:1#<,WÝHåJ,'C<*$R&'K7 V3&
ÅåL}×Ø-W"U @,' &5#%À~QPå,'&('&J2¿$å ?:H*X5Ç3-/Å$ *'Å1 '&9åX,' &Ü#c
L}«dP,+:&5#% ½L «dPWD«J<'&(&J2UZ<9C<&9.1%.» 4×Ø-W ,.O?:'Þ?2½L.ccWP-<$-?<Q'
$J@H*+ S,' &5#% LPWDÅÈX.CCÚ<@H* Û/- * ?<¾%'&( <,'¾< #%,H#'&
C<'W*X.C<}*'-,'&5#%[LO~QP[ÝLP[@*;<H?<&J2Æ(Å&(WD
ÈX@ }B M R&('KV ÚC<.O(',+1/1#%&6&(''À*FÀVH<.1#%V$ *ÅWM8
;/1&'K%»:#a ÛC<'@H*VU1*J<,+ K<<$7 ~<Dää ,+ &5#%Ý~»* ~DÜT ~_ 9
,'&5#%ÝaD_}«9[4$#%5: *Ý,.-C. @'!$#%':[ /;<}Ý&'.O@
α
:<7A X;</&+K<4$[[$= [,',+'Da +!$#%HL äPU/4.5%b
( )
+ +
= +
−
−
ÈXÞ*@Õ'!$#%'&('.K
α
Å O7A M; /1&'K%Ô),' -C#*'¾?<2 '!$#%HGKÀÝWR'-?%=/5α
−
.V &<JKM: D<ÈX-$#&Ü >$B,' -C#*
K<0:'Ý\*?<&(!Ý /1:3&Ü#%$
α
«dD~Gdα
^dD ~<DQÈX. ([ Q#<K<4:( *',$ ?%W/'.\/Å<'&}å'--Q *J@H* =2<('&('Ý?2 ×ØSW'Ka=#,H0:@Å.;<-\&[1VGD
"»#'$ a&%]' ( *)Q+,$-/.021a3+54Å768)G9 J½;:=<?>31A@CB*DÁE4F6HGI J+KGMº½9<L4Ã?:
MG<.8+F]NG<Â+& I<9]+KG*:-.I M%"*>NO*-P0Q1a3+R ;:S<?>31T.*@CD E4U MG<]+V J 0<*DâáÞ:V':U
H:K</;<[«#<=V'-C &('U/Å$KDä<T12:'å8*.$#<'U<['&''2Æ&(''*T /H
<Â,'' &(' <ÁÃDRÈ>}W0 <Å'&9VÉV&0'K /#<&ÕKV'H*&02½#%J@H*6
C<+'\/5\/(,'0%($#%'&}[&(Q Y$VU $«/+:>_#aZV'CW?G#*U:44$X'U 5
/1#<&-K+H&2@:$@H* C$*Q'&:X&('.9GKÅ Y$ÃD
È[H?<&(X6C<}RHÝ/;<",'.&0' c.dT <"503&å$#%Å'F,+C Ü*3&åF<.K
Y,+ É}/1;<X\1V'Å4*H?<&9@'$^R_:?:U/&(4 @H*4%'ÝV ×XE4Ó