• Aucun résultat trouvé

Les chrétiens en Jordanie, dynamiques identitaires et gestion du pluralisme

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Partager "Les chrétiens en Jordanie, dynamiques identitaires et gestion du pluralisme"

Copied!
9
0
0

Texte intégral

(1)

HAL Id: hal-00338481

https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00338481

Submitted on 13 Nov 2008

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

Les chrétiens en Jordanie, dynamiques identitaires et gestion du pluralisme

Géraldine Chatelard

To cite this version:

Géraldine Chatelard. Les chrétiens en Jordanie, dynamiques identitaires et gestion du pluralisme. Les Cahiers de l’Orient, 2009, pp.41-56. �hal-00338481�

(2)

46527&8:9<;>=<?A@CB+D8FE@:9<8,7G;

H

?JI1E'=KEMLENM7&8:?O:8:=MI;PLRQ7&SAT,D@:UV%7'=W@:?PEX:YZRZ[8:?

H ?\E@,7^]A@:?\E1=<S>?_8FL`T:SJ9<9<SAaPLb@cedfLb@:98,]A@:?=g7.hAS LA7.9<@ IT,Di7&5,E1=<@:?JI;jWV%7&=<@:?PElk j

V%71mA8,?=MI(5fhA8,7.91j

H^nCo p

@FE91j

n

Qq

n

2r

@FE

2s

?tSt]>@uZvt7&@fwAxx

s

H^y Y-@FEAY69W9e=W8:?T:@CNM7&8:?Oz8u=MI(@:X Ql8,7&=eI

{

@|ceZRSA;}u9W@j\~&S>7G;8,?=W@u?;@[mA@PI^E=<S?€;PLhJ9‚LA7G8u9W=MI&Z[@ƒT\S?N1@PI„I&=<SJ??t@:9@tI1E…@,?€T:S?PE17&8\I†E@ƒ8„]A@:TƒT:@:9gLb=;jW8FLE17&@PI

hA8z‡bIˆ;@‰9W8‰7&5,mA=<S?ŠaPLb=RS>?\E‹8:;ShPE5ŒLA?@-=e;5zSJ9<SmJ=<@"9<8,ŽT:=MI^E@- o ‡i7&=W@:X H 7&8zavA8:8FE1D=MI1E@‰S L’‘)LA7&aPLA=<@2“„” { @

ceZRSA;}u9W@jJ~GS>7&;8:?=W@:?-@PI^E_T:@:9gL=…;j•Lb?–T:S>?N@PI(I&=<SJ??A8:9<=^I&Z—@€8PI„I^LbZ—5˜;8:?I—9W@˜Tz8:; 7&@€;jgLb?-S>7&; 7G@˜=eI&9W8:Z[=WaPL)@

ZRSJ;@27?=MIG56;@ I7&@:9W8FE1=<S?I=<?PE@,7GT:S>?N1@ I(I&=<SJ??@:9W9e@ IaPLb=™I2je=<?I'hA=<7&@652mA8u9W@:Z—@:?PE;@9<8…E17G8:;>=KE1=<S>?—@FLA7GS>hA5:@2??A@_I1LA7

9e@š; 7&SJ=‚E;@PIŠZR=<?S7=KE5PI„” { @ I’T:SJZRZL?t8FLE5PI›7&@:9œ=WmJ=•@FL™IG@PIIGS>?\Ež=Ÿ?I^E=‚EMLE1=<S? ?A8:9<=†I(5z@tI’T:SJZRZ—@ hA827^E1=W@tI

=œ?\E5,m7&8:?PE@\IR;PL-N1S?ATFE1=<S??@:Z—@u?\ERI&SAT:=<8:9<XEStLiE@,N1S>=MIR9W@€T:SZ¡ZLb?8FLE827'=MI&Z[@ˆ@PI^E¢@:NMN1=eT\8:Tz@uZ—@:?PE¢@2?;=œm Lb5ˆ@u?

T:8,?A8:9<=†I(8:?\E9MjW@,£h7&@ I(I&=<SJ?ŒhASA9œ=KE'=<aPLb@ˆ;8u?I_;je8„LE17&@PIR@\I&hA8:T:@PI_@FE¢@,?ŒmA827&8:?PE1=MI¤IG8u?\E91jW8:T:T:} I_;@9W8ŒcWZ[=<?S7&=‚E5j

T,D 7&5„E'=<@:??t@C¥%9<8CT:=‚ES‡@:??t@FE5C@FE8FL£_7&@PI¤IGStLA7GT:@PIIGSJT,=W8:9W@PI&XATFLb9‚EMLA7&@,9<9W@ I@FEl5:T2S>?tS>ZR=WaPLb@ I„”

{ @PICT:Di7&5FE=<@:?JI…;J@R¦„S7&;8,?=W@¡7&@2h7&5PI&@:?\E@,?PE§@2? ]A=œ7GS>?‹¨©ª;«Lb?@¡hASh LA9W8FE1=<S?|;@ r Z[=e9W9e=<SA?JI…;J«D8,vA=‚E8:?PE&IGXI&S=‚E

w¨Ax¡xxx‹¥w¬ix­xxx[hA@27¤I&S? ?t@PI„”

{

@¡?SAZ_vt7&@R8FvI&SA9‚L€;@\I§T,D 7&5„E'=<@:?I§@PI1E+@2?‹8FLAmJZ—@:?PE8„E1=<S>?‹TzS>?AI^E8,?\E@¡ZR8:=^I

9e@„LA7h7&ShS7†E1=<S?ƒ86v>8u=MI„IG5;@6hA9•LI®;J@9W8ZRSJ=‚E=<5;A@,h Lb=MILA?|I&=W}:T:9W@:X?tS>?—hA8PIE8,?\E¥T:8FLIG@;@91jM5:Z[=<m7&8FE=<S?X

aPL=JES LbT,Dt@5,mA8:9<@:Z—@u?\ET,D 7G5FE'=•@u?AI+@FEZ6LI1L9WZ[8:?I®;@PI§T:8FE5,mtS>7=<@ IfI&SAT:=<Sh7&S>N1@\I¤I&=<SJ??t@:9e9W@ I+9e@\IhA9•LI®5:9e@,]>5P@\I&X

Z[8:=MI+I^LA7^ES L El;PL—N18:=‚El;jgLb?@fvA8:=MI„I&@;PL¡E8„L£—;@6?8„E8u9<=‚EG5 ”

{

@PIT:D 7&5FE1=•@u?IA~&S7&;8:?=W@:?JI?t@CT:S?I^E=‚EMLb@,?PEhA8PIL?t@

Z[=<?S7&=‚E5‰¯&T:SAZh8zTFE@ ¯ƒZ—8u=MI‹;=MI'hA@,7(I&5\@°I1LA7[L?t@˜vAS??@ŒhA8,7^E1=•@;PL"E@,7'7&=‚E†S>=g7G@¥Œ9e8N1SJ=MI`;8u?I`9e@ Iƒ±uS>?t@tI

LA7^vA8:=<?A@PI+@„E.7^LA7&829e@\I„” H 9MI8,hh827^E1=<@:??@:?PE ¥…Lb?@¢;>=<±\8:=<?A@;jn mA9<=†I(@\I&X9W@tIT:SAZ¡ZLb?8FLE5\I9W@ IhA9gLI=WZ¡hAS7^E8,?\E@PI

5FE8,?PEX¥[hA8,7ME§h7&@PI&aPLb@ƒ52mA8u9•@tIGX9W@PICm7&@zTtI%S>7^E1DtSJ;iSt£>@ƒ@FE§9<@ I9e8„E'=<?JI¢'S L²T:8FE1DtS>9<=WaPLb@PIC7&SAZR8:=œ?I“&XI^Lb=•]b=MI¢;@tI

m7&@:TPIT:8FE1DtSJ9<=<aPL)@PI&X;=‚E&I8FLI„I&=Z—@:9œ³A=‚E@PIGX;@C7=KE@6S7†E1DtS;St£>@6ZR8:=MI7&8„EeE8:T,Dt5PI¥

p

SJZR@ ”:Y–9^jŽ@z£>T:@,h E=<S?[;jgLb?A@

hA@FE1=‚E@CT:SZRZ_Lb?8„LE5C8,7&ZR5:?=e@:??t@:XJ9W@PIT:D 7G5FE'=•@u?AIA~&S>7G;8u?=W@:?IIG@CT:S>?I&=•;J},7G@,?PElT:SZRZ[@C;@ IYC7&8,v>@PI8FLƒZR´:Z`@

E1=‚E17&@€aPLb@|9e8€Z—8G~GS>7&=‚E5€;@˜9•8hASh Lb9<8FE=<S>?-ZLI^Lb9eZ—8:?A@˜9<8zaPLb@u9W9W@˜TzSJZh E@€8FLI¤I&=…;@ I[Z—=œ?tS>7&=‚E5\I—@FE1D?=WaPLb@tI

;jeS7'=gmA=<?A@CT:8FLbT:8 I&=W@:??@ ”

{

@PI‹T:D 7&5„E1=<@:?Iƒ;@Œ¦µS>7&;82?=e@zXCaPLje=e9MI|IG@Œ;=†I(@:?\E—;jeS7'=<mA=œ?t@˜hA8:9W@ I^E=œ?=W@:??@StL–E17&8,?JI<~GS>7&;82?=e@:??A@:X6IG@:9<SJ?"9Ž@

Tu9<=g]b8,mA@RhASJ9<=‚E'=•T:SJU'=<;@:?\E'=‚E8:=g7G@PI§aPL=;SZR=<?A@[9e8ƒI&SAT:=<5FE5~&S7&;8:?=e@:??t@¡;@2h L=MIC9W@ I§8:??5:@ I 2¶s xX I2jW=œ?I(T27=g]>@u?\E

;8,?IR;@PI¢7&5:N15,7&@:?PE&I¢?8FE=<S?8FLA£-?S?UT:S>?N1@ I(I&=<SJ??@:9MI—^‡²T:S>Z¢h7=MIR9W@­7&5:N15,7G@u?\EhA8,?827&8,vA@,“R@„E?«S>?\E~(8uZ—8:=^I

@F£h7&=eZ—5:X@,?‰E82?PE`aPLb@Œm7'S LAhA@2X6;@˜]>S>9<S?PE5;«=g7'7&5z;J@,?\E'=WI&Z[@S L’;@‰I&T:=MI¤I&=<SA?” H 9WI|I&@ŒhA9W8u=<mA?@:?PE—hA@FL’;@

;>=eI(T27=<Z—=œ?A8„E'=<S?JI–;8:?I"9W@FLA7(I‰7G8,hhAS>7ME&I–8F]A@zT·9W@FLA7¤I3TzS>?tTu=KESt‡t@:?I"ZLI^Lb9eZ—8:?JIGX|S L¸vA=W@:?¸@:?tT:S>7G@·8F]>@\T

9e«8:;Z[=<?J=MI1E17&8FE1=<S?—StL‹9<@\IfI&@27G]A=WT:@ I;@I(5:TFLA7&=‚E56Z—´:Z—@_I&=9W@ I E@2?JI&=<SJ?I?@I&S?PElhA8PI.ESPE8,9<@:Z—@u?\E8FvIG@:?PE@PIµ”

H

9†I

?jeS?PE€hA8\I;je@,£thA5,7&=e@:?tT:@ž;A@]A=<SJ9W@:?T:@Š=<?PE@,7GT:S>ZRZRLA?8FLE8:=g7&@i”

H

9MIhA8,7^E=<T:=<hA@u?\E8:TFE=g]A@:Z—@:?PE¥"EStLI9W@tI

;S>ZR8:=<?A@ I€;@"9<8‰]A=W@I&SAT:=<8:9W@"8FL¹hAS=œ?\EˆaPLb@‰91je5:9W=‚E@35:T:S?SZ¡=WaPLb@:XR=<?PE@:9<9e@zTFEMLb@:9œ9W@:XRTFLb9‚EMLA7&@:9<9W@"@FE‹ZR´:Z`@

hAS>9<=‚E=WaPLb@ƒT:SJZh E@¡Lb?@[h7&ShAS 7ME1=<S>?;@ƒT:D 7G5FE'=•@u?I§E17&}PII1LAhA5,7&=e@„LA7&@ƒ¥º9W@,LA7Ch7&ShS7†E1=•S>?€;8:?I9W8[hAS>h Lb9W8FE1=<SJ?

E1SPE8,9<@i”

{

@PI+T:D 7G5FE'=•@u?AI+;@6¦µS>7G;8,?=W@67&@:9W}z]>@:?PE;jgLA?@T:8„E5,mAS>7=<@RaPLb@69W«S?[hA@„LEaPLb8u9<=<N'=W@,7+;@—¯Z—=œ?tS>7&=‚E5RI&=œ9W@:?AT:=W@FLI&@¯&X

8FLI¤I&=™vA=W@:?‹;PL€N18:=‚E®;@¡9W@FLA7§aPL=•5FEMLb;@RaPLb@¡;PLˆN18:=‚E®aPLje=e9MICI&S?PEvA=W@:?|I&S L]A@:?PE®StLvA9<=W5PI§;@ I§8:?8:9œ‡bI&@ ICI^LA7§9W@tI

T,D 7&5„E'=<@:?AI;J«VC7=W@:?PEXR91j•Lb?¹;5:T:S L9•8u?\EŒIG8,?I;S L E@3; @39^jW8FLE17&@i”VC?žEM7&8,=KE@»hA827N1S=MI;jM@FLA£¼T:SZ¡Z—@3;j•L?

8,hhA@,?;=WT\@­;@PI¢T:D 7G5FE'=•@u?AI¢;J@[Ql8u9•@tI1E'=<?t@:XT:@‹aPL=hA@FLE¢I&@6~^LI^E=<N^=W@,7hA8,79W@ƒ7&½9<@­aPLljW¥6~&S Lb5­9W8º¦µS>7&;82?=e@‹@P?

B¾=MI<~&S7&;8,?=W@%~'LI&aPLjW¥¡L?A@ƒ;8„E@[7&5:T:@,?\E@:X.S L˜vA=•@u?@u?tT\S>7&@[hA827f9<8ƒN1S>71E@[h7'ShS7†E1=•S>?€;jW=œ?A;=g]=W;PLI;jWS>7'=ŸmJ=<?b@

hA8u9•@tI1E1=<?=e@:??A@;8:?AI39e@¹7&St‡t8FLbZ—@D8\T:D5:Z[=‚E@i”`Q7&5zT,=MI&S?I3T:@,hA@:?t;8u?\E–aPLje@:?š¦„S7&;8,?=W@:X˜9•@tI»T,D 7G5FE'=•@u?I

S>7'=ŸmJ=<?A8:=g7&@ I¢;@­9W8º7&=g]b@‹S>7&=<@:?PE8:9<@‹;PL¦µStLA7G;8u=<??@˜IGS>?\EChA8PI¢ZRSJ=<?I?tSJZv7&@FLA£²aPLb@­Tz@FLJ£²S7&=gmJ=<?A8:=<7&@PI¢;A@

(3)

{ 8º]A=MI&=<SJ?Œ9W8ƒhJ9gLI7&5,hA8:?t;PLb@­T:D@:±|9W@PI7&827&@PI¢@ I¤I&8,‡A=MI&E@PI¢@FE~&StLA7?8:9e=MI^E@\ISAT:T:=<;@:?PE8„L£aPLb=E17&8:=‚E@2?PE;@‹T:@

m7&StLAhA@¢@PI^E®aPLb@69<@ I§T:D 7&5„E1=e@:?AI™~&S7&;8,?=W@:?ICI&S?PE9<@ I+h7&SPE5,mA5\I§;PL|ZRS?827&aPLb@R¥¡aPLb=™=W9MI¾]>StLb@,?\ELA?t@¡9<S‡8„LE5

=œ?A;5:N@:TFE=gvA9e@i”B¾@„EeE@_]A=MI&=<SA?­hA8,71E§;PL|h7G5PI^LAhhASI&5—aPLb@_9W@ IC=<;@:?\E'=‚E5\I6IGSJT:=<8:9W@ IC@FE®9e«8:T\T:}\IC;@ I…T,D 7&5„E'=<@:?I…¥[9W8

]A=e@‹h LJvA9W=eaPLb@ŒIGS>?\E¢5FEM7S>=KE@uZ_@u?\E¢;5FE@,7'ZR=<?A5PI¢h8,7R9<@„L7R82hhA8,7^E@,?t8,?T:@€T:S?N1@ I¤I&=<SA??@:9e9W@:X+aPLb=f9W@PIhA9W8\T:@|@P?

S>hhtS)I=‚E'=•S>?¹8,]A@zT9W8Z—8'~&S7=KE5Z6LI1L9WZ[8:?t@9W8:aPLb@:9e9W@ IG@,7&8:=‚EI&@FLb9<@"hAS7†E@FLIG@3;@»9•8?S7&ZR@=•;@u?\E'=KE8u=Ÿ7&@ ”

Q.S LI¤IG5:@ƒ¥|I&S?€@,£ E17&´:ZR@:XT:@FEME@ƒ82hh7'SAT,D@ƒTzS>?AT:9gLE…¥¡LA?@€ce;D=eZ—Z[=‚EMLb;@j=œ?A;52hA8tI(I(8,vA9e@zX8FL²Z[=W@FLA£AX@FE…T\@

I&@,7&8:=‚E¢9W@|T\8PI—@:?Œ¦µS>7&;82?=e@zX%I&S LIR9W8­h7&S E@:T¤E1=<S>?²;J«Lb?‰Z_S>?t8,7&aPLb@€5:T:9W8u=<7&5ˆaPL=§mA8,7&8:?PE1=‚E¢8„LJ£–T:D 7G5FE1=<@:?I6L?

7&@:ZhA8,7^E…T:S?PEŽ7&@º9W«=†I&9W8:Z[=MI&Z—@ ”.B+@FEME@[hA@27¤I'hA@:T„E1=‚]b@ºN8:=‚EC91jW5:T:S?SJZR=W@ƒ;j•Lb?@‹8:?8:9œ‡bI&@‹;@PIRI'‡I^E}:Z—@PIRI&SAT:=<8FL£

T:S>Z¢hJ9W@,£A@ I…;8u?AIC9W@PI&aPLb@:9MIIµje=<?I(},7&@:?PE+9•@tI…T,Di7&5FE=<@:?IC;8,?I…9<@ IfhA8,‡I…;@[T„L9‚EMLA7G@¡Z6LI^Lb9eZ—8:?@ ”

n

?ˆ5:T:9e8:=g7G8u?\E

9e@ I¢; ‡?A8:Z[=WaPLb@ I=W;@:?PE=‚E8:=g7&@PI_@FE9<@|ZRSA;@­;@‹mA@PI^E=<S?Œ;PL-hA9gLA7&8:9<=†I(Z—@º7G@u9W=<mJ=W@FLA£€E@u9®aPLje=e9CI2jW@z£>@,7&T:@ˆ;8u?I

9^jn E8FEA~&S7&;8,?=W@:?XS>?—hA@FLE.h7ShSI&@,7LA?t@8FLE17&@9<@:TFEMLA7@;@PI+ZRSA;@PI®;J«=œ?IG@,7^E=<S?ƒ;@PI®TuDi7&5FE1=W@:?JI®;@6¦„S7&;8,?=Ž@

;8,?IC9W@FLA7C@:? ]A=g7GS>??A@:Z—@:?PECIGSJT,=•8u9@FE§aPLb@:9<aPLb@\I8,71m LAZ[@:?\E&IfhAS LA7f?\Lb8u?tT:@,7+L?t@¡]A=†I&=•SJ?­hb@PI„I&=<Z[=MI1E@[;@[9W@FLA7

h7&5PI&@2?PEl@FE;@f9<@„LA78z]>@:?=g7'”

! " #!" " !%$&"'(&) *"$&+,.-

{ 8|;t‡t?A8 I^E1=W@|D8:T:D5:Z—=‚E@­7&},mA?@ŒI1LA7¡9W8|¦„S7&;8,?=•@˜;@2h>Lb=eIƒI&8€T,7G5:8FE1=<S?-@:? w @:?-@,£A@,7&Oz8u?\ECLA?ŒhAS L]ASJ=Ÿ7

ZRSJ;527&5:Z[@:?\E+8FLE†S>7=‚E8:=g7&@:X8FLES 7'=‚E8,7&=eI&Z—@—;S>?\E+9<@PI…;@:m7&5PI+]A8,7&=W@:?PE®;8,?JIC9W@6E@:ZhI§@u?‹N1SJ?tTFE'=•S>?‹;A@PI§N1S>7&Tz@tI

hAS>9<=‚E=WaPLb@PI§aPL=9gL=T:S?PE@PI1E@,?PE+IG89e52mJ=‚E=eZR=‚EG5 ”#/_8u?AIE1SPLI+9W@PI§T:8 IGXTz@6hAStL]>SJ=g7+?jW@PI^EhA8PIE1Dt5:SAT,7&8FE1=<aPLb@6vA=W@P?

aPLb@º9W8[7&5:N5,7&@:?T:@‹¥¡Lb?@ƒ9e5:mA=‚E=œZ—=‚E5ƒ=†I(9W8:Z[=WaPLb@ƒ¥`E17G8F]b@,7¤I91je8 IGT:@:?;8:?AT:@[h7&ShD5FE=<aPLb@ƒ;A@PICqR8zTuDt5:Z[=‚E@PI¢@FE

9e@„LA7€;SJZR=<?A8FE1=<S?I&5:TFLb9W8:=œ7G@’I1LA7€9<@ I€9œ=W@,LA£I&8:=<?PE(I€;A@ { 8 y @zT:aPLb@"@FEˆ;@ y 5:;=œ?A@"N8PI„I&@-hA8,7^E1=W@";@"9W8

7'D5FES 7=<aPLb@C;PL—7&5,mA=œZ—@ ” y 8:=MIT\«@ I^E9<SJ=<?R;«´FE17&@C9<@6IG@FL9A7&5,N5,7&@:?\E(”

{

86ZRSJ?t8,7&T:D=W@686hAS LA7Stvµ~¤@zTFE'=<N;@I(@6Z—8:=œ?\E@:?=œ7@FElhAStLA7ZR5FE1DtSJ;@;@_I(«8 I¤I1LA7&@,7.L?‹I&S LE1=<@:?ƒI^LbN^N'=MIG8uZ—Z—@u?\E

9e827^mA@|;@€I&8­vA8 I&@i” n 9<9W@?t@­hA@FLE¢S L?t@º]b@FLERI&«8:9e=W5:?A@,79W@PI¢h7&=œ?tT:=œhb8:9W@PIRN1S>7GT:@PI[IGSJT:=<8:9W@ IR@FE¢8ˆ; S?T­hAS LA7

D8,vA=‚EMLb;@‹;J@­?t5,mASATu=•@|8,]A@:T|@:9<9W@ I;8:?ICLb?ŒN1SJ?tTFE'=•S>??t@uZ—@:?PE…hA8FE17'=<ZRSJ?=W8:9+@FE%T:9œ=W@:?PE5:9<=MI^E@‹@FE;@‹N'8:=g7(@‹;@tI

8,7^vA=‚E17&82mA@PI„”bV%7§9e@ I§T:D 7G5FE'=•@u?AI&X¥_E17&8F]>@,7¤I§9W@FLA7¤IC=<?I^E=‚EMLiEM=<SJ?AICTzSJZRZ_Lb?8„LE8u=Ÿ7&@PI…@FE+9<@FLA7(IC5:9<=‚E@ If9W8,ŽaPLb@ I&X IGS>?\E

@,?°v>S>??t@|hAS)I&=‚E1=•S>?-;8:?I—T:@FEWE@|?5,mASAT,=<8FE=<S?” H 9WI[?t@²IGS>?\EhA8\IR9<@ IƒI&@FLb9MI„” n ?-@:NMN'@„EX®LA?ZRS>‡t@:?-@:NMN'=WT\8:T\@

;je=<?I^E8FLA7&@279<8C7&@:9e8„E1=<S>?`T:9e=W@:?PE5:9<=†I1E@:XJDt5,7&=‚E56;@9^jŽ5,hASJaPLb@S#0ƒ9<86¦µS>7G;8,?=W@65FE8:=‚EI&S LIZR8:?t;8FE™vt7=KE8u??=WaPLb@:Xb8

5FE5ª;@ªT,S?JIGS>9<=W;A@,7 ;@PI m7&S LAhA@PI IGSJT2=<8FLA£ =W;@:?PE1=WN^=W5 I ¥ hA8,71E1=g7 ;@ªT:8,7&8zTFE5,7&=eI^E=<aPLb@ I 7&@:9<=<mJ=W@FLI(@\I&X

@FE1D ?tSJ9<=œ?m Lb=MI^E=<aPLb@ IS L‰IGSJT2=<S>mA5zS>m7&82hD=<aPLb@PI@FE…;jWS>7MmA82?=†I(@276=<?JI1E'=KEMLE1=<S>??t@:9e9W@:Z[@:?\EC9MjM@,£th7&@PI¤I&=•SJ?€;@ƒ9e@„LA7FI

hA8,7^E1=<TFLb9W8,7&=MI&Z[@\IR@FE9<@„LA767&@:9W8FE=<S?Œ¥|9W8­ZRSA?8,7&T:D=W@|@FE%8FLA£=<?I^E=‚EMLE1=<S?JI¢;A@­91jn E8FE(” { 8ƒ¦„S7&;8,?=<@ˆ@PI^E%;S>?tT

T:8,7&8:T„E5,7'=eI(5:@ hA8,7Lb?ªhJ9gLA7&8:9<=MI¤Z—@ =œ?I1E'=KEMLE1=<S>??t8:9e=MI(5 aPL=›SATFE17'S=<@ hA8,7š9e8 9W5,mJ=MI(9W8FE'=•S>? ;@PI @PIhA8:T\@tI

;je@,£h7G@PI„I&=<S?X;jWS>71mA8,?=MI(8FE1=<S?—@FE;jW8:TFE1=g]A=‚E5 I¥;@PIm7&StLAhA@\I7G@,9<=œmA=W@FLA£—'¥I&8F]>SJ=g79W@PIZ_LI1L9WZ—8u?AI+I^Lb??=‚E@ I&X

@FELA?@C;=œ±u8u=<?A@;@CT:SJZRZL?t8FLE5PITzS>?N@ I¤I&=<SJ??t@:9e9W@PIT:D 7&5FE=<@:??@\I'“Z[8:=MI5,mb8u9W@:Z—@:?PEl¥¾LA?Rm7&StLAhA@C@„E1D ?=WaPLb@:X

T:@:9‚L=_;@tIˆB+=œ7GT:8PI„I&=W@:?JIˆ@FE`‘T,D5FET2D}:?@ I|=MI(I^LI|;@]b8,m Lb@PIˆ;je=eZ—Z[=<m7&8FE=<S?›;PL¹B+8FLbT:8 I&@zX@FE‹8„L£E17=•viL™I

vA5:;S L=<?t@tI§;@\IfZ—8,71mA@PI§8,7&=<;@ I„”bB+@¡N18:=MI&8:?PEXT:@,7ME8,=<?I§8PI'hA@:T„E&I§;@PI+7&@:9<8FE=<S?JIE17&8,?AI']A@,7(I(8u9W@PI§@:?\E17&@PI+m7StLAhA@PI

I&@I&S?PE™EŽ7'S L]A5z@PI@u?tT:8:; 7&5z@tIhA8,7T:@FEME@CS 71mA8,?=MI&8„E'=<S?[=W?JI1E'=‚EMLE1=•S>??t@u9W9W@:XZR8:=†IGX?S LI9W@…]b@27'7&S?JIhJ9KLI9<SJ=<?AXTz@

?je@PI1EhA8PI+91je=<?PE5,m7G8u9W=‚E5;PLˆT:D8:ZRh€I&SATu=•8u9aPLb=@PI^E8:=<?I&=;5:T:S LAhA5 ” n ?`@uNMN@FEX89W«@,£>T:@,h E=<S>?`;@ I~GLA7&=<;=WTFE=<S>?I

;@I1E8µEMLiEChA@,7¤IGS>?i?@:9<X9W@PIRT:Di7&5FE1=<@:?IRI&S?PE¢I&S LAZ¡=MI_8FL-; 7&S=‚E%T,SZRZ_Lb?XD ‡iv7&=W;@­;@‹; 7&SJ=‚E…=MI&9e8:Z—=eaPLb@‹@FE%;@

; 7&S>=KEƒhSI&=‚E=<NƒSAT:T:=e;@:?\E8u9•XS10 8FLbTFLA?t@‰T:9W8FLI&@‰?t@‰9W@tIˆZ—@FE‹@,?›5FE8„E‹;@hA8,7†E1=•TFL9W8,7&=MI&Z—@‰S L¹;«=<?JN5,7&=<S7=KE5

~GLA7&=<;=WaPLb@ ”

/R@FL£3E1‡ihA@tIˆ;jWS>71mA8,?=MI(8FE=<S?JI|=<?I1E'=‚EMLE1=•S>??t@u9W9W@tIˆT:S?AT:@,7?@:?PEˆI'hA5:T:=<N'=WaPL@:Z—@:?PE`9e@\I|T:Di7&5FE=<@:?JI32CT:@:9gL=_;@tI

T:S>ZRZLb?8FLE5PIT:S?N'@PI„I&=•SJ??@:9e9W@PIGXR@FEˆT:@:9gL=—aPLb=[S71m8,?=MI(@"9W8‰7&@,h7&5\I(@u?\E8µE1=•S>?ŠhAS9<=‚E'=WaPLb@3@FEˆ9MjM8:TzT:} I€8FL£

T,D8,71mA@ I.h LvA9e=WaPLb@ I„”

465!798':#;<;>=#?@A=AB.C!7D8':#?FE5&7G7H":#??A5I"I"5!7

{ «n

E8µE…D8:T,Dt5:Z[=‚E@:XaPL=7&@:T:S??8JœECvA=W@:?|L?;SZ—8u=<?A@­h7=•]>5­;@‹9e8‹T,7&S‡8:?tT:@º7G@u9W=<mJ=W@FLIG@:X@:?PE@,?t;Œ=eZRhASI&@,7

LA?@T:@27^E8,=<?A@6N1S7Z_@;@%7G5,m L9W8FE=<S?—;@tI=<?I^E=‚EMLE1=<S?JI7G@u9<=<mA=e@„LI(@PI&XT:Di7&5FE=<@:??@ IT:SJZRZ—@6ZL™I1L9<Z—8:?A@PI„”B§«@PI1E

(4)

hA8,7^E1=<@3;@ž9W«@PIhA8\T:@ IGSJT:=<8:9ƒ@:?9KL=ƒN'=g£b8:?PE;@PI²T:8:; 7(@PIT:S?N@PI„I&=<SJ??t@u9MIµ” /_@,h L=MI91jM52hASJaPLb@3;PL Z—8:?;8FE

v7&=‚E8:??=<aPL)@:X9<8¢B¾S?I^E=‚EMLiE1=<S>?`@FE9<89e52mJ=MI&9W8FE=<S>?|IG@¡I&S? E=<?JIGT,7&=‚E@PI+;8:?I+9W@; 7&S=‚EN^=<9;A@PIDB@?&H.; @ B™S EeE†S>Z_8u?I

@,?5:9W8,71mJ=MI„IG8u?\E¥»Lb?@›;>=<±\8:=<?A@|;@›T:SJZRZL?t8FLE5PI²T:S>?N1@\I„I&=<SJ??@:9W9e@\I-T:D 7&5FE1=W@:??@\I9W8mb8,7&8,?\E'=<@Š;jgLb?A@

8FLE1S?SZR=e@‰I1E8FEML E82=g7&@;8:?JI‹9W8ŒmA@PI^E=<S?3;@9<@FLA7¤I‹8:NMN&8:=g7G@PI‹=œ?\E@,7&?@PIGX6;82?I­9W«S7^mA8,?=MI(8FE=<S?3;«L?›I'‡I^E}:Z`@

@:?IG@u=<mA?@:Z—@:?PE®T:S>?iN1@ I¤I&=<SJ??t@:9eX;8:?JI§9e8RZR=†I(@R@:?ƒhA9<8\T:@R;«Lb?ƒ7&5PIG@:8FL;jCLJ]t7&@PICI&SAT:=<8:9W@tI§@„E+T:827'=‚E8FE1=g]A@\I§@FE

;8,?I9W@PI–~GLA7&=<;=WTFE=<S>?I¼;@ I^E8FEMLiEŠhA@,7(I'S? ?t@:93'T:8FLI&@\IZ—8FE17'=<ZRSJ?=W8:9W@ I&XI1LbT:T:@ I¤I&=<SA?I&X"@FETi”“„”BD8zaPLb@

T:S>ZRZLb?8FLE5R8,hhA9<=eaPLb@R9W@¡; 7GSJ=‚E®T:8,?S?‹;@ºIGS>? n mA9œ=MIµ@ ” n ?N1=œ?tX™9W@tI§8zTFE'=g]A=‚E5\I§;J@RT:S?JI1E17^LbTFE1=<S?X;@¡T„L9‚E@R@FE

9e@ IZRS L]A@:Z—@:?PE&I8PI(I&SAT:=<8FE=œN&I;@PI

n

mA9<=†I(@\II&S?PEI&82?I@,?PE17G8F]A@ ”

{ «=œ?t;J52hA@u?t;8:?T:@‹;PL7&St‡>8FLbZ[@ƒD8zTuDt5:Z[=‚E@‹;@[¦„S7&;8,?=W@:X=<?\E@,7^]b@:?PLb@ƒ@:? ¨ r X?A«8ƒhA8PI¢5FE5ƒ9e«SAT:T:8PI&=•SJ?€;A@

7&@:ZR@FEMEM7G@‰@,?›T:8„LI&@‰9W@I1E8µEMLiE‹;@PIˆT:SZRZ_Lb?8„LE5PIˆT:S>?N1@\I„I&=<SJ??@:9W9e@\I|TzSJZRZ[@-T:@:9W8‰NMLEƒ9W@‰Tz8PIˆ;8u?Iˆ9W@tI

;>=<T„E8FEMLA7&@PI€9<8,ŽaPL)@PI;@

o

‡7&=W@3@FE;«

H

7&8,³¼S10 9•@PI5\T:S>9W@ I5FE17&82? mA},7&@\IStL 9•@tI€vA=W@:?JI;@ I

n

mA9<=MI(@PIŒNMLA7&@:?PE

?8FE=<S?8:9e=MI(5PI–@FE²9e@\I‰h7&=g]A=e9W},mb@PI–5:;PLbT:8„E'=<N&I";@ I–T:S Z—Z_Lb?8„LE5PI"9<827^mA@:Z—@:?PE7G@uZR=MI–@:?¸aPLb@\I^E=<S>?tXº]ASA=g7&@

8Fv7&SmA5PIµ”B¾S?PE17G8,=g7&@:Z—@:?PE§¥[9W«

n

m‡h E@—5,mA8:9<@:Z—@u?\EX 9W«=œ?I^E8„LA7&8µE1=•S>?ˆ;J«Lb?|; 7GSJ=‚E+hASI'=‚E=<Nf?A«@:ZRhJ=W5FE8RhA8PI6I1LA7C9W@tI

h7&5,7S>mA8FE1=K]b@PI¼;@tI

n

mJ9<=MI(@ I¼@u? Z—8FE'=•},7&@ ;@ ~1LA7=W;=MTFE1=•S>? ;@ I I^E8FEMLiE&I·hA@27¤I&S? ?t@u9MIµ”

{ 8 B¾S?JI1E'=KEMLE1=<S>?

h7&S>ZL9gm L)5:@R@:? ¬\w|@ I1EE†StL2~&S LA7¤I§@,?ƒ]A=<m Lb@FLA7§8FLz~&S>LA7&;«DPLb=M” n 9<9W@[NeLE§I&8:9gLb5:@[¥R9e«5,hASAaPLb@_hA827f9<@ I§Z¡=W9e=W@FL£

@:T:T:9W5PI&=W8tI1E1=<aPL)@PI–T:S>ZRZ—@ ¯9W8ŠhJ9‚LI-9e=gvb5,7&8:9W@Š;A@PIhb8z‡bI–8,7&8,vA@PI-hAS LA7-T:@ŠaPLb=|T:S?Tz@,7&?@Š9e@I^E8„EML E²;@PI

T,D 7&5„E'=<@:?AI2¯„”

n

?3@:NMN'@„EX6¥˜vA=W@:?3;@ I‹5,mA8,7G;JI&X69<@ŒhAS L]bS=g7ƒDA8:T:D5:Z[=KE@:X6;82?I|I&8-T:S?PE1=<?PLb=‚E5@FE—m7:Tz@¥‰I(8

;>=<Z—@:?JI&=<SJ?—7&@:9e=<mA=e@„LI(@:XSJT¤E17'S=<@8„LJ£

n

mA9<=†I(@ IL?t@_9W=gvb@u71E5;«8:TFE1=<S?ƒ@:? ]A=W8,vA9e@i”

n

?‹T:S?PE17&@2hA8,7†E1=•@:X9W@67&52mJ=<Z—@R8

7&@:T,Dt@,7&T:D59W@_IGStLE1=•@u?—hASJ9<=‚E=<aPL@;@PI+N1S7&T:@PI7&@:9W=œmA=W@FLI(@ I;PLƒhA8,‡IGX)hA827@,£A@:ZRhA9e@RI^LA79W8aPL@PI1E'=•S>?—;@ I { =W@FLJ£

I&8:=<?PE&I§;A@_¦2527^LI&8:9W@:Z S L€;8:?JII(8¡9gLEME@RT2S>?\E17&@¡9<@\ICZƒS L]A@:ZR@:?PE&I+hASA9œ=KE'=WaPLb@PII&@R7&5:T:9W8uZ—8:?PE®;@PI§=W;5:SJ9<SmJ=•@tI

I&SATu=•8u9<=MI^E@\I 8FL hAStL]>SJ=g7 ;8:?AI 9W@tI

n

E8µE&I ]AS=eI&=<?I:”

n

? N1=<?AX 91jW@:N^N1S7^Eš;@PI

n

m9œ=MI(@PI @:? Z—8FE=<},7&@ ;@

;5F]A@:9<ShhA@:Z[@:?\E‹;je=<?I^E=‚EMLE1=<S?JII&SAT:=<8:9e@ Iˆ@ I^Eº;@,h L=WI­E1S L2~&S LA7¤IƒLA?›T:SJZhA9W5uZ—@:?PEº8,hh7&5:T:=W5-aPL=R;52m7&},]b@

;je8FLE82?PE¢9<@ IRN'=<?A8u?tT:@ IR;A«L?

n

E8µE7G5,h L E5­hAS LA7[IG8|;5:hA@,?;8:?AT:@|5\T:S?SZR=WaPL@|;@€91je@,£ E527=•@FLA7R^7&@:Z—=†IG@€;@

5uZR=<m7&5PI ~&S7&;8:?=W@:?JI&X 8:=<;A@ =<?PE@27'?8FE=<S?8:9W@:X 8FL:~GStLA7&;j<DPLb= =<? ]b@PI1E'=MI¤IG@:Z[@:?\E&IªhA8,7 ;@PI TzS>ZhA82mJ?=W@>I

5FE17&8,?imA},7&@PI“„”

{

@PI3=<?I^E=‚EMLE1=<S?JI3TzSJZRZ_Lb?8„LE8u=Ÿ7&@PI3ShA},7&@2?PEXŒI^LA7ME1SPLE–8FL ?=g]A@\8FL ;@PI–hA8,7&S=†I(I&@ I3@„E–;@PI"=<?I^E=‚EMLiE1=<S>?I

I&T:SJ9•8u=Ÿ7&@ I&XLA?ƒE17&8F]A8:=<9;@[TzS>Dt5PI&=<SJ?€I&SAT:=<8:9e@—@FE§;@ƒI&SATF=W8:9e=MI(8FE1=<S?”

n

?‹hJ9‚LI…;@[9<@FLA7¤ICN1S?ATFE1=<S?II'hA=g7&=‚EMLb@:9e9W@ I&X

@u9<9W@ IT:S>?\E17'=gv L)@:?PE.N1S7^E@,Z_@u?\E¥6Z_8u=<?\E@u?=<7.L?—T:D 7&=MI^E=<8:?=MI&Z—@¡I&SAT:=<SJ9<SmJ=•aPLb@%‡`T:SJZh7&=MIh8,7&ZR=9W@tIT:D 7G5FE'=•@u?I

9e@ I.hA9gLI;A5:T:D 7&=MI^E=<8:?=†IG5 I„” H 9AN8FLElT:@,hA@:?;8:?PE?tStE@,7™LA?t@C;>=<N1N'527&@:?T:@C=eZRhAS7^E8,?PE@C;82?JI9W8%?A8FEMLA7G@C;@PI@PIhA8PTz@tI

T:S>ZRZLb?8FLE8:=g7&@\I—S>7^E1DtSJ;iSt£>@€@FE9•8FE'=<?tXf9<@PI—;@FLA£-h7&=e?T:=<hA8:9W@tI—TzS>?N@PI„I&=<S?I—T:D 7&5FE=<@:??@\I—;PL"hA8,‡IGXf@FE¢hA8,7

I^Lb=‚E@[;8,?I…9e8—T:S?T:@,h E=<S?|aPL)«S>?\E+9<@ ICZ—@:Zv7&@ I…;@[T\@PI…;@FLJ£T:S?N1@ I¤I&=<SJ?I…;@[9W«8,7^E=<TFLb9e8„E'=<S?ˆ@u?\E17&@ºIhD},7G@

T:S>ZRZLb?8FLE8:=g7&@C@„EIhD},7G@fh LvA9e=WaPLb@ ”

/ƒjgL?T:½ E5:X?tStLI¢8F]>S>?AI91jn mJ9<=MI(@‹S>7^E1DtSJ;iSt£>@:X9<8|I(@FL9W@ n mA9e=MIG@­aPLb=§@z£A=MI1E8u=KE@,?‘7G8,?I<~&S7&;8,?=W@|8,]A8:?PE9•@tI

ZRStLA]A@:Z—@:?PE&I‹ZR=MI„I&=<SJ??8:=<7&@PIº;@°9W8‰I(@:T:S?;@ZRSJ=KE'=<5-;PL H @‰I&=<}zTu9W@ ”*/_5,hA@:?;8:?PE`;PL3Ql8FEM7'=•8,7&T:8FE—m7&@zT

S>7ME1DSA; S £A@;@¦„5,7^LIG8:9<@:Z[X@:9<9W@`Iµje@ I1E9<S>?im E@:ZhI+9<=WZ[=‚EG5:@¥8\I¤I^LA7G@,7+9^jW@,£A@,7GTu=WT:@¢;PLˆTFL9KE@ ”

n

9<9W@@ I^EZR827&aPLb5\@

hA8,7™LA?6E17&}PIlN1S>7MElT,9<=•]b82mA@C@u?\E17&@:XA;«LA?RT:½ E5:X D8FLElT,9•@,7^mA5S 7'=gmA=<?A8:=œ7G@C;@C4%7&}zT:@C@FEXA;«LA?_8FLE17&@CT2½PE5:Xtv>8PIT:9<@,71mb5

@FE|9W8,ŽTPI²8,7&8,vA@PIµ”B§@PI;J@27'?=W@,7¤I²@z£A=<mA@:?PE;@,h Lb=MIŒ9W@ H ¢@žI&=e}\T:9W@91jM8,7G8zvA=MIG8FE'=•S>?¹;@ž9W8D=W5,7G8,7&T:D=W@:X_L?

ZRStLA]A@:Z—@:?PE…T:S?T:SZR=‚E8:?PE…;@ƒ9e«@:? mA8,mA@:Z—@:?PE…;@PI9W8z†TPIS7†E1DtSJ;iSt£>@PI;8:?I9W@º?t8FE'=•S>?t8u9W=MI&Z[@‹8,7&8,v>@ ” { jW5u9W=‚EG@

9e8,ŽaPLb@R;@¡9<8RT:SAZ¡ZLb?8FLE5[IG«@ I1E+T,Dt8,71mA5:@R;@¡;5„]A@:9<ShJhA@,7+9<@ I§8:T„E'=g]A=‚E5PI§TzSJZRZ6L?A8„LE8u=Ÿ7&@PI+?S?|I^E17&=<T„E@uZ_@u?\E

I'hA=g7&=‚EMLb@:9e9W@PI…@u?‹ZRS>vA=W9e=MI&8:?\E+;@PI+7G@tI(I&S LA7&T:@PI§N1=œ?A8:?AT:=W},7(@PI§DS7¤I§;@PI+7&5 I&@z8FLJ£ˆ@\T:T:9W5PI&=W8 I^E=<aPLb@PIµ”Bf@\If?tStE8FvA9•@tI

S>7ME1DSA; S £A@PIGX[;@"hA8,7^Eˆ9<@FLA7(I8:T„E'=g]A=‚E5PI€h7GSJN1@PI„I&=<SJ??t@:9e9W@PI&X­IGSJT:=<8:9W@PI²@FEˆhAS>9<=‚E=<aPL)@PI&XƒI&S?PE‹E17&}PI9<8,71mA@uZ—@:?PE

@,? mA8,mb5PI;8:?JI.Lb?[@ IhA8:T:@6ZLb9‚E'=WT:S?N@PI¤I&=<SA??A@u9bS#0‹=œ9MI®T:½PE1S=<@:?PE ;@PIZ6LI^Lb9<Z—8u?IGX>LA?@C7&5:8:9W=‚E56aPLb=8~GStLb5fL?

!#"%$&' ('*)*$+&,.-!/102$3!+141"%$&5)*1076*8+#891:!#";$<$)=>+&8#"?$1@&A.$+B6C)*86$+, -!

6*D+ED)$F)EG)*HI/1)*8!$J+*)E8#4>".$K0?)*8+>#"$G@&AL$&+>F6C.)E86$&+,.-F$&-&6*(+J*88!"$JLM+*89#N

(5)

LA?=eaPLb@:Z—@:?PE§Tz8,7&=‚E8FE1=<N+S L5:;PLbT:8FE1=<NX Z—8:=MIC8„LI„I&==<?PE@:9<9M@zTFEMLb@,9™]ASA=g7&@¡hASA9œ=KE'=<aPL)@[¥E17&8F]>@,7¤I§hA8,7C@F£b@:ZhA9W@:XLb?A@

=œ?I1E'=KEMLE1=<S>?RE@:9œ9W@9W@RB¾9gLJvºS>71E1DSA; S £A@;«Y6Z—Z[8:?‹;S?PE9W@ I+8:T„E'=g]A=‚E5PICIhAS>71E1=•]>@PI&XTFLb9‚EMLA7&@:9W9e@\I§@FE9•@PI§;5,vA8FE+I1LA7

;@PI+I^Lz~¤@„E&I;@I&SAT,=<5„E5_IGS>?\E.S L]A@27^E@PI¥¾E1S LI„”iB+@6T:9‚LAv`@PI^El9<8,71mA@uZ—@:?PElNM7&5:aPLb@:?PE5ChA8,79W«5:9<=‚E&@Z6L™I1L9<Z—8:?A@6aPL)=

@PI^E%8FLI¤I&=+Tz@u9W9W@|8,]A@:T|9W8:aPLb@:9e9W@­9W«5:9W=‚E@­S7^E1DtSJ;iSt£>@­=<?PE@,7&82mJ=‚E%@,?€hASJ9<=‚E=eaPLb@ˆ@FE;8,?AIR9W@PIR8:NMN8u=<7&@\I„”

n

?S LE17&@2X

9e«8,vI&@:?T:@¢;J«Lb?[7&5PIG@:8FLˆ5:;PLbTz8FE'=<N™E17&}\I+;5F]>@u9•S>hhA58hA@,7'Z[=MI®8FLJ£ºS>7ME1DSA; S £A@\I+;@¡IG@¡I&SAT:=<8:9e=MI&@,7®;}PI+9W@FLA7hA9‚L™I

~¤@„L?t@ ,mA@—@u?ˆT:½ E1S ‡t8u?\E§;@PICZL™I1L9<Z—8:?I&XI&SA=‚E§;8,?AIC9M@PI…5:T:SA9<@PI§h LJvA9W=eaPLb@\II&SJ=KEX™hS L7f9•@tI§hA9‚L™I…N1S>7^EMLA?t5:@PIGX

;8,?I;@ I5:T:SA9<@ I.h7&=•]b5z@tIlh7&StE@\I†E82?PE@PI™E17G}PI.hA@FL—h7&SI&5,9<‡\E@PI„”B+@FEME@C5z;PLbT:8FE1=<S?R;8:?I™Lb?¡Z—=e9W=e@„Lƒ?S?—;SJZR=<?A5

hA8,79W«

n

mJ9W=†IG@69W@PI86S L]A@27^EI1LA79<8I&SAT:=<5FE5@FEI^LA79W«@ IhA8:T\@%h LvA9W=eTzX;S>?\E9<86?8„EMLA7&@%ZL™I1L9WZ[8:?t@%?A@69•@FLA7hA827&8JœE

aPLb«Lb?@CTzSJZhASI&8,?\E@:X)I&=A;SZR=<?A8u?\E@6I&S=‚EU'@:9<9W@ ”

Q.827RT:S?PE17&8PIME@:X9W«n mA9e=MIG@˜9W8FE=œ?t@:X+aPL=§;A5,hA@:?;;PL-Ql8FE17^=W8,7GT:8FE¢9e8„E1=œ?-;@|¦µ5,7^LI&8:9W@:Z—Xf@PI1E¢T:8,7&8:T„E5,7'=MI&5:@|hA8,7R9Ž8

T:S>Dt5PI&=<SJ?›@:?PE17G@»IG@PI|N1=<;A}u9W@PIˆ8,7G8zv>@ I|@„E|I&S?›T,9W@,71mA5‰aPLb=¡I2jW@PI1E[E17&}PIƒ]A=‚E@-8,7&8„vA=†IG5‰82h7&}PI|9W@ Iˆ@:NMN1S>7^E&Iˆ;@PI

Z[=MI„I&=<SJ??t8u=Ÿ7&@ IC@FLA7GS>hA5:@2?IC¥[9W8ƒN^=<?€;PL

H

¢}:Z[@­I&=W}:T:9W@:X.@FE®hA8,7C9<8[TzS>?AT:@:?\E17&8µE1=•S>?ˆ;J@\ICZRS>‡>@u?I…N^=<?A8:?AT:=e@27FI

8FL£€Z—8:=œ?I…;@PI§7&@:9e=<mA=e@„LJ£)”JQ.S L7I&8¤E1=MI&N'8:=g7&@[9W8¡]>SJT:8„E1=<S>?€I&SAT:=<8:9W@[aPL)«@:9W9e@ƒI&@R7&@:T:S??8JœEX.9<@¡7G½>9W@[;@[91jn mA9<=MI(@

9e8„E'=<?@;J52hA8PI„I&@;J@Œ9<SA=œ?39W«@,£>@,7&T:=WTP@;PL’TFL9KE@ ”+V%7—hA@:?;8:?PERhA9‚LI&=W@FLA7¤I`;J5:Tz@u??=W@ I&XC9W@ŒT:9W@,71mA5°9W8FE1=<?38Œ?=Ž5

9^jŽ@z£A=MI1E@,?T\@¸;jgLb? @PI'hb8:T:@ h LJvA9W=WT @u? ¦„S7&;8,?=<@:XT\S?JI&=<;A5,7&82?PE"E†StLiE›T:@¸aPLb=-5FE8:=‚E3DtS>7(IŠ;@¸9W«@\I'hb8:T\@

T:S>ZRZLb?8FLE8:=g7&@ƒT:Di7&5FE=<@:?€T:SJZRZ—@ƒ;S>ZR=<?A5[hA8,7;@ If]>8u9W@FLA7(I6ZLI^Lb9<Z[8:?A@PIµ”JY=<?I&=eX.hAS LA7f7&@¤E@,?=g79W@tI9<8,ŽT>I

;8,?IŒ91jW@ I'hA8:T:@3T:SAZ¡ZLb?8FLE8:=g7G@:X[5:TzS>9W@PI@FE CL]7&@PI-I&SAT,=<8:9W@ IS>?\E€5¤E5"Z6Lb9‚E'=<hA9e=W5:@ I&X[=<?=‚E=W8:9e@:Z—@:?PEI&8,?I

m7&8,?;@CS L]A@27^EMLA7&@C8FL£—Z—@:Z_vt7&@ I;@PI8FLE17&@\IT:S?N1@PI„I&=WS>?AI¥%9W«@z£>T:@,h E=<S?R;@PIZ—@u9<³A=‚E@ I„”

o

=AT:@„EME@fhS9œ=KE'=WaPLb@8

vA=e@:?‹@FLˆhAS LA7f@2NMN1@FE+;@hA@,7Z[@„EeE17&@R¥fE1S LI+9<@ I§T:8FE1DSA9œ=Wa Lb@PI&X™9•8FE'=<?AI§@FEZ_@u9<³A=‚E@ I§T:S?N1S>?t;PLI&X)Lb?‹8:T:Tz}PI§¥6L?t@

5:;PLbT:8FE1=<S?‹;@RaPL8:9<=‚E5:X@:9e9W@R8¡8„L™I(I&=.@FLT:SJZRZ—@7&5PI^Lb9‚EG8FE®;@_h7G@,?; 7&@R9<@PI§T\8FE1DtS>9<=WaPLb@ I§;8u?AIL?‹@:?im7&@:?8,mb@ ”

{ @¡7&@,hA9<=¾I1LA7C9W@PIC=<?I^E=‚EMLE1=<S?ICTzSJZRZ_Lb?8„LE8u=Ÿ7&@[8[9<SA?m E@,ZhIC9W=eZ[=KE5[9e@„LA7¤IT:8,hA8zTu=KE5tI…;@ºIGSJT:=W8:9<=†I(8„E'=<S?ˆ;@tI

T:8FE1DS9<=WaPLb@tI`8,]A@\TŒ9W@ IƒZLI^Lb9eZ—8:?Iƒ@FE—9W@PI‹S7ME1DSA; S £A@PIµ”

H

9MI`S>?\E—@FL3hA9gLI‹;@ŒZ—8:9¥‰I(«=œ?\E5,m7&@,7`;8:?JI‹9W@tI

=œ?I1E'=KEMLE1=<S>?AIf?t8FE=<S>?t8:9e@ I§@FE?A«S>?\Em Lb}27&@R5FE5RT:SS>h\E5PI§; 82?If9W@PI+mAS L]A@,7&?t@uZ—@:?PE&ICI1LbT\T:@PI„I&=<NIµ” o 8:?I§;StLE@R@,?

7&5:8:TFE1=•S>?3¥Tz@FEME@˜ZR827^mA=<?A8u9W=MI(8FE1=<S?X6=<9MI‹S?PE`;5F]A@:9<ShAhA5;@,h L=WI­9W@PIº8u??t5\@PI

¬ix‰LA?3@:? mA8,mA@:Z—@:?PE—hA9‚L™I

Z[827&aPLb5­;8:?AI9W@PIZ_StLA]A@:Z—@:?PE&I¢;«S>hhASI'=‚E=<S?8FL7&52m=eZ—@I1LA79<@­Z_SJ;@|I&SAT:=<8:9e=MI^E@‹StL²hA8,?827&8FvA@ I¢@FE¢I'S?PE

I^LA7'7&@2h7&5PI&@2?PE5PIChA827ZR=9W@ I9W@:8:;@,7¤I¢@FE§9W@PIZ[=W9<=‚E&8:?\E&ICD=MI^ES7'=<aPLb@PI;A@ƒ9e8[mA8„LbTuDt@ƒ8:?PE=œZ_SJ?8,7GTuD=WaPLb@ƒaPLb=S?PE

T:S>?i?PL²9e@\ICh7&=†IGS>?AIfhASA9œ=KE'=WaPLb@ I„” { «8FEME1=‚EMLb;@[TzSJZRZ6L?A8,LE8,7=eI^E@—;@[9e«n mA9<=MI(@[9e8„E'=<?A@[8¡E17G}PIC9<8,71mA@:Z—@u?\E§5,]ASJ9KLb5

;@,h L=MI.LA?A@fE17&@,?PE82=œ?t@6;A«8:??t5:@:X>E†StLiE8FLiE8,?PEI&S LI9•8%h7(@PI(I&=<SJ?—;@69W«

n

E8FEXbaPLA=9W«8T:S>?\E17&8:=g?PE@zXJhA8,7@F£A@:ZRhJ9W@:Xb¥

StL]t7&@%hA9‚LI9e827^mA@:Z—@:?PEIG@PI5:T:SJ9•@tI8FLA£`5:9e},]>@tIZLI^Lb9eZ—8:?I@„E¥I&@T:S>?N1S7&ZR@,78FLA£[h7GS>m7&82Z¡Z—@PI§I&T:SA9<8:=œ7G@tI

S>NMN1=WTu=W@:9MI&XaPLb@|I&S LI9W8[h7&@ I¤I&=<SJ?;@PI¢N^=W;}:9W@ I@„EC;@\I@zT:T:9e5\I&=e8 I1E1=<aPL@\I=MI¤I1L™I;@ IN8uZ—=e9W9e@\I9<SAT:8:9W@tI%aPL=S>?\E

7&5:8:9<=†IG5ƒaPLb@ƒT:9e527=WT:8:9W=†I&Z—@ƒ@FE§7&@2h9œ=MITzSJZRZ_Lb?8„LE8u=Ÿ7&@ƒStv>5,7&8:=<@:?PE§9W«8,]>@u?=Ÿ7;@tI%T:8FE1DS9<=WaPLb@tI%;8,?I9e8­IGSJT:=<5„E5

~&S>7G;8u?=W@:??@i”

YfL:~&S LA7&;A«D\L=<X‹Z[´:Z—@I&=|9W«5\T:8,7^E€E@,?t; ¥·I(@ž7&5:;PLb=g7(@PX‹9<@PI–S>7ME1DSA; S £A@\IIGS>?\E€E1S L2~&StLA7(I‰9•8,7^mA@:Z—@:?PEhA9‚L™I

7&@,h7&5PIG@,?PE5\I+aPLb@9<@ I+9<8FE=<?I+@FE9<@\I+Z[@:9<³A=‚E@PI+;8:?I+9<@mS L]A@,7?@:Z—@u?\EX@µE+IS?PE@,?tT:S>7G@_I1LA7'7&@,h7&5\I&@,?\E5PIhA8,7&Z—=

9e«5:9e=‚E@C5:TzS>?tSJZR=eaPLb@C@2?hA8,7^E=<TFLb9e=W@,7;8,?AI9e@CTzSJZRZ[@27&T:@@FE;8,?AIT:@,7^E82=œ?II&@:TFE@„LA7¤I=œ?t;PLI^E17'=W@:9MI@FEl8,m7'=•T:SJ9<@PIµ”

5 B"B.5 :@?AH.7G@ B.H":#? 8:#;<;>=#?@A=AB@AH5 5'7!B 7:=#7 I"@ B=AB.5'II"5 =#? :5 ;=#7 =I.; @?A5&7G5'I@ B.H":#?7

H.? B.55'IHH5'= 7 5&7

n

?R@:NMN@FEX9<8%9W=gvb@,7^E5f7&@:9<=gmA=e@„L™IG@C@tI1EmA8,7&8,?\E1=<@%Z—8:=MI8FLI¤I&=9W=<Z[=‚E5\@C=œZRhA9e=WT:=‚E@:Z—@u?\EhA8,7.9W8CB¾S?JI1E'=KEMLE1=<S>?_aPL=<XA@P?

N'8:=MI&8:?PE;@9W«=MI&9W8uZš9W867&@:9e=<mA=<SJ?ƒ;@91j

n

E8FE@„E;PL‹ZRS>?t8,7(aPLb@:X=<?AI^E8FLA7&@¢;PL|ZR´:Z—@RT:S LAh‹T:S>ZRZ—@S7&; 7&@6h LvA9W=WT

;@º9<8ƒTzSJ@F£A=MI1E@u?tT:@ƒ=œ?\E@,7'7&@:9<=<mJ=W@FLI&@¡Lb?€S7&; 7&@[Z6LI1L9WZ—8u?b” /_8:?JITz@ƒTP8z; 7&@:XS>?|hA@„LE§8,71m LAZR@:?PE@,7aPLb@:X.hA8,7

@F£A@:ZRhJ9W@:X™9W8h7&5:;=WT:8FE1=<S?ˆTuDi7&5FE1=<@:??A@R8FLAh7&}\I§;@PIfZLI^Lb9<Z[8:?I§@PI1E+@2?‹T:S>?\E17&8:;=<TFE=<S?‹8z]>@:T¡9W8RB+S>?I1E'=KEML E1=<SJ?

h L=eIGaPL@[91jWS>7G; 7&@[=eI&9W8:Z[=WaPLb@[?je8z;>Z—@FE+hA8\IC9W8ƒT:S>? ]>@,7¤I&=<SA?|;@ ICZLI^Lb9eZ—8:?I…8FLT:D 7&=MI^E=<8:?=MI&Z[@i”™B+@,hA@:?;8:?\EX

9e@ I_T,DSI&@PIR?t@˜I&S?PEhA8\I[I&=7&=<mJ=W;@PIµ” n ?²@uNMN@FEX9<8|B+S?JI1E'=‚EMLE1=•S>?²8FLI„I&=vA=e@:?²aPLb@9W@|; 7GS>=‚E=MI&9W8:Z[=WaPLb@|N1S>?\E

9^jWS>v2~(@FE®;je=<?PE@,7h7&5FE8¤E1=<S>?AI„”

n

?ˆStLiE17&@:XT:@[I&S?PE9<@ IE17'=gvLA?8FLA£€T:=g]A=e9MI…aPL=I&S?PE§I^LI(T:@2h E'=gvA9W@PI§;A«´FE17&@[IG8u=WI&=†I…@P?

T:8PI…;@[hJ9W8:=<?PE@[TzS>?tTP@27'?8:?PE¾;@PICh7&5:;=<T\8FE1=<S?I…TuDi7&5FE=<@:??@ I„”VC7C9W8f~'LI^E=<T:@ƒT:=g]=W9e@zX.@u?ˆ¦„S7&;8,?=<@:X.8ƒ;A«8FLE17&@PI

I&S LA7&T:@PI;jW=œ?IhJ=<7&8„E'=<S?RaPLb@C9W86T:D827=W8 ”iV6?RTzS>??t8u=KE.8:=<?I&=;@PIT:8\I;@CTzS>? ]>@,7¤I&=<SJ?—8FL`T:D 7&=MI^E=<8:?=MI&Z—@6aPLb=IGS>?\E

E1S9<5,7&5PIlh8,79<@ I=<?I^E=‚EMLE1=<S?JI+I&8:?I.hAS LA7†E82?PEl´FEM7G@CS>NMN1=WTu=Ž8:9œ=MI(5PIlhA8,79W«=<?I(T,7&=gh E=<S?ºI1LA79•@tIl7&@,mA=†I1E17&@PI;A«n E8¤ElT,=g]A=e91”

Q.827T:S>?\EM7&@zXS>??t@CT:S??8:=‚EhA8 I;J«@,£A@:ZRhA9e@C;A«=<?A;=g]=W;PLI8:T:TFLI(5\I;J«8,hASI^E8\I&=<@C;@,]b8u?\E9<@ I™E17'=gv Lb?8FLA£”'/_@%N8:=‚E

(6)

T:S>ZRZLb?8FLE537&@:9œ=<mA=W@FLI&@›;J«S7=ŸmJ=<?A@ ”RB+@:T:=‹@ I^E|]t7&8:=‹;8,?I9W@PI²;@FLA£¸I(@:?JIGXƒ8:9<S>7(IZ—´uZ—@›aPLb@ž9e@›; 7&S=‚E

Z_LI1L9WZ—8u?¼;A@ž9e83hA@,7¤IGS>??t@ž@ I^E@2?·hASI&=‚E=<S>?¼;SJZR=<?A8:?PE@hA827Œ7&8,hhAS7ME€8FL ; 7'S=‚ET,Di7&5FE=<@:?@„EaPLb@ž9W8

T:S>?\]A@,7(I&=<SJ?;A«L?T:D 7G5FE'=•@u?²¥­9W«=MI&9e8:Z @PI1E9e52mA8u9W@ ” { @PI¢7&8,7&@\ITz8tI¢T:S??PLI[IGS>?\E9<@­N8:=‚E;A«=<?A;=•]b=W;PLIRaPLb=+?A@

hA@FL]A@:?PEN8:=g7&@C;=†I„IGStLb; 7G@f9<@FLA7¤IZ—8,7&=<8,mb@PI;8:?JI9W@FLA7¤I

n

m9<=MI(@PI;A«S>7'=ŸmJ=<?A@ ”

/R@FL£²8FLE17G@PIChAS=œ?\E&I;@ƒT:S?PE@,?\E'=•@FLJ£²8FLbaPLb@:99W@ IT:D 7(5FE1=•@u?I¢I(@[7&5:N1},7&@:?PEI&S L]A@:?\ECTzS>ZRZ—@­9W@PIZ—@FEME8,?PE…@,?

I&=‚EMLb8FE1=<S?;je=<?N5,7&=<S>7&=‚E5Œ~'LA7&=<;=WaPLb@·I&S?PE9Mje=<?A5,mb8:9œ=KE5·@,?\E17&@žT2D 7&5FE=<@:?JI°@FEZ6LI^Lb9eZ—8:?JI²;J8:?AI9W@ŠT:8PI²;@tI

Z[827=W8,mA@\I=<?\E@,7'7&@:9<=<mJ=W@FLA£AXA8:=œ?I&=AaPLb@C9W@PI;=MI'hASI&=‚E'=•S>?I9W5,mA8:9<@ IT:S?T:@27?t8:?PE91jeD5,7&=‚E82mA@C;@PIN1@uZ—Z—@tIµ”

B¾SZRZ—@­9W@ƒ; 7&S>=KEC;@ƒ9W8ºN8:Z[=W9e9W@ºZLI1L9WZ[8:?@PI1E6I1E8FEML E82=g7&@:Z—@u?\E…@,?|hASI&=‚E'=•SJ?€;@ƒ;SJZR=<?A8FE=<S>?ˆhA8,7C7&8,hhAS7^E

8FL£—; 7&S=‚E&I;@C9<8fN8uZ—=e9W9e@§;J@\IT:SJZRZ6Lb?A8FLE5PIlT:D 7&5FE=<@:??@zX>9W@ I.;=MI&hAS)I&=KE'=<S?JI ;@f9e8CT:Dt8,7&=e8f91jM@:ZRhAS7^E@,?PE@,?Tz8tI

;@¡TzS>?\E17&8:; =<TFE=<S?”bB%jW@ I^E+9•@¡Tz8tI+hAS LA7+9<@ IfZ—8,7&=<82m@PI§=<?>E@27^7&@29œ=<mA=W@FLJ£2>L?t@¡N@:Z[Z—@RTuDi7&5FE=<@:??@hA@FLE®5,hAS LI&@,7

LA?"DSJZRZ—@ŒZ6LI^Lb9<Z[8:?–8FL"E17'=gviL?A8:9C=MI&9W8uZ—=WaPL@:XCZR8:=^IRLA?"DtSJZRZ[@T:D 7&5FE1=•@u?–?@˜hA@„LERhA8PI&X6I&=<?tS>?–@,?žIG@

T:S>?\]A@,71E'=eI„IG8:?PEX5,hAS LI&@27ºLA?t@‰N1@:Z[Z—@"Z_LI1L9WZ—8u?t@ ”/R@-Z[´:Z—@:X9<S7¤I&aPLb@-9e@-; 7&SJ=KE‹T:8,?tS>?’@PI^E‹ZLb@FE|I1LA7

T:@,7^E8,=<?AI§TuDt8,hA=‚E17&@PIGX9W8[I&DA8,7&=<8[I2je8,hhA9e=WaPLb@hA8,7+;5:N8FLE(”:Y=œ?I&=WX9e@R; 7&S=‚ET:8:?tS>?ƒh7&5zTu=MIG8u?\EaPLb@T\«@PI1E9W89<SJ=; L

hA8z‡bIaPLb=¾I(«8,hhA9e=WaPLb@,7@:?€Z—8FE'=•},7&@ƒ;A«DA5,7&=‚E8,mA@ƒS L²;@­I^LbT:Tz@PI„I&=<SJ?tXT\«@PI^E…;S?PE§9<8‹T:D8,7&=W8ƒaPL=@PI1EC82hhJ9<=WaPLb5\@

8FL£—T:D 7&5„E1=e@:?AI;8:?JIT:@C;SAZR8:=œ?A@i”

n

E9MjWS>?—I&8:=‚ElaPLb@%9•@tIlN'=<9e9W@ I.?A«DA5,7&=‚E@2?PElaPLb@C;«LA?A@C;@uZR=WU^hA8,71E(”

H 9ƒN8FLEIG8F]ASA=g7T:@2hA@u?t;J8:?\EaPLje=<9º‡ 8ž;@PIZ—8:?=W},7&@ Iƒ~^LA7&=W;=eaPLb@:Z—@:?PE@„EI&SAT,=<8:9W@:Z[@:?\E8:T:T:@2h E8FvA9W@tI²;A@

T:S>?\E1S LA7'?@27‹T:@PI‹;=eNMN'=WTFLb9‚E5 I!2f9W@PIˆ8FLES 7'=KE5PIƒ7&@:TzS>??t8u=1I¤IG@u?\Eƒ9<@ I‹Z—8,7&=W8,mA@PIˆT:=•]b=e9MI‹TzS>?\E17&8:TFE5PIº¥°9W«5„E17&8,? mA@27

aPLb@u9<9W@aPLb@aPLbSA=™I&SJ=KE9<87&@:9e=<mJ=•SJ?ƒ;@PI®5,hAS L£AXJE8,?;=MI+9M@%E@\I^E8,ZR@:?\EhA@,7'ZR@FE;«SATFE17St‡t@,7Lb?@hA8,7^E5,mA8:9<@¥RI(8

;@PI&T:@:?t;8u?tT\@%N15:Z[=<?A=<?A@ ”

H ?JI&=MI^ES?JI`=<T:=I^LA7¡Lb?-hAS>=<?PE 2+9<8°IGSJT:=<5FE5@PI^E_h9‚LIƒTzS>?AI(@,7^]A8„E17=•T:@ŒaPLb@Œ9W@Œ; 7GS>=‚EX¾‡–TzSJZh7&=MIƒaPLb@Œ9<@; 7&S=‚E

=†I&9W8:Z[=WaPLb@ ” n ?—@:NMN'@„EXJ9<@ IZ—8,7&=<8,mA@ I=œ?\E@,7'7&@:9<=<mJ=W@FLA£‹I&S? EZ[8:9J]iL™I;@ChA8,7^El@¤E;jW8FLEM7&@zX@FEl@,?—StLiEM7&@C9<8ChJ9gLAhA8,7^E

;@PIfN18:Z—=e9e9W@ I&XT,D 7G5FE'=•@u??t@ I§T:SJZRZ—@¡ZLI^Lb9eZ—8:?@ I&X;5PI'DA527=KE@,?PE+=<?\E5,m7&8:9<@:Z—@u?\E+9<@FLA7(IfN'=<9W9e@ Iµ”B+8,7§;@¡N8:=‚EX™@FE

~¤@[]A8:=MIC‡|7G@z]>@:?=œ71XT:«@ I^E+LA?€S7&;P7G@[hA8µE17'=•8,7&T:8:9<X@FE§?S?€T:S? N@PI„I&=<S??A@:9<XaPLb=S7^mA8,?=MIG@ƒ;@tI…hA8,?I@:?PE1=W@,7¤I%;@tI

7&@:9<8FE=<S>?AII&SAT:=<8:9W@tI @u?\E17&@CT,Di7&5FE1=<@:?JI @FEZ6L™I1L9<Z—8:?I„”

5 C&75!? B@ B.H:#?*@I"5!;5&? B@AHG55 B H? B.C G@ B.H:#? @A=H?#7 B.H)B=AB.H:#?7 A5I 3B@ B

{ «S7^mA8,?=MIG8FE'=•S>? ;@\I¹T:SJZRZL?t8FLE5PI¹TzS>?N1@ I¤I&=•SJ??@:9e9Ž@PI¹T:D 7G5FE1=<@:??A@PI¹@PI1E’;«=<?I'hA=<7&8FE=<S>? SPEeE1SZR8:?A@ ” n ?

Z[8„E'=<}27&@;@67&@2h7&5PI&@:?\E8FE1=<S?[hAS9œ=KE'=WaPLb@:XT jW@ I^E9<@; 7GS>=‚E;@\I+Z¡=<?tS>7&=‚E5PI+=MI„I1Lˆ;@_91jW@,£hA5,7&=W@:?T:@@„LA7&S>hA5z@,??@aPL)=

8·I&@,7^]A=ˆ;@ŠZRSJ;}:9W@Š=œ?A=‚E=W8u9‹@„EaPLb=ƒmA8,7&8:?\E'=‚E²8FL£ T,D 7&5„E'=<@:?AIŒL?t@ž7&@,h7&5\I&@:?PE8FE1=•S>?h7GS>hAS 7ME1=<S??@:9e9W@Š8,L

Q.8279•@uZ—@:?PEl@¤ELA?@f=<?PE5,m7G8FE1=<S?R8FLA£[=<?I1E1=‚EMLE1=<S?JI;@C9W«

n

E8µEG”

/R@[ZR8:?=W},7&@—T:S?JI^E82?PE@[;@2h L=eI…9e8—T,7&5:8„E'=<S?ˆ;PL€h7&@:ZR=M@,7…T:S>?AI&@:=<9T:S?JI^Lb9‚E8FE=<Nhb8,7C9W«5:Z—=g7^YCvA;8:9e9W8:D H @,7C@,?

w iX%E1S LI|9W@PIˆmAStL]>@,7&?@:Z—@u?\E&I€T:SZh E@,?\Eˆ8FL¼ZRSJ=<?JI‹L?ŠZ—=œ?A=MI^E17&@–T,D 7&5„E'=<@:?tX¡9<@‰hA9gL™II&S L]A@:?PEˆ;@„L£AX

T,D8,71mA5 IC;@RhAS>7ME@,N1@FLb=e9W9W@PIC=eZRhAS7†E82?PE&I…;8,?JI…;@ I6IG@:TFE@,LA7¤II&5:TFLb9W8,7&=MI&5PI 29W8f~'LI^E=<T:@[T:=g]b=e9W@:X.9e«=<?A;PL™I1E17'=<@[@„Ef9•@

T:S>ZRZ—@,7&Tz@:X9e@ I8:N^N8:=g7(@PI+5„E17&8,? mA}27&@PI&X9W@PI+N1=<?A8u?ATz@PI&X9W@ IE17&8F]>8FL£ƒh LAvA9e=WTPIGX@FET ” { @tIT:D 7G5FE'=•@u?I+IGS>?\E™E17&}PI.vA=W@P?

7&@,h7&5PIG@,?PE5\I+¥6EStLI9W@PI§5:T:D@:9<SJ?AI§;PL€I(@:TFE@FLA7h LvA9e=WT2J9W8;=œhA9<SJZ—8FE=<@:X9W@tI+N=œ?A8:?tT:@ Ih LAvA9e=WaPLb@PI&X@FEZ—´:Z[@9Ž@

T:S>ZRZ—8:?;@:Z—@:?PE…;@º9W«8,7&Z[5z@ ”.B+@,7^E8:=<?@PICE17&}\ICDA8FLE@PIN1S?TFE=<S?I8:;Z[=<?J=MI1E17&8FE1=g]A@PI¢S LZR=e9W=‚E8:=<7&@PI9W@FLA7IGS>?\E

T:@,hA@:?;8:?PE¢;@2Z[@„LA7&5:@PI_;>=WNMN'=WTu=W9W@uZ—@:?PE¢8zT:T:@PI„I&=gvA9W@ I32¥ºLA?t@|@,£AT:@2h E'=<S?Œh7G}PI&X+8FLbTFLb?ŒmAS L]A@27'?A@FLA7RT:=g]A=e9§;A@

h7&St]A=<?tT:@CT:D 7&5FE=<@:?R?A«8 ~(8:Z—8u=MI5FE5f?tSJZRZ[5zXJ¥¾Lb?@C@,£AT\@,h E1=•S>?h7G}PI5,mb8:9e@:Z—@:?PEXA8FLbTFLA?RT:Di7&5FE1=W@:?¡?A«8C;5,hA8 I(I(5

9e@fm7G8:;@C;@%9<=W@FLE@,?t8:?PEmA5,?527&8:9A;8u?I9W«8,7&Z—5:@ ”

y

8:=MICT:@„EME@­¯&; =MI&T,7&=<Z[=<?A8FE=<S?¯C?A«8RhA8PIf]A=MI(5¡hA8\II'hA5:T:=WN'=WaPLb@uZ—@:?PE®9e@\ICT:D 7G5FE'=•@u?AI„”

n

?|@:N1N'@„EXvA=<@:?|aPL)«@u9W9W@[?A@

I&S=‚EhA8PIh7&5F] L)@fhA8,7;@ I™E@F£iE@PISJNMN=eT:=W@:9MI&X L?t@%7&52hA8,7^E1=‚E1=<SA?R;@ IT2DA8,7^mA@\I;J8:?AI9W86Dt8FLE@C8:;Z[=<?=MI^E17&8„E1=<S>?—@FEl9W@

T:S>7hI—;@PI—SJNMN1=eT:=W@,7„I—@ I^E—I'‡I1E5uZ_8FE'=•aPLb@Œ@:?°]iLb@Œ;@TPS?JIG@,7^]>@,7¡Lb?-5:aPLb=e9e=gvA7&@€@:?PE17G@m7GStLAhA@PIƒIGSJT:=<8„LJ£»StL

hAS>9<=‚E=WaPLb@PI&XJZ—@:Zv7(@PI;@ I;=eNMN5,7&@:?\E@PI.m7&8:?;@\IN18:Z[=W9e9M@\IStL`;@PIE17'=gv LI v>5:;S L=<?@\I&XJDtSJZRZ[@\I;PL‹I1Lb;¡S L`;PL

?S7&;3;PLžhA8„‡I&XC‘7&8,?AI<~&S>7G;8u?=W@:?I‹@FERQl8,9<@ I1E1=œ?=W@:?I‹9<S>‡>8FLJ£8FL3E17'½?@:XT,Di7&5FE=<@:?JI‹@FE`B+8FLbT:8\I&=e@:?IGX6T,DA8zaPLb@

m7&StLAhA@fN1=<?J=MI„IG8u?\E.hA8,7+I&@I'hA5zTu=•8u9W=MI&@,7;8:?JI.L?t@%?=WT:DA@2 9W@ IB+8FLbTz8PI&=W@u?I;8:?JI9W«8,7&Z—5:@:X9<@PIT:D 7G5FE'=•@u?AI;8u?I9W8

;>=ghA9<SJZ—8FE=<@@„E9<8N'=<?A8u?tT:@:X@FET ”

n

?`StLiEM7&@:X9<8h7&5:N15,7&@:?AT:@;PL‹7&52m=œZ—@D8\T:D5:Z—=‚E@aPLb8,?\E¥_9•8_?tSJZR=<?A8FE1=<S?ƒ;A@

‘7&8,?AI<~&S7&;8:?=e@:?AIƒ@FE_?S?";@|Q.8:9<@\I^E=œ?=W@:?I`@u?-hASI'=‚E=WS>?–;«8FLES 7'=‚E58E1S L2~&S LA7¤IE17&8,?AI&T:@:?t;5Œ9e@\Iƒ;=g]A=†I(=<SJ?I

(7)

5FE17'S=‚E@PI°8F]A@\TŠ9^jW@ I^E8FvA9<=MI&DAZ[@:?\EZ6LI1L9WZ[8:?tX­aPLb=‹S>? E€v>5,?5:N'=WT:=W8u=W@:?PEhA9‚LI-aPLb@Š9W@tI°8FLE17&@PI-;@\IhAS)I1E@PI

8FEeE17'=gviLb5PI8FLA£—T:D 7&5„E1=<@:?I;8,?I9<8CD8FLE@fN1S?ATFE1=<S?h LAvA9e=MaPLb@zX>9<@CTzS>7'hI ;@PISNMN^=WT:=W@,7¤I@FE9<@fmAS L]A@27?t@:Z[@:?\E(”

Y ;5:T:S L9<5;@T\@PI[h7G8FE'=•aPLb@tIRLb?@;=†IGT,7&=eZR=<?A8FE=<S>?3hASI'=‚E=g]A@aPLb=8ŒhA@,7&ZR=†Iº8FLJ£TuDi7&5FE1=W@:?JI‹@:?E8,?PE¡aPLb@

m7&StLAhA@¡LA?8:T:T:} ICh7&=g]A=e9W5,mA=W5­8FLA£€7&@\I„I&S LA7&T:@PI;@ƒ9W«

n

E18FE(”b‘S LIC?A«S>?\EfhAS L7ME8,?\EfhA8\I5FE5ƒ5,mA8:9W@:Z[@:?\E6IG@,7^]A=MI2”

B¾@„LJ£šaPLb=‹S?PE€E1=g7&5Š8,]A8:?\E8,mA@PI-@FEh7&@\I^E1=gmA@Š;@Š9W«

n

E8µES?PE²;5,N1@:?t;PL 9W8 Z_S>?A8,7GT,D=W@·@FE-IGS>?¸I1EM‡9W@Š;A@

mAStL]>@,7'?@:Z—@:?PE(” { @PI8FLE17G@PII(@­I&S?PE…8FEWE8:aPLb5PI¥ƒ9W«@:?I(@:ZvA9e@ƒ;PL²h7&S„~&@FE§hASJ9<=‚E=<aPLb@­@„E6IGSJT:=<8:9Dt8:T:DA5:Z¡=KE@­@FE

?S?·hA8PI-I&=eZRhA9W@uZ—@:?PE˜¥9<@FLA7h7&Sh7&@žI^E8¤EML ET:S>Z¢Z_Lb?8„LE8u=Ÿ7&@:XƒaPLb«=W9MIS?PET2S?JI&=W;5,7&5›T:S>ZRZ—@»Lb?¼;@PI

Z_Lb9‚E=<hJ9W@PI¢5:T,7G8u?AI¢;@,7'7&=<},7&@‹9e@\I&aPL)@u9MIRI&@[E8,hA=eI„I&8:=‚E9•@|T:9œ=W@:?PE5:9<=MI&Z—@­@FE9•@ºhA8FE@27'?8:9<=MI¤Z—@‹T:SJZRZ—@­ZRSA;@PI¢;@

;S>ZR=<?A8FE=<S>?b”

n ?RS LEM7G@:XJ;@\II&=W},mA@ I¾IGS>?\E7&5PI&@27^]A5 I8FLA£`T:D 7&5FE1=W@:?JI ;J8:?JI9W@PITu=Ÿ7¤TzS>?AI&T,7&=<h E'=•S>?AI5:9W@:TFES 7G8u9•@PIS10`9<@FLA7?SJZv7G@

@PI^E‹I&=gmA?=eN'=WT:8„E'=<N&”*/R@,h Lb=MIƒL?t@‰aPLb=<?±\8:=œ?A@;A«8:??A5:@PI&X9e@ I‹T:D=WNMN^7&@ I|I1LA7­9W8-T:SJZhASI&=‚E=<S?"7&@:9e=<mA=e@„LI&@-;@°9Ž8

hAS>h LA9<8„E'=<S?XŒZ—@PI1LA7&5:@ hA8,737&@:T:@:?JI(@:Z—@:?PE&IGX˜?@ I&S? E"h9KL™I3h LAvA9e=W5PIµ”ºY9<S7¤I›aPLb@ ;J«8FLE17&@PI›=<?;=WT:8FE@FLA7¤I

hA@,7&ZR@FEME@,?\E+;@ƒI&8F]>SJ=g7CaPLb@R9W8¡h7&ShS 7ME1=<S?|;@PI…T:D 7&5„E'=<@:?AIC;8:?IC9<8RhAS>h Lb9<8FE=<S?ºv>8:=†I„IG@:X.9e@R?SJZvt7&@[;@[9<@„LA7FI

7&@,h7&5PIG@,?PE82?PE&I8FLRQl8,7&9W@:Z[@:?\E.@\I^ElT,S?JI1E8,?PE(”iVC?R8PI¤I&=MI1E@6¥¾LA?hAD5:?tSJZR}:?A@6I&=eZ—=e9W8:=g7(@fhAStLA7.9<@ IB+8FLbT\8PI&=W@:?I@FE

9e@ IvA5:;S L=<?Iµ” /_@­N18:=‚EX+T:@PI—I&=W},m@\I7&5PIG@,7']A5PI—I&S?PEC]LI¢hA8,79W@­hAS L]AS=g7RT:SZRZ[@ˆ;@tI¢7&@:ZhA8,7^E&I¢N'8zT:@|¥|9W8

ZRSJ?PE5z@6;@PIhA8,71E1=†IaPLb=™I&@C7&5:T:9W8:Z—@u?\E;@69W«=†I(9W8:ZhASJ9<=‚E=eaPLb@i”B+@FEeE@I^EŽ7&8µE52m=e@?A«@\I^E@:NMN'=WT:8zT:@6aPL)«@:?¡hb8,7^E1=•@:X@P?

@uNMN@FEX9W«5u9W@\TFES 7&8¤E?«@PI^EhA8\IRT:8,h E=<N29W@ŒI'‡I1E}:ZR@|?A«S vA9e=<mA@­hA8 IR9W@PI—5:9W@:TFE@FLA7(IRT:D 7&5„E1=<@:?IR¥­]AS E@,7htStLA76LA?

T:8,?;=W;8FET,Di7&5FE=<@:?”#/R@\I+5FEMLb;@PI®;@¡I&SAT:=<SJ9<SmA=<@R5u9W@:T„ES 7&8:9<@ZRSJ?PE17G@,?PEaPLb«LA?ƒ?SAZ_vt7&@=eZRhAS7†E8,?\E;«5u9•@:TFE@FLA7¤I

T,D 7&5„E'=<@:?AI‰]AS E@,?\EŒhtStLA7–;@PI–T:8,?t;>=•;8FE&I"Z6LI1L9WZ—8u?I2”

n

?š@,NMN@FEX|;@PI–T:82?;=<;8FE&I–T,D 7G5FE'=•@u?I–;@PI-hA8,71E1=†I

ShhASI'=‚E=<S?[8„L[7G5,mJ=<Z—@I&S?PEI^LIGTP@2h E1=•vA9W@ I;@6?t5,mASATu=W@,7;@\I8:9e9e=W8:?Tz@tI 5u9W@\TFE†S>7&829<@ IStL`;@PIl7&@,hAS7^E&I;@¾]ASA=•£

8F]A@\TC9<@ I=WI&9e8:Z—=†I1E@PI@FE]A=MI&@¾]b@27¤I&8 ”

,>'G $'* *"'('*$'- ',G"&" "G$' !*& ' ! #'#! '

{ jn

E8¤E_8,m=‚ECE17&}PIƒI1EM7'=•TFE@:Z[@:?\E[I1LA7¡9•8˜N1S?TFE=<S?-;@˜91je@ IhA8:T:@€T:SJZRZL?t8FLE8:=g7&@€8:N^=<?–aPLje=e9.~GStLb@€9e@|7&½9<@€;A@

E8,ZhAS?‹@u?\E17&@R;>=<N1N'527&@:?PE&ICI&@2mJZ—@:?PE&I+hAS E@,?PE1=•@u9W9W@uZ—@:?PE®T:S?N^9W=WTFEMLb@:9eIC;@R9W8ºI&SAT:=<5FE5 ”

o

@FL9•@¡9W«@,£h7G@tI(I&=<SJ?‹?SJ?

hAS>9<=‚E=WaPLb@¡;@\If=<;A@:?PE1=‚E5\I+7&@:9œ=<mA=W@FL™IG@PI§@ I^E®8FL E†S>7=‚E5 ” H ?JI1E1=e9W9e5z@¡;8:?AIf9W@[I'‡I1E}uZ—@R5:;PLbT:8„E'=<N1X™;82?If9W87'D5„ES>7'=•aPLb@

;PL‹hAStL]>S>=g7®@FE;@PI+529œ=KE@tI+9W8,WaPL)@PI+@„E7&@,9<=<mJ=W@FLI&@PIGXJL?t@_7G@,h7&5PIG@,?PE8FE1=•S>?`;@_9W867G@u9W8FE1=•S>?|IGSJT:=<8:9W@@PI1E;@_ZR=MI&@ 2

T:«@tI1E9<8­N8:Z[=e9W9W@:XhA@FE=‚E@‹StL²m7&8,?;@zXaPL=®@PI^E9<@‹7&5:T:@:h E8:T,9•@|;@PI]A8:9W@FLA7¤IGX9e8ƒmA8,7&8:?\E@­;@­9W«S7&; 7&@|I&SATu=•8u9§@FE

hAS>9<=‚E=WaPLb@ ”YfL-hASJ=<?PE¢aPLb@|9<8|?8„E'=<S?@\I^EC] Lb@ˆT:SJZRZ—@ˆLA?²@:?JI&@:Zvb9e@ˆ;@N8:Z[=W9e9W@PI6Lb?=W@ IR@FE¢5:aPLA=g]>8u9W@:?PE@\I„”

/R8,?IT:@„EME@…]A=MI&=<SJ?tX=œ9@PI1E9<5,mA=‚E=eZ—@6aPLb@;A@PIm7&StLAhA@\I+;@6N18:Z[=W9e9W@PIhA8,7^E8,mA@:82?PE™LA?t@%hb8,7^E1=•TFL9W8,7&=‚E5=e;@:?\E'=‚E8:=g7G@

h7&S>hi7&@ TFLA9‚EMLA7&@:9<9W@:X 7&@:9<=œmA=W@FLI&@:Xª@FE1Di?=WaPL@ ”<”<”“ @F£th7&=œZ—@:?PE 9e@„LA7 hA8,7^E1=•TFL9W8,7&=MI&Z—@ ;A8:?JI 9W@ T\8:; 7G@

T:S>ZRZLb?8FLE8:=g7&@›StL 8PI¤IGSJT,=W8FE1=<N8FLI„I&=ƒ9<SA? m E@:ZhIaPLb«@:9e9W@ IŒ?t@h7&5„E@,?;@:?PEhA8PI´„E17&@Dt5,mA5:ZRS>?=WaPLb@›@FE

hAS>9<=‚E=MI&5:@ ”iB+@:T:=@\I^E]7&8:=<XA8F]b@:TC;@\I™]b8,7&=<8:?PE@PIGX>hAS LA7™9•@tIZ6LI^Lb9eZ—8:?JI T:SJZRZ—@fhAStLA7.9<@\IT:D 7&5FE1=W@:?JI µ”

Q.8\I¤I&8:?\E;@PI?=•]b@z8FLJ£—h7&=g]b5PI+@„ET:SZRZ_Lb?8„LE8u=Ÿ7&@PI+8„L‹?=•]b@z8FLƒhASJ9<=‚E=WaPLb@:X9W@%7&52mJ=WZ[@ChAS LI¤I&@¥T:@aPLb@69W@~(@FL

hAS>9<=‚E=WaPLb@ºI(«S>71mA8,?=MI(@[?S?‹hA8tI…@:?|N1SJ?tTFE'=•S>?ˆ;J«Lb?@RhASJ9<=‚E'=WaPLb@—;@tI§hA8,7^E1=MI…@FE§;@PI…=e;5zSJ9<SmJ=<@ I…T:S?PE@PI1E8µE8,=Ÿ7&@ I&X

I&S=e@:?\EU'@,9<9W@tI‹I&SAT:=<8:9e=MI^E@\IƒS L›=eI&9W8uZ—=MI^E@PIGX%Z—8:=MIƒ@:?"N1SJ?tTFE=<S>?–;@ Iƒ8:NMN'=W9e=W=<SJ?JI`9e=<mJ?t8,mA},7&@\Iƒ;=‚E@ Iƒ9<SAT:8:9W@uZ—@:?PE

FE17&=gvA8:9W@PI”AB+@PI§8:NMN'=e9W=W8FE'=•S>?AI+T:S?I^E=‚EMLb@,?\E@,?ƒ¦„S7&;8,?=W@9W8¢v>8 I&@;@RT:SJZRZLb?8FLE5PIE17&}PI®8,?T:=W@:??@ I„”ABf«@ I^E.LA?

5u9•5uZ—@:?PE°;5FE@,7'ZR=<?A8:?PE°;8,?JI–9<@ II1E17&8¤E5,mJ=•@PI"Z—8FE17'=<Z`S>?=<8:9W@ I–@FE-aPLA=ˆS>71mA8,?=eI(@¹@,?AT:S7&@¹8FL2~&S LA7&;«D\L=ˆ;A@

?SJZv7G@FLJ£ˆ@ IhA8:T:@ I§;J«=<?PE@,7&8zTFE'=•S>?‹;8:?I§9e@R;SJZ_8u=<?A@Rh LvA9e=WT 2)9W@PI+7G5tIGSJ9‚LE1=<S?I§;@[TzS>?N19e=‚E&I…@:?PE17&@R=<?;=•]A=W;PL.I

@FEN18:Z[=e9W9W@PICI&@:9<SJ?ƒ9W@; 7GSJ=‚ET:S L EMLAZR=W@,71X9•@:aPL@:9.I^LAvI&=MI1E&@@:?tT:S>7G@8FLz~&StLA7G;«D\L=;A8:?JILb?@7&@:9W8FE1=g]A@R8FLES?SZR=W@

@FE.?t@6T:SAZh7&@:?;ƒ8FLbT„L?t@6;=eZ—@:?I&=<SJ?—T:S?N'@\I„I&=<SJ??@:9W9e@\X9<@PIh7&SAT:@PI¤I1LIhAS9<=‚E'=WaPLb@ I9•SJT:8„LJ£>X)Z—8:=MI+5,mA8:9W@:Z—@u?\E

T:@,7^E8,=<?t@tI¢9<SmJ=<aPLb@ I¢;@ƒhA8,7^E@,?t8,7&=<8FE5zT:S>?tS>ZR=<aPL)@PIµ”

o

8,?I7&@,?PE17G@,7;82?JI9•@­;5FE8:=<9<X;=MI&S?I¢aPLb@­;@,h Lb=MICLA?A@

w "!#$%&(')!*)!+ , --./01 232-! 45!6.7')!89 "!$2 )-."2;:<="2;>?2>@# ?2A%

4>B) $$!)B)!+!C>@7C&>@!D%E"2F(!$2G2>@H)A:?I.<JK -%$!!$2# "!C>)"H)>E 4>E- !+71!+$%.!-%!E.&>LMKN4OPQ#R9QPST3M#TUH)AV< W$!?.

A!')/49 4!!$2+ !C>@H%<.>E2X 89!$2XYB@>)I- 4>Z2A.@1!$2 [B@!#!C>)\/3*)#>$! "!#]*)!$2 4?0^%*)32XI+ A 4-`_)!a

(8)

I'hDA},7&@ChAS9œ=KE'=WaPLb@@FET:@@PI„IG@u?\E'=•@u9W9W@uZ—@:?PE ;8,?I;@FLA£[vLE&I!2;«LA?@Chb8,7^E.htStLA7T,7&5z@,7 LA?t@6=<;@:?PE=‚E5Ch7&Sh 7&@,Z—@:?PE

~&S>7G;8u?=W@:??@hA8,7§ShhAS)I&=KE1=<S>?ˆ¥6L?t@¡=W;@:?PE=‚E5hA8:9e@\I^E=œ?=Ž@,??@zX™@FE®;«8FLE17G@_hA827†EhS LA7§8,NMN'8:=gvb9e=g7§9e@—;>=MIGT:StLA7(I§;@

9e«=MI&9W8:Z·hASA9œ=KE'=<aPLb@i”

V%7…T:@,7^E8,=<?AIT:D 7&5FE1=W@:?JI¢I&S?PE§8FLI(I&=¾I1LI&T\@,h E1=gvA9W@ ICaPLb@ƒT:@27^E8,=<?JIZLI^Lb9eZ—8:?JI;A«´FE17&@R7&5:T:@,h E1=<N&IC¥ƒTz@[;=†I(TzStLA7¤I

=W;@:?PE=œN1=WT\8FE'=•S>?€E17'=gvb8u9W@|Tz8,7R=e9MIRhA8,7^E8,mA@2?PE¢8F]b@:T|9W@ IRZLI^Lb9eZ—8:?IR9e@ IRZ—´:Z—@tI—I^E17^LbT„EMLA7&@PI[IGSJT2=<8:9e@ I_@FEX+@u?

m7&8,?;@hA8,7^E=<@:X9W@PI+Z—´:Z—@ I]A8:9W@FLA7¤ICI&SAT:=<8:9W@tI®T:8,7&8zTFE5,7'=MI^E=<aPLb@ I+;@ I§I&SATu=•5FE5PIE17G8:;>=KE'=<S??@:9<9W@ I 2>hb8FE17'=•8,7&T:8:9W@ I&X

N1S>7^E@2ZR@:?PE+LA?=W@PI&XS109<8­IGSJ9<=W;8,7&=‚E5ƒ@:?PE17&@[=<?;=g]=W;PLI@,E§N18:ZR=e9e9W@ I@PI1E+vIFE1=W@­I^LA79<8[vA8PIG@ƒ;@º9W8[hA8,7G@u?\E5 ”YfL

?=•]b@z8FL ;@ I9<SAT:8:9e=‚E5PIGX[9W8»hAS9<=‚E=eaPLb@3ZL?=WT:=<hA8u9W@žI(«@ I1E€;«8:=<9e9W@FLA7¤I|ES L2~&S LA7¤I@F£A@27&T:5:@ŠI^LA7Œ9•@ZRSA;@3;@tI

8u9<9W=e8:?tT:@ I+@:?PE17&@N'8:ZR=e9W9e@ I®@FE9<=<mA?8,mA@PIGX8u?tT,7&5 I+;8:?AI+9e@,LA7¤I7&@:9<8FE=<S?JI+;@6]>SJ=MI&=œ?A82mA@:X;@6hA8,7^E@,?t8,7&=<8FE8,m7&=<TzSJ9W@

@FERh9‚LIƒ8\T:=W@:??@:Z—@u?\E—;8,?I`;J@˜]>@:=e9e9W@PIº8u9W9e=W8:?T:@ I`;5:N'@:?JI&=g]b@ I`@FE—SNMN'@:?I&=g]b@PI[E17&82?JI&TzS>?N@PI„I&=<SJ??t@:9e9W@PI„” { 8

hAS>9<=‚E=WaPLb@ƒ;PL9e=<mA?8,mA@~&StLb=‚E…8:=<?I&=+;J«Lb?@[m7&8:?t;@º9W5,mA=‚E=eZ[=KE5ƒTuDt@:±­9W@PI¢N'8:ZR=e9W9e@ I~&S7&;8:?=W@u??t@ IaPL=]A@FLb9W@u?\E

vA=e@:?`8:;>DA527&@,7+¥Tz@_Z_SJ;@;@N1SJ?tTFE=<S>??t@:Z[@:?\E@FE9<=œmA?A8,mA@PI®T:D 7&5FE=<@:?JI§@„EZ6L™I1L9WZ—8u?AICI&@67G@FE17&S L]A@,?\E8FLE1S L7

Lb?@C=W;@:?PE=‚E5®E@,717'=‚ES7'=<8:9W@fhA8,7^E82mA5:@CaPLA=I(«8u?AT27&@C;8,?I.9W«DA=MI^ES=g7&@C@FE9<8fmA5:?t5:8:9<S>mA=W@ ”

y

8:=MIT:@C9e8:?imA8,mA@C;PLƒ9<=<mJ?A82mA@%?A«@PI1E™hA8\I@,?PE@2?;A8zvA9W@fhA8 I™E†StLiE™9•@%ZRS?;A@:XA@,?hA8,71E1=<TFLb9e=W@,7„I.hA8,79<@PI.¦µS>7G;8,?=W@u?I

S7&=gmA=œ?A@ŠhA8:9W@tI1E'=<?=W@:??@PIµ”‹B¾SZRZ—@ 9W@ I"ZLI1L9WZ[8:?IGX9•@tI»T:D 7&5FE1=•@u?I›I&@žE17&S L]A@,?\E-;S?T¹Tu9W=g]b5tI–@:?PE17G@

¦„S7&;8,?=<@:?I7z;J@6IGStLbT2D@@FE¦µS 7&;8,?=W@:?JI;A«S>7'=ŸmJ=<?A@fhA8:9M@PI1E1=<?=e@:??A@ ”

,, $ ',G *! , # #, #

{

@_7G5,mJ=<Z—@ºIG@hAS)IG@¡TzSJZRZ[@6Lb?‹8,7'vA=‚E17&@RaPLb=™;SA=‚E+ZR8:=e?\E@,?=<7f9W@PI§5:aPLb=e9W=gvA7&@PI…@,?PE17&@RT:S?N1@ I¤I&=<SA?JI„”bV%7§;@,h Lb=^I

9e@ I82??A5:@PI 2¶s xXA;@f?S L]A@:9e9W@ IN1S>7GT:@PI=eI„I^Lb@\I;@%9W86I(SAT,=<5FE5CT:=g]A=e9W@CZLI^Lb9eZ—8:?@CT:S?NM7&S?PE@,?\E.9<@fhAS L]ASJ=Ÿ7@u?

9e@­IGS>ZRZ—8:?PE§;«=MI¤9W8:Z[=MI&@27C9e8¡]A=W@—@FE§9^jW@PIhA8PTz@¡h LAvA9e=WTPI„” { @¡7G5,mJ=<Z—@­I(«@ I^E]iLT:S?PE17&8,=<?\E§;@[T:5z;@,7C8:N1=œ?;@[?A@

hA8PI€Z—@FEMEM7&@3I&8"9W5,mJ=KE'=WZ¡=KE5»7G@u9<=<mA=e@„L™IG@@:?›hA5,7&=e9F2=MI&9e8:Z—=†IG8FE=<S>?’;PL ;=MI&T:S LA7¤IˆhASJ9<=‚E'=•aPLb@:XR;PL T:S?PE@2?PL¼;A@

9^jŽ@u?AI&@:=<mJ?t@:Z[@:?\EX|;@PI+h7S>mi7&8,ZRZ—@tI®‘XZ6Lb9‚E'=ŸhJ9W=eT\8FE1=WS?‹;@9<8RT:S>?I1E17^LbT¤E1=<S>?‹;@RZRSI&aPLb5:@PIGX™S vA9<=œmA8„E'=<S?‹;A@

7&@PI'hA@zTFE@,7@,?Rh LvA9e=WT69W@~(@b?@;J@C7&8:ZR8:;A8:?X@FE ¥%h7G5PI&@„?PE StL]>@,7†EMLA7G@6¥C91je=MI&9e8:Z·E17G8,?JI&?t8FE'=•S>?t8u9)aPL«=e9?A«@PI^ElhA8tI

hAS)I(I&=•vA9W@";A«@:?;=œm Lb@27­ESPE8,9<@:Z—@:?PE(”C¦LIGaPLjM8FLA£¹8:??5:@ I

2¶s

xX¡9<@ I€T:Di7&5FE=<@:?IŒI2jW5FE8:=<@:?PEˆT:S?N1S>71E8FvA9<@:Z—@u?\E

=œ?I1E8:9œ9W5 IRI&S LI9<8[EMLE@,9<9W@­;jgLb?A@­N1SJ=;S>ZR=<?A8:?PE@ ” y 8:9œm7G5IGS>?T:S?PE@,?\L-=eI&9W8:Z[=WaPLb@:X9W«@ IhA8:T:@ƒh LJvA9W=eT‹8,]A8:=gE

N'=<?=™hA8,7§´FE17&@hA@,7GOFL€TzS>ZRZ—@7&@:9e8„E1=•]b@:Z—@:?PE?@FLE17G@ ” /_8F?AIL?‹TzS>?\E@F£ E@R;@hJ9KLA7&8:9e=MI&Z—@_7G@u9W=<mJ=W@FLA£AX.I&=™hA8,7^E1=•@P9

aPLb@I&S=‚EˆT:@‰7G@:TFLA9R;@"9W8‰?@„LE17&8:9œ=KE5‰7&@:9<8FE=g]A@";@"9W«@PIhA8:T:@‰h LAvA9e=WT:XR=<97&@:Z—@FEˆ@,?ŠTz8FLI&@";@\I€5:aPLb=e9W=•vt7&@>I

h7&5:T:5:;@2?PE&I„”

o

=™vA=W@:?€aPL)«8FL:~GStLA7&;A«D\L=•X9W@­I&@:?PE=<Z[@:?\ECT2D 7&5FE=<@:?X@,?|¦µS>7G;8,?=W@:X@\I^E…T:@:9‚Lb=;J«Lb?@ƒZ[=<?S7&=†IG8FE=<S>?

;5uZ_S>m7&82hD=eaPLb@¢@FEIGSJT,=•8u9W@2A;@%vA=W@:?ƒ;@PI+Z—8:?=W},7&@PIGX)9Ž@PIT:D 7&5FE=<@:?JI§I&@¡IG@:?PE@:?PE @,? ]A8:D=MI+@FEZ_@u?A8zT:5PIhA8279W@tI

Z[8:?=WN'@PI1E8FE1=<S?I.7&@:9<=<mJ=W@FLIG@tIGX)IGSJT2=e8:9W@PI@„E™htS>9<=‚E=WaPLb@PI;@C9W«=MI¤9W8:Zƒ”

{

S>=<?;A@­7&@\I^E@,7hA8\I¤I&=<NIGX¾=W9†I_S>?\E¢@,?PE17G@,h7'=MIR;@|;5:N@:?A; 7&@ºLA?Tz@,7^E8:=<?ZRSJ;@ˆ;@ˆ]A=g]t7&@:U'@:?I&@:Zvb9e@ˆ8z]>@:T|9W@tI

Z_LI1L9WZ—8u?IGX®LA?t@²IG5,7&=W@˜;@­]>8u9W@FLA7(IRhA8,7^E8,mA5:@\I„”Y69<S7¤I—aPLb@€T,Dt8:aPLb@€T:SJZRZL?t8FLE5|7&@,?;hA9‚LI¡]A=MI&=gvb9e@€9<@>I

I&=gmJ?A@\IŠN'=g£b@PI¹@FE›ZRS L]A8:?\E&IŠ;@ I&S? 8,hhb8,7^E@2?8,?AT\@¸TzS>?N1@ I¤I&=•SJ??@:9e9W@:XŒhA827Š9e@ ]>´FE@:Z—@,?PE›S L hA8,7Š9•8

Z_LE=ghA9<=eT\8FE=<S?¹;@ IŒ9W=e@„LJ£ ;@3TFL9KE@:X[aPL)@3;@žZRSJ=<?I@:?¹ZRSJ=<?I²;@žT:D 7&5„E1=<@:?IŒN17&5:aPLb@:?PE@2?PE€9W@PI²5:T:SJ9•@tI

h LvA9e=WaPLb@PIS#0ƒ9W«@:?JI(@:=gmA?A@uZ—@:?PEl;@PI]A8:9W@FLA7¤I=MI&9e8:Z—=eaPLb@ I8C5„E5f7&@,? N1S7&T:5zXJaPLb@f9W«@\I'hA8\T:@fh LvA9e=WTC@FEl9<8fhASJ9<=‚E=<aPL)@

;@PI.hA8,7^E1=MI=<?PE},m7G@u?\ELA?@C;=eZ—@:?I&=<S>?—=MI&9e8:Z—=eaPLb@fhA9gLIm7&8,?;@zXJaPLb@C9W@PI=W;5:SJ9•S>m=W@PI.hA8:?A8,7G8Fvb@PI@FEIGSJT:=<8:9e=MI1E@tI

I&S?PEl@,?hA@,71E@C;@¾]A=‚E@ I¤I&@zXJ9W@tI TuDi7&5FE=<@:?JI7&@:T:Dt@,7&T:D@:?PELA?R9W8:? mA8,mb@fhASJ9<=‚E=<aPL@C;5zT:S>?N@PI„I&=<SA??8:9e=MI&58:9‚E@,7'?A8„E1=œN(”

YfL:~&S LA7&;A«D\L=<XA;8:?I™Lb?RT:S?PE@F£iE@fhAS)IMEU'8,7G8FvA=eI^E@zXJ9<@C;=†IµT:S LA7¤I;@f9W5,mA=‚E=œZ—8FE=<S?R;PL—7&5,mA=eZ—@I&@f7&@:Tz@u?\E17&@6I^LA7™LA?

T:8:; 7&@I^E17'=<T„E@uZ_@u?\E§~&S>7G;8,?=W@u?b” { «=<;A5:S>9•S>mA=W@˜hAS9œ=KE'=WaPLb@ŒhA8,?t8,7&8,vA@@tI1ER7&@,Z¢hJ9W8:T:5\@€hA8,7¡LA?t@˜7&D5FES 7=<aPL@;PL

;5F]A@:9<ShhA@:Z[@:?\E—5:T:S?SJZR=<aPL)@Œ@„E—;PL39<=gvb5,7&8:9e=MI&Z—@ ” { @PIƒT:Di7&5FE1=W@:?JI‹I&@˜7G@,hAS)I&=KE'=<S??@:?\ERhA8,7[7G8,hhAS 7†E¡¥ŒT:@PI

?S L]A@:9e9W@ IZ—8FE17&=<T:@\I+=e;5zSJ9<SmJ=<aPLb@\I!2tE17=•v>8:9e@ IS Lƒ?A5:SJ9<=gvA527&8:9e@ IGXI&SJ=KE@,?ƒ9W@PI]>8u9W=W;8u?\EXI&S=‚E @,?ƒ9W@PI+T:S?PE@\I^E8,?\E(”

Q.S L7Tz@[N18u=<7&@zX=<9†I§E@,?PE@,?\E…;@¡EM7&8,?AI&N1S>7&ZR@27@u?€N1S7&T:@PI¢9<@FLA7¤IN8:=•vA9W@ I¤I(@\I@:?|7&8PI(I(@uZvA9W8:?PE…9<@ I5:?@,71mJ=W@PI%;@tI

T:S>ZRZLb?8FLE5PI§7&@:9<=<mJ=W@FLI(@PI…@FE+9<=<mA?8,mA},7G@tI…5:T:9W8FE5:@PI§hA8,7§9e«@,£ASA;@¡71LA7&8,9.@„Ef9W«5:ZR=œm7G8FE'=•S>?­]>@,7¤I…;@PI§hA8z‡bIfhA9gL™I

h7&S)IhA},7&@PIµ” n ?ŒLE1=<9<=MI(8u?\E9W8|h7&@PI(I&@€?8FE=<S?8:9W@:Xf9<@ IvL9<9W@FE=<?JIRhA8,7&SA=eI¤I&=W8,L£–@FE H ?PE@,7?@FEX+@,??tSJZRZ[8:?\ER;@PI

Références

Documents relatifs

To test whether the vesicular pool of Atat1 promotes the acetyl- ation of -tubulin in MTs, we isolated subcellular fractions from newborn mouse cortices and then assessed

Néanmoins, la dualité des acides (Lewis et Bronsted) est un système dispendieux, dont le recyclage est une opération complexe et par conséquent difficilement applicable à

Cette mutation familiale du gène MME est une substitution d’une base guanine par une base adenine sur le chromosome 3q25.2, ce qui induit un remplacement d’un acide aminé cystéine

En ouvrant cette page avec Netscape composer, vous verrez que le cadre prévu pour accueillir le panoramique a une taille déterminée, choisie par les concepteurs des hyperpaysages

Chaque séance durera deux heures, mais dans la seconde, seule la première heure sera consacrée à l'expérimentation décrite ici ; durant la seconde, les élèves travailleront sur

A time-varying respiratory elastance model is developed with a negative elastic component (E demand ), to describe the driving pressure generated during a patient initiated

The aim of this study was to assess, in three experimental fields representative of the various topoclimatological zones of Luxembourg, the impact of timing of fungicide

Attention to a relation ontology [...] refocuses security discourses to better reflect and appreciate three forms of interconnection that are not sufficiently attended to