Proposition on the Theory of Policing

HAL Id: hal-00744208

https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00744208

Submitted on 22 Oct 2012

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Fabien Jobard

To cite this version:

Fabien Jobard. Proposition on the Theory of Policing. Penal Field, 2012, IX,

http://champpenal.revues.org/8286. �hal-00744208�

1234566578543579AB58ACB92AC657D57E89F9A26295

267777 C89C

Actes de colloque/Conference Proceedings – L’œuvre singulière d’un penseur cosmopolite : Hommages à Jean-Paul Brodeur

Proposition on the theory of policing

¹ 7 ^!

1234523

"5B7C8B9E65785495AB7#38765#7D$%CB#7&3575CA'(C36782D538 7C4C9B7D$4562))$#7D38CAB7C37F29A#

D53*7 D$E5AA95# 7C3B238 7D5 76C7 )6CE57 D5 76C 7+28E57 DCA# 7 6C7D$+9A9B92A7 5B7 6C7 B,$28957 D5 76C7)269E5 -.C3B53875*)2#57D.C%28D7657)82/5B7B,$289&357D571234567898AB4C3D07#2A7D58A95872348C5075B76C )6CE57&3.2EE3)57DCA#7E5639'E97176.966$C69#F57)269E9587207&397E2A#B9B3576C7)958857+2ADCB89E57D576C B,$2895 7 D5 7 6C 7 )269E5 7 C4CAE$5 7 )C8 7 5CA'(C36 7 82D538 7 6 7 5#&39##5 7 5A#39B5 7 3A5 7 C))82E,5

#2E92629&357D57E5B7966$C69#F57)269E958075A7F2AB8CAB7)2387&35665#78C9#2A#76C7F$B,2D5785B5A35 )C8 7 5CA'(C36 7 82D538 7 A5 7 )234C9B 7 3B85 7 &3C69+9$5 7 D5 7 #2E92629&350 7 C4CAB 7 D5 7 +28F3658 7 3A5 17B,$28957#2E92629&357D576C7)269E57207+2AD$57#3876C7A2B92A7D57#23458C9A5B$7-.5F)6297D57E5BB5 A2B92A7657E2AD39B747)8$E9#587#2A7CEE5)B92A07C4CAB7D57+28F365873A57)82)2#9B92A7D5717B,$2895 )269B9&357D576C7)269E572

5,9# 7 C8B9E65 7 8549#9B# 7 #5458C6 7 C83F5AB# 7 B,CB 7 5CA'(C36 7 82D538 7 D54562)5D 7 +28 7 CB 7 65C#B 7 B62 D5ECD5#72A7B,57826572+7B,573#572+7+28E579A7B,57D5+9A9B92A7CAD7C75A58C67B,528772+7)269E9A75,5 C3B,2875*CF9A5#7B,57B,5285B9EC67)82/5EB7B,CB7E,C8CEB58985#71234567898AB4C3D07,9#76C#B7%22907CAD C##5##5#76,5857:65C676C665##A5##;07B,57B23E,#B2A572+7B,57B,528772+7)269E9A7)3B7+286C8D79A7B,5

%2290 7 +9B# 7 <5 7 B,5A 7 23B69A5# 7 C 7 #2E92629EC6 7 C))82CE, 7 2+ 7 65C6 7 6C665##A5##0 7 E2A#9D589A 7 B,CB 5CA'(C36782D538.#7E,2#5A7F5B,2D7E236D7A2B7%57E2A#9D585D7C7#2E92629EC672A57B7B,CB7)29AB07C :#2E92629EC67B,528772+7)269E9A;7696675F58507%C#5D72A7B,57E2AE5)B72+7#245859AB77+B587,C49A E65C8677D5+9A5D7B,9#7E2AE5)B.#7CEE5)B5D7F5CA9A07C7:)269B9EC67B,528772+7)269E9A;79#7+28F36CB5D

67892A3BCDE7CAF

Index de mots-clés : 5CA'(C36782D53807+28E507966$C69#F57)269E95807#23458C9A5B$07B,$28957D5 6C7)269E50749265AE57)269E9=85

Index by keyword : 5CA'(C36782D53807+28E507)269E5765C676C665##A5##07)269E5749265AE50

#245859AB707B,528772+7)269E9A

Notes de la rédaction

58CD3EB92A778CA>29#'C49587(89238

AF8ABE7829

Introduction

Jean-Paul Brodeur: a new theoretical approach of policing

567898AB4EB3AF4E34EF46433E7496AA39F346BEA8EF86A4EF26834F643 8A46346473496AF67734E483343EA4B3A3E774628D8F34D4FEFF3 643B7EF86A4F64F2343F464F23467EF86A48A4634F643A6934E864F346 734EA49F64F2EF466F34E438A346348A46983F496A83348A48F 26734648A4634648F4EF

5,9#7E2AB89%3B92A79#7CA7?2%4923#6778CB,587#CD@72))28B3A9B77B278549#9B7CB765C#B7B62 D5ECD5#72+7D9#E3##92A#7D54562)5D7%775CA'(C36782D538769B,7C749567B27C##9A7+28E579B#

)82)58 7 )6CE5 7 9A 7 B,5 7 D5+9A9B92A 7 CAD 7 B,5287 7 2+ 7 )269E9A 7 # 7 549D5AE5D 7 %7 7 4C8923#

)3%69ECB92A#

0 7 #3E, 7 D5%CB5# 7 8536C867 7 %823,B 7 3# 7 B25B,580 7 CAD 7 9B 7 6966 7 %5 7 2A67 7 B22 ACB38C67+287F77B89%3B57B27BCE9657B,579##3572+7)269E57%83BC69B772AE57CC9A7A7CB7C7B9F5 6,5A07C#79B7B5AD#7B27,C))5A074C8923#73A856CB5D7EC#5#7,C45785E5AB677)3B7B,573#572+7+28E5

%7785AE,7)269E9A7C3B,289B95#79A7B,57#)2B69,B

1

5CA'(C36 7 82D5380 7 9A 7 ,9# 7 )2#B,3F23# 7 6289 7 123 4 567898AB 4 C3D0 7 B,2823,67 85'5*CF9A5D7B,579F)28BCAE572+7),7#9EC67+28E579A7)269E9A7CEB92A075#)5E9C66779A7E,C)B58 B076,9E,7E2458#7B,57B,528772+7)269E9A75,576,2657)38)2#572+7B,9#7E,C)B5879#7B2785+3B5 CAD7B,5A7CF5AD72A79BBA58.#7(C(7?5678934346469345EE8B@7-5B73#7955)79A F9AD0 7 B,23,0 7 B,CB 7 9A 7 B,5 7 D 7 %229 7 E2FF5F28CB9A 7 85AE, 7 )269E5 7 #2E92629#B

!2F9A9&357E2A/C8D5B076,27)C##5D7C6C779A7F0782D5387,CD7E2A#9D585D7B,CB7B,9#

FCBB587A 7),7#9EC67+28E579A7B,57D5+9A9B92A72+7)269E9A7A7 2E 4D33A4B83A4F66 492 86FEA93 7 ?82D5380 7 DC@ 7 7 #,C66 7 B,585+285 7 BC95 7 5CA'(C36.# 7 6C8A9A 7 C# 7 C )85B589B92A07CAD7+2876,CB79B7CEB3C66779#07957CA79A49BCB92A

2

7#,C667,2A287B,9#79A49BCB92A7+98#B7%779AB82D3E9A7B,57B,5285B9EC67C9F72+7567898AB4C3D CAD7C##5##9A76,5857:65C676C665##A5##;?7877 BE7834678983

@07B,57B23E,#B2A572+7B,5 B,528772+7)269E9A7)3B7+286C8D79A7B,57%22907+9B#7 7#,C667B,5A723B69A57C7#2E92629EC6 C))82CE, 7 2+ 7 65C6 7 6C665##A5##0 7 E2A#9D589A 7 B,CB0 7 C# 7 7 6966 7 B87 7 B2 7 D5F2A#B8CB50 5CA'(C36782D538.#7E,2#5A7F5B,2D7E236D7A2B7%57E2A#9D585D7C7#2E92629EC672A57B B,CB7)29AB07C7:#2E92629EC67B,528772+7)269E9A;7696675F58507%C#5D72A7B,57E2AE5)B72+

#245859AB7 7 5679A 7 2A 7 B,9# 7 E2AE5)B 7 6966 7 E2F)56 7 3# 7 B2 7 E65C867 7D5+9A5 7 9B# 7 CEE5)B5D F5CA9A0 7 %5+285 7 65 7 +28F36CB5 7 238 7 )82)2#5D 7 :)269B9EC6 7 B,5287 7 2+ 7 )269E9A;0 7 CAD E2AE63D5

3

A7,9# 7B85CB7 72A7)269E9A7?1234567898AB4C3D@075CA'(C367#BCB5# 7B,CB 7,579# 787 3F38A34F646834E4A3438A8F86A46467898AB4EA4!F6"48AF693463464F23 3733AF464E4F23646467898AB7?F@7<9#7D5+9A9B92A7D8746A4F234A6F86A46473BE77 8AB43EA4628D8F34F646F237?F@7B79#7)82D3E5D79A7B,576C#B7)C5#72+7B,57E,C)B58 D542B5D7B27B,57B,528772+7)269E9A7?E,C)B587B07G@

4

HB8999A670 7 6,965 7 2A5 7 2+ 7 5CA'(C36 7 82D538.# 7 C#)98CB92A# 7 6C# 7 B2 7 &35#B92A 7 :B,5 ACB38572+7B,5287;7?567898AB4C3D07I@07B,575AD7)82D3EB72+7,9#79A&398776C#7C7D5+9A9B92A0 A2B 7 C 7 B,5287J 7 C# 7 9+ 7 B,5 7 FC9A 7 D9++9E36B7 7 6C7 7 A2B 7 #2 7 F3E, 7 9A 7 D5694589A 7 C 7 #5B 7 2+

)82)2#9B92A# 7 D58945D 7 +82F 7 5#BC%69#,5D 7 2%#584CB92A# 7 C# 7 9A 7 5F%8CE9A0 7 9A 7 C 7 #9A65

#BCB5F5AB07%2B,7B,57#)5E9+9E9B77CAD7#E2)572+7B,57)269E9A79A#B9B3B92A7287B,57)82%65F B,CB7567898AB4C3D7CEB3C6677D5C6#769B,79#7A2B79A7+CEB7)269E9A7C#7C7B,5285B9EC672%/5EB )58BC9A9A7B27#)5E9+9E79A2665D57C85C#7?#2E9C67#E95AE507),962#2),772872B,58#076,9E, 6236D7B38A7)269E9A7B,528779AB27C7#2E92629EC607)269B9EC60K7B,5287@782D538.#7)82%65F0 6,9E,7,579AB82D3E5#7C#7567898AB4C3D.#7:E,C665A5;7?D@079#7B,573A9B772+7)269E57+28E5#0 6,9E,7,57E2A#9D58#7B27%57E,C665A5D7%77B,57#ECBB589A7CAD7D9458#9B77B,CB72%#58458#7C85 9A9B9C667 7 E2A+82AB5D 7 69B, 7 6,5A 7 5*CF9A9A 7 B,5 7 9A#B9B3B92A 7 CAD 7 9B# 7 C5AB# 7 <9#

5

L

The duality of social spaces and circumstances

D5+9A9B92A 7 9A42645# 7 CA 7 5*B5A#945 7 3#5 7 2+ 7 )638C6# 7 A 7 :)269E9A 7 C5AB#;

0 7 : 7 #5458C6 E2AA5EB5D728CA98CB92A#;7A7CAD79#7F5CAB7B275F%8CE579A79B#75AB985B77B,576,2657#5B72+

)269E9A 7 CEB949B95# 7 CAD 7 #BCB3B5# 7 A 7 +82F 7 +9ACAE9C6 7 E89F5 7 D5B5EB945# 7 B2 7 +22D 7 #C+5B7 2++9E58#7B27%5CB7)269E5F5A07+82F76C675A+28E5F5AB7B279AB56695AE5

38 7 85CD58 7 F9,B 7 %5 7 #38)89#5D 7 B2 7 85C69850 7 B,23,0 7 B,CB 7 5CA'(C36 7 82D538 E2A#9D585D 7 ,9# 7 B,5287 7 2+ 7 )269E9A 7 C# 7 3A#CB9#+CEB2870 7 +8C3,B 7 C# 7 ,5 7 +56B 7 9B 7 6C# 7 %7 EAF8A683464896EA937?K@7F2EF49EAA6F4D343AF837436737?567898AB4C3D07F@

6

5,57+98#B7#3E,7CAB9A2F779#7B27%57+23AD79A7B,57D9#E28DCAE57%5B655A7:2)5AA5##;7CAD :#5E85B;7M,965782D53876C#7C+B587C7F2A9#B9E7B,528772+7)269E9A72807C#7,57E6C9F5D79A B,57+98#B7)C5#72+7567898AB4C3D07C7B,528772+76789349673F3A37?567898AB4C3D07N'@0 ,576C#7E2A+82AB5D769B,7C7D3C6785C69B772+7)269E9A7(269E9A07,57C835D07CEB3C6677,C#

B627A2A'24586C))9A7+CE5B#072A572+76,9E,79#72)5A7CAD7B,572B,587#5E85B

7

5,57#5E2AD7CAB9A2F77?6,9E,79#7#)5E9+9E7B27B,57B,528772+7)269E9A@785#B#72A7)269E9A

%59A7C7BC9AB5D72EE3)CB92A7?9BBA5807PNIB@079A#2+C87C#7)269E9A762897+5CB385#

#2F572+7B,57E,C8CEB589#B9E#72+79B#7BC85B#7CAD79#7BC9AB5D7%77#3#)9E92A7?07G@J7C DC897#9D57B,CB7#BCAD#79A7#BC897E2AB8C#B7B27B,572B,587+CE5B72+7)269E9AAC7)82+5##92A 6,9E,0 7 %7 75##5AE50 7 2)58CB5# 7 3AD58 7C 7859F57 2+7 659B9FCE7 7? 59A580 7 NN@0 7E2A#5AB

?H92CA0787D607B@07287B83#B7?ECAA9A07G@

8

7 #,C66 7 C835 7 ,585 7 B,CB 7 B,5 7 D9#E28DCAE5# 7 F5AB92A5D 7 %7 7 5CA'(C36 7 C85 7 A2 D9#E28DCAE5#7CB7C66

9

5,57E98E3F#BCAE5#7B,CB765D7,9F7B27)2#9B7B,5#57D9#E28DCAE5#7?9572)5AP#5E85B72A7B,5 2A57,CAD07B83#BP,2#B969B772A7B,572B,58@7EC667+287C7#2E92629EC6785C##5##F5AB076,9E,76966 5AC%65 7 3# 7 B2 7 85),8C#5 7 5CA'(C36 7 82D538.# 7 )2#9B92A 7 5,9# 7 85),8C#9A 7 F9,B 7 %5 E2A#9D585D7CA7CBB5F)B7CB7+28F36CB9A7C7698676B89E74F23646473BE747E73A37#

F5AB92A5D 7 5C869580 7 82D538.# 7 C))82CE, 7 6C# 7 A2B 7 D5429D 7 2+ 7 #2F5 7 CF%939B7 7 #9AE50 C6B,23,7,9#79AB5AB92A76C#7B27)82D3E57C7:B,5287;72+7)269E9A7A7C7:F2A9#B9E;7B,528772+

)269E9A07545A7A7,575AD5D73)769B,72++589A7C7F5857D5+9A9B92A72+7)269E9A7A7#698E7 12364EA4#698E74#F9F307E58B2A7E2A#9D585D7B,CB079A7#2E9C67#E95AE5#07C7B,52877,CD B27%57C7D5D3EB9457#5B72+7629EC66779AB58856CB5D7)82)2#9B92A#07#3E,7C#7+2879A#BCAE57B,5 )82D3EB92A 72+ 7 854263B92AC87 79D5C# 7#B5FF9A 7 +82F 7 C 78269A 7 D9#E85)CAE7 7%5B655A 5*)5EB5D 7 CAD 7 CEB3C6 7 #C6C895# 7 12B,9A 7 2+ 7 B,5 7 99AD 7 69B, 7 82D5380 7 6,2 7 85#B89EB5D ,9F#56+ 7 B2 7 D5+9A9A 7 ,9# 7 2%/5EB0 7 C# 7 2))2#5D 7 B2 7 C 7 B,5287 7 2+ 7 B,9# 7 2%/5EB 7 M5 7 C8350 ,2654580 7 B,CB 7 9B 7 9# 7 )85E9#567 7 B,5 7 6CE9 7 2+ 7 C 7 B,5287 7 B,CB 7 65D 7 ,9F 7 B2 7 E2A#9D58 7 B,5#5 D9#E28DCAE5#7C#7)C8B9C66779A4C69DCB9A7,9#726A7D5+9A9B92A

10

387B,5285B9EC67E2A#B83EB7#BC8B#7+82F76,58575CA'(C3672E4E8376,CB7D5+9A5#

287CB765C#B7E,C8CEB58985#7)269E9A79#79B#7:65C676C665##A5##;07957B,57C%969B77B2765C667 9A+89A572A7B,57#,C85D76C67572AD7B,9#7E2FF2A7823AD0754587B,9A7#5B#73#7C)C8B

11

5,5773BE747E73A372*7F282A785+58#7B27CA779A+89A5F5AB7FCD572A7B,57#,C85D 6C6 769B, 7 C 7 4956 7 B2 7 9AE85C#5 7 5A58C6 7 85#)5EB 7 B,5852+0 7 5 7 D8949A 7 D26A 7 C 7 2A5'6C7

#B855B7B,57682A76C776,5A7B879A7B27ECBE,73)769B,7C783AC6C7072875C45#D82))9A72A )894CB57E2A458#CB92A#73#9A7F285728765##7#2),9#B9ECB5D79AB58E5)B92A076985BC))9A7CAD 85E28D9A7D549E5#075BE

782D5387E2A#9D585D765C676C665##A5##7C#7945A7%77B,576C60 9A,585AB 7 B2 7 CA7 7 )269E9A 7 CEB949B7 7 5,5 7 "CACD9CA 7 "2D5 7 2+ 7 E89F9AC6 7 )82E5D3850 7 ,5 2%#5845D0 7 E2A#9#B# 7 9A 7 CA 7 5*B5A#945 7 9A45AB287 7 2+ 7 C66 7 B8CA#85##92A# 7 C66265D 7 B2 7 B,5 )269E5769B,23B7+5C872+7)82#5E3B92A7?567898AB4C3D07G'G@

12

M,CB7CA75F)989EC675*CF9ACB92A7CEB3C66778545C6#79#7B,CB076,96579A#E89%5D79A7B,5765BB58

13

L

"2A#9D589A7B,CB7B,57628D72+7C7)269E572++9E58075#)5E9C6677C7E89F9AC679A45#B9CB280 9#079A7CAD72+79B#56+07F2857E85D9%657B,CA7B,CB72+7C7D837D5C658J7B,CB07,26545807B,9#

)2#B36CB579#765C95A5D079+7A2B7#,CBB585D076,5A54587B,57E89F9AC6#.7#BCB5F5AB#7C85

#3%#BCAB9CB5D7%775*B58AC67565F5AB#7#3E,7C#7F5D9EC67+9AD9A#J

"2A#9D589A7B,CB07A2B73A9AB585#B9A6707QECD97CADR7H56F23A907A54587,C49A7%55A 9A7)269E57E3#B2D77%5+28507,CD7A27)892875*)5895AE572A76,9E,7B27856773)2A7B2 D5#9A7CA756C%28CB57695J7B,CB7H56F23A9785E5945D7C6F2#B7A2765C67CD49E5 B,823,23B7B,57D837B8C++9E99A7)82E55D9A#J7B,CB7BC95A7C#7C76,26507B,5#5 +CEB28#7)58#3CD57B,57"238B7B,CB7B,57C6655D785#9#BCAE57B27C885#B76C#79A45AB5D7%7 B,57CEE3#5D7B27/3#B9+77B,57#58923#A5##7CAD762ECB92A72+7B,57,C5FCB2FC#7CAD7B,5 65#92A#7+23AD72A7B,57D5BC9A557QKR

2+ 7 B,5 7 E2D50 7 65C6 7 6C665##A5## 7 9# 7 %7 7 D5+9A9B92A 7 A5458 7 #5B 7 9A 7 #B2A5 7 9B 7 9# 7 #,9+B9A0 3A#BC%650 7 +8C9650 7 #3%/5EB 7 B2 7 85E3889A 7 CBBCE9# 7 +82F 7 %2B, 7 #2E95B7 7 CAD 7 FC9#B8CB5#0 628895D7CB7B,579D5C7B,CB7#2F57#)CE57B,577,C457A27E2AB82673)2A79#7B,8949A7&39B57C)C8B +82F7B,578536C87A28FCB945728D587?6,CB75CA'(C367D3%#7B,57:5*B8C'65C6;79A7567898AB C3D@ 7 5,9# 7 9# 72A5 7 9A#BCAE5 7 ?CF2A 72B,58#

@ 7 2+ 7 B,5 765C6 7 D2EB89A5 7 85#28B9A7 B2 7 B,5 E2AE5)B72+7C%#2649A75*E3#5AC66C7#7#3%/5EB7B278A496A93F64C))8C9#C67+82F7/3D5#7$A 96A93F67A2B79A7B58F#72+7CA775*55B9EC67CAC67#9#72+7B,57"2D507%3B7C+B587B,2823,67 5*CF9ACB92A72+7B,57E2AE85B57E2AB5*B72+7B,57)269E9A79AB5845AB92A7<5AE507B,5765C6728 9665C67ACB38572+7)269E9A76C665##A5##79#7+98#B7C##5##5D7%77B,57E238B#076,27D5E9D57B27B9) B,57#EC65759B,5872A7B,57#9D572+7B,57#,C85D76C672879A7B,578C77C85C72+765C676C665##A5##

(82)5873AD58#BCAD9A72+7B,5765C676C665##A5##7C6655D6775A/275D7%77)269E9A7C5AB#

B,3# 7 5ABC96# 7 5*CF9A9A 7 CEB3C6 7 D5E9#92A# 7 2+ 7 FC9#B8CB5# 7 85C8D9A 7 )269E9A 9AB5845AB92A#7B,577,C457%55A7C#95D7B27CD/3D9ECB57M,CB7#3E,7CA75*CF9ACB92A78545C6#

9#7B,CB76C665##A5##79#72A67765C673AD587E58BC9A7E2AD9B92A#7E77C83F5AB79#7B,CB7B,585 5*9#B#7C7698E74E9346473BE747E73A3076,9E,77#,C6675*)62857#3EE9AEB67

14

5C957+2879A#BCAE57C7NN7)269E9A79AB5845AB92A7)9BB9A7C7E89F9AC679A45#B9CB92A7B5CF +82F 7 B,5 7 85CB58 7 (C89# 7 C85C 7 CC9A#B 7 CA 7 C6655D 7 ,5829A 7 D5C6580 7 EH56F23A9 7 5,9#

)C8B9E36C879AB58CEB92A736B9FCB567765D7B27B,57NNN7E2A49EB92A72+7B,5785AE,72458AF5AB

%77B,57382)5CA7"238B72+7<3FCA7 9,B#7A72A7:B28B385;7E,C85#076,9E,7,CD72A6775458

%55A 7 )85##5D 7 CC9A#B 7 B,5 7 53899#, 7 2458AF5AB 7 3AB96 7 B,5A 7 ?C96D899#0 7 NNNJ 7 2D570 O07BF@745A7C+B587B,9#7382)5CA'654567458D9EB07,26545807B,579AE89F9ACB5D7)269E5 F58567 7 85E5945D 7 #3#)5AD5D 7 )89#2A 7 #5AB5AE5# 7 +82F 7 B,5 7 85AE, 7 E238B# 7 ?2A 7 B,9#

#9A9+9ECAB79AE2A#9#B5AE707#557"C,A07I@7#7+287382)5CA7/3D5#07B,577E2A#9D585D B,CB7E7H56F23A9079A7CDD9B92A7B27,C49A7%55A7#3%/5EB5D7B27,3F969CB9A7CAD7D58CD9A B85CBF5AB07,CD7%55A7%5CB5A7D389A7,9#7+238'DC77E3#B2D7076,9E,07#B9667CEE28D9A7B27B,5 382)5CA7E238B07EC3#5D7B,5762##72+7,9#765+B7575

15

C)2A78549569A7B,9#7EC#507B,5785AE,7/3D5#7#BCB5D7C78CB,5879AB585#B9A7)2#9B92A

16

M,CB 7 9# 7 65C6 7 6C665##A5##S 7 5,9# 7 E238B 7 D5E9#92A 7 FC7 7 E2AB89%3B5 7 B2 7 238 3AD58#BCAD9A72+79B765F5AB# 7)8249A7B,57682AD29A# 7 C85785&3985D 7%7 7/3D5# 7B2

#3EE5##+3667 7 E2A458B 7 CA 7 C665CB92A 7 9AB2 7 C 7 85E28D5D 7 +CEB 7 ?2A 7 B,9# 7 E2A458#92A0 7 #55 2%C8D0 7 G@ 7 ECB589C6 7 565F5AB# 7 #3E, 7C# 7 C 7 F5D9EC6 7 E58B9+9ECB5# 728 7 #BCB5F5AB# 7 %7 B,98D')C8B7769BA5##5#076,96575*B85F56779F)28BCAB7B27B,9#7E58B9+9ECB92A7)82E5##07C857%7 A27F5CA#7#3++9E95AB

7AD55D07+266269A7B,57C83F5AB#7)3B7+286C8D7%77B,57/3D5#72+

B,57(C89#7C))5C67E238B79A7NNN07B27B,5#575*B58AC67E2AD9B92A#7B,57)3BCB945749EB9F7A55D#

B27CDD72A57B,CB7)58BC9A#7B279B#726A7E2A#B9B3B92A7B,5749EB9F7ECA72A677%57E85D9%6579+

,5P#,5 7 D25# 7 A2B 7 %562A 7 B2 7 B,5 7 :3#3C6 7 #3#)5EB; 7 ECB52870 7 B,5 7 67893 4 63F F5AB92A5D7%77-557?ND@79A7,9#7#5F9AC67)C)587B7ECA7545A7%57#C9D7B,CB7B,57#3EE5##+36 E2A458#92A 7 2+ 7 B,5 7 C665CB92A 7 9AB2 7 C 7 85E28D5D 7 +CEB 7 85#B# 7 2A 7 :)5AC6 7 4989A9B7; 7 9B#56+

/3D5#7D9#E89F9ACB57%5B655A7B,576286D72+7B,2#576,27D279A267?,267B27695@7CAD7B,5 6286D 7 2+ 7 B,2#5 7 6,2 7 D2ATB 7 M9B, 7 3A69BB9A 7 E7A9E9#F0 7 B,5 7 /3D5# 72%#5845D 7B,CB 7 B,5 )6C9AB9++7,CD7A2B7%55A7C%657B27#557C76C6758

076,9E,7B27B,5F7ECF57C#7C7E2A+98FCB92A72+

17

L

M,5A54587B,573#572+7+28E579#73AA5E5##C87728724586,56F9A0749265AE57%5E2F5#

96659B9FCB57B7ECA7B,5A7,9D57%5,9AD7CA7CEE3#CB92A72+7458%C67C##C36B073A6C6+36 85%56692A7287C##C36B9A7C7)269E572++9E587B7B,CB7#BC5075#BC%69#,9A7B,57B83B,

%5E2F5#7D9++9E36B7?-57!23##C607NDD07B@

,9#7#9AE589B77-5C67CD49E576236D7,C45749B9CB5D7,9#7B5#B9F2A775,57/3D57D8C6#7C74587 E65C8769A57CF2A7%59A#7B,573A%65F9#,5D7?CAD7E85D9%65@72A7B,572A57,CAD07B,57BC9AB5D

?CAD79AC3D9%65@72A7B,572B,587))679A7B27B,5765C67+956D7C7B58F9A26277%288265D7+82F B,57#5F92B9E#72+7#E95AE57CAD7B5E,A2627079B7E236D7%57#C9D7B,CB7B,57)6C9AB9++7ECA72A677%5 ,5C8D 7 CAD 7 E85D9%65 7 9+ 7 ,5P#,5 7 E2A+28F# 7 B2 7 C 7 82E9',C8D 7 :#E89)B; 7 ?989E,0 7 NN@0 5#BC%69#,5D7%77B,57/3D5#7CAD7C#73AE2F)82F9#9A7C#7B,57#E89)B72+7C7F5BC67D5B5EB280 6,9E,759B,587D25#7287D25#7A2B7%55)76,5A76C695D7B,823,7%77C7)C##5A587?2%C8D0 -9A,C8DB07D@7<5AE507B,57E85D9%969B772+7H56F23A9.#7B5#B9F2A7785#B5D7A59B,5872A7B,5 E63F#9A5## 7 2+ 7 B,5 7 )269E5 7 A28 7 2A 7 B,5 7 23B8C523#A5## 7 2+ 7 B,5 7 C%3#5 7 ,5 7 ,CD 7 %55A

#3%/5EB5D 7 B2 7 %2B, 7 E2AD9B92A#0 7 B,23, 7 A5E5##C870 7 6585 7 9A#3++9E95AB 7 <9# 7 )82%CB945 +28E576C#7C7)82D3EB72+7,9#7:E2FF2A7FCA;7E2AD9B92A7+7,9#7%59A7,9B,58B273ABC9AB5D

%77CA77)89287E2AA5EB92A#7B27B,5765C67FCE,9A57CAD7B,57B89E9#79B7ECA7B5CE,77237+7,9#

6CE972+7)5AC67CBB89%3B5#

M,5B,58 7 B,5 7 )2B5AB9C6 7 #3EE5## 7 2+ 7 B,5 7 C6655D 7 C%3#5 7 AC88CB945 7 %5 7 D5#E89%5D

%288269A 7B,57#E89)B 7E2AE5)B 7+82F7B,57#2E92627 72+7 #E95AE57CAD7B5E,A2627 7287B,5 )385P9F)3857D9E,2B2F77+82F7CAB,82)26277?!236C#07NFF@07C7)C8B9E36C86775*9323#

#)CE579#7%59A723B69A5D76,5859A796659B9FCB57)269E9A7C%3#57#BC8B#7%59A7E2A#9D585D7C#

#3E, 7 %7 7 #2E95B7

7 M,965 7 B,9# 7 9# 7 A2B 7 B,5 7 )6CE5 7 B2 7 5*)6285 7 B,5 7 )C8B9E36C8# 7 2+ 7 9B#

9AE5)B92A07657FC77A5458B,565##7#95BE,723B7B,57C85C72+7CDF9##9%969B772+7)269E9A7C%3#5 C#7#2F5799AD72+7&3CD896CB58C6769B,79AB58856CB5D7458B9E5#75,57+98#B7458B5*07C#7657,C45 /3#B7#55A079# 7B,CB72+7)5AC67)389B775,57#5E2AD72A57 856CB5# 7B2 7B,57FCA9B3D572+7B,5 C%3#5076,9E,7,C#7B27%5785FC89C%6575,98D7E2F5#7B,57549D5AE576,5B,587FCB589C6728 B5#B9F2A9C6079B79#7#3%/5EB7B27B,57#CF57)389B7785&3985F5AB#7C#7B,57)3BCB945749EB9F76C#

+769BA5##5#7C857856CB5D7B27B,5749EB9F79A7CA776C7072879+7B,577D27A2B72++587B,573C8CAB55#

85&3985D 7%7 7B,57/3D9E9C6 7#E89)B 79A7B58F# 72+7 8569C%969B7 7 28 7)389B707B,5A7B,5987 628D 79#

D9#E85D9B5D 7 CAD 7 ECAA2B 7 BC95 7 CD4CABC5 7 2+ 7 CA7 7 :2)58CB28# 7 2+ 7 +CEB3C69B7; 7 CA7F285

?!362A07NNI07NND@7B7B,57+238B,7E28A587695#7B,57E2AB5*B72+7B,57C%3#57"2A458B9A CA7C6655D7+CEB79AB27C785E28D5D72A579F)695#75#BC%69#,9A7%572AD7D23%B7B,CB7B,57)269E5 CEB5D769B,23B7%59A79A7DCA587287B,85CB5A5D79A7CA776C77B7#,236D7%57A2B5D7,5857B,CB B,9#7)82)58B772+7B,57&3CD896CB58C679#7A2B7D5429D72+7)269E9A79AB5845AB92A7A79A76C858 )82)28B92A# 7 B,CA 7 B,5 7 2B,58# 7 A 7 C 7 85)28B 7 2A 7 D9#E9)69AC87 7 6C)#5# 7 69B,9A 7 B,5 7 567893

%EF86AE7307B,57!985EB2872+7B,57U(17?$A39F86A4& A E734347E45678934%EF86AE73

@ A2B5D7B,CB7B,5775C86778CB9272+75#BC%69#,5D7+CEB#7+63EB3CB5D7%5B655A7IV7CAD7V72+

C6655D7EC#5#76,5A7B,57E6C9FCAB7,9F#56+76C#7A2B7BC85B5D7%77C7E2F)6C9AB7+82F7B,5 )269E50 7 CAD 7 2A67 7 FV 7 B2 7 IV 7 6,5A 7 B,5 7 )269E5 7 ,CD 7 +965D 7 C 7 E2F)6C9AB 7 CC9A#B 7 B,5 E6C9FCAB75,57!985EB287B,5A7CDD5D

18

M9B,23B 7 45AB389A 7 +38B,58 7 9AB2 7 C 7 D5BC965D 7 5*)6CACB92A 7 2+ 7 B,5 7 E2A#B8C9AB# 7 2+

E2A458B9A7CA7C6655D7+CEB79AB27CA75#BC%69#,5D72A5076572%#58457B,CB79B79#7)85E9#56779A B,2#57#2E9C67#)CE5#76,5857)269E9A7F2#B7B5AD#7B2785#28B7B27+28E57B,CB7B,9#7C))82CE,79#

65C#B 7 699567 7 B2 7 B8958 7 E238B 7 CEB92A 7 565CB5D 7 38%CA 7 C85C# 7 +5CB385 7 #3E, 7 C 7 ,9, )82)28B92A72+7723A7FC65#769B,7)89287E2A49EB92A#7A7CAD7CA7545A7,9,587A3F%5872+

723A 7 FC65# 7 :9A26A 7 B2 7 6C6 7 5A+28E5F5AB;0 7 69B, 7 C 7 )269E5 7 85E28D 7 +28 7 ,C49A 7 %55A C885#B5D7CB765C#B72AE57A7B,CB79B79#7D9++9E36B7B27+9AD769BA5##5#769B,7A27)5AC6785E28DA28 545A7:A2A'3AE65CA;7B,98D7)C8B95#07945A7B,5765456#72+7#2E9C67#585CB92A79A7#3E,7C85C#

?-C8CA507N@7<9,7B5A#92A7C85C#076,5857B,57)269E57C857F2#B76995677B2785#28B7B2 +28E5+367CEB92A07C857B,2#576,5857)269E9A7C%3#579#7B,5765C#B76995677B27%57%823,B7B27B,5

#)2B69,B7A7#3E,7#2E9C67#)CE5#07#965AE57CAD749265AE57%5,C45769957%2B,7#9D5#72+72A57CAD

19

L

The place of sovereignty in the theory of policing

B,57#CF57EW%93#7#B89)

<5AE507B,572)5AA5##P#5E85B7D3C69B776,9E,782D5387E2A#9D585D7B27%57CA72%#BCE657B2 ,9# 7)269E9A7 :B,5287; 7CEB3C667 7C))5C8#07 9A7B,575F)989EC6 785C69B7 72+7B,57%5E2F9A72+

49265AB7545AB#07B27%57C7E2F)2A5AB72+7)269E9A7C87 +82F7%5,C49A7C# 7CA728CA9#F

#)69BB9A79AB27B627#5)C8CB5728CA9#F#07,9,7CAD76267)269E9A7?82D53807NDG@07)269E9A 9# 7 E2A#B9B3B94567 7 D3C6 7 2)5A 7 28 7 #5E85B0 7 D5)5AD9A 7 2A 7 B,5 7 E98E3F#BCAE5#0 7 )6CE50 7 28 )82BC2A9#B#75,57D98B707#3#)5EB07:BC9AB5D;7#9D572+7)269E9A07E2A#9D585D7%7782D5387B2

%57C7,9AD8CAE57B27,9#7B,528772+7)269E9A07C++5EB#7%2B,7)269E9A7C5AB#7CAD7B,57#2E95B7 9A76,9E,7B,5779AB5845A57AD7#9AE57A2B7C667#5EB92A#72+7#2E95B7785E59457CA7545A7#,C8572+

69,B07)269E57CEB92A#079A7B38A075B73A545A75*)2#9B92A7B27B,57)3%69E7C85

20

AD7#207+82F7C765C67)29AB72+7495607B,57E2AE5)B72+7:2)5AA5##;7F3#B7%57E2A#9D585D79A 9B#7856CB92A7B27)3%69E9B707C#79A7:2)5AA5##7CAD7)3%69E9B772+7)82E55D9A#;7+2879A#BCAE50 6,9E,73C8CAB55#75&3C69B772+7C8F#075BE73#B9E579#7D2A576,5A7%2B,7)C8B95# 75B7+C98 CEE5##7B279B076,5A7E,C85#07)822+#07CAD7F2B94CB92A#7C857FCD57)3%69EJ76,5A07#9F)670 B,57)269E9A79AB5845AB92A79#7%59A7:D8CFCB985D;7?ECAA9A0707*@076,9E,75AC%65#

B,575A58C67)3%69E7B27CEB7C#7C7/3D5728076,9E,7CF23AB#7B27B,57#CF507FC95#7/3D5#

)3%69E677CEE23ABC%6572+7,267B,577/3D5

7H2E92629EC67#B3D95#72A7B,573#572+7+28E57%7 )269E9A7C5AB#07,265458078545C67B,CB7C665CB92A#72+7C%3#57B5AD7B27%5785E5945D79A7CA 9AE85D9%6775*9323#7#)CE5J7CA73A+C987#)CE5079A7+CEB076,9E,7)8545AB#7F2#B7C665CB92A#

+82F 7 5458 7 E82##9A 7 B,5 7 B,85#,26D 7 2+ 7 )3%69E9B70 7 +28 7 6CAB 7 2+ 7 %59A 7 ,5C8D 7 28 7 #9F)67 C3D9%65

21

5,57)3%69E9B772+7)269E9A076,9E,7B23E,5#7%2B,7B,57D5FCAD7+2872)5AA5##7CAD7B,57#CD CE9A2665DF5AB 7 2+7 B,5 7:BC9AB5D;7 #9D5 72+ 7B,57 /2%0 79# 7 C 7 957 7 9##35 7+28 7 CA7 7 B,5287 72+

)269E9A 7 H,CD267 7 DC89A5##0 7 +C8 7 +82F 7 9F)5D9A 7 B,5 7 D54562)F5AB 7 2+ 7 C 7 B,5287 7 2+

)269E9A7C#782D5387#55F5D7B27+5C8079#79A7+CEB7B,57B23E,#B2A572+7C7)269B9EC67B,528772+

)269E9A07C#7657C857C%23B7B27#,26

22

B7ECA7%57A2B5D7B,CB79A7#2E9C67#)CE5#72+78565CB92A076,5857B,57A55D7+287)269E9A79#7B,5 F2#B7385AB07C#762A7C#7D549CAB7%5,C4928#7D27A2B75*E55D7E58BC9A769F9B#7?E83D57CAD 2%4923#75D9B9A72+7E,C857#,55B#07%6CBCAB7F9#BC95#72A7B,57#2E9C679D5AB9B772+72))2A5AB#0

#,22B9A 7 2+ 7 C 7 ,CADE3++5D 7 9AD949D3C60 7 5BE@0 7 )269E5 7 D549CAE5 7 6966 7 A2B 7 %5 7 D9#E9)69A5D

?85C8D65## 7 2+ 7 B,5 7 #EC65 7 2+ 7 D9#E9)69AC87 7 F5C#385#@ 7 5CA'(C36 7 82D538.# 7 D5+9A9B92A 85#B#72A7CA79F)69E9B7E2AB9A33F72+7)269E9A7F5CA#7EF26834F64348A46346473 96AF67734E483343EA7QKR

23

5,9#785FC897D25#7A2B7+9B7B,575F)989EC6785C69B772+7,267B,57)269E57856CB57B27B,576C6 5,585 7 9# 7 9AD55D 7 #3E, 7 C 7 B,9A 7 C# 7 C 7 D549CAB 7 856CB92A#,9) 7 B2 7 B,5 7 6C60 7 6,9E, 7 ECA 7 %5 )3A9#,5D7%77C7/3D507/3#B7C#7B,58579#7#3E,7C7B,9A7C#7C7+28F72+76C665##A5##76,9E,7#,C66 A2B7%57)3A9#,5D079A#2+C87C#79B79#795)B7,9DD5A7+82F7B,57/3D5T#7#9,B7A7C7E58BC9A76C7 B,5A076575AD73)769B,7B627B7)5#72+7)269E9A712B79A7B,57#5A#572+7B627D9++585AB7)269E9A 9A#B9B3B92A#07#3E,7C#7,9,7CAD76267)269E9A07CAD7A2B79A7B,57#5A#572+7B627CABC2A9#B9E )269E9A7)8CEB9E5#7A7B,57%5CB7)269E5FCA74#7B,573AD58E24587C5AB07+2879A#BCAE57A7%3B B62 7 :F2DC69B95#; 7 2+ 7 )269E9A0 7 D5)5AD9A 7 2A 7 B,5 7 E98E3F#BCAE5# 7 CAD 7 #2E9C6 7 #)CE5 6,5859A7C7945A7)269E9A79AB5845AB92A7BC95#7)6CE575,5857#9F)67 7C857#)5E9+9E7#2E9C6

#)CE5#76,5857A27C))5C676966754587%57FCD57CC9A#B7CA77)269E9A79AB5845AB92A7A76,585 )269E9A 7 C5AB# 7 B,3# 7 859A 7 #3)85F5 7 A 7 #3E, 7 #)CE5# 7 28 7 E98E3F#BCAE5#0 7 )269E9A 9A#B9B3B92A#785)6CE57B,576C607)85#E89%9A7B,57A28F#0769B,7B,573AD58#BCAD9A7B,CB7A2 6C67ECA75*9#B769B,23B7)3A9#,F5AB7(269E9A079A7#3E,7#)CE5#7287E98E3F#BCAE5#07)58BC9A#

24

H245859A79#7,576,27D5E9D5#72A7B,575*E5)B92A

A sociological theory of policing (or:

what a decisionist theory of policing is not)

H2E9C67#E95AE5#7C8572+B5A78563EBCAB7B27CDF9B7,267D5E9#9457B,57458775*9#B5AE572+

)269E9A7+28E5#7A79A7B,5769D587#5A#57A79#79A7)58)5B3CB9A7#2E9C6728D5807CAD7545A F28579A7)82D3E9A79B7H2E92629#B#7B,3#7C8357B,CB728D587,C#7A267%55A

9AB58AC6985D79A7CD4CAE5D7#2E95B95#7CAD7B,CB785#28B9A7B27+28E57,C#7%5E2F5 3AA5E5##C877M,9657B,57789,B677)29AB723B7B,CB749265AB7)269E9A79AB5845AB92A#7C85 B,575*E5)B92A78CB,587B,CA7B,57A28F07B,9#765CD#7B,5F7B2785F2457C667B8CE5#72+

)269E573#572+7+28E57+82F7B,5987CAC67#5#

B27C7D5E9#92A9#B7B,528772+76C676,585%77?C#72))2#5D7B27A28FCB949#F@7B,576C67D25#7A2B D589457+82F7#2F57#3)85F57A28F7?"2A#B9B3B92A0796672+7 9,B#07"2D5K@07%3B7+82F7B,5 9AD949D3C675#B38572+76,254587D5E9D5#769B,7A2789#972+7%59A7D9#C66265D7<58579#7,26 U58FCA7/389#B7"C867HE,F9BB7?NGB07@7+28F36CB5D7B,9#7D5E9#92A9#B7B,528772+76C6

5,9#7D5+9A9B92A72+7#245859AB779#7B62+26D7#245859A79#7,576,2#57D5E9#92A7ECAA2B7%5 C))5C65D7C#762A7C#79B76C#7FCD579A75*E5)B92AC67E98E3F#BCAE5#J7CAD7#245859A7C6#27,5 6,2 7 FC7 7 D5E9D5 7 B,CB 7 E98E3F#BCAE5# 7 ,C45 7 %5E2F5 7 5*E5)B92AC6 7 CAD 7 28D9AC87 7 6C6#

E5C#57B27C))6775,57E2AE5)B72+7:)269E57D9#E85B92A;7?2A572+7B,5726D5#B79A7B,57#2E9262772+

)269E9A 7 A 7 #55 7 X62E9C8#0 7 NDO@ 7 9# 7 B2 7 %5 7 3AD58#B22D 7 9A 7 B,5 7 E2AB5*B 7 2+ 7 B,5 7 6CBB58 CEE5)BCB92A0 7C# 79663#B8CB5D 7%7 7B,5 7%9BB587#BCB5F5AB 7 FCD5 7O 7 75C8# 7C2 7%7 7B,57 B,5A

!985EB2872+7U(17?C%245@07E2FF5AB9A72A7B,57)2##9%969B772+7)2#B',2E785689B9A72+7CA7

#9B3CB92A7(269E9A7C5AB#079A7E58BC9A7#2E9C67#)CE5#07C8579A7C7)2#9B92A7B27E3B72++7CEE5##7B2 B,5765C67#7#B5F7+2872B,587)C8B95#07B,3#75++5EB945677#69BE,9A7B27C7859F572+75*E5)B92A A7#2F57#)5E9+9E7C85AC#07B,576C679#7#9F)677A2B7B,57#CF5

25

5,9# 7 )5E369C8 7 856CB92A#,9) 7 2+ 7 )269E9A 7 C5AB# 7 B2 7 #245859AB7 7 ,C# 7 4C8923#

85)58E3##92A#75,57F2#B72%4923#7,C#7B27D2769B,7B,57HBCB57A7957)3%69E7C3B,289B95#79A E58BC9A7#2E9C67#)CE5#7287E98E3F#BCAE5#0:B,575*E5)B92A78545C6#7F2#B7E65C8677B,575##5AE5 2+ 7 B,5 7 #BCB5T# 7 C3B,289B7; 7 ?HE,F9BB 7 NGB0 7 N0 7 B8CA# 7 HE,6C%0 7 G@ 7 A 7 #3E, 7 #)CE5# 7 28 E98E3F#BCAE5#0 765C6 7#BCADC8D# 7)587#5 7A2 7 62A58 7)58+28F 7#CB9#+CEB289670 7CAD 7)3%69E C3B,289B95#7,C457B276956D7B,57#628D72+7)26587B2785CE,7C7D5E9#92A7B,CB7ECA72A677%5 +9AC6

26

5,57F2#B7#C695AB7B,5285B9EC67E2A#5&35AE572+7B,57D5E9#92A9#F78545C65D7%77B,57+C96385 2+7E89F9AC67/3#B9E57B27CEB7CC9A#B765C676C665##A5##07,26545807D25#7A2B7)58BC9A7B27#BCB5 )26587%3B7A73AD58#BCAD9A7#245859AB779A7B,57#5A#57E2A+5885D7B279B7%77HE,F9BB7A7B2 B,57856CB92A#,9)7%5B655A7)269E9A7CAD7B,57)269B9EC675+2857BCE969A7B,9#7D9F5A#92A0 ,26545807 65 7A55D 7B2 7 )855F)B94567 7,9,69,B 7 B,57 DCA58# 79A,585AB 7B2 7C))679A 7B,5 E2AE5)B72+7#245859AB77B27)269E9A7C5AB#07945A7B,57FCA77C%#263B9#B7E2AE5)B92A#7A

%5C89A 7 A2 7 856CB92A#,9) 7 6,CB#25458 7 69B, 7 B,5 7 85C69B7 7 2+ 7 238 7 E3885AB 7 #2E95B95# 7 A 5A58CB5D785E5AB677%77HE,F9BB.#7D5E9#92A9#F

27

3876,2657C83F5AB79#7%C#5D72A7B,5726D07E2FF2A)6CE579D5C7? 59##0728D3C07NFI@

B,CB7B,574C8923# 7#)CE5# 7B,CB 7FC95 73) 7C 7#2E95B7 785E59457D9++585AB 7B7)5# 72+7)269E9A M,CB 7 9# 7 #38)89#9A 7 9# 7 B,CB 7 B,5 7 B,5285B9EC6 7 85)58E3##92A# 7 #55F 7 B2 7 ,C45 7 %55A 245862295D075#)5E9C66779A7B58F#72+7D5B58F9A9A7B,5789,B7+9B7+2876C679AB27)269E9A7#

5F),C#985D7%77(958857C4857?07GI@

28

M,5A 7 82D538 7 )82)2#5D 7 C 7 65C6 7 6C665##A5##'E5AB585D 7 D5+9A9B92A 7 2+ 7 )269E9A0 7 ,5 5*E63D5D 7 +82F 7 B,5 7 #E2)5 7 2+ 7 B,9# 7 D5+9A9B92A 7 B,5 7 +CEB 7 B,CB 7 B,5 7 6C60 7 +C8 7 +82F 7 %59A 3A9458#C60 79# 7 CAD 7 85FC9A# 7C 7 #2E9C667 75*E63#945 7C##5B 7 A 7C# 79+7 6,CB5458 7 D5C6B 769B, 7C

29

A political theory of policing

#2E92629EC67CAC67#9#72+7B,57D9++585AB9C679F)65F5ABCB92A72+7B,576C67%77)269E9A7C5AB#

?957B,57#2E9262772+7:6C675A+28E5F5AB;079A7B,57#B89EB587#5A#507C#75AC5D7%776CE90 NIG@7D9D7)58BC9A7B27C7#)5E9+9E7C85C72+7#2E92629EC679A45#B9CB92A07%3B7A2762A587,CD CA7 7 85654CAE5 7 B2 7 B,5 7 B,5287 7 2+ 7 )269E9A 7 82D538 7 2%#5845D 7 B,CB 7 )269E9A 7 6C#

+3ADCF5ABC6677:#565EB945;7?567898AB4C3D07N@07%3B7#3E,7C7E2A#9D58CB92A7D9D7A2B,9A B2 7 C6B58 7 ,9# 7 D5+9A9B92A 7 2+ 7 )269E9A0 7 6,2#5 7 :E2F)65B5A5##; 7 ,5 7 6CAB5D 7 B2 7 )82B5EB0 9A269A7+366765667B,CB79B76C# 7%59A7B,85CB5A5D7%7 7D3C69B7K7 5#28B9A7B2 7HE,F9BB.#

D5E9#92A9#F79#7A2B7/3#B7B,57B,5285B9EC67E2A#5&35AE572+7C7E2AE85B576C6'%C#5D7C))82CE, 2+7B,57#2E9262772+7)269E9A79B7C6#27D25#7/3#B9E57B27B,57D3C69B77CAD7:BC9AB5D;7ACB38572+

)269E9A

5,9#7D5E9#92A9#B7B,52877,C#79B#726A73AD58679A7#2E9C67528C),775,823,23B7F2#B 2+7#2E95B707)269E9A7C5AB#7C857#3%/5EB5D7B27B,57#,C85D76C6076,9E,7B,577ECA75FCAE9)CB5 +82F72A6779A7#2F57#)5E9+9E7#5EB92A#72+7#C9D7#2E95B77<5AE50785#28B9A7B27HE,F9BB7A72A5 2+7B,57/389#B#76,27#9B7CB7B,5745877E28572+7CA72A29A7#ECADC679A79AB5665EB3C67,9#B287

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

30

5#9D5#07#245859AB77D25#7A2B79F)677C%#263B57)2658759B,5875,57)8CEB9EC67)2658#72+

)269E9A7 C5AB# 79A7 C85C# 72+7 #245859AB7 785FC9A7 5AE62#5D 7 69B,9A 7B,57 %23AD# 72+7 B,5

&3CD896CB58C6 7 65 7 ,C45 7 D8C6A 7 C%245 7 5,5 7 )269E5 7 #B966 7 A55D 7 B2 7 C##5## 7 B,5 7 ACB385 7 2+

6,254587B,577C857+CE9A07B,57699569,22D72+7E85D9%65769BA5##5#07CAD7B,57FCA9B3D572+

B,57DCFC57B,57 7FC779A+69EB75,5987#245859AB7 79#7%59A769F9B5D7%77B,57CAB9E9)CB5D 85E5)B92A7A7%77B,5987E2665C35#07CAD7B,5A7%77B,57/3D5#7A72+7B,57)2#B'9AB5845AB92A AC88CB9457B,57769667%57C%657B27)82D3E575,9#7E2A#B8C9AB7#5458567785#B89EB#7B,59876CB9B3D5

?ECAA9A0 7 NIDJ 7 2%C8D0 7 O@0 7 CAD 7 E2A#BCAB67 7 9AD5*5# 7 )269E9A 7 CEB92A 7 2AB2 7 B,5 ACB38572+7B,575A4982AF5AB79A76,9E,7C7945A7)269E9A79AB5845AB92A7BC95#7)6CE575,5 )269E57A7B,5#57:#B855BE28A587)269B9E9CA#;79A7B,57628D#72+7M9669CF7X587E3987?NII@7A C857)269B9EC67CEB28#79A#2+C87C#07+CE5D769B,7CA73)E2F9A79AB58CEB92A07B,577,C457B27C##5##

6,CB7ECA7287ECAA2B7%57E2A#9D585D7)269B9EC6677CEE5)BC%657%5,C49287+82F7B,5F7?#557C

#9F96C8762897%772#9C,7EE<57FCA72A7%28D587)CB8267C5AB#7CB7B,57E5*9E2'CH7%28D580 5 7 EE<57FCA0 7@ 7(269E9A 7 C5AB#0 7 CB 7 B,5 7 4587 7 F2F5AB 7 2+7 5AC9A 7 9AB2 7CA 9AB58CEB92A07C857%3#77C39A7B,57)269B9EC67FCADCB575AB83#B5D7B27B,5F7%77B,57#2E95B7 527%57F2857)85E9#507B,577C857%3#77C##5##9A76,5B,587287A2B7B,57)269B9EC67E2AD9B92A#

C857F5B7B,CB76236D7C66267B,5F7B275AC579A7CA7CEB72+7#245859AB707#,236D7B,57769#,7B2 D27#2

31

5,9#79#7,267:)269E57D9#E85B92A;07C#7)3B7+286C8D7%77128B,7F589ECA7#2E92629#B#7+28

#5458C6 7 D5ECD5#0 7 #,236D 7 %5 7 3AD58#B22D 7 5EC3#5 7 2A5 7 +28F 7 2+ 7 )2658 7 5*9#B# 7 B,CB 9AE63D5#7B,573#572+7+28E507)2##9%6773)7B27B,579A+69EB92A72+7D5CB,07CAD7%5EC3#572A57+28F 2+ 7 )2658 7 5*9#B# 7 B,CB 7 E2FFCAD# 7 85#)5EB 7 B2 7 C66 7 2B,58 7 +28F# 7 2+ 7 )2658 7 9A 7 E58BC9A E98E3F#BCAE5#07B,5A7B,9#7D9#E85B92AC877+28F72+7)26587)58BC9A#7B27#245859AB779B79#7C )269B9EC6 7 )2658 7 2807 C# 7 #35#B5D 75C8695807 6,CB 79# 7 CB 7#BC957 ,585 79# 7A2B 7 F58567 7 B,5

#3%#B9B3B92A72+7B,576C67%77B,57)3857)265872+7B,57#BCB507%3B7F234678F89E748A48F43 33A93

32

H5458C6775C8#7,C457)C##5D7C685CD77#9AE577CDD5D7B27EC*7M5%58T#7+CF23#

D5+9A9B92A72+7B,57HBCB57C#7:B,57F2A2)26772A7659B9FCB5749265AE5;076,9E,7 CF5AD5D7CAD7C3F5AB5D7C#7C7:F2A2)26772A7),7#9EC67CAD7#7F%269E749265AE5;J 2A57E236D7545A7#C77:F2A2)26772A7#7F%269E7659B9FCB5749265AE5;079A#2+C87C#7B,5 F2A2)26772A7#7F%269E749265AE579#7B,57E2AD9B92A7+287)2##5##9A7B,5789,B7B2 5*58E9#57B,57F2A2)26772A7),7#9EC6749265AE579B#56+7?238D953707B@

L

F)989EC6 7 3AD58#BCAD9A 7 2+ 7 B,5 7 +CB5 7 2+ 7 )269E5')58)5B8CB5D 7 CEB# 7 2+ 7 6C665##A5##

5AC%65#73#7B27D569A5CB57C7#)CE572+7#245859AB776,5859A7)269E9A7C5AB#7FC772)58CB5 M,CB7D25#7#3E,7CA79A#9,B75ABC96S7M,CB79#7B,57CDD5D74C63572+723872%#584CB92A#S785 657#9F)67785)6CE9A72A57E2AE5)B7?)269E57D9#E85B92A728765C676C665##A5##@769B,7CA2B,58

?#245859AB7@S 7 5,5 7 D5B238 7 B,823, 7 HE,F9BBT# 7 D5E9#92A9#B 7 B,5287 7 C))5C8# 7 B2 7 %5 D5E9#945079AC#F3E,7C#7B,57A567)58#)5EB945#79B72)5A#7C662673#7B27+9B7)269E9A79AB27B,5 69D58 7 +8CF56289 7 2+ 7 :)269B9EC6 7 B,5287;0 7 CA 7 C85C 7 B,CB 7 5F%8CE5# 7 %2B, 7 B,5 7 B,5287 7 2+

/3#B9E57E,CF)92A5D7%77 C66#7287<C8B7?#557ECAA9A07@7CAD7B,57B,528772+7B,57HBCB5 28079A7C7%82CD587#5A#5072+7B,57)269B7

33

AB585#B9A677A7C##3F9A7CA72A57#B9667A55D#7B27%57E2A49AE5D7B,CB7)269E9A7#,236D

%57#B3D95D7C#7CA7565F5AB72+7B,57B,528772+7B,57HBCB57A079A7(958857238D953.#765EB385#72A B,57HBCB5076,9E,7,C457/3#B7%55A7)3%69#,5D79A785AE,7?238D95307@07)269E9A07CAD F2857%82CD677E258E92A07,C457/3#B74CA9#,5D7+82F7B,57D5+9A9B92A72+7B,57HBCB507B,CA9#7B2 C7E654587E2A/389A7B89E97H38)89#9A6779A7#3E,7C7E2AB5*B07B,57628D7:)269E5;7#9F)677D25#

A2B7C))5C879A7B,57BC%65 72+7E2AB5AB# 72+7B,57FF')C5 7E2F)5AD93FJ 7CAD 723B72+7B,5 8CAD7B2BC672+7A9A572EE3885AE5#79A7B,576,2657%22907F2#B7E2A#9#B79A7C7F5B2A7F9E73#5 2+7B,57B58F075AE2F)C##9A7B,576,265785)85##9457C))C8CB3#72+7B,57HBCB57CAD7EC#3C667

&32B5D79A7B,5749E9A9B772+7#3E,7B58F#7C#7:C8F7;7287:C6679A#B9B3B92A#76,2#57FCADCB579#7B2 3C8CAB55 7 6C6 7 CAD 7 28D58; 7 ?73A3D73 4 3 4 8AF8FF86A 4 EAEF 3 4 6 4 BEEAF8 763J707O07GN07GO07GI@7<58579#7C7#CF)6572+7,267B,57D9##9F36CB92A72+7),7#9EC6 +28E57CAD7)269E9A79A7B2DC7T#7)269B779#7%59A7EC8895D723B

34

+07,265458072A573A69AD#7B,57B,85CD72+765C676C665##A5##7B27B,57458775AD07C#79#7F7 E6C9F7,58507B27D9#E24587B,57A2B92A72+7#245859AB7079B7C))5C8#7&39B57E65C8677B,CB76,CB79#

CB7#BC9579#7F2857B,CA7),7#9EC6749265AE57C#7C7F5857C))5ADC572+7:#7F%269E749265AE5;

2876,CB7B,57E2AE5)B72+7#245859AB77C#7#3))28B5D7%77DC9677)269E9A7CEB92A765CD#7B279#7C D55)5873AD58#BCAD9A72+7B,57)269B9EC67D9F5A#92A72+7)269E9A7E2#B7C3B,28#07+266269A 9BBA5807,C457)3B7),7#9EC67+28E57CB7B,57E28572+7B,5987E2AE5)B92A72+7)269E9A7H2F5076995 82D53807,C457%396B7CA75AB9857F2D567C823AD76C665##A5##75877+567A7ECAA9A79#72A5 A 7 ,C45 785695D 7 2A 7 B,5 7 E2AE5)B 7 2+ 7 5*E5)B92A 7 C# 7 C 7 FC/28 7C#)5EB 72+ 7 B,5 7 D5+9A9B92A 72+

)269E9A 7 AD 7 6,5A 7 B,57 7 D9D0 7 B,57 7 )8245D 7 8563EBCAB 7 B2 7 +3667 7 2)5A 7 B,5 7 5A#39A B,5285B9EC67)58#)5EB945

7M,9E,7)58#)5EB945#07B,5A075B73A62E95D76,5A785#28B9A7B2 B,9#7E2AE5)BS

35

52 7 HE,F9BB0 7 FC99A 7 D5E9#92A# 7 9A 7 CA 7 5*E5)B92AC6 7 #9B3CB92A 7 ?95 7 5*58E9#9A

#245859AB7@7CF23AB#7B275*)85##9A7B,57)269B9EC6J79A72B,587628D#079A7HE,F9BBT#79D5C07B2 D9#B9A39#,9A7%5B655A7+895AD7CAD7+257287B,57)82D3EB72+7#245859A7D5E9#92A'FC99A 9# 7A2B 7 #2 7F3E, 7 B,5 7 HBCB5 7 C# 7B,5 7 )269B9EC6 7 9B#56+ 7 5,5 7 HBCB5 7 9# 7 %3B 7 C 7 #)5E9+9E 7#,C)50

#56+'5A9A5585D7%7 7B,57:)269B9EC673A9B;7A7B,57)269B7 7A79A7B,57E238#572+7)58+28F9A

#245859A7D5E9#92A'FC99A79B#56+75,57+CF23#7#BCB5F5AB7#C7#79B7C667F23496A93F464F23 FEF343634F23496A93F464F234678F89E77?HE,F9BB07NGB0707B8CA#7HE,6C%@J7CAD B,57)269B9EC67C#765667C#7B,57)269B77C857D5+9A5D7%77B,9#7)5E369C87F2F5AB76,5A7+895AD79#

#5)C8CB5D 7 +82F 7 +25 7 ?NGB0 7 7 J 7 B8CA# 7 HE,6C% 7 F23 4 39889 4 678F89E7 4 8F8A9F86A 4 F6 2892 4 678F89E7 4 E9F86A 4 EA 4 6F83 4 9EA 4 D3 4 393 4 8 4 F2EF 4 D3F33A 4 83A 4 EA 3A307F@7!5E9#92A'FC99A79A7CA75*E5)B92AC67#9B3CB92A79#7B,57)C8B9E36C86779AB5A#5 F2F5AB 76,5A7B,57)269B9EC67 FCA9+5#B# 79B#56+0 7CAD 7B,9# 7FCA9+5#BCB92A79# 7B,57E,CAA56 B,823,76,9E,7C7E2FF3A9B707C7#2E95B7079D5AB9+95#79B#726A75A5F77EE28D9A7B27B,9#

9AB58)85BCB92A0 7 6,9E, 7 9# 7 %C#5D 7 2A 7 B,5 7 +98#B 7 )C5# 7 2+ 7 HE,F9BBT# 7123 4 '6A93F 4 6 4 F23

36

L

Conclusion

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

B7B,CB7#BC572+7+28F36CB9A72387,7)2B,5#9#07657#,236D785+8C9A7+82F7CA77C%#263B9#B 9AB58)85BCB92A 7 2+ 7 B,5 7 E2AE5)B 7 2+ 7 5A5F7 7 HE,F9BB 7 C))C85AB67 7 85695D 7 2A 7 C 7 8CB,58 )82E5D38C6079+7A2B7BC3B2629EC67E2AE5)B92A72+79B7D5429D72+7)892875##5AE507B,575A5F779#

6,254587,C))5A#7B27%57E2A#9D585D7C#7#3E,7A7,9#73#572+7B,57B58F07HE,F9BB7)9E95D73)

?CAD 7 #3%458B5D 7 A 7 #55 7 X584$CA0 7 NN0 7 DF@ 7 2A 7 CA 7 9D5C 7 2AE5 7 3#5D 7 %7 7 <556 7 B2 5#BC%69#, 7 B,5 7 )269B9EC6 7 E2FF3A9B7 7 (3B37 4 2E 4 E76 4 EEA93 4 E 4 38A8F86A 4 6 4 F23 3A34289248A4B3A3E742E4D33A43E34D463A42876623412343A3484F23 3F289E74833A934?8348FF789234)833A@4E4F234E783A4F64D34A3BEF88348A4284788AB F6FE78F7?NNF07F7Z7)58#7B8CA#6CB92A7+82F7)3438A48F48348FF789234)833A4E7438A 4A3B833A343348A438A3473D3A8B3A416FE78F*F@7B76236D7%57CACE,82A9#B9E7B2 BC95 7 HE,F9BB.# 7 3 7 B2 7 F5CA 7 :+2859A58; 7 9A 7 B,5 7 F2D58A 7 ACB92A'#BCB5 7 #5A#50 7 C#

#2F52A576,207C6B,23,7)85#5AB72A7B,57ACB92AC67B5889B287079#79A7+CEB75AD265D769B,7C D9++585AB7E9B985A#,9)7 CB,5807,579#7B,57#B8CA5807287B,572B,587A7<556.#749567B,5A07B,5

#B8CA58 7 9# 7 6,25458 7 D25# 7 A2B 7 )C8BC95 7 B2 7 B,5 7 5B,9E# 7 2+ 7 B,5 7 E2FF3A9B70 7 9B# 7 #,C85D 4C635#K 7 #9F)67 7 )3B0 7 9B# 7 F285# 7 ?83 4 #8FF3A@ 7 EE28D9A 7 B2 7 B,9# 7 C83F5AB0 7 F2D58A )269E9A7C5AB#079A76,CB54587#)CE5#72+7#245859AB77C8578CAB5D7B27B,5F07C8575*)5EB5D B27E2AB8267B,573AD9#E9)69A5D07B,2#576,2#57F285#7BC9575*E5)B92A7A7287C857#3))2#5D7B2 BC9575*E5)B92A7A7+82F7B,57D2F9ACAB72A5#7#7!9D9587C##9A7?07GB@7)3B79B79A7,9#

85E5AB75B,A28C),772+7C7)269E57+28E507B,5#57C857:5A5F95#;7?,9#7B58F@07D5+9A5D7C#7#3E,

%5EC3#572+7B,5987%59A7:85/5EB5D79A7C78CD9EC672B,58A5##;

37

H5989A76,CB54587E82)#73)76,5A7BC99A7#58923#677B,579D5C7B,CB765C676C665##A5##7695#

CB 7 B,5 7 4587 7 E285 7 2+ 7 B,5 7 E2AE5)B 7 2+ 7 )269E9A 7 A 7 95 7 6,5A 7 5*CF9A9A 7 B,5 7 BCA9%65 FCA9+5#BCB92A#72+7B,9#7)C8B9E36C87%8CAD72+76C665##A5##7A7B,3#73A+26D#7C7#3%#BCAB9C6 D9F5A#92A72+7)269E9A7B,57D9F5A#92A72+7B,57)269B9EC6072+75B,9EC672B,58A5##76,9E,07CB

#2F57#)5E9+9E7#BC572+79B#7D54562)F5AB07D5+9A5#7B,5769F9B#7CAD7ACB38572+7B,57)269B77#

9+07#2F56,5857%56267B,578CB92AC6'65C67HBCB507)269E9A7C5AB#765857%3#96775AC5D79A )58)5B3CB9A 7 9B# 7 #3%#BCAB9C60 7 9885D3E9%67 7 )269B9EC6 7 D9F5A#92A 7 A 7 6,9E,0 7 9A 7 C66 699569,22D07D25#75*)6C9A7B,59879885D3E9%65749265AE579AD55D7##5##9A7B,576,26578CA5 2+ 7 B,5285B9EC6 7E2A#5&35AE5# 7 #B5FF9A 7 +82F 7 B,5 7 D5+9A9B92A 7 )82)2#5D 7 %7 7 5CA'(C36 82D53879A7567898AB4C3D07,265458076236D7BC9573#7+C87%572AD7B,57#E2)572+7B,9#7B89%3B5 A76,9E,7657A267,C457B27%89A7B27C7E2AE63#92A

38

5,5857ECA7%5769BB657D23%B7B,CB769B,7#3E,7E2AE5)B#7C#7B,57)269B707#245859AB77287B,5 5A5F707545A7B,57F2#B75F)989EC67?A2B7B27#C775F)989E9#B@785#5C8E,72A7)269E9A76236D ,9A57C762B7%5BB5872AB274C8923#7C85C#72+7)269B9EC67B,52877B,CA79#7E3885AB677B,57EC#57A C##3F9A7)82)2A5AB#72+7#C9D785#5C8E,765857CEB3C667769669A7B27856CB57B27CA77B,52877CB C667A7)C8B9E36C807B,57%369 72+7E3F36CB5D 785#5C8E,7 2A 7B,57856CB92A#,9)7%5B655A7B,5 :8CE9C6PF9A289B7 7 B,85CB; 7 CAD 7 )269E9A0 7 6,9E, 7 B5AD# 7 B2 7 #35#B 7 B,CB 7 B,5 7 D5855 7 2+

)269E9A7?C#7)587B,57A3F%5872+7)269E572++9E58#7287B,57+3AD9A72+7)269E57D5)C8BF5AB#@79#

#2F5,2679AD5*5D7B27B,57A3F%5872+76CE97)52)6579A7C7945A7E9B7076236D7F2#B7699567

39

9AC6670776CAB7B27D9#85C8D7B,57458779A+635AB9C67+28F36CB92A72+7B,57+3AEB92A72+

B,57#BCB57%77"C867HE,F9BB07ACF5677B,CB7B,57#BCB579#7D5+9A5D7%77B,57)85#5AE572+79B#

5A5F95#7AD7A26076,CB79#765+B79#75##5AB9C66776,CB76C#7)85#5AB7C685CD779A7B,5 E9B772+7CAB9&39B775,CB79#079B.#7C7)269#7B,CB7C685CD7785D5+9A5#7B,57F9A9FC67#BCB50 6,58579B769B58C6677E2A#9#B#72+7B,5728CA98CB92A72+7E2AD9B92A#72+738%CA769+57?K@

M,CB7B,5A7B,57#BCB57)8249D5#79A79B#7F9A9FC67+3AEB92A79#7E85CB9A7E2AD9B92A#7+28 B,5728D58677E25*9#B5AE572+7#B8CA58#7?9BBA58079A782D53807I07@

+9AD7)82F9#9A7B,5285B9EC672))28B3A9B95#7,585

-5B73#7955)79A7F9AD07,26545807B,CB72A')89AE9)6578CE9C6989A72+7B,575A5F776236D 2458#9F)69+7 7 B,5 7 )82%65F0 7 #B9+69A 7 9B# 7 ,5389#B9E 7 D9F5A#92A 7 A 7 B,9# 7 85#)5EB0 7 B,5 85/5EB92A 7 2+ 7 CA7 7 HE,F9BB9CA 7 D9F5A#92A 7 2+ 7 )269E9A 7 %7 7 5CA'(C36 7 82D538 7 CAD 7 ,9#

E2665C35 7 2A 7 9BBA580 7 69B, 7 6,2F 7 ,5 7 FC9ABC9A5D 7 ,9,67 7 +5E3AD 7 5*E,CA5#0 7 9#

#2F56,CB7D9#E2AE58B9A7562679#7CA75*E58)B72+76,CB79BBA587#C9D79A7B,57E238#572+

B,5#575*E,CA5#

40

7#2F56,CB7)38869A7)C##C579A#2+C87C#79B7E65C8677C))5C8#7B,CB72A79BBA587?69B, B,572%4923#7C))82%CB92A72+7,9#79AB5862E3B28@785+3#5#7B278CAB7)269E9A79B#785C67#BCB3#79A B,57E2A#B9B3B92A72+7)269B95#7"58BC9A6707C#79BBA587,9F#56+7#C7#07)269E9A7C5AB#7C8579A E,C8572+7B,579AB58AC6728D5872+7B,57E9B7076,9E,7E2A#9#B#79A7B,576374963+8F3A9346 FEAB37C9A07A2B7:+2859A58#;72899ACB9A7+82F7D9++585AB7ACB92A#7287E23AB895#07%3B :#B8CA58#;79A7B,57#5A#57B,CB7B,5987F285#7D27A2B7E2AE38076,9E,785&3985#72A572+7B,5 823)#7B275A+28E57#2F57D9#E9)69A507#2F57#,C85D75B,9E#7B27C66267+287C7,C8F2A923#769+5 9A7C7#,C85D738%CA75A4982AF5AB7<5AE507B,2#576,27E2AB89%3B507B,823,7B,57#245859A CEB#72+7)269E9A07B27%396D9A7B,57)269B707C857A59B,587B,576CE9#07B,57+2859A58#7287B,5 128B, 7+89ECA#07 %3B 7B,573A48F26F 466F 7 ?F#657 7I0 7BG@0 7B,5 7E26737?CA ECCA5A07NID@07CAD7F2857BC3B2629EC6677B,5767893463F4?-5507ND@7!9#E9)69A5 5A+28E5D7CB7B,59875*)5A#57?",22A,07NNI@79#7B,575458'85A565D7+23AD9A7CEB72+7B,5 )269B9EC6 7 E2FF3A9B7 7 C9A0 7 )269E9A 7 C3B,289B95# 7 C85 7 #265 7 /3D5# 7 2+ 7 B,5 7 )269B9EC6 FCADCB5 7 B,57 7 C85 7 5AB83#B5D 7 69B,0 7 6,9E, 7 9# 7 #3%/5EB 7 B2 7 E,CA5 7 C# 7 B,5 7 #2E95B7 7 9B#56+

E,CA5#77EC#579A7)29AB79#7B,57:C77,3AB;7CEB949B95#72+7B,57:E28C6#7D949#92A;72+7B,5 156 7 [289 7 (269E5 7 !5)C8BF5ABK 7 6,9E, 7 #)C895D 7 B,5 7 HB2A56C66 7 F245F5AB 7 CAD 545AB3C667765D7B27C7E2F)65B5785458#C672+7B,57)269B9EC67FCADCB5785C8D9A7B,57#BCB3#72+

C77)52)6579A7B,57)269B9EC67E2FF3A9B77"2A458#567072A677C+B587D5ECD5#72+79AD9++585AE5 65857B,57#BC++72+7B,57-2#7A565#7(269E57!5)C8BF5AB7%59A7B26D7B,CB7B,59875A5F776C#

E5*9ECA 7 F98CAB#0 7 6,9E, 7 36B9FCB5670 7 75C8 7 C+B58 7 75C80 7 E2AB89%3B5D 7 B2 7 %396D9A 7 B,5 )269B9EC679D5AB9B772+7B,5#57F98CAB#769B,9A7B,57)269B9EC67E2FF3A9B779A7B,57CH07287CB 65C#B79A7"C69+28A9C7?#E2%C807NNN@75,57)269B9EC67FCADCB57B8CA#6CB5#79AB27CEB92A749C B,575E2A2F772+7+28E5728785#B8C9AB07C#7C##5##5D7287545A7)2AD585D7%77B,57)269E57D389A B,579AB58CEB92A7?#9F96C86707#557C4850707B'BG@

41

5CA'(C36782D5387D25#7A2B7#C772B,5869#579A7,9#7945A7D5+9A9B92A72+7)269E9A7F6 3A6934E864F3464734EA49F64F2EF466F34E438A346348A46983F M576236D7#C77B,CB79B7,C#7C#7F3E,7B27D2769B,7D5+9A9A7C7)3%69E728D587?C7#5B72+7#,C85D 8365#7CAD78536CB92A#@7C#769B,7E2AB89%3B9A7B27C7#3%#BCAB9C67D5+9A9B92A72+7B,57)269B9EC6 AD55D07B,9#79#76,CB7FC95#7)269E9A7C#7CA79A#B9B3B92A7#27E2AB82458#9C6079A7B,57#B82A58

#5A#579B79#762ECB5D7CB7B,57,5C8B72+7B,57)269B9EC675,9#79#7C6#276,CB7FC95#7CA77CBB5F)B7CB CF5AD9A728785+28F9A79B7#3E,7C7D9++9E36B7BC#976,CB782657ECA7)269E9A7C5AB#7C##3F5 9+7A2B7B,CB72+7E2AB82669A7CAD7E9496989A7B,57+89A572+7#2E9C6728D58S

42

HB966079B7#,236D7%5785F5F%585D7B,CB7EC8879A723B7CEB#72+7#245859AB77?9A7B,57#5A#5 D5+9A5D7 C%245@7D25# 7A2B 75*5F)B 7B,57)269E57+82F 785#)5EB9A 7#2F5 78365#7\39B5 7B,5 2))2#9B57B,577C8578CB,5875AF5#,5D79A74C8923#7E2A#B8C9AB#7)58BC9A9A7B27B,57ACB38572+

B,598 7 9AB5862E3B280 7 B,5 7 ACB385 7 2+ 7 B,5 7 62ECB92A 7 28 7 2+ 7 B,5 7 E826D0 7 %3B 7 C6#2 7 B2 7 B,5 E98E3F#BCAE5# 7 CAD 7 B,5 7 )269B9EC6 7 E2AB5*BA6,CB5458 7 9# 7 ,C))5A9A 7 9A 7 )269B9E# 7 CB 7 B,5 F2F5AB7C87+82F7%59A7C7945A07)269E57D9#E85B92A79#7E2A#BCAB677%59A7C##5##5D7D389A CEB92A7%77B,57)269E57B,5F#5645#076,2754C63CB576,CB7B,57)269B9EC67E2FF3A9B779#769C%65 B2 7 59B,58 7 5AD28#50 7 28 7 85/5EB 7 C# 7 A2 7 62A58 7 E2A#B9B3B9A 7 65C6 7 6C665##A5##0 7 %3B 7 )385

43

5,57826572+7B,57)269E579#7%5#B73AD58#B22D7C#7C7F5E,CA9#F7+287B,57D9#B89%3B92A72+

A2A'A52B9C%6573EA75F)6275D79A7CEE28DCAE5769B,7B,57D9EBCB5#72+7CA79AB39B945 8C#)72+7678F89E775*95AE95#

EE9EA

D5)C8B3857+82F7B,576C675,57)269B9EC67FCADCB57E2A+5885D7B27)269E9A7C3B,289B95#79#7A2B CA79ABCA9%657945AJ79B75B#7B5#B5D7%77B,57)269E5769B,75CE,72+7B,579AB58CEB92A#7B,57 3AD58BC95

<5AE57A75AD28#9A07C+B5875CA'(C36072A79BBA58.# 7D5+9A9B92A72+7)269E9A7A765 6236D7#C77?5F),C#9#7CDD5D72A7D9++585AE5#@

44

M,585 7 :)269B9EC6; 7 85+58# 7 B2 7 %2B, 7 B,5 7 )269E5 7 C##5##9A 7 B,5 7 #E2)5 7 2+ 7 B,5 7 FCADCB5 5AB83#B5D7B27B,5F7%77B,57E2FF3A9B707CAD7B,57#B83EB389A07#3%#BCAB9C675++5EB72+7B,598 CEB92A7)82)5872A7B,57ACB3857CAD7%23ADC895#72+7B,57)269B77#7ECA7%57#55A07)269E9A7,C#

69BB657B27D2769B,7F5857E94969B7079B79#72+7C7D9++585AB728D587C6B25B,5807B23E,9A7B,574587 +23ADCB92A# 7 2+ 7 238 7 )269B9EC6 7 #2E95B95# 7 A 7 C# 7 9+ 7 )269E9A 7 C3B,289B95# 7 ,CD 7 #2F5,26 9A,589B5D7B,57)269B9EC67FCADCB572+72++#5BB9A7%2B,7B,57E26D78CB92AC69B772+7B,57HBCB57CAD B,57%38D5A72+7C7D9#5AE,CAB5D76286D

45

989E,7E07NN075,57D5'#E89)B92A72+7B5E,A9EC672%/5EB#078A79/9587M07-C677?D#@07#2E8AB 1392A676B,-878AB4#6983F07"CF%89D507E57(85##07O'B

AD58#2A7E0707$A412E774F645678F89E74'2EAB3.45678934EA4&3AE38348A4EA9307*+28D0

*+28D7CA9458#9B77(85##

9BBA58707076285AE5719,B9AC657476C7)238#39B57D57M966957H3BB2A07) 8EA9343F4#698 F 07O0 G07DO'GF7?B8CD7D576.C8B9E657)C8375A7NIB078A7CE2%7?D98@07NIB07123456F3AF8E7464/3646 '88AE740F893@

9BBA58 70 782D538 7'(0 72%C8D7 07-$477 0707!$%CB73B238 7 D579BBA5807) 8EA93 43F

#698 F 07O07G07IN'GBO

6CE97!07NIG075,57E2%9698CB92A72+7-C607123406AE746413BE74#F83070707O'BN 238D9537(0707#472FEF4'64E4'6773B3434EA934456575807(C89#07H5396

82D538 7 '(0 7 ?5D@0 7 NDG0 7 <9, 7 CAD 7 -26 7 (269E9A 7 5FC89# 7 2A 7 B,5 7 (269E9A 7 2+ 7 (269B9EC6 EB949B95#07#698E7456D7307G07O07OI'O7?8549#5D7CAD73)DCB5D7458#92A78A7-C7)269E57)269B9&35 -C 7 ,C3B5 7 )269E50 7 9A 713 4 8EB3 4 3 4 7E 4 67893 4 5EF893 4 3F 4 393F86A0 7 E2AB8$C60 7 (85##5#

3A9458#9BC985#7D57E2AB8$C607G07O'OB@

82D5387'(07?D98@07O07-C7)269E575A7)9=E5#7D$BCE,$5#07'88A676B8307GD0707G'I 82D5387'(07071234567898AB4C3D07*+28D07*+28D7CA9458#9B77(85##

82D538 7 '(0 7 D0 7 \35 7 D985 7 FC9AB5ACAB 7 D5 7 6C 7 )269E5 7 S0 7 9A 7 E2A/C8D5B 7 !0 7 ",C345A5B 7 0 E&35B5C3 7 0 7 ?D98@0 7%6F3 4 8A 8F3 4 4 73 4 9263 4 6789833 4 !455578::;"0 7 (C89#0 7 -C

!$E23458B507OO'FD

82D5387'(07D07<C3B575B7%C##57)269E57C)8=#76577#5)B5F%8507'88A676B8307B0707GG'O

?85)89#78A75CA'(C36782D5387D.,958747C3/238D.,3907A3F$827#)$E9C67D57'88A676B8307BB07070 )7O'BO07)8$#5ABCB92A77E&35B5C3@

3A2A 7 U0 7 0 7 -5 7 E2A#BCB 7 F$D9EC6 7 )53B'96 7 F5BB85 7 4 7 6.$)85345 7 65# 7 +82AB9=85# 7 D5 7 6C 7 +28E5 )269E9=85 7 6$9B9F51S 7 A&33B5 7 #38 7 3A 7 D9#)2#9B9+ 7 F$D9E2'6$C6 7 D5 7 D$)9#BC5 7 D5# 7 49265AE5#

)269E9=85#07) 8EA9343F4#698 F 07GO0707G'GF

"C,A707I07EB3C69B$7D576.C883B7 747H5E85BC8772+7HBCB57+287B,57<2F57!5)C8BF5AB75*7)C8B5 CFDC7D37I7/39A7779AE9D5AB79#26$7237)8$E$D5AB7D2FFC5C%657S7'7F34<4'6A78F07FF0 'OF

",22A,7H07NNI07567898AB4E4698E7489878A307*+28D07"6C85AD2A7(85##

"26692B'5,$6=A57"07NNN07"C867HE,F9BB7458#3#7EC*7M5%587389D9EC67 CB92AC69B77CAD7E2A2F9E CB92AC69B7078A7E23++57",071234'2E773AB3464'E74#928FF07-2AD85#0758#27229#

"26692B'5,$6=A57"07N07E2D58A78CB92AC69B95#72+7B,57)269B9EC6782F723EC36B7B27M5%5807=E+

C3D34#F8307N07'07FO'DI77

"28A549A7",0707(63#7D57G77)269E958#7#CAEB92AA$#75A7N071348BE607F7/39665B

!236C# 7 E0 7 NFF0 758F 4 EA 4 )EAB3 4 >A 4 >AE78 4 6 4 '6A93F 4 6 4 5677F86A 4 EA 1ED660-2AD85#07 23B65D57]7X5CA7(C36

!362A 7 0 7 NNI0 7 -5# 7 2)$8CB538# 7 D5 7 +CEB3C69B$ 7 -5# 7 9A8$D95AB# 7 FCB$8956# 7 5B 7 C++5EB356# 7 D5 6.$49D5AE57,9#B289&35075678F8+0707GN07FO'DO

!362A 7 0 7 NND0 713 4 F 68A 4 697E83 4 13 4 96A8F86A 4 698E73 4 3 4 7EFF3FEF86A 4 36AA37730 (C89#07^D9B92A#7D576.<HH

F#6577"07I07'834678934EA43AE746789.4?63EA4?+383A9344@A:745B:07*+28D0

*+28D7CA9458#9B77(85##

#E2%C8707NNN07/E934678934EA4F234EC8AB464E4678F89E7483AF8F.4=3+89EA4>389EA EA4F234164>AB37345678934)3EF3AF445::745BA07589565707CA9458#9B772+7"C69+28A9C7(85##

C##9A7!07071E46934347634A34EAF26676B834347E4678934349EF8307(C89#07H5396 C4857(0707\3CAD76C7)269E57+C%89&3576.28D857#2E9C67CA75A'D5>47D5#7)269B9&35#7)3%69&35#7D5 6C7)269E51S7/334EADE83434983A934678F89307ON07F07G'O

9#E,5871070717U358857C3*7F98CAB#7S727-57F2D=657D37ECF)7476.$)853457D576.$E2A2F957D3 FC9AB95A 7 D5 7 6.28D85 7 5B 7 D5 7 6C 7 #3%458#92A 7 5A 7 8$B5AB92A 7 CDF9A9#B8CB9450 7 E2AB89%3B92A 7 C3 7 ⁵

"2A8=#7D576.##2E9CB92A78CA>C9#57D57HE95AE57(269B9&3507HB8C#%23807#5EB92A7B,$FCB9&357A_N H5EB92A7B,$FCB9&357N07171973588507A97)C9*775A&33B5#7#38765#728D85#7)269B9&35#7D9#62&3$#72 9#E,587107H)985707N07-.^BCB7+CE57C3*7966$C69#F5#075678F8+0707G07I'

<2D#2A 7 0 7 0 7 H3#)5EB#0 7 D5+5ADCAB# 7 CAD 7 49EB9F# 7 9A 7 B,5 7 85AE, 7 E89F9AC6 7 )82E5## 7 5,5 E2AB5*B72+785E5AB785+28F07$AF3AEF86AE74EA4'6EEF8341E4EEF3707O07B07ID'DF 2%C8D707G07 C67+CEB#7CAD7AC88CB945#07567898AB4EA4#6983F07G07B07BG'BD

2%C8D 7 0 7 O0 7 -5 7 A2345C3 7 FCADCB 7 )269E958 7 C985 7 6C 7 )269E5 7 DCA# 7 65# 7 82A5# 7 D9B5# 7 `D5 A2A'D829B.07'88A676B8307GD0707G'

2%C8D 7 0 7 -9A,C8DB 7 !0 7 D0 7 "2AB826 7 CAD 7 3C8D9CA#,9) 7 7 E2F)C89#2A 7 %5B655A 7 B62

#3845966CAE57#)CE5#0786779AB58ACB92AC67C98)28B7CAD7!CFFC895.#7,23#9A7)82/5EB079A7!5+65F7E

?D@07#3877EA934EA4&63AEA937'834'6AF674EA4-36A079A65707F58C6D7(%P (85##07II'

X62E9C8#7"07NDO071234$3E46456789307"C69+28A9C07HC57(3%69ECB92A#75458677<966#

X587E3987M07NII075678934#F33F96A345678F898EA0",9EC207",9EC27CA9458#9B77(85##

X584$CA7'07NN07(3B374'E74#928FF4134678F89343AF34 97EF86A43F468F88F 07(C89#0 (85##5#73A9458#9BC985#7D578CAE5

X87A5A707071 FEF434FF8934EA934G$$$³7GG³48397307(C89#07UC669FC8D074267

-C8CA57<07N075,5785AE,7892B#7CAD7#585CB92A078A7MCDD9AB2A7!072%C8D707X9A7E

?D#@07/86F8AB48A4F234H4EA4EA934>4'6EEF834>AE780"3662F)B2A07M96CA07I'G -57!23##C67(07NDD072F344734EF3489878AE8307(C89#07U(107F9A9#B=857D576.AB$89538 -55707ND07H2F57#B83EB38C67C#)5EB#72+7)269E57D549CAE579A7856CB92A#769B,7F9A289B77823)#078A H,5C89A7"07HB5AA9A7(,7?D#@07IBEA8EF86AE745678934)38EA934$F4#F9F3EA4'6AF670 5282AB2073BB58628B,#07BN'D

ECAA9A7(X07NII07 365#07"2665C35#07CAD7H9B3CB92AC66773#B9+95D7EB92A#078A7ECAA9A7(X0 CA7ECCA5A77?D#@07567898AB4>4J83464F234#F33F071567[28907 CAD2F7<23#507I'DD ECAA9A7(X07G07567898AB4'6AF8AB3A98307",9EC207CA9458#9B772+7",9EC27(85##

ECAA9A7(X0707)369EF89467898AB48A4E492EAB8AB46707236D5807(C8CD9F7(3%69#,58#

EE<57FCA07E"077 5#)5EB7+28723B#9D58#S7 5#)5EB7+287B,576C6S75,57F28C6754C63CB92A72+

,9,7#EC6579##35#7%77CH79FF98CB92A72++9E58#0706AE7464F234/6E74>AF26676B89E74$AF8FF30 F07B07FGO'FO

E285C37D57566C9A7"07N079265AE5#7966$9B9F5#75B7)3%69E9B$7D576.CEB92A7)269E9=85075678F8+070 G07N'B

EY66587M07G07>4)EAB364=8A4'E74#928FF48A456F7CE4?63EA4126B2F07[C650 [C657CA9458#9B77(85##

E&35B5C3707B0756789343AF342FEF43F4E92 07(C89#07(85##5#7D57HE95AE5#7(2 59A587 07NN0712345678F89464F234567893075282AB2075282AB27CA9458#9B77(85##07^D75D

59##70728D3C7!07NFI07A4982AF5AB7CAD78CA98CB92A77(58#)5EB94572A7B,57(269E5078A 28D3C7!7?D@0712345678934#8+4#698676B89E74?E071567[289072,A7M96577]7H2A#07O'OB 2D657 7 10 7 O0 7 528B3850 7 9265AE50 7 CAD 7 B,5 7 U62%C6 7 MC8 7 2A 7 5588280 7>389EA 4 #6983F 4 6

$AF3AEF86AE741E4569338AB07NN07B'BI

HC64770707E(#7BC%657&35#B92A#72458785AE,7`(85#9D5AB.#7H)7.785456CB92A#07=38EEF07F /CA4958

HE,F9BB7"07NG07)34-3B84345678F8923A075869A07!3AE9587]7<3F%62B7?B8CD7CA677123 '6A93F464F2345678F89E707B8CA#67U7HE,6C%07",9EC207",9EC27CA9458#9B77(85##07I@

8A3

7 7H55079A7) 8EA9343F4#698 F 4?07 5A$7-$4775D@07B,57#)5E9C67+5CB38572A72A79BBA58.#

E2AB89%3B92A7B27B,57#2E9262772+7)269E9A07C#765667C#7B,579A49BCB92A75*B5AD5D7%775CA'(C367B2

#5458C67723A785AE,7#E,26C8#079AE63D9A77238#7B836707B27E2AB89%3B57B27B,57AA9458#C8779##3572+

"CACD9CA7/238AC67'88A676B837?O@07E2FF5F28CB9A7B,57+CF23# 7NDB79##3572A7)269E9A 5D9B5D7%775CA'(C367,9F#56+

77287B,57%5A5+9B72+7+2859A785CD58#76,27FC77A2B7%57+CF969C8769B,785E5AB785AE,7D54562)F5AB#

9A7B,57+956D07,58579#7C7%895+7E2F)5AD93F72+7CA3C8777ACB92AC67,5CD69A5#7?%5C89A79A7F9AD B,CB7A2 765## 7B,CA7B7)269E57CAD75ADC8F58957)58#2AA567,C457%55A785)28B5D7%77B,57ACB92AC6 )85## 7 C# 7 99665D 7 2A 7 D3B7 7 9A 7 @ 7 B,5 7 D5F9#5 7 2+ 7 M9##CA 7 6'[CFA90 7 C 7G'75C8'26D 7 FCA 7 6,2 C))5C8#7B27,C457%55A7E,295D7B27D5CB,76,9657%59A7C885#B5DJ7B,57CE&39BBC607%77C7E89F9AC67E238B79A 19E50 7 2+ 7 B 7 )269E5F5A 7 CEE3#5D 7 2+ 7 ,C49A 7 8C)5D 7 C 7 )82#B9B3B5J 7 B,5 7 E2A+98FCB92A0 7 %7 7 CA CDF9A9#B8CB9457E238B072+7B,57E2F)36#287785B985F5AB72+7C7)269E572++9E5876,27,CD7D9#E62#5D7B,5 )269E5 7 +965# 7 2+ 7 B62 7 85AE, 7 E565%89B95#0 7 9A7 C 7F245 7 B2 7)82B5#B7 B,5 745877 5*9#B5AE5 72+ 7#3E, 7 +965#

?6,9E,7,57E2A#9D585D7CA79A+89A5F5AB72A7E9496769%58B95#@J7B,57#3#)5A#92A72+7B,57)89#2A7#5AB5AE5 )82A23AE5D79A77CC9A#B7#5458C67)269E572++9E58#76,27,CD072A7B,57%C#9#72+7+285D7549D5AE50 CEE3#5D7C7FCA72+7CBB5F)B5D7F38D587CC9A#B7C7)269E5FCAJ7CAD7B,578C6677EC665D7%77C7)269E573A92A 28CA98CB92A7B27)82B5#B7C7E2FF5F28CB9457)6CB57B,CB7C7#3%38%CA7E9B77E23AE9679A7B,5785CB587(C89#

C85C7)6CAA5D7B27)3B73)79A785F5F%8CAE572+7FN'75C8'26D7697a989076,27D95D79A7E3#B2D77CB7B,5762EC6 )269E57#BCB92A

G7 738785AE,'6CA3C57:B8CA#6CB92A;79#7C7D569%58CB57:B85C#2A;76,2#57)38)2#579#7B27C##2E9CB5 B,57B58F7B2723EC36B.#7,589BC57EE28D9A7B27E9E,56723EC36B076C665##A5##07C#75*5F)69+95D7%7 BC* 7 54C#92A0 7 9# 7 C 7 +28F 7 2+ 7 6C6 7 C429DCAE5 7 A55D5D 7 %7 7 B,5 7 #2E9C6 7 28D58 7 B2 7 )58)5B3CB5 9B#56+7:-C665##A5##79#7A27CEE9D5AB72879F)58+5EB92A7B79#7CA7C%#263B5677)2#9B9457565F5AB72+7#2E9C6 +3AEB92A9A7-59#6CB92A7C66C7#7)8249D5#7)82B5EB5D07)82+9BC%65#7#)CE5#76,5857B,576C67FC77%5 4926CB5D0 7 2B,58# 7 6,585 7 9B 7 FC7 7 %5 7 9A285D0 7 CAD 7 2B,58# 7 #B966 7 6,585 7 4926CB92A# 7 C85 7 )3A9#,5D;

?23EC36B0 7 NIF0 7 &32B5D 7 9A 7 9#E,580 7 H)985 7 N0 7 DF0 7 238 7 B8CA#6CB92A@ 7 HB8CA567 7 5A23,0 82D5387FC95#7C6F2#B7A2785+585AE576,CB#254587B2723EC36B79A7567898AB4C3D

B775,573#572+7B,57)85#5AB7)C8B9E9)657:)269E9AK07C62A769B,7B,57)638C67+28F72+7:C5AB#;07,56)5D E2A457 7 B,5 7 F36B9)69E9B7 7 2+ 7 CEB28# 7 CAD 7 CEB92A# 7$A 4 78A3 4 8F2 4 4 8A3AF6 4 6 4 36A 6386AE7748A67348A467898AB4$4334F2343+386A4L67898AB4EB3AF4F64F23464L67893 28924B3A3E774334F64D789496AFED7E837?567898AB4C3D07G@7H557,267B,9#7)85#5AB )C8B9E9)6576C#79AB82D3E5D79A7E&35B5C3T#7Q85AE,'6CA3C5R7D9#E238#57?E&35B5C307B07O@

O7 7A7+CEB075CA'(C36782D538.#7)85#B9579A7B,57A62'HC*2A76286D76C#76C85677%C#5D72A7,9#

)82F2B9A7B,9#7B62+26D7D5+9A9B92A72+7)269E9A07B,57:,9,;7CAD7B,57:626;7?82D53807NDGPG0 DP@

F77C9A07+CEB#7C%23AD79A785E5AB785AE,7A56#7?M966#,5807J7HC64707@

I77H5507F28575A58C66707,267/3D5#7B5AD7B27:E85CB5;7B,576C67D5)5AD9A72A7B,598726A7)58E5)B92A 2+76,5B,587#2E95B7.#75*)5EBCB92A#7C857%59A7F5B7287A2B7?X87A5A0707@

D7 7A7B,579A#3++9E95AE772+7F5D9EC67E58B9+9ECB5#7)587#507#557?9A7B,5785AE,7E2AB5*B@7B,5785E5AB 5F)989EC67D5F2A#B8CB92A79A73A2A0707C#765667C#7#5458C6785FC89#79A7E285C37D57566C9A0 N07DI'DN79A7)C8B9E36C8

N77#72))2#5D7B276,CB7,C#762A7%55A7B,57EC#579A7E2FF2A'6C67)82E5D3850785AE,76C67D9D7A2B )8249D57+287B,57)85#5AE572+7C765C67E23A#567D389A7)269E57E3#B2D707CB765C#B73AB967B,57"2D572+

"89F9AC67(82E5D38576C#785+28F5D79A7CA3C877NNG7?<2D#2A07@7C785+28F7B,CB76C#7CEB3C667 B89585D7%77#5458C67D5CB,#79A7)269E57E3#B2D707/3#B769957B,57O73A5077EB7B,CB7#3%#5&35AB67 E2F)65F5AB5D79B76C#7)C8B677C7E2A#5&35AE572+7B,57E2AD5FACB92A72+78CAE579A7B,57H56F23A9 HE,F9BB7"07NGB075678F89234123676B834J834HE8F3744132346A434#63*A8F*F075869A0

!3AE958 7 ] 7 <3F%62B 7 ?B8CD 7 % 7 75678F89E7 4 123676B 4 6 4 '2EF3 4 6A 4 F23 4 '6A93F 4 6

#6338BAF07B8CA#67U7HE,6C%07"CF%89D507E57(85##@

H92CA 7 MU0 7 87D6 7 X0 7 B0 7E8A3 4 EA 4 ?39F83A3 4 8A 4 567898AB 4 123 4 383A930 MC#,9AB2A075,571CB92AC67ECD5F95#7(85##

HB5AA9A7 (,07 0 74C63CB9A 7(269E5 7"2F)6C9AB# 7 -59#6CB92A7 7H35#B5D 78CF56289078A U26D#F9B,707-569#7"7?D#@07'8878EA4I38B2F464567898AB4&63AEA934)369E94EA (EA4/8B2F07*+28D07<C8B07BI'FG

C96D899#7107NNN07(269E57B28B38579A78CAE507%3F237EA4EEF37464(EA4/8B2F07I07B0 B'BG

CA7ECCA5A707NID075,57C##,265078A7ECAA9A7(07CA7ECCA5A77?D#@07567898AB4>48346 F234F33F071567[28907 CAD2F7<23#507'GI

M966#,587X070785AE,79AB56695AE57E,95+7CEE3#5D72+7#)79A72A7/238AC69#B071234&E8EA07 2EB2%85

EC#5

77287C7#9F96C87D5F2A#B8CB92A7D8C69A72A7D9#E9)69AC877CEB92A7+965#7+82F7B,57(C89#7)269E57+28E50

#557E285C37D57566C9A07N

775,57U(179#7B,5785AE,7)269E572458#559A7%2D77CAD7)3%69E7E2F)6C9AB#7C3B,289B77?AD58#2A0 07GNO@7!5#)9B57,C49A7%55A7E2FF9##92A5D7%77B,57B,5A7E9A9#B5872+7AB5892807B,5785)28B 85FC9A5D73A)3%69#,5D

7 7EE28D9A7B27B,57!985EB2872+7B,57U(107B,57)269E57C857CB7B,5785E5949A75AD72+7OV72+7C66 D9#E9)69AC877CEB92A7CC9A#B7E94967#584CAB#79A78CAE5076,5A7B,5772A677CEE23AB7+287DV72+7B,575AB985 E94967#5849E57#BC++7?27C/5CA79A7"28A549A07@782F7B,9#7)58#)5EB94507B,57)269E57C857#3%/5EB7B2

#B89EB7E2AB82679AD55D7<26545807B,9#7CDF9A9#B8CB94507D9#E9)69AC8707287545A7E26659C67E,CAA567+28 B,57#5BB65F5AB72+7D549CAE5#79#72A57B,9A07CAD7)3%69E7/3#B9E572+7B,57)3%69E7+28E57&39B57CA2B,58

?HB5AA9A07@

G7 7 (5B58 7 X 7 ECAA9A 7 ?G0 7 CAD 7 F2#B 7 9F)28BCAB67 7 0 7 FD@ 7 2++58# 7 C 7 F36B9D9F5A#92AC6 D5+9A9B92A 7 2+ 7 )269E9A0 7 F5AB92A9A 7 B,5 7 5*E5)B92A 7 C# 7 C 7 4CA9#,9A 7 )29AB 7 :5,5 7 )269E5 7 C# 7 CA 28CA98CB92A 7 9A 7 A62'F589ECA 7 #2E95B95#0 7 E2A#B9B3B5D 7 2+ 7 FCA7 7 D9458#5 7 C5AE95#0 7 C85 C3B,289BCB945677E228D9ACB5D07659B9FCB5728CA98CB92A#75,577#BCAD785CD77B27C))677+28E5073)7CAD 9AE63D9A7+CBC67+28E5079A7)269B9EC6677D5+9A5D7B5889B2895#75,577#5597B27#3#BC9A7)269B9EC6677D5+9A5D 28D587CAD728D589A749C7B8CE99A07#3845966CAE57CAD7C885#B7#7#3E,07B,57785&39857E2F)69CAE57B2 E2FFCAD7+82F7626587)58#2AA567CAD7E9B985A#7CAD7B,57C%969B77B27)82E55D7%775*E5)B92AC2873 678F89484973E74C348A4F28438A8F86A7?6,9E,7FC95#79B7&39B573A9&35@07F2343+93F86A4846346 E4EA828AB468AF4F2EA4E4F692F6A3464F23496A93F46467898AB4=EAA8AB46A7436F3438B2F 78A34F64F284A6F86A432E88AB4F2EF4F28483A86A4M2E4A6F4D33A437743+7634E7F26B2 678F89E7 4 F2368F 4 A6FED7 4 'E7 4 #928FF 4 2E3 4 8FF3A 4 ED6F 4 F23 4 86FEA93 4 6 L3+93F86AE7848A4F234E934649837?ECAA9A0707IN'D@

B77B7#,236D7%57A2B5D7B,CB7B,9#75B,A28C),7076,9E,7D8C6#72A7B,57E2AE5)B72+7B,575*E5)B92A7?:C

#FC667#BCB572+75*E5)B92A;@0769A99A79B7B27MC6B5875A/CF9A7?C##9A0707GG@07C9F#7B272++587CA :CAB,82)2627 7 2+ 7 B,5 7 HBCB5;0 7 9A 7 C 7 )58#)5EB945 7 B,CB 7 ,C# 7 F285 7 B2 7 D2 7 69B, 7 B,5 7 )2#BE262A9C6 D9F5A#92A72+7B,57CEB92A72+7B,57HBCB57B,CA769B,7B,57B,528772+7B,57HBCB57343

49BE8A9BA8B98EA

/ 3A934 739F6A893

Fabien Jobard, « Proposition on the theory of policing », Champ pénal/Penal field [En ligne], Vol. IX | 2012, mis en ligne le 12 mai 2012, Consulté le 22 octobre 2012. URL :

http://champpenal.revues.org/8286 ; DOI : 10.4000/champpenal.8286

48A49

Fabien Jobard

Director of CESDIP (UMR 8183, CNRS/UVSQ/M. de la Justice).

Contact: fabjob@cesdip.fr

>F897344N34EF3

Propositions sur la théorie de la police [Texte intégral]

Paru dans Champ pénal/Penal field, Vol. IX | 2012

9E83BCD48A49

© Champ pénal