Transparent Message-Passing Parallel Applications Checkpointing in Kerrighed

HAL Id: inria-00000868

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00000868

Submitted on 28 Nov 2005

HAL

is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire

destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Transparent Message-Passing Parallel Applications Checkpointing in Kerrighed

Matthieu Fertré, Christine Morin

To cite this version:

Matthieu Fertré, Christine Morin. Transparent Message-Passing Parallel Applications Checkpointing

in Kerrighed. [Research Report] PI 1768, 2005, pp.13. �inria-00000868�

I ^R

I ^S

A

I^N STIT^U

T ^D E R

E^C HERC^H

E EN IN^F OR^M

AT^IQ UEE^T

SY^ST ÈME^S

ALÉA^TO^IRES

P U B L I C A T I O N I N T E R N E

N

I R I S A

CAMPUS UNIVERSITAIRE DE BEAULIEU - 35042 RENNES CEDEX - FRANCE

ISSN 1166-8687

1768

TRANSPARENT MESSAGE-PASSING PARALLEL APPLICATIONS CHECKPOINTING IN KERRIGHED

MATTHIEU FERTRÉ AND CHRISTINE MORIN

INSTITUT DERECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ETSYSTÈMESALÉATOIRES

Campus de Beaulieu – 35042 Rennes Cedex – France Tél. : (33) 02 99 84 71 00 – Fax : (33) 02 99 84 71 71 http://www.irisa.fr

"!!!$#% !'&()

*,+

&-. )/1023

+

4

57698:8<;=?>A@ BC>AD:8EDEFHGI69JKMLN;DE=?O:8<=?J>P5MQRD:=SJ7GRG

TVUXWZY\['].^:W`_bab].c'd\egfha^:W

i d\jlkZ^'Y\W inmporq T

i absbtueuv:wxYyeujz_eu_AYy^'d\_b^(_{x|x}z~€rjx‚h^']sbdy^ƒl„h„h…†{:‡Nˆwz‰z^:W

ŠŒ‹:Ž'xb‘zŽz’ €pjx“”wh•bw<UXW'–vtuaWZY\^'d—Wwld\^.“eu•X^:t˜UaWy^:•PYyj™^'šX^:vabYy^›W\veu^'_AYye˜œ9vwlˆˆbt˜egv'wlYyeujz_W:žŒŸ3 b^EW¡^

wzˆbˆbtueuv:wxY\e˜jh_W¢wzdy^rjz£¤Yy^:_Œ].^:W\Wywz‰z^'¥SˆwhWyWyeu_b‰(ˆwld—wltut˜^:t9wzˆbˆbtueuv:wxYyeujz_9W¢“e˜Yy ¦t˜jh_b‰^šX^EvaXY\e˜jh_Yyeu].^zž¢TVeu_v^

Y\ b^™_Vab]"s§^'djz£`_bjX•X^EWeu_¨v't˜a9WZY\^'d—WegW‰hdyjx“eu_b‰–©Yy b^™ˆbd\jzs9wlsbeut˜e˜YZUªjl£w_bjX•X^£«wleut˜ady^¬•Xadyeu_b‰Yy b^

^'šX^:vabYyeujz_­jz£®wz_¯wlˆˆbt˜egv'wlYyeujz_¯e˜_v'dy^EwzWy^:WNwl_•­Yy ^wzˆbˆbtueuv:wxY\e˜jh_­^šX^EvaXY\e˜jh_$Yyeu].^™]w<Uªs9^‰zd\^:wlYy^:d

Y\ wl_¦Yy ^vtuaWZY\^'dr].^Ewl_¦Yyeu]N^s§^YZ“”^'^:_£«wleut˜abd\^:W°?±¬Ÿ²3³C´µžŸjw<‚zjzeg•›d\^:W¡Y\wzd¡Y\e˜_‰Nwzˆbˆbtueuv:wxYyeujz_¦£¶d\jz]

Y\ b^(s9^:‰zeu_b_beu_b‰–XWyjz].^`£«wlabt˜Y3Yyjztu^'d—wl_AY”]N^Ev— wl_euWy]WWyav— ¦whW3v— b^:v—·Vˆ§jzeu_hY¸<d\^:W¡Y\wzd¡Ywzdy^`_b^'^E•X^:•ž¹abd¡¥

d\^'_AY\t˜Uh–v— b^Ev—·Aˆ§jzeu_AYµ¸xdy^EWZY—wldyY"].^:v— wz_beuWy]W.wld\^^:eºY\ b^'d.eu].ˆbt˜^:].^'_AYy^E•»•be˜d\^:vYytuU$e˜_¯Yy ^¬wlˆbˆbtuegv'wxY\e˜jh_

Wyjzad\v'^`vjX•X^®sVU›wlˆbˆt˜egv'wlYyeujz_Wˆbd\jz‰zd—wl].].^'d—W©jhdwld\^peu_hY\^'‰hd\wlYy^:•›e˜_vjh]N]ab_begv'wlYyeujz_›^:_A‚Veudyjh_b].^'_AY\W

Wyav— wzW¢±

i©q jzd

i¢¼

±ªžh½P^rˆdyjhˆ9jAW¡^3eu_.Yy begW©ˆwzˆ9^:d¢w(_b^:“¨wzˆbˆbd\jhwhv— "eu_“ beuv— ›v— ^:v—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AY¸<d\^:W¡Y\wldyY

].^Ev— wl_begWy].Wp£¶jzd®ˆwzd\wzt˜tu^'twlˆbˆbtuegv'wxY\e˜jh_W®wld\^"eu]Nˆt˜^:]N^:_AYy^:•¾e˜_w¦v't˜a9WZY\^'d(W¡eu_b‰ztu^WyUXWZY\^']¿eu]wl‰z^jzˆX¥

^:d\wlYyeu_b‰W¡UXW¡Yy^:]ž”½À beut˜^Yy begW·z^:dy_^'ttu^'‚h^'twzˆbˆbd\jhwzv— ¦euWp].jzd\^vjz].ˆbtu^š¦Yyjeu].ˆbt˜^:].^'_AYrYy 9wl_™jlY\ b^'d

wzˆbˆbd\jhwhv— b^:W:–VeºYpegW].jzd\^(‰z^:_b^'d—wltns§^:v:wlaWy^eºYp•bjA^EW_bjzYpdy^EfAabe˜d\^wl_VU›].jX•Xe˜œ9v'wlYyeujz_–v'jz].ˆbeutuwlYyeujz_jzd

d\^'tueu_b·Ve˜_b‰jz£Y\ b^›wlˆbˆt˜egv'wlYyeujz_W(“ wlYy^:‚z^'d®Y\ b^›vjh]N]ab_begv'wlYyeujz_^'_V‚Ve˜d\jz_b].^:_hY(Y\ b^'UPdy^:t˜U¬jh_žÁ`abd

wzˆbˆbd\jhwhv— " whWs9^:^'_eu]Nˆt˜^:]N^:_AYy^:•Neu_ŒÂÃbÄnÄnŶÆÇÃbÈWye˜_b‰ht˜^rWyUXWZY\^']Ée˜]wl‰h^3jzˆ§^'d—wxYyeu_b‰WyUVW¡Yy^:],swhW¡^E•

jh_ÊŤËÌnÍCž i ^:d¡£¶jhdy]wl_9v^®dy^EW¡abt˜Y\Wwzdy^®ˆbd\^:Wy^'_AYy^E•Œeu_Yy begWˆwzˆ9^:d:ž

ΙÏAÐRÑ\Ò"Ó xԍz’

W¡eu_b‰ztu^pWyUXWZY\^'],eu]wl‰h^z–hv— ^:v—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AY\e˜_b‰9–lˆwzd\wzt˜tu^'twzˆbˆbtueuv:wxY\e˜jh_–z‰ht˜jhswltbv'jAjhd\•be˜_wlYyeujz_–

Õ(Öoroq¡×(ØrÖÙ

–§vtuaWZY\^'d

ÚgÛnÜyÝßÞ:à3ÜáâuÝßãSäå

æçrè\é«éSêEëíì¡îhïðuìZñ¶éSñ«ìyòëíñ?ëíóSèEïðuñ

æôæõêEñ?ëíó«éSëíö<ìµïç÷µñ«ëíölòëíñ«ëíóßèEïð˜ñ

Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique Institut National de Recherche en Informatique (UMR6074) Université de Rennes 1 – Insa de Rennes et en Automatique – unité de recherche de Rennes

!!!&) ¦ 4¦ 0 3 + 4

 ’ ^EW‰zd—wlˆbˆ§^:W•X^3v'wztuv'abtuwlYy^:abd\WWyjz_AYY\dy[EWaXYyeut˜egWyc'^:Wˆ§jzadtu^:Wwzˆbˆbtueuv:wxYyeujz_9WW\veu^'_AYye˜œ9fAab^EW'ž

¹^EWwlˆbˆt˜egv'wlYyeujz_WWyjz_AY›W¡jhab‚z^:_AY.•X^EW›wlˆˆbt˜egv'wlYyeujz_W.ˆ9wld—wltut˜[:t˜^EWN•b^tujz_‰zab^™•Xabd\c'^¬v'jz].]"a_beufAawz_AY

ˆ9wld]N^EWyW\wl‰h^zž ¹jz].].^Ptu^P_jz]"sdy^¾•b^P_a9•bW¦•wl_Wtu^:W¦‰zd—wlˆbˆ§^:W•X^Pv:wltgvabtgwxY\^'abd—Wwlab‰h]N^:_AYy^z–

tgwˆbd\jzswzsbeut˜e˜Yyc•X^Œ•bc£«wleututuwz_v^›•ab_ª_a9•wzab‰z].^:_hY\^^'tut˜^›wzaW\W¡e©^'Ytuw™•babdyc:^›•^šXc:v'aXYyeujz_$•ab_b^

wzˆbˆbtueuv:wxY\e˜jh_»ˆ§^'abYY\dy^¾Wyabˆ§c'd\e˜^:abd\^¬wla»Yy^:]Nˆ9W›].jxUz^:_»^:_AYyd\^¬•Xc£«wze˜tutuwz_v^EW›•X^™tgwª‰zd—wlˆˆ9^hž Ù wl_W

v'^vjz_AY\^šVYy^h–ˆ9jhabdc'‚Ve˜Yy^:d•X^dy^:tuwz_v^:d(t˜^EWwlˆbˆbtuegv'wxY\e˜jh_W(•X^'ˆabeuWt˜^›•Xc:sbaXY^:_v:wzW•X^•Xc'£«wleut˜tgwl_v'^z–

•b^:W.].c:v:wl_begW¡].^•X^Yyjht˜c:d\wz_v^wlaXšª£«wzaXYy^EWvjh]N].^tgwW\wla‚z^'‰Awld—•X^›^'Y.tgwdy^EWZY—wlabd—wxY\e˜jh_­•X^ˆ§jzeu_hY

•b^Nd\^'ˆdyegW¡^EW(•wzˆbˆbtueuv:wxY\e˜jh_Wyjz_AYwxYyYyd—w<Uhwl_AY—W'ž × c'_bc:d\wzt˜^:]N^:_AY:–tu^:W].cEv'wl_euWy].^:W(•X^›W\wlab‚h^'‰hwzd\•b^"^Y

d\^:W¡Y\wzabd—wxYyeujz_À•X^Pˆ9jhe˜_AY™•X^¾d\^'ˆdyegW¡^PW¡jh_hY¦]NegW^'_a‚Ad\^¾•Xeud\^:vµY\^'].^'_AY•bwl_W¦tu^PvjX•X^W¡jhabd—v^¾•X^

twlˆbˆbtuegv'wxY\e˜jh_ªjza$Wyjz_AY"eu_AYyc'‰hdycEW•bwz_Wtu^:W"^'_V‚Ve˜d\jz_b_^'].^'_AY\W"•X^¦v'jz].]"ab_euv:wxYyeujz_ªv'jz].].^Œ±

i©q jha

i¢¼

±ªž¢€pjzaW.ˆdyjhˆ9jAW¡jh_W•wl_Wv'^Y›wldyYyegvtu^ab_b^_bjza‚z^'tutu^wzˆbˆbd\jVv— ^fAaberv'jz_WyeuW¡Yy^! Pe˜_AY\c'‰zd\^'d.tu^:W

].cEv'wl_euWy].^:W(•X^›W\wlab‚h^'‰hwzd\•b^^Yd\^:W¡Y\wzabd\wlYyeujz_¾•b^ˆ9jhe˜_AY•X^d\^'ˆbd\euWy^.•wzˆbˆbtueuv:wxY\e˜jh_¾ˆwzd\wzt˜tu['tu^N•wl_W

a_W¡UXW¡Yy['].^¬•^šXˆbtujze˜Y\wlYyeujz_" Heu].wz‰z^™ab_eufAab^¬ˆ§jzad›‰zd—wlˆbˆ§^¬•X^¾v:wltgvabtgwxY\^'abd—W:ž7¹^YyYy^¾wzˆbˆbd\jVv— ^

WyUXWZY\['].^^:W¡YpˆbtuaW®vjh]Nˆt˜^'šV^ ›]N^'Y¡Y\dy^^:_!ab‚Vdy^fAab^"t˜^EWpwlabYyd\^:W]wlegW^:t˜tu^^:W¡YpˆbtuaWp‰zc'_c'd—wltu^v'wld

^:t˜tu^›_b^¦_bc:v'^:W\W¡e˜Yy^¦ˆwzW•X^Œ].jX•Xe˜œ9v'wlYyeujz_–d\^:v'jz].ˆbeutuwlYyeujz_Hjza$d\c'cE•Xe˜Yyeujz_$•X^¦t˜eu^'_W•X^:WNwlˆˆbt˜egv'wlYyeujz_W

fAab^:tufAab^™Wyjze˜Yt#^'_V‚Ve˜d\jz__b^'].^'_AY•X^¬vjh].]"ab_begv'wlYyeujz_»W¡abdtu^:fAab^:trv^EW•X^'d\_beu['d\^:WNdy^:ˆ9jAW¡^:_AY:ž¨€rjlY\dy^

wzˆbˆbd\jXv— b^w¦cY\cN].egW¡^.^:_$ab‚Vd\^•bwz_W®t˜^WyUXWZY\['].^N•%^'šVˆt˜jheºY—wxYyeujz_& e˜]wl‰h^"ab_eufAab^›ÂÃbÄnÄnŶÆÇÃbÈ

£¶jh_•XcWyabdʢŤËÌnÍCž Ù ^EWd\c:WyabtºY—wxY—W•a_b^c'‚xwltuawlYyeujz_H•X^ˆ9^:d¡£¶jhdy]wz_v^EW®Wyjz_AYˆbd\c:Wy^'_AYycEW•bwl_9Wv^Y

wzd¡Y\euv't˜^hž

',Ó

ŽE»‘)(

 ’ Wywzab‚z^:‰hwzd\•X^¾^Ydy^EWZY—wlabd—wxY\e˜jh_•X^Hˆ9jhe˜_AY\W•X^d\^'ˆbd\euWy^z–`wlˆbˆbtuegv'wxY\e˜jh_W¦ˆwld—wltut˜[:t˜^EW'–

v'jVjzd—•Xe˜_9wxYyeujz_¨‰ht˜jhswltu^z– Õ(Ö¢opoq¡×(ØrÖ¢Ù –rWyUVW¡Yy[:].^¾•^šXˆbtujze˜Y\wxY\e˜jh_ $eu]wl‰z^¾ab_begfha^z–r‰hd\wzˆbˆ9^EWŒ•X^

v:wltgvabtgwxY\^'abd—W

8 9

)4 ¦&¢)

Tbveu^'_AYye˜œ9vŒwzˆbˆbtueuv:wxY\e˜jh_Wwld\^›jz£¤Yy^'_­]N^EWyW\wl‰h^¥ßˆwzW\Wye˜_b‰ˆwzd\wzt˜tu^'twlˆbˆbtuegv'wxY\e˜jh_W“e˜Yy ­t˜jh_b‰¬^šX^EvaXY\e˜jh_

Y\e˜].^hžPŸj¾‰za9wld—wl_AYy^:^.Yy b^:e˜dNdy^:t˜egwlst˜^›^'šX^:vabYyeujz_–£«wlatºYYyjztu^'d—wl_9v^›].^:v— 9wl_begW¡]Wwld\^›_b^'^E•X^:•­W¡eu_v^

wzˆbˆbtueuv:wxY\e˜jh_^'šV^EvaXY\e˜jh_NYyeu]N^p].w<Us9^‰hdy^EwxY\^'dYy 9wl_NYy b^p]N^Ewl_NYyeu].^rs§^£¶jzd\^3£«wleutuabdy^°?±¬Ÿ²3³´Cjl£RYy b^

v't˜a9WZY\^'dEž

m Yyd—wz•Xe˜Yyeujz_9wlthwzˆbˆbd\jhwhv— ®egWv— b^:v—·Vˆ§jzeu_hYwl_•d\^:W¡Y\wzd¡Y].^Ev— wl_begWy].W:žŸ3 ^W¡Y\wxY\^¢jz£XYy b^ˆbdyjh‰zd—wl]MeuW

ˆ§^'d\eujV•beuv:wltut˜U(Wyw<‚h^:•®jz_WZY—wlsbtu^W¡Yyjhd\wz‰z^©•Xabd\eu_b‰r^šX^EvaXY\e˜jh_;:x“ b^'_w£«wleutuabdy^¢jVv:vabd—W:–:Y\ b^v'jz].ˆbaXY—wxY\e˜jh_

egWWy AabYp•Xjx“_wz_•ŒYy b^ˆbd\jz‰hd\wz] euW3d\^:W¡Y\wzd¡Y\^:•Œ£¶dyjh] Yy ^tuwhWZYrv— b^Ev—·Aˆ§jzeu_AY:ž

q _ÀY\ b^¾wzdy^EwHjl£Wyv'e˜^:_AYye˜œ9v¬vjh].ˆbaXYyeu_b‰9–”ˆdyjh‰zd—wl].].^'d—W.aW¡a9wltut˜U¯e˜].ˆbtu^'].^'_AYwlˆbˆbtuegv'wxY\e˜jh_ÀW¡ˆ§^¥

v'eºœ§v™v— b^:v—·Vˆ§jzeu_hY¸<d\^:W¡Y\wzd¡YN]N^Ev— wl_euWy]W.“ beuv— ¨wld\^e˜_AY\^'‰zd—wxY\^:•¯e˜_»Y\ b^¬wlˆbˆt˜egv'wlYyeujz_¨W¡jhabd\v'^v'jX•X^zž

Ÿj™d\^'tu^:w<‚z^•X^:‚z^:t˜jhˆ9^:d\W®£¶d\jz] Yy b^›sabd\•b^'_HYyj¾].wz_wl‰h^N£«wlabt˜YYyjht˜^:d\wz_AYeuW\W¡a^:W:–wl_$wzˆbˆbd\jhwhv— PegW(Yyj

eu].ˆbtu^'].^'_AYv— b^Ev—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AYµ¸xdy^EWZY—wldyY(W¡Yyd—wxY\^'‰he˜^EW(e˜_HY\ b^›vjh]N]ab_begv'wlYyeujz_H^'_V‚Ve˜d\jz_]N^:_AY\WWyav— ªwzW±

i¢q

wz_•

i¢¼

±2jz_Œ“ euv— ¦]N^EWyW\wl‰h^¥ßˆwzW\Wye˜_b‰s9wzWy^:•Œwzˆbˆbtueuv:wxY\e˜jh_Wwzdy^`swzWy^:•ž

Ø

jx“^:‚z^:d:–Ady^Evjh]Nˆe˜tue˜_‰"jzd

d\^'tueu_b·Ve˜_b‰NY\ b^wlˆbˆbtuegv'wxY\e˜jh_¦egWjz£¤Yy^'__b^:^:•X^E•nž

½^Œˆbd\jzˆ§jhWy^›w™_b^:“ wlˆbˆbd\jhwhv— P“ euv— ­v'jz_WyegWZY—We˜_ªeu].ˆbtu^'].^'_AYyeu_b‰v— b^:v—·Vˆ§jzeu_hY¸<d\^:W¡Y\wzd¡Y(].^:v— X¥

wz_begW¡]W(£¶jhdˆwld—wltut˜^:t¢wlˆˆbt˜egv'wlYyeujz_WwhWˆwzd¡Yjl£rw™v't˜aW¡Yy^:dTVeu_b‰ztu^ŒTVUXW¡Yy^'] q ]wl‰z^¬°STbT q ´"Á`ˆ§^'d—wxY\e˜_‰

TXUVW¡Yy^:] °SÁ(Tb´ž m TbT q jzˆ§^'d—wxY\e˜_‰ŒW¡UXW¡Yy^:]‰he˜‚h^:WY\ b^"eutut˜aWyeujz_™Y\ wxY(w›vtuaW¡Yy^'d`euW®w›Wye˜_‰ztu^"]"atºY\e˜ˆbd\jl¥

v'^:W\W¡jhdC]wzv— beu_b^zž qYˆdyjx‚Veg•X^:WY\ b^`W\wl].^eu_hY\^'dy£«wzv'^pwzW©wYyd—wz•Xe˜Yyeujz_wztbjzˆ§^'d—wxY\e˜_‰W¡UXW¡Yy^']É£¶jzdwl_ŒTX± i

]whv— be˜_^”“e˜Yy .Wyjz].^wz•b•Xe˜Yyeujz_9wltV£¶ab_vYyeujz_wzt˜e˜Yyeu^:WCWyav— .wzWˆbd\jXv^EWyW].e˜‰hd\wlYyeujz_žÂÃbÄnÄnŶÆÇÃbÈ=<u{>wl_9•

Á`ˆ§^'_§TbT q <íƒ6>Xwld\^©YZ“”jr^šbwl].ˆbtu^:Wjl£Wyav— "WyUXWZY\^']WswzWy^:•jh_ʢŤËÌnÍCžÁ`advjh_AYyd\e˜sbabYyeujz_egWwz_^šVY\^'_X¥

Wyeujz_jl£Y\ b^(e˜_AY\^'dy£«wzv^(jz£wl_™TbT q jzˆ§^'d—wxY\e˜_‰NWyUXWZY\^'] £¶jhd3v't˜a9WZY\^'d—W3“eºY\ v— ^:v—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AY¸<d\^:W¡Y\wldyYWyUXWZY\^']

v:wltutuW”£¶jhdrˆwzd\wzt˜tu^'twzˆbˆbtueuv:wxYyeujz_9W'ž©½À e˜tu^(Yy b^"e˜].ˆbtu^'].^'_AY—wxYyeujz_jz£v— b^Ev—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AYµ¸xdy^EWZY—wldyY”].^Ev— wl_begWy].W

egW].jzd\^vjh]Nˆt˜^'šwxY`·z^'d\_b^:tnt˜^:‚z^'tYy wz_wlYraWy^'drtu^'‚h^'tS–XYy begWpwzˆbˆbd\jhwhv— Œˆbd\jx‚Veu•X^EW”£¶abtutYyd—wl_9W¡ˆwzdy^:_vU

£¶jhd`wzˆbˆbtueuv:wxYyeujz_9Wpwl_9•]N^EWyW\wl‰h^¥ßˆwzW\Wye˜_b‰v'jz].]"ab_euv:wxYyeujz_^:_A‚Veudyjh_b].^'_AY\WrYy b^:U¦d\^'tuUjz_žr½Àe˜Yy Pjzabd

wzˆbˆbd\jhwhv— –xt˜^:‰hwhvU"wzˆbˆbtueuv:wxYyeujz_9W'–l“ 9wxYy^:‚z^:dYy b^pv'jz].]"a_v'wlYyeujz_Nt˜eusbd—wld\UYy b^:Ua9W¡^h–hvjhabtg•s§^rv— b^Ev—·h¥

ˆ§jzeu_AYy^E•¦“e˜Yy jzaXYrv— wz_b‰zeu_b‰NYy b^se˜_wzdyUhž

q

_Y\ beuWrˆwlˆ§^'dE–b“”^®ˆdyjhˆ9jAW¡^(_b^:“7WyUXWZY\^']v:wltutuW£¶jzd3Yyd—wl_9W¡ˆwzdy^:_AY3].^EWyW\wl‰h^¥ßˆwzW\W¡eu_b‰ˆwld—wltut˜^:twlˆX¥

ˆt˜egv'wlYyeujz_W3v— b^Ev—·Aˆ§jzeu_AYyeu_b‰Ne˜_Yy ^ÃÄnÄnŶÆÇÃȪTVe˜_‰ztu^TXUVW¡Yy^:] q]wl‰h^®v't˜aW¡Yy^:d`Á`ˆ9^:d\wlYyeu_b‰TVUXWZY\^']

<‡6>ߞ©Ÿ3 b^pˆdyjhˆ9jAW¡^E•e˜_AY\^'dy£«wzv^®wltut˜jx“rWW¡UXW¡Yy^:] eu_be˜YyegwxY\^:•Œv— ^:v—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AY\e˜_b‰9ž±¬jzd\^'jx‚z^:d:–z£¶dyjh] Yy b^®eu•b^'_X¥

Y\eºœ9^'djl£ *& ˆbdyjXv'^:W\Wjz£§w`ˆwld—wltutu^'tVwlˆbˆbtuegv'wxY\e˜jh_–lwltutVYy ^”jhsXkZ^:vY\W3°¶ˆdyjXv^EWyWy^:W:–l•bwlY\w®WZY\dy^Ewl]W\´_b^:^:•X^E•

Y\j.s9^v— b^Ev—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AYy^E•›£¶jhd3Yy b^“ jztu^®ˆ9wld—wltut˜^:tRwzˆbˆbtueuv:wxY\e˜jh_wzdy^•XegWyv'jx‚z^:dy^E•nž

Ÿ3 b^¦dy^:]wleu_be˜_‰¬jl£Y\ beuWˆwzˆ9^:d"egW"jhdy‰Awl_be@?'^E•whW£¶jht˜tujx“rWATV^EvµYyeujz_­ƒ¬ˆbd\^:Wy^'_AY\Ww™swzv—·V‰hdyjhab_•

jh_­].^:v— 9wl_begW¡]W"£¶jzd.v— b^:v—·Vˆ§jzeu_AYyeu_b‰¾ˆwzd\wzt˜tu^'t3wlˆˆbt˜egv'wlYyeujz_WNwl_9•ª£¶jzd.v— b^Ev—·Aˆ§jzeu_AYyeu_b‰¾ˆdyjXv^EWyWy^:Weu_

ÊŤËÌn͌jzˆ§^'d—wxYyeu_b‰®W¡UXW¡Yy^']žCTV^:vYyeujz_N‡`•X^EWyv'dyeus§^:WYy b^3•X^EW¡eu‰z_jl£9].^Ev— wl_begWy].W“”^ w<‚h^¢eu_AYy^'‰hd\wlYy^E•eu_

ÃÄnÄnŶÆÇÃțeu_jhd\•b^'dY\j`eu].ˆbtu^'].^'_AY©wpv'jAjhd\•be˜_wlYy^E•v— b^:v—·Vˆ§jzeu_AYyeu_b‰`W¡Yyd—wxY\^'‰zU®£¶jhd].^:W\W\wl‰z^'¥Sˆ9wzW\W¡eu_b‰

s9wzWy^:•›ˆ9wld—wltut˜^:t§wzˆbˆbtueuv:wxYyeujz_9W'ž©TV^EvµYyeujz_3BNˆbdy^EW¡^:_AY\W”ˆbd\^'tue˜].eu_wld\U.ˆ9^:d¡£¶jhdy]wl_9v^®dy^EW¡abt˜Y\W”jhsXY\wze˜_b^E•›jh_

Y\ b^ˆbd\jlY\jlYZUVˆ9^®“”^ w<‚z^®e˜].ˆbtu^'].^:_hY\^:•nž©³eu_wltutuUz–9TV^EvµY\e˜jh_….v'jz_v't˜a•b^:W:ž

C0D öFEGHI

"&-)¦4

Ÿ3 ^'d\^pwld\^rW¡^:‚z^:d\wztWZY\d\wlYy^:‰zeu^:W:–lt˜eu·z^`vjVjzd—•Xeu_wxY\^:•Njzdab_vjVjhd\•Xeu_wlYy^:•.v— b^Ev—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AYyeu_b‰ˆdyjzYyjXvjhtuW:–ltujz‰l¥

s9wzWy^:•¬ˆdyjzYyjXvjhtuW:–Y\j™wltut˜jx“ d\jztut˜s9wzv—·¸<d\^:v'jx‚z^'d\Ujl£]N^EWyW\wl‰h^¥ßˆwzW\Wye˜_b‰Œˆwld—wltut˜^:twzˆbˆbtueuv:wxY\e˜jh_W'žŸ3 ^'U

•beR^'d(jz_¬Yy b^.“3w<U¦Y\ b^'U™]wz_wl‰h^"•X^'ˆ§^'_9•X^'_v'e˜^EW(e˜_9vabd\dy^E•™sVU¬vjh]N]ab_begv'wlYyeujz_Wps9^'YZ“^:^'_¬Y\ b^wlˆX¥

ˆt˜egv'wlYyeujz_ˆbdyjXv'^:W\W¡^EW¢Y\j.‰zawzd\wz_hY\^'^`Yy wlYpwN‰ztujzswztRv'jz_WyegWZY\^'_AYrWZY—wxYy^v:wl_s9^d\^:W¡Yyjhdy^E• <B>ߞ

o ^Ev^:_hY\t˜UwtujlY”jl£“”jzd\·" whW©s§^'^:_Œ•Xjz_^rYyj"e˜_AYyd\jX•Xav'^r£«wlatºYYyjztu^'d—wl_9v^].^:v— wz_begW¡]W©eu_›ˆwzd\wzt˜tu^'t

ˆdyjh‰zd—wl].].e˜_b‰p^'_V‚Ve˜d\jz_b].^:_hY—W'–lWyav— NwzW± i©q wl_• i©¼ ±$–xaW¡^E•"eu_Yy b^•Xjh].wze˜_jl£§ be˜‰h "ˆ§^'dy£¶jzd\]wl_v'^

v'jz].ˆbaXY\e˜_‰ž

Ÿ3 b^.‰ht˜jhswltCvjVjhd\•Xeu_wlYy^:•Pv— b^:v—·Vˆ§jzeu_AYyeu_b‰¦W¡Yyd—wxY\^'‰zU™ 9wzW®s9^:^'_e˜].ˆbtu^'].^:_hY\^:•eu_³9wleutuW\wx£¶^ i©¼ ±

<í… >ߖV¹jX¹ b^:v—· <}6>ߖATAY—wldyœ9Wy 1<| >ߖh±

i¢q

¹ Ø ¥¼ ¹ <~>ߖh³Ÿp¹¢¥¡¹ wld\] <6>9wl_9•

m

±P¸l±

i©q

<˜{E„>ߞŸ3 b^

i

wzdyegWTVa9•›ab_beu‚z^:d\Wye˜YZU whW©eu].ˆbt˜^:].^'_AYy^E•›jlY\ b^'d—W¢W\v— b^:]N^®W¡a9v— ŒwzW¢ˆ9^EWyWye˜].egWZY\euv <˜{h{>wl_•Œv'wla9Wywzt.<u{Eƒ >

tujz‰h‰zeu_b‰ž

Ø

jx“”^'‚h^'dE–©vjz].ˆwzdyeu_b‰PYy b^EW¡^™•XeR^'d\^'_AY›WZY\d\wlYy^'‰he˜^EWYy b^:U$ w<‚z^Wy bjx“_­eu_ <˜{<ƒ >Yy wlYYy b^

v'jVjzd—•Xe˜_9wxYy^E•›v— b^Ev—·Aˆ§jzeu_AY3W\v— b^:]N^®jR^'d—WYy b^(s§^:W¡Yrvjz].ˆbtu^šXe˜YZUˆ9^:d¡£¶jhdy]wz_v^pYyd—wz•X^'¥Sjeu_vtuaWZY\^'d—W'ž

W¡eu_b‰Y\ b^:Wy^`v'jz].]"a_beuv:wxY\e˜jh_t˜eusbd—wld\e˜^EW'–hdy^:sbabeutu•Xeu_b‰jhd¢d\^'tue˜_·Aeu_b‰Y\ b^pˆ9wld—wltut˜^:t9wlˆˆbt˜egv'wlYyeujz_egW¢jz£¤Yy^:_

_^'^:•b^:•nž

Ÿ3 b^EW¡^^:_V‚Aeud\jz_b].^'_AY—Wd\^'tuU›jh_¦ˆbd\jXv^EWyWv— b^Ev—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AYyeu_b‰N].^:v— wz_beuWy]W”Yyj›W\w<‚z^`Yy b^W¡Y\wlYy^(jl£^:whv— 

ˆdyjXv^EWyWjl£®w¾ˆwzd\wzt˜tu^'twzˆbˆbtueuv:wxYyeujz_ž$Ÿjªv— b^Ev—·Aˆ§jzeu_AYNwPˆbd\jVv'^:W\WwlYjzˆ§^'d—wxYyeu_b‰W¡UXW¡Yy^'] tu^'‚h^'twl_9•

“e˜Yy jzaXYp].jX•Xe˜œ9v'wlYyeujz_jl£Yy ^"W¡jhabd—v^vjX•X^h–bYy ^'d\^euWrw.“eg•X^d—wl_‰z^(jl£Cw<‚xwleutuwzsbt˜^tueusbd\wzdyeu^:WWyav— ™wzW

¹jh_•Xjhd <˜{E‡6>3jzd Ö ˆ§v—·VˆXY <˜{B>ߞ q _$jhd\•X^:dYyjWyw<‚h^›wl_•$dy^EWZY\jzd\^.Yy b^WZY—wxYy^¦jl£rw¬ˆdyjh‰zd—wl]–w¾“eu•X^

d—wl_‰z^™jl£WyUXWZY\^'] v'wltutgW›wld\^™e˜_AY\^'d—v^'ˆbYy^:•¨eu_jhd\•X^:dYyj­·z^'^:ˆ»Yyd—wzv—·­jz£(Yy b^Pˆbdyjh‰zd—wl] W¡Y\wlYy^­°?W¡a9v— 

whW(].^'].jzd\U¬]wlˆbˆ§^:•d\^'‰he˜jh_Wwl_•Pjzˆ§^'_œtu^ wz_•Xtu^:W—´µž¦TVjh].^›W¡UXW¡Yy^']Wv:wltutuWv:wl_Hs9^.£¶jhdyseu•b•b^'_ž

q _»wz•b•beºY\e˜jh_–CaWy^'dy¥Stu^'‚h^'tv— ^:v—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AY¸<d\^:W¡Y\wldyY].^:v— wz_begW¡]WNv'wl__bjlYNdy^EWZY\jzd\^£¶jzdN^šbwl].ˆbtu^ŒˆdyjXv^EWyW

Wy^:W\Wye˜jh_Œeg•X^'_AYye˜œ^:d:ž

² ¹ o

<u{E…>euW¢w(ˆbdyjzkZ^:vY©jl£R·z^'d\_b^:tº¥ßt˜^:‚z^:tXˆbdyjXv'^:W\WCv— b^:v—·Vˆ§jzeu_hY\e˜_‰`£¶jhdCYy ^`ʢŤËÌͦ·h^'d\_b^'tSž²

¹ o

v:wl_­v— ^:v—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AY"s§jlY\ ­d\^'‰habtuwzd"wl_9•$]"atºY\eºY\ bdy^Ewz•X^E•°¶ˆbYy bd\^:wh•bW\´ˆbd\jz‰zd—wl]W jx“^:‚z^'d"eºY•XjV^:W_bjlY

Wyabˆbˆ§jzdyY¦v— b^Ev—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AYyeu_b‰$wz_•9¸<jhddy^EWZY\jzd\e˜_‰ªjl£ˆbd\jVv'^:W\WaWye˜_‰$jzˆ§^'_Ÿp¹

i ¸ qôi

jzdËÅgÍ •Xjh]wleu_

WyjXv—·z^'Y\W:ž€r^:‚z^:d¡Y\ b^'tu^:W\W'–h² ¹ o

W¡abˆˆ9jhd¡Y—W©wz•b•be˜_b‰ v'wzt˜tuswhv—·VW<Yyja9W¡^:d¡¥ßt˜^:‚z^:tbvjX•X^z–h“ begv— .wzdy^v:wltut˜^E•

“ ^'_wv— b^Ev—·Aˆ§jzeu_AYCeuWwls§jzaXYCY\js9^pˆ9^:d¡£¶jhdy].^:•–hwl_9•“ ^'_e˜Y¢euW©dy^EWZY—wldyYy^:•°¶jhd¢v'wzdyd\eu^:Wjz_wl£¤Yy^'d¢Yy b^

v— ^:v—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AYµ´µžŸ3 euWpeuW jx“7± i¢q vjz].]ab_begv'wxY\e˜jh_™v'wl_s§^ wz_•Xtu^:•sVU›Y\ b^£«wlatºYrY\jztu^'d—wl_AYr‚z^:d\Wyeujz_

jz£ m ±P¸l± i©q ž

TVeu_b‰ht˜^`TXUVW¡Yy^:] q ]wz‰z^jzˆ§^'d—wxY\e˜_‰W¡UXW¡Yy^']W•X^:•Xegv'wlYy^E•"Y\j"vtuaW¡Yy^:d\W¢ w<‚z^3d\^:v^:e˜‚h^:•.wtujlY¢jz£ne˜_AYy^:d¡¥

^EWZYCeu_NYy b^rv't˜aW¡Yy^:d©vjh]N]ab_be˜YZUzžŸ3 b^:Wy^3jzˆ§^'d—wxY\e˜_b‰WyUXWZY\^']W‰ztujzswzt˜tuU]wl_wz‰z^wltutXjzˆ§^'d—wxY\e˜_‰®WyUXWZY\^']

d\^:Wyjzad\v'^:W©Wyav— ŒwhW¢ˆbd\jXv^EWyWy^:W:–z].^'].jhdyUWy^'‰z].^:_hY—W'–V•bwlY\w"W¡Yyd\^:wz]W'–hœtu^:W:–zY\ Aa9W^EwzWye˜_‰"vtuaW¡Yy^'d”aW\wl‰h^

wz_•Nˆbd\jz‰zd—wl].].eu_b‰žÁ`ˆ§^'_§TbT q <ƒ>9wl_•ÂÃbÄnÄnŶÆÇÃbÈ <˜{>9wld\^”YZ“j(^šbwz]Nˆt˜^EWCjl£nW¡a9v— .WyUXWZY\^']WCswhW¡^E•

jh_¬Ê¢Å¤ËÌnÍ©ž ^:‰hwzv'UŒ± i©q wlˆˆbt˜egv'wlYyeujz_Wp•X^:Wye˜‰h_b^:•Œ£¶jzdp]"abt˜Yyeuˆbd\jVv'^:W\W¡jhd3].whv— beu_b^:Wrv:wl_s9^"^šX^:v'aXYy^E•

jh_v't˜a9WZY\^'d—W3“eºY\ bjzaXYpwz_VU›].jV•beºœ9v:wxY\e˜jh_jhddy^Evjh]Nˆe˜tgwxY\e˜jh_ž¢Á`abd‰zjAwltReuWYyj.e˜_AY\^'‰zd—wxY\^(ˆwld—wltut˜^:twlˆX¥

ˆt˜egv'wlYyeujz_W3v— b^Ev—·Aˆ§jzeu_AYµ¸xdy^EWZY—wldyY¢].^:v— wz_beuWy]W”e˜_W¡a9v— ¦wl_¦jzˆ§^'d—wxY\e˜_b‰.WyUVW¡Yy^:] £¶jzd3£¶abtutRYyd—wl_9W¡ˆwzdy^:_vU

wz_•¦e˜_•b^'ˆ§^'_•X^:_v^(£¶d\jz]%wlˆbˆt˜egv'wlYyeujz_W3wl_9•¦v'jz].]"ab_euv:wxYyeujz_tue˜sbd—wld\eu^:W:ž

D

ñ«ëíóßè

! #"%$"'&( ) %

(*+ ! (,+ & " -. /103245

(*+ 67

(,

&8$

-. /103245

" *( ! +9 &8$ 6 -.: 6

; ::9./ 1 <= >& (*+

?

@&

³e˜‰habd\^N{A

o

^:W¡Y\wzd¡YaWy^'dy¥Seu_AYy^:d¡£«whv^®^šbwl].ˆbtu^

A B

3 DC

Á`ad`“”jzd\·™wleu].W(wlY®]wl·Veu_b‰v— b^:v—·Vˆ§jzeu_hY\e˜_‰¦wl_9•¬d\^:W¡Y\wldyYyeu_b‰¦]N^EWyW\wl‰h^¥ßˆwzW\Wye˜_b‰›wzˆbˆbtueuv:wxY\e˜jh_W®^:wzWyUzž

q _vjh_hY\d\whWZYYyj^šXeuW¡Yyeu_b‰Nˆbd\jlkZ^:vY\W:–zY\ b^®£«wlabt˜Y”Yyjztu^'d—wl_9v^p].^Ev— wl_begWy].W”wld\^p^:_AYyeudy^:t˜U.eu]Nˆt˜^:]N^:_AYy^:•¦eu_

Y\ b^Á(T›£¶jzdrwlˆˆbt˜egv'wlYyeujz_Wwz_•¦t˜eusbd—wld\e˜^EWeu_•X^:ˆ9^:_•X^:_v^hž

½^. w<‚z^"•b^œ_b^E•¾wz_•¬eu].ˆbt˜^:].^'_AYy^E•¾wvjz].]wl_9•V¥Stueu_b^"aWy^'d®eu_hY\^'dy£«wzv'^z–nwŒ“3w<U¦Yyjdy^'Yyd\e˜^:‚z^"wzt˜t

ˆdyjXv^EWyWy^:W3jz£©wˆwld—wltutu^'twlˆˆbt˜egv'wlYyeujz_£¶d\jz] *& jz£Y\ b^']–§‰ztujzswztvjVjhd\•Xeu_wlYy^:•v— b^Ev—·Aˆ§jzeu_AYyeu_b‰›wl_9•

d\^:W¡Y\wzd¡Y\e˜_‰ˆbd\jlY\jXvjztgW:ž³eu_wltut˜Uh–XYy ^dy^EWZY\jzd—wxYyeujz_Œjl£jzˆ§^'_WZY\dy^Ewl]W3 wzW3s§^'^:_dy^Ewltue"?:^:•nž

EGFIH JLKNMPORQTSVUXWZY\[^]_M.`aKNb c3deKNfhgDijUTOkST`ml5noKNM.`aYqpa`9r.S^`aKphWYsftK

Ÿ3 ^v— b^Ev—·Aˆ§jzeu_AYµ¸xdy^EWZY—wldyYre˜_AYy^:d¡£«whv^]aW¡Y®s§^Wye˜].ˆbtu^.wl_•™^EwzWyUŒY\jŒaWy^zž(Ÿ3 VaW`“^ w<‚z^"v— jhWy^'_Yyj

a9W¡^®Yy ^Wywz]N^(eu_AYy^'dy£«wzv'^®£¶jzdˆwzd\wzt˜tu^'tnwlˆˆbt˜egv'wlYyeujz_Wwz_•W¡^Efha^'_AYyegwltnˆbd\jXv^EWyWy^:W:ž

Ÿjrv— b^:v—·Vˆ§jzeu_AYwl_wlˆbˆt˜egv'wlYyeujz_–:“^©Wyab‰z‰h^:W¡YnYy b^£¶jht˜tujx“eu_b‰vjz].]wl_9•V¥Stueu_b^Ce˜_AY\^'dy£«wzv^Duvxwxuy.zx{}| ~a

€{zat|{~t‚ƒzt|„§–z'|„s§^'eu_b‰(Yy ^pˆbd\jXv^:W\Weg•X^'_AYye˜œ^:d¢jl£ *& jl£RYy b^pˆwld—wltut˜^:tbwlˆbˆt˜egv'wlYyeujz_.ˆbd\jVv'^:W\W¡^EW'ž

Á`ˆbYyeujz_†… za‡h{xuwxPa…{~}ˆ‰­°«jzdŠ… zb´Nwzt˜tujx“rWY\jªv— b^:v—·Vˆ§jzeu_hY.jz_t˜U­wWy^:fAab^'_AY\euwzt”ˆdyjXv^EWyW:ž­½Àe˜Yy jzaXY

Y\ b^jzˆbYyeujz_–XY\ b^ˆwzd\wzt˜tu^'twzˆbˆbtueuv:wxY\e˜jh_¦£¶d\jz_AY\e˜^:deuWrv:wltgvabtgwxY\^:•wzWr•b^:W\vd\e˜s§^:•eu_™TX^:vµY\e˜jh_¬‡bžíƒXž”ÁpY\ b^'d

jhˆXYyeujz_9W^'_wzsbtu^YyjŒv— jAjAW¡^®Y\ b^"W¡Yyjzd—wl‰h^(]N^E•Xegw¬°R…‹tw„}|ŒsŽ„}|y_‘‹mw‹t{‡‰m’l´µ–zYyjŒwh•b•w›v— b^:v—·Vˆ§jzeu_AY

•b^:W\vd\e˜ˆXY\e˜jh_P°I…„@“ „PwxPu‡t|1zat|{~“<´wl_9•›Y\j.v'dy^EwxY\^®wNv— b^:v—·Vˆ§jzeu_AY”“ begv— euW3^'šVˆ§jzdyY\wzsbtu^pY\j.wz_bjlY\ b^'d

v't˜a9WZY\^'d°R…w.”zx{‡PhŒ•}ˆ.wV´ž

m

“3w<U£¶jzdˆ§^'d\e˜jX•Xegv'wzt˜tuU¾v— b^Ev—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AYyeu_b‰wl_Hwlˆbˆt˜egv'wlYyeujz_euW(Y\jtuwzab_v— eºY“e˜Yy Yy euWeu_AYy^:d¡£«whv^ A

‡hwaˆx|Œ•}ˆwa–‡.—P~ €{zat|{~t‚˜… zhw.‡t|{„}|ua|P‰Ph™šu{‹P‹tŒ~h„§–

s9^:e˜_‰®w`ˆwxYyYy^:dy_jl£ˆ§^'d\e˜jX•Xegve˜YZUwl_9•

u{‹P‹tŒ~h„ps9^:e˜_b‰pYy b^”ab_b].jX•Xe˜œ^:•Nvjh].].wz_•(Y\jptgwlab_v— "Yy b^3wlˆˆbt˜egv'wlYyeujz_ž qYwzt˜tujx“rW ›6œ 0)7

(-(/*0 ž

Ÿ3 b^”aWy^'dv'wl_v— bjVjhWy^CYy b^3v— b^Ev—·Aˆ§jzeu_AY£¶d\jz] “ begv— Yyj`dy^EWZY\jzd\^CYy ^wlˆˆbt˜egv'wlYyeujz_eu_wpt˜egW¡YWy bjx“e˜_‰

e˜Y\WpWyw<‚Veu_b‰N•wxYy^wz_•¦•b^:W\vd\e˜ˆXY\e˜jh_°?W¡^:^³e˜‰habdy^.{<´wl£¤Yy^:d^šX^:v'aXYyeu_b‰.Yy ^j‡awxhŒ.‡.vjh].].wz_•nž

C0D öFEGHI

EGF U7`aU@n<K`Pp}ORKTK =phUGftKNMPMKNM UXWZYsSoiei kOIftY `hORUTS

Ÿ3 ^Á(T_b^'^E•bWYyj(•X^Y\^:vµY©wzt˜tVˆbd\jXv^:W\Wy^:Wjz£§wz_wlˆˆbt˜egv'wlYyeujz_£¶d\jz] Y\ b^3ˆbeg•jl£ *& jl£bY\ b^'] sVUtujVjz·Ve˜_‰

wlY3œt˜egwxY\e˜jh_t˜eu_b·XWwl_•vjh].]"ab_begv'wlYyeujz_WZY\dy^Ewl]W3eu_¦jhd\•X^:d3Yyjv— b^Ev—·Aˆ§jzeu_AYrwˆ9wld—wltut˜^:tRwzˆbˆbtueuv:wxY\e˜jh_ž

q _­wPTbT q vtuaW¡Yy^:d.Á(THWyav— $wzWNÃbÄnÄnŶÆÇÃbÈC–Cˆbd\jXv^EWyWy^:Wwz_•$W¡Yyd\^:wz].W"v'wl_ªs§^Œ].eu‰zd—wxY\^:• <u{:}6>

£¶d\jz] jh_b^®_bjX•X^®Yyj.wl_bjzYy b^:d:ž©TVjYy b^•XeR^'d\^'_AYˆbdyjXv'^:W\W¡^EW¢jz£wNˆwld—wltut˜^:t§wzˆbˆbtueuv:wxY\e˜jh_¦v'wz_Œs§^W¡ˆbd\^:wh•

jh_Œ]wl_VU_bjX•X^EW'–X^:‚z^:_Œe˜£Yy ^'d\^®wzdy^`œtueuwlYyeujz_Œtueu_b·XW3s9^'YZ“^:^'_›Y\ b^(ˆbd\jVv'^:W\W¡^EW'ž m ˆbd\jVv'^:W\W–bv'dy^EwxYy^E•

sVUŒYy b^a{.‡PyŒWyUVW¡Yy^:]v:wltutn£¶dyjh] ˆbd\jXv^EWyW # –begWpw * jl£ˆbdyjXv'^:W\W # ž q£ # wz_• wld\^_bjlYrd\ab_b_e˜_b‰

jh_¾Y\ b^Wywz].^N_jV•b^z–egWw

œ *

Wyjz_jl£”ˆbdyjXv'^:W\W

#

^:tuWy^ egWw

!"* (!

Wyjz_Pjl£3ˆbd\jVv'^:W\W

# ž q

£”w

ˆdyjXv^EWyW

+

egWrw.W¡jh_¦jz£r–

+

euWw

7($7

jl£ˆbd\jVv'^:W\W¡^EW,wz_•

# ž

Ÿjw<‚hjzeg•™v— b^:v—·Vˆ§jzeu_AYyeu_b‰Yy ^“ bjht˜^NW¡UXW¡Yy^:]–w¦W¡jht˜abYyeujz_¬egW`Yyj¦v— ^:v—·Yy b^`ÇÃŤË! #"$AÃ

v:wlˆwzsbeut˜e˜YZUzž

m

ˆbd\jXv^EWyW¦v'wlˆ9wlsbeut˜e˜YZU <˜{x|>(euWw$ˆdyjXv^EWyW¦wxYyYyd\e˜sbabYy^¬Y\ wxY™v'wz_s§^Wy^YE–rab_Wy^YE–`wl_9•

eu_b b^:dye˜Yy^E•nžr²”U¦•X^'£«wlabt˜Y:–Rwˆbd\jXv^EWyWr•bjA^EWr_bjzYp w<‚h^(Yy b^`ÇÃ%ŤË& #"$hÃv:wlˆwzsbe˜tue˜YZUŒ“ begv— ¬v'wz_

s§^^:_wlsbtu^:•sVUw›vjh]N]wz_•t˜eu_b^£¶jhdr^:whv— ˆdyjXv^EWyWrjl£©wlˆbˆt˜egv'wlYyeujz_Wtgwla_v— b^:•tgwxY\^'d£¶d\jz] wW¡ ^'tut?ž

q£CwNˆbd\jVv'^:W\W3•XjV^:W_bjzY w<‚z^`Yy b^'`ÇÃŤË& #"%$AÃv'wzˆwlsbeutueºYZU›e˜Yr“eut˜t_jlYs9^v— ^:v—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AY\^:•nž

m ˆbd\jXv^EWyW“ begv— ._b^'^E•bWYyjs§^rv— b^Ev—·Aˆ§jzeu_AYy^E•"sbabY©“ bjhWy^”£«wxYy ^'dCˆbd\jXv^:W\WegWC_bjlY©v— b^Ev—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AY\wzsbtu^

egW¢w - 7 ** °¤£¶jhd¢^šbwz]Nˆt˜^h–hˆbd\jXv^EWyWy^:Wp{pwl_•4Be˜_¦³eu‰zady^`ƒ“ beuv— ¦W¡ bjx“rWwˆwzd\wzt˜tu^'t§wlˆbˆbtuegv'wxY\e˜jh_

Y\js9^›v— b^Ev—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AYy^E•´µž m ˆbd\jXv^EWyW®“ bjAW¡^£«wxY\ b^'degW(d\^'].jlY\^.wz_•P_b^'^E•bW®Yyj™s§^v— b^:v—·Vˆ§jzeu_hY\^:•PeuWw

!@*(!$* * °¤£¶jzd”eu_WZY—wl_v'^z–Vˆbd\jXv^:W\W|e˜_³eu‰zady^`ƒbž½P^®v'wltutu^:• )(* $!')( )* wt˜jXv'wzt9d\jVjlY¢ˆdyjXv^EWyW

wz_•wltutneºY—Wt˜jXv:wlt•X^EWyv'^'_•bwz_AY\W:ž

³dyjh] *$ jz£`Y\ b^¾wzˆbˆbtueuv:wxYyeujz_»ˆbd\jXv^:W\Wy^:W:–©Yyd—w<‚z^:d\Wyeu_b‰PtujXv'wztpwl_•»d\^'].jlY\^œt˜egwxY\e˜jh_»Yyd\^'^¬wl_9•

v— ^:v—·Ve˜_‰Yy b^`ÇÃŤË+! #"$hÛv'wlˆ9wlsbeut˜e˜YZUz–A“”^rœ_• *& jz£nYy b^`ˆwld—wltutu^'t9wzˆbˆbtueuv:wxY\e˜jh_ - 74**ž

Ÿ3 ^'_–V“”^®wh•b•Œwzt˜t§Yy ^`tujXv'wltnwz_•›d\^'].jlY\^`•X^EWyv'^'_•wl_AY\Wjl£Y\ begW3ˆbdyjXv'^:W\W©Y\j"Y\ b^`tuegWZYjl£ˆbdyjXv'^:W\W¡^EWCYyj

s§^v— b^Ev—·Aˆ§jzeu_AYy^E•nž

½À b^:_¯w™ˆdyjXv^EWyW"jl£Y\ beuWtueuW¡YegW"wlY¡Y\whv— b^:•ªYyj¾wPWZY\dy^Ewl]-, “^v— b^:v—·e˜£Yy b^¦jlYy ^'dNˆbdyjXv'^:W\W¡^EW

wlY¡Y—wzv— b^E•®Yyj.,wld\^¢wltud\^:wz•bU`eu_Yy ^tueuW¡Y:ž

Ö

tgW¡^h–xeº£bˆdyjXv^EWyWy^:W w<‚z^©Yy b^/`ÇÃ%ŤË& #"$hÃ"v'wlˆ9wlsbeut˜e˜YZUz–

“”^p‰hj"abˆ¦e˜_ŒYy b^®tujVv:wltRwl_•Œdy^:].jlYy^pœtueuwlYyeujz_Y\dy^:^`tujVjz·Ve˜_‰£¶jzdwl_jlYy ^'d¢ ^:wz•ŒdyjVjzYˆbd\jXv^:W\W:ž

q

£e˜Y3euW

Y\ b^Wywz].^` b^Ewz•ŒdyjVjlYE–XWZY\dy^Ewl]0,$v'wz_Œs§^®eu‰z_jzd\^:•›eu_¦Yy b^(ˆwzd\wzt˜tu^'tRwlˆbˆt˜egv'wlYyeujz_›£¶d\jz_AY\e˜^:d3v:wltgvabtgwxY\e˜jh_

s§^:v:wlaWy^©e˜YegWd\^:•Xa_•bwl_AY“e˜Yy œt˜egwxY\e˜jh_ž q_³eu‰zady^ƒb–xWZY\dy^Ewl]1,32"euWe˜‰h_bjzd\^:•®eu_£¶dyjh_AYyeu^'dv:wltgvabtgwxY\e˜jh_

eu_™vjh_hY\d\whWZY3“e˜Yy ™WZY\dy^Ewl],4zž

EGFE ˜ORKNphYqpxfxd OIftY c%UDUXp%5eOISeY `PK5 c d_KNfxg ijU^OIS^`,YsS/5 noKNM.`aYqpa`

6#786#7:9 ; ÓÓ xÔ<:=XŽ Ï Ô¨‘?> Ï ‘A@B Ó <:=RŽ

Ÿ3 ^v— b^Ev—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AYyeu_b‰ˆbd\jlYyjXv'jzt”euW.•Xeu‚Veu•X^E•­eu_¯Yy bd\^'^WZY\^'ˆW3AH°Z{<´Y\jd\^Y\dyeu^'‚h^¦wzt˜t3ˆbd\jXv^:W\Wy^:Wjl£`wz_

wzˆbˆbtueuv:wxY\e˜jh_»wz_•­]wz·z^Yy b^:]Wyt˜^:^'ˆbeu_b‰Heu_»jhd\•b^'dNYyj$W¡Yyjhˆ»v'jz].]"ab_euv:wxYyeujz_9W'–®°?ƒz´Y\j$v— b^:v—·Vˆ§jzeu_AY

Y\ b^']–°?‡h´Y\j.v'jz].].eºYY\ b^v— b^Ev—·Aˆ§jzeu_AY”e˜£©W¡a9v'v^EWyW¡£¶abtut?ž

€pjˆdyjXv^EWyW® whWwvjz].ˆbtu^Y\^.·A_jx“t˜^E•X‰z^Njl£”ˆbdyjXv'^:W\W¡^EW`eu_V‚zjht˜‚h^:•™eu_Yy b^›v— b^Ev—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AY:ž.³bd\jz] w

d\jVjlY”ˆbdyjXv'^:W\W'–V“”^®v:wld\^`wls§jzabYw“ bjht˜^(W¡asX¥ßwzˆbˆbtueuv:wxY\e˜jh_Œwl_•Œdy^:].jlYy^(Wyjz_W”jl£Yy b^WyabsX¥ôwlˆbˆbtuegv'wxY\e˜jh_

ˆdyjXv^EWyWy^:W®sbabY“^•Xj_bjzY·A_jx“ eº£3d\^'].jlY\^.Wyjz_9W( w<‚z^.•X^:W\v^:_•bwz_hYjhd_bjlYEž›Ÿ3 b^.e˜_X£¶jhdy]wlYyeujz_euW

•beuW¡Yyd\e˜saXYy^E•nž

D

ñ«ëíóßè

Node A Node B

3 2

1 4

5 6

7

S2 S1

8

9

Process

Remote filiation Local filiation

Parallel application frontier Communication stream Process without Checkpointable capability

³e˜‰habdy^ƒA m ˆ9wld—wltut˜^:tRwzˆbˆbtueuv:wxY\e˜jh_¦d\ab_b_beu_b‰.jz_¬ÂÃbÄnÄnŶÆÇÃbÈ

³eud\W¡Yjl£”wzt˜tS–Y\ b^.ˆwld—wltutu^'tCwlˆbˆt˜egv'wlYyeujz_P£¶dyjh_hY\e˜^:d(euWv:wltgvabtgwxY\^:•n–nY\ b^'_HwltutYy ^›wlˆbˆbtuegv'wxY\e˜jh_¾ˆbd\jl¥

v'^:W\W¡^EW w<‚h^Cs9^:^'_NWZY\jzˆbˆ§^:•d\^:v'^'eu‚Ve˜_b‰`wrW¡eu‰z_9wltSžŸ3 b^'_–<£¶jzdY\ b^3Wywz·z^Cjl£v— ^:v—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AY\e˜_b‰pˆ9^:d¡£¶jhdy]wl_9v^z–

wrˆbdyjXv'^:W\Wwl_9•(eºY—WtujXv'wltA•X^:W\v^:_•bwz_hY—Wwzdy^¢v— ^:v—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AY\^:•®e˜_"ˆwld—wltut˜^:tz“e˜Yy d\^'].jzYy^¢•X^EWyv'^'_•wl_AY\W°«wl_9•

Y\ b^'eudd\^'tgwxYyeu‚z^(tue˜_^®jz£•b^:W\v^'_AYµ´µž

½À b^:_d\^:v^:e˜‚Veu_b‰$w$WyabsX¥ôwlˆbˆt˜egv'wlYyeujz_Àv— b^:v—·Vˆ§jzeu_AY›dy^Efha^:W¡Y›£¶jzdwHt˜jXv'wztpd\jVjlY›ˆbd\jXv^:W\W –”_bjh_

st˜jXv—·Ve˜_‰NˆdyjXv^EWyW3v— b^Ev—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AYdy^EfAab^:W¡Y\Wwzdy^Wy^'_AY£¶jzdrwzt˜tne˜Y\WtujXv'wzt•X^:W\v^:_•bwz_hY—Wwl_•¦_bjh_st˜jXv—·Ve˜_‰

WyabsX¥ôwlˆˆbt˜egv'wlYyeujz_"v— ^:v—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AYdy^Efha^:W¡Y\W£¶jzdwltutAYy b^3d\^'].jlY\^”Wyjz_Wjl£Yy b^EW¡^”ˆbd\jVv'^:W\W¡^EW'ž½À b^'_ˆ9jAW¡e˜Yyeu‚z^

d\^'ˆt˜eu^:W®£¶d\jz] wzt˜t©Yy b^›•X^EWyv'^'_•wl_AY\W( w<‚h^s§^'^:_Hdy^Ev^'eu‚z^E•n–wˆ§jhWyeºY\e˜‚h^.dy^:ˆbt˜U¾euWWy^'_AY(£¶d\jz] Yyj™e˜Y\W

Wyjztuegve˜Yyjzd.°¶tujXv'wzt©v— b^:v—·Vˆ§jzeu_hY(vjh]N].e˜Y—´ž½À b^:_wzt˜tC ^:wz•¾dyjVjzY®ˆbd\jXv^EWyWy^:W` w<‚z^NtujVv:wltut˜U¬v'jz].].eºYyYy^E•

Y\ b^'eudrv— b^Ev—·Aˆ§jzeu_AY:–VY\ b^v— b^:v—·Vˆ§jzeu_AY3egW”£¶abtut˜Uvjh]N].e˜Y¡Y\^:•nž

m WptujXv'wltd\jAjzYpˆbd\jXv^:W\Wy^:Wpwzdy^vjVjzd—•Xeu_wxY\jzd—W”£¶jzd`Yy b^:e˜d®dy^EW¡ˆ§^:vYyeu‚z^"Wyabswzˆbˆbtueuv:wxY\e˜jh_–Y\ b^v'jVjzd—•Xeº¥

_9wxYyeujz_egW3 be˜^:d\wzd\v— euv:wltSž

6#786#7 ŒÏ 'ŽEX<Ž

³jzd®^:whv— ¬dy^EWZY—wldyYy^E•™ˆbd\jVv'^:W\W –§“”^N].wz·z^_bjz_Psbt˜jXv—·Veu_b‰Œd\^:fAab^EWZY—WrY\j¦d\^:W¡Yyjhdy^"wzt˜ttujXv'wltWyjz_W®jl£

wz_•$Wy^'_•$_bjz_$st˜jXv—·Ve˜_‰¬dy^EfAab^:W¡Y\W"YyjPdy^EWZY\jzd\^Yy b^W¡asX¥ßwzˆbˆbtueuv:wxY\e˜jh_Wjz£r“ beuv— $Yy b^t˜jXv:wlt”dyjVjlYeuW

wd\^'].jzYy^›Wyjz_jl£ žŸ3 ^.£¶jztut˜jx“eu_b‰™WZY\^'ˆ$v'jz_WyeuW¡Y\We˜_H“3wle˜Yyeu_b‰™dy^:ˆbtue˜^EW(£¶dyjh] Y\ b^›•X^:W\v^:_•bwz_hY—W(Yyj

v'jz].].eºYY\ b^(dy^EWZY\jzd—wxY\e˜jh_ž o ^:W¡Y\wldyYyeu_b‰.s§^'‰zeu_W3“e˜Yy Yy ^wlˆbˆbtuegv'wxY\e˜jh_¦ ^:wz•¦d\jAjzY\W3ˆbd\jXv^EWyWy^:W:ž

²”^£¶jhdy^v— b^:v—·Vˆ§jzeu_hY\e˜_‰–'ˆdyjXv^EWyWy^:W w<‚z^Cs§^'^:_"•X^'ˆt˜jxUh^:•®sVUpY\ b^”ÃbÄnÄnŶÆÇÃbț‰ztujzswztxY\whW¡·(W\v— b^:•V¥

at˜^:djzdsVU›Y\ b^ˆbd\jz‰zd—wl].].^'dEžCŸ3 wxYegW“ VUŒˆbd\jXv^EWyWy^:W3wld\^(dy^EWZY—wldyYy^E•Œjh_ŒY\ b^'eudrjzd\eu‰zeu_wltR^šX^EvaXY\e˜jh_

_jV•b^z–e˜£ˆ§jhW\W¡eusbtu^z–RY\jd\^:Wyˆ§^:vµY®Yy ^Njhdyeu‰zeu_wzt•X^:ˆbtujxUA].^:_hYEž Ø jx“^:‚z^'dE–nwxY®Yy b^NY\e˜].^.jl£”dy^EWZY\jzd—wxYyeujz_–

ˆdyjXv^EWyWy^:W:–l“ begv— .“^:dy^ˆdy^:‚Aeujza9W¡tuUd\ab_b_beu_b‰jz_w(£«wze˜tu^:•N_bjX•X^h–Awzdy^3d\^:W¡Y\wzd¡Y\^:•Njz_NYy ^r_bjX•X^r bjAWZY\e˜_‰

C0D öFEGHI

A B C 1

2 3 4

5

6

A B C

1

2 3 4

5

6

³eu‰zabd\^‡A

i

wld—wltut˜^:t©wlˆbˆt˜egv'wlYyeujz_s9^'£¶jzd\^.wz_•Hwx£¤Y\^'dwdy^EWZY\jzd—wxY\e˜jh_¾“e˜Yy £¶^'“”^'d_bjX•X^EW°«€pjV•b^euW

jhaXYjl£jzd—•X^'dµ´

Y\ b^'eudrˆwzdy^:_AYrˆbdyjXv'^:W\W'ž¢³eu‰zabd\^‡Wy bjx“rWwl_™^'šXwz].ˆbt˜^jz£wz_™wlˆbˆbtuegv'wxY\e˜jh_ˆbdy^:‚Ve˜jhaW¡tuU›d\ab_b_beu_b‰jh_‡

_jV•b^:W3“ begv— euW3d\^:W¡Y\wzd¡Y\^:•›jh_jz_btuU¦ƒ_bjX•X^:W:ž

EGF 9ijKNS [ `aphKYsb\M noKNM.`PUTphY `aOIUTS

ÃÄnÄnŶÆÇÃÈHˆbd\jx‚Aeg•X^EW•bwxY—wWZY\dy^Ewl]W3“eºY\ ™^šVYyd\^'].e˜Yyeu^:W“ euv— ™v'wz_s9^].jx‚h^:•¦£¶dyjh] jh_b^_bjX•X^(Yyj

wz_bjlY\ b^'d(wl_9•¾wld\^"eg•X^:_hY\eºœ9^:•¬sVU¬wŒab_begfha^N_Vab]s9^:d <u{:~>Sž"Ÿ3 euW®eg•X^'_AYye˜œ^:d®]w<Us§^Nwzt˜d\^:wh•XUe˜_PaW¡^

wlY`Y\ b^.Yyeu].^.jl£d\^:W¡Yyjhd\wlYyeujz_ž½^.aWy^.wWy wld\^:•¾ wzWy AY\wlst˜^Njz_P“ beuv— PYy ^N·h^'U™egW®Yy b^.jhtu•WZY\dy^Ewl]

eg•X^:_hY\eºœ9^'dwl_•P•bwxY—wŒegW`Yy b^._b^:“ÉW¡Yyd\^:wz]%eg•X^:_hY\eºœ9^'dEž½À b^'_d\^:W¡Y\wldyYyeu_b‰9–§e˜£”w¦ˆbd\jXv^:W\W`_b^'^E•bW`Yyjs9^

se˜_•b^:•YyjwWZY\dy^Ewl]–e˜Y`tujVjz·XWrwlYrYy b^jztg•™WZY\dy^Ewl]eu•X^:_AYye˜œ^'d`e˜_™Y\ b^ whW¡ AY—wlsbtu^"wl_9•eº£Ce˜Y®•XjV^:Wp_bjlY

^'šXeuW¡Y:–3w_b^'“ WZY\dy^Ewl] egW›vd\^:wlYy^E•nž m YYy b^™^:_•»jl£`d\^:W¡Yyjhd\wlYyeujz_­Yy b^™ whW¡ AY—wlsbtu^v:wl_¨s§^¬•X^'tu^Y\^:•nž

±¬^Yy jV•WpaWy^:•¬Yyj¦sbe˜_9•¾wl_9•¾•X^'Y\wzv— Pw›ˆbd\jXv^:W\WY\j¦w¦WZY\dy^Ewl] e˜_v'whW¡^jz£¢].e˜‰hd\wlYyeujz_¬wzdy^"Yy b^.Wywz].^

£¶jhd`v— b^Ev—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AYµ¸xdy^EWZY—wldyY:ž m dy^EWZY\jzd\^:•™vjh].]"ab_begv'wlYyeujz_¬W¡Yyd\^:wz]%•XjV^EWp_bjzY`eu].ˆbt˜U™wz_AUjx‚z^:dy ^:wz•jh_

v'jz].ˆbaXY—wxY\e˜jh_Wye˜_9v^®Yy b^:dy^egW3_bj.].^:W\Wywz‰z^`£¶jzd\“”wzd\•be˜_b‰9ž

`"!¦)

m ˆbd\jlY\jlYZUVˆ§^ whW(s9^:^'_e˜].ˆbtu^'].^:_hY\^:•eu_HÃbÄnÄnŶÆÇÃbÈÀTT q Á(T <‡>Sž.Ÿ3 begW(ˆbd\jlYyjzYZUVˆ9^Ne˜_9vtua•X^:Ww

v— ^:v—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AY¸<d\^:W¡Y\wldyY`a9W¡^:d¡¥ße˜_AY\^'dy£«wzv^°«Wy^'^›TV^EvµY\e˜jh_H‡ž˜{<´µ–ˆ9wld—wltut˜^:twzˆbˆbtueuv:wxY\e˜jh_¾£¶d\jz_AYyeu^'dv:wltgvabtgwxY\e˜jh_

°?W¡^:^TX^:vµY\e˜jh_»‡žƒh´“ euv— ¨•XjV^:WN_bjzY.Uh^YNY\wz·z^v'wld\^jl£`W¡Yyd\^:wz].W:–©jhˆ9^:_»W¡Yyd\^:wz].Wd\^:W¡Yyjzd—wxY\e˜jh_ °«Wy^'^

TX^:vµY\e˜jh_$‡bžBA´`£¶jhd {xuyhwPWZY\dy^Ewl]W'–‰ztujzswzt© beu^'d—wld—v— begv'wlt©v'jVjzd—•Xe˜_9wxYyeujz_Hv— b^Ev—·Aˆ§jzeu_AYyeu_b‰¬wl_9•

d\^:W¡Yyjhd\wlYyeujz_¾°?W¡^:^"TV^:vYyeujz_‡bž‡h´ž

Ÿ3 begWNW¡^EvµYyeujz_ªˆdy^EW¡^:_hY—W^šXˆ§^'d\e˜].^:_hY—Wd\^:wzt˜e@?'^E•¾Y\j¾^:‚<wzt˜a9wxYy^Œjzabd"wzt˜‰hjzd\eºY\ b]W'–Yyj¾]N^EwzWyabd\^Yy b^

W¡Yyjhd\wz‰z^©eu].ˆwzvYCjz_"ˆ§^'dy£¶jzd\]wl_v'^z–<Y\j®‚xwzt˜eg•bwxY\^”wzˆbˆbtueuv:wxY\e˜jh_"d\^:W¡Yyjzd—wxY\e˜jh_“e˜Yy bjhaXYC_bjX•X^¢£«wze˜tuabd\^:Wwl_9•

Y\j.‚z^'d\e˜£¶UŒWZY\dy^Ewl] d\^:W¡Yyjhd\wlYyeujz_ž

D

ñ«ëíóßè

eFIH GijKpxOkb@KNS^`PY c%UTS/5 O`hORU^SeM

Ö šVˆ§^'d\eu]N^:_AY\wxY\e˜jh_WN w<‚z^Œs9^:^'_¨•Xjz_b^aWye˜_‰v't˜aW¡Yy^:d\Wjl£(ƒ™Y\j B_bjX•X^:WNvjh].]"ab_begv'wlYyeu_b‰PYy bd\jzab‰h 

Ö Yy b^:dy_b^'Y`{E„z„(±™sbe˜Yµ¸lW'žCŸ3 b^r_jV•b^:W¢wzdy^ˆ§^'d—Wyjz_wztvjh]NˆaXYy^:d\W¢“eºY\  i ^:_AYyeuab] q¡q ¹ i wz_•›…X{<ƒ(±¬²

jz£].^'].jhdyUhž

Ÿ3 b^›ÂÃbÄnÄnŶÆÇÃbÈ»‰ht˜jhswltY—wzWy·¾Wyv— ^:•Xabtu^'d(egW•XegWywzsbt˜^E•¾•Xadyeu_b‰Yy b^^'šXˆ9^:dyeu].^'_AY\W:žNTVjY\ b^'d\^.euW

_jˆbd\^'^'].ˆXY\e˜‚h^ˆbd\jVv'^:W\W©].eu‰zd—wxYyeujz_wz_•.ˆbd\jVv'^:W\W¡^EWCwld\^pWyˆbdy^Ewz•£¶jztutujx“e˜_b‰(Y\ begW©d\abt˜^ AwWyjz_ˆdyjXv^EWyW

d\ab_W®jh_¾_bjX•X^

n+ 1 ^]NjX•Xat˜j N^– N s§^'eu_b‰Yy ^Y\jlY—wlt_Vab]"s§^'d(jl£_bjX•X^:W(wl_9•

nY\ b^._bjX•X^N“ beuv— 

 jhW¡Y\W3e˜Y\Wˆwzdy^:_AY”ˆbd\jXv^EWyW:ž

¹ b^Ev—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AYyeu_b‰Yyeu].^:W3d\^:WyabtºY”£¶d\jz] Yy ^(w<‚h^'d—wl‰h^rjl£C…"v'jz_Wy^:v'aXYyeu‚z^®].^:wzWyabd\^'].^'_AY—W'ž

o

^:W¡Y\wzd¡Y\e˜_‰

Y\e˜].^ whW3s9^:^'_].^:whW¡abd\^:•¦wx£¤Y\^'drd\^'s§jVjlYyeu_b‰N^:whv— ¦_bjX•X^EW3jl£Yy b^v't˜a9WZY\^'dEž

Ù

abd\e˜_b‰H^'šVˆ§^'d\eu]N^:_AY\W:–¢]wl_VU$W¡Yyjzd—wl‰h^¦wzˆbˆbd\jhwzv— ^:W w<‚z^s9^:^'_»aWy^:•nž¨Ÿ3 b^™€p³CT»v^:_hY\d\wzt˜e@?'^E•

Wy^'d\‚z^:d"aWy^:•$YyjHWZY\jzd\^¦v— b^Ev—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AY"œ9t˜^EW"egWN^šVYy^:dy_wzt¢Y\j¾Y\ b^™vtuaW¡Yy^'dEžH½À b^'_¯Yy ^v— bjAW¡^:_­W¡Yyjzd—wl‰h^

wzˆbˆbd\jhwhv— euWYy ^®a9W¡^®jl£Yy b^®_bjX•X^:W”tujXv'wltR wzd\•¦•Xd\e˜‚h^:W¢£¶jzd\].wlY¡Y\^:•›a9W¡eu_b‰Yy b^ 4¦œ9t˜^'¥ßWyUXWZY\^']–VYy b^

v— ^:v—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AYœtu^:Wp]"aW¡Yps§^]wl_Vawzt˜tuU¦v'jzˆbeu^:•jz_¬wzt˜t_bjX•X^:Wrjl£Yy b^WZY\jzd—wl‰z^(s§^£¶jhdy^Y\ b^d\^:W¡Yyjhd\wlYyeujz_

v:wl_¦Y\wz·z^(ˆbtgwzv^hž

eF noKNM `hM

q

_MwHœd—WZYŒ^'šXˆ9^:dyeu].^'_AY:–“”^¾ w<‚h^¬vjh]Nˆ9wld\^:•¯YZ“j¯v— b^:v—·Vˆ§jzeu_hY\e˜_‰$wltu‰zjzd\e˜Yy b]WA¾Y\ b^¬œd—W¡YŒjz_b^¾euW

Y\d\w<‚h^'d—W¡eu_b‰Yy ^Yyd\^'^›jz£rˆbd\jVv'^:W\W¡^EW®£¶dyjh] Y\ b^Œd\jVjlYwz_•ªv— b^Ev—·Aˆ§jzeu_AY\W^Ewzv— ªˆbd\jXv^EWyWjh_b^Œwl£¤Yy^'d"Yy b^

jzYy b^:d:–zYy b^rWy^:v'jz_•Njh_b^euW©Yyd—w<‚z^:d\Wye˜_‰pY\ b^3Yyd\^'^rjz£§ˆdyjXv^EWyWy^:W:–zWy^'_•be˜_b‰_jz_.sbtujVv—·Veu_b‰ˆbd\jXv^:W\WCv— b^Ev—·h¥

ˆ§jzeu_AY›dy^EfAab^:W¡Y\W.wl_9•­Y\ b^'_¨“3wle˜Yyeu_b‰£¶jzd›whv—·A_jx“t˜^E•X‰z].^'_AY—W'ž m Wwzˆbˆbtueuv:wxY\e˜jh_¯ˆbd\jXv^EWyWy^:Wwzdy^•XegWZ¥

ˆ9wxY\v— ^:•¨jz_Yy b^•XeR^'d\^'_AY_bjX•X^:WŒjl£Yy ^PvtuaW¡Yy^:d:–pWy^'_9•Xe˜_‰$_bjz_ sbt˜jXv—·Veu_b‰­v— b^Ev—·Aˆ§jzeu_AYŒd\^:fAab^:W¡Y\W

j§^:d\W¢jl£v'jzabd—W¡^ps9^'Y¡Yy^:d3dy^EW¡abt˜Y\W¢Yy 9wl_›“3wle˜Yyeu_b‰"Wy^:fAab^:_hY\euwzt˜tuUN£¶jzd^:wzv— ŒˆbdyjXv'^:W\W¢v— b^Ev—·Aˆ§jzeu_AY:ž o ^:Wyabt˜Y\W

£¶jhdwz_›wlˆbˆbtuegv'wxY\e˜jh_›vjh]Nˆ§jhWy^:•Njz£©{:}(ˆbd\jXv^:W\Wy^:W©wzdy^pWy bjx“_.eu_Œ³e˜‰habdy^ BžŸj"W¡Yya9•XUWZY\jzd—wl‰z^WyUXWZY\^']

eu].ˆwzvY:–h“^3 w<‚h^aWy^:•.w(€p³CTNv^:_AYyd—wltue"?:^:•NW¡^:dy‚h^'djzdY\ b^t˜jXv:wltb•XegW¡·"jl£R^:wzv— .vtuaW¡Yy^:dC_bjX•X^zž o ^:Wyabt˜Y\W

•b^'].jz_W¡Yyd—wxY\^3Yy b^`e˜_AY\^'d\^:W¡Y¢jl£RYy ^pˆwzd\wzt˜tu^'twzt˜‰hjzd\eºY\ b]Éwz_•Wy bjx“­Y\ wxY”eºYeuWaW\wlsbtu^aWye˜_b‰wv^:_hY\d\wztº¥

e@?'^E•œtu^"W¡^:dy‚h^'dEž”Áp£©vjhabd\Wy^z–bYy b^"W¡Yyjhd\wz‰z^WyUVW¡Yy^:] 9wzWrwz_™e˜].ˆwhvµY:–§W¡je˜Y`Wy bjzatu•s§^eu_hY\^'d\^:W¡Yyeu_b‰.Yyj

Y\^:W¡YreºYrjh_w.•XegW¡Yyd\e˜sbabYy^:•¦œtu^WyUVW¡Yy^:]ž

m W¡^Evjz_9•¦^'šXˆ9^:dyeu].^'_AYp whW‚xwltueu•bwlYy^E•jzabdrd\^:W¡Y\wzd¡Yr].^Ev— wl_begWy] jz_¬wN£¶^:“^:dp_Vab]s9^:drjl£C_bjX•X^EW'ž

m _›wlˆbˆt˜egv'wlYyeujz_›vjh_W¡Yye˜YyaXY\^:•.jl£C{E}(ˆbdyjXv'^:W\W¡^EWdyab__be˜_‰jz_ B_bjX•X^EW© whW©s§^'^:_›v— b^:v—·Vˆ§jzeu_hY\^:•nžŸ3 b^:_

Y\ b^wzˆbˆbtueuv:wxY\e˜jh_¬ wzW`s§^'^'_¾dy^EWZY—wldyYy^:•jh_PƒX–n‡jhd B¦_bjX•X^:Wp£¶d\jz]Yy b^.Wywz].^v— b^Ev—·Aˆ§jzeu_AY:–§aWye˜_b‰ŒYy b^

tujXv'wztb•XeuWy·jz£§^Ewzv— v't˜a9WZY\^'dC_bjX•X^jhdYy b^^'šAY\^'d\_wltX€`³TNWy^'d\‚z^:d£¶jhdYy b^rW¡Yyjhd\wz‰z^hž³e˜‰habdy^r…®Wy bjx“rWYy b^

d\^:Wyabt˜Y\W:ž

Ù

abd\e˜_‰^'šVˆ§^'d\eu]N^:_AY\W:–h^Ewzv— ›ˆbd\jXv^EWyWjl£nY\ b^`ˆ9wld—wltut˜^:t§wzˆbˆbtueuv:wxYyeujz_Œdyab_9W¢jh_Yy b^®_bjX•X^

n+ 1

“e˜Yy 

n

Y\ b^_bjX•X^( bjAWZY\e˜_b‰Ne˜Y\W3ˆwzdy^:_hYˆbd\jXv^EWyW:ž

q

YegW”Yy b^“”jzd—W¡Y3v:wzWy^p£¶jhdY\ b^d\^:W¡Y\wldyYyeu_b‰Nwltu‰zjzd\e˜Yy b]

Wyeu_v^wNˆbd\jXv^:W\Wv'wz_b_bjzYrs9^d\^:W¡Yyjhdy^E•Œab_AY\e˜teºY—Wˆwld\^'_AYˆbd\jXv^:W\W3egWdy^EWZY\jzd\^:•nž©Ÿ3 9wxYregW“ VU›Yy ^'d\^euW

wN“”^:wz·›•XeR^'d\^'_9v^aWye˜_‰.€`³CT¦Wy^'d\‚z^:d3jzd3Yy ^t˜jXv'wzt•XegW¡·XW3jl£^:whv— v't˜aW¡Yy^:d_bjX•X^zž

m Y\ be˜d—•P^šXˆ9^:dyeu].^'_AY wzW(s§^'^:_ª•Xjz_b^NY\j‚xwzt˜eg•bwxY\^NYy b^W¡Yyd\^:wl] dy^EWZY\jzd—wxYyeujz_ž i d\jVv'^:W\W(“”wzeºY\e˜_‰

eu_wWyUXWZY\^'] v:wltutv'wl__bjlY3s9^v— b^Ev—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AYy^E•›sVUY\ b^vabd\dy^:_AY”eu].ˆbt˜^:].^'_AY\wlYyeujz_jl£Y\ b^(ˆbd\jVv'^:W\W3WZY—wxYy^

^'šVYyd—wzvµY\e˜jh_H]N^Ev— wl_euWy]2ˆdyjx‚Veg•X^:•HsVU­ÂÃbÄnÄnŶÆÇÃbÈ©ž¾Ÿ3 VaW"e˜Y]wz·z^:W_bjlY.vabd\dy^:_AYytuUPˆ§jhW\W¡eusbtu^Yyj

v— ^:v—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AYpd\^:wzt“”jzd\tu•wzˆbˆbtueuv:wxYyeujz_9W'ž m W`WyjVjz_¬whWYy euW`t˜eu].eºY—wxY\e˜jh_¬“e˜tuts9^NW¡jht˜‚h^:•n–§“^W¡ bjhabtg•™s9^

wzsbtu^.Yyj¬v— b^Ev—·Aˆ§jzeu_AYe˜_•baWZY\dyegwltwlˆbˆbtuegv'wxY\e˜jh_W:ž›³bjzd"_bjx“–“”^. w<‚z^NYy^EWZY\^:•Hjhabd“jhdy·Pwls§jzaXYjhˆ9^:_

C0D öFEGHI

³eu‰zabd\^ B0A¹jAWZYpjz£Cˆwld—wltut˜^:twlˆˆbt˜egv'wlYyeujz_¬v— b^Ev—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AYyeu_b‰aWyeu_b‰ŒWy^:fAab^'_AY\euwztjzdpˆwld—wltut˜^:twltu‰zjhdye˜Yy ].W

wz_••XeR^'d\^'_AYpW¡Yyjhd\wz‰z^`WyUXWZY\^']W:ž¹ b^:v—·Vˆ§jzeu_hYrWye"?:^(euW} B.±¾²`ž

³eu‰zabd\^…A¯¹jhW¡Y¦jz£wlˆbˆt˜egv'wlYyeujz_d\^:W¡Y\wzd¡Y\e˜_b‰­jz_Mƒb–p‡­jhd,B¯_bjX•X^:W¦£¶d\jz] Yy b^HW\wl].^Pv— b^Ev—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AY:ž

¹ ^:v—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AYrWye"?:^®egWr} BN±¬²®ž

D

ñ«ëíóßè

W¡Yyd\^:wz]W(dy^EWZY\jzd—wxYyeujz_Pjz_ªwl_H^EW¡ˆ§^:v'euwzt˜tuU¾“d\eºYyYy^:_$wlˆbˆbtuegv'wxY\e˜jh_žŒŸ3 begWwzˆbˆbtueuv:wxYyeujz_HegWvjh].ˆ9jAW¡^E•Pjz£

YZ“”j›ˆbd\jXv^EWyWy^:W°«w¦ˆwld\^'_AYpˆbd\jXv^EWyW®wl_•¬eºY—W®Wyjz_§´µž(³eud—WZY(w {xuyhw.¦W¡Yyd\^:wl] egWpjhˆ9^:_b^:•–9Y\ b^'_

Y\ b^¬v— beutu•»ˆbd\jXv^EWyW.Wy^'_•bWŒ•bwxY—w¾Y\jªeºY—W.ˆwld\^'_AYsVU$Y\ b^¬WZY\dy^Ewl]–Yy b^™ˆwzdy^:_AY.ˆdyeu_AY\WNYy ^™dy^Ev^'eu‚z^E•

•wxY\wž wlYy^:d:–XY\ b^vjh].]"ab_begv'wlYyeujz_egWrWZY\jzˆbˆ§^:•H°«sbaXYrY\ b^"W¡Yyd\^:wl] dy^:].wze˜_9Wjzˆ§^'_9´Y\j]wl·z^wfAabe˜Yy^

tujz_‰Œvjh]NˆaXY\wlYyeujz_¾•Xadyeu_b‰›“ begv— ¾w¦v— b^:v—·Vˆ§jzeu_hY`euW®Wyw<‚h^:•nž m Y`Y\ b^"^:_•¬jz£CYy b^Nvjz].ˆbabY\wxY\e˜jh_–§Yy b^

v— e˜tg•ˆbdyjXv'^:W\WW¡^:_•bWrWyjz].^•bwlY\wYyj›e˜Y\Wrˆwld\^'_AYYyj^:_Wyabdy^®Y\ wxYrY\ b^"W¡Yyd\^:wz] euWpWZY\e˜tutjhˆ9^:_ž m YrtgwzW¡Y:–

Y\ b^W¡Yyd\^:wl]euWpvtujhWy^:•wl_•¦Yy ^wlˆbˆbtuegv'wxY\e˜jh_Yy^'d\].e˜_9wxYy^EW'žŸ3 beuWpwlˆbˆbtuegv'wxY\e˜jh_¦ 9wzWs§^'^:_Wyav:v^:W\W¡£¶abt˜tuU

v— ^:v—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AY\^:•Àwl_9•¨dy^EWZY—wldyYy^:•–dy^:s9jVjlY\e˜_‰$jzd›_jlYwzt˜t`_bjX•X^:W¦jl£Y\ b^Pv't˜a9WZY\^'dEž Ÿ3 beuW¦^šXˆ§^'d\e˜].^:_hY

‚xwzt˜eg•bwxY\^:W”Y\ b^WZY\dy^Ewl] d\^:W¡Yyjhd\wlYyeujz_ž

* )&!')

½^© w<‚h^ˆbdy^EW¡^:_AYy^:•`Y\ b^©eu]Nˆt˜^:]N^:_AY\wxY\e˜jh_jl£Vˆwld—wltutu^'tzwzˆbˆbtueuv:wxYyeujz_v— b^Ev—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AYµ¸xdy^EWZY—wldyY§].^Ev— wl_begWy].W

eu_›wv't˜aW¡Yy^:dTbT q Á(Tnž ^:‰hwhvU"wzˆbˆbtueuv:wxYyeujz_9W©v'wz_.Y\wl·h^rwz•X‚xwz_hY—wl‰h^jl£RYy b^EW¡^p]N^Ev— wl_euWy]WYyjY\jztu^'d—wxY\^

_jV•b^`£«wze˜tuabd\^:W3eu_™wNv't˜a9WZY\^'d“e˜Yy bjhaXYrdy^EfAabe˜d\eu_b‰wl_VU].jV•beºœ9v:wxY\e˜jh_jhd3dy^:sbabeutu•Xeu_b‰9ž

m vjh_A‚h^'_beu^'_AY(vjz].]wl_9•V¥Stueu_b^"eu_AYy^'dy£«wzv'^" whWps§^'^:_P•X^EW¡eu‰z_^:•Y\jŒY\dyeu‰z‰h^'dpˆ9wld—wltut˜^:twlˆˆbt˜egv'wlYyeujz_W

v— ^:v—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AY\e˜_b‰.wl_9•¦d\^:W¡Y\wzd¡Y\e˜_‰žŸ3 beuWre˜_AYy^:d¡£«whv^wltutujx“rW”WyUXWZY\^']e˜_be˜YyegwxY\^:•v— b^Ev—·Aˆ§jzeu_AY:ž m tutWyUXWZY\^']

jhsXkZ^:vY\W¢jl£wˆwzd\wzt˜tu^'t9wlˆbˆbtuegv'wxY\e˜jh_›v'wz_s9^®•X^Y\^:vµY\^:•.£¶d\jz] Y\ b^peg•X^'_AY\eºœ^:d¢jz£ *& jz£nYy b^®wlˆbˆbtuegv'wxY\e˜jh_

ˆdyjXv^EWyWy^:W:žª½^ 9w<‚z^Œeu].ˆbtu^'].^'_AYy^E•¯wP‰ztujzs9wlt3vjVjzd—•Xeu_wxY\^:•$v— b^Ev—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AYyeu_b‰HWZY\d\wlYy^:‰zUzž$±¬jzd\^'jx‚z^:d

“”^.wld\^wlst˜^NYyjd\^:W¡Yyjzd\^v'jz].]"a_beuv:wxY\e˜jh_PW¡Yyd\^:wl]W`“eºY\ bjzabYwz_VU™jx‚z^'d\ b^Ewz•™wx£¤Y\^'d(d\^:W¡Y\wldyYyeu_b‰W¡eu_v^

•be˜d\^:vYv'jz].]"a_beuv:wxY\e˜jh_¾egW(ˆbdy^EW¡^:dy‚h^:•¾s9^'YZ“^:^'_Hvjz].]ab_begv'wxY\e˜_‰¦ˆbd\jXv^EWyWy^:W®^'‚h^'_eº£”ˆbd\jVv'^:W\W¡^EW(wld\^

_jlYdy^EWZY\jzd\^:•Œjz_Yy b^:e˜djhdyeu‰zeu_wzt§^'šX^:vabYyeujz__bjX•X^zž

³abd¡Y\ b^'d\].jzd\^z–A“^` w<‚z^^'šXˆ9^:dyeu].^'_AYy^E•›wˆbd\jlY\jlYZUVˆ§^re˜_ÃbÄnÄnŶÆÇÃbșjhˆ9^:d\wlYyeu_b‰"WyUXWZY\^'] “ begv— 

•b^'].jz_W¡Yyd—wxY\^:WYy ^^›veu^'_v'UŒjz£Yy ^ˆwld—wltut˜^:tv— b^:v—·Vˆ§jzeu_AYyeu_b‰Nwzt˜‰hjzd\eºY\ b] wl‰Awleu_W¡Yw.Wy^:fAab^:_hY\euwztne˜]N¥

ˆt˜^:]N^:_AY\wxY\e˜jh_ž m ˆwzd\wzt˜tu^'t§wlˆbˆt˜egv'wlYyeujz_Œv:wl_s§^`d\^:W¡Y\wzd¡Y\^:•.^'‚h^'_›e˜£Wyjz].^p_bjX•X^EWwzdy^pjzaXY”jl£jzd—•X^:dwxY

d\^:W¡Y\wzd¡Y\e˜_‰Y\e˜].^hž3³eu_wltutuUz–bY\ b^d\^:W¡Yyjhd\wlYyeujz_jl£Cjzˆ§^'_™W¡Yyd\^:wl]W° *(/´ wzWs§^'^:_™‚xwltueu•bwlYy^E•

sVU›^'šXˆ9^:dyeu].^'_AY\W:ž

¹abd\d\^'_AYytuUz–Yy b^›a9W¡^:de˜_AYy^:d¡£«whv^egW_b^Ewld\t˜U¾v'jz].ˆbtu^Y\^›sbaXY"e˜Y"•XjV^:W_bjlY"Wyabˆbˆ§jzdyY"Uz^'Yˆ9^:dyeujX•Xegv'wlt

wzˆbˆbtueuv:wxY\e˜jh_¾v— b^:v—·Vˆ§jzeu_AY:ž(Ÿ3 b^d\^:W¡Y\wzd¡Y®wltu‰zjzd\e˜Yy b] egWpˆwzd\wzt˜tu^'tue@?'^:•¾wl_•Y\ b^Nˆwld—wltut˜^:t˜e@?:wlYyeujz_™jz£©Yy b^

v— ^:v—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AY\e˜_b‰Nwltu‰zjhdye˜Yy b] egW3wzWs9^EWZYrwzW”“”^`v:wl_¦Wyeu_v^®“^(•XjN_bjlY3“3wl_AYY\jNv'^'_AYyd—wltue@?'^peu_X£¶jhdy]wxY\e˜jh_

wzs9jhaXY“ begv— ˆdyjXv^EWyWy^:W”_b^:^:•X^E•›Y\js9^v— ^:v—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AY\^:•nž

¹ b^Ev—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AYyeu_b‰›wz_•dy^EWZY—wldyYyeu_b‰.dy^Ewlt± i©q wlˆbˆt˜egv'wlYyeujz_WrWy bjhabtu•s§^"ˆ§jhW\W¡eusbtu^W¡jVjh_ž”Ÿ3 ^]wleu_

ˆdyjhsbt˜^:] egW"w™tueu]Ne˜Y\wlYyeujz_ªjz£”Y\ b^ŒˆdyjXv^EWyW"WZY—wxYy^^'šVYyd—wzvµY\e˜jh_H]N^Ev— wl_euWy] <u{:}>ˆbd\jx‚Veu•X^E•sAU$ÃbÄ

ÄnŶÆÇÃbȓ euv— euWr_bjlYrwlst˜^®Yyj›v— ^:v—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AYrwNˆbd\jVv'^:W\W”“”wzeºY\e˜_b‰.eu_™wNWyUXWZY\^'] v:wltut?ž

½^`ˆtuwz_›YyjN^šXˆ§^'d\e˜].^:_hY”jz_¦tuwzdy‰h^'dv't˜a9WZY\^'d—W©Y\j"^'‚xwzt˜awlYy^`Yy b^(W\v'wltgwlse˜tueºYZU.jz£jzabd3wlˆbˆdyjAwzv— ›wl_9•

“e˜Yy d\^:wztne˜_•baWZY\dyegwltwzˆbˆbtueuv:wxY\e˜jh_W'žC½^wleu]wlYre˜_AY\^'‰zd—wxY\e˜_‰jhabddy^EW¡atºY—W3e˜_Yy ^ˆbabsbtuegv(dy^:t˜^EwzWy^ <u{>

jz£pÃbÄnÄnŶÆÇÃbÈHW¡eu_b‰ht˜^WyUVW¡Yy^:] eu].wz‰z^(jzˆ§^'d—wxY\e˜_‰.WyUXWZY\^']ž

Á`abd¢£¶aXYyady^`“jhdy·“e˜tut£¶jXv'aW¢jh_›W¡ 9wld\^:•.].^'].jzd\U.wlˆbˆbtuegv'wxY\e˜jh_›v— b^:v—·Vˆ§jzeu_AYyeu_b‰e˜_¦W¡eu_b‰ztu^pWyUXWZY\^']

eu]wl‰h^Œjzˆ§^'d—wxY\e˜_‰WyUXWZY\^']W.wl_•­jz_­eu].ˆbtu^'].^'_AYyeu_b‰HjlY\ b^'dNd\jztut˜swhv—·¸<d\^:vjx‚h^'d\U¾W¡Yyd—wxYy^:‰zeu^:WNW¡a9v— ¯wzW

tujz‰h‰zeu_b‰NYyjŒwzt˜tujx“ ˆdyjh‰zd—wl].].^'d—W¢Y\jŒWy^'tu^:vµYpYy b^"W¡Yyd—wxY\^'‰hUŒ“ begv— euWrYy b^].jhdy^wzˆbˆbd\jzˆbd\euwlYy^®Yyj›Yy b^:e˜d

wzˆbˆbtueuv:wxY\e˜jh_ž

C0D öFEGHI

# (/&* !"7œ4

A›½^¦“”jzatu•ªtueu·z^›Y\j¬Y\ wl_b·

i

whWyv:wlt

×

wzt˜tgwld—•$wz_•

o

^:_wla• jlYyYyegwlaXšª“ bj

 9w<‚z^. b^'tuˆ§^:•Yyj™eu_AYy^:‰zd—wxYy^.Y\ b^›ˆbd\jzˆ§jhWy^:•Pˆwzd\wzt˜tu^'t©wzˆbˆbtueuv:wxYyeujz_ªv— b^Ev—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AYµ¸xdy^EWZY—wldyY®].^Ev— wl_begWy].W

eu_™Y\ b^NÃbÄnÄnŶÆÇÃbÈ$jzˆ§^'d—wxY\e˜_b‰›WyUXWZY\^']žpŸ3 begWr“”jzd\·Œ 9wzWrs§^'^:_¬ˆwzd¡Y\euwzt˜tuUŒ£¶a_•X^:•¬sAU

Ù(×(m ab_9•X^'d

Y\ b^¹Á¹ m7i©Ö¢m v'jz_AYyd—wzvY:ž

x3¦&”

<˜{> Õ ^:dyd\eu‰z b^E•›“”^'sWyeºY\^z–® AY¡Y\ˆ;A¸z¸<“““ž·z^:dyd\eu‰z b^E•nžjhdy‰X¸Vž

<ƒ>lÁ`ˆ§^'_§TbT q “^:sW¡e˜Yy^h–( AY¡Yyˆ.Aí¸h¸<“““žjzˆ§^'_W\W¡eSžjzd\‰V¸Vž

<‡>"¹`ž±¬jzd\e˜_–

o ž jlYyYyegwlaXšn–

× ž ¼ wzt˜tuc'^h–

i ž × wltutuwzd\•n–

Ù

ž±¬wzdy‰h^'d\Uz– ž¥žn²”^'dyYy bjha–wl_•

q

žTXv— X¥

^:d\Wyjz_–

Õ

^'d\dyeu‰z ^:•$wz_•­•bwlY\wPˆwld—wltutu^'tueuWy] A¹tuaWZY\^'dvjh].ˆbaXYyeu_b‰jz_ÀTVeu_b‰ztu^TXUVW¡Yy^:]

q

]wl‰h^

jhˆ9^:d\wlYyeu_b‰W¡UXW¡Yy^:].W:–`e˜_

*(*4+ !(

4bž

qôÖ©Ö©Ö

–RTV^'ˆXYEž9ƒl„h„B9ž

<B > Ö

žR€"ž§±$ž

Ö

tu_bj?:wl VUh–

ž m

tu‚VeuWyeS–Nž¥ô±ªž§½wz_b‰–Rwl_•

Ù

žR²®žhjz b_Wyjz_–

m

Wyabdy‚h^'U¦jl£©d\jztut˜swhv—·A¥

d\^:v'jx‚z^:dyU¬ˆdyjzYyjXvjhtuWeu_$].^:W\W\wl‰z^'¥Sˆ9wzW\W¡eu_b‰™W¡UXW¡Yy^:].W:– # + + *œ 3( , ( –C‚zjztSž‡ B–_bjž‡b–

ˆˆž‡A|z…Bh„z~–Vƒz„z„AƒXž

<…>9ž

^'jh_–

m ž

žn³euWy b^:d:–Rwl_•

i

žTAY\^'^:_b·VeuW¡Yy^h–<³9wleutº¥ZTXwl£¶^

i©¼

± A m

ˆ§jzdyY\wlst˜^ˆwzv—·xwl‰h^£¶jzd®•XegWZ¥

Y\dyeusbaXY\^:•ˆbd\jz‰hd\wz]N].eu_b‰N“eºY\ ¦Y\d\wz_Wyˆwld\^'_AY3dy^Evjx‚z^:dyUh–pŸ^:v— ž

o

^'ˆžu–n{ z‡ž

<}> × žTAYy^:t˜tu_b^:d:– l¹jV¹ b^Ev—·$A¹ ^:v—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AY\e˜_b‰¬wz_•ˆbd\jVv'^:W\W(].e˜‰hd\wlYyeujz_P£¶jzd"± i¢q –e˜_ ,! "#$

*(7 *%- 2 - 0&)*&!F!!"! * (F , ›œ *(aœ ž qôÖ¢Ö©Ö ¹jz].ˆbaXY\^'d

TXjVv'e˜^'YZUz–{ h}b–Aˆbˆž9…hƒl}&b…l‡{zž

<í|6> m ž m ‰zs9wld\euwwz_• o žV³bd\eu^:•X]wl_–&\TAY\wzd¡œ§W¡ ;A³wzabt˜Y¡¥SYyjztu^'d—wl_AY•bUA_9wl].euv`± i©q ˆdyjh‰zd—wl]WCjz_›v't˜a9WZ¥

Y\^'d—W©jz£“jhdy·XW¡Y\wxY\e˜jh_W:–3e˜_('

-

0&)*&!

,

›œ *6(aœ **) 56- +*œ &(,

:* ( 7 +*œ 3(

– jhW

m

tuwz]Ne˜YyjAW'–n{ bž

<~> m žX²jhaXYy^:e˜tutu^'dE– Ø ž¥ žV²”jza?:euwz_b^z– i ž ^']wld\eu_be˜^:d:–AŸ(ž Ø c'd—wlatºYE–Awz_•›³”ž¹”wlˆbˆ§^'tuj– Ø UVsbdyeg•ˆbd\^¥

^:].ˆXYyeu‚z^(Wyv— ^:•Xabtueu_b‰£¶jhd].ˆbenwlˆˆbt˜egv'wlYyeujz_Wjz_ŒYy b^®‰zd\eg•bW'– i d\^:Wy^'_AY\wlYyeujz_›eu_…xYy  qôÖ¢Ö©Ö ¸ m ¹”±

q_AY\^'d\_wxY\e˜jh_wltn½jzd\·XW¡ bjhˆŒjh_ × d\eu•¬¹jh]NˆaXYyeu_b‰–b€pjx‚z^:]"sbd\^(ƒz„z„ Bž

<> × ž-R b^'_b‰9– žTV beS–wl_• ž ¼ ž Õ wzt˜ch–<³Ÿp¹¢¥¡¹ wld\] A m _¾eu_X¥ß].^'].jzd\U™v— b^:v—·Vˆ§jzeu_hYy¥Ss9wzWy^:•

£«wzabt˜YCYyjztu^'d—wl_AYCd\ab_AYyeu]N^”£¶jhd¹ wld\] ¨wl_•N± i©q –e˜_ 4./ 0&)*&!;+*0&(

* + !( +*œ ( F –9TXwz_ Ù eu^:wl‰hj–9¹ m –9TV^'ˆbYy^']s9^:dpƒl„h„Bž

<u{:„>TnžxTbwl_b·xwld—wl_–&9ž<±ªžlTXfAabUVdy^EW'–x²®žE²3wzdyd\^YyY:– m ž a].W\•bwze˜_b^h–ž Ù ab^'tut?– i ž Ø wld\‰zd\jx‚z^z–Ewl_• Ö ž o jl¥

]wz_–.yŸ3 b^ m ±¸x± i©q v— b^Ev—·Aˆ§jzeu_AYµ¸xdy^EWZY—wldyY©£¶d\wz].^'“”jzd\·&ACTVUXW¡Yy^']N¥ße˜_eºY\euwlYy^:•v— b^Ev—·Vˆ9jhe˜_AYyeu_b‰9–

eu_ * (7F2143.# + , , ›œ *6(aœ –9TXwz_hY\^³b^h–€r^:“M±™^'šVegvj9– T m –RÁ®vYyjzs§^'drƒz„z„z‡ž

<u{z{> m ž9²”jzabYy^'eutut˜^:d:–b³”ž§¹”wzˆbˆ9^:t˜tuj–9Ÿ(ž Ø c:d\wzabtºYE– × ž Õ d—w<“^?'eu·R– i ž ^']wld\eu_be˜^:d:–bwz_•³”ž±¬wl‰h_beu^Y¡Y\^z–

<± i©q ¹ Ø ¥¼ ƒAw"£«wlatºY”Yyjht˜^:d\wz_hY3± i©q £¶jhd3‚zjztgwxY\e˜tu^p_jV•b^:WswzWy^:•Œjz_›ˆ§^:W\W¡eu].euW¡Yyegv®W¡^:_•X^'d3swhW¡^E•

].^EWyW\wl‰h^©t˜jh‰z‰he˜_b‰9–¢eu_ ) 5 - +*œ4&( */F &7 +*œ 3( 65, + 4.78xž i  bjV^'_be˜š

T m A qôÖ©Ö©Ö ¸ m ¹”±ª–€pjx‚z^']s9^:dpƒl„h„z‡bž

D

ñ«ëíóßè