HAL Id: inria-00072099
https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00072099
Submitted on 23 May 2006
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub-
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
A deterministic biologically plausible classifier
Thierry Viéville, Sylvie Crahay
To cite this version:
Thierry Viéville, Sylvie Crahay. A deterministic biologically plausible classifier. [Research Report]
RR-4489, INRIA. 2002. �inria-00072099�
a p p o r t
d e r e c h e r c h e
THÈME 3
INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE
A deterministic biologically plausible classifier
Thierry Viéville and Sylvie Crahay
N° 4489-version2
Version initiale Juin 2002 / Version révisée Mars 2003
$&%')(+**,.-')/10'32)23(465798,2:0'3(<;=*>4?%4+,
@ACBDFEGH IKJMLNEONPRQLNSUT1JVACTRD&DFEXWKD&PRQYACSUJCERZ
SUD&PR[1E\Z^]CT1J_JC`E\Z6QT1J_J^PRSU\a\NPbJCQE\
cdOeTbfgELihj]_k+\a\eEE
lmPRnCn?T1OeLo]_EOeEQYACEOaQYACEpJ^qr1rMs1tuWwv1EOa\aSUT1J6xH ydEOe\aSUT1JSzJCS{LNSzPR|UE}R~CSzJVxR11x&
ydEOa\aSUT1JOa`vSU\a`E=VPbOa\xR11GH b FnCPR[1E\
>uCRM loE[1PROa]CSUJC[CSUT1|UT1[1SUQ>PR|vSU\a~CPR|Q|zPR\a\eSUCQ>PbLaSzT1JZOeEQEJML\eEOeSzE\TbEXnEOgW
SzDFEJMLa\&ACPvREEJC|USz[1AMLaEJLaA^PbL=]CPbLYP<Q|zPR\e\aS{^Q>PbLaSzTRJ.Q>PbJ?EOaEPR|zSUE]SUJLNACEA~CD&PRJ
vSU\a~CPR|QT1OeLaEoS{LNA |zPbLNEJCQSUE\¡TR¢PR?T1~_L£1¤DF\ZoACSUQYAZoQT1J_\aSU]CEOeSzJC[¥LNACEvSU\a~CPR|
n^PbLNAM¦P>k\|§PuLNEJ_QSUE\Z+SU\¨TRJC|Uk©QT1DFn^PbLaSz_|zEooSULaA¡Pªv1EOekF\enEQS{^Qn_OaT+QE\e\aSUJC[©PbOaQYACS{LNEQW
LN~COeERZ^]CE\aQOeSz?E]MkLNACE¢\eTbWKQPR|z|UE]@ACT1OenE¢DFT]_E|)«
¬ ~COanCOeSz\eSzJ_[1|UkEJCT1~C[1AZ¦LNACSU\&EnEOaSUDFEJMLYPR|mEv+SU]CEJ_QESU\®SUJQT1ACEOaEJCQEoSULaA PR|¯W
[1T1OaS{LNA_D&\&]CEOaS{v1E] °OeT1D±LNA_EV\eLNPbLNSU\eLaSzQPR|m|zEPROaJCSUJC[¤LNACET1OekRZ°T1|z|UToSzJ_[²LNACET1Oa³´TR
y¨PRnCJCSU³6«ªT1OeEnCOeEQSz\eE|{k1ZLNA_EOaESz\iP¡]CT1~C_|zE|zSUJC³6µoT1JT1JCEA^PRJC]ZLNA_Ey¨PRnCJ_Sz³LNACEXW
T1OekVTR¶EOa\jLaTT1|U\iLaTEvbPR|z~CPbLNEFPRJ_]¥PbJ^PR|{kE©LNACEF@ACTROan?E=D&T+]CE|·nEOe°T1OeD&PRJCQE\PRJC]
T1J©LNACE¦TRLNACEO·A^PRJ_]ZRLNA_Sz\DFT+]CE|Sz\dPRJSzJMLNEOaE\eLNSUJC[¢°OaT1JMLgWKEJ_]©°T1O·PR|U[1T1OeSULaACDF\·]CEOaS{v1E]
°OaT1D¸LNACEªy¨PRnCJ_Sz³¡LaACETROek1«
@A_E<nCOaE\aEJMLQTRJLaOaSUC~_LaSzT1J¹]_Ev1E|zTRnC\LaACSU\Sz]_E>P´PRJC]¹EX_n?EOeSzDFEJLa\SULa\nEOe°T1OºW
D®PbJCQE\~C\eSzJ_[¡P©LNSUJMk\aSU[1J|§PRJ_[1~^PR[1EªOeEQT1[1JCS{LNSUT1JEnEOaSUDFEJML>«
»¼M½¾e¿©À uÁR Â E~COeT1J^PR|jQ|§Pb\a\aS{^EOZ ¬ ~_nEOev+Sz\eE]Ã|zEPROaJCSUJC[CZmy¨PRnCJCSU³.]_SzDFEJ_\aSUT1JZ
ĦSzTR|zT1[RSzQPR|DFT]_E|
ÅÅÆÈÇÇÉÊdË:ÌuÍÏÎwÍÑÐÒÓÔeÕwÖ3ÍØ×Ìm×Ù^ÚÛÜÌÜÔdÝXÞÞÝßÅàÔgÓ>ÍáÖ)ÔaâmÓÔgÕãÖ)ÍÑ×ÌjäªÐXÕãåãæjÝÞÞç
!
J QE~CSQT1J_QEOeJCE|zPVQ|zPR\a\eSUCQ>PbLaSzT1J v+SU\a~CE|z|UECSUT1|zTR[1S~CEbZ·]CE\=EW
n`OaSUEJCQE\iOe`QEJMLNE\iT1JMLmnEOaDFSU\]CE¢DFELeLNOeEEJ|U~CDFSzBOaE|zE¢)PRS{L~CE|UEQT1OgLNEvSU\a~_E|
A+~_D®PbSzJnTR~_vbPRSULm]CSU\aQOaSUDFSzJCEO]_E\mT1fgELa\o]CE\eT1JEJMv+SzOeT1JCJCED&EJMLjEJ¤£1=DF\Z6QØE\eL
]CSzOeEP>vRPbJLFDD&E]CE|UE\FP>vRT1SzOFOe`E|U|UEDFEJML®PRJ^PR|{k+\a`\Z¦QE~CSJÏE\gL®QT1DFn^PbLaSzC|UE
+~ÑP>v1EQ~CJ_EPbOaQYACS{LNEQLN~_OaE¢LNOaB\o\an?`QS{~CEbZ]C`QOeSULaE]^PbJC\o|zE¢DFT]_B|UE]_E@A_T1Oan?ER«
ELaLaEj`v+SU]CEJCQEªEn?`OaSUDFEJMLYPb|zEjE\eLLaT1~_L
)PRS{LQT1AC`OaEJMLaEªP>v1EQi|zE\PR|U[1T1OeSULaACDFE\
]C`OeSUvR`\¨]CE|§PjLaAC`T1OeSzE\gLYPbLaSz\gLNS~CE]_E|ØPRnCnCOeEJMLNSU\a\aPR[1EmSz\e\a~CEm]CE\·LNONP>vbPR~=]CEy¨PRnCJCSU³6«
cd|U~C\¢nCOe`QSU\a`DFEJMLSU|k P~_J¤]_T1~CC|UEF|zSUEJµª]Ø~CJ_E=n^PROeL¢|zPLNAC`T1OaSUE=]CE©y¨PRn_JCSz³VTR¶OeE
~CJT1~_LaSz|?nTR~CO¦`vRPb|z~CEOELPRJ^PR|{k+\aEO|UEjDFT+]CB|UEj]CEj@A_T1Oan?ERZC]ÑPR~LNOaEin^PROeL¦QEjDFT+]CB|UE
E\eL~CJ¤nCOa`XWãLaONPRS{LNED&EJMLSUJMLN`OeE\e\NPRJML=n?T1~CO¢]CE\PR|U[1T1OeSULaACDFE\Sz\e\a~C\]CEF|§PLNAC`T1OaSUEF]CE
y¨PRnCJCSU³6«
P´nCOa`\aEJLaE QTRJLaOaSUC~_LaSzT1J ]C`vRE|UT1nCn?E²QELaLaE²SU]C`E¤EL|§P´LNE\eLNE
LaONP>v1EOa\~CJCE
En`OaSUDFEJMLYPbLaSzTRJV]CE¢OaEQT1J_J^PRSU\a\NPbJCQEEJ|§PRJ_[1~CE¢]CE\o\eSz[1J_E\«
À Ü ¾ ¡ |zPR\a\eSUCQ>PbLaE~COmJCE~_OaT1J^Pb|3Z nCnCOeEJMLNSU\a\aPR[1E¢\a~Cn?EOgv+Sz\e`RZ"!iSUD&EJC\aSUT1J]CE
y¨PRnCJCSU³6Z?T]_B|UE\mCSzTR|zT1[RS~CE\
. /
F&!¨10Ã¥¦X#V¦¢ 32b
ĦSzTR|zT1[RSzQPR|jv+Sz\e~^PR|Q|zPR\a\eSU^QPbLNSUT1J9SU\PE|U|{Wã³+J_TÜoJ PbJC]ÃvREOek QT1DFD&TRJZªC~_L\eLaSz|U|
SzJMLNOeSz[R~CSzJ_[)PRQL>« i\Sz|U|z~_\eLNOaPbLNE] SUJ54Sz[C«ª£RZªPRJ76ºT1fgEQL98¤Sz\OaEQT1[RJCSzE]9SUJ v1EOgk
E+LNOeEDFEj\aS{LN~CPbLNSUT1JC\µ·ACEOeERZEv1EJSULNACEOaEiSU\¦J_TEnC|USUQS{Lv+Sz\e~^PR|?Q~CE\;:)E]C[1ERZ+LNEXLa~COaEbZ
ELNQb«z«=<«>4^T1O=\a~_fgEQLN\¡J_TRL&P>PROeETbLaACSz\&nCSUQLa~COaEbZLNA_EOeEQT1[1JCS{LNSUT1J.~_\a~^PR|U|{kLYPR³bE\
PRTR~_LP¤\aEQT1JC]« \gLNEn.°~COeLaACEOZSULPRnCn?E>PROe\®LaA^PbL&LNACSU\¡Q|§PR\e\aS{^Q>PuLNSUT1J¹Sz\®D&PR]CE
6º?E°T1OeE8¡PRJMk²v+SU\a~^PR|¦TRLeLNT1D©Wã~Cn´PRJ^PR|{k+\aSU\µA_EOaEbZ¦E\eEED"LNTOeEQTR[1JCSUELNACE¡]CT1[
SULa\aE|{
@?AB
?ESUJC[=PRC|UELaTn?EOeQES{v1Eª\eT1DFEjTRLaACEi]_T1[\eSz|UACT1~CELaLaE\E]_[1EiT1O¨LNEXLa~COaEb«
IKJTRLNA_EOT1Oe]C\ZC]CPbLYPQ|§Pb\a\aS{^QPbLNSUT1J\aEEDF\LNT ( v+Sz\e~^PR|PbJ^PR|{k\eSz\ZCQTRJLaONPROgkFLNT
E>PROe|zSUEOiv+SUEo\¢TRv+SU\a~^PR|]^PbLYP®nCOaT+QE\a\aSUJC[DCrMFEPbJC] P¡?TRLaLaT1D©WK~Cnn_OaT+QE\e\aSUJC[CZoS{LNA
E+LNOaPRQLaSzT1J<Tbd\aT1DFEG6K\ek+D?T1|USzQ8©SUJ_°T1OeD®PuLNSUT1JSU\jJCTRLi|zSU³RE|UkLNT?ELaACE°OaTRJLgWKEJC]TR
\a~CQYA]^PbLYP=Q|§PR\e\aS{^Q>PuLNSUT1JVDFEQYACPRJCSU\aD«
T1OaE[1EJCEONPR|U|{k1ZLaACEjPbCSz|US{LKk&LaT©[1OeT1~Cn¡\gLNSUD~C|USSUJMLNT©\e~CQYAQ>PuLNE[RT1OaSUE\Sz\¦P°~CJC]CPuW
D&EJMLYPR|E|U|{WãE\gLYPRC|USU\aACE]QT1OgLNSUQ>PR|àQT1[1JCS{LNS{v1EnCOeTQE\a\H:)Eb«Ø[ICØxbr EJ<«
4Sz[R~COaE£1µ@ACE&OaEQT1[1JCS{LNSUT1J¥TR¦LaACE®]_T1[SUJ¥LaACSU\nCSUQLa~COaEK:)SUD&PR[1E&]CEv+SU\aE] Mk¤l«
«
}1PRDFE\+<T+QQ~_Oa\L6º?E°T1OeE8S{LN\¨\aSU|UACT1~CELaLNEmT1Od\aACPRnEmSU\¨n?EOeQESUvRE]«¨@ACSU\nCSUQLa~COaEmSU\¨E|U|
³+J_TÜoJEQ>PR~_\aEQT1DFnC~_LaEOov+Sz\eSzT1J\aQSzEJLaSz\gLN\QT1J_°E\a\eE]JCTbL?ESUJC[®PRC|UEªLNT®PRJ^PR|{k+E
SULGCrMFE3«
IKJ&T1Oe]CEO·LaTP>vRT1Sz]&PRJMkFPbDCSU[1~CS{LKk1Z+|zELd~C\d\eLNPbLNELaA^PbL>ZMSUJFLNACEnCOeE\eEJMLT1Oe³?Z]^PuLYP
Q|zPR\a\eSU^QPbLNSUT1J \eSzDFnC|{k¥D&EPRJC\©?ESUJC[VPRC|UE®LNTnC~_LP ')M'NO&( TRJ P[RSUvREJ ]^PuLYP
SzJCn_~_LP:)Eb«Ø[C«Q6KT1AZLNA_EOaESU\FP<]CT1[F8R<« @ACSU\F]CS{¶EOa\=°OaT1D
RS&TU )
:)ER«Ï[C«VC{£EJ<
oACEOeE®JCTbL¢T1JC|{k¤P &( C~_LPDFT1OaEFQTRD&n_|zEX 6º\aED&PRJMLNSUQ®\gLNOa~_QLN~_OaE8=Sz\E+LNOaPRQLaE]
°OaT1D P¡[RSUvREJ<]^PbLNP®SUJCnC~_L«i@ACE)PRQLLNACSU\i|zPR?E|Sz\
')M'
Sz\iSz|U|z~_\eLNOaPbLNE]<SzJ 4Sz[_«x+Z
oACEOeE¢PRJPRD_Sz[1~_T1~C\nCSUQLa~COaEªSU\nCOeE\eEJMLNE]Z^oSULaALK¦TFn?T1\a\eSzC|UEªQ|zPR\e\aS{^Q>PbLaSzTRJC\« L
PF[RSUvREJLaSzDFEbZ^T1JC|{kT1JCEPR|{LNEOaJ^PbLaSUvRE¢Sz\on?EOaQES{v1E]«
4Sz[R~COaExµ JE_PRDFnC|UE©TR 6KD~C|{LNS¯WK\gLYPR_Sz|USULKk(8nCSUQLN~_OaERµLaACEkRT1~CJC[®¦T1DFEJØ\ªQYA_SzJSU\
LNACEªT1|U]¦T1D&PRJØ\oJCT1\eER« ! #"$&%(')!*,+.-0/1-&2346587958:;"=<?>@BACEDF%G&'
H H
I$&%JLKM9KMN8APOQa«@ACEFv1EOek<E|U|d³+J_TÜoJ¤)PRQLZACEOeERZSU\ªLNA^PuL>ZPbLP[1SUvREJ¤LNSUD&EbZ
LaACE®kRT1~CJC[SR LaACE¡T1|U]²T1D&PRJ SU\n?EOeQES{v1E]ZdC~_LJCES{LNACEO?TRLNA²TRLNA_EDZ
JCT1OoPRJMkSUJMLNEOeDFE]CSzPbLNE\aA^PbnEb«
loEQEJML·\eEOeSzE\TR_EnEOaSUDFEJMLN\A^P>v1E¦EJC|USz[1AMLaEJLaACSz\CSUT1|UT1[1SUQ>PR|MDFEQYACPRJCSU\aDµ]^PuLYP
Q|zPR\a\eSU^QPbLNSUT1JFQ>PbJ©E¦OaE>Pb|zSUE]=SzJ©LaACE¦A~CD&PRJ©v+SU\a~^PR|_QT1OgLNEoS{LNA=|zPbLNEJCQSUE\·Tb?PRTR~_L
£1DF\$CÑ£ E?oA_SzQYAZ_QT1JC\eSz]_EOaSUJC[©LaACEv+SU\a~^PR|n^PbLaA¦P>k+\|§PbLaEJCQSzE\ CrxE3ZD&P>k&T1JC|{k¡?E
QT1DFn^PbLaSz_|zEoS{LNAP<vREOgk\an?EQSU^QnCOeTQE\a\eSzJ_[²PROeQYACS{LNEQLN~COeEVPbJC]DFEQYA^PRJCSU\aDZLaACE
\aTbWãQ>PR|U|zE]T # « v1EJ 6ºA_Sz[1A´|UEvRE|"8v+SU\a~^Pb|m]CPbLYP Q|zPR\a\eSUCQ>PbLaSzT1J\a~CQYA PR\
)PRQEOaEQT1[1JCS{LNSUT1J C{£VUUE·PR\nTRSzJMLNE]<T1~_LOaEQEJMLa|UkVkQCØRFEQ>PRJVEOaE>Pb|zSUE] PbLi\e~CQYA P
v1EOgk)PR\eLoOaPbLNEb«
@A_Sz\SU\PRJ.EnEOaSUDFEJMLYPR|iEv+Sz]_EJCQE LaA^PbL¡]^PbLYP¤Q|zPR\a\eSUCQ>PbLaSzT1J (P vSU\a~CPR|
TRLeLNT1D©Wã~Cn¤PRJ^PR|{k+\aSU\PbJC]¥J_TRLªLNACEFTRLaACEOj¦P>k OaT1~_JC]Zà°T1OjLNA_E=\aSUD&n_|zE&OaEPR\aT1J LNACPbL
LNACEOaE¢Sz\oEJCT1~C[1ALNSUDFE¢T1JC|{kLNTF]CT&SULoSUJLNACEª°T1OeD&EOP>k1«
@A_Sz\FD&P>kEv+SUEE].PR\FPLNOa~_Sz\eDZ¨C~_LFoACEJQT1JC\eSz]CEOaSUJC[¤D®PbJk ]^PbLYP<Q|§PR\ºW
\aS{^Q>PbLaSzTRJ²CSUT1|UT1[1SUQ>PR|DFT+]CE|U\ :°\aEE®Eb«Ø[C«PCÏG1GFE°T1O¢POaEvSUE <¢T1O¢\eLNPbLNSU\eLaSzQPR|¨PROeLaSU^QS§Pb|
PR|z[RT1OaS{LNACDF\:)\eEE CÏG1 FE°T1OoPbJTv1EOev+SUE <mS{LmPRnCn?E>PbOa\LNA^PuLoSULmSU\mJ_TRLLNACE¢QPR\aEb«
¬ ~COanCOeSz\eSzJ_[1|UkEJCT1~C[1AZ¦LNACSU\&EnEOaSUDFEJMLYPR|mEv+SU]CEJ_QESU\®SUJQT1ACEOaEJCQEoSULaA PR|¯W
[1T1OaS{LNA_D&\&]CEOaS{v1E] °OeT1D±LNA_EV\eLNPbLNSU\eLaSzQPR|m|zEPROaJCSUJC[¤LNACET1OekRZ°T1|z|UToSzJ_[²LNACET1Oa³´TR
y¨PRnCJCSU³6µ·LNACEªPbOaQYACS{LNEQLN~_OaEªTRàLaACEj]CEOaS{v1E]PR|U[1T1OeSULaACDF\A^P>v1EjLaACEj\NPbD&EjPROaQYACS{LNEQLa~COaE
PR\moACPbLiACPR\?EEJVnCOeT1n?T1\aE]MkDCÑ1x Ew«oT1OaEnCOaEQSU\aE|UkRZLNACEOaESz\P®]_T1~CC|UE|USUJC³6µT1J
T1JCE©A^PbJC]ZLaACEy¨PRn_JCSz³LNA_ET1OgkVTR¶EOe\iLNT+T1|U\LaTEvbPR|U~^PbLaE=PRJC] PRJCPR|Uk+ELNACE@ACT1Oan?E
D&T+]CE|6PRJC]¡TRJ&LaACEoTRLNACEOdA^PRJC]ZLNA_Em@A_T1Oan?EDFT+]CE|6SU\¨PRJ®SUJMLNEOaE\gLNSUJC[°OeT1JMLeWKEJC]F°T1O
PR|z[RT1OaS{LNACDF\o]CEOaS{v1E]°OaT1D¸LNACEªy¨PRn_JCSz³®LNACET1OekR«
@A_E[1T1PR|TRLNACSU\¦TROa³SU\LNTF]CEvRE|UT1nVLaACSz\o]CTR~CC|UE|USUJC³6«
IKJ P £>\gL\aEQLaSzT1J E<OaEv+SUE¡LNACE<@ACTROan?E<D&T+]CE|jPRJC] ]CE\aQOaSUE S{LN\QTRD&n_~W
LYPbLaSzT1JCPR|onCOaT1n?EOgLNSUE\«9IKJ.LNA_EJCE+L\eEQLNSUT1J ¦EVOaEv+SU\aS{LLNA_EV¦E|z|³JCToJ¹JCE>PROeE\gLeW
JCESU[1ATRO&Q|§Pb\a\aS{^EOa\&EQ>PR~C\eELaACSU\&D&P>k´?ETRJCETRmLNACE\aSUDFnC|UE\eL®P>kLaT¤EXnC|§PbSzJ
LNACEQT1JCQEn_La\jTR·LaACEy¨PbnCJCSU³LaACET1Ogk¦E©ACPvRELNT®QT1J_\aSU]CEOeE] ACEOeER« inCn_|Uk+SUJC[LNACSU\
nCSzEQETRLNA_ET1Ogk1Z¦Ejn_OaT1n?T1\aEmSUJ®LNA_ELNA_SzOe]\aEQLNSUT1JPJCTRLaSzT1J®TR 6KT1n_LNSUDFSzE]®JCE>PROeE\gLeW
JCESU[1ATROjQ|zPR\a\eSUCEO98©oACSzQYAµ :)S<\eLNPbLNSU\eLaSzQPR|·]CSUDFEJC\eSzTRJ¤SU\ªDFSzJ_SzD&PR|PbJC]oACSUQYA7:°SzS<
\aEEDF\iLNT&E¢LNA_E?E\gLjQTRD&n_~_LYPbLaSzTRJ^PR|OaEnCOaE\aEJMLNPbLNSUT1J<TRLNACE@ACT1OenED&T+]CE|3«
W
nEOaSUD&EJMLYPbLaSzT1JTRLNACSU\mD&EQYA^PRJCSU\aD SU\oOaEnT1OgLNE]SUJLaACE¢|§Pb\eLm\aEQLNSUT1J«
!ª <o2F < &o
i\¢nTRSzJMLNE]¥TR~_L¢SzJ LNA_E&SUJMLNOeT]C~_QLNSUT1JZ]^PuLYPQ|zPR\a\eSUCQ>PbLaSzT1J¥Q>PRJ¤?E=OaE>Pb|zSUE]²SUJ LaACE
A+~_D®PbJvSU\a~CPR|QT1OeLaEoSULaA<|§PbLaEJCQSzE\jTR¨PR?T1~_L£1&D&\*CÑ£EPR\]CELNPRSU|zE]<SzJ 4Sz[C«G
«jIKJC]CEE]ZàJCTbLªPR|U|v+SU\a~^PR|SzJ°T1OaD&PbLaSzT1JVQ>PRJ<?E=PRJ^Pb|Uk+E]<T1JLNA_E©^PR\eSz\jTbLNACSU\i^Oe\eL
P>v1E=TbdSzJ_°TROaD&PbLNSUT1J<nCOeTQE\e\aSUJC[Q:)ER«Ï[C«i)PbQSzPR|EX_n_OaE\e\aSUT1J¤T1OiSU]CEJMLaSULKkRZàT1OiQT1DFnC|zEX
\eLNSUD~_|z~C\=OeEQT1[1JCS{LNSUT1JPR\nCOaTRnT1\eE] SUJ 4SU[C«d£T1OxVPROeE¡T1JC|{k¥P>vRPbSz|zPRC|UE|zPbLNEO+<_~_L
T1fgEQL-6º|zPRE|zSU>PuLNSUT1JS8ªSU\mPR|UOaE>Pb]_kn?EOe°TROaDFE]oACEJ\a~CQYAVP=QT1[1J_SULaSzT1JT+QQ~_Oa\«
T1OaEnCOaEQSU\aE|{k1Z^\e~CQYA|zPbLNEJCQSUE\ CrxEPROeET1J_|Uk®QT1DFn^PuLNSUC|zEmoSULaAP\enEQS{^Qj°EE]W
°T1Oe¦PROa]9PRJC]9\gLNONPbSz[1AMLgWã°T1OgPROe]9JCE~COaT1JCPR|PbOaQYACS{LNEQLN~_OaE CØ1x E3ZPb\V\aQYA_ED&PbLNSUE] SUJ
4Sz[_«CrCZ_oS{LNALK¦T®n^PbLaA¦P>k+\µ$:°)PR\gL<
( I&+,-
PRJC]
S! «
àEL~C\OaEv+SUE PRJC] PRJ^PR|{k+E ( V&+,- ) PRJC]¹LNACEJÃ]_Sz\eQ~C\e\ S!
«
ÍÑÌuåºÔ·ÎwæÜÍÑÖ"!uÐ!RÔgÕ !ÜÕwÔeÖ3ÔgÌÎãÖ$#ÐXÎ3ÔeÕ3ÍáÐXÒRÙ{Õw×%#'&R×XÎwæªåº×%#(!ÜÛÜÎ3ÔgÕÖwåºÍÑÔgÌbåºÔÐXÌuâÒÑÍÏÙ{Ô
ÖwåºÍÑÔgÌbåºÔ%)+*Ô·æuÐNÓÔÍØÌÎwÕ3×âÛuågÔeâÖ)ÔeÓÔgÕãÐXÒbÙ{×>×XÎwÌÜ×XÎwÔeÖÕwÔgÓ>ÍØÔ*àÍØÌ-,.&uÐÖ)ÍáåÙUÐåKÎãÖÙ{×Õ &R×XÎ3æjÖ3Í0/eÔeÖ)1!uÕ3×YÓ>ÍáâÍØÌ-,
ÎwæÜÔÕwÔeÐâÜÔgÕ$*àÍÏÎwæªÐ¦Ö3ÔgÒØÙ¯Æ:åº×ÌÎwÔgÌÎwÖàâ×ågÛ2#ÔgÌÎ3
4Sz[R~COaE¦G_µcOeSzD&PbLaEvSU\a~CPR|_]^PuLYPjQ|zPR\e\aS{^Q>PbLaSzTRJZ1°OaT1DCØ1x EoSULaA=nEOaDFSz\e\aSUT1Jµ
! " #$%&'(#) *,+-#.
/ *
0)1 ' 234
&56&'7-8 2$9 -:;=<;>.?7@<.A;?7(CB-#. 2$
DB3E2FG,HI?J(
KML E
@:NM ,O#&B-O,:#@MB-
1
P 2$74&'QRQNJ 2$7(#
,ES 2$72$QN
N# T
@;&5U@
/
KPV
"S7&5WS:X 2$M45 QR ,4*;:NYB*R 2$M4;F
#O@3F#
O-#.MES
2$3 2$O(#RZ&[]\)^_WB&S-434
2 a`bH
0
2$= *R " #$
@
KYc
4X 2$4
0
4
:
F&'F#F-,
46`d<TQNe`gfES7 2$, F5: " :#Fh. 2
1
*YB&S-:,4
2 R '#F94, T'2FG$5MQN6F@-&
"S-58@i$4
@3Z&
Vj QN=k
Vj
_
0)1 2.
2
F@'lQ#:Fm 2$45$QN7&$
n
*!
@'RoB5p
&
K
j
2$3'"S-57.4
@:!4Ep
&7@WR 55*W4S!::
0
'
#FN'W 2$C4&S4F
@:TZ&
c9q
_
0G1 2
2
F@ Fr 2$9 " #$ *84&.F ]Q-#.4F 2$
@;OioB5p
&sZ4H_
KCj 4
2('2Fs(#
r '2F)2$QN
0
oQ
Q4oBoB*MQ:N3@C.( "&, 2$i47@
RZ&t
q
_MQN='7*M@
@:RZ@t
q
_3B&S-:(4
2.'M 2$
7@mQ#:FCES8 2$C&'Q
:N
K]c
=
2=:
-'!@
0 1
F#.B(Z J= ''-
QN&_348 Qu
j
2$
nrd ]M5 8ES9 2$i
*=ES] 2$8:&-dQ#4Q4&.F-]@Cv942$N=&'(##
0w1
2F-4i 2$-
QN
Q4 5No=74(&*
d 4=@
*
K@x
y{z|}oz(~}Del i(;R]}=l }oW} ezeW};
@ACE=~CJC]CEOa|{k+SzJC[PROeQYACS{LNEQLN~COeE=TRdLNACE ( &+,- nCPbLNAM¦PkTRLNACE@ACT1Oan?E
D&T+]CE|àD®P>k?E¢]CEQT1DFnTR\aE]SzJLKT®C|UT+QY³+\µ
£1«°OaT1D LNACE \gLNSUD~C|U~C\SzJCn_~_L¥P v1EOek ACSU[1A ]CSUD&EJC\aSUT1J^Pb|PbOaONP>k¹Tb;6KSzJMLNEOaJ^Pb|
vbPR|z~_E\98jvRPb|z~CE\PXM"%SU\oQT1DFnC~LNE](
x«°OaT1D P\a~CC\eELTR¨LNACSU\ªv1EQLNT1OTR¨vbPR|z~_E\aLaACE=]^PbLNPQ|zPR\a\eSU^QPbLNSUT1JZS3«ÏER«©LaACE
]CELaEQLNSUT1JTb·PH6º|zPR?E|"8W-,Z^SU\mn?EOg°T1OaDFE]SUJ 6KT1JCEª\gLNEn8Y«
LGN S
V4 V1
V2 IT
Hippocampus
Entorhinal cortex Perirhinal cortex
X r
Parahippocampal
&
Data classification
100 msec
Category learning
from stimulus to interval values from internal values to data classification
4Sz[R~COaEFrCµ iJ¥PRC\gLNONPbQL\aSUD&n_|zS{^E]¥vSUE TR¦LaACE®@A_T1Oan?E®DFT+]CE|dPbJC]²S{LN\¢OaE|§PuLNSUT1JC\
oSULaAACSUnCn?TQPRDFn^PR|PROeE>PR\Z^\aEE¢LaE+Lo°T1O]CELYPRSU|z\«
À àF À ¼ _ ¼
@ACEVQT1DFnC|zEXQE|U|U~C|§PbO®QYA^PbONPRQLNEOeSz\gLNSUQ\TbjLNACEn^PROeSzELYPR|mPRJ_]v1EJMLNONPb|]_SUv+SU\aSUT1J TR
LNACEvSU\a~CPR|\gk+\eLNED D&PR³bES{LjE\enEQSzPR|U|Uk\a~CS{LYPbC|zELNT¡n_OaTv+Sz]CEvRPbOaSUT1~C\iQT1D_SzJ^PuLNSUT1JC\
TRLNACE®]^PbLNPVSzJ_nC~_L>« ¬ ~CQYA´QT1DCSUJ^PbLNSUT1JC\\aACT1~_|z]ACE|zn °TRO]^PbLNPVQ|zPR\e\aS{^Q>PbLaSzTRJZ¨PR\
]CSz\eQ~C\e\aE]SzJLNA_E\eE ~CE|3«
+ - "!#$&%('
ÕwÍØ×ÕÎ3×Î3æÜÔÍÑÌÙ{ÔgÕwÍØ×ÕÎwÔ#(!R×ÕãÐXÒ^åº×Õ)ÎwÍÑåeÐXÒCÐXÕwÔeÐ2)1ÍáÖÎ3æÜÔ
Ö3×åeÐXÒÑÒØÔaâ !uÐÕ3ÍÑÔºÎãÐXÒ{ßNÓÔgÌÎ3ÕãÐXÒ !bÐYÎ3æ+*Ð*)+UÖ3×%#ÔºÎwÍ0#ÔeÖÍ# !uÕ3× !bÔeÕ3Ò,)¢ågÐÒØÒÑÔeâ.- !uÐÕ3Ó×>ågÔgÒÑÒØÛuÒÑÐÕ0/!uÐYÎwæ+*Ð*)1)
ÌuÔgÛÜÕw×ÌuÖÍÑÌ¢Î3æuÔÍÑÌÎ3ÔgÕ3Æ&ÜÒØ× &uÖ×Ù#23 !ÜÕw×4°ÔaåKÎÎw×mÎwæÜÔ !uÐXÒÑÔÖ)Î3ÕwÍ0!RÔeÖ×Ù52Ý376æuÍÑÖ !uÐXÒÑÔÖ°ÎwÕ3Í!bÔaÖ×Ù#2Ý
!uÕ3×&4°ÔeåKÎÎw×ÎwæÜÔÍÑÌÙ{ÔgÕwÍØ×ÕÎ3Ô# !R×ÕãÐXÒåg×Õ3Î3Ô983#:ÎwæÜÔgÕÙ{ÔeÔeâ>ƧÙ{×Õ*ÐÕwâ !uÐYÎwæ1*Ð*)ÖÍØÌuågÒØÛbâÔ·Î3æÜÔ;2ÇÓ>ÍÑÖ3ÛuÐXÒ
ÐÕ3ÔaÐ2)?Ö3ÔgÔ=<>*?Ù{×Õ ,ÔgÌÜÔeÕwÐÒÕ3ÔeÓÍÑÔ*3@6æÜÍáÖ(!uÐYÎwæ+*Ð*)=ÍáÖåº× # !R×Ö3Ôeâ&×XÙÙ{ÔeÐYÎwÛÜÕwÔjâÜÔºÎ3ÔaåKÎw×ÕãÖ+UÖ3Í0#(!ÜÒÑÔ%)
åg×%#(!ÜÒÑÔA8ªÐXÌuâjæB)+!RÔgÕ3ÆÈåg×%#(!ÜÒÑÔA8iågÔgÒÑÒÑÖC1;+UÔ%3,-3;<ç"DE?_Ù{×ÕÐX̪ÍÑÌÎwÕ3×âÛbåKÎ3ÍÑ×Ì13 WÔeÛÜÕw×ÌuÖàÍÑ̪ÎwæÜÍÑÖ !uÐXÎ3æ+*Ð*)
Ö3æÜ×*¤ÐiÒÑ×*¤Ö3ÔgÌuÖ3ÍÏÎwÍØÓ>ÍØÎ0)ªÎ3תåg×ÌÎ3ÕãÐÖ)Î)MæÜÍ,æ©Ö!uÐYÎwÍÑÐÒ_ÕwÔeÖ3×ÒÑÛÎwÍØ×Ì )ÐXÌuâÒÑ×*<Î3Ô# !R×ÕãÐXÒ^ÕwÔeÖ3×ÒÑÛÎwÍØ×Ì×Õ
Ö3ÛuÖ)ÎwÐÍØÌÜÔaâmÕwÔeÖ !R×ÌuÖ3ÔeÖÎ3×Ó>ÍáÖ)ÛbÐXÒÖ)Î3Í#¨ÛÜÒÑÍ3
ÔgÔÙ{×ÕàÍÑÌuÖ)ÎwÐXÌbåºÔ(<ÝXÞ*?)GFæuÐ!¢Ý¨Ù{×ÕÐâÍáÖwåºÛuÖwÖ)ÍÑ×Ì 3
IKJ¥LNACE®Q>PR\eE¡TR)Pb\eL]^PbLYPQ|zPR\a\eSUCQ>PbLaSzT1JZ·LNACE&D&PR[1JCT+QE|z|U~C|zPRO=n^PuLNAMP>k¤TRLaACE
n^PROaSUELNPR|§uv1EJLaONPR|¨]CS{v+Sz\eSzT1J²TRLNA_E&v+SU\a~^PR|\ek+\eLaED Sz\SUJvRT1|{v1E]ZdPR\©PR\e\aEOeLNE] Mk>CU£ E
oACEOeE¡S{LSU\]CEDFT1JC\eLaONPbLaE]²LaA^PbLONPRn_Sz]¥Q>PbLaE[1T1OeSzPbLNSUT1J¥TRJ^PbLa~CONPb|¨\eQEJCE\©SU\QT1|UT1O
C|zSUJC]«
mEOeE¤E¥QT1JC\eSz]CEOLaACE ]CELaEQLaSzTRJ TR\eLYPuLNSUQ¤v+SU\a~^PR|¢SUJ_°T1OeD®PuLNSUT1JZioACSU|UE¥]^PuLYP
Q|zPR\a\eSU^QPbLNSUT1J¹TR¢]kJCPRDFSzQv+SU\a~^PR|EvREJMLN\SUJMv1T1|{v1E\TbLNACEO¡QTROeLNSUQ>Pb|LNOaPRQY³\oACEOaE
D&TbLNSUT1J]CELaEQLaSzTRJVT+QQ~_Oa\«
À ¼ 7 C ¼ = À Á_>²°^>B1_ À 7
\gLNEn°~COeLaACEOZJCE~COaT1J_\®°T1~CJ_]SUJLaACESUJ_°EOaSUT1O&LaEDFn?T1ONPR|:°IK@ <FQT1OeLaEOaE\an?T1JC]
LNTv1EOek²QT1DFnC|UE´\gLNSUD~C|U~C\=°E>PuLN~COeE\I:)Eb«Ø[ CÏsEJ<ZdOaE[MPROe]C|zE\a\=TRm\eSzETRO©nTR\aS{LNSUT1JT1J
LNACEOeELNSUJ^P_«Q4^T1OSUJC\gLYPRJCQERZ¨\aT1DFEJCE~COaTRJC\FSzJ LaACSz\=OeE[1SUT1J´OaE\an?T1JC]´\aE|zEQLaSUvRE|{kLNT
)PRQE\iTRnCPROeLaSzQ~C|§PbOiTv1EONPR|U|°EPbLN~COeEQYA^PbONPRQLNEOeSz\gLNSUQ\« !jPRD&PR[1ESzJLNACSU\jPROeE>P¡SUJC]C~_QE
]CSz\eT1Oa]_EOa\Tb6T1fgEQLdOaEQT1[1J_SULaSzT1J«·@ACEOeEoPROaE¦D®PbJkJCE~_OaTbWãnCAMk\eSzTR|zT1[RSzQPR|CEv+SU]CEJ_QE\
(%" 9 C.9%
6æÜÔeÕ3ÔÐÕ3ÔÎ*×dågÒÑÐÖ3Ö3ÔeÖ^×Ù+åºÔeÒØÒáÖ^Ù{Õw×%#¥Î3æÜÔÕ3ÔgÎ3ÍÑÌuÐdÐXÌbâ
PW#Ð%,ÌÜ×åºÔeÒØÒÑÛÜÒáÐXÕ )YÐXÌuâ !uÐÕ3Ó×>ågÔgÒÑÒØÛuÒÑÐÕ3 6æuÔeÖ3ÔÎ *×·åºÔgÒÑÒÎ0)+!RÔeÖ^ÐXÕwÔàåº×ÌÎãÐXÍÑÌÜÔeâ¨ÍØÌâÍ1ÔgÕwÔgÌÎ !uÐXÕ3ÎwÖ
×ÙàÎ3æÜÔPW.)_ÐÌuâ©Î3æuÔ9)©æuÐNÓÔâÍ 1ÔgÕwÔgÌΦÕ3ÔaÖ !R×ÌuÖ3Ô !ÜÕw×%!RÔgÕ3Î3ÍÑÔeÖ +{Í1 #Ð,ÌÜ×åºÔeÒØÒÑÛÜÒáÐXÕ¨ågÔgÒÑÒÕwÔeågÔ!ÎwÍØÓÔ
!
ÔgÒáâÜÖÐÕ3Ô¦ÝNÆ:çÎ3Í#ÔeÖÒÑÐÕ ,ÔgÕàÎwæuÐXÌ !bÐXÕwÓ×åºÔeÒØÒÑÛÜÒáÐXÕåºÔeÒØÒ_ÕwÔeåºÔ!Î3ÍÑÓÔ ) !
ÔgÒáâÜÖ!bÐXÕwÓ×åºÔeÒØÒÑÛÜÒáÐXÕæuÐNÓÔ &RÔºÎ)ÎwÔgÕ
ÐåºÛÜÍØÎ0)%)uÕ3ÔaÖ)×ÒØÛÎwÍØ×Ì #Ð%,ÌÜ×åºÔeÒØÒÑÛÜÒáÐXÕàæuÐNÓÔ &bÔgÎ)Î3ÔeÕÖ3ÔgÌuÖ3ÍØÎ3ÍÑÓÍØÎ0)%)-#Ð%,ÌÜ×ågÔgÒÑÒØÛÜÒáÐXÕågÔgÒÑÒÑÖÕ3ÔaÖ !R×Ìuâ *ÔgÒÑÒMÎ3×
#×YÓ>ÍÑÌ2,mÖ)Î3Í#¨ÛÜÒÑÍ)*àæÜÔeÕ3ÔaÐÖ!uÐXÕwÓ×åºÔeÒØÒÑÛÜÒáÐXÕågÔgÒÑÒÑÖâ×mÌu×XÎ !bÐXÕwÓ×åºÔeÒØÒÑÛÜÒáÐXÕågÔgÒÑÒÑÖÕ3ÔaÖ!R×Ìbâ *ÔeÒØÒ+Î3×iåº×ÒÑ×Õ
Ö)Î3Í#¨ÛuÒØÍ )2*àæÜÔeÕ3ÔaÐÖ #Ð,Ìu×>ågÔgÒÑÒØÛuÒÑÐÕågÔgÒÑÒÑÖàâÜצÌu×XÎ3
6æuÔ #Ð,ÌÜ×åºÔgÒÑÒÑÛÜÒÑÐÕ.!uÐXÎ3æ+*Ð*) +{×ÒÑâÜÔgÕÎ3æuÐÌFÎ3æuÔ !uÐÕ3Ó×>ågÔgÒÑÒØÛuÒÑÐÕdÍØÌ !ÜæB)>ÒØ× ,ÔgÌuÔºÎ3ÍáågÖC1åg×ÌÎ3ÍÑÌ>ÛÜÔeÖ¨Î3æÜÔ
!uÕ3×åºÔaÖ3Ö3ÍÑÌ2,o×XÙ6Ó>ÍáÖ)ÛbÐXÒCâÔºÎãÐXÍÑÒÒÑÔeÐâÍØÌ-,oÎ3×mÎ3æÜÔ !RÔgÕãåºÔ!ÜÎ3ÍÑ×Ì¢×Ù?Ö)æuÐ%!bÔÍØÌÐXÕwÔeÐ(2çmÐÌuâ #×YÓÔ#¦ÔeÌÎÍÑÌ
ÐÕ3ÔaÐÖ#2 DdÐÌuâmä
6 3ËÈÎæuÐÖ?ÒÑÔeÖwÖÖ)>ÌuÐ!ÜÎ3ÍáåÕwÔgÒáÐ*)ÖCÎ3æuÐÌoÎwæÜÔ !bÐXÕwÓ×åºÔeÒØÒÑÛÜÒáÐXÕ !uÐXÎ3æ+*Ð*)%)1&ÜÛÎÍÑÖÙUÐÖ)Î3ÔeÕ3
" ;$# 9G"!#$&%&%
ÔeÕ3ÔзÖ)Ôaåº×Ìbâ¨Ó>ÍáÖ)ÛuÐÒåº×Õ3Î3ÍáågÐÒ+!uÐYÎwæ1*Ð*)%)!bÐXÕwÍØÔgÎwÐXÒÐ̦â×Õ)Æ
ÖwÐXÒ )ÍÑÌ *àæÜÍÑåãæÎ3æuÔdÌÜÔgÛuÕ3×ÌuÖÍØÌjÒáÐ*)ÔeÕÇ('×Ù 2 3 !uÕ3×&4°ÔeåKÎàÎwצÎ3æÜÔÎwæÜÍáå)Ö)Î3ÕwÍ0!RÔeÖ×Ù 2·Ý¦ÍÑÖåg×ÌuÖ3ÍáâÔgÕwÔeâ 3
XÕ3ÔaÐ 2ÝÎwæÜÔgÌ !ÜÕw×4°ÔaåKÎãÖ_Î3×;2ç-)&2D(+{×Õ?ä6 )%#ÍáâÜâÒÑԺƧÎ3Ô#(!R×ÕãÐXÒuåg×Õ3Î3Ô981)ÐÌuâä
6 +#ÔeâÍáÐXÌoÖ3Û2!RÔºÆ
ÕwÍÑ×ÕàÎwÔ#(!b×ÕwÐÒåg×Õ3Î3ÔA8136æÜÍÑÖ !uÐXÎ3æ+*Ð*)ÍÑÖ#ÐXÍÑÌÜÒ)ªÐ̪ÔA8>Î3ÔeÌuÖ)ÍÑ×̪×Ù^Î3æÜÔ #Ð,Ìu×>ågÔgÒÑÒØÛuÒÑÐÕ !uÐYÎwæ1*Ð*)%)
&uÛÎÌÜ×XÎ×ÌÜÒ,)%3
* ,+-"% Í#(!ÜÒÑÍÏÙ)>ÍÑÌ2,=Î3æuÔÖ3ÍÏÎwÛuÐYÎwÍØ×Ì.ågÔgÒÑÒÑÖmÍØÌ 2D=ÐXÕwÔ !uÐÕ)ÎwÍÑågÛÜÒÑÐÕ3Ò,)®Ö3ÔgÌbÖ)ÍØÎ3ÍÑÓÔjÎw×&Ö#ÐÒØÒ
#×YÓ>ÍÑÌ2,× & 4°ÔeåºÎwÖ×Õ¦ÎwæÜÔ#¦×YÓ>ÍÑÌ2,Ôeâ,Ô×ÙÒáÐXÕ,Ôm× & 4°ÔeåºÎwÖ/àåºÔgÒÑÒáÖÍÑÌâ×ÕãÖ3ÐÒä
6´ÕwÔeÖ !R×ÌuâFÎ3×Î3æÜÔ
#×YÓÔ#ÔgÌÎ×XÙ·ÒÑÐÕ ,ÔiÖwåºÔeÌÜÔeÖÖ3ÛuåãæÐÖÍáÖågÐXÛbÖ)Ôaâ *àÍØÎ3ææÜÔaÐâ #¦×YÓÔ#ÔgÌÎãÖ/ågÔgÒÑÒÑÖÍÑÌÓÔgÌÎwÕwÐÒàä 6
ÕwÔeÖ !R×ÌuâjÎw×oÎwæÜÔ #×YÓÔ#ÔgÌÎ×ÙÖ#ÐÒØÒ_×%& 4°ÔaåKÎãÖÐ%,ÐXÍÑÌuÖ)ÎÎ3æuÔgÍÑÕ &bÐå)+,Õw×ÛÜÌbâ 3
ÔeÔ¨Ù{×ÕÍÑÌuÖ)ÎwÐXÌbåºÔ.<ÝXÞ?)
FæbÐ! 3eÞÙ{×ÕÐâÍáÖ3ågÛuÖwÖ)ÍÑ×Ì 3
0
F× # #×̪ÔA8ÜÐ#(!ÜÒÑÔeÖà×Ù?Ö)Ûbåãæ¢âÍÑÖ3×ÕãâÔeÕwÖÍÑÌuåºÒÑÛuâÔÓ>ÍÑÖ3ÛuÐXÒÐ,Ìu×Ö3ÍÑÐ-)Ü×ÕÎ3æÜÔdÍÑÌuÐ%&ÜÍØÒÑÍØÎ0)mÎw×oÍÑâÜÔgÌÎ3ÍØÙ)
× & 4°ÔeåºÎwÖÍÑÌÎwæÜÔ¢Ó>ÍÑÖ3ÛuÐÒ*×ÕwÒÑâ )àÐÌuâ !ÜÕw×Ö3×%!uÐ%,ÌÜ×Ö)ÍáÐ2)?Ð&Ö)Û2&ÜÎ0)1!RÔ¢×Ù·Ó>ÍáÖ)ÛbÐXÒÐ%,ÌÜ×Ö)ÍáÐÎ3æuÐXÎÐ11ÔeåºÎwÖ
Ö !RÔeåºÍ! åeÐXÒÑÒ)ÎwæÜÔÕwÔeåº× ,ÌÜÍØÎ3ÍÑ×Ì×XÙ_×ÌuågÔÙUÐ%#ÍØÒÑÍÑÐÕÙUÐågÔeÖ3
:)ER«Ï[C« CÑxRZ1r EJ<·PR?T1~_L·LaACE)PRQL·LNA^PuL·LNACEv+SU\a~^Pb|CLNEDFn?T1ONPb|CPROeE>PR\°~_JCQLaSzT1JFSU\OaE|§PbLaE]
LNTF]^PbLNPFQ|§Pb\a\aS{^QPbLNSUT1J«
)>>B
¼ 6Ü Á
¾
² ¼
À
F
¼
À
LiP=QT1DFnC~_LYPuLNSUT1J^PR|à|UEvRE|)Z6LaACE¢JCE~_OaT1J^Pb|àT1~_LNn_~_LN\oTRLNACE¢@ PbJC] ¬ @ ¬ LaONPRJC\g°T1OaD
°E>PbLa~COaEØ\D&PRn_\TRT1fgEQLN\SUJMLNTFT1fgEQLC|zE\G:)ER«Ï[C« CØxbr EJ<« S{LNALaACSz\¦³+SUJC]TR?EA^P>vMW
SzT1OZ·\a~_QYAJCE~COeT1JC\=PbOaE\eT1DFELNSUDFE\=QPR|z|UE]Q6K^PRJ^PbJ^P8&T1O 6º[1OaPRJC]WãD&P8&JCE~_OaT1JC\ CÑxRE
EQ>PR~C\eELaACEk\aE|UEQLNS{v1E|UkOaE\an?T1JC]]C~COaSUJC[&T1fgEQLmOaEQT1[1J_SULaSzT1J«
@A_Sz\ªD~C\eLª?E~_JC]CEOe\eLaTT+] :)\eEE©Eb«Ø[C«*CÏr E A^Pbn s®°T1OjP®]CSz\eQ~C\e\aSUT1J¥PRTR~_LLaACE
IK@ JCE~COaT1JCPR|àEA^P>v+SzT1OB<¦oSULaALaACEª°T1|z|UToSzJ_[®nCOeT1n?EOeLaSzE\µ
LNACEOaEjSU\JCTbLP~CJ_S~CE 6K[1ONPRJ_]WKD&P8oJ_E~COeT1J°T1OP[1SUvREJ 6º[RONPRJC]+WKD&P8YµSUJC]CEE]Z
\aEv1EOaPR|oJCE~_OaT1JC\®QT+]CE]CS{¶EOaEJML®QT1J^[1~COaPbLNSUT1JC\&TRªP [1S{v1EJ.T1fgEQLZ°T1OFSUJW
\eLNPRJCQE]CEnEJC]CSUJC[¡T1JS{LN\ovSU\a~CPR|PR\an?EQL:°ER«Ï[C«S{LN\G ! T1OaSUEJMLNPbLNSUT1JN<X«IKJTRLNACEO
¦TROa]C\ZC¦ED~C\gLiACPvRE¢\aEvREOaPR| #%B!+#+ °T1OoP=[1SUvREJT1fgEQL%
¦EªD~C\eLoACPvREªJCTRLTRJC|Uk6º[RONPRJC]+WKD&P8JCE~_OaT1JC\_~_LoPR|U\aT6KJCTbWK[RONPRJC]+WKD&P8mJCE~W
OaT1J_\µSUJC]CEE]Z^LNACEª]_ELNEQLaSzT1JTRLNACE¢T+QQ~COaOeEJCQETb·PRJT1+fgEQLmD~C\eLm?E|UE>PbOaJ
JCTRLT1JC|{k®oS{LNAEX_PRDFnC|zE\¦oACEOaEjLNA_EiT1fgEQLSU\¦n_OaE\eEJML>Z^_~_LPR|U\aToSULaAE_PRD©W
nC|UE\ªoACEOeE=LNACE=T1+fgEQLSU\PRC\aEJML>ZSzJ T1Oe]CEOjLaT U % ELK¦EEJ¤LNACE\aE
LK¦Tª\eSULa~^PbLaSzT1J_\« \PiQT1JC\aE~CEJCQEmLaACE 6KJCTbWãT1fgEQL8Q>Pb\aED~C\eL?EPR|U\aTiQT+]CE]
PRJC]LNA_ETRfgEQLiOeEQTR[1JCS{LNSUT1JSz\mPFOaE|zPbLaSUvREQT1DFn^PROaSU\aTRJTR?TRLNAQ>Pb\aE\g
6º[1OaPRJC]WãD&P8&JCE~_OaT1JC\©PR|z\eTn^PROgLNSzPR|U|Uk¥OaE\an?T1JC] LNTVT1fgEQL=oSULaA´PROaE®JCTRLT1JC|{k
6º[1OaPRJC]WãD&P8Yµ\aSUJCQEªEªD®P>k¡A^P>v1E¢QT+]CE]EXCPbD&n_|zE\ooA_EOaEªLaACEªT1fgEQLoT+QQ~_Oa\
oSULaA TRLNACEOªT1fgEQLN\ZS3«ÏER«¦EFD&P>k<A^P>v1EFQT+]CE] 6K[1ONPbJC]WKD&P¡oS{LNA¤P^PRJCPRJ^P8NZ
6º[1OaPRJC]WãD&P¡oSULaAfgT1ACJ+WK\aDFS{LNAS8=ELNQb«z«&SUJ¥T1Oe]CEOªLaT?E&PRC|UE&LaT]CELaEQL 6º[RONPRJC]+W
D&P8©SUJ \aEv1EOaPR|d\aS{LN~^PuLNSUT1JC\ZàS{L¢SU\ªQ|UE>PROªLNACPbLjLNA_E\aEFJCE~COaTRJC\PR|z\eTOaE\enTRJC]<LNT
TRLNA_EOT1fgEQLa\«
%
6æÜÔ¨ÍÑÌÙ{ÔeÕ3ÍÑ×ÕÎ3Ô#(!R×ÕãÐXÒCåº×Õ)ÎwÔA8jÍÑÖÎ3æÜ×Û2,æ¢Î3×åg×ÌuÖ3ÍáÖ°Î×Ù^Î3æÜÕwÔgÔ !uÐXÕ3ÎwÖ6æÜÔ 6 :
+{Î3æÜÔ×åeåºÍ!ÜÍÏÎãÐXÒâÍÑÓ>ÍÑÖ3ÍÑ×Ìj×XÙÎ3æÜÔÍÑÌÎ3ÕãÐYƧÎ3Ô#(!R×ÕãÐXÒMåº×Õ)ÎwÔA81)>ÎwæÜÔ76 +¯ÎwæÜÔ#ÔeâÍáÐX̪âÍÑÓ>ÍÑÖ3ÍØ×ÌG1)ÜÐÌuâÎ3æÜÔ
6
+zÖ)Û2!RÔgÕwÍÑ×ÕÎ3Ô#(!b×ÕwÐÒÖ)ÛÜÒáåºÛbÖ 136æÜÔ6 : ÍáÖÛuÖ)ÔaâFÙ{×Õ #Ð)>ÍØÌ-,©âÜÍÑÖwåºÕwÍ0#ÍÑÌuÐYÎwÍØ×ÌuÖ &bÔgÎ *ÔeÔgÌÝNÆ
!uÐXÎ)ÎwÔgÕwÌuÖ*àæuÍÑåãæâÜÍ 1ÔgÕ·ÍÑ̪Ù{×Õ#)1åg×ÒÑ×Õ )RÖ3Í/gÔ%)1×Õ3ÍÑÔgÌÎwÐXÎ3ÍÑ×Ì )R×Õ &ÜÕwÍ0,æÎwÌÜÔeÖwÖ3 6æÜÔ 6ÍáÖÛbÖ)ÔaâjÙ{×Õ
ÕwÔeåg×%,ÌÜÍÏÎwÍØ×Ì×XÙbçXÆ¡× & 4°ÔeåºÎwÖ3'×XÎwædÎ3æuÔ 6ÐXÌbâ 6
ÐXÕwÔ6Î3æu×Û2,æÎ_Î3× &RÔÛuÖ3Ôeâ¨ÍØÌÙUÐågÍÑÐÒÕwÔeåg×%,ÌÜÍÏÎwÍØ×Ì
ÐÌuâjÍÑ̪Î3æÜÔ¨Õ3Ôaåº×%,ÌÜÍØÎ3ÍÑ×Ìj×XÙCÙUÐ#ÍÑÒØÍáÐXÕ×%& 4°ÔaåKÎãÖ36æÜÔ 6
#Ð*) &RÔdÎwæÜÔ.!ÜÒáÐågÔdÍÑÌ *àæÜÍÑåãæ¢Î3æÜÔÙ{ÔaÐYÎwÛÜÕ3Ô
#Ð%!uÖ^×XÙ1×%&4°ÔeåKÎãÖ+*àæuÍÑåãæoåg×ÌÎwÐÍØÌÖ3Ô!uÐÕwÐXÎ3ÔÍØÌÜÙ{×Õ#ÐXÎ3ÍÑ×ÌÐ&R×ÛÎÔeÐåãæ !ÜÕwÍ0#ÍØÎ3ÍÑÓÔ×Ù1ÐÌ×%& 4°ÔaåKÎ)Ö)Ûbåãæ
ÐÖàåº×ÒØ×Õ)>×ÕwÍÑÔgÌÎwÐXÎ3ÍÑ×Ì )>×ÕÙ{×Õ # 1 &RÔeåº× #Ô×%& 4°ÔaåKÎ
!
ÒÑÔeÖ3
S{LNA LaACE\eEQTRJC\aSU]CEOaPbLNSUT1JC\Z·LNACE¡\aE|UEQLNSUT1JDFEQYA^PbJCSz\eD±TRLaACE]^PuLYPVQPbLNE[1T1Oek
D®P>k¤?E®v+SzE¦E]´PR\©P
$#% B+
+
µS3«ÏER«°T1OP]^PuLYP_Z
R #%B R !PRP #%+)!#+ SU\\eE|UEQLNE]Z·LNACE&]^PbLNPQ>PuLNE[RT1Oek ?ESUJC[LaACE
nCOaT>SzD&PR|àn_OaTRLaTRLKk+nEØ\mQ>PbLaE[1TROek1«
IKJ©LaACEQT1DFnC~_LNEOSzDFnC|UEDFEJLNPbLNSUT1JFTR^LaACE@ACT1OenE¦D&T+]CE| :)QPR|U|zE]
#%(
ZREb«Ø[_«
CU£>rE<=\a~_QYA 6ºJCEPROaE\eLgWKJCESz[1A?T1O98D&EQYA^PRJCSU\aD ?EA^P>v+SUT1O®SU\&SzDFnC|UEDFEJMLaE]ZmPR|{LNACTR~C[1A
LNACE&~CJC]CEOa|{k+SzJC[ 6º]CSU\eLNPRJCQE8FSU\P[1EJCEONPR|d\eEDFS{Wã]CSU\eLYPbJCQE®EQ>PR~C\eE¡S{LSz\^PR\eE] T1J¥P
^JCS{LNEnCOaEQSU\aSUT1J ~^PbJLaSUCQ>PbLaSzT1J.PRJC]´\anCPROa\eEOeEnCOeE\aEJMLYPbLaSzT1JZPR\=]CSU\aQ~C\a\eE]¹SUJ´LaACE
JCE+Lm\aEQLNSUT1J«
S{LNA¥\aT1DFE®nT1\gLeWãnCOaT+QE\a\aSUJC[Q>PbLaE[1TROaSU>PbLaSzT1J CU£>tFEdD&Pk¤?EF]CEOeSUvRE] °OaTRD LNACSU\
JCE>PROeE\gLeWKJ_ESU[1AT1OoDFEQYACPRJCSU\aD«
eW };e eJ (;R]}=J 8}oWUiz7] }oz7
lmE[MPROa]_SzJC[®)PR\eLi]^PbLYP®Q|zPR\a\eSU^QPbLNSUT1JZLaACE©@ACTROan?E©DFT]CE|-CØRFESz\i^PR\aE]<T1JLNA_E°T1|¯W
|zToSUJC[n_OaT1n?EOgLKkI:3PR\d]CEDFT1JC\eLaONPbLaE]Z°T1OSUJC\eLNPRJCQEMkFD&PR\a³SUJC[EXnEOaSUD&EJMLN\ CØG1tE<Xµ
1 C9 2 9 C
,ÍØÓÔgÌ¡×%& 4°ÔaåKÎåºÒáÐÖwÖ)Í
!
ågÐXÎ3ÍÑ×Ì )?Î3æÜÔ
!
ÌuÐXÒ
C1 E
×ÙCÐåg×%#(!ÜÒÑÔA8× & 4°ÔeåºÎ #Ð*) &bÔÕwÔgÒáÐYÎwÔeâmÎ3×oÐåg×%#.&uÍØÌuÐXÎ3ÍÑ×Ì×XÙ 9
3?Ë:Ìj×ÕãâÔgÕ
ÍÑÌÙ{×Õ #ÐXÒÑÒ,)Î3×âÍáÖ3ågÛuÖwÖÎ3æÜÍáÖÐÖ !RÔeåKÎ )ÒØÔgÎÛuÖåg×ÌuÖ3ÍÑâÜÔgÕ5-:ÙUÐÌuåA)"/·ÔA8ÜÐ#(!ÜÒÑÔeÖ
+UÍ1 -)ågÔgÌÎwÐÛÜÕãÖ/#Ð*) &RÔâÔgÎ3ÔaåKÎ3Ôaâ¢ÐÖÖ)× #ÔºÎ3æuÍØÌ2, *àæÜÍÑåãæ !ÜÕ3×*8Í#ÍÏÎwÍØÔaÖ"*3Õ3Î3 -)æÜ×ÕwÖ3Ô / #
-)æÛ-#ÐÌB/
!uÕ3×Î3×XÎ0)+!RÔeÖÐXÕwÔ·ÔÛÜÍÑÓYÐXÒÑÔgÌÎ/>ÎwæÜÍÑÖÍÑÖÕw×Û2,æÜÒ,)oÔÛÜÍÑÓYÐXÒÑÔgÌÎÎ3×ÐâÜâjЦÌÜÔ* !ÜÕw×XÎw×XÎ0)+!RÔÍÑÌ&bÔgÎ*ÔeÔgÌ./
+UÍØÍ1?Ù{Õ3× ,Ö?ÔA8ÍÑÖ)Î$*àÍÏÎwæÜÍØÌÎ*×dÙ{×Õ#Ö_ÎãÐâ!R×ÒÑÔeÖ×ÕÙ{Õw×%,¨ÍØÎwÖ3ÔgÒØÙ )ÜâÔgÎ3ÔeåºÎ3ÍÑÌ2,Î3æÜÔ·ågÐXÎ3Ô,×Õ )¨Ù{Õw×%,Õ3ÔÛÜÍØÕwÔeÖ
ÎwתâÔºÎwÔeåKΨÖ3×%#ÔgÎ3æÜÍÑÌ2, *àæÜÍáåãæ !uÕ3×*8Í#¦ÍØÎ3ÍÑÔeÖ *3Õ 3Î 3ÎwÐâ2!b×ÒØÔaÖ
Î3×jÙ{Õw×%,XÆÈÍØÎ)Æ:Ö)ÔeÒÏÙ !uÕ3×Î3×XÎ0)+!RÔeÖ/ÎwæÜÍÑÖdÍÑÖ
Ìu×XÎàÔÛÜÍÑÓYÐXÒÑÔgÌÎàÎ3×ÐâuâÐÌÜÔ* !ÜÕw×XÎw×XÎ0)+!RÔ%)&ÜÛÎàÎw×oâÔºÎwÔeåºÎ
A+9. A
ågÐXÎ3Ô,×Õ) /
+UÍØÍÑÍ1CÖ)Í#ÍØÒáÐXÕwÒ) )XågÐXÎ3Ô,×ÕwÍØÔaÖÖ3ÛuåãæÐÖ -! Ö)æ /âÔ ! ÌÜÔeâ )Ö3Ð*)Ö)XÐÖ -3ÐXÌÜÍ#ÐXÒáÖ *àÍØÎ3æÖ3ÒØÍ!2!RÔgÕãÖ^ÐXÌuâ¨ÎwÐÍØÒÔ98ågÔ!Î
âÜ×Ò!ÜæÜÍÑÌuÖ×Õ *àæuÐÒØÔA/ 33^Õ3ÔÛÜÍØÕwÔÎ3× !R×Ö)Î)Æ!ÜÕ3×ågÔeÖwÖ?ÎwæÜÔ·Õ3ÔaÖ)ÛuÒÏÎ×Ù_âÍRÔeÕ3ÔeÌÎâÜÐYÎãÐYÆ:åºÒáÐÖwÖ)Í! ågÐXÎ3ÍÑ×Ì 3
Ë:Ì×XÎwæÜÔgÕ*×ÕãâÜÖ)Î3æÜÔ !ÜÕw×XÎ3×Î0)+!bÔgÆ!ÜÕw×*8Í0#ÍØÎ0) #ÔaåãæuÐXÌÜÍáÖ # ÍÑÌÎ3ÕwÍØÌbÖ)ÍáågÐÒØÒ,)âÔ ! ÌuÔ-3åº×Ì4°ÛÜÌuåºÎ3ÍÑ×ÌB/×Ù
!uÕ3×Î3×XÎ0)+!RÔeÖ &ÜÛÎàÌÜ×Î -3âÍáÖ4°ÛÜÌbåKÎ3ÍÑ×Ì //ЦågÐYÎwÔ,×Õ )¦âÔ ! ÌÜÔaâ &B)oÐdÒÑ×%,ÍÑåeÐXÒRÔA8!ÜÕwÔeÖwÖ)ÍÑ×ÌÖ)ÔeÔ#ÖÎ3× &bÔ !ÜÛÎ
ÍÑÌÐâÍÑÖ4°ÛÜÌuåºÎ3ÍÑÓÔÌÜ×Õ#ÐXÒÙ{×Õ#.ÍÑÌ¢×ÕwâÔeÕÎw× &RÔÍ#(!ÜÒØÔ#ÔgÌÎ3Ôaâ &B)jåg×%# &ÜÍØÌbÐYÎ3ÍÑ×ÌbÖ×XÙ?Ö3Ûuåãæ¢ÌuÔeÐXÕwÔeÖ)Î)Æ
ÌuÔgÍ,æ+&b×ÕàåºÒáÐÖwÖ)Í! ÔgÕãÖ3
X ! ÕwÖ)ÎdÔA8>ÎwÔgÌuÖ3ÍØ×Ì )ÐÒØÒÑ×*àÍÑÌ2,iÎ3×¢åº× #.&ÜÍÑÌÜÔÎwæÜÔoÍÑÌuÛÜÔeÌuåºÔo×ÙÖ3ÔgÓÔgÕãÐXÒ !ÜÕw×XÎw×XÎ0)+!RÔeÖ·ÍáÖ·Î3æÜÔmÌÜ×XÎwÍØ×Ì×Ù
¢ÆWÔeÐÕ3ÔaÖ°Î3ÆWÔgÍ,æ+&b×Õ 6Ö)Î3Í#ÐYÎwÍØ×Ì=+zÖ)ÔeÔÔ%3,-3 <,3eÊ*? )FæuÐ%!ǦÙ{×ÕÐÌjÍØÌÎ3Õw×âÛuåºÎ3ÍÑ×ÌG13
.+ *( !92A 3 6æÜÔ !RÔgÕãåºÔ!ÜÎ3ÍÑ×Ì&×ÙÐ &uÕ3ÍÑÔ") !uÕ3ÔaÖ)ÔeÌÎwÔeâFÖ3æuÐ%!bÔiÍÑÖ¦Ö)Î3Õw×Ì2,Ò)
Í#(!uÐXÍÑÕwÔeâ ) *àæÜÔgÌ¢ÍØÎÍáÖÙ{×ÒÑÒØ×*Ôeâ &B)ªÐXÌÜ×Î3æÜÔeÕ -#ÐÖ )>ÍÑÌ2,/!uÐYÎ3Î3ÔeÕ3Ì 3 %
×*ÔgÓÔeÕ)bÐÖâÜÔ#×ÌuÖ)Î3ÕãÐYÎwÔeâ&B)
ÔeÒØÔaåKÎwÕ3×Æ !ÜæB)Ö3ÍØ×ÒØ× ,ÍáågÐXÒ+#ÔeÐÖ)ÛuÕ3Ô#¦ÔeÌÎwÖ?âÜÛÜÕ3ÍÑÌ2,ÓÍáÖ3ÛuÐXÒ#ÐÖ )ÍÑÌ2,dÔ98!bÔeÕ3Í#ÔgÌÎwÖ <çÊ*?)>Ö3Ûuåãæ #ÐÖ )â×>ÔeÖ
Ìu×XÎCÕ3ÔaâÛuåºÔ?Î3æÜÔÍÑÌÜÍØÎ3ÍáÐXÒ>Õ3ÔaÖ !R×ÌbÖ)Ô ) &uÛÎ6Ö)æÜ×Õ)ÎwÔgÌdÍØÎ6ÐXÌuâ¨ÌÜÔgÛuÕ3×ÌuÖ+ÍÑ̨Ë06FÕ3ÔaÖ!R×Ìuâ.&ÜÕwÍØÔ#)Î3×·ÐÖ)Î3Í#¨ÛÜÒÑÛuÖ
!uÕ3ÔaÖ)ÔeÌÎwÔeâiâÛÜÕwÍØÌ-,ÝÞ.#ÖÐÌuâmÎ3æÜÔeÌ #ÐÖ )Ôeâ 3
6æuÍÑÖÖ)Û2, ,ÔaÖ°ÎãÖ¦Î3æuÐXÎ !ÜÕw×>ågÔeÖwÖ)ÍÑÌ2,=ÍáÖoÌÜ×ÎmÍÑÌÜæÜÍ&ÜÍÏÎwÔeâ &uÛÎmÍÑÌÎwÔgÕwÕ3Û-!Î3Ôaâ & )&Î3æÜÔ #ÐÖ ))æuÐÒÏÎwÍØÌ-,=Î3æÜÔ
LNACEv1EOgk\aA_T1OeLoT1_\aEOgv1E]|zPbLNEJCQSUE\GCrM FEPROaEjTRJC|Uk¡QT1DFn^PuLNSUC|zEjoS{LNAPRJSUJ_°T1OºW
D&PbLNSUT1J^T OeE|zPbLNE]&LaT¢LaACEEDFSU\a\eSzT1J®TR?LNACE^Oe\eL \an_Sz³bE\ ::oACEJ&JCTRL¨Pª~CJ_S~CE
\anCSU³REMkJCE~COaT1J<Tb·E>PbQYAJCE~COaTRJ^PR|à|zPkREO«
@A_Sz\ªSU\jJCTRLiT1JC|{kV]_~CE©LNTn_OaT+QE\e\ª\aACTROeLª|zPbLNEJCQSUE\« i\j]CEv1E|zT1n?E] SUJ CÑbFEwZ?LNACSU\
PR\a\e~CDFn_LNSUT1J SU\^PR\eE] T1J LaACE En?EOaSUDFEJMLYPb|EvSU]CEJCQE¤LNA^PbLZiDFT1\gLTbLaACE<LNSUD&EbZ
P²\aEQT1JC] \enCSz³bE PROaOeSUv+SUJC[²v+SzPP²\ek+J^PRn_\aE Sz\¡\aSU[1JCS{^Q>PRJMLa|Uk PbLaLaEJ~^PbLaE]ZoACEJ J_TRL
SzJCA_SzCS{LNE]Z°T1OjRuWY£>1®DF\ :)Eb«Ø[_«j°T1Oj\aTRD&ELNA^PR|zPRDFSUQ©EQS{LYPuLNT1OgkSUJCnC~_La\jLNTQTROeLNSUQ>Pb|
nk+OaPRDFSz]^Pb|àQE|U|U\HCrMsFEJ<«
@A_Sz\mA^PR\LKT®QT1JC\aE~CEJCQE\µ
£1«LNACELNONPbJC\aDFS{LaLNE]SUJ_°T1OeD&PbLNSUT1JSU\D~CQYADFT1OaEªOeE|zPbLNE]LNT©LaACE U+'SB + TRP
JCE~_OaT1J^Pb|\eSz[1JCPR|LaA^PRJVLaTLNACE
M' ) )F
vbPR|z~_ELNOaPRJC\eD&S{LaLaE]>:)Eb«Ø[_«iv+S§P®LaACE
\anCSU³REª°OeE ~CEJ_Qk <« ¬ EE CØx9U E°T1OP=]CEvRE|UT1nCDFEJMLiPR?T1~_LOaPbLNEjvREOa\e~C\oLNEDFn?T1ONPb|
T1Oa]_EOQT+]CSUJC[CZ
x«o\aSUJCQELaACEo|§PbLaEJCQk=TR?LNACE^Oe\eL¨\an_Sz³bETRPª[1S{v1EJ¡JCE~COaT1J&SU\dP¢]_SzOeEQL¨]CEQOeE>PR\eSzJC[
°~CJCQLNSUT1JVTRLNACEJCE~_OaT1JSzJCn_~_LvbPR|U~CE :3P+~CPRJMLNS{LYPbLaSUvRE©DFT]CE|Sz\mnCOaTRnT1\eE]SUJ
CÑx U EJ<ZTRJC|Uk¤JCE~COaTRJC\oS{LNA²LaACE + "'+ [1EJCEOaPbLNE®\anCSU³RE\)PR\eLEJ_T1~C[1A
LNTF?E¢LNPR³REJSUJMLNT®PRQQT1~CJML>«
\gLNEn°~COgLNACEOZ
:)S<|UELo~C\QT1JC\aSU]CEOoLaA^PbLLaACEjLNED&n?T1OaPR|]CSU\aQOaSUDFSzJ^PuLNSUT1JTbP=JCE~COaTRJ :°\aEEEb«Ø[_«
CØtE°T1OPbJ¥EXLaEJC\eSUvRE\eLa~C]_k <SU\TRPR?T1~_L 1ZQT1JC\eSz]CEOaSUJC[LNACPbL¢LK¦T
\anCSU³RE\PbOaOaS{v+SzJ_[oS{LNACSUJ LNACEF\NPbD&E£FDF\PROaE©v+SUEE]PR\ª\eSzD~C|{LYPRJCET1~C\SzJ_nC~_L
MkLNACE¢JCEX+LiJCE~CONPb|àSzJCn_~_LPRJC]
:)SUSJ<d|zEL~C\Pb\a\a~_D&EjLaA^PbLoPuLE>PbQYA\eLYPb[1ERZ_LaACEjJCE~CONPb|SUJCnC~_La\OaEQES{v1E]]_~COaSUJC[FP
LNED&n?T1OaPR|oSUJC]CT TR I:)ER«Ï[C« CØRFEJ<SU\iLYPR³bEJ<SUJMLNTPRQQT1~CJMLZPR\
\aQYACED&PbLNSUE]SzJI4SU[C«?
ÕwÔeÖ !R×ÌuÖ3ÔàÌÜ×XÎ×ÌÜÒ,)¨Îw×dÎwæÜ×Ö3ÔÌÜÔeÛÜÕ3×ÌuÖ^ÕwÔgÒáÐYÎwÔeâ¦Î3×dÎ3æÜÔÖ°ÎwÍ0#ÛÜÒØÛbÖ)1&ÜÛÎ×XÎ3æuÔgÕ?ÌuÔgÛÜÕw×ÌuÖ?ÐXÒáÖ)× 3_Åà×Û2,æuÒ)
Ö !RÔeÐ)>ÍÑÌ2,-)!uÕ3×åºÔaÖ3Ö3ÍÑÌ2,¦Ö *àÍØÎwåãæuÖÎw×ÐÌÜ×XÎwæÜÔgÕÎãÐXÕ,ÔgÎ3
X¥Ö°ÎwÔ!Ù{ÛÜÕ)ÎwæÜÔgÕ ) <Ç >*?6âÔ#×ÌbÖ°ÎwÕwÐXÎ3ÔÎwæuÐYÎ #¦×Ö°Î×XÙ6ÎwæÜÔ¨ÍÑÌÙ{×Õ #ÐYÎwÍØ×ÌÐ&R×ÛÜÎÎ3æuÔ¨ÍÑÌ2!ÜÛηÍÑÖÐNÓYÐXÍÑÒÑÐ%&ÜÒÑÔ
ÍÑ̪ÐÖ)æÜ×Õ)ÎàÔ!b×åãæi×XÙ^Ð&R×ÛÎàÇÞ #Ö3
S{LNA=LaACE\eEPb\a\a~_D&nLNSUT1JZMLNACELaEDFn?T1ONPR|]CSU\aQOeSzDFSUJ^PbLaSzT1J&SU\\aSUD&n_|Uk=D&PR]_Em]_~COaSUJC[
¦QT1J_\aEQ~_LNS{v1ESzJMLaEOevbPR|U\ :)|USz³bEoA_EJC~CSU|z]CSUJC[®P©LNEDFn?T1ONPb| 6ºACSU\eLaT1[1ONPbD8iTR
LNACEo\an_Sz³bEiT+QQ~_OaOaEJCQE\+<dPRJC]F¦EmE>Pb\aSU|UkFQT1DFnC~_LNEoLNA_EmJ~CDEOTbn?T1\a\eSz_|zEmQT1DCSUJ^PuW
LNSUT1JC\Z^S)«ÏER« oZCoACEOaESz\LNA_EªJ+~_D?EOmTRJ_E~COaPR|àSzJ_nC~_LN\Z6PRQLaSUvRE]_~COaSUJC[
LNACE£>\eL ÃDF\«@ACSz\¦]CSU¶EOe\¦°OaTRD oACPbL¦¦PR\PR\e\a~CDFE]SUJ¡LaACEiT1OeSz[RSzJ^Pb|?°T1OeD~C|zPbLaSzT1J«
Previous stage neurons
outputs
Input neuron
1st spike delay T
i th spike delay i th d
1s t
n th ../..
10 ... 20 msec temporal window
temporal resolution 1 msec
i
dmin
4Sz[R~COaE©µ ¬ QYACED®PuLNSUQ=OaEn_OaE\eEJMLYPuLNSUT1J TRLNACE\anCSU³RE©LaEDFn?T1ONPR|QTRDCSUJ^PbLaSzT1J_\µmT1JC|{k
LNACE \enCSU³RE\ OeEQESUvRE] ]C~COaSUJC[ P.LaEDFnTRONPR|oSzJC]_TÜ¢ZS3«ÏER« ]C~COeSzJ_[ LNACE ^Oe\eL
²PROeE LNPR³REJ9SUJLaT.PbQQTR~CJML>« ¬ n_Sz³bE\oS{LNA_SzJ P´LaEDFnTRONPR|ªOeE\aTR|z~_LaSzTRJ TR
PRTR~_L =PROeEQTRJC\aSU]CEOeE]¤PR\\aSUD~C|{LYPRJ_ET1~C\ :°SzJLNACSU\jE_PRDFnC|UELaACE£>\gLj\an_Sz³bE\ªTR
LNACE >\gLFPRJ LaA´JCE~COeT1JC\B<«²@A_E¤£\eL=\enCSz³bEJ_E~COeT1J^PR|]_E|zPk²Sz\=QT1JC\eSz]CEOaE] PR\LaACE
D&TR\eLOeE|UEvbPRJMLJCE~COaT1JSUJ_°T1OeD®PuLNSUT1JZ+SzJLaACSz\ 6ã)PR\eL¦CONPbSzJS8JCE~COaTRJ^PR|?EACPv+SUT1O« 4^~COºW
LNACEOaDFT1OaEbZJCE~COeT1JC\¨T1~_LanC~_LN\PROeEoLaOaEPbLNE]®Mk=LNA_ESUJCnC~_L¨JCE~COaTRJ¡~C\eSzJC[P¢nCOaT1[ROaE\e\aS{v1E
SzJCA_SzCS{LNSUT1JDFEQYA^PRJ_Sz\eDZPR\o]CELYPRSU|zE]SUJLNACEªLNEX+L>«
+ C 1 0- 9 529 %
6æÜÔeÕ3ÔÐÕ3Ô !R×ÖwÖ3Í0&ÜÒÑÔ!RÔgÕ#¨ÛÜÎwÐYÎwÍØ×ÌuÖ?Ù{×ÕÐ
,ÍØÓÔg̨Ö3ÔºÎC×XÙâÜÐXÎwÐ23
%
×*ÔgÓÔgÕ )eÍÑÌ !ÜÕwÐåKÎwÍÑågÔ%)YÐYÎ^Ð,ÍØÓÔgÌÎwÔ#(!R×ÕãÐXÒ>Õ3ÔaÖ)×ÒØÛÜÎ3ÍÑ×̦ÐXÌuââÛÜÕwÍØÌ2,·ÐàÎwÍ0#Ô
*àÍÑÌuâ×*ÍØÎÍÑÖÌÜ×Î !b×Ö3Ö3Í0&uÒØÔÎ3××%&bÖ)ÔeÕ3ÓÔÐÒØÒRÎ3æuÔeÖ3Ô !RÔgÕ#¨ÛÜÎwÐYÎwÍØ×ÌuÖ3æbÐYÎæuÐ%!2!bÔeÌuÖÍáÖ?ÎwæuÐYÎ"*àæuÔgÌ )
ÐXÎÐ ,ÍØÓÔgÌiÎ3Í#Ô )RÐ̪ÍØÌ-!ÜÛÎæuÐÖ &bÔeÔgÌâÜÔºÎ3ÔaåKÎwÔeâ )1ÐXÒÑÒ+ÍÑÌ2!ÜÛÎãÖÍÑ̪Î3æuÔ "!$#&%(')'+*,.-_ÍÑÌÎ3ÔgÕwÓYÐXÒ_ÐXÕwÔ
Ó>ÍÑÔ*ÔeâÐÖ -)Ö)>ÌuåãæÜÕw×ÌÜ×ÛuÖ *àÍÏÎwæ/ 3 6æÜÍáÖ #ÔeÐÌuÖ^ÎwæuÐYÎ?Î3æÜÔ "!ÍÑÌÎ3ÔeÕ3ÓYÐXÒbÍÑÖ?ÌÜ×XÎ ! 8Ôeâ(&ÜÛÎÎ3ÕwÍ0, ,ÔeÕ3Ôaâ.&B)
ÎwæÜÔ73aÖ°Î?×åeåºÛÜÕwÕ3ÍÑÌ2,ÍÑÌ2!ÜÛÎ 3 %
×*ÔgÓÔgÕ )*ÔÐXÕwÔàÍØÌoÐdÖ3ÍØÎ3ÛuÐXÎ3ÍÑ×Ì *àæÜÔeÕ3Ô/ ÍáÖÓÔgÕ )¨ÒáÐXÕ,Ô )Ö3×Î3æuÐXÎÐYÎÎ3æÜÔ
ÔeÌuâ×XÙ+ÔaÐåãæ0 ! ÍÑÌÎwÔgÕwÓYÐXÒ )ÔgÎÐÌÜ×XÎwæÜÔgÕàÖ !ÜÍ)ÔÓÔgÕ )ÒØÍ)ÔeÒ) +zÐXÒ#¦×Ö°Î 1Í0#(#ÔeâÍáÐYÎwÔgÒ,)o×ågågÛÜÕwÖ)Ö°ÎãÐXÕ3Î3ÍÑÌ2,Ð
ÌuÔ* !2143 ÍØÌÎwÔgÕwÓNÐÒÐXÌuâ ! ÌuÐÒØÒ,)ÐÒØÒÑ×*àÍÑÌ2,¨Îw×åº×ÌbÖ)ÍáâÔgÕåg×ÌuÖ3ÔeågÛÎ3ÍÑÓÔÍÑÌÎwÔgÕwÓYÐXÒáÖ×XÙ^âÛÜÕãÐYÎ3ÍÑ×Ì5 3
¨ELPbJCTRLNA_EOF\eLaEn°~_OeLNA_EOZ¨LNACE@ACT1OenEDFT]_E|oPR\e\a~CDFE\P¤nCOeT1[1OeE\a\eSUvREVSUJCACS¯W
CSULaSzTRJ.DFEQYA^PbJCSz\eD Z¨LNACE¤£>\eL®\an_Sz³bE\SUJCQOeE>PR\eSzJ_[²LNACESUJCACSUCSULaSzTRJ°T1OFTRLaACEO&SzJ_nC~_L
\anCSU³RE\EDFS{LaLNE]Mk¡TbLNACEOJCE~COaTRJC\«@ACSU\¦\eA~CJMLNSUJC[=SzJ_ACSz_SULaSzT1J¡D&EQYA^PRJCSU\aD :)\eEEjEb«Ø[_«
CU£ÜUE°T1OjPCSzTR|zT1[RSzQPR|z|{knC|§Pb~C\aSUC|UE=\aSUD~C|zPbLNSUT1JN<iD&P>k?E©OeE|zPbLNE] LaT¡)PR\gLeWK\enCSU³+SUJC[SUJW
ACSz_SULaT1Oek<SUJMLNEOgWKJ_E~COeT1JC\SzJ¤QT1JMLNPRQL¢oS{LNA LNACEF\aTRD®PTRnMkOaPRDFSz]CPR|QE|z|U\ :°ER«Ï[C«ICÏrFE<X«
i\PQT1JC\eE ~CEJ_QERZJ_TRLPR|z|J_E~COeT1J^PR|SUJCnC~_La\_~_LTRJC|UkVLNACEF^Oa\gLN\ZPROeE&LNPR³REJ²SUJMLNT
PRQQT1~CJML>«
@A_E\aE¢)PRQLN\oA^P>v1E¢LK¦T&QTRJC\aE+~_EJCQE\ZOaE[MPROa]_SzJC[FLNA_EQT1DFnC~_LNPbLNSUT1J^PR|nCOaT+QE\a\µ
·1_ À À ¼ ¼ À ( ãÀ ¥_ À d LaACE ~^PRJMLNS{LYPuLNS{v1EdvRPb|z~CEDFEPuW
\a~COeE] °OeT1D PV[1S{v1EJJ_E~COeT1JMk¥LaACEJCEXL©JCE~COeT1J^PR|SzJ_nC~_L©SU\LaA+~_\©]CSUOaEQLN|{k
OaE|§PbLaE]VLaT¡S{LN\]CE|zP>kPb\i\aQYA_ED&PbLNSUE] SzJ 4Sz[C««\i]CSU\aQ~C\a\eE] nCOaEv+SzT1~_\a|{k1Z
LNACSU\=]CE|§P>kSU\=LNA~C\&PTR~CJC]CE]vbPR|U~CED:°oS{LNA PRJC]
RvbPR|z~_E\+<oS{LNAP
, R #%++ «
@ACEmONPbLaSzT¢?ELKEEJLaACE\eEmLKT ~^PbJLaSULaSzE\ZS3«ÏER« SU\¨LaACE 'S
R? R#
TRiLNACE]CPbLYP¥vbPR|U~CEb«9@ACSU\J~CD?EOoSU|z|EnCOaEQSUT1~C\SUJ¹T1Oe]CEO&LNT
EvbPR|U~^PbLaE¢LaACE¢\eLNPbLNSU\eLaSzQPR|ànEOe°T1OeD&PRJCQE\TbLaACE¢D&T+]CE|3«
Cu
¼ ¼
>
À
¼ ¼
À
(
ãÀ
²_
À
¨
PRDFT1JC[¢LNACEONPbLaACEO¨A~C[1EmJ~CD?EO
TRSUJCnC~_LoJCE~COaTRJC\G:°LKk+nCSUQ>PR|U|{kLNACEª]_SzDFEJ_\aSUT1J TRLNACEjJ_E~COeT1J^PR|%6ãv1EQLNTRO98iA^PR\
PRJT1Oe]CEOTRdD&PR[1JCS{LN~_]CE©TR +<mTRJC|UkVP¡OaPbLNACEOi\eD®Pb|z|J+~_D?EOªSU\LYPb³REJ SUJMLNT
PRQQT1~CJML>«¡@ACSz\Sz\P³bEk¤n?T1SzJMLSzJ LNA_E¡@ACT1OenE&DFT]_E|¨PRJC]¤SULA^PR\?EEJ²EW
nEOaSUDFEJMLNE]LNACPbLmP=\aSUD&n_|zE$6KLaACOaE\aACTR|z]S8ªD&EQYA^PRJCSU\aD :°Q>PRJ_QE|USUJC[®SUJ_°T1OeD&PbLNSUT1J
\aD&PR|U|EJ_T1~C[1ALNT=A^P>vREP©]CE|§P>kA_Sz[1A_EOLNA^PbJLaACEjLNSUDFEªoSzJC]_TÜ <SU\mPR|zOeE>PR]kP
nC|zPR~C\aSUC|UEDFT+]CE|TRLaACE¢JCE~_OaT1J^Pb|àD&EQYA^PRJCSU\aD«
IKJ LNACE<QT1DFnC~_LaEO\aSUD~_|§PbLaSzTRJÃTR¢LaACE<@ACT1OenEDFT+]CE|C{£>r EJ<ZoLNACE ' DR?
B++KR?$?B+
Sz\FTRiPR?T1~_L «IãL&Sz\FEX_n?EQLNE]LNT ?EACSz[RACEOFSUJ´LaACE
$ C G & "A (ABG.
36ËÈÎæuÐÖ$&bÔeÔgÌ ÛuÐXÌÎwÍ
!
Ôaâåg×ÌuÖ3ÍáâÔgÕwÍØÌ-,
ÎwæÜÔ.!uÕ3ÔeÓÍÑ×ÛbÖÖ°ÎãÐ,ÔdÌÜÔgÛuÕ3×ÌuÐXÒÍØÌ2!uÛÎwÖ
+(#%9( +9(
*ÔeÍ0,æÎwÔeâ&B)
-)ÍÑÌÜæÜÍ&ÜÍÏÎwÍØ×Ìåº×>ÔoågÍØÔeÌÎãÖ / !"#¦ÐÌuâÒÑÍ0#ÍØÎ3Ôeâ & )ЩÎwæÜÕ3ÔaÖ)æu×Òáâ%$2)×%&ÜÎwÐXÍÑÌÜÍÑÌ2,=Ù{×ÕoÎ3æuÔÌÜÔeÛÜÕ3×Ì
×ÛÎ !uÛÎ'&ÐÌÔ98!ÜÕ3ÔaÖ3Ö3ÍÑ×Ìm×ÙÎwæÜÔ·Ù{×Õ#
& #)("*,+.-
0/
!12.34$25
687
/
7:9 ÍáÖÎwæÜÔdâÔeågÕ3ÔaÐÖ3ÍØÌ-,ÕãÐYÎwÍØ× +¯Î0)+!ÜÍáågÐÒØÒ,)mÐXÕw×ÛuÌuâ 3YßXÝdÙ{×ÕÖ3Í0#ÛÜÒáÐYÎ3ÍÑ×ÌbÖ 1
*àæuÍØÒÑÔ (1*;=<>#@?BA)< 7C68DFEHGI 3 9JGLKNM2G ?BAO<QP 6DFEHG2IR9SGLKLM2G06 ÍáÖÎ3æuÔdÖ)Í,ÌÙ{ÛÜÌuåºÎ3ÍÑ×Ì 3
